betaFeedback

WorksMathematics

On Wilker-Type Properties

Abstract

Wilker-type properties record how a compact set can be split along a binary open cover, and they are precisely the continuity conditions for the union operation on open lattices, governing the topology of power and function spaces. We give a unified treatment of the four properties \W, \Ww, \Wi and \Win. We prove that \Wi and \Win are hereditary for arbitrary subspaces, whereas \W and \Ww are hereditary only for closed subspaces; all four are preserved by continuous retracts, and \Ww, \Wi, \Win are finitely additive over topological sums. For KC-spaces \Ww and \Wi coincide, and spaces whose compact subspaces are Hausdorff belong to \Win. Using Kovár's compact KC-space M0M_0 and its variant \QQ^{+}, we obtain countably infinite compact KC-spaces in \Wi\setminus\W, showing \Wi is strictly weaker than \W. Conversely, we construct compact T1T_1 spaces whose product fails \Ww, proving the classes \Ww and \Wi are not reflective. We further show Vietoris constructions need not preserve \Wi, and prove that \Ok(M_0)\cong \Ck(M_0,\Sier) is not sober and fails property~SS. Open problems are collected at the end.

Introduction

Power spaces form one of the central objects of domain theory, because they supply semantic models for programming languages endowed with nondeterministic choice [1, 2, 3]. Classically, the upper power space of a space XX is constructed from the nonempty compact saturated subsets of XX, and it is again a domain whenever XX is a continuous domain; the construction is then well behaved both algebraically and order-theoretically. When XX is an arbitrary topological space, however, compact saturated sets no longer retain these properties, and the hypotheses underlying the construction must be identified individually. The hypotheses that prove to be relevant are refinement properties of compact sets with respect to open covers, and they can be formulated without any reference to order theory.

The prototype of such a property is the following question. Let XX be a topological space, let K⊆XK \subseteq X be compact and let U1,U2⊆XU_1,U_2 \subseteq X be open with K⊆U1∪U2K \subseteq U_1 \cup U_2. In what sense can KK be decomposed into two parts L1⊆U1L_1 \subseteq U_1 and L2⊆U2L_2 \subseteq U_2 subject to a prescribed smallness requirement? If the pieces are required to be compact, one speaks of the Wilker property W; if they are only required to be Lindelöf, of the weak Wilker property WwW_{\mathrm{w}}. In both properties the decomposition is effected by subsets of the ambient space. If, in addition, the pieces are required to lie inside KK, one obtains the inner weak Wilker property WiW_{\mathrm{i}} and the inner compact refinement property WinW_{\mathrm{in}}; in that case the requirement K⊆L1∪L2K \subseteq L_1 \cup L_2 forces K=L1∪L2K=L_1\cup L_2, so that the decomposition is a genuine decomposition of KK itself. The terminology goes back to the study of Wilker spaces and of the sobriety of function spaces carried out in [4], where the four properties were introduced and compared for the first time.

The interest in these properties is not merely combinatorial. They are equivalent to continuity statements for the binary union operation on lattices of open sets, namely

μ:OL(X)×OL(X)⟶Ok(X),μ(U,V)=U∪V,\mu:\mathcal{O}_{L}(X)\times\mathcal{O}_{L}(X)\longrightarrow\mathcal{O}_{k}(X),\qquad\mu(U,V)=U\cup V,

where OL(X)\mathcal{O}_{L}(X) and Ok(X)\mathcal{O}_{k}(X) carry the topologies generated by the sets Φ(L)={U∈O(X):L⊆U}\Phi(L)=\{U\in\mathcal{O}(X):L\subseteq U\} for LL Lindelöf and for LL compact respectively. The weak Wilker property is exactly the continuity of μ\mu, and the inner weak Wilker property is exactly the continuity of all the restrictions μK\mu_K obtained by replacing XX with a compact subspace KK [4]. Continuity of such operations is in turn the technical heart of the theory of power spaces [1, 2, 5], and it is also the key to the sobriety of function spaces with the compact-open topology: the property S introduced in [6], which characterizes sobriety of Ck(X,Y)C_k(X,Y) for sober YY under a mild order-theoretic hypothesis, is a closure condition that can only be verified through precisely this kind of refinement argument.

Three groups of questions arising from this circle of ideas remain open, and they constitute the object of the present paper.

  1. Permanence. Which of the four properties are inherited by subspaces, by closed subspaces, by retracts, by topological sums? A property of compact sets that is not inherited by closed subspaces is of limited utility, since closed subspaces arise naturally in the constructions of power spaces.

  1. Separation. Are the four properties distinct? In particular, is Wi\mathrm{W}_{i} strictly weaker than W\mathrm{W}, that is, is there a space in which every compact set can be decomposed into Lindelöf pieces lying inside it, but not into compact pieces? Without such examples the hierarchy collapses and the inner conditions lose their meaning.

  1. Preservation and reflection. Do the properties survive the passage to products, to the power spaces PS(X)\mathrm{P}_{S}(X) and PH(X)\mathrm{P}_{H}(X), and to the function space Ck(X,S)\mathrm{C}_{k}(X,S)? Do they entail sobriety? Questions of this type determine whether the classes W\mathrm{W}, Ww\mathrm{W}_{w}, Wi\mathrm{W}_{i} can serve as a working category of spaces, for instance whether they are reflective in the category of T0T_{0} spaces.

Our answer to the first group is complete for subspaces, retracts and sums. The inner properties Wi\mathrm{W}_{i} and Win\mathrm{W}_{in} are hereditary for arbitrary subspaces, while W\mathrm{W} and Ww\mathrm{W}_{w} are hereditary for closed subspaces only, and we show by example that the latter cannot be improved: there is a locally supercompact space in W∖Wi\mathrm{W}\setminus\mathrm{W}_{i}, so Ww\mathrm{W}_{w} fails to be hereditary for arbitrary subspaces. All four properties are preserved by continuous retracts, and Ww\mathrm{W}_{w}, Wi\mathrm{W}_{i}, Win\mathrm{W}_{in} are finitely additive over topological sums. A useful criterion is that, for KC-spaces, the weak and the inner weak Wilker properties coincide, and that a space all of whose compact subspaces are Hausdorff belongs to Win\mathrm{W}_{in}; both criteria reduce the verification of the inner conditions to compact Hausdorff pieces, where normality is available.

For the second group we use Kovár’s countably infinite compact Fréchet–Urysohn hyperconnected KC-space M0M_{0} [7]. Since M0M_{0} is countable, every subset of it is Lindelöf, which gives Wi\mathrm{W}_{i}; hyperconnectedness together with the KC property forbids a decomposition into two proper closed pieces, which excludes W\mathrm{W}. The same argument applies to the space Q+=Q∪{∞}\mathbb{Q}^{+}=\mathbb{Q}\cup\{\infty\} obtained by adding to Q\mathbb{Q} a point whose neighbourhoods are the complements of compact subsets of Q\mathbb{Q}. Thus Wi\mathrm{W}_{i} is strictly weaker than W\mathrm{W}, and the two properties are separated by countably infinite compact KC-spaces.

The third group presents the principal difficulties, and our results in this direction are predominantly negative. Compactness is not preserved by products in this context, and we exploit this in two ways. First, following the cofinitе modification of compact T1T_{1} spaces [8], we construct compact T1T_{1} spaces PP and QQ, modelled on a grid of cardinality ℵ2\aleph_{2} augmented by two points, such that every subspace of PP and of QQ lies in Win\mathrm{W}_{in}, while P×QP\times Q fails even Ww\mathrm{W}_{w}; the obstruction arises from a cardinality argument showing that no two Lindelöf pieces cover the grid. Since P⊔QP\sqcup Q then belongs to Win\mathrm{W}_{in} but its square does not, the full subcategories determined by Ww\mathrm{W}_{w} and by Wi\mathrm{W}_{i} are not reflective in the category of T0T_{0} spaces. Second, we combine the same grid with a hereditarily compact T1T_{1} topology and with a one-point compactification, and obtain a hereditarily compact T1T_{1} space EE and a compact Hausdorff space YY such that E×Y∈Ww∖WiE\times Y\in\mathrm{W}_{w}\setminus\mathrm{W}_{i}; this shows that the product theorem for Ww\mathrm{W}_{w} is sharp, and that Wi\mathrm{W}_{i} is not preserved by products even when both factors satisfy strong compactness conditions. We also show that the Vietoris constructions do not preserve Wi\mathrm{W}_{i}: the upper Vietoris space PS(Z)\mathrm{P}_{S}(Z) and the lower Vietoris space PH(Z)\mathrm{P}_{H}(Z) of a compact T1T_{1} space Z∈WinZ\in\mathrm{W}_{in} may both fail Ww\mathrm{W}_{w}, and this failure persists over locally compact Hausdorff spaces. Finally, we prove that Ok(M0)≅Ck(M0,S)\mathcal{O}_{k}(M_{0})\cong\mathrm{C}_{k}(M_{0},S) is not sober, and that Ck(M0,S)\mathrm{C}_{k}(M_{0},S) fails property SS; this gives a concrete counterexample in the theory of sobriety of function spaces, and it shows that the sobriety hypothesis in the characterization given in [6] cannot be omitted.

Taken together, the results show that the four Wilker-type properties behave like a genuine hierarchy of topological invariants: they are stable under the constructions that preserve compactness, they collapse over KC-spaces, and they are separated by explicit countable compact examples. The counterexamples indicate that the obstructions are of a cardinality-theoretic rather than of an order-theoretic nature, and this is the point of view adopted throughout.

Preliminaries

We collect in this section the notions and the elementary facts that are used repeatedly in the sequel. For the standard material on topology we refer to Engelking [9], and for domain theory and the theory of continuous lattices to Gierz et al. [2] and Abramsky and Jung [10]. Throughout, a space is a topological space and maps are continuous; we write O(X)\mathcal{O}(X) for the family of all open subsets of XX and cl⁡A\operatorname{cl}A, int⁡A\operatorname{int}A for the closure and the interior of A⊆XA\subseteq X.

Separation, specialization and saturation

Definition 2.1. A space XX is T0T_0 if distinct points have distinct closures, and T1T_1 if every singleton is closed. On a T0T_0 space the specialization order is defined by

x≤y⟺x∈cl⁡{y}.x \leq y \quad\Longleftrightarrow\quad x \in\operatorname{cl}\{y\}.

It is a partial order, and every open set is upward closed with respect to it. A subset A⊆XA \subseteq X is saturated if A=↑AA = \mathord{\uparrow} A, where ↑A={y:∃a∈A, a≤y}\mathord{\uparrow} A = \{y : \exists a \in A,\ a \leq y\}; equivalently, AA is an intersection of open sets. The saturation of an arbitrary subset A⊆XA \subseteq X is

sat⁡A=⋂{U∈O(X):A⊆U},\operatorname{sat} A = \bigcap\{U \in\mathcal{O}(X) : A \subseteq U\},

so that sat⁡A\operatorname{sat} A is the smallest saturated set containing AA.

Thus a subset of a T0T_0 space is saturated exactly when it is an intersection of open sets, and sat⁡A\operatorname{sat} A is saturated for every AA. In a T1T_1 space the specialization order is discrete and all subsets are saturated, so that saturation carries no information; it becomes meaningful only for T0T_0 spaces that are not T1T_1, which is precisely the situation in the study of power spaces.

Definition 2.2. Let XX be a space.

  1. XX is Hausdorff if distinct points have disjoint open neighbourhoods, and normal if disjoint closed sets have disjoint open neighbourhoods.

  2. XX is KC if every compact subset of XX is closed.

  3. XX is hyperconnected if any two nonempty open subsets of XX intersect.

  4. XX is Fréchet–Urysohn if for every A⊆XA \subseteq X and every x∈cl⁡Ax \in\operatorname{cl} A there is a sequence (an)(a_n) in AA converging to $x.

Every Hausdorff space is KC, and every KC space is T1T_1; neither implication reverses. In a hyperconnected space the complement of a proper closed set is a nonempty open set, so the union of two proper closed sets is proper. This remark is used in §3 to exclude the Wilker property.

Compact and Lindelöf subsets

Definition 2.3. A subset KK of a space XX is compact if every cover of KK by open subsets of XX has a finite subcover, and Lindelöf if every such cover has a countable subcover. We write K(X)\mathcal{K}(X) for the family of all nonempty compact subsets of XX and L(X)\mathcal{L}(X) for the family of all nonempty Lindelöf subsets of XX. For A⊆XA \subseteq X we put L(A)={L∈L(X):L⊆A}\mathcal{L}(A) = \{L \in\mathcal{L}(X) : L \subseteq A\} and K(A)={K∈K(X):K⊆A}\mathcal{K}(A) = \{K \in\mathcal{K}(X) : K \subseteq A\}, so that L(A)\mathcal{L}(A) and K(A)\mathcal{K}(A) are the families of nonempty Lindelöf, respectively compact, subsets of the subspace AA.

Compactness and Lindelöfness are intrinsic properties of the subspace KK, but it is convenient to test them with covers by open sets of the ambient space, as in Definition 2.3; the two readings agree. The following permanence facts will be used without further mention.

References

  1. [1]M. B. Smyth, Power domains and predicate transformers: a topological view, in: Automata, Languages and Programming (ICALP 1983), Vol. 154 of Lecture Notes in Computer Science, Springer, Berlin, 1983, pp. 662–675. doi:10.1007/BFb0036946.
  2. [2]G. Gierz, K. H. Hofmann, K. Keimel, J. D. Lawson, M. Mislove, D. S. Scott, Continuous Lattices and Domains, Vol. 93 of Encyclopedia of Mathematics and its Applications, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, 2003. doi:10.1017/CBO9780511542725.DOI
  3. [3]Y. Chen, H. Kou, Z. Lyu, Upper powderomains of quasicontinuous dcpos, Theoretical Computer Science 1006 (2024) 114663. doi:10.1016/j.tcs.2024.114663.DOI
  4. [4]X. Xu, Wilker spaces, function spaces and related topics, preprint (2026).
  5. [5]E. Michael, Topologies on spaces of subsets, Transactions of the American Mathematical Society 71 (1) (1951) 152–182. doi:10.1090/S0002-9947-1951-0420109-4.
  6. [6]X. Xu, Y. Bao, X. Zhang, n function spaces equipped with isbell topology and scott topology, Mathematical Structures in Computer Science 32(8) (2022) 1099–1116. doi:10.1017/S0960129523000014.DOI
  7. [7]M. M. Kovář, On maximality of compact topologies, Dagstuhl Seminar Proceedings 4351 (2005) 1–10. doi:10.1016/j.topol.2003.01.002.
  8. [8]X. Xu, W. Ji, Smyth power space is not always co-sober (2026). doi:10.48550/arXiv.2608.02047.DOI
  9. [9]R. Engelking, General Topology, 2nd Edition, Vol. 6 of Sigma Series in Pure Mathematics, Heldermann Verlag, Berlin, 1989, ISBN 3-88538-006-4. URL https://openlibrary.org/isbn/3885380064
  10. [10]S. Abramsky, A. Jung, Domain theory, in: S. Abramsky, D. M. Gabbay, T. S. E. Maibaum (Eds.), Handbook of Logic in Computer Science, Vol. 3: Semantic Structures, Oxford University Press, Oxford, 1994, pp. 1–168. doi:10.1093/oso/9780198537625.003.0001.DOI
  11. [11]J. R. Isbell, Function spaces and adjoints, Mathematica Scandinavica 36 (1975) 317–339. doi:10.7146/math.scand.a-11581.DOI
  12. [12]P. T. Johnstone, Stone Spaces, Vol. 3 of Cambridge Studies in Advanced Mathematics, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, 1982, ISBN 0-521-33779-8. URL https://openlibrary.org/isbn/0521337798
  13. [13]K. H. Hofmann, J. D. Lawson, The spectral theory of distributive continuous lattices, Transactions of the American Mathematical Society 246 (1978) 285–310. doi:10.1090/S0002-9947-1978-0515540-7.DOI
  14. [14]S. Vickers, Topology via Logic, Vol. 5 of Cambridge Tracts in Theoretical Computer Science, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, 1989, ISBN 0-521-36062-5. URL https://openlibrary.org/isbn/0521360625
  15. [15]X. Xu, Y. Ji, A countable metric space whose hoare power space is not co-sober, preprint (2026). doi:10.48550/arXiv.2610.05868.
  16. [16]X. Jia, A. Jung, H. Li, A note on coherence of dcpos, Topology and its Applications 209 (2016) 235–238. doi:10.1016/j.topol.2016.06.011.DOI

Paper details

vlnc:W_szqn7fq7
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC0-1.0
Usage

views · 0

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Mathematics

ChatGPT (OpenAI)

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents