betaFeedback

WorksPhysics and Astronomy

Eulerian ion energisation in three-dimensional hybrid-Vlasov-Maxwell turbulence

Abstract

In collisionless plasma turbulence, energy is transferred from electromagnetic fluctuations to the particles. However, the relative contributions of different ion energisation mechanisms remain unclear. We investigate ion energisation in three-dimensional hybrid Vlasov–Maxwell simulations of decaying turbulence at βi0=0.25β_{i0}=0.25 and βi0=4β_{i0}=4, where βi0β_{i0} is the initial ratio of ion thermal to magnetic pressure. Using the exact ion momentum equation, we decompose the ion energisation rate ji⋅E\mathbf{j}_i\mathbf{\cdot}\mathbf{E} into the work done on the parallel, diamagnetic, curvature, agyrotropic and polarisation ion currents. This decomposition requires neither gyrotropy nor scale separation and, therefore, remains valid where guiding-centre theory breaks down. We show that the agyrotropic term, which has no guiding-centre counterpart, accounts for 21 %21\,\% of the energisation at βi0=0.25β_{i0}=0.25 and 91 %91\,\% at βi0=4β_{i0}=4. We find that the dominant instantaneous energisation term changes with βi0β_{i0}, from the polarisation current at low βi0β_{i0} to the diamagnetic and agyrotropic currents at high βi0β_{i0}, at all resolved scales. In addition, we show that reversible exchange with the ion bulk flow dominates the instantaneous rate, so the time-integrated energy transfer is larger at βi0=4β_{i0}=4 even though the instantaneous rate is smaller. Our results provide quantitative evidence that guiding-centre drifts alone cannot describe ion energisation in kinetic-scale turbulence and that the dominant energisation term depends on βiβ_i. The results also highlight the key role of non-local thermodynamic-equilibrium effects in energy conversion in collisionless plasma turbulence.

Introduction

Turbulence in weakly collisional, magnetised plasmas transfers energy from large-scale electromagnetic fluctuations to scales where it can be converted to particles ([43, 37, 13]). Which kinetic mechanisms mediate that transfer, in what proportion, and how the partition depends on plasma parameters are long-standing questions central to the thermodynamics of the solar wind, planetary magnetosheaths, the intracluster medium, and accretion flows [24].

Much of the work to date has focused on individual energisation mechanisms and the rate at which each transfers field energy to particles. Landau and transit-time damping, ion-cyclotron damping, stochastic heating, and energisation in reconnecting current sheets have each been studied in isolation and diagnosed directly in numerical simulations and in in situ spacecraft observations [29, 30, 25, 26, 1, 14, 23, 12, 47, 3]. A complementary line of work quantifies the exchange between bulk-flow and internal energy through the pressure–strain interaction −(Ps⋅∇)⋅Us-(\boldsymbol{P}_s \cdot\nabla) \cdot\boldsymbol{U}_s, where Us\boldsymbol{U}_s and Ps\boldsymbol{P}_s are the bulk velocity and pressure tensor of species ss, both in simulations and in spacecraft data [53, 55, 15, 4, 39, 10, 7, 17]. This approach can be extended beyond the second moment to the energy conversion carried by all higher moments of the distribution [11] and to the generalised entropy production that accompanies it [58], which separates the thermal from the non-thermal part of the velocity distribution function (VDF). A gap remains between the two approaches. The first attributes energisation to a basic plasma mechanism. However, each mechanism must be identified and diagnosed separately, and no single one accounts for the whole budget. The second closes the budget for the transfer between bulk and internal energy and, in its higher-moment form, resolves where that energy goes in velocity space, but it does not identify which field–particle interaction drove the transfer. What is missing is an exact, complete, term-by-term decomposition of the work done by the fields that does not presuppose which mechanism operates.

Such a decomposition is obtained in the Eulerian frame by expressing the current of species ss, js=qsnsUs\boldsymbol{j}_s = q_s n_s \boldsymbol{U}_s, through the generalised Ohm’s law, that is, the momentum equation of the species solved for the electric field E\boldsymbol{E}. Here qsq_s, nsn_s and Us\boldsymbol{U}_s are the charge, number density and bulk velocity of species ss. The work js⋅E\boldsymbol{j}_s \cdot\boldsymbol{E} then separates into the work done by E\boldsymbol{E} on the current parallel to the magnetic field B=Bb^\boldsymbol{B} = B\hat{\boldsymbol{b}} and on the diamagnetic, curvature, agyrotropic and polarisation currents. Because this approach follows from the exact momentum equation, it requires no ordering assumption and remains meaningful where guiding-centre theory fails. TenBarge et al. [51] introduced this Eulerian decomposition for electrons in magnetic reconnection (see also Steinvall et al. 2025) and contrasted it with the Lagrangian, guiding-centre picture. Its counterpart for ions in turbulence has not, to our knowledge, been examined. For typical terrestrial magnetosheath conditions, the ordering parameter ρi/LB\rho_i/L_B is routinely of order unity [41]. Here LBL_B is the magnetic-field gradient scale and ρi=vth,i,⊥/Ωci\rho_i = v_{\mathrm{th},i,\perp}/\Omega_{ci} is the ion gyroradius, with vth,i,⊥=2Ti,⊥/miv_{\mathrm{th},i,\perp} = \sqrt{2T_{i,\perp}/m_i} the ion thermal speed, Ωci=eB/mic\Omega_{ci} = eB/m_i c the ion cyclotron frequency, Ti,⊥T_{i,\perp} the ion temperature perpendicular to b^\hat{\boldsymbol{b}}, mim_i the ion mass, ee the elementary charge and cc the speed of light. As a result, the guiding-centre approach does not apply in such an environment, and an Eulerian description is required.

Two features of the ion energisation in turbulence make an Eulerian description necessary. First, the natural adiabaticity parameter for ions is the ratio of the local magnetic-field radius of curvature to the gyroradius ρc/ρi\rho_c/\rho_i [2, 32]. The ratio falls to and below unity in the sheets and vortices that populate kinetic-scale turbulence, so that the ion VDF becomes agyrotropic [50, 46, 56, 41] (Valentini et al. 2016), and the magnetic moment μ=miv⊥2/2B\mu= m_i v_\perp^2/2B is not conserved. Here, v⊥v_\perp is the particle velocity perpendicular to b^\hat{b}. Second, βi\beta_i controls the relative size of the terms in Ohm’s law. At high βi\beta_i, ions decouple from the field over a broad range of scales, and the Hall and electron-pressure terms increasingly set the electric field [36, 20] (Califano et al. 2020). One therefore expects the partition of the budget among the currents, and not only its amplitude, to depend on βi\beta_i.

In this paper, we quantify the Eulerian ion energisation budget in three-dimensional, three-velocity-dimensional (3D3V) hybrid-Vlasov–Maxwell (HVM) simulations of decaying turbulence at βi0=0.25\beta_{i0}=0.25 and βi0=4\beta_{i0}=4. Specifically, we address: (i) what can be said about ion energisation in strong turbulence when guiding-centre theory does not apply; (ii) which terms dominate the budget, and in particular whether those associated with the departure of the ion VDF from a gyrotropic Maxwellian matter; (iii) whether the local and volume-integrated pictures agree; (iv) how the budget evolves as the turbulence develops; and (v) how it depends on the plasma conditions.

The paper is organised as follows. §2 sets out the decomposition and its relation to the guiding-centre energisation terms, with the derivation given in Appendix B. §3 describes the simulations. §4 presents the spectra, ion VDF departures from a Maxwellian, magnetic-field geometry, and energisation budget. §5 discusses the results and §6 concludes. Appendix A gives the decomposition in the code normalisation.

Ion energisation rate

Eulerian decomposition

We follow the derivation of TenBarge et al. [51], adapted to ions and written in the Gaussian units used by the HVM code. The starting point is the exact ion momentum equation, obtained by taking the first moment of the Vlasov equation,

dUidt+1mini∇⋅Pi=emi(E+Ui×Bc),(1)\frac{\mathrm{d}\mathbf{U}_i}{\mathrm{d}t}+\frac{1}{m_i n_i}\nabla\cdot\mathbf{P}_i=\frac{e}{m_i}\left(\mathbf{E}+\frac{\mathbf{U}_i\times\mathbf{B}}{c}\right), \tag*{(1)}

where d/dt≡∂t+Ui⋅∇\mathrm{d}/\mathrm{d}t\equiv\partial_t+\mathbf{U}_i\cdot\nabla is the convective derivative following the bulk flow. We write the pressure tensor as a gyrotropic part plus an agyrotropic part,

Pi=pi⊥I+(pi∥−pi⊥)b^b^+Πiagy,(2)\mathbf{P}_i=p_{i\perp}\mathbf{I}+(p_{i\parallel}-p_{i\perp})\hat{b}\hat{b}+\mathbf{\Pi}_i^{\mathrm{agy}}, \tag*{(2)}

with b^=B/B\hat{b}=\mathbf{B}/B, pi∥=b^⋅Pi⋅b^p_{i\parallel}=\hat{b}\cdot\mathbf{P}_i\cdot\hat{b} and pi⊥=12[Tr⁡(Pi)−pi∥]p_{i\perp}=\frac{1}{2}\left[\operatorname{Tr}(\mathbf{P}_i)-p_{i\parallel}\right]. The tensor Πiagy\mathbf{\Pi}_i^{\mathrm{agy}} is defined by (2.2), so that it is traceless and carries all the non-gyrotropic information.

Substituting (2.2) into (2.1), solving for the electric field, and expanding the divergence of the anisotropy term with the magnetic curvature κ=b^⋅∇b^\boldsymbol{\kappa}=\hat{b}\cdot\nabla\hat{b}, with local radius of curvature rc=∣κ∣−1r_c=\lvert\boldsymbol{\kappa}\rvert^{-1}, gives

E+Ui×Bc=1eni∇pi⊥+b^eni∇⋅[(pi∥−pi⊥)b^]+pi∥−pi⊥eniκ+1eni∇⋅Πiagy+miedUidt.(3)\mathbf{E}+\frac{\mathbf{U}_i\times\mathbf{B}}{c} =\frac{1}{e n_i}\nabla p_{i\perp} +\frac{\hat{b}}{e n_i}\nabla\cdot\left[(p_{i\parallel}-p_{i\perp})\hat{b}\right] +\frac{p_{i\parallel}-p_{i\perp}}{e n_i}\boldsymbol{\kappa} +\frac{1}{e n_i}\nabla\cdot\mathbf{\Pi}_i^{\mathrm{agy}} +\frac{m_i}{e}\frac{\mathrm{d}\mathbf{U}_i}{\mathrm{d}t}. \tag*{(3)}

Taking the cross product of (2.3) with B\mathbf{B}, using (Ui×B)×B=−B2Ui⊥(\mathbf{U}_i\times\mathbf{B})\times\mathbf{B}=-B^2\mathbf{U}_{i\perp}, and multiplying by c/B2c/B^2 gives the perpendicular bulk velocity as a sum of drifts,

Ui⊥=c E×BB2+ceniB2B×∇pi⊥+c(pi∥−pi⊥)eniB2B×κ+ceniB2B×∇⋅Πiagy+miceB2B×dUidt.(4)\mathbf{U}_{i\perp}=\frac{c\,\mathbf{E}\times\mathbf{B}}{B^2}+\frac{c}{en_iB^2}\mathbf{B}\times\nabla p_{i\perp}+\frac{c(p_{i\parallel}-p_{i\perp})}{en_iB^2}\mathbf{B}\times\boldsymbol{\kappa}+\frac{c}{en_iB^2}\mathbf{B}\times\nabla\cdot\boldsymbol{\Pi}_i^{\mathrm{agy}}+\frac{m_ic}{eB^2}\mathbf{B}\times\frac{\mathrm{d}\mathbf{U}_i}{\mathrm{d}t}. \tag*{(4)}

The second term on the right-hand side of (3) is parallel to b^\hat{\mathbf{b}} and thus vanishes when taking the cross product with it. The last term of (4) is the inertial drift, which reduces to the familiar expression (mic2/eB2) ∂tE⊥(m_ic^2/eB^2)\,\partial_t\mathbf{E}_{\perp} for the polarisation drift in a uniform, static field, i.e., when Ui≃UE\mathbf{U}_i\simeq\mathbf{U}_E, and hence the name. However, it is evaluated here with the full bulk acceleration. It therefore also contains the curvature drift of the bulk parallel flow, miUi∥2(c/eB2) B×κm_iU_{i\parallel}^2(c/eB^2)\,\mathbf{B}\times\boldsymbol{\kappa}, and the advection of the remaining drifts by the flow (see Appendix § 12).

The ion energisation rate follows from ji⋅E=eniUi⋅E=ji∥E∥+eniUi⊥⋅E⊥\mathbf{j}_i\cdot\mathbf{E}=en_i\mathbf{U}_i\cdot\mathbf{E}=j_{i\parallel}E_{\parallel}+en_i\mathbf{U}_{i\perp}\cdot\mathbf{E}_{\perp}. The UE\mathbf{U}_E term does no work, since UE⋅E=0\mathbf{U}_E\cdot\mathbf{E}=0 identically. Each remaining term can be rearranged using the vector identity (B×X)⋅E=X⋅(E×B)(\mathbf{B}\times\mathbf{X})\cdot\mathbf{E}=\mathbf{X}\cdot(\mathbf{E}\times\mathbf{B}) so that the E×B\mathbf{E}\times\mathbf{B} velocity appears explicitly,

ji⋅E=ji∥E∥+UE⋅∇pi⊥+(pi∥−pi⊥)UE⋅κ+UE⋅∇⋅Πiagy+miniUE⋅dUidt.(5)\mathbf{j}_i\cdot\mathbf{E}=j_{i\parallel}E_{\parallel}+\mathbf{U}_E\cdot\nabla p_{i\perp}+(p_{i\parallel}-p_{i\perp})\mathbf{U}_E\cdot\boldsymbol{\kappa}+\mathbf{U}_E\cdot\nabla\cdot\boldsymbol{\Pi}_i^{\mathrm{agy}}+m_in_i\mathbf{U}_E\cdot\frac{\mathrm{d}\mathbf{U}_i}{\mathrm{d}t}. \tag*{(5)}

Equation (5) is an exact identity; we make no approximations beyond the definitions of the pressure tensor in (2), and in particular make no assumptions about gyrotropy, small ρi/LB\rho_i/L_B, or slow time variation. Each term is the rate of work done by the electric field on one component of the ion current. We therefore refer to them as terms rather than as channels or mechanisms.

It will be useful below to regroup the diamagnetic and curvature terms by splitting (pi∥−pi⊥)UE⋅κ(p_{i\parallel}-p_{i\perp})\mathbf{U}_E\cdot\boldsymbol{\kappa} into pi∥UE⋅κ−pi⊥UE⋅κp_{i\parallel}\mathbf{U}_E\cdot\boldsymbol{\kappa}-p_{i\perp}\mathbf{U}_E\cdot\boldsymbol{\kappa},

Wdia+Wcurv1=UE⋅∇pi⊥−pi⊥UE⋅κ+pi∥UE⋅κ.(6)W_{\mathrm{dia}}+W_{\mathrm{curv1}}=\mathbf{U}_E\cdot\nabla p_{i\perp}-p_{i\perp}\mathbf{U}_E\cdot\boldsymbol{\kappa}+p_{i\parallel}\mathbf{U}_E\cdot\boldsymbol{\kappa}. \tag*{(6)}

The names are justified in § 2.2. Finally, expanding the polarisation term with Ui⋅∇Ui=∇(Ui2/2)−Ui×ωi\mathbf{U}_i\cdot\nabla\mathbf{U}_i=\nabla(U_i^2/2)-\mathbf{U}_i\times\boldsymbol{\omega}_i, where ωi=∇×Ui\boldsymbol{\omega}_i=\nabla\times\mathbf{U}_i is the bulk vorticity, separates it into a local, a kinetic-energy-gradient and a vortical part,

Wpol=miniUE⋅(∂Ui∂t+∇(Ui22)−Ui×ωi).(7)W_{\mathrm{pol}}=m_in_i\mathbf{U}_E\cdot\left(\frac{\partial\mathbf{U}_i}{\partial t}+\nabla\left(\frac{U_i^2}{2}\right)-\mathbf{U}_i\times\boldsymbol{\omega}_i\right). \tag*{(7)}

Relation to guiding-centre energisation

The terms of (5) differ from the guiding-centre energisation terms. In the Lagrangian guiding-centre (LGC) description, we obtain the ion energy evolution from the guiding-centre energy equation [38], averaged over guiding centres in a local volume. Previous studies of particle energisation retained the parallel electric field and the work done on the grad-BB, curvature and polarisation drifts [18] (Li et al. 2017). Following these studies, we obtain

dEiLGCdt=ji∥E∥+pi⊥DEln⁡B+(pi∥+miniUi∥2)UE⋅κ+mini2Dg∣UE∣2(8)\frac{\mathrm{d}\mathcal{E}_{i}^{\mathrm{LGC}}}{\mathrm{d}t} = j_{i\parallel}E_{\parallel} + p_{i\perp}D_{E}\ln B + \left(p_{i\parallel}+m_{i}n_{i}U_{i\parallel}^{2}\right)\boldsymbol{U}_{E}\cdot\boldsymbol{\kappa} + \frac{m_{i}n_{i}}{2}D_{g}\lvert\boldsymbol{U}_{E}\rvert^{2} \tag*{(8)}

where DE≡∂t+UE⋅∇D_{E}\equiv\partial_{t}+\boldsymbol{U}_{E}\cdot\nabla and Dg≡∂t+(UE+Ui∥b^)⋅∇D_{g}\equiv\partial_{t}+(\boldsymbol{U}_{E}+U_{i\parallel}\hat{\boldsymbol{b}})\cdot\nabla are the convective derivatives along the E×B\boldsymbol{E}\times\boldsymbol{B} flow and the guiding centre, respectively, and EiLGC=32pi+12mini(Ui∥2+∣UE∣2)\mathcal{E}_{i}^{\mathrm{LGC}}=\frac{3}{2}p_{i}+\frac{1}{2}m_{i}n_{i}(U_{i\parallel}^{2}+\lvert\boldsymbol{U}_{E}\rvert^{2}). The bulk-flow part of the Fermi term, miniUi∥2UE⋅κm_{i}n_{i}U_{i\parallel}^{2}\boldsymbol{U}_{E}\cdot\boldsymbol{\kappa}, corresponds to the work done on the curvature drift of the bulk parallel flow, i.e., the centrifugal part. In contrast to (5), equation (2.8) assumes that the magnetic moment is conserved and that ρi/LB≪1\rho_{i}/L_{B}\ll1.

To relate the two descriptions, we use the exact evolution of the magnetic field strength along the E×B\boldsymbol{E}\times\boldsymbol{B} flow (see Appendix B) and rewrite (2.8) in terms of the Eulerian terms of (2.5),

dEiLGCdt=W∥+Wdia+Wcurv1+miniUi∥2UE⋅κ+mini2Dg∣UE∣2−∇⋅(pi⊥UE)−βi⊥2J∥E∥(9)\frac{\mathrm{d}\mathcal{E}_{i}^{\mathrm{LGC}}}{\mathrm{d}t} = W_{\parallel}+W_{\mathrm{dia}}+W_{\mathrm{curv1}} + m_{i}n_{i}U_{i\parallel}^{2}\boldsymbol{U}_{E}\cdot\boldsymbol{\kappa} + \frac{m_{i}n_{i}}{2}D_{g}\lvert\boldsymbol{U}_{E}\rvert^{2} - \nabla\cdot(p_{i\perp}\boldsymbol{U}_{E}) - \frac{\beta_{i\perp}}{2}J_{\parallel}E_{\parallel} \tag*{(9)}

where βi⊥=8πpi⊥/B2\beta_{i\perp}=8\pi p_{i\perp}/B^{2} and J∥J_{\parallel} is the total parallel current. Subtracting (2.9) from (2.5), we obtain the difference between the two descriptions,

ji⋅E−dEiLGCdt=Wagy+∇⋅(pi⊥UE)+βi⊥2J∥E∥+Wrot+W⊥(10)\boldsymbol{j}_{i}\cdot\boldsymbol{E} -\frac{\mathrm{d}\mathcal{E}_{i}^{\mathrm{LGC}}}{\mathrm{d}t} = W_{\mathrm{agy}}+\nabla\cdot(p_{i\perp}\boldsymbol{U}_{E}) +\frac{\beta_{i\perp}}{2}J_{\parallel}E_{\parallel} +W_{\mathrm{rot}}+W_{\perp} \tag*{(10)}

where Wrot=miniUi∥UE⋅DEb^W_{\mathrm{rot}}=m_{i}n_{i}U_{i\parallel}\boldsymbol{U}_{E}\cdot D_{E}\hat{\boldsymbol{b}} is the work associated with the rotation of the magnetic field direction along the E×B\boldsymbol{E}\times\boldsymbol{B} flow, and W⊥W_{\perp} contains three terms of first and second order in the non-E×B\boldsymbol{E}\times\boldsymbol{B} perpendicular flow u⊥=Ui⊥−UE\boldsymbol{u}_{\perp}=\boldsymbol{U}_{i\perp}-\boldsymbol{U}_{E} (see Appendix B). We note that WrotW_{\mathrm{rot}} is part of the full guiding-centre energy equation, but previous studies neglected it [18] (Li et al. 2017). Since ji⋅E\boldsymbol{j}_{i}\cdot\boldsymbol{E} is exact, (2.10) captures the part of the work done by the field on the ions that the truncated guiding-centre description misses.

Equations (2.9) and (2.10) have several implications. First, Wcurv1W_{\mathrm{curv1}} does not correspond to the Fermi term. Wcurv1W_{\mathrm{curv1}} depends on the pressure anisotropy pi∥−pi⊥p_{i\parallel}-p_{i\perp}, whereas the Fermi term depends on pi∥+miniUi∥2p_{i\parallel}+m_{i}n_{i}U_{i\parallel}^{2}. The difference pi⊥UE⋅κp_{i\perp}\boldsymbol{U}_{E}\cdot\boldsymbol{\kappa} contributes to the betatron term, while the centrifugal part is included in WpolW_{\mathrm{pol}}. Therefore, a small Wcurv1W_{\mathrm{curv1}} does not imply weak Fermi energisation. The rewriting in (2.6) separates the two contributions, i.e., WbetaW_{\mathrm{beta}} corresponds to the betatron term up to the flux and twist terms, and WFermiW_{\mathrm{Fermi}} to the Fermi term without its centrifugal part. Second, the terms in (2.10) are of two types. On the one hand, the flux term integrates to zero over the periodic domain, and the twist term and WrotW_{\mathrm{rot}} remain finite even where guiding-centre theory is valid. Thus, these terms emerge from the truncation underlying the usual derivation of (2.8). On the other hand, WagyW_{\mathrm{agy}} and W⊥W_{\perp} vanish in the gyrotropic, small-ρi/LB\rho_{i}/L_{B} limit and, therefore, quantify the breakdown of the guiding-centre description itself. In particular, WagyW_{\mathrm{agy}} has no guiding-centre counterpart and provides the simplest diagnostic of this breakdown. In this study, we use (2.10) qualitatively (§5) and leave a term-by-term evaluation for future work.

Relation to the kinetic energisation mechanisms

The terms in (5) also relate to the individual energisation mechanisms that transfer field energy to particles, as listed in § 1. The decomposition rearranges a fluid moment, whereas Landau and transit-time damping, cyclotron damping, and stochastic heating describe resonances in velocity space. The two are therefore not in one-to-one correspondence, and each term collects both resonant and non-resonant contributions. Broadly, ion Landau damping acts through E∥E_{\parallel} and is carried by W∥W_{\parallel} ([30]), while transit-time damping acts through the mirror force and enters through the betatron term, that is, through WdiaW_{\mathrm{dia}} in (5) ([3]). Ion-cyclotron damping is gyrophase-resonant, so it enters WagyW_{\mathrm{agy}} instantaneously, but its secular effect is the gyrotropic relaxation of the pressure anisotropy, which acts on the coefficients of Wcurv1W_{\mathrm{curv1}} and WdiaW_{\mathrm{dia}} although it does not do work through them ([27, 1]). Stochastic heating ([23]) and energisation in reconnecting current sheets ((Li et al. 2017)) are not confined to a single term: the first appears among the perpendicular terms, and the second combines parallel acceleration with Fermi energisation.

Numerical simulations

Governing equations and numerical setup

We use the hybrid-Vlasov–Maxwell (HVM) code ([52]), which advances the Vlasov equation for the ion phase-space density fi(x,v,t)f_i(\boldsymbol{x},\boldsymbol{v},t),

∂tfi+v⋅∇fi+emi(E+vc×B)⋅∇vfi=0.(11)\partial_t f_i+\boldsymbol{v}\cdot\nabla f_i+\frac{e}{m_i}\left(\boldsymbol{E}+\frac{\boldsymbol{v}}{c}\times\boldsymbol{B}\right)\cdot\nabla_v f_i=0. \tag*{(11)}

The electrons are treated as a charge-neutralising fluid with a reduced mass ratio mi/me=100m_i/m_e=100, so de=0.1did_e=0.1d_i, where di=c/ωpi=c/(4πne2/mi)1/2d_i=c/\omega_{pi}=c/(4\pi n e^2/m_i)^{1/2} is the ion inertial length. The electric field is obtained from a generalised Ohm’s law in which electron inertia is retained,

(1−de2∇2)E=−Uic×B+J×Benc−∇Peen+4πde2c2∇⋅(UiJ+JUi−JJen),(12)(1-d_e^2\nabla^2)\boldsymbol{E}=-\frac{\boldsymbol{U}_i}{c}\times\boldsymbol{B}+\frac{\boldsymbol{J}\times\boldsymbol{B}}{en c}-\frac{\nabla P_e}{en}+\frac{4\pi d_e^2}{c^2}\nabla\cdot\left(\boldsymbol{U}_i\boldsymbol{J}+\boldsymbol{J}\boldsymbol{U}_i-\frac{\boldsymbol{J}\boldsymbol{J}}{en}\right), \tag*{(12)}

where J=(c/4π)∇×B\boldsymbol{J}=(c/4\pi)\nabla\times\boldsymbol{B} is the total current density neglecting the displacement current. Equation (12) also assumes quasi-neutrality so that ∂tJ≃(c2/4π)∇2E\partial_t\boldsymbol{J}\simeq(c^2/4\pi)\nabla^2\boldsymbol{E}. We use an isothermal electron closure Pe=nTe0P_e=nT_{e0} and βe0=8πpe0/B2=0.1\beta_{e0}=8\pi p_{e0}/B^2=0.1 in both runs.

Table 1 summarises the parameters of the two runs. These runs were previously used to study electron-only reconnection in decaying turbulence ([20]). The spatial domain is a triply periodic cube of side L=6πdiL=6\pi d_i discretised on a uniform Np3N_p^3 grid, while velocity space spans [−U,U][-U,U] in each direction on an Nv3N_v^3 grid. With Np=256N_p=256, the grid spacing is Δx=0.074di=0.74de\Delta x=0.074d_i=0.74d_e, so that the electron inertial length is resolved by fewer than two cells and the sub-ded_e range is not resolved. High-order compact filters [31] suppress spurious energy accumulation at the grid scale.

At tΩci=0t\Omega_{ci}=0, a uniform background field B0=B0z^\boldsymbol{B}_0=B_0\hat{\boldsymbol{z}} is imposed. Superposed on it are isotropic three-dimensional magnetic fluctuations δB=δB⊥+δB∥z^\delta\boldsymbol{B}=\delta B_{\perp}+\delta B_{\parallel}\hat{\boldsymbol{z}}, initialised through a vector potential perturbation δA\delta\boldsymbol{A} with δB=∇×δA\delta\boldsymbol{B}=\nabla\times\delta\boldsymbol{A}. The fluctuations are seeded in the narrow band 0.3≤kdi≤10.3\le kd_i\le1 with root-mean-square amplitude δBrms,0/B0=0.5\delta B_{\mathrm{rms},0}/B_0=0.5. The turbulence is therefore injected near the ion scales, which is relevant to planetary magnetospheres such as Earth’s, where the correlation length is typically λc∼10di\lambda_c\sim10d_i ([48]), rather than the solar wind, where an extended MHD cascade precedes the ion scales.

βi0\beta_{i0}δBrms,0/B0\delta B_{\mathrm{rms},0}/B_0βe\beta_eDim.L (di)L\ (d_i)NpN_pDim.U (vth,i)U\ (v_{\mathrm{th},i})NvN_v
Run A0.250.50.13D6π6\pi2563V7.057
Run B40.50.13D6π6\pi2563V5.057

Table 1. Parameters of the two hybrid-Vlasov–Maxwell runs. Both start from isotropic ion VDFs and electron pressure, Ti⊥/Ti∥=Te⊥/Te∥=1T_{i\perp}/T_{i\parallel}=T_{e\perp}/T_{e\parallel}=1, with magnetic fluctuations seeded in 0.3≤kdi≤10.3 \leq k d_i \leq1.

Unless stated otherwise, all quantities are shown at the time of peak root-mean-square current density, Jrms=⟨∣J−⟨J⟩∣2⟩1/2J_{\mathrm{rms}}=\langle|\mathbf{J}-\langle\mathbf{J}\rangle|^2\rangle^{1/2}. This peak occurs at tΩci=13.20t\Omega_{ci}=13.20 for βi0=0.25\beta_{i0}=0.25 and tΩci=15.60t\Omega_{ci}=15.60 for βi0=4\beta_{i0}=4, and it is the conventional proxy for the time at which the turbulence is fully developed [45, 53].

Diagnostics

We compute the moments nin_i, Ui\mathbf{U}_i, and Pi\mathbf{P}_i directly from fif_i on the velocity grid, and evaluate spatial derivatives spectrally, as the solver does [52].

The convective derivative in Ui,pol\mathbf{U}_{i,\mathrm{pol}} and WpolW_{\mathrm{pol}} requires ∂tUi\partial_t\mathbf{U}_i. However, the field dumps are separated by ΔtΩci≃1.2\Delta t\Omega_{ci}\simeq1.2, which is too coarse to resolve it. Therefore, we evaluate the polarisation drift and the polarisation term as residuals,

Ui,pol=Ui⊥−UE−Ui,dia−Ui,curv1−Ui,agy,(13)\mathbf{U}_{i,\mathrm{pol}}=\mathbf{U}_{i\perp}-\mathbf{U}_E-\mathbf{U}_{i,\mathrm{dia}}-\mathbf{U}_{i,\mathrm{curv1}}-\mathbf{U}_{i,\mathrm{agy}}, \tag*{(13)}
Wpol=eniUi,pol⋅E=ji⋅E−W∥−Wdia−Wcurv1−Wagy.(14)W_{\mathrm{pol}}=en_i\mathbf{U}_{i,\mathrm{pol}}\cdot\mathbf{E}=\mathbf{j}_i\cdot\mathbf{E}-W_{\parallel}-W_{\mathrm{dia}}-W_{\mathrm{curv1}}-W_{\mathrm{agy}.} \tag*{(14)}

This is not an approximation. Substituting the momentum equation (1) for dUi/dtd\mathbf{U}_i/dt in WpolW_{\mathrm{pol}} and using UE⋅E=0\mathbf{U}_E\cdot\mathbf{E}=0 gives (3.3b) identically. However, the computed WpolW_{\mathrm{pol}} includes discretisation errors in the other four terms and numerical dissipation. Since the budget closes by construction, its closure does not test the accuracy of the calculation.

Results

Development of the turbulence and fluctuation spectra

Figure 1 shows the time evolution of the reduced perpendicular power spectra P(k⊥)P(k_\perp) of the electric field, ion density, magnetic field, and ion bulk velocity for runs A and B. Throughout the paper, we define k⊥k_\perp with respect to the background magnetic field B0\mathbf{B}_0, not the local field, so k⊥=kx2+ky2k_\perp=\sqrt{k_x^2+k_y^2}. For βi0=0.25\beta_{i0}=0.25 (figure 1a–d), the electric and magnetic spectra are close to one another around the ion gyroradius. Both are consistent with a k⊥−8/3k_\perp^{-8/3} scaling over 1≲k⊥di≲51\lesssim k_\perp d_i\lesssim5, as expected for a kinetic-Alfvén cascade [8]. At k⊥de≳1k_\perp d_e\gtrsim1, both fall off exponentially under the numerical filter acting at the grid scale. The electric-field spectrum between ρi\rho_i and ded_e is somewhat steeper than the PE(k⊥)∼k⊥2PB(k⊥)P_E(k_\perp)\sim k_\perp^2P_B(k_\perp) expected when the Hall term sets E⊥\mathbf{E}_\perp. We attribute this to the short sub-ion range ρi=0.5 di=5 de\rho_i=0.5\,d_i=5\,d_e, and the numerical filter acts from k⊥de≃1k_\perp d_e\simeq1. Decomposing E\mathbf{E} into terms of (3.2) (not shown) confirms that the Hall term dominates below ρi\rho_i and follows k⊥2PBk_\perp^2P_B just below ρi\rho_i before steepening.

Time evolution of the reduced perpendicular power spectra

Figure 1. Time evolution of the reduced perpendicular power spectra for βi0=0.25\beta_{i0}=0.25 (top row) and βi0=4\beta_{i0}=4 (bottom row). (a,e) Electric field, (b,f) ion density, (c,g) magnetic field and (d,h) ion bulk velocity. Solid and dot-dashed lines show the perpendicular and parallel components, respectively. Line darkness increases with time, as indicated in the legend. Vertical dashed lines mark k⊥ρi=1k_\perp\rho_i=1 and k⊥de=1k_\perp d_e=1, and black solid lines indicate the reference power laws quoted in the text. All quantities are in code units.

For βi0=4\beta_{i0}=4 (figure 1e–h), the magnetic spectrum is nearly unchanged, but the electric spectrum is shallower, close to k⊥−2/3k_\perp^{-2/3}. This follows from the change of regime in Ohm’s law. When the ions decouple from the magnetic field, the perpendicular electric field is set not by the ideal term −Ui×B/c-\mathbf{U}_i\times\mathbf{B}/c but by the Hall and electron-pressure terms. Both scale as k⊥δBk_\perp\delta B, so that PE(k⊥)∼k⊥2PB(k⊥)∼k⊥−2/3P_E(k_\perp) \sim k_\perp^2 P_B(k_\perp) \sim k_\perp^{-2/3}. The same flattening is observed in the Earth’s magnetosheath [36, 16].

In both runs, the ion bulk velocity spectrum steepens sharply below the ion gyroradius, with an effective slope close to −4-4. This is consistent with the strong decoupling of the ion flow from the magnetic fluctuations reported in hybrid and fully kinetic 3D simulations [19, 21, 13].

The spectra therefore indicate that run A resolves the k⊥ρi<1k_\perp\rho_i<1 physics well but has only a short sub-ion range, limited by the reduced mass ratio. In contrast, run B displays a fully developed sub-ion cascade, with more than one decade separating ρi=2di\rho_i=2d_i from de=0.1did_e=0.1d_i.

Departures of the ion VDFs from a Maxwellian

Two terms of (2.5) require the ion VDF to depart from an isotropic Maxwellian. Wcurv1W_{\mathrm{curv1}} vanishes unless the pressure is anisotropic and the field is curved along the E×B\boldsymbol{E}\times\boldsymbol{B} flow, while WagyW_{\mathrm{agy}} vanishes unless the ion VDF is non-gyrotropic. We therefore characterise those departures before turning to the field geometry and the budget.

Figure 2 shows, for run A, the isotropic ion pressure pi=13Tr⁡(Pi)p_i=\frac{1}{3}\operatorname{Tr}(\boldsymbol{P}_i), the pressure anisotropy pi⊥/pi∥p_{i\perp}/p_{i\parallel} and Swisdak’s agyrotropy measure [50]

Qi=(pi,122+pi,132+pi,232pi⊥2+2pi∥pi⊥)1/2∈[0,1],(15)\sqrt{Q_i}=\left(\frac{p_{i,12}^{2}+p_{i,13}^{2}+p_{i,23}^{2}}{p_{i\perp}^{2}+2p_{i\parallel}p_{i\perp}}\right)^{1/2}\in[0,1], \tag*{(15)}

where the off-diagonal elements are taken in the local field-aligned frame oriented such that the last two diagonal components are equal.

The pressure anisotropy spans a broad range, 0.5≲pi⊥/pi∥≲50.5\lesssim p_{i\perp}/p_{i\parallel}\lesssim5. The joint distribution of pi⊥/pi∥p_{i\perp}/p_{i\parallel} and βi∥=8πpi∥/B2\beta_{i\parallel}=8\pi p_{i\parallel}/B^2 (Figure 2f) has its upper envelope bounded by the mirror-instability threshold (Hellinger et al. [22]), as previously reported for turbulent plasmas in the Earth’s magnetosheath (Richard et al. [41]). Nevertheless, the bulk of the distribution lies well inside that bound, near isotropy. Measured against the empirical threshold in Figure 2(f), which corresponds to a growth rate γ=10−2Ωci\gamma=10^{-2}\Omega_{ci}, only 0.06 % of the grid cells are potentially mirror unstable. The lower envelope, pi⊥/pi∥≃0.5p_{i\perp}/p_{i\parallel}\simeq0.5, is not set by the firehose thresholds, which are non-positive at these βi∥\beta_{i\parallel} and therefore unreachable.

Figure 2. Departures of the ion VDFs from an isotropic Maxwellian for run A (βi0=0.25\beta_{i0}=0.25) at tΩci=13.20t\Omega_{ci}=13.20. (a) Ion scalar pressure pip_i, (b) pressure anisotropy log⁡10(pi⊥/pi∥)\log_{10}(p_{i\perp}/p_{i\parallel}) and (c) agyrotropy Qi\sqrt{Q_i}, all shown on the faces of the simulation domain. (d) Distributions of the ratios of the eigenvalues of the ion pressure tensor. (e) Distributions of the alignment of the corresponding principal directions with the local magnetic field. (f) Joint distribution of pi⊥/pi∥p_{i\perp}/p_{i\parallel} and βi∥\beta_{i\parallel}, with the mirror, ion-cyclotron, parallel- and oblique-firehose thresholds (for γ=10−2Ωci\gamma=10^{-2}\Omega_{ci}) shown as dashed lines.

The agyrotropy locally reaches Qi≃0.42\sqrt{Q_i}\simeq0.42, although its volume average is only 0.14. We decompose the ion pressure tensor into its principal axes, with eigenvalues λ1≥λ2≥λ3\lambda_1\ge\lambda_2\ge\lambda_3 and eigenvectors e^1,e^2,e^3\hat{e}_1,\hat{e}_2,\hat{e}_3. We find (Figure 2e) that e^3\hat{e}_3 is preferentially aligned or anti-aligned with the local magnetic field b^\hat{b}, which indicates that the ion VDF is narrowest along b^\hat{b}, i.e., a strong predominance of perpendicular-heating processes in low-beta turbulence. This result is consistent with the heavy tails of the λ1/λ3\lambda_1/\lambda_3 and λ2/λ3\lambda_2/\lambda_3 distributions (Figure 2d) and with the skew of pi⊥/pi∥p_{i\perp}/p_{i\parallel} towards values greater than unity.

Figure 3 shows the same analysis for run B. Consistent with the spectra, the ion pressure develops much finer sub-ion-scale structure than at low βi0\beta_{i0}. Both the pressure anisotropy and the agyrotropy are strongly reduced, 0.9≲pi⊥/pi∥≲1.10.9\lesssim p_{i\perp}/p_{i\parallel}\lesssim1.1 and Qi≲0.05\sqrt{Q_i}\lesssim0.05, an order of magnitude smaller than in run A. In addition, the whole anisotropy distribution lies well inside all four thresholds. The sub-ion-scale turbulence therefore does not drive significant departures from a gyrotropic Maxwellian at this βi0\beta_{i0}, and no instability can realistically constrain the anisotropy. Because the ion VDFs are nearly isotropic, the principal axes are nearly degenerate, and their orientation relative to b^\hat{b} is nearly random.

Departures of the ion VDFs from an isotropic Maxwellian

Figure 3. Departures of the ion VDFs from an isotropic Maxwellian for run B (βi0=4\beta_{i0}=4) at tΩci=15.60t\Omega_{ci}=15.60. (a) Ion scalar pressure pip_i, (b) pressure anisotropy log⁡10(pi⊥/pi∥)\log_{10}(p_{i\perp}/p_{i\parallel}) and (c) agyrotropy Qi\sqrt{Q_i}, all shown on the faces of the simulation domain. (d) Distributions of the ratios of the eigenvalues of the ion pressure tensor. (e) Distributions of the alignment of the corresponding principal directions with the local magnetic field. (f) Joint distribution of pi⊥/pi∥p_{i\perp}/p_{i\parallel} and βi∥\beta_{i\parallel}, with the mirror (magenta), ion-cyclotron (pink), parallel-firehose (blue) and oblique-firehose (cyan) thresholds (for γ=10−2Ωci\gamma=10^{-2}\Omega_{ci}) shown as dashed lines.

In summary, at βi0=0.25\beta_{i0}=0.25 the ion VDFs develop a broad range of pressure anisotropies whose upper envelope follows the mirror threshold, together with substantial local agyrotropy. At βi0=4\beta_{i0}=4, they remain close to isotropic and well inside every threshold. In neither run is the bulk of the distribution held at a marginal-stability boundary. We return in §5 to the apparent paradox that WagyW_{\mathrm{agy}} nevertheless dominates the budget at βi0=4\beta_{i0}=4, where the agyrotropy is smallest.

Magnetic-field geometry

The magnetic-field curvature enters ion energisation through UE⋅κU_E\cdot\boldsymbol{\kappa}. In addition, the loss of μ\mu conservation in strongly curved regions (rc∼ρir_c\sim\rho_i) renders the ion motion chaotic and leads to pitch-angle scattering [2, 32, 41]. Figure 4 shows, for both runs, the current density magnitude and the radius of curvature normalised to the local ion gyroradius, rc/ρir_c/\rho_i, together with the distributions of UE⋅κU_E\cdot\boldsymbol{\kappa} and of ∣κ∣|\boldsymbol{\kappa}| normalised to its root-mean-square value ∣κ∣rms|\boldsymbol{\kappa}|_{\mathrm{rms}}. The gyroradius is evaluated cell by cell as ρi=βi⊥di\rho_i=\sqrt{\beta_{i\perp}}d_i, with βi⊥=8πpi⊥/B2\beta_{i\perp}=8\pi p_{i\perp}/B^2 the local perpendicular ion beta. The regions of strongest curvature are organised into thin, sheet-like structures that coincide with current sheets. In both runs, rcr_c falls to the local gyroradius there, rc/ρi≲1r_c/\rho_i\lesssim1, while the bulk of the volume has rc≳10 ρir_c\gtrsim10\,\rho_i. The magnetic moment is therefore not an adiabatic invariant in the regions expected to dominate energisation [53], which justifies the Eulerian approach adopted here.

Figure 4. Magnetic-field geometry for run A (βi0=0.25\beta_{i0} = 0.25, tΩci=13.20t\Omega_{ci} = 13.20, top row) and run B (βi0=4\beta_{i0} = 4, tΩci=15.60t\Omega_{ci} = 15.60, bottom row). (a,d) Current density magnitude ∣J∣|\mathbf{J}| and (b,e) log⁡10(rc/ρi)\log_{10}(r_c/\rho_i), the radius of curvature rc=∣κ∣−1r_c = |\boldsymbol{\kappa}|^{-1} normalised to the local ion gyroradius, both on the faces of the simulation domain. (c) Probability density function of UE⋅κU_E \cdot\boldsymbol{\kappa}, the rate common to the curvature and Fermi terms, on a linear abscissa. The dashed lines are fits to (16). (f) Probability density function of ∣κ∣|\boldsymbol{\kappa}| normalised to its root-mean-square value, with the ∣κ∣|\boldsymbol{\kappa}| and ∣κ∣−2.5|\boldsymbol{\kappa}|^{-2.5} reference slopes indicated. In (c) and (f), both runs are shown, distinguished by opacity. All quantities are in code units.

The distribution of ∣κ∣/∣κ∣rms|\boldsymbol{\kappa}|/|\boldsymbol{\kappa}|_{\mathrm{rms}} is insensitive to βi0\beta_{i0}. In both runs, it rises as ∣κ∣|\boldsymbol{\kappa}| at small curvature, as required for a three-dimensional isotropic random field [57, 5], and peaks at the rms value, which is ∣κ∣rms=0.1 di−1≈0.2 ℓ⊥−1|\boldsymbol{\kappa}|_{\mathrm{rms}}=0.1\,d_i^{-1}\approx0.2\,\ell_\perp^{-1} at βi0=0.25\beta_{i0}=0.25 and 0.03 di−1≈0.05 ℓ⊥−10.03\,d_i^{-1}\approx0.05\,\ell_\perp^{-1} at βi0=4\beta_{i0}=4, where ℓ⊥\ell_\perp is the perpendicular correlation length of the magnetic field. Measured against the gyroradius, the two runs are almost indistinguishable, ∣κ∣rmsρi=0.05|\boldsymbol{\kappa}|_{\mathrm{rms}}\rho_i = 0.05 at βi0=0.25\beta_{i0} = 0.25 and 0.06 at βi0=4\beta_{i0} = 4, so that ∣κ∣rms∝ρi−1|\boldsymbol{\kappa}|_{\mathrm{rms}} \propto\rho_i^{-1}. In neither run does the tail reach the ∣κ∣−2.5|\boldsymbol{\kappa}|^{-2.5} scaling predicted for MHD turbulence (Yang et al. [57]) and reported in the magnetosheath (Bandyopadhyay et al. [5]; Richard et al. [41]). Both fall off considerably faster. The same behaviour was found in the fully kinetic simulations of Sebastian & Comisso [44] and follows from the moderate fluctuation amplitude, δBrms,0/B0=0.5\delta B_{\mathrm{rms},0}/B_0 = 0.5, which is too weak to produce sharp field-line bends.

The distribution of UE⋅κU_E \cdot\boldsymbol{\kappa} (Figure 4c) is sharply peaked at zero with near-exponential tails. It is close to symmetric at βi0=0.25\beta_{i0} = 0.25 (skewness 0.04) but appreciably skewed at βi0=4\beta_{i0} = 4 (skewness 0.86). Its width differs strongly between the runs, ∣UE⋅κ∣rms=0.024Ωci|U_E \cdot\boldsymbol{\kappa}|_{\mathrm{rms}} = 0.024\Omega_{ci} at βi0=0.25\beta_{i0} = 0.25 against 0.004Ωci0.004\Omega_{ci} at βi0=4\beta_{i0} = 4. This behaviour reflects an order-of-magnitude decrease in ion-velocity fluctuations (Figure 1d,Figure 1h), a threefold decrease in rms curvature, and weaker alignment between UEU_E and κ\boldsymbol{\kappa}. Alfvénic fluctuations are expected to result in a near-symmetric distribution, with the flow and curvature out of phase so that field-line contraction and expansion nearly cancel (Sebastian & Comisso [44]). The positive skewness at βi0=4\beta_{i0} = 4 indicates a small net excess of contraction.

Spatial distribution and volume-integrated budget

Figure 5 and Figure 6 show the total ion energisation Wtot=ji⋅EW_{\mathrm{tot}} = \mathbf{j}_i \cdot\mathbf{E} and each term of (5) for the two runs, on a common colour scale. The energisation is strongly intermittent. It is concentrated in thin structures that occupy a small fraction of the volume and alternate in sign, as is generic in kinetic turbulence (Wan et al. [53]; Chasapis et al. [15]; Bandyopadhyay et al. [4]). The parallel and curvature terms are visually negligible in both runs. In contrast, the diamagnetic, agyrotropic and polarisation terms reach comparable amplitudes, with WpolW_{\mathrm{pol}} organised into the largest-scale structures and WagyW_{\mathrm{agy}} into the finest.

Figure 5. Decomposition of the ion energisation rate for run A (βi0=0.25\beta_{i0}=0.25) at tΩci=13.20t\Omega_{ci}=13.20. (a) Total Wtot=ji⋅EW_{\mathrm{tot}}=\mathbf{j}_i\cdot\mathbf{E}, (b) parallel W∥W_{\parallel}, (c) diamagnetic WdiaW_{\mathrm{dia}}, (d) curvature Wcurv1W_{\mathrm{curv1}}, (e) agyrotropic WagyW_{\mathrm{agy}} and (f) polarisation WpolW_{\mathrm{pol}}, all on the same colour scale and in code units.

Figure 6. Decomposition of the ion energisation rate for run B (βi0=4\beta_{i0}=4) at tΩci=15.60t\Omega_{ci}=15.60. (a) Total Wtot=ji⋅EW_{\mathrm{tot}}=\mathbf{j}_i\cdot\mathbf{E}, (b) parallel W∥W_{\parallel}, (c) diamagnetic WdiaW_{\mathrm{dia}}, (d) curvature Wcurv1W_{\mathrm{curv1}}, (e) agyrotropic WagyW_{\mathrm{agy}} and (f) polarisation WpolW_{\mathrm{pol}}, all on the same colour scale and in code units.

Table 2 gives the volume-integrated budget. At βi0=0.25\beta_{i0}=0.25, the polarisation current dominates, carrying 76% of the total, followed by the agyrotropic term at 21%. The diamagnetic term contributes only 5%, and the curvature and parallel terms are at the per cent level, with the former opposite in sign to the total. At βi0=4\beta_{i0}=4, the composition changes qualitatively. The total is 3.9 times smaller; the agyrotropic term alone carries 91%, and the diamagnetic term 45%, while the polarisation term reverses sign and removes 34%. We return to the sign reversal in §§§ 4.6 and 5.3 The parallel and curvature terms are negligible in both runs. The last three columns of Table 2 give the pressure–strain interaction and its two parts. They are not terms of (5) but measure a different exchange, and we return to them in § 5.

energisation rate (2.5)pressure–strain
WtotW_{\mathrm{tot}}W∥W_{\parallel}WdiaW_{\mathrm{dia}}Wcurv1W_{\mathrm{curv1}}WagyW_{\mathrm{agy}}WpolW_{\mathrm{pol}}PS−piθi-p_i\theta_i−Πi:Di-\boldsymbol{\Pi}_i:\mathbf{D}_i
Run Acode units30.140.301.58−0.806.2422.8111.782.499.29
βi0=0.25\beta_{i0}=0.251001.05.3−2.620.775.739.18.330.8
per cent
σ (10−3)\sigma\ (10^{-3})31.50.43528.12.1617.741.0———
SS+0.36−0.55+0.00+0.48−0.60−0.18———
α\alpha7.771.943.301.193.515.52———
ξ (10−3)\xi\ (10^{-3})18.20.12711.80.3327.2921.2———
Run Bcode units7.65−0.013.40−0.046.92−2.627.492.295.20
βi0=4\beta_{i0}=4100−0.244.5−0.690.5−34.297.929.968.0
per cent
σ (10−3)\sigma\ (10^{-3})7.890.07638.590.2437.104.03———
SS+0.60+0.51+0.40−1.29+0.42−0.35———
α\alpha8.042.527.291.749.0711.68———
ξ (10−3)\xi\ (10^{-3})4.590.02564.880.06254.272.51———

Table 2. Volume-integrated ion energisation rate and the statistics of its pointwise distribution for each term of (2.5) at peak JrmsJ_{\mathrm{rms}}. For each run, the first two lines give the volume integral in code units, rounded to two decimal places, and its percentage of the total, computed from the unrounded values. The polarisation term is the residual (3.3b), so the five terms sum to the total by construction. The last four lines give the standard deviation σ\sigma and skewness SS of the measured distribution, and the shape and scale parameters α\alpha and ξ\xi of the generalised double Pareto fit (4.2); σ\sigma and ξ\xi are in units of 10−310^{-3} code units, while SS and α\alpha are dimensionless. The last three columns give the pressure–strain interaction PS=−(Pi⋅∇)⋅Ui\mathrm{PS}=-(\mathbf{P}_i\cdot\nabla)\cdot\mathbf{U}_i and its two parts, computed from (5.4). They are not part of the decomposition (2.5); their percentages are given relative to WtotW_{\mathrm{tot}}, and they have not been fitted with (4.2).

Figure 7 shows the corresponding distributions of the ion energisation terms normalised to the rms total energisation Wtot,rmsW_{\mathrm{tot,rms}}. Similar to the distribution of UE⋅κU_E\cdot\kappa, they are sharply peaked at zero with pronounced non-Gaussian wings. The volume integrals in Table 2 therefore accumulate in a small fraction of cells. We characterise these distributions by fitting a generalised double Pareto (GDP) form,

Figure 7. Probability density functions of the terms of (5) normalised to the rms total ion energisation Wtot,rmsW_{\mathrm{tot,rms}} for (a) run A (βi0=0.25\beta_{i0}=0.25) and (b) run B (βi0=4\beta_{i0}=4) at the time of peak JrmsJ_{\mathrm{rms}}. Solid lines show the measured distributions, and dashed lines show the generalised double Pareto fits (16), with parameters listed in Table 2. (c) Average of ∣W∣|W| conditioned on QJ=14J2/⟨J2⟩Q_J=\frac{1}{4}J^2/\langle J^2\rangle and normalised to the unconditional average, for both runs (distinguished by opacity). The horizontal line marks unity, and the vertical dotted line marks the mean ⟨QJ⟩=1/4\langle Q_J\rangle=1/4. All quantities are in code units.

P(W)=12ξ(1+∣W∣αξ)−(α+1)(16)P(W)=\frac{1}{2\xi}\left(1+\frac{\lvert W\rvert}{\alpha\xi}\right)^{-(\alpha+1)} \tag*{(16)}

by maximum likelihood on the unbinned values of all grid cells. This GDP distribution may arise from a superposition of Laplace distributions whose inverse scale follows a Gamma distribution of shape α\alpha. We note that this interpretation is not unique. The Laplace distribution with exponential wings is expected for the product of two fluctuating fields such as ji\mathbf{j}_i and E\mathbf{E}, and the Gamma mixing accounts for variations in local energisation intensity between structures. The parameter α\alpha controls the wings, which decay as P(W)∝∣W∣−(α+1)P(W)\propto|W|^{-(\alpha+1)}. It is the inverse squared coefficient of variation of the Gamma-distributed rate, so small α\alpha indicates energy exchange concentrated in intermittent coherent structures [44]. In the opposite limit, α→∞\alpha\to\infty, the mixing distribution collapses and (16) reduces to a Laplace distribution of scale ξ\xi, i.e. to the case of no intermittency.

Table 2 also gives σ\sigma and the skewness SS of each measured distribution, together with the fitted α\alpha and ξ\xi. We find that every term is narrower at βi0=4\beta_{i0}=4, but not by the same factor. The width decreases by a factor of 10.2 for WpolW_{\mathrm{pol}} and 8.9 for Wcurv1W_{\mathrm{curv1}}, against only 2.5 for WagyW_{\mathrm{agy}}. The widest distribution therefore changes from WpolW_{\mathrm{pol}} at βi0=0.25\beta_{i0}=0.25 to the diamagnetic and agyrotropic terms at βi0=4\beta_{i0} = 4. The total decreases by a factor of 4.0, close to the 3.9 factor found for the volume integral. The local statistics thus reproduce the change of composition seen in the budget.

Moreover, α\alpha increases for every term, suggesting that energisation becomes less intermittent as βi0\beta_{i0} increases. The βi0=4\beta_{i0} = 4 run has an extended sub-ion range and essentially no MHD range, whereas at βi0=0.25\beta_{i0} = 0.25, the injection scale lies above the ion gyroradius and the sub-ion range is short (§ 4.1). The less intermittent distributions are thus found in the run whose cascade is almost entirely kinetic. This is consistent with the crossover, observed in situ in turbulent space plasma and in numerical simulations, from multifractal scaling in the inertial range to non-Gaussian monoscaling below the ion gyroscale [28, 33, 42].

In addition, we compute the average of ∣W∣|W| for each term of (5), conditioned on the local current density and normalised to its unconditional value, ⟨∣W∣∣QJ⟩/⟨∣W∣⟩\langle|W| \mid Q_J \rangle/\langle|W| \rangle (Figure 7c). Here QJ=14J2/⟨J2⟩Q_J = \frac{1}{4}J^2/\langle J^2\rangle is the current contribution to the second invariant of the magnetic-field gradient tensor, normalised such that ⟨QJ⟩=1/4\langle Q_J \rangle= 1/4, marked by the vertical dotted line.

Every term behaves the same way in both runs. Below ⟨QJ⟩\langle Q_J \rangle, the conditional average is flat, and below unity, between 0.2 and 0.6 depending on the term, so the low-current volume is energised less than average. The curves cross unity just above ⟨QJ⟩\langle Q_J \rangle and then rise steeply, reaching a factor of 2 to 3 by QJ≃5Q_J \simeq5. The parallel term rises most steeply and reaches ≃8\simeq8 at βi0=4\beta_{i0} = 4, so W∥W_{\parallel} is the term most tightly confined to the current sheets, even though it is negligible in the volume integral. This is consistent with the formation of field-aligned electric fields in regions of electron-only reconnection [20], to which we return in § 4.5. The two runs are nearly indistinguishable once QJQ_J is measured against its own mean, so this organisation is insensitive to βi0\beta_{i0}. The only systematic difference is that the βi0=0.25\beta_{i0} = 0.25 run reaches larger QJQ_J, its current density being more extreme relative to its mean.

Taken together with the heavy tails of Figure 7(a,Figure 7b), this locates the intermittency of the energisation. The fits to (16) show that energy exchange is concentrated in rare events, and the conditional averages show that these events occur in regions of intense current, where the radius of curvature also falls to the local ion gyroradius (§ 4.3). We note, however, that an enhancement of 2 to 3 means the strongest-current cells are preferentially energised, not that they carry most of the budget, which also depends on their filling factor.

Scale dependence of the decomposition

The spatial distributions in figures 5 and 6 do not show how the terms depend on scale. Figure 8 therefore shows the reduced power spectra P(k⊥)P(k_{\perp}) of the individual drift velocities (left column) and of the individual terms of (5) (right column) for the two runs.

Reduced power spectra of the perpendicular drift velocities and the terms of (2.5)

Figure 8. Reduced power spectra of (a,c) the perpendicular drift velocities and (b,d) the terms of (2.5), for (a,b) run A at tΩci=13.20t\Omega_{ci}=13.20 and (c,d) run B at tΩci=15.60t\Omega_{ci}=15.60. Vertical dashed lines mark k⊥ρi=1k_\perp\rho_i=1 and k⊥de=1k_\perp d_e=1. All quantities are in code units.

At βi0=0.25\beta_{i0} = 0.25 (Figure 8a,Figure 8b), the E×B\mathbf{E} \times\mathbf{B} and polarisation drifts dominate the perpendicular ion flow at k⊥ρi≲1k_{\perp}\rho_i \lesssim1, where the diamagnetic drift is roughly two orders of magnitude smaller. At sub-ion scales, the diamagnetic drift becomes comparable to the polarisation drift, which decreases. The power of the agyrotropic drift is between two and three orders of magnitude below that of the E×B\mathbf{E} \times\mathbf{B} drift at k⊥di<1k_{\perp}d_i < 1 and within an order of magnitude of that of the diamagnetic drift at sub-ion scales. In contrast, the curvature drift power is several orders of magnitude smaller at all scales.

In terms of energisation, the power of WpolW_{\mathrm{pol}} exceeds every other term by about an order of magnitude at k⊥di<1k_{\perp}d_i < 1. Furthermore, at sub-ion scales (k⊥ρi>1k_{\perp}\rho_i > 1), the diamagnetic term’s power becomes comparable to that of the polarisation term, and together they dominate all other terms across all scales, with W∥W_{\parallel} negligible throughout the range.

At βi0=4\beta_{i0}=4 (Figure 8c,Figure 8d), the diamagnetic drift has a nearly flat spectrum over a broad sub-ion range and dominates the non-E×BE\times B flow there. At sub-ion scales, the agyrotropic term’s power becomes comparable to the diamagnetic term’s, and the two track each other closely from k⊥ρi≃1k_{\perp}\rho_i\simeq1 down to the grid scale, whereas the polarisation term is an order of magnitude smaller than either. In addition, the parallel-term spectrum, several orders of magnitude below the total, shows a bump around the electron skin depth. This indicates the formation of field-aligned electric fields at these scales through electron inertia and can be attributed to the onset of electron-only reconnection, as diagnosed in the same simulation by Granier et al. [20].

In both runs, the spectrum of the total is set by the largest individual term rather than by a cancellation between terms. At βi0=0.25\beta_{i0}=0.25, δWtot2\delta W_{\mathrm{tot}}^2 lies on top of δWpol2\delta W_{\mathrm{pol}}^2 over most of the resolved range and falls only slightly below δWpol2\delta W_{\mathrm{pol}}^2 and δWdia2\delta W_{\mathrm{dia}}^2 at sub-ion scales. At βi0=4\beta_{i0}=4, the total tracks δWdia2\delta W_{\mathrm{dia}}^2 and δWagy2\delta W_{\mathrm{agy}}^2 closely from k⊥ρi≃1k_{\perp}\rho_i\simeq1 down to k⊥de≃3k_{\perp}d_e\simeq3. It falls below them only at the smallest resolved scales, where the compact filter acts and where every term is in any case some six orders of magnitude below its peak.

The scale-by-scale picture therefore agrees with the volume-integrated budget of Table 2. The polarisation current carries the energisation at βi0=0.25\beta_{i0}=0.25, while the diamagnetic and agyrotropic currents carry it at βi0=4\beta_{i0}=4, at every scale and in the integral. What changes with scale is the ordering below the dominant term, and in particular the rise of WagyW_{\mathrm{agy}} through k⊥ρi≃1k_{\perp}\rho_i\simeq1, which is where the ion VDF ceases to be gyrotropic.

Time evolution

Figure 9 shows the volume-integrated terms as a function of time for both runs, together with the box-averaged ion temperatures. The earliest output times carry an initialisation transient of amplitude ∼103\sim10^3 in code units. We attribute it to the initial state, isotropic Maxwellian ion VDFs with superposed magnetic fluctuations, not being a stationary solution of the HVM equations (see e.g. Malara et al. 2018, for the analogous case of sheared flows). Both the instantaneous and the cumulative panels therefore start after it, at tΩci=2.5t\Omega_{ci}=2.5.

Volume-integrated terms of equation (2.5) as a function of time for runs A and B

Figure 9. Volume-integrated terms of (5) as a function of time, for run A (βi0=0.25\beta_{i0}=0.25, top) and run B (βi0=4\beta_{i0}=4, bottom). Left, the instantaneous integral ∫W d3x\int W\,\mathrm{d}^{3}x on a symmetric-logarithmic ordinate. Right, its running time integral from t0Ωci=2.5t_0\Omega_{ci}=2.5, ∫t0tdt′∫W d3x\int_{t_0}^{t}\mathrm{d}t'\int W\,\mathrm{d}^{3}x, i.e. the energy transferred by each term, together with the cumulative pressure–strain interaction (dashed blue) and the box-averaged ion temperature TiT_i and its perpendicular and parallel components normalised to their values at t0Ωci=2.5t_0\Omega_{ci}=2.5 (right-hand axis). The vertical dashed line marks the analysis time at which we take table 2 and the spatial maps. All quantities are in code units.

At βi0=0.25\beta_{i0}=0.25, every term, including the total, oscillates in sign with an amplitude several times its mean, and WtotW_{\rm tot} swings between −15-15 and +32+32. The oscillations of WpolW_{\rm pol} track those of WtotW_{\rm tot} in period and amplitude, while the remaining terms largely cancel one another. The running time integral (Figure 9b) is far less oscillatory. The net transfer is positive and reaches ≃45\simeq45 code units by the analysis time. The diamagnetic (≃65\simeq65) and agyrotropic (≃22\simeq22) terms carry most of it, with smaller but non-negligible contributions from the parallel electric field and the curvature term. In contrast, the cumulative polarisation term is negative throughout (≃−50\simeq-50) and drives a net decrease of ion energy in the early stage of the simulation.

At βi0=4\beta_{i0}=4, the diamagnetic, agyrotropic, and polarisation terms also oscillate with a longer period, and the total remains positive except for a single trough near tΩci≃13t\Omega_{ci}\simeq13, where it approaches zero. The parallel and curvature terms contribute a little at early times and then decay to nearly zero. The cumulative transfer, ≃140\simeq140 code units at the analysis time, is dominated by the agyrotropic term (≃205\simeq205). The diamagnetic term supplies roughly 40 % as much (≃85\simeq85), the parallel and curvature terms are negligible, and the polarisation term is again negative throughout (≃−155\simeq-155).

The comparison of panels (b) and (d) reveals a result that the snapshot budget of table 2 does not show. The cumulative transfer to the ions from tΩci=2.5t\Omega_{ci}=2.5 to the respective analysis times is larger at βi0=4\beta_{i0}=4 than at βi0=0.25\beta_{i0}=0.25, by a factor of about three, even though the instantaneous rate at peak JrmsJ_{\mathrm{rms}} is a factor of 3.9 smaller. We return to this in §5.1.

Discussion

What ji⋅Ej_i\cdot E does and does not measure

Before discussing the results, we clarify that the ion energisation rate in (5) is not the ion heating rate. Taking the dot product of the ion momentum balance (1) with UiU_i gives the bulk-flow energy equation,

∂Eif∂t+∇⋅(EifUi+Pi⋅Ui)=(Pi⋅∇)⋅Ui+ji⋅E,(17)\frac{\partial\mathcal{E}_i^{\mathrm{f}}}{\partial t}+\nabla\cdot\left(\mathcal{E}_i^{\mathrm{f}}U_i+P_i\cdot U_i\right)=(P_i\cdot\nabla)\cdot U_i+j_i\cdot E, \tag*{(17)}

where Eif=mini∣Ui∣2/2\mathcal{E}_i^{\mathrm{f}}=m_in_i\lvert U_i\rvert^2/2. Subtracting it from the second moment of the Vlasov equation (11) gives the internal-energy equation,

∂Eith∂t+∇⋅(EithUi+hi)=−(Pi⋅∇)⋅Ui,(18)\frac{\partial\mathcal{E}_i^{\mathrm{th}}}{\partial t}+\nabla\cdot\left(\mathcal{E}_i^{\mathrm{th}}U_i+h_i\right)=-(P_i\cdot\nabla)\cdot U_i, \tag*{(18)}

where Eith=32niTi=12Tr⁡(Pi)\mathcal{E}_i^{\mathrm{th}}=\frac{3}{2}n_iT_i=\frac{1}{2}\operatorname{Tr}(P_i) and hih_i is the heat-flux vector. In addition, Poynting’s theorem gives

∂Eem∂t+∇⋅(c E×B4π)=−∑sjs⋅E.(19)\frac{\partial\mathcal{E}^{\mathrm{em}}}{\partial t}+\nabla\cdot\left(\frac{c\,E\times B}{4\pi}\right)=-\sum_s j_s\cdot E. \tag*{(19)}

with Eem=B2/8π\mathcal{E}^{\mathrm{em}} = B^2/8\pi where the electric field energy is not included since the displacement current is neglected in the HVM model (§ 3.1). The rate ji⋅E\mathbf{j}_i \cdot\mathbf{E} is thus the source in the ion bulk-flow equation and the ion share of the sink in the field equation. It measures the energy the field gives up to the ions. It is not the ion heating rate, because it says nothing about how that energy is subsequently divided between bulk flow and internal energy. That division is governed by the pressure–strain interaction [55, 10, 7, 17], which transfers energy between the two reservoirs without adding to their sum. The two diagnostics are therefore complementary. Equation (5) says through which current, and where, the field loses energy to the ions, whereas the pressure–strain says how much of what the ions receive ends up as heat. A term that is large in (2.5) identifies the former, not the latter.

To clarify how the energy transferred to the ions is partitioned, we compute the pressure–strain interaction [55, 10],

−(Πi⋅∇)⋅Ui=−piθi−Πi:Di,(20)-(\boldsymbol{\Pi}_i \cdot\nabla) \cdot\mathbf{U}_i = -p_i\theta_i - \boldsymbol{\Pi}_i : \mathbf{D}_i, \tag*{(20)}

where θi=∇⋅Ui\theta_i = \nabla\cdot\mathbf{U}_i is the dilatation of the ion flow, Πi=Pi−piI\boldsymbol{\Pi}_i = \mathbf{P}_i - p_i\mathbf{I} is the deviatoric pressure tensor, and Di=12[∇Ui+(∇Ui)T]−13θiI\mathbf{D}_i = \frac{1}{2}\left[\nabla\mathbf{U}_i+(\nabla\mathbf{U}_i)^{\mathsf{T}}\right]-\frac{1}{3}\theta_i\mathbf{I} is the traceless strain-rate tensor. We note that Πi\boldsymbol{\Pi}_i differs from the non-gyrotropic tensor Πiagy\boldsymbol{\Pi}_i^{\mathrm{agy}} of (2), as it also includes the gyrotropic anisotropy pi∥−pi⊥p_{i\parallel}-p_{i\perp}. The pressure dilatation −piθi-p_i\theta_i corresponds to ion heating (cooling) by compression (expansion) of the flow, whereas the Pi-D term −Πi:Di-\boldsymbol{\Pi}_i:\mathbf{D}_i corresponds to heating by incompressible deformation of the flow, often referred to as “viscous-like collisionless dissipation” although reversible (Yang et al. 2017b,a; Bandyopadhyay et al. 2023; Cassak & Barbhuiya 2022). With the sign convention of (5.4), both terms are sources of ion internal energy in (5.2).

Figure 10 shows the three terms for the two runs at the time of peak JrmsJ_{\mathrm{rms}}, with the same colour scale as ji⋅E\mathbf{j}_i \cdot\mathbf{E} in Figure 5 and Figure 6. The local amplitude of the pressure–strain interaction is comparable to that of the ion energisation rate. At βi0=0.25\beta_{i0}=0.25, the pressure–strain interaction is organised in structures of a few did_i, whereas at βi0=4\beta_{i0}=4 it exhibits much finer structures elongated along B0\mathbf{B}_0. This organisation is consistent with the finer ion-pressure structure at βi0=4\beta_{i0}=4 (Figure 3). In both runs, pressure dilatation dominates the maps, with large local amplitudes of both signs, whereas the Pi-D term is much weaker locally, particularly at βi0=4\beta_{i0}=4.

Figure 10. Ion pressure–strain interaction for run A (βi0=0.25\beta_{i0}=0.25, tΩci=13.20t\Omega_{ci}=13.20, top row) and run B (βi0=4\beta_{i0}=4, tΩci=15.60t\Omega_{ci}=15.60, bottom row). (a,d) Pressure–strain interaction −(Pi⋅∇)⋅Ui-(\mathbf{P}_i\cdot\nabla)\cdot\mathbf{U}_i, (b,e) pressure dilatation −piθi-p_i\theta_i and (c,f) Pi-D term −Πi:Di-\boldsymbol{\Pi}_i:\mathbf{D}_i, all on the faces of the simulation domain. The colour scale is that of figures 5 and 6, and all quantities are in code units.

However, the volume-integrated values (Table 2) show the opposite ordering. We find that the volume-integrated Pi-D term is 3.7 and 2.3 times larger than the pressure dilatation at βi0=0.25\beta_{i0}=0.25 and βi0=4\beta_{i0}=4, respectively. We interpret this as pressure dilatation cancelling between compressing and expanding regions, so the Pi-D term accounts for most of the net conversion into internal energy. This result is consistent with previous kinetic simulations of turbulence, which showed that pressure dilatation is locally large but oscillates in sign, whereas the Pi-D term dominates the net heating [55, 40].

Furthermore, the pressure–strain interaction and ji⋅E\mathbf{j}_i \cdot\mathbf{E} together close the instantaneous ion energy budget. Integrating (5.1) and (5.2) over the periodic domain, the flux terms vanish, and we obtain

ddt∫Eith d3x=−∫(Πi⋅∇)⋅Ui d3x,(21)\frac{\mathrm{d}}{\mathrm{d}t}\int\mathcal{E}_i^{\mathrm{th}}\,\mathrm{d}^3x=-\int(\boldsymbol{\Pi}_i\cdot\nabla)\cdot\mathbf{U}_i\,\mathrm{d}^3x, \tag*{(21)}
ddt∫Eif d3x=∫ji⋅E d3x+∫(Πi⋅∇)⋅Ui d3x.(22)\frac{\mathrm{d}}{\mathrm{d}t}\int\mathcal{E}_i^{\mathrm{f}}\,\mathrm{d}^3x=\int\mathbf{j}_i\cdot\mathbf{E}\,\mathrm{d}^3x+\int(\boldsymbol{\Pi}_i\cdot\nabla)\cdot\mathbf{U}_i\,\mathrm{d}^3x. \tag*{(22)}

At βi0=4\beta_{i0}=4, we find that the pressure–strain interaction accounts for 98 % of the ion energisation rate. This suggests that nearly all of the energy transferred from the field to the ions at this time is converted into internal energy, whereas the ion bulk-flow energy remains nearly constant, dt∫Eif d3x≃0.16d_t\int\mathcal{E}_i^f\,\mathrm{d}^3x\simeq0.16 code units. In contrast, at βi0=0.25\beta_{i0}=0.25, the pressure–strain interaction accounts for only 39 % of ji⋅E\mathbf{j}_i\cdot\mathbf{E}, so that the remaining 18.4 code units increase the ion bulk-flow energy. This value is comparable to Wpol=22.8W_{\rm pol}=22.8, i.e., the work done to accelerate the ion bulk flow. We interpret this as reflecting the reversible exchange between the field and the ion bulk flow discussed later in §5.3. We note that these are instantaneous values at a single time. Therefore, as for the energisation, the net heating should be assessed using the time-integrated budget.

Figure 9(b,Figure 9d) shows the time-integrated pressure–strain interaction together with the time evolution of the ion temperature, normalised to its value at tΩci=2.5t\Omega_{ci}=2.5, i.e. after the transient phase. First, we note that the cumulative pressure–strain interaction exceeds the cumulative ion energisation by a factor of ≃4.6\simeq4.6 at βi0=0.25\beta_{i0}=0.25 and ≃1.7\simeq1.7 at βi0=4\beta_{i0}=4 at the time of peak JrmsJ_{\rm rms}. Since the two differ by the change in bulk-flow energy (21), (22), the ion bulk flow loses energy over this interval in both runs, so that the internal energy gained exceeds what the field supplies. Nevertheless, the cumulative pressure–strain interaction follows the temperature evolution remarkably well, particularly for the perpendicular temperature Ti⊥T_{i\perp}. The ion temperature rises by ≃15\simeq15 % in run A and by only ≃1\simeq1 % in run B over the same interval. However, the initial thermal energy is sixteen times larger in run B, so the absolute thermal energy gained, 32Δ(niTi)V\frac{3}{2}\Delta(n_iT_i)V, is of the same order in both runs, ≃190\simeq190 and ≃210\simeq210 code units, respectively.

Relation to the guiding-centre description

Question (i) in § 1 asked whether ion energisation can be characterised when guiding-centre theory does not apply. Equations (9) and (10) show that the measured budget consists of a part that regroups the betatron and Fermi terms and a part that is not captured by the guiding-centre description. Our results show that the latter is significant. In particular, WagyW_{\mathrm{agy}}, which directly quantifies the breakdown of the guiding-centre description, accounts for 21 % of the instantaneous budget at βi0=0.25\beta_{i0} = 0.25 and dominates it at βi0=4\beta_{i0} = 4 even though the ion VDFs are nearly isotropic and gyrotropic in the latter case (Figure 3). Furthermore, we show that the ion energisation is preferentially enhanced in regions of large current density. There, the radius of curvature decreases to the local ion gyroradius, rc∼ρir_c \sim\rho_i, in the current sheets, so that the magnetic moment is not conserved. Therefore, the guiding-centre description breaks down precisely where energisation is concentrated.

The βi\beta_i dependence

The sign of the βi\beta_i energisation trend depends on the measure used. At peak JrmsJ_{\mathrm{rms}}, the volume-integrated energisation is about 3.9 times smaller at βi0=4\beta_{i0} = 4, whereas the cumulative transfer in Figure 9 is about three times larger. The two are not in conflict. At βi0=0.25\beta_{i0} = 0.25, the instantaneous integral is dominated by a reversible exchange between the field and the ion bulk flow that changes sign from trough to trough, whereas the running integral measures what remains once that oscillation has averaged out. A snapshot, even at peak JrmsJ_{\mathrm{rms}}, may therefore report the phase of the oscillation rather than the secular transfer, and a statement about the βi\beta_i dependence should rest on the cumulative budget (§ 4.6).

The budget composition also changes with βi0\beta_{i0}. At βi0=4\beta_{i0} = 4, the agyrotropic term accounts for 91 % of the instantaneous budget, and the polarisation term reverses sign, so the polarisation current contributes negative work while the bulk-flow energy remains nearly constant. However, this occurs in the run with smaller agyrotropy, Qi≲0.05\sqrt{Q_i} \lesssim0.05, compared with 0.42 at βi0=0.25\beta_{i0} = 0.25. To clarify this, we compute the divergence of the non-gyrotropic pressure tensor, which enters Wagy=UE⋅∇⋅ΠiagyW_{\mathrm{agy}} = U_E \cdot\nabla\cdot\boldsymbol{\Pi}_{i}^{\mathrm{agy}}. We find that ⟨∣∇⋅Πiagy∣⟩=0.066\langle\lvert\nabla\cdot\boldsymbol{\Pi}_{i}^{\mathrm{agy}} \rvert\rangle= 0.066 and 0.047, and ∣∇⋅Πiagy∣rms=0.082\lvert\nabla\cdot\boldsymbol{\Pi}_{i}^{\mathrm{agy}} \rvert_{\mathrm{rms}} = 0.082 and 0.053 code units, at βi0=0.25\beta_{i0} = 0.25 and βi0=4\beta_{i0} = 4, respectively. Therefore, the divergence is 30–35 % smaller at βi0=4\beta_{i0} = 4, whereas the volume-integrated WagyW_{\mathrm{agy}} is slightly larger (6.92 against 6.24 code units). Since the E×B\boldsymbol{E} \times\boldsymbol{B} velocity is also weaker at βi0=4\beta_{i0} = 4, this suggests that the electric field and the agyrotropic drift Ui,agyU_{i,\mathrm{agy}} are more closely aligned at βi0=4\beta_{i0} = 4. In other words, the large contribution of WagyW_{\mathrm{agy}} at βi0=4\beta_{i0} = 4 results from a better correlation between E\boldsymbol{E} and Ui,agyU_{i,\mathrm{agy}} rather than from a larger non-gyrotropic stress.

The reduction of Wcurv1W_{\mathrm{curv1}} with βi0\beta_{i0} is not, as it might appear, a consequence of the reduced anisotropy ratio. What enters (5) is the absolute anisotropy pi∥−pi⊥p_{i\parallel} - p_{i\perp}. At fixed B0B_0 and n0n_0, the ion pressure is sixteen times larger at βi0=4\beta_{i0} = 4, so the ratio collapses even if the absolute anisotropy does not. Indeed, we measure pi∥−pi⊥=−0.04−0.06+0.04p_{i\parallel} - p_{i\perp} = -0.04^{+0.04}_{-0.06} and −0.02−0.05+0.05-0.02^{+0.05}_{-0.05} code units in runs A and B, respectively, which are comparable, whereas the spread of pi⊥/pi∥p_{i\perp}/p_{i\parallel} differs by an order of magnitude. The βi\beta_i dependence of Wcurv1W_{\mathrm{curv1}} is instead carried by UE⋅κ\boldsymbol{U}_E \cdot\boldsymbol{\kappa}, whose rms falls by a factor of six between the runs, and within that partly by the curvature, whose rms falls by a factor of three, from 0.1 di−10.1\,d_i^{-1} to 0.03 di−10.03\,d_i^{-1}, with the normalised distribution unchanged. The measured values satisfy ∣κ∣rci≃0.05\lvert\boldsymbol{\kappa} \rvert_{r_{\mathrm{ci}}} \simeq0.05 in both runs, i.e., ∣κ∣rms∝ρi−1∝βi0−1/2\lvert\boldsymbol{\kappa} \rvert_{\mathrm{rms}} \propto\rho_i^{-1} \propto\beta_{i0}^{-1/2}. Its origin remains to be established. The volume integral of Wcurv1W_{\mathrm{curv1}} falls by more than the rms of UE⋅κU_E \cdot\boldsymbol{\kappa}, from −0.80-0.80 to −0.04-0.04. Since it is the signed integral of a quantity that changes sign throughout the volume, the additional reduction reflects a loss of correlation between the anisotropy and UE⋅κU_E \cdot\boldsymbol{\kappa} rather than a further fall in amplitude.

Limitations

The turbulence studied here is injected in the three lowest wavenumber shells of the box, so there is no extended MHD cascade above the ion scales. The results apply to magnetosheath-like turbulence rather than to the solar wind. The injection band, 0.3≤kdi≤10.3 \le k d_i \le1, is the same in both runs, but ρi\rho_i is not. It corresponds to kρi≃0.15k\rho_i \simeq0.15–0.50.5 at βi0=0.25\beta_{i0}=0.25 and 0.60.6–22 at βi0=4\beta_{i0}=4, so run B has essentially no range of scales above the ion gyroradius and its turbulence is kinetic from the injection scale down. Comparisons between the runs at fixed kdik d_i therefore sample different parts of the cascade. The mass ratio is reduced to mi/me=100m_i/m_e=100, and the grid spacing is 0.74de0.74d_e, so the sub-ded_e range is unresolved and the sub-ion range at βi0=0.25\beta_{i0}=0.25 spans less than a decade. Turbulence decays rather than being driven, so we measure the budget against a moving background. Finally, we obtain the polarisation term as the residual (3.3b), which includes numerical errors and the effect of the numerical filter, and is therefore the least independently constrained quantity in the budget.

Conclusions

We presented an analysis of the Eulerian ion energisation rate in three-dimensional hybrid-Vlasov–Maxwell simulations of decaying turbulence at βi0=0.25\beta_{i0}=0.25 and βi0=4\beta_{i0}=4, based on its decomposition into the work done on the parallel, diamagnetic, curvature, agyrotropic and polarisation ion currents. Our main results are as follows.

  1. The Eulerian decomposition is exact and differs from the guiding-centre description, and the magnetic moment is expected not to be conserved where the energisation happens. (5) requires neither gyrotropy nor scale separation. By comparing it with the guiding-centre energisation rate (2.9), we show that the curvature term does not correspond to the Fermi term. Therefore, a small Wcurv1W_{\mathrm{curv1}} does not imply weak Fermi energisation. In addition, the difference between the two descriptions (2.10) reduces to a few terms, including the agyrotropic term, which has no guiding-centre counterpart. The radius of curvature falls to the local ion gyroradius in the current sheets of both runs.

  1. Which current carries the energisation changes with βi0\beta_{i0}, and the explicitly non-gyrotropic term is never negligible across and below the ion scales. The polarisation current carries the budget at βi0=0.25\beta_{i0}=0.25, and the diamagnetic and agyrotropic currents carry it at βi0=4\beta_{i0}=4. WagyW_{\mathrm{agy}} carries 21 % of the instantaneous budget at βi0=0.25\beta_{i0}=0.25 and 91 % at βi0=4\beta_{i0}=4, and it dominates the cumulative budget at βi0=4\beta_{i0}=4.

  1. The local and volume-integrated pictures agree. The same currents carry the energisation at every resolved scale and in the volume integral, with the total spectrum following the largest single term rather than resulting from a cancellation between terms.

  1. The instantaneous budget is dominated by a reversible exchange, and the cumulative budget is the relevant measure. The instantaneous measure is dominated by a reversible exchange that oscillates in sign. The instantaneous rate at peak JrmsJ_{\mathrm{rms}} is 3.9 times smaller at βi0=4\beta_{i0}=4, whereas the cumulative transfer is larger. Statements about the βi\beta_i dependence should therefore rest on the cumulative budget.

  1. The ion VDFs are not held at marginal stability, and the fall of Wcurv1W_{\mathrm{curv1}} with βi0\beta_{i0} is carried by the curvature, not by the anisotropy. At βi0=0.25\beta_{i0}=0.25 the mirror threshold bounds the upper envelope of the anisotropy distribution but not its bulk. At βi0=4\beta_{i0}=4 the whole distribution lies well inside every threshold. The absolute anisotropy pi∥−pi⊥p_{i\parallel}-p_{i\perp} is comparable in the two runs, so that the collapse of pi⊥/pi∥p_{i\perp}/p_{i\parallel}

with βi0\beta_{i0} follows the sixteen-fold rise of the ion pressure. The adiabaticity parameter rc/ρir_c/\rho_i is essentially independent of βi0\beta_{i0}, while the absolute curvature scales as ρi−1\rho_i^{-1}. The βi0\beta_{i0} dependence of Wcurv1W_{\mathrm{curv}1} follows UE⋅κU_E \cdot\boldsymbol{\kappa}, whose rms falls in step with ∣κ∣rms|\boldsymbol{\kappa}|_{\mathrm{rms}} and with the ion velocity fluctuations.

Finally, ji⋅E\boldsymbol{j}_i \cdot\boldsymbol{E} is the rate at which the electromagnetic field gives energy to the ions, not the rate at which the ions are heated. How much of it ends as internal energy is set by the pressure–strain interaction (5.4), and the two diagnostics are needed together. All quantities entering (2.5), except the time derivative in WpolW_{\mathrm{pol}}, are accessible to multispacecraft measurements in the terrestrial magnetosheath, where these results can be tested directly [4, 56, 41].

Acknowledgements

L.R. thanks Archie F. A. Bott and Benjamin D. G. Chandran for insightful discussions.

Funding

L.R. has received funding from the European Union’s Horizon Europe research and innovation programme under the Marie Skłodowska-Curie grant agreement No. 101272207 (“MicroDynaMIQ”). Funded by the European Union. Views and opinions expressed are, however, those of the authors only and do not necessarily reflect those of the European Union or the European Research Executive Agency. Neither the European Union nor the granting authority can be held responsible for them. S.S.C. is supported by the National Research Agency (ANR) grant “MiCRO” with the reference number ANR-23-CE31-0016. O.P. is supported by the FIS2 Starting Grant FIS-2023-00246 “PhAse-sPAce cOmplexity in turbulent nearly-reversible plasmas (PAPAO)” (CUP B53C24009610001) funded by the Italian Ministry of University and Research. J.M.T. was supported by NASA Grant 80NSSC23K0099.

Declaration of generative AI use

L.R. acknowledges the use of Claude Opus 5.5 (Anthropic) for assistance with postprocessing and writing the manuscript. All AI-generated content was reviewed and verified by the authors, who take full responsibility for the content of the publication.

Declaration of interests

The authors report no conflict of interest.

Normalisation of the energy-conversion equations

The HVM code uses the normalisation of Valentini et al. [52],

U‾=vA,ω‾=Ωci,l‾=vA/Ωci=c/ωpi=di,P‾=n‾mivA2(23)\overline{U}=v_A,\qquad\overline{\omega}=\Omega_{ci},\qquad\overline{l}=v_A/\Omega_{ci}=c/\omega_{pi}=d_i,\qquad\overline{P}=\overline{n}m_i v_A^2 \tag*{(23)}
E‾=m‾vAΩci/e,B‾=m‾cΩci/e,q‾=e,m‾=mi(24)\overline{E}=\overline{m}v_A\Omega_{ci}/e,\qquad\overline{B}=\overline{m}c\Omega_{ci}/e,\qquad\overline{q}=e,\qquad\overline{m}=m_i \tag*{(24)}

where vAv_A is the Alfvén speed, Ωci\Omega_{ci} the ion cyclotron frequency, ee the elementary charge, mim_i the ion mass and n‾\overline{n} a reference density. In these units, the three normalisation ratios that appear in (2.4) all reduce to the Alfvén speed,

cE~B~=vA,cP~q~n~B~l~=vA2Ωcidi=vA,m~cU~ω~q~B~=U~=vA,(25)\frac{c\tilde{E}}{\tilde{B}}=v_A,\qquad\frac{c\tilde{P}}{\tilde{q}\tilde{n}\tilde{B}\tilde{l}}=\frac{v_A^2}{\Omega_{ci}d_i}=v_A,\qquad\frac{\tilde{m}c\tilde{U}\tilde{\omega}}{\tilde{q}\tilde{B}}=\tilde{U}=v_A, \tag*{(25)}

so that the normalised drift decomposition is identical in form to (2.4) with all factors of cc removed,

U~i⊥=E~×B~B~2+B~×∇~p~i⊥n~iB~2+p~i∥−p~i⊥n~iB~2B~×κ~+B~×∇~⋅Π~iagyn~iB~2+m~iB~2B~×dU~idt~,(26)\tilde{U}_{i\perp}=\frac{\tilde{E}\times\tilde{B}}{\tilde{B}^2}+\frac{\tilde{B}\times\tilde{\nabla}\tilde{p}_{i\perp}}{\tilde{n}_i\tilde{B}^2}+\frac{\tilde{p}_{i\parallel}-\tilde{p}_{i\perp}}{\tilde{n}_i\tilde{B}^2}\tilde{B}\times\tilde{\kappa}+\frac{\tilde{B}\times\tilde{\nabla}\cdot\tilde{\Pi}^{\mathrm{agy}}_i}{\tilde{n}_i\tilde{B}^2}+\frac{\tilde{m}_i}{\tilde{B}^2}\tilde{B}\times\frac{\mathrm{d}\tilde{U}_i}{\mathrm{d}\tilde{t}}, \tag*{(26)}

and (2.5) becomes

j~i⋅E~=j~i∥E~∥+U~E⋅∇~p~i⊥+(p~i∥−p~i⊥)U~E⋅κ~+U~E⋅∇~⋅Π~iagy+m~in~iU~E⋅dU~idt~,(27)\tilde{\boldsymbol{j}}_i\cdot\tilde{E}=\tilde{j}_{i\parallel}\tilde{E}_{\parallel}+\tilde{U}_E\cdot\tilde{\nabla}\tilde{p}_{i\perp}+(\tilde{p}_{i\parallel}-\tilde{p}_{i\perp})\tilde{U}_E\cdot\tilde{\kappa}+\tilde{U}_E\cdot\tilde{\nabla}\cdot\tilde{\Pi}^{\mathrm{agy}}_i+\tilde{m}_i\tilde{n}_i\tilde{U}_E\cdot\frac{\mathrm{d}\tilde{U}_i}{\mathrm{d}\tilde{t}}, \tag*{(27)}

with U~E=E~×B~/B~2\tilde{U}_E=\tilde{E}\times\tilde{B}/\tilde{B}^2.

Derivation of the guiding-centre correspondence

This appendix derives (2.9) and (2.10). Apart from (2.8) itself, every step is an identity.

Field strength and direction

Since (E×B)×B=B2(b^E∥−E)(E\times B)\times B=B^2(\hat{b}E_\parallel-E), the electric field can be written exactly as E=E∥b^−UE×B/cE=E_\parallel\hat{b}-U_E\times B/c. We note that this is an identity rather than a frozen-in assumption, since any Hall or electron-pressure contribution to E⊥E_\perp is contained in UEU_E. Faraday’s law therefore splits, without approximation, as

DEB=(B⋅∇)UE−B∇⋅UE−c∇×(E∥b^).(28)D_EB=(B\cdot\nabla)U_E-B\nabla\cdot U_E-c\nabla\times(E_\parallel\hat{b}). \tag*{(28)}

We project (B1) on b^\hat{b} and use b^⋅DE(Bb^)=DEB\hat{b}\cdot D_E(B\hat{b})=D_EB together with two identities. Applying b^⋅∇\hat{b}\cdot\nabla to b^⋅UE=0\hat{b}\cdot U_E=0 gives b^⋅(b^⋅∇)UE=−UE⋅κ\hat{b}\cdot(\hat{b}\cdot\nabla)U_E=-U_E\cdot\kappa, and Ampère’s law without displacement current gives b^⋅(∇×b^)=4πJ∥/cB\hat{b}\cdot(\nabla\times\hat{b})=4\pi J_\parallel/cB. The field strength then evolves as

DEln⁡B=−∇⋅UE−UE⋅κ−4πJ∥E∥B2,(29)D_E\ln B=-\nabla\cdot U_E-U_E\cdot\kappa-\frac{4\pi J_\parallel E_\parallel}{B^2}, \tag*{(29)}

where J∥J_\parallel is the total parallel current, which at sub-ion scales is carried mostly by the electrons [19, 13]. Thus, the field strength follows the E×BE\times B flow except where a parallel electric field acts along twisted field lines. Projecting (B1) instead on the plane perpendicular to b^\hat{b} and contracting with UEU_E gives

UE⋅DEb^=12∂∥∣UE∣2−cBUE⋅[∇×(E∥b^)],(30)U_E\cdot D_E\hat{b}=\frac{1}{2}\partial_\parallel\lvert U_E\rvert^2-\frac{c}{B}U_E\cdot\left[\nabla\times(E_\parallel\hat{b})\right], \tag*{(30)}

so that WrotW_{\mathrm{rot}} can be evaluated without a time derivative.

The guiding-centre rate

The non-relativistic guiding-centre energy equation of Northrop [38], for a particle of parallel velocity v∥v_\parallel and magnetic moment μ\mu, may be written

dϵdt=qv∥E∥+μDEB+mv∥2UE⋅κ+mv∥UE⋅DEb^+m2d∣UE∣2dt,(31)\frac{\mathrm{d}\epsilon}{\mathrm{d}t}=qv_\parallel E_\parallel+\mu D_EB+mv_\parallel^2U_E\cdot\kappa+mv_\parallel U_E\cdot D_E\hat{b}+\frac{m}{2}\frac{\mathrm{d}\lvert U_E\rvert^2}{\mathrm{d}t}, \tag*{(31)}

with d/dt following the guiding centre. The third and fourth terms both arise from b^⋅dUE/dt=−UE⋅db^/dt\hat{\mathbf{b}} \cdot\mathrm{d}\mathbf{U}_{E}/\mathrm{d}t=-\mathbf{U}_{E}\cdot\mathrm{d}\hat{\mathbf{b}}/\mathrm{d}t in the parallel equation of motion, with db^/dt=DEb^+v∥κ\mathrm{d}\hat{\mathbf{b}}/\mathrm{d}t=D_{E}\hat{\mathbf{b}}+v_{\parallel}\boldsymbol{\kappa}. The third is the centrifugal term and the fourth the work done as the field direction rotates following the E×B\mathbf{E}\times\mathbf{B} flow. Averaging (B 4) over the guiding centres in a local volume, using n⟨μ⟩B=pi⊥n\langle\mu\rangle B=p_{i\perp} and mn⟨v∥2⟩=pi∥+mnUi∥2mn\langle v_{\parallel}^{2}\rangle=p_{i\parallel}+mnU_{i\parallel}^{2}, and dropping the fourth term as in Dahlin et al. [18] and Li et al. (2017), gives (8).

Correspondence and residual

Substituting (B 2) into (8) and using Wdia=∇⋅(pi⊥UE)−pi⊥∇⋅UEW_{\mathrm{dia}}=\nabla\cdot(p_{i\perp}\mathbf{U}_{E})-p_{i\perp}\nabla\cdot\mathbf{U}_{E}, the two occurrences of pi⊥UE⋅κp_{i\perp}\mathbf{U}_{E}\cdot\boldsymbol{\kappa} cancel and (9) follows. Subtracting it from (5) leaves Wagy+Wpol−WpolLGCW_{\mathrm{agy}}+W_{\mathrm{pol}}-W_{\mathrm{pol}}^{\mathrm{LGC}} plus the flux and the twist. To evaluate Wpol−WpolLGCW_{\mathrm{pol}}-W_{\mathrm{pol}}^{\mathrm{LGC}}, we split the ion bulk velocity exactly as Ui=UE+Ui∥b^+u⊥\mathbf{U}_{i}=\mathbf{U}_{E}+U_{i\parallel}\hat{\mathbf{b}}+\mathbf{u}_{\perp}, where u⊥\mathbf{u}_{\perp} is the sum of the diamagnetic, curvature, agyrotropic and polarisation drifts of (4), and write Di≡∂t+Ui⋅∇D_{i}\equiv\partial_{t}+\mathbf{U}_{i}\cdot\nabla for the derivative in WpolW_{\mathrm{pol}}. Inserting the split into Wpol=miniUE⋅DiUiW_{\mathrm{pol}}=m_{i}n_{i}\mathbf{U}_{E}\cdot D_{i}\mathbf{U}_{i} and expanding Dib^=DEb^+Ui∥κ+(u⊥⋅∇)b^D_{i}\hat{\mathbf{b}}=D_{E}\hat{\mathbf{b}}+U_{i\parallel}\boldsymbol{\kappa}+(\mathbf{u}_{\perp}\cdot\nabla)\hat{\mathbf{b}}, the term miniUi∥2UE⋅κm_{i}n_{i}U_{i\parallel}^{2}\mathbf{U}_{E}\cdot\boldsymbol{\kappa} cancels the centrifugal part of WpolLGCW_{\mathrm{pol}}^{\mathrm{LGC}} identically, and 12mini(Di−Dg)∣UE∣2=miniUE⋅(u⊥⋅∇)UE\frac{1}{2}m_{i}n_{i}(D_{i}-D_{g})|\mathbf{U}_{E}|^{2}=m_{i}n_{i}\mathbf{U}_{E}\cdot(\mathbf{u}_{\perp}\cdot\nabla)\mathbf{U}_{E}. The remaining terms are WrotW_{\mathrm{rot}} and

W⊥=mini[Ui∥UE⋅(u⊥⋅∇)b^+UE⋅Diu⊥+UE⋅(u⊥⋅∇)UE](32)W_{\perp}=m_{i}n_{i}\left[U_{i\parallel}\mathbf{U}_{E}\cdot(\mathbf{u}_{\perp}\cdot\nabla)\hat{\mathbf{b}}+\mathbf{U}_{E}\cdot D_{i}\mathbf{u}_{\perp}+\mathbf{U}_{E}\cdot(\mathbf{u}_{\perp}\cdot\nabla)\mathbf{U}_{E}\right] \tag*{(32)}

which vanishes identically if the perpendicular ion flow is purely E×B\mathbf{E}\times\mathbf{B}. This gives (10).

References

  1. [1]AFSHARI, A. S., HOWES, G. G., SHUSTER, J. R., KLEIN, K. G., MCGINNIS, D., MARTINOVIĆ, M. M., BOARDERSEN, S. A., BROWN, C. R., HUANG, R., HARTLEY, D. P. & KLETZING, C. A. 2024 Direct observation of ion cyclotron damping of turbulence in Earth’s magnetosheath plasma. Nat. Commun. 15 (1), 7870.DOI
  2. [2]ARTEMYEV, A. V., NEISHTADT, A. I. & ZELENYI, L. M. 2014 Rapid geometrical chaotization in slow-fast Hamiltonian systems. Phys. Rev. E 89 (6), 060902.pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/25019711
  3. [3]ARZAMASSKIY, LEV, KUNZ, MATTHEW W., CHANDRAN, BENJAMIN D. G. & QUATAERT, ELIOT 2019 Hybrid-kinetic Simulations of Ion Heating in Alfvénic Turbulence. Astrophys. J. 879 (1), 53.DOI
  4. [4]BANDYOPADHYAY, RIDDHI, MATTHAEUS, WILLIAM H., PARASHAR, TULASI N., YANG, YAN, CHASAPIS, ALEXANDROS, GILES, BARBARA L., GERSHMAN, DANIEL J., POLLOCK, CRAIG J., RUSSELL, CHRISTOPHER T., STRANGEWAY, ROBERT J., TORBERT, ROY B., MOORE, THOMAS E. & BURCH, JAMES L. 2020a Statistics of Kinetic Dissipation in the Earth’s Magnetosheath: MMS Observations. Phys. Rev. Lett. 124 (25), 255101.DOI
  5. [5]BANDYOPADHYAY, RIDDHI, YANG, YAN, MATTHAEUS, WILLIAM H., CHASAPIS, ALEXANDROS, PARASHAR, TULASI N., RUSSELL, CHRISTOPHER T., STRANGEWAY, ROBERT J., TORBERT, ROY B., GILES, BARBARA L., GERSHMAN, DANIEL J., POLLOCK, CRAIG J., MOORE, THOMAS E. & BURCH, JAMES L. 2020b In Situ Measurement of Curvature of Magnetic Field in Turbulent Space Plasmas: A Statistical Study. Astrophys. J. Lett. 893 (1), L25.
  6. [7]BARBHUIYA, M. HASAN & CASSAK, PAUL A. 2022 Pressure–strain interaction. III. Particle-in-cell simulations of magnetic reconnection. Phys. Plasmas 29 (12), 122308.DOI
  7. [8]BOLDYREV, STANISLAV & PEREZ, JEAN CARLOS 2012 Spectrum of Kinetic-Alfvén Turbulence. Astrophys. J. 758 (2), L44.DOI
  8. [10]Cassak, Paul A. & Barbhuıya, M. Hasan 2022 Pressure–strain interaction. I. On compression, deformation, and implications for Pi-D. Phys. Plasmas 29 (12), 122306.DOI
  9. [11]Cassak, Paul A., Barbhuıya, M. Hasan, Liang, Haoming & Argall, Matthew R. 2023 Quantifying Energy Conversion in Higher-Order Phase Space Density Moments in Plasmas. Phys. Rev. Lett. 130 (8), 085201.DOI
  10. [12]Cerri, S. S., Arzamasskiy, L. & Kunz, M. W. 2021 On Stochastic Heating and Its Phase-space Signatures in Low-beta Kinetic Turbulence. Astrophys. J. 916 (2), 120.DOI
  11. [13]Cerri, Silvio Sergio, Grošelj, Daniel & Franci, Luca 2019 Kinetic Plasma Turbulence: Recent Insights and Open Questions From 3D3V Simulations. Front. Astron. Space Sci. 6, 64.
  12. [14]Chandran, Benjamin D. G., Li, Bo, Rogers, Barrett N., Quataert, Eliot & Germaschewski, Kai 2010 Perpendicular Ion Heating by Low-frequency Alfvén-wave Turbulence in the Solar Wind. Astrophys. J. 720 (1), 503–515.
  13. [15]Chasapis, Alexandros, Matthaeus, W. H., Parashar, T. N., Wan, M., Haggerty, C. C., Pollock, C. J., Giles, B. L., Paterson, W. R., Dorelli, J., Gershman, D. J., Torbert, R. B., Russell, C. T., Lindqvist, P.-A., Khotyaintsev, Y., Moore, T. E., Ergun, R. E. & Burch, J. L. 2018 In situ Observation of Intermittent Dissipation at Kinetic Scales in the Earth’s Magnetosheath. Astrophys. J. Lett. 856 (1), L19.
  14. [16]Chen, C. H. K. & Boldyrev, S. 2017 Nature of Kinetic Scale Turbulence in the Earth’s Magnetosheath. Astrophys. J. 842 (2), 122.
  15. [17]Conley, S. A., Juno, J., TenBarge, J. M., Barbhuıya, M. H., Cassak, P. A., Howes, G. G. & Lichko, E. 2024 The kinetic analog of the pressure–strain interaction. Phys. Plasmas 31 (12), 122117.DOI
  16. [18]Dahlin, J. T., Drake, J. F. & Swisdak, M. 2014 The mechanisms of electron heating and acceleration during magnetic reconnection. Phys. Plasmas 21 (9), 092304.
  17. [19]Franci, Luca, Landi, Simone, Verdini, Andrea, Matteini, Lorenzo & Hellinger, Petr 2018 Solar Wind Turbulent Cascade from MHD to Sub-ion Scales: Large-size 3D Hybrid Particle-in-cell Simulations. Astrophys. J. 853 (1), 26.DOI
  18. [20]Granier, C., Cerri, S. S. & Jenko, F. 2024 Electron-only Reconnection and Ion Heating in 3D3V Hybrid-Vlasov Plasma Turbulence. Astrophys. J. 974 (1), 11.arxiv.org/abs/2405.16686
  19. [21]Grošelj, Daniel, Mallet, Alfred, Loureiro, Nuno F. & Jenko, Frank 2018 Fully Kinetic Simulation of 3D Kinetic Alfvén Turbulence. Phys. Rev. Lett. 120 (10), 105101.DOI
  20. [22]Hellinger, Petr, Trávníček, Pavel, Kasper, Justin C. & Lazarus, Alan J. 2006 Solar wind proton temperature anisotropy: Linear theory and WIND/SWE observations. Geophys. Res. Lett. 33 (9), L09101.DOI
  21. [23]Hoppock, Ian W., Chandran, Benjamin D. G., Klein, Kristopher G., Mallet, Alfred & Verscharen, Daniel 2018 Stochastic proton heating by kinetic-Alfvén-wave turbulence in moderately high-beta plasmas. J. Plasma Phys. 84 (6), 905840615.DOI
  22. [24]Howes, Gregory G. 2024 The fundamental parameters of astrophysical plasma turbulence and its dissipation: Non-relativistic limit. J. Plasma Phys. 90 (5), 905900504.DOI
  23. [25]Howes, Gregory G., Klein, Kristopher G. & Li, Tak Chu 2017 Diagnosing collisionless energy transfer using field–particle correlations: Vlasov–Poisson plasmas. J. Plasma Phys. 83 (1), 705830102.DOI
  24. [26]Juno, James, Howes, Gregory G., TenBarge, Jason M., Wilson, Lynn B., Spitkovsky, Anatoly, Caprioli, Damiano, Klein, Kristopher G. & Hakim, Ammar 2021 A field–particle correlation analysis of a perpendicular magnetized collisionless shock. J. Plasma Phys. 87 (3), 905870316.
  25. [27]Kennel, C. F. & Engelmann, F. 1966 Electrostatic Space Diffusion from Weak Plasma Turbulence in a Magnetic Field. Phys. Fluids 9 (12), 2377–2388.DOI
  26. [28]Kiyani, K. H., Chapman, S. C., Khotyaintsev, Yu. V., Dunlop, M. W. & Sahraoui, F. 2009 Global Scale-Invariant Dissipation in Collisionless Plasma Turbulence. Phys. Rev. Lett. 103 (7), 075006.DOI
  27. [29]Klein, K. G. & Howes, G. G. 2016 Measuring collisionless damping in heliospheric plasmas using field-particle correlations. Astrophys. J. 826 (2), L30.DOI
  28. [30]Klein, Kristopher G., Howes, Gregory G. & TenBarge, Jason M. 2017 Diagnosing collisionless energy transfer using field–particle correlations: Gyrokinetic turbulence. J. Plasma Phys. 83 (4), 53583401.
  29. [31]Lele, Sanjiva K. 1992 Compact finite difference schemes with spectral-like resolution. J. Comput. Phys. 103 (1), 16–42.
  30. [32]Lemoine, Martin 2023 Particle transport through localized interactions with sharp magnetic field bends in MHD turbulence. J. Plasma Phys. 89 (5), 175890501.
  31. [33]Leonardis, E., Sorriso-Valvo, L., Valentini, F., Servidio, S., Carbone, F. & Veltri, P. 2016 Multifractal scaling and intermittency in hybrid Vlasov–Maxwell simulations of plasma turbulence. Phys. Plasmas 23 (2), 022307.
  32. [36]Matteini, L., Alexandrova, O., Chen, C. H. K. & Lacombe, C. 2017 Electric and magnetic spectra from MHD to electron scales in the magnetosheath. Mon. Not. R. Astron. Soc. 466 (1), 945–951.
  33. [37]Matthaeus, W. H. 2021 Turbulence in space plasmas: Who needs it? Phys. Plasmas 28 (3), 032306.
  34. [38]Northrop, Theodore G. 1963 Adiabatic charged-particle motion. Rev. Geophys. 1 (3), 283.DOI
  35. [39]Pezzi, O., Liang, H., Juno, J. L., Cassak, P. A., Vásconez, C. L., Sorriso-Valvo, L., Perrone, D., Servidio, S., Roytershteyn, V., TenBarge, J. M. & Matthaeus, W. H. 2021 Dissipation measures in weakly collisional plasmas. Mon. Not. R. Astron. Soc. 505 (4), 4857–4873.
  36. [40]Pezzi, O., Yang, Y., Valentini, F., Servidio, S., Chasapis, A., Matthaeus, W. H. & Veltri, P. 2019 Energy conversion in turbulent weakly collisional plasmas: Eulerian hybrid Vlasov-Maxwell simulations. Phys. Plasmas 26 (7), 072301.
  37. [41]Richard, Louis, Servidio, Sergio, Svenningsson, Ida, Artemyev, Anton V., Klein, Kristopher G., Yordanova, Emiliya, Chasapis, Alexandros, Pezzi, Oreste & Khotyaintsev, Yuri V. 2025 Non-Maxwellianity of ion velocity distributions in the Earth’s magnetosheath. Phys. Rev. E 112 (5), 1053201.
  38. [42]Richard, Louis, Sorriso-Valvo, Luca, Yordanova, Emiliya, Graham, Daniel B. & Khotyaintsev, Yuri V. 2024 Turbulence in Magnetic Reconnection Jets from Injection to Sub-Ion Scales. Phys. Rev. Lett. 132 (10), 105201.
  39. [43]Schekochihin, A. A., Cowley, S. C., Dorland, W., Hammett, G. W., Howes, G. G., Quataert, E. & Tatsuno, T. 2009 Astrophysical gyrokinetics: Kinetic and fluid turbulent cascades in magnetized weakly collisional plasmas. Astrophys. J. Suppl. Ser. 182 (1), 310–377.
  40. [44]Sebastian, Samuel T. & Comisso, Luca 2025 Magnetic Field-line Curvature and Its Role in Particle Acceleration by Magnetically Dominated Turbulence. Astrophys. J. Lett. 994 (1), L1.
  41. [45]Servidio, S., Matthaeus, W. H., Shay, M. A., Cassak, P. A. & Dmitruk, P. 2009 Magnetic Reconnection in Two-Dimensional Magnetohydrodynamic Turbulence. Phys. Rev. Lett. 102 (11), 115003.
  42. [46]Servidio, S., Valentini, F., Perrone, D., Greco, A., Califano, F., Matthaeus, W. H. & Veltri, P. 2015 A kinetic model of plasma turbulence. J. Plasma Phys. 81 (1), 325810107.
  43. [47]Squire, Jonathan, Meyrand, Romain, Kunz, Matthew W., Arzamasskiy, Lev, Schekochihin, Alexander A. & Quataert, Eliot 2022 High-frequency heating of the solar wind triggered by low-frequency turbulence. Nat. Astron. 6 (6), 715–723.
  44. [48]Stawarz, J. E., Eastwood, J. P., Phan, T. D., Gingell, I., Shay, M. A., Burch, J. L., Ergun, R. E., Giles, B. L., Gershman, D. J., Contel, O. Le, Lindqvist, P.-A., Russell, C. T., Strangeway, R. J., Torbert, R. B., Argall, M. R., Fischer, D., Magnes, W. & Franci, L. 2019 Properties of the Turbulence Associated with Electron-only Magnetic Reconnection in Earth’s Magnetosheath. Astrophys. J. Lett. 877 (2), L37.
  45. [50]Swisdak, M. 2016 Quantifying gyrotr0py in magnetic reconnection. Geophys. Res. Lett. 43 (1), 43–49.
  46. [51]TenBarge, Jason M., Juno, James & Howes, Gregory G. 2024 Electron energization in reconnection: Eulerian vs Lagrangian perspectives. Phys. Plasmas 31 (2), 022901.DOI
  47. [52]Valentini, F., Trávníček, P., Califano, F., Hellinger, P. & Mangeney, A. 2007 A hybrid-Vlasov model based on the current advance method for the simulation of collisionless magnetized plasma. J. Comput. Phys. 225 (1), 753–770.DOI
  48. [53]Wan, M., Matthaeus, W. H., Roytershteyn, V., Karimabadi, H., Parashar, T., Wu, P. & Shay, M. 2015 Intermittent Dissipation and Heating in 3D Kinetic Plasma Turbulence. Phys. Rev. Lett. 114 (17), 175002.
  49. [55]Yang, Yan, Matthaeus, W. H., Parashar, T. N., Wu, P., Wan, M., Shi, Y., Chen, S., Roytershteyn, V. & Daughton, W. 2017b Energy transfer channels and turbulence cascade in Vlasov-Maxwell turbulence. Phys. Rev. E 95 (6), 061201.DOI
  50. [56]Yang, Yan, Pecora, Francesco, Matthaeus, William H., Roy, Sohom, Cuesta, Manuel Enrique, Chasapis, Alexandros, Parashar, Tulasi, Bandyopadhyay, Riddhi, Gershman, D. J., Giles, B. L. & Burch, J. L. 2023 Quantifying the AgYrotropy of Proton and Electron Heating in Turbulent Plasmas. Astrophys. J. 944 (2), 148.DOI
  51. [57]Yang, Yan, Wan, Minping, Matthaeus, William H., Shi, Yiping, Parashar, Tulasi N., Lu, Quanming & Chen, Shiyi 2019 Role of magnetic field curvature in magnetohydrodynamic turbulence. Phys. Plasmas 26 (7), 072306.DOI
  52. [58]Zhdankin, Vladimir 2022 Generalized Entropy Production in Collisionless Plasma Flows and Turbulence. Phys. Rev. X 12 (3), 031011.DOI

Paper details

vlnc:W_tygnz6ex
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 8

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Physics and Astronomy

Claude Opus 5.5 (bare)

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents