betaFeedback

WorksPhysics and Astronomy

The unfinished picture of low-energy antineutron interactions: open issues and hints for future research possibilities

Abstract

This report examines the open questions that remain unsolved following the measurements with antineutrons (nˉ\bar n) as probes conducted up to the 1990s at the LEAR facility at CERN. It also presents suggestions for possible new experiments at a future, upgraded AD complex, which can potentially provide access to new areas of physics.

Introduction

nˉ\bar{n} induced interactions and annihilation dynamics

Using antineutrons as probes to study the dynamics of NˉN\bar{N}N annihilations provides several benefits over reactions initiated by antiprotons. The key point is that the (nˉp\bar{n}p) system has a definite isospin of I=1I = 1, while the (pˉp\bar{p}p) system contains both I=0I = 0 and I=1I = 1 components. This acts as a strong selection rule, ruling out several initial states and restricting the possible combinations of quantum numbers for any intermediate states or resonances that can be formed after the annihilation.

On the other hand, the (pˉn\bar{p}n) system, which can be realized using a deuterium target, displays the same isospin features as the (nˉp\bar{n}p) system. Antiprotons provide several practical benefits for experiments, such as the ability to undergo annihilations at rest, while nˉ\bar{n} annihilation must occur in flight and therefore it involves a wider spectrum of initial partial waves, which depend on the available energy. Moreover, pˉ\bar{p} beams can be generated with comparatively high intensities, enabling the collection of higher statistics.

However, annihilations in the (pˉn\bar{p}n) system are affected by significant complications. The neutron bound in the deuteron carries a Fermi momentum that cannot be directly determined, which prevents a complete reconstruction of the reaction kinematics. Although, in principle, the recoiling nucleon can be measured, its momentum is typically small and therefore it is hard to detect. In addition, the recoiling nucleon may rescatter either with other nucleons or with the particles generated in the annihilation, potentially degrading the cleanliness of the final state.

Antiproton beams interacting with deuteron targets face an additional challenge: annihilation can occur on either the proton or neutron, creating two distinct sources that must be carefully disentangled to isolate the pure I=1I = 1 component.

A key advantage of using antineutron beams as probes is the complete absence of Coulomb interactions. Unlike antiproton-proton (or nuclear) scattering, which is distorted by electromagnetic effects, nˉ\bar{n} interactions are governed solely by the strong force, enabling cleaner and more precise measurements.

Further details on nˉ\bar{n} physics are reported in [1]. In the following, a short summary of the most important features of antineutron interactions will be given.

Antineutron beams: historical overview

Two primary techniques had been leveraged to produce antineutron beams: (i) extraction from external targets, where protons strike a solid target (typically Fe or Cu), and time-of-flight information is used to select the emitted nˉ\bar{n}, and (ii) production via the charge-exchange (CEX) reaction.

Brando et al. first employed the external-target method at the AGS-PS in 1981, extracting antineutrons in the 0.3–1 GeV/cc momentum range [2].

On the other hand, the pˉp→nˉn\bar{p}p \rightarrow\bar{n}n CEX reaction is endothermic, with a threshold momentum of 97.5 MeV/cc, and was exploited to produced antineutrons on CH2_2 or liquid hydrogen targets. Gunderson et al. pioneered this technique at Argonne ZGS in 1981 [3], using a 1 GeV/cc pˉ\bar{p} beam. Armstrong et al., later in 1987, refined this method at BNL AGS [4], employing 505–520 MeV/cc pˉ\bar{p} beams on a segmented CH2_2 target to yield a continuous nˉ\bar{n} spectrum (100–500 MeV/cc) at a ∼0.2 nˉ\bar{n}/s rate.

A major step forward occurred at CERN’s LEAR (Low Energy Antiproton Ring) in the late 1980s, exploiting intense low-energy pˉ\bar{p} beams. PS178 pioneered tagged nˉ\bar{n} beams in 1988 [5], using CEX on a liquid H2_2 target with a 10610^6 pˉ\bar{p}/s beam, enabling a full reaction reconstruction.

LEAR’s largest nˉ\bar{n}-production setup was installed at PS201 (OBELIX) and in operation since 1990 [6]: the apparatus consisted of a cylindrical magnetic spectrometer built around a 0.5 T dipole. An upstream production liquid H2_2 target intercepted 305 or 412 MeV/cc pˉ\bar{p} beams; forward-directed nˉ\bar{n}’s, produced via CEX, were collimated, while other charged pˉ\bar{p}-annihilation products were detected and the corresponding reactions vetoed by a surrounding scintillator hodoscope (called VETO-BOX).

Due to space constraints, OBELIX could not tag nˉ\bar{n}’s directly. Post-collimation, the nˉ\bar{n} beam traversed a second liquid H2_2 reaction target, that sometimes was followed by disk-shaped nuclear targets. Depending on the incident pˉ\bar{p} momentum, the nˉ\bar{n} flux intensity ranged in the interval 30–60 nˉ/106pˉ\bar{n}/10^{6}\bar{p}, and the experiment could collect ∼35\sim35 million annihilation events over three data-taking periods.

The nˉ\bar{n} momentum was derived iteratively from time-of-flight (TOF), as described in Ref. [7] and shortly summarized in the following. A sketch of the experimental arrangement is reported in Figure 1 [1].

Sketch of the experimental antineutron beam arrangement

Figure 1. Sketch (not to scale) of the experimental nˉ\bar{n} beam arrangement of the OBELIX experiment at LEAR. From Ref. [6].

The total TOF, from beam scintillator T0T_0 to the first hit of the annihilation products on a suitable scintillator hodoscope, comprises four parts (see Figure 1 for reference):

  1. pˉ\bar{p} travel time t1t_1 for the beam scintillator (T0T_0) to the entrance window of the PT Production Target, over the spˉs_{\bar{p}} path length;

  2. pˉ\bar{p} travel time inside PT over the zCz_C path length from the entrance target wall to the CEX vertex (CC);

  3. nˉ\bar{n} time-of-flight from the CEX vertex to the AA annihilation vertex in the RT Reaction Target;

  4. time for the fastest pion produced in the annihilation to the XX hit on the scintillator hodoscope (TOFINO).

This translates to the following equation:

tmeas=t1+t2+t3+t4=spˉvpˉ(0)+∫0zCdz′vpˉ(z′)+l+dvnˉ+sπvπ(1)\begin{aligned} t_{meas} &= t_1+t_2+t_3+t_4 \\ &= \frac{s_{\bar{p}}}{v_{\bar{p}}(0)}+\int_{0}^{z_C}\frac{dz'}{v_{\bar{p}}(z')}+\frac{l+d}{v_{\bar{n}}}+\frac{s_{\pi}}{v_{\pi}} \tag*{(1)} \end{aligned}

The first contribution is known from the incoming pˉ\bar{p} momentum at the target entrance. The fourth can be estimated by assuming the charged pion travels at light speed (vπ=cv_{\pi}=c), after reconstructing the annihilation vertex AA from at least two charged tracks, to determine the distance sπs_{\pi} to the hit on the hodoscope.

The critical step is to correctly determine the CEX vertex position, which affects both the second and third TOF contributions. With forward collimation making the zz coordinate dominant, zCz_C yields the pˉ\bar{p} travel time t2t_2 inside the target and the nˉ\bar{n} flight time t3t_3 over the distance ll to the annihilation vertex. The nˉ\bar{n} speed vnˉv_{\bar{n}} follows from two-body CEX kinematics once the nˉ\bar{n} emission angle is known.

zCz_C emerges iteratively, discretizing the ppˉ(z)p_{\bar{p}}(z) momentum along the target to model the energy loss. The equation

zC=∫ppˉ(0)ppˉβ dpdE/dx(2)z_C=\int_{p_{\bar{p}}(0)}^{p_{\bar{p}}}\frac{\beta\,dp}{dE/dx} \tag*{(2)}

is solved iteratively for the zCz_C value that matches the measured total TOF to the sum of the mentioned four components (Eq. (1)); in Eq. (2) β\beta is pˉ\bar{p} velocity and dE/dxdE/dx is energy loss per path length in the target.

These iterations introduce a relative uncertainty in nˉ\bar{n} momentum, which scales with the step size and rises at low momenta. Thus, a momentum determination for nˉ\bar{n}’s below 50 MeV/cc was deemed unreliable and the corresponding events were cut off.

Typical antineutron momentum spectra as reconstructed in Figure 2.

Figure 2. Experimental momentum spectrum of antineutrons produced via CEX reaction in the OBELIX nˉ\bar{n} facility. From Ref. [1]. The plot on the left is a raw spectrum, including random coincidences without background subtraction, while on the right the true spectrum is depicted after the corrections for apparatus resolution.

ttotal cross section

The total cross sections for antinucleon-induced interactions below 500 MeV/cc are among the best-measured quantities in antinucleon physics. Figure 3 collects data from Armstrong et al. [4] (open triangles) and OBELIX [7] (black points).

Comparison of $\bar{N}N$ total cross section at low momenta

Figure 3. Comparison of NˉN\bar{N}N total cross section at low momenta. The open triangles are from Ref. [7], the full points are from Ref. [4]. The solid line, whose extrapolation to lower momenta is shown by the dashed part, is from Ref. [8]. Figure from Ref. [1].

Armstrong et al. used a transmission technique (empty vs. full target), revealing a trend compatible with A+B/pA+B/p. OBELIX also measured total cross sections in the 50–400 MeV/cc range via transmission with a thick target and narrow beam (total error ∼10%\sim10\%); results overlap well with those by Armstrong et al.

Figure 3 includes, for completeness, Bugg et al.’s solid/dashed extrapolation for pˉp\bar{p}p [8]. Notably, nˉp\bar{n}p cross section lies below σT(pˉp)\sigma_T(\bar{p}p) under 200 MeV/cc.

nˉp\bar{n}p annihilation cross section.

The first nˉp\bar{n}p annihilation cross section measurements in the 500–800 MeV/cc range came from Banerjee et al.’s bubble-chamber experiment (1985) [9, 10], using CEX-produced nˉ\bar{n}; they reported as integrated cross section σann=(55.4±2.2)\sigma_{\mathrm{ann}} = (55.4 \pm2.2) mb.

Armstrong et al. derived σann\sigma_{\mathrm{ann}} by subtracting a parametrization of the elastic cross section from the total one (procedure affected by a 15–20% uncertainty); the result was consistent with a A+B/pA+B/p scaling law.

At BNL AGS, Mutchler et al. (1988) [11] measured βσann=(40±3)\beta\sigma_{\mathrm{ann}} = (40 \pm3) mb at 22 MeV/cc and (32±5)(32 \pm5) mb at 43 MeV/cc, as well as, for the first time, the S-wave scattering length imaginary part aI=(−0.83±0.07)a_I = (-0.83 \pm0.07) fm.

OBELIX, later on, covered the 50–400 MeV/cc range (see Figure 4) [12]. The points measured by OBELIX agree well with Armstrong data but carry a normalization error as large as 7%. They can be fitted with an effective-range expansion (including S-, P-, D-waves), with D-wave contributing (4.7±0.6)%(4.7 \pm0.6)\% up to 200 MeV/cc.

Fit of $\sigma_{\mathrm{ann}}(\bar{n}p)$ measured by OBELIX up to 400 MeV/$c$

Figure 4. Fit of σann(nˉp)\sigma_{\mathrm{ann}}(\bar{n}p) measured by OBELIX up to 400 MeV/cc including S- (solid line), P- (dotted line) and D- (dashed line at the bottom of the picture) wave contribution. From Ref. [12].

nˉ\bar{n}-nucleus annihilation cross section.

OBELIX sometimes used additional nuclear targets (made of various materials) downstream of the liquid H2_2 production target, to measure nˉ\bar{n} annihilation cross sections on different nuclei as a function of projectile momentum [13].

An A2/3A^{2/3} scaling with the AA nucleus mass number emerged (2% accuracy), implying surface-dominated annihilations with localized, large hadronic cross sections.

The momentum dependence roughly followed the antineutron β\beta; the annihilation cross sections were overall consistent with σann=(α+B/p)Ax\sigma_{\mathrm{ann}} = (\alpha+ B/p)A^x (see Figure 5) trend, with x∼2/3x \sim2/3.

Three-dimensional plot of the measured $\sigma_{\mathrm{ann}}(\bar{n}p; A)$

Figure 5. Three-dimensional plot of the measured σann(nˉp;A)\sigma_{\mathrm{ann}}(\bar{n}p; A), as a function of the antineutron momentum and the atomic number. From Ref. [13].

Open Puzzles in Antineutron Behavior

LEAR data analyses performed up to early 2000s reveal puzzles when compared with later AD experiments and modern theory. Key open questions are summarized below.

nˉ\bar{n} annihilation cross sections on nuclei at low momenta

Friedman et al. [14] [14] developed an optical-potential model fitting the momentum dependence of pˉA\bar{p}A annihilation cross sections on nuclei. However, the potential fails to reproduce nˉ\bar{n}-induced interactions: as Figure 6 shows, predictions (solid line) systematically underestimate the data across different nuclear species, pointing at a missing component in the model specific for nˉ\bar{n} interaction.

Total annihilation cross sections for C, Al, Cu, and Pb

Figure 6. Total annihilation cross sections compared to the results from the model by Friedman et al. (solid curves for nˉ\bar{n}, dashed curves for pˉ\bar{p}. From Ref. [14]. Experimental data for nˉ\bar{n} from Ref. [13].

Indeed, antineutrons lack the Coulomb component essential for pˉ\bar{p}, and this suggests that a focusing effect could be missing. The scarce pˉA\bar{p}A existing data prevent comparison: ASACUSA’s unique point for pˉ\bar{p} annihilation on Tin [15] is exceeded both by the model and by the nˉ\bar{n}-Sn cross section measurements (see Figure 7).

Total annihilation cross sections on Sn

Figure 7. Total Nˉ\bar{N} annihilation cross sections on Sn compared to the results based on the potential derived in Ref.[14] (solid black curve for nˉ\bar{n}, dashed red curve for pˉ\bar{p}). Experimental points for nˉ\bar{n} from Ref. [13], for pˉ\bar{p} (single red point) from [15]. From Ref. [14].

Such discrepancies demand precise, simultaneous measurements of in-flight nˉ\bar{n} and pˉ\bar{p} annihilation cross sections, ideally on identical targets and energies, using the same experimental setup.

The elastic nˉp\bar{n}p cross section

OBELIX derived the nˉp\bar{n}p elastic cross section by subtracting the annihilation cross section from the total one. As detailed in Sec. I A 3, the annihilation trend with the momentum is smooth, yet the total cross section (Sec. I A 2) shows a dip-bump trend at 65–80 MeV/c.

as shown in Figure 8.

Experimental total and annihilation $\bar{n}p$ cross sections

Figure 8. Experimental value of the total (Ref. [7], black triangles) and annihilation (Ref. [12], black circles) (nˉp\bar{n}p) cross sections. Data by OBELIX. The solid curve represents the calculation of σann(nˉp)\sigma_{\mathrm{ann}}(\bar{n}p) performed in Ref. [12], the dotted one the calculation of σT(nˉp)\sigma_{\mathrm{T}}(\bar{n}p) by using the same parametrization.

This dip-bump behavior prevents fitting both cross sections with shared effective-range parameters [16]; σT\sigma_{\mathrm{T}} fits fail markedly.

The origin of such an anomaly remains unclear, possibly due to an irregular elastic behavior (see Figure 9, post-subtraction). Points at 64.5 and 80 MeV/c the S-wave meet the unitarity lower bound: σel≥k24π⋅σ2\sigma_{\mathrm{el}} \ge\frac{k^2}{4\pi} \cdot\sigma^2

Elastic and minimum elastic cross sections as a function of antineutron momentum

Figure 9. Black triangles: elastic cross section as a function of pˉn\bar{p}n obtained from the difference between the total [7] and annihilation [12] cross sections. Diamonds: lower limits of the elastic cross sections due to the unitarity constraints. From Ref.[7].

Proposed explanations invoke a near-threshold quasi-nuclear bound state in the nˉp\bar{n}p spin-triplet configuration [17]. Strong isospin violation between I=0I = 0 and I=1I = 1 channels could determine different low-momentum NˉN\bar{N}N behaviors: large, opposite-sign scattering lengths a0a_0 and a1a_1 might manifest in a repulsive interaction in pˉp\bar{p}p, while an attractive one should be effective in nˉp\bar{n}p.

Alternatively, elementary nuclear mechanisms, like a Ramsauer-Townsend effect [18], could suppress the elastic cross section via an interference mechanism.

vvs. aannihilation sources

The isospin ratio RR may quantitatively be defined as

R=σT(I=0)+σT(I=1)2σT(I=1)R = \frac{\sigma_T(I = 0) + \sigma_T(I = 1)}{2\sigma_T(I = 1)}

or, alternatively, it can be expressed by

r=σT(I=0)/σT(I=1)=2R−1r = \sigma_T(I = 0)/\sigma_T(I = 1) = 2R - 1

At 70 MeV/cc, r=2.5±0.4r = 2.5 \pm0.4 indicates I=0I = 0 dominance (to be compared to r=1.1±0.1r = 1.1 \pm0.1 at 300 MeV/cc), possibly generated by coherent ω\omega, δ\delta, ρ\rho-exchange (central/tensor terms in the medium range NˉN\bar{N}N interaction) [19].

At low momenta, σann(nˉp)<σann(pˉp)\sigma_{\mathrm{ann}}(\bar{n}p) < \sigma_{\mathrm{ann}}(\bar{p}p) consistently [20] (as shown in Figure 10): the value R∼1.7R \sim1.7 (r=2.4±0.4r = 2.4 \pm0.4) is obtained at 70 MeV/cc, while it approaches 1 at 300–500 MeV/cc, and then it rises again (with r→1.5r \to1.5) near 700 MeV/cc. In addition, the Bombay-CERN-Neuchâtel-Tokyo data [9], dating back to the 70’s, report σann(nˉp)=55.4±2.2\sigma_{\mathrm{ann}}(\bar{n}p) = 55.4 \pm2.2 mb, to be compared to σann(pˉp)=77.9±0.6\sigma_{\mathrm{ann}}(\bar{p}p) = 77.9 \pm0.6 mb (500–800 MeV/cc), and signal a further inconsistency which calls for deeper scrutiny.

Total antineutron-proton and antiproton-proton annihilation cross sections

Figure 10. Total (nˉp\bar{n}p) annihilation cross section (full black points) and (pˉp\bar{p}p) annihilation cross sections (red markers), from Ref. [14].

The differential CEX cross sections

Charge-exchange (CEX) processes also exhibit unresolved issues: few low-momentum measurements exist, which present strong disagreements (Figure 11, all data from experiment performed in the Eighties).

Charge-exchange cross sections

Figure 11. CEX cross sections data: black circles by Hamilton et al. [21], open circles by Brückner et al. [22].

Near-threshold data, in fact, disagree sharply: Hamilton et al.’s data (1980, open triangles) [21] follow the endothermic trend, while Brückner et al.’s data (1987, full points) [22] show a linear decrease, which is still unexplained and warrants new measurements.

Differential CEX is even murkier, with sparse high-momentum data. Figure 12 compiles full-angular scans:

Differential Charge-EXchange cross section showing PS199 and Nakamura measurements

Figure 12. Differential Charge-EXchange cross section. Open and full circles are from Ref. [23], full triangles are from Ref. [24].

PS199 (1985) [23] measurements at 693 MeV/cc (open circles) and 875 MeV/cc (full circles) are shown together with Nakamura et al.’s data (1987) [24] at 780 MeV/cc (full triangles).

PS199 data diverge sharply from others, especially at backward angles and zero degrees.

Forward discrepancies persist at lower momenta: Brückner et al.’s data (1987) at 183, 287, 505, 590 MeV/cc [22] vs. indirect backward estimates by OBELIX (99–400 MeV/cc) [7] are shown in Figure 13. OBELIX aligns with Brückner’s data near 300 MeV/cc and follows the endothermic trend of Hamilton’s measurements (Figure 11), but the two experiment diverge sharply at 183 MeV/cc. New precise differential CEX measurements especially at forward angles are therefore essential.

Forward Charge-EXchange cross section

Figure 13. Forward Charge-EXchange cross section. The triangles are by Brückner [22], the red points from 100 to 400 MeV/cc are by OBELIX [7], the full points at ∼800\sim800 MeV/cc are from Nakamura [24].

Several effects observed by OBELIX in nˉ\bar{n} annihilations to exclusive final states, characterized by flavor signatures, are tied to annihilation dynamics mechanisms and final state quark content, and are mainly to be investigated through spectroscopic techniques. Some of these phenomena still lack full explanations, which demand more precise experimental data and refined models for a complete accounting.

Dynamical selection rules and the onset of strangeness in annihilation reactions

OBELIX probed nˉ\bar{n}-induced annihilation to two-body states with distinct flavor content, to trace the strangeness production onset in annihilation processes.

Low-momentum, or at rest, annihilations can ideally access non-perturbative nucleon sea quarks. Interestingly, non-trivial dynamical selection rules emerge, transcending quantum-number conservation and exhibiting peculiar behaviors which vary with reaction energy, i.e. they depend on the excited nˉp\bar{n}p partial waves.

From OBELIX data a strong contrast emerges in the production of hidden strangeness versus non-strange mesons: in nˉp→ϕπ+\bar{n}p \to\phi\pi^{+} and nˉp→ωπ+\bar{n}p \to\omega\pi^{+} reactions, the trend of cross sections vs. momentum reveals a strong OZI violation depending on the reaction energy [25]. ϕπ+\phi\pi^{+} production follows SS-wave annihilation (dashed line in Figure 14), differently from the strangeness-free ωπ+\omega\pi^{+}; phase-space-corrected ratios scale as well with the momentum. A strong OZI violation, up to a factor of 20 larger, indicates the nucleon strangeness content as a possible origin of the abundant production of ϕ\phi mesons: vector-meson nonet ideal mixing would preclude the presence of strange valence quarks were they not already available, in some form, in the initial state.

Trends as a function of antineutron momentum

Figure 14. Trends as a function of nˉ\bar{n} momentum of: (a) nˉp→ϕπ+\bar{n}p \to\phi\pi^{+} and (b) nˉp→ωπ+\bar{n}p \to\omega\pi^{+} cross sections. The curve superimposed is the trend expected for pure SS-wave annihilation as given by Dover-Richard model [19]. (c) Ratio between the ϕπ+\phi\pi^{+} and and ωπ+\omega\pi^{+} yields, as a function of pnˉp_{\bar{n}}. From Ref. [25].

This implies that ϕ\phi mesons likely arise from polarized excitations of the sˉs\bar{s}s sea in nucleons and antinucleons, modulated by annihilation partial waves and quantum numbers. This mechanism echoes high-energy deep inelastic scattering’s color transparency effect, where sˉs\bar{s}s spins were found to align with nucleon spin.

Open-strangeness channels like nˉp→K∗0K+\bar{n}p \to K^{*0}K^{+}, on the other hand, show no SS-wave scaling (Figure 15) [25], favoring the simple rescattering mechanism over more complex dynamics.

Cross section as a function of antineutron momentum

Figure 15. Trends of the cross section as a function of nˉ\bar{n} momentum of nˉp→K‾0∗K+\bar{n}p \to\overline{K}^{0*}K^{+}. Data from Ref. [25].

Beyond polarized sea quarks or rescattering, intermediate sˉsq\bar{s}s q strange tetraquark can moreover play as an alternate viable hypotheses.

However, other two-body channels like nˉp→ηπ+\bar{n}p \to\eta\pi^{+} obey simple quark-line rules without evident anomalies [26]. Its cross section tracks PP-wave momentum dependence (see Figure 16), matching the expected quantum-number conservation rules for the production of two pseudoscalar mesons.

Cross section as a function of antineutron momentum

Figure 16. Trend as a function of nˉ\bar{n} momentum of nˉp→ηπ+\bar{n}p \to\eta\pi^{+} cross sections. The curve superimposed are the trend expected for pure PP-wave annihilation (magenta) and PP plus higher waves as provided by Dover-Richard model [19]. Data from Ref. [26].

Hunting for Baryonium Signatures

Several theoretical models predict N‾N\overline{N}N bound states (baryonium), based on the short-range attraction in I=0I=0 (ω\omega, σ\sigma exchange) overtaking I=1I=1 repulsion (determine by ρ\rho exchange) [19]. Yet, the annihilation process does not provide unambiguous signatures so far, demanding more precise data and refined potentials.

In spite of substantially negative findings gathered over the years, hints for such a structure still persist, and the search is still ongoing. In the past decades, a JPC=1−−J^{PC}=1^{--} resonance (1.911 GeV/c2c^{2}, 29 MeV width) was suggested by E687 in six-pion photoproduction [27], and a signal was observed as well by DM2 near-threshold, in e+e−e^{+}e^{-} annihilation to six pions [28]. OBELIX sought for similar signatures in nˉp→3π+2π−π0\bar{n}p \to3\pi^{+}2\pi^{-}\pi^{0} but found no signal, setting for such a state σ≤0.5\sigma\leq0.5 mb [29].

More recently, a X(1835)X(1835) state close to the N‾N\overline{N}N threshold was observed in high energy experiments in J/ψJ/\psi radiative decays, as well as in BB decays. The X(1835)X(1835) is a light pseudoscalar resonance first observed by BES in 2005 and confirmed by BESIII with high significance: BES observed it in J/ψ→γppˉJ/\psi\to\gamma p\bar{p} [30], while more recently BESIII confirmed its presence in J/ψ→γπ+π−J/\psi\to\gamma\pi^{+}\pi^{-} [31] and J/ψ→γ3π+3π−J/\psi\to\gamma3\pi^{+}3\pi^{-} [32]. Its mass (1836.5±3.0(stat)−2.1+5.6(syst) MeV/c2)(1836.5 \pm3.0(\mathit{stat})^{+5.6}_{-2.1}(\mathit{syst})\ \mathrm{MeV}/c^{2}) and width (190±9(stat)−3.6+3.8(syst) MeV)(190 \pm9(\mathit{stat})^{+3.8}_{-3.6}(\mathit{syst})\ \mathrm{MeV}) were measured, with >20σ>20\sigma significance; observed decay modes include the also ηKS0KS0\eta K^{0}_{S}K^{0}_{S} and γϕ\gamma\phi. High precision BESIII data are still being investigated to provide additional indications through line shapes and couplings analyses, especially close the ppˉp\bar{p} threshold. Alternative explanations for such a signal suggest the identification as glueball, η′\eta' or ssˉs\bar{s} radial excitations, but no consensus exists yet on its nature.

In addition, Belle observed a structure in B→DpˉpB \to D\bar{p}p and B→KpˉpB \to K\bar{p}p decays [33, 34]. While LHCb and Belle II did not provide any significant new observation for such a structure, investigations are still on-going to ascertain possible near-threshold dynamics related effects.

Meson spectroscopy in gluon rich environments

N‾N\overline{N}N annihilation reactions create gluon-rich environments, ideal for producing and observing exotic states, like purely gluonic glueballs or quark-gluon hybrids.

Meson spectroscopy studies at LEAR exploited mainly antiproton annihilations at rest on hydrogen targets of different densities to select the partial wave composition of the initial pˉp\bar{p}p state. Such a control is made possible by the Stark effect, a density-dependent mechanism which allows to tune the quantum numbers of the atomic levels from which annihilation occurs.

However, compared to modern experiments, LEAR’s statistics remain limited, so additional NˉN\bar{N}N annihilation data would complement investigations of specific meson and baryon excitations.

Antineutron beams, in particular, remained underutilized for meson spectroscopy. Beyond the pioneering OBELIX experiment, which analyzed some selected and exceptionally clean exclusive channels with charged pions in the final state, with a background level below 5%, their full potential is still to be exploited. In the analysis of the nˉp→2π+π−\bar{n}p \rightarrow2\pi^{+}\pi^{-} channel, OBELIX extracted signals possibly linked to the f0(1500)f_{0}(1500) and f2(1565)f_{2}(1565) resonances, using 35,118 events with nˉ\bar{n} momenta over the 50–300 MeV/c range [35].

Channels with open and hidden strangeness

The spectroscopy of states produced in nˉp\bar{n}p annihilation with open or hidden strangeness would yield valuable insights, thanks to distinctive sets of selection rules. Although OBELIX statistics for exclusive final states with strangeness was so small as to preclude full spin-parity analyses, invariant mass distributions still reveal interesting key indications, as detailed below. Certain channels offer fresh perspectives on unconfirmed states, aided by exceptionally clean data samples.

a.a. nˉp→K+K−π+\bar{n}p \rightarrow K^{+}K^{-}\pi^{+}. This channel probes hidden-strangeness strangeonia: many expected states in the 1−−1^{--} sector are still unconfirmed, while some observation play as potential exotics decaying to strange quarks. Resonances decaying to K+K−K^{+}K^{-} carry JPC=(even)++J^{PC} = \text{(even)}^{++} or (odd)−−\text{(odd)}^{--} quantum numbers, and include f0f_{0}, f2f_{2}, a0a_{0}, ϕ\phi mesons and their radial excitations. Such a reaction can also illuminate open-strangeness radial excitations production, like K∗K^{*}, K1K_{1}, and K2K_{2} states.

OBELIX selected 241 exclusive events in this reaction via kaon identification (for both of them) with dE/dxdE/dx and β\beta measurements, kinematic cuts, and a 4C fit. Figure 17(a) displays the invariant mass distributions for the (K+K−)(K^{+}K^{-}) system, where clear ϕ(1020)\phi(1020) and f2(1525)f_{2}(1525) signals appear. The contributions of intermediate states to the remaining spectral regions require thorough investigation, which is prevented with the available tiny statistics.

Figure 17. Invariant mass spectra of the ( K+K−K^{+}K^{-} ) and ( K−π+K^{-}\pi^{+} ) pairs from the nˉp→K+K−π+\bar{n}p \rightarrow K^{+}K^{-}\pi^{+} reaction, with particles selected by means of a 4C fit and particle identification criteria for both kaons; OBELIX data.

On the right panel of Figure 17 the (K−π+)(K^{-}\pi^{+}) invariant mass spectrum is shown, which reveals a prominent K∗0(892)K^{*0}(892) peak.

b.b. nˉp→KS0KS0π+\bar{n}p \rightarrow K^{0}_{S}K^{0}_{S}\pi^{+}. The (KS0KS0)(K^{0}_{S}K^{0}_{S}) system has fixed quantum numbers JPC=(even)++J^{PC} = \text{(even)}^{++}. Consequently, ϕ\phi mesons, as well as, in general, other strangeonium excitations (with JPC=1−−J^{PC} = 1^{--}), cannot decay into this channel. Intermediate f0f_{0} and f2f_{2} mesons decaying to KS0KS0K^{0}_{S}K^{0}_{S} can pair with a pion in the final state, but this occurs only from initial states with G=−1G=-1 (i.e., at low energies: 1S0{}^{1}S_{0}, 3P1{}^{3}P_{1}, 3P2{}^{3}P_{2} waves). Conversely, the a0πa_{0}\pi final state requires G=+1G=+1.

OBELIX analyzed this channel, selecting 687 events for nˉ\bar{n} momenta of 50–400 MeV/c. Although enhanced particle identification and a precise KS0K^{0}_{S} vertex reconstruction were unavailable, the (KS0KS0)(K^{0}_{S}K^{0}_{S}) invariant mass distribution in Figure 18(b) shows preliminary indications for a2(1320)a_{2}(1320) and f2(1525)f_{2}(1525) signals. In the same figure, panel (a) reports the distribution of the (KS0π+)(K^{0}_{S}\pi^{+}) system, where a hint for a K∗+K^{*+} can be observed.

Figure 18. Invariant mass distributions of the ( KS0π+K^{0}_{S}\pi^{+} ) and ( KS0KS0K^{0}_{S}K^{0}_{S} ) system from the nˉp→KS0KS0π+\bar{n}p \rightarrow K^{0}_{S}K^{0}_{S}\pi^{+} reaction selected by means of a 6C fit; OBELIX data. The dashed lines in panel (b) indicate the peak position of the a2(1320)a_{2}(1320) and the f2(1525)f_{2}(1525) resonances.

c.c. nˉp→KL0K±π∓π+\bar{n}p \rightarrow K^{0}_{L}K^{\pm}\pi^{\mp}\pi^{+}. This channel offers a promising avenue for inspecting resonant (KKˉπ)(K\bar{K}\pi) states, that would potentially add information for the resolution of the long-standing E/ιE/\iota puzzle [36], clarifying pseudoscalar-axial-vector superpositions in the 1.3–1.5 GeV/c2c^{2} region. In nˉp\bar{n}p annihilation, GG-parity conservation restricts the possible initial states for this reaction to PP-wave, favoring axial-vector meson production. A selection rule further constrains the (K0K±)(K^{0}K^{\pm}) system to IG=1+I^{G}=1^{+}, allowing intermediate contributions to the recoiling (ππ)(\pi\pi) channel only from a0a_{0}, a2a_{2}, and ρ\rho resonances.

ooscillation studies

Searches for nˉ\bar{n}-nn oscillations probe physics beyond the Standard Model, particularly Grand Unified Theory (GUT) predictions of varying timescales. Such oscillations would violate baryon number by ΔB=2\Delta B = 2, providing unambiguous new physics signals.

Experiments dedicated to nˉ\bar{n}-nn oscillations studies divide into free-neutron and nuclear-bound searches. Concerning the latter, Super-Kamiokande set a lower limit on the oscillation period of 4.7×1084.7 \times10^{8} s (90% CL) studying interactions on 16O{}^{16}\mathrm{O} [37]. Conversely, for free neutrons, which offer cleaner, model-independent measurements, the ILL experiment (1994) obtained τnnˉ>8.6×108\tau_{n\bar{n}} > 8.6 \times10^{8} s (90% CL) [38].

Recent proposals leverage new techniques, where the nˉA\bar{n}A scattering length, estimated via optical potentials [39], plays a key role. A new, promising approach foresees the usage of ultracold neutrons (with kinetic energies on the order of 100 neV) trapped in suitable bottles. The experimental sensitivity of such experiments depends on the wall reflectivity for the antineutrons possibly generated following an oscillation in the trap and on their annihilation rate, which allows their detection. With such an approach an improvement by several orders of magnitude over the current limits of the τ(nˉn)\tau(\bar{n}n) oscillation period could potentially be achieved.

More details on the derivation of the oscillation period with ultra-cold neutrons can be found, for instance, in Ref. [40].

The wall reflectivity depends on the potential of the antineutron-nucleus interaction, therefore, as mentioned above, on the antineutron-nucleus scattering length. There are basically two ways to determine such a quantity, both of which invoke hadronic physics: from a fit of existing X-ray spectroscopy data from antiprotonic atoms, or from the measurement of annihilation cross sections at very low energies, i.e in S-wave. Data on antiprotonic atoms exist, but unfortunately they do not provide a sufficiently precise estimate at ultra-cold energies. However, very accurate input values are required to properly model the reflection process, in order to properly optimize the bottle materials and shapes.

Measurements of S-wave annihilation and elastic nˉ\bar{n} cross sections are still missing at present, but could in principle be performed with backward-produced antineutrons in pˉp→nnˉ\bar{p}p \rightarrow n\bar{n} CEX reactions, as suggested in Ref. [41, 42] and shortly described in the next Section.

Novel Antineutron beams at the Antiproton Decelerator (AD)

Producing antineutrons via charge exchange (CEX) to enable the studies outlined above requires slowly extracted antiprotons with momentum ≥100\geq100 MeV/cc. As a figure of merit, 9 MeV/cc center-of-mass backward-emitted antineutrons from CEX from 200 MeV/cc antiprotons would be produced with a cross section of (4.7±1.9) μb(4.7 \pm1.9)\ \mu\mathrm{b}/sr [41, 42].

CERN’s AD facility currently delivers 4×107pˉ/24 \times10^{7}\bar{p}/2 min at 100 MeV/cc to the ELENA ring, but still lacks slow extraction. Implementing such a line would demand significant set-up modifications, yet remains, in principle, feasible. If achieved, it could yield spills of ∼4×104pˉ\sim4 \times10^{4}\bar{p}, matching LEAR-era intensities.

Past attempts of fast extractions at 300 and 502 MeV/cc were successful, and experts deem both slow and high-momentum extraction viable for future AD upgrades, if supported by sufficient community interest. A key hurdle, however, is the available space: all experimental areas in the AD complex are currently occupied, and new setups would strain the existing infrastructure.

Some ideas for a possible future leverage of the AD facility to complete studies of low-energy interactions at low energy were described in Ref. [42].

Prospects for future Antineutron-Based Experiments

Some suggestions for simplified set-ups for providing new measurements to clarify several of the issues discussed above are outlined in the following:

  • Differential elastic and total cross sections measurements:

    • nˉ\bar{n} beam: tagged beam with a production (CEX) target and a scatterer;

    • detector: a compact neutron detector (fiber-based, for instance);

    • experimental set-up: small equipment, less than 1 m long.

  • Systematic measurements of σann(nˉp)\sigma_{ann}(\bar{n}p) and σann(pˉp)\sigma_{ann}(\bar{p}p) from 700 down to 50 MeV/cc:

    • non-magnetic set-up;

    • good angular coverage;

    • nˉ\bar{n} beam: produced by CEX, production target needed;

    • reaction target(s): same vessel for LH2\mathrm{LH}_{2} (down to 200 MeV/cc), gaseous H2\mathrm{H}_{2} at lower pˉ\bar{p} momenta.

  • Meson spectroscopy studies:

    • nˉ\bar{n} beam: intense beam required, slow extraction mandatory;

    • detector: full acceptance magnetic detector with PID capabilities to identify and measure all the emitted particles.

Conclusions

Experiments using antineutrons as probes yielded significant results through the 1990s. Yet, limited statistics hampered precision, leaving key questions, and long-standing puzzle unresolved. Larger datasets, including new samples of pˉp\bar{p}p annihilations, are essential for comparisons and resolution of the open issues. No other facility has ever matched, as of today, LEAR’s antineutron beam intensity and momentum resolution.

A promising path forward lies in the opportunity of slow extraction of high-energy (≥200\ge200 MeV/cc) pˉ\bar{p} beams from CERN’s AD, which could potentially enable a new generation of antineutron experiments revitalizing this research line.

References

References

  1. [1]Bressani, T. and Filippi, A., Phys. Rep. 383, 213 (2003).
  2. [2]Brando, T. et al., Nucl. Instr. and Meth. B180, 461 (1981).
  3. [3]Gunderson, B. et al., Phys. Rev. D23, 587 (21981).
  4. [4]Armstrong T. et al., Phys. Rev. D36, 659 (1987).
  5. [5]Cugusi, L. et al., Nucl. Instr. Meth. A270, 354 (1988).
  6. [6]Agnello, M. et al., Nucl. Instr. Meth. A399, 11 (1997).
  7. [7]Iazzi, F. et al. (OBELIX Collaboration), Phys. Lett. B475, 378 (2000).
  8. [8]Bugg, D.V. et al., Phys. Lett. B194, 563 (1987).
  9. [9]Banerjee, S. et al., Z. Phys. C28, 163 (1985).
  10. [10]Banerjee, S. et al., Z. Phys. C32, 163 (1986).
  11. [11]Mutchler, G.S. et al., Phys. Rev. D38, 742 (1988).
  12. [12]Bertin, A. et al. (OBELIX Collaboration), Nucl. Phys. B (Proc. Supp.) 56A, 227 (1997).
  13. [13]Astrua, M. et al., Nucl. Phys. A697, 209 (2002).
  14. [14]Friedman, E. et al., Nucl. Phys. A925, 141 (2014).
  15. [15]Bianconi, A. et al., Phys. Lett. B704, 461 (2011).
  16. [16]Mahalanabis, J. et al., Nucl. Phys. A485, 546 (1988).
  17. [17]Kudryavtsev, A.E. and Druzhinin, B.L., ITEP-23-94 (1994).
  18. [18]Bressani, T., Proceedings V Conference on Heavy Quarks at Fixed Targets (eds. J. Bediaga, J. Miranda, A. Reis), Frascati Physics Series 20, 363 (2001).
  19. [19]Dover, C.B. et al., Prog. Part. Nucl. Phys. 29, 97 (1992).
  20. [20]Zenoni, A. et al., Phys. Lett. B461, 405 (1999).
  21. [21]Hamilton, R.P. et al., Phys. Rev. Lett. 44, 1179 (1980).
  22. [22]Brückner, W. et al., Phys. Lett. B169, 469 (1987).
  23. [23]Barbina, C. et al., Nucl. Phys. A612, 346 (1997).
  24. [24]Nakamura, K. et al., Phys. Rev. Lett. 53, 885 (1984).
  25. [25]Filippi, A. et al. (OBELIX Collaboration), Nucl. Phys. A655, 453 (1999).
  26. [26]Filippi, A. et al. (OBELIX Collaboration), Phys. Lett. B471, 263 (1999).
  27. [27]Frabetti, P.L. et al. (E687 Collaboration), Phys. Lett. B514, 419 (1998).
  28. [28]Alessandro, S. et al. (DM2 Collaboration), Phys. Lett. B212 (1988).
  29. [29]Filippi, A. et al. (OBELIX Collaboration), Phys.Lett. B527, 39 (2002).
  30. [30]Bai, J.Z. et al. (BES Collaboration), Phys. Rev. Lett. 91, 022001 (2003).
  31. [31]Ablikim, M. et al. (BESIII Collaboration), Phys. Rev. Lett. 106, 072002 (2011).
  32. [32]Ablikim, M. et al. (BESIII Collaboration), Phys. Rev. D88, 091502(R) (2013).
  33. [33]Abe, K. et al. (Belle Collaboration), Phys. Rev. Lett. 89, 051802 (2002).
  34. [34]Abe, K. et al. (Belle Collaboration), Phys. Rev. Lett. 88, 181803 (2002).
  35. [35]Bertin, A. et al. (OBELIX Collaboration), Phys. Rev. D57, 55 (1998).
  36. [36]A. Masoni, PoS ACAT05, 046 (2005).
  37. [37]Abe, K. et al. (Super-Kamiokande Collaboration), Phys. Rev. D103, 012008 (2021).
  38. [38]Baldo Ceolin, M. et al., Z. Phys. C63, 409 (1994).
  39. [39]Friedman, E. and Gal, A., Phys. Rev. D78, 016002 (2008).
  40. [40]Fujioka, H. and Higuchi, T., arXiv [nucl-ex]: 2508.17725 (2025).
  41. [41]Filippi, A. et al., arXiv (nucl-ex): 2503.06972 (2025).
  42. [42]Amsler, C. et al., Technical Report CERN-SPSC-2025-010 SPSCI-261 (2025).

Paper details

vlnc:W_t7mgrx92
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 0

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Physics and Astronomy

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents