betaFeedback

WorksMathematics

Geography of Klein bottle Luttinger surgery

Abstract

We propose and study a modification of Auroux's uniqueness question on Luttinger surgery by replacing Lagrangian tori with Klein bottles. In Kodaira dimension −∞-\infty, we introduce two simple graphs whose connected components give bounds and, in several cases, exact counts of Klein bottle Luttinger equivalence classes. In Kodaira dimension zero, we provide examples of numerical invariants supporting infinitely many equivalence classes and prove a homological non-triviality theorem for Lagrangian Klein bottles in all symplectic Calabi–Yau surfaces with positive Euler characteristic. In positive Kodaira dimensions, we construct examples in which Klein bottle Luttinger surgery changes the symplectic Kodaira dimension.

Introduction

Auroux’s question

Luttinger surgery [28, 13, 1] was originally introduced as a symplectic cut-and-paste operation along an embedded Lagrangian torus LL in a symplectic four-manifold. It removes a Weinstein neighborhood D∗LD^{*}L and reglues it by a contactomorphism of S∗L≅T3S^{*}L \cong T^{3} with its canonical contact structure. In the Lagrangian framing, this map fixes the longitude classes and sends the meridian class [μ][\mu] to [μ]+k[γ′][\mu] + k[\gamma'], where k∈Zk \in\mathbb{Z} and [γ′][\gamma'] is the class of the Lagrangian push-off of an essential simple closed curve γ⊂L\gamma\subset L. The resulting symplectic form agrees with the original outside the surgery region, while the global topology may change. It has become a powerful tool for constructing symplectic 44-manifolds, including exotic examples, and revealing the diversity of their topology and smooth structures.

For a closed symplectic 44-manifold (X,ω)(X,\omega), we define its Auroux data by

A(X,ω)=(c12,c2,c1⋅[ω],[ω]2).\mathcal{A}(X,\omega) = \left(c_{1}^{2}, c_{2}, c_{1}\cdot[\omega],[\omega]^{2}\right).

Here c1c_1 is the first Chern class of any ω\omega-compatible almost-complex structure, c2c_2 is the Euler characteristic of XX, and “integral” means that [ω][\omega] is the image of a class in H2(X;Z)H^2(X;\mathbb{Z}). Auroux posed the following question in [5 Question 2.6].

Question 1.1 (Auroux). Let (X1,ω1)(X_1,\omega_1) and (X2,ω2)(X_2,\omega_2) be closed integral symplectic 44-manifolds with the same Auroux data. Is (X2,ω2)(X_2,\omega_2) symplectomorphic to a symplectic manifold obtained from (X1,ω1)(X_1,\omega_1) by a finite sequence of Luttinger surgeries?

The formulation of the above question in McDuff–Salamon [32 Problem 11] imposes the additional requirement that the surgeries be performed along pairwise disjoint Lagrangian tori. Surgeries along a disjoint collection can be performed successively, so the disjoint version is more restrictive than the sequential version. In Appendix § 7, we show that a hyperelliptic surface admits two integral symplectic forms with the same Auroux data that are related by sequential Luttinger surgeries, but cannot be related by disjoint Luttinger surgeries. In the rest of the paper, we will only consider the sequential version. The related question in the smooth category has an affirmative answer under the simply-connected assumption by Baykur–Sunukjian [BS13].

Recently, Question 1.1 was answered negatively in [21]. More precisely, Iida constructs integral symplectic forms with the same Auroux data on CP2#10CP‾ 2\mathbb{CP}^2\#10\overline{\mathbb{CP}}^{\,2} and S#2CP‾ 2S\#2\overline{\mathbb{CP}}^{\,2}, where SS is the Craighero–Gattazzo numerical Godeaux surface. These manifolds are homeomorphic, but their symplectic Kodaira dimensions are −∞-\infty and 22, respectively. They therefore cannot be related by Luttinger surgeries, since Luttinger surgeries preserve symplectic Kodaira dimension [20 Theorem 1.1].

There are also counterexamples for which the symplectic Kodaira dimensions agree. We give some examples addressing the additional conditions proposed in [21 Question 4.1].

Example 1.2 (Obstruction from minimality). Let m>n>0m>n>0 be integers. Equip X0=S2×S2X_0=S^2\times S^2 with the product symplectic form ω0\omega_0 with [ω0]=mA+2nB[\omega_0]=mA+2nB, where AA and BB denote the Poincaré duals of the two S2S^2-factors. On X1=CP2#CP‾ 2X_1=\mathbb{CP}^2\#\overline{\mathbb{CP}}^{\,2}, choose a blowup symplectic form ω1\omega_1 with [ω1]=(m+n)H−(m−n)E[\omega_1]=(m+n)H-(m-n)E, where HH and EE denote the Poincaré duals of the line and exceptional classes. Both forms are integral and have the same Auroux data:

A(X0,ω0)=A(X1,ω1)=(8,4,2m+4n,4mn).\mathcal{A}(X_0,\omega_0)=\mathcal{A}(X_1,\omega_1)=(8,4,2m+4n,4mn).

However, (X0,ω0)(X_0,\omega_0) is symplectically minimal, whereas (X1,ω1)(X_1,\omega_1) contains a symplectic exceptional sphere of area m−n>0m-n>0. Since Luttinger surgery preserves symplectic minimality [Wel07] [20 Proposition 3.1], these two integral symplectic manifolds have the same Auroux data but cannot be related by a sequence of Luttinger surgeries.

Example 1.3 (Minimal irrational ruled surfaces). Fix a closed Riemann surface Σg\Sigma_g of genus g>0g>0, and let L\mathcal{L} be a holomorphic line bundle of degree −1-1 over Σg\Sigma_g. Consider X0=Σg×CP1X_0=\Sigma_g\times\mathbb{CP}^1, X1=P(O⊕L)X_1=\mathbb{P}(\mathcal{O}\oplus\mathcal{L}). These are the trivial and nontrivial S2S^2-bundles over Σg\Sigma_g. For i=0,1i=0,1, let SiS_i be a section and FF a fiber, chosen so that Si2=−iS_i^2=-i, Si⋅F=1S_i\cdot F=1, F2=0F^2=0. For integers m>n>0m>n>0, we may choose integral symplectic forms with [ω0]=2nS0+mF[\omega_0]=2nS_0+mF, [ω1]=2nS1+(m+n)F[\omega_1]=2nS_1+(m+n)F. Since c1(Xi)=2Si+(2−2g+i)Fc_1(X_i)=2S_i+(2-2g+i)F, a direct calculation gives

A(X0,ω0)=A(X1,ω1)=(8−8g,4−4g,4n(1−g)+2m,4mn).\mathcal{A}(X_0,\omega_0)=\mathcal{A}(X_1,\omega_1)=(8-8g,4-4g,4n(1-g)+2m,4mn).

Both manifolds are symplectically minimal. However, by [20 Theorem 1.2], every Luttinger surgery on a symplectic four-manifold with Kodaira dimension −∞-\infty leaves the manifold unchanged. Consequently, imposing minimality does not suffice to make Question 1.1 true.

Example 1.4 (Two forms on the same rational surface). Let X=CP2#2CP‾2X = \mathbb{CP}^{2}\#2\overline{\mathbb{CP}}^{2} and choose blowup symplectic forms ω0,ω1\omega_{0},\omega_{1} with [ω0]=5H−E1−E2[\omega_{0}] = 5H - E_{1} - E_{2}, [ω1]=6H−3E1−2E2[\omega_{1}] = 6H - 3E_{1} - 2E_{2}. Their Auroux data agree:

A(X,ω0)=A(X,ω1)=(7,5,13,23).\mathcal{A}(X,\omega_{0}) = \mathcal{A}(X,\omega_{1}) = (7,5,13,23).

Nevertheless, these forms are not symplectomorphic by [22 Lemma 1.10]. On the other hand, every Luttinger surgery on a symplectic four-manifold with Kodaira dimension −∞-\infty leaves its symplectomorphism class unchanged [20 Theorem 1.2]. Thus (X,ω0)(X,\omega_{0}) and (X,ω1)(X,\omega_{1}) cannot be related by Luttinger surgeries, despite having the same underlying smooth manifold.

We next give a counterexample in which both forms are defined on the same minimal smooth four-manifold. The obstruction comes from the restrictions on the lattice automorphisms.

Example 1.5 (Enriques surface). Let XX be the underlying smooth four-manifold of an Enriques surface. Consider the Enriques lattice Λ=H2(X;Z)/Tor⁡≅U⊕E8(−1)\Lambda= H^{2}(X;\mathbb{Z})/\operatorname{Tor} \cong U \oplus E_{8}(-1) and its automorphism group O(Λ)O(\Lambda). Choose D0,D1∈ΛD_{0},D_{1} \in\Lambda such that D02=D12=d>0D_{0}^{2} = D_{1}^{2} = d > 0, but D0D_{0} and D1D_{1} lie in distinct orbits of O(Λ)O(\Lambda). Such pairs exist already in the hyperbolic summand U⊂ΛU \subset\Lambda. Indeed, choose a basis s1,s2s_{1},s_{2} with s12=s22=0s_{1}^{2} = s_{2}^{2} = 0 and s1⋅s2=1s_{1}\cdot s_{2} = 1, and take D0=6s1+s2D_{0} = 6s_{1} + s_{2}, D1=3s1+2s2D_{1} = 3s_{1} + 2s_{2}, so that D02=D12=12D_{0}^{2} = D_{1}^{2} = 12. But by [34 Proposition 3.4], the smallest positive pairings of D0D_{0} and D1D_{1} with integral square-zero classes are 1 and 2, respectively. Since lattice isometries preserve these pairings, D0D_{0} and D1D_{1} lie in distinct O(Λ)O(\Lambda)-orbits.

Note that every positive class in H2(X;R)H^{2}(X;\mathbb{R}) admits a Kähler representative since a generic complex structure on XX contains no (−2)(-2)-curves; see [12]. Thus we may choose two symplectic forms ω0,ω1\omega_{0},\omega_{1} representing D0,D1D_{0},D_{1}, respectively. They have the same Auroux data

A(X,ω0)=A(X,ω1)=(0,12,0,12).\mathcal{A}(X,\omega_{0}) = \mathcal{A}(X,\omega_{1}) = (0,12,0,12).

Suppose that (X,ω0)(X,\omega_{0}) and (X,ω1)(X,\omega_{1}) were related by a sequence of Luttinger surgeries. By [20 Theorems 1.1 and 1.3, Proposition 3.1], every intermediate manifold is minimal of symplectic Kodaira dimension zero and has the same integral homology as XX. In particular, every intermediate manifold has b2+=1b_{2}^{+} = 1. Corollary 2.10 therefore applies at each step. Composing the resulting lattice isometries gives an automorphism of Λ\Lambda which maps PD⁡([ω0])\operatorname{PD}([\omega_{0}]) to PD⁡([ω1])\operatorname{PD}([\omega_{1}]), contrary to our choice of D0,D1D_{0},D_{1}. Hence (X,ω0)(X,\omega_{0}) and (X,ω1)(X,\omega_{1}) cannot be related by Luttinger surgeries. This gives a negative answer to [21 Question 4.1], even for symplectic forms on the same manifold which is also minimal.

Lagrangian Klein bottle Luttinger surgery

The preceding examples show that Auroux data do not determine Luttinger surgery equivalence in many cases, even after imposing minimality and fixing the underlying smooth manifold. Nevertheless, Luttinger surgery can also be performed along Lagrangian Klein bottles [33, 38]. In contrast to surgery along Lagrangian tori, the two manifolds in Examples 1.2, 1.3, and 1.4 are all related by a single Klein bottle (KB) Luttinger surgery. We refer to Adaloglou–Evans [2 §1.1, §3.1, §3.2] for Lagrangian Klein bottles in S2×S2S^{2}\times S^{2} whose surgery produces CP2#CP‾2\mathbb{CP}^{2}\#\overline{\mathbb{CP}}^{2}, and Sections 3 and 4 for the other two examples.

All the counterexamples to Auroux’s question in the previous section, including Iida’s one [21], rely on various properties for torus Luttinger surgery established by Ho–Li [20], which in turn build on Welschinger’s result [Wel07] using SFT compactness [6]. This leads us to investigate which of these properties extend to Klein bottle Luttinger surgery and what new phenomena could arise. Comparisons between torus and Klein bottle Luttinger surgery are summarized in Table 1, where all the assertions can be found in [20] or the subsequent sections of this paper. Remarkably, in § 6, we use symplectic cyclic branched covers to show the following.

References

  1. [1]D. Auroux, S. K. Donaldson, and L. Katzarkov. Luttinger surgery along Lagrangian tori and non-isotopy for singular symplectic plane curves. Math. Ann., 326(1):185–203, 2003.
  2. [2]Nikolas Adaloglou and Jonathan David Evans. Lagrangian Klein bottles in S² × S². Comment. Math. Helv., 2026.
  3. [3]Michèle Audin. Quelques remarques sur les surfaces lagrangiennes de Givental. J. Geom. Phys., 7(4):583–598, 1990.DOI
  4. [4]Denis Auroux. Symplectic 4-manifolds as branched coverings of CP². Invent. Math., 139(3):551–602, 2000.
  5. [5]Denis Auroux. Some open questions about symplectic 4-manifolds, singular plane curves and braid group factorizations. In European Congress of Mathematics, pages 23–40. Eur. Math. Soc., Zürich, 2005.
  6. [6]F. Bourgeois, Y. Eliashberg, H. Hofer, K. Wysocki, and E. Zehnder. Compactness results in symplectic field theory. Geom. Topol., 7:799–888, 2003.DOI
  7. [7]Wolf P. Barth, Klaus Hulek, Chris A. M. Peters, and Antonius Van de Ven. Compact complex surfaces. Springer-Verlag, Berlin, second edition, 2004.
  8. [9]Anthony Conway, Patrick Orson, and Mark Powell. Unknotting nonorientable surfaces. J. Eur. Math. Soc. (JEMS), 2025. Published online first.arxiv.org/abs/2306.12305
  9. [10]Bo Dai, Chung-I Ho, and Tian-Jun Li. Nonorientable Lagrangian surfaces in rational 4-manifolds. Algebr. Geom. Topol., 19(6):2837–2854, 2019.arxiv.org/abs/1902.08901
  10. [11]Josef G. Dorfmeister and Tian-Jun Li. The relative symplectic cone and T²-fibrations. J. Symplectic Geom., 8(1):1–35, 2010.DOI
  11. [12]Igor V. Dolgachev. A brief introduction to Enriques surfaces. In Development of Moduli Theory—Kyoto 2013, volume 69 of Advanced Studies in Pure Mathematics, pages 1–32. Mathematical Society of Japan, Tokyo, 2016.
  12. [13]Yakov Eliashberg and Leonid Polterovich. New applications of Luttinger’s surgery. Comment. Math. Helv., 69(4):512–522, 1994.
  13. [14]M. Furuta. Monopole equation and the 11/8-conjecture. Math. Res. Lett., 8(3):279–291, 2001.
  14. [15]Hansjörg Geiges. Symplectic structures on T²-bundles over T². Duke Math. J., 67(3):539–555, 1992.DOI
  15. [16]Robert E. Gompf. Symplectically aspherical manifolds with nontrivial π₂. Math. Res. Lett., 5(5):599–603, 1998.
  16. [17]Robert E. Gompf and András I. Stipsicz. 4-manifolds and Kirby calculus, volume 20 of Graduate Studies in Mathematics. American Mathematical Society, Providence, RI, 1999.DOI
  17. [18]M. J. D. Hamilton. Representing homology classes by symplectic surfaces. Math. Res. Lett., 19(5):1021–1024, 2012.DOI
  18. [19]Tara S. Holm and Liat Kessler. Circle actions on symplectic four-manifolds. Comm. Anal. Geom., 27(2):421–464, 2019.arxiv.org/abs/1507.05972
  19. [20]Chung-I Ho and Tian-Jun Li. Luttinger surgery and Kodaira dimension. Asian J. Math., 16(2):299–318, 2012.arxiv.org/abs/1108.0479
  20. [21]Nobuo Iida. On Auroux’s Luttinger-surgery uniqueness question. arXiv:2609.29561, 2026.arxiv.org/abs/2609.29561
  21. [22]Yael Karshon and Liat Kessler. Distinguishing symplectic blowups of the complex projective plane. J. Symplectic Geom., 15(4):1089–1128, 2017.arxiv.org/abs/1407.5312
  22. [23]R. C. Kirby and L. R. Taylor. Pin structures on low-dimensional manifolds. In Geometry of low-dimensional manifolds, 2 (Durham, 1989), volume 151 of London Math. Soc. Lecture Note Ser., pages 177–242. Cambridge Univ. Press, Cambridge, 1990.DOI
  23. [24]Tian-Jun Li. Quaternionic bundles and Betti numbers of symplectic 4-manifolds with Kodaira dimension zero. Int. Math. Res. Not., pages Art. ID 37385, 28, 2006.
  24. [25]Ai-Ko Liu. Some new applications of general wall crossing formula, Gompf’s conjecture and its applications. Math. Res. Lett., 3(5):569–585, 1996.DOI
  25. [26]Bang-He Li and Tian-Jun Li. Symplectic genus, minimal genus and diffeomorphisms. Asian J. Math., 6(1):123–144, 2002.DOI
  26. [27]François Lalonde and Dusa McDuff. The classification of ruled symplectic 4-manifolds. Mathematical Research Letters, 3(6):769–778, 1996.
  27. [28]Karl Murad Luttinger. Lagrangian tori in R⁴. J. Differential Geom., 42(2):220–228, 1995.
  28. [29]Tian-Jun Li and Weiwei Wu. Lagrangian spheres, symplectic surfaces and the symplectic mapping class group. Geom. Topol., 16(2):1121–1169, 2012.DOI
  29. [30]Yukio Matsumoto. An elementary proof of Rochlin’s signature theorem and its extension by Guillou and Marin. In À la recherche de la topologie perdue, volume 62 of Progr. Math., pages 119–139. Birkhäuser Boston, Boston, MA, 1986.
  30. [31]John W. Morgan and Zoltán Szabó. Homotopy K3 surfaces and mod 2 Seiberg-Witten invariants. Math. Res. Lett., 4(1):17–21, 1997.
  31. [32]Dusa McDuff and Dietmar Salamon. Introduction to symplectic topology. Oxford Graduate Texts in Mathematics. Oxford University Press, Oxford, third edition, 2017.
  32. [33]S. Yu. Nemirovskii. The homology class of a Lagrangian Klein bottle. Izv. Ross. Akad. Nauk Ser. Mat., 73(4):37–48, 2009.
  33. [34]Shengzhen Ning. Comparing Kähler cone and symplectic cone of one-point blowup of Enriques surface. J. Lond. Math. Soc. (2), 111(3):Paper No. e70117, 23, 2025.arxiv.org/abs/2407.10217
  34. [35]Hiroshi Ohta and Kaoru Ono. Notes on symplectic 4-manifolds with b₂⁺ = 1. II. Internat. J. Math., 7(6):755–770, 1996.
  35. [36]Federica Pasquotto. On the Geography of Symplectic Manifolds. PhD thesis, Leiden University, 2004.
  36. [37]V. A. Rohlin. Two-dimensional submanifolds of four-dimensional manifolds. Funkcional. Anal. i Priložen., 5(1):48–60, 1971.DOI
  37. [38]V. V. Shevchishin. Lagrangian embeddings of the Klein bottle and the combinatorial properties of mapping class groups. Izv. Ross. Akad. Nauk Ser. Mat., 73(4):153–224, 2009.
  38. [39]Gleb Smirnov. On Lagrangian tori in K3 surfaces. J. Symplectic Geom., 23(4):835–851, 2025.arxiv.org/abs/2211.00620
  39. [40]Tatsuo Suwa. On hyperelliptic surfaces. J. Fac. Sci. Univ. Tokyo Sect. I, 16:469–476, 1969.DOI
  40. [41]Margaret Symington. Four dimensions from two in symplectic topology. In Topology and geometry of manifolds (Athens, GA, 2001), volume 71 of Proc. Sympos. Pure Math., pages 153–208. Amer. Math. Soc., Providence, RI, 2003.
  41. [42]Clifford Henry Taubes. More constraints on symplectic forms from Seiberg-Witten invariants. Math. Res. Lett., 2(1):9–13, 1995.DOI
  42. [43]Lisa Traynor. Symplectic packing constructions. J. Differential Geom., 42(2):411–429, 1995.
  43. [44]Michael Usher. Kodaira dimension and symplectic sums. Comment. Math. Helv., 84(1):57–85, 2009.
  44. [45]C. T. C. Wall. Diffeomorphisms of 4-manifolds. J. London Math. Soc., 39:131–140, 1964.DOI

Paper details

vlnc:W_skbhz9je
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 0

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Mathematics

AI, LLM tools

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents