betaFeedback

WorksPhysics and Astronomy

0νββ0νββ decay nuclear matrix elements under Left-Right symmetric model from the spherical quasi-particle random phase approximation method with realistic force

Abstract

We perform the calculation of nuclear matrix elements for the neutrinoless double beta decays under a Left-Right symmetric model mediated by light neutrino, and we adopt the spherical quasi-particle random-phase approximation (QRPA) approach with realistic force. For eight nuclei: 76^{76}Ge, 82^{82}Se, 96^{96}Zr, 100^{100}Mo, 116^{116}Cd, 128^{128}Te, 130^{130}Te and 136^{136}Xe, related nuclear matrix elements are given. We analyze each term and the details of contributions of different parts are also given. For the qq term, we find that the weak-magnetism components of the nucleon current contribute equally as other components such as axial-vector. We also discuss the influence of short-range correlations on these NMEs. It is found that RR term are more sensitive to the short range correlation than other terms due to the large portion of the contribution from high exchange momenta.

decay nuclear matrix elements under Left-Right symmetric model from the spherical quasi-particle random phase approxim

Abstract

Introduction

As a rare and unobserved process, the neutrinoless double beta (0νββ0\nu\beta\beta) decay attracts attentions from communities of nuclear and particle physics. This second-order weak process, with an even-even nucleus decaying to its neighboring with two additional protons and with two electrons emitted, has no neutrinos in its products. This is different from the other mode of double beta decay, namely two neutrinos double beta decay which has been observed for years. The absence of neutrinos in the decay product indicates one thing, that this process is a lepton-number-violating (ΔL=2\Delta L = 2) process, and its discovery suggesting the new physics beyond the particle standard model.

Neutrino is the light Fermions ever known in our universe. It is still surrounded by many unsolved puzzles, including the origin of its mass, its mass hierarchy, and whether it is Dirac or Majorana particle [1]. The 0νββ0\nu\beta\beta decay is the key for our understanding of these problems. Accurately calculated nuclear matrix elements(NMEs) are particularly important in the search for 0νββ0\nu\beta\beta decay, as the half-lives of this process are dependent on its NMEs, which describe the nuclear transition during this process. It is the key to extract the so-called effective neutrino mass ∣mββ∣|m_{\beta\beta}| or other new physics parameters from measured half life of 0νββ0\nu\beta\beta depending on the underlying mechanisms, once the process is observed. There are a large amount of nuclear calculations with different many-body approaches focusing on the determination of NMEs, for instance, the works from large scale shell model (LSSM) [2, 3, 4], the quasi-particle random-phase approximation (QRPA) [5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11], the interacting boson model (IBM) [12, 13] and energy-density functional (EDF) theory [14, 15, 16, 17]. However, a significant challenge remains: NMEs derived from different nuclear models can differ by as much as a factor of three [18, 19]. A promising avenue of reducing the discrepancy in calculations of NMEs is to develop the ab initioab\ initio methods, which is still challenging task especially for heavier nuclei [20].

Most of the above calculations focus on the neutrino mass mechanism where the only new physics ingredient one introduce is the neutrino mass term. These mass terms are most probably come from the so-call neutrino see-saw mechanism, they are usually embedded in much more complicated new physics model. One of such model which could naturally incorporate such mechanism is an extension to the standard model, the Left-Right symmetric model (LRSM). Within the framework of LR symmetric model, besides the usual neutrino mass mechanism, one has more underlying mechanisms for 0νββ0\nu\beta\beta-decay from the qq part of the neutrino propagator besides the mass part. The qq term of neutrino propagator generally induces the η\eta mechanism associated with the mixing of left- and right-handed gauge bosons and λ\lambda mechanism related to the mass ratio of these two bosons.

For these extra NMEs of LRSM, there have been less studies and inadequate nuclear many-body calculations compared to that of the mass mechanism. The existing limited calculations adopt different many-body approaches, including LSSM [21], QRPA [22, 23, 24], and projected Hatree-Fock Bogolyubov (PHFB) approach [25]. More recently, several new calculations of NMEs relevant to LRSM have been conducted. These include evaluations of the NMEs associated with the mass and λ\lambda mechanisms, using LSSM [26, 27] and QRPA [28] approaches, which incorporate higher-order nucleon currents based on the improved formalism from Ref. [29]. It was found that the including pseudoscalar contributions enhance qGTqGT matrix elements significantly in the Ref. [26, 27]. Additionally, the competition of contributions in the decay rate between the mass and λ\lambda mechanisms was also discussed in the QRPA calculations [28] based on relevant calculated NMEs. Then the MM components in the qq terms have often been considered suppressed and hence neglected in the previous calculations. However, recent work using the LSSM approach [30] have shown that these MM components are essential for the calculations of relevant LRSM NMEs. Till now, such QRPA calculations that incorporate these MM components in LRSM NMEs are still absent.

Generally speaking, we still lack thorough investigation over the LRSM NMEs from various calculations, and the calculations for these NMEs are far from abundant. Therefore, in this work, we calculate the NMEs for the LRSM using the pn-QRPA approach, employing a large model space and realistic NN interactions, for all the mechanisms mediated by light neutrinos, the mass, η\eta and λ\lambda mechanisms.

This article is structured as follows: we begin with a brief introduction to the underlying formalism of the LRSM and the formalism of the QRPA method. Next, we present the results of the NMEs and discuss the various contributions of these terms. Furthermore, we will also examine the influence of different SRC parametrizations. Finally, we draw our conclusions.

formalism

Ignoring the contribution from heavy neutrino, the 0νββ0\nu\beta\beta half-life for the LR symmetric model with λ\lambda and η\eta mechanisms can be written as [29, 30, 31]:

[T1/20ν]−1={Cmm(∣mββ∣me)2+Cλλ⟨λ⟩2+Cηη⟨η⟩2+Cmλ∣mββ∣me⟨λ⟩cos⁡ψ1+Cmη∣mββ∣me⟨η⟩cos⁡ψ2+Cλη⟨λ⟩⟨η⟩cos⁡(ψ1−ψ2)}.(1)\left[T_{1/2}^{0\nu}\right]^{-1} = \left\{ C_{mm}\left(\frac{|m_{\beta\beta}|}{m_e}\right)^2 + C_{\lambda\lambda}\langle\lambda\rangle^2 + C_{\eta\eta}\langle\eta\rangle^2 + C_{m\lambda}\frac{|m_{\beta\beta}|}{m_e}\langle\lambda\rangle\cos\psi_1 + C_{m\eta}\frac{|m_{\beta\beta}|}{m_e}\langle\eta\rangle\cos\psi_2 + C_{\lambda\eta}\langle\lambda\rangle\langle\eta\rangle\cos(\psi_1-\psi_2)\right\}. \tag*{(1)}

Here, the mββ=∑jUej2mjm_{\beta\beta} = \sum_j U_{ej}^2m_j is the effective neutrino mass. And other parameters such as ⟨λ⟩\langle\lambda\rangle or ⟨η⟩\langle\eta\rangle are given in [29]: ⟨λ⟩=∣λ∑jUejTej∗(gV′/gV)∣\langle\lambda\rangle= |\lambda\sum_j U_{ej}T_{ej}^{*}(g'_V/g_V)| and ⟨η⟩=∣η∑jUejTej∗∣\langle\eta\rangle= |\eta\sum_j U_{ej}T_{ej}^{*}|. The two phase angles are

ψ1=arg⁡[(∑jmjUej2)(∑jUejTej∗(gV′/gV))∗]\psi_1 = \arg\left[\left(\sum_jm_jU_{ej}^2\right)\left(\sum_jU_{ej}T_{ej}^{*}(g'_V/g_V)\right)^{*}\right]

and

ψ2=arg⁡[(∑jmjUej2)(∑jUejTej∗)∗].\psi_2 = \arg\left[\left(\sum_jm_jU_{ej}^2\right)\left(\sum_jU_{ej}T_{ej}^{*}\right)^{*}\right].

The UU and TT are the constituents of a generalized 6×66\times6 Pontecorvo-Maki-Nakagawa-Sakata (PMNS) matrix [32]. It is typically assumed that gV≈gV′g_V \approx g'_V, leading to ψ1≈ψ2\psi_1 \approx\psi_2.

The explicit forms of coefficients CC's, which are the combinations of nuclear matrix elements (NMEs) and phase-space factors (PSFs), can also be found in Ref. [30], with G01,02,03=G01,02,03G_{01,02,03} = \mathcal{G}_{01,02,03}, G04,05,06=G04,05,06/(meR)G_{04,05,06} = \mathcal{G}_{04,05,06}/(m_eR) and G07,08,09,10,11=G07,08,09,010,011/(meR)2G_{07,08,09,10,11} = \mathcal{G}_{07,08,09,010,011}/(m_eR)^2:

Cmm=G01Mm2C_{mm} = G_{01}M_m^2
Cmλ=−G03MmMω−+G04MmMq+Cmη=G03MmMω+−G04MmMq−−G05MmMP+G06MmMRCλλ=G02Mω−2+G011Mq+2−2G010Mω−Mq+Cηη=G02Mω+2+G011Mq−2−2G010Mω+Mq−+G08MP2+G09MR2−G07MPMRCλη=−2G02Mω−Mω+−2G011Mq+Mq−+2G010(Mω−Mq−+Mω+Mq+),(2)\begin{aligned} C_{m\lambda} &= -G_{03}M_mM_{\omega-} + G_{04}M_mM_{q+} \\ C_{m\eta} &= G_{03}M_mM_{\omega+} - G_{04}M_mM_{q-} - G_{05}M_mM_P \\ &\quad+ G_{06}M_mM_R \\ C_{\lambda\lambda} &= G_{02}M_{\omega-}^2 + G_{011}M_{q+}^2 - 2G_{010}M_{\omega-}M_{q+} \\ C_{\eta\eta} &= G_{02}M_{\omega+}^2 + G_{011}M_{q-}^2 - 2G_{010}M_{\omega+}M_{q-} \\ &\quad+ G_{08}M_P^2 + G_{09}M_R^2 - G_{07}M_PM_R \\ C_{\lambda\eta} &= -2G_{02}M_{\omega-}M_{\omega+} - 2G_{011}M_{q+}M_{q-} \\ &\quad+ 2G_{010}(M_{\omega-}M_{q-} + M_{\omega+}M_{q+}), \tag*{(2)} \end{aligned}

with MmM_m, MωM_\omega, MqM_q, MRM_R and MPM_P explicitly included. These NMEs may consist of different parts:

Mm=−MF+MGT+MTMω±=±MωF+MωGT±+MωT±Mq±=±MqF+MqGT±±MqT±MR=MRGT+MRT.(3)\begin{aligned} M_m &= -M_F + M_{GT} + M_T \\ M_{\omega\pm} &= \pm M_{\omega F} + M_{\omega GT\pm} + M_{\omega T\pm} \\ M_{q\pm} &= \pm M_{qF} + M_{qGT\pm} \pm M_{qT\pm} \\ M_R &= M_{RGT} + M_{RT}. \tag*{(3)} \end{aligned}

These different parts of NMEs MIM_I can be written in a general form:

MI=⟨0f+∥hI(r,r+)OI∥0i+⟩,(4)M_I = \langle0_f^+ \lVert h_I(r,r_+)\mathcal{O}_I \rVert0_i^+\rangle, \tag*{(4)}

where II's are different parts in eq. (3), ∣0i+⟩|0_i^+\rangle and ∣0f+⟩|0_f^+\rangle represent the ground states of initial and final nuclei. The distance rr is defined as ∣rm−rn∣|r_m-r_n|, and r+r_+ is given by ∣(rm+rn)/2∣|(r_m+r_n)/2|, where rm(n)r_{m(n)} are the coordinates of the decaying nucleon, labeled as mm or nn, respectively.

For the mass, qq, RR and PP terms, the neutrino potentials hI(r,r+)h_I(r,r_+) in (4) are expressed in the form:

hI(r,r+)=fsrc2(r)2Rπ∫fI(q,r,r+)q dqq+Em−(Ei+Ef)/2,(5)h_I(r,r_+) = f_{\mathrm{src}}^2(r)\frac{2R}{\pi}\int f_I(q,r,r_+)\frac{q\,dq}{q+E_m-(E_i+E_f)/2}, \tag*{(5)}

where EiE_i (EfE_f) is the ground state energy of the initial (final) nucleus, and EmE_m is the energy of the intermediate nucleus. In order to account for the characteristics of nuclear force at short distance, which is missing in the nuclear wave functions from many-body calculations, a short-range correlation (SRC) function fsrc(r)=1−ce−ar2(1−br2)f_{\mathrm{src}}(r)=1-ce^{-ar^2}(1-br^2) [33, 34] is introduced in the calculations of neutrino potentials (5). In our work, we apply the Argonne V18 and CD-Bonn parametrizations of the SRC, where the parameters aa, bb, and cc in the fsrcf_{\mathrm{src}} are taken from Ref. [35]. The effects of SRC on the NMEs will be discussed later. With the inclusion of pseudo-scalar and weak-magnetism terms, as an usual convention, the ff's functions in the neutrino potentials are given by the following form[30]. For the mass term:

fF=j0(qr)gV2(q2)f_F = j_0(qr)g_V^2(q^2)
fGT=fGTAA+fGTAP+fGTPP+fGTMMf_{GT} = f_{GT}^{AA} + f_{GT}^{AP} + f_{GT}^{PP} + f_{GT}^{MM}
fGT=−j0(qr)(gA2(q2)−gA(q2)gP(q2)mNq23+gP2(q2)4mN2q43+gM2(q2)4mN22q23)(6)f_{GT} = -j_0(qr)\left(g_A^2(q^2)-\frac{g_A(q^2)g_P(q^2)}{m_N}\frac{q^2}{3}+\frac{g_P^2(q^2)}{4m_N^2}\frac{q^4}{3}+\frac{g_M^2(q^2)}{4m_N^2}\frac{2q^2}{3}\right) \tag*{(6)}
fT=fTAP+fTPP+fTMM=j2(qr)(gA(q2)gP(q2)mNq23−gP2(q2)4mN2q43+gM2(q2)4mN2q23)f_T=f_T^{AP}+f_T^{PP}+f_T^{MM} =j_2(qr)\left(\frac{g_A(q^2)g_P(q^2)}{m_N}\frac{q^2}{3}-\frac{g_P^2(q^2)}{4m_N^2}\frac{q^4}{3}+\frac{g_M^2(q^2)}{4m_N^2}\frac{q^2}{3}\right)

for the qq term:

fqF=j1(qr)qrgV2(q2)f_{qF}=j_1(qr)qr g_V^2(q^2)
fqGT±=fqGTAA+fqGTAP+fqGTPP∓fqGTMM=13j1(qr)qr(gA2(q2)+gA(q2)gP(q2)q2mN−gP2(q2)q44mN2∓gM2(q2)q22mN2)f_{qGT\pm}=f_{qGT}^{AA}+f_{qGT}^{AP}+f_{qGT}^{PP}\mp f_{qGT}^{MM} =\frac{1}{3}j_1(qr)qr\left(g_A^2(q^2)+\frac{g_A(q^2)g_P(q^2)q^2}{m_N}-\frac{g_P^2(q^2)q^4}{4m_N^2}\mp\frac{g_M^2(q^2)q^2}{2m_N^2}\right)
fqT±=fqTAA+fqTAP+fqTPP∓fqTMM=23j1(qr)qr(−gA2(q2)+gA(q2)gP(q2)q22mN)−q3r20mN2gP2(q2)q2(2j1(qr)/3+j3(qr))∓q3r30mN2gM2(q2)(j1(qr)+3j3(qr)),(7)f_{qT\pm}=f_{qT}^{AA}+f_{qT}^{AP}+f_{qT}^{PP}\mp f_{qT}^{MM} =\frac{2}{3}j_1(qr)qr\left(-g_A^2(q^2)+g_A(q^2)g_P(q^2)\frac{q^2}{2m_N}\right)-\frac{q^3r}{20m_N^2}g_P^2(q^2)q^2\left(2j_1(qr)/3+j_3(qr)\right)\mp\frac{q^3r}{30m_N^2}g_M^2(q^2)\left(j_1(qr)+3j_3(qr)\right), \tag*{(7)}

and for the R and P terms:

fRGT=−R3mNgA(q2)gM(q2)j0(qr)q2f_{RGT}=-\frac{R}{3m_N}g_A(q^2)g_M(q^2)j_0(qr)q^2
fRT=−R6mNgA(q2)gM(q2)j2(qr)q2f_{RT}=-\frac{R}{6m_N}g_A(q^2)g_M(q^2)j_2(qr)q^2
fP=gV(q2)gA(q2)j1(qr)qr+,(8)f_P=g_V(q^2)g_A(q^2)j_1(qr)qr_+, \tag*{(8)}

where R=1.2A1/3R=1.2A^{1/3} is the nuclear radius, and jλj_\lambda (λ=0,1,2,3\lambda=0,1,2,3) is the spherical Bessel function with rank λ\lambda. Considering the effects of finite nucleon size, the vector, axial-vector, weak-magnetism and induced pseudo-scalar momentum dependent form factors in the fIf_I function are considered:

gV(q2)=gV/[1+q2/(ΛV)2]2g_V(q^2)=g_V/[1+q^2/(\Lambda_V)^2]^2
gA(q2)=gA/[1+q2/(ΛA)2]2g_A(q^2)=g_A/[1+q^2/(\Lambda_A)^2]^2
gM(q2)=[(μp−μn)+1]gV(q2)g_M(q^2)=[(\mu_p-\mu_n)+1]g_V(q^2)
gP(q2)=2mNgA(q2)q2+mπ2.(9)g_P(q^2)=\frac{2m_Ng_A(q^2)}{q^2+m_\pi^2}. \tag*{(9)}

We take gV=1.0g_V=1.0 and gA=1.27g_A=1.27 in this work. mπm_\pi and mNm_N are the pion and nucleon mass, respectively. The anomalous nucleon magnetic moment is μp−μn≈3.71\mu_p-\mu_n\approx3.71. The cutoffs are ΛV=0.85GeV\Lambda_V=0.85\mathrm{GeV}, ΛA=1.086GeV\Lambda_A=1.086\mathrm{GeV}, respectively.

Note that we change the definition of Mq0νM_q^{0\nu}, this is due to the fact that earlier calculation has only the axial-vector included, induced current such as Pseudo-Scalar and weak magnetism terms are neglected. If these terms are included, we find that a factor of 1/31/3 should be absorbed in the definition of MqGTAAM_{qGT}^{AA} in the sense that we

treat MqM_q on equal footing as MmM_m or MωM_\omega. In general, MqGT=13MqGToM_{qGT}=\frac{1}{3}M_{qGT}^{o}, MqF=MqFoM_{qF}=M_{qF}^{o} and MqT=−2MqToM_{qT}=-2M_{qT}^{o}, where the NME parts with superscript oo refers to those defined in [28, 30, 31]. In the meantime, the corresponding phase space factors are also changed by dividing a factor 1/31/3.

For the neutrino potential hI(r)h_I(r) with I=ωFI=\omega F, ωGT\omega GT and ωT\omega T in ω\omega terms, the expressions have a little difference from those in (5),

hI(r)=fsrc2(r)2Rπ∫fI(qr)q2 dq[q+En−(Ei+Ef)/2]2(10)h_I(r)=f_{src}^2(r)\frac{2R}{\pi}\int f_I(qr)\frac{q^2\,dq}{[q+E_n-(E_i+E_f)/2]^2} \tag*{(10)}

Here, the ff's functions of the ω\omega term are:

fωF=j0(qr)gV2(q2)f_{\omega F}=j_0(qr)g_V^2(q^2)
fωGT±=fGTAA+fGTAP+fGTPP±fGTMM=j0(qr)(gA2(q2)−gA(q2)gP(q2)mNq23+gP(q2)4mN2q43±gM2(q2)4mN22q23)f_{\omega GT\pm}=f_{GT}^{AA}+f_{GT}^{AP}+f_{GT}^{PP}\pm f_{GT}^{MM} =j_0(qr)\left(g_A^2(q^2)-\frac{g_A(q^2)g_P(q^2)}{m_N}\frac{q^2}{3}+\frac{g_P(q^2)}{4m_N^2}\frac{q^4}{3}\pm\frac{g_M^2(q^2)}{4m_N^2}\frac{2q^2}{3}\right)
fωT±=fTAP+fTPP±fTMM=j2(qr)(gA(q2)gP(q2)mNq23−gP2(q2)4mN2q43±gM2(q2)4mN2q23).(11)f_{\omega T\pm}=f_T^{AP}+f_T^{PP}\pm f_T^{MM} =j_2(qr)\left(\frac{g_A(q^2)g_P(q^2)}{m_N}\frac{q^2}{3}-\frac{g_P^2(q^2)}{4m_N^2}\frac{q^4}{3}\pm\frac{g_M^2(q^2)}{4m_N^2}\frac{q^2}{3}\right). \tag*{(11)}

Meanwhile the operator OIO_I in the NMEs can be expressed as:

OF,qF,ωF=1O_{F,qF,\omega F}=1
OGT,qGT,ωGT,RG=σm⋅σnO_{GT,qGT,\omega GT,RG}=\boldsymbol{\sigma}_m\cdot\boldsymbol{\sigma}_n
OT,qT,ωT,RT=3(σm⋅r^)(σn⋅r^)−σm⋅σnO_{T,qT,\omega T,RT}=3(\boldsymbol{\sigma}_m\cdot\hat{r})(\boldsymbol{\sigma}_n\cdot\hat{r})-\boldsymbol{\sigma}_m\cdot\boldsymbol{\sigma}_n
OP=i(σm−σn)⋅(r^×r^+),(12)O_P=i(\boldsymbol{\sigma}_m-\boldsymbol{\sigma}_n)\cdot(\hat{r}\times\hat{r}_+), \tag*{(12)}

where r^=r/r\hat{r}=r/r and r^+=r+/r+\hat{r}_+=r_+/r_+.

To calculate these NMEs, certain many-body approaches are needed. In this work, the spherical proton-neutron quasi-particle random-phase approximation (pn-QRPA) with realistic force is employed. Although the QRPA approach lacks higher-order many-body correlations, it can incorporate a larger model space in the calculations compared to the nuclear shell model. Within the QRPA framework, we choose the BCS vacua as the initial and final ground states of the parent and daughter nucleus, while the virtual states of the intermediate odd-odd nucleus can be expressed as one phonon excitations:

∣Jπm⟩=QmJπ†∣0⟩=∑pn(XmpnJπApn†+YmpnJπA~pn)∣0⟩.(13)|J^\pi m\rangle=Q_{m}^{J\pi\dagger}|0\rangle=\sum_{pn}\left(X_{mpn}^{J\pi}A_{pn}^{\dagger}+Y_{mpn}^{J\pi}\widetilde{A}_{pn}\right)|0\rangle. \tag*{(13)}

Here mm refers to the index of the intermediate states and Apn†=αp†αn†A_{pn}^{\dagger}=\alpha_p^\dagger\alpha_n^\dagger is the two quasi-particle creation operator, with ατ\alpha_{\tau} the quasi particle and ∣0⟩|0\rangle the vacuum state approximated as BCS vacuum [5].

The forward XX and backward YY amplitudes are obtained by solving the following equations:

\begin{pmatrix} A & B \\ -B & -A \end{pmatrix} \begin{pmatrix} X \\ Y \end{pmatrix} = \omega \begin{pmatrix} X \\ Y \end{pmatrix}. \tag*{(14)}\end{pmatrix}

These amplitudes are then the key inputs for the calculation of NMEs. The ω\omega represents corresponding energy eigenvalues. The matrices AA and BB are defined as follows:

Apn,p′n′Jπ=δpp′δnn′(Ep+En)−2gph(upvnup′vn′+vpunvp′un′)F(pnp′n′,J)−2(upunup′un′+vpvnvp′vn′)×(gppT=1G(pnp′n′,JT=1)+gppT=0G(pnp′n′,JT=0)),(15)\begin{aligned} A^{J^\pi}_{pn,p'n'}={}&\delta_{pp'}\delta_{nn'}(E_p+E_n)\\ &-2g_{ph}(u_pv_nu_{p'}v_{n'}+v_pu_nv_{p'}u_{n'})F(pnp'n',J)\\ &-2(u_pu_nu_{p'}u_{n'}+v_pv_nv_{p'}v_{n'})\\ &\quad\times\left(g_{pp}^{T=1}G(pnp'n',JT=1)+g_{pp}^{T=0}G(pnp'n',JT=0)\right), \tag*{(15)} \end{aligned}
Bpn,p′n′Jπ=−2gph(upvnvp′un′+vpunup′vn′)F(pnp′n′,J)+2(upunvp′vn′+vpvnup′un′)×(gppT=1G(pnp′n′,JT=1)+gppT=0G(pnp′n′,JT=0)),(16)\begin{aligned} B^{J^\pi}_{pn,p'n'}={}&-2g_{ph}(u_pv_nv_{p'}u_{n'}+v_pu_nu_{p'}v_{n'})F(pnp'n',J)\\ &+2(u_pu_nv_{p'}v_{n'}+v_pv_nu_{p'}u_{n'})\\ &\quad\times\left(g_{pp}^{T=1}G(pnp'n',JT=1)+g_{pp}^{T=0}G(pnp'n',JT=0)\right), \tag*{(16)} \end{aligned}

where JπJ^\pi denotes angular momentum and parity of virtual intermediate states. The EpE_p and EnE_n are quasi-particle energy of proton and neutron respectively. They are obtained from sloving the BCS equations [5]. GG and FF are G-matrix elements obtained from the Brückner G-matrix equations.

The parameters gppg_{pp}’s and gphg_{ph} are the renormalized strengths for the two-body residual interaction of particle-particle and particle-hole channels, respectively. The gphg_{ph} is traditionally fixed to reproduce the experimental position of the giant Gamow-Teller resonance (GTGR) strength, and gph=1g_{ph}=1 is used in current calculation. While for the particle-particle channel, there are two kinds of interaction matrix elements: isoscalar (T=0) and isovector (T=1). Following the procedure in the work [8], we employ two parameters gppT=0g_{pp}^{T=0} and gppT=1g_{pp}^{T=1} to renormalize these two interaction strengths, which should be adjusted independently. These two parameters are typically fixed in the 2νββ2\nu\beta\beta calculations. The isoscalar parameter gppT=0g_{pp}^{T=0} is determined by fitting the measured half-life of 2νββ2\nu\beta\beta decay. Meanwhile, the isovector parameter gppT=1g_{pp}^{T=1} is adjusted so that the Fermi NME MF2νM_{F}^{2\nu} vanishes, thereby restoring the isospin symmetry in 2νββ2\nu\beta\beta [8, 36].

With the solutions of pn-QRPA equations and summing over all the intermediate states, the NMEs of 0νββ0\nu\beta\beta decay can be expressed as:

MI0ν=∑Jπ,ki,kf∑pp′nn′(−1)jn+jp′+J+J2J+1×{jpjnJjn′jp′J}(pp′;J∥hI(r,r+)OI∥nn′;J)×(0f+∥[cp′†c~n′]J∥Jkfπ⟩⟨Jkfπ∥Jkiπ⟩×(Jkiπ∥[cp†c~n]J∥0i+),\begin{aligned} M_I^{0\nu}={}&\sum_{J^\pi,k_i,k_f}\sum_{pp'nn'}(-1)^{j_n+j_{p'}+J+J}\sqrt{2J+1}\\ &\times\left\{\begin{matrix}j_p&j_n&J\\j_{n'}&j_{p'}&J\end{matrix}\right\}(pp';J\|h_I(r,r_+)O_I\|nn';J)\\ &\times(0_f^+\|[c_{p'}^\dagger\widetilde{c}_{n'}]_J\|J_{k_f}^\pi\rangle\langle J_{k_f}^\pi\|J_{k_i}^\pi\rangle\\ &\times(J_{k_i}^\pi\|[c_p^\dagger\widetilde{c}_n]_J\|0_i^+), \end{aligned}

where kik_i and kfk_f label the different pnQRPA solutions corresponding to initial and final even-even nucleus. The one-body transition densities in the MI0νM_I^{0\nu} can be expressed as:

(0f+∥[cp′†c~n′]J∥Jkfπ⟩2J+1=[vp′(f)un′(f)Xp′n′Jπkf+up′(f)vn′(f)Yp′n′Jπkf],\frac{(0_f^+\|[c_{p'}^\dagger\widetilde{c}_{n'}]_J\|J_{k_f}^\pi\rangle}{\sqrt{2J+1}} = \left[v_{p'}^{(f)}u_{n'}^{(f)}X_{p'n'}^{J^\pi k_f}+u_{p'}^{(f)}v_{n'}^{(f)}Y_{p'n'}^{J^\pi k_f}\right],
(Jkiπ∥[cp†c~n]J∥0i+⟩2J+1=[up(i)vn(i)XpnJπki+vp(i)un(i)YpnJπki],(17)\frac{(J_{k_i}^\pi\|[c_p^\dagger\widetilde{c}_n]_J\|0_i^+\rangle}{\sqrt{2J+1}} = \left[u_p^{(i)}v_n^{(i)}X_{pn}^{J^\pi k_i}+v_p^{(i)}u_n^{(i)}Y_{pn}^{J^\pi k_i}\right], \tag*{(17)}

where the BCS occupation and vacancy amplitudes v(i)(v(f))v^{(i)}(v^{(f)}), u(i)(u(f))u^{(i)}(u^{(f)}) are derived from the solutions of BCS equations for the initial (final) even-even nucleus. These amplitudes contain important pairing information relevant to this nuclear process. The overlap of the intermediate states between initial nuclei and final nuclei can be expressed as:

⟨Jkfπ∣Jkiπ⟩=∑pn(XpnJπkfXpnJπki−YpnJπkfYpnJπki)×(up(f)up(i)+vp(f)vp(i))(un(f)un(i)+vn(f)vn(i))×⟨BCSf∣BCSi⟩,(18)\begin{aligned} \langle J_{k_f}^\pi|J_{k_i}^\pi\rangle=\sum_{pn}\left(X_{pn}^{J^\pi k_f}X_{pn}^{J^\pi k_i}-Y_{pn}^{J^\pi k_f}Y_{pn}^{J^\pi k_i}\right) \\ &\times\left(u_p^{(f)}u_p^{(i)}+v_p^{(f)}v_p^{(i)}\right)\left(u_n^{(f)}u_n^{(i)}+v_n^{(f)}v_n^{(i)}\right) \\ &\times\langle BCS_f|BCS_i\rangle, \tag*{(18)} \end{aligned}

where ⟨BCSf∣BCSi⟩\langle BCS_f|BCS_i\rangle is the overlap factor between initial and final BCS vacua, which is usually set to unity.

RESULTS AND DISCUSSION

gpairpg_{pair}^{p}gpairng_{pair}^{n}gpairpg_{pair}^{p}gpairng_{pair}^{n}⟨gpair⟩\langle g_{pair}\ranglegppT=1g_{pp}^{T=1}gppT=0g_{pp}^{T=0}
76Ge{}^{76}\mathrm{Ge}0.840.940.870.970.910.920.59
82Se{}^{82}\mathrm{Se}0.780.940.830.990.890.910.60
96Zr{}^{96}\mathrm{Zr}0.810.660.870.820.790.850.63
100Mo{}^{100}\mathrm{Mo}0.890.810.910.830.860.870.63
116Cd{}^{116}\mathrm{Cd}0.870.810.730.770.800.770.66
128Te{}^{128}\mathrm{Te}0.770.870.810.870.830.860.57
130Te{}^{130}\mathrm{Te}0.740.840.800.870.810.870.58
136Xe{}^{136}\mathrm{Xe}0.690.900.770.800.790.830.53

Table 1. TABLE I. The proton and neutron pairing strength gpairg_{pair} for the initial and final nuclei, as well as their average value ⟨gpair⟩\langle g_{pair}\rangle. The isovector and isoscalar particle-particle parameters gppT=1g_{pp}^{T=1}, gppT=0g_{pp}^{T=0} for the residual interaction.

In this work, we calculate 0νββ0\nu\beta\beta NMEs for eight nuclei 76Ge{}^{76}\mathrm{Ge}, 82Se{}^{82}\mathrm{Se}, 96Zr{}^{96}\mathrm{Zr}, 100Mo{}^{100}\mathrm{Mo}, 116Cd{}^{116}\mathrm{Cd}, 128Te{}^{128}\mathrm{Te}, 130Te{}^{130}\mathrm{Te} and 136Xe{}^{136}\mathrm{Xe}. The single particle levels are obtained from a Coulomb-corrected Woods-Saxon potential. In this work, we adopt a single-particle model space comprising 8 major oscillator shells (N=0–7). This model space is sufficiently large to incorporate all relevant valence orbitals for the nuclei of interest and the contribution from higher oscillator shells (N>7) is basically negligible.

The G-matrix elements obtained from realistic NN potential (CD-Bonn) are employed to pairing interaction in BCS method for ground states and residual interaction in QRPA equation for intermediate states. The BCS model is adopted to account for the residual isovector pairing interactions among nucleons (neutron-neutron and proton-proton). Typically, the strength of the pairing interactions gpairg_{pair} as an overall factor multiplied to the G-matrix elements is adjusted to reproduce the phenomenological pairing gaps from the five-point formula [37] with the experimental masses taken from Ref. [38]. The residual interaction of the particle-particle channel of the QRPA phonon is divided into two parts as mentioned above, isoscalar and isovector parts, with corresponding renormalization factors gppg_{pp}’s. These renormalized parameters are presented in the Table I, where the average value of pairing strength ⟨gpair⟩\langle g_{pair}\rangle are close to the gppT=1g_{pp}^{T=1} as predicted in [8].

In the Table II and III, the 0νββ0\nu\beta\beta-decay NMEs for eight nuclei obtained from our pn-QRPA approach are presented. For each nuclei, NMEs without SRC are tabulated, as well as results with the Argonne-V18 (AV18) and CD-Bonn SRC parametrizations consistently obtained from corresponding nuclear force [35] are presented. In this work, for the sake of comparison with various calculations, the factor gA(0)g_A(0) and gV(0)g_V(0) are both set to be one, of each component such as AA, AP, PP and MM, while the MM components are divided by gA2g_A^2 (gA=1.27g_A = 1.27) when adding to the total GT and Tensor NMEs.

76Ge^{76}\mathrm{Ge}82Se^{82}\mathrm{Se}96Zr^{96}\mathrm{Zr}100Mo^{100}\mathrm{Mo}
AV18cd-Bonnw/oAV18cd-Bonnw/oAV18cd-Bonnw/oAV18cd-Bonnw/o
MFM_F-1.482-1.600-1.522-1.360-1.463-1.390-1.033-1.108-1.057-1.952-2.090-1.994
MGTM_{GT}AA5.5676.1015.8694.8535.3195.1042.4262.7462.6235.0875.6775.433
AP-2.126-2.362-2.342-1.890-2.096-2.075-1.165-1.306-1.299-2.226-2.487-2.468
PP0.7180.8110.8200.6390.7210.7280.4140.4690.4760.7800.8840.895
MM0.8191.0001.0920.7250.8820.9630.4790.5860.6420.8971.0961.200
total4.6675.1695.0244.0514.4914.3531.9712.2722.1984.1974.7534.604
MTM_TAP-0.989-0.986-0.960-0.931-0.928-0.905-0.743-0.742-0.723-1.296-1.293-1.261
PP0.3620.3600.3490.3380.3370.3270.2720.2710.2630.4780.4770.462
MM-0.239-0.239-0.228-0.221-0.221-0.212-0.178-0.178-0.169-0.311-0.311-0.296
total-0.775-0.774-0.752-0.730-0.728-0.709-0.582-0.581-0.564-1.011-1.009-0.982
MωFM_{\omega F}-1.458-1.571-1.499-1.333-1.432-1.365-1.001-1.072-1.025-1.877-2.007-1.921
MωGTM_{\omega GT}AA5.4946.0055.7954.8355.2815.0852.6452.9522.8405.2685.8305.611
AP-2.095-2.327-2.309-1.867-2.070-2.050-1.167-1.305-1.299-2.207-2.462-2.446
PP0.7070.7990.8080.6310.7110.7180.4100.4650.4720.7690.8710.882
MM0.8050.9831.0760.7140.8700.9500.4730.5800.6360.8831.0801.183
ω+\omega_+ total4.6045.0874.9614.0414.4624.3422.1822.4712.4074.3784.9094.781
ω−\omega_- total3.6073.8683.6273.1563.3833.1641.5951.7521.6193.2833.5703.315
MωTM_{\omega T}AP-0.958-0.956-0.931-0.903-0.901-0.878-0.710-0.708-0.689-1.242-1.239-1.208
PP0.3510.3500.3390.3290.3280.3180.2600.2600.2520.4590.4580.444
MM-0.232-0.232-0.221-0.216-0.215-0.206-0.171-0.171-0.164-0.299-0.299-0.286
ω+\omega_+ total-0.752-0.750-0.729-0.708-0.706-0.688-0.555-0.554-0.538-0.969-0.967-0.941
ω−\omega_- total-0.464-0.463-0.455-0.440-0.440-0.432-0.343-0.341-0.336-0.597-0.596-0.587
MqFM_{qF}-0.944-0.971-0.857-0.886-0.910-0.806-0.704-0.722-0.647-1.355-1.387-1.247
MqGTM_{qGT}AA1.4191.4841.3251.2171.2731.1300.4650.5040.4151.1291.2011.030
AP2.8692.9922.7402.5472.6542.4281.4361.5101.3682.8272.9642.692
PP-1.271-1.329-1.226-1.136-1.186-1.094-0.693-0.728-0.670-1.330-1.395-1.284
MM-2.172-2.362-2.256-1.932-2.098-2.001-1.247-1.360-1.301-2.361-2.571-2.456
q+q_+ total4.3644.6114.2373.8264.0423.7051.9812.1301.9194.0914.3653.961
q−q_- total1.6711.6821.4401.4311.4401.2230.4350.4430.3061.1631.1760.915
MqTM_{qT}AA3.5103.5043.4143.3063.3003.2192.5902.5852.5204.3934.3854.273
AP-1.873-1.869-1.799-1.746-1.743-1.680-1.394-1.390-1.340-2.448-2.443-2.355
PP0.5610.5600.5320.5170.5150.4900.4140.4130.3930.7260.7240.689
MM0.2140.2150.2000.1940.1960.1790.1560.1560.1420.2660.2680.247
q+q_+ total2.0652.0622.0221.9561.9511.9191.5131.5111.4852.5062.4992.453
q−q_- total2.3312.3282.2712.1962.1942.1401.7071.7051.6622.8362.8312.760
RGTRGT8.87311.24012.7568.04510.16511.5105.6327.1518.13710.67913.53615.376
RTRT-2.783-2.780-2.646-2.641-2.638-2.514-2.239-2.237-2.131-3.950-3.947-3.762
PP-0.672-0.682-0.630-0.635-0.643-0.598-0.153-0.155-0.1490.3540.3600.329

Table II. TABLE II. 0νββ0\nu\beta\beta-decay NMEs for 76Ge^{76}\mathrm{Ge}, 82Se^{82}\mathrm{Se}, 96Zr^{96}\mathrm{Zr} and 100Mo^{100}\mathrm{Mo} from pn-QRPA calculation. The results are obtained in the model spaces(N=0N=0-7). For each nuclei, there are three kinds of NMEs presented in the table which are only different in the SRC, where AV18 (CD-Bonn) represents the results calculated with the Argonne (Charge-dependent-Bonn) type SRC parametrizations, w/o denotes the results without SRC.

As most calculations, in the light neutrino mass mechanism, the GT parts dominate the NMEs, with the largest contribution coming from the AA components. MFM_F contributes about 1/3 from the naive analysis with Fierz rearrangement and the reduction from MTM_T is about 10-20% as in most QRPA calculations. Different behaviors for these two parts are observed in most Shell Model calculations [21], where smaller MFM_F and negligible MTM_T is observed.

Actually, a lot of QRPA calculations have been done for the light neutrino mass mechanism, from either the QRPA with realistic forces [8, 9] or with the so-called self-consistent calculations based on the Skyrme density functional [11]. Our results are close to those from the realistic force since we are using the same residual interactions, while these results are generally smaller than that of Skyrme DFT, the reason still needs to be investigated though comparative studies.

While the NME differs for different many-body approaches, for different nuclei, the NME also varies. Their difference could be as large as a factor of two. Our calculations shows that 76Ge{}^{76}\mathrm{Ge} has the largest NME, almost twice larger than the smallest one from 136Xe{}^{136}\mathrm{Xe}.

Concerning the ω\omega terms, their differences to the mass terms arise only from the energy denominator (eq. (10)), and since M0νM^{0\nu} is less sensitive to the intermediate states excitation energies than the NME for 2νββ2\nu\beta\beta-decay. As a result, MωFM_{\omega F}, MωGTM_{\omega GT} and MωTM_{\omega T} are quite close to the corresponding terms of the mass terms. The difference for the GTGT part is less than 10% and for the Fermi part is less than 7%, etc.

As observed in LSSM calculations [30], the qq term behaves quite differently as the mass term, as different components contribute differently. In fact, as stated above, that we absorb the factor 1/3 to the definition of MqGTM_{qGT}, in this sense that the q term can be written in an uniform form as sums of the Fermi, GT and Tensor parts like that for the mass and ω\omega terms. The Fermi NME is reduced by 20-50% compared to counterpart in the mass term. Meanwhile, for the GT part, the AA components in q terms are largely hindered by a factor 1/3 as explained above. Unlike the mass term, now AP components are the dominant ingredients for GT part, about twice larger in magnitude than other components. In this sense, earlier calculations [22] with contributions only from AA components may give incomplete estimation over the NMEs for qGT part. The MM component from induced weak magnetic current which emerges as a sub leading order contribution according to Naive Dimension Analysis (NDA) from Chiral effective field theory, is expected to be suppressed. However, as first discovered in LSSM calculations, it appears as leading order contribution with a similar magnitude as AA or AP component, the reason of such enhancement is discussed in [30]. Its contribution to the total NME depends on the type of nuclear current, since there is a sign difference of weak-magnetism current for V-A and V+A currents. So the MM component comes out as an enhancement to cancel the contribution from PP component or as an cancellation to cancel the contribution from AA component. In general, compared to counterparts in mass term, all components besides AA component is getting enhanced in magnitude due to contributions from higher exchange momenta.

However, the most significant difference between the qq term and mass term is from the tensor part. For mass term, the tensor part comes out as a sub-leading order contribution with roughly 10% corrections to the GT part. But for q term, qTqT part could be as important as qGTqGT in QRPA calculations, this is already observed in [22], and now our calculation confirms this with more components included. For qTqT part, AA component dominates the NME, while AP component gives a reduction of about 50% to that of AA. The PP and MM components are smaller, they give a correction about 10%. The overall contributions of qTqT could be as important as qGTqGT.

We also find that mass term and q term are weakly correlated, given that their ratios are nearly nucleus independent, although for different nuclei their individual values are quite different.

For the R term, MRGTM_{RGT} is larger than other parts such as MGTM_{GT} and MqGTM_{qGT} for each nuclei and has the largest value in all LRSM NMEs. The large values of the MRGTM_{RGT} were also reported in the previous QRPA calculations [22] and LSSM calculations [30]. The same situation happens to the RTRT parts, which also have magnitudes that are

116^{116}Cd128^{128}Te130^{130}Te136^{136}Xe
AV18cd-Bonnw/oAV18cd-Bonnw/oAV18cd-Bonnw/oAV18cd-Bonnw/o
MFM_F-1.354-1.427-1.361-1.532-1.651-1.568-1.304-1.408-1.336-0.629-0.681-0.642
MGTM_{GT}AA3.4853.7733.6125.1695.7125.4644.3184.7904.5752.4502.6972.571
AP-1.280-1.408-1.387-2.125-2.365-2.341-1.827-2.035-2.015-1.020-1.130-1.115
PP0.4250.4760.4770.7360.8320.8390.6390.7210.7290.3530.3970.399
MM0.4700.5690.6160.8391.0231.1160.7290.8890.9700.3960.4800.522
total2.9213.1933.0854.3004.8134.6543.5814.0283.8902.0282.2612.179
MTM_TAP-0.528-0.527-0.514-1.309-1.306-1.277-1.180-1.177-1.151-0.586-0.584-0.572
PP0.1950.1940.1890.4640.4630.4500.4180.4170.4060.2060.2050.200
MM-0.125-0.125-0.120-0.293-0.293-0.281-0.264-0.264-0.253-0.129-0.129-0.124
total-0.410-0.410-0.400-1.026-1.025-1.001-0.925-0.924-0.902-0.460-0.459-0.449
MωFM_{\omega F}-1.261-1.329-1.271-1.521-1.635-1.559-1.305-1.404-1.338-0.625-0.674-0.640
MωGTM_{\omega GT}AA3.3843.6593.5155.2115.7325.5064.3944.8494.6522.4312.6672.555
AP-1.246-1.371-1.352-2.103-2.338-2.316-1.813-2.018-1.999-0.996-1.104-1.090
PP0.4140.4640.4660.7260.8200.8280.6310.7130.7200.3440.3870.390
MM0.4580.5550.6030.8271.0071.1000.7200.8770.9580.3860.4680.510
ω+\omega_+ total2.8363.0973.0044.3474.8384.7003.6584.0873.9662.0182.2402.170
ω−\omega_- total2.2682.4082.2563.3223.5893.3362.7663.0002.7791.5401.6601.538
MωTM_{\omega T}AP-0.521-0.520-0.507-1.257-1.254-1.226-1.133-1.130-1.105-0.563-0.561-0.549
PP0.1920.1910.1860.4470.4460.4340.4030.4020.3910.1990.1980.193
MM-0.123-0.123-0.118-0.284-0.283-0.271-0.256-0.256-0.244-0.126-0.125-0.120
ω+\omega_+ total-0.406-0.405-0.394-0.985-0.983-0.960-0.888-0.887-0.865-0.442-0.440-0.431
ω−\omega_- total-0.252-0.252-0.248-0.633-0.632-0.623-0.571-0.569-0.563-0.286-0.285-0.282
MqFM_{qF}-1.051-1.068-0.978-0.968-0.996-0.878-0.808-0.832-0.730-0.373-0.385-0.330
MqGTM_{qGT}AA0.9340.9680.8701.2371.3021.1381.0031.0600.9170.6020.6310.551
AP1.8041.8701.7142.7612.8852.6242.3342.4422.2161.3521.4091.281
PP-0.786-0.817-0.754-1.274-1.333-1.226-1.093-1.144-1.052-0.624-0.651-0.599
MM-1.285-1.389-1.320-2.229-2.422-2.311-1.932-2.100-2.003-1.069-1.158-1.103
q+q_+ total2.7492.8812.6494.1064.3573.9683.4413.6593.3231.9922.1071.916
q−q_- total1.1551.1591.0111.3421.3531.1031.0461.0550.8390.6670.6710.549
MqTM_{qT}AA1.7801.7771.7324.6964.6874.5894.2234.2174.1282.1292.1262.083
AP-1.010-1.008-0.973-2.346-2.342-2.265-2.114-2.110-2.041-1.038-1.035-1.003
PP0.2960.2960.2820.6580.6570.6260.5920.5900.5630.2870.2880.274
MM0.1110.1100.1000.2360.2390.2180.2130.2130.1930.1030.1040.096
q+q_+ total0.9980.9970.9782.8622.8552.8152.5692.5642.5301.3151.3141.294
q−q_- total1.1361.1331.1033.1543.1513.0852.8342.8292.7701.4431.4421.413
RGTRGT5.8167.3038.21810.82213.67515.4889.45911.95313.5375.1836.5267.364
RTRT-1.671-1.669-1.593-4.028-4.024-3.848-3.643-3.640-3.481-1.809-1.807-1.730
PP0.3070.3130.287-0.420-0.427-0.391-0.335-0.341-0.311-0.385-0.390-0.363

Table 3. TABLE III. The same as in Table II but for 116^{116}Cd, 128^{128}Te, 130^{130}Te and 136^{136}Xe.

significantly larger than the corresponding parts of the mass and ω\omega terms.

Finally for the MPM_{P} term, it can be found that they are the smallest terms in magnitude for all LRSM NMEs and their contributions to the decay rates should be negligible. This suppresses the p-wave effect [31] and makes the RR term dominate the η\eta mechanism[30]. The results from current calculation and previous LSSM calculation suggests that we can safely neglect this term and simplify the expression in eq. (2) if the limited accuracy is required.

In the last part, we focus our discussion on the effects of the src on the NMEs. As stated above, the src originates from the strong repulsive core of the nuclear force which alternates the short-range behaviors of various operators

such as the two-body operator for 0νββ0\nu\beta\beta-decay. To understand its effect on NMEs besides these absolute values of NMEs with or without srcs presented in Table.Table II,III, we give explicitly the ratios of NME with different SRC parametrizations to that without any src in Table.Table IV.

76Ge^{76}\mathrm{Ge}82Se^{82}\mathrm{Se}96Zr^{96}\mathrm{Zr}100Mo^{100}\mathrm{Mo}116Cd^{116}\mathrm{Cd}128Te^{128}\mathrm{Te}130Te^{130}\mathrm{Te}136Xe^{136}\mathrm{Xe}
FFAV180.970.980.980.980.990.980.980.98
CD-Bonn1.051.051.051.051.051.051.051.06
GTGTAV180.930.930.900.910.950.920.920.93
CD-Bonn1.031.031.031.031.041.031.041.04
TTAV181.031.031.031.031.031.031.031.03
CD-Bonn1.031.031.031.031.021.021.021.02
ωF\omega FAV180.970.980.980.980.990.980.980.98
CD-Bonn1.051.051.051.041.051.051.051.05
ωGT+\omega GT_{+}AV180.930.930.910.920.940.920.920.93
CD-Bonn1.031.031.031.031.031.031.031.03
ωT+\omega T_{+}AV181.031.031.031.031.031.031.031.03
CD-Bonn1.031.031.031.031.031.021.021.02
ωGT−\omega GT_{-}AV180.991.000.990.991.011.001.001.00
CD-Bonn1.071.071.081.081.071.081.081.08
ωT−\omega T_{-}AV181.021.021.021.021.021.021.021.02
CD-Bonn1.021.021.021.021.021.011.011.01
qFqFAV181.101.101.091.091.071.101.111.13
CD-Bonn1.131.131.121.111.091.131.141.17
qGT+qGT_{+}AV181.031.031.031.031.041.031.041.04
CD-Bonn1.091.091.111.101.091.101.101.10
qT+qT_{+}AV181.021.021.021.021.021.021.021.02
CD-Bonn1.021.021.021.021.021.011.011.02
qGT−qGT_{-}AV181.161.171.421.271.141.221.251.21
CD-Bonn1.171.181.451.291.151.231.261.22
qT−qT_{-}AV181.031.031.031.031.031.021.021.02
CD-Bonn1.031.031.031.031.031.021.021.02
RGTRGTAV180.700.700.690.690.710.700.700.70
CD-Bonn0.880.880.880.880.890.880.880.89
RTRTAV181.051.051.051.051.051.051.051.05
CD-Bonn1.051.051.051.051.051.051.051.04
PPAV181.071.061.031.081.071.071.081.06
CD-Bonn1.081.071.031.091.091.091.101.07

Table IV. The ratios between matrix elements with and without SRC.

Let’s fist focus on the mass term. For MGTM_{GT}, the AV18 SRC reduces the NME by about 4%-9% in magnitude, while the cd-Bonn SRC enhances the NME by about 4%. The deviation between these two src is about 10%, this agrees with other calculations[35]. For MFM_{F}, the deviation due to the different SRC is around 5%-8%, which is little less than the variations observed in MGTM_{GT}. For MTM_{T}, the uncertainties arising from various SRC parametrizations range from 1% to 3%, indicating that the effect of SRC on MTM_{T} is negligible. Similar behaviors are observed for the ω\omega-term, since it is basically the same as mass term. An enhancement of the qq-term are observed for both src parametrizations, the magnitudes are generally around 10% for the Fermi and GT parts, but there are exceptions for the qGT−qGT- part for certain nuclei, this enhancement could go as high as 40%, this is mostly caused by the cancellations among different components. On the other hand, the important tensor part from the qq term seems not affected by the src and the inclusion of src changes the NME by only a few percent. So is the P term, the general effects of src are below 10%.

Finally, we consider the effect of SRC on the R term. While the effect of src on the tensor part is smaller as that on the tensor parts of other terms, drastic reduction is observed for the RGT part, especially for the Argonne src. The effects of src on RGTRGT have the similar but milder effects as the case of heavy neutrino mass mechanism in various literature [8, 10]. While the CD-Bonn src leads to a reduction about 10%, the Argonne src has much wilder effects, a reduction about 30% is observed in our calculations, and also it seems that such reduction is nucleus independent. In order to understand the origin of this large reduction of src on the RGTRGT part, we present the transfer momentum distributions of the matrix elements MRGM_{RG} and MGTM_{GT} in Figure 1, by comparing the results with or without src. One can clearly see that for MGTM_{GT}, the largest contribution comes from the momentum around 100 MeV (mπm_{\pi}), whereas for MRGTM_{RGT}, major contribution is dominated by the region where momentum is around 300 MeV. It is mainly due to an additional q2q^{2} multiplied to the spherical Bessel function j0(qr)j_{0}(qr) in the integrand (8), which enhances the contribution from higher transfer momentum. This implies the importance of short-range contributions for this part of NME, that’s why the src which alters the short-range behavior of various operator plays an important role here. As shown in the Figure 1, there is a notable difference in the results of those with or without src in the region where q>600q > 600 MeV for MRGTM_{RGT}. While the src is not included, we see no contribution to MRGTM_{RGT} from these high momenta, similar is seen for that of GTGT part in mass mechanism. But if the src is included, the behavior for MGTM_{GT} and MRGTM_{RGT} differs greatly, a strong cancellation appears at this high momentum region for the latter. Meanwhile, a cancellation is barely observed for MGTM_{GT}. Therefore, from Figure 1, we find that the reduction from src for MRGTM_{RGT} mainly comes from a drastic distortion of the transition strength distributions as a function of exchange momentum. The magnitude of the changes from the two src’s differs by about 20 percent. Compared to the CD-Bonn src, the AV18 src reduce the strength at low qq peak and enhance the high qq reduction. While for CD-Bonn src, the reduction at high qq overwhelm the enhancement at low qq, this is in contrary to the case of MGTM_{GT}. This emphasizes the importance of correctly describing the short range behaviors of the nuclear force.

Image not extracted

Figure 1. (Color online) The GTGT and RGTRGT part of NMEs for 76Ge^{76}\mathrm{Ge} as a function of momentum transfer qq. ‘AV18’ (‘CD-Bonn’) represents the results obtained with Argonne (CD-Bonn) SRC parametrization and ‘w/o’ represents the results without src included.

CONCLUSION

In this work, the nuclear matrix elements of 0νββ0\nu\beta\beta under LR symmetric model are calculated by the QRPA approach for eight nuclei: 76Ge{}^{76}\mathrm{Ge}, 82Se{}^{82}\mathrm{Se}, 96Zr{}^{96}\mathrm{Zr}, 100Mo{}^{100}\mathrm{Mo}, 116Cd{}^{116}\mathrm{Cd}, 128Te{}^{128}\mathrm{Te}, 130Te{}^{130}\mathrm{Te} and 136Xe{}^{136}\mathrm{Xe}. The weak-magnetism components of the nucleon current are incorporated for NME calculations. We then find that these components in the qq term play an important role, although they are usually considered to be suppressed. This conclusion is consistent with the previous LSSM calculation [30]. The RR term becomes the largest term for all LR symmetric model NMEs, hence their contributions to decay rates is also important. Furthermore, we discuss the effect of different SRC parametrizations on the NME. We find that certain parts of the NME (e.g. MRGTM_{RGT}) are more sensitive to the SRC than other due to a large reduction from high exchange momentum region.

ACKNOWLEDGEMENT

This work is supported by National Key Research and Development Program of China (2021YFA1601300). This work is also supported by Chinese Academy of Sciences Project for Young Scientists in Basic Research (YSBR-099). The numerical calculations in this paper have been carried out on the supercomputing system in the Southern Nuclear Science Computing Center.

References

  1. [1]J. Schechter and J. W. F. Valle, Phys. Rev. D 25, 2951 (1982).
  2. [2]J. Menéndez, J. Phys. G 45, 014003 (2017).
  3. [3]M. M. Neacsu, Phys. Rev. C 93, 024308 (2016).
  4. [4]R. A. Sen’kov and M. Horoi, Phys. Rev. C 88, 064312 (2013).
  5. [5]F. Šimkovic, G. Pantis, J. D. Vergados, and A. Faessler, Phys. Rev. C 60, 055502 (1999).
  6. [6]V. Rodin, A. Faessler, F. Šimkovic, and P. Vogel, Nucl. Phys. A 766, 107 (2006).
  7. [7]M. Kortelainen and J. Suhonen, Phys. Rev. C 76, 024315 (2007).
  8. [8]F. Šimkovic, V. Rodin, A. Faessler, and P. Vogel, Phys. Rev. C 87, 045501 (2013).
  9. [9]J. Hyvärinen and J. Suhonen, Phys. Rev. C 91, 024613 (2015).
  10. [10]D.-L. Fang, A. Faessler, and F. Šimkovic, Phys. Rev. C 97, 045503 (2018).
  11. [11]W.-L. Ly, Y.-F. Niu, D.-L. Fang, J.-M. Yao, C.-L. Bai, and J. Meng, Phys. Rev. C 108, L051304 (2023).
  12. [12]J. Barea, J. Kotila, and F. Iachello, Phys. Rev. C 91, 034304 (2015).
  13. [13]F. F. Deppisch, L. Graf, F. Iachello, and J. Kotila, Phys. Rev. D 102, 095016 (2020).
  14. [14]T. R. Rodríguez and G. Martínez-Pinedo, Phys. Rev. Lett. 105, 252503 (2010).
  15. [15]L. S. Song, J. M. Yao, P. Ring, and J. Meng, Phys. Rev. C 90, 054309 (2014).
  16. [16]L. S. Song, J. M. Yao, P. Ring, and J. Meng, Phys. Rev. C 95, 024305 (2017).
  17. [17]J. M. Yao, L. S. Song, K. Hagino, P. Ring, and J. Meng, Phys. Rev. C 91, 024316 (2015).
  18. [18]J. M. Yao, J. Meng, Y. F. Niu, and P. Ring, Prog. Part. Nucl. Phys. 126, 103965 (2022).
  19. [19]M. Agostini, G. Benato, J. A. Detwiler, J. Menéndez, and F. Šimkovic, Rev. Mod. Phys. 95, 025002 (2023).
  20. [20]J. M. Yao, B. Bally, J. Engel, R. Wirth, T. R. Rodríguez, and H. Hergert, Phys. Rev. Lett. 124, 232501 (2020).
  21. [21]E. Caurier, F. Nowacki, A. Poves, and J. Retamosa, Phys. Rev. Lett. 77, 1954 (1996).
  22. [22]K. Muto, E. Bender, and H. V. Klapdor, Z. Phys. A 334, 187 (1989).
  23. [23]G. Pantis, F. Šimkovic, J. D. Vergados, and A. Faessler, Phys. Rev. C 53, 695 (1996).
  24. [24]J. Suhonen and O. Civitarese, Phys. Rep. 300, 123 (1998).
  25. [25]T. Tomoda, Rep. Prog. Phys. 54, 53 (1991).
  26. [26]S. Sarkar, Y. Iwata, and P. K. Raina, Phys. Rev. C 102, 034317 (2020).
  27. [27]Y. Iwata and S. Sarkar, Front. Astron. Space Sci. 8, 727880 (2021).
  28. [28]F. Šimkovic, D. Štefánik, and R. Dvornický, Front. Phys. 5, 57 (2017).
  29. [29]D. Štefánik, R. Dvornický, F. Šimkovic, and P. Vogel, Phys. Rev. C 92, 055502 (2015).
  30. [30]D.-L. Fang, B. A. Brown, and F. Šimkovic, Phys. Rev. C 110, 045502 (2024).
  31. [31]M. Doi, T. Kotani, and E. Takasugi, Prog. Theor. Phys. Suppl. 83, 1 (1985).
  32. [32]L.-z. Xing, Phys. Rev. D 85, 013008 (2012).
  33. [33]M. Kortelainen, O. Civitarese, J. Suhonen, and J. Toivanen, Phys. Lett. B 647, 128 (2007).
  34. [34]G. A. Miller and J. E. Spencer, Ann. Phys. 100, 562 (1976).
  35. [35]F. Šimkovic, A. Faessler, H. Müther, V. Rodin, and M. Stauf, Phys. Rev. C 79, 055501 (2009).
  36. [36]V. Rodin and A. Faessler, Phys. Rev. C 84, 014322 (2011).
  37. [37]M. Bender, K. Rutz, P. G. Reinhard, and J. A. Maruhn, Eur. Phys. J. A 8, 59 (2000).
  38. [38]M. Wang, W. Huang, F. Kondev, G. Audi, and S. Naimi, Chin. Phys. C 45, 030003 (2021).

Paper details

vlnc:W_th4fkxea
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 0

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Physics and Astronomy

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents