WorksPhysics and Astronomy
Untangling flow-harmonic correlations in OO and Pb–Pb collisions at the LHC using event-shape engineering
Abstract
Symmetric cumulants measure the correlation between the event-by-event fluctuations of the flow harmonics and , which, for higher harmonics, is influenced by the nonlinear response to the elliptic () and triangular () flow. Event-shape engineering, which selects events by the reduced flow vector , is expected to control this contribution. However, its power is limited by the small forward multiplicity in light-ion collisions. In this work, we study the effect of the and selections on the symmetric cumulants in OO and Pb–Pb collisions at ~TeV using EPOS4 with an ATLAS-like acceptance. Using the law of total covariance, the symmetric cumulant is separated into a selected part, which follows the differences between the classes, and a residual part within them. It is observed that in OO collisions the correlations of with and remain almost entirely within the classes, unlike in Pb–Pb collisions. Nevertheless, events with the smallest in central OO collisions show weaker correlations of with and , which is attributed to approaching its linear response. In Pb–Pb collisions, the and selections act separately on the two factors of the nonlinear coupling of , which establishes a way to isolate them experimentally.
Introduction
Heavy-ion collisions at the Relativistic Heavy Ion Collider (RHIC) and at the Large Hadron Collider (LHC) produce a hot and dense medium of deconfined quarks and gluons, known as the quark–gluon plasma (QGP) [1, 2, 3], whose formation at high temperature is predicted by lattice QCD [4]. Since the QGP is short-lived, it cannot be observed directly, and its formation is inferred from the signatures it leaves on the final-state hadrons, such as strangeness enhancement [5], jet quenching [6], quarkonium suppression [7] and collective flow [8, 9]. Among these, the collective flow probes the expansion of the medium as a whole. Its comparison with hydrodynamic calculations shows that the QGP behaves as a nearly perfect fluid, with a ratio of shear viscosity to entropy density close to the conjectured lower bound of [9, 10].
The collective flow arises because the pressure gradients of the produced medium convert the spatial anisotropy of the overlap region into a momentum-space anisotropy of the final-state particles [8, 9]. This anisotropy is quantified by the Fourier coefficients of the azimuthal distribution of the particles,
where is the azimuthal angle of a particle and is the th-order symmetry-plane angle. The coefficients and are known as elliptic and triangular flow. The initial anisotropy, characterized by the eccentricities , fluctuates from event to event because the positions of the nucleons and of their constituents fluctuate [11, 12]. Hydrodynamic calculations show that and respond nearly linearly to and [13, 14], whereas and have two contributions. In terms of the complex flow vectors and eccentricities , where is the participant-plane angle,
i.e., a linear response to and with the coefficients , and a nonlinear response to and to with the coefficients and [14, 15, 16, 17]. The ALICE Collaboration has shown that the nonlinear contributions dominate and in noncentral Pb–Pb collisions [18, 19].
The correlation between the event-by-event fluctuations of two flow harmonics, and , is measured with the symmetric cumulant [20],
where the brackets denote the average over events, and with its normalized form , which divides by . In Pb–Pb collisions, is negative, i.e., events with a larger tend to have a smaller , which is attributed to the anticorrelation between and in the initial geometry. In contrast, is positive and is dominated by the nonlinear response of to [21, 22, 23]. The symmetric cumulants have also been measured in pp, p–Pb and Xe collisions [24, 25, 26]. It is important to note that in small systems, few-particle correlations from jets and resonance decays, known as nonflow, contribute strongly to the four-particle correlators, and their removal requires subevent methods or explicit subtraction [27, 28, 29, 30, 31].
A complementary way to study the coupling of flow harmonics is event-shape engineering, where events of the same centrality are classified according to the magnitude of the reduced flow vector measured in a rapidity window separated from the one used for [32] [33]. Since follows the event-by-event value of , the selection changes the average at fixed centrality, and the response of the other harmonics reveals how they are coupled to . Using this method in Pb–Pb collisions, the ATLAS Collaboration found that decreases when is increased by the selection, whereas and increase with and also increases with [34], as expected from the sum of a linear and a nonlinear term in hydrodynamics. The ALICE Collaboration has recently observed the same correlations of and with in Pb–Pb and Xe–Xe collisions and has separated the linear and nonlinear parts of in the classes [35]. As predicted in Ref. [36] with the multiphase transport model [37], the selection changes the nonlinear part strongly, while the linear part and the coupling coefficient depend little on it, except in the most central collisions. Event-shape selections, also with other observables such as transverse spherocity [38], have been used to study the correlation between and the mean transverse momentum [39], the initial and final-state anisotropies [40, 41], global properties of the medium [42] and symmetry plane correlations [43].
In 2025, the LHC provided OO and Ne–Ne collisions at TeV. These collisions produce charged-particle multiplicities between those of pp and Pb–Pb collisions, which makes them a bridge between small and large systems [44, 45, 46, 47]. The ALICE, ATLAS and CMS collaborations have measured and in OO and Ne–Ne collisions and found that the difference between the two systems follows the different shapes of the and nuclei [48, 49, 50], in agreement with hydrodynamic calculations [51, 52]. Multiparticle correlations between harmonics, such as the symmetric cumulants and the symmetry plane correlations, have been proposed as further probes of the nuclear structure and of the medium response in these systems [31, 53, 54].
The event-shape measurements compare the response of the flow harmonics with the symmetric cumulants only qualitatively [35]. To our knowledge, the symmetric cumulants themselves have not been studied in classes, either in Pb–Pb or in light-ion collisions. It is thus not known how much of the correlation between and fluctuations is carried by the variation of and that the and selections control, and how much remains within the selected classes. This question is particularly important in light-ion collisions, where the multiplicity in the forward window used to measure is about an order of magnitude smaller than in Pb–Pb collisions. The measured then follows the underlying less closely, and the selection may not reduce the lower-order harmonics enough to change the correlations between them.
In this paper, we study the effect of the and selections on the two-particle flow coefficients (–) and on the symmetric cumulants SC(3, 2), SC(4, 2), SC(4, 3), SC(5, 2), SC(5, 3), and SC(5, 4), and their normalized forms in OO and Pb–Pb collisions at TeV using the EPOS4 model [55, 56]. The pseudorapidity acceptance, the centrality estimator and the definition follow those of the ATLAS event-shape analysis [34], and the transverse-momentum range is GeV/. We separate the symmetric cumulant of -integrated events into a selected part, , which follows the differences between the classes, and a residual part, , which remains within them. This shows directly how much of each correlation the selection carries. The dependence on the acceptance is checked with wider windows.
The paper is organized as follows. Section II describes the event samples, the selections, the observables and the nonflow subtraction. Section III presents the results for and for the symmetric cumulants. Section IV summarizes the findings. The comparison of EPOS4 with measurements, the dependence on the nonflow suppression and the dependence on the window are given in the Appendices A, B and C.
Event generation and analysis method
Event generation
EPOS4 is a general-purpose event generator that treats pp, p–A and A–A collisions within the same framework [55, 56]. The primary interactions are parallel parton–parton scatterings that respect energy conservation and include saturation. The resulting strings are cut into segments, which are separated into a core and a corona according to their energy loss. The core is evolved hydrodynamically and is hadronized microcanonically, whereas the corona segments hadronize as strings. The core fraction grows with the multiplicity, so that the collective response increases continuously from pp to Pb–Pb collisions. EPOS4 has recently been compared with the multiplicity dependence of soft observables, including , in Pb–Pb, Xe–Xe and OO collisions [57].
The samples used in this work were generated with EPOS4 version 4.0.3 in its full configuration: the core–corona procedure is activated, the core is evolved hydrodynamically with the standard EPOS equation of state, a nonzero string formation time is used, and the hadronic phase is described by the UrQMD hadronic cascade [58, 59]. The events are minimum bias, without any trigger or kinematic selection. The decays of , and of the weakly decaying strange baryons are switched off, while the other strongly and electromagnetically decaying hadrons are decayed. The generator uses a spherical Woods–Saxon density with radius fm and diffuseness fm, i.e., fm for and fm for . The results shown in this paper are based on about OO and Pb–Pb events.
Centrality and classes
The analysis uses charged primary particles with and GeV/ for the flow observables. The pseudorapidity range is that of the ATLAS analysis of Ref. [34], which used GeV/. The centrality is defined from the sum of the transverse energy, , of charged primary particles in the acceptance of the ATLAS forward calorimeters, . For Pb–Pb collisions, the centrality classes are 10% wide, from 0–10% to 70–80%. For OO collisions, the centrality classes are 0–10%, 10–20%, 20–30%, 30–40%, 40–70% and 70–100%, i.e., they are wider in peripheral collisions, where the multiplicity is small and the statistical uncertainties of the multiparticle correlators are large.
The reduced flow vector of order is
where the sums run over charged primary particles in and . This window is separated by at least 0.8 units of pseudorapidity from the tracks used for the flow observables. To study the dependence on the acceptance, is also computed in two wider windows, and , which extend the default window outward and keep the same separation from the tracks (Appendix C). Since changes with multiplicity, a selection over a wide centrality class would partly select the events by their multiplicity instead of their shape. To avoid this, the events of each 1%-wide centrality interval are sorted by (or ) and divided into five classes with equal numbers of events. The classes are labeled by the fraction of events with a larger , i.e., the 0–20% class contains the 20% of events with the largest , and the 80–100% class the 20% with the smallest .2 A class of a wider centrality class, e.g., 0–10%, combines the same class of all its 1% intervals, so that each interval contributes the same fraction of its events. In the following, the 0–20% and 80–100% classes are called the highest and lowest classes, and all events of a centrality class, without a selection, are called -integrated events.
Two-particle and symmetric cumulants
The two-particle cumulant is computed with the 2-subevent method, with subevent A at and subevent B at ,
where the double brackets denote the average over pairs and then over events, weighted by the number of pairs. The pseudorapidity gap of two units suppresses short-range nonflow, such as resonance decays and near-side jet fragments. When is negative, is not defined and that point is not shown.
In terms of multiparticle correlations, the symmetric cumulant of harmonics and is [20]
which equals Eq. (4) in the absence of nonflow. A positive (negative) means that and are correlated (anticorrelated) from event to event. We study , , , , and . Through the nonlinear terms of Eqs. (2) and (3), and probe the nonlinear part of , while and connect to and to mainly through their common dependence on . The normalized symmetric cumulant,
removes the dependence on the magnitudes of and . This is important for the event-shape selection, which changes these magnitudes directly. For example, in the highest class of the 0–10% OO centrality class, is a factor of 1.8 larger than for -integrated events, while changes by only 5%. For this reason, the strength of the correlations in the classes is discussed with , whose significance is nearly the same as that of , since is much more precise than the symmetric cumulants. Here is computed with all particles in , which is the same particle set as the four-particle correlator. All multiparticle correlators are calculated with the -cumulant method [20, 60]. The symmetric cumulants are computed in bins of unit multiplicity of the tracks and then averaged with the weight , which reduces the effect of multiplicity fluctuations within a centrality or class. The statistical uncertainties are obtained with the delete-one jackknife method using 10 subsamples. The significance of a difference between a class and -integrated events is computed with their uncertainties added in quadrature, which neglects their positive correlation and therefore underestimates the significance.
Nonflow subtraction
The four-particle correlator in Eq. (7) still contains nonflow, which grows towards low multiplicity as in the independent-source picture [30, 61]. Following Refs. [30, 31], nonflow is subtracted with a template from the low-multiplicity (LM) class, which is the 70–100% centrality class of -integrated events,
The scale factor follows the multiplicity dependence of nonflow ( scaling), , where is the effective multiplicity of the centrality or class. The scale factor is computed in every centrality and class, and the denominator of Eq. (8) is not subtracted. In the 0–40% OO centrality classes, the subtraction changes by a few percent at most, while the fraction of that it removes grows from 2% in the 0–10% centrality class to 37% in the 30–40% centrality class. In the 40–70% centrality class, it removes most of , so the results there depend on how well the LM template describes the nonflow. The symmetric cumulants are shown up to 70% centrality in OO collisions and up to 60% in Pb–Pb collisions. For OO collisions, however, we restrict the discussion to the centrality classes where of -integrated events has a significance of about three standard deviations or more and the subtraction is a moderate correction, i.e., 0–40% for , 0–30% for , 0–20% for and , and 0–10% for . The 70–100% OO centrality class is the LM class itself, so its subtracted symmetric cumulants vanish by construction, and it is used only for .
Selected and residual correlation
A selection divides the events of a centrality class into classes , each with a fraction of the events; here, these are the five classes of Sec. II, so that . Since is the covariance of and , Eq. (4), it can be split into two parts with the law of total covariance. The first part, which we call the residual part, , is the correlation that remains among events of similar : is computed in each class and averaged over the classes. The second part, the selected part , is the correlation between the averages of the classes: it is nonzero only if the classes with a larger also have a larger (or smaller) . The two parts add up to of -integrated events,
where and are measured in class and . In the statistics literature, the two parts are known as the within-class and between-class terms [62].
Two limiting cases illustrate the meaning of the two parts. If measured exactly and the classes were very narrow, all events of a class would have the same , and would vanish in every class. The whole correlation of with would then appear as a difference of and between the classes, i.e., it would be in . In the opposite case, carries no information on , all classes have the same and , and the whole correlation is in . A real selection lies between these two cases, since is measured with a finite number of particles at forward rapidity and follows at midrapidity only partly. Therefore, measures how much of the correlation the selection controls, and is what the selection cannot remove.
The sign of follows from how the two harmonics respond to the selection. For example, if the highest class has a larger and a smaller than average, and the lowest class the opposite, as observed in Pb–Pb collisions (Sec. III A), the products in Eq. (10) are negative, and is negative, like itself. If, instead, the selection changes only one harmonic of the pair, is small, irrespective of how strongly that harmonic changes. This is the case for with the selection, whose classes vary but hardly . It is important to note that the two parts need not have the same sign: when has the sign opposite to that of , is larger in magnitude than itself, as for with the selection in Pb–Pb collisions (Sec. III E).
Both parts are divided by of -integrated events, which gives and , so that their sum is of -integrated events. Note that is not of one class, since it uses the denominator of -integrated events. The subtraction of each class enters , while is built from of the classes. The size of also depends on the number of classes. As finer classes resolve more of the variation of with ; with ten classes of 10%, it increases only slightly. Since the symmetric cumulants are averaged over multiplicity bins with the weight , Eq. (10) is not exact. We have verified that the sum of the two parts reproduces of -integrated events within 2.1 times its statistical uncertainty, and within 4% of its value where is significant, for every system, centrality class, harmonic pair and selection shown here.
Results and discussion
Response of the flow coefficients to the and selections
An event-shape selection can change the correlations between flow harmonics only to the extent that it changes the harmonics themselves. We therefore begin with the flow coefficients. Figure 1 shows for –5 as a function of in OO and Pb–Pb collisions, for -integrated events and for the highest and lowest classes. For -integrated events, in OO collisions depends weakly on , whereas in Pb–Pb collisions it increases strongly from central to mid-central collisions, following the elliptic shape of the overlap region, and decreases again in peripheral collisions. The higher harmonics are smaller and depend less on centrality, since they originate mainly from fluctuations of the initial geometry [11, 12, 13]. It is important to note that the two-unit pseudorapidity gap does not remove the away-side jet correlations, which grow towards low multiplicity [27] and, being peaked at , contribute with a negative sign to the odd harmonics. As a result, is negative in OO collisions below
Figure 1. Upper panels: (a), (b), (c) and (d) as a function of in OO and Pb–Pb collisions at TeV using EPOS4, for -integrated events (black) and for the highest (0–20%, red) and lowest (80–100%, blue) classes. Each point corresponds to one centrality class and is placed at the of its own events. Lower panels (e)–(h): ratio of the class to -integrated events. Centrality classes with a negative are not shown. The uncertainties are statistical.
, and is positive only in the 0–10% and 10–20% centrality classes.
The lower panels of Figure 1 show the ratio of in the classes to that of -integrated events. One can observe that the highest class has a larger and the lowest class a smaller one, irrespective of the collision system, which confirms that the forward follows at midrapidity. In OO collisions, the change in the highest class grows with and reaches about 20% in the 0–10% centrality class, although in the peripheral centrality classes it can also contain nonflow correlations between the forward window and midrapidity. At the same , the ratios for OO and peripheral Pb–Pb collisions are of similar size, with a somewhat stronger selection in Pb–Pb collisions at . This implies that the power of the selection is set mainly by the multiplicity rather than by the collision system. This is because the measured is the sum of the underlying flow vector and of a statistical fluctuation due to the finite number of particles in the forward window, and the latter decreases with multiplicity [8, 32, 63]. In the 0–50% Pb–Pb centrality classes, the selection increases by about 30% in the highest class and decreases it by about 30% in the lowest class.
The other harmonics respond to the selection through their coupling to . The triangular flow, , responds with the opposite sign in both systems: it is smaller in the highest class and larger in the lowest class, by up to about 10%. This anticorrelation between and was observed by ATLAS in Pb–Pb collisions with the same selection [34] and originates from the anticorrelation between and in the initial geometry: an overlap region that is strongly elongated leaves less room for a triangular deformation [21, 64, 65]. In contrast, follows , and, as for , its change is larger in Pb–Pb collisions than in OO collisions. In the lowest class of OO collisions, the decrease of is seen only in the 0–10% and 10–20% centrality classes. This is the expected behavior of the nonlinear response of Eq. (2), i.e., the selection changes the nonlinear term through , while it leaves the linear term in nearly unchanged [35, 36]. As a result, the lowest class contains events in which is closer to its linear response. The pentagonal flow has a nonlinear term proportional to Eq. (3) [19]. In Pb–Pb collisions, also follows , but in mid-central collisions its change is smaller than that of , since the increase of is partly compensated by the decrease of in the product . In OO collisions, is defined only in the 0–10% and 10–20% centrality classes and has large uncertainties in the classes.
Figure 2 shows the same quantities for the selection. In Pb–Pb collisions, the selection changes by about 20–30% in the 0–40% centrality classes. In OO collisions, the change is much weaker: only +6% and −3% in the highest and lowest classes of the 0–10% centrality class, and it decreases further towards peripheral collisions. In the 30–40% centrality class, the ordering is even reversed, so that the selection does not resolve there, and that noflow origin of this reversal cannot be excluded. The weaker response, compared with that of to the selection at the same , is because is at least a factor of two smaller than , so that the statistical fluctuation of in the forward window dominates over the triangular flow. The selection decreases slightly in the highest class, as expected from the anticorrelation of and , and leaves nearly unchanged, since the nonlinear term of depends on and not on . On the other hand, of Pb–Pb collisions increases in the highest class, which reflects the non-linear coupling of to . The and selections thus act on the higher harmonics through the same nonlinear couplings that produce the correlations studied below.
Figure 2. Upper panels: (a), (b), (c) and (d) as a function of in OO and Pb–Pb collisions at TeV using EPOS4, for -integrated events (black) and for the highest (0–20%, red) and lowest (80–100%, blue) classes. Each point corresponds to one centrality class and is placed at the of its own events. Lower panels (e)–(h): ratio of the class to -integrated events. Centrality classes with a negative are not shown. The uncertainties are statistical.
Correlations of with and : NSC(3,2) and NSC(4,2)
Figures 3(a) and 3(c) show NSC(3,2) as a function of . For -integrated events, NSC(3, 2) is negative in OO and Pb–Pb collisions, which reflects the anticorrelation of and fluctuations inherited from and [20, 21, 64, 65]. In OO collisions, its magnitude is largest in the 20–30% centrality class and decreases towards central collisions, whereas in Pb–Pb collisions it decreases steadily from peripheral collisions to about zero in the 0–10% centrality class. The magnitude of NSC(3, 2) in Pb–Pb collisions is smaller than measured by ALICE at TeV (Appendix A).
In OO collisions, the selection changes NSC(3, 2) mainly in the lowest class of central collisions. Compared with -integrated events, its magnitude is 22% and 18% smaller in the 0–10% and 10–20% centrality classes, with a significance of 5.6 and 4.6 standard deviations, respectively. The highest class stays close to -integrated events. In the 20–30% and 30–40% centrality classes, both classes agree with -integrated events within their uncertainties, i.e., the reduction disappears as the selection becomes weaker. Events with a small thus show a weaker anticorrelation between and , as expected if a part of is driven by the same fluctuations that produce . The selection has a smaller effect: only the highest class of the 0–10% centrality class differs from -integrated events, with a slightly larger magnitude. In Pb–Pb collisions, both the highest and the lowest classes give values of NSC(3, 2) closer to zero than -integrated events. This is not a contradiction, since NSC(3, 2) of -integrated events is not the average of its values in the classes: the selection in Pb–Pb collisions turns a large part of the fluctuations into a difference between the classes, and the anticorrelation of and then appears in , as a difference of between the classes, rather than in (Sec. III E). The selection behaves differently: in the 10–60% Pb–Pb centrality classes, the highest class gives a larger magnitude than -integrated
events, in the same direction as in OO collisions, and the lowest class gives a smaller one.
Figure 3(b) and (Figure 3d) show NSC(4, 2), which in hydrodynamics is dominated by the nonlinear response of to [22, 64, 65]. For -integrated events, NSC(4, 2) is positive, increases with in OO collisions and connects to the values of peripheral Pb–Pb collisions, after which it decreases towards central Pb–Pb collisions, as also reported in Ref. [31] with the multiphase transport model. In OO collisions, the highest class stays close to -integrated events. In contrast, the lowest class gives a 29% smaller value in the 0–10% centrality class, with a significance of 6.6 standard deviations, and a weaker reduction in the 10–20% centrality class, while no change is seen in the 20–30% centrality class. The same reduction of NSC(3, 2) and NSC(4, 2) is found with the 2-subevent method, which suppresses nonflow without a template (Appendix B). The reduction of NSC(4, 2) is attributed to the reduction of the nonlinear contribution to in events with a small seen in Figure 1: when is small, is closer to its linear response to , which is only weakly correlated with [64]. In the 10–50% Pb–Pb centrality classes, both the highest and the lowest classes give a much smaller NSC(4, 2) than -integrated events, as for NSC(3, 2). The selection leaves NSC(4, 2) essentially unchanged in both systems. of its value for -integrated events, while NSC(5, 3) increases. This increase is small in the individual centrality classes, but it has the same sign in all of the 0–50% centrality classes, and its weighted mean is 17% of the value for -integrated events, with a significance of 4.1 standard deviations. In the lowest class, NSC(5, 3) decreases, so that the highest class exceeds the lowest one by 48% of the value for -integrated events on average, with a significance of 6.3 standard deviations. This is a direct consequence of the nonlinear term . Within a class, varies little, so that the correlation of with is removed, while the fluctuations of that remain follow those of with a strength proportional to . The larger of the highest class thus strengthens the correlation of with , and the small of the lowest class weakens it in favor of the linear response of to . The selection shows the reverse pattern: in the highest class of the 10–50% centrality classes, NSC(5, 3) decreases to about three quarters of its value for -integrated events, while NSC(5, 2) is larger. This is the same mechanism with the roles of and exchanged, i.e., the and selections separate the two factors of the nonlinear coupling.
Figure 3. NSC(3,2) (left) and NSC(4,2) (right) as a function of in OO and Pb–Pb collisions at TeV using EPOS4, for -integrated events (black) and for the highest (red) and lowest (blue) classes of the (upper) and (lower) selections, with the nonflow subtraction, in the centrality ranges given in Sec. II. The uncertainties are statistical.
Figure 5. Same as Figure 4 for NSC(5, 4), for the (a) and (b) selections. The OO results are not shown, since their uncertainties are of order unity.
In OO collisions, these correlators are significant only in the most central centrality classes (Sec. II), and they are therefore not shown in Figure 4. There, they have the same signs as in Pb–Pb collisions, and the highest class shows the same trends, i.e., a smaller NSC(5, 2) and a larger NSC(5, 3). However, the changes with the and selections are not significant, so that the present OO sample cannot establish them.
Figure 4. NSC(4, 3), NSC(5, 2) and NSC(5, 3) (columns from left to right) as a function of in Pb–Pb collisions at TeV using EPOS4 for -integrated events (black) and for the highest (red) and lowest (blue) classes of the (upper) and (lower) selections, with the nonflow subtraction, in the 0–60% centrality classes. The uncertainties are statistical.
Correlations of v4 and v5 with the lower harmonics: NSC(4,3), NSC(5,2) and NSC(5,3)
Figure 4 shows NSC(4, 3), NSC(5, 2) and NSC(5, 3) as a function of in Pb–Pb collisions. For -integrated events, NSC(4, 3) is negative, as measured by ALICE [22, 23], and its magnitude grows from central to peripheral collisions. This is because the nonlinear part of follows , and is anticorrelated with [65]. Both NSC(5, 2) and NSC(5, 3) are positive, as also measured [22], which is expected from the nonlinear response of to [65].
The response of NSC(4, 3) to the event-shape selection resembles that of NSC(3, 2) and NSC(4, 2). In mid-central collisions, its magnitude is smaller in both the highest and the lowest classes than in -integrated events, most clearly in the highest one, since the selection turns a part of the fluctuations, which couple to , into a difference between the classes. The selection reduces the magnitude mainly in the lowest class.
The most interesting feature is that the selection changes NSC(5, 2) and NSC(5, 3) in opposite directions. In the highest class of the 10–40% centrality classes, NSC(5, 2) decreases to between one quarter and two fifths of its value for -integrated events, while NSC(5, 3) increases.
Correlation between v4 and v5
Figure 5 shows NSC(5, 4) in Pb–Pb collisions. Through the nonlinear terms of Eqs. (2) and (3), and share a dependence on , which would correlate them positively, while the anticorrelation of and enters with the opposite sign, so that the two contributions partly cancel. One can observe that NSC(5, 4) of -integrated Pb–Pb events is small, with both signs, and it differs from zero by at most three standard deviations in the 0–50% centrality classes, as do the values in the classes. In OO collisions, is of the order of , which makes the uncertainties of NSC(5, 4) of order unity, and it is therefore not shown. In OO collisions, SC(5, 4) differs from zero by at most 2.1 standard deviations, except in the 10–20% centrality class, where it is negative with a significance of 5.0 standard deviations. The adjacent centrality classes do not show it, so we do not interpret it as a flow correlation. A measurement of this correlator in OO collisions requires much larger samples than those of the other symmetric cumulants, and the selection does not change this.
How much of the correlation is carried by the selection
The changes of the normalized symmetric cumulants in the classes can be summarized by asking which fraction of the correlation of -integrated events the selection carries. Figure 6 and Figure 7 show the normalized symmetric cumulants of -integrated events, separated into and according to Eq. (10). In general, is large only when the selection changes both harmonics of the pair, i.e., when the selected resolves the common driver of their fluctuations.
Figure 6. NSC, NSC and NSC (columns from left to right) of -integrated events (black), separated into NSC (green) and NSC (purple) according to Eq. (10), as a function of in OO and Pb–Pb collisions at TeV using EPOS4, for the (upper) and (lower) selections, in the centrality ranges given in Sec. II. The nonflow subtraction enters NSC. The uncertainties are statistical.
Figure 7. NSC, NSC and NSC (columns from left to right) of -integrated events (black), separated into NSC (green) and NSC (purple) according to Eq. (10), as a function of in Pb–Pb collisions at TeV using EPOS4, for the (upper) and (lower) selections, in the 0–60% centrality classes. The nonflow subtraction enters NSC. The uncertainties are statistical.
For the selection in OO collisions, is negative and is positive, which is consistent with the anticorrelation of and the correlation of with seen in Figure 1. These parts are, however, small: they are at most 8% of and in the 0–10% centrality class and decrease towards peripheral collisions. In OO collisions, carries more than 90% of the correlation between and , and between and , and the same holds for and . As one moves to Pb–Pb collisions, increases strongly: in the 10–40% centrality classes, it is 50–71% of , 37–42% of , 18–34% of and 39–50% of , i.e., the selection captures a large fraction of the correlations that involve . The exception is , which is small and negative, since the increase of with is accompanied by a decrease of . For the selection, and are small in both systems, since the classes differ little in . In Pb–Pb collisions, where the selection changes strongly, is 10–30% of , and in the 10–40% centrality classes, whereas in OO collisions it is below 1%. For the selection in Pb–Pb collisions, is positive, since both and increase with , and it is compensated in part by a negative , i.e., the small of -integrated events results from a partial cancellation.
In OO collisions with an acceptance similar to that of ATLAS, the selection thus changes the magnitudes of , , and , but it does not separate the correlations between them. The normalized symmetric cumulants change only moderately, mainly in the lowest class of central collisions, and the selection cannot be used to remove the contribution of to these correlations in the way it partly does in Pb–Pb collisions. Extending the window outward to or 7.8 increases the power of the selection only moderately (Appendix C), which implies that these conclusions do not depend on the details of the acceptance.
Summary
In summary, this work studies the response of the flow coefficients and the symmetric cumulants to the and selections in OO and Pb–Pb collisions at TeV using EPOS4, with an acceptance similar to that of ATLAS. The separation of the symmetric cumulants into and shows directly how much of a correlation the selection controls. It is observed that is large only when the selection changes both harmonics of the pair, i.e., when resolves the common driver of their fluctuations. This implies that a change of in a class should be interpreted together with this decomposition. For example, both classes of Pb–Pb collisions give a smaller magnitude of , since the selection moves the correlation into the differences between the classes.
The power of the selection is set mainly by the multiplicity in the forward window rather than by the collision system. In OO collisions, the statistical fluctuation of dominates over the flow signal, and carries more than 90% of \mathrm{SC}(4,2)$, whereas it carries about half of them as one moves to mid-central Pb–Pb collisions. Thus, the selection in OO collisions changes the magnitudes of the flow harmonics, but it cannot remove the contribution of to their correlations. Nevertheless, the lowest class of central OO collisions selects events in which is closer to its linear response to , and the magnitudes of and are 22% and 29% smaller in the 0–10% centrality class. This reduction persists with the 2-subevent method, which hints that it is not caused by nonflow. In Pb–Pb collisions, the and selections act separately on the two factors of the nonlinear term , i.e., a larger shifts the correlation of from to , and the selection does the reverse.
EPOS4 does not reproduce the strength of and in central Pb–Pb collisions, and these results therefore serve as a model baseline. However, the mechanisms discussed here follow from the structure of the nonlinear response and from the finite resolution of , and are expected to hold beyond this model. This study not only shows that event-shape engineering in light-ion collisions requires a much better resolution of than the forward windows studied here provide, but also establishes event-shape-selected measurements of and in Pb–Pb collisions as a probe of the nonlinear mode coupling.
Acknowledgments
I gratefully acknowledge support from the Hungarian National Research, Development and Innovation Office (NKFIH) under Contract Nos. NKFIH NKKP ADVANCED_25 K153456, 2025-1.1.5-NEMZ_KI-2025-00005 and 2024-1.2.5-TET-2024-00022. I also acknowledge the Wigner Scientific Computing Laboratory (WSCLAB) in Budapest, Hungary, for providing the computational resources used in this study.
Comparison with measurements
To show how well EPOS4 describes the observables studied here, its results for -integrated events are compared with measurements, using the kinematic selection, the pseudorapidity gap and, as far as possible, the centrality estimator of each measurement, i.e., the multiplicity in the FT0C acceptance, , for ALICE in OO collisions [48], the transverse energy in for CMS [50], and the multiplicity in the FT0 acceptance for Pb–Pb collisions. As in the measurement [23], of Pb–Pb collisions uses the four-particle cumulant without a gap and without nonflow subtraction, divided by of the 2-subevent method with [21]. The difference between and TeV is neglected, since the normalized symmetric cumulants depend only weakly on the collision energy [22, 23].
One can observe in Figure 8 that EPOS4 reproduces the weak centrality dependence of in OO collisions and agrees with both measurements within about 7% in the 5–40% centrality classes, while it is above the data in the most central collisions and below the ALICE values in the 40–60% centrality classes. For , EPOS4 lies above the data in central collisions and decreases faster towards peripheral collisions. This hints that EPOS4 has either too small a or too large negative away-side correlations in peripheral OO collisions.
Figure 8. (left) and (right) as a function of centrality in OO collisions at TeV measured by ALICE [48] (upper, , GeV/, ) and CMS [50] (lower, , GeV/, ), compared with EPOS4. Bars and boxes show the statistical and systematic uncertainties of the data, and bands the statistical uncertainties of EPOS4.
For Pb–Pb collisions (Figure 9), the magnitude of in EPOS4 is well below the measured one except in the 50–60% centrality class, and has a weaker centrality dependence than measured, while agrees with the data in the 10–60% centrality classes. The results of the main text are therefore a model baseline: the trends with centrality and the signs of the correlators in noncentral collisions are reproduced, but the strength of the correlations in Pb–Pb collisions is not.
Figure 9. NSC(3, 2) (a), NSC(4, 2) (b) and NSC(4, 3) (c) as a function of centrality in Pb–Pb collisions measured by ALICE at TeV [23] (, GeV/), compared with EPOS4 at TeV. Bars and boxes show the statistical and systematic uncertainties of the data, and bands the statistical uncertainties of EPOS4.
Dependence on the nonflow suppression
The reduction of and in the lowest class of central OO collisions (Section III B) could also arise if the selection changed the nonflow at midrapidity, e.g., through jets that reach both the forward window and the tracks. To test this, the symmetric cumulants are also computed with the 2-subevent method [27, 28], with two particles from and two from , for and 2. This method needs no template, and the denominator of Eq. (8) is computed with the same subevents.
One can observe in Figure 10 that the lowest class is reduced by about the same factor with all methods in the 0–10% and 10–20% centrality classes, irrespective of how much nonflow they remove, while the highest class stays close to unity. Without a gap, the reduction has a significance of 3.0 and 3.4 standard deviations for in these two centrality classes, and of 2.6 standard deviations for in the 0–10% centrality class. With the gap, the uncertainties are four to eight times larger, and the ratios agree with those of the other methods. This implies that the reduction is not caused by nonflow.
Figure 10. Ratio of NSC(3, 2) (a) and NSC(4, 2) (b) in the lowest (diamonds) and highest (squares) classes to -integrated events in OO collisions at TeV using EPOS4, for four nonflow treatments (line styles). A method is shown only where its SC(, ) of -integrated events has a significance of at least three standard deviations, and its points are shifted horizontally in the order of the legend. The uncertainties are statistical.
Dependence on the qn window
To test the dependence on the window, is also computed in and , which extend the default window outward. As shown in Figure 11, the ratio of in the highest to that in the lowest class of the 0–10% OO centrality class increases only from 1.44 to 1.51 with the first window, and the widest window gives no further increase. This is because the correlation with midrapidity decreases with , so that the region adds as much fluctuation to as signal.
Figure 11. Dependence of the (upper) and (lower) selections on the pseudorapidity window of , (default, blue), (orange) and (purple), in OO and Pb–Pb collisions at TeV using EPOS4, as a function of for centrality classes 0–70%. Left: ratio of in the highest to that in the lowest class. Middle: NSC(4, 2) of the lowest class (b) and NSC(3, 2) of the highest class (e). Right: NSC(4, 2) (c) and NSC(3, 2) (f), Eq. (10). The values for -integrated events are shown in black. The symmetric cumulants use the nonflow subtraction. The uncertainties are statistical.
Accordingly, and in the 0–10% OO centrality class increase only from 7–8% to 9–11% of and , and of the lowest class changes by at most 9% (1.1 standard deviations), so that the window does not change the conclusions.
References
References
- [1]J. Adams et al. (STAR), Experimental and theoretical challenges in the search for the quark gluon plasma: The STAR Collaboration’s critical assessment of the evidence from RHIC, Nucl. Phys. A 757, 102 (2005), arXiv:nucl-ex/0501009.DOI
- [2]K. Adcox et al. (PHENIX), Formation of dense partonic matter in relativistic nucleus-nucleus collisions at RHIC: Experimental evaluation by the PHENIX collaboration, Nucl. Phys. A 757, 184 (2005), arXiv:nucl-ex/0410003.DOI
- [3]S. Acharya et al. (ALICE), The ALICE experiment: a journey through QCD, Eur. Phys. J. C 84, 813 (2024), arXiv:2211.04384 [nucl-ex].
- [4]A. Bazavov et al. (HotQCD), Equation of state in (2+1)-flavor QCD, Phys. Rev. D 90, 094503 (2014), arXiv:1407.6387 [hep-lat].DOI
- [5]J. Rafelski and B. Muller, Strangeness Production in the Quark - Gluon Plasma, Phys. Rev. Lett. 48, 1066 (1982), [Erratum: Phys.Rev.Lett. 56, 2334 (1986)].
- [6]K. Aamodt et al. (ALICE), Suppression of Charged Particle Production at Large Transverse Momentum in Central Pb-Pb Collisions at √sNN = 2.76 TeV, Phys. Lett. B 696, 30 (2011), arXiv:1012.1004 [nucl-ex].
- [7]T. Matsui and H. Satz, J/ψ Suppression by Quark-Gluon Plasma Formation, Phys. Lett. B 178, 416 (1986).DOI
- [8]S. A. Voloshin, A. M. Poskanzer, and R. Snellings, Collective phenomena in non-central nuclear collisions, Landolt-Bornstein 23, 293 (2010), arXiv:0809.2949 [nucl-ex].arxiv.org/abs/0809.2949
- [9]U. Heinz and R. Snellings, Collective flow and viscosity in relativistic heavy-ion collisions, Ann. Rev. Nucl. Part. Sci. 63, 123 (2013), arXiv:1301.2826 [nucl-th].DOI
- [10]P. Kovtun, D. T. Son, and A. O. Starinets, Viscosity in strongly interacting quantum field theories from black hole physics, Phys. Rev. Lett. 94, 111601 (2005), arXiv:hep-th/0405231.pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/15903845
- [11]B. Alver and G. Roland, Collision geometry fluctuations and triangular flow in heavy-ion collisions, Phys. Rev. C 81, 054905 (2010), [Erratum: Phys.Rev.C 82, 039903 (2010)], arXiv:1003.0194 [nucl-th].arxiv.org/abs/1003.0194
- [12]M. Luzum, Flow fluctuations and long-range correlations: elliptic flow and beyond, J. Phys. G 38, 124026 (2011), arXiv:1107.0592 [nucl-th].DOI
- [13]H. Niemi, G. S. Denicol, H. Holopainen, and P. Huovinen, Event-by-event distributions of azimuthal asymmetries in ultrarelativistic heavy-ion collisions, Phys. Rev. C 87, 054901 (2013), arXiv:1212.1008 [nucl-th].
- [14]F. G. Gardim, F. Grassi, M. Luzum, and J.-Y. Ollitrault, Mapping the hydrodynamic response to the initial geometry in heavy-ion collisions, Phys. Rev. C 85, 024908 (2012), arXiv:1111.6538 [nucl-th].DOI
- [15]D. Teaney and L. Yan, Non linearities in the harmonic spectrum of heavy ion collisions with ideal and viscous hydrodynamics, Phys. Rev. C 86, 044908 (2012), arXiv:1206.1905 [nucl-th].DOI
- [16]L. Yan and J.-Y. Ollitrault, v4, v5, v6, v7: nonlinear hydrodynamic response versus LHC data, Phys. Lett. B 744, 82 (2015), arXiv:1502.02502 [nucl-th].
- [17]J. Qian, U. W. Heinz, and J. Liu, Mode-coupling effects in anisotropic flow in heavy-ion collisions, Phys. Rev. C 93, 064901 (2016), arXiv:1602.02813 [nucl-th].DOI
- [18]S. Acharya et al. (ALICE), Linear and non-linear flow modes in Pb-Pb collisions at √sNN = 2.76 TeV, Phys. Lett. B 773, 68 (2017), arXiv:1705.04377 [nucl-ex].
- [19]S. Acharya et al. (ALICE), Higher harmonic non-linear flow modes of charged hadrons in Pb-Pb collisions at √sNN = 5.02 TeV, JHEP 2020 (5), 085, arXiv:2002.00633 [nucl-ex].
- [20]A. Bilandzic, C. H. Christensen, K. Gulbrandsen, A. Hansen, and Y. Zhou, Generic framework for anisotropic flow analyses with multiparticle azimuthal correlations, Phys. Rev. C 89, 064904 (2014), arXiv:1312.3572 [nucl-ex].DOI
- [21]J. Adam et al. (ALICE), Correlated event-by-event fluctuations of flow harmonics in Pb-Pb collisions at √sNN = 2.76 TeV, Phys. Rev. Lett. 117, 182301 (2016), arXiv:1604.07663 [nucl-ex].
- [22]S. Acharya et al. (ALICE), Systematic studies of correlations between different order flow harmonics in Pb-Pb collisions at √sNN = 2.76 TeV, Phys. Rev. C 97, 024906 (2018), arXiv:1709.01127 [nucl-ex].
- [23]S. Acharya et al. (ALICE), Measurements of mixed harmonic cumulants in Pb-Pb collisions at √sNN = 5.02 TeV, Phys. Lett. B 818, 136354 (2021), arXiv:2102.12180 [nucl-ex].
- [24]S. Acharya et al. (ALICE), Investigations of Anisotropic Flow Using Multiparticle Azimuthal Correlations in pp, p-Pb, Xe-Xe, and Pb-Pb Collisions at the LHC, Phys. Rev. Lett. 123, 142301 (2019), arXiv:1903.01790 [nucl-ex].
- [25]A. M. Sirunyan et al. (CMS), Observation of Correlated Azimuthal Anisotropy Fourier Harmonics in pp and p + Pb Collisions at the LHC, Phys. Rev. Lett. 120, 092301 (2018), arXiv:1709.09189 [nucl-ex].
- [26]M. Aaboud et al. (ATLAS), Correlated long-range mixed-harmonic fluctuations measured in pp, p+Pb and low-multiplicity Pb+Pb collisions with the ATLAS detector, Phys. Lett. B 789, 444 (2019), arXiv:1807.02012 [nucl-ex].
- [27]J. Jia, M. Zhou, and A. Trzpek, Revealing long-range multiparticle collectivity in small collision systems via subevent cumulants, Phys. Rev. C 96, 034906 (2017), arXiv:1701.03830 [nucl-th].DOI
- [28]P. Huo, K. Gajdošová, J. Jia, and Y. Zhou, Importance of non-flow in mixed-harmonic multi-particle correlations in small collision systems, Phys. Lett. B 777, 201 (2018), arXiv:1710.07567 [nucl-ex].DOI
- [29]M. Aaboud et al. (ATLAS), Measurement of long-range multiparticle azimuthal correlations with the subevent cumulant method in pp and p + Pb collisions with the ATLAS detector at the CERN Large Hadron Collider, Phys. Rev. C 97, 024904 (2018), arXiv:1708.03559 [hep-ex].
- [30]Z. Wang, J. Jia, J. Chen, S. Huang, C. Zhang, and Z. Yan, Nonflow Subtraction Beyond Two-Particle Correlations, Rept. Prog. Phys. 89, 108601 (2026), arXiv:2606.10258 [nucl-th].DOI
- [31]N. Mallick and S. Prasad, Improved nonflow control for multiparticle correlators and system-size-dependent evolution from OO to Pb–Pb collisions at the LHC (2026), arXiv:2610.36922 [nucl-ex].
- [32]J. Schukraft, A. Timmins, and S. A. Voloshin, Ultrarelativistic nuclear collisions: event shape engineering, Phys. Lett. B 719, 394 (2013), arXiv:1208.4563 [nucl-ex].
- [34]G. Aad et al. (ATLAS), Measurement of the correlation between flow harmonics of different order in lead-lead collisions at √sNN=2.76 TeV with the ATLAS detector, Phys. Rev. C 92, 034903 (2015), arXiv:1504.01289 [hep-ex].
- [35]D. Ali Hassan Abdallah et al. (ALICE), Correlations and fluctuations of flow with event shape engineering in Pb-Pb and Xe-Xe collisions at the LHC (2026), arXiv:2211.08473 [nucl-ex].
- [36]N. Magdy, O. Evdokimov, and R. A. Lacey, A method to test the coupling strength of the linear and non-linear contributions to higher-order flow harmonics via Event Shape Engineering, J. Phys. G 48, 025101 (2020), arXiv:2002.04583 [nucl-ex].DOI
- [37]Z.-W. Lin, C. M. Ko, B.-A. Li, B. Zhang, and S. Pal, A Multi-phase transport model for relativistic heavy ion collisions, Phys. Rev. C 72, 064901 (2005), arXiv:nucl-th/0411110.DOI
- [38]S. Prasad, S. Tripathy, B. Sahoo, and R. Sahoo, Event topology classifiers at the Large Hadron Collider, Phys. Rept. 1181, 1 (2026), arXiv:2506.03782 [hep-ph].DOI
- [39]N. Magdy and R. A. Lacey, Novel investigations of the correlation between the mean transverse momentum and anisotropic flow in shape-engineered events, Phys. Lett. B 821, 136625 (2021), arXiv:2105.04879 [nucl-th].DOI
- [40]S. Prasad, N. Mallick, S. Tripathy, and R. Sahoo, Probing initial geometrical anisotropy and final azimuthal anisotropy in heavy-ion collisions at Large Hadron Collider energies through event-shape engineering, Phys. Rev. D 107, 074011 (2023), arXiv:2207.12133 [hep-ph].DOI
- [41]S. Prasad, A. Menon K R, R. Sahoo, and N. Mallick, Higher order flow coefficients: A messenger of QCD medium formed in heavy-ion collisions at the Large Hadron Collider, Phys. Lett. B 868, 139753 (2025), arXiv:2505.01471 [hep-ph].DOI
- [42]S. Prasad, N. Mallick, D. Behera, R. Sahoo, and S. Tripathy, Event topology and global observables in heavy-ion collisions at the Large Hadron Collider, Sci. Rep. 12, 3917 (2022), arXiv:2112.03892 [hep-ph].DOI
- [43]S. Tripathy, S. Prasad, and R. Sahoo, Event-shape dependence of symmetry plane correlations using the Gaussian estimator in Pb-Pb collisions at the LHC using a multi-phase transport model, Phys. Rev. D 112, 114012 (2025), arXiv:2504.09275 [nucl-ex].DOI
- [44]J. L. Nagle and W. A. Zajc, Small System Collectivity in Relativistic Hadronic and Nuclear Collisions, Ann. Rev. Nucl. Part. Sci. 68, 211 (2018), arXiv:1801.03477 [nucl-ex].DOI
- [45]J. F. Grosse-Oetringhaus and U. A. Wiedemann, A Decade of Collectivity in Small Systems (2024), arXiv:2407.07484 [hep-ex].
- [46]J. Brewer, A. Mazeliauskas, and W. van der Schee, Opportunities of OO and ρO collisions at the LHC, in Opportunities of OO and ρO collisions at the LHC (2021) arXiv:2103.01939 [hep-ph].arxiv.org/abs/2103.01939
- [47]A. Huss, A. Kurkela, A. Mazeliauskas, R. Paatenlainen, W. van der Schee, and U. A. Wiedemann, Discovering Partonic Rescattering in Light Nucleus Collisions, Phys. Rev. Lett. 126, 192301 (2021), arXiv:2007.13754 [hep-ph].DOI
- [48]I. J. Abualrob et al. (ALICE), Evidence of Nuclear Geometry-Driven Anisotropic Flow in O+O and Ne+Ne Collisions at sNN=5.36 TeV, Phys. Rev. Lett. 137, 082301 (2026), arXiv:2509.06428 [nucl-ex].DOI
- [49]G. Aad et al. (ATLAS), Measurement of the azimuthal anisotropy of charged particles in √sNN = 5.36 TeV 16O+16O and 20Ne+20Ne collisions with the ATLAS detector, Phys. Rev. C 113, 045205 (2026), arXiv:2509.05171 [nucl-ex].
- [50]A. Hayrapetyan et al. (CMS), Observation of Long-Range Collective Flow in O+O and Ne+Ne Collisions and Implications for Nuclear Structure Studies, Phys. Rev. Lett. 137, 082302 (2026), arXiv:2510.02580 [nucl-ex].DOI
- [51]G. Giacalone et al., Exploiting Ne20 Isotopes for Precision Characterizations of Collectivity in Small Systems, Phys. Rev. Lett. 135, 012302 (2025), arXiv:2402.05995 [nucl-th].
- [52]A. Menon Kavumpadikkal Radhakrishnan, S. Prasad, N. Mallick, R. Sahoo, and G. G. Barnafoldi, Constraining α-cluster compactness in 16O and 20Ne at TeV energies using azimuthal anisotropy (2026), arXiv:2607.26758 [hep-ph].
- [53]D. Behera, S. Prasad, N. Mallick, and R. Sahoo, Effects of clustered nuclear geometry on the anisotropic flow in O-O collisions at the LHC within a multiphase transport model framework, Phys. Rev. D 108, 054022 (2023), arXiv:2304.10879 [hep-ph].DOI
- [54]S. Prasad and R. Sahoo, Nuclear geometry driven symmetry plane correlations in OO and Ne–Ne collisions at the Large Hadron Collider (2026), arXiv:2605.00866 [hep-ph].arxiv.org/abs/2605.00866
- [55]K. Werner, Revealing a deep connection between factorization and saturation: New insight into modeling high-energy proton-proton and nucleus-nucleus scattering in the EPOS4 framework, Phys. Rev. C 108, 064903 (2023), arXiv:2301.12517 [hep-ph].arxiv.org/abs/2301.12517
- [56]K. Werner, Core-corona procedure and microcanonical hadronization to understand strangeness enhancement in proton-proton and heavy ion collisions in the EPOS4 framework, Phys. Rev. C 109, 014910 (2024), arXiv:2306.10277 [hep-ph].DOI
- [57]S. K. Malik, F. U. Haider, P. Bhagat, A. Bhasin, and R. Gupta, Scaling of soft QGP signatures in relativistic lead, xenon, and oxygen collisions in EPOS4, Phys. Rev. C 114, 025203 (2026), arXiv:2608.10578 [hep-ph].DOI
- [58]S. A. Bass et al., Microscopic models for ultrarelativistic heavy ion collisions, Prog. Part. Nucl. Phys. 41, 255 (1998), arXiv:nucl-th/9803035.DOI
- [59]M. Bleicher et al., Relativistic hadron hadron collisions in the ultrarelativistic quantum molecular dynamics model, J. Phys. G 25, 1859 (1999), arXiv:hep-ph/9909407.DOI
- [60]A. Bilandzic, R. Snellings, and S. Voloshin, Flow analysis with cumulants: Direct calculations, Phys. Rev. C 83, 044913 (2011), arXiv:1010.0233 [nucl-ex].DOI
- [61]N. Borghini, P. M. Dinh, and J.-Y. Ollitrault, Flow analysis from multiparticle azimuthal correlations, Phys. Rev. C 64, 054901 (2001), arXiv:nucl-th/0105040.DOI
- [62]S. M. Ross, A First Course in Probability, 6th ed. (Prentice Hall, Upper Saddle River, NJ, 2002).
- [63]J. Jia, Event-shape fluctuations and flow correlations in ultra-relativistic heavy-ion collisions, J. Phys. G 41, 124003 (2014), arXiv:1407.6057 [nucl-ex].DOI
- [64]G. Giacalone, L. Yan, J. Noronha-Hostler, and J.-Y. Ollitrault, Symmetric cumulants and event-plane correlations in Pb + Pb collisions, Phys. Rev. C 94, 014906 (2016), arXiv:1605.08303 [nucl-th].DOI
- [65]X. Zhu, Y. Zhou, H. Xu, and H. Song, Investigating the correlations of flow harmonics in 2.76A TeV Pb–Pb collisions, J. Phys. Conf. Ser. 779, 012062 (2017), arXiv:1609.02628 [nucl-th].DOI










