WorksPhysics and Astronomy
Decoupled asymmetric thin-shell wormholes
Abstract
We construct reflection-asymmetric thin-shell wormholes by joining a Schwarzschild exterior to its minimal geometric deformation, which shares the same mass and redshift function, so that the asymmetry is carried entirely by the gravitational-decoupling sector. The deformed side is a black hole sourced by a scalar field coupled to nonlinear electrodynamics, in its branch with a real scalar. We show that the total radial null energy of shell and bulk obeys an exact identity and becomes positive for a sufficiently strong deformation. The momentum flux across the shell equals the radial null-energy density of the bulk, and retaining it yields the linear stability condition in closed form. We prove that stability with a conventional shell response requires the bulk to violate the radial null energy condition at the throat; the deformation instead enlarges the stable domain and moves the transition radius inside the photon sphere. For a stationary extension built on Kerr, the junction is solved exactly in the spin, which fixes how the angular momentum is shared between shell and bulk and where the shell behaves as a rotating fluid. A free-precession model provides an estimate of the gravitational-wave signal of the throat.
Introduction
Traversable wormholes are globally nontrivial geometries connecting two otherwise separated spacetime regions. In four-dimensional general relativity, the flare-out condition forces a violation of the null energy condition (NEC) in a neighborhood of a smooth throat [2, 3] [1]. The cut-and-paste construction of Visser [4, 5] confines all the exotic stress energy to a timelike hypersurface, whose dynamics is governed by the Darmois–Israel equations [6, 7]. Thin-shell wormholes are therefore clean laboratories in which the global geometry and the material properties of the throat can be separated. Their linearized radial stability was first analysed by Poisson and Visser Poisson and Visser [8] and has since been extended to charged and cosmological exteriors [9, 10, 11], to higher dimensions [12], and to general dynamic thin shells [13, 14, 15]. Alternative surface equations of state, including Chaplygin and generalized Chaplygin gases, provide complementary stability analyses that emphasize the role of the shell constitutive law [16, 17]. Regular-black hole backgrounds have also been used to examine the response of thin shells to radial perturbations [18]. The matching of wormhole interiors to exterior vacua through thin shells [19, 20, 21], and the analogous treatment of gravastars [22], have shown how the energy conditions on the shell constrain the construction. The distinction between negative local surface density and integrated matter measures has also been explored for non-spherical thin-shell geometries [23].
Most constructions identify two copies of the same exterior. Reflection symmetry is not demanded by the junction formalism, and joining different geometries enlarges the parameter space and changes the mechanical problem of the throat [15, 24]. In the usual implementation, however, the two sides differ in their masses, charges or cosmological constants, which mixes the effect of the asymmetry with that of different asymptotic data. When the redshift and shape functions of a side differ, the shell also exchanges momentum with the bulk, a feature emphasized in the generic analysis of Ref. [15]. In particular, the asymmetric construction and its variable surface equation of state were already treated systematically in Ref. [24]; the present work does not claim asymmetry or the existence of a flux term as new in themselves. Its distinction is the controlled comparison of a Schwarzschild exterior with its radial deformed image, while keeping the redshift function and ADM mass fixed.
Gravitational decoupling (GD), and in particular its minimal geometric deformation (MGD) version [26, 27, 28, 29], offers a controlled way to produce such an asymmetry. Originally devised in the brane-world context [30, 31, 32, 33], the method has since been developed into a general scheme for anisotropic sources, together with its extended, inverse and lower-dimensional versions and its relation to the complexity of self-gravitating systems [34, 35, 36, 37, 38, 39, 40]. It has produced hairy, rotating and field-sourced black holes [41, 42, 43, 44, 45, 46, 47] and stellar configurations of fundamental fields and hybrid stars [48, 49, 50], and the geodesics, quasinormal modes and spectroscopy, thermodynamics, information and entanglement entropies and conformal anomalies of the resulting black holes have been analysed [51, 52, 53, 54, 55, 56, 57, 58, 59, 60]. GD has also been connected with quantum gravity [61], with analog gravity in fluid flows [62] and with the holographic description of the quark–gluon plasma [63]. Also, MGD has been used to construct and deform wormhole geometries [64]. Here we ask a sharper question: what thin-shell physics results when the two exteriors glued at the throat are a black hole and its own MGD image, with the same mass and the same redshift function? We answer it for a Schwarzschild seed and an explicit deformed exterior: the black hole sourced by a scalar field coupled to nonlinear electrodynamics constructed in Ref. [65]. Its solution space has two branches, and we glue the one whose matter sector is best behaved, with a real scalar field and a regular electromagnetic coupling.
The main results are the following. For a Schwarzschild seed the decoupling sector reduces to algebraic identities that give the bulk energy conditions in closed form. The total radial null-energy quantifier of shell and bulk obeys an exact identity in which the throat value of the deformation cancels. The momentum flux across the shell equals the radial null-energy density of the bulk at the throat, and with it the linear stability condition takes a closed form that depends on the deformation only through the ratio of this flux to the surface density. We prove that stability with a shell response in the interval requires the bulk to violate the radial NEC at the throat, determine how the adopted branch modifies the stability domain, and show that two profiles with the same slope at the throat have identical linear stability but different finite-amplitude behaviour. Finally, for a circular stationary extension in which the deformed side is built on Kerr, we solve the junction exactly in the spin, compute the Komar angular momentum and its distribution between shell and bulk, and determine where the rotating shell admits an interpretation as a surface fluid. We then recompute the Newtonian inertia of the shell and use it in a free-precession model, in the spirit of Ref. [66], to estimate the gravitational signal of a precessing throat. Rotating thin shells assembled from Kerr exteriors were studied in Ref. [67], while counter-rotating low-dimensional shells were considered in Ref. [68].
The paper is organized as follows. Section II presents the decoupling sector for a Schwarzschild seed, the deformed exterior and its energy conditions. Section III builds the asymmetric thin-shell wormhole and establishes the exotic-matter identity. Section IV contains the radial dynamics, the closed-form stability condition and its consequences. Section V develops the stationary extension, its junction and angular-momentum budget, the inertia of the shell and a free-precession estimate of its gravitational signal. Section VI summarizes the results, and Appendix A contains the expansion of the inertia tensor. We use signature and units .
The deformed exterior
Decoupling sector for a Schwarzschild seed
In MGD the total source is and only the radial potential of the seed is deformed [28]. For the vacuum seed ,
where is the integration constant of the closure and its radial profile. Since for Schwarzschild, the quasi-Einstein equations of the decoupling sector collapse to
which satisfy the separate conservation law identically. With , the null and strong combinations follow without solving anything,
Outside the horizon the radial NEC is controlled by the sign of alone.
The deformed exterior is the one of Ref. [65], generated by the linear closure , which with Eqs. (2) integrates to with . In terms of
the deformation is fixed by the falloff exponent , the length and the amplitude , whose sign is that of . We take , so that , and , so that and both ends of the wormhole will have ADM mass . The source is the Lagrangian , with and , for which the closure holds identically when and . A canonical scalar, , selects for every ; the representative case has and
Admissibility, energy conditions and the regular branch
On the deformed side we retain . The geometry is Lorentzian, horizon free and regular there if for all ; since in Eq. (4) is monotonic, this reduces to , a weaker requirement than the single-horizon condition of the black hole, . For both are satisfied for every throat.
With , Eqs. (3) become
For the scalar–vector source one finds and . In the canonical case this gives
so the two branches of Ref. [65] are the two signs of , uniformly in . For the scalar is real, regular for and tends to a constant as ; the price is , which is the failure of the odd-parity criterion [69, 70] and, by the same identity, a tangential NEC violation. For the vector coupling has the correct sign but : the scalar is imaginary, the radial NEC is violated throughout the exterior, and the bulk already supplies the kind of matter that supports wormholes by itself. We adopt the branch , which we call the regular branch; the name refers to the reality of the scalar field and to the regularity of the geometry and of the electromagnetic coupling in the retained region. In it the radial NEC holds everywhere in the bulk, decreases monotonically from to , and the energy density is non-negative for ; a throat placed beyond that radius leaves a deformed exterior with and .
Steeper profiles improve the effective fluid further. For and , Eqs. (6) give for , for , everywhere, wherever because , and
Since exceeds the other two radii, a throat at leaves a bulk satisfying the null, weak and dominant energy conditions, the strong one being violated by the last of Eqs. (6). These profiles correspond to , for which a real action requires , and are treated here as effective fluids.
Asymmetric thin-shell wormhole
Junction conditions and surface sources
Let be Schwarzschild and its deformed counterpart,
From each manifold we remove and identify the boundaries , whose induced metric is [5, 8]. The first junction condition requires only the intrinsic geometry to agree: the proper time and the areal radius of the shell are common, while the coordinate times are fixed on each side separately by
Figure 1. Euclidean embeddings of constant-time equatorial sections of the reflection-asymmetric thin-shell wormhole for and . The Schwarzschild exterior (blue) and the MGD exterior (orange) are joined at . Their respective radial metric functions are and , where and . The left panel shows the meridional profiles, and the right panel their surfaces of revolution.
and need not coincide since are unrelated coordinates of different manifolds. The unit normals point from the shell into the respective exteriors, , and with the extrinsic curvatures are
The Lanczos equations , with and , give
The sum of the two square roots is the signature of gluing two exterior regions. The construction is traversable for and , and the areal radius has a minimum at .
The reflection asymmetry can also be displayed geometrically by embedding constant-time equatorial sections of the two static exteriors into Euclidean three-space. For , their induced two-metrics are
A surface of revolution with cylindrical coordinates has the Euclidean line element . Equating the two line elements gives
with . The opposite signs distinguish the outward-directed embeddings of the two exterior regions, joined at the common throat. Figure 1 uses the profile (5) to illustrate how a purely radial MGD deformation changes the spatial embedding while leaving the redshift function and asymptotic mass unchanged. These Euclidean embeddings exist wherever ; the condition is satisfied over the plotted range for the parameters chosen. The figure represents the static geometry, not the stationary rotating extension.
The matter fields of the decoupling sector live on only, and the shell must source them. This is implemented by adding to the action the surface terms , which produce the jump conditions below. For the static configuration the vector equation integrates to , and with , ,
so the shell carries the whole charge. For the representative model , which coincides with for the electromagnetic invariant and coupling function reconstructed in Ref. [65]. The scalar requires a surface density equal to the jump of its normal derivative,
which is real in the regular branch.
Static shell and exotic-matter balance
At we write , , and . Equations (12) reduce to
The ratio is independent of the deformation, because the common redshift function makes the deformation rescale both static curvature components on the minus side by . The density is negative for every admissible throat, so the weak and dominant energy conditions fail on the shell, whereas the surface NEC, , holds for and is saturated at the photon sphere independently of [20, 21].
The surface density and the surface NEC are different indicators, and the volume combinations of the bulk are a third. To compare the shell and the bulk on the same footing we use the radial combination, in the spirit of the volume-integral quantifier of Ref. [71], for which a thin shell contributes with vanishing radial pressure and the proper normal distance. The radial quantifier is a specific combination defined on the static slice, with its proper volume element, rather than a universal invariant measure of exotic matter:
the first term from and the second from , since is vacuum. By Eq. (3) the bulk integrand is . Integration by parts produces the throat term , which cancels the explicit dependence of the shell term, and a term at infinity that vanishes because for . The result is the identity
valid for any MGD profile with that falloff. The explicit boundary dependence on cancels, which does not make independent of the deformation: the integral retains a functional dependence on the whole profile on ; for a monotonic profile the sign of is the sign of .
For the regular branch the two contributions move in opposite directions. The shell becomes more exotic, being times the symmetric value, while the bulk, whose is positive, more than compensates. At first order in the deformation Eq. (19) can be integrated in closed form for the representative model, with and .
which gives , and at , and . At finite deformation changes sign at , and for the same throats. Beyond these values the radial null energy of the configuration as a whole is positive. This statement concerns the radial combination only: the shell density remains negative and the tangential NEC remains violated in the bulk, so the exotic character of the configuration is redistributed rather than removed. Figure 2 shows both quantifiers together with the direct evaluation of Eq. (18).
Figure 2. Radial null-energy quantifiers in units of the symmetric value , as functions of the deformation strength for the representative model (5) with . Solid: shell contribution . Dashed: shell plus deformed bulk from the identity (19). Circles: direct evaluation of the definition (18). The total quantifier vanishes at .
Radial dynamics and linear stability
The analysis of this section concerns the static, spherically symmetric wormhole of Sec. III and perturbations that preserve its symmetry, with the two exteriors held fixed, in the framework of Refs. [8, 10, 11, 15].
Equation of motion and momentum flux
The first of Eqs. (12) contains only through . With , it gives , and since , also . Adding the squares,
where . This is the asymmetric generalization of the Poisson–Visser potential [8, 24]: the last term, quadratic in the asymmetry, vanishes for . Equation (21) determines the motion once is known, and is fixed by the conservation of the surface stress tensor.
The contracted Gauss–Codazzi equations give , where are the tangent vectors of [7, 15]. Its component, with , involves , which vanishes on . On , with and and the normal of Sec. III,
so only the radial null combination of the bulk crosses the shell. Dividing by , the conservation law reads
where the second form uses Eq. (3). The first term is the adiabatic work of the surface pressure, and is the momentum flux delivered by the bulk. It is not an additional assumption on the shell matter: it vanishes only where , which for a radial MGD means , a condition incompatible with a nontrivial asymptotically flat deformation. Equivalently, writing the deformed metric as with , the flux is , the form given in Ref. [15]. In the regular branch and the flux is positive.
Since , the flux is a function of and , and Eq. (23) with a surface equation of state is a closed first-order equation for . We characterize the equation of state near equilibrium by
with for a barotropic shell. For ordinary matter would be the squared speed of sound, which motivated the interval in the early analyses [8]. For exotic shell matter the microscopic meaning of is not settled, and we use it as a response coefficient, with as the conventional benchmark.
At the static radius the stresses (17) satisfy by construction, and by virtue of the flux: with and , one finds , and holds only when is included. If the flux is dropped while , and the equation of state are kept,
and the configuration that would be perturbed in that approximation is not an equilibrium. A natural measure of the flux is its ratio to the surface density,
which is the only combination of the deformation that will appear in the stability condition. Since , has the sign opposite to that of at the throat.
Closed-form stability condition
A small departure from equilibrium obeys , so the throat is linearly stable when and then oscillates with proper frequency . To compute we use , which turns the first of Eqs. (12) into . Two derivatives evaluated at an equilibrium, where , give
The second derivative of follows from Eq. (23) and the definitions (24),
On the static profile , and because the derivative of along the trajectory coincides with that of at ; hence there. The term produced by this derivative cancels exactly the term in , and the second derivative of the deformation drops out. Collecting terms we obtain the following result,
and for the Schwarzschild seed, using and ,
The structure of Eq. (29) is transparent. The first two terms describe the curvature of the background as felt by the shell; the third is the response of the shell matter, weighted by , to the slope of the static density, since along the family of static configurations; the last term is the explicit radius dependence of the equation of state, which always acts in favour of stability for . In Eq. (30), is proportional to the slope of the static density, , and collects the background curvature and the flux. For one has and Eqs. (30)–(31) reduce to the result of Poisson and Visser [8]; for they give . We have checked Eqs. (30)–(31) symbolically against the direct second derivative of Eq. (21).
Two general features follow. First, the throat physics depends on the closure hierarchically: fixes the static stresses, fix the flux and, through , the linear stability, while the whole profile on fixes admissibility, the total exotic content and the finite-amplitude motion. Second, for a barotropic shell the stability condition reads
while at the condition does not involve and reduces to ; the division defining is never used there. The radius where vanishes separates the two regimes. It is the photon sphere for , where the static density is extremal, and it moves when the flux is present. As a function of , is strictly decreasing on each side of , since .
Now we define
which satisfy and for all . So, using the previous result with : (i) a linearly stable throat with some exists if and only if , the window being ; (ii) it is stable for every if and only if ; (iii) if every stable configuration has or . Since and , a window requires , that is, at the throat: the bulk must violate the radial NEC there, and for the scalar–vector source the scalar is imaginary by Eq. (16).
The above implies that the inequalities among , and follow from and , and because has no real roots. Direct substitution gives at and at . For one has , so stability requires , and monotonicity gives ; this proves (i) and, together with for , (ii). For there are three cases: if then and , so ; if then monotonicity gives and stability requires ; if then and the throat is unstable. This proves (iii).
The above statements hold for any radial MGD deformation of Schwarzschild, whatever the closure, and it gives the mechanical meaning of the windows: the momentum flux must be directed so as to make the slope of the static density positive while keeping the curvature term small, and this requires negative radial null energy to cross the shell. The symmetric wormhole, with , is the familiar case without such windows [8, 11], and the obstruction persists for every deformation whose bulk satisfies the radial NEC at the throat. In the model (4) the windows would require with , far beyond the single-horizon bound of the black hole.
For the regular branch,
and Figure 3 shows that this band lies entirely below . The deformation nevertheless reshapes the stability domain in two ways. The transition radius moves inside the photon sphere: decreases monotonically with , being , and for , and in the representative model, and tends to the root of as , which for and is . And for , where stability requires , the threshold rises with the deformation from its Schwarzschild value towards the bound
Figure 3. The plane of throat radius and flux parameter of Eq. (26). Dotted: , the transition between the two stability regimes. Solid and dashed: the thresholds and of Eq. (33). A window of stability with exists only in the shaded region above . The band below the axis is the range (34) spanned by the regular branch of the representative model.
which is the limit of Eq. (32). At , for example, for Schwarzschild and for . The stable domain is enlarged, but it never reaches the interval . Figure 4 displays the regions evaluated directly from Eq. (30), and Table I compares the two branches of the deformed exterior once glued to Schwarzschild.
Figure 4. Regions of linear stability, , for a barotropic shell in the representative model (5): (a) symmetric Schwarzschild wormhole, ; (b) ; (c) . The solid curve is , the dotted line the transition radius , and , and the band marks .
Finite-amplitude motion
Linear stability does not determine the size of the basin. To probe it we give the throat a radial velocity at . The equation of motion requires , so the initial density is fixed by the first of Eqs. (12), , and the shell obeys the linear barotropic law , with the static values of Eq. (17) held fixed for the whole family of initial data. Equation (23), flux included, is integrated inwards and outwards from and the potential (21) is built from the solution. Small-velocity perturbations of thin-shell wormholes have also been considered for regular Hayward exteriors [18]; here the finite-amplitude analysis retains the momentum flux associated with the radial MGD deformation. The motion is confined to , and it is an oscillation when two turning points bracket within the admissible domain. Along each solution the tangential pressure computed from the second of Eqs. (12), with and , reproduces the equation of state to a relative accuracy better than , so the trajectories satisfy the full set of junction conditions. The critical velocity at which one of the barriers disappears is stable to six digits under changes of the integration tolerance and of the sampling of .
| regular branch, | |||
| Geometry | |||
| throat value | |||
| single-horizon black hole exterior | for all | only for | |
| Bulk energy conditions | |||
| for | for | ||
| Field theory | scalar field | real | imaginary |
| Exotic matter | shell content, | larger | smaller |
| total radial quantifier | larger, positive for large | more negative | |
| Radial stability | momentum flux | ||
| transition radius | |||
| window | none | if |
Table 1. Properties of the asymmetric wormhole for the two branches of the canonical model , grouped by type. Comparisons refer to the symmetric Schwarzschild wormhole with the same throat radius.
Figure 5(a) shows the result for , and , a configuration that is linearly stable by Eq. (32). The well deepens with until, at , the inner barrier disappears; just below it the shell oscillates between and . The potential depends on the initial velocity through and on the chosen equation of state, so the critical velocity characterizes the pair formed by the exteriors and this surface-matter prescription. Figure 5(b) tests the hierarchy of the previous subsection within the same prescription, with identical , and . The profile with and has the same and as the representative profile with , but instead of . The two give the same , but different critical velocities, and : for an initial velocity between them the throat oscillates with and collapses with .
Figure 5. Effective potential of the moving throat for a linear barotropic shell with and ; the motion takes place where . (a) Representative model with and initial velocities , and , the critical value being . (b) Profiles and with equal and and different (see text), for , between their critical velocities; the inner barrier exists only for .
Stationary extension
A circular stationary ansatz and its effective source
Stationary, axisymmetric wormholes are conveniently described by circular metrics, in which the Killing fields and are orthogonal to a family of two-surfaces [72]. Such a metric is not determined by its static limit: the static exterior of § 1.1 is the limit of many stationary families, and generating techniques such as the Newman–Janis [73] and Gürses–Gürsey algorithms [74] or the procedure of Azreg-Aïnou [75] each select one of them, which in general does not solve the field equations of a given matter sector. We do not use a generating technique. We prescribe a circular extension by a physical requirement: both ends must keep the same mass and the same angular momentum, so that, as in the static case, the asymmetry is confined to the radial potential.
Denote by the Kerr rotation parameter, , and , . We keep as Kerr and take for the metric whose components , , and are those of Kerr with the same and , while
This defines a family of circular stationary metrics, exact in , which is one choice among many with the same static limit. Its source is an effective anisotropic tensor; it does not by itself identify the scalar–vector matter of the static solution, and whether the scalar–vector action admits rotating fields producing it is a separate question. For the metric is Kerr and the source vanishes; for it reduces to Eq. (1) with the source of § 1.1. Since and the Kerr ergosurface lies at , the retained region contains neither horizon nor ergoregion; with and , , bounded on , all metric functions are smooth there, so the curvature invariants are finite, and the junction surface is timelike.
Since the metric (36) depends only on and and is invariant under the simultaneous inversion , the components , , and vanish identically. The remaining off-diagonal component of the meridional block vanishes as well: a direct calculation gives for an arbitrary profile and to all orders in . The effective source therefore shares the circular structure of Kerr, and its off-diagonal components are confined to the block. Because , the covariant and mixed components of this block, , and , differ from one another, and we characterize the source through its components in the orthonormal frame of the zero-angular-momentum observers (ZAMOs),
in which has the diagonal components , , , and the single off-diagonal component . Since the metric is invariant under , the diagonal frame components are even in and is odd. The diagonal components therefore coincide with those of the static anisotropic fluid of Eqs. (3) up to , and the leading new quantity is an azimuthal momentum density,
The mixed component follows from , valid at first order with the Kerr frame dragging . At second order the diagonal components are corrected and ; the Ricci scalar, for instance, is
which vanishes for and reduces to the static value for .
Along the combination is , unchanged up to . Along the azimuthal null directions ,
so rotation splits the tangential NEC according to the sense of motion, by an amount of first order in the spin. In the regular branch , and for slow rotation both azimuthal combinations remain negative: the effective source of the stationary extension inherits, point by point, the energy-condition pattern of the static one.
Junction, angular momentum and the rotating shell
The junction surface is , with intrinsic coordinates . Since the metrics have no components, the unit normal pointing towards increasing is on either side, and for it for all intrinsic components, including . The induced metrics of the two sides coincide, so the first junction condition holds, and the extrinsic curvature of computed with this normal is times that of Kerr, , because only differs. In the wormhole the physical normals point into and respectively, that is, towards increasing on both sheets but with opposite orientation relative to ; hence , and . The Lanczos equations then give
exactly in and for every covariant component, where is the surface stress tensor of the symmetric Kerr–Kerr wormhole [67]; indices are raised with the common induced metric , so the same factor multiplies the mixed components. On the shell we use the ZAMO basis of , , , , with and . The energy density measured by these observers is
with and the Kerr functions at ; for this is the density of Ref. [67]. It is a frame component, not an eigenvalue of ; the two coincide only where the matter is at rest with respect to the ZAMOs.
Angular momentum. The Komar angular momentum of a closed two-surface is [76]
where has period , is the future unit normal of the slice , is the unit normal of within the slice pointing towards the asymptotic region of the sheet considered, and ; with this orientation for every sphere of Kerr. Since is a Killing field, , and for a sphere the integrand reduces to
In Eq. (36) every factor except is that of Kerr, so the integrand is times the Kerr integrand at every point of the sphere, and
exactly in . On the Komar angular momentum is for every sphere. Consider a slice consisting of the two sheets joined at , bounded by the spheres at infinity of and , where on both since . Stokes’ theorem applied to the Komar two-form states that the sum of the two boundary values, , equals the angular momentum of everything in between, the shell plus the deformed bulk. The shell contribution is the sum of the values of on the two faces of , each evaluated with the normal pointing into its own sheet, and the bulk contribution is :
The shell value is confirmed independently by the Israel surface current,
which we have evaluated with the exact surface stress tensor at finite spin; both routes agree to all orders in . The bulk value is the Komar integral of the effective source. In the regular branch it is negative; this states how the total angular momentum is shared, and does not by itself define a local sense of rotation of the bulk. The local quantity is the ZAMO momentum density (38), negative for .
Rotating surface fluid. The shell admits an interpretation as a rotating surface fluid if has a timelike eigenvector. In the ZAMO basis , and the block has the components , and . The eigenvalue problem , with indices raised by , gives , whose discriminant is . The block has two real eigenvalues with a timelike eigenvector, and is of Hawking–Ellis type I [77], if and only if
for the eigenvalues are complex and the tensor is of type IV. By Eq. (41) all three quantities carry the factor , so the domain where Eq. (48) holds is that of the Kerr–Kerr shell and is independent of the deformation. The condition depends on and is imposed at every point of . It fails only in a band of radii around the photon sphere, where vanishes while does not; the band is widest at the equator and narrows towards the poles, where , so the set of throats for which the fluid interpretation fails somewhere on is the equatorial band. It is , and for , and , with half-width to leading order; at , for comparison, it reduces to for . Inside the band the geometry is regular and only the fluid interpretation of the shell is lost.
Outside the band the timelike eigenvector defines the angular velocity of the shell matter. At first order in the spin it is independent of ,
and of the deformation; the dependence, a differential rotation of the shell, appears at order . The denominator reflects the band: the expansion is not uniform near , and Eq. (49) applies for large compared to the band width. At the same order the budget (46) and the angular velocity are related by , with the relativistic moment of inertia
which is weighted by the surface enthalpy of the static shell. This is an identity at first order in . For , where and , the shell matter rotates against the local inertial frames while carrying positive angular momentum.
A second extension. Demanding instead on gives, at first order, , so and the Komar angular momentum is constant on . Continuity of the induced metric then forces , which is smaller than one in the regular branch, and the shell carries . This shows that the static limit does not select a unique rotation. The static results of Secs. III and IV are common to both extensions, as are the first-order matter angular velocity and the type-I analysis due to the value of on each side; the rescaling (41), the equality of the asymptotic angular momenta and the budget (46) belong to the ansatz (36).
Inertia of the shell and the radial mode
Two different notions of inertia can be attached to the rotating shell. The relativistic moment of inertia (50) is the response of the angular momentum of the shell to its rotation relative to the local inertial frames. A Newtonian inertia tensor, of the kind used in Ref. [66] to describe the precession of the Kerr–Kerr shell, is an auxiliary descriptor of the surface distribution, , which requires positions for the points of and a choice of area element. Following Ref. [66] we represent as the oblate spheroid , of the flat Boyer–Lindquist background, weight it with the ZAMO density (42), which is negative, and use the proper area element . Expanding to second order in (Appendix A),
The deformation enters and only through the overall factor , which cancels in . The moments are negative because , and the positive ellipticity reflects the oblate shape of a distribution of negative energy. These values depend on the representation: with the area element of the flat spheroid, used in Ref. [66], , and other embeddings give other values. The ellipticity quoted in Ref. [66] corresponds to the flat element; the reconstruction of the two integrals in Appendix A shows that it differs from the flat-element value because of the weight of the part of the density in . The gravitational quadrupole of each asymptotic end is the Geroch–Hansen moment of Kerr, [78, 79], independent of the throat; the shell quadrupole defined by is a different object, and it is not the radiative quadrupole of either end.
The radial degree of freedom of the throat is described dynamically by Sec. IV. In the static configuration on both sides by Eq. (10), since the redshift function is common, so the proper frequency of the linear radial mode is seen at either infinity as
for a barotropic shell, where restores the units. This is the frequency of spherical radial oscillations of the static throat between fixed exteriors, defined where the throat is stable. It is not a polar mode of the rotating system, and a purely spherical pulsation does not radiate quadrupolar waves; a radiative signal at this frequency would require its coupling to nonspherical multipoles in the rotating geometry. In the regular branch, Figure 6 gives – for between and ; for , and , , that is .
Figure 6. Frequency at infinity of the linear radial mode of the static throat, Eq. (52), in the regular branch of the representative model (5), for (solid), (dashed) and (dotted). (a) As a function of the throat radius at fixed . (b) As a function of at . Curves are drawn where the throat is linearly stable. In physical units .
A free-precession estimate
The stationary configuration has a timelike Killing field and emits no gravitational radiation; rotation about the symmetry axis is not radiative. A precessing throat is a different, nonstationary configuration. To estimate its signal we adopt, in the spirit of Ref. [66], the following phenomenological model, which is an additional dynamical hypothesis rather than a consequence of the stationary solution: the shell moves as a rigid axisymmetric body with the inertia tensor (51) and angular momentum ; its symmetry axis is tilted by an angle with respect to , no torque acts on it, and the radiation is computed with the quadrupole formula, neglecting radiation reaction. The exteriors are not perturbed self-consistently, so the estimate is not derived from the linearized field equations and junction conditions.
For an axisymmetric body the torque-free Euler equations give a symmetry axis
which precesses about at the inertial rate [80]. With Eqs. (46) and (51),
independent of the deformation; the negative sign, a consequence of , means that the axis precesses against . This rate is a property of the rigid-body model; it is neither the frame-dragging rate nor the matter angular velocity , and the body-frame rate , with the spin about the symmetry axis, is not the frequency seen by a distant observer. The trace-free quadrupole of the body,
rotates rigidly with , and the quadrupole formula at distance gives, for an observer at inclination with respect to and the usual polarization basis,
The signal has the harmonics and , with amplitudes proportional to and respectively, as for freely precessing rigid bodies [81, 82]. It vanishes for , when the body merely spins about its symmetry axis, and for ; for it reduces to the Kerr–Kerr model. Restoring units,
The deformation enters only through the factor relative to the Kerr–Kerr shell, through and , while the frequencies do not depend on it. Both quantities are shown in Figure 7. For , , and , Eq. (57) gives and, at , ; with the two harmonics reach at and at , respectively. With the flat area element the amplitude is smaller by the factor , about 10% at , which measures the representation dependence of the estimate.
Figure 7. Free-precession estimate of Sec. V.D. (a) Amplitude scale of Eq. (57), normalized to , with the proper (solid) and flat (dashed) area elements. (b) Precession rate Eq. (54) normalized to . The shaded band is the interval where the surface stress tensor is of type IV somewhere on the shell, shown for .
These figures are conditional on the model and set its domain. The expansion requires ( in the example) and a throat outside the band where the shell is not a fluid. The quadrupole formula assumes a weak field in the generation region, which a throat at does not provide, and it ignores backscattering, the coupling to the effective bulk matter and the presence of two asymptotic regions, each of which receives radiation. Radiation reaction is neglected: at fixed the fraction of angular momentum radiated per precession cycle scales as . Within these limits Eq. (57) is an order-of-magnitude estimate of the signal of a precessing throat, not a prediction derived from the exact solution.
Conclusions
We have constructed thin-shell wormholes whose two sides are a Schwarzschild exterior and its MGD, with the same mass and the same redshift function. The asymmetry of the throat is then a property of the decoupling sector alone, and the deformed side was chosen as the best-behaved black hole available in the scalar–vector family, with a real scalar field and a regular electromagnetic coupling.
The construction yields three structural results that do not depend on the particular closure. The total radial null energy of shell and bulk obeys an exact identity in which the value of the deformation at the throat drops out, so that a shell made more or less exotic by the deformation is compensated in the bulk; for the regular branch the configuration as a whole acquires positive radial null energy once the deformation is large enough, while its tangential and surface exotic character remains. The momentum that the bulk transfers to a moving shell is precisely its radial null-energy density, and the radial stability of the throat is governed by the ratio of this flux to the surface density, which makes linear stability blind to the curvature of the profile while the finite-amplitude basin is not. The stability with a shell response in the conventional interval demands that negative radial null energy flow into the shell, so that it cannot be obtained by gluing a black hole exterior whose bulk satisfies the radial null energy condition; what such a deformation does instead is enlarge the stable domain and move the transition between the two stability regimes inside the photon sphere.
For the stationary extension that keeps the same mass and angular momentum on both sides, the junction is solved exactly in the spin, with the shell being the Kerr–Kerr shell rescaled by the same factor that governs its static exotic content. The Komar angular momentum on the deformed side is the Kerr value weighted by the square root of the deformation, which fixes exactly how the angular momentum is shared between shell and bulk, and the shell is a rotating surface fluid everywhere except in a band around the photon sphere whose width depends on the spin but not on the deformation. The two routes to the angular momentum of the shell, through the Komar integral and through the surface current, agree to all orders in the spin.
The Newtonian inertia tensor used in previous estimates of precessional emission has been recomputed and shown to depend on the representation of the throat, which corrects the ellipticity quoted before and identifies it as an auxiliary descriptor. Used within a rigid-body model of free precession, it gives a signal at the precession rate and its second harmonic whose frequencies are blind to the deformation, while the amplitude carries the same rescaling as the surface stresses. The deformation thus leaves on the rotating throat a clean multiplicative imprint, set by its value at the junction.
Because both exteriors share the mass, the redshift function and, in the stationary extension, the angular momentum of Schwarzschild or Kerr, the asymmetric wormhole is locally indistinguishable from a black hole for observables tied to the exterior geometry alone, such as the photon ring or orbital dynamics far from the throat. Its imprint must therefore be sought in the dynamics of the throat itself. A stable throat oscillating radially, or a precessing rotating shell, would emit at characteristic frequencies fixed by the mass, the spin and the throat radius. For stellar-mass objects these lie in the band of the ground-based detectors, from tens of hertz for precession to kilohertz for radial oscillations. Continuous-wave searches by LIGO, Virgo and KAGRA, and the higher sensitivity expected from the Einstein Telescope and Cosmic Explorer, could constrain such signals, while echoes in the ringdown of compact-object mergers offer a complementary window on any reflecting structure near the photon sphere. In this model the deformation leaves the frequencies unchanged and acts on the amplitude through a single factor set at the junction. Measuring a frequency together with an amplitude would thus, in principle, separate the geometric parameters of the throat from the strength of the decoupling sector. Although these expectations are speculative, they show that thin-shell wormholes built by GD make definite, falsifiable statements about the throat that do not rely on any deviation of the exterior from general relativity.
More broadly, this work establishes GD as a controlled tool for building asymmetric junctions: it fixes the asymptotic data and the causal structure of both sides and isolates the physics of the throat in a single, separately conserved sector. This opens a research line along several natural directions. The same construction can be applied to charged, cosmological and regular black hole seeds, and to other closures of the decoupling sector, to map how the exotic content, the momentum flux and the stability windows depend on the matter that supports the deformation. Thin shells joining a deformed exterior to other interiors, such as gravastars and regular cores, can be treated with the same identities. Promoting the fixed-background treatment to the coupled Einstein–scalar–vector problem, with the field junction conditions imposed on the moving shell, will test the stability results against perturbations of the decoupling sector. Deriving the stationary extension from an axisymmetric decoupling will turn the rotating ansatz into a solution of a definite theory. Finally, the linearized field equations around the slowly rotating configuration, with linearized junction conditions that include the displacement of the shell and outgoing radiation at both ends, will replace the free-precession model by a fully relativistic calculation of the gravitational-wave signal. Together, these steps would turn the asymmetric wormhole into a concrete benchmark for confronting exotic compact objects with gravitational-wave observations.
Acknowledgments
The work of Kazuharu Bamba was supported in part by the JSPS KAKENHI Grant No. 25KF0176 and a grant-in-aid of academic research of Yamaguchi Scholarship Foundation.
Inertia tensor of the rotating shell
This appendix collects the expansion of the Newtonian inertia tensor of the rotating shell used in § 1.4. We expand the density measured by the zero-angular-momentum observers to second order in the spin and integrate it over the oblate spheroid that represents the throat, first with the area element of the flat spheroid and then with the proper area element induced on the junction surface. Writing both integrals with their angular weights makes explicit which terms fix the ellipticity, how the deformation factors out of every ratio, and how the result depends on the representation of the throat. The same decomposition allows a term-by-term reconstruction of the integrals of Ref. [66], which identifies the origin of the difference with the ellipticity quoted there.
To second order in , the density (42) multiplied by has the form
For the spheroid of § 1.4, gives for and for . The flat area element of this spheroid is , so that . The angular integrals needed are
the first for the terms and the second for the term of . Integrating over and ,
where the term enters with the average of the weights and , and with the weight . The isotropic coefficient cancels in the ellipticity, which is .
The proper area element of differs from the flat one by the term in , . With the weights
this adds to the bracket of and to that of , so that , and gives Eq. (51). The factor of multiplies all moments and drops out of every ratio. We have checked both results against a direct numerical integration of the exact density with the exact area elements.
The area element used in Ref. [66] is the flat one, written there as with , and its expansion of the density has the form (A1) with the same and with , which differs from by and does not affect the ellipticity. With this , the brackets reported there are
The first coincides with Eq. (60); the second corresponds to a weight instead of for the term in , and leads to . With the weight (A2) the same expansion gives , the flat-element value above.
References
References
- [2]M. Visser, Lorentzian Wormholes: From Einstein to Hawking (AIP Press, New York, 1995).DOI
- [3]F. S. N. Lobo, ed., Wormholes, Warp Drives and Energy Conditions, Fundamental Theories of Physics, Vol. 189 (Springer, Cham, 2017).DOI
- [4]M. Visser, Physical Review D 39, 3182 (1989).
- [5]M. Visser, Nuclear Physics B 328, 203 (1989).
- [6]G. Darmois, Les équations de la gravitation einsteinienne (Gauthier-Villars, Paris, 1927).
- [7]W. Israel, Il Nuovo Cimento B 44, 1 (1966).
- [8]E. Poisson and M. Visser, Physical Review D 52, 7318 (1995).
- [9]E. F. Eiroa and G. E. Romero, General Relativity and Gravitation 36, 651 (2004).
- [10]F. S. N. Lobo and P. Crawford, Classical and Quantum Gravity 21, 391 (2004).
- [11]E. F. Eiroa, Physical Review D 78, 024018 (2008).
- [12]G. A. S. Dias and J. P. S. Lemos, Physical Review D 82, 084023 (2010).
- [13]M. Ishak and K. Lake, Physical Review D 65, 044011 (2002).
- [14]F. S. N. Lobo and P. Crawford, Classical and Quantum Gravity 22, 4869 (2005).
- [15]N. M. Garcia, F. S. N. Lobo, and M. Visser, Physical Review D 86, 044026 (2012).
- [16]E. F. Eiroa and C. Simeone, Physical Review D 76, 024021 (2007).
- [17]E. F. Eiroa, Physical Review D 80, 044033 (2009).
- [18]M. Halilsoy, A. Ovgun, and S. H. Mazharimousavi, European Physical Journal C 74, 2796 (2014).
- [19]J. P. S. Lemos, F. S. N. Lobo, and S. Q. de Oliveira, Physical Review D 68, 064004 (2003).
- [20]F. S. N. Lobo, Classical and Quantum Gravity 21, 4811 (2004).
- [21]F. S. N. Lobo, General Relativity and Gravitation 37, 2023 (2005).
- [22]P. Martín-Moruno, N. M. García, F. S. N. Lobo, and M. Visser, Journal of Cosmology and Astroparticle Physics 03, 034.
- [23]S. H. Mazharimousavi and M. Halilsoy, European Physical Journal C 74, 3067 (2014).
- [24]S. D. Forghani, S. H. Mazharimousavi, and M. Halilsoy, European Physical Journal C 78, 469 (2018).
- [25]J. Ovalle, Phys. Lett. B 788, 213 (2019), arXiv:1812.03000 [gr-qc].DOI
- [26]J. Ovalle, Modern Physics Letters A 23, 3247 (2008).
- [27]R. Casadio, J. Ovalle, and R. da Rocha, Classical and Quantum Gravity 32, 215020 (2015).
- [28]J. Ovalle, Physical Review D 95, 104019 (2017).
- [29]J. Ovalle and R. Casadio, Beyond Einstein Gravity: The Minimal Geometric Deformation Approach in the Brane-World, SpringerBriefs in Physics (Springer, Cham, 2020).DOI
- [30]R. Casadio, J. Ovalle, and R. da Rocha, Classical and Quantum Gravity 31, 045016 (2014).
- [31]R. Casadio, J. Ovalle, and R. da Rocha, EPL (Europhysics Letters) 110, 40003 (2015).
- [32]R. da Rocha, European Physical Journal C 77, 355 (2017).
- [33]A. Fernandes-Silva and R. da Rocha, European Physical Journal C 78, 271 (2018).
- [34]J. Ovalle, R. Casadio, R. da Rocha, and A. Sotomayor, European Physical Journal C 78, 122 (2018).
- [35]E. Contreras, European Physical Journal C 78, 678 (2018).
- [36]E. Contreras and P. Bargueño, European Physical Journal C 78, 558 (2018).
- [37]E. Contreras and P. Bargueño, European Physical Journal C 78, 985 (2018).
- [38]E. Contreras, Á. Rincón, and P. Bargueño, European Physical Journal C 79, 216 (2019).
- [39]R. Casadio, E. Contreras, J. Ovalle, A. Sotomayor, and Z. Stuchlík, European Physical Journal C 79, 826 (2019).
- [40]E. Contreras and Z. Stuchlík, European Physical Journal C 82, 706 (2022).
- [41]J. Ovalle, R. Casadio, R. da Rocha, A. Sotomayor, and Z. Stuchlík, European Physical Journal C 78, 960 (2018).
- [42]J. Ovalle, R. Casadio, R. da Rocha, A. Sotomayor, and Z. Stuchlík, EPL (Europhysics Letters) 124, 20004 (2018).
- [43]J. Ovalle, R. Casadio, E. Contreras, and A. Sotomayor, Physics of the Dark Universe 31, 100744 (2021).
- [44]E. Contreras, J. Ovalle, and R. Casadio, Physical Review D 103, 044020 (2021).
- [45]J. Ovalle, E. Contreras, and Z. Stuchlík, Physical Review D 103, 084016 (2021).
- [46]P. J. Arias, P. Bargueño, E. Contreras, and E. Fuenmayor, Astronomy 1, 2 (2022).
- [47]R. Avalos, P. Bargueño, and E. Contreras, Fortschritte der Physik 71, 2200171 (2023).
- [48]R. da Rocha, Physical Review D 102, 024011 (2020).
- [49]R. Casadio and R. da Rocha, European Physical Journal C 83, 537 (2023).
- [50]R. da Rocha, Eur. Phys. J. C 82, 34 (2022), arXiv:2111.11995 [gr-qc].DOI
- [51]A. Ramos, C. Arias, R. Ávalos, and E. Contreras, Annals of Physics 431, 168557 (2021).
- [52]R. Avalos and E. Contreras, European Physical Journal C 83, 155 (2023).
- [53]R. T. Cavalcanti, R. C. de Paiva, and R. da Rocha, European Physical Journal Plus 137, 1185 (2022).
- [54]V. F. Guimarães, R. T. Cavalcanti, and R. da Rocha, Class. Quant. Grav. 42, 175011 (2025), arXiv:2506.20044 [gr-qc].DOI
- [55]R. C. de Paiva, K. S. Alves, R. T. Cavalcanti, and R. da Rocha, Annals Phys. 492, 170540 (2026), arXiv:2512.14920 [gr-qc].DOI
- [56]H. Navarro and R. da Rocha, Class. Quant. Grav. 43, 155005 (2026), arXiv:2602.20386 [hep-th].DOI
- [57]A. Fernandes-Silva, A. J. Ferreira-Martins, and R. da Rocha, Physics Letters B 791, 323 (2019).
- [58]R. da Rocha and A. A. Tomaz, European Physical Journal C 79, 1035 (2019).
- [59]R. da Rocha and A. A. Tomaz, European Physical Journal C 80, 857 (2020).
- [60]P. Meert and R. da Rocha, European Physical Journal C 82, 175 (2022).
- [61]R. Casadio, I. Kuntz, and R. da Rocha, Eur. Phys. J. Plus 140, 703 (2025), arXiv:2403.13099 [gr-qc].DOI
- [62]R. Casadio, C. N. Souza, and R. da Rocha, Eur. Phys. J. C 84, 767 (2024), arXiv:2402.04682 [gr-qc].DOI
- [63]R. da Rocha, Eur. Phys. J. Plus 139, 1006 (2024), arXiv:2409.17325 [hep-th].DOI
- [64]O. A. Almatroud, M. Rizwan, M. Alshammari, M. Z. Bhatti, S. Alshammari, and Z. Yousaf, European Physical Journal C 85, 1285 (2025).
- [65]M. Gonzalez-Espinoza, Y. Gómez-Leyton, Z. Stuchlík, and F. Tello-Ortiz, Physical Review D 114, 044021 (2026).
- [66]S.-W. Kim, Journal of the Korean Physical Society 82, 436 (2023).
- [67]P. F. Kashargin and S. V. Sushkov, Gravitation and Cosmology 17, 119 (2011).
- [68]S. H. Mazharimousavi and M. Halilsoy, European Physical Journal C 74, 3073 (2014).
- [69]R. Gannouji and Y. R. Baez, Journal of High Energy Physics 02, 020 (2022).
- [70]Y. R. Baez and M. Gonzalez-Espinoza, Classical and Quantum Gravity 40, 085017 (2023).
- [71]M. Visser, S. Kar, and N. Dadhich, Physical Review Letters 90, 201102 (2003).
- [72]E. Teo, Physical Review D 58, 024014 (1998).
- [73]E. T. Newman and A. I. Janis, Journal of Mathematical Physics 6, 915 (1965).
- [74]M. Gürses and F. Gürsey, Journal of Mathematical Physics 16, 2385 (1975).
- [75]M. Azreg-Aïnou, Physical Review D 90, 064041 (2014).
- [76]A. Komar, Physical Review 113, 934 (1959).
- [77]S. W. Hawking and G. F. R. Ellis, The Large Scale Structure of Space-Time (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, 1973).
- [78]R. Geroch, Journal of Mathematical Physics 11, 2580 (1970).
- [79]R. O. Hansen, Journal of Mathematical Physics 15, 46 (1974).
- [80]L. D. Landau and E. M. Lifshitz, Mechanics (Pergamon Press, Oxford, 1976).
- [81]M. Zimmermann and E. S. Jr., Physical Review D 20, 351 (1979).
- [82]D. I. Jones and N. Andersson, Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society 331, 203 (2002).