Introduction
The axion is a well-motivated dark matter candidate, and its relic abundance is usually set by the misalignment mechanism [1 , 2 , 3 ] , in which Hubble friction holds a homogeneous displacement of the field fixed until the Hubble rate drops below the axion mass, after which the field oscillates and redshifts like matter. If the Peccei–Quinn (PQ) symmetry [4 , 5 , 6 , 7 ] is broken before the observable scales leave the horizon, the axion is also a light spectator during inflation and acquires fluctuations of order H I / ( 2 π ) H_I/(2\pi) H I / ( 2 π ) , where H I H_I H I is the inflationary Hubble rate. These fluctuations were first studied as a source of axion density perturbations in Ref. [8 ] and soon identified as isocurvature perturbations [9 , 10 ] . The absence of isocurvature in the cosmic microwave background (CMB) bounds the inflationary Hubble scale [11 , 12 , 13 , 14 , 15 , 16 , 17 ] , and the bound depends on the axion decay constant during inflation, on the later evolution of the perturbation, and on the ultraviolet (UV) completion [13 , 18 , 19 , 20 , 21 ] .
The same fluctuations carry energy and contribute to the abundance. Their contribution can be computed either as gravitational particle production [22 , 23 , 24 , 25 ] (see Ref. [26 ] for a review) or as the classical evolution of a stochastic field. Fields with masses near the inflationary Hubble rate are produced mainly around the end of inflation [27 , 28 , 29 , 30 , 31 ] . For light scalars, on the other hand, the infrared modes generate large isocurvature, which a nonminimal coupling to gravity can suppress [32 , 33 ] .
Ref. [34 ] computed the transition from de Sitter expansion to radiation domination analytically for a light minimally coupled spectator and found a late-time distribution strongly peaked at low momenta. If inflation lasts long enough, a light field approaches the stochastic equilibrium distribution [35 ] , whose variance can replace the initial displacement [36 , 37 ] . Related ideas have been applied to spectator scalar dark matter [38 , 39 , 40 , 41 ] and to vector dark matter [42 , 43 , 44 , 45 ] .
A time-dependent kinetic function also tilts the axion spectrum. Such kinetic functions were introduced for inflationary magnetogenesis [46 , 47 ] , dark photon production [48 , 49 ] , and axion dark matter production [50 ] . For an axion, the kinetic function can come from an evolving radial expectation value of the PQ field [13 , 18 , 19 ] or from a curved field-space metric (e.g., in supergravity and string compactifications [51 , 52 , 53 ] ).
The CMB bound can be evaded either by suppressing the isocurvature or by tilting it to become more blue. A larger effective decay constant during inflation suppresses the axion isocurvature, either through a large radial field [13 , 18 , 19 , 54 ] or through the field-space metric [53 ] , and a nonminimal kinetic coupling to gravity has a similar effect [55 ] . A large axion mass during inflation also removes the CMB scale isocurvature [56 , 57 , 58 ] , and if the axion becomes light only after the CMB scales exit, the later fluctuations can set the QCD axion abundance [59 , 60 ] . An extremely blue spectrum arises instead if the radial field of the axion evolves during inflation [61 , 62 , 63 ] . For a self-interacting scalar, whose condensate spends most of inflation near the boundary of the slow-roll region of its potential, the effective mass stays close to H I H_I H I and the tilt is generated dynamically [64 ] . A positive coupling to the Ricci scalar gives a blue tilt and erases the initial displacement, which allows scalar dark matter to come entirely from inflationary fluctuations [65 , 66 ] . The two couplings that we study here, a kinetic function and a curvature coupling, act in both ways.
In this work, we ask when inflationary fluctuations dominate the abundance of an axion-like particle (ALP) compared to the conventional misalignment production and what this implies for isocurvature. We extend the analytic matching of Ref. [34 ] to scenarios with either a nonminimal coupling or a noncanonical kinetic term, both of which have well-motivated UV realizations. Our matching keeps the axion mass after inflation and the jump in the rate of change of the kinetic function at the end of inflation, and gives the late-time spectrum fully analytically for both couplings. The same calculation fixes the misalignment normalization without an onset prescription and shows that the fluctuations carry the misalignment abundance of an effective homogeneous displacement, so that the two contributions can be compared directly.
The isocurvature perturbation contains a term linear in the fluctuations, proportional to the mean displacement, which reproduces the familiar misalignment result, and a term quadratic in the fluctuations that remains when the mean vanishes. We then confront the fluctuation-dominated abundance with the current CMB isocurvature limit, including the quadratic term that survives when the mean vanishes. We identify the conditions under which axions produced from inflationary fluctuations can dominate over misalignment while satisfying the stringent isocurvature constraint. The early estimate of Ref. [67 ] for the QCD axion predates this constraint, and the red spectra that give a large abundance there exceed it at the pivot by many orders of magnitude (see § 0.5 ). The more comprehensive treatment here also revises the conclusion of Ref. [50 ] that red spectra can supply all of the dark matter. That analysis imposed the isocurvature bound in its misalignment-dominated form (the linear term), which misses the quadratic term that dominates once the fluctuations set the abundance.
For the noncanonical kinetic coupling, we consider two scenarios. A linear exponential kinetic function realizes the constant-slope history that we solve exactly, whereas a quadratic exponential produces a running slope, with a spectrum that is strongly blue on CMB scales and less blue on the smaller scales that dominate the abundance. Since these scales leave the horizon tens of e e e -folds apart, running can suppress the CMB-scale isocurvature relative to the fluctuation abundance, substantially relaxing the mass thresholds obtained with a constant slope. Inflationary fluctuations can then supply all of the dark matter for axion masses as low as 0.7 e V 0.7\,\mathrm{eV} 0.7 eV at H I = 10 13 G e V H_I=10^{13}\,\mathrm{GeV} H I = 1 0 13 GeV and approximately 0.01 e V 0.01\,\mathrm{eV} 0.01 eV at the tensor bound, H I = 4.7 × 10 13 G e V H_I=4.7\times10^{13}\,\mathrm{GeV} H I = 4.7 × 1 0 13 GeV , while satisfying the pivot-scale isocurvature constraint.
The remainder of the paper is organized as follows. In Sec. II, we define the model, and in Sec. III we
solve the production problem fully analytically. We compute the abundance in Sec. IV and the isocurvature in § 0.5 , which also contains an estimate for the QCD axion (§ 0.5 A). In Sec. VI, we relate the analytic slope to the linear and quadratic exponentials, including the running of the slope, and in Sec. VII we summarize our results. Apps. A–C derive the infrared spectrum and the density correlator and treat slowly varying kinetic histories, and App. D gives UV realizations of the kinetic functions.
Setup
We consider a canonical inflaton ϕ \phi ϕ and a spectator axion η \eta η with action
S = ∫ d 4 x − g [ M P l 2 2 R − 1 2 ( ∂ ϕ ) 2 − V ( ϕ ) − 1 2 K 2 ( ϕ ) ( ∂ η ) 2 − 1 2 ξ R η 2 − U ( η ) ] , (1) S=\int d^4x\sqrt{-g}\left[\frac{M_{\mathrm{Pl}}^2}{2}R-\frac{1}{2}(\partial\phi)^2-V(\phi)-\frac{1}{2}K^2(\phi)(\partial\eta)^2-\frac{1}{2}\xi R\eta^2-U(\eta)\right], \tag*{(1)} S = ∫ d 4 x − g [ 2 M Pl 2 R − 2 1 ( ∂ ϕ ) 2 − V ( ϕ ) − 2 1 K 2 ( ϕ ) ( ∂ η ) 2 − 2 1 ξ R η 2 − U ( η ) ] , (1)
where M P l = 2.435 × 10 18 G e V M_{\mathrm{Pl}}=2.435\times10^{18}\,\mathrm{GeV} M Pl = 2.435 × 1 0 18 GeV is the reduced Planck mass, R R R is the Ricci scalar, and the signature is ( − , + , + , + ) (-,+,+,+) ( − , + , + , + ) . The functions V V V and U U U are the inflaton and axion potentials, K 2 ( ϕ ) > 0 K^2(\phi)>0 K 2 ( ϕ ) > 0 is the axion kinetic metric, and ξ \xi ξ is dimensionless. We study the two couplings separately, either a varying K ( ϕ ) K(\phi) K ( ϕ ) with ξ = 0 \xi=0 ξ = 0 [50 ] or a constant ξ \xi ξ with K = 1 K=1 K = 1 [65 , 66 ] , and we take the canonical minimally coupled theory (K = 1 K=1 K = 1 and ξ = 0 \xi=0 ξ = 0 ) as our reference case. We work in a spatially flat FLRW background, d s 2 = − d t 2 + a 2 d x 2 = a 2 ( − d τ 2 + d x 2 ) ds^2=-dt^2+a^2dx^2=a^2(-d\tau^2+dx^2) d s 2 = − d t 2 + a 2 d x 2 = a 2 ( − d τ 2 + d x 2 ) , with Hubble rate H = a ˙ / a H=\dot a/a H = a ˙ / a , where dots and primes denote derivatives with respect to cosmic time t t t and conformal time τ \tau τ , respectively. With these conventions, the Ricci scalar is given by
R = 6 ( 2 H 2 + H ˙ ) = 6 a ′ ′ a 3 . (2) R=6(2H^2+\dot H)=\frac{6a''}{a^3}. \tag*{(2)} R = 6 ( 2 H 2 + H ˙ ) = a 3 6 a ′′ . (2)
We use the term “axion” for any light pseudoscalar with an approximate shift symmetry. One realization is the angular mode of a complex PQ field,
χ = σ 2 e i η / f η , η ∼ η + 2 π f η , (3) \chi=\frac{\sigma}{\sqrt{2}}e^{i\eta/f_\eta},\qquad\eta\sim\eta+2\pi f_\eta, \tag*{(3)} χ = 2 σ e i η / f η , η ∼ η + 2 π f η , (3)
where σ \sigma σ is the radial field and f η f_\eta f η is the late-time axion decay constant. We assume that PQ symmetry is broken before observable modes leave the horizon and stays broken, and that the radial field tracks a stable minimum σ 0 ( ϕ ) \sigma_0(\phi) σ 0 ( ϕ ) with mass m σ m_\sigma m σ well above the inflationary Hubble rate H I H_I H I , the relevant physical momenta, and the rates of background evolution.4 Integrating out σ \sigma σ of a canonical complex field gives the axion kinetic function K = σ 0 / f η K = \sigma_0/f_\eta K = σ 0 / f η [13 , 18 , 19 ] , while a curved field-space metric provides another realization (App. D § 0.12.2 ).
The symmetry must also stay broken after inflation, which for instantaneous reheating, with a radiation temperature T R H ≃ 8 × 10 13 G e V ( H I / 10 10 G e V ) 1 / 2 T_{\mathrm{RH}} \simeq8 \times10^{13}\,\mathrm{GeV}\,(H_I/10^{10}\,\mathrm{GeV})^{1/2} T RH ≃ 8 × 1 0 13 GeV ( H I /1 0 10 GeV ) 1/2 , requires f η ≳ T R H f_\eta\gtrsim T_{\mathrm{RH}} f η ≳ T RH if the PQ sector is in equilibrium with the bath. However, a PQ sector that is coupled weakly enough never to thermalize is not restored even for f η < T R H f_\eta< T_{\mathrm{RH}} f η < T RH .5
We take K ( ϕ e ) = 1 K(\phi_e)=1 K ( ϕ e ) = 1 at the end of inflation and assume that the exit keeps K = 1 K=1 K = 1 thereafter, i.e., η \eta η is canonically normalized after reheating. At fixed ϕ \phi ϕ the canonical angular field has period 2 π K ( ϕ ) f η 2\pi K(\phi)f_\eta 2 π K ( ϕ ) f η , and its decay constant at horizon exit of the CMB pivot scale, k ∗ = a ∗ H ∗ k_* = a_*H_* k ∗ = a ∗ H ∗ , is given by
f I = K ∗ f η , K ∗ ≡ K ( ϕ ∗ ) . (4) f_I = K_*f_\eta,\qquad K_* \equiv K(\phi_*). \tag*{(4)} f I = K ∗ f η , K ∗ ≡ K ( ϕ ∗ ) . (4)
The kinetic coupling preserves the shift symmetry, while U U U and the curvature interaction break it. The latter can arise, for a compact axion, from the periodic operator − ξ R f η 2 [ 1 − cos ( η / f η ) ] -\xi Rf_\eta^2[1-\cos(\eta/f_\eta)] − ξ R f η 2 [ 1 − cos ( η / f η )] . We expand both interactions about η = 0 \eta=0 η = 0 and work in the harmonic regime, U ( η ) ≃ 1 2 m η 2 η 2 U(\eta) \simeq\frac{1}{2}m_\eta^2\eta^2 U ( η ) ≃ 2 1 m η 2 η 2 , with constant m η 2 ≡ U , η η ( 0 ) m_\eta^2 \equiv U_{,\eta\eta}(0) m η 2 ≡ U , η η ( 0 ) . During inflation we retain the curvature mass but neglect the potential mass, which requires m η ≪ K H I m_\eta\ll KH_I m η ≪ K H I along the relevant part of the trajectory.6
We consider kinetic functions whose logarithm is linear or quadratic in ϕ \phi ϕ ,
K λ 2 ( ϕ ) = e λ ϕ / M P l , K γ 2 ( ϕ ) = e γ ϕ 2 / M P l 2 , (5) K_\lambda^2(\phi)=e^{\lambda\phi/M_{\mathrm{Pl}}},\qquad K_\gamma^2(\phi)=e^{\gamma\phi^2/M_{\mathrm{Pl}}^2}, \tag*{(5)} K λ 2 ( ϕ ) = e λ ϕ / M Pl , K γ 2 ( ϕ ) = e γ ϕ 2 / M Pl 2 , (5)
with dimensionless λ \lambda λ and γ \gamma γ , which we call the linear and quadratic exponentials. The quadratic exponential starts with the dimension-six interaction − ( γ / 2 M P l 2 ) ϕ 2 ( ∂ η ) 2 -(\gamma/2M_{\mathrm{Pl}}^2)\phi^2(\partial\eta)^2 − ( γ /2 M Pl 2 ) ϕ 2 ( ∂ η ) 2 , and its higher terms allow a larger slope ∣ p ∣ |p| ∣ p ∣ than the truncated form (App. D § 0.12.1 ). Both functions equal unity at ϕ = 0 \phi=0 ϕ = 0 , and if inflation ends at ϕ e ≠ 0 \phi_e\ne0 ϕ e = 0 , the conditions K ( ϕ e ) = 1 K(\phi_e)=1 K ( ϕ e ) = 1 and K = 1 K=1 K = 1 thereafter require modifying them near the exit.
We characterize the kinetic evolution by
p ≡ d ln K d ln a = K , ϕ K ϕ ˙ H , (6) p \equiv\frac{\mathrm{d}\ln K}{\mathrm{d}\ln a}=\frac{K_{,\phi}}{K}\frac{\dot{\phi}}{H}, \tag*{(6)} p ≡ d ln a d ln K = K K , ϕ H ϕ ˙ , (6)
where K , ϕ = d K / d ϕ K_{,\phi}=\mathrm{d}K/\mathrm{d}\phi K , ϕ = d K / d ϕ , and a positive p p p corresponds to a growing K K K . For a canonical inflaton rolling toward smaller ϕ \phi ϕ we have ϕ ˙ / H ≃ − 2 ϵ M P l \dot{\phi}/H \simeq-\sqrt{2\epsilon}M_{\mathrm{Pl}} ϕ ˙ / H ≃ − 2 ϵ M Pl , with ϵ ≡ − H ˙ / H 2 \epsilon\equiv-\dot{H}/H^2 ϵ ≡ − H ˙ / H 2 being the slow-roll parameter, which gives
p λ = − λ ϵ 2 , p γ = − 2 ϵ γ ϕ M P l . (7) p_\lambda=-\lambda\sqrt{\frac{\epsilon}{2}},\qquad p_\gamma=-\sqrt{2\epsilon}\gamma\frac{\phi}{M_{\mathrm{Pl}}}. \tag*{(7)} p λ = − λ 2 ϵ , p γ = − 2 ϵ γ M Pl ϕ . (7)
The blue spectra considered below correspond to p < 0 p<0 p < 0 , and hence to λ > 0 \lambda>0 λ > 0 or, on the ϕ > 0 \phi>0 ϕ > 0 branch, to γ > 0 \gamma>0 γ > 0 . Note that the linear exponential gives a constant p p p when ϵ \epsilon ϵ is constant, while ∣ p γ ∣ |p_\gamma| ∣ p γ ∣ decreases as ϕ \phi ϕ approaches zero. Our calculations in Secs. III–§ 0.5 only assume a constant p p p and do not rely on the specific form of K ( ϕ ) K(\phi) K ( ϕ ) . We map our results onto the specific forms in Eq. (5) in Sec. VI.
Gravitational axion production
With the canonical variable v ≡ z η v\equiv z\eta v ≡ z η , where z ≡ a K z\equiv aK z ≡ a K , and with the potential mass neglected, the quadratic action during inflation can be written, after an integration by parts, as
S η = 1 2 ∫ d τ d 3 x [ v ′ 2 − ( ∇ v ) 2 − M 2 v 2 ] , (8) S_\eta=\frac{1}{2}\int\mathrm{d}\tau\,\mathrm{d}^3x\left[v'^2-(\nabla v)^2-\mathcal{M}^2v^2\right], \tag*{(8)} S η = 2 1 ∫ d τ d 3 x [ v ′2 − ( ∇ v ) 2 − M 2 v 2 ] , (8)
where
M 2 = { − ( a K ) ′ ′ a K , ξ = 0 , ( 6 ξ − 1 ) a ′ ′ a , K = 1. (9) \mathcal{M}^2=
\begin{cases}
-\dfrac{(aK)''}{aK}, & \xi=0,\\
(6\xi-1)\dfrac{a''}{a}, & K=1.
\end{cases} \tag*{(9)} M 2 = ⎩ ⎨ ⎧ − a K ( a K ) ′′ , ( 6 ξ − 1 ) a a ′′ , ξ = 0 , K = 1. (9)
The modes of comoving wavenumber k k k obey
v k ′ ′ + ( k 2 + M 2 ) v k = 0 , v k v k ∗ ′ − v k ∗ v k ′ = i . (10) v_k''+(k^2+\mathcal{M}^2)v_k=0,\qquad v_kv_k^{*\prime}-v_k^*v_k'=i. \tag*{(10)} v k ′′ + ( k 2 + M 2 ) v k = 0 , v k v k ∗ ′ − v k ∗ v k ′ = i . (10)
We approximate reheating as an instantaneous transition from de Sitter expansion to radiation domination [34 ] . Setting a e = 1 a_e=1 a e = 1 and τ e = − H I − 1 \tau_e=-H_I^{-1} τ e = − H I − 1 , the scale factor is given by
a ( τ ) = { − ( H I τ ) − 1 , τ ≤ τ e , 2 + H I τ , τ ≥ τ e . (11) a(\tau)=
\begin{cases}
-(H_I\tau)^{-1}, & \tau\leq\tau_e,\\
2+H_I\tau, & \tau\geq\tau_e.
\end{cases} \tag*{(11)} a ( τ ) = { − ( H I τ ) − 1 , 2 + H I τ , τ ≤ τ e , τ ≥ τ e . (11)
Both a a a and a ′ a' a ′ are continuous at τ e \tau_e τ e , and R R R has no delta function there. Instead, it drops from 12 H I 2 12H_I^2 12 H I 2 to zero, and the curvature mass switches off. In the kinetic coupling case, we take
K ( τ ) = { a p ( τ ) , τ < τ e , 1 , τ ≥ τ e . (12) K(\tau)=
\begin{cases}
a^p(\tau), & \tau<\tau_e,\\
1, & \tau\geq\tau_e.
\end{cases} \tag*{(12)} K ( τ ) = { a p ( τ ) , 1 , τ < τ e , τ ≥ τ e . (12)
with a constant p p p . This treats the geometry at leading order in slow roll while retaining the evolution of K K K (we relate it to Eq. (5) in Sec. VI). The kinetic function is continuous at the transition, where K ′ K' K ′ drops from p H I pH_I p H I to zero, and for the curvature coupling K = 1 K=1 K = 1 throughout.
In de Sitter space, ( a K ) ′ ′ / ( a K ) = ( 2 + κ ) / τ 2 (aK)^{\prime\prime}/(aK)=(2+\kappa)/\tau^2 ( a K ) ′′ / ( a K ) = ( 2 + κ ) / τ 2 , where
κ ≡ τ 2 [ K ′ ′ K + 2 a ′ a K ′ K ] = p ( p + 3 ) + d p d ln a (13) \kappa\equiv\tau^2\left[\frac{K^{\prime\prime}}{K}+2\frac{a^{\prime}}{a}\frac{K^{\prime}}{K}\right]=p(p+3)+\frac{\mathrm{d}p}{\mathrm{d}\ln a} \tag*{(13)} κ ≡ τ 2 [ K K ′′ + 2 a a ′ K K ′ ] = p ( p + 3 ) + d ln a d p (13)
is the effective curvature parameter [50 ] . For constant p p p we have κ = p ( p + 3 ) \kappa=p(p+3) κ = p ( p + 3 ) , and the mode equation can be written as
v k ′ ′ + [ k 2 − ν 2 − 1 4 τ 2 ] v k = 0 , (14) v_k^{\prime\prime}+\left[k^2-\frac{\nu^2-\frac{1}{4}}{\tau^2}\right]v_k=0, \tag*{(14)} v k ′′ + [ k 2 − τ 2 ν 2 − 4 1 ] v k = 0 , (14)
with
ν 2 = { 9 4 + κ = ( 3 2 + p ) 2 , ξ = 0 , 9 4 − 12 ξ , K = 1. (15) \nu^2=\begin{cases}
\frac{9}{4}+\kappa=\left(\frac{3}{2}+p\right)^2, & \xi=0,\\
\frac{9}{4}-12\xi, & K=1.
\end{cases} \tag*{(15)} ν 2 = { 4 9 + κ = ( 2 3 + p ) 2 , 4 9 − 12 ξ , ξ = 0 , K = 1. (15)
We take p > − 3 / 2 p>-3/2 p > − 3/2 in the kinetic case and ξ < 3 / 16 \xi<3/16 ξ < 3/16 in the curvature case, choosing ν > 0 \nu>0 ν > 0 . The normalized Bunch–Davies solution [68 ] is then given by
v k i n ( τ ) = − π τ 2 e i π ( 2 ν + 1 ) / 4 H ν ( 1 ) ( − k τ ) , (16) v_k^{\mathrm{in}}(\tau)=\frac{\sqrt{-\pi\tau}}{2}e^{i\pi(2\nu+1)/4}H_\nu^{(1)}(-k\tau), \tag*{(16)} v k in ( τ ) = 2 − π τ e iπ ( 2 ν + 1 ) /4 H ν ( 1 ) ( − k τ ) , (16)
where H ν ( 1 ) H_\nu^{(1)} H ν ( 1 ) is the Hankel function of the first kind and the mode approaches e − i k τ / 2 k e^{-ik\tau}/\sqrt{2k} e − ik τ / 2 k as − k τ → ∞ -k\tau\to\infty − k τ → ∞ .
Outside the horizon, − k τ ≪ 1 -k\tau\ll1 − k τ ≪ 1 , the dominant mode satisfies
η k ∝ a ν − 3 / 2 − p , (17) \eta_k\propto a^{\nu-3/2-p}, \tag*{(17)} η k ∝ a ν − 3/2 − p , (17)
with p = 0 p=0 p = 0 in the curvature case. For the kinetic coupling, ν = 3 / 2 + p \nu=3/2+p ν = 3/2 + p , and the field approaches a constant outside the horizon. The kinetic history then sets the frozen spectrum without any subsequent superhorizon growth. A positive curvature coupling, 0 < ξ < 3 / 16 0<\xi<3/16 0 < ξ < 3/16 , instead damps both the fluctuations and the homogeneous displacement, which obey the same long-wavelength equation [65 , 66 ] .
Across τ e \tau_e τ e the field η k \eta_k η k and its conjugate momentum a 2 K 2 η k ′ a^2K^2\eta_k^\prime a 2 K 2 η k ′ are continuous. However, the jump in K ′ K^\prime K ′ makes v k ′ v_k^\prime v k ′ discontinuous, and the matching data are given by
V k ≡ v k ( τ e ) = v k i n ( τ e ) , V_k\equiv v_k(\tau_e)=v_k^{\mathrm{in}}(\tau_e), V k ≡ v k ( τ e ) = v k in ( τ e ) ,
W k ≡ v k ( τ e + ) = v k i n ′ ( τ e ) − p H I V k . (18) W_k\equiv v_k(\tau_e^+)=v_k^{\mathrm{in}\prime}(\tau_e)-pH_I V_k. \tag*{(18)} W k ≡ v k ( τ e + ) = v k in ′ ( τ e ) − p H I V k . (18)
For the curvature coupling, p = 0 p=0 p = 0 and v k ′ v_k^\prime v k ′ is continuous.
In radiation domination K = 1 K=1 K = 1 and R = 0 R=0 R = 0 , and with the constant potential mass retained the mode equation v k ′ ′ + ( k 2 + a 2 m η 2 ) v k = 0 v_k^{\prime\prime}+(k^2+a^2m_\eta^2)v_k=0 v k ′′ + ( k 2 + a 2 m η 2 ) v k = 0 becomes the Weber equation in y ≡ τ + 2 / H I y\equiv\tau+2/H_I y ≡ τ + 2/ H I , where a = H I y a=H_Iy a = H I y . In terms of x ≡ k / m η H I x\equiv k/\sqrt{m_\eta H_I} x ≡ k / m η H I , the normalized positive-frequency out mode is given by
v k o u t ( y ) = e − π x 2 / 8 ( 2 m η H I ) 1 / 4 D − ( 1 + i x 2 ) / 2 ( e i π / 4 2 m η H I y ) , (19) v_k^{\mathrm{out}}(y)=\frac{e^{-\pi x^2/8}}{(2m_\eta H_I)^{1/4}}D_{-(1+ix^2)/2}\left(e^{i\pi/4}\sqrt{2m_\eta H_I}\,y\right), \tag*{(19)} v k out ( y ) = ( 2 m η H I ) 1/4 e − π x 2 /8 D − ( 1 + i x 2 ) /2 ( e iπ /4 2 m η H I y ) , (19)
where D a D_a D a is the parabolic cylinder function.
At late times v k o u t ≃ ( 2 ω k ) − 1 / 2 exp ( − i ∫ ω k d τ ) v_k^{\mathrm{out}}\simeq(2\omega_k)^{-1/2}\exp(-i\int\omega_k\,\mathrm{d}\tau) v k out ≃ ( 2 ω k ) − 1/2 exp ( − i ∫ ω k d τ ) up to a constant phase, with ω k 2 = k 2 + a 2 m η 2 \omega_k^2=k^2+a^2m_\eta^2 ω k 2 = k 2 + a 2 m η 2 . For nonrelativistic modes we have ∣ ω k ′ / ω k 2 ∣ ≃ H / m η |\omega_k^\prime/\omega_k^2|\simeq H/m_\eta ∣ ω k ′ / ω k 2 ∣ ≃ H / m η , and once H ≪ m η H\ll m_\eta H ≪ m η the particle interpretation is adiabatic even for wavelengths larger than the Hubble radius.
After the transition, v k = α k v k o u t + β k v k o u t ∗ v_k=\alpha_kv_k^{\mathrm{out}}+\beta_kv_k^{\mathrm{out}*} v k = α k v k out + β k v k out ∗ , where
α k = i [ v k o u t ∗ W k − v k o u t ∗ ′ V k ] τ e , \alpha_k=i\left[v_k^{\mathrm{out}*}W_k-v_k^{\mathrm{out}*\prime}V_k\right]_{\tau_e}, α k = i [ v k out ∗ W k − v k out ∗ ′ V k ] τ e ,
β k = − i [ v k o u t W k − v k o u t ′ V k ] τ e . (20) \beta_k=-i\left[v_k^{\mathrm{out}}W_k-v_k^{\mathrm{out}\prime}V_k\right]_{\tau_e}. \tag*{(20)} β k = − i [ v k out W k − v k out ′ V k ] τ e . (20)
The coefficients satisfy ∣ α k ∣ 2 − ∣ β k ∣ 2 = 1 |\alpha_k|^2-|\beta_k|^2=1 ∣ α k ∣ 2 − ∣ β k ∣ 2 = 1 and give the late-time occupation number n k = ∣ β k ∣ 2 n_k=|\beta_k|^2 n k = ∣ β k ∣ 2 , which is exact for the specified background and kinetic history, with the potential mass neglected during inflation, and reduces to the minimally coupled calculation of Ref. [34 ] at p = ξ = 0 p=\xi=0 p = ξ = 0 .
If we also neglect the mass after inflation, the out modes are plane waves, and Eqs. (16) and (18) give
n k = ∣ W k ∣ 2 + k 2 ∣ V k ∣ 2 2 k − 1 2 = π 8 q [ ∣ q H ν ′ ( q ) + ( p + 1 2 ) H ν ( q ) ∣ 2 + q 2 ∣ H ν ( q ) ∣ 2 ] − 1 2 , (21) \begin{aligned}
n_k=\frac{|W_k|^2+k^2|V_k|^2}{2k}-\frac{1}{2} \\
&=\frac{\pi}{8q}\left[\left|qH_\nu^{\prime}(q)+\left(p+\frac{1}{2}\right)H_\nu(q)\right|^2+q^2|H_\nu(q)|^2\right]-\frac{1}{2}, \tag*{(21)}
\end{aligned} n k = 2 k ∣ W k ∣ 2 + k 2 ∣ V k ∣ 2 − 2 1 = 8 q π [ q H ν ′ ( q ) + ( p + 2 1 ) H ν ( q ) 2 + q 2 ∣ H ν ( q ) ∣ 2 ] − 2 1 , (21)
where q ≡ k / ( a e H I ) q\equiv k/(a_eH_I) q ≡ k / ( a e H I ) , H ν ≡ H ν ( 1 ) H_\nu\equiv H_\nu^{(1)} H ν ≡ H ν ( 1 ) , and p = 0 p=0 p = 0 for the curvature coupling. For the canonical minimally coupled field (ν = 3 / 2 \nu=3/2 ν = 3/2 ) this is exactly n k = 1 / ( 4 q 4 ) n_k=1/(4q^4) n k = 1/ ( 4 q 4 ) , and at conformal coupling (K = 1 K=1 K = 1 , ξ = 1 / 6 \xi=1/6 ξ = 1/6 , ν = 1 / 2 \nu=1/2 ν = 1/2 ) it vanishes identically, as expected. However, the massive occupation number also depends on the relative phase of V k V_k V k and W k W_k W k and cannot be inferred from the massless result alone.
Infrared spectrum
For q ≪ 1 q\ll1 q ≪ 1 , the field spectrum at the end of inflation, where a e K e = 1 a_eK_e=1 a e K e = 1 , is
P η , e ( k ) = k 3 2 π 2 ∣ V k ∣ 2 ≃ C ν ( H I 2 π ) 2 q 3 − 2 ν , \mathcal{P}_{\eta,e}(k)=\frac{k^3}{2\pi^2}|V_k|^2\simeq\mathcal{C}_\nu\left(\frac{H_I}{2\pi}\right)^2q^{3-2\nu}, P η , e ( k ) = 2 π 2 k 3 ∣ V k ∣ 2 ≃ C ν ( 2 π H I ) 2 q 3 − 2 ν ,
C ν ≡ [ 2 ν − 3 / 2 Γ ( ν ) Γ ( 3 / 2 ) ] 2 , (22) \mathcal{C}_\nu\equiv\left[\frac{2^{\nu-3/2}\Gamma(\nu)}{\Gamma(3/2)}\right]^2, \tag*{(22)} C ν ≡ [ Γ ( 3/2 ) 2 ν − 3/2 Γ ( ν ) ] 2 , (22)
with C 3 / 2 = 1 \mathcal{C}_{3/2}=1 C 3/2 = 1 . We define the spectral tilt of the axion spectrum by
n η − 1 ≡ d ln P η , e d ln k = 3 − 2 ν = { − 2 p , ξ = 0 , 3 − 9 − 48 ξ , K = 1. (23) n_\eta-1\equiv\frac{\mathrm{d}\ln\mathcal{P}_{\eta,e}}{\mathrm{d}\ln k}=3-2\nu=\begin{cases}
-2p, & \xi=0,\\
3-\sqrt{9-48\xi}, & K=1.
\end{cases} \tag*{(23)} n η − 1 ≡ d ln k d ln P η , e = 3 − 2 ν = { − 2 p , 3 − 9 − 48 ξ , ξ = 0 , K = 1. (23)
A positive n η n_\eta n η gives a red spectrum, as earlier modes leave the horizon with a smaller K K K , and for the curvature coupling n η − 1 ≃ 8 ξ n_\eta-1\simeq8\xi n η − 1 ≃ 8 ξ at small ξ \xi ξ .
To leading order in q q q we find W k ≃ d H I V k W_k\simeq dH_IV_k W k ≃ d H I V k , where d ≡ ν − 1 2 − p d\equiv\nu-\frac{1}{2}-p d ≡ ν − 2 1 − p . As long as gradients and the mass are negligible, v k ′ ′ ≃ 0 v_k'' \simeq0 v k ′′ ≃ 0 in radiation domination, and v k = V k + W k ( τ − τ e ) v_k=V_k+W_k(\tau-\tau_e) v k = V k + W k ( τ − τ e ) . With a = 1 + H I ( τ − τ e ) a=1+H_I(\tau-\tau_e) a = 1 + H I ( τ − τ e ) , the axion mode η k = v k / a \eta_k=v_k/a η k = v k / a then evolves as
η k ( a ) ≃ [ d + 1 − d a ] η k , e , (24) \eta_k(a)\simeq\left[d+\frac{1-d}{a}\right]\eta_{k,e}, \tag*{(24)} η k ( a ) ≃ [ d + a 1 − d ] η k , e , (24)
where η k , e = V k \eta_{k,e}=V_k η k , e = V k is its value at the end of inflation, so d η k , e d\eta_{k,e} d η k , e is the amplitude of the constant mode. The kinetic coupling has d = 1 d=1 d = 1 , whereas the curvature coupling has d = ν − 1 2 d=\nu-\frac{1}{2} d = ν − 2 1 , which exceeds unity for ξ < 0 \xi<0 ξ < 0 , lies between zero and unity for 0 < ξ < 1 / 6 0<\xi<1/6 0 < ξ < 1/6 , and becomes negative for 1 / 6 < ξ < 3 / 16 1/6<\xi<3/16 1/6 < ξ < 3/16 .
With μ ≡ m η / H I \mu\equiv m_\eta/H_I μ ≡ m η / H I and n q ≡ n k = q a e H I n_q\equiv n_{k=q a_e H_I} n q ≡ n k = q a e H I , the leading occupation spectrum for q , μ ≪ 1 q,\sqrt{\mu}\ll1 q , μ ≪ 1 and ∣ d ∣ ≫ max ( q , μ ) |d|\gg\max(q,\sqrt{\mu}) ∣ d ∣ ≫ max ( q , μ ) is
q 3 n q 2 π 2 ≃ c R D μ d 2 P η , e ( q ) H I 2 F ( q μ ) , (25) \frac{q^3 n_q}{2\pi^2}\simeq\frac{c_{\rm RD}}{\sqrt{\mu}}\frac{d^2\mathcal{P}_{\eta,e}(q)}{H_I^2}\mathcal{F}\left(\frac{q}{\sqrt{\mu}}\right), \tag*{(25)} 2 π 2 q 3 n q ≃ μ c RD H I 2 d 2 P η , e ( q ) F ( μ q ) , (25)
where c R D = π / [ 2 Γ 2 ( 3 / 4 ) ] ≃ 1.046 c_{\rm RD}=\pi/[2\Gamma^2(3/4)]\simeq1.046 c RD = π / [ 2 Γ 2 ( 3/4 )] ≃ 1.046 and
F ( x ) = Γ 2 ( 3 / 4 ) e − π x 2 / 4 ∣ Γ ( 3 4 + i x 2 4 ) ∣ 2 . (26) \mathcal{F}(x)=\frac{\Gamma^2(3/4)e^{-\pi x^2/4}}{\left|\Gamma\left(\frac{3}{4}+\frac{ix^2}{4}\right)\right|^2}. \tag*{(26)} F ( x ) = Γ ( 4 3 + 4 i x 2 ) 2 Γ 2 ( 3/4 ) e − π x 2 /4 . (26)
The left-hand side is the comoving number per logarithmic momentum interval in units of ( a e H I ) 3 (a_eH_I)^3 ( a e H I ) 3 . The factor d 2 d^2 d 2 accounts for the transfer to the constant radiation era mode, and F \mathcal{F} F describes the subsequent massive evolution (App. A). Note that the same c R D c_{\rm RD} c RD fixes the misalignment normalization, as we show in Sec. IV.
Using F ( 0 ) = 1 \mathcal{F}(0)=1 F ( 0 ) = 1 and F ( x ≫ 1 ) ≃ Γ 2 ( 3 / 4 ) / ( π x ) \mathcal{F}(x\gg1)\simeq\Gamma^2(3/4)/(\pi x) F ( x ≫ 1 ) ≃ Γ 2 ( 3/4 ) / ( π x ) , we find
n q ∝ { q − 2 ν , q ≪ μ , q − 2 ν − 1 , μ ≪ q ≪ 1. (27) n_q\propto\begin{cases}
q^{-2\nu}, & q\ll\sqrt{\mu},\\
q^{-2\nu-1}, & \sqrt{\mu}\ll q\ll1.
\end{cases} \tag*{(27)} n q ∝ { q − 2 ν , q − 2 ν − 1 , q ≪ μ , μ ≪ q ≪ 1. (27)
The turnover occurs near the horizon scale at the onset of oscillations. Defining this onset by H = m η H=m_\eta H = m η gives a o s c = μ − 1 / 2 a_{\rm osc}=\mu^{-1/2} a osc = μ − 1/2 and k o s c = a e m η H I k_{\rm osc}=a_e\sqrt{m_\eta H_I} k osc = a e m η H I , or q o s c = μ q_{\rm osc}=\sqrt{\mu} q osc = μ . Longer modes begin to oscillate outside the horizon and evolve locally like a misalignment field. Shorter modes instead enter the horizon while relativistic and redshift as radiation until they become nonrelativistic, which gives the extra factor 1 / x 1/x 1/ x .
Setting p = ξ = 0 p=\xi=0 p = ξ = 0 , we recover from Eq. (25) the minimally coupled spectrum of Ref. [34 ] , including its normalization. To this order, couplings with the same tilt give the same spectral shape and differ only by d 2 d^2 d 2 . For example, n η − 1 = 0.3 n_\eta-1=0.3 n η − 1 = 0.3 corresponds to p = − 0.15 p=-0.15 p = − 0.15 in the kinetic case and to ξ ≃ 0.0356 \xi\simeq0.0356 ξ ≃ 0.0356 in the curvature case, with transfer coefficients d = 1 d=1 d = 1 and d = 0.85 d=0.85 d = 0.85 , respectively, and the two normalizations differ by d 2 ≃ 0.72 d^2\simeq0.72 d 2 ≃ 0.72 . In Figure 1 we compare Eq. (25) with the full matching.
Figure 1. Late-time occupation spectra for μ ≡ m η / H I = 10 − 8 \mu\equiv m_\eta/H_I = 10^{-8} μ ≡ m η / H I = 1 0 − 8 and four choices of p p p and ξ \xi ξ . Lines show Eq. (25) , and circles show the full matching, Eq. (20) . The turnover lies near q = μ q=\sqrt{\mu} q = μ .
Note that at conformal coupling d = 0 d=0 d = 0 and Eq. (25) does not apply. In this case the full matching gives n q ∝ q − 1 n_q\propto q^{-1} n q ∝ q − 1 in the deep infrared [34 ] , as the nonzero potential mass breaks conformal invariance and allows production.
Infrared cutoff
We separate fluctuations within the present Hubble patch from longer modes, which contribute to its approximately homogeneous axion displacement. Following Refs. [34 , 69 ] , we adopt a sharp split at k I R = a 0 H 0 k_{\rm IR}=a_0H_0 k IR = a 0 H 0 , giving
q I R ≡ k I R a e H I = a 0 H 0 a e H I , (28) q_{\rm IR}\equiv\frac{k_{\rm IR}}{a_eH_I}=\frac{a_0H_0}{a_eH_I}, \tag*{(28)} q IR ≡ a e H I k IR = a e H I a 0 H 0 , (28)
where a 0 a_0 a 0 and H 0 H_0 H 0 are the present scale factor and Hubble rate.
For instantaneous reheating followed by entropy conservation, we find
q I R = H 0 H I T R H T 0 ( g ∗ , s , 0 g ∗ , s , e ) 1 / 3 , q_{\rm IR}=\frac{H_0}{H_I}\frac{T_{\rm RH}}{T_0}\left(\frac{g_{*,s,0}}{g_{*,s,e}}\right)^{1/3}, q IR = H I H 0 T 0 T RH ( g ∗ , s , e g ∗ , s , 0 ) 1/3 ,
T R H = ( 90 π 2 g ∗ , e ) 1 / 4 M P l H I , (29) T_{\rm RH}=\left(\frac{90}{\pi^2g_{*,e}}\right)^{1/4}\sqrt{M_{\rm Pl}H_I}, \tag*{(29)} T RH = ( π 2 g ∗ , e 90 ) 1/4 M Pl H I , (29)
where T R H T_{\rm RH} T RH is the temperature immediately after reheating, T 0 T_0 T 0 is the present photon temperature, and g ∗ , e g_{*,e} g ∗ , e and g ∗ , s g_{*,s} g ∗ , s count the effective energy and entropy degrees of freedom. We assume that inflation began early enough for the lowest included mode to start well inside the horizon and in its adiabatic regime, k I R / ( a i H I ) ≫ max ( 1 , ν 2 − 1 / 4 ) k_{\rm IR}/(a_iH_I)\gg\max(1,\sqrt{\nu^2-1/4}) k IR / ( a i H I ) ≫ max ( 1 , ν 2 − 1/4 ) . Longer inflation only adds modes to the patch mean and leaves the split unchanged.
Integrating Eq. (22) over q I R < q < q m a x ≪ 1 q_{\rm IR}<q<q_{\rm max}\ll1 q IR < q < q max ≪ 1 , we obtain the variance at the end of inflation,
⟨ δ η 2 ⟩ e ≃ C ν ( H I 2 π ) 2 { q m a x 3 − 2 ν − q I R 3 − 2 ν 3 − 2 ν , ν ≠ 3 2 , ln ( q m a x / q I R ) , ν = 3 2 . (30) \langle\delta\eta^2\rangle_e\simeq C_\nu\left(\frac{H_I}{2\pi}\right)^2
\begin{cases}
\dfrac{q_{\rm max}^{3-2\nu}-q_{\rm IR}^{3-2\nu}}{3-2\nu}, & \nu\ne\frac{3}{2},\\
\ln(q_{\rm max}/q_{\rm IR}), & \nu=\frac{3}{2}.
\end{cases} \tag*{(30)} ⟨ δ η 2 ⟩ e ≃ C ν ( 2 π H I ) 2 ⎩ ⎨ ⎧ 3 − 2 ν q max 3 − 2 ν − q IR 3 − 2 ν , ln ( q max / q IR ) , ν = 2 3 , ν = 2 3 . (30)
In the scale-invariant case with ν = 3 / 2 \nu= 3/2 ν = 3/2 , the variance measures the logarithmic range of modes included in the patch fluctuations. In the effectively massless limit, additional inflation before the patch scale left the horizon increases the variance of the patch mean [70 , 71 , 72 ] .
The longest included mode exits the horizon N I R = ln ( 1 / q I R ) N_{\mathrm{IR}} = \ln(1/q_{\mathrm{IR}}) N IR = ln ( 1/ q IR ) e e e -folds before the end of inflation, and neglecting the potential mass requires its accumulated effect on the retained modes to remain small. For the constant-p p p kinetic model, one can show that a sufficient condition is ∫ d N m η 2 / [ ( 3 + 2 p ) K 2 H 2 ] ≪ 1 \int dN\,m_\eta^2/[(3+2p)K^2H^2] \ll1 ∫ d N m η 2 / [( 3 + 2 p ) K 2 H 2 ] ≪ 1 , with the integral taken over these N I R N_{\mathrm{IR}} N IR e e e -folds.
For fixed d ≠ 0 d \ne0 d = 0 , the massive number integral has the same infrared behavior as the variance, i.e., logarithmic at ν = 3 / 2 \nu= 3/2 ν = 3/2 , power-law sensitive to q I R q_{\mathrm{IR}} q IR for a red spectrum, and convergent as q I R → 0 q_{\mathrm{IR}} \to0 q IR → 0 for a blue one. Note that modes below k I R k_{\mathrm{IR}} k IR also oscillate once H < m η H < m_\eta H < m η , without reentering the horizon, and contribute through the local displacement used for misalignment. We use the same split in Sec. IV.
Ultraviolet sensitivity
The sharp transition produces high-frequency tails, and for q ≫ 1 q \gg1 q ≫ 1 the massless result (21) becomes
n k ≃ { p 2 4 q 2 , ξ = 0 , p ≠ 0 , ( 1 − 6 ξ ) 2 4 q 4 , K = 1. (31) n_k \simeq\begin{cases}
\dfrac{p^2}{4q^2}, & \xi= 0,\ p \ne0,\\
\dfrac{(1-6\xi)^2}{4q^4}, & K = 1.
\end{cases} \tag*{(31)} n k ≃ ⎩ ⎨ ⎧ 4 q 2 p 2 , 4 q 4 ( 1 − 6 ξ ) 2 , ξ = 0 , p = 0 , K = 1. (31)
The q − 2 q^{-2} q − 2 tail comes from the jump in K ′ K' K ′ and makes the comoving number diverge linearly. The q − 4 q^{-4} q − 4 tail comes from the jump in a ′ ′ a'' a ′′ , and the number then converges, but the relativistic energy diverges logarithmically unless ξ = 1 / 6 \xi= 1/6 ξ = 1/6 . These tails are artifacts of the sharp transition and are suppressed for k / a e ≫ Δ t − 1 k/a_e \gg\Delta t^{-1} k / a e ≫ Δ t − 1 when the exit lasts a time Δ t \Delta t Δ t .
For the quadratic exponential, an exit at ϕ e = 0 \phi_e = 0 ϕ e = 0 gives K e ′ = 0 K'_e = 0 K e ′ = 0 and removes the q − 2 q^{-2} q − 2 tail, although a nonzero K e ′ ′ K''_e K e ′′ can still change the coefficient of the q − 4 q^{-4} q − 4 tail. As a check, we integrated Eq. (10) through a smooth exit over the last Δ N ≤ 2 \Delta N \le2 Δ N ≤ 2 e e e -folds, with K = 1 K = 1 K = 1 and K e ′ = K e ′ ′ = 0 K'_e = K''_e = 0 K e ′ = K e ′′ = 0 at the transition, and found that for p = − 0.15 p = -0.15 p = − 0.15 and μ = 10 − 8 \mu= 10^{-8} μ = 1 0 − 8 the q − 2 q^{-2} q − 2 tail is suppressed at high momentum, while modes with q ≤ 10 − 2 q \le10^{-2} q ≤ 1 0 − 2 change by less than 0.1 % 0.1\% 0.1% .
Above q ∼ 1 q \sim1 q ∼ 1 the result depends on how reheating proceeds, and for the kinetic coupling the sharp transition makes the number diverge. The abundance is then reliable only if these modes contribute little, which is the case here, as q 3 n q q^3 n_q q 3 n q scales as q 3 − 2 ν q^{3-2\nu} q 3 − 2 ν below the turnover and as q 2 − 2 ν q^{2-2\nu} q 2 − 2 ν above it and, for 1 < ν < 3 / 2 1 < \nu< 3/2 1 < ν < 3/2 , peaks near μ \sqrt{\mu} μ , far below q ∼ 1 q \sim1 q ∼ 1 . Within the instantaneous transition one can follow the spectrum up to q ∼ 1 q \sim1 q ∼ 1 , as the mass plays no role at the matching for q ≫ μ q \gg\sqrt{\mu} q ≫ μ .7
Relic abundance
In a comoving patch we write
η = η ˉ ( t ) + δ η , η c = f η θ c , (32) \eta= \bar{\eta}(t) + \delta\eta,\qquad\eta_c = f_\eta\theta_c, \tag*{(32)} η = η ˉ ( t ) + δ η , η c = f η θ c , (32)
where the mean η ˉ \bar{\eta} η ˉ comes from modes longer than the patch and δ η \delta\eta δ η from shorter ones. As discussed in Sec. III B, the patch is the present Hubble volume. Before the mass term becomes important, the radiation era transfer (24) leaves η ˉ \bar{\eta} η ˉ as a constant mode, with amplitude η c \eta_c η c , and a mode decaying as 1 / a 1/a 1/ a , and we assume that the decaying mode is negligible by the time the field begins to oscillate.
Fluctuations in the band q I R ≤ q ≤ q max q_{\mathrm{IR}} \le q \le q_{\max} q IR ≤ q ≤ q m a x have comoving number density a 3 n η f l u c = H I 3 I a^3n_\eta^{\mathrm{fluc}} = H_I^3\mathcal{I} a 3 n η fluc = H I 3 I , with
I ≡ 1 2 π 2 ∫ q I R q max d q q 2 n q . (33) \mathcal{I} \equiv\frac{1}{2\pi^2}\int_{q_{\mathrm{IR}}}^{q_{\max}}dq\,q^2n_q. \tag*{(33)} I ≡ 2 π 2 1 ∫ q IR q m a x d q q 2 n q . (33)
In all cases studied below, the modes that dominate the abundance become nonrelativistic well before matter–radiation equality, and those that are still relativistic at that time carry a negligible share of the energy. We can then take ρ η f l u c ≃ m η n η f l u c \rho_\eta^{\mathrm{fluc}} \simeq m_\eta n_\eta^{\mathrm{fluc}} ρ η fluc ≃ m η n η fluc .
After reheating the entropy density is s e = ( 2 π 2 / 45 ) g ∗ , s , e T R H 3 s_e = (2\pi^2/45)g_{*,s,e}T_{\mathrm{RH}}^3 s e = ( 2 π 2 /45 ) g ∗ , s , e T RH 3 , with T R H T_{\mathrm{RH}} T RH from Eq. (29) . Once production has ended, the yield n η f l u c / s = H I 3 I / s e n_\eta^{\mathrm{fluc}}/s = H_I^3\mathcal{I}/s_e n η fluc / s = H I 3 I / s e stays constant, provided the axion is stable and decoupled and entropy is conserved, and the fluctuation abundance is given by
Ω η f l u c h 2 = 2.744 × 10 8 ( m η G e V ) H I 3 I s e . (34) \Omega_\eta^{\mathrm{fluc}}h^2 = 2.744 \times10^8 \left(\frac{m_\eta}{\mathrm{GeV}}\right)\frac{H_I^3\mathcal{I}}{s_e}. \tag*{(34)} Ω η fluc h 2 = 2.744 × 1 0 8 ( GeV m η ) s e H I 3 I . (34)
For misalignment we use the regular homogeneous solution, treating the relativistic degrees of freedom as constant through the onset of oscillations. In radiation domination, with the time origin chosen so that a 2 = 2 H I t a^2 = 2H_I t a 2 = 2 H I t , we have H = 1 / ( 2 t ) H = 1/(2t) H = 1/ ( 2 t ) and find
η ˉ ( t ) η c = Γ ( 5 / 4 ) ( m η t 2 ) − 1 / 4 J 1 / 4 ( m η t ) , (35) \frac{\bar{\eta}(t)}{\eta_c} = \Gamma(5/4)\left(\frac{m_\eta t}{2}\right)^{-1/4}J_{1/4}(m_\eta t), \tag*{(35)} η c η ˉ ( t ) = Γ ( 5/4 ) ( 2 m η t ) − 1/4 J 1/4 ( m η t ) , (35)
which approaches unity as m η t → 0 m_\eta t \to0 m η t → 0 . The other solution behaves as t − 1 / 2 ∝ 1 / a t^{-1/2} \propto1/a t − 1/2 ∝ 1/ a at early times and is the decaying mode we have neglected. Averaging over oscillations at m η t ≫ 1 m_\eta t \gg1 m η t ≫ 1 , we find a 3 ρ η m i s = c R D η c 2 m η 1 / 2 H I 3 / 2 a^3\rho_\eta^{\mathrm{mis}} = c_{\mathrm{RD}}\,\eta_c^2m_\eta^{1/2}H_I^{3/2} a 3 ρ η mis = c RD η c 2 m η 1/2 H I 3/2 , with c R D = 4 Γ 2 ( 5 / 4 ) / π = [ 2 Γ 2 ( 3 / 4 ) ] c_{\mathrm{RD}} = 4\Gamma^2(5/4)/\pi= [2\Gamma^2(3/4)] c RD = 4 Γ 2 ( 5/4 ) / π = [ 2 Γ 2 ( 3/4 )] as in Eq. (25) . The misalignment abundance can then be written as
Ω η m i s h 2 = 2.744 × 10 8 c R D η c 2 m η 1 / 2 H I 3 / 2 s e G e V . (36) \Omega_\eta^{\mathrm{mis}}h^2 = 2.744 \times10^8\frac{c_{\mathrm{RD}}\,\eta_c^2m_\eta^{1/2}H_I^{3/2}}{s_e\,\mathrm{GeV}}. \tag*{(36)} Ω η mis h 2 = 2.744 × 1 0 8 s e GeV c RD η c 2 m η 1/2 H I 3/2 . (36)
As s e ∝ ( M P l H I ) 3 / 2 s_e \propto(M_{\mathrm{Pl}}H_I)^{3/2} s e ∝ ( M Pl H I ) 3/2 , the displacement that gives the observed abundance does not depend on H I H_I H I ,
η D M = 1.08 × 10 10 G e V ( 10 M e V m η ) 1 / 4 ( g ∗ , e 106.75 ) 1 / 8 , (37) \eta_{\mathrm{DM}}=1.08\times10^{10}\,\mathrm{GeV}\left(\frac{10\,\mathrm{MeV}}{m_\eta}\right)^{1/4}\left(\frac{g_{\ast,e}}{106.75}\right)^{1/8}, \tag*{(37)} η DM = 1.08 × 1 0 10 GeV ( m η 10 MeV ) 1/4 ( 106.75 g ∗ , e ) 1/8 , (37)
for g ∗ s , e = g ∗ , e g_{\ast s,e}=g_{\ast,e} g ∗ s , e = g ∗ , e .
In terms of η D M \eta_{\mathrm{DM}} η DM , Eq. (36) reads Ω η m i s h 2 = 0.12 η c 2 / η D M 2 \Omega_\eta^{\mathrm{mis}}h^2=0.12\,\eta_c^2/\eta_{\mathrm{DM}}^2 Ω η mis h 2 = 0.12 η c 2 / η DM 2 . Comparing Eqs. (34) and (36) , we find that the fluctuations give the same abundance as a homogeneous displacement Q \sqrt{Q} Q , with
Q ≡ H I 2 μ c R D I , (38) Q\equiv\frac{H_I^2\sqrt{\mu}}{c_{\mathrm{RD}}}\mathcal{I}, \tag*{(38)} Q ≡ c RD H I 2 μ I , (38)
so that Ω η f l u c h 2 = 0.12 Q / η D M 2 \Omega_\eta^{\mathrm{fluc}}h^2=0.12\,Q/\eta_{\mathrm{DM}}^2 Ω η fluc h 2 = 0.12 Q / η DM 2 and
Ω η f l u c Ω η m i s = Q f η 2 θ c 2 . (39) \frac{\Omega_\eta^{\mathrm{fluc}}}{\Omega_\eta^{\mathrm{mis}}}=\frac{Q}{f_\eta^2\theta_c^2}. \tag*{(39)} Ω η mis Ω η fluc = f η 2 θ c 2 Q . (39)
Fluctuations alone then give the observed abundance at the mass m ∗ m_\ast m ∗ where Q = η D M 2 Q=\eta_{\mathrm{DM}}^2 Q = η DM 2 . Using Eq. (25) , Q Q Q can be written as
Q ≃ d 2 ∫ q I R q max d ln q P η , e ( q ) F ( x ) , x ≡ q / μ . (40) Q\simeq d^2\int_{q_{\mathrm{IR}}}^{q_{\max}}\mathrm{d}\ln q\,P_{\eta,e}(q)\,\mathcal{F}(x),\qquad x\equiv q/\sqrt{\mu}. \tag*{(40)} Q ≃ d 2 ∫ q IR q m a x d ln q P η , e ( q ) F ( x ) , x ≡ q / μ . (40)
The modes that set Q Q Q depend on the tilt. For a red spectrum the longest modes dominate, and Q Q Q depends on q I R q_{\mathrm{IR}} q IR . For a flat spectrum every logarithmic interval below the turnover contributes equally, and Q ∝ ln ( μ / q I R ) Q\propto\ln(\sqrt{\mu}/q_{\mathrm{IR}}) Q ∝ ln ( μ / q IR ) .
For a blue spectrum, 1 < ν < 3 / 2 1<\nu<3/2 1 < ν < 3/2 , the contribution per logarithmic interval peaks near q ∼ μ q\sim\sqrt{\mu} q ∼ μ and the integral converges at both ends. In this case the cutoffs contribute little for q I R ≪ μ ≪ q max ≪ 1 q_{\mathrm{IR}}\ll\sqrt{\mu}\ll q_{\max}\ll1 q IR ≪ μ ≪ q m a x ≪ 1 , and extending the integral to 0 < x < ∞ 0<x<\infty 0 < x < ∞ gives
Q ≃ d 2 C ν ( H I 2 π ) 2 J μ ( n η − 1 ) / 2 , (41) Q\simeq d^2\mathcal{C}_\nu\left(\frac{H_I}{2\pi}\right)^2\mathcal{J}\,\mu^{(n_\eta-1)/2}, \tag*{(41)} Q ≃ d 2 C ν ( 2 π H I ) 2 J μ ( n η − 1 ) /2 , (41)
with J ≡ ∫ 0 ∞ d x x 2 − 2 ν F ( x ) \mathcal{J}\equiv\int_0^\infty\mathrm{d}x\,x^{2-2\nu}\mathcal{F}(x) J ≡ ∫ 0 ∞ d x x 2 − 2 ν F ( x ) . For fixed g ∗ g_\ast g ∗ , the abundance then scales as
Ω η f l u c ∝ H I 2 − ( n η − 1 ) / 2 m η n η / 2 . (42) \Omega_\eta^{\mathrm{fluc}}\propto H_I^{2-(n_\eta-1)/2}m_\eta^{n_\eta/2}. \tag*{(42)} Ω η fluc ∝ H I 2 − ( n η − 1 ) /2 m η n η /2 . (42)
As μ ≪ 1 \mu\ll1 μ ≪ 1 , a bluer spectrum gives less abundance at a given mass and requires a heavier axion.
Ref. [67 ] estimated this abundance for a light scalar with arbitrary ξ \xi ξ by following modes through horizon exit and reentry, and found it dominated by modes near k ≃ k o s c k\simeq k_{\mathrm{osc}} k ≃ k osc . In their estimate a mode still outside the horizon at the onset of oscillations carries only its gradient energy at that time, which suppresses it by ( k / k o s c ) 2 (k/k_{\mathrm{osc}})^2 ( k / k osc ) 2 . Its potential energy m η 2 ∣ η k ∣ 2 / 2 m_\eta^2|\eta_k|^2/2 m η 2 ∣ η k ∣ 2 /2 is larger by a factor of order ( k o s c / k ) 2 (k_{\mathrm{osc}}/k)^2 ( k osc / k ) 2 , and these modes evolve like a local misalignment field, F ≃ 1 \mathcal{F}\simeq1 F ≃ 1 . Applied to the QCD axion with f η = H I f_\eta=H_I f η = H I , which maximizes their abundance, the estimate makes the fluctuations important for ξ ≲ − 0.033 \xi\lesssim-0.033 ξ ≲ − 0.033 . Such couplings give red spectra, which exceed our pivot benchmark by many orders of magnitude if the fluctuations account for all of the dark matter (Sec. V).8
We take a low and a high inflationary scale, H I = 10 10 H_I=10^{10} H I = 1 0 10 and 10 13 G e V 10^{13}\,\mathrm{GeV} 1 0 13 GeV , with g ∗ , e = g ∗ s , e = 106.75 g_{\ast,e}=g_{\ast s,e}=106.75 g ∗ , e = g ∗ s , e = 106.75 , g ∗ s , 0 = 3.91 g_{\ast s,0}=3.91 g ∗ s , 0 = 3.91 , T 0 = 2.7255 K T_0=2.7255\,\mathrm{K} T 0 = 2.7255 K , h = 0.674 h=0.674 h = 0.674 , and q max = 10 − 2 q_{\max}=10^{-2} q m a x = 1 0 − 2 . The CMB pivot k ∗ = 0.05 M p c − 1 k_\ast=0.05\,\mathrm{Mpc}^{-1} k ∗ = 0.05 Mpc − 1 then leaves the horizon N ∗ ≡ ln ( a e H I / k ∗ ) = 51.7 N_\ast\equiv\ln(a_eH_I/k_\ast)=51.7 N ∗ ≡ ln ( a e H I / k ∗ ) = 51.7 and 55.2 55.2 55.2 e-folds before the end of inflation, from Eq. (29) with a 0 H 0 a_0H_0 a 0 H 0 replaced by k ∗ k_\ast k ∗ .
The mass m ∗ m_\ast m ∗ rises steeply with the tilt and, from Eq. (42) , falls with the inflationary scale as m ∗ ∝ H I − ( 5 − n η ) / n η m_\ast\propto H_I^{-(5-n_\eta)/n_\eta} m ∗ ∝ H I − ( 5 − n η ) / n η (see Figure 2 ). For example, for n η − 1 = 0.3 n_\eta-1=0.3 n η − 1 = 0.3 we find m ∗ = 384 G e V m_\ast=384\,\mathrm{GeV} m ∗ = 384 GeV at H I = 10 10 G e V H_I=10^{10}\,\mathrm{GeV} H I = 1 0 10 GeV , where Q / η D M = 7.7 × 10 8 G e V \sqrt{Q}/\eta_{\mathrm{DM}}=7.7\times10^8\,\mathrm{GeV} Q / η DM = 7.7 × 1 0 8 GeV , and m ∗ = 1.1 k e V m_\ast=1.1\,\mathrm{keV} m ∗ = 1.1 keV at H I = 10 13 G e V H_I=10^{13}\,\mathrm{GeV} H I = 1 0 13 GeV . The curvature coupling with the same tilt has d 2 ≃ 0.72 d^2\simeq0.72 d 2 ≃ 0.72 , which lowers its abundance at fixed mass by this factor and raises its m ∗ m_\ast m ∗ by about 1.65 1.65 1.65 .
Figure 2. The axion mass m ∗ m_\ast m ∗ at which the fluctuations alone give Ω η h 2 = 0.12 \Omega_\eta h^2=0.12 Ω η h 2 = 0.12 , as a function of the tilt, for constant kinetic slope. Curves are labeled by H I H_I H I in GeV, and 4.7 × 10 13 G e V 4.7 \times10^{13}\,\mathrm{GeV} 4.7 × 1 0 13 GeV is the tensor bound, H I < π M P l r A s / 2 H_I < \pi M_{\mathrm{Pl}}\sqrt{rA_s/2} H I < π M Pl r A s /2 with tensor-to-scalar ratio r < 0.036 r < 0.036 r < 0.036 [73 ] and scalar amplitude A s = 2.1 × 10 − 9 A_s=2.1\times10^{-9} A s = 2.1 × 1 0 − 9 . Thick segments satisfy the pivot isocurvature benchmark [51 ] with zero mean, thin segments exceed it, and black dots mark the threshold P S = P S max P_S=P_S^{\max} P S = P S m a x . The smallest allowed mass is 4.5 k e V 4.5\,\mathrm{keV} 4.5 keV at H I = 10 13 G e V H_I=10^{13}\,\mathrm{GeV} H I = 1 0 13 GeV and 0.14 k e V 0.14\,\mathrm{keV} 0.14 keV at the tensor bound.
These masses require long-lived, weakly coupled ALPs. A photon coupling g η γ γ = α e m / ( 2 π f η ) g_{\eta\gamma\gamma} = \alpha_{\rm em}/(2\pi f_\eta) g η γ γ = α em / ( 2 π f η ) , for example, with f η = 10 12 G e V f_\eta= 10^{12}\ \mathrm{GeV} f η = 1 0 12 GeV gives a photon-decay lifetime of only 1.7 s at m η = 384 G e V m_\eta= 384\ \mathrm{GeV} m η = 384 GeV . An exact η → − η \eta\to-\eta η → − η symmetry can forbid single-axion decays, but it does not by itself suppress thermal pair production. The QCD axion, whose mass is fixed by f η f_\eta f η and depends on temperature, does not lie on these curves, and we treat it separately in § 0.5 A. For n η − 1 ≥ 0.1 n_\eta-1 \ge0.1 n η − 1 ≥ 0.1 at both scales the field starts to oscillate above 10 3 G e V 10^3\ \mathrm{GeV} 1 0 3 GeV , where g ∗ g_* g ∗ is constant and Eq. (35) holds.
Isocurvature
Once the axion behaves as pressureless matter, its entropy perturbation relative to the radiation is, at linear order, given by
S η = 3 ( ζ η − ζ γ ) = δ ρ η ρ ˉ η − 3 4 δ ρ γ ρ ˉ γ . (43) S_\eta= 3(\zeta_\eta-\zeta_\gamma) = \frac{\delta\rho_\eta}{\bar{\rho}_\eta} - \frac{3}{4}\frac{\delta\rho_\gamma}{\bar{\rho}_\gamma}. \tag*{(43)} S η = 3 ( ζ η − ζ γ ) = ρ ˉ η δ ρ η − 4 3 ρ ˉ γ δ ρ γ . (43)
where ζ i \zeta_i ζ i is the curvature perturbation on uniform-density slices of species i i i . Adiabaticity is a property of the perturbations, not of the mechanism that set the mean density [74 , 75 ] , and an axion made of vacuum fluctuations need not be adiabatic. Inflationary axion isocurvature was studied in Refs. [8 , 9 ] . However, since the density is quadratic in the field, a vanishing mean removes the linear contribution but leaves a quadratic one. At zero mean the leading density perturbation is therefore quadratic in the field, and by linear order we mean linear in δ ρ η \delta\rho_\eta δ ρ η , not in δ η \delta\eta δ η .
Modes that are still outside the horizon when the oscillations begin, k I R < k ≪ k o s c k_{\rm IR} < k \ll k_{\rm osc} k IR < k ≪ k osc , are frozen at that time and shift the local misalignment displacement from η c \eta_c η c to η c + X \eta_c + X η c + X . Here X X X is the long-wavelength part of δ η \delta\eta δ η after the radiation era transfer (24) , in which each mode enters with its constant amplitude d η k , e d\,\eta_{k,e} d η k , e , and X X X is Gaussian with
P X ( k ) = d 2 P η , e ( k ) = d 2 C ν ( H I 2 π ) 2 q 3 − 2 ν . (44) \mathcal{P}_X(k) = d^2\mathcal{P}_{\eta,e}(k) = d^2\mathcal{C}_\nu\left(\frac{H_I}{2\pi}\right)^2q^{3-2\nu}. \tag*{(44)} P X ( k ) = d 2 P η , e ( k ) = d 2 C ν ( 2 π H I ) 2 q 3 − 2 ν . (44)
On scales k ≪ k o s c k \ll k_{\rm osc} k ≪ k osc the long-mode density on a uniform-radiation slice is then proportional to ( η c + X ) 2 (\eta_c+X)^2 ( η c + X ) 2 , and including the short modes in the mean density gives
δ ρ η ρ ˉ η ≃ 2 η c X + X 2 − ⟨ X 2 ⟩ η c 2 + Q . (45) \frac{\delta\rho_\eta}{\bar{\rho}_\eta} \simeq\frac{2\eta_cX+X^2-\langle X^2\rangle}{\eta_c^2+Q}. \tag*{(45)} ρ ˉ η δ ρ η ≃ η c 2 + Q 2 η c X + X 2 − ⟨ X 2 ⟩ . (45)
The numerator omits the short modes, which we estimate below, and ⟨ X 2 ⟩ < Q \langle X^2\rangle< Q ⟨ X 2 ⟩ < Q because X X X contains only the long modes. If the rest of the dark matter is adiabatic, the total cold dark matter entropy perturbation is S = ( Ω η / Ω c ) S η S=(\Omega_\eta/\Omega_c)S_\eta S = ( Ω η / Ω c ) S η , with Ω c \Omega_c Ω c the cold dark matter density, and its power spectrum follows from Wick’s theorem,
P S ( k ) ≃ ( Ω η Ω c ) 2 4 η c 2 P X ( k ) + P X 2 ( k ) ( η c 2 + Q ) 2 , (46) \mathcal{P}_S(k) \simeq\left(\frac{\Omega_\eta}{\Omega_c}\right)^2\frac{4\eta_c^2\mathcal{P}_X(k)+\mathcal{P}_{X^2}(k)}{(\eta_c^2+Q)^2}, \tag*{(46)} P S ( k ) ≃ ( Ω c Ω η ) 2 ( η c 2 + Q ) 2 4 η c 2 P X ( k ) + P X 2 ( k ) , (46)
with
P X 2 ( k ) = k 3 π 2 ∫ d 3 ℓ ( 2 π ) 3 P X ( ℓ ) P X ( ∣ k − ℓ ∣ ) (47) \mathcal{P}_{X^2}(k)=\frac{k^3}{\pi^2}\int\frac{d^3\ell}{(2\pi)^3}\mathcal{P}_X(\ell)\mathcal{P}_X(\lvert\mathbf{k}-\boldsymbol{\ell}\rvert) \tag*{(47)} P X 2 ( k ) = π 2 k 3 ∫ ( 2 π ) 3 d 3 ℓ P X ( ℓ ) P X (∣ k − ℓ ∣) (47)
and P X = 2 π 2 P X / k 3 \mathcal{P}_X=2\pi^2\mathcal{P}_X/k^3 P X = 2 π 2 P X / k 3 . The first term describes the interference between the mean and the fluctuations. The second term survives at η c = 0 \eta_c=0 η c = 0 , where S η S_\eta S η is, in the long-mode approximation, a shifted and rescaled χ 2 \chi^2 χ 2 field [76 , 77 , 78 , 79 ] .
Modes with q ≳ μ q \gtrsim\sqrt{\mu} q ≳ μ require the momentum-dependent kernel of App. B. On scales k ≪ k o s c k \ll k_{\rm osc} k ≪ k osc they give white noise, P S ∝ k 3 \mathcal{P}_S \propto k^3 P S ∝ k 3 , which is subdominant at small k k k for ν > 3 / 4 \nu>3/4 ν > 3/4 . Note that white noise dominates only when the short modes dominate the convolution, as for superheavy dark matter [30 , 31 , 80 ] .
For 3 / 4 < ν < 3 / 2 3/4<\nu<3/2 3/4 < ν < 3/2 and q I R ≪ q ∗ ≪ μ q_{\rm IR}\ll q_*\ll\sqrt{\mu} q IR ≪ q ∗ ≪ μ , with q ∗ = e − N ∗ q_*=e^{-N_*} q ∗ = e − N ∗ , the convolution converges at both ends. We nevertheless keep the infrared cutoff, whose effect remains appreciable near scale invariance. Modes longer than the present horizon belong to no, and both momenta in Eq. (47) must satisfy ∣ ℓ ∣ , ∣ k − ℓ ∣ > k I R |\ell|,|\mathbf{k}-\boldsymbol{\ell}|>k_{\rm IR} ∣ ℓ ∣ , ∣ k − ℓ ∣ > k IR , which gives
P S ( k ∗ ) ≃ ( Ω η Ω c ) 2 4 η c 2 P X ( k ∗ ) + D c P X 2 ( k ∗ ) ( η c 2 + Q ) 2 , (48) \mathcal{P}_S(k_*) \simeq\left(\frac{\Omega_\eta}{\Omega_c}\right)^2\frac{4\eta_c^2\mathcal{P}_X(k_*)+\mathcal{D}_c\,\mathcal{P}_X^2(k_*)}{(\eta_c^2+Q)^2}, \tag*{(48)} P S ( k ∗ ) ≃ ( Ω c Ω η ) 2 ( η c 2 + Q ) 2 4 η c 2 P X ( k ∗ ) + D c P X 2 ( k ∗ ) , (48)
where D c ( ν ; q I R / q ∗ ) \mathcal{D}_c(\nu;q_{\rm IR}/q_*) D c ( ν ; q IR / q ∗ ) is given in App. B and corrections from the short modes are suppressed by ( q ∗ / μ ) 4 ν − 3 (q_*/\sqrt{\mu})^{4\nu-3} ( q ∗ / μ ) 4 ν − 3 . Without the cutoff,
D ( ν ) = π 2 Γ 2 ( 3 2 − ν ) Γ ( 2 ν − 3 2 ) Γ 2 ( ν ) Γ ( 3 − 2 ν ) , 3 4 < ν < 3 2 . (49) \mathcal{D}(\nu)=\frac{\sqrt{\pi}}{2}\frac{\Gamma^2\left(\frac{3}{2}-\nu\right)\Gamma\left(2\nu-\frac{3}{2}\right)}{\Gamma^2(\nu)\Gamma(3-2\nu)},\qquad\frac{3}{4}<\nu<\frac{3}{2}. \tag*{(49)} D ( ν ) = 2 π Γ 2 ( ν ) Γ ( 3 − 2 ν ) Γ 2 ( 2 3 − ν ) Γ ( 2 ν − 2 3 ) , 4 3 < ν < 2 3 . (49)
If the axion makes up all of the dark matter and the mean vanishes,
P S ( k ∗ ) ≃ D c P X 2 ( k ∗ ) Q 2 . (50) \mathcal{P}_S(k_*)\simeq\mathcal{D}_c\frac{\mathcal{P}_X^2(k_*)}{Q^2}. \tag*{(50)} P S ( k ∗ ) ≃ D c Q 2 P X 2 ( k ∗ ) . (50)
Up to D c \mathcal{D}_c D c , this is the square of P X ( k ∗ ) / Q \mathcal{P}_X(k_*)/Q P X ( k ∗ ) / Q , the fraction of Q Q Q per logarithmic interval at the pivot. For 1 < ν < 3 / 2 1<\nu<3/2 1 < ν < 3/2 and negligible endpoint corrections, Eq. (41) turns it into ( D c / J 2 ) ( q ∗ / μ ) 6 − 4 ν (\mathcal{D}_c/\mathcal{J}^2)(q_*/\sqrt{\mu})^{6-4\nu} ( D c / J 2 ) ( q ∗ / μ ) 6 − 4 ν , and the pivot power is set by the separation between the CMB and oscillation scales. Far above the cutoff the isocurvature spectrum is blue, with tilt 2 ( n η − 1 ) 2(n_\eta-1) 2 ( n η − 1 ) .
As a benchmark, we use the Planck limit on uncorrelated, scale-invariant cold dark matter isocurvature at the pivot, β i s o < 0.038 \beta_{\rm iso}<0.038 β iso < 0.038 [17 ] , which for A s = 2.1 × 10 − 9 A_s=2.1\times10^{-9} A s = 2.1 × 1 0 − 9 gives10
P S ( k ∗ ) < P S max ≡ β i s o 1 − β i s o A s = 8.3 × 10 − 11 . (51) \mathcal{P}_S(k_*)<\mathcal{P}_S^{\max}\equiv\frac{\beta_{\rm iso}}{1-\beta_{\rm iso}}A_s=8.3\times10^{-11}. \tag*{(51)} P S ( k ∗ ) < P S m a x ≡ 1 − β iso β iso A s = 8.3 × 1 0 − 11 . (51)
Figure 3 shows the abundance ratio, the dark matter line, and the region that exceeds this benchmark for blue spectra.11 When the fluctuations make up all of the dark matter, the flat and mildly red spectra of Figure 4 give P S ( k ∗ ) ∼ 10 − 2 P_S(k_*) \sim10^{-2} P S ( k ∗ ) ∼ 1 0 − 2 –10 − 1 10^{-1} 1 0 − 1 , as their long-wavelength power is not suppressed. Blue spectra move Q Q Q to small scales, and at H I = 10 10 G e V H_I = 10^{10}\ \mathrm{GeV} H I = 1 0 10 GeV we find that they satisfy the benchmark
Figure 3. Fluctuation to misalignment abundance ratio for the kinetic coupling at H I = 10 10 G e V H_I = 10^{10}\ \mathrm{GeV} H I = 1 0 10 GeV (top) and 10 13 G e V 10^{13}\ \mathrm{GeV} 1 0 13 GeV (bottom), for n η − 1 = 0.3 n_\eta- 1 = 0.3 n η − 1 = 0.3 (left) and 0.4 0.4 0.4 (right). The color shows Ω η f l u c / Ω η m i s = Q / ( f η θ c ) 2 \Omega_\eta^{\mathrm{fluc}}/\Omega_\eta^{\mathrm{mis}} = Q/(f_\eta\theta_c)^2 Ω η fluc / Ω η mis = Q / ( f η θ c ) 2 , and the dashed line marks equal contributions. The thick black line corresponds to Ω η h 2 = 0.12 \Omega_\eta h^2 = 0.12 Ω η h 2 = 0.12 and above it, in gray, the axion overcloses the universe, and the line drops vertically at m ∗ m_* m ∗ . Thin dotted lines mark Ω η = 0.1 Ω c \Omega_\eta= 0.1\Omega_c Ω η = 0.1 Ω c and 0.01 Ω c 0.01\Omega_c 0.01 Ω c , labeled 10% and 1% in panel (a). Hatched regions exceed the pivot benchmark (51) , with P S P_S P S from Eq. (46) and Ω η / Ω c = ( η c 2 + Q ) / η D M 2 \Omega_\eta/\Omega_c = (\eta_c^2 + Q)/\eta_{\mathrm{DM}}^2 Ω η / Ω c = ( η c 2 + Q ) / η DM 2 . The right axes give ∣ θ c ∣ |\theta_c| ∣ θ c ∣ for f η = T R H f_\eta= T_{\mathrm{RH}} f η = T RH , the approximate thermal restoration boundary for T c ≃ f η T_c \simeq f_\eta T c ≃ f η , with T R H T_{\mathrm{RH}} T RH listed in each panel.
Figure 4. Same as Figure 3 for a red spectrum, n η − 1 = − 0.05 n_\eta- 1 = -0.05 n η − 1 = − 0.05 (left), and a flat one, n η − 1 = 0 n_\eta- 1 = 0 n η − 1 = 0 (right). The fluctuations alone supply the dark matter at m ∗ = 2.2 × 10 5 e V m_* = 2.2 \times10^5\,\mathrm{eV} m ∗ = 2.2 × 1 0 5 eV and 1.1 × 10 7 e V 1.1 \times10^7\,\mathrm{eV} 1.1 × 1 0 7 eV for H I = 10 10 G e V H_I = 10^{10}\,\mathrm{GeV} H I = 1 0 10 GeV , and at 2.1 × 10 − 7 e V 2.1 \times10^{-7}\,\mathrm{eV} 2.1 × 1 0 − 7 eV and 2.4 × 10 − 5 e V 2.4 \times10^{-5}\,\mathrm{eV} 2.4 × 1 0 − 5 eV for H I = 10 13 G e V H_I = 10^{13}\,\mathrm{GeV} H I = 1 0 13 GeV . Along the whole dark matter line shown the isocurvature exceeds the pivot benchmark. Only a small, subdominant axion component at low mass satisfies it.
n η − 1 > 0.27 (kinetic, constant p ) , ξ > 0.032 (curvature) , (52) \begin{aligned}
n_\eta- 1 &> 0.27 \qquad\text{(kinetic, constant }p\text{)},\\
\xi&> 0.032 \qquad\text{(curvature)}, \tag*{(52)}
\end{aligned} n η − 1 ξ > 0.27 (kinetic, constant p ) , > 0.032 (curvature) , (52)
with m η ≳ 200 G e V m_\eta\gtrsim200\ \mathrm{GeV} m η ≳ 200 GeV and 310 G e V 310\ \mathrm{GeV} 310 GeV , respectively. The curvature threshold corresponds to n η − 1 > 0.26 n_\eta- 1 > 0.26 n η − 1 > 0.26 , in agreement with ξ ≳ 0.03 \xi\gtrsim0.03 ξ ≳ 0.03 found in Ref. [66 ] . Above the threshold the pivot power falls quickly, by five orders of magnitude at n η − 1 = 0.4 n_\eta- 1 = 0.4 n η − 1 = 0.4 , and for n η − 1 = 0.3 n_\eta- 1 = 0.3 n η − 1 = 0.3 , with zero mean we find P S ( k ∗ ) ≃ 4 × 10 − 12 P_S(k_*) \simeq4 \times10^{-12} P S ( k ∗ ) ≃ 4 × 1 0 − 12 , with the isocurvature power exceeding the adiabatic power A s A_s A s only for k ≳ 10 3 M p c − 1 k \gtrsim10^3\ \mathrm{Mpc}^{-1} k ≳ 1 0 3 Mpc − 1 . As shown in Figure 2 , the threshold increases with the scale of inflation, from n η − 1 > n_\eta- 1 > n η − 1 > 0.26 0.26 0.26 at H I = 5 × 10 9 G e V H_I = 5 \times10^9\,\mathrm{GeV} H I = 5 × 1 0 9 GeV to 0.34 0.34 0.34 at H I = 10 13 G e V H_I = 10^{13}\,\mathrm{GeV} H I = 1 0 13 GeV (where m η ≳ 4.5 k e V m_\eta\gtrsim4.5\,\mathrm{keV} m η ≳ 4.5 keV ) and 0.36 0.36 0.36 at the tensor bound, H I = 4.7 × 10 13 G e V H_I = 4.7 \times10^{13}\,\mathrm{GeV} H I = 4.7 × 1 0 13 GeV [73 ] . Over the same range the threshold mass decreases from 1.4 T e V 1.4\,\mathrm{TeV} 1.4 TeV to 0.14 k e V 0.14\,\mathrm{keV} 0.14 keV . Below 5 × 10 9 G e V 5 \times10^9\,\mathrm{GeV} 5 × 1 0 9 GeV the turnover approaches q max q_{\max} q m a x and the fixed band becomes sensitive to the cutoff.
On smaller scales the isocurvature grows but is still allowed. For n η − 1 = 0.3 n_\eta- 1 = 0.3 n η − 1 = 0.3 at H I = 10 10 G e V H_I = 10^{10}\,\mathrm{GeV} H I = 1 0 10 GeV we find P S ≃ 3 × 10 − 11 \mathcal{P}_S \simeq3 \times10^{-11} P S ≃ 3 × 1 0 − 11 at k = 1 M p c − 1 k = 1\,\mathrm{Mpc}^{-1} k = 1 Mpc − 1 , where the Lyman-α \alpha α forest gives the strongest small-scale limit [83 ] , and P S ≃ 8 × 10 − 9 \mathcal{P}_S \simeq8 \times10^{-9} P S ≃ 8 × 1 0 − 9 at k = 10 4 M p c − 1 k = 10^4\,\mathrm{Mpc}^{-1} k = 1 0 4 Mpc − 1 . On these scales the μ \mu μ distortion from cold dark matter isocurvature is suppressed by ( k e q / k ) 2 (k_{\mathrm{eq}}/k)^2 ( k eq / k ) 2 [83 ] , and for this spectrum we estimate the μ \mu μ -type distortion is at most of order ≲ 10 − 15 \lesssim10^{-15} ≲ 1 0 − 15 , many orders of magnitude below the COBE/FIRAS bound.
Along the dark matter line, η c 2 + Q = η D M 2 \eta_c^2 + Q = \eta_{\mathrm{DM}}^2 η c 2 + Q = η DM 2 , a residual mean adds the linear term, which on the fluctuation-dominated branch limits how large the mean can be. In Figure 3 the fluctuation-dominated end of the dark matter line satisfies the benchmark for n η − 1 = 0.3 n_\eta- 1 = 0.3 n η − 1 = 0.3 only at H I = 10 10 G e V H_I = 10^{10}\,\mathrm{GeV} H I = 1 0 10 GeV , and for n η − 1 = 0.4 n_\eta- 1 = 0.4 n η − 1 = 0.4 at both scales. We find that at H I = 10 10 G e V H_I = 10^{10}\,\mathrm{GeV} H I = 1 0 10 GeV the benchmark requires Ω η m i s / Ω η f l u c < 3.1 × 10 − 5 \Omega_\eta^{\mathrm{mis}}/\Omega_\eta^{\mathrm{fluc}} < 3.1 \times10^{-5} Ω η mis / Ω η fluc < 3.1 × 1 0 − 5 , 2.7 × 10 − 3 2.7 \times10^{-3} 2.7 × 1 0 − 3 , and 0.52 0.52 0.52 for n η − 1 = 0.3 n_\eta- 1 = 0.3 n η − 1 = 0.3 , 0.4 0.4 0.4 , and 0.5 0.5 0.5 , respectively. Larger means are excluded until misalignment dominates by a wide margin, Ω η m i s / Ω η f l u c > 6.7 × 10 5 \Omega_\eta^{\mathrm{mis}}/\Omega_\eta^{\mathrm{fluc}} > 6.7 \times10^5 Ω η mis / Ω η fluc > 6.7 × 1 0 5 , 3.8 × 10 3 3.8 \times10^3 3.8 × 1 0 3 , and 4.4 4.4 4.4 . For H I = 10 13 G e V H_I = 10^{13}\,\mathrm{GeV} H I = 1 0 13 GeV and n η − 1 = 0.4 n_\eta- 1 = 0.4 n η − 1 = 0.4 , where m ∗ = 36 k e V m_* = 36\,\mathrm{keV} m ∗ = 36 keV , the corresponding bound is 8 × 10 − 5 8 \times10^{-5} 8 × 1 0 − 5 . For f η = 10 12 G e V f_\eta= 10^{12}\,\mathrm{GeV} f η = 1 0 12 GeV these bounds require ∣ θ c ∣ ≲ 4 × 10 − 6 |\theta_c| \lesssim4 \times10^{-6} ∣ θ c ∣ ≲ 4 × 1 0 − 6 at H I = 10 10 G e V H_I = 10^{10}\,\mathrm{GeV} H I = 1 0 10 GeV and n η − 1 = 0.3 n_\eta- 1 = 0.3 n η − 1 = 0.3 , and ∣ θ c ∣ ≲ 4 × 10 − 4 |\theta_c| \lesssim4 \times10^{-4} ∣ θ c ∣ ≲ 4 × 1 0 − 4 at H I = 10 13 G e V H_I = 10^{13}\,\mathrm{GeV} H I = 1 0 13 GeV and n η − 1 = 0.4 n_\eta- 1 = 0.4 n η − 1 = 0.4 .
In the kinetic realization such a small mean is an assumption about the initial conditions, unless the axion is heavy before the observable scales leave the horizon and relaxes to the same minimum it has at late times. In the curvature realization the small mean arises dynamically. If inflation lasted long enough before the patch scale left the horizon, ξ > 0 \xi> 0 ξ > 0 erases the pre-inflationary displacement [65 ] , and leaves only the modes longer than the present horizon, ⟨ η c 2 ⟩ ≃ P X ( k I R ) / ( 3 − 2 ν ) \langle\eta_c^2\rangle\simeq\mathcal{P}_X(k_{\rm IR})/(3 - 2\nu) ⟨ η c 2 ⟩ ≃ P X ( k IR ) / ( 3 − 2 ν ) . For the curvature coupling with n η − 1 = 0.3 n_\eta- 1 = 0.3 n η − 1 = 0.3 at H I = 10 10 G e V H_I = 10^{10}\,\mathrm{GeV} H I = 1 0 10 GeV this gives Ω η m i s / Ω η f l u c ≃ 4 × 10 − 7 \Omega_\eta^{\rm mis}/\Omega_\eta^{\rm fluc} \simeq4 \times10^{-7} Ω η mis / Ω η fluc ≃ 4 × 1 0 − 7 , well below the bound.12
In the opposite limit, η c 2 ≫ Q \eta_c^2 \gg Q η c 2 ≫ Q , only the linear term in Eq. (48) survives. Using K ∗ = q ∗ K_* = q_* K ∗ = q ∗ for the kinetic coupling and Eq. (17) for the curvature coupling, we obtain
P S ( k ∗ ) = ( Ω η Ω c ) 2 ( 2 θ c ) 2 d 2 C ν e − 2 ( 1 − d ) N ∗ ( H I 2 π f I ) 2 (53) \mathcal{P}_S(k_*) = \left(\frac{\Omega_\eta}{\Omega_c}\right)^2 \left(\frac{2}{\theta_c}\right)^2 d^2 C_\nu e^{-2(1-d)N_*} \left(\frac{H_I}{2\pi f_I}\right)^2 \tag*{(53)} P S ( k ∗ ) = ( Ω c Ω η ) 2 ( θ c 2 ) 2 d 2 C ν e − 2 ( 1 − d ) N ∗ ( 2 π f I H I ) 2 (53)
with f I = K ∗ f η f_I = K_* f_\eta f I = K ∗ f η from Eq. (4) . For d = C ν = 1 d = C_\nu= 1 d = C ν = 1 and f I = f η f_I = f_\eta f I = f η this is the standard result [9 , 11 , 12 , 16 ] , and with f I f_I f I and the transfer factor included it agrees with Refs. [19 , 21 ] . Beyond the harmonic regime, 2 / θ c 2/\theta_c 2/ θ c is replaced by ∂ ln Ω η m i s / ∂ θ c \partial\ln\Omega_\eta^{\rm mis}/\partial\theta_c ∂ ln Ω η mis / ∂ θ c .
The kinetic coupling has d = 1 d = 1 d = 1 and acts through f I f_I f I . For p = − 0.15 p = -0.15 p = − 0.15 at H I = 10 10 G e V H_I = 10^{10}\,\mathrm{GeV} H I = 1 0 10 GeV , we have K ∗ = e 0.15 N ∗ ≃ 2.3 × 10 3 K_* = e^{0.15N_*} \simeq2.3 \times10^3 K ∗ = e 0.15 N ∗ ≃ 2.3 × 1 0 3 , and at fixed θ c \theta_c θ c the isocurvature is smaller than in the canonical case by C ν / K ∗ 2 C_\nu/K_*^2 C ν / K ∗ 2 . This is the evolving radius mechanism [13 , 18 , 19 ] written as a kinetic function. The curvature coupling has K = 1 K = 1 K = 1 and acts instead through the factor d C ν e − ( 1 − d ) N ∗ d\sqrt{C_\nu}e^{-(1-d)N_*} d C ν e − ( 1 − d ) N ∗ , which is 3.3 × 10 − 4 3.3 \times10^{-4} 3.3 × 1 0 − 4 for n η − 1 = 0.3 n_\eta- 1 = 0.3 n η − 1 = 0.3 and H I = 10 10 G e V H_I = 10^{10}\,\mathrm{GeV} H I = 1 0 10 GeV [66 ] . However, it requires a larger initial displacement, by 1 / [ d e − ( 1 − d ) N t o t ] 1/[d e^{-(1-d)N_{\rm tot}}] 1/ [ d e − ( 1 − d ) N tot ] , which grows exponentially with the total number of e-folds N t o t N_{\rm tot} N tot .
The QCD axion
The QCD axion has m η ≃ 5.7 μ e V ( 10 12 G e V / f η ) m_\eta\simeq5.7\,\mu\mathrm{eV}\,(10^{12}\,\mathrm{GeV}/f_\eta) m η ≃ 5.7 μ eV ( 1 0 12 GeV / f η ) [84 ] , and its temperature-dependent mass starts the oscillations at T o s c ∼ 0.2 T_{\rm osc} \sim0.2 T osc ∼ 0.2 –1.5 G e V 1.5\,\mathrm{GeV} 1.5 GeV for the decay constants considered here [85 ] . Equation (38) then no longer applies, and we define Q Q Q through Eq. (39) instead. Modes outside the horizon at T o s c T_{\rm osc} T osc oscillate with the zero mode and enter Q Q Q directly. For shorter modes we use the constant mass transfer (26) , and the results below are estimates. Taking T o s c = 1 G e V T_{\rm osc} = 1\,\mathrm{GeV} T osc = 1 GeV , we find k ∗ / k o s c ≃ 3 × 10 − 9 k_*/k_{\rm osc} \simeq3 \times10^{-9} k ∗ / k osc ≃ 3 × 1 0 − 9 , independent of H I H_I H I .
Within this estimate, a single power law cannot give the full abundance while satisfying the pivot benchmark. Misalignment gives Ω η m i s ∝ θ c 2 f η 7 / 6 \Omega_\eta^{\rm mis} \propto\theta_c^2 f_\eta^{7/6} Ω η mis ∝ θ c 2 f η 7/6 [86 ] , which implies η D M ∝ f η 5 / 12 \eta_{\rm DM} \propto f_\eta^{5/12} η DM ∝ f η 5/12 and even at the edge of the harmonic regime, θ D M ≡ η D M / f η ≃ 1 \theta_{\rm DM} \equiv\eta_{\rm DM}/f_\eta\simeq1 θ DM ≡ η DM / f η ≃ 1 , one needs η D M ≳ 10 11 G e V \eta_{\rm DM} \gtrsim10^{11}\,\mathrm{GeV} η DM ≳ 1 0 11 GeV . A flat spectrum, with Q ≃ 0.8 H I \sqrt{Q} \simeq0.8H_I Q ≃ 0.8 H I , reaches this value for H I ≳ 10 11 G e V H_I \gtrsim10^{11}\,\mathrm{GeV} H I ≳ 1 0 11 GeV , but then P S ( k ∗ ) ≃ 3 × 10 − 2 \mathcal{P}_S(k_*) \simeq3 \times10^{-2} P S ( k ∗ ) ≃ 3 × 1 0 − 2 . A blue spectrum satisfies the pivot benchmark only for n η − 1 ≳ 0.6 n_\eta- 1 \gtrsim0.6 n η − 1 ≳ 0.6 , and in this case Q ≲ 3 × 10 8 G e V \sqrt{Q} \lesssim3 \times10^8\,\mathrm{GeV} Q ≲ 3 × 1 0 8 GeV even at the tensor bound. The fluctuations then supply less than 10 − 5 10^{-5} 1 0 − 5 of the dark matter, and a curvature coupling, with d 2 < 1 d^2 < 1 d 2 < 1 , gives even less.
The running slope of the quadratic exponential (Sec. VI) improves this situation. At the tensor bound we find that the pivot benchmark allows N γ ≲ 12.6 N_\gamma\lesssim12.6 N γ ≲ 12.6 , corresponding to a pivot tilt of 0.70 0.70 0.70 and a local tilt of 0.46 0.46 0.46 near k o s c k_{\rm osc} k osc , and the same estimate gives Q ≃ 2 × 10 11 G e V \sqrt{Q} \simeq2 \times10^{11}\,\mathrm{GeV} Q ≃ 2 × 1 0 11 GeV , comparable to the smallest η D M \eta_{\rm DM} η DM . Within our estimate the running case therefore remains marginal.
However, if we adopt T c ≃ f η T_c \simeq f_\eta T c ≃ f η for the PQ restoration temperature, then non-restoration after instantaneous reheating requires f η ≳ T R H ≃ 6 × 10 15 G e V f_\eta\gtrsim T_{\rm RH} \simeq6 \times10^{15}\,\mathrm{GeV} f η ≳ T RH ≃ 6 × 1 0 15 GeV at the tensor bound. Within the misalignment estimate used here this raises η D M \eta_{\rm DM} η DM to order 10 13 G e V 10^{13}\,\mathrm{GeV} 1 0 13 GeV , and the fluctuations fall short also for the running slope. A different PQ thermal potential would require a separate analysis. The same is true for a slower reheating, which changes N ∗ N_* N ∗ , the entropy density s e s_e s e , and the transfer of the modes that start to oscillate before reheating ends, and which also lowers T R H T_{\rm RH} T RH and with it the bound f η ≳ T R H f_\eta\gtrsim T_{\rm RH} f η ≳ T RH .
These conclusions assume that the axion stays light during inflation. If it is heavy while the CMB scales leave the horizon and becomes light later, the CMB scale isocurvature is removed and the later fluctuations can set the QCD axion abundance [59 , 60 ] , a case that a single power law does not describe.
In the misalignment-dominated regime the couplings still help. Eq. (53) applies with the QCD relation between θ c \theta_c θ c and f η f_\eta f η , i.e., a kinetic function raises the bound on H I H_I H I by K ∗ / C ν K_*/\sqrt{C_\nu} K ∗ / C ν , and a curvature coupling lowers the isocurvature by d 2 C ν e − 2 ( 1 − d ) N ∗ d^2 C_\nu e^{-2(1-d)N_*} d 2 C ν e − 2 ( 1 − d ) N ∗ .
Kinetic functions
The results above assume a constant slope p p p , which is independent of the specific form of the kinetic function. For the linear and quadratic exponential functions we are interested in, p p p is related to the inflation trajectory by Eq. (7) . For the linear exponential at nearly constant ϵ \epsilon ϵ , the slope p λ p_\lambda p λ is nearly constant, and if the inflaton also generates the curvature perturbation, we find
ϵ ∗ ≃ H I 2 8 π 2 M P l 2 A s , λ ≃ − 2 p 2 π A s M P l H I . (54) \epsilon_* \simeq\frac{H_I^2}{8\pi^2 M_{\mathrm{Pl}}^2 A_s}, \qquad\lambda\simeq-2p\frac{2\pi\sqrt{A_s}M_{\mathrm{Pl}}}{H_I}. \tag*{(54)} ϵ ∗ ≃ 8 π 2 M Pl 2 A s H I 2 , λ ≃ − 2 p H I 2 π A s M Pl . (54)
A slope p = − 0.15 p = -0.15 p = − 0.15 then requires λ ≃ 2.1 × 10 4 \lambda\simeq2.1 \times10^4 λ ≃ 2.1 × 1 0 4 at H I = 10 10 G e V H_I = 10^{10}\,\mathrm{GeV} H I = 1 0 10 GeV and λ ≃ 21 \lambda\simeq21 λ ≃ 21 at 10 13 G e V 10^{13}\,\mathrm{GeV} 1 0 13 GeV . The large value at low scales reflects the small inflaton excursion, 2 ϵ M P l \sqrt{2\epsilon}M_{\mathrm{Pl}} 2 ϵ M Pl per e e e -fold, over which in K K K must change by ∣ p ∣ |p| ∣ p ∣ . Note that the relevant expansion parameter is λ ϕ / M P l \lambda\phi/M_{\mathrm{Pl}} λ ϕ / M Pl , which reaches 15.5 at the pivot, and K λ K_\lambda K λ must be read as a resummed kinetic function, such as the one provided by the hyperbolic field space of App. D 2, and not as its leading derivative operator. Eq. (54) fixes λ \lambda λ but not the potential, the scalar tilt, or the exit [21 ] . The high-scale case is the most natural one, and at H I = 10 13 G e V H_I = 10^{13}\,\mathrm{GeV} H I = 1 0 13 GeV the tensor-to-scalar ratio is r = 2 H I 2 / ( π 2 M P l 2 A s ) ≃ 1.6 × 10 − 3 r = 2H_I^2/(\pi^2M_{\mathrm{Pl}}^2A_s) \simeq1.6 \times10^{-3} r = 2 H I 2 / ( π 2 M Pl 2 A s ) ≃ 1.6 × 1 0 − 3 , within the reach of next-generation B B B -mode searches [87 ] . A detection of primordial gravitational waves at this level would then point to the part of parameter space where a constant kinetic slope is easiest to realize, with a keV-scale ALP and a strongly blue isocurvature spectrum.
For the quadratic exponential we adopt an idealized constant ϵ \epsilon ϵ trajectory that ends at the stationary point of K γ K_\gamma K γ , ϕ e = 0 \phi_e = 0 ϕ e = 0 , with ϕ ≃ 2 ϵ M P l N \phi\simeq\sqrt{2\epsilon}\,M_{\mathrm{Pl}}N ϕ ≃ 2 ϵ M Pl N with N = ln ( a e / a ) N = \ln(a_e/a) N = ln ( a e / a ) , which gives
K γ 2 = e N 2 / N γ 2 , p γ = − N N γ 2 , N γ ≡ ( 2 ϵ γ ) − 1 / 2 . (55) K_\gamma^2 = e^{N^2/N_\gamma^2}, \qquad p_\gamma= -\frac{N}{N_\gamma^2}, \qquad N_\gamma\equiv(2\epsilon\gamma)^{-1/2}. \tag*{(55)} K γ 2 = e N 2 / N γ 2 , p γ = − N γ 2 N , N γ ≡ ( 2 ϵ γ ) − 1/2 . (55)
Since the magnitude of the slope grows with the number of e e e -folds before the end of inflation, the spectrum is bluest on CMB scales, with local tilt n η ( N ) − 1 ≃ 2 N / N γ 2 n_\eta(N)-1 \simeq2N/N_\gamma^2 n η ( N ) − 1 ≃ 2 N / N γ 2 , and flatter on the scales that dominate the abundance. Since ∣ d p / d N ∣ = N γ − 2 ≪ 1 |dp/dN| = N_\gamma^{-2} \ll1 ∣ d p / d N ∣ = N γ − 2 ≪ 1 , each mode leaves the horizon with the constant p p p amplitude at its local slope. The kinetic coupling has d = 1 d = 1 d = 1 throughout, and since p = 0 p = 0 p = 0 at the exit the q − 2 q^{-2} q − 2 tail of Eq. (31) is absent. Eq. (25) then applies mode by mode with
P η , e ( q ) ≃ C ν ( N ) ( H I 2 π ) 2 e − N 2 / N γ 2 , ν ( N ) = 3 2 − N N γ 2 , (56) \mathcal{P}_{\eta,e}(q) \simeq C_{\nu(N)}\left(\frac{H_I}{2\pi}\right)^2 e^{-N^2/N_\gamma^2}, \qquad\nu(N) = \frac{3}{2} - \frac{N}{N_\gamma^2}, \tag*{(56)} P η , e ( q ) ≃ C ν ( N ) ( 2 π H I ) 2 e − N 2 / N γ 2 , ν ( N ) = 2 3 − N γ 2 N , (56)
where N = − ln q N = -\ln q N = − ln q . Approximating C ν ≃ 1 C_\nu\simeq1 C ν ≃ 1 and F ≃ 1 \mathcal{F} \simeq1 F ≃ 1 below the turnover, and assuming q I R < μ < q max q_{\mathrm{IR}} < \sqrt{\mu} < q_{\max} q IR < μ < q m a x , we obtain the long mode estimate
Q γ , l o n g ≃ ( H I 2 π ) 2 π N γ 2 [ erf N I R N γ − erf N o s c N γ ] , (57) Q_{\gamma,\mathrm{long}} \simeq\left(\frac{H_I}{2\pi}\right)^2 \frac{\sqrt{\pi}N_\gamma}{2}\left[\operatorname{erf}\frac{N_{\mathrm{IR}}}{N_\gamma} - \operatorname{erf}\frac{N_{\mathrm{osc}}}{N_\gamma}\right], \tag*{(57)} Q γ , long ≃ ( 2 π H I ) 2 2 π N γ [ erf N γ N IR − erf N γ N osc ] , (57)
with N I R = − ln q I R N_{\mathrm{IR}} = -\ln q_{\mathrm{IR}} N IR = − ln q IR and N o s c = 1 2 ln ( H I / m η ) N_{\mathrm{osc}} = \frac{1}{2}\ln(H_I/m_\eta) N osc = 2 1 ln ( H I / m η ) , the number of e e e -folds before the end of inflation at which k o s c k_{\mathrm{osc}} k osc leaves the horizon.13
Using the band, transfer, and isocurvature limit of Secs. IV and V, we find that the limit at H I = 10 10 G e V H_I = 10^{10}\,\mathrm{GeV} H I = 1 0 10 GeV requires N γ < 15.6 N_\gamma< 15.6 N γ < 15.6 , or a pivot tilt above 0.43, with a threshold mass m η ≃ 1.4 G e V m_\eta\simeq1.4\,\mathrm{GeV} m η ≃ 1.4 GeV . This is more than two orders of magnitude below the 200 GeV found for a constant slope. The gain mostly comes from the running and the modes that set the abundance see a local tilt of only about 0.1. The threshold corresponds to
γ ≃ 2 × 10 7 \gamma\simeq2 \times10^7 γ ≃ 2 × 1 0 7 , and at H I = 10 11 H_I = 10^{11} H I = 1 0 11 , 10 12 10^{12} 1 0 12 , and 10 13 G e V 10^{13}\,\mathrm{GeV} 1 0 13 GeV it moves to N γ < 15.4 N_\gamma< 15.4 N γ < 15.4 , 15.1, and 14.7, with masses 0.74 MeV, 0.59 keV, and 0.73 eV, respectively. At the tensor bound, H I = 4.7 × 10 13 G e V H_I = 4.7 \times10^{13}\,\mathrm{GeV} H I = 4.7 × 1 0 13 GeV , we find N γ < 14.4 N_\gamma< 14.4 N γ < 14.4 and m η ≃ 0.01 e V m_\eta\simeq0.01\,\mathrm{eV} m η ≃ 0.01 eV , and the required coupling falls from γ ≃ 23 \gamma\simeq23 γ ≃ 23 at 10 13 G e V 10^{13}\,\mathrm{GeV} 1 0 13 GeV to γ ≃ 1 \gamma\simeq1 γ ≃ 1 .
Both kinetic functions can be realized without breaking the axion shift symmetry (App. D). In supergravity with Z Z Z the inflaton and A A A the axion multiplet, a Kähler term Z A ( Z , Z ˉ ) ( A + A ˉ ) 2 \mathcal{Z}_A(Z,\bar Z)(A+\bar A)^2 Z A ( Z , Z ˉ ) ( A + A ˉ ) 2 reproduces either one along an α \alpha α -attractor trajectory, and the linear exponential also follows from a hyperbolic field space, K = − n M P l 2 ln ( T + T ˉ ) \mathcal{K}=-nM_{\mathrm{Pl}}^2\ln(T+\bar T) K = − n M Pl 2 ln ( T + T ˉ ) , with ∣ λ ∣ = 8 / n |\lambda|=\sqrt{8/n} ∣ λ ∣ = 8/ n . This field space must be strongly curved at low scales, and for p = − 0.15 p=-0.15 p = − 0.15 at H I = 10 10 G e V H_I=10^{10}\,\mathrm{GeV} H I = 1 0 10 GeV we need n ≃ 1.8 × 10 − 8 n\simeq1.8\times10^{-8} n ≃ 1.8 × 1 0 − 8 , and a T T T -model at the same scale already requires an attractor parameter α ≃ 4 × 10 − 7 \alpha\simeq4\times10^{-7} α ≃ 4 × 1 0 − 7 . The renormalizable radial completion of App. D gives K 2 = 1 + ϕ 2 / M P l 2 K^2=1+\phi^2/M_{\mathrm{Pl}}^2 K 2 = 1 + ϕ 2 / M Pl 2 , and along the constant-ϵ \epsilon ϵ trajectory its slope satisfies ∣ p ∣ < 1 / N |p|<1/N ∣ p ∣ < 1/ N , which is too small for the spectra of Sec. V. These constructions realize the kinetic functions but not the trajectory, the stabilization, or the exit, which must be specified separately, and none of them generates the curvature coupling ξ \xi ξ .
Conclusions
The answer to the question in our title is yes, and the CMB sets the price. The two contributions can be compared directly because they are the same physics. We showed that modes still outside the horizon when the field starts to oscillate act as a local misalignment field, and the fluctuations carry the misalignment abundance of a displacement Q \sqrt{Q} Q , dominating when Q > f η 2 θ c 2 Q > f_\eta^2\theta_c^2 Q > f η 2 θ c 2 . By matching the Sitter Hankel modes onto the radiation era parabolic cylinder modes, we obtained the late-time spectrum fully analytically, including the jump in K ′ K' K ′ at the end of inflation, and the same calculation fixes the misalignment normalization without the order one ambiguity of an onset prescription.
The main constraint on this scenario comes from isocurvature, since the energy density is quadratic in the field and setting the mean to zero removes only the linear isocurvature term. The remaining quadratic term exceeds the Planck limit at the pivot by 8–9 orders of magnitude for a flat or red spectrum, and a canonical axion therefore cannot be fluctuation-dominated dark matter. A blue tilt moves the power away from the scales probed by the CMB. However, a blue spectrum gives less abundance at a given mass and requires a heavier axion. For a constant kinetic slope the pivot limit requires n η − 1 ≳ 0.27 n_\eta-1\gtrsim0.27 n η − 1 ≳ 0.27 and a long-lived ALP heavier than about 200 GeV at H I = 10 10 G e V H_I=10^{10}\,\mathrm{GeV} H I = 1 0 10 GeV , and n η − 1 ≳ 0.34 n_\eta-1\gtrsim0.34 n η − 1 ≳ 0.34 with m η ≃ 4.5 k e V m_\eta\simeq4.5\,\mathrm{keV} m η ≃ 4.5 keV at H I = 10 13 G e V H_I=10^{13}\,\mathrm{GeV} H I = 1 0 13 GeV (Figure 2 ). The mean must also be small, and at H I = 10 10 G e V H_I=10^{10}\,\mathrm{GeV} H I = 1 0 10 GeV it may supply at most 3 × 10 − 5 3\times10^{-5} 3 × 1 0 − 5 of the abundance for n η − 1 = 0.3 n_\eta-1=0.3 n η − 1 = 0.3 and up to a third for n η − 1 = 0.5 n_\eta-1=0.5 n η − 1 = 0.5 . A positive curvature coupling erases the mean dynamically, whereas for a kinetic function a mean as small as ∣ θ c ∣ ≲ 4 × 10 − 6 |\theta_c| \lesssim4 \times10^{-6} ∣ θ c ∣ ≲ 4 × 1 0 − 6 (for f η = 10 12 G e V f_\eta= 10^{12}\,\mathrm{GeV} f η = 1 0 12 GeV at H I = 10 10 G e V H_I = 10^{10}\,\mathrm{GeV} H I = 1 0 10 GeV ) must be assumed. With a running slope these requirements become weaker, since the CMB constrains the tilt at the pivot, while the abundance is set tens of e-folds later, near k o s c k_{\mathrm{osc}} k osc . The quadratic exponential is very blue at the pivot and only mildly blue near k o s c k_{\mathrm{osc}} k osc . It lowers the required mass from 200 G e V 200\,\mathrm{GeV} 200 GeV to 1.4 G e V 1.4\,\mathrm{GeV} 1.4 GeV at H I = 10 10 G e V H_I = 10^{10}\,\mathrm{GeV} H I = 1 0 10 GeV and from 4.5 k e V 4.5\,\mathrm{keV} 4.5 keV to 0.7 e V 0.7\,\mathrm{eV} 0.7 eV at 10 13 G e V 10^{13}\,\mathrm{GeV} 1 0 13 GeV , and at the tensor bound it reaches 0.01 e V 0.01\,\mathrm{eV} 0.01 eV with an O ( 1 ) \mathcal{O}(1) O ( 1 ) coupling, γ ≃ 1 \gamma\simeq1 γ ≃ 1 .
The situation is less favorable for the QCD axion, as its mass is fixed by f η f_\eta f η and it starts to oscillate late, near T ∼ 1 G e V T \sim1\,\mathrm{GeV} T ∼ 1 GeV . Within our estimate no single power law gives both the observed abundance and a small enough pivot isocurvature. A running tilt brings Q \sqrt{Q} Q to about 2 × 10 11 G e V 2 \times10^{11}\,\mathrm{GeV} 2 × 1 0 11 GeV near the tensor bound, close to the smallest misalignment displacement. However, if the PQ symmetry is restored near T ≃ f η T \simeq f_\eta T ≃ f η , keeping it broken after instantaneous reheating requires f η ≳ 6 × 10 15 G e V f_\eta\gtrsim6 \times10^{15}\,\mathrm{GeV} f η ≳ 6 × 1 0 15 GeV , which raises η D M \eta_{\mathrm{DM}} η DM to order 10 13 G e V 10^{13}\,\mathrm{GeV} 1 0 13 GeV and closes this window as well. A different PQ thermal history or a lower reheating temperature would require a separate analysis.
Realizing these kinetic functions at low inflationary scales requires large couplings or strongly curved field spaces, as the inflaton moves only 2 ϵ M P l \sqrt{2\epsilon}\,M_{\mathrm{Pl}} 2 ϵ M Pl per e-fold. The linear exponential needs λ ≃ 2 × 10 4 \lambda\simeq2 \times10^{4} λ ≃ 2 × 1 0 4 at H I = 10 10 G e V H_I = 10^{10}\,\mathrm{GeV} H I = 1 0 10 GeV (falling to about 20 20 20 at 10 13 G e V 10^{13}\,\mathrm{GeV} 1 0 13 GeV ), and its hyperbolic realization needs a strongly curved field space with n ≃ 2 × 10 − 8 n \simeq2 \times10^{-8} n ≃ 2 × 1 0 − 8 . The high-scale case is the most natural one, and it predicts r ≃ 1.6 × 10 − 3 r \simeq1.6 \times10^{-3} r ≃ 1.6 × 1 0 − 3 at H I = 10 13 G e V H_I = 10^{13}\,\mathrm{GeV} H I = 1 0 13 GeV , within the reach of next-generation B B B -mode searches.
Both functions can be embedded in supergravity, but a renormalizable radial completion gives too small a slope, and none of these constructions fixes the inflaton trajectory or the exit. We leave two questions for future work. First, the blue non-Gaussian isocurvature should be confronted with a full CMB likelihood and not only with a limit at the pivot. Second, its growth on small scales, which is still allowed by Lyman-α \alpha α and spectral distortion data, should be followed into early structure formation and induced gravitational waves [88 ] , given that for n η − 1 = 0.3 n_\eta- 1 = 0.3 n η − 1 = 0.3 at H I = 10 10 G e V H_I = 10^{10}\,\mathrm{GeV} H I = 1 0 10 GeV it exceeds the adiabatic power above k ∼ 10 3 M p c − 1 k \sim10^{3}\,\mathrm{Mpc}^{-1} k ∼ 1 0 3 Mpc − 1 .
Acknowledgments
We thank Ameen Ismail for his contributions in the early stages of this project, and Marcos A. G. García and Santiago Agüí Salcedo for useful discussions. S.J.L. is partly supported by the Samsung Science and Technology Foundation under Project Number SSTF-BA2201-06. The work of S.V. is supported by the Kavli Institute for Cosmological Physics at the University of Chicago. The work of B.Y. is partly supported by the NSF grant PHY-2309456.
Derivation of the infrared spectrum
At τ e = − 1 / H I \tau_e = -1/H_I τ e = − 1/ H I the small argument form H ν ( 1 ) ( q ) ≃ − ( i / π ) Γ ( ν ) ( 2 / q ) ν H_\nu^{(1)}(q) \simeq-(i/\pi)\Gamma(\nu)(2/q)^\nu H ν ( 1 ) ( q ) ≃ − ( i / π ) Γ ( ν ) ( 2/ q ) ν leads to
∣ V k ∣ 2 ≃ C ν 2 H I q − 2 ν , W k ≃ d H I V k , (58) |V_k|^2 \simeq\frac{\mathcal{C}_\nu}{2H_I}q^{-2\nu}, \qquad W_k \simeq dH_I V_k, \tag*{(58)} ∣ V k ∣ 2 ≃ 2 H I C ν q − 2 ν , W k ≃ d H I V k , (58)
where the second relation follows from v k i n ∝ ( − τ ) 1 / 2 − ν v_k^{\mathrm{in}} \propto(-\tau)^{1/2-\nu} v k in ∝ ( − τ ) 1/2 − ν and Eq. (18) , with corrections of order q 2 q^2 q 2 for ν > 1 \nu> 1 ν > 1 . For 0 < ν < 1 0 < \nu< 1 0 < ν < 1 corrections of order q 2 ν q^{2\nu} q 2 ν also appear. The identity
D α ( 0 ) = 2 α / 2 π Γ [ ( 1 − α ) / 2 ] (59) D_\alpha(0) = \frac{2^{\alpha/2}\sqrt{\pi}}{\Gamma[(1-\alpha)/2]} \tag*{(59)} D α ( 0 ) = Γ [( 1 − α ) /2 ] 2 α /2 π (59)
applied to Eq. (19) gives
∣ v k o u t ( 0 ) ∣ 2 = π 2 m η H I e − π x 2 / 4 ∣ Γ ( 3 4 + i x 2 4 ) ∣ 2 . (60) |v_k^{\mathrm{out}}(0)|^2 = \frac{\pi}{2\sqrt{m_\eta H_I}} \frac{e^{-\pi x^2/4}}{\left|\Gamma\left(\frac{3}{4}+\frac{ix^2}{4}\right)\right|^2}. \tag*{(60)} ∣ v k out ( 0 ) ∣ 2 = 2 m η H I π Γ ( 4 3 + 4 i x 2 ) 2 e − π x 2 /4 . (60)
For q ≪ 1 q \ll1 q ≪ 1 and μ ≪ 1 \mu\ll1 μ ≪ 1 the out mode at y e = 1 / H I y_e = 1/H_I y e = 1/ H I can be replaced by its value at y = 0 y = 0 y = 0 , with relative error of order max ( q , μ ) \max(q,\sqrt{\mu}) max ( q , μ ) , and the term v k o u t ′ / V k v_k^{\mathrm{out}\prime}/V_k v k out ′ / V k in Eq. (20) is smaller than v k o u t W k v_k^{\mathrm{out}}W_k v k out W k by a factor of order max ( q , μ ) / d \max(q,\sqrt{\mu})/d max ( q , μ ) / d . Keeping v k o u t W k v_k^{\mathrm{out}}W_k v k out W k and using Eqs. (58) and (60) gives Eq. (25) . This approximation fails as d → 0 d \to0 d → 0 , where both terms must be kept. At p = 0 p = 0 p = 0 , ξ = 1 / 6 \xi= 1/6 ξ = 1/6 , and exactly zero mass the in and out modes are plane waves and β k = 0 \beta_k = 0 β k = 0 . Note that the massive formula should not be evaluated by setting m η = 0 m_\eta= 0 m η = 0 in its prefactor.
We evaluated Eq. (20) for μ = 10 − 8 \mu= 10^{-8} μ = 1 0 − 8 and 10 − 12 10^{-12} 1 0 − 12 , 0.01 ≤ x ≤ 30 0.01 \leq x \leq30 0.01 ≤ x ≤ 30 with q ≤ 10 − 2 q \leq10^{-2} q ≤ 1 0 − 2 , p ∈ { 0 , 0.05 , − 0.15 , − 0.25 } p \in\{0, 0.05, -0.15, -0.25\} p ∈ { 0 , 0.05 , − 0.15 , − 0.25 } at ξ = 0 \xi= 0 ξ = 0 , and ξ ∈ { 0.020 , 0.036 } \xi\in\{0.020, 0.036\} ξ ∈ { 0.020 , 0.036 } at p = 0 p = 0 p = 0 . The in and out modes satisfy their Wronskian conditions, ∣ α k ∣ 2 − ∣ β k ∣ 2 = 1 |\alpha_k|^2 - |\beta_k|^2 = 1 ∣ α k ∣ 2 − ∣ β k ∣ 2 = 1 holds to working precision, and Eq. (25) agrees with the exact result to better than 2 × 10 − 5 2 \times10^{-5} 2 × 1 0 − 5 in this range. At conformal coupling the exact result follows n q ∝ q − 1 n_q \propto q^{-1} n q ∝ q − 1 below the turnover.
Density correlator
The produced modes are highly occupied and squeezed, so we treat the field as a classical Gaussian field in which each mode follows a real growing-mode transfer function, η k ( t ) = G k ( t ) η k , e \eta_k(t) = G_k(t)\eta_{k,e} η k ( t ) = G k ( t ) η k , e . On a uniform radiation slice, where K = 1 K = 1 K = 1 and R = 0 R = 0 R = 0 , the density is quadratic in the field, and two modes with comoving momenta ℓ \ell ℓ and ℓ ′ = k − ℓ \ell' = k - \ell ℓ ′ = k − ℓ contribute through the kernel
E ℓ , ℓ ′ ( t ) = 1 2 G ˙ ℓ G ˙ ℓ ′ + ( m η 2 − ℓ ⋅ ℓ ′ a 2 ) G ℓ G ℓ ′ , (61) \mathcal{E}_{\ell,\ell'}(t) = \frac{1}{2}\dot{G}_\ell\dot{G}_{\ell'} + \left(m_\eta^2 - \frac{\ell\cdot\ell'}{a^2}\right)G_\ell G_{\ell'}, \tag*{(61)} E ℓ , ℓ ′ ( t ) = 2 1 G ˙ ℓ G ˙ ℓ ′ + ( m η 2 − a 2 ℓ ⋅ ℓ ′ ) G ℓ G ℓ ′ , (61)
where the bar averages over the mass oscillations but not over the slower spatial evolution. The mean density and the connected density spectrum of the fluctuations are then
ρ ˉ f l u c = ∫ d 3 ℓ ( 2 π ) 3 E ℓ , − ℓ P η , e ( ℓ ) , \bar{\rho}_{\mathrm{fluc}}=\int\frac{\mathrm{d}^{3}\ell}{(2\pi)^{3}}\mathcal{E}_{\ell,-\ell}P_{\eta,e}(\ell), ρ ˉ fluc = ∫ ( 2 π ) 3 d 3 ℓ E ℓ , − ℓ P η , e ( ℓ ) ,
P ρ , f l u c ( k ) = 2 ∫ d 3 ℓ ( 2 π ) 3 E ℓ , ℓ ′ 2 P η , e ( ℓ ) P η , e ( ℓ ′ ) , (62) P_{\rho,\mathrm{fluc}}(k)=2\int\frac{\mathrm{d}^{3}\ell}{(2\pi)^{3}}\mathcal{E}_{\ell,\ell'}^{2}P_{\eta,e}(\ell)P_{\eta,e}(\ell'), \tag*{(62)} P ρ , fluc ( k ) = 2 ∫ ( 2 π ) 3 d 3 ℓ E ℓ , ℓ ′ 2 P η , e ( ℓ ) P η , e ( ℓ ′ ) , (62)
with P η , e = 2 π 2 P η , e / k 3 P_{\eta,e}=2\pi^{2}P_{\eta,e}/k^{3} P η , e = 2 π 2 P η , e / k 3 . The mean field adds a cross term with the fluctuations, which we include before dividing by the square of the total mean density.
Two limits matter. For ℓ , ℓ ′ ≪ k o s c \ell,\ell'\ll k_{\mathrm{osc}} ℓ , ℓ ′ ≪ k osc both modes are still outside the horizon when the oscillations begin and follow the same homogeneous solution, so the kernel reduces to a constant and Eq. (46) follows. At k ≪ k o s c k\ll k_{\mathrm{osc}} k ≪ k osc , pairs with ℓ , ℓ ′ ≳ k o s c \ell,\ell'\gtrsim k_{\mathrm{osc}} ℓ , ℓ ′ ≳ k osc give a k k k -independent contribution to P ρ , f l u c P_{\rho,\mathrm{fluc}} P ρ , fluc , which is white noise, while the long-mode contribution scales as k 3 − 4 ν k^{3-4\nu} k 3 − 4 ν . The ratio of the two is of order ( k / k o s c ) 4 ν − 3 (k/k_{\mathrm{osc}})^{4\nu-3} ( k / k osc ) 4 ν − 3 . This classical treatment omits vacuum fluctuations, which a full calculation includes through the renormalized composite operator correlator [34 ] .
For the power law we measure comoving momenta in units of a e H I a_{\mathrm{e}}H_{\mathrm{I}} a e H I , so that k = q k=q k = q , and write P X ( ℓ ) = 2 π 2 P X ( ℓ ) / ℓ 3 ∝ ℓ − 2 ν P_{X}(\ell)=2\pi^{2}P_{X}(\ell)/\ell^{3}\propto\ell^{-2\nu} P X ( ℓ ) = 2 π 2 P X ( ℓ ) / ℓ 3 ∝ ℓ − 2 ν . The convolution (47) then follows from
∫ d 3 ℓ ( 2 π ) 3 ℓ − 2 ν ∣ k − ℓ ∣ − 2 ν = k 3 − 4 ν ( 4 π ) 3 / 2 Γ 2 ( 3 2 − ν ) Γ ( 2 ν − 3 2 ) Γ 2 ( ν ) Γ ( 3 − 2 ν ) , (63) \int\frac{\mathrm{d}^{3}\ell}{(2\pi)^{3}}\ell^{-2\nu}|\mathbf{k}-\boldsymbol{\ell}|^{-2\nu}
=\frac{k^{3-4\nu}}{(4\pi)^{3/2}}\frac{\Gamma^{2}\left(\frac{3}{2}-\nu\right)\Gamma\left(2\nu-\frac{3}{2}\right)}{\Gamma^{2}(\nu)\Gamma(3-2\nu)}, \tag*{(63)} ∫ ( 2 π ) 3 d 3 ℓ ℓ − 2 ν ∣ k − ℓ ∣ − 2 ν = ( 4 π ) 3/2 k 3 − 4 ν Γ 2 ( ν ) Γ ( 3 − 2 ν ) Γ 2 ( 2 3 − ν ) Γ ( 2 ν − 2 3 ) , (63)
valid for 3 / 4 < ν < 3 / 2 3/4<\nu<3/2 3/4 < ν < 3/2 , which gives P X 2 ( q ) = D ( ν ) P X 2 ( q ) P_{X^{2}}(q)=D(\nu)P_{X}^{2}(q) P X 2 ( q ) = D ( ν ) P X 2 ( q ) with D D D from Eq. (49) . Restricting both momenta to ∣ ℓ ∣ , ∣ k − ℓ ∣ > q I R |\ell|,|k-\ell|>q_{\mathrm{IR}} ∣ ℓ ∣ , ∣ k − ℓ ∣ > q IR leaves an elementary angular integral. With u = ℓ / k u=\ell/k u = ℓ / k , ϵ = q I R / k \epsilon=q_{\mathrm{IR}}/k ϵ = q IR / k , and w = max ( ∣ 1 − u ∣ , ϵ ) w=\max(|1-u|,\epsilon) w = max ( ∣1 − u ∣ , ϵ ) ,
D c ( ν ; ϵ ) = 1 2 ν − 2 ∫ ϵ ∞ d u u 1 − 2 ν [ w 2 − 2 ν − ( 1 + u ) 2 − 2 ν ] . (64) D_{\mathrm{c}}(\nu;\epsilon)=\frac{1}{2\nu-2}\int_{\epsilon}^{\infty}\mathrm{d}u\,u^{1-2\nu}\left[w^{2-2\nu}-(1+u)^{2-2\nu}\right]. \tag*{(64)} D c ( ν ; ϵ ) = 2 ν − 2 1 ∫ ϵ ∞ d u u 1 − 2 ν [ w 2 − 2 ν − ( 1 + u ) 2 − 2 ν ] . (64)
This reduces to D ( ν ) D(\nu) D ( ν ) as ϵ → 0 \epsilon\to0 ϵ → 0 and stays finite for ν ≥ 3 / 2 \nu\geq3/2 ν ≥ 3/2 . At the pivot ϵ = k I R / k ∗ = 4.5 × 10 − 3 \epsilon=k_{\mathrm{IR}}/k_{*}=4.5\times10^{-3} ϵ = k IR / k ∗ = 4.5 × 1 0 − 3 , independent of H I H_{\mathrm{I}} H I . Because D c D_{\mathrm{c}} D c depends on k k k through ϵ \epsilon ϵ , the tilt of P S P_{S} P S exceeds 2 ( n η − 1 ) 2(n_{\eta}-1) 2 ( n η − 1 ) near the cutoff.
Slowly varying kinetic histories
For a slowly varying K ( τ ) K(\tau) K ( τ ) with ξ = 0 \xi=0 ξ = 0 we approximate ln K \ln K ln K by linear pieces in ln a \ln a ln a , keeping K K K continuous. In the de Sitter interval j j j , with slope p j p_{j} p j , the basis modes are Hankel functions with ν j = 3 / 2 + p j \nu_{j}=3/2+p_{j} ν j = 3/2 + p j . At each boundary we match the field η = v / z \eta=v/z η = v / z and its conjugate momentum π η = a 2 K 2 η ′ = z v ′ − z ′ v \pi_{\eta}=a^{2}K^{2}\eta'=zv'-z'v π η = a 2 K 2 η ′ = z v ′ − z ′ v , and we put them in a matrix form
M j ( τ ) = ( v j / z v j ∗ / z z v j ′ − z ′ v j z v j ∗ ′ − z ′ v j ∗ ) , (65) M_{j}(\tau)=
\begin{pmatrix}
v_{j}/z & v_{j}^{*}/z\\
zv_{j}'-z'v_{j} & zv_{j}^{*'}-z'v_{j}^{*}
\end{pmatrix}, \tag*{(65)} M j ( τ ) = ( v j / z z v j ′ − z ′ v j v j ∗ / z z v j ∗ ′ − z ′ v j ∗ ) , (65)
whose columns are the field and momentum of the normalized Hankel mode v j v_{j} v j of interval j j j and of its conjugate.
The coefficients ( α j , β j ) (\alpha_{j},\beta_{j}) ( α j , β j ) of the mode in the basis ( v j , v j ∗ ) (v_{j},v_{j}^{*}) ( v j , v j ∗ ) then satisfy
\begin{pmatrix}
\alpha_{j+1}\\
\beta_{j+1}
\end{pmatrix}
=M_{j+1}^{-1}(\tau_{j})M_{j}(\tau_{j})
\begin{pmatrix}
\alpha_{j}\\
\beta_{j}
\end{pmatrix}, \tag*{(66)}\end{pmatrix}
where τ j \tau_{j} τ j is the boundary between intervals j j j and j + 1 j+1 j + 1 . Starting from ( α 1 , β 1 ) = ( 1 , 0 ) (\alpha_{1},\beta_{1})=(1,0) ( α 1 , β 1 ) = ( 1 , 0 ) and ending in the radiation era basis (19) , we obtain ( α k , β k ) (\alpha_{k},\beta_{k}) ( α k , β k ) as a product of explicit matrices.
This extends the constant p p p result to histories with a varying tilt, such as the quadratic exponential of Sec. VI, whose spectrum is blue across the CMB window and flatter near k o s c k_{\mathrm{osc}} k osc . In the leading approximation each mode sees a single interval, with the slope at its horizon exit, which gives Eq. (56) . For a smooth history the result converges as the intervals are refined. Each boundary is a kink in K K K , however, and like the jump in K ′ K' K ′ at the end of inflation (Sec. III C) it excites spurious high-frequency modes, so a finite discretization is reliable only below a momentum cutoff that rises as the intervals are refined.
Realizations of the kinetic function
This appendix gives explicit realizations of the kinetic functions K λ K_{\lambda} K λ and K γ K_{\gamma} K γ of Eq. (5) .
Radial realization
If K K K comes from the radial mode, K = σ 0 ( ϕ ) / f η K=\sigma_{0}(\phi)/f_{\eta} K = σ 0 ( ϕ ) / f η . A renormalizable parent potential,
V p a r e n t = V 0 ( ϕ ) + λ σ 4 ( σ 2 − f η 2 − c σ ϕ 2 ) 2 , (67) V_{\mathrm{parent}}=V_{0}(\phi)+\frac{\lambda_{\sigma}}{4}\left(\sigma^{2}-f_{\eta}^{2}-c_{\sigma}\phi^{2}\right)^{2}, \tag*{(67)} V parent = V 0 ( ϕ ) + 4 λ σ ( σ 2 − f η 2 − c σ ϕ 2 ) 2 , (67)
gives on the broken branch
σ 0 2 ( ϕ ) = f η 2 + c σ ϕ 2 , K 2 ( ϕ ) = 1 + γ ϕ 2 M P l 2 , \sigma_{0}^{2}(\phi)=f_{\eta}^{2}+c_{\sigma}\phi^{2},\qquad K^{2}(\phi)=1+\gamma\frac{\phi^{2}}{M_{\mathrm{Pl}}^{2}}, σ 0 2 ( ϕ ) = f η 2 + c σ ϕ 2 , K 2 ( ϕ ) = 1 + γ M Pl 2 ϕ 2 ,
γ = c σ M P l 2 f η 2 , m σ 2 = 2 λ σ σ 0 2 . (68) \gamma=c_{\sigma}\frac{M_{\mathrm{Pl}}^{2}}{f_{\eta}^{2}},\qquad m_{\sigma}^{2}=2\lambda_{\sigma}\sigma_{0}^{2}. \tag*{(68)} γ = c σ f η 2 M Pl 2 , m σ 2 = 2 λ σ σ 0 2 . (68)
A large γ \gamma γ needs no large coupling and for f η = 10 11 G e V f_{\eta}=10^{11}\,\mathrm{GeV} f η = 1 0 11 GeV , γ = 2 × 10 7 \gamma=2\times10^{7} γ = 2 × 1 0 7 corresponds to c σ ≃ 3 × 10 − 8 c_{\sigma}\simeq3\times10^{-8} c σ ≃ 3 × 1 0 − 8 . This is, however, only the leading term of the quadratic exponential. Along the trajectory of Sec. VI it gives K 2 = 1 + N 2 / N γ 2 K^{2}=1+N^{2}/N_{\gamma}^{2} K 2 = 1 + N 2 / N γ 2 and ∣ p ∣ = N − 1 ( N / N γ ) 2 / [ 1 + ( N / N γ ) 2 ] < 1 / N |p|=N^{-1}(N/N_{\gamma})^{2}/[1+(N/N_{\gamma})^{2}]<1/N ∣ p ∣ = N − 1 ( N / N γ ) 2 / [ 1 + ( N / N γ ) 2 ] < 1/ N , too small to sustain p = − 0.15 p=-0.15 p = − 0.15 near N ∼ 50 N\sim50 N ∼ 50 and the higher terms of the quadratic exponential are what keep the slope growing. The blue spectra of § 0.5 therefore need a nonpolynomial σ 0 ( ϕ ) \sigma_{0}(\phi) σ 0 ( ϕ ) or a curved field space of the kind discussed next.
Integrating out σ \sigma σ also corrects the inflaton kinetic term,
L k i n , ϕ = − 1 2 [ 1 + ( d σ 0 d ϕ ) 2 ] ( ∂ ϕ ) 2 , (69) \mathcal{L}_{\mathrm{kin},\phi}=-\frac{1}{2}\left[1+\left(\frac{\mathrm{d}\sigma_{0}}{\mathrm{d}\phi}\right)^{2}\right](\partial\phi)^{2}, \tag*{(69)} L kin , ϕ = − 2 1 [ 1 + ( d ϕ d σ 0 ) 2 ] ( ∂ ϕ ) 2 , (69)
which must remain small, ∣ d σ 0 / d ϕ ∣ ≲ 1 |d\sigma_0/d\phi| \lesssim1 ∣ d σ 0 / d ϕ ∣ ≲ 1 . Since σ 0 \sigma_0 σ 0 changes by ∣ p ∣ σ 0 |p|\sigma_0 ∣ p ∣ σ 0 per e-fold while the canonical inflaton moves by 2 ϵ M P l \sqrt{2\epsilon}\,M_{\rm Pl} 2 ϵ M Pl , this requires
∣ p ∣ K f η ≲ 2 ϵ M P l = H I 2 π A s , (70) |p|Kf_\eta\lesssim\sqrt{2\epsilon}\,M_{\rm Pl}=\frac{H_I}{2\pi\sqrt{A_s}}, \tag*{(70)} ∣ p ∣ K f η ≲ 2 ϵ M Pl = 2 π A s H I , (70)
or f η ≲ 10 11 G e V f_\eta\lesssim10^{11}\,\mathrm{GeV} f η ≲ 1 0 11 GeV at the pivot for p = − 0.15 p=-0.15 p = − 0.15 and H I = 10 10 G e V H_I=10^{10}\,\mathrm{GeV} H I = 1 0 10 GeV . Since T R H ≃ 8 × 10 13 G e V T_{\rm RH}\simeq8\times10^{13}\,\mathrm{GeV} T RH ≃ 8 × 1 0 13 GeV there, the PQ sector must then avoid thermal restoration through weak couplings to the bath (Sec. II). The reduction also requires m σ ≫ H m_\sigma\gg H m σ ≫ H , ∣ σ ˙ 0 / σ 0 ∣ |\dot{\sigma}_0/\sigma_0| ∣ σ ˙ 0 / σ 0 ∣ and physical momenta below m σ m_\sigma m σ , and loop corrections to V 0 V_0 V 0 must remain under control. A trajectory that approaches σ 0 = 0 \sigma_0=0 σ 0 = 0 invalidates the angular description before it produces an arbitrarily large enhancement.
Supergravity
Let Z Z Z be a dimensionless inflaton multiplet, S S S a stabilizer, and A = ( s + i η ) / 2 A=(s+i\eta)/\sqrt{2} A = ( s + i η ) / 2 the axion multiplet, whose real part s s s is the saxion. We take
K = − 3 α 2 M P l 2 ln ( 1 − Z Z ˉ ) 2 ( 1 − Z 2 ) ( 1 − Z ˉ 2 ) + S S ˉ + 1 2 Z A ( Z , Z ˉ ) ( A + A ˉ ) 2 + Δ K s t a b , (71) \mathcal{K}=-\frac{3\alpha}{2}M_{\rm Pl}^{2}\ln\frac{(1-Z\bar{Z})^{2}}{(1-Z^{2})(1-\bar{Z}^{2})}+S\bar{S}+\frac{1}{2}Z_A(Z,\bar{Z})(A+\bar{A})^{2}+\Delta\mathcal{K}_{\rm stab}, \tag*{(71)} K = − 2 3 α M Pl 2 ln ( 1 − Z 2 ) ( 1 − Z ˉ 2 ) ( 1 − Z Z ˉ ) 2 + S S ˉ + 2 1 Z A ( Z , Z ˉ ) ( A + A ˉ ) 2 + Δ K stab , (71)
W = S W ( Z ) + W b r ( A ) . (72) W=S\mathcal{W}(Z)+W_{\rm br}(A). \tag*{(72)} W = S W ( Z ) + W br ( A ) . (72)
The first term of K \mathcal{K} K describes the hyperbolic disk, K Z Z ˉ = 3 α M P l 2 / ( 1 − Z Z ˉ ) 2 K_{Z\bar{Z}}=3\alpha M_{\rm Pl}^{2}/(1-Z\bar{Z})^{2} K Z Z ˉ = 3 α M Pl 2 / ( 1 − Z Z ˉ ) 2 , as in Ref. [89 ] . The F F F -term potential is given by
V F = e K / M P l 2 ( K I J ˉ D I W D J ˉ W ˉ − 3 ∣ W ∣ 2 M P l 2 ) , (73) V_F=e^{\mathcal{K}/M_{\rm Pl}^{2}}\left(\mathcal{K}^{I\bar{J}}D_IW D_{\bar{J}}\bar{W}-\frac{3|W|^{2}}{M_{\rm Pl}^{2}}\right), \tag*{(73)} V F = e K / M Pl 2 ( K I J ˉ D I W D J ˉ W ˉ − M Pl 2 3∣ W ∣ 2 ) , (73)
with D I W = ∂ I W + K I W / M P l 2 D_IW=\partial_IW+\mathcal{K}_IW/M_{\rm Pl}^{2} D I W = ∂ I W + K I W / M Pl 2 . Along S = s = 0 S=s=0 S = s = 0 and Z = Z ˉ Z=\bar{Z} Z = Z ˉ , and neglecting the small term W b r W_{\rm br} W br , we have K = W = 0 \mathcal{K}=W=0 K = W = 0 and K S S ˉ = 1 \mathcal{K}_{S\bar{S}}=1 K S S ˉ = 1 , so that
Z = tanh ϕ 6 α M P l , V = ∣ W ( Z ) ∣ 2 . (74) Z=\tanh\frac{\phi}{\sqrt{6\alpha}\,M_{\rm Pl}},\qquad V=|\mathcal{W}(Z)|^{2}. \tag*{(74)} Z = tanh 6 α M Pl ϕ , V = ∣ W ( Z ) ∣ 2 . (74)
A linear W ∝ Z \mathcal{W}\propto Z W ∝ Z gives the T T T -model [89 , 90 , 91 , 92 , 93 ] . The real function
ϕ ^ ( Z , Z ˉ ) = 3 α 8 M P l ln ( 1 + Z ) ( 1 + Z ˉ ) ( 1 − Z ) ( 1 − Z ˉ ) (75) \hat{\phi}(Z,\bar{Z})=\sqrt{\frac{3\alpha}{8}}M_{\rm Pl}\ln\frac{(1+Z)(1+\bar{Z})}{(1-Z)(1-\bar{Z})} \tag*{(75)} ϕ ^ ( Z , Z ˉ ) = 8 3 α M Pl ln ( 1 − Z ) ( 1 − Z ˉ ) ( 1 + Z ) ( 1 + Z ˉ ) (75)
equals ϕ \phi ϕ on the trajectory, and the choices
Z A = e λ ϕ ^ / M P l or Z A = e γ ϕ ^ 2 / M P l 2 (76) Z_A=e^{\lambda\hat{\phi}/M_{\rm Pl}}\qquad\text{or}\qquad Z_A=e^{\gamma\hat{\phi}^{2}/M_{\rm Pl}^{2}} \tag*{(76)} Z A = e λ ϕ ^ / M Pl or Z A = e γ ϕ ^ 2 / M Pl 2 (76)
give K A A ˉ = K 2 ( ϕ ) K_{A\bar{A}}=K^{2}(\phi) K A A ˉ = K 2 ( ϕ ) there. Because Z A Z_A Z A multiplies ( A + A ˉ ) 2 (A+\bar{A})^{2} ( A + A ˉ ) 2 , it preserves the axion shift symmetry until W b r W_{\rm br} W br is included, and it leaves the inflationary trajectory unchanged. Terms such as [94 ]
Δ K s t a b = − c S ( S S ˉ ) 2 M P l 2 − c A S S ˉ Z A ( A + A ˉ ) 2 M P l 2 − c Z S S ˉ Y 2 M P l 2 , (77) \Delta\mathcal{K}_{\rm stab}=-c_S\frac{(S\bar{S})^{2}}{M_{\rm Pl}^{2}}-c_A\frac{S\bar{S}Z_A(A+\bar{A})^{2}}{M_{\rm Pl}^{2}}-c_Z\frac{S\bar{S}\mathcal{Y}^{2}}{M_{\rm Pl}^{2}}, \tag*{(77)} Δ K stab = − c S M Pl 2 ( S S ˉ ) 2 − c A M Pl 2 S S ˉ Z A ( A + A ˉ ) 2 − c Z M Pl 2 S S ˉ Y 2 , (77)
with Y = 2 Im [ 6 α M P l artanh Z ] \mathcal{Y}=\sqrt{2}\operatorname{Im}[\sqrt{6\alpha}M_{\rm Pl}\operatorname{artanh}Z] Y = 2 Im [ 6 α M Pl artanh Z ] , can stabilize the transverse directions. They vanish on the trajectory and, for positive coefficients, raise the masses of the transverse fields. Their coefficients must be fixed by the full mass matrix and the cutoff, and small α \alpha α is not automatically stable. The axion potential, the exit from inflation, and the saxion dynamics remain separate model building questions.
The linear exponential also follows directly from the geometry, without a choice of Z A Z_A Z A . For K = − n M P l 2 ln ( T + T ˉ ) \mathcal{K}=-nM_{\rm Pl}^{2}\ln(T+\bar{T}) K = − n M Pl 2 ln ( T + T ˉ ) and u ≡ Re T u\equiv\operatorname{Re}T u ≡ Re T , the fields ϕ = n / 2 M P l ln ( u / u 0 ) \phi=\sqrt{n/2}M_{\rm Pl}\ln(u/u_0) ϕ = n /2 M Pl ln ( u / u 0 ) and η = n / 2 M P l Im T / u 0 \eta=\sqrt{n/2}M_{\rm Pl}\operatorname{Im}T/u_0 η = n /2 M Pl Im T / u 0 , with constant u 0 u_0 u 0 , have kinetic terms
L k i n = − 1 2 ( ∂ ϕ ) 2 − 1 2 e − 8 / n ϕ / M P l ( ∂ η ) 2 , (78) \mathcal{L}_{\rm kin}=-\frac{1}{2}(\partial\phi)^{2}-\frac{1}{2}e^{-\sqrt{8/n}\,\phi/M_{\rm Pl}}(\partial\eta)^{2}, \tag*{(78)} L kin = − 2 1 ( ∂ ϕ ) 2 − 2 1 e − 8/ n ϕ / M Pl ( ∂ η ) 2 , (78)
so ∣ λ ∣ = 8 / n |\lambda|=\sqrt{8/n} ∣ λ ∣ = 8/ n , with the sign set by the direction of the roll, and ∣ p ∣ = 2 ϵ / n |p|=2\sqrt{\epsilon/n} ∣ p ∣ = 2 ϵ / n . The example p = − 0.15 p=-0.15 p = − 0.15 at H I = 10 10 G e V H_I=10^{10}\,\mathrm{GeV} H I = 1 0 10 GeV requires n ≃ 1.8 × 10 − 8 n\simeq1.8\times10^{-8} n ≃ 1.8 × 1 0 − 8 , a small field-space curvature radius. For comparison, a T T T -model at this scale needs α ≃ 4 × 10 − 7 \alpha\simeq4\times10^{-7} α ≃ 4 × 1 0 − 7 . This geometry is related to the one used in Ref. [53 ] to obtain blue axion spectra. These constructions realize K ( ϕ ) K(\phi) K ( ϕ ) locally but do not generate the shift-breaking curvature term in Eq. (1) . For ξ ≠ 0 \xi\ne0 ξ = 0 that term, and any terms induced by a Jordan to Einstein frame transformation, must be specified separately.
References