In this paper we study functions of pairs of unitary operators and pairs of contractions with commutators in the Schatten-von Neumann class Sp. We obtain commutator estimates and prove that our functional calculus is multiplicative modulo Sp. On the other hand, we show that our commutator estimates do not extend to the case p>2. We also obtain an extension of the Carey–Pincus trace formula. The main tool of this paper is a technique of triple operator integrals.
Introduction
In [3] we studied functions of almost commuting self-adjoint operators and obtained essential improvements of earlier results of [20]. Recall that operators T and R on Hilbert space are called almost commuting if their commutator [T,R]:=TR−RT belongs to the trace class S1. In this paper we are going to study functions of almost commuting unitary operators and almost commuting contractions. In fact, we consider the more general case of p-almost commuting unitary operators and p-almost commuting contractions (operators T and R on Hilbert space are called p-almost commuting if [T,R] belongs to the Schatten–von Neumann class Sp).
Note also that the case of p-almost commuting self-adjoint operators was considered in [23].
Recall that the function φ(U,V) of not necessarily commutingunitary operators U and V is defined as the double operator integral
φ(U,V)=∬T2φ(x,y)dEU(x)dEV(y),
where EU and EV are the spectral measures of U and V.
Recall that the theory of double operator integrals of the form
∬Φ(x,y)dE1(x)QdE2(y)(1)
was developed by M.Sh. Birman and M.Z. Solomyak in [7]–[9]. Here E1 and E2 are spectral measures on Hilbert space, Φ is a bounded measurable function and Q is a bounded linear operator on Hilbert space. We also refer the reader to [2] and [22] for more information on double operator integrals.
The maximal class of functions Φ for which the double operator integral (1.1) can be defined in a natural way as a bounded linear operator for an arbitrary bounded operator Q is called the class of Schur multipliers with respect to E1 and E2. This class is denoted by ME1,E2.
It is well known (see [18], [2] and [6]) that Φ∈ME1,E2 if and only if Φ belongs to the Haagerup tensor productLE1∞⊗hLE2∞ of the spaces LE1∞ and LE2∞, i.e. Φ admits a representation
Φ(x,y)=n∑un(x)vn(y),
with functions un in LE1∞ and vn in LE2∞ satisfying the conditions
n∑∣un∣2∈LE1∞andn∑∣vn∣2∈LE2∞.
Note that in the same way one can define the Haagerup tensor product of subspaces of L∞.
It was observed in [1] that if φ is a function on T2 that belongs to the homogeneous Besov class B∞,11(T2) (see § 2), then φ∈LE1∞⊗hLE2∞ for arbitrary unitary operators U and V which allows one to define the functional calculus
φ↦φ(U,V),φ∈B∞,11(T2).
It was shown in [1] (see Theorem 12.4) that this functional calculus satisfies a Lipschitz type estimate in the Schatten–von Neumann norm of Sp for p∈[1,2], i.e. the following inequality holds
whenever U1, V1, U2 and V2 are bounded self-adjoint operators such that U2−U1∈Sp and V2−V1∈Sp. We refer the reader to [12] for the definition and basic properties of Schatten–von Neumann classes.
On the other hand, it was proved in [5] (see Theorem 7.3) that inequality (1.2) is false in the norm of Sp for p>2 and it is also false in the operator norm.
In this paper we consider the functional calculus φ↦φ(U,V), φ∈B∞,11(T2), for p-almost commuting unitary operators U and V, i.e. unitary operators with commutators in the Schatten–von Neumann class Sp.
We show that in § 4 that in the case p∈[1,2] the calculus φ↦φ(U,V), φ∈B∞,11(T2), admits a commutator Lipschitz estimate in the Schatten–von Neumann norm Sp. However, we establish in § 7 that the situation completely changes in the norm of Sp for p>2 as well as in the operator norm. Also, we show that for p∈[1,2], the calculus φ↦φ(U,V) is multiplicative modulo Sp.
In § 5 we establish an extension of the Carey–Pincus trace formula [10] which is an analogue of the Helton–Howe trace formula [13].
In § 6 we obtain analogs of the results of § 4 for functions of contractions while in § 7 we show that the commutator estimate obtained in § 4 do not extend to the case p>2.
In § 2 we define the Besov space B∞,11(T2) which plays a very important role in this paper. Finally, we give a detailed introduction in triple operator integrals in § 3.
The Besov space B∞,11(T2) of periodic function
In this section we define the Besov class B∞,11(T2) of two variables which will play an important role in this paper.
Let w be an infinitely differentiable function on R such that
w≥0,suppw⊂[21,2],andw(s)=1−w(2s)for s∈[1,2](3)
and define the trigonometric polynomials Wn, n≥0, by
and we say that f belongs to the Besov class Bp,qs(T2), s>0, 1≤p,q≤∞, if
{2ns∥fn∥Lp}n≥0∈ℓq.(5)
We refer the reader to [2], [17] and [23] for the definition and basic properties of Besov spaces.
Triple operator integrals
Both in [1] and [3] an important role was played by triple operator integrals, i.e. expressions of the form
∭Φ(x,y,z)dE1(x)Q1dE2(y)Q2dE3(z).(6)
Here E1, E2 and E3 are spectral measures on Hilbert space, Q1 and Q2 are bounded linear operators on Hilbert space and Φ is a bounded measurable function. We call Φ the symbol of the triple operator integral (6).
As in the case of double operator integrals, for such triple operator integrals to make sense, the function Φ and the operators Q1 and Q2 have to satisfy certain conditions. We mention here several approaches to triple operator integrals.
In [20] triple operator integrals of the form (6) were defined for functions Φ in the integral projective tensor product LE1∞⊗iLE2∞⊗iLE3∞, see [20] for the definition. It turns out that if Φ∈LE1∞⊗iLE2∞⊗iLE3∞, Q1 and Q2 are bounded operators, then the triple operator integral in (6) determines a bounded linear operator. Also, for Φ∈LE1∞⊗iLE2∞⊗iLE3∞, the conditions that Q1∈Sp and Q2∈Sq with 1/p+1/q≤1 ensure that the triple operator integral in (6) belongs to the Schatten–von Neumann class Sr, where 1/r=1/p+1/q.
Let us also mention an earlier definition of triple, or even multiple, operator integrals given in [St] as well as the definition of multiple operator integrals for Hilbert–Schmidt operators given in [16].
We dwell on the next two approaches in more detail. In [14] the authors considered triple operator integrals of the form (3.1) in the case when Φ belongs to the Haagerup tensor productLE1∞⊗hLE2∞⊗hLE3∞ of the L∞ spaces which consists of functions Φ of the form
Φ(x,y,z)=j,k≥0∑αj(x1)βjk(x2)γk(x3)
where {αj}j≥0, {γk}k≥0∈L∞(ℓ2), {βjk}j,k≥0∈L∞(B), where B is the space of matrices that induce bounded linear operators on $\ell^2 equipped with the operator norm. For such functions Φ the triple operator integral in (3.1) can be expressed in the following way:
where the limit on the right exists in the weak operator topology. Also, the triple operator integral in (3.1) can be expressed as the product of the block operator matrices
All three block operator matrices on the right-hand side determine bounded linear operators, see [4].
It was established in [4] that if Φ∈LE1∞⊗hLE2∞⊗hLE3∞, Q1∈Sp, Q2∈Sq with p,q∈[2,∞], then the triple operator integral in (3.1) belongs to Sr, where 1/r=1/p+1/q. Here and in what follows for convenience, by T∈S∞ we mean that T is a bounded linear operator.
We proceed now to the most important approach for us to triple operator integrals. This approach was offered in [1] and was slightly refined in [4]. It allows us to define triple operator integrals of the form (3.1) for functions Φ in Haagerup-like tensor products of L∞ spaces.
We say that a measurable function Φ of three variables belongs to the Haagerup-like tensor productL∞(E1)⊗hL∞(E2)⊗hL∞(E3)of the first kind if it admits a representation
Φ(x,y,z)=j,k≥0∑αj(x)βk(y)γjk(z)(7)
with {αj}j≥0, {βk}k≥0∈L∞(ℓ2) and {γjk}j,k≥0∈L∞(B). We equip the space L∞(E1)⊗hL∞(E2)⊗hL∞(E3) with the norm
the infimum being taken over all representations of the form (3.2).
Let us now define triple operator integrals of the first gender with symbol Φ in the tensor product L∞(E1)⊗hL∞(E2)⊗hL∞(E3).
Suppose that 1≤p≤2. For Φ∈L∞(E1)⊗hL∞(E2)⊗hL∞(E3), for a bounded linear operator T, and for an operator R of class Sp, we define the triple operator integral
W=∭Φ(x,y,z)dE1(x)TdE2(y)RdE3(z)
of the first gender as the following continuous linear functional on Sp′, 1/p+1/p′=1 (on the class of compact operators in the case p=1):
Q↦trace((∭Φ(x,y,z)dE2(y)RdE3(z)QdE1(x))T).
It follows easily from the above Schatten–von Neumann properties of triple operator integrals with symbols in the Haagerup tensor product L∞⊗hL∞⊗hL∞ that W∈Sp and
∥W∥Sp≤∥Ψ∥L∞⊗hL∞⊗hL∞∥T∥Sp∥R∥,1≤p≤2,(8)
see [1] and [4]. Note that a considerably more general result on Schatten–von Neumann properties of triple operator integrals of the first gender is given in Theorem 5.1 of [4].
Let us proceed now to Haagerup tensor products of the second kind and triple operator integrals of the second gender.
We say that a function Φ belongs to the Haagerup-like tensor productL∞(E1)⊗hL∞(E2)⊗hL∞(E3)of the second kind if Φ admits a representation
Φ(x,y,z)=j,k≥0∑αjk(x)βj(y)γk(z)(9)
where {βj}j≥0, {γk}k≥0∈L∞(ℓ2), {αjk}j,k≥0∈L∞(B). The norm of Φ in the space L∞⊗hL∞⊗hL∞ is defined by
the infimum being taken over all representations of the form (3.4).
We proceed now to the definition of triple operator integrals of the second gender with integrand in the tensor product L∞(E1)⊗hL∞(E2)⊗hL∞(E3).
Suppose that Φ∈L∞(E1)⊗hL∞(E2)⊗hL∞(E3), T is a bounded linear operator, and R∈Sp, 1≤p≤2. The continuous linear functional
Q↦trace((∭Φ(x,y,z)dE3(z)QdE1(x)TdE2(y))R)
on the class Sp′ (on the class of compact operators in the case p=1) determines an operator W of class Sp, which we call the triple operator integral
A considerably more general result on Schatten–von Neumann properties of triple operator integrals of the second gender is given in Theorem 5.2 of [4].
Functions of p-almost commuting unitary operators
In this section we obtain commutator estimates for the calculus φ↦φ(U,V), φ∈B∞,1(T2) in Schatten–von Neumann norms Sp, 1≤p≤2, and show that this calculus is multiplicative modulo Sp.
With a function φ in B∞,1(T2) we associate two divided differences defined on T2 by
where by L∞ we can mean the L∞ space with respect to arbitrary Borel measures.
Theorem 4.1. Let 1≤p≤2 and φ∈B∞,1(T2). Let U and V be unitary operators and let Q be a bounded linear operator such that [U,Q]∈Sp and [V,Q]∈Sp. Suppose that φ is a function in the Besov class B∞,11(T2). Then [φ(U,V),Q]∈Sp,
Proof. The equality (11) can be proved by straightforward calculations for φ(ζ,τ)=ζmτn, where m,n∈Z. Hence, (11) and (12) hold for the trigonometric polynomials φ on T2.
Suppose now that φ is an arbitrary function in B∞,11(T2). Then D[1]φ∈L∞⊗hL∞⊗hL∞ and D[2]φ∈L∞⊗hL∞⊗hL∞ by Theorem 12.3 in [1]. Hence, the integrals in (11) are well defined. The function φ∈B∞,11(T2) can be can be represented in the form
φ=n≥0∑φn,
where φn:=φ∗Wn, where the trigonometric polynomials Wn are defined by (2.2). The required result is proved for each function φn. Hence, we have
In [10] the authors discovered the following trace formula for almost commuting unitary operators U and V on Hilbert space. They showed in Theorem (5.10) that for trigonometric polynomials φ and ψ the following trace formula holds
and the series converges absolutely, this proves the theorem. ■
The case of functions of contractions
Let T be a contraction on Hilbert space, i.e. ∥T∥≤1. Recall that each contraction T has a unique semispectral measureET defined on the σ-algebra of Borel subsets of T.
Recall that a map E defined on a σ-algebra Ω with values in the space B(H) of bounded linear operators on a Hilbert space H is called a semispectral measure if
0≤E(Δ)≤I,Δ∈Ω,
and E is countably additive in the strong operator topology.
The semispectral measure ET of a contraction T on H can be defined by
ET(Δ)=PHEU(Δ)H,Δ⊂T,
where U∈B(K) is a unitary dilation of T and PH is the orthogonal projection on K onto H. For a function f in the disc-algebra CA and a contraction T the following equality holds
f(T)=∫Tf(ζ)dET(ζ).
Denote by ET the semi-spectral measure of T. Let φ∈CA⊗hCA. We define φ(T,R) for contractions T and R by
In particular, φ(T,R) is well defined for φ∈(B∞,11)+(T2). We refer the reader to [5] for more detail. Here by (B∞,11(T2))+ we understand the subspace of B∞,11(T2) of functions that are analytic on D2.
Note that the definition of double operator integrals with respect to semispectral measures is similar to the case of spectral measures. Note also that double operator integrals with respect to semispectral measures appeared first in [Pe2]. We refer the reader to [5] for more information.
Theorem 6.1. Let 1≤p≤2 and let T and R be contractions and let Q be a bounded linear operator such that [T,Q]∈Sp and [R,Q]∈Sp. Suppose that φ∈(B∞,11)+(T2). Then [φ(T,R),Q]∈Sp,
In this section we prove that the commutator estimates for p∈[1,2] in Theorem 4.1 and Theorem 6.1 do not hold for p>2.
Theorem 7.1. Let M>0 and let 2<p≤∞. Then there exist unitary operators U and V, a bounded operator Q and an analytic polynomial f in two variables such that
Now Theorem 7.1 is an obvious consequence of Theorem 7.3 in [5].
A.B. Aleksandrov St.Petersburg State University Universitetskaya nab., 7/9 199034 St.Petersburg, Russia
St.Petersburg Department Steklov Institute of Mathematics Russian Academy of Sciences Fontanka 27, 191023 St.Petersburg Russia email: [email protected]
V.V. Peller St.Petersburg State University Universitetskaya nab., 7/9 199034 St.Petersburg, Russia
St.Petersburg Department Steklov Institute of Mathematics Russian Academy of Sciences Fontanka 27, 191023 St.Petersburg Russia email: [email protected]
Funding. The research on § 2-4 is supported by Russian Science Foundation [grant number 23-11-00153]. The research on § 5–§ 7 is supported by a grant of the Government of the Russian Federation for the state support of scientific research, carried out under the supervision of leading scientists, agreement 075-15-2025-013.
Conflict of interests. The authors declare no conflict of interests,
References
[1]A.B. Aleksandrov, F.L. Nazarov and V.V. Peller, Functions of noncommuting self-adjoint operators under perturbation and estimates of triple operator integrals, Advances in Math. 295 (2016), 1-52.arxiv.org/abs/1505.07173
[2]Aleksandrov A. B. , Peller V. V., Operator Lipschitz functions, Uspekhi Matem. Nauk. 71:4 (2016), 3–106 (Russian). English transl.: Russian Math. Surveys 71:4 (2016), 605–702.DOI
[3]A. B. Aleksandrov and V.V. Peller, Functions of almost commuting operators and an extension of the Helton–Howe trace formula, J. Funct. Anal. 271 (2016), 3300–3322.arxiv.org/abs/1508.04702
[4]A.B. Aleksandrov and V.V. Peller, Multiple operator integrals, Haagerup and Haagerup-like tensor products, and operator ideals, Bull. London Math. Soc. 49 (2017), 463–479.
[5]A.B. Aleksandrov and V.V. Peller, Functions of perturbed pairs of noncommuting contractions, Izvestia RAN, 84 (2020), 538–581 (Russian). English Transl.: Izvestiya: Mathematics 84 (2020), 659–682.arxiv.org/abs/1808.08566
[6]A.B. Aleksandrov and V.V. Peller, Haagerup tensor products and Schur multipliers, Algebra i Analiz 36:5 (2024), 70–85.arxiv.org/abs/2410.22523
[7]M.S. Birman and M.Z. Solomyak, Double Stieltjes operator integrals, Problems of Math. Phys., Leningrad. Univ. 1 (1966), 33–67 (Russian). English transl.: Topics Math. Physics 1 (1967), 25–54, Consultants Bureau Plenum Publishing Corporation, New York.
[9]M.S. Birman and M.Z. Solomyak, Double Stieltjes operator integrals. III, Problems of Math. Phys., Leningrad. Univ. 6 (1973), 27–53 (Russian).
[10]R.W. Carey and J.D. Pincus, Almost commuting pairs of unitary operators and flat currents, Int. Equat and Operator Theory 4 (1981), 45–122.DOI
[12]I.C. Gohberg and M.G. Krein, Introduction to the theory of linear nonselfadjoint operators in Hilbert space, Nauka, Moscow, 1965.
[13]J.W. Helton and R. Howe, Integral operators, commutators, traces, index, and homology, in “Lecture Notes in Math.”, vol. 345, pp. 141–209, Springer-Verlag, New York, 1973.DOI
[14]K. Juschenko, I.G. Todorov and L. Turowska, Multidimensional operator multipliers, Trans. Amer. Math. Soc. 361 (2009), 4683–4720.arxiv.org/abs/math/0701645
[16]B.S. Pavlov, On multiple operator integrals, Problems of Math. Anal., No. 2: Linear Operators and Operator Equations (Russian), 99–122. Izdat. Leningrad. Univ., Leningrad, 1969.
[17]J. Peetre, New thoughts on Besov spaces, Duke Univ. Press., Durham, NC, 1976.
[18]V.V. Peller, Hankel operators in the theory of perturbations of unitary and self-adjoint operators, Funktsional. Anal. i Prilozhen. 19:2 (1985), 37–51 (Russian). English transl.: Funct. Anal. Appl. 19 (1985), 111–123.DOI
[20]V.V. Peller, Functional calculus for a pair of almost commuting self-adjoint operators, J. Funct. Anal. 112 (1993), 325–345.