WorksPhysics and Astronomy
Comment to: "Rewording Theoretical Predictions at Colliders with Vacuum Amplitudes"
Abstract
This comment highlights flaws in two central results presented by Ramírez-Uribe et al. in the titular letter, Phys. Rev. Lett. 133, 211901 (2024) [arXiv:2404.05491]. Firstly, the authors incorrectly claim that integrands of differential scattering cross-sections are obtained as single "residues" of vacuum amplitudes, although a sharp distinction of initial and final states requires to consider two iterated discontinuities. Secondly, they wrongly state that non-pinched thresholds always locally match in such a differential representation.
Residues of vacuum amplitudes
The authors of ref. [1]{1} propose a development of the idea of deriving integrands for interference diagrams from vacuum graphs [2, 3, 4, 5, 6]. At its core we find eqs. (R.4) and (R.5), which can be shown to be incorrect by means of a tree-level counterexample: . We apply eq. (R.5) to the computation of the residue of the cut of Figure 1b. In the rest frame of , we find{2}:
Figure 1. According to the authors of ref. [1], (a) is the residue of the cut in (b), but their kinematics are different.
where , and . Note that .
The correct result for the interference diagram of Figure 1a corresponds to eq. (1) but substituting the tilded Mandelstam invariants with their original expressions: and . Their mistake originates from the energy flow associated with the cut of the vacuum diagram, which is incompatible with that of the interference diagram. Ramírez-Uribe et al. appear to be partially aware of this fact, which explains their adjustment of the energy sign in eq. (R.8) () in order to obtain the correct phase-space integration measure. Even so, eq. (R.5) yields integrands with incorrect numerators and denominators for any diagram with singularities that are not -channel, making it unsuitable for any genuine process. Fixing this mistake, which affects energies and spatial momenta differently, requires significant conceptual novelties [4, 6, 7].
Threshold matching
The authors claim that “threshold singularities match locally among the different phase-space residues” and that “the local matching of thresholds requires phase-space residues with the same number of external particles and is not restricted by kinematical cuts.”. These statements are incorrect. Among other things, they would imply the observable-independent cancellation of Glauber modes, and make obsolete a wealth of literature concerning threshold regularisation [8, 9, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 15].
Consider as a counterexample the leading-order loop-induced decay process , mediated by a closed bottom-quark loop. A single phase-space residue (Figure 2b) contributes to eq. (R.4). Since , the diagram of Figure 2b has non-pinched threshold singularities associated with the production of two real bottom quarks. These thresholds cannot locally match against any other phase-space residue, since the cross-section only receives contributions from a single phase-space residue to begin with. In processes with final-state jets and kinematical cuts, the matching of non-pinched thresholds crucially depends on both the observable and phase-space point, whereas the matching of pinched threshold is guaranteed by the observable infrared-safety. In particular, eq. (R.17) does not hold in the presence of general observables for non-pinched thresholds. Furthermore, when the matching does occur, it generally involves phase-space residues with different multiplicities. This is the case for the two cut contributions shown in Figure 2c, part of the NLO QCD correction to the decay process .
Figure 2. From left to right: vacuum diagram cut, corresponding interference diagram for , and two interference diagrams for . Red lines in figs. 2b and 2c are Cutkosky cuts that involve the observable, and dashed lines denote non-pinched threshold singularities.
References
where the numerator is obtained by applying Feynman rules to the vacuum graph. We then use eq. (R.5) of the author’s letter to compute as:
with . This yields the incorrect expression for the interference contribution that we report in eq. (1), omitting coupling constants, colour, and averaging factors.
References
- [1]S. Ramírez-Uribe, P. K. Dhani, G. F. R. Sborlini, and G. Rodrigo, Rewording Theoretical Predictions at Colliders with Vacuum Amplitudes, Phys. Rev. Lett. 133, 211901 (2024), arXiv:2404.05491 [hep-ph].
- [2]T. Kinoshita, Mass singularities of Feynman amplitudes, J. Math. Phys. 3, 650 (1962).
- [3]G. F. Sterman, An Introduction to quantum field theory (Cambridge University Press, 1993).DOI
- [4]Z. Capatti, V. Hirschi, A. Pelloni, and B. Rujil, Local Unitarity: a representation of differential cross-sections that is locally free of infrared singularities at any order, JHEP 04, 104, arXiv:2010.01068 [hep-ph].DOI
- [5]T. Blažek and P. Maták, Cutting rules on a cylinder: a simplified diagrammatic approach to quantum kinetic theory, Eur. Phys. J. C 81, 1050 (2021), arXiv:2104.06395 [hep-ph].
- [6]Z. Capatti, Singularities of Feynman diagrams and their local cancellation in collider cross-sections, Ph.D. thesis, Zurich, ETH (2023), available from https://www.research-collection.ethz.ch/handle/20.500.11850/647466.DOI
- [7]Z. Capatti, L. Huber, and M. Ruf, Multi-partonic interactions, iterated discontinuities and the virtuality expansion in deep inelastic scattering, (2025), arXiv:2506.16489 [hep-ph].arxiv.org/abs/2506.16489
- [8]D. E. Soper, Techniques for QCD calculations by numerical integration, Phys. Rev. D 62, 014009 (2000), arXiv:hep-ph/9910292.DOI
- [9]W. Gong, Z. Nagy, and D. E. Soper, Direct numerical integration of one-loop Feynman diagrams for N-photon amplitudes, Phys. Rev. D 79, 033005 (2009), arXiv:0812.3686 [hep-ph].DOI
- [10]S. Becker and S. Weinzierl, Direct numerical integration for multi-loop integrals, Eur. Phys. J. C 73, 2321 (2013), arXiv:1211.0509 [hep-ph].DOI
- [11]S. Buchta, G. Chachamis, P. Draggotis, and G. Rodrigo, Numerical implementation of the loop-tree duality method, Eur. Phys. J. C 77, 274 (2017), arXiv:1510.00187 [hep-ph].arxiv.org/abs/1510.00187
- [12]Z. Capatti, V. Hirschi, D. Kermanschah, A. Pelloni, and B. Ruijl, Numerical Loop-Tree Duality: contour deformation and subtraction, JHEP 04, 096, arXiv:1912.09291 [hep-ph].DOI
- [13]D. Kermanschah, Numerical integration of loop integrals through local cancellation of threshold singularities, JHEP 01, 151, arXiv:2110.06869 [hep-ph].DOI
- [14]D. Kermanschah, Numerical integration of loop integrals in momentum space, Ph.D. thesis, Zurich, ETH (2022).DOI
- [15]M. Vicini and D. Kermanschah, Numerical integration of the double- and triple-box integrals using threshold subtraction, PoS LL2024, 078 (2024), arXiv:2407.21511 [hep-ph].arxiv.org/abs/2407.21511
- [17]Z. Capatti, Exposing the threshold structure of loop integrals, Phys. Rev. D 107, L051902 (2023), arXiv:2211.09653 [hep-th].DOI
- [18]Z. Capatti, V. Hirschi, D. Kermanschah, A. Pelloni, and B. Ruijl, Manifestly Causal Loop-Tree Duality, (2020), arXiv:2009.05509 [hep-ph].arxiv.org/abs/2009.05509
- [19]Z. Capatti, V. Hirschi, D. Kermanschah, and B. Ruijl, Loop-Tree Duality for Multiloop Numerical Integration, Phys. Rev. Lett. 123, 151602 (2019), arXiv:1906.06138 [hep-ph].DOI
- [20]R. Runkel, Z. Szőr, J. P. Vesga, and S. Weinzierl, Causality and loop-tree duality at higher loops, Phys. Rev. Lett. 122, 111603 (2019).
- [21]I. Bierenbaum, S. Catani, P. Draggiotis, and G. Rodrigo, A Tree-Loop Duality Relation at Two Loops and Beyond, JHEP 10, 073, arXiv:1007.0194 [hep-ph].
- [22]S. Catani, T. Gleisberg, F. Krauss, G. Rodrigo, and J.-C. Winter, From loops to trees by-passing Feynman’s theorem, JHEP 09, 065, arXiv:0804.3170 [hep-ph].

