WorksMathematics
Kernel retracts of co-sober spaces
Abstract
Kernel retracts of co-sober spaces need not be co-sober, even when the ambient space is countably infinite and compact. We construct a co-sober -space and a continuous idempotent map satisfying in the specialization order, whose image with the subspace topology is not co-sober. The construction starts from a countable compact KC anti-Hausdorff space of van Douwen type and adjoins an infinite chain. We classify the -irreducible compact saturated subsets of the extension and show that each is a point saturation. The kernel operator collapses the added chain to a distinguished point while fixing the original space, thereby recovering the non-co-sober seed as its image. This answers negatively two questions of Xu and Zhao, concerning continuous kernel operators and arbitrary retracts, and contrasts with the known preservation of co-sobriety by continuous closure operators.
Introduction
Sobriety and co-sobriety are distinct properties in non-Hausdorff topology and domain theory. The notion of a co-sober space was introduced by Escardó, Lawson and Simpson in connection with a dual form of the Hofmann–Mislove theorem; see [2]. In a co-sober space, every -irreducible compact saturated set is the saturation of a unique point. It is easy to give a co-sober space which is not sober (see, e.g., [6 Example 2.1]). Escardó, Lawson and Simpson asked whether every sober space is co-sober ([2 Problem 9.7]). In [6], Wen and Xu gave a negative answer to this problem by proving that Isbell’s lattice constructed in [3] equipped with the lower topology is sober but not co-sober. Based on Wen and Xu’s result, Shen et al. [5] further obtained a dcpo whose Scott topology is sober but not co-sober.
A basic theme in the theory is the preservation of co-sobriety under natural topological constructions (see [6, 7, 8]). Wen and Xu proved, among other things, that closed subspaces and saturated subspaces of co-sober spaces are co-sober, and that the image of a co-sober space under a continuous closure operator is co-sober [6]. Motivated by this result, Xu and Zhao asked whether the analogous assertion holds for kernel operators [7 Question 9.5]. With the convention
a continuous map is a kernel operator if
Email addresses: xiqxu2002163.com (Xiaoquan Xu), [email protected] (Fengshuo Xu), [email protected] (Haitao Ji), [email protected] (Dong Qiu). They also asked whether an arbitrary retract of a co-sober space must be co-sober [7 Question 9.6]. We answer both questions negatively within the class of countable compact spaces. The construction separates two requirements: co-sobriety of the ambient space and failure of co-sobriety in the kernel image. We start with a countable compact anti-Hausdorff seed which is not co-sober. We then attach a countable chain to . The chain is topologized so that all non-principal compact saturated sets whose projection covers the whole seed admit explicit nontrivial decompositions and hence fail to be -irreducible. The remaining -irreducible compact saturated sets project onto proper -irreducible compact subsets of , and those are forced to be singletons. This makes the extension co-sober. Finally, a kernel operator collapses the added chain to one distinguished point of while fixing the old copy of , so that its image recovers the non-co-sober seed.
It is useful to formulate the conclusion in the language of retracts. If and are continuous, , and , we shall call a kernel retract of . Dually, the condition corresponds to the closure-operator situation; one may naturally call such an a closure retract. The known positive theorem for closure operators and our negative theorem for kernel operators therefore exhibit a genuine asymmetry between these two kinds of order-compatible retracts.
Our main result is the following.
Theorem 1.1. There exist a countably infinite compact co-sober -space and a continuous kernel operator such that the subspace is not co-sober. Consequently, a kernel retract, and hence a retract, of a co-sober space need not be co-sober.
The proof uses the equality form of -irreducibility, not the stronger condition involving inclusions in unions, and all images carry the subspace topology. The sliced almost-disjoint family and the seed topology are due to van Douwen; the infinite-chain extension and the analysis of its compact saturated sets provide the kernel counterexample. Section 3 records the seed construction and classifies its proper -irreducible compact subsets. Sections 4–5 define the extension, determine its specialization order, and construct the kernel operator. Sections 6–8 establish co-sobriety of the extension and failure of co-sobriety of its image.
Preliminaries
Compactness is used without any separation assumption. We write and for the family of all infinite subsets of .
Let be a topological space. A subset is saturated if it is the intersection of all open sets containing it. If is , this is equivalent to being an upper set with respect to the specialization order. We write
for the saturation of a point .
A nonempty compact saturated set is called -irreducible if
implies or . The family of all such sets is denoted by . A -space is co-sober if for every there exists a unique point such that
Recall that a space is a -space if every compact subset is closed, and it is anti-Hausdorff if every two nonempty open subsets intersect. A space is called a -space if every convergent sequence has a unique limit. A Fréchet space means a Fréchet–Urysohn space: for every and , a sequence in converges to . We shall use the following observation of Künzi and van der Zypen [4 Lemma 1].
Lemma 2.1 (Künzi and van der Zypen). Every Fréchet -space is a -space.
Proof. Let be a compact subset of a Fréchet US-space , and let . By the Fréchet property there is a sequence of points of converging to . Since is compact, the sequence has a cluster point . Using the Fréchet property again, one can choose a subsequence of converging to . Since is a US-space, limits of convergent sequences are unique, and hence . Thus is closed.
Lemma 2.2. Let be a non-singleton compact KC anti-Hausdorff space. Then is not co-sober.
Proof. Since is , every subset is saturated. Suppose
with and nonempty compact subsets. By the KC property, both are closed. If both are proper, then and are disjoint nonempty open sets, contradicting anti-Hausdorffness. Hence is -irreducible. Since is non-singleton while every point saturation in a -space is a singleton, is not co-sober.
A van Douwen-type seed space
We use the sliced maximal almost-disjoint construction of van Douwen. We first state the required combinatorial result and then record the properties of his seed space needed for the extension.
A sliced MAD theorem of van Douwen
The following is the case of van Douwen’s slicing theorem for maximal almost-disjoint (MAD) families on a countable set; see [1 Sections 5–7]. The underlying set is countable; the family itself is not asserted to be countable.
Theorem 3.1 (van Douwen). There exist an infinite family and a map such that:
distinct have finite intersection;
for every infinite there exists such that is infinite;
if
is infinite, then
Equivalently, for every there exists with .
Remark 3.2. Conditions (M1) and (M2) say that is an -MAD family. Condition (M3) is precisely the slicing condition denoted by (E) in van Douwen’s construction; see [1 p. 151]. Its existence in ZFC follows from van Douwen’s slicing theorem, in particular Theorem 7.1 of [1], after identifying the countably infinite set occurring there with .
For and , call
a branch piece. Put and let the complements of all branch pieces form a subbase for a topology on .
Proposition 3.3. The space is countably infinite, compact, , KC and anti-Hausdorff. Moreover every proper closed subset of is contained in a set of the form
where and are finite.
Proof. We record the parts of the sliced van Douwen construction that will be used later.
First, is onto: apply (M3) to . Consequently each singleton occurs as a branch piece, and hence is .
If is open and , then is finite. It is enough to check this for subbasic open sets. If a subbasic open set containing is the complement of , then ; by (M1), its complement meets in only finitely many points. The property is preserved under finite intersections and arbitrary unions. It follows that every branch piece is compact: an open cover contains one member covering , and that member misses only finitely many points of .
Next, every proper closed subset is small in the stated sense. Pick . Since is open, there is a basic neighbourhood of , given by a finite intersection of subbasic open sets, contained in . Taking complements shows that is contained in a finite union of branch pieces and hence in for suitable finite and . On the other hand, itself is not small: if and are finite, choose and then a point of outside , using (M1).
Every proper closed set is compact, because it is a closed subset of a finite union of compact branch pieces and finitely many points. To see that is compact, take an open cover and choose one nonempty member . The complement is a proper closed, hence compact, subset and therefore has a finite subcover; adjoining gives a finite cover of .
Van Douwen’s argument for the topology determined by such an -MAD family and slicing shows that is Fréchet and US; see [1 pp. 149–151], in particular properties (8)–(10) and condition (E). Hence Lemma 2.1 implies that is a KC-space. Finally, if two nonempty open sets were disjoint, then and would be proper closed small sets whose union is , contradicting the fact that is not small. Thus is anti-Hausdorff.
Proposition 3.4. If is a -irreducible compact subset, then is a singleton.
Proof. By the KC property, is closed. By Proposition 3.3, there are a finite set and a finite such that
For each , define
If is infinite, an injective enumeration of converges to by the branch-convergence property in the preceding proof. Since is closed, . Hence every is contained in , and it is compact: the finite case is immediate and the infinite case is a branch piece. Together with the finitely many singletons belonging to , these sets give a finite cover of by compact subsets of . Since is , all of them are saturated. Repeated use of -irreducibility shows that must coincide with one of these pieces.
A finite piece containing at least two points splits into two nonempty proper finite compact subsets, so a finite -irreducible piece is a singleton. If is infinite, choose with . Then
is a union of two nonempty proper compact subsets, again contradicting the -irreducibility of . Thus only the singleton case is possible.
By Lemma 2.2 and Proposition 3.3, itself is not co-sober.
The infinite-chain extension
Fix . Let
Write the old points as , , and the new chain points as , .
For , put
and for define
We declare to be open if and only if:
(E1) is open in ;
(E2) is an upper set in with its usual order;
(E3) if , then ;
(E4) if , then and is compact in .
Proposition 4.1. Conditions (E1)–(E4) define a topology on .
Proof. The empty set and satisfy the conditions. Let be open. Conditions (E1)–(E3) are stable under intersections. If , then both and are nonempty. Since is anti-Hausdorff, , and
is compact. Thus is open.
Now let , where each is open. Conditions (E1)–(E3) are immediate. If , choose with . Then and
Since is closed and is compact, the right-hand side is compact. Hence arbitrary unions are open.
Lemma 4.2. The map is a topological embedding.
Proof. The old trace of every open is open in . Conversely, let be open. If , then is open in . If , then
is open: condition (E4) holds because is a closed subset of the compact space . In both cases the old trace is exactly .
Specialization order and the kernel operator
Proposition 5.1. For and one has
and there are no other comparabilities between an old point and a new point.
Proof. The first assertion follows from Lemma 4.2 and the property of . Condition (E2) gives whenever . For the converse, the set
is open by (E1)–(E4), since its residual old set is empty. If , then and . Thus if and only if .
Condition (E3) says that every open neighbourhood of contains every , so . If , the open set contains and no chain point. Conversely, for every old point there is an open set containing a prescribed but omitting : use old trace when , and when , together with a suitable tail. Hence no new point specializes to an old point.
Corollary 5.2. The space is .
Define
Proposition 5.3. The map is a continuous kernel operator.
Proof. Idempotence is immediate. By Proposition 5.1,
while every old point is fixed. Hence for every .
For continuity, let be open. If , then
If , then
Both sets satisfy (E1)–(E4), so is continuous.
Compact saturated sets in the extension
Put
Lemma 6.1. The sets , , and are nonempty compact saturated subsets of .
Proof. The sets and are point saturations and hence supercompact. The set is saturated by Proposition 5.1. Let be an open cover of and choose with . By (E2), contains every with . By (E4), is compact. The set is compact by Lemma 4.2 and is contained in . Hence finitely many members of cover it. Together with , they cover .
Finally, let cover . Compactness of the old copy yields finitely many members covering all old points. One of them contains and therefore, by (E3), contains every chain point. Thus is compact.
Define
The same inverse-image computation as in Proposition 5.3 shows that is continuous.
Lemma 6.2 (Full-projection classification). Let be saturated and suppose . Then either or for some .
Proof. For each , the fibre consists only of , so all these old points belong to . If , saturation and Proposition 5.1 force every into , and hence .
Assume . Since , the set
is nonempty. Saturation makes an upper set of , so it has a least element and equals . Thus .
There are strict decompositions
All terms are nonempty compact saturated sets by Lemma 6.1, and both pieces in each union are proper.
Corollary 6.3. Neither nor any is -irreducible.
Co-sobriety of the extension
Theorem 7.1. The space is co-sober.
Proof. Let . We first show that is a -irreducible compact subset of . It is nonempty and compact by continuity of , and it is saturated because is .
Suppose
where , are nonempty compact subsets of . Since is KC, both and are closed. Put
Both sets are nonempty. They are saturated because and are saturated in the -space and inverse images of saturated sets under continuous maps are saturated. They are compact because they are closed subsets of the compact set . Since
-irreducibility gives or , and therefore or . Hence is -irreducible.
If , Lemma 6.2 gives or for some , contradicting Corollary 6.3. Therefore . By Proposition 3.4,
for some .
If , the fibre consists only of , and hence
Suppose . If , saturation gives , whereas ; hence . If , then consists of chain points. Its set of levels is a nonempty upper subset of , hence equals for its least element . Thus
In all cases is a point saturation. Conversely, every point saturation is supercompact and hence -irreducible: in any cover by compact saturated subsets, a member containing the point contains its entire saturation. Thus the proof gives the exact classification
By Corollary 5.2, each representing point is unique, so is co-sober.
The kernel image is not co-sober
By definition,
By Lemma 4.2, the restriction
is a homeomorphism. Since is non-singleton, compact, , KC and anti-Hausdorff, Lemma 2.2 shows that , and hence , is not co-sober.
Theorem 8.1. There exist a countably infinite compact co-sober -space and a continuous kernel operator such that , endowed with the subspace topology, is not co-sober. Hence the answer to [7 Question 9.5] is negative.
Since , the image equals the fixed-point set,
and together with the inclusion is a retraction. Moreover the composite inclusion–retraction is exactly the kernel operator .
Corollary 8.2. A kernel retract of a co-sober space need not be co-sober. In particular, a retract of a co-sober space need not be co-sober, so the answer to [7 Question 9.6] is negative.
Concluding remarks
The construction exhibits a sharp contrast between closure and kernel retracts. The image of a co-sober space under a continuous closure operator is co-sober [6], whereas Theorem 8.1 shows that the analogous assertion for a kernel operator fails. In retract language, closure retracts preserve co-sobriety, while kernel retracts do not.
The infinite chain supplies the decompositions used in this example. Every saturated set whose projection covers all of is, by Lemma 6.2, either or one of the , and each has a nontrivial compact saturated decomposition:
All remaining -irreducible compact saturated sets have proper projection to the seed, and the seed classification then collapses that projection to a singleton. These decompositions allow co-sobriety of the ambient space to coexist with non-co-sobriety of its kernel image.
The result suggests a broader study of preservation properties under order-compatible retracts. In particular, it is natural to compare closure retracts, kernel retracts and arbitrary retracts for other non-Hausdorff properties arising in domain theory.
Declaration of competing interest
The authors declare that they have no known competing financial interests or personal relationships that could have appeared to influence the work reported in this paper.
Data availability
No research data were used in this theoretical study.
Declaration of generative AI and AI-assisted technologies in the manuscript preparation process
During the preparation of this manuscript, the authors used ChatGPT (OpenAI) for language editing, organization of the exposition, literature cross-checking, and assistance with checking mathematical arguments. After using this tool, the authors reviewed and edited the content as needed and take full responsibility for the content of the publication.
References
- [1]E. K. van Douwen, An anti-Hausdorff Fréchet space in which convergent sequences have unique limits, Topology Appl. 51 (1993) 147–158. https://doi.org/10.1016/0166-8641(93)90147-6.
- [2]M. Escardó, J. D. Lawson, A. Simpson, Comparing Cartesian closed categories of (core) compactly generated spaces, Topology Appl. 143 (2004) 105–145. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.topol.2004.02.011.
- [3]J. Isbell, Completion of a construction of Johnstone, Proc. Amer. Math. Soc. 85 (1982) 333–334. https://doi.org/10.1090/S0002-9939-1982-0656096-4.
- [4]H.-P. A. Künzi, D. van der Zypen, Maximal (sequentially) compact topologies, in: W. Gähler, G. Preuss (Eds.), Categorical Structures and Their Applications, World Scientific, 2004, pp. 173–187. https://doi.org/10.1142/9789812702418_0013.
- [5]C. Shen, G. Wu, X. Xi, D. Zhao, Sober Scott spaces are not always co-sober, Topology Appl. 282 (2020) 107316. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.topol.2020.107316.
- [6]X. Wen, X. Xu, Sober is not always co-sober, Topology Appl. 250 (2018) 48–52. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.topol.2018.10.003.
- [7]X. Xu, D. Zhao, Some open problems on well-filtered spaces and sober spaces, Topology Appl. 301 (2021) 107540. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.topol.2020.107540.
- [8]B. Zhao, Z. He, K. Wang, On co-sober spaces, Houston J. Math. 49(4) (2023) 971–988.DOI