betaFeedback

WorksPhysics and Astronomy

Heterostructure morphology stability maps in multiphase nanoparticles

Abstract

In the rapidly growing field of nanocombinatorics, the advent of megalibraries of multiphase nanoparticles (NPs) has created a need for predictive computational approaches. A notable characteristic of multiphase NPs is the internal interface architecture that arises from the joining of constituent phases at boundaries. We propose a strategy to predict the ground-state interface architecture from the DFT-calculated surface and interfacial energies of all constituent phases as input and use this strategy to create stability maps to predict multiphase NP morphologies. A Potts model, a qq-state generalization of the Ising model, in which q−1q-1 spins represent discretized regions of a constituent phase, provides a flexible, discretized representation of a (q−1)(q-1)-phase nanoparticle with arbitrary interfacial join morphology. Interactions between spins represent interactions between phases, or interfacial energies. To model the surface of a nanoparticle, an additional spin represents the surrounding environment and interaction energies with this spin are surface energies. We apply a Monte Carlo algorithm to search for the lowest-energy spin configuration. The trade-off between surface and interfacial energy minimization drives the formation of an interface morphology. We calculate a biphase nanoparticle interface morphology stability map to study the relation between the three biphase morphologies we found. Next, we use the stability map to predict NP morphologies of sample biphase systems and compare these to experimentally available data. We repeat the grid search approach for triphase nanoparticle interface morphologies and discover 11 triphase morphologies, nine more than previously enumerated. We then predict sample triphase systems and finally revisit experimentally reported triphase morphologies.

calculate a biphase nanoparticle interface morphology stability map to study the relation between the three biphase morphologies we found. Next, we use the stability map to predict NP morphologies of sample biphase systems and compare these to experimentally available data. We repeat the grid search approach for triphase nanoparticle interface morphologies and discover 11 triphase morphologies, nine more than previously enumerated. We then predict sample triphase systems and finally revisit experimentally reported triphase morphologies.

Nanostructures exhibit valuable optical, chemical, electronic, and magnetic properties applicable in catalysis, [1] plasmonics,[2, 3, 4, 5] medicine and therapeutics, [6, 7] and information storage.[7, 8] Introducing multiple metals improves the catalytic, [1, 9, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 15, 16] optical, [17, 18] electronic, [17, 18] plasmonic, [5, 19, 20] and magnetic[7, 8] properties of monometallic nanostructures, resulting in the formation of multicomponent nanoparticles (NPs). Multicomponent NPs can be single-phase or phase-separate to form multiphase NPs. The internal interfaces that arise between different phases within these multicomponent NPs hold promise for enhancing electronic, [17, 21] plasmonic,[5, 18] and catalytic[12, 19] properties through techniques such as charge transfer tuning and strain engineering[18, 19, 20, 21, 22, 23] as well as defect engineering. [24] Internal domain morphology and distribution become important in catalytic, [25, 26] energy conversion, [17] and biomedical applications,[17, 21] thus warranting further investigation. Researchers are developing nanoparticle megalibraries to expedite the discovery of new multiphase nanoparticles. [20, 22, 27, 28, 29, 30, 31, 32] While previous theoretical works have studied sample nanoparticle systems, [20, 33, 34] a comprehensive study of how domain interfacial and surface energies interplay to shape internal NP morphology remains unexplored.

While many studies attribute lattice mismatch as the driving force of multicomponent nanoparticle architecture, [12, 17, 18, 33] quantitative examination of the role of interfacial and surface energies is still under study. [20, 22, 33] To determine the lowest-energy internal interface morphology within multiphase NPs, Chen et al. proposed an idealized geometry-based method.[20] Chen et al. use eq. (1), reproduced here, to calculate NP total energy by summing the surface and interfacial energies of a particle’s domains; or in the case of multiphase NPs, of the constituent phases. In eq. (1), ii and jj represent a constituent phase of an nn-phase NP, thereby taking on values between 1 and nn. The total energy EE of the NP is the sum of the surface energies and the interfacial energies of the constituent phases multiplied by their corresponding surface and interfacial areas. The surface energy of a domain ii is the surface energy per unit area of phase ii, γi\gamma_i, multiplied by the corresponding surface area, AiA_i. The interfacial energy of domains ii and jj, is the interfacial energy per unit area, σij\sigma_{ij}, of phases ii and jj multiplied by the shared interfacial area, AijA_{ij}. Evaluating eq. (1) requires (i) the identity of the phases, ii and jj, (ii) their corresponding surface energies γi\gamma_i, (iii) interfacial energies σij\sigma_{ij}, and (iv) the corresponding surface (Ai,Aj)(A_i, A_j) and interfacial areas AijA_{ij}.

E=∑i=1n(γiAi+(∑j>inσijAij))(1)E = \sum_{i=1}^{n} \left(\gamma_i A_i + \left(\sum_{j>i}^{n} \sigma_{ij} A_{ij}\right)\right) \tag*{(1)}
Sketch accompanying eq. 1 showing the surface and interfacial energies of a multiphase NP

Figure 1. Sketch accompanying eq. (1) to calculate the total energy of a multiphase NP. The total energy is the sum of the surface and interfacial energies of the phases α\alpha, β\beta, δ\delta.

To determine the values of γi\gamma_i and σij\sigma_{ij}, and hence EE, we first need the identities of the phases ii and jj. The grand canonical linear programming (GCLP) [35] approach implemented within the Open Quantum Materials Database (OQMD) [36, 37] calculates the T=0T = 0 K thermodynamically stable ground-state, bulk phases from the elemental composition, which we use to determine the total number of domains nn as well as their identity. We note the OQMD does not include solid solutions, so the results of this approach do not capture their formation within a NP. The results from Ref. 20 suggest that this limitation does not have a significant impact on the predicted internal NP morphology. We use Density Functional Theory (DFT) to calculate the surface (γ\gamma) and interfacial energies (σ\sigma) of each phase. Although DFT evaluates these energies under T=0T = 0 K conditions, using these has previously worked well in modeling experimental NP morphologies.[20, 38]

The total energy of the morphology is then determined by the values of AiA_i and AijA_{ij}, or the surface and interfacial areas of the constituent phase domains. Prior work obtained AiA_i and AijA_{ij} analytically for highly idealized geometries, and the simplifying assumption of equivolume amounts of each phase. The distribution of phases within the NP affects the values of AiA_i and AijA_{ij}, which impacts the calculated NP total energy. To find the lowest-energy morphology configuration, one can enumerate the possible domain distributions and use simple geometric relations to calculate AiA_i and AijA_{ij}. When applying eq. (1) to each enumerated morphology, Chen et al. showed in select triphase cases (Au–Co–Pd3_3Sn, Ag–Cu–Co) that the lowest-energy morphology calculated coincides with the experimentally observed morphology,[20, 38] implying that the use of an idealized geometry model in conjunction with DFT to solve eq. (1) is a remarkably good simple approximation of the total energy of multicomponent nanoparticles.

To find the stable NP morphology with minimum total energy, we must minimize EE with respect to AiA_i and AijA_{ij}. Since ii and jj are decided by the NP composition, so are γi\gamma_i and σij\sigma_{ij}. The remaining optimizable parameter is the area that each phase occupies, or the surface and interfacial area terms AiA_i and AijA_{ij}. As morphologies become more complicated, such as the tetra-phase nanoparticles illustrated in Figure S1 in Ref. 20, the analytical calculation of AiA_i and AijA_{ij} becomes difficult. Furthermore, this method limits the search for the lowest-energy configuration among the configurations that are manually enumerated; however, it is plausible that the lowest-energy morphology may be missed during manual enumeration. We need an improved method to explore all non-idealized geometries of interface configurations while minimizing the NP total energy.

We propose the Potts model, a generalized qq-state Ising model,[39, 40, 41] as a discretized, coarse-grained representation of multiphase nanoparticles, and minimize it with a spinconserved Metropolis Monte Carlo (MC) algorithm, [42, 43] or equivalently Kawasaki exchange dynamics, to search for the ground-state interface morphology. In our proposed Potts model, each qq spin state represents membership to a domain, [44, 45] and the model has previously been applied to a range of boundary-driven phenomena, including grain growth, 46 Ostwald ripening, [47, 48] foam evolution, [45, 49] bubble evolution, crystallization, and nucleation. [44, 50] These applications share a common physical basis: the Potts model evolves toward the configuration that minimizes total boundary area, [44] which is precisely the quantity that governs NP interface morphology in eq. (1). MC search is well suited to this minimization because it can efficiently explore high-dimensional configuration spaces [51] without requiring prior knowledge of the energy landscape.

To map a multicomponent NP onto the Potts model, we define a spin state, qq, as representing the identity of a phase. The nn-phase NP is mapped onto a Potts lattice surrounded by some environment. Because we represent the environment as an additional spin, we use an (n+1)(n+1)-spin Potts model, and each lattice point represents a discretized volume of space. The energy of the system becomes a discretized version of eq. (1), or a sum of nearest-neighbor (NN) and next-nearest-neighbor (NNN) interactions described by the Hamiltonian in eq. (2). The additional shell of NNN interactions mitigates lattice anisotropy effects. [44] The surface and interfacial energies of the constituent phases set the interaction energy between lattice sites, held in the zero-diagonal symmetric matrix, JqmqnJ_{q_mq_n}, which represents interfacial energies when qmq_m, qnq_n (spins on lattice sites mm and nn, respectively) are phases and surface energies when either represents the environment.

H=12∑m,nNN, NNNJqmqn(1−δqmqn)(2)H = \frac{1}{2} \sum_{m,n}^{\mathrm{NN,\,NNN}} J_{q_mq_n}(1-\delta_{q_mq_n}) \tag*{(2)}

The identity of the phases, represented by values of qq, is determined via methods such as GCLP, as described previously. [35, 36, 37] To capture the phase-separation effects observed in multiphase NPs, like interactions in the Potts model must be energetically favorable. Equation 1 accounts for this via its zero-energy internal energy of each phase. In the Potts model, this is replicated by using zero-energy like spin interactions, or internal energy of each phase, that do not contribute to the NP total energy. This approach is also used in computational grain evolution studies to reduce computational cost, particularly when the interface is the region of interest. [45] We use the Kronecker delta, δ\delta, to discount the internal energy: δ\delta takes spin states qmq_m and qnq_n as inputs and is valued at 1 when they are the same and valued at 0 otherwise. Multiplying the interaction energy matrix JqmqnJ_{q_m q_n} by a (1−δqmqn)(1-\delta_{q_m q_n}) term ensures that only unlike spin interactions contribute to the total energy of the particle,

and we multiply the overall sum by a factor of one-half to correct for double counting of pairwise lattice interactions. The result is a discretized total energy equation, eq. 2, in the familiar form of a Monte Carlo Hamiltonian, which we minimize using a Metropolis Monte Carlo algorithm. [42, 43]

We solve for the ground-state spin configuration – equivalently, the ground-state NP interface morphology – using the methodology illustrated in Figure 2. After determining the number and identity of the constituent phases (denoted here as A and B), we initialize a lattice with randomly distributed spins representing finite amounts of A, B, and Environment. We input sample surface and interfacial energies into JqmqnJ_{q_mq_n}, then evolve the lattice under the spin-conserved Metropolis algorithm with eq. 2 as the Hamiltonian, using a simulated annealing approach to avoid entrapment in local minima. We categorize the final spin configuration both visually and quantitatively from the spin-state distribution, into a ground-state interface morphology. We repeat this procedure at least five times per input parameter configuration, using five different random initial lattices, to sample the energy landscape at each point. As we show later, this approach recovers complex morphologies that would be difficult to enumerate manually or express with a simple idealized geometric relation for AiA_i and AijA_{ij}. We first apply this approach to biphase morphologies and find that the inclusion of transitional morphologies causes significant shifts in the stability map boundaries. We then apply a Monte Carlo Potts (MCP) model to triphase particles and find a substantially richer morphology landscape than previously assumed.

Schematic of the proposed Monte Carlo Potts model applied to multiphase nanoparticle interface morphology determination

Figure 2. Schematic of the proposed Monte Carlo Potts model applied to multiphase nanoparticle interface morphology determination with illustrated inputs and outputs. (A) The identity of the phases, their volume fractions, and their pairwise interaction energies (i.e. surface and interfacial energies) are input to a Monte Carlo Potts model, which calculates the ground-state interface morphology from the inputs. The Potts model has lattice points representing an integrated region of space of each phase. (B) Schematic of a sample biphase calculation. The Potts model is initialized by distributing spins, each representing membership to a phase A, B, C, etc., across a lattice. The pairwise interaction energies of the spins are surface and interfacial energies. A spin-conserved Metropolis Monte Carlo algorithm is applied to the Potts model to minimize eq. (1) via its discretized form, the Hamiltonian in eq. (2). The resulting ordered lattice is schematized to determine the NP interface morphology of the constituent phases of the NP.

Results

We use the MCP model to calculate NP morphology stability maps, then use them to predict NP morphologies, and subsequently compare the predictions with their experimentally observed counterparts. We first present biphase NPs followed by triphase NPs.

Biphase nanoparticle interface morphologies and stability map

We sampled interface morphologies by varying surface and interfacial energies, from which we calculated a stability map of biphase nanoparticle interface morphologies. Creating a biphase stability map requires the surface energies of the two phases and their interfacial energy, so we normalize the surface and interfacial energies by the largest surface energy to reduce the number of parameters to two. For example, take sample phases A and B, with phase A having the higher surface energy. The energy of the system is described using parameters γB/γA\gamma_{B}/\gamma_{A} and σAB/γA\sigma_{AB}/\gamma_{A}, so that the interaction energy matrix Jqmqn=(01γB/γA10σAB/γAγB/γAσAB/γA0)J_{q_mq_n} = \begin{pmatrix} 0 & 1 & \gamma_{B}/\gamma_{A} \\ 1 & 0 & \sigma_{AB}/\gamma_{A} \\ \gamma_{B}/\gamma_{A} & \sigma_{AB}/\gamma_{A} & 0 \end{pmatrix}. Normalization using this convention imposes the constraint that γB/γA\gamma_{B}/\gamma_{A} must be less than or equal to 1. Indeed, we find the inverted solution for values γB/γA>1\gamma_{B}/\gamma_{A} > 1 — the same spin arrangement with the identities of A and B swapped. In the remainder of this paper, we will label phases alphabetically by decreasing surface energies such that γA≥γB\gamma_{A} \ge\gamma_{B}. MCP assumes phase-segregating phases, which adds the constraint that the interfacial energy parameter, σAB\sigma_{AB}, must be greater than the internal bulk energy, 0. If the interfacial energy were negative, the two phases would mix in our Potts model, which would result in a new phase requiring a new spin representation. Furthermore, though we expect interfacial energies to be lower than surface energies [52] — otherwise a surface would always preferably form over an interface, and no interface would form — which would result in an upper bound of σAB/γA<1\sigma_{AB}/\gamma_{A} < 1, we later show that exploring values above 1 is necessary to recover all morphology phase boundaries. The biphase morphology stability map is thus constructed as a function of γB/γA\gamma_{B}/\gamma_{A} and σAB/γA\sigma_{AB}/\gamma_{A}, within the limits of γB/γA≤1\gamma_{B}/\gamma_{A} \le1 and σAB/γA>0\sigma_{AB}/\gamma_{A} > 0.

We input sample combinations of γB/γA\gamma_{B}/\gamma_{A} and σAB/γA\sigma_{AB}/\gamma_{A} into MCP in a grid search fashion to construct the biphase NP stability map. We categorize MCP-calculated biphase particles into three different interface morphologies, shown with their sample MCP outputs and idealized schematics in Table 1. The Core@Shell (CS) consists of a core surrounded by a shell of the other phase, sharing one interface; only the shell domain has a surface. The Janus (J) morphology is a single particle split into two side-by-side domains that share an interface, with each domain retaining its own surface. The 2 separate particles (2p) morphology consists of two fully separate single-phase particles, each with its own surface and no shared interface between them. The Janus morphology additionally exhibits two transitional architectures, both observed experimentally: [1, 14, 19, 53, 54, 55] the Lens-type morphology, in which the core domain contacts the environment but exposes less surface than in the idealized Janus case – placing it on the boundary between Janus and Core@Shell – and the Dumbbell morphology, in which the particle is pinched along the interface, increasing surface area and decreasing interfacial area relative to idealized Janus. Both are topologically equivalent to Janus but capture variations in interface character that the discretized Potts lattice resolves and that the idealized geometry approach cannot.

Beyond the classification in Table 1, the discretized lattice lets us classify each MCP output quantitatively from the number of A−BA-B, A−EnvironmentA-\text{Environment}, and B−EnvironmentB-\text{Environment} nearest-neighbor spin interactions in the final configuration. A morphology is Core@Shell when one of the A−EnvironmentA-\text{Environment} or B−EnvironmentB-\text{Environment} counts is zero; the phase with zero environment contacts is the core, confirmed by the other phase’s environment-contact count being much larger than the A−BA-B count. A morphology falls into the Janus family when all three contact types are nonzero, with their relative magnitudes distinguishing the three variants: Lens-type occurs when one environment-contact count is close to zero and the A−BA-B count approaches the Core@Shell value; idealized Janus occurs when the two environment-contact counts are approximately equal; and Dumbbell occurs when both environment-contact counts are again approximately equal but larger than in the idealized Janus case, with a correspondingly smaller A−BA-B count. Finally, 2p is identified when the A−BA-B count is zero and both environment-contact counts are at their maximum. Figure 3 illustrates this quantitative classification, where we observe discontinuous changes of A−EnvironmentA-\text{Environment} interactions along which we can draw a boundary representing the transition from one NP morphology to another.

Biphase NP morphology stability maps for 2D square and 3D cubic lattices

Figure 3. Biphase NP morphology stability maps calculated with MCP on a (A) 2D square lattice and (B) 3D cubic lattice, as a function of γB/γA\gamma_{B}/\gamma_{A} and σAB/γA\sigma_{AB}/\gamma_{A}. The output lattices are described in terms of the number of A–B, A–Environment, and B–Environment NN interactions, normalized by the total number of interactions in the lattice points occupied by the NP; the shading shows the percentage of A–Environment interactions. We define NP morphology boundaries (dashed lines) along the discontinuous changes in the amount of A–Environment and A–B interactions, which correspond to changes in NP morphology. Points I–V mark the sample inputs and the corresponding MCP output, schematic, and morphology (Core@Shell, Lens-type, Janus, Dumbbell, and 2p) shown at right.

These morphologies are mapped onto a stability map which captures the effect of surface

MorphologyTypeSample MCP outputIdealized Morphology# of surfaces# of interfaces
Core@ShellCS[red core surrounded by blue shell][blue sphere with red core]11
Lens-type (transitional)J[red lens-like region within blue particle][blue sphere with pink lens-like region]21
JanusJ[red and blue adjoining regions][sphere divided into pink and blue regions]21
Dumbbell (transitional)J[red and blue adjoining particles][pink and blue adjoining spheres]21
2p2pnPnP[separate red and blue particles][separate pink and blue spheres]20

Table 1. Biphase morphology descriptions. This table contains the names, visualizations, and characteristics of three topologically distinct biphase particle morphologies and two transition morphologies. The names of the morphologies are followed by categorical type: Core@Shell (CS), Janus (J, including the Lens-type and Dumbbell transition morphologies), and nn separate particles (nPnP). Then, a sample MCP model output and a schematic of the idealized morphology, and finally the number of surfaces and interfaces each morphology exhibits, which allows for morphology categorization while illustrating the range of architectures biphase morphologies exhibit.

and interfacial energies on morphology, with phase boundaries representing a change in ground-state morphology. Although these plots are interface morphology phase diagrams, with the boundaries between them representing boundaries between morphologies, we will refer to the diagrams as stability maps and to the morphology boundary curves as phase boundaries for simplicity. We calculated a biphase morphology stability map by inputting combinations of γB/γA\gamma_B/\gamma_A and σAB/γA\sigma_{AB}/\gamma_A, each ranging from 0.005 to 1 as parameters into the MCP model to calculate the location of the phase boundaries between the morphologies discovered. To investigate the dependence of the formation of two separate particles on interfacial energy, we later input values of σAB/γA\sigma_{AB}/\gamma_A beyond 1 into the MCP model. MCP morphology outputs reveal internal interface morphology changes with input surface and interfacial energies of the constituent phases, which form the phase boundaries in Figure 3. We calculate the biphase stability maps using a 2-dimensional square lattice (Figure 3A) and 3-dimensional cubic lattice (Figure 3B) in the Potts model, which yield slightly shifted phase boundaries owing to the dimensionality of the lattice. The 3-dimensional cubic lattice increases the surface and interfacial areas relative to its 2-dimensional square counterpart, thus increasing the values of AiA_i and AijA_{ij} in eq. (1), which impact the values of surface (γi\gamma_i) and interfacial (σij\sigma_{ij}) energies at which one morphology is preferred over another. Beyond this quantitative comparison, the 3D lattice also offers a view of internal interface architecture, complementing the largely two-dimensional snapshots typical of experimental characterization techniques. [44]

Figure 3 illustrates the effects of surface and interfacial energies on ground-state morphology formation. We will walk through Figure 3A, beginning in the lower left of the biphase stability map. Point I is in the CS morphology region, which occurs when the interfacial energy is sufficiently smaller (as determined by the phase boundary) than the surface energy of the core. Moving to Point II, the surface energy of the shell (γB\gamma_B) increases relative to the core (γA\gamma_A), leading to the exposure of both surfaces as neither one is wholly preferred. The initial reduction of the B surface produces the transitional Lens-type morphology. As the B surface shrinks, the A surface increases and a phase boundary forms. Exposure of both surfaces leads to the formation of the Janus morphology. Continuing to Point III, we find the Janus morphology with evenly distributed A and B domains about the center of the particle. From this point, increasing the interfacial energy between A and B brings us to Point IV, where the A and B domains pinch to minimize their interfacial area. The interfacial area decreases, resulting in increased surface areas. A pinched Janus morphology forms, also known as the Dumbbell morphology. Continuing to increase the interfacial energy brings us to Point V, where it becomes more favorable to completely eliminate the interfacial area at the expense of increased surface area. The NP separates into two single-phase particles (2p) with no interface between A and B. The 2p morphology is only observed when σAB/γA>γB/γA+1\sigma_{AB}/\gamma_A > \gamma_B/\gamma_A + 1, or in other words when σAB>γA+γB\sigma_{AB} > \gamma_A + \gamma_B. This MCP-calculated Janus-2p boundary in Figure 3A recovers the Dupré equation, [56] which describes the energy required to separate two surfaces. We observe the same trends across Points I through V in the 3-dimensional stability map in Figure 3B. Although the results presented assume a ratio of 1 : 1 amount of spins A:BA : B, we repeated the study using ratios varying from 1 : 2 to 1 : 10 and obtained the same stability map. All morphologies in the biphase stability map have the number of interfaces predicted in Ref. 20: at most one interface. This study finds the number of surfaces differentiates between biphase morphologies: either 1 or 2.

Because these observed biphase morphologies are geometrically simple, we can solve for the areas AiA_i and AijA_{ij} in eq. (1) using simple geometric relations and the new set of three biphase morphologies for consideration. We call this the idealized geometry approach, which is described in Ref. 20. In Figure 4A, we label the necessary geometric dimensions of each morphology. We use eq. (1) to calculate the energy of each morphology and select the lowest energy one. Phase boundaries occur where two morphologies are degenerate in energy. In the 2D case (Figure 4B), each domain maintains equal areas such that AA=ABA_A = A_B, leading to the constraint AA,Janus=AB,Janus=AA,Core@Shell=AB,Core@Shell=AA,2p=AB,2pA_{A,\mathrm{Janus}} = A_{B,\mathrm{Janus}} = A_{A,\mathrm{Core@Shell}} = A_{B,\mathrm{Core@Shell}} = A_{A,\mathrm{2p}} = A_{B,\mathrm{2p}}. We compare the phase boundaries derived from the idealized geometry approach with the MCP-derived phase boundaries in Figure 4B in the 2D case. We observe a triple point in both stability map calculation approaches, implying there exists some combination of surface and interfacial energies such that all three morphologies are degenerate. We repeated this approach for the 3D case in Figure 4C, with the only change being that each domain maintains the same volume (VA=VBV_A = V_B) across morphologies. The phase boundaries of the 3D consideration are shifted compared to those of the 2D consideration due to the factor differences between the geometric relations of circles (πr2\pi r^2) and spheres (((4/3)πr3)((4/3)\pi r^3)). Additionally, we observe a triple point in the idealized geometry approach but not in the MCP-calculated approach. Two features of the idealized geometry approach explain the differences in Figure 4B&C: (1) morphologies do not necessarily exhibit a spherical shape and (2) the approach omits transitional interface morphologies. For example, the MCP-predicted transition Dumbbell morphology is a Janus morphology, but it is not a perfect sphere. The idealized geometry approach underestimates the surface areas and overestimates the interfacial area. Similarly, the Lens-type morphology has an increased interfacial area

Illustrated variables and phase-boundary comparisons for 2D and 3D constraints

Figure 4. (A) The illustrated variables necessary for calculating eq. 1 for each morphology using the idealized geometry approach. Phase boundaries occur where at least two morphologies are degenerate in energy. The geometry-derived phase boundaries (solid lines) are compared to the MCP-calculated phase boundaries (dashed lines) under (B) 2D constraints, meaning both MCP and the idealized geometry approach utilize an equal-area constraint, and a square lattice. (C) The 3D case uses an equal-volume constraint and a cubic lattice to reveal further expansion of the Janus region when moving from the idealized geometry to the MCP approach.

compared to the idealized Janus morphology.

The MCP approach requires no a priori knowledge of candidate morphologies and can instead explore all internal interface configurations directly. We find two transitional Janus morphologies (Lens-type and Dumbbell) which expand the Janus morphology space and significantly shift the stability map boundaries. Therefore, it becomes important to consider transitional morphologies when deriving stability maps.

Prediction of biphase morphologies

In this section, we predict biphase NP morphologies using the MCP-calculated biphase stability map from combinations of DFT-calculated surface and interfacial energies. We select phase-separating combinations of isostructural elemental phases, map them onto phases A and B, and use corresponding surface and interfacial energies along the close-packed direction from existing DFT databases. [52, 57] Other crystallographic directions are compared in the Supplementary Information. We model the NP in vacuum, enabling the use of DFT-calculated surface energies. We use the above-mentioned DFT interfacial and surface energy databases to calculate the ratios γB/γA\gamma_B/\gamma_A and σAB/γA\sigma_{AB}/\gamma_A to predict the biphase morphology using the stability map. The resulting morphology predictions are shown in Figure 5, separated by structure (FCC, BCC, and HCP).

Biphase morphology prediction maps for FCC-FCC, BCC-BCC, and HCP-HCP systems

Figure 5. All pairwise combinations of phase-separating isostructural elemental phases drawn from DFT-calculated interfacial energy data in Ref. 52 are matched to the corresponding surface energies in Ref. 57. The DFT-calculated surface[57] and interfacial[52] energies of each A-B system are used to calculate the ratios σAB/γA\sigma_{AB}/\gamma_A and γB/γA\gamma_B/\gamma_A, with phase A representing the phase with the higher surface energy of the two. The (γB/γA,σAB/γA)(\gamma_B/\gamma_A, \sigma_{AB}/\gamma_A) point is then plotted on the biphase stability map to predict biphase NP morphologies. The crystallographic direction selected for the surface and interfacial energies is along the phase structure’s close-packed direction. The selected elemental phase-separating (A) FCC-FCC systems are predicted using energies along the close-packed [111] direction, (B) BCC-BCC systems along the [110] direction, and finally (C) HCP-HCP systems along the [1] direction.

Figure 5A lists NP morphology predictions of phase-separating elemental FCC phases. The values used to plot the predictions in Figure 5 are listed in Table S1 in the Supplementary Information. MCP predicts all FCC systems as Core@Shell. The same analysis is conducted for BCC structures using the close-packed direction of [110] in Figure 5B, in which Core@Shell is the most frequently observed morphology, although MCP predicts one Janus NP (W−Cr) and one NP on the phase boundary of Core@Shell and Janus (V−Ta). In Figure 5C, we find HCP systems along the [1] direction, which also reveal Core@Shell as the most commonly observed NP morphology, followed by two Janus NPs (Zn−Cd, Tl−Cd) and one on the Core@Shell-Janus phase boundary (Tc−Co). Overall, Core@Shell is the most frequently observed morphology when using DFT-calculated surface and interfacial energies, which supports the hypothesis in Ref. 34 that DFT calculations of surfaces in vacuum will tend to predict Core@Shell NP morphologies.

Phase APhase BγADFT\gamma_{A}^{DFT} [J m−2^{-2}]γAexp,0K\gamma_{A}^{exp,0K} [J m−2^{-2}]γBDFT\gamma_{B}^{DFT} [J m−2^{-2}]γBexp,0K\gamma_{B}^{exp,0K} [J m−2^{-2}]σABDET\sigma_{AB}^{DET} [J m−2^{-2}]
Co (fcc)Ag2.0422.5190.7731.1970.505
CuAg1.3141.7000.7731.1970.106
IrAg2.2842.9290.7731.1970.707
NiAg1.9242.3650.7731.1970.212
AgPb0.7731.1970.2530.5230.006
RhAg1.9892.6110.7731.1970.413
AlPb0.7951.2830.2530.5230.317
Co (fcc)Au2.0422.5190.7421.3510.187
IrAu2.2842.9290.7421.3510.671
PtAu1.4792.3730.7421.3510.066
RhAu1.9892.6110.7421.3510.243
CaSr0.4610.4740.3420.3790.005
Co (fcc)Cu2.0422.5191.3141.7000.357
IrCu2.2842.9291.3141.7000.201
NiCu1.9242.3651.3141.7000.0004
RhCu1.9892.6111.3141.7000.100
IrPd2.2842.9291.3381.9910.086
IrPt2.2842.9291.4792.3730.050
RhPd1.9892.6111.3381.9910.090
BaCs0.3120.3450.0600.7040.056
Phase APhase BγADFT\gamma_{A}^{DFT} [J m−2^{-2}]γAexp,0K\gamma_{A}^{exp,0K} [J m−2^{-2}]γBDFT\gamma_{B}^{DFT} [J m−2^{-2}]γBexp,0K\gamma_{B}^{exp,0K} [J m−2^{-2}]σABDFT\sigma_{AB}^{DFT} [J m−2^{-2}]
BaK0.3120.3450.1080.1340.077
BaRb0.3120.3450.0820.1070.082
CrFe3.2012.8852.4472.6230.104
CrLi3.2012.8850.4980.4681.299
CrMo3.2012.8852.7972.0800.005
WCr3.2282.3103.2012.8850.017
FeLi2.4472.6230.4980.4680.491
WFe3.2282.3102.4472.6230.103
MoLi2.7972.0800.4980.4680.946
NbLi2.0742.4850.4980.4680.631
TaLi2.3422.0500.4980.4680.868
VLi2.4211.8600.4980.4680.882
WLi3.2282.3100.4980.4681.270
MoNa2.7972.0800.2180.2301.427
WMo3.2282.3102.7972.0800.029
NbNa2.0742.4850.2180.2301.032
TaNa2.3422.0500.2180.2301.143
WNa3.2282.3100.2180.2301.865
VNb2.4211.8602.0742.4850.037
VTa2.4211.8602.3422.0500.016
BeZn1.790—0.348—0.625
Co (hcp)Cd2.108—0.200—0.583
OsCd2.920—0.200—1.189
ReCd2.581—0.200—1.087
RuCd2.577—0.200—0.661
TcCd2.234—0.200—0.806
TiCd1.966—0.200—0.093
TlCd0.256—0.200—0.052
ZnCd0.348—0.200—0.184
OsCo (hcp)2.920—2.108—0.176
ReCo (hcp)2.581—2.108—0.106
RuCo (hcp)2.577—2.108—0.223

Table S1. This table provides further details regarding the input parameters for the prediction of biphase morphologies from DFT-calculated interfacial energies, as well as the DFT-calculated and experimental surface energies.

Comparison of MCP biphase morphologies with experimental data

We use the biphase stability map to compare MCP-predicted morphologies with experimentally reported ones and find that six of eight predictions match experiment. We compare the impact of surface and interfacial energy choices on morphology prediction. There are two surface energy choices: DFT-calculated ones[57] and experimental ones.[58] The interfacial energies of our systems are generally not available from experiment, so we use DFT-calculated ones from two sources which use different calculation approaches: 1) the database by Salgado-Casanova et al., [52] which separates the coherency strain energy contribution from the interfacial energy, and 2) Refs. 20 and 33, which do not explicitly perform this separation. We note that an approximation of eq. (1) is the neglect of volume-dependence to the NP total energy (e.g. coherency strain), which is discussed in the Supplementary Materials of Ref. 20. Calculating interfacial energies is complex and requires careful consideration of input structures; therefore we constrain our study to cases for which the interfacial energies are calculated.

We applied the MCP model to eight experimentally reported multimetallic nanoparticles: Co−AgCo-Ag,[33] Co−AuCo-Au,[33, 59] Rh−AuRh-Au,[60] Ni−AgNi-Ag,[61] Cu−AgCu-Ag,[33, 61] Ni−CuNi-Cu,[61] Co−Pd3SnCo-Pd_{3}Sn,[20] and Cu−Pd3SnCu-Pd_{3}Sn.[20] These eight systems are plotted on the biphase stability map in Figure 6. Table S1 contains the details of each system in Figure 6, including their surface and interfacial energies. Surface and interfacial energies along the close-packed direction are used in the DFT-calculated cases, whereas the experimental surface energies are an average across all crystallographic directions since these generally cannot be reliably measured along a single crystallographic orientation.[58] The MCP model results agree with the experimentally reported biphase morphologies in six of eight NP systems (Rh−AuRh-Au, Ni−AgNi-Ag, Cu−AgCu-Ag, Ni−CuNi-Cu,

Predicted biphase morphologies corresponding to experimentally reported multiphase NPs

Figure 6. Predicted biphase morphologies corresponding to experimentally reported multiphase NPs. Each A−B point represents the morphology formed by phase A and phase B, with phase A being the phase with the higher surface energy. Core@Shell morphologies take the form of A@B. The point color signifies the experimentally reported morphology, which is compared with the morphology phase region color it is located in. Like colors suggest good agreement between MCP and unlike colors imply poor agreement. Predicted morphologies agree with experimentally reported morphologies in six of eight NPs. DFT-calculated interfacial energies for some systems differ so a dashed line representing this range is provided for reference. Each A−B system is plotted from surface and interfacial energies, using combinations of DFT-calculated and experimental ones. The FCC structure is utilized for the single-element phases and the L12_2 structure is utilized to represent the Pd3Sn\mathrm{Pd}_3\mathrm{Sn} phase. The values plotted are reproduced in Table S1.

Figure 9 (PDF p. 17).

Co–Pd3Sn\mathrm{Pd}_3\mathrm{Sn}, Cu–Pd3Sn\mathrm{Pd}_3\mathrm{Sn}. As the predictions are largely in agreement with experiment, we will next illustrate one case for which multiple morphologies are experimentally reported (Cu–Ag) and then discuss the two conflicting cases. We note that there are a large number of additional experimentally reported multiphase NP morphologies (reproduced in Table S4–Table S7), but the DFT calculations of these surface and interfacial energies are not available to enable our MCP model prediction.

CompositionExpt. morphologyExpt. referenceExpt. notes
Pt-Fe-Nisingle-phase NP10.1126/science.1252553
AuAgCu10.1126/science.aaf8402Au 70%, ∼40nm diameter
PtAuCurandom (alloy)10.1073/pnas.1800884115–
PtCurandom (alloy)10.1073/pnas.1800884115–
PtNirandom (alloy)10.1073/pnas.1800884115–
Pt-Nisolid solution (single-phase)10.1016/j.calphad.2018.11.013randomly mixed core structure
PdAu10.1073/pnas.1800884115
PdNi10.1073/pnas.1800884115
Pt47Ni53\mathrm{Pt}_{47}\mathrm{Ni}_{53}10.1073/pnas.1800884115
RhNi10.1073/pnas.1800884115
RhCo10.1073/pnas.1800884115
PtPd10.1073/pnas.1800884115
RhPt10.1073/pnas.1800884115
Pt49Cu51\mathrm{Pt}_{49}\mathrm{Cu}_{51}10.1073/pnas.1800884115
PdCu10.1073/pnas.1800884115
PdCo10.1073/pnas.1800884115
PtCo10.1073/pnas.1800884115
PtBi10.1073/pnas.1800884115
CompositionExpt. morphologyExpt. referenceExpt. notes
Pt0.69Sb0.31\mathrm{Pt}_{0.69}\mathrm{Sb}_{0.31}10.1073/pnas.1800884115
Pt0.85Sb0.15\mathrm{Pt}_{0.85}\mathrm{Sb}_{0.15}10.1073/pnas.1800884115
Pt30Au36Cu34\mathrm{Pt}_{30}\mathrm{Au}_{36}\mathrm{Cu}_{34}10.1073/pnas.1800884115∼18\sim18 nm
PtCu\mathrm{PtCu}10.1073/pnas.1800884115
PtNi\mathrm{PtNi}10.1073/pnas.1800884115
Sn\mathrm{Sn}-Ag\mathrm{Ag}-Cu\mathrm{Cu}amorphous outer layer, mixed core with Ag3Sn\mathrm{Ag}_{3}\mathrm{Sn} precipitates10.1039/C5NR00462D∼18\sim18 nm
PdCuPtNiCo\mathrm{PdCuPtNiCo}HEA10.1021/acsnano.2c07787∼10\sim10 nm
CuPdIr\mathrm{CuPdIr}solid solution (single-phase)10.1016/j.ijhydene.2021.09.192
CuAgIr\mathrm{CuAgIr}solid solution (single-phase)10.1016/j.ijhydene.2021.09.192
CuAgPd\mathrm{CuAgPd}solid solution (single-phase)10.1016/j.ijhydene.2021.09.192

Table S4. Experimentally reported single-phase (solid-solution) multicomponent nanoparticles.

CompositionPhase APhase BPhase CPhase DExpt. morphologyExpt. referenceExpt. notes
Ag\mathrm{Ag}Cu\mathrm{Cu}Au\mathrm{Au}Ni\mathrm{Ni}Janus w/ inner shell around Au-Ni w/ Cu shell10.1021/jacs.1c11118annealed at 160 °C for 4h followed by 185 °C for 6h
Ag\mathrm{Ag}Cu\mathrm{Cu}Au\mathrm{Au}Ni\mathrm{Ni}Striped w/ split: Ag + Cu half-shells around Au-Ni10.1021/jacs.1c11118annealed at 185 °C for 6h
CoPdAgCu\mathrm{CoPdAgCu}Co\mathrm{Co}PdSn(Cu)\mathrm{PdSn(Cu)}AuCu\mathrm{AuCu}AuAg\mathrm{AuAg}striped w/ split; 4-phase with 5 interfaces10.1126/science.aav4302
Au-CoNi-NiSn-PdSnAu\mathrm{Au}Ni\mathrm{Ni}PdSn\mathrm{PdSn}Ni\mathrm{Ni}
Au0.18Co0.14Ni0.33Pd0.18Sn0.17; Au0.17Co0.11Ni0.33Pd0.24Sn0.15; Au0.18Co0.09Ni0.33Pd0.25Sn0.15; Au0.20Co0.12Ni0.32Pd0.20Sn0.16; Au0.20Co0.11Ni0.30Pd0.21Sn0.18\mathrm{Au}_{0.18}\mathrm{Co}_{0.14}\mathrm{Ni}_{0.33}\mathrm{Pd}_{0.18}\mathrm{Sn}_{0.17};\ \mathrm{Au}_{0.17}\mathrm{Co}_{0.11}\mathrm{Ni}_{0.33}\mathrm{Pd}_{0.24}\mathrm{Sn}_{0.15};\ \mathrm{Au}_{0.18}\mathrm{Co}_{0.09}\mathrm{Ni}_{0.33}\mathrm{Pd}_{0.25}\mathrm{Sn}_{0.15};\ \mathrm{Au}_{0.20}\mathrm{Co}_{0.12}\mathrm{Ni}_{0.32}\mathrm{Pd}_{0.20}\mathrm{Sn}_{0.16};\ \mathrm{Au}_{0.20}\mathrm{Co}_{0.11}\mathrm{Ni}_{0.30}\mathrm{Pd}_{0.21}\mathrm{Sn}_{0.18}Au\mathrm{Au}CoNi\mathrm{CoNi}NiSn\mathrm{NiSn}PdSn\mathrm{PdSn}pie w/ core (most common); then Striped followed by the 4-interface, 3-surface morphology10.1126/science.aav4302
CompositionPhase APhase BPhase CPhase DExpt. morphologyExpt. referenceExpt. notes
AuAg-AuCu-NiSn-PdSn and AuAg-AuCu-Co-PdSnheterotetramers with five interfaces10.1126/science.aav4302
Ag-Cu-CoNi-PdSnheterotetramer with four interfaces10.1126/science.aav4302
Ag-Cu-Ni-PdSnCuAgPdSnNiheterotetramer with four interfaces10.1126/science.aav4302
Au0.17Ag0.12Cu0.22Ni0.14Pd0.19Sn0.16\mathrm{Au}_{0.17}\mathrm{Ag}_{0.12}\mathrm{Cu}_{0.22}\mathrm{Ni}_{0.14}\mathrm{Pd}_{0.19}\mathrm{Sn}_{0.16}heterotetramer with four interfaces10.1126/science.aav4302
Au0.17Ag0.15Cu0.17Co0.23Pd0.18Sn0.10\mathrm{Au}_{0.17}\mathrm{Ag}_{0.15}\mathrm{Cu}_{0.17}\mathrm{Co}_{0.23}\mathrm{Pd}_{0.18}\mathrm{Sn}_{0.10}; Au0.18Ag0.16Cu0.20Co0.23Pd0.13Sn0.10\mathrm{Au}_{0.18}\mathrm{Ag}_{0.16}\mathrm{Cu}_{0.20}\mathrm{Co}_{0.23}\mathrm{Pd}_{0.13}\mathrm{Sn}_{0.10}; Au0.11Ag0.15Cu0.17Co0.28Pd0.19Sn0.10\mathrm{Au}_{0.11}\mathrm{Ag}_{0.15}\mathrm{Cu}_{0.17}\mathrm{Co}_{0.28}\mathrm{Pd}_{0.19}\mathrm{Sn}_{0.10}AuAgAuCuCoPdSnstriped w/ split; 4-phase with 5 interfaces10.1126/science.aav4302
Ag0.32Cu0.20Co0.21Pd0.15Sn0.12\mathrm{Ag}_{0.32}\mathrm{Cu}_{0.20}\mathrm{Co}_{0.21}\mathrm{Pd}_{0.15}\mathrm{Sn}_{0.12}CoCuAgPdSn10.1126/science.aav4302

Table S7. Experimentally reported tetraphase nanoparticle morphologies.

To understand how interfacial and surface energies compete to influence morphology, we use the Cu−Ag NP as an example. Experimentally, biphase Cu−Ag NPs form either a Core@Shell or a random alloy depending on the precursor used [61] and are also reported as both 2p[33] and Janus.[20] Another work reports the Cu–Ag NP can present as Core@Shell or Janus depending on the size of Cu core used [62] The wide range of experimental reports suggests the energetic stability is only one factor controlling morphology. We can use the biphase stability map to study how the Cu–Ag point could move within the stability map.

Cu–Ag is firmly Core@Shell when using DFT-calculated interfacial energy values from Ref. 52 which separate out the strain energy component. When using experimental surface energy values extrapolated to T=0T = 0 K from Ref. 63, γB/γA\gamma_{\mathrm{B}}/\gamma_{\mathrm{A}} increases. The DFT interfacial energies in Ref. 20 increase σAB/γA\sigma_{\mathrm{AB}}/\gamma_{\mathrm{A}} because they do not separate out the coherency strain energy component from the interfacial energy, moving the Cu–Ag point towards the phase boundary. Each calculation scheme reflects how energetic contributions can shift the predicted NP morphology. We can extend this thinking to study the cases where there is a discrepancy between the MCP-predicted and experimentally-reported NP morphology.

Here we discuss possible reasons for discrepancies between experimentally-reported NP morphologies and the MCP-predicted ones. We divide these explanations into two categories: (I) the experimentally reported morphology is not the energetically stable ground state, and (II) the approximations underlying the input to MCP may be inaccurate. There are three main possible inaccuracies: (A) the input phases may be incorrect, or the DFT-calculated (B) surface energies and (C) interfacial energies may be inaccurate. (A) may occur when using OQMD to determine NP phases due to underlying assumptions of T=0T = 0 K, bulk materials, and perfectly ordered phases. For example, OQMD does not consider solid solution formation nor phases formed at higher temperatures. In (B), the surface energy databases provide energies at T=0T = 0 K and in vacuum. Chen et al. report surface passivation effects not considered by DFT calculations of surfaces in vacuum result in a decrease in surface energy difference between two metals. [34] Additionally, although DFT surface energies tend to have generally good agreement with experiment, [57] in some cases they may be widely inaccurate, such as in Au.[64] In (C), the interfacial energies are only calculated for coherent interfaces and in some cases do not account for coherency strain. We will focus on the impact of these three inaccuracies resulting from calculation schemes as we discuss the two exceptions in Figure 6.

As we discuss later, comparison of triphase NP predictions with experiment introduces one additional category of explanation, arising from the larger space of possible morphologies in three-phase systems.

In the following sections, we analyze how changes in surface and interfacial energies may impact the morphology predicted by the stability map to study the impact of each inaccuracy on MCP-predicted NP morphology. Since MCP predictions agree with experimental reports in six of the eight NPs, only the two discrepancies (Co–Ag and Co–Au) are discussed in further detail in the sub-sections below.

Co–Ag NP

The Co–Ag NP is predicted here as a Core@Shell morphology but is experimentally reported as a Janus morphology. [33] This discrepancy could be ascribed to two factors belonging in categories (I) and (II). Most polyelemental NPs are annealed at around 600 °C; [20, 22] however the Co–Ag system was annealed at a lower temperature of 185 °C. [33] The lower annealing temperature may imply the prediction error falls into (I) because the Co–Ag NP was not able to reach its energetic ground state. As for (II), we note both Refs. 20 and 52 used an FCC structure for Co; however Co only undergoes a phase transition from HCP to FCC at 427 °C. The lower annealing temperature of 185 °C could mean that HCP Co more accurately represents the phase present in the NP. We can instead estimate the new location of the HCP Co–FCC Ag point on the stability map. The HCP surface energy of Co is slightly higher than that of its FCC structure, [57] thereby increasing γA\gamma_A. The incoherency of the HCP Co domain with the FCC Ag domain is also expected to increase the interfacial energy of the Co–Ag interface, σAB\sigma_{AB}. For a Janus morphology to form, the increase in interfacial energy must be fractionally larger than the increase in surface energy. Furthermore, the surface passivation effects not considered by existing DFT surface energy calculations would decrease the surface energy difference [34] between Co and Ag, which thereby increases the ratio γB/γA\gamma_{B}/\gamma_{A} towards the Janus region. Finally, other computational studies of Co–Ag biphase NP determined the NP lies on the boundary between Core@Shell and Janus, with the transition attributable to the choice of substrate and NP seed.[65] Thus, the morphology formed may depend on the experimental conditions considered.

Co–Au NP.

The Co–Au NP is predicted as a Core@Shell morphology whereas it is experimentally reported as a Janus morphology. The Co–Au NP is reported as Janus in two cases using different annealing temperatures: 230 °C and 500 °C,[33] which are below and above the HCP–FCC transition, respectively. As stated earlier in the Co–Ag discussion, the HCP surface energy of Co is slightly larger than its FCC counterpart,[57] thus we can estimate a slight increase in γA\gamma_{A} for the fabrication case at 230 °C. DFT-calculated surface energies for Au are almost half the experimental surface energy of Au,[63, 64] leading to a doubling of γB\gamma_{B}. As for the Co–Au interfacial energy, only the coherent FCC–FCC structure is known. Thus, these three inaccuracies fall into category (II). Incorporating the estimated surface energy adjustments would shift the point further right, closer to the phase boundary between Core@Shell and Janus.

Summary of biphase morphology comparison to experiment.

As the above subsections highlight, the morphology stability map is a tool for studying the impact of selected surface and interfacial energies on NP morphologies. The stability map may additionally be used to investigate the significance of coherency strain energies as opposed to interfacial energies when designing multiphase NPs, as illustrated by the vertical shift between points using the calculation scheme in Refs. 20, 33 and the points derived from Salgado-Casanova et al.’s DFT-calculation scheme. Additionally, NPs are often fabricated with a stabilizing surface layer to prevent NP aggregation,[20, 22, 61] so the surface energies of the phases may be calculated to more accurately reflect the NP environment. The stability map remains the same in each case, but the points will shift under the different surface and interfacial energy choices.

Triphase nanoparticle interface morphologies

We next extend the grid search approach used previously in the biphase NP morphology to search for triphase NP interface morphologies. The triphase NPs consist of three domains (A, B, C) surrounded by some environment, and are thus modeled using six unlike interactions: A–B (σAB\sigma_{AB}), A–C (σAC\sigma_{AC}), B–C (σBC\sigma_{BC}), A–Environment (γA\gamma_A), B–Environment (γB\gamma_B), and C–Environment (γC\gamma_C). As described earlier in the biphase case, we reduce the number of parameters by normalizing the six interactions by the largest surface energy, leaving us with five ratios: γB/γA\gamma_B/\gamma_A, γC/γA\gamma_C/\gamma_A, σAB/γA\sigma_{AB}/\gamma_A, σAC/γA\sigma_{AC}/\gamma_A, σBC/γA\sigma_{BC}/\gamma_A. We order the phases by decreasing surface energy such that γA≥γB≥γC\gamma_A \ge\gamma_B \ge\gamma_C to reduce the number of grid points required to calculate the triphase stability map without loss of generality. The parameter bounds derived in the biphase NP also apply here, with γB/γA\gamma_B/\gamma_A, γC/γA≤1\gamma_C/\gamma_A \le1 and σAB/γA\sigma_{AB}/\gamma_A, σAC/γA\sigma_{AC}/\gamma_A, σBC/γA≤1\sigma_{BC}/\gamma_A \le1 defining the bounds of the grid search.

We perform MCP calculations for triphase NPs using a grid of 30,250 points and find 11 topologically distinct morphologies, which we list in Table 2. The Pie morphology consists of three radially distributed domains about the center of the particle, such that each domain has a surface and an interface with every other domain. The Striped morphology is divided into three parallel domains such that the outer domains do not share an interface but share an interface with the central domain. Each domain has a surface. The Venn morphology is a transitional morphology similar to Striped, with the central domain reducing to a point such that it does not have a surface. This morphology is transitional because it exists between the Striped morphology and the next morphology, Pokéball, by reducing a surface to a point and thus has a distinct number of surfaces and interfaces. The Pokéball morphology is an extension of the biphase Janus morphology with a third domain lying along the central interface. All domains share an interface with each other. The Janus with Core@Shell morphology is a Janus morphology with one of the domains containing the third domain. The inner domain only shares an interface with the domain that encapsulates it. The Onion morphology is a layered morphology consisting of layered shells surrounding a core. The Shell with Janus core morphology is a Janus morphology encapsulated by a third domain which forms the shell. The Shell with 2 cores morphology consists of one domain encapsulating two separated domains such that these two do not share an interface. The remaining three morphologies are included for completeness, but they represent a summation of single-phase and biphase morphologies. For this reason, we call these morphologies non-contiguous. The Janus + 1p morphology consists of a Janus biphase particle and a separate single-phase particle. The Core@Shell + 1p morphology contains a biphase Core@Shell particle and a separate single-phase particle. The 3p morphology consists of three separate single-phase particles.

Table 2. Triphase morphology descriptions. This table contains the names, visualizations, and characteristics of the eleven topologically distinct triphase NP interface morphologies. First, we list the names of each one followed by its categorical type. Then, we show the MCP output and the idealized schematic representation. Finally, we show the respective number of surfaces and interfaces.

MorphologyTypeSample MCP outputIdealized Morphology# of surfaces# of interfaces
PokéballPo[image][image]23
Janus with Core@ShellJ-CS[image][image]22
OnionCS[image][image]12
Shell with Janus coreSJ[image][image]13
Shell with 2 coresS2[image][image]12
Janus + 1pJ+1p[image][image]31
Core@Shell + 1pCS+1p[image][image]31
3pnnP[image][image]30

Table 1 (PDF p. 25).

Another more informative view of these 11 distinct triphase morphologies is presented in Figure 7 by decreasing number of interfaces, with Figure 7A illustrating the snapshots and schematic representations of three-interface triphase morphologies, followed by Figure 7B, containing two-interface morphologies, and so on with Figure 7C&D. Within each subsection, the morphologies are ordered by decreasing number of surfaces. For example, starting in Figure 7A, the Pie morphology exhibits three surfaces, followed by the two-surface Pokéball morphology, then the single-surface Shell with Janus core morphology. Of the 11 distinct morphologies, we only find five experimentally reported (Pie, [33] Striped, [33] Onion, [32] Venn, [33] and Janus + 1p[33]).

Snapshots of the triphase NP interface morphologies

Figure 7. Snapshots of the triphase NP interface morphologies found via MCP as well as their corresponding schematic depiction. (A) The three-interface triphase morphologies, ordered by decreasing number of surfaces, are Pie, Pokéball, and Shell with Janus core. (B) The two-interface triphase morphologies in order of decreasing number of surfaces are Striped, Janus with Core@Shell and Venn, followed by Onion and Shell with 2 cores. (C) The single-interface triphase morphologies observed in order of decreasing number of surfaces are the Janus + 1p and the Core@Shell + 1p morphologies. (D) The triphase morphology with no interface is the 3p morphology. We note the number of interfaces and surfaces do not uniquely define a triphase morphology. See Table 2 for qualitative descriptions of each morphology.

The triphase morphologies found agree with the predicted number of possible interfaces from Ref. 20, who predict the number of interfaces for an nn-phase particle to fall between n−1n-1 and n(n−1)/2n(n-1)/2. This relation implies that triphase particles must be composed of a minimum of two interfaces and a maximum of three interfaces, which is true for all of the eight contiguous triphase morphologies found (Pie, Striped, Venn, Pokéball, Janus with Core@Shell, Onion, Shell with Janus core, and Shell with 2 cores). We additionally find that the number of surfaces must lie between 1 and 3 in the triphase case, or more generally between 1 and nn. The categorization of triphase morphologies by number of surfaces and number of interfaces is shown in Figure 7. The distribution of morphologies in Figure 7 illustrates that the number of interfaces does not uniquely define a NP interface morphology, nor does the number of surfaces in conjunction with the number of interfaces. In Figure 7B, both the Onion and the Shell with 2 cores morphologies have one surface and two interfaces, yet are topologically distinct morphologies. Likewise, the Janus with Core@Shell and Venn morphologies each have two surfaces and two interfaces.

Prediction of triphase morphologies

We predict triphase NP morphologies by extending the same approach: we select phase-separating ternary combinations of isostructural elemental phases from the interfacial energy database in Ref. 52 along the close-packed direction, and use the matching DFT-calculated surface energies from Ref. 57 to sort the phases by decreasing surface energy into labels A, B, and C. We then calculate the ratios σAB/γA\sigma_{AB}/\gamma_A, σBC/γA\sigma_{BC}/\gamma_A, σAC/γA\sigma_{AC}/\gamma_A and γB/γA\gamma_B/\gamma_A, γC/γA\gamma_C/\gamma_A and use these as inputs into the MCP model to predict triphase NP morphologies, the results of which are summarized in Table 3, which lists the identities of Phases A, B, and C, followed by their surface and interfacial energies ratios and the MCP-predicted morphology. The values used to calculate these ratios are reproduced in Table S3 of the Supplementary Information and predictions using different choices of experimental surface and DFT-calculated interfacial

Phase APhase BPhase C[hkl]γBDFT/γADFT\gamma_{B}^{DFT}/\gamma_{A}^{DFT}γCDFT/γADFT\gamma_{C}^{DFT}/\gamma_{A}^{DFT}σABDFT/γADFT\sigma_{AB}^{DFT}/\gamma_{A}^{DFT}σACDFT/γADFT\sigma_{AC}^{DFT}/\gamma_{A}^{DFT}σBCDFT/γADFT\sigma_{BC}^{DFT}/\gamma_{A}^{DFT}
BaKRb[100]0.3780.2940.3310.3690.001
CoCuAg[100]0.5920.3270.1590.3390.063
CoCuAg[110]0.6450.3580.1980.3520.085
CoCuAg[111]0.6440.3780.1750.2470.052
CoRhAg[100]0.9380.3270.0130.3390.170
CoRhAu[100]0.9380.3470.0130.1590.133
CoRhCu[100]0.9380.5920.0130.1590.060
CoZnCd[1]0.1650.0950.0350.2760.087
CrFeLi[100]0.6880.1270.0410.5250.271
CrFeLi[110]0.7640.1560.0320.4060.153
CrFeLi[111]0.7950.1580.0440.4330.189
CrMoFe[100]0.8760.6880.0740.0410.042
CrMoLi[100]0.8760.1270.0740.5250.373
CrMoLi[110]0.8740.1560.0020.4060.296
Phase APhase BPhase C[hkl]γBDFT/γADFT\gamma_{B}^{DFT}/\gamma_{A}^{DFT}γCDFT/γADFT\gamma_{C}^{DFT}/\gamma_{A}^{DFT}σABDFT/γADFT\sigma_{AB}^{DFT}/\gamma_{A}^{DFT}σACDFT/γADFT\sigma_{AC}^{DFT}/\gamma_{A}^{DFT}σBCDFT/γADFT\sigma_{BC}^{DFT}/\gamma_{A}^{DFT}
CrMoLi[111]0.8620.1580.0730.4330.334
CrNbLi[100]0.6260.1270.0830.5250.313
CrNbLi[111]0.6810.1580.1140.4330.257
CrTaLi[100]0.6800.1270.0530.5250.323
CrTaLi[111]0.7860.1580.1090.4330.323
IrCoAg[100]0.8800.2880.0110.2830.298
IrCoAu[100]0.8800.3050.0110.2940.140
IrCoCu[100]0.8800.5210.0110.0960.140
IrCuAg[100]0.5210.2880.0960.2830.056
IrCuAg[110]0.5630.3120.0950.3330.074
IrCuAg[111]0.5750.3380.0880.3100.046
IrPtAg[110]0.6060.3120.0360.3330.015
IrPtAu[100]0.6540.3050.0240.2940.034
IrPtAu[110]0.6060.2980.0360.3070.052
IrPtAu[111]0.6480.3250.0220.2940.029
MoFeLi[100]0.7850.1450.0480.4260.310
MoLiNa[100]0.1450.0680.4260.6620.042

Table S3. This table reproduces the input parameters for the prediction of triphase morphologies from DFT-calculated interfacial energies[52] and surface energies.[57] Predictions are made for all phase-separating isostructural ternary combinations of elemental metals. Phases A, B, and C are ordered according to decreasing DFT-calculated surface energy. Next, we provide the orientation selected for the surface and interfacial energies. All surface and interfacial energies are normalized by the surface energy of Phase A, γADFT\gamma_{A}^{DFT}, and are therefore dimensionless.

energies are presented in the Supplementary Information.

Table 3: MCP model predictions of triphase morphologies from existing surface and interfacial energy databases. We select all phase-separating ternary isostructural combinations of elemental metals exhibiting FCC, BCC, or HCP structures that lie on the convex hull and for which their ternary combination does not form any ordered compound on the convex hull. Elemental phases A, B, and C are ordered according to decreasing DFT-calculated surface energy. The ratios of surface and interfacial energies are calculated from the DFT energies in Refs. 57 and 52 along the close-packed direction and input into the MCP model. For Cr−Mo−Fe, Mo−Fe−Li, and W−Mo−Fe, the ratios are calculated along the [100] direction (Table S3). In this table, the input ratios are provided (γB/γA\gamma_B/\gamma_A, γC/γA\gamma_C/\gamma_A, σAB/γA\sigma_{AB}/\gamma_A, σBC/γA\sigma_{BC}/\gamma_A, σAC/γA\sigma_{AC}/\gamma_A), followed by the MCP-predicted morphology. Additional details regarding the DFT values used to calculate the parameter ratios are found in Table S3.

Phase APhase BPhase CγB/γA\gamma_B/\gamma_AγC/γA\gamma_C/\gamma_AσAB/γA\sigma_{AB}/\gamma_AσBC/γA\sigma_{BC}/\gamma_AσAC/γA\sigma_{AC}/\gamma_APredicted Morphology
CoZnCd0.1650.0950.0350.0870.276Janus w/ Core@Shell
CrFeLi0.7640.1560.0320.1530.406Onion
CrMoFe0.8760.6880.0740.0420.041Shell w/ Janus core
CrMoLi0.8740.1560.0020.2960.406Onion
IrCuAg0.5750.3380.0880.0460.310Onion
IrPtAu0.6480.3250.0220.0290.294Onion
MoFeLi0.7850.1450.0480.3100.426Onion
OsCoCd0.7220.0680.0600.2000.407Onion
ReCoCd0.8170.0770.0410.2260.421Onion
ReCoZn0.8170.1350.0410.0290.002Shell w/ 2 cores
ReTiMg0.7620.2110.0770.0820.109Shell w/ Janus core-like
ReTiHf0.7620.6620.0770.0030.053Shell w/ 2 cores
ReTlCd0.0990.0770.5460.0200.421Janus w/ Core@Shell
ReZnCd0.1350.0770.0020.0710.421Janus w/ Core@Shell
RhCuAg0.6610.3890.0500.0530.208Onion
RuCoCd0.8180.0780.0870.2260.256Shell w/ Janus core
TcCoCd0.9440.0890.0250.2610.361Onion

Table 3.

Phase APhase BPhase CγB/γA\gamma_B/\gamma_AγC/γA\gamma_C/\gamma_AσAB/γA\sigma_{AB}/\gamma_AσBC/γA\sigma_{BC}/\gamma_AσAC/γA\sigma_{AC}/\gamma_APredicted Morphology
Tc_cTiCd0.8800.0890.0080.0420.361Onion
Tc_cTiZr0.8800.7210.0080.0140.075Onion
Tc_cTlCd0.1150.0890.4830.0230.361Janus w/ Core@Shell
Tc_cZrMg0.7210.2440.0750.0180.007Shell w/ 2 cores
TiHfMg0.8690.2770.0040.0520.108Onion
TiTlCd0.1300.1020.1660.0270.048Janus w/ Core@Shell
TiZrTl0.8190.1300.0160.0400.166Onion
WCrFe0.9920.7580.0050.0320.032Shell w/ 2 cores
WCrLi0.9920.1540.0050.4020.393Shell w/ Janus core
WCrMo0.9920.8660.0050.0020.009Shell w/ 2 cores
WFeLi0.7580.1540.0320.1520.393Onion
WMoFe0.8050.6320.0010.0390.027Onion
WMoLi0.8660.1540.0090.2930.393Onion
WMoNa0.8660.0680.0090.4420.578Onion

Table 3 (PDF p. 29).

The predicted morphologies fall into four categories: Onion, Janus with Core@Shell, Shell with Janus core, and Shell with 2 cores. Morphologies denoted with the suffix “-like” are intermediate morphologies in transition to their listed morphology – we list their competing morphology in the Supplementary Information. These four morphologies are extrapolations of the Core@Shell biphase morphology, likely reflecting the effects discussed earlier in the biphase discussion: namely, MCP minimizes the number of surfaces, owing to the trend that surface energies are larger than interfacial energies. The triphase morphologies are a Core@Shell morphology with varying topologies in the core. The core in the NPs in Table 3 is either a Core@Shell (forming the Onion morphology), a Janus core (forming the Shell with Janus core), or the 2p morphology (forming the Shell with 2 cores morphology). The interfacial energy ratios determine which morphology forms, much the same way that the biphase counterpart σAB/γA\sigma_{AB}/\gamma_A differentiates between the Core@Shell, Janus, and 2p morphologies. Thus, ground-state morphology predictions from DFT-calculated surface and interfacial energies tend toward Core@Shell in biphase NPs and a Core@Shell variant in triphase NPs. Predictions using ratios along the [?], [?], and average amongst all three lowest-index directions are listed in Table S3, with no significant changes in our conclusions. Surface passivation, which is not captured by DFT surface energies calculated in vacuum, decreases the difference between surface energies,[34] driving γB/γA\gamma_B/\gamma_A and γC/γA\gamma_C/\gamma_A toward 1. In the triphase stability map, only Pie and Striped morphologies are predicted at γB/γA=1.0\gamma_B/\gamma_A = 1.0 (Figure S3), and almost all predicted morphologies are Pie or Striped at γB/γA=0.9\gamma_B/\gamma_A = 0.9 (Figure S3), which may explain why these are the most frequently reported experimental triphase morphologies.

Stability map for triphase NP morphologies

Figure S3. Stability map for triphase NP morphologies calculated from MCP on a 3D lattice using a domain-contact threshold of 0.0: two domains are considered to share an interface if they have at least one NN or NNN interaction between them. A looser threshold is shown in Figure S4.

Comparison of MCP triphase morphologies with experiment

We applied the MCP model to experimentally reported triphase NPs (Co−Cu−Ag, Co−Pd3_3Sn−Ag, Co−Pd3_3Sn−Au, Co−Pd3_3Sn−Cu, and Ni−Cu−Ag) fabricated via megalibrary synthesis. [1, 20, 33] We input the elemental composition of each NP into OQMD to determine the number of phases and their identity. The equilibrium OQMD phases are categorized as Phase A, B, and C in Table 4. As in the biphase NP, the NPs are modeled in a vacuum for simplicity, which allows for the use of DFT-calculated surface energies. We calculate the values of γA\gamma_A, γB\gamma_B, γC\gamma_C, σAB\sigma_{AB}, σAC\sigma_{AC}, σBC\sigma_{BC} (which are reproduced in Table S2) using the corresponding DFT-calculated surface and interfacial energies from databases in Refs. 57 and 52. These parameters are input into MCP and the output morphology visualized and categorized by the number of each unlike spin interaction, and reported in Table 4. The MCP output is compared to the experimentally-reported morphology listed in the final column.

Experimentally-Reported CompositionPhase APhase BPhase CMCP-Predicted Morphology*Experimentally-Reported Morphology
Ag0.23Cu0.47Co0.30Ag_{0.23}Cu_{0.47}Co_{0.30} [20]CoCuAgOnionStriped, [20, 33]
Ag0.66Cu0.27Co0.07Ag_{0.66}Cu_{0.27}Co_{0.07} [66]Pie, [22]
Ag0.43Cu0.19Co0.38Ag_{0.43}Cu_{0.19}Co_{0.38} [22]Striped with Onion character,** [66]
Ag−Cu−Co [20, 33]Janus + 1p [33]
Ag−Co−PdSn [20]CoPd3SnPd_{3}SnAgShell w/ Janus corePie [20]
Au0.30Co0.37Pd0.19Sn0.14Au_{0.30}Co_{0.37}Pd_{0.19}Sn_{0.14} [20]CoPd3SnPd_{3}SnAuShell w/ 2 coresPie [20]
Au0.33Co0.34Pd0.18Sn0.15Au_{0.33}Co_{0.34}Pd_{0.18}Sn_{0.15} [20]
Au0.24Co0.58(PdSn)0.18Au_{0.24}Co_{0.58}(PdSn)_{0.18} [20]
Au0.31Co0.34Pd0.21Sn0.14Au_{0.31}Co_{0.34}Pd_{0.21}Sn_{0.14} [20]
Au0.30Co0.26Pd0.30Sn0.14Au_{0.30}Co_{0.26}Pd_{0.30}Sn_{0.14} [20]
Au0.33Co0.24Pd0.26Sn0.17Au_{0.33}Co_{0.24}Pd_{0.26}Sn_{0.17} [20]
Au0.30Co0.29Pd0.30Sn0.11Au_{0.30}Co_{0.29}Pd_{0.30}Sn_{0.11} [20]
Au0.38Co0.33Pd0.23Sn0.06Au_{0.38}Co_{0.33}Pd_{0.23}Sn_{0.06} [20]
Co−Cu−PdSn(Cu) [20]CoPd3SnPd_{3}SnCuJanus w/ Core@Shell-likeStriped [20]
Ag−Cu−Ni [33]NiCuAgOnionJanus w/ Core@Shell-like**

Table 4. MCP comparison with experimentally reported triphase polyelemental NPs. In the first column, the stoichiometric experimental composition is listed when reported, otherwise the general composition of each domain is provided instead. Next, the identities of equilibrium OQMD phases A, B, and C are provided. The experimentally-reported phases are equivalent to the OQMD equilibrium phases in all but the PdxSnyPd_{x}Sn_{y} phases, where the experimental phase varies widely. We use Pd3SnPd_{3}Sn instead for simplicity, as in Ref. 20. The corresponding parameters γA,γB,γC,σAB,σAC,σBC\gamma_{A}, \gamma_{B}, \gamma_{C}, \sigma_{AB}, \sigma_{AC}, \sigma_{BC} are from DFT-calculated surface and interfacial energies in Refs. 20,33,52,57,64, which are only reported for the FCC or L12_2 structure for these phases. These parameter ratios were input into MCP to calculate an output morphology that is reported in the next column and compared to the experimentally-reported morphology in the final column. Further calculation details, including the values of the input parameters, are found in the Supplementary Information Table S2. *Using DFT-calculated interfacial and surface energies. MCP predictions from experimental surface energies are given in Table S2. **In Refs. 33,66, the authors do not report a morphology. In these two cases, we examine the figures provided to discern morphology.

Temperature for γ\gamma extrapolation [K]Phase APhase BPhase CγA\gamma_A [J m−2^{-2}]γB\gamma_B [J m−2^{-2}]γC\gamma_C [J m−2^{-2}]σAB\sigma_{AB} [J m−2^{-2}]σAC\sigma_{AC} [J m−2^{-2}]σBC\sigma_{BC} [J m−2^{-2}]MCP-predicted Morphology
DFTCoPd3Sn\mathrm{Pd}_{3}\mathrm{Sn}Au2.0421.330*0.7420.7690.5130.016Shell w/ 2 cores
0CoAuPd3Sn\mathrm{Pd}_{3}\mathrm{Sn}2.5191.3511.330*0.5130.7690.016Onion
773.15CoPd3Sn\mathrm{Pd}_{3}\mathrm{Sn}Au2.2481.330*1.2350.7690.5130.016Onion-like
873.15CoPd3Sn\mathrm{Pd}_{3}\mathrm{Sn}Au2.2131.330*1.2200.7690.5130.016Onion-like
1023.15CoPd3Sn\mathrm{Pd}_{3}\mathrm{Sn}Au2.1611.330*1.1970.7690.5130.016Onion-like
DFTCoCuAg2.0421.3140.7730.2080.8330.369Onion
0CoCuAg2.5191.7001.1970.2080.8330.369Onion
773.15CoCuAg2.2481.4841.0270.2080.8330.369Onion
873.15CoCuAg2.2131.4561.0050.2080.8330.369Onion
1023.15CoCuAg2.1611.4140.9720.2080.8330.369Onion
DFTCoPd3Sn\mathrm{Pd}_{3}\mathrm{Sn}Cu2.0421.330*1.3140.7690.2080.336Janus w/ Core@Shell-like
0CoCuPd3Sn\mathrm{Pd}_{3}\mathrm{Sn}2.5191.7001.330*0.2080.7690.336Janus w/ Core@Shell-like
773.15CoCuPd3Sn\mathrm{Pd}_{3}\mathrm{Sn}2.2481.4841.330*0.2080.7690.336Janus w/ Core@Shell
873.15CoCuPd3Sn\mathrm{Pd}_{3}\mathrm{Sn}2.2131.4561.330*0.2080.7690.336Janus w/ Core@Shell
1023.15CoCuPd3Sn\mathrm{Pd}_{3}\mathrm{Sn}2.1611.4141.330*0.2080.7690.336Janus w/ Core@Shell
DFTCoPd3Sn\mathrm{Pd}_{3}\mathrm{Sn}Ag2.0421.330*0.7730.7690.8330.192Shell w/ Janus core
DFTNiCuAg1.9241.3140.7730.1120.2120.369Onion

Table S2.

MCP predicts the ground-state thermodynamic morphology of the Co−Cu−Ag NP to be Onion, the Co−Pd3_3Sn−Ag NP to be a Shell with Janus core, the Co−Pd3_3Sn−Au NP to be a Shell with 2 cores morphology, the Co−Pd3_3Sn−Cu NP to be Janus with Core@Shell-like, and Ni−Cu−Ag to exhibit an Onion morphology. The reader will note that the MCP-predicted triphase morphologies are different from the experimentally observed morphologies listed in Table 4. In the Co–Cu–Ag NP, multiple morphologies are experimentally reported and the MCP prediction is close to one report. For the four remaining NPs (Co–Pd3_3Sn–Ag, Co–Pd3_3Sn–Au, Co–Pd3_3Sn–Cu, and Ni–Cu–Ag), the MCP-predicted morphologies are one topological transition away from the experimentally-observed morphology: they differ by the addition or subtraction of only one surface or interface. We discuss each NP prediction below, as well as reasons why the MCP-predicted morphology may differ from the experimentally-reported one.

As in the biphase case above, we attribute discrepancies between MCP-predicted morphologies and experimentally reported triphase morphologies to categories (I) and (II). The triphase case also introduces a third possibility: (III) the discovery of new triphase morphologies here may warrant re-evaluation of previously reported morphologies. For example, some transition triphase morphologies are observed experimentally – such as the morphology transition between Janus with Core@Shell and Pokéball, listed in Table 4 as Janus with Core@Shell-like, but have previously been categorized as Striped or Pie. [33] Category (II) also carries extra weight in the triphase case: the greater structural complexity of three- and four-element NPs makes phase-identity and interfacial-energy approximations (IIA and IIC) more likely to introduce error. For example, the Pd–Sn domain in these NPs is approximated as the L12L1_{2}-structured Pd3_3Sn, a simplification of the true, more variable Pdx_xSny_y stoichiometry. For these reasons, there may be a discrepancy between the MCP-predicted NP morphology and its experimental counterpart. Each NP in the table from top to bottom is discussed below, beginning with the Co–Cu–Ag NP.

The Co–Cu–Ag NP is experimentally reported to exhibit either a Striped, [20, 33] Pie, [22] or Striped with Onion character [66] morphology. The final report of a Janus + 1p morphology [33] was annealed at a much lower temperature and for less time than the other reports, thus it is likely that this fabrication method is diffusion-limited and the NP did not reach the energetic ground state (I). The remaining reported NP morphologies were fabricated using megalibrary

synthesis methods, with small variations in annealing time and temperature. One challenge faced in the megalibrary fabrication techniques is the diffusion of the components through the polymer solution,[29] which highlights the impact of kinetics on morphology formation. Both the Striped and Pie morphologies are reached when the outer layer of the Onion morphology retracts and does not form a shell, implying the Onion morphology may be reached if diffusion were permitted to continue over an extended period of time. In the final study, no morphology is reported but the images provided[66] indicate a Striped morphology with Onion character – a Striped morphology in process of transitioning to an Onion morphology, which aligns with the MCP-predicted morphology.

For the Co−Pd3Sn−Ag\mathrm{Co}-\mathrm{Pd}_3\mathrm{Sn}-\mathrm{Ag} NP, upon first glance the predicted Shell with Janus core morphology appears far from the reported Pie morphology. However, the only difference between the two is that one of the Pie domains has extended to cover the other two. The topological transition from Pie to Shell with Janus core suggests that it is possible the NP morphology is diffusion-limited, which prevents the formation of the ground-state morphology, falling into category (I). We additionally find support for (II) as there is a wide distribution of phases that could represent Phase B, the PdxSny\mathrm{Pd}_x\mathrm{Sn}_y phase. Of the available surface and interfacial energies for PdxSny\mathrm{Pd}_x\mathrm{Sn}_y phases, DFT-calculated values are only available for L12L1_2-structured Pd3Sn\mathrm{Pd}_3\mathrm{Sn}.[20] Lastly, support for (III) comes from the analysis of the transition between the reported Pie and predicted Shell with Janus core morphologies: it is possible that a Pie morphology may be confused for a Shell with Janus core morphology depending on the angle of visualization.

In the Co−Pd3Sn−Au\mathrm{Co}-\mathrm{Pd}_3\mathrm{Sn}-\mathrm{Au} NP, we find a few reasons for the discrepancy between the predicted Shell with 2 cores morphology and the observed Pie, all of which fall into category (II). We see the same issue as discussed above with the PdxSny\mathrm{Pd}_x\mathrm{Sn}_y phase. Closer examination of the NP compositions reveals that in all but one case, the reported Pd−Sn\mathrm{Pd}-\mathrm{Sn} phase is not Pd3Sn\mathrm{Pd}_3\mathrm{Sn}. Additionally, the experimental surface energy of Au is known to be approximately double that of the DFT-calculated surface energy.[64] Instead, we use the experimental surface energy of Au given in Ref. 58 and extrapolate to temperatures matching experimental conditions (T=773,873,1023T = 773, 873, 1023 K) to obtain a corrected MCP prediction, which is an Onion-like morphology: an Onion with mixing between the two outer layers.

The Co–Cu–PdSn(Cu) NP is predicted as Janus with Core@Shell-like, meaning a Janus with Core@Shell in transition to a Pokéball morphology. The difference between the predicted Janus with Core@Shell-like morphology and the reported Striped morphology is that the core domain has extended to come into contact with the surface as well as another domain. The transformation from one morphology to the other lends support to category (I), that the reported experimental morphology is diffusion-limited, which prevents the formation of the ground-state morphology. Category (II) also applies here because Phase B, the PdxSny\mathrm{Pd}_x\mathrm{Sn}_y phase, is approximated using the L12L1_2 Pd3Sn\mathrm{Pd}_3\mathrm{Sn} structure in the DFT interfacial and surface energy calculations. [20] To investigate this effect, we applied MCP using experimental surface energies for Cu and Co[58] and predicted a Janus with Core@Shell morphology. This is an interesting case because, when the temperature dependence of the experimental surface energies is included, the ordering of the surface energies changes, so the identities of phases A, B, and C change from Co, Pd3Sn\mathrm{Pd}_3\mathrm{Sn}, and Cu to Co, Cu, and Pd3Sn\mathrm{Pd}_3\mathrm{Sn}. This causes the phases with surfaces exposed in the Janus with Core@Shell morphology to switch places, which does not change the type of interface present but does change the amount of each one present. There is some experimentally reported Cu presence in Phase B, which is not taken into consideration in our approach. Lastly, Janus with Core@Shell is a complex morphology that may be difficult to discern from Striped in a two-dimensional microscopy image, so this case also falls into category (III).

The Ni–Cu–Ag NP is reported in Ref. 33 without a determined morphology. The images provided suggest a Janus with Core@Shell-like morphology. In contrast, MCP predicts an Onion morphology. The annealing temperatures and times in Ref. 33 are much lower than in the megalibrary synthesis methods from the other sources listed in the table, so the reported morphologies are unlikely to be equilibrium morphologies, falling into category (I). The predicted Onion morphology is again one topological transition away from the Janus with Core@Shell morphology: the outer, non-core-containing, Janus domain of the Janus with Core@Shell morphology can envelop the Core@Shell portion to form the Onion morphology, perhaps with a further annealing.

The predicted ground-state thermodynamically stable morphologies are more complex than the experimentally reported morphologies, which may imply that these more complex morphologies are less kinetically accessible since the as-implemented MCP model only captures energetically stable morphologies. Additionally, the more complex MCP-predicted morphologies may be easily confused when identified from a microscopy image, a two-dimensional projection of a three-dimensional NP. MCP can inform NP characterization, particularly the internal architecture of interfaces, as fabricated NPs become more complex. Although this study does not include kinetic or strain considerations, it may be possible for future studies to modify the MCP approach presented here to include these effects and study their relative importance. Despite the predictions not aligning concretely with experimentally reported morphologies, this work provides a tool for studying triphase NPs and comparing the impact of surface and interfacial energies on ground-state NP morphology predictions.

We conducted a study of the distribution of DFT-calculated surface and interfacial energies of elemental phases using the databases in Refs. 57 and 52. The range of the ratios of interfacial to surface energies, or equivalently σ/γ\sigma/\gamma, as well as the ratios between surface energies, γ/γ\gamma/\gamma, are calculated from this dataset to screen for MCP-predicted NP morphologies. The Venn, Pie, Striped, Onion, and Janus + 1p morphologies are experimentally reported[20, 22, 32, 33] and lie within range of DFT-calculated surface and interfacial energies, whereas the Pokéball, Shell with Janus core, Janus with Core@Shell, Shell with 2 cores, and Core@Shell + 1p do lie within range of DFT-calculated surface and interfacial energies, but are not yet experimentally reported. The remaining morphology, 3p, is neither experimentally reported nor within range of DFT-calculated surface and interfacial energies. 3p is unlikely to be experimentally reported for the same reason that 2p is unlikely to be observed in the biphase NP case: the interfacial energies between the three constituent phases must be larger than their individual surfaces. The remaining ten morphologies lie within range of DFT-calculated surface and interfacial energies, which implies they may occur at the proper combination of ratios.

Idealized schematic representations of triphase morphologies distributed by number of surfaces and interfaces

Figure 8. Idealized schematic representations of all triphase morphologies predicted, distributed by number of surfaces and number of interfaces. Those outlined with boxes are within the range of DFT-calculated surface and interfacial energy ratios from DFT surface energy[57] and interfacial energy[52] databases. The morphologies highlighted in purple are experimentally reported.[20, 22, 32, 33] Morphologies highlighted by orange boxes are predicted by systems in the DFT surface energy[57] and interfacial energy[52] databases (individual systems reported in Table 3).

Conclusions

The field of nanocombinatorics is growing rapidly but currently lacks a predictive computational approach to determining internal interface morphology of multiphase nanoparticles. This work addresses that gap with our proposed Monte Carlo Potts model, to predict multiphase nanoparticle interface morphologies as a function of surface and interfacial energies. MCP provides a discretized, flexible representation of multiphase NPs that requires no prior enumeration of candidate morphologies, in contrast to the idealized-geometry approach. It applies to any number of phases, any stoichiometric ratio, and any environment, and recovers non-idealized transition morphologies – such as the Dumbbell and Lens-type biphase architectures – that analytically-derived phase boundaries from idealized geometry cannot capture. This systematic search across surface and interfacial energy ratios makes it possible to construct stability maps for bi- and triphase NPs, which can then be used to predict morphologies of other phase-separating elemental combinations. The approach is extensible to nn-phase NPs beyond n=3n = 3, and its discretized lattice additionally provides a three-dimensional view of internal interface architecture that is difficult to capture in the two-dimensional snapshots typical of experimental microscopy.

Applying MCP to biphase and triphase NPs surfaced three biphase morphologies and 11 triphase morphologies. These morphologies follow the “number of interfaces in an nn-phase NP” rule proposed in Ref. 20 (between n−1n - 1 and n(n−1)/2n^{(n-1)/2}) and an analogous rule for the number of surfaces (between 1 and nn), but we show that neither the interface count, nor the surface count, nor the two together, uniquely determine a morphology. The ground-state architecture depends on the relative surface and interfacial energies of the component phases, as captured in the stability maps. Applying DFT-calculated energies to elemental phase combinations, MCP predictions tend toward Core@Shell-like morphologies, consistent with the hypothesis that DFT surface energies calculated in vacuum favor Core@Shell formation. [34]

Comparison with experimentally reported NPs shows agreement in the majority of biphase systems, and in the triphase case, the discrepancies are systematic and interpretable – most MCP predictions differ from experiment by only a single topological transition, consistent with kinetically limited rather than incorrect ground-state predictions.

The current model has limitations that point to clear next steps. It does not include kinetic effects, coherency strain, or temperature dependence, all of which likely contribute to the discrepancies observed between predicted and experimentally reported morphologies. Input approximations – including the T=0T = 0 K, bulk, fully-ordered-phase assumptions implemented within OQMD, and the use of vacuum-calculated DFT surface energies – may cumulatively push predictions away from their true energetic ground state. Additionally, the NP total energy equation does not factor in NP size-dependence or contact with the substrate. Potential avenues for improvement of the model include incorporating kinetic effects via a kinetic MC algorithm, or by increasing resolution via a further discretization of the Potts model into an atomistic simulation.

Methods

Biphase NP morphologies

For MCP calculation of the 2D cases, we used a 50×5050 \times50 square lattice with periodic boundary conditions and, by extension, a 50×50×5050 \times50 \times50 cubic lattice for 3D cases. We initialized a random distribution of the 3 spins (q=0,1,2q = 0, 1, 2, representing the environment, phase A, and phase B, respectively) on the underlying lattice. We tailored the number of spins representing the environment (q=0q = 0) to allow the formation of separate particles. If the amount of q=0q = 0 spins is too low, the system is artificially constrained in such a way that the A and B phases must be in contact. The volume ratio of Environment spins on the 2D square lattice is 70% and 90% on the 3D cubic lattice. All results discussed assume equal amounts of A and B unless otherwise noted. We applied a spin-conserved Metropolis MC algorithm with a simulated anneal to the random initial lattice using three dimensionless temperature steps of kT=0.25kT = 0.25, 0.125, 0.05. As a check on the three-step anneal, we also repeated the calculations with a finer schedule in which kTkT was lowered from 0.25 to 0.04, each step set to 90% of the previous value, and obtained the same morphologies.

In 2D, each temperature step was held for 10,000 MC timesteps and 600 MC timesteps in 3D. We fine-tuned the two simulation parameters of temperature and number of equilibration steps to allow the simulation to reach a converged energy state before a decrease in temperature while minimizing computational resources. The initial temperature step is adjusted such that the acceptance probability of an uphill spin swap is ∼ 80% and the number of MC timesteps is dictated by the minimum number required for the simulation total energy to not change beyond 0.01% in the last 10% of the timesteps. For example, in 2D simulations, the simulation energy convergence at that temperature occurs when the energy does not change more than 0.01% during the last 1,000 MC timesteps at that temperature step. We repeat each run five times and select the one with the lowest energy as the representative morphology.

We systematically applied the MCP method to sample input ratios to calculate the effect of interfacial and surface energies on biphase NP morphologies. We iterate in a grid search fashion over the two values in Jqmqn=(01γB/γA10σAB/γAγB/γAσAB/γA0)J_{q_mq_n} = \begin{pmatrix} 0 & 1 & \gamma_B/\gamma_A \\ 1 & 0 & \sigma_{AB}/\gamma_A \\ \gamma_B/\gamma_A & \sigma_{AB}/\gamma_A & 0 \end{pmatrix} to calculate a stability map by visualization and categorization of the MCP output. We perform the grid search over γB/γA\gamma_B/\gamma_A and σAB/γA\sigma_{AB}/\gamma_A in the range of 0.005 to 1 in increments of 0.0025, and extend the upper range to 2 for σAB/γA\sigma_{AB}/\gamma_A.

We use a point-by-point iteration over the final lattice to count the number of A–Environment, B–Environment, and A–B nearest neighbor spin interactions, which provides a numerical value on the amount of A surface, B surface, and A–B interface observed in the output lattice. We categorize the output morphology from these values according to the definitions of each morphology (see also Table 1 for the surface and interface counts). In short, any morphology with zero A–Environment or B–Environment interactions is a Core@Shell. A morphology with no A–B interactions is 2p. A morphology with any number of all three interactions is a Janus morphology. Thus, a categorical A–B biphase NP interface morphology is mapped to a pair of γB/γA\gamma_B/\gamma_A and σAB/γA\sigma_{AB}/\gamma_A values, forming a ground-state NP morphology stability map.

Triphase NP morphologies

Following the construction of the biphase NP morphology stability map, we applied the same procedure to triphase particles. Triphase NPs are composed of sample phases A, B, and C, represented by four spins, q=0,1,2,3q = 0, 1, 2, 3, representing the environment followed by each of the three phases. The four spins form six unlike interactions: A–Environment, B–Environment, C–Environment, A–B, A–C, and B–C. These interactions are described by the respective surface and interfacial energies of the phases, γA\gamma_A, γB\gamma_B, γC\gamma_C, σAB\sigma_{AB}, σAC\sigma_{AC}, and σBC\sigma_{BC}. We conducted a comprehensive search of this reduced parameter space, as described earlier in the biphase section, to calculate a triphase morphology stability map. We conduct the grid search over the range of 0.1 to 1 in increments of 0.1 for each ratio. Our ordering of phases by decreasing surface energy allows us to remove some combinations of ratios without loss of generality, so for mm increments, we can map out the grid using m(m+1)2×m(m+1)2×m\frac{m(m+1)}{2} \times\frac{m(m+1)}{2} \times m points. As before, to allow separation of A, B, and C into three separate particles, a minimum amount of environment q=0q = 0 spins must be present in the lattice system. The volume ratio of Environment spins on the 2D square lattice is 50% and 90% on the 3D cubic lattice. All results discussed use equal numbers of spins of A, B, and C. As in the biphase case, we apply the same counting procedure to A–Environment, B–Environment, C–Environment, A–B, A–C, and B–C interactions and take into account the connectivity of each phase to distinguish topologically distinct triphase morphologies.

These approaches can extend to nn-phase systems using an (n+1)×(n+1)(n + 1) \times(n + 1) interaction energy matrix populated with n(n+1)2\frac{n(n+1)}{2} non-zero terms. The non-zero terms used to model the system comprise nn surface energy terms (γ1,γ2,…,γn−1,γn)(\gamma_1, \gamma_2, \ldots, \gamma_{n-1}, \gamma_n) and n(n−1)2\frac{n(n-1)}{2} interfacial energy terms between unlike phases. These terms populate the interaction energy matrix JqmqnJ_{q_m q_n}, which serves as input into MCP and allows for the solution of eq. (2), the discretized form of eq. (1).

Conflicts of interest

There are no conflicts to declare.

Data availability

The data supporting this article have been included as part of the Supplementary Information.

Acknowledgement

E.S. acknowledges support by the National Science Foundation Graduate Research Fellowship award NSF DGE-1842165. The authors acknowledge financial support of this research by the International Institute of Nanotechnology at Northwestern University. This research was supported in part through the computational resources provided by the Quest high performance computing facility at Northwestern University which is jointly supported by the Office of the Provost, the Office for Research, and Northwestern University Information Technology.

Supplementary Information: additional calculation details, including surface and interfacial energies used in MCP predictions, further comparison of the use of DFT and experimental data in MCP predictions, and tables of compiled published experimental multiphase nanoparticle data

  • Table S1. Input parameter details for biphase nanoparticle interface morphology compared to experimental references

  • Table S2. Input parameter details for triphase nanoparticle interface morphology compared to experimental references, with consideration for temperature

  • Figure S1. Schematic illustration of biphase NP morphology transitions along the biphase stability map

Schematic of biphase NP morphologies transition across the Potts-calculated biphase stability map

Figure S1. Schematic of biphase NP morphologies transition across the Potts-calculated biphase stability map. As the ratio of interfacial energy relative to the largest surface energy (σAB/γA\sigma_{AB}/\gamma_A) increases in (A), the ground-state NP morphology predicted by MCP evolves from Core@Shell, to Lens-type, and then to an idealized Janus in an effort to minimize interfacial area. Once the ratio surpasses 1, meaning σAB>γA\sigma_{AB} > \gamma_A, the predicted ground-state NP morphology is now Dumbbell, which decreases the shared interfacial area and increases the surface area, and eventually the interface is removed altogether, forming 2 separate particles (2p). In (B), the increase in surface energy ratio (γB/γA\gamma_B/\gamma_A) between the two phases changes the predicted ground-state NP morphology. Beginning at the same point as before, with the A@B Core@Shell morphology, the increase in surface energy of B relative to A results in the formation of the Lens-type morphology to reduce the amount of B surface area. Further increase in γB\gamma_B results in the idealized Janus morphology, where the surface area of B has further decreased from the surface area of B in the Lens-type morphology. Once the ratio γB/γA\gamma_B/\gamma_A surpasses 1, a Lens-type morphology forms once more, with the aim to decrease the surface area of B, since the surface energy of B now surpasses that of A. Continuing to increase the γB/γA\gamma_B/\gamma_A ratio results in the formation of a B@A Core@Shell NP, where there is no more B surface present.

  • Table S3. Input parameter details for triphase nanoparticle interface morphology predictions using DFT-calculated surface and interfacial energies

  • Table S4. Compilation of published experimental single-phase nanoparticle data

  • Table S5. Compilation of published experimental biphase nanoparticle data

CompositionPhase APhase BExpt. morphologyMCP predicted morphologyExpt. referenceExpt. notesRelated comp. referencesComp. notes
AgCuAuAuAgJanus–10.1126/sciadv.abj5505
Not reportedAuAgsolid solution–10.1021/jacs.1c1118Core@Shell (Au@Ag) domains mix after annealing at 500 °C for another 12 h; 30-50 nm10.1021/jp510725a; 10.1021/jp200642dno Janus at large scale
Not reportedAuCuCore@Shell (Au@Cu)solid solution10.1021/jacs.1c1118Authors note similar heating causes evolution from Core@Shell to alloy structure
CompositionPhase APhase BExpt. morphologyMCP predicted morphologyExpt. referenceExpt. notesRelated comp. referencesComp. notes
AuCuCore@Shell (Cu@Au)–10.1039/C6NR03560Dsurface reconstruction for thin shells leads to new shapes
Not reportedCore@Shell (Au@Cu)alloy10.1021/jacs.1c11118Authors note similar heating causes evolution from Core@Shell to alloy structure
Au (fcc)Fe (bcc)Janus–10.1039/D1NR00383Fsolid solution at room temperature; phase-separation to Janus when heated to 700 °C
CompositionPhase APhase BExpt. morphologyMCP predicted morphologyExpt. referenceExpt. notesRelated comp. referencesComp. notes
Au0.57Pd0.27Sn0.16Au_{0.57}Pd_{0.27}Sn_{0.16}AuPd1.7SnPd_{1.7}SnJanus–10.1126/science.aav4302
Au0.57Pd0.27Sn0.16Au_{0.57}Pd_{0.27}Sn_{0.16}AuPdSnJanus–10.1126/science.aav4302
AuPd3SnPd_{3}SnCore@Shell
AuPtCore@ShellCore@Shell (Pt@Au)10.1038/nmat2156
AuPtNiJanus–10.1073/pnas.1800884115
AuAgAuCuJanus–10.1126/science.aaf8402Au 30%, AgxCuyAg_xCu_y; ∼40 nm
Au0.21Ag0.32Pd0.32Sn0.15Au_{0.21}Ag_{0.32}Pd_{0.32}Sn_{0.15}AuAgPdSnJanus–10.1126/science.aav4302
CompositionPhase APhase BExpt. morphologyMCP predicted morphologyExpt. referenceExpt. notesRelated comp. referencesComp. notes
Co0.17Ni0.25Cu0.1Pd0.15Ag0.15Au0.15Co_{0.17}Ni_{0.25}Cu_{0.1}Pd_{0.15}Ag_{0.15}Au_{0.15}AuAgCuPd(Cu)CoNi(Pd)Janus–10.1126/sciadv.abj5505
AuAgCuPdCoNiJanus–10.1126/sciadv.abj5505
AuCuAuAgJanus–10.1126/sciadv.abj5505
AuCuCoNiJanus–10.1126/science.aaf840210 - 15 nm
AuCu-PdSnAuCuPdSnJanus–10.1126/science.aav4302
Co2Ni4CuPdAu2Co_{2}Ni_{4}CuPdAu_{2}AuCuPdCoNiJanus–10.1126/sciadv.abj5505
CompositionPhase APhase BExpt. morphologyMCP predicted morphologyExpt. referenceExpt. notesRelated comp. referencesComp. notes
AuNiPtCore@Shell (AuNi@Pt)–10.1021/acscatal.5 b01656
Au0.32Co0.34Pd0.34\mathrm{Au}_{0.32}\mathrm{Co}_{0.34}\mathrm{Pd}_{0.34}AuPdCo–10.1126/science.aaf8402
Au0.32Co0.34Pd0.34\mathrm{Au}_{0.32}\mathrm{Co}_{0.34}\mathrm{Pd}_{0.34}AuPdCoJanus–10.1126/science.aav4302
CompositionPhase APhase BExpt. morphologyMCP predicted morphologyExpt. referenceExpt. notesRelated comp. referencesComp. notes
Not reportedCoAgJanus/2p alloyCore@Shell10.1021/jacs.1c11118160 °C for 4 h leads to 2p; 500 °C anneal for 12 h leads to Janus; annealing at 230 °C for 6 h also leads to Janus10.1039/d2fd00114d: predicts quasi-Janus; 10.1039/C6NR03560D: surface reconstruction leads to new shapes; 10.1088/0957-4484/27/11/115702https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/36349781/; depends on substrate
CompositionPhase APhase BExpt. morphologyMCP predicted morphologyExpt. referenceExpt. notesRelated comp. referencesComp. notes
CoAuCore@ShellCore@Shell (Co@Au), next closest is Janus10.1021/cr100449nRedox reaction to avoid diffusion of shell into core10.1039/C6NR03560DCore@Shell (Co@Au); surface reconstruction for thin shells
Not reportedJanus10.1021/jacs.1c1118Annealing at 230 °C for 6 h10.1021/jp302260bChanges with decreasing temperature: solid solution at high temp, then Onion-like, then Janus
Not reportedCoNiJanus–10.1021/jacs.1c11118500 °C anneal for 12 h leads to Janus; 185 °C for 6 h
CompositionPhase APhase BExpt. morphologyMCP predicted morphologyExpt. referenceExpt. notesRelated comp. referencesComp. notes
Not reported2pAnnealing at 230 °C for 6h
Co0.50Pd0.32Sn0.18\mathrm{Co}_{0.50}\mathrm{Pd}_{0.32}\mathrm{Sn}_{0.18}Co\mathrm{Co}Pd1.7Sn\mathrm{Pd}_{1.7}\mathrm{Sn}Janus–10.1126/science.aav4302
–Co\mathrm{Co}Pd3Sn\mathrm{Pd}_{3}\mathrm{Sn}–Janus–
Co0.66Pd0.17Sn0.17\mathrm{Co}_{0.66}\mathrm{Pd}_{0.17}\mathrm{Sn}_{0.17}Co\mathrm{Co}PdSn\mathrm{PdSn}Janus–10.1126/science.aav4302
Co-PdSnCo\mathrm{Co}CuPdSn\mathrm{CuPdSn}Janus–10.1126/science.aav4302
Co\mathrm{Co}Pt\mathrm{Pt}alloyed; L10L1_{0} structure–10.1039/B705912Bcontrolled by deposition rate
CompositionPhase APhase BExpt. morphologyMCP predicted morphologyExpt. referenceExpt. notesRelated comp. referencesComp. notes
Core@Shell (Co@Pt; CoPt@Pt)10.1039/C6NR03560D; 10.1038/nmat3458surface reconstruction for thin shells leads to new shapes
CoNiJanus/2p–10.1021/jacs.1c1118230 °C for 6h leads to 2p; 500 °C anneal for 12h leads to Janus
Co-PdSnCoCuPdSnJanus–10.1126/science.aav4302
CoPd3_3SnJanusJanus10.1126/science.aav4302
CompositionPhase APhase BExpt. morphologyMCP predicted morphologyExpt. referenceExpt. notesRelated comp. referencesComp. notes
Co0.38Ni0.23Pd0.18Sn0.21\mathrm{Co}_{0.38}\mathrm{Ni}_{0.23}\mathrm{Pd}_{0.18}\mathrm{Sn}_{0.21}CoNiPdSnJanus–10.1126/science.aav4302“For example, CoNiPdSn NPs with two different compositions show either a bi-phase structure (Fig. S27B) or a tri-phase structure (Fig. 5B})”(tri-phase composition is Co0.13Ni0.35Pd0.26Sn0.26\mathrm{Co}_{0.13}\mathrm{Ni}_{0.35}\mathrm{Pd}_{0.26}\mathrm{Sn}_{0.26})
(Elodie’s note: looks more like Striped to me)
CompositionPhase APhase BExpt. morphologyMCP predicted morphologyExpt. referenceExpt. notesRelated comp. referencesComp. notes
CoNi-PdSnCoNiPdSnJanus–10.1126/science.aav4302
CuAgJanus, 2pCore@Shell (Cu@Ag)10.1021/jacs.1c111182p small NP, then heated to form Janus; Janus when heated 160 for 4h, “lenticular” shape
Core@Shell (Cu@Ag)10.1039/C6NR03560Dsurface reconstruction for thin shells leads to new shapes
CompositionPhase APhase BExpt. morphologyMCP predicted morphologyExpt. referenceExpt. notesRelated comp. referencesComp. notes
Core@Shell (Cu@Ag)10.1103/PhysRevB.73.113402surface reconstruction for thin shells leads to new shapes
JanusJanus or Core@Shell depending on surface & interfacial energy method used10.1126/sciadv.adj6129
Core@Shell (Cu@Ag), 2p, Janus10.1039/B705912Bmorphology changes depending on size of Cu cores
CompositionPhase APhase BExpt. morphologyMCP predicted morphologyExpt. referenceExpt. notesRelated comp. referencesComp. notes
solid solution10.1016/j.calphad. 2018.11.013The randomly mixed core of the Ag-Cu nanoparticles (22 mol% Cu) – choice of precursor is important and decides if Core@Shell or random alloy10.1039/C2NR11954DDFT to study transition from CS to Janus
CompositionPhase APhase BExpt. morphologyMCP predicted morphologyExpt. referenceExpt. notesRelated comp. referencesComp. notes
CuCoJanus, 2pJanus10.1021/jacs.1c11118Heat to form Janus: Janus obtained after annealing at 230 ∘C230\,^{\circ}\mathrm{C} for 6 h (∼40\sim40 nm); 2p obtained after heating at 185 ∘C185\,^{\circ}\mathrm{C} for 6 h (∼20\sim20 nm Co & ∼15\sim15 nm Cu)
Cu0.92Pd0.08\mathrm{Cu}_{0.92}\mathrm{Pd}_{0.08}-Cu0.2(PdSn)0.8\mathrm{Cu}_{0.2}(\mathrm{PdSn})_{0.8}; Cu0.46Pd0.39Sn0.15\mathrm{Cu}_{0.46}\mathrm{Pd}_{0.39}\mathrm{Sn}_{0.15}CuPdSnCu(Pd)Janus–10.1126/science.aav4302
CompositionPhase APhase BExpt. morphologyMCP predicted morphologyExpt. referenceExpt. notesRelated comp. referencesComp. notes
CuNi-PdSnCuNiPdSnJanus–10.1126/science.aav4302
Not reportedCuAgJanusCore@Shell (Cu@Ag)10.1021/jacs.1c11118; 10.1016/j.calphad.2018.11.013; 10.1039/C6NR03560DAnnealing at 160 °C for 4 h (∼25 nm); 2p small NP, then heated to form Janus; “lenticular” shape; surface reconstruction for thin shells leads to new shapes
CompositionPhase APhase BExpt. morphologyMCP predicted morphologyExpt. referenceExpt. notesRelated comp. referencesComp. notes
Core@Shell (Cu@Ag)10.1103/PhysRevB.73.113402
CuAuCore@Shell (Cu@Au)–10.1039/C6NR03560Dsurface reconstruction for thin shells leads to new shapes
CuCoJanusCore@Shell (Co@Cu) in 2D; Janus in 3D10.1021/jacs.1c11118Annealing at 230 °C for 6 h (∼40 nm)
2pAnnealing at 185 °C for 6 h, ∼20 nm Co & ∼15 nm Cu
CompositionPhase APhase BExpt. morphologyMCP predicted morphologyExpt. referenceExpt. notesRelated comp. referencesComp. notes
CuNiCore@Shell (Cu@Ni)Core@Shell10.1016/j.calphad. 2018.11.013; 10.1021/jacs.1c11118230 °C for 6h; depends on order of deposition10.1021/jp302260bChanges with temperature: solid solution @ high temp, then Onion-like, then Janus @ low temp
CuNiCore@Shell (Cu@Ni); Core@Shell (Cu@Ni)Core@Shell10.1016/j.calphad. 2018.11.013; 10.1021/jacs.1c11118230 °C for 6h; depends on order of deposition
CompositionPhase APhase BExpt. morphologyMCP predicted morphologyExpt. referenceExpt. notesRelated comp. referencesComp. notes
Cu0.88Ir0.12Cu_{0.88}Ir_{0.12}, Cu0.79Ir0.21Cu_{0.79}Ir_{0.21}CuIrCore@Shell10.1021/jacs.2c02538on
CompositionPhase APhase BExpt. morphologyMCP predicted morphologyExpt. referenceExpt. notesRelated comp. referencesComp. notes
Cu0.88Rh0.12\mathrm{Cu}_{0.88}\mathrm{Rh}_{0.12}, Cu0.79Rh0.21\mathrm{Cu}_{0.79}\mathrm{Rh}_{0.21}CuRhCore@Shell10.1021/jacs.2c02538reaction temperature of 260 °C; “If the temperature is increased too slowly, the reaction will yield a higher dispersion of particle diameters and lead to the formation of very large bimetallic crystals.”
CompositionPhase APhase BExpt. morphologyMCP predicted morphologyExpt. referenceExpt. notesRelated comp. referencesComp. notes
Cu0.88Ru0.12\mathrm{Cu}_{0.88}\mathrm{Ru}_{0.12}, Cu0.94Ru0.06\mathrm{Cu}_{0.94}\mathrm{Ru}_{0.06}, Cu0.79Ru0.21\mathrm{Cu}_{0.79}\mathrm{Ru}_{0.21}CuRuCore@Shell10.1021/jacs.2c02538reaction temperature of 270 °C; “If the temperature is increased too slowly, the reaction will yield a higher dispersion of particle diameters and lead to the formation of very large bimetallic crystals.”
CompositionPhase APhase BExpt. morphologyMCP predicted morphologyExpt. referenceExpt. notesRelated comp. referencesComp. notes
GaInJanushttps://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S2590238519300050
Au3Ir7Au_{3}Ir_{7}, Au5Ir5Au_{5}Ir_{5}, Au7Ir3Au_{7}Ir_{3}IrAuCore@Shell (Ir@Au)https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S016943321831938XLaser irradiation for 30 minutes; caption description indicates Lens
IrPtCore@ShellCore@Shell10.1038/nmat2156
MnNicubic Core@Shell–10.1021/cr040090g
CompositionPhase APhase BExpt. morphologyMCP predicted morphologyExpt. referenceExpt. notesRelated comp. referencesComp. notes
NiAgJanusCore@Shell (Ni@Ag)10.1126/sciadv.adj612910.1016/j.calphad.2018.11.013 says core@Shell
2p10.1021/jacs.1c11118Annealing at 230 °C for 6 h.
Core@Shell (Ni@Ag)10.1039/C6NR03560Dsurface reconstruction for thin shells leads to new shapes
Ag3_3Ni, AgNi, AgNi3_310.1103/PhysRevB.65.165422small (<7<7 nm); Ag/Ni interface is relatively loose; NPs in a dielectric matrix10.1039/C6NR03560Dsurface reconstruction for thin shells leads to new shapes; Ni@Ag
CompositionPhase APhase BExpt. morphologyMCP predicted morphologyExpt. referenceExpt. notesRelated comp. referencesComp. notes
AgNiCore@Shell (Ag@Ni)10.1016/j.calphad.2018.11.01323–31 nm depending on composition
Not reportedNiAuJanus–10.1021/jacs.1c11118Annealed at 500 °C for 6h, then 700 °C for 2 hours to see Janus; ∼50 nm diameter10.1016/j.calphad.2017.05.002phase diagram study of changing particle size
Not reportedJanus → Core@Shell10.1039/C4NR03559Csome Au mixed into Ni; forms Core@Shell after oxidation (Onion w/ outer oxidized layer)
CompositionPhase APhase BExpt. morphologyMCP predicted morphologyExpt. referenceExpt. notesRelated comp. referencesComp. notes
Janus10.1126/sciadv.adj 6129annealing at 230 °C for 6 h
Not reported10.1016/j.calphad. 2018.11.013interesting for both experimental and theoretical studies if the size of alloy particles decreases to nanoscale and the discontinuous precipitation is not possible.
CompositionPhase APhase BExpt. morphologyMCP predicted morphologyExpt. referenceExpt. notesRelated comp. referencesComp. notes
Au0.24Ag0.24\mathrm{Au}_{0.24}\mathrm{Ag}_{0.24} Ni0.52\mathrm{Ni}_{0.52}NiAuAgJanus–10.1126/science.aaf8402likely AuAg alloy (111) and Ni (111); ∼30 nm, ∼20 nm, ∼35 nm”
Not reported10.1021/jacs.1c11118Annealed at 500 °C for 4 h; Ag deposited on Ni/Au Janus seeds
NiAuPtCore@Shell (Ni@AuPt)–10.1021/acscatal.5b01656
NiCuCore@Shell (Ni@Cu)Core@Shell10.1021/jacs.1c11118
CompositionPhase APhase BExpt. morphologyMCP predicted morphologyExpt. referenceExpt. notesRelated comp. referencesComp. notes
10.1016/j.calphad. 2018.11.013
NiRhCore@Shell (Ni@Rh)10.1039/C6NR 03560Dsurface reconstruction for thin shells leads to new shapes
NiPtCore@Shell (Ni@Pt)–10.1021/acscatal.5 b0165610.1063/1.1828 033
Core@Shell (Ni@Pt)10.1039/C6NR03 560Dsurface reconstruction for thin shells leads to new shapes
CompositionPhase APhase BExpt. morphologyMCP predicted morphologyExpt. referenceExpt. notesRelated comp. referencesComp. notes
solid solution (single-phase);10.1016/j.calphad.2018.11.013
Janus alloy (single-phase)10.1073/pnas.1800884115
NiPdCore@Shell (Ni@Pd)–10.1039/B513587Gclusters: j=6j=6nm
NiPd10.1039/C6NR03560Dsurface reconstruction for thin shells leads to new shapes
NiPdSnJanus–10.1126/science.aav4302
CompositionPhase APhase BExpt. morphologyMCP predicted morphologyExpt. referenceExpt. notesRelated comp. referencesComp. notes
Ni\mathrm{Ni}Pt\mathrm{Pt}Core@Shell (Ni@Pt\mathrm{Ni}@\mathrm{Pt})–10.1021/acscatal.5 b01656
solid solution (single-phase)10.1016/j.calphad.2018.11.013randomly mixed core structure
random (alloy)10.1073/pnas.1800884115
Ni0.6Sn0.4\mathrm{Ni}_{0.6}\mathrm{Sn}_{0.4}-Ni0.08(PdSn)0.92\mathrm{Ni}_{0.08}(\mathrm{PdSn})_{0.92}NiSn\mathrm{NiSn}(Ni\mathrm{Ni})PdSnJanus–10.1126/science.aav4302
Cu0.33Ni0.32Pd0.16Sn0.19\mathrm{Cu}_{0.33}\mathrm{Ni}_{0.32}\mathrm{Pd}_{0.16}\mathrm{Sn}_{0.19}NiCu\mathrm{NiCu}PdSn(NiCu)Janus–10.1126/science.aav4302
Co0.38Ni0.23Pd0.18Sn0.21\mathrm{Co}_{0.38}\mathrm{Ni}_{0.23}\mathrm{Pd}_{0.18}\mathrm{Sn}_{0.21}Janus–10.1126/science.aav4302
Ni0.32Pd0.37Sn0.31\mathrm{Ni}_{0.32}\mathrm{Pd}_{0.37}\mathrm{Sn}_{0.31}NiPd\mathrm{NiPd}PdSnJanus–10.1126/science.aav4302
CompositionPhase APhase BExpt. morphologyMCP predicted morphologyExpt. referenceExpt. notesRelated comp. referencesComp. notes
RhAuRandom (alloy)Core@Shell (Rh@Au)10.1038/s41565-024-01626-0
Core@Shell (Rh@Au & Au@Rh)10.1021/la902674ucan depend on the support
Core@Shell (Au@Rh)10.1016/J.VACUUM.2011.07.014
Janus10.1021/ACS.NA NOLETT.1C02225
Core@Shell (Rh@Au)Core@Shell10.1039/C6NR03560Dsurface reconstruction for thin shells leads to new shapes
CompositionPhase APhase BExpt. morphologyMCP predicted morphologyExpt. referenceExpt. notesRelated comp. referencesComp. notes
Co0.75Rh0.25\mathrm{Co}_{0.75}\mathrm{Rh}_{0.25}Rh (fcc)CoCore@ShellCore@Shell (for FCC [100]/FCC [100])10.1103/PhysRevB.69.235416¡7 nm; surface segregation; Co is fcc at smaller sizes, then hcp at 4-6 nm; “The Co-rich Co3_3Rh1_1 [has] a large majority of hcp grains, while the Rh-rich sample (Co0.39_{0.39}Rh0.61_{0.61}) is mainly fcc, although its composition is closer to Co2_2Rh3_3 than to Co1_1Rh3_3 ...The two samples with compositions close to Co1_1Rh1_1 (Co0.53_{0.53}Rh0.47_{0.47} and Co0.45_{0.45}Rh0.55_{0.55}
CompositionPhase APhase BExpt. morphologyMCP predicted morphologyExpt. referenceExpt. notesRelated comp. referencesComp. notes
RuPtCore@Shell–10.1038/nmat2156“highly distorted hcp Ru cores that are primarily in the metallic state but show little order beyond 8 Å. In contrast, the 1-2 monolayer thick Pt shells are relatively crystalline but are slightly distorted (compressed) relative to bulk fcc P”https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/19731934/
CompositionPhase APhase BExpt. morphologyMCP predicted morphologyExpt. referenceExpt. notesRelated comp. referencesComp. notes
Au1Pd4Au_{1}Pd_{4}PdAuCore@Shell–10.1039/A80575 3B∼2nm
PdPtCore@Shell mixes–10.1038/nmat2156 10.1021/cr040090g
Pd3NiPd_{3}Ni, Pd4NiPd_{4}Ni, Pd6NiPd_{6}Ni, Pd8NiPd_{8}NiPdNiCore@Shell (Pd@Ni)–10.1126/sciadv.a ap8817
Ag0.55Pd0.26Sn0.19Ag_{0.55}Pd_{0.26}Sn_{0.19}PdSnAgJanus–10.1126/science.aav4302
SnAg–10.1016/j.calphad.2018.11.013
CompositionPhase APhase BExpt. morphologyMCP predicted morphologyExpt. referenceExpt. notesRelated comp. referencesComp. notes
PdPtCore@Shell–10.1039/A805753BPVP-stabilized; particle size depends on composition; < 5 nm
Pd3_3SnAg–Core@Shell–
PdSnCuJanus–10.1126/science.aav4302
Pd3_3SnCuJanus
Cu0.46_{0.46}Pd0.39_{0.39}Sn0.15_{0.15}Pd2.6_{2.6}SnCuJanus–10.1126/science.aav4302
Cu0.92_{0.92}Pd0.08_{0.08}-Cu0.2_{0.2}(PdSn)0.8_{0.8}CuPdSnCu(Pd)Janus–10.1126/science.aav4302
CompositionPhase APhase BExpt. morphologyMCP predicted morphologyExpt. referenceExpt. notesRelated comp. referencesComp. notes
PdAuCoPdPdAuCoPdJanus–
PdCuIrCore@Shell–10.1002/ange.202016199
CompositionPhase APhase BExpt. morphologyMCP predicted morphologyExpt. referenceExpt. notesRelated comp. referencesComp. notes
Pt46_{46}Au54_{54}PtAuJanusCore@Shell (Pt@Au)10.1073/pnas.180088411518 nm; annealing: under Ar gas flow, ramp to 150 °C within 1 h, hold at 150 °C for 48 h, cooldown to 25 °C within 1 h, switch the atmosphere to H2_2, ramp to 500 °C within 2 h, hold at 500 °C for 12 h, cooldown to 25 °C within 2 h
CompositionPhase APhase BExpt. morphologyMCP predicted morphologyExpt. referenceExpt. notesRelated comp. referencesComp. notes
Core@Shell (Au@Pt)10.1039/A805753Belectrochem
10.1002/ppsc.201700401redox; sequential synthesis
PtRhCore@Shell–10.1021/cr040090gsome surface segregation of core to shell
PtRuCore@Shell–some surface segregation of core to shell
PtPdCore@Shell (Pt@Pd)–10.1021/cr040090gbulk mixes; strong surface segregation of Pd
PtAuCu–random (alloy)–10.1073/pnas.1800884115
CompositionPhase APhase BExpt. morphologyMCP predicted morphologyExpt. referenceExpt. notesRelated comp. referencesComp. notes
PtCu–random (alloy)–10.1073/pnas.1800884115
Pt₃₂Au₃₆Ni₃₂PtNiAuJanus–10.1073/pnas.1800884115

Table S5. Experimentally reported biphase nanoparticle morphologies compared with Monte Carlo Potts (MCP) predictions.

  • Table S6. Compilation of published experimental triphase nanoparticle data

CompositionPhase APhase BPhase CExpt. morphology*MCP predicted morphologyExpt. referenceExpt. notes
Ag0.23Cu0.47Co0.30Ag_{0.23}Cu_{0.47}Co_{0.30}AgCuCoStripedOnion10.1126/science.aav4302
Co0.07Cu0.27Ag0.66Co_{0.07}Cu_{0.27}Ag_{0.66}Striped (in transition to Onion)10.1126/sciadv.abj5505∼30\sim30 nm
Not listedPie10.1126/sciadv.adj6129∼75\sim75 nm; Co deposited on Ag/Cu Janus seed
Not listedStriped10.1021/jacs.1c11118Annealed at 600 °C, ∼55\sim55 nm in diameter
Not listedJanus + 1p10.1021/jacs.1c11118Annealed at 185 °C
Ag0.43Cu0.19Co0.38Ag_{0.43}Cu_{0.19}Co_{0.38}Pie10.1126/science.aaf8402
CompositionPhase APhase BPhase CExpt. morphology*MCP predicted morphologyExpt. referenceExpt. notes
Co0.13Ni0.35Pd0.26Sn0.26Co_{0.13}Ni_{0.35}Pd_{0.26}Sn_{0.26}NiSnPdSnCoNiPie–10.1126/science.aav4302
Au0.37Co0.18Ni0.36Sn0.09Au_{0.37}Co_{0.18}Ni_{0.36}Sn_{0.09}NiSnCoNiAuPie–10.1126/science.aav4302
Au0.29Co0.17Ni0.19Pd0.20Sn0.15Au_{0.29}Co_{0.17}Ni_{0.19}Pd_{0.20}Sn_{0.15}AuPdSnCoNiPie–10.1126/science.aav4302
Au0.25Ni0.24Pd0.20Sn0.31Au_{0.25}Ni_{0.24}Pd_{0.20}Sn_{0.31}; Au-NiSn-PdSnAuPdSnNiSnPie–10.1126/science.aav4302
Ag-NiSn-PdSnAgPdSnNiSnPie–10.1126/science.aav4302
Au0.30Ag0.19Cu0.29Co0.22Au_{0.30}Ag_{0.19}Cu_{0.29}Co_{0.22}AuAgAuCuCoStriped–10.1126/science.aav4302∼\sim45 nm diameter
CompositionPhase APhase BPhase CExpt. morphology*MCP predicted morphologyExpt. referenceExpt. notes
Au0.12Ag0.30Cu0.28Pd0.20Sn0.10\mathrm{Au}_{0.12}\mathrm{Ag}_{0.30}\mathrm{Cu}_{0.28}\mathrm{Pd}_{0.20}\mathrm{Sn}_{0.10}AuAgAuCuPdSn(Cu)Pie–10.1126/science.aav4302∼\sim45 nm diameter
Au0.06Ag0.10Co0.24Pd0.39Sn0.21\mathrm{Au}_{0.06}\mathrm{Ag}_{0.10}\mathrm{Co}_{0.24}\mathrm{Pd}_{0.39}\mathrm{Sn}_{0.21}AuAgCoPdSnPie–10.1126/science.aav4302∼\sim45 nm diameter
Au0.13Cu0.27Co0.30Pd0.15Sn0.15\mathrm{Au}_{0.13}\mathrm{Cu}_{0.27}\mathrm{Co}_{0.30}\mathrm{Pd}_{0.15}\mathrm{Sn}_{0.15}AuCuPdSn(Cu)CoPie–10.1126/science.aav4302∼\sim45 nm diameter
Co0.34Cu0.29Pd0.21Sn0.16\mathrm{Co}_{0.34}\mathrm{Cu}_{0.29}\mathrm{Pd}_{0.21}\mathrm{Sn}_{0.16}CoCuPdSn(Cu)Striped–10.1126/science.aav4302
Ag0.30Cu0.30Pd0.27Sn0.13\mathrm{Ag}_{0.30}\mathrm{Cu}_{0.30}\mathrm{Pd}_{0.27}\mathrm{Sn}_{0.13}AgCuPdSn(Cu)Pie–10.1126/science.aav4302
Ag0.33Co0.23Pd0.27Sn0.17\mathrm{Ag}_{0.33}\mathrm{Co}_{0.23}\mathrm{Pd}_{0.27}\mathrm{Sn}_{0.17}AgCoPd2Sn\mathrm{Pd}_2\mathrm{Sn}Pie–10.1126/science.aav4302
CompositionPhase APhase BPhase CExpt. morphology*MCP predicted morphologyExpt. referenceExpt. notes
Ag0.43Co0.23Pd0.23Sn0.11\mathrm{Ag}_{0.43}\mathrm{Co}_{0.23}\mathrm{Pd}_{0.23}\mathrm{Sn}_{0.11}AgCoPdSnPie–10.1126/science.aav4302
Ag-Cu-PdSnAgCuPdSnPie (3/4); Striped (1/4)–10.1126/science.aav4302
Au0.30Co0.37Pd0.19Sn0.14\mathrm{Au}_{0.30}\mathrm{Co}_{0.37}\mathrm{Pd}_{0.19}\mathrm{Sn}_{0.14}AuCoPd1Sn1\mathrm{Pd}_{1}\mathrm{Sn}_{1}Pie–10.1126/science.aav4302When annealed for longer times (5 days) at a higher temperature (750 °C), the two-interface NPs evolved into three-interface structures; three-interface NPs remained relatively unchanged; evaporative loss of Sn; 15 to 60 nm
Au0.33Co0.34Pd0.18Sn0.15\mathrm{Au}_{0.33}\mathrm{Co}_{0.34}\mathrm{Pd}_{0.18}\mathrm{Sn}_{0.15}
Au0.24Co0.58(PdSn)0.18\mathrm{Au}_{0.24}\mathrm{Co}_{0.58}(\mathrm{PdSn})_{0.18}
CompositionPhase APhase BPhase CExpt. morphology*MCP predicted morphologyExpt. referenceExpt. notes
Au0.31Co0.34Pd0.21Sn0.14\mathrm{Au}_{0.31}\mathrm{Co}_{0.34}\mathrm{Pd}_{0.21}\mathrm{Sn}_{0.14}AuCoPd1.5Sn\mathrm{Pd}_{1.5}\mathrm{Sn}Pie–
Au0.30Co0.26Pd0.30Sn0.14\mathrm{Au}_{0.30}\mathrm{Co}_{0.26}\mathrm{Pd}_{0.30}\mathrm{Sn}_{0.14}AuCoPd2Sn\mathrm{Pd}_{2}\mathrm{Sn}Pie–
Au0.33Co0.24Pd0.26Sn0.17\mathrm{Au}_{0.33}\mathrm{Co}_{0.24}\mathrm{Pd}_{0.26}\mathrm{Sn}_{0.17}AuCoPd3Sn\mathrm{Pd}_{3}\mathrm{Sn}PieShell w/ 2 cores
Au0.30Co0.29Pd0.30Sn0.11\mathrm{Au}_{0.30}\mathrm{Co}_{0.29}\mathrm{Pd}_{0.30}\mathrm{Sn}_{0.11}
Au0.38Co0.33Pd0.23Sn0.06\mathrm{Au}_{0.38}\mathrm{Co}_{0.33}\mathrm{Pd}_{0.23}\mathrm{Sn}_{0.06}AuCoPd4Sn\mathrm{Pd}_{4}\mathrm{Sn}Pie–
Ag-AuCu-NiAgAuCuNiVenn*10.1021/jacs.1c111 18
CompositionPhase APhase BPhase CExpt. morphology*MCP predicted morphologyExpt. referenceExpt. notes
Au-Ag-NiNiAuAgVenn (Au@Ag-Ni)10.1021/jacs.1c11118160 °C for 4h; Ag deposition only on Au surface, Cu deposition has not been triggered yet. Au-Ni Janus is formed with Ag deposited on top
Au-Cu-NiNiAuCuVenn (Au@Cu-Ni)10.1021/jacs.1c11118
AuCu-CuNi-PdSnCuNiAuCuPdSnPie10.1126/science.aav4302
AuAg-NiSn-PdSnNiSnAuAgPdSnPie10.1126/science.aav4302
Au-CoNi-PdSnCoNiAuPdSnPie10.1126/science.aav4302
CompositionPhase APhase BPhase CExpt. morphology*MCP predicted morphologyExpt. referenceExpt. notes
Ag-CuNi-PdSnCuNiAgPdSnPie10.1126/science.aav4302
Ag-CoNi-PdSnCoNiAgPdSnPie10.1126/science.aav4302
CoNi-CuNi-PdSnCoNiCuNiPdSnStriped10.1126/science.aav4302
AuAgCu-CoNi-PdSnCoNiAuAgCuPdSnPie10.1126/science.aav4302
Co0.13Ni0.35Pd0.26Sn0.26\mathrm{Co}_{0.13}\mathrm{Ni}_{0.35}\mathrm{Pd}_{0.26}\mathrm{Sn}_{0.26}; biphase is Co0.38Ni0.23Pd0.18Sn0.21\mathrm{Co}_{0.38}\mathrm{Ni}_{0.23}\mathrm{Pd}_{0.18}\mathrm{Sn}_{0.21}CoNiPdSnPie; Striped*10.1126/science.aav4302CoNiPdSn NPs with two different compositions show either a bi-phase structure or a tri-phase structure
Au0.25Ni0.24Pd0.20Sn0.31\mathrm{Au}_{0.25}\mathrm{Ni}_{0.24}\mathrm{Pd}_{0.20}\mathrm{Sn}_{0.31}AuPdSnNiSnPie10.1126/science.aav4302
CompositionPhase APhase BPhase CExpt. morphology*MCP predicted morphologyExpt. referenceExpt. notes
Au0.10AgxCuy\mathrm{Au}_{0.10}\mathrm{Ag}_{x}\mathrm{Cu}_{y}AgAuAgAuCuStriped10.1126/science.aaf8402
Au0.50AgxCuy\mathrm{Au}_{0.50}\mathrm{Ag}_{x}\mathrm{Cu}_{y}AuAgAuAgCoAuCuStriped10.1126/science.aaf8402
Au0.19Ag0.24Cu0.28Co0.14Ni0.15\mathrm{Au}_{0.19}\mathrm{Ag}_{0.24}\mathrm{Cu}_{0.28}\mathrm{Co}_{0.14}\mathrm{Ni}_{0.15}AuAgAuCuCoNiStriped10.1126/science.aaf8402
Au0.25Ni0.24Pd0.20Sn0.31\mathrm{Au}_{0.25}\mathrm{Ni}_{0.24}\mathrm{Pd}_{0.20}\mathrm{Sn}_{0.31}AuNiPdSn(Ni)Pie10.1126/science.aav4302
Au0.24Cu0.38Pd0.25Sn0.13\mathrm{Au}_{0.24}\mathrm{Cu}_{0.38}\mathrm{Pd}_{0.25}\mathrm{Sn}_{0.13}Au(Cu)CuPd2_2SnStriped10.1126/science.aav4302
Ag0.22Ni0.24Pd0.21Sn0.33\mathrm{Ag}_{0.22}\mathrm{Ni}_{0.24}\mathrm{Pd}_{0.21}\mathrm{Sn}_{0.33}AgPd(Ni)PdSn(Ni)Pie10.1126/science.aav4302
CompositionPhase APhase BPhase CExpt. morphology*MCP predicted morphologyExpt. referenceExpt. notes
Au-Co-NiAuCoNiStriped10.1021/jacs.1c11118
Ag-Cu-NiAgCuNiJanus w/ Core@Shell*Onion10.1021/jacs.1c11118

Table S6. Experimentally reported triphase nanoparticle morphologies compared with Monte Carlo Potts (MCP) predictions. An asterisk (*) marks morphologies discerned by eye. Phases are listed as reported in each experimental study and are not ordered by surface energy.

  • Table S7. Compilation of published experimental tetraphase nanoparticle data

  • Figure S2. Triphase NP morphology stability map calculated on a 2D lattice

Stability map for triphase NP morphologies at $\gamma_B/\gamma_A = 0.1$

(a)

Stability map for triphase NP morphologies at $\gamma_B/\gamma_A = 0.2$

(b)

Figure S2. Stability map for triphase NP morphologies calculated from MCP on a 2D lattice.

  • Figure S3. Triphase NP morphology stability map calculated on a 3D lattice

  • Figure S4. Triphase NP morphology stability map calculated on a 3D lattice with a looser domain-contact threshold (2.0)

Stability map for triphase NP morphologies

Figure S4. Stability map for triphase NP morphologies calculated from MCP on a 3D lattice using a domain-contact threshold of 2.0: two domains are considered not to share an interface if they have fewer than 3 NN and NNN interactions between them. A Venn morphology region appears at this threshold. Compare with Figure S3, which uses a threshold of 0.0.

Supplementary text

Table S1: This table provides further details regarding the input parameters for the prediction of biphase morphologies from DFT-calculated interfacial energies, [52] as well as the DFT-calculated[57] and experimental[63] surface energies. Experimental surface energies are difficult to measure along specific crystallographic directions, so they can be interpreted as an average over all directions. [63] The experimental surface energies are extrapolated to 0 K, and “—” indicates that no experimental value is available. The DFT-calculated interfacial energies are reported along the close-packed direction, in other words, [111] for FCC structures, [110] for BCC, and [1] for HCP. Predictions are made for all phase-separating isostructural binary combinations of elemental metals. Phases A and B are ordered according to decreasing DFT-calculated surface energy. Co is paired with FCC metals (Ag, Au, Cu) using the DFT-calculated surface energy of FCC Co, and with HCP metals (Cd, Os, Re, Ru, Tc, Zn) using that of HCP Co.

Phase APhase BγADFT\gamma_{A}^{DFT} [J m−2^{-2}]γAexp,0K\gamma_{A}^{exp,0K} [J m−2^{-2}]γBDFT\gamma_{B}^{DFT} [J m−2^{-2}]γBexp,0K\gamma_{B}^{exp,0K} [J m−2^{-2}]σABDFT\sigma^{DFT}_{AB} [J m−2^{-2}]
TcCo (hcp)2.234—2.108—0.057
Co (hcp)Zn2.108—0.348—0.075
HfMg1.709—0.545—0.103
ReHf2.581—1.709—0.138
TiHf1.966—1.709—0.008
HfTl1.709—0.256—0.189
HfY1.709—1.004—0.062
ReMg2.581—0.545—0.281
TcMg2.234—0.545—0.015
TiMg1.966—0.545—0.211
ZrMg1.610—0.545—0.041
OsTl2.920—0.256—1.646
ReTi2.581—1.966—0.200
ReTl2.581—0.256—1.410
ReZn2.581—0.348—0.005
ReZr2.581—1.610—0.385
TiSc1.966—1.267—0.024
TcTi2.234—1.966—0.019
TcTl2.234—0.256—1.079
TcZr2.234—1.610—0.167
TiTl1.966—0.256—0.327
TiY1.966—1.004—0.201
TiZr1.966—1.610—0.032
ZrTl1.610—0.256—0.079
ZrY1.610—1.004—0.036

Table 5.

Table S2: Input parameters with temperature effect on surface energy values. The DFT-calculated surface energy is given,[57] followed by experimentally-reported surface energies extrapolated to the stated temperature. [63] Interfacial energy values reported are DFT-calculated values from Ref. 20, except for Ni–Ag from Ref. 52. *Experimental surface energies are not available, so the DFT-calculated value from Ref. 20 is used.

Phase APhase BPhase C[hkl]γBDFT/γADFT\gamma_{B}^{DFT}/\gamma_{A}^{DFT}γCDFT/γADFT\gamma_{C}^{DFT}/\gamma_{A}^{DFT}σABDFT/γADFT\sigma_{AB}^{DFT}/\gamma_{A}^{DFT}σACDFT/γADFT\sigma_{AC}^{DFT}/\gamma_{A}^{DFT}σBCDFT/γADFT\sigma_{BC}^{DFT}/\gamma_{A}^{DFT}
MoLiNa[111]0.1840.0840.3880.5810.009
NbLiNa[100]0.2020.0960.4990.5010.059
NbLiNa[111]0.2320.1070.3780.5290.011
NiCuAg[100]0.6650.3670.0220.2330.071
NiCuAg[110]0.6830.3790.0290.2520.090
NiCuAg[111]0.6830.4020.0000.1100.055
OsCoCd[1]0.7220.0680.0600.4070.200
OsTlCd[1]0.0880.0680.5640.4070.018
ReCoCd[1]0.8170.0770.0410.4210.226
ReCoZn[1]0.8170.1350.0410.0020.029
ReHfMg[1]0.6620.2110.0530.1090.040
ReHfTl[1]0.6620.0990.0530.5460.073
ReTiCd[1]0.7620.0770.0770.4210.036
ReTiHf[1]0.7620.6620.0770.0530.003
ReTiMg[1]0.7620.2110.0770.1090.082
ReTiTl[1]0.7620.0990.0770.5460.127
ReTiZr[1]0.7620.6240.0770.1490.013

Table 6.

Phase APhase BPhase C[hkl]γBDFT/γADFT\gamma_{B}^{DFT}/\gamma_{A}^{DFT}γCDFT/γADFT\gamma_{C}^{DFT}/\gamma_{A}^{DFT}σABDFT/γADFT\sigma_{AB}^{DFT}/\gamma_{A}^{DFT}σACDFT/γADFT\sigma_{AC}^{DFT}/\gamma_{A}^{DFT}σBCDFT/γADFT\sigma_{BC}^{DFT}/\gamma_{A}^{DFT}
ReTlCd[1]0.0990.0770.5460.4210.020
ReZnCd[1]0.1350.0770.0020.4210.071
ReZrMg[1]0.6240.2110.1490.1090.016
ReZrTl[1]0.6240.0990.1490.5460.030
RhCuAg[100]0.6310.3480.0640.1810.068
RhCuAg[110]0.6700.3720.0550.2360.088
RhCuAg[111]0.6610.3890.0500.2080.053
RhNiAg[100]0.9500.3480.0240.1810.221
RhNiAu[100]0.9500.3700.0240.1420.080
RhNiCu[100]0.9500.6310.0240.0640.021
RuCoCd[1]0.8180.0780.0870.2560.226
TaLiNa[100]0.1860.0880.4750.6460.055
TaLiNa[111]0.2010.0930.4120.5780.010
TcCoCd[1]0.9440.0890.0250.3610.261
TcTiCd[1]0.8800.0890.0080.3610.042
TcTiMg[1]0.8800.2440.0080.0070.095
TcTiTl[1]0.8800.1150.0080.4830.146
Phase APhase BPhase C[hkl]γBDFT/γADFT\gamma_{B}^{DFT}/\gamma_{A}^{DFT}γCDFT/γADFT\gamma_{C}^{DFT}/\gamma_{A}^{DFT}σABDFT/γADFT\sigma_{AB}^{DFT}/\gamma_{A}^{DFT}σACDFT/γADFT\sigma_{AC}^{DFT}/\gamma_{A}^{DFT}σBCDFT/γADFT\sigma_{BC}^{DFT}/\gamma_{A}^{DFT}
TcTiZr[1]0.8800.7210.0080.0750.014
TcTlCd[1]0.1150.0890.4830.3610.023
TcZrMg[1]0.7210.2440.0750.0070.018
TcZrTl[1]0.7210.1150.0750.4830.035
TiHfMg[1]0.8690.2770.0040.1080.052
TiHfTl[1]0.8690.1300.0040.1660.096
TiHfY[1]0.8690.5110.0040.1020.031
TiTlCd[1]0.1300.1020.1660.0480.027
TiZrMg[1]0.8190.2770.0160.1080.021
TiZrTl[1]0.8190.1300.0160.1660.040
TiZrY[1]0.8190.5110.0160.1020.018
VNbLi[110]0.8560.2060.0150.3640.261
VNbLi[111]0.8660.2010.0720.4360.327
VTaLi[110]0.9670.2060.0070.3640.358
VTaLi[111]1.0000.2010.0780.4360.411
WCrFe[100]0.9190.6320.0820.0270.038
WCrFe[110]0.9920.7580.0050.0320.032

Table 7.

Phase APhase BPhase C[hkl][hkl]γBDFT/γADFT\gamma_{B}^{DFT}/\gamma_{A}^{DFT}γCDFT/γADFT\gamma_{C}^{DFT}/\gamma_{A}^{DFT}σABDFT/γADFT\sigma_{AB}^{DFT}/\gamma_{A}^{DFT}σACDFT/γADFT\sigma_{AC}^{DFT}/\gamma_{A}^{DFT}σBCDFT/γADFT\sigma_{BC}^{DFT}/\gamma_{A}^{DFT}
WCrLi[100][100]0.9190.1160.0820.5070.482
WCrLi[110][110]0.9920.1540.0050.3930.402
WCrLi[111][111]0.9910.1570.0900.4340.429
WCrMo[100][100]0.9190.8050.0820.0010.068
WCrMo[110][110]0.9920.8660.0050.0090.002
WFeLi[100][100]0.6320.1160.0270.5070.249
WFeLi[110][110]0.7580.1540.0320.3930.152
WLiNa[100][100]0.1160.0550.5070.7230.034
WLiNa[111][111]0.1570.0720.4340.6160.008
WMoFe[100][100]0.8050.6320.0010.0270.039
WMoLi[100][100]0.8050.1160.0010.5070.343
WMoLi[110][110]0.8660.1540.0090.3930.293
WMoNa[100][100]0.8050.0550.0010.7230.533
WMoNa[110][110]0.8660.0680.0090.5780.442

Table 8.

γB/γA = 0.3 slice of MCP-calculated triphase 2D morphology stability map

Figure c.

γB/γA = 0.4 slice of MCP-calculated triphase 2D morphology stability map

Figure d.

Grid of morphology stability maps

Figure e. yB/yA=0.5y_B/y_A = 0.5 slice of MCP-calculated triphase 2D morphology stability map; threshold=0.0. The horizontal column parameter is σBC/yA\sigma_{BC}/y_A, with values 0.1, 0.2, 0.3, 0.4, 0.5, 0.6, 0.7, 0.8, 0.9, and 1.0. The vertical row parameter is γC/yA\gamma_C/y_A, with values 0.5, 0.6, 0.7, 0.8, 0.9, and 1.0. The horizontal axis is σAB/yA\sigma_{AB}/y_A and the vertical axis is σAC/yA\sigma_{AC}/y_A. Legend: Striped; Pokeball; Janus w/ CS; Pie; Shell w/ Janus core; Shell w/ 2 cores; 1p+CS; Onion.

Grid of morphology stability maps

Figure f. yB/yA=0.6y_B/y_A = 0.6 slice of MCP-calculated triphase 2D morphology stability map; threshold=0.0. The horizontal column parameter is σBC/yA\sigma_{BC}/y_A, with values 0.1, 0.2, 0.3, 0.4, 0.5, 0.6, 0.7, 0.8, 0.9, and 1.0. The vertical row parameter is γC/yA\gamma_C/y_A, with values 0.6, 0.7, 0.8, 0.9, and 1.0. The horizontal axis is σAB/yA\sigma_{AB}/y_A and the vertical axis is σAC/yA\sigma_{AC}/y_A. Legend: Striped; Pokeball; Janus w/ CS; Pie; Shell w/ Janus core; Shell w/ 2 cores; Onion.

Panel (g): $\gamma_B/\gamma_A = 0.7$ slice of MCP-calculated triphase 2D morphology stability map, threshold=0.0, with axes $\sigma_{BC}/\gamma_A$, $\sigma_{AC}/\gamma_A$, $\sigma_{AB}/\gamma_A$, and $\gamma_C/\gamma_A$, and legend Striped, Pokeball, Janus w/ CS, Pie, Shell w/ Janus core, Onion

Figure 10. (g) γB/γA=0.7\gamma_B/\gamma_A = 0.7 slice of MCP-calculated triphase 2D morphology stability map; threshold=0.0. Striped; Pokeball; Janus w/ CS; Pie; Shell w/ Janus core; Onion.

Panel (h): $\gamma_B/\gamma_A = 0.8$ slice of MCP-calculated triphase 2D morphology stability map, threshold=0.0, with axes $\sigma_{BC}/\gamma_A$, $\sigma_{AC}/\gamma_A$, $\sigma_{AB}/\gamma_A$, and $\gamma_C/\gamma_A$, and legend Striped, Pokeball, Janus w/ CS, Pie, Onion

Figure 11. (h) γB/γA=0.8\gamma_B/\gamma_A = 0.8 slice of MCP-calculated triphase 2D morphology stability map; threshold=0.0. Striped; Pokeball; Janus w/ CS; Pie; Onion.

Panel (i): $\gamma_B/\gamma_A = 0.9$ slice of MCP-calculated triphase 2D morphology stability map, threshold=0.0, with axes $\sigma_{BC}/\gamma_A$, $\sigma_{AC}/\gamma_A$, $\sigma_{AB}/\gamma_A$, and $\gamma_C/\gamma_A$, and legend Striped, Pokeball, Pie

Figure 12. (i) γB/γA=0.9\gamma_B/\gamma_A = 0.9 slice of MCP-calculated triphase 2D morphology stability map; threshold=0.0. Striped; Pokeball; Pie.

Figure j.

γB/γA = 0.2 slice of MCP-calculated triphase 3D morphology stability map

Figure 13. γB/γA=0.2\gamma_B/\gamma_A = 0.2 slice of MCP-calculated triphase 3D morphology stability map; threshold=0.0. σBC/γA\sigma_{BC}/\gamma_A; σAC/γA\sigma_{AC}/\gamma_A; γC/γA\gamma_C/\gamma_A; σAB/γA\sigma_{AB}/\gamma_A. Striped; Pokeball; Janus w/ CS; Pie; Shell w/ Janus core; 1p+CS; Onion; 1p+Janus. (b)

γB/γA = 0.3 slice of MCP-calculated triphase 3D morphology stability map

Figure 14. γB/γA=0.3\gamma_B/\gamma_A = 0.3 slice of MCP-calculated triphase 3D morphology stability map; threshold=0.0. σBC/γA\sigma_{BC}/\gamma_A; σAC/γA\sigma_{AC}/\gamma_A; γC/γA\gamma_C/\gamma_A; σAB/γA\sigma_{AB}/\gamma_A. Striped; Pokeball; Janus w/ CS; Pie; Shell w/ Janus core; Onion; 1p+Janus. (c)

γB/γA = 0.4 slice of MCP-calculated triphase 3D morphology stability map

Figure d (PDF p. 119). γB/γA=0.4\gamma_B/\gamma_A = 0.4 slice of MCP-calculated triphase 3D morphology stability map; threshold=0.0. σBC/γA\sigma_{BC}/\gamma_A; σAC/γA\sigma_{AC}/\gamma_A; σAB/γA\sigma_{AB}/\gamma_A. Pokeball; Janus w/ CS; Pie; Shell w/ Janus core; Onion.

γB/γA = 0.5 slice of MCP-calculated triphase 3D morphology stability map

Figure e (PDF p. 119). γB/γA=0.5\gamma_B/\gamma_A = 0.5 slice of MCP-calculated triphase 3D morphology stability map; threshold=0.0. σBC/γA\sigma_{BC}/\gamma_A; σAC/γA\sigma_{AC}/\gamma_A; σAB/γA\sigma_{AB}/\gamma_A. Striped; Pokeball; Janus w/ CS; Pie; Shell w/ Janus core; Onion; 1p+Janus.

γB/γA = 0.6 slice of MCP-calculated triphase 3D morphology stability map, shown as a grid of colored morphology maps with legends for Pokeball, Janus w/ CS, Pie, Shell w/ Janus core, and Onion

Figure f (PDF p. 120).

γB/γA = 0.7 slice of MCP-calculated triphase 3D morphology stability map, shown as a grid of colored morphology maps with legends for Striped, Pokeball, Janus w/ CS, Pie, Shell w/ Janus core, and Onion

Figure g.

Three-by-ten grid of triphase 3D morphology stability maps for $\gamma_B/\gamma_A = 0.8$

Figure h. γB/γA=0.8\gamma_B/\gamma_A = 0.8 slice of MCP-calculated triphase 3D morphology stability map threshold=0.0

Axes: σBC/γA\sigma_{BC}/\gamma_A, σAC/γA\sigma_{AC}/\gamma_A, σAB/γA\sigma_{AB}/\gamma_A, and γC/γA\gamma_C/\gamma_A. Columns are labelled 0.1, 0.2, 0.3, 0.4, 0.5, 0.6, 0.7, 0.8, 0.9, and 1.0. Legend: Striped; Pokeball; Janus w/ CS; Pie; Shell w/ Janus core.

Two-by-ten grid of triphase 3D morphology stability maps for $\gamma_B/\gamma_A = 0.9$

Figure i. γB/γA=0.9\gamma_B/\gamma_A = 0.9 slice of MCP-calculated triphase 3D morphology stability map threshold=0.0

Axes: σBC/γA\sigma_{BC}/\gamma_A, σAC/γA\sigma_{AC}/\gamma_A, σAB/γA\sigma_{AB}/\gamma_A, and γC/γA\gamma_C/\gamma_A. Columns are labelled 0.1, 0.2, 0.3, 0.4, 0.5, 0.6, 0.7, 0.8, 0.9, and 1.0. Legend: Striped; Pokeball; Pie.

One-by-ten grid of triphase 3D morphology stability maps for $\gamma_B/\gamma_A = 1.0$

Figure j (PDF p. 121). γB/γA=1.0\gamma_B/\gamma_A = 1.0 slice of MCP-calculated triphase 3D morphology stability map threshold=0.0

Axes: σBC/γA\sigma_{BC}/\gamma_A, σAC/γA\sigma_{AC}/\gamma_A, σAB/γA\sigma_{AB}/\gamma_A, and γC/γA\gamma_C/\gamma_A. Columns are labelled 0.1, 0.2, 0.3, 0.4, 0.5, 0.6, 0.7, 0.8, 0.9, and 1.0. Legend: Striped; Pie.

MCP-calculated triphase 3D morphology stability map for $\gamma_B/\gamma_A=0.2$

Figure b. γB/γA=0.2\gamma_B/\gamma_A = 0.2 slice of MCP-calculated triphase 3D morphology stability map; threshold=2.0. Axes: σBC/γA\sigma_{BC}/\gamma_A, σAC/γA\sigma_{AC}/\gamma_A, σAB/γA\sigma_{AB}/\gamma_A, and γC/γA\gamma_C/\gamma_A. Legend: Venn; Striped; Pokeball; Janus w/ CS; Pie; Shell w/ Janus core; 1p+CS; Onion.

MCP-calculated triphase 3D morphology stability map for $\gamma_B/\gamma_A=0.3$

Figure c. γB/γA=0.3\gamma_B/\gamma_A = 0.3 slice of MCP-calculated triphase 3D morphology stability map; threshold=2.0. Axes: σBC/γA\sigma_{BC}/\gamma_A, σAC/γA\sigma_{AC}/\gamma_A, σAB/γA\sigma_{AB}/\gamma_A, and γC/γA\gamma_C/\gamma_A. Legend: Striped; Pokeball; Janus w/ CS; Pie; Shell w/ Janus core; 1p+CS; Onion; 1p+Janus.

MCP-calculated triphase 3D morphology stability map for $\gamma_B/\gamma_A=0.4$

Figure 15. γB/γA=0.4\gamma_B/\gamma_A=0.4 slice of MCP-calculated triphase 3D morphology stability map; threshold=2.0. Horizontal parameter: σBC/γA\sigma_{BC}/\gamma_A. Vertical parameter: γC/γA\gamma_C/\gamma_A. Horizontal axis: σAB/γA\sigma_{AB}/\gamma_A. Vertical axis: σAC/γA\sigma_{AC}/\gamma_A. Legend: Venn; Striped; Pokeball; Janus w/ CS; Pie; Shell w/ Janus core; Onion. (d)

MCP-calculated triphase 3D morphology stability map for $\gamma_B/\gamma_A=0.5$

Figure 16. γB/γA=0.5\gamma_B/\gamma_A=0.5 slice of MCP-calculated triphase 3D morphology stability map; threshold=2.0. Horizontal parameter: σBC/γA\sigma_{BC}/\gamma_A. Vertical parameter: γC/γA\gamma_C/\gamma_A. Horizontal axis: σAB/γA\sigma_{AB}/\gamma_A. Vertical axis: σAC/γA\sigma_{AC}/\gamma_A. Legend: Striped; Pokeball; Janus w/ CS; Pie; Shell w/ Janus core; Onion; 1p+Janus. (e)

γ_B/γ_A = 0.6 slice of MCP-calculated triphase 3D morphology stability map

Figure f (PDF p. 125).

γ_B/γ_A = 0.7 slice of MCP-calculated triphase 3D morphology stability map

Figure g (PDF p. 125).

Panel (h): $\gamma_{B}/\gamma_{A}=0.8$ slice of MCP-calculated triphase 3D morphology stability map; threshold=2.0. Axes show $\sigma_{BC}/\gamma_{A}$, $\sigma_{AC}/\gamma_{A}$, $\sigma_{AB}/\gamma_{A}$, and $\gamma_{C}/\gamma_{A}$; columns are labeled 0.1 through 1.0. Legend: Striped, Pokeball, Janus w/ CS, Pie, Shell w/ Janus core, Onion.

Figure 17 (PDF p. 126). (h)

Panel (i): $\gamma_{B}/\gamma_{A}=0.9$ slice of MCP-calculated triphase 3D morphology stability map; threshold=2.0. Axes show $\sigma_{BC}/\gamma_{A}$, $\sigma_{AC}/\gamma_{A}$, $\sigma_{AB}/\gamma_{A}$, and $\gamma_{C}/\gamma_{A}$; columns are labeled 0.1 through 1.0. Legend: Striped, Pokeball, Janus w/ CS, Pie.

Figure 18 (PDF p. 126). (i)

Panel (j): $\gamma_{B}/\gamma_{A}=1.0$ slice of MCP-calculated triphase 3D morphology stability map; threshold=2.0. Axes show $\sigma_{BC}/\gamma_{A}$, $\sigma_{AC}/\gamma_{A}$, $\sigma_{AB}/\gamma_{A}$, and $\gamma_{C}/\gamma_{A}$; columns are labeled 0.1 through 1.0. Legend: Striped, Pie.

Figure 19 (PDF p. 126). (j)

References

  1. [1]Huang, L.; Chen, P. C.; Liu, M.; Fu, X.; Gordiichuk, P.; Yu, Y.; Wolverton, C.; Kang, Y.; Mirkin, C. A. Catalyst design by scanning probe block copolymer lithography. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America 2018, 115, 3764–3769.DOI
  2. [2]Rycenga, M.; Cobley, C. M.; Zeng, J.; Li, W.; Moran, C. H.; Zhang, Q.; Qin, D.; Xia, Y. Controlling the synthesis and assembly of silver nanostructures for plasmonic applications. Chemical Reviews 2011, 111, 3669–3712.DOI
  3. [3]Maier, S. A.; Brongersma, M. L.; Kik, P. G.; Meltzer, S.; Requicha, A. A. G.; Atwater, H. A. Plasmonics – A Route to Nanoscale Optical Devices. Advanced Materials 2001, 13, 1501–1505.doi.org/10.1002/1521-4095(200110)13:19<1501::aid-adma1501>3.0.co;2-z
  4. [4]Maier, S. A.; Kik, P. G.; Atwater, H. A.; Meltzer, S.; Harel, E.; Koel, B. E.; Requicha, A. A. Local detection of electromagnetic energy transport below the diffraction limit in metal nanoparticle plasmon waveguides. Nature Materials 2003, 2, 229–232.pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/12690394
  5. [5]Du, J. S.; Cherqui, C.; Ueltschi, T. W.; Wahl, C. B.; Bourgeois, M.; Van Duyne, R. P.; Schatz, G. C.; Dravid, V. P.; Mirkin, C. A. Discovering polyelemental nanostructures with redistributed plasmonic modes through combinatorial synthesis. Science Advances 2023, 9, eadj6129.DOI
  6. [6]Caruso, F.; Hyeon, T.; Rotello, V.; Doane, T. L.; Burda, C. The unique role of nanoparticles in nanomedicine: imaging, drug delivery and therapy. Chemical Society Reviews 2012, 41, 2885–2911.
  7. [7]Frey, N. A.; Peng, S.; Cheng, K.; Sun, S. Magnetic nanoparticles: synthesis, functionalization, and applications in bioimaging and magnetic energy storage. Chemical Society Reviews 2009, 38, 2532–2542.DOI
  8. [8]Shen, B.; Sun, S. Chemical Synthesis of Magnetic Nanoparticles for Permanent Magnet Applications. Chemistry – A European Journal 2020, 26, 6757–6766.DOI
  9. [9]Hitt, J. L.; Li, Y. C.; Tao, S.; Yan, Z.; Gao, Y.; Billinge, S. J.; Mallouk, T. E. A high throughput optical method for studying compositional effects in electrocatalysts for CO2 reduction. Nature Communications 2021, 12, 1–10.DOI
  10. [10]Huang, L.; Zheng, C. Y.; Shen, B.; Mirkin, C. A. High-Index-Facet Metal-Alloy Nanoparticles as Fuel Cell Electrocatalysts. Advanced Materials 2020, 32, 2002849.DOI
  11. [11]Shen, B.; Huang, L.; Shen, J.; He, K.; Zheng, C. Y.; Dravid, V. P.; Wolverton, C.; Mirkin, C. A. Crystal structure engineering in multimetallic high-index facet nanocatalysts. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 2021, 118, e2105722118.DOI
  12. [12]Liu, G. et al. Hydrogen-Intercalation-Induced Lattice Expansion of Pd@Pt Core-Shell Nanoparticles for Highly Efficient Electrocatalytic Alcohol Oxidation. Journal of the American Chemical Society 2021, 143, 11262–11270.DOI
  13. [13]Talapin, D. V.; Lee, J. S.; Kovalenko, M. V.; Shevchenko, E. V. Prospects of colloidal nanocrystals for electronic and optoelectronic applications. Chemical Reviews 2010, 110, 389–458.DOI
  14. [14]Qiu, J.; Xie, M.; Lyu, Z.; Gilroy, K. D.; Liu, H.; Xia, Y. General Approach to the Synthesis of Heterodimers of Metal Nanoparticles through Site-Selected Protection and Growth. Nano Letters 2019, 19, 6703–6708.DOI
  15. [15]Ha, M.; Kim, J. H.; You, M.; Li, Q.; Fan, C.; Nam, J. M. Multicomponent Plasmonic Nanoparticles: From Heterostructured Nanoparticles to Colloidal Composite Nanostructures. Chemical Reviews 2019, 119, 12208–12278.DOI
  16. [16]Lim, B.; Jiang, M.; Camargo, P. H.; Cho, E. C.; Tao, J.; Lu, X.; Zhu, Y.; Xia, Y. Pd-Pt bimetallic nanodendrites with high activity for oxygen reduction. Science 2009, 324, 1302–1305.DOI
  17. [17]Liu, J.; Zhang, J. Nanointerface Chemistry: Lattice-Mismatch-Directed Synthesis and Application of Hybrid Nanocrystals. Chemical Reviews 2020, 120, 2123–2170.DOI
  18. [18]Sun, Y.; Foley, J. J.; Peng, S.; Li, Z.; Gray, S. K. Interfaced metal heterodimers in the quantum size regime. Nano Letters 2013, 13, 3958–3964.DOI
  19. [19]Green, I. X.; Tang, W.; Neurock, M.; Yates, J. T. Spectroscopic observation of dual catalytic sites during oxidation of CO on a Au/TiO2 catalyst. Science 2011, 333, 736–739.DOI
  20. [20]Chen, P.-C.; Liu, M.; Du, J. S.; Meckes, B.; Wang, S.; Lin, H.; Dravid, V. P.; Wolver- ton, C.; Mirkin, C. A. Interface and heterostructure design in polyelemental nanoparticles. Science 2019, 363, 959–964.
  21. [21]Mangeri, J.; Heinonen, O.; Karpeyev, D.; Nakhmanson, S. Influence of elastic and surface strains on the optical properties of semiconducting core-shell nanoparticles. Physical Review Applied 2015, 4, 014001.DOI
  22. [22]Chen, P. C.; Liu, X.; Hedrick, J. L.; Xie, Z.; Wang, S.; Lin, Q. Y.; Hersam, M. C.; Dravid, V. P.; Mirkin, C. A. Polyelemental nanoparticle libraries. Science 2016, 352, 1565–1569.DOI
  23. [23]Gamler, J. T.; Ashberry, H. M.; Sang, X.; Unocic, R. R.; Skrabalak, S. E. Building Random Alloy Surfaces from Intermetallic Seeds: A General Route to Strain-Engineered Electrocatalysts with High Durability. ACS Applied Nano Materials 2019, 2, 4538–4546.DOI
  24. [24]Gamler, J. T.; Leonardi, A.; Sang, X.; Koczkur, K. M.; Unocic, R. R.; Engel, M.; Skrabalak, S. E. Effect of lattice mismatch and shell thickness on strain in core@shell nanocrystals. Nanoscale Advances 2020, 2, 1105–1114.DOI
  25. [25]Zhang, W.; Yang, J.; Lu, X. Tailoring galvanic replacement reaction for the preparation of Pt/Ag bimetallic hollow nanostructures with controlled number of voids. ACS Nano 2012, 6, 7397–7405.DOI
  26. [26]Saleem, F.; Zhang, Z.; Cui, X.; Gong, Y.; Chen, B.; Lai, Z.; Yun, Q.; Gu, L.; Zhang, H. Elemental segregation in multimetallic core-shell nanoplates. Journal of the American Chemical Society 2019, 141, 14496–14500.DOI
  27. [27]Smith, P. T.; Wahl, C. B.; Orbeck, J. K.; Mirkin, C. A. Megalibraries: Supercharged acceleration of materials discovery. MRS Bulletin 2023, 1–12.DOI
  28. [28]Kluender, E. J.; Hedrick, J. L.; Brown, K. A.; Rao, R.; Meckes, B.; Du, J. S.; Moreau, L. M.; Maruyama, B.; Mirkin, C. A. Catalyst discovery through megalibraries of nanomaterials. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 2019, 116, 40–45.DOI
  29. [29]Smith, P. T.; Ye, Z.; Pietryga, J.; Huang, J.; Wahl, C. B.; Orbeck, J. K. H.; Mirkin, C. A. Molecular Thin Films Enable the Synthesis and Screening of Nanoparticle Megalibraries Containing Millions of Catalysts. Journal of the American Chemical Society 2023, 145, 14031–14043.DOI
  30. [30]Steimle, B. C.; Fenton, J. L.; Schaak, R. E. Rational construction of a scalable heterostructured nanorod megalibrary. Science 2020, 367, 418–424.DOI
  31. [31]Schaak, R. E.; Steimle, B. C.; Fenton, J. L. Made-to-Order Heterostructured Nanoparticle Libraries. Accounts of Chemical Research 2020, 53, 2558–2568.DOI
  32. [32]Wood, C. H.; Sanchez-Delgado, C. L.; Sternlicht, H.; Soliman, S. S.; Alem, N.; Schaak, R. E. Automated Benchtop Synthesis of a Quadrillion-Plus Member Core@Multishell Nanoparticle Library Using a Massively Generalizable Nanochemical Reaction. ACS Nano 2025, 19, 40568–40578.DOI
  33. [33]Huang, L.; Shen, B.; Lin, H.; Shen, J.; Jibril, L.; Zheng, C. Y.; Wolverton, C.; Mirkin, C. A. Regioselective Deposition of Metals on Seeds within a Polymer Matrix. Journal of the American Chemical Society 2022, 144, 4792–4798.DOI
  34. [34]Chen, P.-C.; Gao, M.; McCand ler, C. A.; Song, C.; Jin, J.; Yang, Y.; Maulana, A. L.; Persson, K. A.; Yang, P. Complete miscibility of immiscible elements at the nanometre scale. Nature Nanotechnology 2024, 19, 775–781.DOI
  35. [35]Akbarzadeh, A. R.; Ozolinş, V.; Wolverton, C. First-principles determination of multicomponent hydride phase diagrams: Application to the Li-Mg-N-H system. Advanced Materials 2007, 19, 3233–3239.DOI
  36. [36]Saal, J. E.; Kirklin, S.; Aykol, M.; Meredig, B.; Wolverton, C. Materials design and discovery with high-throughput density functional theory: The open quantum materials database (OQMD). JOM 2013, 65, 1501–1509.DOI
  37. [37]Kirklin, S.; Saal, J. E.; Meredig, B.; Thompson, A.; Doak, J. W.; Aykol, M.; Rühl, S.; Wolverton, C. The Open Quantum Materials Database (OQMD): assessing the accuracy of DFT formation energies. npj Computational Materials 2015, 1, 1–15.DOI
  38. [38]Shen, B.; Huang, L.; Shen, J.; Meng, L.; Kluender, E. J.; Wolverton, C.; Tian, B.; Mirkin, C. A. Synthesis of metal-capped semiconductor nanowires from heterodimer nanoparticle catalysts. Journal of the American Chemical Society 2020, 142, 18324–18329.DOI
  39. [39]Potts, R. B. Some generalized order-disorder transformations. Mathematical Proceedings of the Cambridge Philosophical Society 1952, 48, 106–109.DOI
  40. [40]Wu, F. Y. The Potts model. Reviews of Modern Physics 1982, 54, 235–268.DOI
  41. [41]Wu, F. Y. Potts Model and Graph Theory. Journal of Statistical Physics 1988, 52, 99–112.DOI
  42. [42]Metropolis, N.; Ulam, S. The Monte Carlo Method. Journal of the American Statistical Association 1949, 44, 335–341.
  43. [43]Metropolis, N.; Rosenbluth, A. W.; Rosenbluth, M. N.; Teller, A. H.; Teller, E. Equation of state calculations by fast computing machines. The Journal of Chemical Physics 1953, 21, 1087–1092.
  44. [44]Holm, E. A.; Battaile, C. C. The computer simulation of microstructural evolution. JOM 2001, 53, 20–23.DOI
  45. [45]Janssens, K. G. Random grid, three-dimensional, space-time coupled cellular automata Srolovitz, D. J.; Anderson, M. P.; Grest, G. S.; Sahni, P. S. Grain growth in two dimensions. Scripta Metallurgica 1983, 17, 241–246.
  46. [47]Tikare, V.; Cawley, J. D. Numerical simulation of grain growth in liquid phase sintered materials-I. Model. Acta Materialia 1998, 46, 1333–1342.DOI
  47. [48]Tikare, V.; Holm, E. A.; Fan, D.; Chen, L. Q. Comparison of phase-field and Potts models for coarsening processes. Acta Materialia 1998, 47, 363–371.DOI
  48. [49]Markworth, A. J. Comments on foam stability, Ostwald ripening, and grain growth. Journal of Colloid and Interface Science 1985, 107, 569–571.DOI
  49. [50]Homer, E. R.; Tikare, V.; Holm, E. A. Hybrid Potts-phase field model for coupled microstructural-compositional evolution. Computational Materials Science 2013, 69, 414–423.
  50. [51]Glotzer, S. C.; Paul, W. Molecular and Mesoscale Simulation Methods for Polymer Materials. Annual Review of Materials Research 2002, 32, 401–436.DOI
  51. [52]Salgado-Casanova, A.; Pietryga, J.; Xia, Y.; Wolverton, C. Interfacial energy DFT-database of coherent isostructural interfaces. 2026; In preparation.
  52. [53]Najafishirtari, S.; Guardia, P.; Scarpellini, A.; Prato, M.; Marras, S.; Manna, L.; Colombo, M. The effect of Au domain size on the CO oxidation catalytic activity of colloidal Au-FeOx dumbbell-like heterodimers. Journal of Catalysis 2016, 338, 115–123.DOI
  53. [54]George, C.; Genovese, A.; Casu, A.; Prato, M.; Povia, M.; Manna, L.; Montanari, T. CO Oxidation on Colloidal Au0.80Pd0.20-FexOy Dumbbell Nanocrystals. Nano Letters 2013, 13, 752–757.DOI
  54. [55]Monji, F.; Jabbareh, M. A. Thermodynamic model for prediction of binary alloy nanoparticle phase diagram including size dependent surface tension effect. Calphad 2017, 58, 1–5.DOI
  55. [56]Israelachvili, J. N. Intermolecular and Surface Forces, 3rd ed.; Elsevier Inc., 2011; Chapter 17, pp 415–467.
  56. [57]Tran, R.; Xu, Z.; Radhakrishnan, B.; Winston, D.; Sun, W.; Persson, K. A.; Ong, S. P. Data Descriptor: Surface energies of elemental crystals. Scientific Data 2016, 3, 1–13.
  57. [58]Mills, K. C.; Su, Y. C. Review of surface tension data for metallic elements and alloys: Part 1 – Pure metals. International Materials Reviews 2006, 51, 329–351.
  58. [59]Ghosh Chaudhuri, R.; Paria, S. Core/shell nanoparticles: Classes, properties, synthesis mechanisms, characterization, and applications. Chemical Reviews 2012, 112, 2373–2433.DOI
  59. [60]Óvári, L.; Berkó, A.; Balázs, N.; Majzik, Z.; Kiss, J. Formation of Rh-Au core-shell nanoparticles on TiO2(110) surface studied by STM and LEIS. Langmuir 2010, 26, 2167–2175.DOI
  60. [61]Pinkas, J.; Sopoušek, J.; Brož, P.; Vykoukal, V.; Buršík, J.; Vřešťál, J. Synthesis, structure, stability and phase diagrams of selected bimetallic silver- and nickel-based nanoparticles. Calphad 2019, 64, 139–148.DOI
  61. [62]Langlois, C.; Alloyeau, D.; Le Bouar, Y.; Loiseau, A.; Oikawa, T.; Mottet, C.; Ricol-leau, C. Growth and structural properties of CuAg and CoPt bimetallic nanoparticles. Faraday Discussions 2008, 138, 375–391.pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/18447027
  62. [63]Tyson, W. R.; Miller, W. Surface free energies of solid metals: estimation from liquid surface tension measurements. Surface Science 1977, 62, 267–276.DOI
  63. [64]Holec, D.; Dumitrashkewitz, P.; Vollath, D.; Fischer, F. D. Surface Energy of Au Nanoparticles Depending on Their Size and Shape. Nanomaterials 2020, 10, 484.DOI
  64. [65]Hizi, A.; Forster, G. D.; Ferrando, R.; Garreau, Y.; Coati, A.; Andreazza-Vignolle, C.; Andreazza, P. Combined atomistic simulations to explore metastability and substrate effects in Ag–Co nanoalloy systems. Faraday Discussions 2023, 242, 35–51.DOI
  65. [66]Wahl, C. B.; Aykol, M.; Swisher, J. H.; Montoya, J. H.; Suram, S. K.; Mirkin, C. A. Machine learning–accelerated design and synthesis of polyelemental heterostructures. Science Advances 2021, 7, eabj5505.DOI

Paper details

vlnc:W_t487kwgk
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 0

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Physics and Astronomy

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents