betaFeedback

WorksPhysics and Astronomy

VudV_{ud} radiative corrections with lattice input

Abstract

We will describe several pioneering efforts in the study of electromagnetic radiative corrections to semileptonic decay processes, with particular emphasis on the role of lattice QCD. These studies are essential for the precise extraction of the matrix element VudV_{ud} from beta decays of pion, free neutron and JP=0+J^P=0^+ nuclei, and are crucial to address several recently-emerged anomalies involving VudV_{ud} and VusV_{us}, which may provide hints for physics beyond the Standard Model.

Anomalies in the top-row CKM matrix elements

Several interesting anomalies that concern the top-row elements in the Cabibbo-Kobayashi-Maskawa (CKM) matrix [1, 2] have recently emerged. First of all, since late 2018 one observes a 3σ3\sigma deviation from the unitarity relation required by the Standard Model (SM) [3]:

∣Vud∣2+∣Vus∣2+∣Vub∣2=0.9985(3)(1)\lvert V_{ud}\rvert^2 + \lvert V_{us}\rvert^2 + \lvert V_{ub}\rvert^2 = 0.9985(3) \tag*{(1)}

which is now frequently referred to in the literature as the Cabibbo angle anomaly (CAA). In the meantime, with the latest lattice calculation of the KπK\pi form factor [4], a previously-known anomaly in VusV_{us} is further intensified:

∣Vus∣Kℓ3=0.2233(6) ,∣Vus∣Kμ2=0.2252(5) ,(2)\lvert V_{us}\rvert_{K\ell3} = 0.2233(6) \,, \qquad\lvert V_{us}\rvert_{K\mu2} = 0.2252(5) \,, \tag*{(2)}

where a 2.5σ2.5\sigma disagreement is observed between the values of ∣Vus∣\lvert V_{us}\rvert extracted from the leptonic decay (Kμ2K_{\mu2}) and semileptonic decay (Kℓ3K_{\ell3}) of the kaon. Although not yet conclusive, the anomalies above provide interesting hints for the existence of physics beyond the Standard Model (BSM).

An interesting feature of the aforementioned anomalies is that, their dominant sources of uncertainty come from the SM theory inputs rather than experiments. From an optimistic point of view, this implies that there is a high chance to discover BSM physics from these observables if one is able to significantly reduce all the major theory uncertainties. This is, however, extremely challenging because most of them are governed by Quantum Chromodynamics (QCD) in its non-perturbative regime, where analytic solutions do not exist. In this talk we will discuss several recent breakthroughs in the understanding of a particular class of SM corrections, namely the electroweak radiative corrections (RCs) that enter the beta decays of hadrons and nuclei and are crucial for the precise extraction of the top-row CKM matrix elements, especially VudV_{ud}.

Single-nucleon radiative correction

Having the largest magnitude, VudV_{ud} plays the most important role in the top-row CKM unitarity. It is extracted (by far) most precisely from 0+→0+0^{+} \to0^{+} superallowed nuclear beta decays through the following master formula:

∣Vud∣2=2984.43 sFt(1+ΔRV)(3)\lvert V_{ud}\rvert^{2} = \frac{2984.43\ \mathrm{s}}{\mathcal{F}t(1+\Delta_{R}^{V})} \tag*{(3)}

where Ft\mathcal{F}t is the ftft-value corrected by nuclear-structure effects, while ΔRV\Delta_{R}^{V} denotes the single-nucleon RC. The latter has long been the dominant source of theory uncertainty, which originates from the single-nucleon axial γW\gamma W-box diagram (see Figure 1, with Hi=nH_i=n and Hf=pH_f=p). These diagrams probe the hadron physics at all scales, in particular at the scale q∼1 GeVq \sim1\ \mathrm{GeV} where effects of non-perturbative QCD dominates. A dispersion relation (DR) analysis of ΔRV\Delta_{R}^{V} in 2018: ΔRV=0.02467(22)\Delta_{R}^{V}=0.02467(22) (which gives ∣Vud∣=0.97366(15)\lvert V_{ud}\rvert=0.97366(15)) [5, 6] exhibits a significant shift of the central value from to the previous best determination in 2006: ΔRV=0.02361(38)\Delta_{R}^{V}=0.02361(38) [7], which was later confirmed by several independent studies [8, 9, 10, 11]. This shift is the main reason for the emergence of the CAA in the recent years, and therefore must be scrutinized with great care.

Image not extracted

Figure 1. The γW\gamma W-box diagrams, where HiH_i and HfH_f are a pair of hadrons.

In a nutshell, the DR representation expresses the γW\gamma W-box diagram amplitude of a hadron HH as an integral of the function MH(Q2)M_H(Q^2), which is the first Nachtmann moment of the parity-odd, spin-independent structure function F3(0)F_3^{(0)} that involves the axial charged weak current and the isoscalar electromagnetic current:

□γWVA∣H=3αe2π∫dQ2Q2mW2mW2+Q2MH(Q2).(4)\Box_{\gamma W}^{VA}\big|_H = \frac{3\alpha_e}{2\pi}\int\frac{\mathrm{d}Q^2}{Q^2}\frac{m_W^2}{m_W^2+Q^2}M_H(Q^2). \tag*{(4)}

The function MH(Q2)M_H(Q^2) receives contributions from all on-shell hadronic states, some of which can be easily accounted for (such as the Born contribution), but most of them are not. In the case of nucleon (i.e. H=NH=N), it turns out the most non-trivial contribution from multi-hadron intermediate states can be related to observables measured in inclusive neutrino-nucleus scattering processes through isospin symmetry [5, 6], which provides the foundation for a data-driven analysis of □γWVA∣N\Box_{\gamma W}^{VA}\big|_N. The limitation, however, comes from the low precision of the neutrino scattering data at Q2∼1 GeV2Q^2 \sim1\ \mathrm{GeV}^{2} which cannot efficiently constrain the physics it the non-perturbative regime [12]. Better-quality data may come from the Deep Underground Neutrino Experiment (DUNE) [13], which is however not in reach in the near future. Therefore, first-principles calculations of MH(Q2)M_H(Q^2) with lattice QCD becomes an unavoidable task for further progress in this topic.

First lattice QCD calculation

The first realistic lattice QCD calculation of hadronic γW\gamma W-box diagrams was performed by Xu Feng, Lu-Chang Jin and their group in early 2020 [14]. They studied the simpler γW\gamma W-boxes of the charged pion as a prototype of the more complicated nucleon box diagrams that will be investigated in the future. Nevertheless, it is by itself interesting as VudV_{ud} can also be measured in the semileptonic pion decay (πe3\pi e3) through the formula [15]:

Γπe3=GF2∣Vud∣2mπ5∣f+(0)∣264π3(1+δ)Iπ(5)\Gamma_{\pi e3} = \frac{G_F^2\lvert V_{ud}\rvert^2m_{\pi}^{5}\lvert f_{+}(0)\rvert^2}{64\pi^3}(1+\delta)I_{\pi} \tag*{(5)}

although its precision is severely limited by the large experimental uncertainties due to the small branching ratio. Among all the theory inputs to the equation above, the pion form factor f+π(0)f_+^\pi(0) and the kinematic factor IπI_\pi are known to satisfactory precision, while the quantity δ\delta which represents the electroweak RC was calculated with Chiral Perturbation Theory (ChPT) [16]: δ=0.0334(10)LEC(3)HO\delta= 0.0334(10)_{\mathrm{LEC}}(3)_{\mathrm{HO}}. The main theory uncertainty comes from the poorly-constrained low energy constants (LECs) in ChPT, which practically originates from the γW\gamma W-box diagrams; a sub-dominant uncertainty comes from higher-order (HO) electroweak corrections.

To pin down the pion box diagrams, we need to know the function Mπ(Q2)M_\pi(Q^2) at all values of Q2Q^2. At large Q2Q^2 (>2 GeV2> 2\ \mathrm{GeV}^2) perturbative QCD works well, so we can adopt a leading-twist approximation with pQCD corrections:

Mπ(Q2)=112[1−∑i=1∞cn(αSπ)n](6)M_\pi(Q^2) = \frac{1}{12}\left[1-\sum_{i=1}^{\infty}c_n\left(\frac{\alpha_S}{\pi}\right)^n\right] \tag*{(6)}

where the coefficients cnc_n are known up to n=4n=4, which fully satisfy our precision requirement [17]. On the other hand, at low Q2Q^2, Mπ(Q2)M_\pi(Q^2) is obtained as a Euclidean spacetime integral:

Mπ(Q2)=−162Q2mπ∫d4x ω(Q,x)ϵμνα0xαHμνVA(x)(7)M_\pi(Q^2)=-\frac{1}{6\sqrt{2}}\frac{\sqrt{Q^2}}{m_\pi}\int d^4x\,\omega(Q,x)\epsilon_{\mu\nu\alpha0}x^\alpha\mathcal{H}^{VA}_{\mu\nu}(x) \tag*{(7)}

where ω(Q,x)\omega(Q,x) is a known function, and

HμνVA(x)=⟨π0(P)∣T[Jμem(x)JνW,A(0)]∣π−(P)⟩(8)\mathcal{H}^{VA}_{\mu\nu}(x)=\langle\pi^0(P)|T[J_\mu^{\mathrm{em}}(x)J_\nu^{W,A}(0)]|\pi^-(P)\rangle \tag*{(8)}

is a four-point correlation function consists of quark contraction diagrams in Figure 2 which were calculated directly on lattice. The calculation was done with five lattice QCD gauge ensembles (DSDR and Iwasaki gauge actions) at the physical pion mass generated by RBC and UKQCD Collaborations using 2+1 flavor domain wall fermions [18].

Image not extracted

Figure 2. Quark contraction diagrams that correspond to HμνVA(x)\mathcal{H}^{VA}_{\mu\nu}(x). Figures are taken from Ref. 14.

The main results are displayed in Figure 3. The left panel shows how fast the spacetime integral in Eq. (7) is saturated with the increase of the integration range RR, and the right panel shows the lattice calculation of Mπ(Q2)M_\pi(Q^2) before and after the continuum extrapolation; the colored bands are lattice calculations while the lines are pQCD predictions. The full □γWVA∣π\left.\Box_{\gamma W}^{VA}\right|_\pi is obtained by combining the pQCD result at Q2>2 GeV2Q^2 > 2\ \mathrm{GeV}^2 and the lattice result at Q2<2 GeV2Q^2 < 2\ \mathrm{GeV}^2. Effects of the main systematic uncertainties, such as the lattice discretization effect, the pQCD uncertainty and the higher-twist effects, are also properly taken into account. The final result reads [□γWA]π=2.830(11)stat(26)syst×10−3\left[\Box_{\gamma W}^{A}\right]_{\pi}=2.830(11)_{\mathrm{stat}}(26)_{\mathrm{syst}}\times10^{-3}, where an overall 1% precision is achieved.

Image not extracted

Figure 3. Main results of the first-principles calculation of Mπ(Q2)M_{\pi}(Q^2). Figures are taken from Ref. 14.

The calculation above produces significant impacts to various aspects in beta decays. First, on the pion semileptonic decay, it reduces the theory uncertainty in the πe3\pi e3 RC by a factor of 3: δ=0.0332(1)γW(3)HO\delta=0.0332(1)_{\gamma W}(3)_{\mathrm{HO}}, and the updated value of ∣Vud∣|V_{ud}| extracted from πe3\pi e3 now reads ∣Vud∣πe3=0.9740(28)exp(1)th|V_{ud}|_{\pi e3}=0.9740(28)_{\mathrm{exp}}(1)_{\mathrm{th}}. Despite still being plagued with large experimental uncertainties, this result is theoretically very clean. In fact, it now provides a major motivation for experimentalists to measure the πe3\pi e3 branching ratio with an order-of-magnitude increase in precision[19], which could eventually turn πe3\pi e3 into an avenue competitive to superallowed nuclear decays in the extraction of VudV_{ud}.

Next, it turns out that the lattice calculation of the pion box diagrams also provide useful information to the single-nucleon box diagrams. The reason is that the multi-hadron contributions at low Q2Q^{2}, which can be economically described by tt-channel Regge exchanges (see Figure 4), is very similar between these two channels. One could then obtain one from the other upon replacing the coupling strength between the Regge trajectory and the target hadron. This provides an independent assessment of the single-nucleon RC: ΔRV=0.02477(24)\Delta_{R}^{V}=0.02477(24) [9] which shows consistency with the DR result, but is based on a much more rigorous error analysis.

Image not extracted

Figure 4. Multi-hadron contribution to Mπ(Q2)M_{\pi}(Q^{2}) (left) and MN(Q2)M_{N}(Q^{2}) (right) at low Q2Q^{2} described by a Regge-exchange picture. Figures are taken from Ref. 9.

Finally, a very similar lattice calculation of the KπK\pi box diagram in the flavor SU(3) limit was recently performed[20], which fixed some of the very important LECs in ChPT that enter the K→πK\to\pi semileptonic decay (Kℓ3K_{\ell3}) which is one of the main channels to extract ∣Vus∣|V_{us}|. Combining this with a recently-proposed new treatment of the loop and bremsstrahlung corrections [21, 22], the theory uncertainty in the long-range electromagnetic RC to the K→πe+νK\to\pi e^{+}\nu decay (Ke3K_{e3}) is reduced by an order of magnitude[23, 24] comparing to the previous state-of-the-art determination using ChPT [25]. This is physically significant in relation to a recently-proposed quantity RV=ΓKe3/Γπe3R_{V}=\Gamma_{K_{e3}}/\Gamma_{\pi e3} that provides a new avenue to extract the ratio Vus/VudV_{us}/V_{ud}. With the reduction of the RC uncertainties in both Ke3K_{e3} and πe3\pi e3, the quantity RVR_{V} is theoretically very clean. Therefore, upon the future improvement of the πe3\pi e3 branching ratio measurement, RVR_{V} will provide the most precise determination of Vus/VudV_{us}/V_{ud} which will shed new lights on the VusV_{us} anomaly. Notice that there are also proposals to calculate the full Kℓ3K_{\ell3} RC, including one-loop and bremsstrahlung contributions, directly on lattice[26]. These calculations, however, are more challenging and may take up to ten years to achieve a permille level precision comparable to the ChPT treatment.

Future prospects

An obvious future step is to calculate the nucleon γW\gamma W-box diagrams following exactly the same way as one does pion. There are several extra complications that make this task much more challenging: (1) The quark contraction becomes more complicated, (2) Much noisier data due to the exponentially-suppressed signal-to-noise ratio at large Euclidean time, and (3) The full control of systematic effects (e.g. excited-state contaminations) becomes more challenging. Nevertheless, there are already several groups, such as the Precision Neutron Decay Matrix Elements (PNDME) and Nucleon Matrix Elements (NME) Collaborations at Los Alamos, that have started initial investigations along this direction[27], so one may optimistically expect the first result to be available within the next one or two years.

There is also an alternative proposal to approach the problem based on the application of the Feynman-Hellmann theorem on lattice [28], which has been successful previously in the study of P-even structure functions [29] but is not yet applied to beta decays. The underlying principle is rather straightforward: Upon introducing a periodic source term into the Hamiltonian,

Hsrc(t)=2λ1∫d3xcos⁡(q⃗⋅x⃗)Jem2(x⃗,t)−2λ2∫d3xsin⁡(q⃗⋅x⃗)JA3(x⃗,t) ,(9)H_{\mathrm{src}}(t) = 2\lambda_{1} \int d^{3}x \cos(\vec{q} \cdot\vec{x})J_{\mathrm{em}}^{2}(\vec{x},t) - 2\lambda_{2} \int d^{3}x \sin(\vec{q} \cdot\vec{x})J_{\mathrm{A}}^{3}(\vec{x},t) \, , \tag*{(9)}

the second-order perturbation to the nucleon energy is related to a convolution of the P-odd structure function F3(x,Q2)F_{3}(x,Q^{2}):

(∂2Eλ(p⃗)∂λ1∂λ2)λ=0=4qxQ2∫01F3(x,Q2)1−Ω2x2 dx,Ω=−2p⃗⋅q⃗/q⃗2,q⃗2=Q2 ,(10)\left(\frac{\partial^{2} E_{\lambda}(\vec{p})}{\partial\lambda_{1}\partial\lambda_{2}}\right)_{\lambda=0} = \frac{4q_{x}}{Q^{2}} \int_{0}^{1} \frac{F_{3}(x,Q^{2})}{1-\Omega^{2}x^{2}} \, dx, \quad\Omega=-2\vec{p}\cdot\vec{q}/\vec{q}^{2}, \quad\vec{q}^{2}=Q^{2} \, , \tag*{(10)}

from which its first Nachtmann moment can be reconstructed through a linear combination with different choices of Ω\Omega. This method may serve as a useful complement to the first approach, especially at large Q2Q^{2} where the direct calculation of four-point functions suffers from large lattice artifacts. In other words, it also provides a useful cross-check of the validity of the leading-twist + pQCD approximation of MN(Q2)M_{N}(Q^{2}) at Q2>2 GeV2Q^{2}>2\ \mathrm{GeV}^{2}. In short, it is always useful to tackle an important problem using several distinct methods in order to avoid unexpected systematic errors associated to specific approaches, and this of course applies to the study of box diagrams as well.

Conclusion

The recently-emerged anomalies in the top-row CKM matrix elements call for a more careful look at the SM theory inputs, in particular the single-nucleon γW\gamma W-box diagrams that are responsible for the dominant theory uncertainty in the electroweak RCs to the free neutron and superallowed nuclear beta decays. In the lack of precise experimental data, one must rely on first-principles calculations with lattice QCD to constrain the hadron physics in the non-perturbative regime that enters the box diagrams.

The first-principles study of the pion γW\gamma W-box diagrams in early 2020 combining the results from 4-loop pQCD at high Q2Q^{2} and lattice QCD calculations at low Q2Q^{2} has achieved an impressive 1% overall precision. Besides serving as a useful prototype for future calculations in the nucleon sector, it is physically interesting by itself as it removes the major theory uncertainty in πe3\pi e3 and prepares it as a future avenue for the high-precision extraction of VudV_{ud}. It also provides the first indirect lattice input for the nucleon box diagrams which confirms the correctness of the DR analysis. Furthermore, a similar calculation of the KπK\pi box diagrams in the flavor SU(3) limit effectively constrains the poorly-known LECs in the ChPT and leads to a significant reduction of the RC uncertainties in Ke3K_{e3}, which may improve the extraction of VusV_{us} and Vus/VudV_{us}/V_{ud}.

Direct lattice calculations of the single-nucleon γW\gamma W-box diagrams are now on the way. They may have the last word on whether the existing CKM anomalies, in particular the CAA, are actually real.

Acknowledgments

The author thank the organizers of the “55{sup}th` Rencontres de Moriond” for the kind invitation, and is grateful to X. Feng, M. Gorchtein, L. Jin, P. Ma and U.-G. Meißner for collaborations in various lattice-related projects. The work of the author is supported in part by the Deutsche Forschungsgemeinschaft (DFG, German Research Foundation) and the NSFC through the funds provided to the Sino-German Collaborative Research Center TRR110 “Symmetries and the Emergence of Structure in QCD” (DFG Project-ID 196253076 - TRR 110, NSFC Grant No. 12070131001).

References

  1. [1]Nicola Cabibbo. Phys. Rev. Lett., 10:531–533, 1963.
  2. [2]Makoto Kobayashi and Toshihide Maskawa. Prog. Theor. Phys., 49:652–657, 1973.
  3. [3]P.A. Zyla et al. PTEP, 2020(8):083C01, 2020.
  4. [4]A. Bazavov et al. Phys. Rev., D99(11):114509, 2019.
  5. [5]Chien-Yeah Seng, Mikhail Gorchtein, Hiren H. Patel, and Michael J. Ramsey-Musolf. Phys. Rev. Lett., 121(24):241804, 2018.
  6. [6]Chien Yeah Seng, Mikhail Gorchtein, and Michael J. Ramsey-Musolf. Phys. Rev., D100(1):013001, 2019.
  7. [7]William J. Marciano and Alberto Sirlin. Phys. Rev. Lett., 96:032002, 2006.
  8. [8]Andrzej Czarnecki, William J. Marciano, and Alberto Sirlin. Phys. Rev. D, 100(7):073008, 2019.
  9. [9]Chien-Yeah Seng, Xu Feng, Mikhail Gorchtein, and Lu-Chang Jin. Phys. Rev. D, 101(11):111301, 2020.
  10. [10]Leendert Hayen. arXiv:2010.07262 [hep-ph].DOI
  11. [11]K. Shiells, P.G. Blunden, and W. Melnitchouk. arXiv:2012.01580 [hep-ph].
  12. [12]T. Bolognese, P. Fritze, J. Morfin, D. H. Perkins, K. Powell, and W. G. Scott. Phys. Rev. Lett., 50:224, 1983.
  13. [13]R. Acciarri et al. arXiv:1601.05471 [physics.ins-det].arxiv.org/abs/1601.05471
  14. [14]Xu Feng, Mikhail Gorchtein, Lu-Chang Jin, Peng-Xiang Ma, and Chien-Yeah Seng. Phys. Rev. Lett., 124(19):192002, 2020.
  15. [15]D. Pocanic et al. Phys. Rev. Lett., 93:181803, 2004.
  16. [16]V. Cirigliano, M. Knecht, H. Neufeld, and H. Pichl. Eur. Phys. J. C, 27:255–262, 2003.
  17. [17]P.A. Baikov, K.G. Chetyrkin, and J.H. Kuhn. Phys. Rev. Lett., 104:132004, 2010.
  18. [18]T. Blum et al. Phys. Rev. D, 93(7):074505, 2016.
  19. [19]A. Aguilar-Arevalo et al. Testing Lepton Flavor Universality and CKM Unitarity with Rare Pion Decay. [Link].
  20. [20]Peng-Xiang Ma, Xu Feng, Mikhail Gorchtein, Lu-Chang Jin, and Chien-Yeah Seng. arXiv:2102.12048 [hep-lat].DOI
  21. [21]Chien-Yeah Seng, Daniel Galviz, and Ulf-G Meißner. JHEP, 02:069, 2020.
  22. [22]Chien-Yeah Seng, Xu Feng, Mikhail Gorchtein, Lu-Chang Jin, and Ulf-G. Meißner. JHEP, 10:179, 2020.
  23. [23]Chien-Yeah Seng, Daniel Galviz, Mikhail Gorchtein, and Ulf-G. Meißner. arXiv:2103.00975 [hep-ph].DOI
  24. [24]Chien-Yeah Seng, Daniel Galviz, Mikhail Gorchtein, and Ulf-G. Meißner. arXiv:2103.04843 [hep-ph].DOI
  25. [25]Vincenzo Cirigliano, Maurizio Giannotti, and Helmut Neufeld. JHEP, 11:006, 2008.
  26. [26]P. Boyle et al. High-precision determination of V_us and V_ud from lattice QCD. [Link].
  27. [27]T. Bhattacharya et al. Unitarity of CKM Matrix, |V_ud|, Radiative Corrections and Semileptonic Form Factors. [Link].
  28. [28]Chien-Yeah Seng and Ulf-G Meißner. Phys. Rev. Lett., 122(21):211802, 2019.
  29. [29]A.J. Chambers, R. Horsley, Y. Nakamura, H. Perlt, P.E.L. Rakow, G. Schierholz, A. Schiller, K. Somfleth, R.D. Young, and J.M. Zanotti. Phys. Rev. Lett., 118(24):242001, 2017.

Paper details

vlnc:W_stc9uga4
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 0

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Physics and Astronomy

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents