betaFeedback

WorksMathematics

Absolutely universal projective embeddings of long-root geometries of orthogonal type

Abstract

Let GG be a split Chevalley group of type BnB_n (n≥3n \geq 3) or DnD_n (n≥4n \geq 4), let LL be its Lie algebra and ΓΓ its long-root geometry, namely ΓΓ is the line-grassmannian of the polar space associated to GG. It is well known that LL hosts a projective embedding of ΓΓ, called the adjoint embedding, which realizes ΓΓ as a projective variety in the projective geometry of the underlying vector space of LL. It is also known that ΓΓ admits the absolutely universal projective embedding, which is such that all projective embeddings of ΓΓ can be obtained from it as projections. When the field FF over which GG is defined is finite, the universal embedding of ΓΓ is just the same as the adjoint embedding. The same is not necessarily true when FF is infinite. Indeed, as we shall prove in this paper, the universal projective embedding of ΓΓ lives in a direct sum K⊕LK\oplus L for an FF-vector space KK, the dual of which is isomorphic to the derivation space Der(F)\mathrm{Der}(F) of FF, which in general is non-trivial. Accordingly, the adjoint embedding of ΓΓ is universal if and only if Der(F)\mathrm{Der}(F) is trivial, namely FF is either perfect of positive characteristic or algebraic over its minimum subfield.

The objects to be considered in this paper

In this paper we shall study some problems concerning projective embeddings of Lie geometries. First of all we must explain what we are talking about, what embeddings and Lie geometries are.

Projective embeddings

Projective embeddings. In this subsection we recall some basics on projective embeddings of point-line geometries, referring the reader to Shult [23] and [24 Chp. 4] and Ronan [22] for more on this topic.

Let Γ=(P,L)\Gamma= (P, L) be a point-line geometry, with PP a the point-set and LL as the set of lines. We assume that Γ\Gamma is connected, namely its collinearity graph is connected, and no two lines of Γ\Gamma are incident with the same set of points; thus we can regard the lines of Γ\Gamma as subsets of PP.

A projective embedding of Γ\Gamma (also embedding for short) is an injective mapping ee from PP to the point-set of the projective geometry PG⁡(V)\operatorname{PG}(V) of a vector space VV, such that the image e(P)e(P) of PP spans PG⁡(V)\operatorname{PG}(V) and every line of Γ\Gamma, regarded as a subset of PP, is mapped by ee onto a line of PG⁡(V)\operatorname{PG}(V). If K\mathbb{K} is the underlying division ring of VV, we say that ee is defined over K\mathbb{K}.

Henceforth, although ee maps Γ\Gamma onto a subgeometry of PG⁡(V)\operatorname{PG}(V), we write e:Γ→Ve:\Gamma\to V to mean that ee embeds Γ\Gamma in PG⁡(V)\operatorname{PG}(V). We will also freely use expressions as “ee embeds Γ\Gamma in VV”, “ee lives in VV” or “VV hosts ee” which, although incorrect, streamline the exposure a bit. Accordingly, we call dim⁡(V)\dim(V) the dimension of ee and we denote it by dim⁡(e)\dim(e).

We say that a geometry is embeddable if it admits an embedding as defined above. In other words, a point-line geometry is embeddable if it can be realized as a projective variety in such a way that its lines are some (possibly not all) of the projective lines contained in that variety. Obviously, a geometry is embeddable only if no two of its lines share more than one point and all of its lines have the same size (which, in the finite case, must be equal to a prime power augmented by 1).

Covers and projections of embeddings

With Γ\Gamma as above, for i=1,2i = 1, 2 let ei:Γ→Vie_i : \Gamma\to V_i be an embedding of Γ\Gamma. We say that e1e_1 covers e2e_2 (also that e2e_2 is a projection of e1e_1) if e1e_1 and e2e_2 are defined over the same division ring and there exists a semi-linear mapping f:V1→V2f : V_1 \to V_2 such that e2=pg⁡(f)∘e1e_2 = \operatorname{pg}(f) \circ e_1, where ∘\circ stands for composition and pg⁡(f):PG⁡(V1)→PG⁡(V2)\operatorname{pg}(f) : \operatorname{PG}(V_1) \to\operatorname{PG}(V_2) is the morphism of projective geometries associated to ff.

The semi-linear mapping ff such that e2=pg⁡(f)∘e1e_2 = \operatorname{pg}(f) \circ e_1, if it exists, is uniquely determined by e1e_1 and e2e_2 up to scalars, namely the morphism pg⁡(f)\operatorname{pg}(f) is unique. (This uniqueness property follows from the connectedness of Γ\Gamma.) Note also that ff is surjective, as it follows from the fact that pg⁡(f)\operatorname{pg}(f) maps e1(P)e_1(P) bijectively onto e2(P)e_2(P) and e2(P)e_2(P) spans PG⁡(V2)\operatorname{PG}(V_2). We call pg⁡(f)\operatorname{pg}(f) the projection of e1e_1 onto e2e_2 and the kernel of ff is the kernel of this projection. Clearly, the kernel of pg⁡(f)\operatorname{pg}(f) is skew with every line of PG⁡(V1)\operatorname{PG}(V_1) joining two distinct points of e1(P)e_1(P). Conversely, every subspace of V1V_1 with this property is the kernel of suitable projections of e1e_1.

If e1e_1 covers e2e_2 we write e1≥e2e_1 \geq e_2. If ff (equivalently, pg⁡(f)\operatorname{pg}(f)) is bijective then we say that e1e_1 and e2e_2 are isomorphic and we write e1≅e2e_1 \cong e_2. If e1≥e2≇e1e_1 \geq e_2 \not\cong e_1 then we say that e1e_1 properly covers e2e_2. Clearly, e1≥e2≥e1e_1 \geq e_2 \geq e_1 iff e1≅e2e_1 \cong e_2.

Absolutely and relatively universal embeddings

An embedding of Γ\Gamma absolutely universal (absolute for short) if it covers all embeddings of Γ\Gamma. Clearly, the absolute embedding, if it exists, is unique up to isomorphisms. It is also clear that a geometry Γ\Gamma admits the absolute embedding only if all of its embeddings are defined over the same division ring.

An embedding e^:Γ→V^\widehat{e} : \Gamma\to\widehat{V} is relatively universal if it admits no proper cover. Equivalently, for every projection ee of e^\widehat{e}, the embedding e^\widehat{e} also covers all embeddings which cover ee (Ronan [22]). If ee is an embedding of Γ\Gamma and e^≥e\widehat{e} \geq e is relatively universal then, up to isomorphism, e^\widehat{e} is the unique relatively universal embedding that covers ee. We call it the universal cover of ee.

The absolute embedding, when it exists, might be regarded as the best one. If no absolute embedding exists for a given embeddable geometry, then we must be happy with relatively universal embeddings; every embeddable geometry admits them, as stated in the next proposition, due to Ronan [22]. The proof amounts to an elementary free contruction; we will recall it in Appendix B.

Proposition 1.1. Every embedding admits the universal cover.

Clearly absolute embeddings are relatively universal. An absolute embedding of a given geometry Γ\Gamma is indeed the universal cover of all embeddings of Γ\Gamma. So, Γ\Gamma admits the absolute embedding if and only if all of its embeddings admit the same universal cover. However this characterization is of little use to check if a given embeddable geometry does admit the absolute embedding. Sufficient conditions for the existence of the absolute embedding have been found by Kasikova and Shult [18], but I am not going to recall them here.

Homogeneity

Given a projective embedding e:Γ→Ve : \Gamma\to V and an automorphism gg of Γ\Gamma, the composite mapping e∘ge \circ g is still an embedding of Γ\Gamma in VV, with the same image as ee. If e∘g≅ee \circ g \cong e then we say that gg lifts to PG⁡(V)\operatorname{PG}(V) through ee and the unique isomorphism e(g)e(g) from ee to e∘ge \circ g is called the lifting of gg. Clearly e(g)e(g), as a collineation of PG⁡(V)\operatorname{PG}(V), stabilizes the image e(Γ)e(\Gamma) of ee. Also, every automorphism of Γ\Gamma admits at most one lifting through ee to PG⁡(V)\operatorname{PG}(V). If all elements of a subgroup GG of Aut⁡(Γ)\operatorname{Aut}(\Gamma) lift to PG⁡(V)\operatorname{PG}(V) through ee then we say that ee is GG-homogeneous (also homogeneous for short when G=Aut⁡(Γ)G = \operatorname{Aut}(\Gamma)). If ee is GG-homogeneous then the liftings of the elements of GG form an isomorphic copy e(G)e(G) of GG in the group of all collineations of PG⁡(V)\operatorname{PG}(V).

Clearly, absolutely universal embeddings are homogeneous and, if an embedding e:Γ→Ve:\Gamma\to V is GG-homogeneous for some subgroup GG of Aut⁡(Γ)\operatorname{Aut}(\Gamma), then its universal cover is GG-homogeneous as well.

So far we have assumed that GG is a subgroup of Aut⁡(Γ)\operatorname{Aut}(\Gamma), namely GG acts faithfully on Γ\Gamma. Suppose now that the action of GG on Γ\Gamma is possibly unfaithful. We say that GG lifts to VV through ee and that ee is linearly GG-homogeneous if GG also acts (possibly unfaithfully) on VV as a group of linear transformations (hence on PG⁡(V)\operatorname{PG}(V) too as a group of linear collineations), the kernel of the action of GG on Γ\Gamma is equal to the kernel of the action of GG on PG⁡(V)\operatorname{PG}(V) and the group induced by GG on PG⁡(V)\operatorname{PG}(V) is the lifting through ee of the subgroup of Aut⁡(Γ)\operatorname{Aut}(\Gamma) induced by GG on Γ\Gamma.

The next proposition easily follows from Ronan’s construction of the universal cover of an embedding (Appendix B).

Proposition 1.2. Let e^:Γ→V^\widehat{e}:\Gamma\to\widehat{V} be the universal cover of an embedding e:Γ→Ve:\Gamma\to V of a geometry Γ\Gamma. Suppose that ee is linearly GG-homogeneous for some group GG acting on Γ\Gamma. Then e^\widehat{e} is also linearly GG-homogeneous, the lifting of GG to V^\widehat{V} stabilizes the kernel K=ker⁡(π)K=\ker(\pi) of the projection π\pi of e^\widehat{e} onto ee and the action of GG on the quotient space V^/K\widehat{V}/K is mapped by π\pi onto the action of GG on VV.

Lie geometries

Lie geometries arise from spherical buildings. At least two settings are possible for the theory of buildings. In this paper we follow the one originally chosen by Tits in [29]. In this setting, Lie geometries are defined as follows.

Given a building Δ\Delta of spherical type and rank at least 2, let JJ be a nonempty subset of the set of types of Δ\Delta. Following Tits [29 Chp. 12], we define a point-line geometry ΔJ\Delta_J as follows: the points of ΔJ\Delta_J are the flags of Δ\Delta of type JJ while the lines are the flags of type j~∪(J∖{j})\widetilde{j}\cup(J\setminus\{j\}), where j∈Jj\in J and j~\widetilde{j} is the adjacency of jj in the Coxeter diagram of Δ\Delta, a point XX and a line YY of ΔJ\Delta_J being incident in ΔJ\Delta_J if they are incident as flags of Δ\Delta. The geometries constructed in this way are called geometries of Lie type in the literature, also Lie geometries for short. They are connected and no two of their lines have more than one point in common.

1.2.1. A few examples. 1. Let Δ\Delta be a building of Coxeter type CnC_n, n≥3n\ge3. Take the integers 1, 2, ..., nn as types as in the picture below. If we put J={1}J=\{1\} then we obtain the polar space Δ1\Delta_1 associated to Δ\Delta while Δn\Delta_n is a dual polar space, dual of Δ1\Delta_1 (here and henceforth, when JJ is a singleton, say J={j}J=\{j\}, we write Δj\Delta_j for short instead of Δ{j}\Delta_{\{j\}}). Put J={2}J=\{2\}; the points of Δ2\Delta_2 are the lines of the polar space Δ1\Delta_1 and the lines of Δ2\Delta_2 are the point-plane flags of Δ1\Delta_1. The geometry Δ2\Delta_2 is called the line grassmannian of the polar space Δ1\Delta_1.

Figure 1.

References

  1. [1]R. J. Blok. The generating rank of the symplectic line-grassmannian, Beitr. Algebra Geom., 44 (2003), 575–580.
  2. [4]R. J. Blok and A. Pasini. Point-line geometries with a generating set that depends on the underlying field, in: Finite Geometries (eds. A. Blokhuis et al.), Kluwer, Dordrecht (2001), 1–25.DOI
  3. [5]R. J. Blok and A. Pasini. On absolutely universal embeddings, Discr. Math. 267 (2003), 45–62.DOI
  4. [6]I. Cardinali, L. Giuzzi and A. Pasini. On the generation of polar grassmannians, in Algebraic Combinatorics and the Moster Group (ed. A. A. Ivanov), London Math. Soc. L.N. 487, Cambridge Univ. Press, Cambridge (2024), 327–368.
  5. [7]I. Cardinali, L. Giuzzi and A. Pasini. The relatively universal cover of the natural embedding of the long root geometry for the group SL(n + 1, K), Alg. Combin. 9 (2026), 231-259.DOI
  6. [8]B. N. Cooperstein. Generating long root subgroup geometries of classical groups over finite prime fields, Bull. Belg. Math. Soc. 5 (1998), 531–548.DOI
  7. [10]B. N. Cooperstein. Generation of embeddable incidence geometries: a survey, in Topics in Diagram Geometry (ed. A. Pasini), Vol. 12 of the series Quaderni di Matematica, II Univ. Naples (2003), 29–57.
  8. [13]A. De Schepper, J. Schillewaert and H. van Maldeghem. On the generating rank and embeding rank of the hexagon Lie incidence geometries, Combinatorica 44 (2024), 355–392.
  9. [14]L. Giuzzi and A. Pasini. Non existence of absolutely universal embeddings of certain Lie incidence geometries, in preparation.
  10. [15]M. Hall Jr. The Theory of Groups, Macmillan, New York, 1959.DOI
  11. [16]J. E. Humphreys, Introduction to Lie Algebras and Representation Theory, Springer, 1972.DOI
  12. [17]J. E. Humphreys, Modular Representations of Finite Groups of Lie Type, Cambridge Univ. Press, 2006.DOI
  13. [18]A. Kasikova and E. E. Shult, Absolute embeddings of point-line geometries, J. Algebra 238 (2001), 265–291.DOI
  14. [19]P. Li. On the universal embedding of the Sp₂n(2) dual polar space, J. Combin. Th. A 94 (2001), 100-117.DOI
  15. [20]P. Li. On the Universal Embedding of the U₂n(2) dual polar space, J. Combin. Th. A 98 (2002), 235-252.DOI
  16. [21]A. Pasini. Embeddings and hyperplanes of the Lie incidence geometry Aₙ,{1,n}(F), Comb. Theory, 4, No. 2 (2024), paper No. 5.
  17. [22]M. A. Ronan. Embeddings and hyperplanes of discrete geometries European J. Combin. 8 (1987), 179–185.DOI
  18. [23]E. E. Shult. Embeddings and hyperplanes of Lie incidence geometries, in Groups of Lie Type and Their Geometries (ed. W. M. Kantor and L. Di Martino), London Math. Soc. Lect. Notes 207, Cambridge Univ. Press, Cambridge 1995, 215-232.DOI
  19. [24]E. E. Shult. Points and Lines, Springer-Verlag, Berlin 2011.
  20. [26]S.D. Smith and H. Völklein. A geometric presentation for the adjoint module of SL₃(K), J. Algebra 127 (1989), 127–138.DOI
  21. [27]O. Taussky and H. Zassenhaus. On the 1-cohomology of the general and special linear groups, Aequationes Math. 5 (1970), 129-201.DOI
  22. [28]J. A. Thas and H. Van Maldeghem. Classification of embeddings of the flag geometries of projective planes in finite projective planes, Parts I, II and III, J. Combin. Th. A, 90 (2000), 159–172 (Part I), 241–256 (Part II) and 173–196 (Part III).
  23. [29]J. Tits. Buildings of Spherical Type and Finite BN pairs, Springer L. N. in Maths. 386, Springer-Verlag, Berlin 1974.DOI
  24. [30]H. Völklein. The 1-Cohomology group of the Adjoint Module of a Chevalley Group, Forum Math. 1 (1989), 1-13.
  25. [31]H. Völklein. On the geometry of the adjoint representation of a Chevalley group, J. Algebra 127 (1989), 139–154.DOI

Paper details

vlnc:W_t46xuxp5
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 7

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Mathematics

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents