WorksMathematics
Degree-one cohomology of metacyclic -groups: a low-bit dichotomy
Abstract
We study the subalgebra generated by degree-one mod- cohomology for metacyclic -groups with unique normal forms, where and . Presentation compatibility forces or and . If , the degree-one-generated algebra is , a four-dimensional algebra shared by the four nonmodular types of Aaboun–Zekhnini. The unique exceptional case , is modular and has infinite-dimensional degree-one algebra . The regular algebra is PBW, Koszul, universally Koszul, and strongly Koszul, whereas the modular algebra is not Koszul. We realize the regular algebra by inflation from the common quotient and identify its quadratic dual with the characteristic-two Jordan plane. For the inversion tower , we give uniform presentations of the full mod- cohomology rings and determine the kernels and images of inflation in every degree. Their direct limit yields the continuous cohomology ring of . We also record an arithmetic consequence for Galois groups arising over cyclotomic -extensions of real quadratic fields.
Introduction
The mod-2 cohomology of metacyclic 2-groups has been studied at the level of the full cohomology ring. Diethelm treated nonabelian split metacyclic -groups [12], Rusin computed the mod-2 rings of metacyclic 2-groups together with their Steenrod operations [27], and Huebschmann subsequently treated the mod- cohomology of general metacyclic groups [17]. These calculations reveal substantial higher-degree structure even for groups with relatively simple presentations. For standard background on finite-group cohomology, see [2, 4, 6]. In particular, the theorem of Chebolu–Mináč–Okay–Schultz–Ure [8 Theorem 1.1] implies that the full mod-2 cohomology ring of a nonabelian finite 2-group is not generated by degree-one classes. For a graded -algebra , write for the subalgebra generated by its degree-one component, and set
This subalgebra records the cup products of degree-one characters and provides a natural object on which to study how the presentation of a metacyclic group controls its cohomology. The relation between degree-one cohomology, Koszul algebras, and quadratic duality has also been investigated in Galois cohomology and pro- group theory [22, 26]. Aaboun and Zekhnini classify metacyclic-nonmodular 2-groups with abelianization of type into four refined presentation types [1 Proposition 2.4]. The types differ in their conjugation and power relations, yet their degree-one-generated cohomology algebras have the same form. We explain this uniformity directly from the lowest 2-adic information in the presentations, before distinguishing the individual types. The relevance of the congruence modulo 4 comes from the Bockstein itself. For a degree-one mod-2 character, the Bockstein can be computed using a set-theoretic lift to , so the resulting cocycle is determined by the corresponding low-bit multiplication law. This provides a direct route from the presentation to the degree-one cup products, without first computing the full cohomology ring. Consider a metacyclic group with unique normal forms
and assume . The power relation records the carry that occurs when the exponent of passes through . The compatibility conditions force
Thus the carry is divisible by except when and . This singles out the modular boundary directly from the presentation. Let be the characters adapted to the generators . In the regular branch, the normal-form multiplication modulo gives the Bockstein relations
As for a degree-one mod- class, these identities determine the entire degree-one-generated algebra:
The algebra is four-dimensional, with basis . At the unique modular boundary , the degree-one algebra instead has the presentation
In this case the powers of remain nonzero in every degree. Thus the divisibility of the carry by distinguishes two different algebraic behaviors. The uniformity in the regular branch also has a group-theoretic explanation. Reducing the two generators modulo their fourth powers gives a surjection onto . Inflation along this quotient induces an isomorphism of degree-one-generated cohomology algebras. Hence the common algebra of the four nonmodular types comes from a single group of order through an explicit homomorphism. We next examine the homological properties of these two algebras. The regular algebra is PBW, Koszul, universally Koszul, and strongly Koszul; its quadratic dual is the characteristic-two Jordan plane. The modular algebra has a minimal cubic relation and is not Koszul. Consequently, the same low-bit condition that determines the degree-one products also determines Koszulity. The common quotient is the first level of the inversion tower
This family permits a comparison between the stable degree-one core and the higher-degree classes of the full cohomology ring. We determine at every finite level and show that inflation kills precisely the ideal generated by the periodicity class coming from the cyclic quotient, while preserving the class restricting nontrivially to . Passing to the direct limit gives
Finally, an arithmetic application shows how the group-theoretic classification determines the degree-one algebra of certain Galois groups over cyclotomic -extensions of real quadratic fields. Once the arithmetic hypotheses select a metacyclic type, the cohomological and Koszul conclusions follow from the presentation.
Metacyclic presentations and low-bit compatibility
Compatibility and abelianization
A metacyclic group is built from two cyclic pieces: a cyclic normal subgroup and a cyclic quotient. We consider finite metacyclic -groups with a cyclic normal subgroup
and cyclic quotient
where . Choose an element whose image generates . Since is normal, conjugation by induces an automorphism of . As is cyclic, there is an odd integer such that . The parameter therefore describes how the quotient generator acts on the normal cyclic subgroup.
Although the image of has order in , the element itself need not have order in . What is required is that belongs to , so there is a uniquely determined integer , with , such that
Thus records the possible discrepancy between the order of and the order of its image in the quotient. More concretely, when products are expressed in terms of powers of and , the relation determines the additional factor that appears whenever the exponent of passes through . It is therefore convenient to regard as the carry in the power relation.
Every element of can be expressed in the form . We assume throughout that these expressions are unique for
In particular, , and we work with the unified presentation
The parameters and describe different aspects of the extension: the first determines the conjugation action, while the second determines the power relation. These parameters are nevertheless constrained by the requirement that both relations hold simultaneously.
Indeed, since lies in the abelian subgroup , conjugation by must act trivially on . At the same time, the element must be fixed by conjugation by . These two compatibility conditions impose congruences on and , which we establish before considering the refined classification of metacyclic 2-groups.
Proposition 2.1. For a presentation (2.1) with the stated normal forms, one has
If, in addition, , then necessarily or . Under this additional hypothesis, moreover,
Proof. For the first congruence, we compare two ways in which acts on the normal subgroup . Since and is abelian, conjugation by acts trivially on . In particular,
On the other hand, after conjugations by and using , we obtain
Thus , and since has order , this gives the first congruence.
For the second congruence, note that
and we hence
Now if , then , so . Thus the remaining factor must divide , implying . Because has been chosen in the range , there are only two possibilities: or .
We next determine the commutator subgroup. Since is cyclic hence abelian, it is abelian, . Because itself is cyclic and therefore abelian, the only nontrivial commutation is , and so . But , so for some odd integer , which then gives
Therefore . It remains to identify the abelianization. Since , the image of in has order at most 2. It is not trivial, because . Thus the image of has order exactly 2.
The defining relation becomes in the abelianization. We have already shown that is either 0 or , and in either case is even. Since has order 2, this gives . Hence . Thus the order of divides . In fact its order is exactly . If , then . Projecting to shows that the image of is trivial, and since the image of generates , this forces . Therefore has order .
Finally, the two cyclic factors are independent. Suppose , . Then . Projecting to gives . The relation therefore reduces to , which forces . Consequently
The preceding proposition explains why the carry condition that will be used later is almost automatic. Under the hypothesis , compatibility leaves only two possible values of the carry: or . The first gives , while the second gives , the unique element of order 2 in . If , then , so both compatible values of are divisible by 4. Thus the condition does not need to be imposed separately once .
There is only one exception: When , the nonzero compatible carry is . This is the unique compatible case in which the carry is not divisible by 4. This exceptional situation is the modular boundary treated separately below.
Product convention and low-bit multiplication
Proposition 2.2. For ,
where if and if .
Proof. The relation implies , and hence . Because , at most one use of is required to return to normal form, giving the stated formula. In particular, with the convention , the exponent is .
Lemma 2.3. Assume and either or . If is in normal form, then
and
Proof. Since , we have that . By Proposition 2.1, the carry is either 0 or . In either case, the carry vanishes modulo 4, yielding the first congruence. The second follows since reduction to normal form changes the exponent of only by multiples of , which is even.
The four refined nonmodular types
We recall the classification of metacyclic-nonmodular 2-groups with abelianization of type given by Aaboun–Zekhnini [1 Proposition 2.4]. Their four types are distinguished by the conjugation action and the power relation. In Types 1 and 2, the action is inversion, so , whereas Types 3 and 4 have for an integer subject to the restrictions below. The power relation is split in Types 1 and 3, where , and nonsplit in Types 2 and 4, where .
The four types, together with their parameter restrictions, are summarized in the following table.
| Type | Parameter restrictions | ||
| 1 | |||
| 2 | |||
| 3 | Either with , or with | ||
| 4 | , |
Table 1.
Thus, the classification separates the groups according to the conjugation action and the possible values of the power parameter . Notably, the case occurs only in Type 3, while Types 3 and 4 both admit .
In every row, . Types 1 and 3 are split. In Types 2 and 4 the classification imposes , so the nonsplit carry is divisible by 4. Hence all four types lie in the regular branch of the low-bit dichotomy without any additional cohomological hypothesis.
The unique low-bit boundary
The only compatible nonsplit presentation with and carry not divisible by 4 is
Proposition 2.4. The group is modular. More precisely, has order and, with , one has
Thus
Proof. The relation shows that has order . Since is even, centralizes , and therefore . From we obtain . The factor commutes with , so the same conjugation formula holds with replaced by . □
Theorem 2.5. Let and let
Define by
Then
In particular, , for every , and . The algebra has -basis and Hilbert series .
Proof. By Proposition 2.4, with we have
where conjugation by acts on as . Since ,
Thus restricts to the generator of , while restricts to the generator of . Consequently, for every , by restriction to .
Moreover, lifts to a homomorphism sending to and to $1: the defining relations are preserved because . Therefore the mod-2 Bockstein of vanishes, and .
The restriction to shows that the powers of persist, while the lift of gives . To determine the remaining products, we first compute the dimension of . This will constrain the differentials in the mod-2 Lyndon–Hochschild–Serre spectral sequence and allow us to identify the first relation involving both generators. Consider the integral homology Lyndon–Hochschild–Serre spectral sequence associated with (see [19, 15]):
Since , the only potentially nonzero term in total degree two is . Under the identification , the action of the generator of is multiplication by . The standard cyclic homology formula [6] gives
Since , multiplication by on has kernel . On the other hand, , and is odd because . Hence
As , all terms of total degree two on the -page vanish. Thus . Since , the universal coefficient theorem yields
We next use the mod-2 cohomology spectral sequence; for the general theory of extension differentials see [16]. Here
The action of on is trivial, because is an odd-power automorphism of . Hence
where , , . The classes and are represented by the global characters and ; in particular, they are permanent cycles. Their product is nonzero in and is also a permanent cycle: there are no incoming differentials, and every outgoing differential vanishes by multiplicativity. Thus
The classes and are linearly independent, since restricts nontrivially to whereas restricts to zero. They therefore form a basis of .
It follows that the class must be killed by a differential. Its only possible outgoing differentials are
and
The second is impossible, since survives to , because restricts nontrivially to . Consequently,
and
The cohomology class belongs to filtration at least two in , and the vanishing of places it in filtration three. This last filtration step is spanned by . Since restricts to zero on , while does not, we conclude that .
We have therefore obtained a surjection
The source has basis . Its images are linearly independent; indeed, in degree one this follows from the independence of ; in degree two from the independence of ; and in every degree at least three from the nonvanishing of . The surjection is therefore an isomorphism. □
The modular boundary shows how the power relation can change the degree-one algebra without changing the dimension of . The classes persist in every degree, in contrast with the finite-dimensional algebra that occurs when the carry is divisible by 4. We now turn to that regular branch and derive its relations directly from the normal-form multiplication law.
The degree-one cohomology dichotomy
We first consider the regular branch, where the power-relation carry is divisible by 4. In this case, the degree-one relations can be obtained directly from the Bockstein, using the normal-form multiplication law established in Section 2. The exceptional modular branch has already been determined in Theorem 2.5, and the two calculations will be combined in the main dichotomy below.
Assume that (2.1) has unique normal forms, , and either or . Proposition 2.1 gives
Define
Lemma 2.3 shows that and are homomorphisms. Their values on and show that they are independent, and Proposition 2.1 shows that they form a basis of .
We use the Bockstein associated to
for which on .
Lemma 3.1. The character lifts to , and hence .
Proof. Set and . Since , the left side of maps to 0 modulo 4, and the right side maps to 0 because . The remaining relations are automatic. □
Lemma 3.2. The character does not lift to . Consequently
Proof. If were a lift, then would be odd. Applying to gives
Since , this would imply , impossible for an odd element. □
The failure of to lift establishes that its Bockstein is nonzero, but does not yet identify the resulting degree-two class. To determine it, we use the multiplication law modulo 4 to compute an explicit representative of .
Lemma 3.3. One has .
Proof. Use the set-theoretic lift . For and , write in normal form. The connecting cocycle is
By Lemma 2.3,
Hence the numerator is 0 modulo 4 when is even and modulo 4 when is odd. The resulting cocycle is
which represents . Mod-2 group cohomology is graded-commutative, and in characteristic 2 the degree-one sign disappears, so
Therefore . □
Theorem 3.4. Let have a metacyclic normal-form presentation (1), with and . Then
and the degree-one-generated cohomology algebra is determined by the following dichotomy.
(1) If , equivalently if or , then
This algebra is four-dimensional, with -basis .
(2) If , then necessarily and . In this case is the modular group , and
This algebra is infinite-dimensional, with -basis and Hilbert series
In particular, the degree-one-generated cohomology algebra depends only on whether the power-relation parameter vanishes modulo 4, and is independent of the remaining admissible presentation parameters.
Proof. Proposition 2.1 shows that presentation compatibility forces or and gives
Consequently, the presentation-adapted characters form a basis of .
Suppose first that . By the compatibility condition, this occurs precisely when or . Lemmas 3.1, 3.2, and 3.3 give , and . These relations induce a surjective homomorphism of graded -algebras
In the source algebra, every monomial of degree at least 3 vanishes, since . Moreover, the degree-two component is spanned by . Since and are linearly independent in and , the images of are linearly independent. The homomorphism is therefore an isomorphism, giving the first assertion.
Now suppose that . Since or , this forces and . By Proposition 2.4, the corresponding group is the modular group . The exact calculation in Theorem 2.5 gives
The defining relations show that this algebra has basis . In particular, it is infinite-dimensional, and its Hilbert series is
The two cases exhaust all compatible values of . Their algebra presentations depend only on the residue of modulo 4, establishing the asserted dichotomy. □
The uniformity in Theorem 3.4 suggests a common group-theoretic source for the degree-one algebra. Since the relevant multiplication law depends only on the presentation modulo 4, we retain the fourth-power residues of the two generators. The resulting quotient makes the cohomological identification compatible with inflation.
Proposition 3.5. Let have a metacyclic normal-form presentation (1), with , , and . Let
Then the assignments
define a surjective homomorphism
with
Moreover, the induced inflation homomorphism restricts to an isomorphism of graded -algebras
Thus every group in the regular branch has the same degree-one-generated cohomology algebra as the fixed group of order 16, and this identification is induced by the presentation-defined quotient map.
Proof. We first verify that the proposed assignments respect the defining relations of . Since , the relation maps to
Likewise, implies
Because , we also have , so the power relation is preserved. Finally, since ,
Hence the assignments extend to a homomorphism . Its image contains both and , so is surjective.
Let
Clearly . In the quotient , the images of and have orders dividing . The relation becomes , since . Moreover, the power relation becomes trivial because . Consequently, is generated by the images of and subject to the relations defining . These relations give a surjective homomorphism , while induces a surjective homomorphism . Since is finite, both maps are isomorphisms. Therefore
We now consider the induced map on cohomology. Let be the characters determined by
Let be the corresponding presentation-adapted characters. By construction,
Since both pairs form bases of their respective first cohomology groups, induces an isomorphism
By Theorem 3.4, both and belong to the regular branch, and hence
and
In particular, both algebras are four-dimensional, with respective bases
Naturality of the cup product gives
Thus maps the displayed basis of the first algebra onto the displayed basis of the second. It follows that its restriction to the degree-one-generated subalgebras is an isomorphism, as claimed.
Corollary 3.6. For every metacyclic-nonmodular 2-group in Types 1–4 of Aaboun–Zekhnini,
Thus the degree-one-generated algebra is independent of the refined type and all admissible parameters.
Proof. Each of the four source presentations has , and none is the exceptional , boundary. Theorem 3.4 applies.
Remark 3.7. Theorem 3.4 isolates the low-bit mechanism behind the degree-one relations across the refined metacyclic types. The full cohomology calculations of Rusin and Huebschmann describe the corresponding ambient rings. The normal-form calculation used here makes the uniformity transparent: the congruence fixes the conjugation contribution, while the compatibility condition on controls the power-relation carry modulo .
Corollary 3.8. In the regular branch,
Among the three nonzero elements of , exactly one has vanishing Bockstein.
Koszulity and Quadratic Duality
The explicit algebra presentations allow us to compare homological properties in the two branches. Related enhanced-Koszul questions have been studied for right-angled Artin groups and in Galois cohomology [7, 21]. The regular algebra is defined by quadratic relations, while the modular boundary has a minimal cubic relation. We first establish the enhanced Koszul properties of the regular algebra and then show that the same low-bit distinction determines Koszulity.
We use the colon criterion for universal Koszulity as developed by Conca [10] and discussed by Conca–De Negri–Rossi [11]. For strong Koszulity we use the notion introduced by Herzog–Hibi–Restuccia [14], also used in the enhanced-Koszul literature [21].
Proposition 4.1. The algebra is PBW and therefore Koszul. It is also universally Koszul and strongly Koszul.
Proof. With degree-lexicographic order , the two quadrics , form a Gröbner basis: their only -polynomial is , which reduces to zero. Thus the algebra is PBW.
For universal Koszulity, set . The nonzero proper ideals generated by degree-one elements are , , , . Using
one obtains
and, whenever is a nonzero linear form outside the degree-one part of one of ,
in the applicable cases. Hence the standard colon criterion gives universal Koszulity.
For strong Koszulity use the basis . Then
and
Every required colon is generated by a subset of the same basis. □
Corollary 4.2. Let have a metacyclic normal-form presentation (1), with and . Then the degree-one-generated cohomology algebra is Koszul if and only if .
More precisely, if , then is PBW, Koszul, universally Koszul, and strongly Koszul. If , then necessarily and , and the corresponding algebra is not quadratic and hence is not Koszul. In particular, all four nonmodular metacyclic types of Abou-Zekhnini lie in the Koszul branch.
Proof. By Theorem 3.4, the degree-one-generated cohomology algebra has precisely two possible presentations, depending on whether vanishes modulo 4.
Suppose first that (mod 4). Then
The preceding proposition shows that this algebra is PBW, Koszul, universally Koszul, and strongly Koszul.
Now suppose that (mod 4). Presentation compatibility forces and , and Theorem 3.4 gives
The relation is a minimal cubic relation. Indeed, the only quadratic relation is , and remains nonzero in . Consequently, the defining ideal of cannot be generated by quadratic relations, so is not quadratic. Since every connected standard graded Koszul algebra is quadratic (see [25]), is not Koszul.
The failure of universal Koszulity can also be seen directly from the colon criterion. In one has . Since and contains no nonzero element of degree one, this annihilator is not generated by linear forms. Thus fails the universal Koszul colon criterion.
Finally, the PBW, universal Koszul, and strong Koszul properties each imply Koszulity. Hence none of these enhanced properties holds in the exceptional branch. This establishes the dichotomy.
Koszulity makes the quadratic dual a natural object to consider, since it describes the Yoneda algebra of the degree-one core; see [3, 24] for general treatments of quadratic duality. In the regular branch, the dual admits a familiar noncommutative presentation, connecting the cohomology calculation with the characteristic-two Jordan plane [18].
Proposition 4.3. Let
Then its quadratic dual is
In particular, is the Jordan plane in characteristic two. It has an -basis and Hilbert series
Since is Koszul, its Yoneda algebra satisfies
Consequently, this description applies to the degree-one-generated cohomology algebra of every group in the regular branch of Theorem 3.4.
Proof. Let . To compute the quadratic dual, write as a quotient of the tensor algebra . Since is commutative, its space of quadratic relations is
Let be the dual basis of . An element
belongs to the orthogonal complement precisely when
Thus is generated by , and the definition of the quadratic dual gives
Equivalently, its defining relation is . Let be the derivation of determined by . Then the same relation presents the Ore extension
The Ore-extension normal form, equivalently obtained by the reduction , gives the -basis (see [20, 5]). Hence its degree- component has dimension , and
On the other hand, the relations of give the basis , so and
By Proposition 4.1, is Koszul. The standard identification of the Yoneda algebra of a Koszul algebra with its quadratic dual therefore gives . Finally, Theorem 3.4 identifies the degree-one-generated cohomology algebra of every group in the regular branch with , so the same description applies throughout that family. □
Cohomology and inflation in the inversion family
The group appearing in Proposition 3.5 is also the first level of a natural inverse system of metacyclic groups. The degree-one algebra is unchanged throughout this system, while higher-degree classes exhibit different behavior under inflation. We determine the full finite-level cohomology rings and their inflation maps in order to identify the classes that persist in the continuous limit.
Let
with quotient maps
Then
Finite-level cohomology and inflation
The mod-2 cohomology of was computed by David Benson in Appendix A of [8], in the course of the proof of Proposition A.1. In his notation, the group is
which agrees with our under and .
Benson’s calculation gives, after renaming the generators to agree with our degree-one characters,
Here is inflated from the degree-two generator of the cohomology of the cyclic quotient .
The second degree-two generator arises in Benson’s calculation from the central extension
Writing , with , the associated Lyndon–Hochschild–Serre spectral sequence has
Benson shows that survives the spectral sequence and gives rise to the degree-two generator . In particular,
Since , it follows that
We take . For each , let
be the quotient map fixing and reducing the exponent of modulo , and define
Because restricts to the identity on , naturality of restriction gives
Thus the degree-two classes are nonzero at every finite level.
Let
be the inflation of the standard degree-two class of . Since the quotient splits, this class is nonzero.
Lemma 5.1. The inflation map
is zero for every .
Proof. For
the first inflation map in the five-term sequence is an isomorphism on , because the parity character pulls back to the parity character. The following restriction map to is therefore zero, so the transgression
is injective. Both groups are one-dimensional, hence the transgression is an isomorphism and the next inflation map in degree is zero.
The preceding lemma determines what happens to the quotient-side periodicity class, while the construction of gives a compatible class restricting nontrivially to . To describe inflation beyond degree , we must identify these classes within the full cohomology ring. The following proposition provides this description and determines the kernel and image of inflation in every degree.
Proposition 5.2. For , write for the presentation-adapted characters and set
Then, with and ,
Under the inflation homomorphism , the generators satisfy
Consequently,
and
In particular, for every . The rank of is in degree and in each positive degree, and its kernel has dimension in degree .
Proof. Let and , where . Since the quotient map has the section , we have the split extension
We use its Lyndon–Hochschild–Serre spectral sequence to compare the cohomology of with that of the two cyclic groups; for resolutions adapted to group extensions, see [29]. The generator acts on by inversion, which acts trivially on both the degree-one character and the degree-two periodicity generator of . Thus
and
where
The classes come from , while come from . To determine the differentials, we identify these four generators with classes already defined on . The classes and are inflated from and represent and . The restriction of to is the nonzero degree-one character, while the restriction of is the nonzero degree-two periodicity class. Thus represent under the edge maps. All four generators are permanent cycles because they are represented by classes in . Since they generate the -page multiplicatively, every differential vanishes and the spectral sequence collapses at .
The classes generate , since their images generate the associated graded algebra. By Theorem 3.4,
These relations give a surjective homomorphism
The source has Hilbert series
The collapse of the spectral sequence gives the same Hilbert series for , so the surjection is an isomorphism in every degree.
The maps fix and reduce the exponent of modulo . Consequently, the presentation-adapted characters satisfy
The identities and give
Likewise, is inflated from , and naturality together with Lemma 5.1 gives
Under the ring presentations just established, is therefore the homomorphism obtained by setting and identifying the other three generators with their counterparts at level . It follows that its kernel is and its image is the displayed subalgebra. The latter has Hilbert series
so its degree-zero component has dimension 1 and every positive-degree component has dimension 2. Comparison with gives the assertions about ranks and kernel dimensions. □
The continuous ring as the resulting limit
The finite-level calculation separates the two periodicity directions in every cohomological degree. The quotient-side class disappears under the next inflation map, while the subalgebra generated by survives unchanged. The continuous cohomology ring is therefore obtained by retaining precisely this stable part of the finite cohomology.
For finite discrete coefficients,
with transition maps given by inflation; see [13 Proposition 4.18] and the standard treatments of continuous cohomology in [28, 23].
The continuous LHS spectral sequence for
has
The inversion action is trivial on , and , so the spectral sequence is concentrated in columns 0 and 1 and collapses. The continuous Bockstein calculation, as in § 3, gives
A class restricting to the nonzero periodicity class of has nonzero powers in every even degree. The finite-level inflation calculation identifies this class and the resulting ring structure explicitly.
Corollary 5.3. One has
Under the direct-limit identification, is represented by the compatible family , while the classes represent zero in the limit.
Proof. By Proposition 5.2, each finite-level ring has the presentation
and inflation preserves while sending to zero. Thus every class divisible by vanishes at the next level, whereas the subalgebras generated by are identified isomorphically under inflation. Taking the direct limit gives
Here is represented by , and the quotient-side classes vanish in the limit. The asserted continuous cohomology ring follows. □
Remark 5.4. The same continuous LHS argument applies to with and an action of 2-power order. The inversion family considered here additionally provides explicit finite-level representatives and determines the inflation maps in every degree.
An arithmetic consequence
The preceding results apply whenever arithmetic conditions identify a Galois group with one of the metacyclic families considered here. In that situation, the group-theoretic classification determines its degree-one cohomology algebra and its Koszul properties. We illustrate this with the real quadratic fields studied by Chems-Eddin and El Mamry.
Let and let be distinct odd primes satisfying the residue-symbol, unit, and 2-class-number conditions considered by Chems-Eddin and El Mamry [9 Theorem 3.10]. Set , and write for the largest power of 2 dividing the class number of . Let denote the cyclotomic -extension of , and let be its maximal unramified pro-2-extension. We consider the Galois group
Theorem 3.10 of Chems-Eddin and El Mamry identifies the metacyclic structure of this group under the stated arithmetic conditions. In particular, when the quartic-residue symbols satisfy
their result selects a group of Type 1 with in the classification recalled in § 2. This allows us to apply the degree-one cohomology and Koszulity results established above.
Corollary 6.1. Assume the hypotheses of [9 Theorem 3.10], and let be determined by . If
then
and
In particular, this degree-one algebra is PBW, Koszul, universally Koszul, and strongly Koszul.
Proof. By [9 Theorem 3.10], the quartic-residue condition identifies as the Type 1 group with and quotient exponent . The degree-one algebra follows from Theorem 3.4, and its enhanced Koszul properties follow from Corollary 4.2. □
References
References
- [1]B. Aaboun and A. Zekhnini, On the metacyclic 2-groups whose abelianizations are of type (2, 2^n), n ≥ 2, and applications, Research in Number Theory 9 (2023), Paper No. 55. https://doi.org/10.1007/s40999-023-00461-x
- [2]A. Adem and R. J. Milgram, Cohomology of Finite Groups, 2nd ed., Grundlehren der mathematischen Wissenschaften, Vol. 309, Springer, Berlin, 2004. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-662-06280-7
- [3]A. Beilinson, V. Ginzburg, and W. Soergel, Koszul duality patterns in representation theory, Journal of the American Mathematical Society 9 (1996), no. 2, 473–527. https://doi.org/10.1090/S0894-0347-96-00192-0
- [4]D. J. Benson, Representations and Cohomology II: Cohomology of Groups and Modules, Cambridge Studies in Advanced Mathematics, Vol. 31, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, 1991. https://doi.org/10.1017/CBO9780511623622
- [5]G. M. Bergman, The diamond lemma for ring theory, Advances in Mathematics 29 (1978), no. 2, 178–218. https://doi.org/10.1016/0001-8708(78)90010-5
- [6]K. S. Brown, Cohomology of Groups, Graduate Texts in Mathematics, Vol. 87, Springer-Verlag, New York, 1982. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-1-4684-9327-6
- [7]A. Cassella and C. Quadrelli, Right-angled Artin groups and enhanced Koszul properties, Journal of Group Theory 24 (2021), no. 1, 17–38. https://doi.org/10.1515/jgth-2020-0049
- [8]S. K. Chebolu, J. Minač, C. Okay, A. Schultz, C. Ure, and D. Benson, The Bloch–Kato conjecture, decomposing fields, and generating cohomology in degree one, Journal of Number Theory 286 (2026), 301–341. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jnt.2026.02.007
- [9]M. M. Chems-Eddin and H. El Mamry, On the existence of the maximal unramified pro-2-extension over the cyclotomic Z₂-extension with prescribed metacyclic Galois group, The Ramanujan Journal 70 (2026), Article 17. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11139-026-01381-x
- [10]A. Conca, Universally Koszul algebras, Mathematische Annalen 317 (2000), no. 2, 329–346. https://doi.org/10.1007/s002080000100
- [11]A. Conca, E. De Negri, and M. E. Rossi, Koszul algebras and regularity, in Commutative Algebra: Expository Papers Dedicated to David Eisenbud on the Occasion of his 65th Birthday, Springer, New York, 2013, pp. 285–315. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-1-4614-5292-8_8
- [12]T. Diethelm, The mod-p cohomology rings of the nonabelian split metacyclic p-groups, Archiv der Mathematik 44 (1985), no. 1, 29–38. https://doi.org/10.1007/BF019378
- [13]D. Harari, Galois Cohomology and Class Field Theory, Universitext, Springer, 2020. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-030-43901-9
- [14]J. Herzog, T. Hibi, and G. Restuccia, Strongly Koszul algebras, Mathematica Scandinavica 86 (2000), no. 2, 161–178. https://doi.org/10.7146/math.scand.a-14287
- [15]G. Hochschild and J.-P. Serre, Cohomology of group extensions, Transactions of the American Mathematical Society 74 (1953), no. 1, 110–134. https://doi.org/10.1090/S0002-9947-1953-0052438-8
- [16]J. Huebschmann, Automorphisms of group extensions and differentials in the Lyndon–Hochschild–Serre spectral sequence, Journal of Algebra 72 (1981), no. 2, 296–334. https://doi.org/10.1016/0021-8693(81)90296-9
- [17]J. Huebschmann, The mod-p cohomology rings of metacyclic groups, Journal of Pure and Applied Algebra 60 (1989), no. 1, 53–103. https://doi.org/10.1016/0022-4049(89)90107-2
- [18]N. K. Iyudu, Representation spaces of the Jordan plane, Communications in Algebra 42 (2014), no. 8, 3507–3540. https://doi.org/10.1080/00927872.2013.788184
- [19]R. C. Lyndon, The cohomology theory of group extensions, Duke Mathematical Journal 15 (1948), no. 1, 271–292. https://doi.org/10.1215/S0012-7094-48-01528-2
- [20]J. C. McConnell and J. C. Robson, Noncommutative Noetherian Rings, revised ed., Graduate Studies in Mathematics, Vol. 30, American Mathematical Society, Providence, RI, 2001. https://doi.org/10.1090/gsm/030
- [21]J. Minač, M. Palaisti, F. W. Pasini, and N. D. Tân, Enhanced Koszul properties in Galois cohomology, Research in the Mathematical Sciences 7 (2020), no. 2, Paper No. 10, 34 pp. https://doi.org/10.1007/s40687-020-00208-5
- [22]J. Minač, F. W. Pasini, C. Quadrelli, and N. D. Tân, Koszul algebras and quadratic duals in Galois cohomology, Advances in Mathematics 380 (2021), Article 107569. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.aim.2021.107569
- [23]J. Neukirch, A. Schmidt, and K. Wingberg, Cohomology of Number Fields, 2nd ed., Grundlehren der mathematischen Wissenschaften, Vol. 323, Springer, Berlin, 2008. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-540-37889-1
- [24]A. Polishchuk and L. Positselski, Quadratic Algebras, University Lecture Series, Vol. 37, American Mathematical Society, Providence, RI, 2005. https://doi.org/10.1090/ulect/037
- [25]S. B. Priddy, Koszul resolutions, Transactions of the American Mathematical Society 152 (1970), 39–60. https://doi.org/10.1090/S0002-9947-1970-0265437-8
- [26]C. Quadrelli, Pro-p groups with few relations and universal Koszulity, Mathematica Scandinavica 127 (2021), no. 1, 28–94. https://doi.org/10.7146/math.scand.a-123644
- [27]D. J. Rusin, The mod-2 cohomology of metacyclic 2-groups, Journal of Pure and Applied Algebra 44 (1987), 315–327. https://doi.org/10.1016/0022-4049(87)90035-1
- [28]J.-P. Serre, Galois Cohomology, Springer Monographs in Mathematics, Springer, Berlin, 1997. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-642-59141-9
- [29]C. T. C. Wall, Resolutions for extensions of groups, Proceedings of the Cambridge Philosophical Society 57 (1961), no. 2, 251–255. https://doi.org/10.1017/S0305004100035155