betaFeedback

WorksPhysics and Astronomy

What crossing symmetry forbids just above c=1c=1

Abstract

What does a unitary two-dimensional conformal field theory look like just above c=1c=1? Using the numerical conformal bootstrap, we study the four-point function of a scalar Virasoro primary ϕϕ such that no primary lighter than ϕϕ appears in its operator product expansion with itself. Slightly above c=1c=1, crossing symmetry excludes the interval 0.17≲Δϕ≲10.17\lesssimΔ_ϕ\lesssim1, although the compact boson realizes every such ΔϕΔ_ϕ at c=1c=1. Combining this exclusion with results from the modular bootstrap, we show that the lightest primary of a compact unitary conformal field theory at c=1.0005c=1.0005 or 1.0011.001 has dimension Δgap<0.17Δ_{\rm gap}<0.17. Further from c=1c=1, the largest excluded central charge at fixed ΔϕΔ_ϕ has two sharp minima near Δϕ=1/2Δ_ϕ=1/2 and 4/74/7. At these values it lies within 2×10−72\times10^{-7} of c=8/7c=8/7, where the Z5\mathbb{Z}_5 parafermion and its charge-conjugation orbifold have scalars of exactly these dimensions.

Introduction

“Everything not forbidden is compulsory.” This popular form of Gell-Mann’s principle1 came to the author’s mind when Simeon Hellerman asked whether there is a compact unitary conformal field theory (CFT) with 1<c<1.0011 < c < 1.001. The author answered yes, Hellerman no. The author’s reason was that nothing in the representation theory of the Virasoro algebra rules out such a theory, which should therefore exist.

Below c=1c = 1, in contrast, representation theory rules out all but a discrete set of theories. Friedan, Qiu and Shenker showed that unitarity allows only the central charges c=1−6/m(m+1)c = 1 - 6/m(m+1), each with finitely many conformal weights [3], so that the unitary theories below c=1c = 1 are built from the minimal models [4, 5]. Above c=1c = 1, every conformal weight h≥0h \ge0 gives a unitary representation.

Yet no compact unitary CFT with 1<c<8/71 < c < 8/7 is known. The known theories closest to c=1c = 1 from above belong to two series whose central charge increases through c=1c = 1, the Zk\mathbb{Z}_k parafermions [6, 7] with c=2(k−1)/(k+2)c = 2(k - 1)/(k + 2) and the N=1\mathcal{N} = 1 superconformal minimal models [8, 9, 10, 11] with c=3/2−12/m(m+2)c = 3/2 - 12/m(m + 2). Both series reach c=1c = 1 at k=m=4k = m = 4, where the theories are orbifolds of the compact boson [12]. The next theories in the two series are the Z5\mathbb{Z}_5 parafermion at c=8/7c = 8/7 and the N=1\mathcal{N} = 1 minimal model with m=5m = 5 at c=81/70c = 81/70. Together with the charge-conjugation orbifold of the Z5\mathbb{Z}_5 parafermion, they are the first known theories above c=1c = 1. A compact unitary CFT with 1<c<8/71 < c < 8/7 could be neither free nor a tensor product of known theories, since no free theory and no tensor product of unitary theories has 1<c<6/51 < c < 6/5. Because representation theory allows such a theory, whether it exists is a question about the remaining consistency conditions, modular invariance and crossing symmetry.

Hellerman himself initiated the modular bootstrap [13], in which one bounds the dimension Δgap\Delta_{\mathrm{gap}} of the lightest primary as a function of cc by modular invariance of the torus partition function. After later improvements [14, 15, 16, 17], the bound at c=1c = 1 is 1/21/2, the gap of the compact boson at the self-dual radius [17]. With an upper bound on the gap alone, however, one cannot show that no theory exists at a given cc, because any theory whose lightest primary lies below the bound is consistent with it. Benjamin, Fitzpatrick, Li and Thaler instead searched directly for modular-invariant partition functions with 1<c<8/71 < c < 8/7 [18]. They found candidate spectra with light scalars at c=1.05c = 1.05–1.131.13, but none with 1<c<1.061 < c < 1.06 and 0.3<Δgap<0.50.3 < \Delta_{\mathrm{gap}} < 0.5. In preliminary work with Langhoff, the same authors also impose integer degeneracies [19] and find that the bound on the gap drops to about 0.20.2 near c=1.01c = 1.01 [20]. Whether their candidates are actual CFTs, however, cannot be decided from the partition function alone.

Four-point functions carry more information than the partition function, since their crossing equation involves the coefficients of the operator product expansion (OPE) as well as the spectrum. Several groups have studied the crossing equation with Virasoro or super-Virasoro blocks numerically [21, 22, 23], and fusion rules have been imposed on the crossing equation with global conformal blocks [24]. At c>1c > 1, Besken bounded the dimension of the first non-trivial primary in the OPE of two identical scalars [25]. Collier, Kravchuk, Lin and Yonnond found numerical evidence that a four-point function of identical scalars whose OPE contains only scalar Virasoro primaries is that of Liouville theory [26], which is not compact. Poland has recently bounded the average exchanged dimension in four-point functions of identical scalars at c=8/7c = 8/7, 81/7081/70 and close to c=1c = 1, imposing only unitarity on the exchanged operators [27]. Several scalars of the known theories at these central charges lie on or near the boundary of his allowed region. These results constrain four-point functions at c>1c > 1, but none of them bounds the dimension of the lightest primary of a compact unitary CFT just above c=1c = 1.

In this paper we apply crossing symmetry to the four-point function of a scalar Virasoro primary ϕ\phi, assuming only that no primary lighter than ϕ\phi appears in the ϕ×ϕ\phi\times\phi OPE. Every compact CFT satisfies this assumption for its lightest primary, which just above c=1c = 1 is a scalar (§ 3). For each central charge cc and each dimension Δϕ\Delta_{\phi}, we ask whether the crossing equation of this four-point function can be satisfied with non-negative squared OPE coefficients. Where it cannot, no unitary CFT has such a primary ϕ\phi, and we call the set of these points (c,Δϕ)(c, \Delta_{\phi}) the excluded region. Using the numerical conformal bootstrap [28, 29], we keep only the derivatives of the crossing equation up to total order Λ\Lambda, so that the excluded region we find can only grow as Λ\Lambda increases. We pay particular attention to sharp features of the region that remains allowed, because in higher dimensions known theories often sit at such features of bootstrap bounds. The three-dimensional Ising model, for instance, sits at a kink of the upper bound on the dimension of its energy operator and at a sharp minimum of the lower bound on its central charge, both viewed as functions of the dimension of its spin field [29, 30]. El-Showk et al. therefore conjectured that it minimizes the central charge among all unitary solutions of crossing symmetry [31].

We first look just above c=1c = 1, where the natural comparison is the compact boson. At c=1c = 1 the dimension of the operator cos⁡(X/R)\cos(X/R) of the boson takes every positive value as the radius RR varies [12, 32]. Since this operator satisfies our assumption for Δϕ≤2\Delta_{\phi} \le2 (§ 2), no Δϕ≤2\Delta_{\phi} \le2 can be excluded at c=1c = 1. Just above c=1c = 1, in contrast, we find that crossing symmetry excludes the whole interval 0.17≲Δϕ≲10.17 \lesssim\Delta_{\phi} \lesssim1 (Figure 1). As we increase Λ\Lambda, the excluded interval extends closer to c=1c = 1 (§ 3).

Figure 1. (a) Excluded region (shaded) at Λ=19\Lambda= 19, with Δϕ\Delta_\phi on the horizontal axis. Its upper boundary is cmin⁡(Δϕ)c_{\min}(\Delta_\phi). Crosses and dots: excluded and allowed points at Λ=19\Lambda= 19. They include points excluded at a lower Λ\Lambda and points allowed at a higher Λ\Lambda, since the excluded region can only grow with Λ\Lambda. Curves: boundary of the allowed region from bisection at Λ=11\Lambda= 11 (dashed), 19 (solid), 23 and 27 (thick). Green line: c=1c = 1, where the compact boson has, as its radius varies, a scalar primary of every dimension Δϕ≤2\Delta_\phi\le2 that satisfies (2). Squares, diamonds and stars: scalar primaries that satisfy (2) by their fusion rules in the known theories with 1<c<6/51 < c < 6/5, namely the Z5\mathbb{Z}_5 parafermion and WB2(5,7)\mathrm{WB}_2(5,7) at c=8/7c = 8/7 and the N=1\mathcal{N} = 1 minimal model with m=5m = 5 at c=81/70c = 81/70. Question marks: lightest scalars of the candidate spectra of Benjamin, Fitzpatrick, Li and Thaler at c=1.05c = 1.05–1.131.13 [18]. (b) Enlargement of the dashed box in (a), with labels for the energy operator ϵ1\epsilon_1 of the Z5\mathbb{Z}_5 parafermion, the twist field τ\tau of WB2(5,7)\mathrm{WB}_2(5,7), and the field Φ13\Phi_{13} of the N=1\mathcal{N} = 1 minimal model.

Combining the excluded interval with results from the modular bootstrap, we obtain an upper bound on the gap. Modular invariance implies that the lightest primary of a compact unitary CFT just above c=1c = 1 is a scalar with dimension below about 1/21/2 [17]. Since the excluded interval extends well above 1/21/2, this scalar must lie below it. We therefore find Δgap<0.17\Delta_{\mathrm{gap}} < 0.17 at c=1.0005c = 1.0005 and at c=1.001c = 1.001, the upper end of Hellerman’s range. This bound is a third of the largest gap possible at c=1c = 1 and lower than the modular bound with integer degeneracies, whose minimum is about 0.20.2 [20]. Our bound weakens as cc increases, but at each central charge we computed up to c=1.10c = 1.10 (Table 1) it remains below 0.30.3, so that a gap in the range 0.3<Δgap<0.50.3 < \Delta_{\mathrm{gap}} < 0.5 is impossible there. In this range of the gap, Benjamin, Fitzpatrick, Li and Thaler found no candidates for c<1.06c < 1.06, and they suggested that a stronger bound on the gap might explain why. The candidates they did find have scalars lighter than our bound. We tested three of them directly, taking ϕ\phi to be the lightest scalar of a candidate and allowing in ϕ×ϕ\phi\times\phi only the operators of that candidate. All three are consistent with the crossing equation, one of them only if some of its dimensions, which are known only numerically, lie outside their quoted uncertainties (§ 3).

ccΛ=11\Lambda= 11Λ=19\Lambda= 19Λ=23\Lambda= 23Λ=27\Lambda= 27
lowerupperlowerupperlowerupperlowerupper
1.00050.2290.7570.1660.9990.1631.0150.159>1.037> 1.037
1.0010.2290.7570.1680.9990.1621.0110.1591.059
1.010.2210.7520.1770.9740.1740.9800.1740.985
1.050.2530.7330.2230.8830.2210.8860.2200.890
1.100.3140.6610.2810.7930.2680.7970.2650.805
1.140.3890.5760.3340.7140.3120.7200.3050.723
1.0001excluded: 0.5, 0.7excluded: 0.25, 0.5
1.00001allowed: 0.3, 0.45, 0.7excluded: 0.45, allowed: 0.9

Table 1. Endpoints of the excluded interval, DΛ(c)<Δϕ<UΛ(c)D_\Lambda(c) < \Delta_\phi< U_\Lambda(c), determined by bisection to ±0.002\pm0.002 (±0.004\pm0.004 for the upper endpoint at c=1.14c = 1.14, Λ=19\Lambda= 19). An entry >x> x means that Δϕ=x\Delta_\phi= x is excluded and that we did not determine the endpoint. Between the lower endpoint and the modular bound Δmod(c)\Delta_{\mathrm{mod}}(c) defined in the text, every Δϕ\Delta_\phi we computed is excluded, on grids of spacing at most 0.07. For the bound (5) we use the lowest points excluded at Λ=19\Lambda= 19, Δϕ=0.1668\Delta_\phi= 0.1668 at c=1.0005c = 1.0005 and 0.1687 at c=1.001c = 1.001. At c=1.0001c = 1.0001 and 1.00001 we computed only the single points listed in the last two rows.

Further from c=1c = 1, scalars of the two known theories at c=8/7c = 8/7 lie on the boundary of the excluded region. As cc increases, the excluded interval shrinks and disappears at c≈1.16c \approx1.16. At fixed Δϕ\Delta_{\phi} the excluded region therefore ends at a central charge cmin⁡(Δϕ)c_{\min}(\Delta_{\phi}), above which the point (c,Δϕ)(c, \Delta_{\phi}) is allowed. As a function of Δϕ\Delta_{\phi}, cmin⁡c_{\min} is the upper boundary of the shaded region in Figure 1. Below this boundary, every point that we computed is excluded at Λ=19\Lambda= 19, except in a narrow range of cc just above 11, which shrinks as Λ\Lambda increases (§ 3). Outside this range, cmin⁡(Δϕ)c_{\min}(\Delta_{\phi}) is therefore a lower bound on the central charge of any unitary CFT with c>1c > 1 that has a primary ϕ\phi of dimension Δϕ\Delta_{\phi} satisfying our assumption. Near the top of the shaded region, cmin⁡(Δϕ)c_{\min}(\Delta_{\phi}) has two sharp local minima, close to Δϕ=1/2\Delta_{\phi} = 1/2 and 4/74/7. These two values are exactly the dimensions of scalars in the two theories at c=8/7c = 8/7. The Z5\mathbb{Z}_5 parafermion has an energy operator with Δ=4/7\Delta= 4/7, and its charge-conjugation orbifold, the W(2,4)W(2,4) minimal model WB2(5,7)\mathrm{WB}_2(5,7), has a twist field with Δ=1/2\Delta= 1/2. As we increase Λ\Lambda, cmin⁡c_{\min} at these two values of Δϕ\Delta_{\phi} approaches 8/78/7, and at the highest order we use, it lies within 2×10−72 \times10^{-7} of 8/78/7. In this sense, the two theories at c=8/7c = 8/7 minimize the central charge at fixed Δϕ\Delta_{\phi}, as the three-dimensional Ising model is conjectured to do. We obtain these minima using only Virasoro symmetry, crossing symmetry, unitarity and our assumption on ϕ\phi. Crossing symmetry also gives an upper bound on the dimension of the lightest scalar in ϕ×ϕ\phi\times\phi heavier than ϕ\phi. Both theories saturate this bound as well. At the bound, the crossing equation truncated to derivatives of order at most Λ\Lambda has a unique solution, and the dimensions in this solution agree with those of Virasoro primaries in ϕ×ϕ\phi\times\phi of the two theories (§ 4).

The other scalars of the three known theories that satisfy our assumption all lie inside the allowed region (Figure 1). Among them, the field Φ13\Phi_{13} of the N=1\mathcal{N} = 1 minimal model at c=81/70c = 81/70 lies just above the boundary, next to a short plateau of cmin⁡c_{\min} (§ 5).

Just above c=1c = 1, the region of light scalars, Δϕ≲0.17\Delta_{\phi} \lesssim0.17, remains allowed, but no theory is known there. Whether it contains one is what remains of Hellerman’s question.

Setup

We consider the four-point function of a real scalar Virasoro primary ϕ\phi with conformal weights hϕ=hˉϕ=Δϕ/2h_{\phi} = \bar{h}_{\phi} = \Delta_{\phi}/2 in a unitary CFT with c>1c > 1,

⟨ϕ(0)ϕ(z,zˉ)ϕ(1)ϕ(∞)⟩=∑OλϕϕO2FhO(z)FhˉO(zˉ).(1)\langle\phi(0)\phi(z,\bar{z})\phi(1)\phi(\infty)\rangle= \sum_{\mathcal{O}} \lambda_{\phi\phi\mathcal{O}}^{2} \mathcal{F}_{h_{\mathcal{O}}}(z)\mathcal{F}_{\bar{h}_{\mathcal{O}}}(\bar{z}). \tag*{(1)}

Here the sum runs over the Virasoro primaries O∈ϕ×ϕ\mathcal{O} \in\phi\times\phi, with conformal weights (hO,hˉO)(h_{\mathcal{O}}, \bar{h}_{\mathcal{O}}), scaling dimension ΔO=hO+hˉO\Delta_{\mathcal{O}} = h_{\mathcal{O}} + \bar{h}_{\mathcal{O}} and spin ℓO=∣hO−hˉO∣\ell_{\mathcal{O}} = \lvert h_{\mathcal{O}} - \bar{h}_{\mathcal{O}}\rvert, and Fh\mathcal{F}_h are the Virasoro blocks [33, 34] at central charge cc. We take all CFTs to be bosonic, so that all spins are integers. Apart from this, our only assumption about the spectrum is

ΔO≥max⁡(Δϕ,ℓO)for every primary O≠1 in ϕ×ϕ,(2)\Delta_{\mathcal{O}} \ge\max(\Delta_{\phi}, \ell_{\mathcal{O}}) \quad\text{for every primary } \mathcal{O} \ne1 \text{ in } \phi\times\phi, \tag*{(2)}

that is, no primary lighter than ϕ\phi appears in the OPE ϕ×ϕ\phi\times\phi (the condition Δ≥ℓ\Delta\ge\ell is the unitarity bound). In a compact CFT the lightest primary satisfies (2) automatically, and heavier primaries can satisfy it as well. In the compact boson, for instance, cos⁡(X/R)×cos⁡(X/R)\cos(X/R) \times\cos(X/R) contains, besides the identity, only cos⁡(2X/R)\cos(2X/R), with Δ=4Δϕ\Delta= 4\Delta_{\phi}, and other Virasoro primaries with Δ≥2\Delta\ge2, the lightest of which is ∂X∂ˉXˉ\partial X\bar{\partial}\bar{X}. The operator cos⁡(X/R)\cos(X/R) therefore satisfies (2) whenever Δϕ≤2\Delta_{\phi} \le2.

Exchanging the operators at 0 and 1 maps zz to 1−z1-z, so that crossing symmetry requires

∑OλϕϕO2FhO,hˉO(z,zˉ)=0,Fh,hˉ(z,zˉ)=Fh(z)Fhˉ(zˉ)−Fh(1−z)Fhˉ(1−zˉ),(3)\sum_{\mathcal{O}} \lambda_{\phi\phi\mathcal{O}}^{2} \mathcal{F}_{h_{\mathcal{O}},\bar{h}_{\mathcal{O}}}(z,\bar{z}) = 0, \qquad\mathcal{F}_{h,\bar{h}}(z,\bar{z}) = \mathcal{F}_{h}(z)\mathcal{F}_{\bar{h}}(\bar{z}) - \mathcal{F}_{h}(1-z)\mathcal{F}_{\bar{h}}(1-\bar{z}), \tag*{(3)}

where the identity contributes F0,0\mathcal{F}_{0,0} with unit coefficient for a unit-normalized ϕ\phi. 2 In a unitary CFT the coefficients λϕϕO2\lambda_{\phi\phi\mathcal{O}}^{2} are non-negative, so that (3) says that a sum of the functions Fh,hˉ\mathcal{F}_{h,\bar{h}} with non-negative coefficients cancels the contribution of the identity. To show that this is impossible at a point (c,Δϕ)(c,\Delta_{\phi}), we look for a linear functional α\alpha on the derivatives ∂zm∂zˉn\partial_z^m \partial_{\bar{z}}^n of (3) at z=zˉ=1/2z = \bar{z} = 1/2 with m+n≤Λm+n \le\Lambda such that

α[F0,0]>0,α[Fh,hˉ+Fhˉ,h]≥0for every (h,hˉ) allowed by (2).(4)\alpha[\mathcal{F}_{0,0}] > 0, \qquad\alpha[\mathcal{F}_{h,\bar{h}} + \mathcal{F}_{\bar{h},h}] \ge0 \quad\text{for every } (h,\bar{h}) \text{ allowed by (2)}. \tag*{(4)}

Here we have combined (h,hˉ)(h,\bar{h}) with (hˉ,h)(\bar{h},h), which appear in (3) with equal coefficients.3 If such a functional exists, applying it to (3) gives a contradiction, because the left-hand side becomes positive. No unitary CFT then has a primary ϕ\phi with these values of cc and Δϕ\Delta_\phi that satisfies (2). A functional that excludes a point at order Λ\Lambda also excludes it at every higher order, so that the excluded region can only grow with Λ\Lambda. We search for these functionals with the semidefinite program solver SDPB [39, 40], as described in Appendix § 8. We first map the (c,Δϕ)(c,\Delta_\phi) plane at Λ=11\Lambda= 11 and 19, and we then determine the parts of the boundary of the excluded region discussed below by bisection up to Λ=31\Lambda= 31.

Just above c=1c = 1

Close to c=1c = 1, the excluded region at fixed cc is an interval DΛ(c)<Δϕ<UΛ(c)D_\Lambda(c) < \Delta_\phi< U_\Lambda(c). We determine its endpoints by bisection (Table 1), and every point that we computed between them is excluded.

At Λ=19\Lambda= 19 the excluded interval hardly changes as cc decreases towards 1, and it is present even at c=1.0001c = 1.0001. How close to c=1c = 1 it extends, however, depends on Λ\Lambda. At c=1.00001c = 1.00001, every point we computed at Λ=11\Lambda= 11 is allowed, whereas at Λ=19\Lambda= 19 the point Δϕ=0.45\Delta_\phi= 0.45 is still excluded. The upper endpoint also grows with Λ\Lambda. At c=1.001c = 1.001, U19=0.999U_{19} = 0.999, whereas U23=1.011U_{23} = 1.011, so that the excluded interval extends beyond Δϕ=1\Delta_\phi= 1.

We now combine the excluded interval with results from the modular bootstrap. Modular invariance implies an upper bound Δmod(c)\Delta_{\mathrm{mod}}(c) on the dimension of the lightest primary. This bound rises from $1/2$ at c=1c = 1 but stays below 0.525 up to $c = 1.14 {citep}[17]. The lightest primary therefore has $\Delta < 1$, and since spins in a bosonic CFT are integers that cannot exceed the dimension, it is a scalar. As the lightest primary of the theory, it satisfies {xref}(2)` (for a complex primary, its real part does), so that its dimension cannot lie inside the excluded interval. Nor can it lie above the excluded interval, because Δmod(c)<U19(c)\Delta_{\mathrm{mod}}(c) < U_{19}(c). Hence

Δgap<DΛ(c)(5)\Delta_{\mathrm{gap}} < D_\Lambda(c) \tag*{(5)}

in any compact, unitary, bosonic CFT, at each value of cc from 1.0005 to 1.14 in Table 1. For this conclusion we need the whole range between DΛ(c)D_\Lambda(c) and Δmod(c)\Delta_{\mathrm{mod}}(c) to be excluded, which we checked on grids of points at each of these values of $c {xref}Table 1. At $c = 1.0005$ and 1.001, the lowest points whose exclusion at $\Lambda = 19$ we verified independently ({xref}Appendix A) are $\Delta_\phi = 0.1668$ and 0.1687, so that $\Delta_{\mathrm{gap}} < 0.167$ and 0.169, respectively. These bounds improve at higher derivative order, since the lower endpoint decreases as $\Lambda$ increases ({xref}Table 1`).

The bound (5) is of no use for the candidate spectra of Benjamin, Fitzpatrick, Li and Thaler at c=1.05c = 1.05–1.13 [18], because their lightest scalars, with dimensions between 0.059 and 0.089, lie well below the excluded interval (Figure 1a). Instead, we tested the spectra themselves. Taking ϕ\phi to be the lightest scalar of a candidate, we allowed in ϕ×ϕ\phi\times\phi only the operators of that candidate, each in a small interval around its quoted dimension (Appendix § 8). We did this for the candidates at c=1.05c = 1.05, 1.09 and 1.13. The other two, at c=1.07c = 1.07 and 1.11, have several low-lying dimensions that are uncertain by order one, so that this procedure would hardly constrain them. To check that the procedure can exclude a wrong spectrum, we applied it to the tensor product of the tricritical Ising model and the Ising model, with ϕ\phi the energy operator of the tricritical Ising model. The actual spectrum of ϕ×ϕ\phi\times\phi in this theory is allowed at Λ=11\Lambda= 11 and 1919, whereas the same spectrum with one scalar moved by 0.10.1 is excluded. All three candidates are consistent with crossing symmetry, but the one at c=1.05c = 1.05 is consistent at Λ=19\Lambda= 19 only if some of its dimensions lie outside their quoted uncertainties.

Two theories at c=8/7c=8/7

In this section we show that the two minima of cmin⁡c_{\min} near Δϕ=1/2\Delta_\phi= 1/2 and 4/74/7 (Figure 1b) correspond to the two known theories at c=8/7c = 8/7. Evaluated at exactly these two values, cmin⁡c_{\min} approaches c=8/7c = 8/7 from below as Λ\Lambda increases, and at Λ=31\Lambda= 31 it lies within 2×10−72 \times10^{-7} of 8/78/7 (Figure 2). Since the two theories exist, the point c=8/7c = 8/7 can never be excluded at these two values of Δϕ\Delta_\phi.

Figure 2. Distance of cmin⁡(1/2)c_{\min}(1/2) and cmin⁡(4/7)c_{\min}(4/7) from 8/78/7 as a function of the derivative order Λ\Lambda. We determine cmin⁡c_{\min} by bisection in cc. Since c=8/7c = 8/7 itself is allowed, a bisection in which every value of cc that we tested below 8/78/7 is excluded tells us only that cmin⁡c_{\min} lies between the largest excluded value and 8/78/7. The corresponding point is then an upper limit (arrow).

The minimum at Δϕ=4/7\Delta_\phi= 4/7 corresponds to the Z5\mathbb{Z}_5 parafermion. In the description of the Zk\mathbb{Z}_k parafermion as the coset SU⁡(2)k/U⁡(1)\operatorname{SU}(2)_k/\operatorname{U}(1), the energy operators ϵj\epsilon_j carry SU⁡(2)\operatorname{SU}(2) spin jj and no U⁡(1)\operatorname{U}(1) charge, and they have h=hˉ=j(j+1)/(k+2)h = \bar{h} = j(j + 1)/(k + 2) [6]. For k=5k = 5, the operator ϵ1\epsilon_1 therefore has Δ=4/7\Delta= 4/7, and ϵ2\epsilon_2 has Δ=12/7\Delta= 12/7. Although ϵ1\epsilon_1 is not the lightest primary of the theory (the spin field σ1\sigma_1 has Δ=4/35\Delta= 4/35), it satisfies (2). Since ϵ1\epsilon_1 carries no Z5\mathbb{Z}_5 charge, the fusion rules allow in ϵ1×ϵ1\epsilon_1 \times\epsilon_1 only neutral primaries from the representations of the parafermion algebra built on the identity, on ϵ1\epsilon_1 and on ϵ2\epsilon_2. All of them except the identity have Δ≥4/7\Delta\ge4/7. Moreover, the coefficient of ϵ1\epsilon_1 itself vanishes, since it contains the SU⁡(2)\operatorname{SU}(2) 3j3j symbol (111000)=0\begin{pmatrix} 1 & 1 & 1 \\ 0 & 0 & 0 \end{pmatrix} = 0 as a factor, so that the OPE ϵ1×ϵ1=1+ϵ2+…\epsilon_1 \times\epsilon_1 = 1 + \epsilon_2 + \ldots starts with ϵ2\epsilon_2. Because assumption (2) allows ϵ1\epsilon_1 in its own OPE, the minimum at Δϕ=4/7\Delta_\phi= 4/7 appears without this selection rule as input.

The minimum at Δϕ=1/2\Delta_\phi= 1/2 corresponds to the charge-conjugation orbifold of the Z5\mathbb{Z}_5 parafermion, the minimal model WB2(5,7)\mathrm{WB}_2(5, 7) of the W(2,4)\mathrm{W}(2, 4) algebra [41, 42, 43, 44]. Its twisted sector contains a field τ\tau with h=hˉ=1/4h = \bar{h} = 1/4 [43]. Like ϵ1\epsilon_1, the field τ\tau is not the lightest primary of its theory, since the twisted sector also contains fields with Δ=1/14\Delta= 1/14 and 3/143/14. To see that τ\tau nevertheless satisfies (2), we computed the fusion rules of the orbifold from its modular SS-matrix with the Verlinde formula [45]. In terms of representations of the W(2,4)\mathrm{W}(2, 4) algebra, they give τ×τ=1+[ψ1ψˉ1]+[ψ2ψˉ2]\tau\times\tau= 1 + [\psi_1\bar{\psi}_1] + [\psi_2\bar{\psi}_2]. Here 11 denotes the vacuum representation, which contains the currents of the algebra, and [ψjψˉj][\psi_j\bar{\psi}_j] the representation built on the charge-conjugation-invariant combination of ψjψˉj\psi_j\bar{\psi}_j and its conjugate, where ψj\psi_j are the parafermion currents with h=j(5−j)/5h = j(5-j)/5. The lightest Virasoro primary in τ×τ\tau\times\tau other than the identity therefore has Δ=8/5\Delta= 8/5, well above Δτ=1/2\Delta_\tau= 1/2.

Besides lying at the minima of cmin⁡c_{\min}, both theories saturate a second bound. At a point (c,Δϕ)(c,\Delta_\phi), we require every scalar in ϕ×ϕ\phi\times\phi other than the identity to have Δ≥g\Delta\ge g, and we raise gg until the point is excluded. Since g>Δϕg > \Delta_\phi, this requirement also removes ϕ\phi itself from ϕ×ϕ\phi\times\phi. For τ\tau, the removal agrees with the fusion rules of the orbifold, which exclude τ\tau from τ×τ\tau\times\tau. For ϵ1\epsilon_1, we nevertheless allow ϵ1\epsilon_1 itself in its own OPE, because the fusion rules of the parafermion algebra permit it and we do not impose the selection rule that sets its coefficient to zero. The largest gg for which the point is still allowed is an upper bound Δ⋆\Delta_\star on the dimension of the lightest scalar in ϕ×ϕ\phi\times\phi heavier than ϕ\phi. At c=8/7c = 8/7, this bound agrees with the exact dimension of that scalar in the two theories, 8/58/5 for τ\tau at Δϕ=1/2\Delta_\phi= 1/2 and 12/712/7 for ϵ1\epsilon_1 at Δϕ=4/7\Delta_\phi= 4/7, to within 10−310^{-3} (Table 2). At such a bound, the truncated crossing equation has a unique solution, and the zeros of the extremal functional, that is, of the functional (4) at the bound, are the dimensions in this solution [46]. Here the zeros lie within 3×10−33 \times10^{-3} of the dimensions of Virasoro primaries of the two theories (Table 2). The converse does not hold, because the functional has no zero at the spin-4 current of the W(2,4)W(2,4) algebra, which appears in τ×τ\tau\times\tau.

τ\tau in WB2(5,7)\mathrm{WB}_2(5,7), Δϕ=1/2\Delta_\phi= 1/2ϵ1\epsilon_1 in Z5\mathbb{Z}_5, Δϕ=4/7\Delta_\phi= 4/7
Δ⋆\Delta_\star at c=8/7c = 8/7 (Λ=11\Lambda= 11 and 1919)1.600<Δ⋆<1.6011.600 < \Delta_\star< 1.6011.714<Δ⋆<1.7151.714 < \Delta_\star< 1.715
exact8/58/5 (ψ1ψˉ1\psi_1\bar{\psi}_1)12/7=1.714312/7 = 1.7143 (ϵ2\epsilon_2)
Λ=19\Lambda= 19 zeros, ℓ=0\ell= 02.40122.4012 [12/5], 6.40186.4018 [32/5], 8.00198.0019 [8]2.57232.5723 [18/7], 6.57396.5739 [46/7], 8.00238.0023 [8]
ℓ=2\ell= 24.40004.4000 [22/5]4.57144.5714 [32/7], 8.57328.5732 [60/7]
ℓ=4\ell= 45.60005.6000 [28/5]5.71435.7143 [40/7], 6.57146.5714 [46/7]
ℓ=6\ell= 67.60017.6001 [38/5]8.57168.5716 [60/7]
ℓ=8\ell= 88.00008.0000 [8], 9.59999.5999 [48/5]8.00008.0000 [8], 9.71459.7145 [68/7]

Table 2. The theories at the two minima of cmin⁡c_{\min}. Top: the upper bound Δ⋆\Delta_\star on the scaling dimension of the lightest scalar primary in ϕ×ϕ\phi\times\phi heavier than ϕ\phi, and the exact dimension of this scalar. Bottom: zeros of the extremal functional with Δ<10\Delta< 10 at the bound at Λ=19\Lambda= 19 (spins ℓ≤8\ell\le8), with the dimensions of the corresponding Virasoro primaries of the exact theory in brackets. For ϵ1\epsilon_1 we computed the bound with ϵ1\epsilon_1 itself included in the spectrum of ϕ×ϕ\phi\times\phi, as explained in the text. At Λ=11\Lambda= 11 the bound is the same when ϵ1\epsilon_1 is left out, so that the saturation does not rely on the selection rule.

The N=1N = 1 minimal model

The third known theory above c=1c = 1 is the N=1N = 1 minimal model with m=5m = 5, at c=81/70c = 81/70. Its Neveu–Schwarz superconformal primaries Φr,s\Phi_{r,s} have h=hˉ=((7r−5s)2−4)/280h = \bar{h} = ((7r - 5s)^2 - 4)/280, so that Φ13\Phi_{13} has Δ=3/7\Delta= 3/7. To decide whether Φ13\Phi_{13} satisfies (2), we need the Virasoro primaries in Φ13×Φ13\Phi_{13} \times\Phi_{13}, since our crossing equation is written in terms of Virasoro blocks. The superconformal family of each Φr,s\Phi_{r,s} contains several Virasoro primaries: Φr,s\Phi_{r,s} itself, the top component G−1/2Gˉ−1/2Φr,sG_{-1/2}\bar{G}_{-1/2}\Phi_{r,s}, whose dimension is larger by one, and further Virasoro primaries of higher dimension. The OPE Φ13×Φ13\Phi_{13} \times\Phi_{13} contains Virasoro primaries from the superconformal families of the identity, of Φ13\Phi_{13} and of Φ15\Phi_{15}. From the superconformal family of Φ13\Phi_{13}, however, only the top component and the Virasoro primaries above it appear, and Φ13\Phi_{13} itself does not [47]. The lightest Virasoro primary in Φ13×Φ13\Phi_{13} \times\Phi_{13} other than the identity is therefore the top component of Φ13\Phi_{13}, with Δ=10/7\Delta= 10/7, followed by Φ15\Phi_{15} with Δ=16/7\Delta= 16/7, so that Φ13\Phi_{13} satisfies (2).

Like the two theories at c=8/7c = 8/7, this model saturates the upper bound Δ∗\Delta_* on the dimension of the lightest scalar in ϕ×ϕ\phi\times\phi heavier than ϕ\phi. Since Φ13\Phi_{13} does not appear in its own OPE, we compute this bound without it. At (c,Δϕ)=(81/70,3/7)(c, \Delta_{\phi}) = (81/70, 3/7), the bound lies within 5×10−45 \times10^{-4} of 10/710/7, the dimension of the top component. Unlike τ\tau and ϵ1\epsilon_1, however, Φ13\Phi_{13} does not lie on the boundary cmin⁡c_{\min} but just above it. Just below this point, cmin⁡c_{\min} has a short plateau that does not move between Λ=19\Lambda= 19 and 2727 (Figure 1b).

On the plateau, the solution of the crossing equation, which we read off from the zeros of the extremal functional, is nevertheless close to the OPE Φ13×Φ13\Phi_{13} \times\Phi_{13} of the N=1\mathcal{N} = 1 minimal model. In this OPE, apart from the conserved currents in the superconformal family of the identity, the Virasoro primaries of the two lowest twists Δ−ℓ\Delta- \ell belong to the superconformal families of Φ13\Phi_{13}, at twist 10/710/7, and of Φ15\Phi_{15}, at twist 16/716/7. On the plateau, the zeros lie at the same two twists, each shifted by about 10−310^{-3}, and at the same spins, except at ℓ=6\ell= 6 (Table 3). The solution on the plateau thus has the structure of the OPE Φ13×Φ13\Phi_{13} \times\Phi_{13}, although no N=1\mathcal{N} = 1 minimal model exists at its central charge.

ℓ\ell\multicolumn{2}{c}{twist ≈10/7\approx10/7}\multicolumn{2}{c}{twist ≈16/7\approx16/7}
plateau, Λ=27\Lambda= 27N=1\mathcal{N} = 1plateau, Λ=27\Lambda= 27N=1\mathcal{N} = 1
001.429911.4299110/7=1.4285710/7 = 1.428572.284352.2843516/7=2.2857116/7 = 2.28571
223.429923.4299224/7=3.4285724/7 = 3.428574.284344.2843430/7=4.2857130/7 = 4.28571
445.429925.4299238/7=5.4285738/7 = 5.42857——
66—52/7=7.4285752/7 = 7.428578.284708.2847058/7=8.2857158/7 = 8.28571
889.429909.4299066/7=9.4285766/7 = 9.4285710.2843210.2843272/7=10.2857172/7 = 10.28571

Table 3. Zeros of the extremal functional with spin ℓ≤8\ell\le8 on the plateau of cmin⁡c_{\min} at (c,Δϕ)=(1.15604,3/7)(c, \Delta_{\phi}) = (1.15604, 3/7), compared with the Virasoro primaries of twist 10/710/7 and 16/716/7 in Φ13×Φ13\Phi_{13} \times\Phi_{13} of the N=1\mathcal{N} = 1 minimal model (c=81/70)(c = 81/70), which belong to the superconformal families of Φ13\Phi_{13} and Φ15\Phi_{15}, respectively. A dash means that there is no such operator. In particular, neither spectrum has an operator of twist 16/716/7 at ℓ=4\ell= 4. At ℓ=6\ell= 6 the functional has no zero near Δ=52/7\Delta= 52/7, the dimension of the operator of twist 10/710/7 in the N=1\mathcal{N} = 1 minimal model. Its squared OPE coefficient, which we computed from the N=1\mathcal{N} = 1 superconformal Ward identities, is tiny, 2.7×10−102.7 \times10^{-10}. That of the operator of twist 16/716/7 at the same spin, 8.2×10−108.2 \times10^{-10}, is comparable, however, and this operator does have a zero. Further zeros with Δ<10\Delta< 10 lie at Δ=4\Delta= 4 (ℓ=4\ell= 4) and 88 (ℓ=8\ell= 8), where the N=1\mathcal{N} = 1 minimal model has conserved currents, at Δ=6.283\Delta= 6.283 and 8.0008.000 for ℓ=0\ell= 0 (exact: 44/7=6.285744/7 = 6.2857 and 88), and at Δ=7.426\Delta= 7.426 for ℓ=2\ell= 2 (exact: 52/7=7.428652/7 = 7.4286). The zeros at Δ=5.405\Delta= 5.405 (ℓ=0\ell= 0), 5.9625.962 and 9.9489.948 (ℓ=2\ell= 2), 4.5324.532 (ℓ=4\ell= 4) and 8.4138.413 (ℓ=8\ell= 8) have no counterpart within 10−210^{-2}.

Discussion

We have found that just above c=1c = 1, crossing symmetry excludes every Δϕ\Delta_{\phi} between about 0.170.17 and 11, although at c=1c = 1 the compact boson has, for a suitable radius, a scalar of each of these dimensions that satisfies our assumption. If the excluded interval reaches c=1c = 1 as Λ→∞\Lambda\to\infty, the allowed region is therefore discontinuous at c=1c = 1. Together with results from the modular bootstrap, the excluded interval implies that a compact unitary CFT at c=1.0005c = 1.0005 or 1.0011.001 must have a scalar lighter than 0.170.17. The candidate spectra of Benjamin, Fitzpatrick, Li and Thaler at c=1.05c = 1.05–1.131.13, outside Hellerman’s range, have their lightest scalars below the excluded interval, as [5] requires. To test them further, one would need their OPE coefficients, which the partition function does not determine.

We expect that by also using the four-point functions that involve the lightest scalar in $\phi \times \phi heavier than ϕ\phi, one can isolate the two theories at c=8/7c = 8/7 in small islands in the space of cc, Δϕ\Delta_\phi and the dimension of that second scalar, as one can for the three-dimensional Ising model [48]. With these four-point functions we also hope to constrain the region of light scalars further and to understand the plateau of cmin⁡c_{\min} just below the N=1\mathcal{N} = 1 minimal model.

To come back to Hellerman’s question, with which we began, the author’s answer is still yes. At the upper end of his range, c=1.001c = 1.001, crossing symmetry and modular invariance now forbid every compact unitary CFT whose lightest primary is heavier than 0.170.17. If everything not forbidden is compulsory, a theory with a lighter scalar must exist there.

Acknowledgments

The author thanks Simeon Hellerman for the question that started this work. The author shared this question with Alessandro Vichi at the workshop “Progress of Theoretical Bootstrap” at YITP, Kyoto, in 2025. Stefanos Kousvos, Alessandro Piazza and Vichi have studied it independently [49], and the author thanks them for coordinating the submission of the two papers to arXiv. The code for the Virasoro conformal bootstrap in this work was written by Claude Opus 5.5 (Anthropic), which also ran the numerical computations and assisted in drafting the manuscript. This work is supported in part by JSPS KAKENHI Grant Numbers 21K03581 and 26K00699.

Numerical details

SDPB requires the positivity conditions (4) to be written as positivity of polynomials in the conformal weights. We obtain this form from Zamolodchikov’s recursion for the Virasoro blocks in the elliptic nome [34], with which each Taylor coefficient of a block at z=1/2z = 1/2 has the form (16q0)hN(h)/D(h)(16q_0)^h N(h)/D(h) with q0=e−πq_0 = e^{-\pi}, where N(h)N(h) is a polynomial and D(h)=∏r,s(h−hr,s(c))D(h) = \prod_{r,s}(h - h_{r,s}(c)) is the product over the poles kept in the recursion. These poles lie at the zeros hr,s(c)=Q2/4−(rb+s/b)2/4h_{r,s}(c) = Q^2/4 - (rb + s/b)^2/4 of the Kac determinant [50], with c=1+6Q2c = 1 + 6Q^2 and Q=b+b−1Q = b + b^{-1}. For 1<c<251 < c < 25 the poles with r≠sr \ne s come in complex-conjugate pairs, while those with r=s≥2r = s \ge2 lie at h<0h < 0. The pole at h1,1=0h_{1,1} = 0 has vanishing residue because the external operators are identical. Hence D(h)>0D(h) > 0 for h>0h > 0, so that positivity of the functional indeed reduces to positivity of polynomials. We truncate the recursion at an order in qq between 20 and 46, chosen at each point such that all Taylor coefficients up to order Λ\Lambda agree with those of a table of much higher order to a relative accuracy of 10−2010^{-20} (10−1610^{-16} in the bisections at Λ=11\Lambda= 11) for internal conformal weights between 0 and 40. We need the highest orders for c−1≲10−4c - 1 \lesssim10^{-4}, because as c→1+c \to1^+ the poles with r≠sr \ne s approach the real axis at h=(r−s)2/4h = (r - s)^2/4.

To decide whether a point is excluded, we expand the crossing equation in ∂zm∂zˉn\partial_z^m \partial_{\bar z}^n with m<nm < n, m+nm + n odd and m+n≤Λm + n \le\Lambda, which gives 55 components at Λ=19\Lambda= 19 and 136 at Λ=31\Lambda= 31. We impose the positivity conditions (4) for the primaries allowed by (2): for even spins ℓ≤40\ell\le40 as functions of Δ≥max⁡(Δϕ,ℓ)\Delta\ge\max(\Delta_\phi,\ell), and for ℓ>40\ell> 40 on 28 lines of fixed twist Δ−ℓ∈{0,0.005,0.01,0.02,0.05,0.1,0.2,0.35,0.5,0.75,1,1.5,2,3,4,6,8,10,12,15,18,22,27,33,40,50,70,100,150}\Delta- \ell\in\{0, 0.005, 0.01, 0.02, 0.05, 0.1, 0.2, 0.35, 0.5, 0.75, 1, 1.5, 2, 3, 4, 6, 8, 10, 12, 15, 18, 22, 27, 33, 40, 50, 70, 100, 150\}, treating ℓ\ell as a continuous variable. In addition, we impose them in the limit ℓ→∞\ell\to\infty at fixed twist and in the limit h,hˉ→∞h,\bar h \to\infty at fixed ratio hˉ/h\bar h/h, so that the functional is positive at large spin and dimension as well. We run SDPB with 512 bits of precision and with error thresholds of 10−3010^{-30} for the dual and 10−6010^{-60} for the primal problem. We count a point as excluded when we obtain a functional that satisfies (4), and as allowed when we obtain instead a solution of the truncated crossing equation. We determine the endpoints in Table 1 by bisection in Δϕ\Delta_\phi and the values of cmin⁡c_{\min} in Figure 2 by bisection in cc. We read off the spectra in Table 2 and Table 3 from the zeros of the functional at the excluded point closest to the bound in question, Δ∗\Delta_* in Table 2 and cmin⁡c_{\min} in Table 3.

To test the candidate spectra in § 3, we allow below Δ=3.5\Delta= 3.5 only the operators of the candidate spectrum. We place each of them in an interval around its quoted dimension, of about the size of the quoted uncertainty, which we sample with spacing at most 0.005. Above Δ=3.5\Delta= 3.5 we impose only (2), because the spectra are truncated at Δ=4\Delta= 4 and are poorly determined near the truncation. Only for the candidate at c=1.05c = 1.05 does the outcome depend on the widths of these intervals. At Λ=19\Lambda= 19 it is excluded, and it remains excluded when we lower the cutoff from Δ=3.5\Delta= 3.5 to Δ=3\Delta= 3. It becomes allowed when we make the intervals 1.5 times wider.

Because the bound Δgap<0.167\Delta_{\mathrm{gap}} < 0.167 rests on the exclusion of Δϕ=0.1668\Delta_{\phi} = 0.1668 at c=1.0005c = 1.0005, we recomputed this exclusion with 768 bits of precision and evaluated the resulting functional with blocks from an independent table of higher order. We found it positive on a grid of even spins up to 3000 and twists up to 1000. Since the poles hr,sh_{r,s} come close to the real axis as c→1+c \to1^+, we also evaluated the functional on finer grids near the points where one of the two conformal weights equals (r−s)2/4(r-s)^2/4. Taking h≤hˉh \le\bar{h}, so that the twist is 2h2h and the spin is ℓ=hˉ−h\ell= \bar{h} - h, we used grids of spacing 10−310^{-3} in twist in two cases. When h=(r−s)2/4h = (r-s)^2/4, the twist is (r−s)2/2(r-s)^2/2, and we covered these twists up to 12.5 for spins up to 3000. When hˉ=(r−s)2/4\bar{h} = (r-s)^2/4, the twist is (r−s)2/2−2ℓ(r-s)^2/2 - 2\ell, and we covered these twists up to 200 for spins up to 400. The functional is positive on all of these grids. We made the same checks at Λ=19\Lambda= 19 for the exclusion of Δϕ=0.1687\Delta_{\phi} = 0.1687 at c=1.001c = 1.001, on which the bound at the upper end of Hellerman’s range rests, and for the exclusion of Δϕ=0.45\Delta_{\phi} = 0.45 at c=1.00001c = 1.00001, in the second case with the grid around the twists (r−s)2/2(r-s)^2/2 refined to a spacing of 2×10−42 \times10^{-4}. In both cases the functional is again positive on all of the grids.

References

  1. [1]M. Gell-Mann. The interpretation of the new particles as displaced charge multiplets. Nuovo Cim., 4 (S2):848–866, 1956. doi: 10.1007/BF02748000.
  2. [2]Helge Kragh. Physics and the totalitarian principle. 2019. arXiv:1907.04623.arxiv.org/abs/1907.04623
  3. [3]Daniel Friedan, Zong-an Qiu, and Stephen H. Shenker. Conformal Invariance, Unitarity and Two-Dimensional Critical Exponents. Phys. Rev. Lett., 52:1575–1578, 1984. doi: 10.1103/PhysRevLett.52.1575.DOI
  4. [4]A. A. Belavin, Alexander M. Polyakov, and A. B. Zamolodchikov. Infinite Conformal Symmetry in Two-Dimensional Quantum Field Theory. Nucl. Phys. B, 241:333–380, 1984. doi: 10.1016/0550-3213(84)90052-X.DOI
  5. [5]Andrea Cappelli, C. Itzykson, and J. B. Zuber. The ADE Classification of Minimal and A1(1) Conformal Invariant Theories. Commun. Math. Phys., 113:1, 1987. doi: 10.1007/BF01221394.
  6. [6]V. A. Fateev and A. B. Zamolodchikov. Parafermionic Currents in the Two-Dimensional Conformal Quantum Field Theory and Selfdual Critical Points in Z(n) Invariant Statistical Systems. Sov. Phys. JETP, 62:215–225, 1985.
  7. [7]Doron Gepner and Zong-an Qiu. Modular Invariant Partition Functions for Parafermionic Field Theories. Nucl. Phys. B, 285:423, 1987. doi: 10.1016/0550-3213(87)90348-8.DOI
  8. [8]Daniel Friedan, Zong-an Qiu, and Stephen H. Shenker. Superconformal Invariance in Two-Dimensions and the Tricritical Ising Model. Phys. Lett. B, 151:37–43, 1985. doi: 10.1016/0370-2693(85)90819-6.DOI
  9. [9]M. A. Bershadsky, V. G. Knizhnik, and M. G. Teitelman. Superconformal Symmetry in Two-Dimensions. Phys. Lett. B, 151:31–36, 1985. doi: 10.1016/0370-2693(85)90818-4.DOI
  10. [10]H. Eichenherr. Minimal Operator Algebras in Superconformal Quantum Field Theory. Phys. Lett. B, 151:26–30, 1985. doi: 10.1016/0370-2693(85)90817-2.DOI
  11. [11]P. Goddard, A. Kent, and David I. Olive. Unitary Representations of the Virasoro and Supervirasoro Algebras. Commun. Math. Phys., 103:105–119, 1986. doi: 10.1007/BF01464283.DOI
  12. [12]Paul H. Ginsparg. Curiosities at c = 1. Nucl. Phys. B, 295:153–170, 1988. doi: 10.1016/0550-3213(88)90249-0.DOI
  13. [13]Simeon Hellerman. A Universal Inequality for CFT and Quantum Gravity. JHEP, 08:130, 2011. doi: 10.1007/JHEP08(2011)130. arXiv:0902.2790.DOI
  14. [14]Simeon Hellerman and Cornelius Schmidt-Colinet. Bounds for State Degeneracies in 2D Conformal Field Theory. JHEP, 08:127, 2011. doi: 10.1007/JHEP08(2011)127. arXiv:1007.0756.DOI
  15. [15]Daniel Friedan and Christoph A. Keller. Constraints on 2d CFT partition functions. JHEP, 10:180, 2013. doi: 10.1007/JHEP10(2013)180. arXiv:1307.6562.DOI
  16. [16]Joshua D. Qualls and Alfred D. Shapere. Bounds on Operator Dimensions in 2D Conformal Field Theories. JHEP, 05:091, 2014. doi: 10.1007/JHEP05(2014)091. arXiv:1312.0038.DOI
  17. [17]Scott Collier, Ying-Hsuan Lin, and Xi Yin. Modular Bootstrap Revisited. JHEP, 09:061, 2018. doi: 10.1007/JHEP09(2018)061. arXiv:1608.06241.DOI
  18. [18]Nathan Benjamin, A. Liam Fitzpatrick, Wei Li, and Jesse Thaler. Descending into the modular bootstrap. JHEP, 09:029, 2026. doi: 10.1007/JHEP09(2026)029. arXiv:2604.01275.DOI
  19. [19]A. Liam Fitzpatrick and Wei Li. Improving modular bootstrap bounds with integrality. JHEP, 07:058, 2024. doi: 10.1007/JHEP07(2024)058. arXiv:2308.08725.DOI
  20. [20]Jesse Thaler. Descending into the Modular Bootstrap. Talk at the École Normale Supérieure Summer Institute, Paris, 26 June 2026, slide 40, indico.in2p3.fr/event/39001; preliminary results of N. Benjamin, A. L. Fitzpatrick, K. Langhoff, W. Li and J. Thaler, 2026.arxiv.org/abs/2604.01275
  21. [21]Chi-Ming Chang and Ying-Hsuan Lin. Bootstrapping 2D CFTs in the Semiclassical Limit. JHEP, 08:056, 2016. doi: 10.1007/JHEP08(2016)056. arXiv:1510.02464.DOI
  22. [22]Ying-Hsuan Lin, Shu-Heng Shao, David Simmons-Duffin, Yifan Wang, and Xi Yin. 𝒩 = 4 superconformal bootstrap of the K3 CFT. JHEP, 05:126, 2017. doi: 10.1007/JHEP05(2017)126. arXiv:1511.04065.DOI
  23. [23]Ying-Hsuan Lin, Shu-Heng Shao, Yifan Wang, and Xi Yin. (2, 2) superconformal bootstrap in two dimensions. JHEP, 05:112, 2017. doi: 10.1007/JHEP05(2017)112. arXiv:1610.05371.DOI
  24. [24]Yu Nakayama and Toshiki Onagi. Conformal bootstrap with duality-inspired fusion rule. Phys. Rev. D, 113(10):L101701, 2026. doi: 10.1103/h2t4-bb53. arXiv:2511.00386.
  25. [25]Mert Besken. Virasoro conformal bootstrap with c > 1. 2021. arXiv:2106.08999.arxiv.org/abs/2106.08999
  26. [26]Scott Collier, Petr Kravchuk, Ying-Hsuan Lin, and Xi Yin. Bootstrapping the Spectral Function: On the Uniqueness of Liouville and the Universality of BTZ. JHEP, 09:150, 2018. doi: 10.1007/JHEP09(2018)150. arXiv:1702.00423.DOI
  27. [27]David Poland. virasoro_blocks: Software for the 2d bootstrap. 2026. arXiv:2610.39106.arxiv.org/abs/2610.39106
  28. [28]Riccardo Rattazzi, Vyacheslav S. Rychkov, Erik Tonni, and Alessandro Vichi. Bounding scalar operator dimensions in 4D CFT. JHEP, 12:031, 2008. doi: 10.1088/1126-6708/2008/12/031. arXiv:0807.0004.DOI
  29. [29]David Poland, Slava Rychkov, and Alessandro Vichi. The Conformal Bootstrap: Theory, Numerical Techniques, and Applications. Rev. Mod. Phys., 91:015002, 2019. doi: 10.1103/RevModPhys.91.015002. arXiv:1805.04405.DOI
  30. [30]Sheer El-Showk, Miguel F. Paulos, David Poland, Slava Rychkov, David Simmons-Duffin, and Alessandro Vichi. Solving the 3D Ising Model with the Conformal Bootstrap. Phys. Rev. D, 86:025022, 2012. doi: 10.1103/PhysRevD.86.025022. arXiv:1203.6064.
  31. [31]Sheer El-Showk, Miguel F. Paulos, David Poland, Slava Rychkov, David Simmons-Duffin, and Alessandro Vichi. Solving the 3d Ising Model with the Conformal Bootstrap II. c-Minimization and Precise Critical Exponents. J. Stat. Phys., 157:869, 2014. doi: 10.1007/s10955-014-1042-7. arXiv:1403.4545.
  32. [32]Robbert Dijkgraaf, Erik P. Verlinde, and Herman L. Verlinde. C = 1 Conformal Field Theories on Riemann Surfaces. Commun. Math. Phys., 115:649–690, 1988. doi: 10.1007/BF01224132.DOI
  33. [33]A. B. Zamolodchikov. Conformal symmetry in two dimensions: an explicit recurrence formula for the conformal partial wave amplitude. Commun. Math. Phys., 96:419–422, 1984. doi: 10.1007/BF01214585.DOI
  34. [34]Al. B. Zamolodchikov. Conformal symmetry in two-dimensional space: Recursion representation of conformal block. Theor. Math. Phys., 73(1):1088–1093, 1987. doi: 10.1007/BF01022967.DOI
  35. [35]Sylvain Ribault. Conformal field theory on the plane. 2014. arXiv:1406.4290.arxiv.org/abs/1406.4290
  36. [36]Harald Dorn and H. J. Otto. Two and three point functions in Liouville theory. Nucl. Phys. B, 429: 375–388, 1994. doi: 10.1016/0550-3213(94)00352-1. arXiv:hep-th/9403141.DOI
  37. [37]Alexander B. Zamolodchikov and Alexei B. Zamolodchikov. Structure constants and conformal bootstrap in Liouville field theory. Nucl. Phys. B, 477:577–605, 1996. doi: 10.1016/0550-3213(96)00351-3. arXiv:hep-th/9506136.DOI
  38. [38]Yu Nakayama. Liouville field theory: A Decade after the revolution. Int. J. Mod. Phys. A, 19:2771–2930, 2004. doi: 10.1142/S0217751X04019500. arXiv:hep-th/0402009.
  39. [39]David Simmons-Duffin. A Semidefinite Program Solver for the Conformal Bootstrap. JHEP, 06:174, 2015. doi: 10.1007/JHEP06(2015)174. arXiv:1502.02033.
  40. [40]Walter Landry and David Simmons-Duffin. Scaling the semidefinite program solver SDPB. 2019. arXiv:1909.09745.arxiv.org/abs/1909.09745
  41. [41]H. G. Kausch and G. M. T. Watts. A Study of W algebras using Jacobi identities. Nucl. Phys. B, 354: 740–768, 1991. doi: 10.1016/0550-3213(91)90375-8.DOI
  42. [42]R. Blumenhagen, M. Flohr, A. Kliem, W. Nahm, A. Recknagel, and R. Varnhagen. W algebras with two and three generators. Nucl. Phys. B, 361:255–289, 1991. doi: 10.1016/0550-3213(91)90624-7.DOI
  43. [43]Cuipo Jiang and Qing Wang. Fusion rules for Z₂-orbifolds of affine and parafermion vertex operator algebras. Isr. J. Math., 240(2):837–887, 2020. doi: 10.1007/s11856-020-2082-0. arXiv:1904.01798.DOI
  44. [44]Doron Gepner and Hervé Partouche. On The Real Part of a Conformal Field Theory. Universe, 4(9): 97, 2018. doi: 10.3390/universe4090097. arXiv:1310.8514.DOI
  45. [45]Erik P. Verlinde. Fusion Rules and Modular Transformations in 2D Conformal Field Theory. Nucl. Phys. B, 300:360–376, 1988. doi: 10.1016/0550-3213(88)90603-7.DOI
  46. [46]Sheer El-Showk and Miguel F. Paulos. Bootstrapping Conformal Field Theories with the Extremal Functional Method. Phys. Rev. Lett., 111(24):241601, 2013. doi: 10.1103/PhysRevLett.111.241601. arXiv:1211.2810.
  47. [47]L. Alvarez-Gaumé and Ph. Zaugg. Structure constants in the N=1 superoperator algebra. Annals Phys., 215:171–230, 1992. doi: 10.1016/0003-4916(92)90303-4. arXiv:hep-th/9109050.
  48. [48]Filip Kos, David Poland, and David Simmons-Duffin. Bootstrapping Mixed Correlators in the 3D Ising Model. JHEP, 11:109, 2014. doi: 10.1007/JHEP11(2014)109. arXiv:1406.4858.DOI
  49. [49]Stefanos R. Kousvos, Alessandro Piazza, and Alessandro Vichi. The Virasoro Bootstrap: from the c ∼ 1 desert to coupled Potts. 2026. to appear.arxiv.org/abs/2611.03565
  50. [50]V. G. Kac. Contravariant Form for Infinite Dimensional Lie Algebras and Superalgebras. In 7th International Group Theory Colloquium: The Integrative Conference on Group Theory and Mathematical Physics, volume 94 of Lect. Notes Phys., pages 441–445, 1979.

Paper details

vlnc:W_t2m8t9ne
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 1

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Physics and Astronomy

Claude Opus 5.5

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents