betaFeedback

WorksPhysics and Astronomy

Magnetic dipole transition in proton-deuteron radiative capture at BBN energies within potential model

Abstract

The pdpd radiative capture reaction plays a vital role in Big Bang nucleosynthesis and stellar proton-proton chain. The study of the low-energy reaction is challenging in both experiments and theories. Using the framework of potential model, we analyze pdpd radiative capture below 1 MeV for both electric dipole (E1E1) and magnetic dipole (M1M1) transitions. The obtained astrophysical SS factors agree well with recent results, especially at energies relevant to sensitive deuterium abundance. The calculated reaction rate shows good agreement, with less than a 5% difference compared to recent works. The extrapolated value for S(0)S(0) including both transitions is determined to be 0.211±0.0160.211 \pm 0.016 eV b. A comparison with experimental data using the χ2χ^2 test reveals the sensitivity of the M1M1 cross section at low energies to the scattering potential depth.

Introduction

The primordial or Big Bang nucleosynthesis (BBN) is the production of the first nuclei of helium, lithium, and other light elements after the Big Bang. The formation and breakdown of deuterium involve a set of reactions, including the established p(n,γ)dp(n,\gamma)d pathway for deuterium production and the processes of deuterium reduction through d(d,n)3Hed(d,n){}^{3}\mathrm{He}, d(d,p)3Hd(d,p){}^{3}\mathrm{H}, and d(p,γ)3Hed(p,\gamma){}^{3}\mathrm{He} (pd\mathit{pd} radiative capture) reactions. The abundance of deuterium makes it a valuable indicator for cosmological parameters because it is highly responsive to the primordial baryon density [1]. Furthermore, it is influenced by the number of neutrino species present in the early Universe [2]. In stars, the pd\mathit{pd} radiative capture reaction is one of the key steps in the proton-proton chain, which converts hydrogen into helium and releases energy [3]. The pd\mathit{pd} radiative capture reaction in the BBN energy range has been extensively studied, especially in the last years, both theoretically and experimentally [4, 5].

Due to the presence of the Coulomb barrier, the cross sections for the pd\mathit{pd} radiative capture reaction at low energies are generally limited, making them challenging to accurately determine in experimental measurements. Ongoing and prospective laboratory experiments are actively exploring nuclear reaction physics, crucial components for input into BBN calculations. The pd\mathit{pd} radiative capture reaction was measured at low energy in several accelerator experiments [6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 15, 16]. In addition, high-energy-density plasmas provide an alternative technique for obtaining cross sections [17]. It is worth highlighting that this reaction is of great significance in astrophysics and is observed not only in the Sun but also in the majority of main-sequence stars throughout the universe. The greatest sensitivity of the primordial deuterium abundance to the pd\mathit{pd} reaction cross section was particularly notable around 80 keV reported in Ref. [16]. Consequently, the experimental data observed below 1 MeV hold a pivotal role in understanding stellar processes in the main sequence and BBN.

In the early 2000s, the Laboratory for Underground Nuclear Astrophysics (LUNA) successfully conducted experiments to obtain important data on the astrophysical SS factor within the low-energy range [7]. At higher energies, data sets were compiled from measurements in Refs. [8, 9, 10, 11, 13, 14, 15, 16]. It is worth noting that these measurements retained considerable uncertainties, which considerably affected the comparison between predicted and observed primordial abundance. A new experimental campaign was relaunched at LUNA in 2016 [5]. The latest experiments conducted by LUNA have effectively decreased the uncertainty in the reaction rate to a level as low as 3% [16]. Several works, such as [18, 19], discussed the astrophysical implications based on the updated pd\mathit{pd} radiative capture rate.

Various theoretical models are extensively employed for extrapolating available data to extremely low energies, including RR-matrix analysis, microscopic approaches, and potential models. The RR-matrix analysis was compiled in Ref. [20]. The ab initio methods recognized as state-of-the-art techniques for the pd\mathit{pd} radiative capture reaction were reviewed in Ref. [4]. The pdpd scattering problem is an excellent testing ground for nuclear interactions, providing essential insights into the dynamics of few-body systems within the simplest nucleon-nucleus context. Advanced theoretical techniques with the help of Faddeev treatment or using hyperspherical harmonics (HH) expansions have been developed to tackle this challenge [21, 22, 23, 24, 25, 26, 27, 28, 29]. The nonlocality has been proposed to provide a better description for the three-nucleon bound states 3He{}^{3}\mathrm{He} and pdpd scattering calculations [30, 31]. The recent theoretical work showed a disagreement at the level of 20–30% with a widely used SS-factor best fit to experimental datasets [32, 33].

Besides the microscopic approach toward the solution of the general problem of nuclear forces, the pdpd radiative capture can be addressed through a potential model that effectively reproduces experimental observations below the three-body breakup threshold [34, 35, 36, 37, 38]. Within the potential model, the radiative capture process can be simply considered as an electromagnetic transition from the single-particle (s.p.) scattering state to the s.p. bound state [34]. The pdpd radiative capture reaction in this work is examined using a phenomenological approach reported in Refs. [34, 35, 36] to obtain astrophysical SS factors, reaction rates, and the extrapolated value of S(0)S(0). The process of pdpd radiative capture is complicated, involving both electric dipole (E1E1) and magnetic dipole (M1M1) transitions, with the latter making a significant contribution. Thus, our main focus is to evaluate the contribution of the M1M1 transition within the potential model. The role of electromagnetic dipole and high-order transitions has been extensively studied with the pair-correlated HH method for pdpd radiative capture in the literature [28]. The comparison between the experimental data and the theoretical ab initio calculation for the three-body problem including the meson exchange currents (MEC) effects shows the sensitivity of M1M1 transitions [11, 24, 39]. In the present work, the sensitivity of the M1M1 transition is also pointed out within the potential model using the well-depth method. We show that describing nuclear three-body systems as a two-body system could provide not only a simple and effective way to describe experimental data but also key inputs of nuclear astrophysics [34, 35]. Also, the nuclear spectroscopic information in 3He{}^{3}\mathrm{He} and pdpd scattering observables are revealed.

The structure of this paper is as follows: In the following section, we will present the fundamental formula for a radiative capture reaction. The detailed formulation of the E1E1 and M1M1 transitions within the potential model can be found in Ref. [40]. The obtained astrophysical SS factors, reaction rates, and elastic scattering observables are discussed in the result section.

Formalism for radiative capture reaction within potential model

Reaction rate and astrophysical S factor

The astrophysical reaction rates per particle pair at a certain temperature TT can be calculated with

⟨σv⟩=8πμ1(kBT)3/2∫0∞g(E)S(E) dE(1)\langle\sigma v \rangle= \sqrt{\frac{8}{\pi\mu}}\frac{1}{(k_B T)^{3/2}}\int_{0}^{\infty} g(E)S(E)\,dE \tag*{(1)}

where kBk_B is the Boltzmann constant and μ\mu is the reduced mass of the pdpd system. The masses of proton and deuteron used in this work are 1.0073 u and 2.0141 u, respectively. The Gamow window function is expressed as

g(E)=exp⁡[−EkBT−2πη(E)](2)g(E)=\exp\left[-\frac{E}{k_B T}-2\pi\eta(E)\right] \tag*{(2)}

where the Sommerfeld parameter is η(E)=e2/(ℏv)\eta(E)=e^2/(\hbar v) with vv being the relative velocity between the proton and the deuteron. As the energy approaches zero, the cross sections σ(E)\sigma(E) exhibit a significant decrease. It is therefore customary to introduce the energy-dependent astrophysical SS factor defined as

S(E)=Ee2πησ(E).(3)S(E)=Ee^{2\pi\eta}\sigma(E). \tag*{(3)}

When S(E)S(E) remains constant, which occurs in the absence of resonances, the integrand in Eq. (1) reaches its peak efficiency at the most effective energy.

To evaluate the agreement between the calculated S(E)S(E) and experimental data, the χ2\chi^2 statistic is defined as

χ2=∑i=1N(Sical−SiexpΔSiexp)2(4)\chi^2=\sum_{i=1}^{N}\left(\frac{S_i^{\mathrm{cal}}-S_i^{\mathrm{exp}}}{\Delta S_i^{\mathrm{exp}}}\right)^2 \tag*{(4)}

where SicalS_i^{\mathrm{cal}} and SiexpS_i^{\mathrm{exp}} are the calculated and experimental astrophysical SS factors for a set of NN selected data points from experiments, respectively. These selected experimental data points below 1 MeV are from Refs. [7, 8, 9, 10, 11, 13, 14, 15, 16], and each data point is associated with an uncertainty denoted as ΔSiexp\Delta S_i^{\mathrm{exp}}.

In the potential model, the internal structure of the interacting nuclei is essentially neglected. The intrinsic spins of the target (II) and incident proton (s=1/2s=1/2) are thus kept unchanged. The system is assumed as the core (target) capturing a proton into the s.p. state. The initial (scattering) state is denoted as ∣[I⊗(ℓi⊗s)ji]Ji⟩\lvert[I\otimes(\ell_i\otimes s)j_i]J_i\rangle, while the final (bound) state is represented as ∣[I⊗(ℓf⊗s)jf]Jf⟩\lvert[I\otimes(\ell_f\otimes s)j_f]J_f\rangle. The total relative angular momentum of the system is j⃗=ℓ⃗+s⃗\vec{j}=\vec{\ell}+\vec{s} with ℓ⃗\vec{\ell} being the relative orbital angular momentum. The channel spin is a result of coupling J⃗=I⃗+j⃗\vec{J}=\vec{I}+\vec{j}. The radiative capture cross section for the electromagnetic dipole (Ω1\Omega1 with Ω≡E\Omega\equiv E or Ω≡M\Omega\equiv M) transitions to a bound state is now written as

σnℓfjfJf(E)=431ℏv(4π3kγ3)1(2s+1)(2I+1)×∑Ω,ℓijiJi∣MΩ1∣2(5)\sigma_{n\ell_f j_f J_f}(E)=\frac{4}{3}\frac{1}{\hbar v}\left(\frac{4\pi}{3}k_\gamma^3\right)\frac{1}{(2s+1)(2I+1)}\times\sum_{\Omega,\ell_i j_i J_i}\left|M_{\Omega1}\right|^2 \tag*{(5)}

where the γ\gamma-ray wave number is defined as

kγ=E−Enℓfjfℏc,(6)k_{\gamma} = \frac{E - E_{n\ell_f j_f}}{\hbar c}, \tag*{(6)}

as a function of the proton energy EE. The binding energy EnℓfjfE_{n\ell_f j_f} is determined within the potential model.

To determine the capture cross sections as described in Eq. (5), it is necessary to compute the matrix elements of the dipole operators. The reduced matrix elements of the Ω1\Omega1 transition are written as

MΩ1=⟨[I⊗(ℓf⊗s)jf]Jf∥OΩ1∥[I⊗(ℓi⊗s)ji]Ji⟩.(7)M_{\Omega1} = \langle[I \otimes(\ell_f \otimes s)_{j_f}]_{J_f} \Vert O_{\Omega1} \Vert[I \otimes(\ell_i \otimes s)_{j_i}]_{J_i} \rangle. \tag*{(7)}

The dipole operators of E1E1 and M1M1 take the forms [40]

OE1=CerY1,(8)O_{E1} = C_e rY_1, \tag*{(8)}
OM1=34π(Cmℓ^+2μps^+2μdI^),(9)O_{M1} = \sqrt{\frac{3}{4\pi}}\left(C_m\hat{\ell}+2\mu_p\hat{s}+2\mu_d\hat{I}\right), \tag*{(9)}

where Y1Y_1 are spherical harmonics, and the hat notations are the projections of the orbital angular momentum and spins. The values of CeC_e and CmC_m are the effective charge and effective magnetic moment, respectively. The magnetic moments that are used in this work are μp=2.79285μN\mu_p = 2.79285\mu_N for proton and μd=0.85744μN\mu_d = 0.85744\mu_N for deuteron [41], where μN\mu_N is the nuclear magneton.

The MΩ1M_{\Omega1} in Eq. (7) can be simplified by the calculation of the s.p. reduced matrix element which can be decomposed into components

MΩ1(s.p.)=A⋅I⋅SF,(10)M_{\Omega1}^{(\mathrm{s.p.})} = A \cdot I \cdot\sqrt{S_F}, \tag*{(10)}

where SFS_F is introduced to account for the fractional parentage coefficient that the system can be described as the presumption. The formula of E1E1 and M1M1 transitions relating to angular-spin coefficients AA can be found in Ref. [40]. The most important ingredient of Eq. (10) is the radial overlap integrals II of two states.

IE1=∫ϕnℓfjf(r)χℓiji(E,r)r dr,(11)I_{E1} = \int\phi_{n\ell_f j_f}(r)\chi_{\ell_i j_i}(E,r)r\,dr, \tag*{(11)}
IM1=∫ϕnℓfjf(r)χℓiji(E,r) dr,(12)I_{M1} = \int\phi_{n\ell_f j_f}(r)\chi_{\ell_i j_i}(E,r)\,dr, \tag*{(12)}

where χℓiji\chi_{\ell_i j_i} and ϕnℓfjf\phi_{n\ell_f j_f} are s.p. wave functions of scattering and bound states, respectively.

Phenomenological potential model

The bound and scattering wave functions are described as eigenfunctions of the usual radial Schrödinger equations for each s.p. wave function

[−ℏ22μ(d2dr2−ℓf(ℓf+1)r2)+Vnℓfjf(r)]ϕnℓfjf(r)=Enℓfjfϕnℓfjf(r),(13)\left[-\frac{\hbar^2}{2\mu}\left(\frac{d^2}{dr^2}-\frac{\ell_f(\ell_f+1)}{r^2}\right)+V_{n\ell_f j_f}(r)\right]\phi_{n\ell_f j_f}(r)=E_{n\ell_f j_f}\phi_{n\ell_f j_f}(r), \tag*{(13)}
[−ℏ22μ(d2dr2−ℓi(ℓi+1)r2)+Vℓiji(r)]χℓiji(E,r)=Eχℓiji(E,r).(14)\left[-\frac{\hbar^2}{2\mu}\left(\frac{d^2}{dr^2}-\frac{\ell_i(\ell_i+1)}{r^2}\right)+V_{\ell_i j_i}(r)\right]\chi_{\ell_i j_i}(E,r)=E\chi_{\ell_i j_i}(E,r). \tag*{(14)}

In both Eqs. (13) and (14), the local potentials Vnℓfjf(r)V_{n\ell_fj_f}(r) and Vℓiji(r)V_{\ell_ij_i}(r) have identical forms and include contributions from nuclear central, spin-orbit coupling, and Coulomb terms

V(r)=Vcent.(r)+Vs.o.(r)(ℓ⃗⋅σ⃗)+VCoul.(r).(15)V(r) = V_{\mathrm{cent.}}(r) + V_{\mathrm{s.o.}}(r)(\vec{\ell} \cdot\vec{\sigma}) + V_{\mathrm{Coul.}}(r). \tag*{(15)}

The nuclear terms are of the Woods-Saxon (WS) form

Vcent.(r)=V0fWS,(16)V_{\mathrm{cent.}}(r) = V_0 f_{\mathrm{WS}}, \tag*{(16)}
Vs.o.(r)=(ℏmπc)2VSrddrfWS,(17)V_{\mathrm{s.o.}}(r) = \left(\frac{\hbar}{m_{\pi}c}\right)^2 \frac{V_{\mathrm{S}}}{r} \frac{d}{dr} f_{\mathrm{WS}}, \tag*{(17)}
fWS(r)=11+e(r−R0)/a0,(18)f_{\mathrm{WS}}(r) = \frac{1}{1 + e^{(r-R_0)/a_0}}, \tag*{(18)}

where R0R_0 and a0a_0 are the radius and diffuseness parameters of the WS potentials, respectively. The value of mπm_{\pi} is the pion rest mass. The parameters V0V_0 and VSV_{\mathrm{S}} are the strengths (depths) of the nuclear central and spin-orbit potentials in MeV, respectively. The repulsive part of the central potential is omitted. While V0V_0 is a negative value, the VSV_{\mathrm{S}} is chosen with a positive value for consistency with the shell model of the nucleus. The Coulomb potential is of a uniformly charged sphere

VCoul.(r)={e22RC(3−r2RC2),r<RC,e2r,r≥RC(19)V_{\mathrm{Coul.}}(r) = \begin{cases} \frac{e^2}{2R_{\mathrm{C}}}\left(3-\frac{r^2}{R_{\mathrm{C}}^2}\right), & r < R_{\mathrm{C}},\\ \frac{e^2}{r}, & r \ge R_{\mathrm{C}} \end{cases} \tag*{(19)}

where RCR_{\mathrm{C}} is the Coulomb radius.

The parameters V0V_0 and VSV_{\mathrm{S}} are fine-tuned to reproduce the ground-state energy EnℓfjfE_{n\ell_fj_f} of the deuteron in Eq. (13). The wave function of the bound state ϕnℓfjf(r)\phi_{n\ell_fj_f}(r) becomes negligible at large distances, and its norm is determined by

⟨ϕnℓfjf∣ϕnℓfjf⟩=1.(20)\langle\phi_{n\ell_fj_f} \mid\phi_{n\ell_fj_f} \rangle= 1. \tag*{(20)}

The potential parameters for the scattering states are similar to those for the bound states. The scattering states χℓiji(E,r)\chi_{\ell_ij_i}(E,r) with continuous energy EE satisfy boundary conditions at infinity replaced by

χℓiji(E,r→∞)→cos⁡δℓiji(E)Fℓi(η,kr)+sin⁡δℓiji(E)Gℓi(η,kr),(21)\chi_{\ell_ij_i}(E,r \to\infty) \to\cos\delta_{\ell_ij_i}(E)F_{\ell_i}(\eta,kr) + \sin\delta_{\ell_ij_i}(E)G_{\ell_i}(\eta,kr), \tag*{(21)}

where Fℓi(η,kr)F_{\ell_i}(\eta,kr) and Gℓi(η,kr)G_{\ell_i}(\eta,kr) are the regular and irregular Coulomb wave functions, respectively; and δℓiji(E)\delta_{\ell_ij_i}(E) represents the nuclear phase shift for the partial wave ℓiji\ell_ij_i.

Results and discussions

Single-particle configuration and potential parameters

There are no excited states in the deuteron, and there is no evidence supporting a low-lying excited state in 3He^{3}\mathrm{He} [42]. We therefore consider the transitions to the ground state of 3He{}^{3}\mathrm{He} with Jf=1/2+J_f = 1/2^{+}. The ground state of 3He{}^{3}\mathrm{He} is modeled as a proton with spin s=1/2s = 1/2 coupled to the deuterium core, which itself possesses an intrinsic spin I=1+I = 1^{+}. In the framework of the shell model, it is conventional to describe 3He{}^{3}\mathrm{He} within a model space characterized by 0ℏω0\hbar\omega, with approximately three nucleons in the 1s1/21s_{1/2} states. The correlation in the 3He{}^{3}\mathrm{He} ground state, resulting from the mixing of higher components, is estimated to be approximately below 10% in shell-model calculation [43].

In this work, the form of WS potential is fitted based on the form of Skyrme Hartree-Fock potential [44]. The version of SLy5 interaction gives the values of R0=2.31R_0 = 2.31 fm and a0=0.37a_0 = 0.37 fm for the central potential. To simplify the model and reduce the number of parameters, we maintain constant values for the parameters a0=0.37a_0 = 0.37 fm, R0=rC=2.31R_0 = r_\mathrm{C} = 2.31 fm, and VS=5V_\mathrm{S} = 5 MeV. It is important to note that the diffuseness and radius parameters have minimal impact on the shape of cross section. Additionally, given the absence of resonances in the energy region below 1 MeV, adjustments to the strength of the spin-orbit interaction do not significantly affect the cross section. Consequently, only adjustment of the depth V0V_0 is used to reproduce simultaneously the binding energy and the pdpd scattering.

For the bound state, an additional proton is captured into the unoccupied 1s1/21s_{1/2} state (ℓf=0\ell_f = 0). The binding energy of 1s1/21s_{1/2} proton is equal to the QQ value of the reaction, which is E1s1/2=−5.49E_{1s_{1/2} } = -5.49 MeV. To reproduce this binding energy, the value of V0b=−32V_0^b = -32 MeV is adopted. The ss-wave asymptotic normalization constant (ANC) in 3^3He is determined to be 1.79 fm−1/21.79\ \mathrm{fm}^{-1/2} in this work, yielding a squared value of 3.2 fm−13.2\ \mathrm{fm}^{-1}. This value is slightly below measurements by less than 10% but falls within the uncertainty of measurements. In particular, the empirical squared ANCs reported are 3.4±0.2 fm−13.4 \pm0.2\ \mathrm{fm}^{-1} in Ref. [45] and 3.5±0.4 fm−13.5 \pm0.4\ \mathrm{fm}^{-1} in Ref. [46]. Additionally, the ANC computed for the Reid soft-core potential is found to be 1.765 fm−1/21.765\ \mathrm{fm}^{-1/2} [47] which is close to the value obtained from our potential model.

The E1E1 transition is predominantly caused by incoming pp waves (ℓi=1\ell_i = 1). The channel spins corresponding to possible captured pp waves (both p1/2p_{1/2} and p3/2p_{3/2}) are Ji=1/2−,3/2−J_i = 1/2^-, 3/2^-. Figure 1 shows the calculated astrophysical SS factor of pdpd radiative capture. For comparison, the dash-dotted line represents the astrophysical SS factor obtained through the ab initio approach, extracted from Table I in Ref. [32]. The dashed line presents our calculation with only the E1E1 transition. Notably, it well describes the data sets from Refs. [10, 14, 15, 16] without modification. However, it is still lower than the LUNA database at very low energy [7]. The extrapolated value of SE1(0)S_{E1}(0) with only E1E1 contribution is 0.160.16 eV b, using V0s=V0b=−32V_0^s = V_0^b = -32 MeV.

Image not extracted

Figure 1. Astrophysical SS factor of d(p,γ)3Hed(p,\gamma){}^{3}\mathrm{He} reaction with experimental data selected from Refs. [7, 8, 9, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 15, 16, 17]. The solid line represents the total calculation with E1E1 (dashed line) and M1M1 (dotted line) transitions. The dash-dotted line shows the astrophysical SS factor using the theoretical ab initio model in Ref. [32].

Sensitivity of M1 transition

The contribution of the M1M1 transition is considered, which enhances the magnitude of the SS factor at low energy. The scattering ss wave (ℓi=0\ell_i = 0) causes the M1M1 transition to the ground state. Figure 2 shows the optimal value V0V_0 when using χ2\chi^2 test in comparison with experimental data from Refs. [7, 8, 9, 10, 11, 13, 14, 15, 16] as displayed in Figure 1. It is evident that the minimum χ2\chi^2 value occurs when the depth V0V_0 is around −27-27 MeV. It is reasonable when V0s=−27V_0^s = -27 MeV is applied to both scattering ss and pp waves. As the depth increases beyond this value, the χ2\chi^2 value remains relatively stable, primarily because the M1M1 contribution is negligible. For instance, when the same potentials for bound and scattering states (V0s=V0b=−32V_0^s = V_0^b = -32 MeV) are adopted, the SS factor for the M1M1 transition is lower by approximately 9 orders of magnitude compared to the primary contribution from the E1E1 transition. In contrast, decreasing the depth leads to an overestimation of the M1M1 strength, highlighting the high sensitivity of the M1M1 transition strength to variations in potential depth.

Image not extracted

Figure 2. Results of the χ2\chi^2 test examining the variation of the depth V0s(M1)V_0^s(M1) of the scattering potential for the ss state. The optimal depth is found to be V0s(M1)=−27V_0^s(M1)=-27 MeV, with values of a0=0.37a_0=0.37 fm and R0=2.31R_0=2.31 fm. The dashed line represents the calculation using V0s(E1)=−25V_0^s(E1)=-25 MeV for scattering states in the E1E1 transition. The dotted line illustrates the calculation using V0s(E1)=−32V_0^s(E1)=-32 MeV, consistent with the bound state. The solid line shows the calculation employing the same scattering potential depths for both E1E1 and M1M1 transitions.

Analysis of elastic cross section and polarization

Validating the scattering potentials requires the calculation of cross sections and polarizations at low energy. The differential cross section for pdpd elastic scattering at Elab=0.4E_{\mathrm{lab}}=0.4 MeV is depicted in Figure 3(aFigure 1, using measurements of angular distributions from Ref. [48]. The χ2\chi^2 value decreases by a factor of 2.7 when using V0=−27V_0=-27 MeV compared to V0=−32V_0=-32 MeV. The optimal depth of the central potential is determined to be approximately −25-25 MeV, as shown in Figure 3(aFigure 2. Notably, an improvement in the cross section is observed when employing the central scattering potential V0=−27V_0=-27 MeV for large scattering angles, with the inclusion of a spin-orbit potential VS=5V_S=5 MeV. Although this inclusion does not have a significant impact on the description of differential cross section, it does play a role in investigating polarization.

Image not extracted

Figure 3. (a1) Angular distributions of differential cross sections for pdpd elastic scattering at Elab=0.4E_{\mathrm{lab}} = 0.4 MeV, with experimental data sourced from Ref. [48]. (b1) Angular distributions of the analyzing power calculated using V0=−27V_0 = -27 MeV with VS=2V_{\mathrm{S}} = 2 MeV (dashed line) and VS=5V_{\mathrm{S}} = 5 MeV (solid line). Data for the analyzing powers at Ec.m.=667E_{\mathrm{c.m.}} = 667 keV are taken from Ref. [49]. (a2, b2) The χ2\chi^2 test examining the variations of the depths of central potential V0V_0 and spin-orbit potential VSV_{\mathrm{S}}, respectively.

In Figure 3(bFigure 1, the calculated analyzing powers are presented with varying strengths of the spin-orbit potential. The strength of VS=5V_S=5 MeV aligns well with data points at 667 keV from Ref. [49]. In contrast, a spin-orbit strength of VS=2V_S=2 MeV fails to replicate in this case. The χ2\chi^2 value for VS=5V_S=5 MeV is reduced by half compared to VS=2V_S=2 MeV. Figure 3(bFigure 2 reveals that the optimal depth of the spin-orbit potential is approximately 4 MeV. The description of pdpd scattering observables, especially the angular distributions of the analyzing powers, is enhanced when including MEC effects, as reported in Ref. [11]. It is important to note that the optical potentials including central and spin-orbit potentials in this study are considered only real and energy-independent at low energy. Therefore, the examination for higher energies is not within the scope of this work.

Spectroscopic factor and the best-fit value of S(0)

The spectroscopic factor SFS_{\mathrm{F}} for the bound state is determined by finding the values of χmin⁡2\chi^2_{\min}. In Figure 4(a), the variations in χmin⁡2\chi^2_{\min} are depicted concerning changes in SFS_{\mathrm{F}} and V0sV_0^{\mathrm{s}}. The best-fit value for SFS_{\mathrm{F}} is identified as 0.9, corresponding to the use of V0s=−26.3V_0^{\mathrm{s}} = -26.3 MeV for both transitions. At the minimum of χ2\chi^2, the relationship between SFS_{\mathrm{F}} and V0sV_0^{\mathrm{s}} follows a linear pattern given by V0s=−21.9−6.1SFV_0^{\mathrm{s}} = -21.9 - 6.1S_{\mathrm{F}} in MeV, as depicted in Figure 4(b). The revised SE1(0)S_{\mathrm{E1}}(0) is now 0.098 eV b. In comparison, Ref. [20], utilizing RR-matrix analysis, reported SE1(0)=0.089±0.004S_{\mathrm{E1}}(0) = 0.089 \pm0.004 eV b, which closely aligns with our calculated value.

Plots of $\chi^2_{\min}$ values and the linear correlation between $S_F$ and $V_0^s$

Figure 4. (a) The different χmin⁡2\chi^2_{\min} values obtained when changing SFS_F and V0sV_0^s. The best value for the proton spectroscopic factor in 3He{}^{3}\mathrm{He} is SF=0.9S_F = 0.9 corresponding to the V0s=−26.3V_0^s = -26.3 MeV, which gives the lowest value of χ2\chi^2. (b) The linear correlation between SFS_F and V0sV_0^s at the minimum χ2\chi^2 expressed by V0s=−21.9−6.1SFV_0^s = -21.9 - 6.1S_F in MeV.

In Figure 5, the inclusion of M1M1 transition leads to an extrapolated value of S(0)S(0) of 0.211 ±\pm 0.016 eV b, using V0s=−26.3V_0^{\mathrm{s}} = -26.3 MeV and SF=0.9S_{\mathrm{F}} = 0.9. The uncertainty in our

S factor as a function of energy for proton-deuteron radiative capture, comparing total, E1, M1, and ab initio calculations with experimental data

Figure 5. Same as Figure 1 but for SF=0.9S_{\mathrm{F}} = 0.9 and V0S=−26.3V_{0}^{\mathrm{S}} = -26.3 MeV.

computed SS factor arises from the variance between calculations utilizing SF=0.9S_{\mathrm{F}} = 0.9 and SF=1.0S_{\mathrm{F}} = 1.0. The contribution of M1M1 in our calculation at zero energy is determined to be SM1(0)=0.113S_{M1}(0) = 0.113 eV which is in excellent agreement with the experimental determination in Refs. [8, 10] reported as 0.12±0.030.12 \pm0.03 eV b and 0.109±0.0100.109 \pm0.010 eV b, respectively. The enhancement of M1M1 transition at very low energy is due to two-body current contributions [10]. Table 1 presents our results of the total S(0)S(0) compared with the other works. The experimental references have reported values such as S(0)=0.166±0.014S(0) = 0.166 \pm0.014 eV b [10], 0.216±0.0100.216 \pm0.010 eV b [7], and 0.219±0.0040.219 \pm0.004 eV b [15]. The calculation of S(0)S(0) with the inclusion of M1M1 contribution is 4% lower than recent experimental values in Refs. [7, 15] and slightly smaller than the ab initioab\ initio value of 0.2190.219 eV b [28, 29]. Using RR-matrix analysis, S(0)S(0) is found to be 0.089±0.0040.089 \pm0.004 eV b (E1E1) and 0.134±0.0060.134 \pm0.006 eV b (M1M1) [20]. Our calculation shows a good agreement with the value reported in the NACRE II compilation [35]. It is worth mentioning that the fit of potential depth for both E1E1 and M1M1 transitions is significantly influenced by very low-energy data points obtained from measurements in Ref. [7]. Specifically, a data point at 4.05 keV (see Table I in Ref. [7]) stands out significantly lower compared to the trend of other data points as shown in Figure 1 and Figure 5.

ReferencesS(0)S(0) (eV b)
Schmid et al. (1996) [50]0.165±0.0140.165 \pm0.014
Viviani et al. (1996) [24]0.1850.185
Viviani et al. (2000) [28]0.2190.219
Casella et al. (2002) [7]0.216±0.0100.216 \pm0.010
Descouvemont et al. (2004) [20]0.223±0.0100.223 \pm0.010
Marcucci et al. (2005) [29]0.2190.219
Xu et al. (2013) [35]0.21±0.040.21 \pm0.04
Iliadis et al. (2016) [51]0.2156−0.0077+0.00820.2156^{+0.0082}_{-0.0077}
Sadeghi et al. (2013) [26]0.2430.243
Turkat et al. (2021) [15]0.219±0.0040.219 \pm0.004
Moscoso et al. (2021) [19]0.219±0.0010.219 \pm0.001
This work0.211±0.0160.211 \pm0.016

Table 1. The values of S(0)S(0) for different experimental and theoretical works.

Around the point where it is emphasized that the primordial deuterium abundance is most sensitive (E=80E = 80 keV) according to Ref. [16], our calculated SS factors are in good agreement with the latest measured values. Particularly, the total SS factors at E=66.7E = 66.7 keV and E=99.5E = 99.5 keV in the present work give 0.602 ±\pm 0.042 eV b and 0.821 ±\pm 0.073 eV b while the experimental values are 0.627 ±\pm 0.025 eV b and 0.850 ±\pm 0.029 eV b [16], respectively. The prediction of SS factor at 91 keV reported in Ref. [19] is 0.799 ±\pm 0.018 eV b which is slightly higher than our value of 0.763 ±\pm 0.065 eV b. In this range of energy, the contribution of the M1M1 transition in our approach is approximately 11% to 16%.

At very low energy, the total SS factor (in eV b) can be approximated as a polynomial function of energy (in MeV). For energies below 40 keV, Ref. [8] reported the linear function S(E)=(0.25±0.04)+7.9ES(E) = (0.25 \pm0.04) + 7.9E. Additionally, a cubic function represented as S(E)=0.2121+5.973E+5.449E2−1.656E3S(E) = 0.2121 + 5.973E + 5.449E^{2} - 1.656E^{3} was reported for energies below 2 MeV in Ref. [16]. Based on the statistical model with data from 11 experiments, Ref. [19] gave S(E)=0.219−0.01+0.01+5.8−0.24+0.24E+6.34−0.82+0.88E2−2.2−0.52+0.52E3S(E) = 0.219^{+0.01}_{-0.01} + 5.8^{+0.24}_{-0.24}E + 6.34^{+0.88}_{-0.82}E^{2} - 2.2^{+0.52}_{-0.52}E^{3}. In the present work, the total SS factor calculated for energies below 100 keV is approximated by

S(E)≈0.211+5.25E+9.47E2−5.54E3,(22)S(E) \approx0.211 + 5.25E + 9.47E^{2} - 5.54E^{3}, \tag*{(22)}

where S(E)S(E) and EE are in eV b and MeV, respectively. The slope of S(E)S(E) from our calculation is slightly lower than those of Refs. [16, 19]. The approximated SS factors for E1E1 and M1M1 transitions using V0s=−26.3V_{0}^{s} = -26.3 MeV and SF=0.9S_{\mathrm{F}} = 0.9 are given by

SE1(E)≈0.098+5.72E+5.94E2+4.59E3,(23)S_{E1}(E) \approx0.098 + 5.72E + 5.94E^{2} + 4.59E^{3}, \tag*{(23)}
SM1(E)≈0.113−0.46E+3.54E2−10.1E3.(24)S_{M1}(E) \approx0.113 - 0.46E + 3.54E^{2} - 10.1E^{3}. \tag*{(24)}

Notably, the slope of SM1(E)S_{M1}(E) is negative, indicating that SM1(E)S_{M1}(E) is influenced by a subthreshold ss-state resonance. In contrast, the positive slope of SE1(E)S_{E1}(E) suggests pp-state resonances above 1 MeV.

Reaction rate

Our calculation of Gamow window functions g(E)g(E) given in Eq. (2) for different temperatures below 1 GK indicates that the effective energy range for this reaction falls below 1 MeV. The recommended Maxwellian-averaged reaction rate NA⟨σv⟩N_{\mathrm{A}}\langle\sigma v\rangle for pdpd radiative capture reaction at temperatures below 1 GK is presented in Table 2. In comparison, Figure 6 illustrates the ratio of rates obtained from Refs. [16, 19, 20, 35, 51, 52] to the rates calculated in the present work. The dashed and solid curves in Figure 6 represent the resulting reaction rates for the calculation without and with the inclusion of M1M1 transition, respectively. Notably, there is a significant difference between these two curves. Our calculation shows a good agreement with Refs. [51, 52] at very low temperatures. Values from Refs. [51, 52] exhibit no significant difference, as both adopted fitting based on theoretical SS factors [32]. The calculated rates are approximately 1.5% higher than the NACRE II compilation [35] but the difference becomes larger at high temperatures. The RR-matrix analysis [20] and the recent best-fit measured SS factors [16, 19] provide rates higher than our calculation below 0.1 GK. The discrepancy between our calculated rates and those from Refs. [16, 19, 51, 52] is below 5%.

Image not extracted

Figure 6. The ratio of reaction rates below 1 GK obtained from Refs. [16, 19, 20, 35, 51, 52] to the calculated rates in this work.

TT (GK)NA⟨σv⟩N_{\mathrm{A}}\langle\sigma v\rangle (cm3^{3} mol−1^{-1} s−1^{-1})TT (GK)NA⟨σv⟩N_{\mathrm{A}}\langle\sigma v\rangle (cm3^{3} mol−1^{-1} s−1^{-1})
0.0019.445×10−129.445 \times10^{-12}0.0021.877×10−081.877 \times10^{-08}
0.0036.159×10−076.159 \times10^{-07}0.0045.460×10−065.460 \times10^{-06}
0.0052.558×10−052.558 \times10^{-05}0.0068.271×10−058.271 \times10^{-05}
0.0072.105×10−042.105 \times10^{-04}0.0084.539×10−044.539 \times10^{-04}
0.0098.677×10−048.677 \times10^{-04}0.0101.514×10−031.514 \times10^{-03}
0.0112.462×10−032.462 \times10^{-03}0.0123.783×10−033.783 \times10^{-03}
0.0135.551×10−035.551 \times10^{-03}0.0147.840×10−037.840 \times10^{-03}
0.0151.073×10−021.073 \times10^{-02}0.0161.428×10−021.428 \times10^{-02}
0.0182.368×10−022.368 \times10^{-02}0.0203.658×10−023.658 \times10^{-02}
0.0258.726×10−028.726 \times10^{-02}0.0301.691×10−011.691 \times10^{-01}
0.0404.426×10−014.426 \times10^{-01}0.0508.774×10−018.774 \times10^{-01}
0.0601.480×10+001.480 \times10^{+00}0.0702.248×10+002.248 \times10^{+00}
0.0803.179×10+003.179 \times10^{+00}0.0904.264×10+004.264 \times10^{+00}
0.1005.497×10+005.497 \times10^{+00}0.1106.871×10+006.871 \times10^{+00}
0.1208.379×10+008.379 \times10^{+00}0.1301.001×10+011.001 \times10^{+01}
0.1401.177×10+011.177 \times10^{+01}0.1501.363×10+011.363 \times10^{+01}
0.1601.561×10+011.561 \times10^{+01}0.1801.987×10+011.987 \times10^{+01}
0.2002.451×10+012.451 \times10^{+01}0.2503.755×10+013.755 \times10^{+01}
0.3005.236×10+015.236 \times10^{+01}0.3506.865×10+016.865 \times10^{+01}
0.4008.621×10+018.621 \times10^{+01}0.4501.048×10+021.048 \times10^{+02}
0.5001.245×10+021.245 \times10^{+02}0.6001.662×10+021.662 \times10^{+02}
0.7002.106×10+022.106 \times10^{+02}0.8002.573×10+022.573 \times10^{+02}
0.9003.059×10+023.059 \times10^{+02}1.0003.561×10+023.561 \times10^{+02}

Table 2. Calculated reaction rates in this work.

Conclusions

Our investigation has provided a quantitative analysis of the role of M1M1 transition in the pdpd radiative capture process at extremely low energies, employing the potential model. The form of the phenomenological potential is derived from microscopic calculations, showcasing the effectiveness of the potential model as a simple yet powerful tool for addressing few-body problems. We have emphasized that the contribution of the M1M1 transition is highly sensitive to scattering potentials. Our calculated astrophysical SS factors, reaction rates, and elastic scattering observables closely align with recent works, showing a difference of less than 10%. This good agreement reinforces the validity of our approach.

Acknowledgments

The authors would like to thank Bui Minh Loc for engaging in discussions. This work was funded by Ho Chi Minh City University of Education Foundation for Science and Technology under grant number CS.2023.19.57. N. L. A. acknowledges the Master, PhD Scholarship Programme of Vingroup Innovation Foundation (VINIF), code VINIF.2023.TS.003.

References

  1. [1]Cooke R J, Pettini M and Steidel C C 2018 Astrophys. J. 855 102
  2. [2]Xu X J, Wang Z and Chen S 2023 Prog. Part. Nucl. Phys. 104043
  3. [3]Arcones A and Thielemann F K 2023 Astron. Astrophys. Rev. 31 1
  4. [4]Adelberger E G, García A, Robertson R G H, Snover K A, Balantekin A B, Heeger K, Ramsey-Musolf M J, Bemmerer D, Junghans A et al. 2011 Rev. Mod. Phys. 83(1) 195–245
  5. [5]Cavanna F 2023 EPJ Web Conf. 279 01002
  6. [6]Bystritsky V M, Gerasimov V V, Krylov A R, Parzhitskii S S, Dudkin G N, Kaminskii V L, Nechaev B A, Padalko V N, Petrov A V, Mesyats G A et al. 2008 Nucl. Instrum. Methods Phys. Res. A 595 543–548
  7. [7]Casella C, Costantini H, Lemut A, Limata B, Bonetti R, Broggini C, Campajola L, Corvisiero P, Cruz J, D’Onofrio A et al. 2002 Nucl. Phys. A 706 203–216
  8. [8]Griffiths G M, Lal M and Scarfe C D 1963 Can. J. Phys. 41 724–736
  9. [9]Bailey G M, Griffiths G M, Olivo M A and Helmer R L 1970 Can. J. Phys. 48 3059–3061
  10. [10]Schmid G J, Chasteler R M, Laymon C M, Weller H R, Prior R M and Tilley D R 1995 Phys. Rev. C 52(4) R1732–R1735
  11. [11]Ma L, Karwowski H J, Brune C R, Ayer Z, Black T C, Blackmon J C, Ludwig E J, Viviani M, Kievsky A and Schiavilla R 1997 Phys. Rev. C 55(2) 588–596
  12. [12]Weller H R 2000 AIP Conf. Proc. 529 442–449
  13. [13]Bystritsky V M, Gazi S, Huran J, Dudkin G N, Krylov A R, Lysakov A, Nechaev B A, Padalko V N, Sadovsky A B, Filipowicz M et al. 2015 Phys. Part. Nucl. Lett. 12 550–558
  14. [14]Tišma I, Lipoglavšek M, Mihovilović M, Markelj S, Vencelj M and Vesić J 2019 Eur. Phys. J. A 55 137
  15. [15]Turkat S, Hammer S, Masha E, Akhmadaliev S, Bemmerer D, Grieger M, Hensel T, Julin J, Koppitz M, Ludwig F, Möckel C, Reinicke S, Schwengner R, Stöckel K, Szücs T, Wagner L and Zuber K 2021 Phys. Rev. C 103(4) 045805
  16. [16]Mossa V, Stöckel K, Cavanna F, Ferraro A, Aliotta M, Barile F, Bemmerer D, Best A, Boeltzig A, Broggini C et al. 2020 Nature 587 210–213
  17. [17]Zylstra A B, Herrmann H W, Kim Y H, McEvoy A, Frenje J A, Johnson M G, Petrasso R D, Glebov V Y, Forrest C, Delettrez J, Gales S and Rubery M 2020 Phys. Rev. C 101(4) 042802
  18. [18]Pisanti O, Mangano G, Miele G and Mazzella P 2021 J. Cosmol. Astropart. Phys. 2021 020
  19. [19]Moscoso J, de Souza R S, Coc A and Iliadis C 2021 Astrophys. J. 923 49
  20. [20]Descouvemont P, Adahchour A, Angulo C, Coc A and Vangioni-Flam E 2004 At. Data Nucl. Data Tables 88 203–236
  21. [21]Friar J L, Gibson B F, Jean H C and Payne G L 1991 Phys. Rev. Lett. 66(14) 1827–1830
  22. [22]Kievsky A, Viviani M and Rosati S 1994 Nucl. Phys. A 577 511–527
  23. [23]Kievsky A, Viviani M and Rosati S 1995 Phys. Rev. C 52(1) R15–R19
  24. [24]Viviani M, Schiavilla R and Kievsky A 1996 Phys. Rev. C 54(2) 534–553
  25. [25]Golak J, Kamada H, Witała H, Glöckle W, Kuroś Żołnierczuk J, Skibiński R, Kotlyar V V, Sagara K and Akiyoshi H 2000 Phys. Rev. C 62(5) 054005
  26. [26]Sadeghi H, Khalili H and Godarzi M 2013 Chin. Phys. C. 37 044102
  27. [27]Vanasse J, Egolf D A, Kerin J, König S and Springer R P 2014 Phys. Rev. C 89(6) 064003
  28. [28]Viviani M, Kievsky A, Marcucci L E, Rosati S and Schiavilla R 2000 Phys. Rev. C 61(6) 064001
  29. [29]Marcucci L E, Viviani M, Schiavilla R, Kievsky A and Rosati S 2005 Phys. Rev. C 72(1) 014001
  30. [30]Doleschall P, Borbély I, Papp Z and Plessas W 2003 Phys. Rev. C 67(6) 064005
  31. [31]Doleschall P and Papp Z 2005 Phys. Rev. C 72(4) 044003
  32. [32]Marcucci L E, Mangano G, Kievsky A and Viviani M 2016 Phys. Rev. Lett. 116(10) 102501
  33. [33]Marcucci L E, Mangano G, Kievsky A and Viviani M 2016 Phys. Rev. Lett. 117(4) 049901
  34. [34]Huang J T, Bertulani C A and Guimaraes V 2010 At. Data Nucl. Data Tables 96 824–847
  35. [35]Xu Y, Takahashi K, Goriely S, Arnould M, Ohta M and Utsunomiya H 2013 Nucl. Phys. A 918 61–169
  36. [36]Ghasemi R and Sadeghi H 2018 Results Phys. 9 151–165
  37. [37]Dubovichenko S B and Dzhazairov-Kakhramanov A V 2009 Eur. Phys. J. A 39 139–143
  38. [38]Dubovichenko S B, Chechin L M, Burkova N A, Dzhazairov-Kakhramanov A V, Omarov C T, Nurakhmetova S Z, Beisenov B U, Ertailyu A and Eleusheva B 2020 Russ. Phys. J. 63 1118–1125
  39. [39]Rice B J, Wulf E A, Canon R S, Kelley J H, Prior R M, Spraker M, Tilley D R and Weller H R 1997 Phys. Rev. C 56(6) R2917–R2919
  40. [40]Anh N L and Loc B M 2022 Phys. Rev. C 106(1) 014605
  41. [41]Mohr P J and Taylor B N 2000 Rev. Mod. Phys. 72(2) 351–495
  42. [42]Tilley D R, Weller H R and Hasan H H 1987 Nucl. Phys. A 474 1–60
  43. [43]Dortmans P J, Amos K and Karataglidis S 1998 Phys. Rev. C 57(5) 2433–2437
  44. [44]Colò G, Cao L, Van Giai N and Capelli L 2013 Comput. Phys. Commun. 184 142–161
  45. [45]Plattner G R, Bornand M and Viollier R D 1977 Phys. Rev. Lett. 39(3) 127–130
  46. [46]Bornand M P, Plattner G R, Viollier R D and Alder K 1978 Nucl. Phys. A 294 492–512
  47. [47]Sasakawa T, Sawada T and Kim Y E 1980 Phys. Rev. Lett. 45(17) 1386–1388
  48. [48]Huttel E, Arnold W, Berg H, Krause H, Ulbricht J and Clausnitzer G 1983 Nucl. Phys. A 406 435–442
  49. [49]Wood M H, Brune C R, Fisher B M, Karwowski H J, Leonard D S, Ludwig E J, K ievsky A, Rosati S and Viviani M 2002 Phys. Rev. C 65(3) 034002
  50. [50]Schmid G J, Viviani M, Rice B J, Chasteler R M, Godwin M A, Kiang G C, Kiang L L, Kie vsky A, Laymon C M, Prior R M, Schiavilla R, Tilley D R and Weller H R 1996 Phys. Rev. Lett. 76(17) 3088–3091
  51. [51]Iliadis C, Anderson K S, Coc A, Timmes F X and Starrfield S 2016 Astrophys. J. 831 107
  52. [52]Coc A, Petitjean P, Uzan J P, Vangioni E, Descouvemont P, Iliadis C and Longland R 2015 Phys. Rev. D 92(12) 123526

Paper details

vlnc:W_svxh3yc5
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 0

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Physics and Astronomy

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents