WorksMathematics
On the kissing number of hyperbolic surfaces with a small systole
Abstract
Parlier proved that there exists a constant such that for any hyperbolic surface of genus with systole the following holds: where is the maximum number of homotopically distinct systoles in (Kissing number). We show that there exists a constant and a sequence of hyperbolic homogeneous surfaces of genus with a bounded systole such that for all . This shows that Parlier's theorem is sharp for a fixed systole length. Our proof uses Bruhat–Tits buildings of type and Hamiltonian surfaces.
Introduction
In his paper [6], Hugo Parlier proves that the number of homotopically distinct systoles (kissing number) in a closed hyperbolic surface of genus and systoles is bounded above by
where is a constant. This implies that the number of systoles in any hyperbolic surface of genus is bounded above by
The search for lower bounds has a long history (see [6]). Paul Schmutz Schaller [8, 9] has shown that there exists a family of arithmetic surfaces with kissing number bounded below by
This is the best known construction to date and therefore there is a gap between Schmutz Schaller’s lower bound and Parlier’s upper bound . In [9], Schmutz Schaller conjectures that the bound is optimal.
Our main theorem shows that Parlier upper bound is sharp in the case of a surface with a bounded systole.
Theorem 1.1. There exists a constant and a sequence of hyperbolic homogeneous surfaces of genus with a bounded systole such that
for all .
The systole in these surfaces is in fact constant in equal to . The proof of the theorem relies on the construction of a certain type of regular surfaces that are associated with a lattice in . These surfaces are “Hamiltonian surfaces”, in the sense of [2]. They will visit every vertex and every edge of a large quotient of the Bruhat–Tits building associated with , exactly once.
The notion of Hamiltonian surfaces derives from a new construction of 2-complexes using an operation of “systolic filling”, in a finite covering space associated with a given surface of infinite genus. This approach was first studied in [1] for systolic fillings associated with a pinched torus, and later in [2], for systolic fillings of hyperbolic surfaces of infinite genus, naturally associated with the group .
On AI usage
No use of AI was made in the conception or the writing of this paper.
Construction of the Hamiltonian surface
By Hamiltonian surface in a 2-complex , we mean a surface which visits every vertex and every edge precisely once. A Hamiltonian surface is said to be periodic if it endowed with a free and cocompact action of a countable group.
Theorem 2.1. The Bruhat–Tits building of type over the field contains three distinct periodic Hamiltonian surfaces, which are cyclically permuted by a group of automorphisms of that acts simply transitively by type-rotating automorphisms.
The group in this theorem was introduced in [3]. It will be described explicitly in the proof.
Proof. We first review the construction of an explicit embedding into of an amalgamated group (of Tits type) following the work of [10, 5, 7, 3, 4]. Namely, we consider the Frobenius group of order 21 defined by:
in which acts on by conjugacy. It is well-known [7] that two distinct copies of in generate a chamber system for the building of .
Furthermore, Tits has shown in [10] (see also [7 p. 48]) that there are three ways to amalgamate three copies of together along two distinct copies of in each group, in order to define a group, which does not collapse, and acts by automorphisms of the Bruhat–Tits building of .
In [5], Kohler, Meixner, and Wester have shown that one of these three amalgams embeds in . Furthermore, they use this embedding to construct exponentially many pairwise non-isomorphic finite transitive chamber systems of type . It will be convenient to use a closely related embedding of the following group , which was introduced by Cartwright, Mantero, Steger, and Zappa in [3, 4]. Thus, we consider the group on seven generators and seven relations:
where . This presentation is an -triangle presentation in the sense of [3 p. 149]. The automorphism group of this triangle presentation is and the extension of by is generated by the , and with commutation relations:
where and .
The following explicit embedding theorem is established in [3 §4, Example] and described in [4 p. 177].
Theorem 2.2. The map
defines to an embedding of into .
The relation with the embedding of Kohler, Meixner, and Wester is explained in the last part of §4 in [3].
It is shown in [3] that the group acts simply transitively on the vertices of the building of . Furthermore, the action is by type-rotating automorphisms. In fact, the type-rotating assumption essentially yields a presentation of of the form given above, namely the -triangle presentation of . For all this, we refer [3 Theorem 3.1].
The type-rotating assumption implies that the group admits a subgroup of index 3, which act by type-preserving automorphisms. Furthermore, the presentation of is easily computed, following [3]. In the particular case above, we find a group on 21 generators and 21 relations, as follows:
where and . We let denote the corresponding finite chamber system.
Our main observation is:
Lemma 2.3. The set of 14 chambers for all and all omitting the value in defines a Hamiltonian surface in .
Proof. Since one value of is omitted, it is clear that the generator appears only twice in the given set of chambers, for all and . To prove that is a hamiltonian surface, it suffices to prove that its links form a Hamiltonian cycle in the links of .
The generic chamber in is given by:
Figure 1. Chamber
By definition, the link of is the graph with edges:
where and . It is straightforward to verify that this graph is a union of three 14-gons. □
To conclude the proof of the theorem, it suffices to prove that permutes cyclically the three lifts of the surfaces to the universal cover . This follows because the action is type-rotating. It is clear that each lift is a periodic Hamiltonian surface in on which act by automorphisms. □
The following result was stated without proof in [2], we can now provide a proof.
Corollary 2.4. The Bruhat–Tits building of type over contains uncountably many Hamiltonian surfaces.
Proof. If denotes a vertex stabilizer in and is one of the three Hamiltonian surfaces in , then the orbit is uncountable, by the orbit–stabilizer theorem. □
Proof of Theorem 1.1
We establish the following theorem which is our main result.
Theorem 3.1. There exists a sequence of simplicially hyperbolic homogeneous surfaces of genus with bounded systole such that
for all $n \ge 1.
We note that Theorem 1.1 follows immediately from this result by replacing every equilateral triangle in with the corresponding hyperbolic triangle of constant curvature and vertex angle . Each systole of length gives rise to a systole of length
in the corresponding smooth surface.
Proof. Let denote the Bruhat–Tits building of . Consider one of the three periodic hamiltonian surface in defined in Theorem 2.1. This surface is -periodic, where is of index in . We will need to use here the group defined in [3] and reviewed in the previous paragraph.
Since is linear, it is residually finite. Therefore, there exists a finite index subgroup of for which the injectivity radius of the cover space is at least . This implies that the systole in is at least .
Let be a decreasing sequence of normal finite index normal subgroups of , and let . The -complex is obtained from by systolic filling in the sense of [2]. The systoles of have length , and is obtained canonically from by adjoining a triangle for every systole. This is in fact easy to see directly from the construction of in Theorem 2.1. Namely, in Lemma 2.3, the surface is obtained by omitting the chambers corresponding to a single index . The systolic filling of is obtained by adjoining all chambers which are lifts of the chambers corresponding to this index. In this construction, every systole is a boundary of such a chamber. It has length , and meets every edge precisely once. The residual finiteness of and the presence of is crucial to find the correct covering space of .
It is clear that the surfaces are simplicially hyperbolic with (by construction) 14 equilateral triangles meeting at every vertex. Furthermore, they are homogeneous surfaces acted upon by the group .
It remains to compute the number of systoles and the genus of . Since every systole meets an edge exactly once, the number of systoles is where is the number of edges of . Since is Hamiltonian, the number of edges in equals the number of edges in .
Since acts freely transitively by type rotating automorphisms on , and acts freely by type preserving automorphisms of , the action of on is free with 3 orbits of vertices, 21 orbits of edges, and 21 orbits of faces. Furthermore, the action on is free with quotient complex . In particular, the surface contains precisely edges and therefore systoles. Furthermore, the Euler characteristic of is
This shows that
for all . □
References
- [1]Barré, Pichot. Surgery on Aut(F_2), Bull. Belg. Math. Soc. Simon Stevin 30(1): 31-50 (july 2023). DOI: 10.36045/j.bmss.210809.DOI
- [2]Barré, Pichot. The Hamiltonian surface of Aut(F_2), preprint (2025).arxiv.org/abs/2507.00213
- [3]Cartwright, D. I., Mantero, A. M., Steger, T., Zappa, A. (1993). Groups acting simply transitively on the vertices of a building of type à 2, I. Geometriae Dedicata, 47(2), 143-166.DOI
- [4]Cartwright, D. I., Mantero, A. M., Steger, T., Zappa, A. (1993). Groups acting simply transitively on the vertices of a building of type à 2, II: The cases q= 2 and q= 3. Geometriae Dedicata, 47(2), 167-223.
- [5]Kohler, P., Meixner, T. and Wester, M., ’The affine building of type A2 over a local field of characteristic 2’, Archiv Math. 42 (1984), 400-407.
- [6]Parlier, H. Kissing numbers for surfaces. Journal of Topology, 6(3), 777-791 (2013).
- [7]Ronan, M., Lectures on Buildings, Academic Press, New York, 1989.
- [8]Schmutz Shaller, P. Extremal Riemann surfaces with a large number of systoles. In Extremal Riemann surfaces (San Francisco, CA, 1995), vol. 201 of Contemp. Math. Amer. Math. Soc., Providence, RI, 1997, pp. 9–19.
- [9]Schmutz Shaller, P. Geometry of Riemann surfaces based on closed geodesics. Bull. Amer. Math. Soc. (N.S.) 35, 3 (1998), 193–214.
- [10]Tits, J., Buildings and Group Amalgamations, London Maths. Soc. Lecture Notes, 121 (Proceedings of Groups - St. Andrews 1985), Cambridge Univ. Press, 1986, 110-127.DOI
