WorksMathematics
On generalizations of the Cohen structure theorem
Abstract
The Cohen structure theorem is an important tool in commutative algebra and algebraic geometry. Recent work of Caviglia, Goswami, and Mesiti addresses the related question of which unital rings admit a maximal ideal for which the natural projection admits a section; for such rings, they prove a structure theorem in terms of semidirect products of rings. In this paper, we extract the underlying mechanism of their structure theorem to address when unital rings admit a nonzero proper ideal whose associated projection map has this property. We also address other settings involving ideals with conditions which are determined by ring theoretic properties of the corresponding quotient.
Introduction
Let be a unital commutative complete Noetherian local ring with maximal ideal . We say that the ring is equicharacteristic if has the same characteristic as its residue field . The Cohen structure theorem, which has numerous applications in commutative algebra and algebraic geometry (see e.g. [Zar47] and [2], along with the introduction of [CGM26] for more discussion on uses of the Cohen structure theorem), states that has a subfield such that the image of under the natural projection map is ; this property is equivalent to the natural projection map admitting a section.
Recent work of Caviglia, Goswami, and Mesiti [CGM26] examines when unital (not necessarily commutative) rings have a maximal two-sided ideal whose associated projection map admits a section. Among their main results is a structure theorem for such rings in terms of semidirect products of rings, [CGM26, Theorem 3.2] (see Section 2 for details on semidirect products of rings; these are the only semidirect products we consider) which was inspired by a communication between the second author and George Janelidze. It is natural to consider whether the underlying mechanism of this result can be adapted to other settings.
What is the importance of the condition of maximality in [CGM26, Theorem 3.2]? The main point of this paper is that, in this discourse, maximality is not at all important; We first pivot away from considering maximal ideals by examining unital rings which satisfy the following property.
Property 1.1. There exists a nonzero proper ideal such that the natural projection map admits a section.
Remark. All of the ideals that we consider are two-sided.
Our main result gives a structure theorem for unital rings which satisfy Property 1.1 in terms of semidirect products.
Theorem 1.2. Let be a unital ring.
(1) Suppose that for rings and such that and are nonzero. Then satisfies Property 1.1 with an ideal such that .
(2) Suppose that satisfies Property 1.1 with an ideal and section . Then .
Remark. (1) Defining the semidirect product requires specifying two structure maps . As will be discussed in § 3, these maps will essentially be multiplication inside of .
(2) The proof of the theorem shows that one may prove similar results when one places conditions on the ideal which may, roughly speaking, be determined by the ring theoretic properties of the corresponding quotient. For example, a proper ideal is a maximal left ideal if and only if is a division ring. As a porism to the proof of Theorem 1.2, if we add the condition of being a maximal left ideal in Property 1.1, then the result holds when we further assume in part (1) that is a division ring; in part (2), we can further conclude that is a division ring. In other words, having Property 1.1 with the added condition of being a maximal left ideal is tantamount to saying that is a semidirect product of a nonzero ring and a division ring. If is commutative, then similar remarks apply when we further assume that is a prime ideal in Property 1.1 and that is an integral domain, or if we further assume that is a maximal ideal in Property 1.1 and that is a field.
(3) Each of the isomorphisms in Theorem 1.2 and its proof are ring isomorphisms.
The paper is organized as follows. In the next section, we provide background on semidirect products of rings. In Section 3 we prove our main result by leveraging the central core of the proof of [CGM26, Theorem 3.2] in this domain. The proof of part (1) leverages the projection map onto the second factor; its kernel is an ideal which witnesses the fact that Property 1.1 holds. The proof of part (2) proceeds by considering the natural map which identifies the abelian group with a subgroup of (the map below). The semidirect product structure on upgrades to a ring homomorphism. The fact that is a section allows one to produce an inverse to by splitting into its “-component” and its “-component” . We also discuss how to prove this result in the other settings mentioned in part (2) of the remark following Theorem 1.2.
Background/Conventions
Throughout the paper, we assume all the rings which we consider are associative but not necessarily unital. If is a ring, we write (respective ) when we consider as a right -module (respectively left -module) over itself in the natural way. For an -module (which may be left or right), we write for the ring of -module endomorphisms of .
We recall the notion of a semidirect product of rings.
Definition. Let and be rings. Let be a ring homomorphism and be a ring anti-homomorphism such that, for every and , we have
The semidirect product with respect to and is defined as follows. The underlying abelian group is given by and we define the product of via
Remark. It is straightforward to check that the semidirect product is a ring. We also have ring homomorphisms and given by and .
If is a ring and is an ideal, we denote the image of under the natural projection map by .
Proof of Theorem 1.2/generalizations
Proof of Theorem 1.2
Proof of Theorem 1.2. We begin the proof of part (1). Consider the map
given by . We have
henceforth, we identify with . With this notation, we have
Composing this map with provides a section to the natural projection map . Indeed, we have , and , so part (1) holds.
We now prove part (2). It is simple to check that the map given by is a ring homomorphism and that the map given by is a ring anti-homomorphism (and also that, for each , the maps and are -module endomorphisms) satisfying the conditions (2.1) and (2.2); henceforth, we suppress the subscripts by writing .
We show that . Consider the map
given by . It is not hard to check that is a ring homomorphism.
Consider now the map given by (since , we have ). It is straightforward to check that is a ring homomorphism.
We now show that and are inverses to each other. We have
To show that , observe that
so we need only show that . Observe that , and since is injective by virtue of being a section, it now suffices to show that , which is clear since . The result follows.
Other settings
We can refine the above proof in several ways. What follows is largely the same argument as in Section 3.1; we sketch the details and keep the same notation.
Recall that a proper ideal in a unital ring is a maximal left ideal if and only if the corresponding quotient is a division ring. In part (1) of Theorem 1.2, if we further assume that is a division ring, then is a left maximal ideal in for which the natural projection map has a section via the map in (3.1). If we assume in part (2) that is a maximal left ideal, then the isomorphism argument still works as above, but we further see that is a division ring.
If we assume that is commutative, then the same argument applies when we add the condition in Property 1.1 that is prime and assume that is an integral domain.
AI statement
The author did not use generative AI in the production of his arguments nor in their exposition. The author used ChatGPT to proofread the paper.
Department of Mathematics, Clemson University, Clemson, SC 29634
Email address: [email protected]
References
- [2]Shiro Goto and Kenji Nishida, Finite modules of finite injective dimension over a Noetherian algebra, J. London Math. Soc. (2) 63 (2001), no. 2, 319–335. MR 1810132DOI