WorksMathematics
On extremal problems related to the Krzyż conjecture
Abstract
We study general extremal problems similar or closely related to the Krzyż conjecture and establish the structural properties of extremal functions, pointing out some differences with the original Krzyż case. We also introduce a family of more specific problems of this kind, interpolating between the Krzyż problem and the problem of maximizing the constant term, and show that they are closely related to the Krzyż conjecture: the conjecture implies the analogous statement for all of them and, conversely, if one of them has the same extremal value as the Krzyż problem, then this value is . This may represent a new approach to attacking the original problem. Finally, we show that for these problems an extremal function whose Taylor coefficients vanish must be the conjectured one; as a special case, we obtain a new proof of a recent result of MacDonald.
Introduction
We study extremal problems for bounded non-vanishing analytic functions in the unit disc that generalize the well-known Krzyż problem. Denote by the class of all analytic functions in the unit disc such that for all in . If in , let
Standard arguments involving normal families show that the supremum is attained for each , hence an extremal function always exists. Since instead of we can consider with , after such rotations we may assume from the start that both and are real and positive. The celebrated Krzyż conjecture, posed in 1968 in [13], states that and the only extremal function normalized in this way is
This problem provides the main inspiration for our study and is still open. Upper bounds, valid for all simultaneously and strictly smaller than (with approximate values of ), were obtained in [10] and [9]. The conjecture has been proved for (cf. [13], [11], [5], [24], [23] and [21]), including a recent computer-assisted proof [26] for , but remains open to this date for all larger values of . For further information and some closely related questions, we mention [11], [15], [23], [19], and [2], as well as the recent preprints [14] and [17], and [8].
We will use the following known facts about normalized extremal functions, which we collect here for convenience. The three parts of the statement can be found respectively in [11], in both [11] and [19], and in [19], Theorem 1.
Theorem A. Let and let be a normalized extremal function for (1), that is, and . Then:
(i) for some with , some , and distinct points with ;
(ii) ;
(iii) if and only if and .
Our purpose is to consider general coefficient extremal problems for non-vanishing bounded analytic functions. A useful survey of extremal problems of this kind is [3]. A comprehensive treatment of various linear and non-linear coefficient extremal problems can be found in the classical reference [12].
Let be analytic in . If for all , the Schwarz–Pick lemma yields . The F. Wiener transform of [19 Section 1.7] is defined by
where is also analytic in and bounded by 1. Since and , the Schwarz–Pick lemma applied to yields for all . Moreover, if , then clearly for all and if and only if is a unimodular constant. In view of this, if we assume that is holomorphic in , continuous in , and non-constant, then the coefficient functional of the form is well defined for every . We study the associated extremal problem of finding
The Krzyż problem corresponds to the special case . Our Theorem 4, formulated in § 2, shows that the maximum in (4) is always attained and, moreover, every extremal function is either a unimodular constant or a singular inner function with at most atoms; that is, a unimodular multiple of a function like in Theorem A (i). This has a flavor of other known results but we have not been able to find a complete proof of the result in this generality in the literature. We also show that if the function defining the functional does not depend on the variable , then all extremal functions are non-constant and, thus, have the same structure as the ones for the original Krzyż problem. On the other hand, we give specific non-trivial examples (where also depends on other variables) showing that an extremal function can actually be constant. It should be mentioned that, for a fixed value of , Romanova [20] studied the extremal problem for bounded non-vanishing analytic functions for the linear functional of the form and derived a similar structure using an extremal problem for functions with positive real part and Loewner chains.
We also discuss some issues related to normalization, since for certain problems we cannot freely assume that because of the risk of losing the structure proved in Theorem 4. Examples are given to illustrate some differences in such cases. For a smaller class of functionals that only depend on the variables and , in § 2 we show that if a normalized extremal function is unique, it must be a function of (Theorem 9).
This last situation, together with some known results for the Krzyż conjecture, motivates our § 3, where we study a special family of such functionals depending only on the coefficients and of . In view of parts (ii) and (iii) of Theorem A, it seems quite appropriate to study convex combinations of the functionals and . It also makes sense to restrict our attention to a smaller class containing all candidates for extremal functions for the Krzyż problem. For we define as the set of all functions which are singular inner functions with at most atoms and for which .
Next, let be a holomorphic function on such that for , real and , the value is real with . By continuity, for we have . Constant functions are allowed. Under these restrictions on , consider the functionals
where and are the usual coefficients of the function and consider
(We write when the dependence on needs to be emphasized.) This is of interest since it forces the inequalities for every ; moreover, holds if and only if , which is precisely the condition known to imply for an extremal function of the Krzyż problem. The following result from § 3 connects the problems (1) and (6).
Theorem 1. Let and let be an admissible functional of the form (5).
(a) If the function is extremal for the Krzyż problem (1), that is, if , then and is the only extremal function for (6).
(b) If , then , the function is extremal for (1), and it is the only extremal function for (6). In particular, if
then and is extremal for the Krzyż problem (1).
(c) If there is only one extremal function for (6), then and this function is .
Note that the original Krzyż problem can be viewed as the limit case of (6) when is constant and tends to zero. Thus, investigating this general problem may indicate a new way of attacking the original conjecture. In particular, (6) is confirmed to be true for , as expressed by Corollary 12, and it seems legitimate to conjecture that for all , with the same expected extremal function as for the normalized Krzyż problem.
Section 4 concerns extremal functions for the special functionals whose initial coefficients are assumed to vanish. There are several statements of this type in the literature. For the Krzyż problem, Brown [4] showed that if for for an extremal function, then the function must be . He actually proved a more general version for spaces posed in [11]. In the Krzyż setting, a general theorem of this type involving the so-called inductive sets was later given in [19]. Recently, MacDonald [17] improved this result by proving that if an extremal function for the Krzyż problem it suffices to assume only to conclude that (see Corollary 23 below). Here denotes the integer part of a real number . Note that [17] uses the notation , which gives the same integer as .
Theorem 2. Let , let be an admissible weight or , and let be a fixed extremal function for (6) (for , this means that is a normalized extremal function for the Krzyż problem (1)). Then the following statements are equivalent:
(a) for .
(b) .
If any of the above conditions is satisfied, then .
Corollary 23 also covers the case of Theorem 2, thus giving a new proof of MacDonald’s theorem. Our proof differs a great deal from MacDonald’s. It is based on the determinant estimates of Efraimidis [7] (generalizing some classical results by Livingston [16]).
Structural results for general non-linear extremal problems
Existence and structure of extremal functions
Recall that, by a theorem of Fatou, every bounded analytic function in has radial limits for almost every . A function bounded by one and such that almost everywhere is said to be inner. For a positive integer , a singular inner function with atoms is a function of the form
where the points are distinct. It is known that every extremal function for the Krzyż problem (1) must have this form with ; see Theorem A (i). In spite of this information, proving that the only normalized extremal function is the function defined in Section 1 has remained elusive up to the time of writing this paper.
In this section we show that all extremal functions for the general problem (4) must have a structure very similar to (7), with one difference: constant functions of modulus one can also be extremal in some cases. Our proof follows an idea for the original Krzyż problem suggested by Donald E. Marshall [18], which in this case requires a careful further discussion in view of the generality of the problem. To this end, the following auxiliary statement will be very useful.
Lemma 3. Let and let be a non-constant holomorphic function on . Then there exists such that
Proof. This statement can be deduced in more than one way. Here is one simple proof.
The restriction of defined by , , is clearly analytic in . By the mean value property of the harmonic function ,
hence there exists with (in particular, ) such that .
Since is not constant in , it cannot be constant on the open set
by the identity principle for holomorphic functions of several complex variables. Now for the value such that and whose existence we have established, choose a connected open neighborhood of the point . Since is not constant on , the open mapping theorem shows that is an open set, hence there exists a point such that
hence
It only remains to check that for any given there exists a function in such that . This is easily seen by considering the polynomial
By our choice of , we have since for all we have and .
We are now ready to prove the existence of extremal functions for (4) and describe their structure. Note that there are some natural additional complications which do not appear in the study of more special problems such as the basic Krzyż problem.
Theorem 4. Let and let be a non-constant function, holomorphic in and continuous in . Then there exists an extremal function for (4). Every such function is either a constant function of modulus one or a singular inner function as in (7), where . Moreover, if does not depend on its first variable , then all extremal functions must be of the form (7).
Proof. Existence. Denote by the -th Taylor coefficient of a function analytic in . In order to show that an extremal function for (4) exists, let be a sequence of functions in such that (note that since is bounded on the compact set ). An application of Montel’s theorem yields a subsequence, say , that converges locally uniformly to some function . By Weierstrass’ theorem, is analytic in and for all . In view of the observations made in § 1, we have for all and all , hence for all . Moreover, since in for all , by Hurwitz’s theorem either is identically zero or (in which case it may still be a constant function). The assumption on continuity of in yields
Thus, will be extremal for (4) if it is not identically zero. It is clear from Lemma 3 that at least for the function found there yields a strictly greater value than the function identically equal to zero, hence the zero function cannot be extremal, and we are done.
Structure. First, we show that if is constant: , then . By Lemma 3, for the function obtained there we must have
In particular, the function , holomorphic in and continuous in , is not constant. Since every constant function with belongs to , we have for , and also for by continuity. Thus, attains its maximum over at the point , and the maximum principle yields , as claimed. We now prove (2) in the case when is not constant. It suffices to prove the statement in the special case when . Otherwise we may consider
Note that multiplication by is a bijective mapping of onto itself, hence if and only if . Also, and is extremal for the functional corresponding to the function if and only if is extremal for the functional corresponding to the function . Thus, it suffices to prove that (as an extremal function for ) has the structure (7) claimed, and it will immediately follow that also has the same structure.
Since is not constant, we have , so we may write , where is analytic in , in , and is real and negative. In what follows, we will consider a fixed value and hence also will be fixed. As we know from [15] or [19], every coefficient of can be written as
where is a polynomial (see also Lemma 22 below), hence
is again a holomorphic function of the variables , which can be written as another holomorphic function
of the variables . Note that the function
is analytic in and has positive real part there, so we can apply to it the theorems of Carathéodory and Toeplitz which can be found in [25 Chapter IV], among other sources. The set
is open, being a finite intersection of open sets. By Sylvester’s criterion, is the set of vectors for which the corresponding Hermitian Toeplitz matrix is positive definite; hence is also convex, and it contains the zero vector . By the Carathéodory–Toeplitz theorem, the quadratic form associated to the Hermitian Toeplitz matrix corresponding to the coefficient vector of is non-negative. Therefore, for , the vectors belong to , since their Toeplitz matrices are obtained by adding the positive definite matrix to times the former one. In particular, belongs to the closure of . If were constant in , continuity would give . Thus, the constant function would also be extremal, which is impossible by the first part of the proof. Hence, is not constant in .
Suppose now, to reach a contradiction, that . Since is open and connected and is not constant there, the open mapping theorem for holomorphic functions of several complex variables implies the existence of such that
On the other hand, by a theorem of Carathéodory [25 Theorem IV.24], there exists a function , analytic in and with positive real part, such that
The function belongs to and satisfies and , hence , which contradicts the assumption that is extremal.
Therefore, . Since all the Toeplitz determinants associated with are non-negative and the first one equals , there is a smallest integer with such that
The Carathéodory–Toeplitz theorem [25 Theorem IV.22] implies that, for some and distinct points with ,
which proves the structural formula (7) for .
Finally, suppose that does not depend on its first variable. If is a constant function, then , hence . Thus, for the function given by Lemma 3 we have
hence no constant function can be extremal. □
Uniqueness and normalizations
It is important to notice that the structure of extremal functions is not quite the same in the most general case as in the Krzyż problem. Also, for the sake of trying to obtain uniqueness, in some cases it may be convenient to consider our extremal problems over a smaller class instead of over the entire class . For example, for the original Krzyż problem we can use rotations as above to see that the maximum defined in (1) is actually equal to
We will refer to this formulation as the normalized Krzyż problem. Three basic questions arise here:
Can a constant function of modulus one actually be extremal for some choice of in the general problem (4)? A trivial example would be , but it is desirable to have an example where does not depend only on .
How many extremal functions can we have for a given problem? Is it possible to have only one such function, or maybe some other small finite number?
Can we impose further normalizations as in the Krzyż problem, such as ? How does this affect the extremal functions, and do we get uniqueness?
In what follows, we answer all these questions by providing appropriate examples.
Our first example answers our question (1) raised above and, regarding question (2), shows that an extremal problem can have a unique solution.
Example 5. The extremal problem associated to the linear functional is maximized only by the constant function . Recalling that for we have (see § 1), this can be seen as follows:
and the maximum value is only attained when , which immediately forces to be constant: . Thus, in this case there is only one extremal function and it is constant.
Note that the functionals which are only functions of , that is,
give rise to some unusual situations. Here is an example.
Example 6. Let .
(a) Let us first maximize over . The value must satisfy . Writing with and , we see that
The maximum is attained only when equality holds throughout; that is, only for
and in this case clearly has modulus , forcing . Thus, there are exactly two extremal functions and they are both constant.
(b) If we want to maximize over the reduced class of all with , we obtain
with equality only for . However, in this case it is immediate that there are many extremal functions different from those described by Theorem 4, e.g., every function of the form
All these functions are obviously bounded by one, non-vanishing in , and have the property . Even the constant function among them () is clearly different from the ones from Theorem 4 and the ones found in the previous analysis.
Both Example 5 and Example 6 (a) are in sharp contrast with the Krzyż problem, for which there are infinitely many extremal functions if we do not assume any normalization. Indeed, at least one extremal function for the Krzyż problem exists, and for each with the function has the same -th coefficient as ; since its value at the origin is , there are uncountably many distinct extremal functions.
As our Example 6 (b) shows, the structure obtained in Theorem 4 can be completely ruined under the additional assumption . One way of getting around this obstacle in order to be able to assume that there is an extremal function with a positive value at the origin is as follows. Define two functions and that satisfy the conditions of Theorem 4 to be associated if there exists with such that . This clearly defines an equivalence relation, so instead of individual functionals we can consider equivalence classes of associated functionals. In each class we can choose one representative, , such that there exists an extremal function for the functional with , because we can find with such that . This may provide a satisfactory solution (albeit not an ideal one).
The next example shows that the problem encountered in our Example 6 does not come from the fact that the functional depended only on . There are other functionals that give rise to the same situation, even though the extremal function fits within the description given in Theorem 4.
Example 7. Let and . We already know that there is an extremal function for this functional but there are none with the property . For a general we have
Equality in the Schwarz–Pick lemma for a non-constant function is only possible for a disc automorphism, which has a zero in , so this case must be ruled out. Thus, equality in the above chain can only hold for a constant function with and , that is, . Hence, there are only two extremal functions, both constant functions of modulus one. However, under the assumption we get
as is well known. Thus, no extremal function has the property .
In order to obtain an associated functional with an extremal function that has a positive value at the origin, instead of we would have to consider the functional , whose extremal functions are .
Further properties of extremal functions
In what follows, we will refer to any function of the form (7) as a candidate function. We will use the notation for the set of all candidate functions with exactly atoms, , while will denote the class of constant functions of modulus one (no atoms in the representation in Theorem 4). Thus, every extremal function for (4) belongs to the set . The following fact was observed in [2 Remark 3.2] for the Krzyż problem, and this easily generalizes to our situation. It shows that finding the maximum of over all admissible functions reduces to finding the supremum of the same quantity only over the functions with the full number of atoms.
Remark 8. Let , , and let be a non-constant function, holomorphic in and continuous in . Then
In particular,
Hence,
To see this, it suffices to show that if for every candidate function with atoms, , then the same is true for every candidate function with atoms. Given , if we choose with different from the atoms of (if , any will do). Then the function
belongs to . It is elementary to see that uniformly on compact sets, hence , also uniformly on compact sets. By Weierstrass’ theorem, it is immediate that the Taylor coefficients of converge to the Taylor coefficients of and therefore also as . Thus, any uniform bound for over the class is also a uniform bound for the functions in .
It has recently been proved by Lei and Zhang [14] (indirectly, by proving the Agler–McCarthy conjecture [2]) that if every extremal function for the original Krzyż problem has exactly atoms, then the Krzyż conjecture is true. Note, however, that even for the Krzyż problem it has not yet been established that every extremal function must have the full number of atoms: , nor that there exists an extremal function with this number of atoms.
It is well-known to the experts that if there is a unique extremal functions for the Krzyż conjecture, then the conjecture holds. This fact admits a partial extension to our generalized problem by following the same argument.
Theorem 9. Let be a non-constant function holomorphic in and continuous in , and consider the functional . If the associated extremal problem (4) has exactly one extremal function with , then for some .
Proof. If is a primitive -th root of unity, then has the same coefficients and as , hence it is also extremal for all . By uniqueness, for all and, in particular, where is the F. Wiener transform of defined by (3) in § 1. Thus, , where is analytic in ; since , also .
Note that, in spite of the restrictive condition on the coefficients, the above result covers the original Krzyż problem. Moreover, the same argument applies verbatim to extremal problems posed over any subclass of that is invariant under the rotations , such as the class considered in the next section.
A special class of problems
Although our Theorem 4 is valid for quite general functionals, we will now focus on a very specific subclass of functionals which will be useful for our purpose and to which Theorem 9 also applies. As a motivation, we first notice the following.
By Theorem A (i) and (ii), every normalized extremal function for the Krzyż problem (1) satisfies and belongs to one of the classes of candidate functions, with . Thus, we actually have
where
Clearly, this class encodes all the information needed about possible extremal functions for the Krzyż problem. We note that contains an uncountable collection of functions with exactly atoms. Namely, let and define
Then is a singular inner function with exactly atoms and
Thus, we have whenever . Note that for we obtain the conjectured extremal function .
One can also find examples of functions in with fewer than atoms when .
Example 10. Let , , which is a singular inner function with one atom. We can express this function as
where are the Laguerre polynomials of order ; cf. [15 p. 258]. Thus, if and only if . This polynomial can be explicitly computed [1 p. 775] as
Since the leading coefficient of the polynomial in is positive, this holds for all sufficiently large .
In the rest of this section we consider special functionals of the form (5), which are convex combinations of and , as defined in Section 1. We refer to such functionals as admissible functionals and to the corresponding functions as admissible weights. For and for each admissible weight , we consider the extremal problem of finding the supremum defined in (6).
Here are a few examples of such functionals:
which correspond, respectively, to the weights
Since , for all we have
By Theorem A (iii), if a fixed normalized extremal function for the Krzyż problem (1) satisfies , then and . This is precisely what makes the functionals interesting for our study, in an attempt to “tighten” as much as possible the inequality and strive for equality.
The classical Krzyż problem corresponds to the weight , which is not admissible, since the equivalence in (9) fails for it. Nevertheless, it will be convenient to allow this limit case in some statements, and we will always say so explicitly. Note that for constant weights with we easily obtain
so the classical extremal value remains the limit of these problems as . Note, however, that this convergence does not itself establish equality for any .
Recall that Example 5, which concerns the functional corresponding to the weight , shows that constant extremal functions are possible when the maximum is taken over the whole class . Here we avoid this problem by imposing the structure from Theorem 4 in view of our definition (8) of the restricted class .
Proposition 11. Let be as in (5). Then and the supremum in (6) is attained, that is, there exists an extremal function (by definition, is a singular inner function with at most atoms).
Proof. The function belongs to and , hence . Let be a sequence in such that . Since , each can be written as
Let . If along a subsequence, then the estimate shows that locally uniformly along that subsequence, so that , and, by the continuity of at , , which contradicts . Hence, is bounded and, passing to a subsequence, we may assume that for all , and for . Then locally uniformly in , where
is either a singular inner function with at most atoms (some atoms may merge or disappear in the limit) or the constant function 1. Since the Taylor coefficients converge, we have ; in particular, is not constant. Thus, and, by the continuity of in ,
By Theorem A (iii), proving the equality for a fixed normalized extremal function would prove the statement of the Krzyż conjecture for that specific function. It is also known that uniqueness of the normalized extremal function is equivalent to the full statement of the conjecture. Our Theorem 1, formulated in the Introduction, collects the analogous relations between the problems (1) and (6). Its proof is simple, but it shows that the two problems are closely related and gives us the flexibility to change from one functional to another when convenient. In particular, part (b) shows that the apparently weaker assumption already implies that . Thus, we believe the result may prove useful for the further study of the Krzyż problem.
Proof of Theorem 1. (a) Let be an extremal function for (6); it exists by Proposition 11. Since and , the inequalities (9) and the inclusion yield
Hence, and . Thus, is also a normalized extremal function for the Krzyż problem (1) and, by (9), . By Theorem A (iii), .
(b) By Proposition 11, there is an extremal function for (6). For any such function , the inequalities (9) and the inclusion yield
Hence, , so is also a normalized extremal function for the Krzyż problem (1) and, by (9), . By Theorem A (iii), and . Since this holds for every extremal function for (6), is the only one. The particular case follows by taking , since and .
(c) Let . The class is invariant under the rotations , which do not change the coefficients and . Hence, proceeding as in the proof of Theorem 9, we see that the unique extremal function satisfies for some with and . By the classical case of the Krzyż conjecture, we have , with equality if and only if . Arguing like in (a), we see that , , and .
Since the Krzyž conjecture has been proved for and a computer-assisted proof for is currently under scrutiny (see § 1), Theorem 1 (a) yields the following.
Corollary 12. Let and let be an admissible functional. Then and given by (2) is the only extremal function for (6).
We hope that Theorem 1 may provide some new directions in the research on the Krzyž problem. The intermediate values of can be seen as a “bridge” between the original Krzyž conjecture and the problem of maximizing the constant term within the class and may also deserve a closer look.
Remark 13. Comparing the extremal functions for the general problem and the original Krzyž problem allows us to deduce some conclusions about the constant term of an extremal function. For instance, if for some admissible weight , then every normalized extremal function for the Krzyž problem (1) satisfies . Indeed, by Theorem A, and (9) yields .
Remark 14. The case admits a natural reformulation in terms of the singular measure associated with . If is written as
then , where is the total mass of this measure. Hence, , where is the minimum of the total mass over all ; it is attained by Proposition 11. Since has total mass 1, the conjecture formulated in Subsection 4.2 for states that every singular inner function with at most atoms, and has total mass at least 1, with equality only for . Moreover, by Theorem 1 (b), the equality would imply that .
In the same spirit as above, we can also prove the following result. Observe that the bound in (c) is only of interest when , since otherwise the maximum on the right-hand side is zero.
Proposition 15. Let be an admissible functional and let be an arbitrary but fixed extremal function for (6). Let be an arbitrary but fixed normalized extremal function for the Krzyž problem (1). Then the following statements hold.
(a) If then .
(b) If is a positive constant, then .
(c) If is a constant with , then
and if , then .
Proof. For part (a), we see that
Consequently, it follows that
which proves that if . If , then by hypothesis, so the first chain of inequalities gives ; moreover, , since whenever . Hence, .
Part (b) follows automatically from part (a) since if is a constant, then .
Finally, for part (c), assume that is a constant. Since , we have
If , this is . If , we use the estimate from Section 1 to obtain , where
The discriminant of is , which is positive since . Hence, is not smaller than the smaller root of , which is the first expression in the maximum, and the claim follows since . □
Remark 16. Using the crude estimate instead of in the proof of part (c), one obtains the simpler bound , which is positive exactly when .
Problems with further assumptions on coefficients
We continue to study the same type of problems as in the previous section, this time under some additional conditions on the coefficients, in the vein of [19]. But first we need to review a number of technical tools that will be needed.
Some estimates for the Carathéodory class
Throughout this section, we will denote by the Carathéodory class of normalized analytic functions in with positive real part:
It is customary to denote the functions in by and their Taylor coefficients by but here we use the letter to avoid confusion with the admissible weights of Section 3. It is well known that every function has the form
where is a Borel probability measure on (which can also be viewed as the unit circle with an appropriate identification). This follows directly from [6 Section 1.9] upon imposing the normalization condition . The above representation is known as the Herglotz representation of and is referred to as its Herglotz measure. Among the Herglotz measures, the ones of special interest to us are the ones supported at point masses on the unit circle , where , for . In this case,
For arbitrary , by Carathéodory’s lemma [6 p. 41], we know that for all , with equality only if the support of the measure is a subset of the -th roots of some unimodular complex number. Livingston Livingston [16] further showed that for all , and this was later generalized in several directions by Efraimidis Efraimidis [7].
Following [7], for a complex number and a function in we consider the determinants
The following was proved by Efraimidis in [7 Theorem 2].
Lemma 17. For in and in we have
for all integers and .
If , then equality holds if and only if the support of the Herglotz measure of is contained in a rotation , , of the set of -th roots of unity and $q_1=q_2=\cdots=q_k=0.
In what follows, we will use Efraimidis’ estimates to prove Theorem 2. We will also need the classical Schur complement formula for determinants; see [22 p. 217].
Lemma 18. Let be a square matrix of complex numbers written in block form
where and are square matrices of sizes and , respectively. If is invertible, then
Proof. The identity follows by taking determinants in the factorization
Lemma 19. Fix an integer and let . Let be a function in , and let be any complex number. Assume that for all . Then
If , then equality holds if and only if the support of the Herglotz measure of is contained in a rotation , , of the set of -th roots of unity and .
Proof. Since , observe that . The idea of the proof is to calculate the determinant and then apply Lemma 17. If , then (10) becomes
Note that
since , so there is nothing left to do.
Assume now that . We see that
where , and the matrix
Observe that is a triangular Toeplitz matrix and thus we may write
where is the identity matrix of size and is the matrix of the same size whose entries are equal to 1 on the first subdiagonal and to 0 elsewhere. Since , then and the hypothesis implies that
By definition of , there exists a unique such that . Thus, and, since , we have that
Summing up, we have that must be invertible and
Recall that, from the hypothesis, the first components of are zero. Since is obtained from by shifting its entries positions downwards and , it follows that for all and thus by (11). Then Lemma 18 yields that
(recall that ). The proof now follows by applying Lemma 17 with and .
Next, we show that the bound on the right-hand side of (10) can be improved when is real.
Lemma 20. Under the assumptions of Lemma 19, if is real, then
Proof. For , (10) is exactly what we want to show. If , we can apply the case , Carathéodory’s lemma, and the triangle inequality to see that
Equivalent formulations of the generalized conjecture
Since the Krzyż conjecture is believed to be true by many experts, we expect the following more general conjecture for problem (6) to be true.
Conjecture. Let and let be an admissible functional. Then and the only extremal function for (6) is .
By Corollary 12, the conjecture holds for , and by Theorem 1 (a), it holds for every for which the Krzyż conjecture is true. This raises the natural question as to whether some parts of the main theorem from [19] (see Theorem A) can also be formulated in this more general context.
For a non-constant function in we may write where for all in . Writing and assuming that is real and negative, it is immediate that the normalized function given by belongs to ; in particular, for all by Carathéodory’s lemma. The relation between the coefficients of and is expressed by the following well-known result; cf. [19], for example.
Lemma 21. Let and be analytic functions in such that , given by their respective power series and . Then
(a) and
(b) For a fixed integer , holds if and only if .
The following formula was described structurally in [19 Proposition 1] but had actually been known earlier to Lewandowski and Szynal [15 Lemma 1], whose detailed survey may not have received all the attention it deserved. The formula was stated there in a more precise form as follows.
Lemma 22. Let and be analytic functions in such that , given by their respective power series and . Assuming that is real and negative and writing and for , we have
We now have all the ingredients needed to prove Theorem 2, formulated in § 1.
Proof of Theorem 2. One implication is trivial, hence it suffices to prove that (a) implies (b). Assume that (a) holds. Since , it is a non-constant function in with , so it can be written as , where is analytic in , , and is real and negative. Writing again and for as in Lemma 22, we have , where and . By our assumption (a) and Lemma 21 (b), we have , that is, , so has a zero of order at least at the origin. Hence, Lemma 22 yields
We will show that for an -tuple of indices if and only if either or there exists such that if (respectively, if ) and all the remaining indices are zero. These are exactly the solutions with ; if , we would have that
which is impossible by the choice of . Then (12) becomes
(note that every product with appears twice in the sum, while for even the term appears once and comes with the factor in (12)). We may apply Lemma 19 for , with (note that ) and Lemma 20 for , also with , to conclude that
A straightforward computation shows that
The maximum of the expression on the left is only attained when , while the maximum on the right is attained only at . Thus, , and readily follows from the chain of inequalities (the first one holds since and )
Moreover, , so equality must hold in all the estimates above; in particular, and equality holds in (10) with .
To finish the proof, it remains to show that . Since and , we can write
for certain , with , and distinct points . Since equality holds in (10) for with , Lemma 19 shows that (hence, ) and that there is with for all . The power series expansion of yields
hence as well. Now Lemma 21 (b) readily implies that . Once we know this, the fact that is proved by following verbatim the proof of the implication (b) (c) of [19 Theorem 1], based on a simple use of a system of linear equations and the properties of the Vandermonde determinant. □
As already mentioned, the case of Theorem 2 is the following result of MacDonald [17]; our proof of it is independent of the one in [17].
Corollary 23. Let and let be a normalized extremal function for the Krzyż problem (1). If , then and .
Proof. By Theorem A, and is an extremal function for (6) with , for which . Thus, the statement is the case of Theorem 2. □
It should be noted that if the recent proof [26] is confirmed for , then this case in Theorem 2 will no longer represent a novelty.
AI disclosure
This project was started in 2024, well before the most recent advances in AI; AI tools were used only in the final stages of our work.
ChatGPT 5.6 Sol was used to simplify our original proof of Lemma 19. More precisely, it suggested the use of the Schur complement formula (Lemma 18) to simplify the notation. The original statement of Theorem 2 (a) included the extra assumption . ChatGPT 6 Astra provided the observation to be found in Lemma 20, which was then used to remove this extra condition. Example 10 in Section 3 was also suggested by ChatGPT 5.6 Sol.
Claude Opus 5.5 (Anthropic) and ChatGPT 6 Astra were used to proofread the manuscript. The former suggested various useful simplifications, improvements in exposition, and observations such as Remark 14.
Acknowledgments
The three authors are partially supported by PID2025-168349NB-I00 from Ministerio de Innovación, Ciencia y Universidades, Spain.
This work was partially supported by the project Pure Mathematics in Norway, funded by Trond Mohn Foundation and Tromsø Research Foundation. This work started when the first author was visiting Universidad Autónoma de Madrid and the first author would like to thank the university for the hospitality as well as Norges tekniske høgskoles fond for covering parts of this travel.
The second author is partially supported by PID2024-160326NA-I00, also from MICIU, and by CIGE/2026/195 from Conselleria d’Educació, Cultura i Universitats, Generalitat Valenciana, Spain.
Department of Mathematical Sciences, Norwegian University of Science and Technology, NO-7491 Trondheim, Norway Email address: [email protected]
Departamento de Matemáticas, Universidad Autónoma de Madrid, 28049 Madrid, Spain Email address: [email protected] URL: https://sites.google.com/view/adrian-llinares/home
Departamento de Matemáticas, Universidad Autónoma de Madrid, 28049 Madrid, Spain Email address: [email protected] URL: http://www.uam.es/dragan.vukotic
References
- [1]M. Abramowitz, I.A. Stegun, Handbook of Mathematical Functions with Formulas, Graphs, and Mathematical Tables, Dover, New York, 1970.
- [2]J. Agler, J.E. McCarthy, The Krzyż conjecture and an entropy conjecture, J. Anal. Math. 144 (2021), 207–226.DOI
- [3]C. Bénéteau and D. Khavinson, A survey of certain extremal problems for non-vanishing analytic functions, In: Complex and harmonic analysis, 45–61, DEStech Publ., Inc., Lancaster, PA, 2007.
- [4]J.E. Brown, On a coefficient problem for nonvanishing H^p functions, Complex Var. Theory Appl. 4 (1985), no. 2–3, 253–265.DOI
- [5]J.E. Brown, Iteration of functions subordinate to schlicht functions, Complex Var. Theory Appl. 9 (1987), 143–152.DOI
- [6]P.L. Duren, Univalent Functions, Springer-Verlag, New York, 1983.
- [7]I. Efraimidis, A generalization of Livingston’s coefficient inequalities for functions with positive real part, J. Math. Anal. Appl. 435 (2016), 369–379.DOI
- [8]I. Efraimidis, A. Llinares, M.J. Martín, E.T. Sawyer, I. Uriarte-Tuero, D. Vukotić, On extremal functions for the Krzyż conjecture, preprint, 2026.
- [9]R.J.P.M. Ermers, Coefficient estimates for bounded nonvanishing functions, Doctoral Thesis, Katholieke Universiteit Nijmegen, Wibro Dissertatiedrukkerij, Helmond, 1990.
- [10]C. Horowitz, Coefficients of nonvanishing functions in H∞, Israel J. Math. 30 (1978), 285–291.
- [11]J.A. Hummel, S. Scheinberg, and L. Zalcmann, A coefficient problem for bounded nonvanishing functions, J. Anal. Math. 31 (1977), 169–190.DOI
- [12]S.Ya. Khavinson, Two papers on extremal problems, AMS Translations, Providence, Rhode Island, 1986.DOI
- [13]J. Krzyż, Coefficient problem for bounded non-vanishing functions, Ann. Polon. Math. 20 (1968), 314–316.
- [14]J. Lei, T. Zhang, Proof of the Agler–McCarthy entropy conjecture, preprint, 2026, https://arxiv.org/abs/2605.03949.
- [15]Z. Lewandowski, J. Szynal, On the Krzyż conjecture and related problems, XIVth Rolf Nevanlinna Colloquium (Joensuu, 1995), 257–268, de Gruyter, Berlin, 1996.
- [16]A.E. Livingston, A coefficient inequality for functions of positive real part with an application to multivalent functions, Pacific J. Math. 120 (1985), no. 1, 139–151.DOI
- [17]S.F. MacDonald, Structural aspects of extremal functions in the Krzyż conjecture, preprint, 2026, https://arxiv.org/abs/2605.08411.
- [18]D.E. Marshall, personal communication with the third author.
- [19]M.J. Martín, E.T. Sawyer, I. Uriarte-Tuero, D. Vukotić, The Krzyż conjecture revisited, Adv. Math. 273 (2015), 716–745.DOI
- [20]S.V. Romanova, Estimates for functionals of bounded nonvanishing functions [Russian], Sibirsk. Mat. Zh. 44 (2003), no. 5, 1113–1123; translation in Siberian Math. J. 44 (2003), no. 5, 869–876.DOI
- [21]N. Samarias, A proof of Krzyż’s conjecture for the fifth coefficient, Complex Var. Theory Appl. 48 (2003), 753–766.
- [22]J. Schur, Über Potenzreihen die im Inneren des Einheitskreises beschränkt sind, J. Reine Angew. Math. 147 (1917), 205–232.
- [23]W. Szapiel, A new approach to the Krzyz conjecture, Workshop on Complex Analysis (Lublin, 1994), Ann. Univ. Mariae Curie-Sklodowska Sect. A 48 (1994), 169–192.
- [24]D.L. Tan, Coefficient estimates for bounded nonvanishing functions (Chinese), Chinese Ann. Math. Ser. A 4 (1983), 97–104.
- [25]M. Tsuji, Potential Theory in Modern Function Theory, Maruzen, Tokyo, 1959.
- [26]F. Wikström, A computer-assisted proof of Krzyż’s conjecture for the sixth coefficient, preprint, 2026, https://arxiv.org/abs/2610.15206.