betaFeedback

WorksPhysics and Astronomy

Neutron scattering sum rules, symmetric exchanges, and helicoidal magnetism in MnSb2_2O6_6

Abstract

MnSb2_{2}O6_{6} is based on the noncentrosymmetric P321P321 space group with magnetic Mn2+^{2+} (S=5/2S={5/2}, L≈0L\approx 0) spins ordering below TN=12T_{\mathrm{N}}=12 K in a helicoidal structure. The ground state magnetic structure, expected to be built and originate from 7 Heisenberg exchange constants, has been shown to be coupled to the underlying crystallographic chirality with polar domain switching being reported. We apply neutron spectroscopy to extract these symmetric exchange constants. Given the high complexity of the magnetic exchange network, crystallographic structure and complications fitting linear spin-wave models, we take advantage of multiplexed neutron instrumentation to use the first moment sum rule of neutron scattering to estimate the 7 exchange constants. We then use these parameters to calculate the low-energy spin-waves in the Néel state to reproduce the neutron response without strong antisymmetric coupling. Using Green's response functions, the stability of long-wavelength excitations in the context of proposed magnetic structures is then discussed. The results show the presence of strong exchange constants for the chiral exchange pathways and illustrate an underlying coupling between crystallographic and magnetic ``chirality" through predominantely symmetric exchange.

Introduction

Magnetic materials that lack an inversion center potentially host coupled magnetic and ferroelectric order parameters while also providing a framework for unusual magnetic excitations like directionally anisotropic (or nonreciprocal) spin-waves.{sup}1,2 Such materials often consist of magnetic ions in a low-symmetry environment with a complex set of magnetic interactions causing the coupling between structural (e.g. ferroelectricity) and magnetic orders.{sup}3–7 Determining these magnetic interactions that provide the basis for coupled structural and magnetic properties is often complicated and based on many parameter fits from complex magnetic ground states.{sup}8,9 In this paper we investigate the magnetic excitations in powder and in an array of single crystals of the helicoidal magnet MnSb$_2$O$_6$ with the goal of extracting the symmetric exchange constants. Given the complexity of the excitation spectrum, the number of predicted exchange constants, and ambiguities of the magnetic structure (tilted versus untilted ground state), we apply a first moment sum rule{sup}20 analysis to extract the symmetric exchange constants and compare the results to the excitation spectrum from mean field linear spin-wave theory.

This approach only depends on the relative orientation of neighboring magnetic moments and does not depend on whether the overall magnetic structure is tilted or untilted as discussed below. We also demonstrate a generalized methodology for obtaining symmetric Heisenberg exchange constants from multiplexed neutron scattering where extensive regions of momentum and energy transfers are sampled.

Iron-langasite (Ba3_3NbFe3_3Si2_2O14_{14})[10, 11, 12, 13] and MnSb2_2O6_6[14, 15, 16, 17, 18] are two examples of magnetic compounds that are based on the noncentrosymmetric P321P321 (#150) space group. The magnetic order in these compounds is different with iron-langasite being described by a simple helix that can be quantified by a time-even pseudoscalar.[15] The magnetic structure in MnSb2_2O6_6, in contrast was first found cycloidal and quantified by a time-even polar vector.[15, 18] Given the fact that magnetic Mn2+^{2+} (S=5/2S = 5/2, L≈0L \approx0) is not expected to have an orbital degeneracy that would enhance any anisotropy in the magnetic Hamiltonian,[19] like antisymmetric terms, it is expected that such terms are small compared to symmetric exchange terms in the magnetic Hamiltonian. Furthermore, diagonal symmetric exchange interactions are coupled to the chirality of the underlying lattice.

The nuclear structure of MnSb2_2O6_6, based on interlaying MnO6_6 and SbO6_6 octahedra is shown in Figure 1(a). The only magnetic ions Mn2+^{2+} arrange in a triangular motif. Magnetic interactions occur in these isolated MnO6_6 octahedra through super-super-exchange (SSE) pathways (Mn-O-O-Mn). In particular, chiral SSE pathways along the cc-axis, shown in Figure 1(b)-(Figure 1c), define the structural chirality of the compound.

Nuclear and magnetic structures of MnSb2O6

Figure 1. (a) Nuclear structure of lattice-chiral MnSb2_2O6_6. The structural chirality can be defined as the helical winding of the Mn-O-O-Mn super-super-exchange pathway with respect to the cc-axis: it is clockwise for left-handed structure (b), and anti-clockwise for right-handed structure (c). Figures made on VESTA.[21] (d) Cycloidal magnetic structure with magnetic parameters ηC\eta_C and ηT\eta_T describing sense of rotations of the spins. (e) Tilted magnetic structure where the spin rotation plane is tilted from the cc-axis by an angle θ\theta. Our previous diffraction work found no evidence of this tilted magnetic structure over the cycloidal one, we discuss this below in the context of a model with symmetric-only exchange constants. Figures made on MAG2POL.[22]

Below TN≈12T_N \approx12 K, the magnetic ground state was found to follow a cycloidal order with a propagation vector k=(0,0,0.182)\boldsymbol{k} = (0, 0, 0.182).[15] Within each triangle of Mn in the (abab)-plane, shown in dashed gray lines in Figure 1(d), the moments are dephased by 120°. The sense of rotation of the spins along the cc-axis and within a basal triangle can be described by magnetic parameters ηC\eta_C and ηT\eta_T, often called magnetic “chiralities”, which directly couple to the crystal chirality σ\sigma through an energy invariant.[18] Later on, the cycloids were reported to be tilted away from the cc-axis, with one of the main axes of the spin envelop parallel to [11ˉ0][1\bar{1}0], as shown in Figure 1(e). This ground state was presented to be necessary to explain the electric polarization measured by pyroelectric current in the (abab)-plane in Ref. 16. The magnetic structure was further investigated by complementary neutron diffraction techniques in Ref. 18, showing no evidence of this tilted magnetic ground state. Furthermore, a mechanism based on the coupled structural and magnetic chiralities is proposed for the ferroelectric switching, which does not require a tilted cycloid ground state.

The magnetic interactions are described by a dominant Heisenberg Hamiltonian H^=∑ijJijS^i⋅S^j\hat{H} = \sum_{ij} J_{ij}\hat{S}_i \cdot\hat{S}_j with the symmetric exchange constants corresponding to the seven SSE pathways in MnSb2_2O6_6.[15] The nearest neighbor exchange paths are shown in Figure 2, where the oxygen

Drawing of the seven nearest neighbors interactions in MnSb2O6

Figure 2. Drawing of the seven nearest neighbors interactions in MnSb2_2O6_6. (a) Intraplane interactions J1J_1 connecting triangles of Mn centered at the lattice origin, and J2J_2 connecting between these triangles. (b) Interplane interactions based on the J1J_1 triangle, J4J_4 is the straight interplane interaction, while J3J_3 and J5J_5 are diagonal chiral interactions. (c) Interplane interactions based on the J2J_2 triangle, with J6J_6 and J7J_7 as chiral exchange interactions. Oxygen atoms are hidden here for clarity. Figure made on MaG2Pol.[22]

atoms are omitted for clarity. Each manganese and antimony atom is surrounded by six oxygen atoms forming edge-sharing octahedra. In a minimalist model considering only interactions between neighboring Mn2+^{2+} ions, there are therefore 7 exchange constants which need to be considered. Intraplane interactions are shown in Figure 2(a) where J1J_1 connects a triangle of MnO6_6 octahedra through a SbO6_6 octahedra centered at the origin, and J2J_2 connects MnO6_6 octahedra between these triangles, through an interplane SbO6_6 octahedron shown in Figure 2(c). Interplane interactions within a Mn triangle connected by J1J_1 are shown in Figure 2(b), where J4J_4 is the straight interplane exchange interaction, and J3J_3 and J5J_5 are diagonal exchange interactions. Similarly, Figure 2(c) shows J6J_6 and J7J_7, the diagonal exchange interactions connecting a Mn triangle linked by J2J_2. Interestingly, J3J_3 and J6J_6 are related to the right-handed helical winding of the Mn-O-O-Mn SSE pathways (shown in Figure 1(c) for J3J_3), while J5J_5 and J7J_7 are related to left-handed SSE pathways (shown in Figure 1(b) for J5J_5). Thus, these chiral exchange paths are interchanged by inversion symmetry between structurally left- and right-handed crystals.[15] We note that only the five first exchange constants were necessary to describe the SSE interactions in iron-langasite, due to structural differences with MnSb2_2O6_6. Indeed, in Ba3_3NbFe3_3Si2_2O14_{14}, the bond distance d2=5.652d_2 = 5.652 Å associated with intertriangle interaction J2J_2 is significantly larger than the bond distance d1=3.692d_1 = 3.692 Å tied to intratriangle interaction J1J_1.[13] On the contrary, in MnSb2_2O6_6, d2=4.845d_2 = 4.845 Å is smaller than d1=5.596d_1 = 5.596 Å, as a result the related interplane interactions J6J_6 and J7J_7 are expected to be more significant as they link magnetic Mn2+^{2+} ions through SSE pathways.

In this paper, we present our inelastic neutron scattering data from both powder and single crystals of MnSb2_2O6_6. We apply the first moment (Hohenberg-Brinkman) sum rule of neutron scattering to extract the exchange constants from the Heisenberg model, therefore characterizing the magnetic Hamiltonian. Then, we apply Green’s functions on a rotating frame to generate spin-wave spectra based on our derived exchange constants. Using the values of the symmetric exchange constants from sum rules of neutron scattering, we refine the parameters to obtain a good description of the neutron inelastic spectra. Based on the Green’s functions neutron response, the stability of spin-wave excitations is further tested for the proposed magnetic structures.

Experimental details

Materials preparation

Materials preparation followed the procedure outlined in Ref. 23. Powders of MnSb2_2O6_6 were prepared by mixing stoichiometric amounts of pure MnCO3_3 and Sb2_2O3_3. After mixing through grinding, the powder was pressed into a pellet and heated up to 1000°C with the process repeated with intermediate grinding. It was found that heating the pellet to higher temperatures introduced the impurity Mn2_2Sb2_2O7_7. Single crystals of MnSb2_2O6_6 were prepared using the flux method. Starting ratios for single-crystal growth were (by weight) 73% of flux V2_2O5_5, 20% of polycrystalline MnSb2_2O6_6 and 7% of B2_2O3_3. The powder was ground and pressed into a pellet and flame sealed in a quartz ampoule under vacuum (less than 10−410^{-4} Torr). B2_2O3_3 was used to lower the melting tempera-

ture of the V2_2O5_5 flux. Back filling the ampoules with ≈ 200 mTorr of Argon gas was found to noticeably improve crystal sizes. Quartz ampoules were then heated to 1000°C at a rate of 60°C/hour and soaked at this temperature for 24 hours. The furnace was then cooled to 700°C at a rate of 2°C/hour and held for 24 hours, before it was switched off and allowed to cool to room temperature. Crystal sizes in the range from a few millimeters to nearly a centimeter were obtained through this procedure.

Neutron spectroscopy

To investigate the magnetic dynamics, neutron spectroscopy was performed on the MACS (NIST, Gaithersburg) triple-axis spectrometer[24] on both single crystals and powder samples. 1.3 g of single crystals were aligned in the (HHL)(HHL) scattering plane on both sides of four aluminium plates and coated with viscous hydrogen free Fomblin oil, as shown in Figure 3. A select fraction of the crystals were aligned with Laue diffraction and the remainder were aligned using polarized optical microscopy based on the crystal morphology. These single crystals were synthesized the same way as the samples measured in our previous studies in Ref. 18, where we have performed Schwinger scattering and transmission polarized optical microscopy and found only a small imbalance of chiral structural domains in the single crystals. This small imbalance distinguishes MnSb2_2O6_6 from the enantiopure single crystals of iron based langasite previously studied.[10, 12, 22] During the coalignment of the single crystals used here for spectroscopy, great care was taken to align the relative aa and bb inplane axes, the choice of what constituted ±[001]\pm[001] was done at random. For the purposes here we consider the average crystal structure to be an equal mixture of the differing chiral domains. We will show in § 3 D that our analysis holds no matter the proportion of chiral structural domains. To probe the dynamics in our array of single crystals, the final energy was fixed to either Ef=2.4E_{\mathrm{f}}=2.4 meV or 3.73.7 meV with BeO and Be filters, respectively, being used on the scattered side to filter out higher order neutrons from the monochromator. For all results presented here the pyrolytic graphite PG(002) monochromator was focused both horizontally and vertically. The lattice parameters were measured to be a=b=8.733a=b=8.733 Å and c=4.697c=4.697 Å. For powder measurements, a 16.3 g sample was used with Ef=3.7E_{\mathrm{f}}=3.7 meV and a BeO filter on the scattered side.

Single crystals of MnSb2O6 aligned on four Al plates

Figure 3. 1.3 g of single crystals of MnSb2_2O6_6 aligned on four Al plates, and coated with Fomblin oil for inelastic neutron scattering.

Results and Discussion

In this section, we will first present the neutron scattering data for both powders and single crystals of MnSb2_2O6_6, before detailing our absolute normalization process. Then, zeroth and first moment sum rules are applied to our inelastic data allowing the extraction of the symmetric exchange constants. We will finally use Green’s functions on a rotating frame to compare the resulting spin-wave spectra to the experimental ones and to test the stability of proposed magnetic structures.

Excitation spectra

Total excitation spectra

The excitation spectra of both powders and single crystals of MnSb2_2O6_6 at T=1.4T=1.4 K are shown in Figure 4, with the Ef=3.7E_{\mathrm{f}}=3.7 meV MACS setup. The powder data in Figure 4(a) display intense low energy magnetic scattering extending from the elastic line to ∼1\sim1 meV, and a weaker band of excitations at approximately twice this value at ∼2\sim2 meV. The single crystal data displayed in Figure 4(b)-(Figure 4c) illustrate two different types of scattering: one with intense dispersive fluctuations that are well defined both in momentum and energy at low energies, and the other with a weaker momentum and energy broadened continuum of scattering extending to larger energy transfers. This continuum of scattering is most apparent at the zone boundaries in the single crystal data. Given the kinematics of these two types of scattering, we associate the lower energy dispersive fluctuations with one-magnon scattering and the higher energy continuum with two-magnon scattering. While two-magnon scattering is expected to be most prominent in S=1/2S = 1/2 magnets[25, 26, 27, 28, 29, 30, 31, 32, 33], it is a direct result of the uncertainty associated with non-commuting observables and has been studied extensively in other large-SS magnets[34, 35, 36]. We discuss this cross section later in the paper in the context of the zeroth moment sum rule and show indeed that these two components of scattering originate from single and multi magnon processes.

Inelastic neutron scattering spectra

Figure 4. (a) Powder averaged inelastic neutron scattering spectrum taken on MACS at T=1.4T=1.4 K. (b)-(c) Single crystal inelastic neutron scattering spectrum from the Ef=3.7E_{\mathrm{f}}=3.7 meV dataset at T=1.4T=1.4 K. The logarithmic intensity scales are chosen to show the two components to the scattering and in particular the higher energy weak scattering displayed at ∼2\sim2 meV.

Powder low-energy spectrum

Results of the low-energy powder inelastic neutron scattering experiment performed on MACS, with fixed final energy Ef=3.7E_f = 3.7 meV are shown in Figure 5. The powder averaged spin-wave dispersion at T=1.4T = 1.4 K, below the Néel magnetic ordering transition, is presented in Figure 5(a), showing low-energy spin dynamics below E≈1.4E \approx1.4 meV. These dynamics are highly dispersive from the magnetic ordering wavevector and are gapless within experimental resolution (ΔE≈0.15\Delta E \approx0.15 meV). In contrast, above TN≈12T_\mathrm{N} \approx12 K, the magnetic scattering is considerably broadened both in momentum and energy indicative of spatially and temporally short-range correlations. This paramagnetic scattering is very strong due to high spin S=5/2S = 5/2 of Mn2+^{2+} magnetic ions, as shown in Figure 5(b) with the spectrum measured at T=25T = 25 K. Both experimental datasets below and above the magnetic ordering temperature also display a decay in intensity with increasing momentum transfer, characteristic of magnetic scattering. The powder averaged spectra establish the presence of dispersive magnetic dynamics and the energy scale of the spin excitations.

Powder inelastic neutron scattering spectrum of the one-magnon cross section

Figure 5. Powder inelastic neutron scattering spectrum of the one-magnon cross section at (a) T=1.4T = 1.4 K (below TNT_\mathrm{N}) and (b) T=25T = 25 K (above TNT_\mathrm{N}).

Single crystal low-energy spectrum

Results of single crystal inelastic neutron scattering performed on MACS with a fixed final energy Ef=2.4E_f = 2.4 meV are displayed in Figure 6 and Figure 7 at T=1.4T = 1.4 K below TNT_\mathrm{N}. The data are illustrative of dispersive dynamics originating from the magnetic ordering wavevector. Constant energy slices at E=0.1E = 0.1 meV and E=1.25E = 1.25 meV are shown in Figure 6(a) and (b). Spin-wave dispersion along (−1,−1,L)(-1,-1,L) and (H,H,0)(H,H,0) are respectively shown in Figure 7(a) and Figure 7(b). Spin-wave branches emerging from nuclear Bragg peak (−1,−1,0)(-1,-1,0) and also its magnetic satellites (−1,−1,0)±k(-1,-1,0)\pm\mathbf{k} are visible in Figure 6(a) and Figure 7(a). Within the instrumental resolution (ΔE≈0.1\Delta E \approx0.1 meV), all modes seem gapless, which is consistent with the low anisotropy measured from electron spin resonance[17], and observed from the tunability of the magnetic structure by small magnetic fields[16, 18].

MACS single crystal inelastic neutron scattering spectra: constant energy slices

Figure 6. MACS single crystal inelastic neutron scattering spectra at T=1.4T = 1.4 K: constant energy slices for (a) E=0.1E = 0.1 meV and (b) E=1.25E = 1.25 meV. The weak scattering in (a) at (H,H)∼−0.5(H,H) \sim-0.5 and displaced at (H,H)∼−1.1(H,H) \sim-1.1 originate from some crystals miss-aligned by ∼60∘\sim60^\circ in the multi crystal mount.

MACS single crystal inelastic neutron scattering spectra: spin-wave dispersion

Figure 7. MACS single crystal inelastic neutron scattering spectra at T=1.4T = 1.4 K: spin-wave dispersion along (a) (−1,−1,L)(-1,-1,L) and (b) (H,H,0)(H,H,0).

As already presented in Figure 4(b,Figure 4c), inelastic neutron scattering data were also obtained on MACS with the same array of single crystals, but with a fixed final energy Ef=3.7E_f = 3.7 meV. In the following of the paper, the dataset used for each analysis will be mentioned.

Absolute normalization of magnetic cross section

In order to straightly compare the magnetic scattering intensities from the different datasets, they have to be converted into absolute units. This is particularly important given our goal of applying sum rules of neutron scattering to obtain the magnetic exchange constants in absolute units of energy. Through this we will apply the zeroth moment sum rule to demonstrate that all of the magnetic spectral weight is measured in the experiments discussed above. We then apply the first moment sum rule to obtain the symmetric exchange constants. In this section, we describe our normalization process, adapted from Ref. 37 and Ref. 38 and introduce our definition for the dynamical structure factor S(Q,E)S(Q,E).

The intensity measured during the experiment I(Q,E)I(Q,E) (in counts) is related to the differential cross section via a convolution with an instrumental-dependent resolution function RR:

I(Q,E)=∫dQ0 dE0 d2σdΩ dEf(Q0,E0)R(Q0,E0,Q,E)(1)I(Q,E) = \int\mathrm{d}Q_0\,\mathrm{d}E_0\,\frac{\mathrm{d}^2\sigma}{\mathrm{d}\Omega\,\mathrm{d}E_f}(Q_0,E_0)R(Q_0,E_0,Q,E) \tag*{(1)}

By assuming a slow variation of this resolution function in the region of study (over the narrow energy range probed in this study), it can be approximated by a constant R0R_0, which allows us to decouple the intensity into:

I(Q,E)≈R0d2σdΩ dEf(Q0,E0)(2)I(Q,E) \approx R_0\frac{\mathrm{d}^2\sigma}{\mathrm{d}\Omega\,\mathrm{d}E_f}(Q_0,E_0) \tag*{(2)}

During the data reduction, the intensity is normalized to the monitor counts based on a low efficiency detector placed in the incident beam after the monochromator and

before the sample. The efficiency of which is inversely dependent to the speed of the incident neutrons, which is proportional to kik_i, giving the normalized intensity (in counts/mon):

Iˉ(Q,E)=kiI(Q,E)=kiR0d2σdΩ dEf(Q,E)(3)\bar{I}(Q,E) = k_i I(Q,E) = k_i R_0\frac{\mathrm{d}^2\sigma}{\mathrm{d}\Omega\,\mathrm{d}E_f}(Q,E) \tag*{(3)}

Having related the measured scattering intensity to the cross section, we now focus on the magnetic differential cross section for unpolarized neutrons and identical magnetic ions. Assuming isotropic spin excitations, we can define the dynamic structure factor S(Q,E)=Sxx=Syy=SzzS(Q,E) = S^{xx} = S^{yy} = S^{zz}, where SαβS^{\alpha\beta} is the dynamic spin correlation function related to the Fourier transform of the spin-spin correlation function. Neglecting the Debye-Waller factor gives the following double differential cross section:

d2σdΩ dEf(Q,E)=Nkfki(γr02)2(g∣f(Q)∣)22S(Q,E)(4)\frac{\mathrm{d}^2\sigma}{\mathrm{d}\Omega\,\mathrm{d}E_f}(Q,E) = N\frac{k_f}{k_i}\left(\frac{\gamma r_0}{2}\right)^2 (g|f(Q)|)^2 2S(Q,E) \tag*{(4)}

where NN is the number of unit cells, γr0/2≈0.2695×10−12\gamma r_0/2 \approx0.2695 \times10^{-12} cm is the typical magnetic scattering length, gg is the Landé factor and f(Q)f(Q) the magnetic form factor. Combining Eq. (3) and Eq. (4) we get the dynamical structure factor (in meV−1^{-1}) from the measured intensity by:

S(Q,E)=Iˉ(Q,E)∣gf(Q)∣2(γr02)22NkfR0(5)S(\mathbf{Q},E)=\frac{\bar{I}(\mathbf{Q},E)}{|g f(\mathbf{Q})|^2\left(\frac{\gamma r_0}{2}\right)^2 2N k_f R_0} \tag*{(5)}

we can write directly the numerical values of the magnetic cross section (γr0/2)2(\gamma r_0/2)^2 into the equation:

S(Q,E)=13.8 b−1Iˉ(Q,E)∣gf(Q)∣22NkfR0(6)S(\mathbf{Q},E)=\frac{13.8\ \mathrm{b}^{-1}\bar{I}(\mathbf{Q},E)}{|g f(\mathbf{Q})|^2 2N k_f R_0} \tag*{(6)}

The key for normalizing the magnetic intensity is thus to evaluate this instrumental-dependent factor NkfR0N k_f R_0 expressed in (meV)(counts/mon)(b−1)(\mathrm{meV})(\mathrm{counts}/\mathrm{mon})(\mathrm{b}^{-1}).

There are several ways reported in the literature for obtaining this instrument calibration factor. One possibility is to evaluate the incoherent scattering from the elastic line of a known standard compound (for example as done in Ref. 39). By energy integrating the measured intensity close to elastic energy transfer, far from any magnetic or nuclear Bragg peak, we obtain, as ki=kfk_i=k_f for elastic scattering:

∫−ϵ+ϵdE Iˉ(Q,E)=NkfR0∑i(biinc)2(7)\int_{-\epsilon}^{+\epsilon} \mathrm{d}E\,\bar{I}(\mathbf{Q},E)=N k_f R_0\sum_i\left(b_i^{\mathrm{inc}}\right)^2 \tag*{(7)}

where biincb_i^{\mathrm{inc}} is the incoherent scattering length of atom ii, and the sum is over the unit cell. Vanadium having a large incoherent scattering cross section compared to its coherent one, it is usually used as a standard sample to normalize inelastic neutron scattering data. We have measured the Vanadium sample in the same geometry and instrumental configuration as our MnSb2_2O6_6 powder sample. With NVN_{\mathrm{V}} the number of Vanadium atoms and its incoherent scattering length bVinc=6.35 fmb_{\mathrm{V}}^{\mathrm{inc}}=6.35\,\mathrm{fm}^{40}, we can write:

NVkfR0=∫−ϵ+ϵdE IˉV(Q,E)(bVinc)2(8)N_{\mathrm{V}}k_fR_0=\frac{\int_{-\epsilon}^{+\epsilon}\mathrm{d}E\,\bar{I}_{\mathrm{V}}(\mathbf{Q},E)}{\left(b_{\mathrm{V}}^{\mathrm{inc}}\right)^2} \tag*{(8)}

By writing NV=mV/(Ar(V)mu)N_{\mathrm{V}}=m_{\mathrm{V}}/(A_{\mathrm{r}}(V)m_{\mathrm{u}}) with mVm_{\mathrm{V}} the mass of the Vanadium sample, Ar(V)A_{\mathrm{r}}(V) the relative atomic mass of Vanadium, and mum_{\mathrm{u}} the atomic mass constant, we can write the ratio N/NV=m/Ar(MnSb2O6)cellmV/Ar(V)N/N_{\mathrm{V}}=\frac{m/A_{\mathrm{r}}(\mathrm{MnSb}_2\mathrm{O}_6)_{\mathrm{cell}}}{m_{\mathrm{V}}/A_{\mathrm{r}}(V)} with mm the mass of the MnSb2_2O6_6 sample, and Ar(MnSb2O6)cellA_{\mathrm{r}}(\mathrm{MnSb}_2\mathrm{O}_6)_{\mathrm{cell}} the relative mass of a unit cell (three formula units of MnSb2_2O6_6 per unit cell), the normalization factor becomes:

NkfR0=m/Ar(MnSb2O6)cellmV/Ar(V)∫−ϵ+ϵdE IˉV(Q,E)0.403 b(9)N k_fR_0=\frac{m/A_{\mathrm{r}}(\mathrm{MnSb}_2\mathrm{O}_6)_{\mathrm{cell}}}{m_{\mathrm{V}}/A_{\mathrm{r}}(V)} \frac{\int_{-\epsilon}^{+\epsilon}\mathrm{d}E\,\bar{I}_{\mathrm{V}}(\mathbf{Q},E)}{0.403\,\mathrm{b}} \tag*{(9)}

This equation allows us to obtain the instrumental calibration factor from the incoherent cross section centered at the elastic (E=0E=0) position.

at the elastic (E=0E=0) position. We note that an alternate way to obtain this calibration constant is to measure the elastic incoherent cross section from the sample given Manganese has a comparatively large incoherent cross section. We did not take this approach in this experiment as we found the elastic line where incoherent scattering is present in our single crystal geometry was contaminated by scattering from hydrogen free (yet fluorine based) Fomblin oil. Fomblin, while having a comparatively small incoherent cross section in comparison to hydrogen, has a non-negligible coherent liquid-like cross section. This cross section is difficult to disentangle from the purely Mn2+^{2+} incoherent cross section and therefore we relied on a separate Vanadium standard of known mass.

Total moment sum rule

Having established the procedure for calibration of the instrument, we now discuss the sum rules of neutron scattering. Magnetic neutron scattering is governed by sum rules which are satisfied by integrating the dynamical spin correlation function Sαβ(Q,E)S^{\alpha\beta}(\mathbf{Q},E) over energy and momentum transfer.^{20} In particular the energy moments, ∫−∞+∞EnSαβ(Q,E) dE\int_{-\infty}^{+\infty}E^nS^{\alpha\beta}(\mathbf{Q},E)\,\mathrm{d}E are given theoretically,^{20,41,42} with n=0,1n=0,1 the zeroth and first moment.

The zeroth moment sum rule is often referred to as the total moment sum rule and corresponds to the integral of all the magnetic spectral weights:^{37,43–45}

3∫d3Q∫dE S(Q,E)∫d3Q=NmS(S+1)(10)\frac{3\int\mathrm{d}^3Q\int\mathrm{d}E\,S(\mathbf{Q},E)}{\int\mathrm{d}^3Q}=N_mS(S+1) \tag*{(10)}

where Nm=3N_m=3 is the number of magnetic ions per unit cell. This quantity can be considered as a conservation rule and allows us to confirm whether we have experimentally measured all of the spectral weight. This rule has become particularly important in itinerant compounds near potential critical points.^{46} We will apply this zeroth moment sum rule to our powder data, which was normalized using a vanadium standard sample, following the process described above. In this case, the total moment can be written as:

I=∫dQ Q2∫dE S(Q,E)∫dQ Q2=S(S+1)(11)I=\frac{\int\mathrm{d}Q\,Q^2\int\mathrm{d}E\,S(Q,E)}{\int\mathrm{d}Q\,Q^2}=S(S+1) \tag*{(11)}

with Q=∣Q∣Q=|\mathbf{Q}|. In order to estimate the spectral contributions from one-magnon and two-magnon scattering, we can introduce the momentum integrated intensity:

I~(E)=3∫dQ Q2S(Q,E)∫dQ Q2(12)\widetilde{I}(E)=\frac{3\int\mathrm{d}Q\,Q^2S(Q,E)}{\int\mathrm{d}Q\,Q^2} \tag*{(12)}

which measures the magnetic density of states.[44, 45] Then the integral ∫Emin⁡Emax⁡dE I~(E)\int_{E_{\min}}^{E_{\max}} \mathrm{d}E\,\tilde{I}(E) gives the spectral weight for the energy interval [Emin⁡,Emax⁡][E_{\min}, E_{\max}]. Figure 8 shows the momentum integrated intensities as a function of the energy. As discussed above, the magnetic intensity consists of two components with a low-energy component which consists of harmonic excitations well defined in momentum and energy and a second considerably weaker component which is broadened in momentum and energy transfer. These correspond to single [Figure 8(a)] and two-magnon [Figure 8(b)] dynamics and are separated in the powder averaged data. We can see that the one- and two-magnon contributions crossover around 1.6 meV (red dashed line), but since the intensities are quite low at this energy we consider 1.6 meV as the upper bound of the one-magnon scattering, and 0.3 meV as its lower bound (blue dashed line).

Momentum integrated intensities

Figure 8. Momentum integrated intensities as a function of the energy, for (a) E∈[0,1.9]E \in[0, 1.9] meV, and (b) E∈[1.3,4]E \in[1.3, 4] meV. The intensities are integrated between the dashed blue (0.4 meV) and red (1.6 meV) lines to get the one-magnon spectral weight I1I_1, and above the red lines to 4 meV to get the two-magnon spectral weight I2I_2.

To extract numerical values for the integrated zeroth moments from our powder data we average the data in momentum. Accounting from the momentum powder average, the QQ-dependence of the integrated intensity is given by:[43, 47]

L(Qmax⁡)=∫0Qmax⁡dQ Q2∫dE S(Q,E)∫0Qmax⁡dQ Q2(13)\mathcal{L}(Q_{\max}) = \frac{\int_{0}^{Q_{\max}} \mathrm{d}Q\,Q^{2}\int\mathrm{d}E\,S(Q,E)}{\int_{0}^{Q_{\max}} \mathrm{d}Q\,Q^{2}} \tag*{(13)}

and is shown in Figure 9 for both (a) one-magnon and (b) two-magnon contributions discussed above. The momentum average in this plot allows us to account for limited kinematic coverage of the detectors at low momentum transfers (see low momentum transfers in Figure 5). From Figure 9, we can see that L(Qmax⁡)\mathcal{L}(Q_{\max}) approximately fully saturates close to 2 Å−1^{-1} thereby illustrating that approximately all of the spectral weight has been sampled.

Integrated intensities as a function of $Q_{\max}$ for one-magnon and two-magnon scattering

Figure 9. Integrated intensities as a function of Qmax⁡Q_{\max} the momentum integration upper bound, for (a) one-magnon and (b) two-magnon scattering. The dashed lines indicate the final values for Qmax⁡=2.05Q_{\max}=2.05 Å.

Based on this momentum average of the powder data, the spectral weight I1=2.7(2)I_1 = 2.7(2) for one-magnon scattering is then calculated by integrating the intensity between 0.3 meV [dashed blue line in Figure 8(a)], and 1.6 meV (dashed red line in Figure 8). The two-magnon spectral weight is obtained by integrating between 1.6 and 4 meV, leading to I2=0.17(1)I_2 = 0.17(1).

The elastic (static) scattering contribution to the total moment is ⟨Sz⟩2\langle S_z\rangle^2 where zz indicates the direction of the Mn2+^{2+} spin in the rotated local frame. From our neutron powder diffraction (previously outlined in Ref. 18) the ordered moment is g⟨Sz⟩=4.6 μBg\langle S_z\rangle= 4.6\,\mu_{\mathrm{B}} at 2.6 K leading to ⟨Sz⟩2=5.3\langle S_z\rangle^2 = 5.3, and a spin reduction from the expected full saturated moment corresponding to S=5/2S=5/2 of ΔS=S−⟨Sz⟩=0.2\Delta S = S-\langle S_z\rangle= 0.2. This missing component from the experimental ⟨Sz⟩\langle S_z\rangle by conservation of spectral weight is expected to reside in the multimagnon component of the neutron dynamics corresponding to longitudinal fluctuations.

Based on this elastic spectral weight, the theoretical total, one-magnon, and two-magnon contributions can be computed.[35, 48] They are compared with those obtained experimentally in Table I. The experimental total moment is 8.2(2)8.2(2), which is to be compared to the expected value of 8.75 for S=5/2S=5/2. The discrepancies can be due to the relatively small QQ-range measured during this experiment and experimental systematic issues such as the use of an external Vanadium standard or small variations in the resolution function over the energy range probed here. Given the small energy and momentum ranges, and that we have integrated the intensity over all momentum and energy, we do not expect that changes in the resolution to be important. However, the results are in good agreement illustrating the relative weights of one- and two-magnon cross sections and the energy range over which the magnetic dynamics are present in MnSb2_2O6_6. This also confirms our assignment of the higher energy component to longitudinal two-magnon scattering and also illustrates all of the spectral weight is sampled in the dynamic range of our experiments.

TheoryExperiment
TotalS(S+1)=8.75S(S+1)=8.758.2(2)8.2(2)
Elastic⟨Sz⟩2=5.3\langle S_z\rangle^2=5.3
One-magnon(S−ΔS)(1+2ΔS)=3.2(S-\Delta S)(1+2\Delta S)=3.22.7(2)2.7(2)
Two-magnonΔS(ΔS+1)=0.2\Delta S(\Delta S+1)=0.20.17(1)0.17(1)

Table I. Contributions of the different components of the scattering for S=5/2S=5/2 and ΔS=0.2\Delta S=0.2 deduced from neutron powder diffraction.

First moment sum rule

The previous discussion of the zeroth moment sum rule has established several points relevant for the rest of the paper. First, we established the energy range of the magnetic dynamics in MnSb2_2O6_6. Second, we have established the relative spectral weights of the single and two-magnon cross sections and found these to be in good agreement with missing spectral weight observed in diffraction experiments. Third, we have established and verified a calibration procedure for the powder data.

Theory

In this section, we discuss the first moment sum rule and how it can be applied to extract symmetric exchange constants. The first moment is defined for general dynamic spin correlation function Sαβ(Q,E)S^{\alpha\beta}(\mathbf{Q},E) as:

⟨E⟩(Q)≡∫−∞∞dE E Sαβ(Q,E)=∫−∞∞dE ⟨[S^α(Q,E),H^]S^β(−Q,0)⟩=⟨[S^α(Q),H^]S^β(−Q)⟩(14)\langle E\rangle(\mathbf{Q}) \equiv\int_{-\infty}^{\infty} \mathrm{d}E\,E\,S^{\alpha\beta}(\mathbf{Q},E) = \int_{-\infty}^{\infty} \mathrm{d}E\,\langle[\hat{S}^{\alpha}(\mathbf{Q},E),\hat{H}]\hat{S}^{\beta}(-\mathbf{Q},0)\rangle = \langle[\hat{S}^{\alpha}(\mathbf{Q}),\hat{H}]\hat{S}^{\beta}(-\mathbf{Q})\rangle \tag*{(14)}

For nuclear scattering from a monotonic system, this reduces to ℏ2Q22M\frac{\hbar^2 Q^2}{2M}, where MM is the mass of the scattering nucleus.[49, 50] For magnetic systems and in the case for symmetric-only exchange where the Hamiltonian has the form H^=∑i,jJijS^i⋅S^j\hat{H}=\sum_{i,j}J_{ij}\hat{S}_i\cdot\hat{S}_j, the Hohenberg-Brinkman first moment sum rule is given by:[20, 37, 43, 44, 45]

⟨E⟩(Q)=∫dE E S(Q,E)=−23∑i,jnijJij⟨S^i⋅S^j⟩[1−cos⁡(Q⋅dij)](15)\langle E\rangle(\mathbf{Q}) = \int\mathrm{d}E\,E\,S(\mathbf{Q},E) = -\frac{2}{3}\sum_{i,j}n_{ij}J_{ij}\langle\hat{S}_i\cdot\hat{S}_j\rangle[1-\cos(\mathbf{Q}\cdot\mathbf{d}_{ij})] \tag*{(15)}

where ⟨S^i⋅S^j⟩\langle\hat{S}_i\cdot\hat{S}_j\rangle is the ground-state equal-time correlation function of spins S^i\hat{S}_i and S^j\hat{S}_j at sites ii and jj, nijn_{ij} is the multiplicity of JijJ_{ij}, the exchange constant associated to the bond vector dij\mathbf{d}_{ij}. This equation assumes symmetric-only exchange as we anticipate is dominant for 3d magnetic transition metal ions in the absence of spin-orbit coupling. Anisotropic terms in the magnetic Hamiltonian appear as constants to this equation for the first moment, however, given the lack of an orbital degree of freedom in Mn2+^{2+} in an octahedra, we expect such terms to be small in comparison to the symmetric Heisenberg exchange and therefore neglect them here.

Knowing the nuclear and magnetic structure of a compound gives the bond vectors dij\mathbf{d}_{ij} and the correlators ⟨S^i⋅S^j⟩\langle\hat{S}_i\cdot\hat{S}_j\rangle. Then, measuring the first moment for different Q\mathbf{Q} values allows to fit the exchange constants, which correspond to the amplitudes of the sinusoidal oscillations. We note that Eqn. 15 only depends on the relative orientation of neighboring spins which has been modelled previously using neutron diffraction. For the following, in terms of notation, the spin S(S+1)S(S+1) will be included in the exchange constants instead of the correlators and the exchange constants are in units of meV.

In MnSb2_2O6_6, 7 nearest neighbors exchange interactions are considered and expected to be relevant, as shown in Figure 2, related to a total of 30 Mn-Mn bonds per unit cell. The first thing to evaluate is the ground-state correlation functions ⟨S^i⋅S^j⟩\langle\hat{S}_i\cdot\hat{S}_j\rangle for each of the bonds. The magnetic ground state of MnSb2_2O6_6 is unclear, rather reported as a pure cycloid in Ref. 15 or tilted from the cc-axis in Ref. 16. But in both cases, the spin structure is helicoidal with the spins co-rotating in the same plane.[18] Thus, the scalar product can be simply evaluated by cos⁡Δθij\cos\Delta\theta_{ij}, with Δθij\Delta\theta_{ij}, the angle difference between the spins in the same rotation plane. The exchange interactions are listed in tbl:2 with their associated multiplicities, bond distances, and ground-state correlators, with k=0.182k=0.182 the propagation vector component along the cc-axis. We emphasize that this method only depends on relative orientation of neighboring spins and not on details for the tilted and non tilted helicoidal structures. Indeed, the ⟨S^i⋅S^j⟩\langle\hat{S}_i\cdot\hat{S}_j\rangle correlators are the same in both models. Therefore, this method allows us an independent means of measuring the exchange constants without details of the long-range magnetic structure that is relevant for spin-wave calculations. We discuss this point later in the context of stability of the long-wavelength excitations once we have

JiJ_inin_idid_i (Å)Δθij\Delta\theta_{ij}cij=⟨S^i⋅S^j⟩=cos⁡Δθijc_{ij}=\langle\hat{S}_i\cdot\hat{S}_j\rangle=\cos\Delta\theta_{ij}
J1J_13d1=5.5961d_1=5.5961
J2J_26d2=4.8445d_2=4.84452π/32\pi/3c1=−0.5c_1=-0.5
J3J_33di=7.3235d_i=7.32352π(k+ϵT/3)2\pi(k+\epsilon_T/3)cR=−0.995c_R=-0.995
J4J_43d4=4.7241d_4=4.72412πk2\pi kc4=0.414c_4=0.414
J5J_53di=7.3235d_i=7.32352π(k−ϵT/3)2\pi(k-\epsilon_T/3)cL=0.58c_L=0.58
J6J_66de=6.7666d_e=6.76662π(k+ϵT/3)2\pi(k+\epsilon_T/3)cR=−0.995c_R=-0.995
J7J_762π(k−ϵT/3)2\pi(k-\epsilon_T/3)cL=0.58c_L=0.58

caption: TABLE II. Summary of the exchange interactions JiJ_i, with their multiplicity in the unit cell nin_i, the related bond distance did_i, the spin angle difference Δθij\Delta\theta_{ij} and the associated ground-state correlation functions cijc_{ij}. Subindices i and e refer to the diagonal bond distances internal and external to the triangle of Mn interconnected by J1J_1. Subindices L and R refer to left- and right-handed correlation functions.

:::

obtained the exchange constants from the first moment analysis.

Furthermore, we note that the correlators for diagonal paths actually depend on the sense of rotations of the spins, and thus on the magnetic parameters ηC\eta_C and ηT\eta_T. From the energy invariant, these magnetic parameters are related to the structural chirality by σ=ηCηT\sigma=\eta_C\eta_T. Thus the correlators for the diagonal exchange paths are cos⁡(2π(ηCk±ηT/3))=cos⁡(2π(k±σ/3))\cos(2\pi(\eta_C k\pm\eta_T/3))=\cos(2\pi(k\pm\sigma/3)) for left- J5J_5, J7J_7 (+) and right-handed J3J_3, J6J_6 (−) exchange interactions. The diagonal exchange interactions are interchanged by inversion symmetry, which corresponds to an inversion of σ\sigma. Thus, ground-state correlators are invariant for a given exchange constant. Thus the analysis holds independently of the structural and magnetic domains populations. This is convenient as a mixture of structural and magnetic domains was previously measured in a single crystal of MnSb2_2O6_6.[18]

For a fixed scattering vector Q\mathbf{Q}, the cosine frequency will only depend on the bond distances. We can therefore define the parameters γ\gamma associated to each of the five distinct bond lengths, which are functions of the exchange constants and ground-state correlation functions:

γ1=J1c1γ2=J2c1γ4=J4c4γi=J3cR+J5cLγe=J6cR+J7cL(16)\begin{aligned} \gamma_1&=J_1c_1\\ \gamma_2&=J_2c_1\\ \gamma_4&=J_4c_4\\ \gamma_i&=J_3c_R+J_5c_L\\ \gamma_e&=J_6c_R+J_7c_L \tag*{(16)} \end{aligned}

where the cic_i are calculated from the co-rotating helicoidal magnetic structure[18] and displayed in Table II.

Single-crystal data

Having discussed the equations and theory for the first moment sum rule applied to MnSb2_2O6_6, we now apply this to our single crystal sample aligned in the (HHL)(HHL) scattering plane. We can simplify the calculation of the first moment by fixing H=H0H=H_0 and varying LL (LL-scan), or fixing L=L0L=L_0 and varying HH (HH-scan). This leads to two different analyses. The LL-scan analysis will be detailed in the following section, while the HH-scan analysis is presented in Appendix A2.

The data is extracted along an LL-scan, considering Q=(H0,H0,L)\mathbf{Q}=(H_0,H_0,L) with LL varying and a given H0H_0. In the following we will consider the Ef=2.4E_f=2.4 meV dataset, as an example, we take H0=0.2H_0=0.2. The spin-wave dispersion along (0.2,0.2,L)(0.2,0.2,L) is shown in Figure 10. For each interaction indexed by spins ii and jj, the corresponding term in the first moment cosine from Eq. (15) can be written as:

MACS single crystal inelastic neutron scattering spectrum

Figure 10. MACS single crystal inelastic neutron scattering spectrum: spin-wave dispersion along (0.2,0.2,L)(0.2,0.2,L). The red dashed lines indicate constant-Q\mathbf{Q} scans shown in Figure 11(a)-(c).

Q⋅dij=2πH0(dij,x+dij,y)+2πLdij,z(17)\mathbf{Q}\cdot\mathbf{d}_{ij}=2\pi H_0(d_{ij,x}+d_{ij,y})+2\pi Ld_{ij,z} \tag*{(17)}

where the distances dijd_{ij} are expressed in lattice units, and the scattering vector in reciprocal lattice units. Using trigonometric identities to expand the cosine term, and summing Eq. (15) over the 30 bonds in the unit cell, a general formula for the first moment is derived, for a fixed H0H_0:

⟨E⟩(H0,L)=A(H0)cos⁡(2πL)+C(H0)(18)\langle E\rangle(H_0,L)=A(H_0)\cos(2\pi L)+C(H_0) \tag*{(18)}

where AA and CC are two H0H_0-dependent functions of the γ\gamma parameters, given by:

A(H0)=23[(1+2c(H0))γi+3γ4+2Σc(H0)γe](19)A(H_0)=\frac{2}{3}\left[(1+2c(H_0))\gamma_i+3\gamma_4+2\Sigma_c(H_0)\gamma_e\right] \tag*{(19)}
C(H0)=−23[2(1−c(H0))γ1+…(20)C(H_0)=-\frac{2}{3}\left[2(1-c(H_0))\gamma_1+\ldots \right. \tag*{(20)}
2(3−Σc(H0))γ2+3γi+3γ4+6γe]2(3-\Sigma_c(H_0))\gamma_2+3\gamma_i+3\gamma_4+6\gamma_e]

where,

c(H0)=cos⁡(2πH0δ1)c(H_0)=\cos(2\pi H_0\delta_1)
Σc(H0)=cos⁡(2πH0δ2)+…\Sigma_c(H_0)=\cos(2\pi H_0\delta_2)+\ldots
cos⁡(2πH0δ3)+cos⁡(2πH0δ4)\cos(2\pi H_0\delta_3)+\cos(2\pi H_0\delta_4)

are H0H_0-dependent harmonic oscillations, and

δ1=3(1−rx)δ2=1δ3=2−3rxδ4=3rx−1\begin{aligned} \delta_1 &= 3(1-r_x) \\ \delta_2 &= 1 \\ \delta_3 &= 2-3r_x \\ \delta_4 &= 3r_x-1 \end{aligned}

are Mn-Mn interatomic distances (in r.l.u.) projected in the (ab)(ab)-plane. rx=0.6329r_x=0.6329 is the aa-axis coordinate of the Mn atom at Wyckoff site 3e, taken from the single crystal neutron diffraction refinement at T=2T=2 K in Ref. 18.

From Eq. (18), for a specific H0H_0, we can compute the first moment as a function of LL, and fit the coefficients A(H0)A(H_0) and C(H0)C(H_0) for a scan along (H0,H0,L)(H_0,H_0,L). The next step is to repeat the same process for several H0H_0, and fit the γ\gamma parameters in coefficients AA and CC with Eq. (19) and Eq. (20).

Examples of calculations of the first moment for different LL, for Q=(0.2,0.2,L)\mathbf{Q}=(0.2,0.2,L) are shown in Figure 11(a)–(c).

Six panels showing constant-$Q$ scans and first moment as a function of $L$

Figure 11. (a)–(c) Constant-QQ scans for different Q=(0.2,0.2,L)\mathbf{Q}=(0.2,0.2,L), indicated with dashed red lines in Figure 10. A fit to a double gaussian is shown in red, and the first moment is calculated from trapezoidal integration where the background is removed from the gaussian fit. (d) First moment as a function of LL for H0=0.2H_0=0.2, fitted to its theoretical expression (red curve). The red data points corresponds to the first moments calculated in the cuts plotted in (a)–(c). (e)–(f) First moment as a function of LL for (e) H0=−0.4H_0=-0.4 and (f) H0=−0.8H_0=-0.8, fitted to theoretical expression in red.

These constant-QQ scans are indicated in red dashed lines in Figure 10. Most of the S(Q,E)S(Q,E) are well fitted by two gaussians, shown in red in the figures, but to take into account any deviation from a two-mode spectrum, the numerical integration of the first moment from Eq. (15) was performed using a trapezoidal integration, with the background removed from these two-gaussian fits. The calculation is performed above 0.2 meV to get rid of any contribution from elastic scattering, and below 1.6 meV to only capture contribution from one-magnon scattering. This criterion is arbitrary, and low-energy scattering can be miscalculated. Actually, due to Eq. (15), lowest energy points contribute less to the first moment (given a low magnetic intensity at low energy), so the differences are not significant within uncertainties. More information concerning the numerical integration and the differences between the methods of integration are given in Appendix A 1.

These first moments are calculated for a range of LL, as shown in Figure 11(d) where first moments computed in Figure 11(a)-(Figure 11c) are highlighted in red. For this specific H0=0.2H_0 = 0.2, the AA and CC parameters are obtained from the fit (red curve) to Eq. (15). The H0H_0-dependence of AA and CC is then obtained by repeating the same procedure for different H0H_0, as illustrated in Figure 11(e)-(Figure 11f) for H0=−0.4H_0 = -0.4 and H0=−0.8H_0 = -0.8.

Finally, a total of 969 first moments ⟨E⟩(Q)\langle E\rangle(Q) were calculated from the MACS Ef=2.4E_{\mathrm{f}} = 2.4 meV dataset for this analysis and are shown as a function of the fitted first moment in Figure 12(a). Finally the γ\gamma parameters are obtained by fitting AA and CC to Eq. (19) and Eq. (20) as shown in Figure 12(b)-(Figure 12c), where the red data points are the coefficients calculated in Figure 11(d)-(Figure 11f). We note from Eq. (18) that some remaining background can be included in the computation of CC, as well as small contributions from anisotropic terms in the magnetic Hamiltonian, as discussed above. For this reason, the H0H_0-independent part of Eq. (20) is not fitted to get the parameters γ4\gamma_4, γi\gamma_i and γe\gamma_e, which are rather fitted with Eq. (19), where AA represents the amplitude of the first moment cosine variation.

Measured and fitted first moments, and fitted coefficients

Figure 12. (a) Measured first moments versus fitted first moments for LL-scan analysis, for the Ef=2.4E_{\mathrm{f}} = 2.4 meV dataset. A total of 969 ⟨E⟩(Q)\langle E\rangle(Q) were taken into account. (b)-(c) Fitting of coefficients (b) AA and (c) CC giving the γ\gamma parameters. The red data points show the values calculated in Figure 11(d)-(Figure 11f).

A similar analysis can be performed by considering a fixed L0L_0 and varying along HH and is detailed in Appendix A 2, giving another set of fitted γ\gamma parameters. Then, these two analyses were performed again with the second single crystal dataset, with Ef=3.7E_{\mathrm{f}} = 3.7 meV, giving two other sets of γ\gamma parameters. This is detailed in Appendix A 3. These fitted γ\gamma parameters are shown in Figure 13, where they have been normalized to γe\gamma_e obtained from the LL-scan analysis for each dataset, in order to get rid of any scale issue coming from the absolute normalization process and to directly compare the fitted parameters. We discuss below how we obtain the overall scaling factor to obtain units of meV.

Fitted parameters for the different analysis and dataset, normalized to $\gamma_{\mathrm{e}}$

Figure 13. Fitted parameters for the different analysis and dataset, normalized to γe\gamma_{\mathrm{e}} obtained in the LL-scan analysis from the Ef=2.4E_{\mathrm{f}} = 2.4 meV dataset. Mean values (green bars) are calculated averaging over the four analysis.

Powder data

As described in § 3 A 2, powder inelastic neutron scattering was also performed on MACS and first moment sum rule can also be applied to these data.

For polycrystalline samples, the intensity measured is related to the powder averaged S(∣Q∣,E)S(|\mathbf{Q}|,E) = ∫dΩQS(Q,E)/4π\int\mathrm{d}\Omega_Q S(Q,E)/4\pi of the dynamic structure factor. This gives the powder averaged first moment sum rule:[43, 45]

⟨E⟩(∣Q∣)=∫dE ES(∣Q∣,E)=−23∑i,jnijJij⟨S^i⋅S^j⟩{1−sin⁡(∣Q∣∣dij∣)∣Q∣∣dij∣}(21)\begin{aligned} \langle E\rangle(|Q|) &= \int\mathrm{d}E\, E S(|Q|,E) \\ &= -\frac{2}{3}\sum_{i,j} n_{ij}J_{ij}\langle\hat{S}_i\cdot\hat{S}_j\rangle\left\{1-\frac{\sin(|Q||d_{ij}|)}{|Q||d_{ij}|}\right\} \tag*{(21)} \end{aligned}

As for the single crystal analysis, for a fixed Q=∣Q∣Q=|Q|, the sine frequency only depends on the bond lengths, which are the same for diagonal exchange paths as listed in Table II, resulting in five distinct bond distances. We can further simplify the first moment by summing over these distinct bond distances:

⟨E⟩(Q)=−23∑iniγi{1−sin⁡(Q∣di∣)Q∣di∣}(22)\langle E\rangle(Q)=-\frac{2}{3}\sum_i n_i\gamma_i\left\{1-\frac{\sin(Q|d_i|)}{Q|d_i|}\right\} \tag*{(22)}

where i∈[1,5]i\in[1,5] is related to the ii-th bond length and the γi\gamma_i are defined in Eq. (16). Due to the very close bond distances (especially d2=4.8445d_2=4.8445 Å and d4=4.7241d_4=4.7241 Å), and the relatively small QQ-range probed in the experiment (from 0.30.3 to 2.052.05 Å−1^{-1}), we were not able to conveniently fit the γ\gamma parameters, because of high correlations in the fitting process. However, we can compare the first moment extracted from the powder inelastic neutron scattering with the theoretical one calculated using the γ\gamma parameters obtained from the single crystal analysis described above.

The first step for extracting the first moment from the experimental data is to define the region of integration for the energy. For the powder, the first moment was integrated for E∈[0.3,1.6]E\in[0.3,1.6] meV to get rid of the elastic and two-magnon scattering. This is justified by the spectral weight calculated in the total moment sum rule analysis described in § 3 C. Due to gapless modes in the one-magnon spectrum, around 0.80.8 Å−1^{-1} and 1.41.4 Å−1^{-1}, as shown in Figure 5(a), the contribution from elastic scattering and one-magnon can be mixed. However, this mixture happens at low energies and low intensities, so that deviations from the actual first moment are small. As for the single crystal analysis, the data were integrated numerically using a trapezoid integration, and the background was removed by fitting with two gaussians. The theoretical γ\gamma parameters calculated from the single crystal first moment sum rule analysis were rescaled to match the scale of the first moment observed in the powder experiment, as we know the powder data have been fairly normalized as it captures all the magnetic spectral weight as detailed in § 3 C. The magnetic form factor is also taken into account during this rescaling process. The theoretical first moment calculated from the γ\gamma parameters obtained from the single crystal sum rules analysis is shown in red in Figure 14, and matches well the first moment computed from the powder experiment. The contribution from each exchange constant associated to their bond distance is shown in thin lines (normalized to the powder computed first moment). From this, we can see how the contributions from J2J_2 and J4J_4 to the first moment are close, which makes the fit difficult within this small wavevector range probed during this experiment.

First moment computed from powder data and calculated contributions

Figure 14. (data points) First moment computed from the powder data, as a function of the scattering vector amplitude. (red thick curve) First moment calculated from the γ\gamma parameters fitted in the single crystal first moment sum rule analysis. (thin curves) Contributions to the first moment from the different exchange paths, normalized to the powder computed first moment.

Determination of exchange constants

In the first moment sum rules analysis, we have used the five γ\gamma parameters which are related to the seven exchange constants. γ1\gamma_1, γ2\gamma_2 and γ4\gamma_4 are uniquely related to J1J_1, J2J_2 and J4J_4, and can be deduced from Eqs. (16a–c), leaving J3J_3, J5J_5, J6J_6 and J7J_7. γi\gamma_i and γe\gamma_e are related in Eqs. (16d) and (16e) to these four chiral exchange constants. Considering the energy minimization using the experimental propagation vector from diffraction,[18] these four unknown exchange constants can be written into three linearly independent equations:

tan⁡2πk=3J3−J5+2(J6−J7)J3+J5+2(J6+J7−J4)γi=J3cR+J5cLγe=J6cR+J7cL(23)\begin{aligned} \tan2\pi k &= \sqrt{3}\frac{J_3-J_5+2(J_6-J_7)}{J_3+J_5+2(J_6+J_7-J_4)} \\ \gamma_i &= J_3 c_{\mathrm{R}}+J_5 c_{\mathrm{L}} \\ \gamma_e &= J_6 c_{\mathrm{R}}+J_7 c_{\mathrm{L}} \tag*{(23)} \end{aligned}

This analysis presents an ambiguity given the presence of three equations and four unknown exchange constants.

This ambiguity is intrinsic originating from many of the exchange parameters corresponding to the same bond distances which is the the basis of the first moment sum rule analysis discussed above. In particular, the exchange constants J3J_3 (J6J_6) and J5J_5 (J7J_7) correspond to the same bond distance and only differ by the SSE pathway defined by the crystal chirality. We therefore need further information to close this set of equations and seek this through a comparison between calculated and measured single crystal excitation spectra, focusing on the overall bandwidth and excitations near the zone boundary.

By calculating the excitation spectra using linear spin-wave theory software SpinW[51] with an simulated instrumental resolution ΔE≈0.1 meV\Delta E \approx0.1\,\mathrm{meV}, we can see that the upper magnon branch along (H,H,0)(H,H,0) is largely affected by a change of the J3J_3 exchange parameter. We note that the calculation was done assuming an untilted structure [cycloidal ground state shown in Figure 1(d)], however, the scattering near the top of the single magnon branch was found not to be sensitive to the tilting of the magnetic moments. Analyzing the scattering near the top of the single magnon branch near the magnetic zone boundary therefore provides an independent means of fixing J3J_3. The experimental spectrum from MACS Ef=2.4 meVE_f = 2.4\,\mathrm{meV} dataset is shown in Figure 15(a), and compared to calculated spectra for different values of J3J_3 in Figure 15(b)–Figure 15(d), where we can observe a significant change of the position and structure of the upper mode. In particular, tuning J3J_3 affects the maximum energy of the one-magnon band and also the splitting of multiple bands at the maximum energy of the single magnon bands observed in the HH-scans. Given our experimental data [Figure 15(a)] and to close off the set of Eqns. (23), we assume no observable splitting of bands in the HH-scans and a maximum single-magnon energy excitation given by experiment. These two observations fix both the absolute value of J3J_3 and also an overall scaling factor taking the data to absolute units of meV. For these calculations, J5J_5, J6J_6 and J7J_7 are obtained by fixing J3J_3 in Eq. (23) resulting in a system of three equations and three unknowns with γi\gamma_i and γe\gamma_e the mean values obtained in the single crystal sum rules analysis shown in Figure 13. We have chosen to fix J3J_3 as it has the lesser influence on the ordering wavevector which is seen by partially differentiating Eq. (23). Finally, the exchange constants obtained by fixing J3J_3 with the best agreement are listed in Table III. The uncertainty associated to J3J_3 is an estimation based on the instrumental resolution of how far from J3=0.25 meVJ_3 = 0.25\,\mathrm{meV} we can observe the band splitting. From this estimated error, and the least-square refinement of γi\gamma_i and γe\gamma_e, we subsequently compute the uncertainties associated to J5,6,7J_{5,6,7}. The obtained exchange constants are compared with the values calculated from DFT from Ref. 15. First we can see that the interactions are overall lower in energy than expected from the DFT calculations. Then, the left-handed interactions J3J_3 and J6J_6 are dominant in comparison to right-handed J5J_5 and J7J_7, as expected to impose the structural chirality of MnSb2_2O6_6.

Spin-wave dispersion along $(H,H,0)$ for MACS single crystal inelastic neutron scattering and linear spin-wave theory calculations

Figure 15. Spin-wave dispersion along (H,H,0)(H,H,0) for: (a) MACS single crystal inelastic neutron scattering spectrum. (b)-(d) Inelastic neutron scattering spectrum calculated from linear spin-wave theory by fixing different J3J_3 values. The other parameters for these calculations are listed in Table V.

J1J_1J2J_2J3J_3J4J_4J5J_5J6J_6J7J_7
DFT[15]0.771.472.21.160.41.940.4
Sum rules0.10(4)0.29(2)0.25(2)0.35(5)0.07(8)0.97(3)0.03(5)
Refined0.100.290.250.250.070.97−0.023

Table III. Symmetric JJ exchange constants obtained by DFT calculations[15] and the mean values from the four single crystal sum rules analyses (normalized to γe\gamma_e and then rescaled to experimental data, in meV, note that all values of JJ in the table are multiplied by S(S+1)S(S+1) with S=5/2S=5/2). The refined parameters using Green’s function approach are highlighted in red.

From mean field theory, the Curie-Weiss temperature can be estimated by summing the exchange constants over the nearest neighbors of a Mn2+\mathrm{Mn}^{2+} ion.[52]

ΘCW=−S(S+1)3kB[2(J1+J3+J4+J5)+4(J2+J6+J7)](24)\Theta_{\mathrm{CW}}=-\frac{S(S+1)}{3k_{\mathrm{B}}}\left[2(J_1+J_3+J_4+J_5)+4(J_2+J_6+J_7)\right] \tag*{(24)}

We note that this equation is not linearly independent from the system in Eq. (23), and thus cannot be used to uniquely determine the four chiral exchange constants J3J_3, J5J_5, J6J_6, and J7J_7. Furthermore, the Curie-Weiss temperature obtained from magnetic susceptibility on MnSb2O6\mathrm{MnSb}_2\mathrm{O}_6 powder, ΘCW=−19.6\Theta_{\mathrm{CW}}=-19.6 K in Ref. [15] and ΘCW=−23\Theta_{\mathrm{CW} }=-23 K in Ref. [17] have a difference ΔT=3.4\Delta T=3.4 K corresponding to an energy difference of ΔE≈0.3\Delta E\approx0.3 meV, which is significant given the low energy scale of the exchange constants in MnSb2O6\mathrm{MnSb}_2\mathrm{O}_6 (see Table II). This variation in experimentally reported results is justifiable given the choice of the linear regime when fitting mean-field Curie Weiss law and reflects the experimental uncertainty. For these reasons, we have not used the experimental Curie-Weiss temperatures as a hard constraint for the exchange constants. On the contrary, we can compute afterwards ΘCW=−26(1)\Theta_{\mathrm{CW}}=-26(1) K, which reasonably agrees with the measured ones, given the experimental variations.

Comparison to spin-wave theory

In the previous sections we have applied the first moment sum rule to extract the complex series of Heisenberg exchange constants in MnSb2O6\mathrm{MnSb}_2\mathrm{O}_6. In this section we compare these results to a mean-field linear spin-wave theory to compare results and also to test for stability of the ground state magnetic structure. We use the Green’s function formalism for this. While this technique for calculating magnetic excitations is more versatile in cases where the low-energy response is determined by a series of single-ion states (such as the case in rare-earths or in the presence of spin-orbit coupling like in, for example, Co2+^{2+} [53] or V3+^{3+} [54] based compounds), it is also useful to test for stability of harmonic long-wavelength magnetic excitations with changes in the local magnetic environment. In this section we first briefly outline the use of the Green’s function technique and then we apply it to calculate the spin excitation spectrum, comparing sum rule results presented above to experiment, then refining results. We then test stability of the proposed magnetic structure and interactions based on the series of exchange constants extracted with the first moment sum rule and refined values. In particular, we discuss the stability of long-wavelength magnetic fluctuations for tilted helicoidal structures.

Green’s functions on a rotating frame

The basic technique for applying the Green’s function approach has been outlined in several previous papers by us. The application of the technique to collinear systems CoO,[53] in the presence of spin-orbit coupling with Co2+^{2+} (S=32S = \frac{3}{2}, leff=1l_{\mathrm{eff}}=1) ions, and CaFe2_2O4_4,[55] based on a spin-only ground state of Fe3+^{3+} (S=52S = \frac{5}{2}) ions. We then recently extended this methodology to the noncollinear magnetic structure of RbFe2+^{2+}Fe3+^{3+}F6_6 which involved coupled spin-only Fe3+^{3+} (S=52S = \frac{5}{2}) and orbitally degenerate Fe2+^{2+} (S=2S = 2, leff=1l_{\mathrm{eff}}=1) ions. In terms of MnSb2_2O6_6 where only a spin-degree of freedom exists (Mn2+^{2+} with S=52S = \frac{5}{2}), we quote only the key results here and refer the reader to Ref. [56] for further details. The methodology here is to use the Green’s functions results from the collinear cases and transform to a local rotating frame of reference for use in incommensurate magnets like MnSb2_2O6_6.

The neutron scattering cross section is proportional to the dynamical structure factor S(Q,ω)S(\mathbf{Q},\omega) which is related to the Green’s response function, G(Q,ω)G(\mathbf{Q},\omega) via the fluctuation-dissipation theorem.

S(Q,ω)=−1π[n(ω)+1]Im⁡G(Q,ω)(25)S(\mathbf{Q},\omega)=-\frac{1}{\pi}[n(\omega)+1]\operatorname{Im}G(\mathbf{Q},\omega) \tag*{(25)}

where n(ω)n(\omega) is the Bose factor. The Green’s function, in the laboratory frame, is defined here as

Gγ~γ~′αβ(i,j′,t)=−iΘ(t)⟨[S^iγ~α(t),S^j′γ~′β(0)]⟩.G_{\tilde{\gamma}\tilde{\gamma}^{\prime}}^{\alpha\beta}(i,j^{\prime},t)=-i\Theta(t)\langle[\hat{S}_{i\tilde{\gamma}}^{\alpha}(t),\hat{S}_{j^{\prime}\tilde{\gamma}^{\prime}}^{\beta}(0)]\rangle.

The three sets of indices in this definition of the Green’s function and used throughout the remaining discussion in this paper are summarized in Table IV.

IndexDescription
γ,γ′\gamma,\gamma^{\prime}sites within unit cell
i,ji,junit cell
α,β,μ,ν\alpha,\beta,\mu,\nuCartesian coordinates

Table IV. Summary of labeling convention for indices.

Following previous methods applying the RPA (random phase approximation),[57, 58] we take an interaction Hamiltonian between Mn2+^{2+} (S=52S = \frac{5}{2}) ions of the form

Hint=12∑ijγγ′Jijγγ′Siγ⋅Sjγ′,\mathcal{H}_{\mathrm{int}}=\frac{1}{2}\sum_{ij}^{\gamma\gamma^{\prime}}\mathcal{J}_{ij}^{\gamma\gamma^{\prime}}\mathbf{S}_{i\gamma}\cdot\mathbf{S}_{j\gamma^{\prime}},

where Jijγγ′\mathcal{J}_{ij}^{\gamma\gamma^{\prime}} is a symmetric Heisenberg exchange parameter. Note that we have

changed notation here from Eqn.15 and written the symmetric exchange J1→7\mathcal{J}_{1\to7}, discussed above in the context of the first moment sum rule, as a diagonal matrix Jijγγ′\mathcal{J}_{ij}^{\gamma\gamma^{\prime}} which we use below when moving to a rotating frame as required for incommensurate magnets. Note also that the factor of 12\frac{1}{2} in Hint\mathcal{H}_{\mathrm{int}} originates from the mean field theory as discussed previously in Refs. 53, 55–57, and 59. As shown in Ref. [56], applying mean field decoupling and converting to a local rotating frame, where we define rotation matrices,

Siγ=RiγS~iγ,S_{i\gamma}=R_{i\gamma}\widetilde{S}_{i\gamma},

with S~iγ\widetilde{S}_{i\gamma} being the spin operators in the rotating frame. As discussed in Ref. [56] the Green’s function equation of motion becomes after transforming to Q\mathbf{Q} and ω\omega space

G~γ~γ~′αβ(Q,ω)=gγ~γ~′αβ(ω)δγ~γ~′+∑γ′μνgγ~γ~′αμ(ω)J~γ~′γ~′μν(Q)G~γ~′γ~′νβ(Q,ω)\widetilde{G}_{\tilde{\gamma}\tilde{\gamma}^{\prime}}^{\alpha\beta}(\mathbf{Q},\omega)=g_{\tilde{\gamma}\tilde{\gamma}^{\prime}}^{\alpha\beta}(\omega)\delta_{\tilde{\gamma}\tilde{\gamma}^{\prime}} +\sum_{\gamma^{\prime}}^{\mu\nu}g_{\tilde{\gamma}\tilde{\gamma}^{\prime}}^{\alpha\mu}(\omega)\widetilde{\mathcal{J}}_{\tilde{\gamma}^{\prime}\tilde{\gamma}^{\prime}}^{\mu\nu}(\mathbf{Q})\widetilde{G}_{\tilde{\gamma}^{\prime}\tilde{\gamma}^{\prime}}^{\nu\beta}(\mathbf{Q},\omega)

where the Fourier transform of the exchange interaction in the rotating frame is

J~(Q)=X′[J(Q+q~)T3N+J(Q−q~)T3N∗+J(Q)(I3⊗nnT)]X(26)\widetilde{\mathcal{J}}(\mathbf{Q})=X^{\prime}\left[\mathcal{J}(\mathbf{Q}+\widetilde{\mathbf{q}})T_{3N} +\mathcal{J}(\mathbf{Q}-\widetilde{\mathbf{q}})T_{3N}^{*} +\mathcal{J}(\mathbf{Q})(I_{3}\otimes\mathbf{n}\mathbf{n}^{T})\right]X \tag*{(26)}
[J~(Q)]γγ′=∑ijJijγγ′e−iQ⋅(ri−rj)(27)[\widetilde{\mathcal{J}}(\mathbf{Q})]_{\gamma\gamma^{\prime}}=\sum_{ij}\mathcal{J}_{ij}^{\gamma\gamma^{\prime}}e^{-i\mathbf{Q}\cdot(\mathbf{r}_{i}-\mathbf{r}_{j})} \tag*{(27)}
X=diag⁡(R1,R2,…,RN)(28)X=\operatorname{diag}(R_{1},R_{2},\ldots,R_{N}) \tag*{(28)}
X′=diag⁡(R1T,R2T,…,RNT)(29)X^{\prime}=\operatorname{diag}(R_{1}^{T},R_{2}^{T},\ldots,R_{N}^{T}) \tag*{(29)}

with q~\widetilde{\mathbf{q}} the ordering wavevector, n\mathbf{n} is the normal to the spin rotation plane and T3N=I3⊗12(IN−nnT)T_{3N}=I_{3}\otimes\frac{1}{2}(I_{N}-\mathbf{n}\mathbf{n}^{T}). We note the use of the notation [n×]ji=ϵijknk[\mathbf{n}\times]_{j}^{i}=\epsilon^{ijk}n_{k} where we have made use of the Levi-Civita symbol for the anti-symmetric tensor. The matrices, RR, rotate each of the NN spins in the unit cell onto a common axis. The single-ion Green’s function is given by

gγ~γ~′αβ(ω)=∑qpSαqpγ~Sβpqγ~′ϕqpω−(ωp−ωq)(30)g_{\tilde{\gamma}\tilde{\gamma}^{\prime}}^{\alpha\beta}(\omega)=\sum_{qp}\frac{S_{\alpha qp}^{\tilde{\gamma}}S_{\beta pq}^{\tilde{\gamma}^{\prime}}\phi_{qp}}{\omega-(\omega_{p}-\omega_{q})} \tag*{(30)}

which has poles corresponding to the transitions between the eigenvalues of the single-ion Hamiltonian, ωp\omega_{p}. We will sum over transitions to and from the ground state, as appropriate for magnon excitations at zero temperature. The rotation back to the lab frame can be achieved by

G‾(Q,ω)=DQ(I3⊗nnT)XG~‾(Q,ω)X′(I3⊗nnT)D−Q+DQT3N∗XG~‾(Q+q~,ω)X′T3N′D−Q+DQT3NXG~‾(Q−q~,ω)X′T3N∗D−Q\underline{G}(\mathbf{Q},\omega)=D_{\mathbf{Q}}(\mathbb{I}_3\otimes\mathbf{n}\mathbf{n}^{T})X\underline{\widetilde{G}}(\mathbf{Q},\omega)X'(\mathbb{I}_3\otimes\mathbf{n}\mathbf{n}^{T})D_{-\mathbf{Q}} +D_{\mathbf{Q}}T_{3N}^{*}X\underline{\widetilde{G}}(\mathbf{Q}+\widetilde{\mathbf{q}},\omega)X'T_{3N}^{\prime}D_{-\mathbf{Q}} +D_{\mathbf{Q}}T_{3N}X\underline{\widetilde{G}}(\mathbf{Q}-\widetilde{\mathbf{q}},\omega)X'T_{3N}^{*}D_{-\mathbf{Q}}

where the matrix DQ=δγγ′eiQ⋅δγ⊗I3D_{\mathbf{Q}}=\delta_{\gamma\gamma'}e^{i\mathbf{Q}\cdot\boldsymbol{\delta}_{\gamma}}\otimes\mathbb{I}_3 accounts for the interference between ions in the unit cell.

Finally the neutron scattering cross section is

S(Q,ω)=gL2f2(Q)∑αβ(δαβ−q^αq^β)Sαβ(Q,ω),S(\mathbf{Q},\omega)=g_L^2f^2(\mathbf{Q})\sum_{\alpha\beta}(\delta_{\alpha\beta}-\hat{q}_{\alpha}\hat{q}_{\beta})S^{\alpha\beta}(\mathbf{Q},\omega),

where the partial dynamical structure factor, Sαβ(Q,ω)S^{\alpha\beta}(\mathbf{Q},\omega) is proportional to the imaginary part of the Green’s function [Eq. (25)], gLg_L is the Landé gg-factor, f(Q)f(\mathbf{Q}) is the Mn2+^{2+} magnetic form factor and the polarization factor selects the component perpendicular to the momentum transfer.

We now apply this theory to MnSb2_2O6_6, which comprises a triangular motif of coupled Mn2+^{2+} (3d53d^5) ions. In an intermediate octahedral field, the single-ion ground state of Mn2+^{2+} is 6S^6S (S=5/2S=5/2, L≈0L\approx0) and the orbital moment is quenched. As a result, the effect of spin-orbit coupling and crystallographic distortions are small and may be neglected. The single-ion Hamiltonian is thus remarkably simple and consists solely of the molecular mean field created by the magnetic coupling to neighboring ions, which breaks time reversal symmetry, HSI=hMFS^z\mathcal{H}_{\mathrm{SI}}=h_{\mathrm{MF}}\hat{S}_z. This “Zeeman-like” term acts to split the 6-fold degenerate ∣S=5/2,m⟩\lvert S=5/2,m\rangle states. At low temperatures (as illustrated in Figure 7 of Ref. 55) when only the ground state is populated, only one transition is allowed under the constraints of dipole selection rules of neutron scattering. We note that this approach is equivalent to semi-classical linear spin-wave theory.

Comparison to Experiment

Inputting the symmetric exchange constants derived from the first moment sum rule into the Green’s function calculation with an untilted magnetic structure, we derive the predicted neutron scattering excitation spectrum in Figure 16(a)-(Figure 16b). This calculation is done with no anisotropic terms. Symmetric exchange is expected to be dominant here owing to the lack of an orbital degree of freedom for Mn2+\mathrm{Mn}^{2+}. The general results are in good qualitative agreement with experiment, however the calculated zone-boundary excitations are clearly in disagreement with experiment with the calculation predicting lower energy excitations than observed in experiment at the zone boundary.

Theoretical dispersive neutron scattering results based on Green's functions for an untilted magnetic ground state

Figure 16. The theoretical dispersive neutron scattering results based on our theoretical calculations using Green’s functions taking an untilted magnetic ground state [see Figure 1(d)]. (a)-(b) display calculations with the exchange parameters fixed from those derived using the first-moment sum rule described in the main text. (c)-(d) show calculations but refining J4J_4 to give agreement with experiment at the zone boundary and J7J_7 refined to keep the ordering wavevector consistent with experiment.

To address this, there are two noteworthy points of our first moment sum rule analysis. First, on inspection of Figure 13, the values of γ4\gamma_4, which fixes J4J_4 maybe dominated by the HH-scan experiment performed with Ef=3.7E_f = 3.7 meV. In comparison to iron based langasite, this value for J4J_4 is also considerably larger in MnSb2O6\mathrm{MnSb}_2\mathrm{O}_6.[13] We therefore consider a case when this value is lowered in Figure 16(c)-(Figure 16d). To ensure the same ordering wavevector we correspondingly tune J7J_7 given the relatively large error bar in our analysis and also the large sensitivity of the magnetic ordering wavevector to this exchange constant (Eqn. (23)). After refining J4,7J_{4,7} (to within one-two sigma of the calculated error bar from the first moment sum rule analysis) we obtain a good description of the data (both along the LL and HH directions) with sum rule and refined exchange parameters illustrated in Table III (refined values from this step highlighted in red).

Stability analysis

Having derived a set of symmetric exchange constants from the first moment sum rule and written down a response function theory for the spin waves in terms of Green’s functions, we discuss stability of the ground state fixed by the magnetic structure. There have been two magnetic structures proposed in the literature involving a tilting of the plane of the helicoid at an angle away from the cc-axis ([Ref. 16 and Figure 1(e)}) and one without tilting ([Ref. 15 and {xref}Fig. 1(d)}). While initially it was proposed that the observed polar domain switching in MnSb2O6\mathrm{MnSb}_2\mathrm{O}_6 requires a tilted structure, other work based on neutron diffraction has suggested that it is not a requirement. While in a previous paper we have argued for the existence of an untilted structure, the goodness of fit to the diffraction data was not markedly worse for the tilted case making the results arguably ambiguous.[18] Here we evaluate the stability of the long-wavelength magnetic excitations as a function of tilting the vertical axis of the spin rotation plane given our exchange constants derived from the first moment rule. We emphasize that the exchange constants derived above from the first moment sum rule depend only on the relative orientation of neighboring spins and is independent of the static magnetic structure being tilted or not. Given the good description of the data to a symmetric-only exchange model, we test here how stable these excitations are when the static

magnetic structure is gradually tilted.

The Green’s function calculation predicts the energy and momentum values of stable harmonic excitations through the imaginary part of the response, given a magnetic ground state and a set of symmetric exchange constants. In the first moment analysis presented above, the exchange constants are derived based on relative orientation of the magnetic moments, and does not depend on global details like tilting of the overall magnetic structure. Our Green’s function analysis, however, does require this tilting as the magnetic ground state determines the local molecular field on each site.

Given that the Green’s function approach predicts stable harmonic excitations as a function of momentum and energy, in this section we search for stable long-wavelength excitations as a function of tilting of the spin rotation plane given our derived exchange parameters based on the first moment rule. We focus on LL-scans as calculations of the excitation spectrum along HH were found to not noticeably change with tilting the spin rotation plane away from the cc-axis over the range of 0–15°. We note that such HH-scans were used above to fix one of the exchange parameters and the overall calibration constant to take the data to absolute units of meV. The two assumptions behind that step, namely the energy value of the top of the single-magnon band and the splitting, are not found to observably change with tilting in our calculations.

In Figure 17, we search for long-wavelength excitations given our sum rule exchange constants as a function of tilting of the vertical main axis of the spin rotation plane away from the cc-axis at an angle θ\theta. The long-wavelength excitations (q→0q \to0) are calculated for several tilt angles and shown in Figure 17(a)–(c), based on the set of parameters derived from the sum rule analysis. Given that the sum rules and the fixing of the value of J3J_3 described above is independent of the tilting of the static magnetic moments, in our stability calculations described here we fix the exchange constants to these determined values and vary the long-range static magnetic structure. On increased tilting, the exchange parameters derived from sum rules show no stable long-wavelength excitations, indicative that the derived exchange parameters combined with a tilted helicoid is unstable. This is further displayed in Figure 17(d)–(e) which plot calculated constant energy cuts (integrating calculated data below 0.02 meV) as a function of tilting of the cycloid away from the cc-axis for both the cases of exchange constants derived from sum rules, and refined values discussed above. In both cases, increased tilting of the helicoid results in unstable long-wavelength excitations. Based on this analysis, we suggest that the derived exchange constants are consistent with an untilted (θ=0\theta= 0) magnetic structure. However, we emphasize that this analysis is based only a Hamiltonian with symmetric-only exchange constants as expected based on the high-spin value of Mn2+^{2+}. We cannot rule out the possibility of small anisotropic or more complex magnetic exchange terms that may arise from the distorted framework surrounding the magnetic ions. In Ref. 18 we have shown with diffraction under magnetic field the possibility to manipulate the spin structure in MnSb2_2O6_6 and that the appearance of electric polarization does not require a tilted structure as raised in Ref. 16. Therefore, the stability analysis above is consistent with our neutron diffraction analysis. The elastic scattering outlined in our previous paper and the spin excitations can be modeled and understood in terms of a symmetric-only exchange model on an untilted structure.

Calculations investigating the stability of long-wavelength spin-waves as a function of tilting the spin rotation plane away from the c-axis

Figure 17. Calculations investigating the stability of long-wavelength spin-waves as a function of tilting the spin rotation plane away from the cc-axis. Calculations of the neutron response for tilts of θ=15∘\theta= 15^\circ (a), 10∘10^\circ (b), and 0∘0^\circ (c) are displayed with low-energy, long-wavelength excitations only stable for tilts of θ∼0∘\theta\sim0^\circ. This is further illustrated in panels (d)-(e) that display the response at low energies as a function of tilt-angle of the spin rotation plane away from the cc-axis. We emphasize that these calculations are done for a magnetic Hamiltonian with symmetric-only exchange constants. No anisotropic terms are included in the magnetic Hamiltonian as discussed in the main text.

Conclusions

In this paper, we have studied structurally chiral polar magnet MnSb2_2O6_6, with magnetic interactions being described by seven symmetric Heisenberg exchanges in the magnetic Hamiltonian. We have presented a method using the first moment sum rule, and have applied this to extract the exchange constants from multiplexed neutron data. This method only depends on the correlators (angles) between neighboring spins and not the tilting of the overall spin rotation plane. Using Green’s functions on a rotating frame, we have reproduced the spin-wave spectra, which are in good agreement with the measured ones and discussed refined values. Finally, we investigated the stability of the magnetic structure in terms of long-wavelength magnetic excitations present at low energies and suggest that the pure cycloid is favored in terms of stability given the derived exchange constants from the first moment sum rule.

Acknowledgments

We would like to thank M. Georgopoulou for helpful discussions. We thank the Carnegie Trust for the Universities of Scotland, the EPSRC, and the STFC for financial support. S.W.C. was supported by the DOE under Grant No. DOE: DE-FG02-07ER46382. Access to MACS was provided by the Center for High Resolution Neutron Scattering, a partnership between the National Institute of Standards and Technology and the National Science Foundation under Agreement No. DMR-1508249.

Single-crystal sum rules analysis

Integration methods for first moment

As the first moments are computed by a numerical integration, it is important to make sure that the integration methods do not have a significant impact on the results of the analysis. This section outlines five integration methods, and the resulting Λ\Lambda parameters are compared in Figure 18, following a LL-scan analysis on the Ef=2.4E_f = 2.4 meV dataset.

Fitted parameters for different integrations methods to compute the first moments

Figure 18. Fitted parameters for different integrations methods to compute the first moments, from the Ef=2.4E_f = 2.4 meV dataset.

In § 3 D 2, the constant-QQ scans are fitted to two gaussians as shown in Figure 11, and then the first moments were calculated by numerically integrating with a trapezoidal rule with the background removed from the fit to a two-gaussian model. The results are shown with bars (C). Of course, the first moments can also be computed without removing the background, resulting with bars (B). Then, they can be computed analytically using the fit parameters of the two-gaussian model, shown with the bars (A) in Figure 18. In order to avoid the mixture of elastic scattering and one-magnon scattering, the elastic line can be fitted to a third gaussian, while the actual data above E=0.2E = 0.2 meV are fitted to two gaussians. Then, the first moments can be again calculated analytically with the fitted parameters of these two gaussians in the good energy range. This is shown in bars (D). Finally, the trapezoidal integration can be performed, removing the background from this three-gaussian model, as shown in bars (E). Finally, it can be seen that all the fitted parameters agree within uncertainties. We have rather chosen to adopt trapezoidal integration, removing the background from the two-gaussian fit, to deal with any deviation from a two-mode spin-wave spectrum.

H-scan

In § 3 D 2, we have described the first moment sum rule analysis of the single crystal data, by fixing some H0H_0 and calculating the first moment as a function of LL. We can perform the same analysis considering Q=(H,H,L0)Q=(H,H,L_0) with HH varying for a chosen L0L_0 (HH-scan). For each interaction indexed by spins ii and jj, the corresponding term in the cosine in Eq. (15) can be written now:

Q⋅dij=2πH(dij,x+dij,y)+2πL0dij,z(31)\mathbf{Q}\cdot\mathbf{d}_{ij}=2\pi H(d_{ij,x}+d_{ij,y})+2\pi L_0d_{ij,z} \tag*{(31)}

where the distances are expressed in lattice units, and the scattering vector in reciprocal lattice units. Similarly as in Eq. (18), a general formula for the first moment can be derived for a fixed L0L_0, using trigonometric identities:

⟨E⟩(H,L0)=Ai(L0)cos⁡(2πδ1H)+…+Ae(L0)[cos⁡(2πδ2H)+…cos⁡(2πδ3H)+cos⁡(2πδ4H)]+C(L0)(32)\begin{aligned} \langle E\rangle(H,L_0) &= A_i(L_0)\cos(2\pi\delta_1H)+\ldots\\ &\quad+A_e(L_0)[\cos(2\pi\delta_2H)+\ldots\\ &\quad\cos(2\pi\delta_3H)+\cos(2\pi\delta_4H)]+C(L_0) \tag*{(32)} \end{aligned}

where we have now three functions AiA_i, AeA_e and CC which are L0L_0-dependent, expressed by:

Ai(L0)=43[γ1+γicos⁡(2πL0)](33)A_i(L_0)=\frac{4}{3}[\gamma_1+\gamma_i\cos(2\pi L_0)] \tag*{(33)}
Ae(L0)=43[γ2+γecos⁡(2πL0)](34)A_e(L_0)=\frac{4}{3}[\gamma_2+\gamma_e\cos(2\pi L_0)] \tag*{(34)}
C(L0)=−23[2γ1+6γ2+3γi+3γ4+6γe]+…(35)C(L_0)=-\frac{2}{3}[2\gamma_1+6\gamma_2+3\gamma_i+3\gamma_4+6\gamma_e]+\ldots \tag*{(35)}
23cos⁡(2πL0)(γi+3γ4)\frac{2}{3}\cos(2\pi L_0)(\gamma_i+3\gamma_4)

Fig. 19(a)-(c) shows some constant-QQ cuts for (H,H,L0=0.4)(H,H,L_0=0.4) and their fit to two gaussians. The first moments are again calculated numerically using trapezoidal integration and the background is removed from the two-gaussian fit. These computed first moments are the red data points in Figure 19(d), along with the HH-dependence of the computed first moment, and the fit to Eq. (32), to extract AiA_i, AeA_e and CC. This operation is repeated for several L0L_0, as shown in Figure 19(e)-(Figure 19f).

Six-panel constant-$Q$ scans and first-moment plots

Figure 19. (a)–(c) Constant-QQ scans for different Q=(H,H,L0=0.4)Q=(H,H,L_0=0.4). A fit to a double gaussian is shown in red, and the first moment is calculated from trapezoidal integration where the background is removed from the gaussian fit. (d) First moment as a function of HH for L0=0.4L_0=0.4, fitted to its theoretical expression (red curve). The red data points correspond to the first moments calculated in the cuts plotted in (a)–(c). (e)–(f) First moment as a function of HH for (e) L0=0L_0=0 and (f) L0=−1L_0=-1, fit to theoretical expression in red.

Finally, a total of 999 first moments ⟨E⟩(Q)\langle E\rangle(Q) are computed for this analysis on this Ef=2.4E_f=2.4 meV dataset, and plotted against the fitted first moments in Figure 20(a). The γ\gamma parameters are then obtained by fitting the measured AiA_i, AeA_e and CC to their theoretical values, as shown in Figure 20(b)-(Figure 20d), where the red data points are the coefficients calculated in Figure 19(d)-(Figure 19f). As for the LL-scan analysis, some remaining background can be included in the computation of CC. For this reason, the L0L_0-independent part of Eq. (35), which corresponds to an overall constant to the first moment sum rule, is not used to get the γ\gamma parameters and hence the exchange constants JiJ_i.

Four-panel plots showing measured versus fitted first moments and fitted coefficients for H-scan analysis

Figure 20. (a) Measured first moments versus fitted first moments for HH-scan analysis, for the Ef=2.4E_{\mathrm{f}} = 2.4 meV dataset. A total of 999 ⟨E⟩(Q)\langle E\rangle(Q) were taken into account. (b)–(d) Fitting of coefficients (b) AiA_{\mathrm{i}}, (c) AeA_{\mathrm{e}} and (d) CC giving the γ\gamma parameters. The red data points show the values calculated in Figure 19(d)–(f).

Second dataset results

The single crystal first moment sum rule analysis was repeated on the second dataset measured on MACS with Ef=3.7E_f=3.7 meV. The results of the LL-scan (469 computed first moments) and HH-scan (487 computed first moments) analyses are respectively shown in Figure 21 and Figure 22.

Four-panel plots showing measured versus fitted first moments and fitted coefficients for L-scan analysis

Figure 21. (a) Measured first moments versus fitted first moments for LL-scan analysis, for the Ef=3.7E_{\mathrm{f}} = 3.7 meV dataset. A total of 469 ⟨E⟩(Q)\langle E\rangle(Q) were taken into account. (b)–(c) Fitting of coefficients (b) AA and (c) CC giving the γ\gamma parameters.

Measured versus fitted first moments and fitted coefficients

Figure 22. (a) Measured first moments versus fitted first moments for HH-scan analysis, for the Ef=3.7E_f = 3.7 meV dataset. A total of 487 ⟨E⟩(Q)\langle E\rangle(Q) were taken into account. (b)–(d) Fitting of coefficients (b) AiA_i, (c) AeA_e and (d) CC giving the γ\gamma parameters.

Parameters for Figure 14

The sum rule analysis had an ambiguity in the set of equations resulting from the fact that several exchange constants corresponded to the same bond distance. We therefore needed to fix one exchange constant through a comparison to the single crystal dispersion as discussed in the main text. This qualitative analysis is described in Figure 15. The parameters for the calculations are listed in Table V.

J1J_1J2J_2J3J_3J4J_4J5J_5J6J_6J7J_7
Fig. 14 (b)0.09880.28590.15000.3491-0.10111.02220.1161
Fig. 14 (c)0.09880.28590.20000.3491-0.01550.99720.0732
Fig. 14 (d)0.09880.28590.25000.34910.07020.97220.0304

Table V. The parameters for the calculations performed in SpinW displayed in Figure 15(b)-(Figure 15d). Parameters varied for the three calculations are highlighted in blue.

References

  1. [10]K. Marty, V. Simonet, E. Ressouche, R. Ballou, P. Lejay, and P. Bordet, Phys. Rev. Lett. 101, 247201 (2008).
  2. [11]K. Marty, P. Bordet, V. Simonet, M. Loire, R. Ballou, C. Darie, J. Kljun, P. Bonville, O. Isnard, P. Lejay, B. Zawilski, and C. Simon, Phys. Rev. B 81, 054416 (2010).
  3. [12]M. Loire, V. Simonet, S. Petit, K. Marty, P. Bordet, P. Lejay, J. Ollivier, M. Enderle, P. Steffens, E. Ressouche, A. Zorko, and R. Ballou, Phys. Rev. Lett. 106, 207201 (2011).
  4. [13]C. Stock, L. C. Chapon, A. Schneidewind, Y. Su, P. G. Radaelli, D. F. McMorrow, A. Bombardi, N. Lee, and S.-W. Cheong, Phys. Rev. B 83, 104426 (2011).
  5. [14]J. N. Reimers and J. E. Greedan, J. Solid State Chem. 79, 263 (1989).
  6. [15]R. D. Johnson, K. Cao, L. C. Chapon, F. Fabrizi, N. Perks, P. Manuel, J. J. Yang, Y. S. Oh, S.-W. Cheong, and P. G. Radaelli, Phys. Rev. Lett. 111, 017202 (2013).
  7. [16]M. Kinoshita, S. Seki, T. J. Sato, Y. Nambu, T. Hong, M. Matsuda, H. B. Cao, S. Ishiwata, and Y. Tokura, Phys. Rev. Lett. 117, 047201 (2016).
  8. [17]J. Werner, C. Koo, R. Klingeler, A. N. Vasiliev, Y. A. Ovchenkov, A. S. Polovkova, G. V. Raganyan, and E. A. Zvereva, Phys. Rev. B 94, 104408 (2016).
  9. [18]E. Chan, J. Pásztorová, R. D. Johnson, M. Songvilay, R. A. Downie, J.-W. G. Bos, O. Fabelo, C. Ritter, K. Beauvois, C. Niedermayer, S.-W. Cheong, N. Qureshi, and C. Stock, Phys. Rev. B 106, 064403 (2022).
  10. [19]K. Yosida, Theory of Magnetism (Springer, New York, 1996).DOI
  11. [20]P. C. Hohenberg and W. F. Brinkman, Phys. Rev. B 10, 128 (1974).
  12. [21]K. Momma and F. Izumi, J. Appl. Crystallogr. 44, 1272 (2011).
  13. [22]N. Qureshi, J. Appl. Crystallogr. 52, 175 (2019).
  14. [24]J. A. Rodriguez, D. M. Adler, P. C. Brand, C. Broholm, J. C. Cook, C. Brocker, R. Hammond, Z. Huang, P. Hundertmarkr, J. W. Lynn, N. C. Maliszewskyj, J. Moyer, J. Orndorff, D. Pierce, T. D. Pike, G. Scharfstein, S. A. Smee, and R. Vilaseca, Meas. Sci. Technol. 19, 034023 (2008).
  15. [25]J. des Cloizeaux and J. J. Pearson, Phys. Rev. 128, 2131 (1962).
  16. [26]G. Müller, H. Thomas, H. Beck, and J. C. Bonner, Phys. Rev. B 24, 1429 (1981).
  17. [27]Y. Endoh, G. Shirane, R. J. Birgeneau, P. M. Richards, and S. L. Holt, Phys. Rev. Lett. 32, 170 (1974).
  18. [28]R. Coldea, D. A. Tennant, and Z. Tylczynski, Phys. Rev. B 68, 134424 (2003).
  19. [29]D. A. Tennant, T. G. Perring, R. A. Cowley, and S. E. Nagler, Phys. Rev. Lett. 70, 4008 (1993).
  20. [30]S. E. Nagler, D. A. Tennant, R. A. Cowley, T. G. Perring, and S. K. Satija, Phys. Rev. B 44, 12361 (1991).
  21. [31]B. Lake, D. A. Tennant, R. A. Cowley, T. Barthel, U. Schollwöck, S. E. Nagler, and C. D. Frost, Phys. Rev. Lett. 111, 137205 (2013).
  22. [32]M. B. Stone, D. H. Reich, C. Broholm, K. Lefmann, C. Rischel, C. P. Landee, and M. M. Turnbull, Phys. Rev. Lett. 91, 037205 (2003).
  23. [33]M. Mourigal, M. Enderle, A. Kloepperpieper, J.-S. Caux, A. Stunault, and H. M. Rønnow, Nat. Phys. 9, 435 (2013).
  24. [34]I. U. Heilmann, J. K. Kjems, Y. Endoh, G. F. Reiter, G. Shirane, and R. J. Birgeneau, Phys. Rev. B 24, 3939 (1981).
  25. [35]T. Huberman, R. Coldea, R. A. Cowley, D. A. Tennant, R. L. Leheny, R. J. Christianson, and C. D. Frost, Phys. Rev. B 72, 014413 (2005).
  26. [36]M. Songvilay, E. Rodriguez, R. Lindsay, M. Green, H. Walker, J. Rodriguez-Rivera, and C. Stock, Physical Review Letters 121, 087201 (2018).
  27. [37]P. R. Hammar, D. H. Reich, C. Broholm, and F. Trouw, Phys. Rev. B 57, 7486 (1998).
  28. [43]P. M. Sarte, A. M. Arévalo-López, M. Songvilay, D. Le, T. Guidi, V. García-Sakai, S. Mukhopadhyay, S. C. Capelli, W. D. Ratcliff, K. H. Hong, G. M. McNally, E. Pachoud, J. P. Attfield, and C. Stock, Phys. Rev. B 98, 224410 (2018).
  29. [44]C. Stock, L. C. Chapon, O. Adamopoulos, A. Lappas, M. Giot, J. W. Taylor, M. A. Green, C. M. Brown, and P. G. Radaelli, Phys. Rev. Lett. 103, 077202 (2009).
  30. [45]M. B. Stone, Y. Chen, J. Rittner, H. Yardimci, D. H. Reich, C. Broholm, D. V. Ferraris, and T. Lectka, Phys. Rev. B 65, 064423 (2002).
  31. [47]M. Songvilay, J. Robert, S. Petit, J. A. Rodriguez-Rivera, W. D. Ratcliff, F. Damay, V. Balédent, M. Jiménez-Ruiz, P. Lejay, E. Pachoud, A. Hadj-Azzev, V. Simonet, and C. Stock, Phys. Rev. B 102, 224429 (2020).
  32. [48]M. Songvilay, S. Petit, F. Damay, G. Roux, N. Qureshi, H. C. Walker, J. A. Rodriguez-Rivera, B. Gao, S.-W. Cheong, and C. Stock, Phys. Rev. Lett. 126, 017201 (2021).
  33. [49]A. Cowley, J. Phys.: Condens. Matter 15, 4143 (2003).
  34. [50]C. Stock, R. A. Cowley, J. W. Taylor, and S. M. Bennington, Phys. Rev. B 81, 024303 (2010).
  35. [51]S. Toth and B. Lake, J. Phys.: Condens. Matter 27, 166002 (2015).
  36. [52]J. S. Smart, Effective field theories of magnetism (Saun- ders, Philadelphia, 1966).DOI
  37. [53]P. M. Sarte, M. Songvilay, E. Pachoud, R. A. Ewings, C. D. Frost, D. Prabhakaran, K. H. Hong, A. J. Browne, Z. Ya- mani, J. P. Attfield, E. E. Rodriguez, S. D. Wilson, and C. Stock, Phys. Rev. B 100, 075143 (2019).
  38. [54]H. Lane, E. Pachoud, J. A. Rodriguez-Rivera, M. Songvi- lay, G. Xu, M. Gehring, J. P. Attfield, R. A. Ewings, and C. Stock, Phys. Rev. B 104, L02011 (2021).
  39. [55]H. Lane, E. E. Rodriguez, H. C. Walker, C. Niedermayer, U. Stuhr, R. I. Bewley, D. J. Voneshen, M. A. Green, J. A. Rodriguez-Rivera, P. Fouquet, S.-W. Cheong, J. P. Attfield, R. A. Ewings, and C. Stock, Phys. Rev. B 104, 104404 (2021).
  40. [56]H. Lane, M. Songvilay, R. A. Ewings, and C. Stock, Phys. Rev. B 106, 054431 (2022).
  41. [57]W. J. L. Buyers, T. M. Holden, and A. Perreault, Phys. Rev. B 11, 266 (1975).
  42. [58]J. F. Cooke, Phys. Rev. B 7, 1108 (1973).

Paper details

vlnc:W_thpg7kkn
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 1

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Physics and Astronomy

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents