betaFeedback

WorksPhysics and Astronomy

The Kraichnan Model and Non-Equilibrium Statistical Physics of Diffusive Mixing

Abstract

We discuss application of methods from the Kraichnan model of turbulent advection to the study of non-equilibrium concentration fluctuations arising during diffusion in liquid mixtures at high Schmidt numbers. This approach treats nonlinear advection of concentration fluctuations exactly, without linearization. Remarkably, we find that static and dynamic structure functions obtained by this method reproduce precisely the predictions of linearized fluctuating hydrodynamics. It is argued that this agreement is an analogue of anomaly non-renormalization which does not, however, protect higher-order multi-point correlations. The latter should thus yield non-vanishing cumulants, unlike those for the Gaussian concentration fluctuations predicted by linearized theory.

Introduction

The Kraichnan model [1, 2, 3] of a passive scalar advected by a turbulent fluid has achieved a paradigmatic status in the modern theory of turbulence [4]. A breakthrough in the analytical calculation of anomalous scaling for scalar structure functions was initiated by the work of Gawȩdzki and Kupiainen [5], who exploited an expansion in the smoothness exponent ξ\xi of the velocity field around the rough limit ξ=0\xi= 0. This was followed very closely by alternative approaches based on expanding in powers of the inverse 1/d1/d of space dimension [6] and in powers of 2−ξ2-\xi for ξ\xi near 2 [7]. The Kraichnan model has been the source of fundamental new concepts in turbulence theory such as Lagrangian slow modes and spontaneous stochasticity [8] and it has proved also a valuable testing ground for general renormalization group methods [9, 10, 11] The contemporaneous reviews of Gawȩdzki [12, 13, 14, 15] written as progress reports still provide some of the most insightful and lucid expositions of this body of work.

More recently, the Kraichnan model has found an entirely new arena of application in the non-equilibrium statistical mechanics of diffusive mixing. The paper of Donev, Fai and vanden-Eijnden [16] (hereafter DFV) has shown that the equations for the scalar concentration field in a binary fluid mixture, which describe its advection by thermal fluctuations of the velocity in an otherwise quiescent fluid, reduce in the high-Schmidt limit to a version of the Kraichnan model and yield an economical scheme for efficient numerical computation. The subsequent work [17] applied the DFV theory analytically to investigate the effects of thermal noise on high-Schmidt turbulent mixing and showed, in the process, that the many powerful mathematical methods devised to treat turbulent advection in the Kraichnan model can be applied also to mixing by thermal fluctuations. In the present paper we shall explain further this application and present a few initial results of our ongoing investigation. This subject seems very suitable for the special journal issue in memory of Krzysztof Gawȩdzki. Among his very wide-ranging research pursuits, Gawȩdzki himself made important contributions to mathematical physics of non-equilibrium statistical mechanics for diffusion processes [18, 19, 20, 21]. We therefore offer this work in tribute to him and to express our deep gratitude for his scientific leadership and personal friendship.

Although diffusive mixing in a laminar fluid may appear to have little in common with turbulence, the physical analogies become apparent on closer inspection. In both problems, for example, there are scale-invariant fluctuations leading to correlations with power-law decay. Concentration correlations for steady-state diffusion with a mean concentration gradient imposed by the Soret effect were first studied by Law and Nieuwoudt [22, 23], who predicted long-ranged correlations characterized by a power-law divergence as k−4k^{-4} of the static structure function at low wave-numbers. This is a special case of the generic long-range fluctuations expected in non-equilibrium statistical steady-states [24, 25]. It was subsequently found by Vailati, Giglio, and co-workers that similar correlations occur also in isothermal free diffusion of a blob of concentration, where the mean concentration gradient is co-evolving with the fluctuations [26, 27, 28]. These non-equilibrium concentration fluctuations have been termed “giant” since they are orders of magnitude larger than thermal equilibrium fluctuations [26]. The scale of the fluctuations is also macroscopic, cut off only by buoyancy effects [26, 27, 28, 29], and, in low gravity environments, quenched only by the finite size of the sample [30, 31, 32, 33]. Indeed, as in turbulent eddy transport, diffusive flux in liquids can be understood to be generated entirely by the non-equilibrium fluctuations [16, 34, 35, 36]. Thus, the diffusion coefficient measured in a macroscopic experiment is in fact an “eddy diffusivity” due to advection of concentration by thermal velocity fluctuations.

The standard equations to describe this physics are the Landau-Lifschitz fluctuating hydrodynamics equations for a binary mixture in a solvent at rest [32, 37]:

ρ∂tv′=−∇p′+η△v′+∇⋅(2ηkBT η(x,t)),(1)\rho\partial_t \mathbf{v}' = -\nabla p' + \eta\triangle\mathbf{v}' + \nabla\cdot\left(\sqrt{2\eta k_B T}\,\boldsymbol{\eta}(\mathbf{x},t)\right), \tag*{(1)}
∂tc=−v′⋅∇c+∇⋅(D∇c).(2)\partial_t c = -\mathbf{v}' \cdot\nabla c + \nabla\cdot(D\nabla c). \tag*{(2)}

The fluctuation velocity v′\mathbf{v}' is assumed incompressible, ∇⋅v′=0\nabla\cdot\mathbf{v}' = 0, for constant mass density ρ\rho of the fluid, with this constraint enforced in (1) by the pressure p′p'. The tensor field η(x,t)\boldsymbol{\eta}(\mathbf{x},t) is Gaussian white-noise, symmetric and traceless, representing thermal fluctuating stress, with zero mean and covariance

⟨ηij(x,t)ηkl(x′,t′)⟩=(δikδjl+δilδjk−23δijδkl)δ3(x−x′)δ(t−t′).(3)\langle\eta_{ij}(\mathbf{x},t)\eta_{kl}(\mathbf{x}',t')\rangle= \left(\delta_{ik}\delta_{jl}+\delta_{il}\delta_{jk}-\frac{2}{3}\delta_{ij}\delta_{kl}\right)\delta^3(\mathbf{x}-\mathbf{x}')\delta(t-t'). \tag*{(3)}

The prefactor 2ηkBT\sqrt{2\eta k_B T} involving the shear viscosity η\eta and temperature TT is dictated by the fluctuation-dissipation relation so that the correct Gibbs equilibrium distribution is obtained for the equal-time velocity statistics with energy equipartition among wave-number modes (e.g., see Appendix A in [38]). We have neglected here, as in [32, 37], the similar thermal noise term in the equation (2) for the concentration cc, since the equilibrium fluctuations which it generates are far smaller than the giant concentration fluctuations (GCF’s) of primary interest. Note that DD in (2) is the molecular diffusivity and that we could also add to the diffusive mass current JD=−D∇c\mathbf{J}_D = -D\nabla c a term JT=−Dc(1−c)ST∇T\mathbf{J}_T = -Dc(1-c)S_T\nabla T corresponding to non-equilibrium mass flux driven by a temperature gradient ∇T\nabla T, with STS_T the Soret coefficient [39].

The present standard theory [34, 37, 40] based upon linearized fluctuating hydrodynamics proceeds by writing an equation for the mean concentration cˉ\bar{c}:

∂tcˉ=∇⋅(D∇cˉ),(4)\partial_t\bar{c} = \nabla\cdot(D\nabla\bar{c}), \tag*{(4)}

by then defining the concentration fluctuation c′=c−cˉc' = c-\bar{c}, and by finally linearizing (2) to obtain

∂tc′=−v′⋅∇cˉ+∇⋅(D∇c′),(5)\partial_t c' = -\mathbf{v}' \cdot\nabla\bar{c} + \nabla\cdot(D\nabla c'), \tag*{(5)}

with the term −v′⋅∇c′-\mathbf{v}'\cdot\nabla c' which is quadratic in fluctuations discarded. The latter linearized equation may then be solved exactly in the case of a stationary, homogeneous mean concentration gradient ∇cˉ\nabla\bar{c} [34, 37] or else approximately when the solution cˉ(x,t)\bar{c}(\mathbf{x},t) of (4) has a gradient ∇cˉ(x,t)\nabla\bar{c}(\mathbf{x},t) which is dependent upon x\mathbf{x} and tt [40]. This simple approach has yielded quite accurate predictions of experimental observations for free diffusion processes, except for minor deviations at early times when concentration gradients are relatively large [28]. However, current experimental efforts in low-gravity environments such as the NEUF-DIX space project [41, 42] are now exploring problems with large concentration gradients, high concentrations, and transient processes where the basic assumptions of the standard theory are invalid.

The exact asymptotic theory of DFV [16] is here very attractive because it is fully nonlinear and the basic assumption of high Schmidt number is well-satisfied in most of the liquid mixtures experimentally considered. An obstacle to serious consideration of this approach may have been the puzzling numerical result obtained in [16] for the single-time structure function S(k,t)S(k,t) in a free-diffusion experiment. Rather than the expected scaling S(k,t)∝k−4S(k,t) \propto k^{-4}, the numerical implementation of the DFV theory in [16] produced a result apparently more consistent with S(k,t)∝k−3S(k,t) \propto k^{-3}. On the other hand, it has now been shown by an exact mathematical analysis [17] that the DFV theory does yield S(k)∝k−4S(k) \propto k^{-4}, in close agreement with linearized theory, at least for a statistical steady state with random injection of concentration fluctuations. It was speculated in [17] that the simulation by DFV in [16] was not run for a sufficient time to observe the correct S(k,t)∝k−4S(k,t) \propto k^{-4} scaling or perhaps had an insufficient wavenumber range to clearly identify the power law exponent. Thus, the DFV theory does appear to give results consistent with linearized fluctuating hydrodynamics and, more importantly, in agreement with laboratory experiment.

In the present paper we further support this conclusion of [17] by solving exactly for the static and dynamic structure functions of the DFV theory in the situation of greatest experimental interest, where the GCF’s are generated by an imposed concentration gradient interacting with thermal velocity fluctuations. We first briefly review the DFV theory and then derive useful forms of the closed equations for the mean concentration and for the 2-point correlation function. We next solve these equations analytically for the simplest case of a stationary, homogeneous mean concentration gradient. The somewhat surprising result we obtain is that the nonlinear DFV theory yields precisely the same result for the structure function as does the standard linearized theory [34, 37, 40]. As we shall discuss, this result may be considered as a simple example of an “anomaly non-renormalization theorem”, which helps to explain the remarkable success of linearized fluctuating hydrodynamics in describing the observations from experiment and numerical simulation for 2nd-order statistics in high-Schmidt liquid mixtures. However, higher-order correlation functions of the concentration fluctuations are not protected by such a result and are unlikely to be given correctly by the Isserlis-Wick theorem for a Gaussian random field in terms of the 2nd-order order correlation function. We discuss some prospects for investigating these higher-order statistics.

DFV Theory and High-Schmidt Limit

In this section, we briefly review the work of DFV [16] on diffusive mixing in the limit of large Schmidt number and low Mach number in an isothermal quiescent fluid. A more detailed survey can be found in [43]. The starting point of the DFV theory differs from (1),(2) in two important respects. The equation (1) for the fluctuating velocity field is unchanged, but DFV assumed that the concentration field c(x,t)c(\mathbf{x},t) in a binary mixture satisfies the modified equation

∂tc=−u′⋅∇c+∇⋅(D0∇c).(6)\partial_t c=-\mathbf{u}'\cdot\nabla c+\nabla\cdot(D_0\nabla c). \tag*{(6)}

This differs from (2) firstly because D0D_0 now represents the bare molecular diffusivity before dressing by thermal fluctuations. Secondly, u′\mathbf{u}' is a coarse-grained advection velocity obtained by convolving the solution v′\mathbf{v}' of (1) with a smoothing kernel σ\sigma,

u′(x,t)=σ⋆v′=∫σ(x,x′)v′(x′,t) d3x′.(7)\mathbf{u}'(\mathbf{x},t)=\sigma\star\mathbf{v}'=\int\sigma(\mathbf{x},\mathbf{x}')\mathbf{v}'(\mathbf{x}',t)\,\mathrm{d}^3\mathbf{x}'. \tag*{(7)}

The cutoff length scale in this kernel, denoted σ\sigma, is taken to be of the order of the radius of the solute molecules. The underlying assumption is that the molecules (or perhaps even colloidal particles in suspension) feel only the fluctuating velocity field averaged over their extent.

With these basic assumptions, DFV then performed an exact asymptotic analysis in the limit of high Schmidt-number limit, Sc0≡ηD0ρ≫1Sc_0\equiv\frac{\eta}{D_0\rho}\gg1. Motivated by the well-known Stokes-Einstein relation D∼kBT/ησD\sim k_{\mathrm{B}}T/\eta\sigma, DFV introduced a small parameter ε≪1\varepsilon\ll1 to order quantities for formal asymptotics, adopting the scaling

η↦ε−1η,D0↦εD0(8)\eta\mapsto\varepsilon^{-1}\eta,\qquad D_0\mapsto\varepsilon D_0 \tag*{(8)}

such that D0η∼(const.)D_0\eta\sim(\mathit{const.}) and Sc0∼ε−2Sc_0\sim\varepsilon^{-2}. In the limit ε≪1\varepsilon\ll1, there exists a time scale separation between the fast viscous dynamics, governing the thermal velocity fluctuations v′\mathbf{v}', and much slower diffusive evolution of the concentration field cc. To formalize this time separation, DFV introduced a “macroscopic” diffusive time τ\tau which is related to the “microscopic” viscous time tt of Eqs. (1),(2) by t=ε−1τt=\varepsilon^{-1}\tau, or, equivalently, by the scaling

t↦ε−1t(9)t\mapsto\varepsilon^{-1}t \tag*{(9)}

with τ\tau renamed tt. This procedure leads to a limiting stochastic advection-diffusion equation for the concentration field in the “macroscopic” time:

∂tc=−w⊙∇c+D0Δc,(10)\partial_t c=-\mathbf{w}\mathbin{\odot}\nabla c+D_0\Delta c, \tag*{(10)}

where ⊙\odot represents a Stratonovich dot product and w(x,t)\mathbf{w}(\mathbf{x},t) is an incompressible, advecting random velocity field which is white noise in time, with zero mean and covariance

⟨w(x,t)⊗w(x′,t′)⟩=R(x,x′)δ(t−t′),R(x,x′)=2kBTη(σ⋆G⋆σT)(x,x′).(11)\langle\mathbf{w}(\mathbf{x},t)\otimes\mathbf{w}(\mathbf{x}',t')\rangle=\mathbf{R}(\mathbf{x},\mathbf{x}')\delta(t-t'), \qquad \mathbf{R}(\mathbf{x},\mathbf{x}')=\frac{2k_{\mathrm{B}}T}{\eta}\left(\boldsymbol{\sigma}\star\mathbf{G}\star\boldsymbol{\sigma}^{\mathrm{T}}\right)(\mathbf{x},\mathbf{x}'). \tag*{(11)}

The tensor G\mathbf{G} is the Green’s function of the linear Stokes operator, which is singular for x=x′\mathbf{x}=\mathbf{x}', unlike the smoothed tensor R\mathbf{R} which is regular at coinciding points. Because of the delta-in-time correlation of the random velocity w\mathbf{w}, Eq. (10) for the concentration field is in fact a version of the Kraichnan model (see below). The spatial realizations of random thermal velocity w\mathbf{w} can be obtained from the stationary Stokes equation with smoothed thermal forcing

−∇q+νΔw+∇⋅(2νkBTρησ)=0(12)-\nabla q+\nu\Delta\mathbf{w}+\nabla\cdot\left(\sqrt{\frac{2\nu k_{\mathrm{B}}T}{\rho}}\boldsymbol{\eta}_{\sigma}\right)=0 \tag*{(12)}

where ησ=σ⋆η\boldsymbol{\eta}_{\sigma}=\boldsymbol{\sigma}\star\boldsymbol{\eta} and qq is determined by ∇⋅w=0\nabla\cdot\mathbf{w}=0. The physical content of the above equation is that viscous diffusion and thermal fluctuations are in instantaneous balance for the effective advecting velocity w\mathbf{w}, with long-range spatial correlations induced by the incompressibility condition.

Whereas the starting advection-diffusion equation in the DFV theory, Eq. (6), contains the bare diffusivity D0D_0 the reduced equation (10) in the limit Sc≫1Sc\gg1 involves a renormalized diffusivity. This can be seen easily by writing the Itō form of Eq. (10):

∂tc=−w⋅∇c+∇⋅(D(x)∇c),(13)\partial_t c=-\mathbf{w}\cdot\nabla c+\nabla\cdot\left(\mathbf{D}(\mathbf{x})\nabla c\right), \tag*{(13)}

with

D(x):=D0I+12R(x,x).(14)\mathbf{D}(\mathbf{x}):=D_0\mathbf{I}+\frac{1}{2}\mathbf{R}(\mathbf{x},\mathbf{x}). \tag*{(14)}

The latter renormalized diffusivity originates from advection by the viscously slaved thermal velocity fluctuations and is similar to an “eddy-diffusivity” due to eliminated turbulent eddies in turbulent flows. As emphasized by DFV, generally D0≪∣D(x)∣D_0\ll\lvert\mathbf{D}(\mathbf{x})\rvert and, indeed, one may consider the limit of vanishing bare diffusivity, D0→0D_0\to0, with essentially no empirical consequence.

The original paper of DFV elaborated two types of numerical algorithm to solve for realizations of c(x,t)c(\mathbf{x},t) in the asymptotic theory; see [16], Appendix B. The first Eulerian method was based on a straightforward predictor-corrector integrator for the stochastic advection-diffusion equation (10) with a staggered finite-volume discretization in space. The realizations of w\mathbf{w} were obtained from the Stokes equation (12) with an iterative Krylov linear solver. Discretizing the advection term w⋅∇c\mathbf{w}\cdot\nabla c with a non-dissipative centered-difference formula was shown to maintain discrete fluctuation-dissipation balance, but requires a non-vanishing bare diffusivity D0D_0 for numerical stability. A second Lagrangian numerical scheme was obtained by a spectral decomposition of the covariance

R(x,x′)=∑αϕα(x)ϕα(x′)R(\mathbf{x},\mathbf{x}') = \sum_{\alpha} \phi_{\alpha}(\mathbf{x})\phi_{\alpha}(\mathbf{x}')

and by then solving the Lagrangian equations for space positions of NN tracer particles

dqn(t)dt=w(qn(t),t)+2D0 η0(t),n=1,…,N=∑αϕα(qn(t))ηα(t)+2D0 η0(t),(15)\frac{d\mathbf{q}_n(t)}{dt} = \mathbf{w}(\mathbf{q}_n(t),t) + \sqrt{2D_0}\,\boldsymbol{\eta}_0(t), \qquad n=1,\ldots,N = \sum_{\alpha}\phi_{\alpha}(\mathbf{q}_n(t))\boldsymbol{\eta}_{\alpha}(t) + \sqrt{2D_0}\,\boldsymbol{\eta}_0(t), \tag*{(15)}

with i.i.d. scalar white-noises ηα(t)\eta_{\alpha}(t) and vector white noise η0(t)\boldsymbol{\eta}_0(t). Efficient evaluation of the summation over α\alpha in (15) requires a non-uniform FFT method to evaluate w(x,t)\mathbf{w}(\mathbf{x},t) only at the particle locations. Finally, with initial tracer particle positions distributed in space according to the concentration field c0(x)c_0(\mathbf{x}), then the field at later times is approximated by

c(x,t)=1N∑n=1Nδ3(x−qn(t)).c(\mathbf{x},t) = \frac{1}{N}\sum_{n=1}^{N}\delta^3(\mathbf{x}-\mathbf{q}_n(t)).

This algorithm has cost scaling linearly in NN and can be applied with D0=0D_0=0, but requires large numbers of particles NN for convergence. Both of these numerical schemes can be applied in the experimentally relevant case of finite spatial domains and can incorporate additional important effects, such as buoyancy.

Another powerful feature of the DFV theory, although not fully exploited in [16], is the existence of closed partial differential equations for the scalar correlation functions of any arbitrary order. This follows from the fact that the long-time, high-ScSc limit concentration equation in the DFV theory, Eq. (10), is indeed a version of the Kraichnan model [1, 2, 4] in which there is no closure problem for correlation functions. In the Kraichnan model, the equal-time pp-point correlation functions Cp(x1,…,xp;t):=⟨c(x1,t)c(x2,t)⋯c(xp,t)⟩C_p(\mathbf{x}_1,\ldots,\mathbf{x}_p;t):=\langle c(\mathbf{x}_1,t)c(\mathbf{x}_2,t)\cdots c(\mathbf{x}_p,t)\rangle averaged over realizations of the thermal velocity w\mathbf{w} for scalar field c(x,t)c(\mathbf{x},t) governed by Eq. (10) satisfy an exact closed differential equation (see e.g., [43]; for a detailed review of the Kraichnan model see [4, 12, 13, 14, 15]). For p=1p=1, C1(x,t)=⟨c(x,t)⟩:=c‾(x,t)C_1(\mathbf{x},t)=\langle c(\mathbf{x},t)\rangle:=\overline{c}(\mathbf{x},t), the mean concentration field, satisfies the diffusion equation with renormalized diffusivity:

∂tc‾(x,t)=12∇xi[Rij(x,x)∇xjc‾(x,t)]+D0Δxc‾(x,t).(16)\partial_t\overline{c}(\mathbf{x},t)=\frac{1}{2}\nabla_{x_i}\left[R_{ij}(\mathbf{x},\mathbf{x})\nabla_{x_j}\overline{c}(\mathbf{x},t)\right]+D_0\Delta_{\mathbf{x}}\overline{c}(\mathbf{x},t). \tag*{(16)}

and for p=2p=2

∂∂tC2(x1,x2,t)=D0∑n=12ΔxnC2(x1,x2,t)+12∑n,m=12∇xni[Rij(xn,xm)∇xmjC2(x1,x2,t)],(17)\begin{aligned} \frac{\partial}{\partial t}C_2(\mathbf{x}_1,\mathbf{x}_2,t)=D_0\sum_{n=1}^{2}\Delta_{\mathbf{x}_n}C_2(\mathbf{x}_1,\mathbf{x}_2,t) \\ &+\frac{1}{2}\sum_{n,m=1}^{2}\nabla_{x_n}^{i}\left[R_{ij}(x_n,x_m)\nabla_{x_m}^{j}C_2(x_1,x_2,t)\right], \tag*{(17)} \end{aligned}

where R\mathbf{R} is the spatial covariance of the random velocity field, given by Eq. (11). Combining these two equations yields a corresponding closed PDE for the concentration 2nd-order cumulant (connected correlation) function C(x1,x2,t):=⟨c(x1,t)c(x2,t)⟩−⟨c(x1,t)⟩⟨c(x2,t)⟩=C2(x1,x2,t)−cˉ(x1,t)cˉ(x2,t)C(x_1,x_2,t) := \langle c(x_1,t)c(x_2,t)\rangle-\langle c(x_1,t)\rangle\langle c(x_2,t)\rangle= C_2(x_1,x_2,t)-\bar{c}(x_1,t)\bar{c}(x_2,t):

∂tC(x1,x2,t)=D0∑n=12ΔxnC(x1,x2,t)+12∑n,m=12∇xni[Rij(xn,xm)∇xmjC(x1,x2,t)]+Rij(x1,x2)∇x1icˉ(x1,t)∇x2jcˉ(x2,t)(18)\begin{aligned} \partial_t C(x_1,x_2,t) &= D_0\sum_{n=1}^{2}\Delta_{x_n}C(x_1,x_2,t) \\ &\quad+\frac{1}{2}\sum_{n,m=1}^{2}\nabla_{x_n}^{i}\left[R_{ij}(x_n,x_m)\nabla_{x_m}^{j}C(x_1,x_2,t)\right] \\ &\quad+R_{ij}(x_1,x_2)\nabla_{x_1}^{i}\bar{c}(x_1,t)\nabla_{x_2}^{j}\bar{c}(x_2,t) \tag*{(18)} \end{aligned}

Similar results hold for all p>2p>2.

Furthermore, multi-time concentration correlations such as C(x,t;x′,t′):=⟨c(x,t)c(x′,t′)⟩−⟨c(x,t)⟩⟨c(x′,t′)⟩C(x,t;x',t') := \langle c(x,t)c(x',t')\rangle-\langle c(x,t)\rangle\langle c(x',t')\rangle can also be obtained in the Kraichnan model. Once the single-time time correlations are known, these can be obtained by solving additional closed PDE’s, e.g. for p=2p=2 one must solve the equation

∂tC(x,t;x′,t′)=∇x⋅((D0I+12R(x,x))⋅∇xC(x,t;x′,t′))(19)\begin{aligned} \partial_t C(x,t;x',t') = \nabla_x\cdot\left(\left(D_0\mathbf{I}+\frac{1}{2}\mathbf{R}(x,x)\right)\cdot\nabla_x C(x,t;x',t')\right) \tag*{(19)} \end{aligned}

for t>t′t>t' with C(x,x′,t′)C(x,x',t') as initial data. The equation (19) follows because of the Markovian character of the dynamics in the Itō form (13). Clearly, this equation implies that the correlations of concentration fluctuations in the Kraichnan model are relaxed by diffusion with the renormalized diffusivity. Thus, the Onsager regression hypothesis [44, 45] becomes exact in the high-Schmidt limit instantaneously in time, without the need for any aging interval. Because the Kraichnan model dynamics is time-reversible, the results for t<t′t<t' are identical to those for t>t′t>t', depending only upon ∣t−t′∣\lvert t-t'\rvert.

The above closed equations have the form of parabolic diffusion equations with position-dependent diffusivities. They can be derived in finite domains with realistic boundary conditions, where they may provide valuable predictions for experimental flows. In general, these equations must be solved computationally using numerical PDE methods, which will become more challenging for complex geometries and especially for high-order statistics with p>2p>2 when the diffusion equation is very multi-dimensional. In the next section we discuss a simple setting where exact analytical solutions are possible.

Diffusion in an Unbounded Fluid

To get some insight about the predictions of the DFV theory, it is useful to consider the idealized case of a fluid mixture in unbounded 3D space, so that velocity statistics are spatially homogeneous and isotropic. In that case the Green’s function of the Stokes operator is given also in closed form by the Oseen-Burgers tensor

Gij(x,x′)=Gij(x−x′)=18πr(δij+rirjr2)(20)G_{ij}(\mathbf{x},\mathbf{x}')=G_{ij}(\mathbf{x}-\mathbf{x}')=\frac{1}{8\pi r}\left(\delta_{ij}+\frac{r_i r_j}{r^2}\right) \tag*{(20)}

with r=x−x′\mathbf{r}=\mathbf{x}-\mathbf{x}'. Consequently, the covariance of the random thermal velocity w\mathbf{w} in the DFV theory becomes

Rij(r)=kBT4πηr(δij+rirjr2),r≫σ(21)R_{ij}(\mathbf{r})=\frac{k_{\mathrm{B}}T}{4\pi\eta r}\left(\delta_{ij}+\frac{r_i r_j}{r^2}\right),\qquad r\gg\sigma \tag*{(21)}

independent of the choice of the filter kernel σ\boldsymbol{\sigma} in (11). In a homogeneous and isotropic flow of this type, the effective diffusivity D\mathbf{D} defined in (14) becomes independent of x\mathbf{x} with Dij=Rij(0)/2=DδijD_{ij}=R_{ij}(0)/2=D\delta_{ij}. (Here and hereafter we assume D0=0D_0=0 for simplicity). The precise value of DD does depend now upon the filter kernel σ\boldsymbol{\sigma}, with the kernel used in [16] selected precisely to give

D=kBT6πησ(22)D=\frac{k_{\mathrm{B}}T}{6\pi\eta\sigma} \tag*{(22)}

in agreement with the Stokes-Einstein relation for a suspension of hard spheres of radius σ\sigma. However, any reasonable choice of filter gives a result identical to (22) with 6π6\pi replaced by another numerical constant of order unity. Thus, with a suitable redefinition of the filter width σ\sigma, sometimes called the “hydrodynamic radius,” the result in (22) can always be taken to hold by convention. The DFV theory thus explains the empirical success of the Stokes-Einstein formula as the effect of strong renormalization of a small bare diffusivity due to advection of solute molecules by thermal velocity fluctuations.

We next discuss some specific situations in unbounded domains where the DFV closed equations for mean and correlation function of the concentration field can be simplified and even solved analytically.

Free Diffusion

As discussed in the Introduction, giant concentration fluctuations with structure function S(k,t)∝k−4S(k,t)\propto k^{-4} have been observed very notably in free decay experiments where an initial blob of concentration diffuses in a fluid at rest [26, 27, 28]. We illustrate here the closed equations that arise from the DFV theory in such free diffusion when the fluid is idealised as unbounded.

A simple initial configuration of the scalar with maximal symmetry is a plane sharp interface at z=0z=0, dividing two regions z>0z>0 with constant concentrations

c={c0z>00z<0(23)c = \begin{cases} c_0 & z > 0 \\ 0 & z < 0 \end{cases} \tag*{(23)}

See Figure 1. We consider here deterministic initial data for the concentration field, for simplicity, but it is easy to include thermal equilibrium fluctuations or other zero-mean random perturbations (see below). The equation (16) for the mean concentration profile reduces here to the 1D diffusion equation,

Initial distribution for a concentration field with a sharp interface

Figure 1. Initial distribution (t=0t = 0) for a concentration field c(z,t)c(z,t) with non-zero value c=c0c = c_0 in the region z>0z > 0 with a sharp interface at z=0z = 0.

∂∂tcˉ(z,t)=D∂z2cˉ(z,t)(24)\frac{\partial}{\partial t}\bar{c}(z,t) = D\partial_z^2\bar{c}(z,t) \tag*{(24)}

with diffusivity DD given by (22). For the step-function initial condition, this has the well-known solution

cˉ(z,t)=c02(1+erf⁡(z2Dt))(25)\bar{c}(z,t) = \frac{c_0}{2}\left(1+\operatorname{erf}\left(\frac{z}{2\sqrt{Dt}}\right)\right) \tag*{(25)}

in terms of the error function erf⁡(z)\operatorname{erf}(z).

The equation (18) for the 2nd-order cumulant can be simplified by introducing relative and mean variables

r=x1−x2=(x,y,z),X=12(x1+x2)=(X,Y,Z)\mathbf{r} = \mathbf{x}_1-\mathbf{x}_2 = (x,y,z), \qquad\mathbf{X} = \frac{1}{2}(\mathbf{x}_1+\mathbf{x}_2) = (X,Y,Z)

and by noting that, from 2D translational symmetry, CC depends only upon r\mathbf{r} and ZZ, so that:

∂tC=12(D+R33(r)2)∂Z2C+(Rij(0)−Rij(r))∂i∂jC+R33(r)∇cˉ(Z+z2)∇cˉ(Z−z2).(26)\partial_t C = \frac{1}{2}\left(D+\frac{R_{33}(\mathbf{r})}{2}\right)\partial_Z^2 C + \left(R_{ij}(\mathbf{0})-R_{ij}(\mathbf{r})\right)\partial_i\partial_j C + R_{33}(\mathbf{r})\nabla\bar{c}\left(Z+\frac{z}{2}\right)\nabla\bar{c}\left(Z-\frac{z}{2}\right). \tag*{(26)}

However, furthermore, there is rotational symmetry around the zz-axis. Working in spherical coordinates defined as (r,θ,ϕ)(r,\theta,\phi), this means that C=C(r,θ,Z,t)C=C(r,\theta,Z,t) must be independent of azimuthal angle ϕ\phi. In those variables, it is tedious but straightforward to show that (26) becomes for r≫σr \gg\sigma

∂tC=kBT4πησ(13+σ4r(1+cos⁡2θ))∂Z2C+kBT3πησ1r2∂∂r[r2(1−3σ2r)∂C∂r]+kBT3πησ1r2sin⁡θ(1−3σ4r)∂∂θ(sin⁡θ∂C∂θ)+kBT4πη1r(1+cos⁡2θ)∇cˉ(Z+z2)∇cˉ(Z−z2),(27)\begin{aligned} \partial_t C={}&\frac{k_{\mathrm{B}}T}{4\pi\eta\sigma}\left(\frac{1}{3}+\frac{\sigma}{4r}(1+\cos^2\theta)\right)\partial_Z^2 C\\ &+\frac{k_{\mathrm{B}}T}{3\pi\eta\sigma}\frac{1}{r^2}\frac{\partial}{\partial r}\left[r^2\left(1-\frac{3\sigma}{2r}\right)\frac{\partial C}{\partial r}\right]\\ &+\frac{k_{\mathrm{B}}T}{3\pi\eta\sigma}\frac{1}{r^2\sin\theta}\left(1-\frac{3\sigma}{4r}\right)\frac{\partial}{\partial\theta}\left(\sin\theta\frac{\partial C}{\partial\theta}\right)\\ &+\frac{k_{\mathrm{B}}T}{4\pi\eta}\frac{1}{r}(1+\cos^2\theta)\nabla\bar{c}\left(Z+\frac{z}{2}\right)\nabla\bar{c}\left(Z-\frac{z}{2}\right), \tag*{(27)} \end{aligned}

where r=(x2+y2+z2)1/2r=(x^2+y^2+z^2)^{1/2} and z=rcos⁡θz=r\cos\theta. Here we can recognize the scale-dependent diffusivity

D(r)=kBT6πησ(1−3σ2r).(28)D(r)=\frac{k_{\mathrm{B}}T}{6\pi\eta\sigma}\left(1-\frac{3\sigma}{2r}\right). \tag*{(28)}

that appeared in our earlier work [43], Eq. (58), for the fully isotropic problem. The end result (27) is a diffusion equation in the 3D space of variables (r,θ,Z)(r,\theta,Z). The initial correlation C0C_0 will depend upon the random initial concentration field adopted, e.g. C0≡0C_0\equiv0 for the deterministic initial data discussed above. Even for the highly symmetric physical configuration considered, the simplified version of the general equation (18) for the concentration correlation CC is too complicated for a fully analytical solution. However, with proper regularization of the divergences at r=0r=0 (e.g. see [43], Eqs. (56)–(57)), the PDE (27) can be solved by numerical discretization methods. Furthermore, the solution may be rationally approximated by a combination of numerics and analysis. Another case which yields similar simplifications is the problem of an initial spherical blob of concentration. Nonequilibrium concentration fluctuations in inhomogeneous, anisotropic and time-dependent free decay is the subject of ongoing work based on the DFV theory and will be presented elsewhere. However, it turns out that with one further simplification the equation (27) becomes mathematically solvable, as discussed in the following subsection.

Constant Concentration Gradient

An even simpler limiting case of the problem in the previous section is obtained by letting t→∞t\to\infty, c0→∞c_0\to\infty so that t=c02/4Dπγ2t=c_0^2/4D\pi\gamma^2 is held fixed for some constant γ\gamma. In that case the error-function profile (25), after subtraction of the divergent constant c0c_0, reduces to the case of constant gradient, cˉ=(∇cˉ)z\bar{c}=(\nabla\bar{c})z with ∇cˉ=γ\nabla\bar{c}=\gamma. This idealized situation has been studied before using linearized fluctuating hydrodynamics and exactly solved within that approximation [34, 37, 40]. Here we study this same problem using the high-Schmidt asymptotic theory of DFV without neglecting nonlinear interactions.

This problem remains anisotropic because of the imposed gradient but it is now fully space-homogeneous and yields a time-independent steady-state. Therefore we may neglect derivatives with respect to ZZ and tt in equation (27), yielding

2r2∂∂r[r2(1−3σ2r)∂C∂r]+2r2sin⁡θ(1−3σ4r)∂∂θ(sin⁡θ∂C∂θ)+3σ2r(1+cos⁡2θ)∣∇c∣2=0,(29)\frac{2}{r^{2}}\frac{\partial}{\partial r}\left[r^{2}\left(1-\frac{3\sigma}{2r}\right)\frac{\partial C}{\partial r}\right]+\frac{2}{r^{2}\sin\theta}\left(1-\frac{3\sigma}{4r}\right)\frac{\partial}{\partial\theta}\left(\sin\theta\frac{\partial C}{\partial\theta}\right)+\frac{3\sigma}{2r}(1+\cos^{2}\theta)|\nabla c|^{2}=0, \tag*{(29)}

whose solution is the steady-state correlation C(r,θ)C(r,\theta),

As a first step in finding the solution, we may consider the correlation function averaged over solid angle:

C‾(r):=14π∫C(r,θ) dΩ=12∫0πsin⁡θ C(r,θ) dθ.(30)\overline{C}(r):=\frac{1}{4\pi}\int C(r,\theta)\,d\Omega=\frac{1}{2}\int_{0}^{\pi}\sin\theta\,C(r,\theta)\,d\theta. \tag*{(30)}

Because of linearity of the equation (29), this averaged correlation satisfies the ODE

1r2∂∂r[r2(1−3σ2r)∂C‾∂r]+σr∣∇c∣2=0.(31)\frac{1}{r^{2}}\frac{\partial}{\partial r}\left[r^{2}\left(1-\frac{3\sigma}{2r}\right)\frac{\partial\overline{C}}{\partial r}\right]+\frac{\sigma}{r}|\nabla c|^{2}=0. \tag*{(31)}

Physically, this ODE corresponds to an isotropic system where the concentration gradient is not pointing in the zz-coordinate direction but is instead pointing in a random direction uniformly distributed over solid angles. The general solution of this ODE is of the form

C‾(r)=−σ∣∇c∣22(r+32σln⁡∣r−32σ∣)+Aln⁡∣1−3σ2r∣+B(32)\overline{C}(r)=-\frac{\sigma|\nabla c|^{2}}{2}\left(r+\frac{3}{2}\sigma\ln\left|r-\frac{3}{2}\sigma\right|\right)+A\ln\left|1-\frac{3\sigma}{2r}\right|+B \tag*{(32)}

for constants AA, BB, but in the large-rr range of interest the solution reduces to

C‾(r)=˙−σ∣∇c∣22r+const.,r≫σ.\overline{C}(r)\mathrel{\dot=}-\frac{\sigma|\nabla c|^{2}}{2}r+\mathrm{const.},\qquad r\gg\sigma.

This result shows the expected scaling ∝r\propto r in physical space associated to GCF’s [17, 37].

We can now look for the solution of the original anisotropic problem (29) in the separable form C(r,θ)=C‾(r)G(θ)C(r,\theta)=\overline{C}(r)\mathcal{G}(\theta). This strategy is successful for the range r≫σr\gg\sigma and leads to the following autonomous equation for G\mathcal{G}

1sin⁡θ∂∂θ(sin⁡θ∂G∂θ)+2G=32(1+cos⁡2θ).(33)\frac{1}{\sin\theta}\frac{\partial}{\partial\theta}\left(\sin\theta\frac{\partial\mathcal{G}}{\partial\theta}\right)+2\mathcal{G}=\frac{3}{2}(1+\cos^{2}\theta). \tag*{(33)}

This ODE can be solved easily by first substituting ξ=cos⁡θ\xi= \cos\theta and finding a particular solution and general homogeneous solution by the Frobenius series method. One of the homogeneous solutions contains a logarithm and must be discarded as unphysical due to its non-smoothness at θ=π/2\theta= \pi/2. The result for the anisotropy factor is then found to be

G(θ)=38(2+sin⁡2θ)+A(1−cos⁡2θ2−cos⁡4θ8+⋯ ),(34)\mathcal{G}(\theta) = \frac{3}{8}(2+\sin^{2}\theta) + A\left(1-\frac{\cos^{2}\theta}{2}-\frac{\cos^{4}\theta}{8}+\cdots\right), \tag*{(34)}

where the constant AA is to be determined by the condition (30). It turns out that the latter condition is satisfied exactly by the indicated particular solution, so that A=0A = 0 and we obtain the final result

C(r,θ)≃−316σ∣∇cˉ∣2r(2+sin⁡2θ),r≫σ.(35)C(r,\theta) \simeq-\frac{3}{16}\sigma|\nabla\bar{c}|^{2}r(2+\sin^{2}\theta), \qquad r \gg\sigma. \tag*{(35)}

To our knowledge, this full physical-space correlation of GCF’s has not been noted in the literature before. See [37] for previous partial results.

The scaling of GCF’s is more typically given in Fourier space by the static structure function

S(k)=∫C(r,θ)eik⋅r d3r=∫0∞r2 dr∫0πsin⁡θ dθ∫02πdϕ C(r,θ)ei(k∥rcos⁡θ+k⊥rsin⁡θcos⁡ϕ),(36)\begin{aligned} S(k) = \int C(r,\theta)e^{i\mathbf{k}\cdot\mathbf{r}}\,d^{3}r \\ &= \int_{0}^{\infty}r^{2}\,dr\int_{0}^{\pi}\sin\theta\,d\theta\int_{0}^{2\pi}d\phi\,C(r,\theta)e^{i(k_{\parallel}r\cos\theta+k_{\perp}r\sin\theta\cos\phi)}, \tag*{(36)} \end{aligned}

where k∥k_{\parallel} is magnitude of the wavenumber component parallel to ∇cˉ\nabla\bar{c} and k⊥k_{\perp} is magnitude of the perpendicular component. The argument of the exponential function in the above expression can be simplified by applying a rotation to the spherical coordinate system (r,θ,ϕ)(r,\theta,\phi) by angle α=tan⁡−1(k⊥/k∥)\alpha= \tan^{-1}(k_{\perp}/k_{\parallel}), which results in standard integrals over the new polar angle θ′\theta'. Introducing an IR cut-off, the integral over rr can be easily evaluated, with the final result given by

S(k)=6πσ∣∇cˉ∣2k^⊥2k4=kBTDη∣∇cˉ∣2k^⊥2k4,kσ≪1(37)S(k) = 6\pi\sigma|\nabla\bar{c}|^{2}\frac{\hat{k}_{\perp}^{2}}{k^{4}} = \frac{k_{\mathrm{B}}T}{D\eta}|\nabla\bar{c}|^{2}\frac{\hat{k}_{\perp}^{2}}{k^{4}}, \qquad k\sigma\ll1 \tag*{(37)}

where k^⊥\hat{k}_{\perp} is the perpendicular component of the unit vector k^=k/k\hat{\mathbf{k}} = \mathbf{k}/k. See Appendix A. Remarkably, this is identical to the result predicted by linearized fluctuating hydrodynamics [34, 37, 40], in the limit of high Schmidt number and with negligible buoyancy effects.

The dynamic structure function is similarly defined in terms of the 2-time correlation function C(r,τ)=⟨c′(x+r,t+τ)c′(x,t)⟩C(\mathbf{r},\tau) = \langle c'(\mathbf{x}+\mathbf{r},t+\tau)c'(\mathbf{x},t)\rangle as

S(k,ω)=∬C(r,τ)eik⋅r−iωτ d3r dτ.(38)S(k,\omega) = \iint C(\mathbf{r},\tau)e^{i\mathbf{k}\cdot\mathbf{r}-i\omega\tau}\,d^{3}r\,d\tau. \tag*{(38)}

Because of space-homogeneity the general equation (19) for 2-time correlations reduces to

∂τC(r,τ)=DΔrC(r,τ)(39)\partial_{\tau} C(\mathbf{r},\tau) = D\Delta_{\mathbf{r}} C(\mathbf{r},\tau) \tag*{(39)}

for τ>0\tau> 0 and the corresponding anti-diffusion equation for τ<0\tau< 0. We thus obtain

S(k,ω)=∫−∞+∞S(k)e−2Dk2∣τ∣e−iωτ dτ=S(k)2Dk2ω2+(Dk2)2=kBTDη∣∇c∣2k⊥2k42Dk2ω2+(Dk2)2,kσ≪1\begin{aligned} S(k,\omega) &= \int_{-\infty}^{+\infty} S(k)e^{-2Dk^2|\tau|}e^{-i\omega\tau}\,\mathrm{d}\tau\\ &= S(k)\frac{2Dk^2}{\omega^2+(Dk^2)^2} \\ &= \frac{k_{\mathrm{B}}T}{D\eta}|\nabla c|^2\frac{k_{\perp}^2}{k^4}\frac{2Dk^2}{\omega^2+(Dk^2)^2}, \qquad k\sigma\ll1 \end{aligned}

once again in perfect agreement with the prediction of linearized theory [34, 37, 40]. Evident here is the central Rayleigh peak which determines the light scattering properties of the mixture.

Conclusions

It is not obvious why the DFV theory results (37),(40) for the concentration structure function should agree with the predictions of linearized fluctuating hydrodynamics in the limit of high Schmidt number. This agreement means that the neglected nonlinear terms which dynamically couple the fluctuations of velocity and concentration do not modify at all the 2nd-order correlations created by the direct random advection of the mean concentration gradient. The situation is somewhat reminiscent of the non-renormalization theorems for the chiral anomaly in quantum gauge theory. The Adler-Bardeen theorem [46, 47], nicely rederived by a renormalization group argument of Zee [48], implies that the result of the leading-order triangle diagram is not modified by higher corrections from nonlinear interactions to any order in perturbation theory. This analogy is fitting for the scalar 2-point correlation function, since its scaling in the Kraichnan model is well-known to be connected with the scalar dissipation anomaly. As discussed by Gawędzki [12], Lecture 3, or [13], Lecture 4, the 2-point correlation scaling in the Kraichnan model is analogous to the exact 4/5th law in hydrodynamic turbulence which expresses the dissipative anomaly. Just as for the 3rd-order velocity structure function in hydrodynamic turbulence, the 2nd-order correlation in the Kraichnan model has scaling given by dimensional analysis and is protected from acquiring anomalous scaling because of the lack of non-constant zero modes of its linear evolution operator. But note that a true dissipative anomaly as D0→0D_0 \to0 will not occur for the concentration variance in diffusive mixing according to the DFV theory, due to the regularity of the advecting velocity w\mathbf{w} at scale σ\sigma! See [16], section 3.1.

The DFV theory results help to explain the remarkable agreement of linearized fluctuating hydrodynamics predictions with existing observations from experiment and simulation. They furthermore confirm the finding of [17] that the DFV theory reproduces the expected scaling ∝k−4\propto k^{-4} of the static structure function. This result opens the door to the use of the DFV theory for problems of current interest with large gradients, high concentrations and transient dynamics [41, 42]. Note that in the derivation of the equation (16) for the mean concentration cˉ(x,t)\bar{c}(\mathbf{x},t) and equation (18) for the fluctuation correlation C(x,x′,t)C(\mathbf{x},\mathbf{x}',t) there is no assumption of a separation in space and time scales for these two quantities, which co-evolve together. Thus, joint solution of these two equations provides a more systematic approach than current approximate solutions of the linearized equations that assume scale separation [40]. There is also no assumption of small concentrations or weak gradients in the derivation of the equations (16),(18), which can be obtained as well with realistic boundary conditions in finite domains. For highly symmetric geometries such as the plane interface in an unbounded fluid discussed in § 3 these equations take simplified forms such as (24),(27) which can be readily solved numerically, if not analytically. A Soret flux JT=−DcST∇Tˉ\mathbf{J}_{T}=-D c S_{T}\nabla\bar{T} associated with a mean temperature gradient can also be incorporated, although closure requires the assumption of weak concentrations so that c(1−c)≃cc(1-c)\simeq c. Without making any of these simplifying assumptions, the Eulerian and Lagrangian numerical methods originally developed in [16] can be applied in finite domains and include additional important effects such as bouyancy. It is hoped that our analytical results will help to spur renewed interest in DFV’s numerical methods, since we now can have confidence that they yield physically valid results.

Lastly, but not least importantly, the DFV theory provides results also for higher pp-point correlations of the concentration field with p>2p>2 and our analysis gives no reason to believe that these will agree with the predictions of linearized fluctuating hydrodynamics. In particular, these higher-order statistics must certainly be non-Gaussian due to the nonlinear coupling term −v′⋅∇c′-\mathbf{v}'\cdot\nabla c' neglected in linearized theory. Methods previously developed to study anomalous scaling in the Kraichnan model apply here, including analytical approaches such as 1/d1/d expansion [6, 49] and Lagrangian numerics [50, 51, 52]. We are currently investigating such higher-order correlations. These non-Gaussian statistics are not only of theoretical interest but might also be observable experimentally, e.g. by multiple-scattering measurements [53]. Such higher-order correlations are now accessible in other condensed matter systems such as atomic quantum gases [54] and, as in those cases, experimental access to such non-Gaussian statistics could provide an entirely new window into the non-equilibrium physics of diffusive mixing.

Acknowledgments

Acknowledgments. We dedicate this paper to the memory of Krzysztof Gawędzki, to whom we are deeply indebted for his profound insights, his unfailing support and, not least, his warm friendship. We are also grateful to A. Vailati and A. Donev for stimulating discussions of nonequilibrium concentration fluctuations. We thank finally the Simons Foundation for support of this work with Targeted Grant No. MPS-663054, “Revisiting the Turbulence Problem Using Statistical Mechanics.”

Calculation of Structure Function

In this appendix, we evaluate the Fourier transform of the correlation function C(r)C(\mathbf{r}) in Eq. (36) in order to obtain the static structure function S(k)S(\mathbf{k}). First, we take the real part so that our integrand contains the expression cos⁡(k⋅r)=cos⁡(k∥rcos⁡θ+k⊥rsin⁡θcos⁡ϕ)\cos(\mathbf{k}\cdot\mathbf{r})=\cos(k_{\parallel}r\cos\theta+k_{\perp}r\sin\theta\cos\phi) instead of the complex exponential. We next simplify the integral by rotating the zz-axis of the integration variable r\mathbf{r} to be parallel with wavevector k\mathbf{k}; see Figure A1. This rotation by angle α=tan⁡−1(k⊥/k∥)\alpha=\tan^{-1}(k_{\perp}/k_{\parallel}) results in new coordinates, (r,θ′,ϕ′)(r,\theta',\phi'), in which the argument k∥rcos⁡θ+k⊥rsin⁡θcos⁡ϕk_{\parallel}r\cos\theta+k_{\perp}r\sin\theta\cos\phi is transformed to rkcos⁡θ′rk\cos\theta'. The measure dΩ=sin⁡θdθdϕ=sin⁡θ′dθ′dϕ′d\Omega=\sin\theta d\theta d\phi=\sin\theta' d\theta' d\phi' is of course invariant under rotations. The remaining term in the integrand, sin⁡2θ\sin^2\theta, transforms as

The spherical coordinate system used in evaluating Eq. (36)

Figure A1. The spherical coordinate system used in evaluating Eq. (36).

sin⁡2θ≡(cos⁡αcos⁡ϕ′sin⁡θ′+sin⁡αcos⁡θ′)2+sin⁡2ϕ′sin⁡2θ′\sin^2\theta\equiv\left(\cos\alpha\cos\phi'\sin\theta'+\sin\alpha\cos\theta'\right)^2+\sin^2\phi'\sin^2\theta'

These simple results can easily be verified by applying the rotation matrix to an arbitrary unit vector u^:=(cos⁡ϕsin⁡θ,sin⁡ϕsin⁡θ,cos⁡θ)\hat{\mathbf{u}}:=(\cos\phi\sin\theta,\sin\phi\sin\theta,\cos\theta):

(cos⁡ϕsin⁡θsin⁡ϕsin⁡θcos⁡θ)=(cos⁡α0sin⁡α010−sin⁡α0cos⁡α)(cos⁡ϕ′sin⁡θ′sin⁡ϕ′sin⁡θ′cos⁡θ′).\begin{pmatrix}\cos\phi\sin\theta\\ \sin\phi\sin\theta\\ \cos\theta\end{pmatrix} = \begin{pmatrix}\cos\alpha&0&\sin\alpha\\ 0&1&0\\ -\sin\alpha&0&\cos\alpha\end{pmatrix} \begin{pmatrix}\cos\phi'\sin\theta'\\ \sin\phi'\sin\theta'\\ \cos\theta'\end{pmatrix}.

We find

S(k)=−316σ∣∇c∣2∫0∞r3 dr∫0πsin⁡θ dθ∫02πdϕ(2+(cos⁡αcos⁡ϕsin⁡θ+sin⁡αcos⁡θ)2+sin⁡2ϕsin⁡2θ)cos⁡(krcos⁡θ)S(k)=-\frac{3}{16}\sigma\lvert\nabla c\rvert^2\int_0^\infty r^3\,dr\int_0^\pi\sin\theta\,d\theta\int_0^{2\pi}d\phi\left(2+\left(\cos\alpha\cos\phi\sin\theta+\sin\alpha\cos\theta\right)^2+\sin^2\phi\sin^2\theta\right)\cos(kr\cos\theta)

where, to simplify the notations, we have renamed the new primed coordinates θ′,ϕ′\theta',\phi' again as θ,ϕ\theta,\phi. We find

S(k)=−38σ∣∇c∣2∫0∞e−r/Lr3 dr∫0πsin⁡θ dθcos⁡(krcos⁡θ)∫02πdϕ−316σ∣∇c∣2∫0∞e−r/Lr3 dr∫0πsin⁡θcos⁡(krcos⁡θ) dθ∫02πdϕ×(cos⁡2αcos⁡2ϕsin⁡2θ+sin⁡2αcos⁡2θ+sin⁡2αsin⁡θcos⁡θ+sin⁡2ϕsin⁡2θ)(40)\begin{aligned} S(k)&=-\frac{3}{8}\sigma\lvert\nabla c\rvert^2\int_0^\infty e^{-r/L}r^3\,dr\int_0^\pi\sin\theta\,d\theta\cos(kr\cos\theta)\int_0^{2\pi}d\phi\\ &\quad-\frac{3}{16}\sigma\lvert\nabla c\rvert^2\int_0^\infty e^{-r/L}r^3\,dr\int_0^\pi\sin\theta\cos(kr\cos\theta)\,d\theta\int_0^{2\pi}d\phi\\ &\quad\times\left(\cos^2\alpha\cos^2\phi\sin^2\theta+\sin^2\alpha\cos^2\theta+\sin2\alpha\sin\theta\cos\theta+\sin^2\phi\sin^2\theta\right) \tag*{(40)} \end{aligned}

where we have also introduced an IR cut-off LL, with the understanding that the limit L→∞L\to\infty will be taken at the end. The double integral in the first line of the above expression is straightforward to evaluate: first note that ∫0πdθsin⁡θcos⁡(krcos⁡θ)=2krsin⁡(kr)\int_0^\pi d\theta\sin\theta\cos(kr\cos\theta)=\frac{2}{kr}\sin(kr), which can be integrated over rr using standard tables of integrals. For example, using [55] formula 4.7 (14), we find lim⁡L→+∞∫0∞e−r/L(kr)2sin⁡(kr) dr=2k\lim_{L\to+\infty}\int_0^\infty e^{-r/L}(kr)^2\sin(kr)\,dr=\frac{2}{k}. Therefore, the first line of Eq. (41) reads

−3π4σ∣∇c∣2∫0∞e−r/Lrr2 dr∫0πsin⁡θ dθ rcos⁡(krcos⁡θ)=3πσ∣∇c∣2k4.(41)-\frac{3\pi}{4}\sigma\lvert\nabla c\rvert^2\int_{0}^{\infty}e^{-r/L_r}r^2\,\mathrm{d}r\int_{0}^{\pi}\sin\theta\,\mathrm{d}\theta\,r\cos(kr\cos\theta)=\frac{3\pi\sigma\lvert\nabla c\rvert^2}{k^4}. \tag*{(41)}

The remaining triple integral in Eq. (41), aside from a factor of −316σ∣∇c∣2-\frac{3}{16}\sigma\lvert\nabla c\rvert^2, can be written as

sin⁡2α∫02πdϕ∫0∞e−r/Lrr3 dr∫0πsin⁡θcos⁡2θcos⁡(krcos⁡θ) dθ+cos⁡2α∫02πdϕ∫0∞e−r/Lrr3 dr∫0πsin⁡3θcos⁡2ϕcos⁡(krcos⁡θ) dθ+∫02πdϕ∫0∞e−r/Lrr3 dr∫0πdθsin⁡2ϕsin⁡3θcos⁡(krcos⁡θ)+sin⁡2α∫02πdϕ∫0∞e−r/Lrr3 dr∫0πsin⁡2θcos⁡θcos⁡(krcos⁡θ) dθ.(42)\begin{aligned} &\sin^2\alpha\int_{0}^{2\pi}\mathrm{d}\phi\int_{0}^{\infty}e^{-r/L_r}r^3\,\mathrm{d}r\int_{0}^{\pi}\sin\theta\cos^2\theta\cos(kr\cos\theta)\,\mathrm{d}\theta\\ &+\cos^2\alpha\int_{0}^{2\pi}\mathrm{d}\phi\int_{0}^{\infty}e^{-r/L_r}r^3\,\mathrm{d}r\int_{0}^{\pi}\sin^3\theta\cos^2\phi\cos(kr\cos\theta)\,\mathrm{d}\theta\\ &+\int_{0}^{2\pi}\mathrm{d}\phi\int_{0}^{\infty}e^{-r/L_r}r^3\,\mathrm{d}r\int_{0}^{\pi}\mathrm{d}\theta\sin^2\phi\sin^3\theta\cos(kr\cos\theta)\\ &+\sin2\alpha\int_{0}^{2\pi}\mathrm{d}\phi\int_{0}^{\infty}e^{-r/L_r}r^3\,\mathrm{d}r\int_{0}^{\pi}\sin^2\theta\cos\theta\cos(kr\cos\theta)\,\mathrm{d}\theta. \tag*{(42)} \end{aligned}

In the last line, the integral over θ\theta vanishes because the integrand is odd under the reflection θ→π−θ\theta\to\pi-\theta. As for the remaining integrals in Eq. (42), those over ϕ\phi are elementary and those over θ\theta can be readily evaluated using the following results:

∫0πsin⁡θcos⁡2θcos⁡(krcos⁡θ) dθ=2k3r3[(k2r2−2)sin⁡(kr)+2krcos⁡(kr)],(43)\begin{aligned} \int_{0}^{\pi}\sin\theta\cos^2\theta\cos(kr\cos\theta)\,\mathrm{d}\theta\\ &= \frac{2}{k^{3}r^{3}}\left[(k^{2}r^{2}-2)\sin(kr)+2kr\cos(kr)\right], \tag*{(43)} \end{aligned}

which can easily be obtained by a change of variable, e.g., as t=cos⁡θt=\cos\theta, and then integrating by parts, and also

∫0πsin⁡3θcos⁡(krcos⁡θ) dθ=4k3r3[sin⁡(kr)−krcos⁡(kr)].\int_{0}^{\pi}\sin^{3}\theta\cos(kr\cos\theta)\,\mathrm{d}\theta = \frac{4}{k^{3}r^{3}}\left[\sin(kr)-kr\cos(kr)\right].

which can be checked by writing sin⁡3θ=sin⁡θ(1−cos⁡2θ)\sin^{3}\theta=\sin\theta(1-\cos^{2}\theta), then using Eq. (43) and the trivial result ∫sin⁡θcos⁡(krcos⁡θ) dθ=2sin⁡(kr)/kr\int\sin\theta\cos(kr\cos\theta)\,\mathrm{d}\theta=2\sin(kr)/kr. Substituting these results back into Eq. (42), we see that the remaining integrals over rr are in fact Laplace transforms of the functions (kr)2sin⁡(kr)(kr)^{2}\sin(kr), sin⁡(kr)\sin(kr) and krcos⁡(kr)kr\cos(kr) which can be evaluated using standard tables of integrals e.g., [55]. In the limit L→+∞L\to+\infty, we find ∫0∞e−r/L(kr)2sin⁡(kr) dr→−2/k\int_{0}^{\infty}e^{-r/L}(kr)^{2}\sin(kr)\,\mathrm{d}r\to-2/k using [55] formula 4.7 (14); ∫0∞e−r/Lsin⁡(kr) dr→1/k\int_{0}^{\infty}e^{-r/L}\sin(kr)\,\mathrm{d}r\to1/k using [55] formula 4.7 (1) and finally ∫0∞e−r/L(kr)cos⁡(kr) dr→−1/k\int_{0}^{\infty}e^{-r/L}(kr)\cos(kr)\,\mathrm{d}r\to-1/k using [55] formula 4.7 (57). Putting all this together, and using Eq. (41), we find

S(k)=3πσk4∣∇cˉ∣2−316σ∣∇cˉ∣2[8πk4(1+cos⁡2α)−24πk4sin⁡2α].S(k)=\frac{3\pi\sigma}{k^{4}}\lvert\nabla\bar{c}\rvert^{2}-\frac{3}{16}\sigma\lvert\nabla\bar{c}\rvert^{2}\left[\frac{8\pi}{k^{4}}(1+\cos^{2}\alpha)-\frac{24\pi}{k^{4}}\sin^{2}\alpha\right].

Simplifying the above expression, using cos⁡2α=k∥2/k2\cos^{2}\alpha=k_{\parallel}^{2}/k^{2} and sin⁡2α=k⊥2/k2\sin^{2}\alpha=k_{\perp}^{2}/k^{2}, and plugging it into Eq. (41) leads to Eq. (37), which is the desired result.

References

  1. [1]Kraichnan, R.H.: Small-scale structure of a scalar field convected by turbulence. The Physics of Fluids 11(5), 945–953 (1968)DOI
  2. [2]Kraichnan, R.H.: Convection of a passive scalar by a quasi-uniform random straining field. Journal of Fluid Mechanics 64(4), 737–762 (1974)DOI
  3. [3]Kraichnan, R.H.: Anomalous scaling of a randomly advected passive scalar. Phys. Rev. Lett. 72, 1016–1019 (1994)pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/10056596
  4. [4]Falkovich, G., Gawȩdzki, K., Vergassola, M.: Particles and fields in fluid turbulence. Reviews of modern Physics 73(4), 913 (2001)DOI
  5. [5]Gawȩdzki, K., Kupiainen, A.: Anomalous scaling of the passive scalar. Physical review letters 75(21), 3834 (1995)DOI
  6. [6]Chertkov, M., Falkovich, G., Kolokolov, I., Lebedev, V.: Normal and anomalous scaling of the fourth-order correlation function of a randomly advected passive scalar. Physical Review E 52(5), 4924 (1995)DOI
  7. [7]Shraiman, B.I., Siggia, E.D.: Anomalous scaling of a passive scalar in turbulent flow. Comptes rendus de l’Académie des sciences. Série II, Mécanique, physique, chimie, astronomie 321(7), 279–284 (1995)
  8. [8]Bernard, D., Gawȩdzki, K., Kupiainen, A.: Slow modes in passive advection. Journal of Statistical Physics 90(3-4), 519–569 (1998)
  9. [9]Gawȩdzki, K.: Inverse renormalization group analysis of a model of turbulent advection. Nuclear Physics. B, Proceedings Supplements 58, 123–139 (1997)DOI
  10. [10]Antonov, N.: Renormalization group, operator product expansion and anomalous scaling in models of turbulent advection. Journal of Physics A: Mathematical and General 39(25), 7825 (2006)
  11. [11]Kupiainen, A., Muratore-Ginanneschi, P.: Scaling, renormalization and statistical conservation laws in the kraichnan model of turbulent advection. Journal of Statistical Physics 126(3), 669–724 (2007)DOI
  12. [12]Gawȩdzki, K.: Turbulence under a magnifying glass. In: Hooft, G., Jaffe, A., Mack, G., Mitter, P.K., Stora, R. (eds.) Quantum Fields and Quantum Space Time. Nato Science Series B, vol. 364, pp. 123–150. Plenum Press, New York (1997). https://arxiv.org/abs/chao-dyn/9610003
  13. [13]Gawȩdzki, K.: Easy turbulence. In: Saint-Aubin, Y., Vinet, L. (eds.) Theoretical Physics at the End of the Twentieth Century: Lecture Notes of the CRM Summer School, Banff, Alberta. CRM Series in Mathematical Physics, pp. 245–275. Springer, New York (2002). https://arxiv.org/abs/chao-dyn/9907024
  14. [14]Gawȩdzki, K.: Soluble models of turbulent advection. Lectures given at the workshop “Random Media 2000”, Madralin by Warsaw, June 19-26, 2000. https://arxiv.org/abs/nlin/0207058
  15. [15]Gawȩdzki, K.: Soluble models of turbulent transport. In: Nazarenko, S., Zaboronski, O.V. (eds.) Non-equilibrium Statistical Mechanics and Turbulence. London Mathematical Society Lecture Note Series. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, UK (2008)
  16. [16]Donev, A., Fai, T.G., Vanden-Eijnden, E.: A reversible mesoscopic model of diffusion in liquids: from giant fluctuations to Fick’s law. Journal of Statistical Mechanics: Theory and Experiment 2014(4), 04004 (2014)DOI
  17. [17]Eyink, G., Jafari, A.: High Schmidt-number turbulent advection and giant concentration fluctuations. Physical Review Research 4(2), 023246 (2022)arxiv.org/abs/2112.13115
  18. [18]Chetrite, R., Falkovich, G., Gawȩdzki, K.: Fluctuation relations in simple examples of non-equilibrium steady states. Journal of Statistical Mechanics: Theory and Experiment 2008(08), 08005 (2008)
  19. [19]Chetrite, R., Gawȩdzki, K.: Fluctuation relations for diffusion processes. Communications in Mathematical Physics 282(2), 469–518 (2008)DOI
  20. [20]Chetrite, R., Gawȩdzki, K.: Eulerian and Lagrangian pictures of non-equilibrium diffusions. Journal of Statistical Physics 137(5), 890–916 (2009)
  21. [21]Gomez-Solano, J.R., Petrosyan, A., Ciliberto, S., Chetrite, R., Gawȩdzki, K.: Experimental verification of a modified fluctuation-dissipation relation for a micron-sized particle in a nonequilibrium steady state. Physical review letters 103(4), 040601 (2009)
  22. [22]Law, B., Nieuwoudt, J.: Noncritical liquid mixtures far from equilibrium: the Rayleigh line. Physical Review A 40(7), 3880 (1989)pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/9902606
  23. [23]Nieuwoudt, J., Law, B.: Theory of light scattering by a nonequilibrium binary mixture. Physical Review A 42(4), 2003 (1990)pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/9904248
  24. [24]Dorfman, J., Kirkpatrick, T., Sengers, J.: Generic long-range correlations in molecular fluids. Annual Review of Physical Chemistry 45(1), 213–239 (1994)DOI
  25. [25]Grinstein, G.: Generic scale invariance and self-organized criticality. In: McKane, A., Droz, M., Vannimenus, J., Wolf, D. (eds.) Scale Invariance, Interfaces, and Non-equilibrium Dynamics. NATO Science Series B:, pp. 261–293. Springer, New York (1995)DOI
  26. [26]Vailati, A., Giglio, M.: Giant fluctuations in a free diffusion process. Nature 390(6657), 262–265 (1997)DOI
  27. [27]Brogioli, D., Vailati, A., Giglio, M.: Universal behavior of nonequilibrium fluctuations in free diffusion processes. Physical Review E 61(1), 1 (2000)pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/11046358
  28. [28]Croccolo, F., Brogioli, D., Vailati, A., Giglio, M., Cannell, D.S.: Nondiffusive decay of gradient-driven fluctuations in a free-diffusion process. Physical Review E 76(4), 041112 (2007)pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/17994941
  29. [29]Segré, P., Sengers, J.: Nonequilibrium fluctuations in liquid mixtures under the influence of gravity. Physica A: Statistical Mechanics and its Applications 198(1-2), 46–77 (1993)DOI
  30. [30]Ortiz de Zárate, J., Peluso, F., Sengers, J.: Nonequilibrium fluctuations in the Rayleigh-bénard problem for binary fluid mixtures. The European Physical Journal E 15(3), 319–333 (2004)
  31. [31]Vailati, A., Cerbino, R., Mazzoni, S., Takacs, C.J., Cannell, D.S., Giglio, M.: Fractal fronts of diffusion in microgravity. Nature communications 2(1), 1–5 (2011)DOI
  32. [32]Cerbino, R., Sun, Y., Donev, A., Vailati, A.: Dynamic scaling for the growth of non-equilibrium fluctuations during thermophoretic diffusion in microgravity. Scientific Reports 5(1), 14486 (2015)arxiv.org/abs/1502.03693
  33. [33]Croccolo, F., Giraudet, C., Bataller, H., Cerbino, R., Vailati, A.: Shad-owgraph analysis of non-equilibrium fluctuations for measuring transport properties in microgravity in the GRADFLEX experiment. Microgravity Science and Technology 28(4), 467–475 (2016)
  34. [34]Brogioli, D., Vailati, A.: Diffusive mass transfer by nonequilibrium fluctuations: Fick’s law revisited. Physical Review E 63(1), 012105 (2000)pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/11304296
  35. [35]Donev, A., Bell, J.B., de La Fuente, A., Garcia, A.L.: Diffusive transport by thermal velocity fluctuations. Physical review letters 106(20), 204501 (2011)pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/21668233
  36. [36]Donev, A., Bell, J.B., De la Fuente, A., Garcia, A.L.: Enhancement of diffusive transport by non-equilibrium thermal fluctuations. Journal of Statistical Mechanics: Theory and Experiment 2011(06), 06014 (2011)DOI
  37. [37]Brogioli, D., Croccolo, F., Vailati, A.: Correlations and scaling proper-ties of nonequilibrium fluctuations in liquid mixtures. Physical Review E 94(2), 022142 (2016)DOI
  38. [38]Bandak, D., Goldenfeld, N., Mailybaev, A.A., Evink, G.: Dissipation-range fluid turbulence and thermal noise. Physical Review E 105(6), 065113 (2022)DOI
  39. [39]De Groot, S.R., Mazur, P.: Non-Equilibrium Thermodynamics. Dover Publications, New York (2013)
  40. [40]Vailati, A., Giglio, M.: Nonequilibrium fluctuations in time-dependent diffusion processes. Physical Review E 58(4), 4361 (1998)DOI
  41. [41]Baaske, P., Bataller, H., Braibanti, M., Carpinеti, M., Cerbino, R., Croc-colo, F., Donev, A., Köhler, W., de Zárate, J.M.O., Vailati, A.: The NEUF-DIX space project-Non-EquilibriUm Fluctuations during Diffu-sion in complex liquids. The European Physical Journal E 39(12), 1–11 (2016)DOI
  42. [42]Vailati, A., Baaske, P., Bataller, H., Bolis, S., Braibanti, M., Carpinеti, M., Cerbino, R., Croccolo, F., Dewandel, J.-L., Donev, A., et al.: Giant fluctuations induced by thermal diffusion in complex liquids. Microgravity science and technology 32(5), 873–887 (2020)
  43. [43]Eyink, G., Jafari, A.: High Schmidt-number turbulent advection and giant concentration fluctuations. Phys. Rev. Research 4, 023246 (2022)arxiv.org/abs/2112.13115
  44. [44]Onsager, L.: Reciprocal relations in irreversible processes. I. Physical review 37(4), 405 (1931)DOI
  45. [45]Onsager, L.: Reciprocal relations in irreversible processes. II. Physical review 38(12), 2265 (1931)DOI
  46. [46]Adler, S.L., Bardeen, W.A.: Absence of higher-order corrections in the anomalous axial-vector divergence equation. Physical Review 182(5), 1517 (1969)DOI
  47. [47]Adler, S.L.: Anomalies to all orders. In: ‘t Hooft, G. (ed.) 50 Years of Yang-Mills Theory, pp. 187–228. World Scientific, Singapore (2005)DOI
  48. [48]Zee, A.: Axial-vector anomalies and the scaling property of field theory. Physical Review Letters 29(17), 1198 (1972)DOI
  49. [49]Chertkov, M., Falkovich, G.: Anomalous scaling exponents of a white-advected passive scalar. Physical review letters 76(15), 2706 (1996)pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/10060768
  50. [50]Frisch, U., Mazzino, A., Vergassola, M.: Intermittency in passive scalar advection. Physical review letters 80(25), 5532 (1998)DOI
  51. [51]Gat, O., Procaccia, I., Zeitak, R.: Anomalous scaling in passive scalar advection: Monte Carlo Lagrangian trajectories. Physical review letters 80(25), 5536 (1998)DOI
  52. [52]Frisch, U., Mazzino, A., Noullez, A., Vergassola, M.: Lagrangian method for multiple correlations in passive scalar advection. Physics of Fluids 11(8), 2178–2186 (1999)
  53. [53]Lemieux, P.-A., Durian, D.: Investigating non-Gaussian scattering processes by using nth-order intensity correlation functions. JOSA A 16(7), 1651–1664 (1999)DOI
  54. [54]Schweigler, T., Kasper, V., Erne, S., Mazets, I., Rauer, B., Cataldini, F., Langen, T., Gasper, T., Berges, J., Schmiedmayer, J.: Experimental characterization of a quantum many-body system via higher-order correlations. Nature 545(7654), 323–326 (2017)DOI
  55. [55]Erdelyi, A., Magnus, W., Oberhettinger, F., Tricomi, F.G.: Tables of Integral Transforms vol. 1. McGraw-Hill, New York (1954)

Paper details

vlnc:W_sqk5pw4g
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 9

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Physics and Astronomy

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents