In the spirit of the recent work by Demmel and Wiedemann \cite{[DW]}, we investigate the validity of the energy balance law for weak solutions to the three-dimensional Navier-Stokes equations with only horizontal dissipation. We prove that famous Lions-Shinbrot type energy conservation criteria, originally established for the classical isotropic Navier-Stokes equations, continue to hold in this anisotropic setting. Furthermore, we present two distinct approaches that handle the torus case and the whole space case, respectively.
Introduction
In geophysical fluids, the Navier-Stokes equations feature anisotropic viscosities of the form −νΔh−ϵ∂332 (see [34]). Here, ϵ is usually much smaller than ν, and the Ekman boundary layers arise in rotating fluid when ϵ→0 (see [34]). In this paper, we are concerned with the following 3D Navier-Stokes equations subject solely to horizontal dissipation
{ut+u⋅∇u−Δhu+∇Π=0,divu=0,u∣t=0=u0(x),(1)
where u represents velocity field and Π stands for the pressure, and Δhu=∂x1x12u+∂x2x22u. The initial velocity u0 satisfies divu0=0.
Very recently, Demmel and Wiedemann [18] proved the energy equality for weak solutions of the two-dimensional Navier-Stokes equations with only horizontal viscosity at the natural energy level, where weak solutions are lack of the regularity of ∂2u1 in the 2D anisotropic incompressible Navier-Stokes system. To this end, some new ingredients were provided in [18], where they split the energy equality into vertical component part and horizontal component part. In addition, the divergence-free condition is fully utilized and an anisotropic commutator estimate of the DiPerna-Lions theory for divergence-free field was established. In the spirit of Demmel and Wiedemann’s work [18], we study the validity of energy balance law
for weak solutions of the tri-dimensional anisotropic Navier-Stokes equations (1), where Ω is either the whole space R3 or the periodic domain T3. Before formulating our results, we recall the progress of energy equality
for weak solutions of the tri-dimensional isotropic Navier-Stokes equations.
Energy conservation of weak solutions not only plays a crucial role in the study of weak-strong uniqueness, but also is closed to the Onsager conjecture. Onsager [33] asserted that the regularity threshold in Hölder spaces of the weak solutions for the validity of the kinetic energy conservation in the ideal fluid is 1/3. Since then, much effort has been devoted to identifying the minimal regularity assumptions that guarantee energy equality for weak solutions to viscous and inviscid flows, see, e.g. [2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 15, 16, 21, 22, 24, 30, 31, 35, 44] and references therein. Concerning the negative part of the Onsager’s conjecture, we refer the reader to [19, 20, 25, 27, 28]. In what follows, we restrict our attention to the energy equality and recall some known results in this direction below: A Leray-Hopf weak solution u to the Navier-Stokes equations satisfies the energy equality (3) if one of the following conditions holds
Inspired by Demmel and Wiedemann’s work [18], a natural question arises whether the well-known properties of the isotropic Navier-Stokes equations continue to hold in this anisotropic setting. Compared with the isotropic counterpart, an extra difficulty stems from the lack of regularity for ∂3uh in the anisotropic Navier-Stokes equations (1), which further complicates the analysis of the anisotropic Navier-Stokes equations. For mathematical results on the anisotropic Navier-Stokes system, we refer the reader to [9, 10, 11, 12, 13, 23, 28, 39, 40, 45, 47] and the references therein. In the present work, we concentrate on the energy equality problem and aim to address whether classical Lions-Shinbrot type criteria for kinetic energy conservation remain valid for the three-dimensional anisotropic Navier-Stokes equations (1).
In what follows, we formulate our criteria for kinetic energy conservation of Leray-Hopf weak solutions to the anisotropic Navier-Stokes equations (1) with partial dissipation for the torus domain T3.
Theorem 1.1. The energy equality of Leray-Hopf weak solutions u to the 3D anisotropic Navier-Stokes equations (1) is valid if one of the following three conditions is satisfied
u∈L4(0,T;L4(T3));
u∈Lp(0,T;Lq(T3)), with p2+q2=1 and q≥4;
∇u∈Lp(0,T;Lq(T3)), with p1+5q6=1 and q≥59.
Now we give some comments. The tri-dimensional anisotropic Navier-Stokes equations (1) are lack of vertical dissipation ∂x3x32u, however, the famous Lions-Shinbrot’s energy conservation class originated from the standard Navier-Stokes equations is still valid for this system. In addition, energy conservation criteria in terms of gradient of velocity obtained in [3, 5, 44] are established for the tri-dimensional anisotropic Navier-Stokes equations (1). It should be pointed out that the proof of Theorem 1.1 is inspired by Demmel and Wiedemann’s recent work [18]. Compared with their deduction, the derivation of this theorem rests on the limiting case of Constantin-E-Titi type commutators shown in [32, 38] for the torus case. The starting point of Theorem 1.1 is different from that in [18], hence, we get the energy identity under the full components of velocity belonging to L4(0,T;L4(T3)) in one step rather than two steps in [18]. Roughly speaking, Demmel and Wiedemann proved that weak solutions satisfy the energy equality from u2∈L4(0,T;L4(R2)) and u2u1∈L2(0,T;L2(R2)) in [18], where the delicate pressure decomposition and directionwise energy splitting are required. Besides, Demmel and Wiedemann’s anisotropic commutator estimates established in [18] allow us to get the same results for the whole space R3. Then, we state our second result as follows.
Theorem 1.2. The energy equality of Leray-Hopf weak solutions u to the 3D anisotropic Navier-Stokes equations (1) is valid if one of the following three conditions is satisfied
u∈L4(0,T;L4(R3));
u∈Lp(0,T;Lq(R3)), with p2+q2=1 and q≥4;
∇u∈Lp(0,T;Lq(R3)), with p1+5q6=1 and q≥59.
It should be pointed out that the Lions’s energy conservation class u∈L4(0,T;L4(R2)) in Theorem 1.2 is still valid for the two dimensional anisotropic Navier-Stokes equations via a slight modification. It is worth remarking that that Demmel and Wiedemann obtained energy conservation of weak solutions of the two-dimensional anisotropic Navier-Stokes equations without any extra integrability assumptions in [18].
The rest of this paper is organized as follows. In Section 2, we present the notations and some basic materials of mollifiers. Several critical lemmas for the proof of Theorem 1.1 and Theorem 1.2 are also given. Section 3 is devoted to our new criteria for energy conservation of weak solutions to the anisotropic Navier-Stokes equations for both the periodic domain T3 and the whole space R3.
Notations and key auxiliary lemmas
Throughout this paper, we will use the summation convention on repeated indices. C will denote positive absolute constants which may be different from line to line unless otherwise stated in this paper. For p∈[1,∞], the notation Lp(0,T;X) stands for the set of measurable functions f on the interval (0,T) with values in X and ∥f∥X belonging to Lp(0,T).
Mollifier kernel: Let ηε:Rn→R be a standard mollifier, i.e. η(x)=C0e−1−∣x∣21 for ∣x∣<1 and η(x)=0 for ∣x∣≥1, where C0 is a constant such that ∫Rnη(x)dx=1. For ε>0, we define the rescaled mollifier ηε(x)=εn1η(εx) and for any function f∈Lloc1(Rn), its mollified version is defined as
fε(x)=(f∗ηε)(x)=∫Rnf(x−y)ηε(y)dy,x∈Rn.
Next, we collect some lemmas which will be used in the present paper.
Lemma 2.1. ([42]) Let p,q,p2,q2∈[1,+∞) and p1,q1∈[1,+∞] with p1=p11+p21, q1=q11+q21. Assume f∈Lp1(0,T;Lq1(Ω)) and g∈Lp2(0,T;Lq2(Ω)), then there holds
ε→0lim∥(fg)ε−fεgε∥Lp(0,T;Lq(Ω))=0.(7)
Lemma 2.2. ([32]) Suppose that f∈Lp(0,T;Lq(Tn)). Then for any ε>0, there holds
∥∇fε∥Lp(0,T;Lq(Tn))≤Cε−1∥f∥Lp(0,T;Lq(Tn)),(8)
and, if p,q<∞
ε→0limsupε∥∇fε∥Lp(0,T;Lq(Tn))=0.(9)
Lemma 2.3. ([32, 38]) Let 1≤p,q,p1,p2,q1,q2≤∞ with p1=p11+p21 and q1=q11+q21. Assume that f∈Lp1(0,T;W1,q1(Tn)) and g∈Lp2(0,T;Lq2(Tn)). Then for any ε>0, there holds
The next lemma was established in [18] for the two-dimensional setting R2 with the special exponents pi=qi=2 for i=1,2. Now, we generalize the result by adopting space-time integral norms with distinct exponents and extending the spatial dimension from two to three.
On the other hand, the continuity of the translations in Lebesgue space gives
∂iun(x−θεz)→∂iun(x)strongly in Lp3(0,T;Lq3(R3)),as ε→0,
f(x−θεz)→f(x)strongly in Lp4(0,T;Lq4(R3)),as ε→0,(20)
provided that 1≤p3,q3,p4,q4<∞.
Then combining (18),(19) and (20), we conclude from the dominated convergence theorem that
R2ε=∂n(unf)ε−un∂nfε→−i=1∑n(∫R3∂znη(z)zidz)∂iun(x)f(x)strongly in Lp(0,T;Lq(R3)),as ε→0=∂nun(x)f(x).(21)
Here in the last equality, we have used the integration by parts and the facts that ∑i=1n∂znzi=1 and ∫R3η(z)dz=1.
Thus, in combination with (2.11) and (2.15), and using the divergence-free condition, we obtain
R1ε+R2ε→(i=1∑n−1∂iui+∂nun)f=0,strongly in Lp(0,T;Lq(R3)), as ε→0.(22)
Thus, the proof of this lemma is completed.
Finally, to end this section, we give the definition of weak solutions to the 3D incompressible anisotropic Navier-Stokes equations.
Definition 2.1. Let Ω=T3 or R3. We call a vector field u a weak solution to the 3D incompressible anisotropic Navier-Stokes equations (1.1) if
u∈L∞(0,T;L2(Ω)),∇hu∈L2(0,T;L2(Ω)),(23)
it is weakly divergence-free, i.e.,
∫Ωu⋅∇ψdx=0
holds for all ψ∈C0∞(Ω) and almost every t, and
∫0T∫Ω∂tϕ⋅u+∇ϕ:(u⊗u)−∇hϕ⋅∇hudxdt=0(24)
holds for every divergence-free ϕ∈C0∞((0,T)×Ω).
Energy conservation of 3D anisotropic Navier-Stokes equations
In this section, we are devoted to the proof of the energy conservation of weak solutions to the 3D anisotropic Navier-Stokes equations (1.1), for both the periodic domain T3 and the whole space R3.
Torus case: T3
Proof of Theorem 1.1. Mollifying the equations (1.1) in spatial direction, we arrive at
∂tuε−Δhuε+(u⋅∇u)ε+∇Πε=0.(25)
Multiplying (3.1) by uε and integrating it with respect to x and t, we conclude by the divergence-free condition and integration by parts that
Before going further, together with u3∈L∞(0,T;L2(T3)), we conclude that ∇u3∈Lp(0,T;Lq(T3)) implies u3∈Lp(0,T;W1,q(T3)). Indeed, for 1≤q≤2, we derive from the Hölder inequality that
Consequently, ∇u3∈Lp(0,T;Lq(T3)) means that u3∈Lp(0,T;W1,q(T3)). With this in hand, we continue to deal with I23. In view of the Hölder inequality, we observe that
Hence, combining (3.16) and (3.22), we verified the assertment (3.5). Now, we are in a position to pass to the limit of ε in (3.2) to get the energy conservation (1.2).
(1) As the natural energy gives ∇hu∈L2(0,T;L2(T3)), by choosing p=q=2 in (3.5), we immediately prove that the condition u∈L4(0,T;L4(T3)) yields the energy equality. It is worth remarking that the rest proof in Theorem 1.1 can be reduced to this special case.
(2) Next, we deal with the case (2) in Theorem 1.1 with q≥4 and p2+q2=1. The Gagliardo-Nirenberg inequality guarantees that
From the result just proved, we obtain the energy equality via (1) in Theorem 1.1 with q≥4.
(3) Now, we focus on the proof of (3). Indeed, note that u∈Lp−12p(0,T;W1,q(T3)), therefore, according to (3.5), it suffices to derive u∈Lp−12p(0,T;Lq−12q(T3)) from (3.5). For q≥59, by the Gagliardo-Nirenberg inequality, we get
Next, we prove that the terms on the right-hand side of (50) vanish as ε→0. Contrary to the strategy adopted for the torus domain, we employ the anisotropic version of Lions’ commutator estimates, instead of Constantin-E-Titi-type commutators, to handle these terms. Precisely, recall (55) and using the Hölder inequality, it gives
Then, by virtue of lemma 2.4 with the choices u=u, f=u1 or u2, p1=p4=p−12p, q1=q4=q−12q, p3=p2=p, q3=q2=q and p=p+12p, q=q+12q, we conclude
div[uu1ε−(uu1)ε]→0,strongly in Lp+12p(0,T;Lq+12q(R3)), as ε→0;
div[uu2ε−(uu2)ε]→0,strongly in Lp+12p(0,T;Lq+12q(R3)), as ε→0.(57)
For term II, we note that the divergence-free condition together with (55) guarantees full regularity for u3. Indeed, ∇hu∈Lp(0,T;Lq(R3)) implies ∇huh∈Lp(0,T;Lq(R3)). From the divergence-free constraint divu=0, we have ∂3u3=−∂h⋅uh, which further yields ∇u3∈Lp(0,T;Lq(R3)).
Based on this, using the integration by parts and the Hölder inequality, we get
Hence, combining (58) and (59), we conclude the proof of assertion (55). Since the proof below is analogous to that in the previous subsection, Theorem 1.2 follows by repeating the arguments therein, and we omit the details.
Acknowledgements
Ye was partially sponsored by the Training Program for Young Backbone Teachers in Higher Education Institutions of Henan Province (2024GGJS022). Wei was partially supported by the National Natural Science Foundation of China under grant (No. 12271433). Wang was sponsored by Natural Science Foundation of Henan Province (No. 232300421077) and supported by the National Natural Science Foundation of China under grant (No. 11971446 and No. 12071113).
Author Declarations statement
The authors have no conflicts to disclose.
Data Availability
This publication is supported by multiple datasets, which are openly available at locations cited in the reference section.
References
[2]H. Beirao da Veiga and J. Yang, On the Shinbrot’s criteria for energy equality to Newtonian fluids: a simplified proof, and an extension of the range of application. Nonlinear Anal. 196 (2020), 111809, 4 pp.
[3]H. Beirao da Veiga and J. Yang, The relations between Hölder continuity assumptions on the direction of vorticity and energy equality. J. Geom. Anal. 35 (2025), 15.DOI
[4]L. C. Berselli, Energy conservation for weak solutions of incompressible fluid equations: The Hölder case and connections with Onsager’s conjecture. J. Differential Equations, 368 (2023), 350–375.
[5]L. C. Berselli and E. Chiodaroli, On the energy equality for the 3D Navier-Stokes equations. Nonlinear Anal. 192 (2020), 111704, 24 pp.arxiv.org/abs/1807.02667
[6]L. C. Berselli and E. Chiodaroli and R. Sannipoli, Energy conservation for 3D Euler and Navier-Stokes equations in a bounded domain: applications to Beltrami flows. J. Nonlinear Sci. 35 (2025), no. 1, Paper No. 10, 30 pp.
[7]L. C. Berselli and S. Georgiadis, Three results on the Energy conservation for the 3D Euler equations. Nonlinear Differ. Equ. Appl. 31, 33 (2024), 1–14.
[8]L. C. Berselli, A. Kaltenbach and M. Růžička, Energy conservation for weak solutions of incompressible Newtonian fluid equations in Hölder spaces with Dirichlet boundary conditions in the half-space. Math. Ann. 391 (2025), no. 4, 5911–5940.
[9]Q. Bie, H. Fang, S. Wang and Y. Zhou, Stability and sharp decay for the 3D incompressible anisotropic Navier-Stokes equations with fractional horizontal dissipation. J. Differential Equations 463 (2026), Paper No. 114167, 38 pp.
[10]C. Cao and Y. Guo, On the two-dimensional Navier-Stokes equations with horizontal viscosity. J. Math. Anal. Appl. 557 (2026), no. 2, Paper No. 130352, 24 pp.
[11]C. Cao and J. Wu, Stability of the 3D Navier-Stokes equations with anisotropic dissipation. Nonlinearity. 38 (2025), no. 9, Paper No. 095012, 10 pp.DOI
[12]C. Cao and J. Wu, Global regularity for the two-dimensional anisotropic Boussinesq equations with vertical dissipation. Arch. Ration. Mech. Anal. 208(2013), no. 3, 985–1004.DOI
[13]J. Chemin, B. Desjardins, I. Gallagher and E. Grenier. Fluids with anisotropic viscosity. M2AN Math. Model. Numer. Anal. 34(2000), no. 2, 315–335.DOI
[15]A. Cheskidov, P. Constantin, S. Friedlander and R. Shvydkoy, Energy conservation and Onsager’s conjecture for the Euler equations. Nonlinearity, 21 (2008), 1233–1252.
[16]A. Cheskidov and X. Luo, Energy equality for the Navier-Stokes equations in weak-in-time Onsager spaces. Nonlinearity, 33 (2020), 1388–1403.arxiv.org/abs/1802.05785
[18]J. Demmel and E. Wiedemann Energy rigidity and weak-strong uniqueness for the 2D anisotropic Navier-Stokes equations. arXiv.2608.19931.
[19]C. De Lellis and L. J. Székelyhidi, The Euler equations as a differential inclusion. Ann. Math. 170 (2009), 1417–1436.
[20]C. De Lellis and L. J. Székelyhidi, Dissipative continuous Euler flows. Invent. Math. 193 (2013), 377–407.DOI
[21]E. Feireisl, P. Gwiazda, A. Świerczewska-Gwiazda and E. Wiedemann, Regularity and energy conservation for the compressible euler equations. Arch Ration Mech Anal. 223 (2017), 1375–1395.DOI
[22]U. S. Fjordholm and E. Wiedemann, Statistical solutions and Onsager’s conjecture. Phys. D. 376-377 (2018), 259–265.DOI
[23]M. Fujii, Large time behavior of solutions to the 3D anisotropic Navie–Stokes equation. Nonlinear Anal. Real World Appl. 71 (2023), Paper No. 103821, 33 pp.arxiv.org/abs/2108.11940
[24]G. P. Galdi, An introduction to the Navier-Stokes initial-boundary value problem, in: Fundamental Directions in Mathematical Fluid Mechanics, in: Adv. Math. Fluid Mech., Birkhäuser, Basel, 2000, 1–70.DOI
[25]V. Giri, H. Kwon and M. Novack. The L³-based strong Onsager theorem. Ann. of Math. (2) 204 (2026), no. 1, 265–421.
[27]P. Isett, A proof of Onsager’s conjecture. Ann. of Math. 188 (2018), 871–963.arxiv.org/abs/1608.08301
[28]R. Ji, L. Tian and J. Wu, 3D anisotropic Navier-Stokes equations in T² × ℝ : stability and large-time behaviour. Nonlinearity. 36 (2023), no. 6, 3219–3237.DOI
[30]T. M. Leslie and R. Shvydkoy. Conditions implying energy equality for weak solutions of the Navier-Stokes equations. SIAM J. Math. Anal. 50 (2018), 870–890.arxiv.org/abs/1606.02363
[31]J. L. Lions, Sur la régularité et l’unicité des solutions turbulentes des équations de Navier Stokes, Rend. Semin. Mat. Univ. Padova, 30 (1960) 16–23.
[32]Q. Nguyen, P. Nguyen and B. Tang, Energy equalities for compressible Navier-Stokes equations. Nonlinearity 32 (2019), 4206–4231.DOI
[33]L. Onsager, Statistical hydrodynamics. Nuovo Cim. (Suppl.) 6 (1949), 279–287.DOI
[35]M. Shinbrot, The energy equation for the Navier-Stokes system. SIAM J. Math. Anal. 5 (1974) 948–954.DOI
[36]Y. Taniuchi, On generalized energy equality of the Navier-Stokes equations. Manuscripta Math. 94 (1997), 365–384.
[38]Y. Wang and Y. Ye, A general sufficient criterion for energy conservation in the Navier-Stokes system. Math Meth Appl Sci. 46 (2023), 9268–9285.
[39]W. Yang, Q. Jiu and J. Wu, The 3D incompressible Navier-Stokes equations with partial hyperdissipation. Math. Nachr. 292 (2019), no. 8, 1823–1836.
[40]L. Xu and P. Zhang, Enhanced dissipation for the third component of 3D anisotropic Navier-Stokes equations. J. Differential Equations 335 (2022), 464–496.
[42]Y. Ye, W. Wei and Y. Wang, Energy equality in the isentropic compressible Navier-Stokes equations allowing vacuum. J. Differential Equations 338 (2022), 551–571.
[44]Z. Zhang, Remarks on the energy equality for the non-Newtonian fluids. J. Math. Anal. Appl. 480 (2019), no. 2, 123443, 9 pp.DOI
[45]P. Zhang and W. Zhu, Continuous dependence on initial data for the solutions of 3-D anisotropic Navier-Stokes equations. J. Funct. Anal. 288 (2025), no. 1, Paper No. 110689, 36 pp.DOI
[47]D. Zhou and J. Wu, H^1-uniqueness, stability and decay for anisotropic Navier-Stokes and Boussinesq equations. J. Differential Equations, 453 (2026), 113930.DOI