betaFeedback

WorksPhysics and Astronomy

A Detailed Description of the CamSpec Likelihood Pipeline and a Reanalysis of the Planck High Frequency Maps

Abstract

This paper presents a detailed description of the CamSpec likelihood which has been used to analyse Planck temperature and polarization maps of the cosmic microwave background since the first Planck data release. We have created a number of likelihoods using a range of Galactic sky masks and different methods of temperature foreground cleaning. Our most powerful likelihood uses 80 percent of the sky in temperature and polarization. Our results show that the six-parameter LCDM cosmology provides an excellent fit to the Planck data. There is no evidence for statistically significant internal tensions in the Planck TT, TE and EE spectra computed for different frequency combinations. We present evidence that the tendencies for the Planck temperature power spectra to favour a lensing amplitude A_L>1 and positive spatial curvature are caused by statistical fluctuations in the temperature power spectra. Using our statistically most powerful likelihood, we find that the A_L parameter differs from unity at no more than the 2.2 sigma level. We find no evidence for anomalous shifts in cosmological parameters with multipole range. In fact, we show that the combined TTTEEE likelihood over the restricted multipole range 2-800 gives cosmological parameters for the base LCDM cosmology that are very close to those derived from the full multipole range 2-2500. We present revised constraints on a few extensions of the base LCDM cosmology, focussing on the sum of neutrino masses, number of relativistic species and the tensor-scalar ratio. The results presented here show that the Planck data are remarkably consistent between detector-sets, frequencies and sky area. We find no evidence in our analysis that cosmological parameters determined from the CamSpec likelihood are affected to any significant degree by systematic errors in the Planck data (abridged).

Introduction

Since the discovery of the cosmic microwave background radiation (CMB) in 1965 [2], observations of the CMB have provided a wealth of new information on the early and late time Universe. The Planck satellite1 [3, 4] is the third space mission dedicated to measuring anisotropies in the CMB, following COBE [5] and WMAP [6, 7]. The first cosmological results from the Planck nominal mission temperature data were presented in [8] and results for the full mission2, including polarization data, have been reported in [9] and [1]. To extract cosmological information from CMB data requires the construction of a likelihood. The likelihoods used in the Planck analysis are described in abbreviated form in [10, 11, 12].3

In this paper we present a detailed description of the CamSpec likelihood that we developed and applied to Planck in each of the three Planck data releases. The CamSpec likelihood has been described in short form in the Planck collaboration likelihood papers PPL13, PPL15 and PPL18 and has been compared with the Plik likelihood in PCP15 and PCP18. Planck is an important legacy dataset and is likely to be analysed by many other researchers in the future.

We believe that it will be useful, particularly for experimentalists who wish to combine Planck with ground based CMB data, to present in a single source a detailed description of exactly what we have done in constructing likelihoods for the Planck collaboration. A second, and perhaps more significant, motivation for this paper has been to address the consistency and fidelity of the Planck data. The Planck data are consistent with the CMB fluctuations predicted for a spatially flat Universe with a power-law spectrum of scalar Gaussian adiabatic fluctuations. This model, which we will refer to as the base Λ\LambdaCDM cosmology is described by six parameters. The values of some of these parameters are not in perfect agreement with some other data, for example direct measurements of the Hubble constant (as will be discussed in Sect. 13.7). It is therefore important to demonstrate the consistency of the Planck results. In developing CamSpec we focussed extensively on the fidelity of the Planck power spectra, testing for consistency between power spectra determined from individual detector-sets and frequency combinations. Such consistency checks are more direct than tests based on consistency of cosmological parameters. The third motivation for this paper is to investigate a number of peculiar results reported in PCP18. These include the tendency of the Planck temperature power spectra to favour a lensing amplitude ALA_L greater than unity4 and to favour closed universes. Neither of these results has been reported at a high statistical significance (at ≲3σ\lesssim3\sigma), but since they could be signs of new physics, internal tensions within the Planck data, or small inconsistencies in the construction of the Planck likelihoods, we felt that a closer investigation was merited. We have therefore created statistically more powerful CamSpec likelihoods than those used in PPL18 and PCP18, primarily by extending sky coverage.5 To motivate the reader, the upper panel in Figure 1.1 shows the residuals of the PCP18 CamSpec coadded TT spectrum6 with respect to the best-fit base Λ\LambdaCDM and foreground model. The lower panel in Figure 1.1 shows residuals for the 12.5HMcl likelihood discussed in this paper which increases the sky area at 143 and 217 GHz compared to the likelihoods used in the Planck legacy papers. The base Λ\LambdaCDM cosmology fitted to this likelihood is almost identical to the best fit base Λ\LambdaCDM cosmology presented in PCP18 (see Sect. 13) but the residuals are visibly smaller. In other words, by constructing a more powerful likelihood, the CMB power spectrum tightens up around the predictions of the base Λ\LambdaCDM cosmology. This is strong evidence in support of the Λ\LambdaCDM model as will be discussed in detail in Sect. 13.

Figure 1.1. TT power spectrum residuals for the CamSpec likelihood as used in PCP18 (upper figure) and for the most powerful likelihood (12.5HMcl) produced for this paper (lower figure). The residuals are computed with respect to the best-fit base Λ\LambdaCDM cosmology and foreground model fitted to the TT spectra at ℓ≥30\ell\ge30 in combination with the low multipole temperature and polarization likelihoods at ℓ<30\ell< 30 (as discussed in Sect. 10).

A short summary of the mathematical framework underlying CamSpec for both temperature and polarization is presented in Sect. 2, with details relegated to Appendix § 17. The application of this theoretical framework to real CMB data requires: (a) an accurate model of unresolved foregrounds, including Galactic contamination; (b) accurate models of beams and instrumental noise; (c) control of instrumental systematics. Since (a)-(c) can lead to biases in the cosmology, a large part of this paper is devoted to these aspects of the analysis. Various choices need to be made to construct a likelihood, for example, the choices of sky cuts, multipole ranges and methods of foreground removal. We present the rationale behind these choices and investigate the robustness of the CamSpec results to these choices.

The rest of this paper is divided into four distinct blocks:

[1] Sections 3 - 6: Preliminaries and instrumental effects.

§ 3 summarizes the Galactic temperature and polarization masks used in this paper. § 4 discusses the maps that we have used to estimate cross-spectra. PCP13 used nominal mission detector-set maps whereas the likelihoods used in PCP15 and PCP18 used half mission cross spectra. In this paper, we compare half mission spectra with spectra constructed from the full mission detector-set maps. § 5 discusses ways of estimating detector noise and analyses correlated noise between detectors. Beam corrections and polarization efficiencies are described in Sect. 6. This section presents a detailed intercomparison of the temperature spectra power spectra measured by different detectors and presents a cross-check of the temperature to polarization leakage corrections applied to the polarization spectra.

[2] Sections 7 - 9: Galactic dust emission in temperature and polarization, extragalactic foregrounds and nuisance parameters.

§ 7 presents an analysis of Galactic dust emission in temperature. In early versions of CamSpec (see PCP13) we corrected for Galactic dust emission in temperature by constructing and fitting dust power spectrum templates together with template power spectra for extragalactic foregrounds. The construction of such templates is discussed in Sect. 7 together with an analysis of the universality of the dust power spectrum as a function of frequency and sky coverage. We analyse CMB-dust correlations, which introduce substantial additional scatter to the power spectrum estimates, especially at 217 GHz, limiting the sky area that can be used reliably at this frequency. This motivates an alternative method of removing Galactic dust by subtracting high frequency maps (as described by [13, 14] and PPL15). We demonstrate that ‘cleaning’ the 143 × 143, 143 × 217 and 217 × 217 spectra7 with higher Planck frequencies removes Galactic dust accurately leaving residual power-spectrum contributions from extragalactic foregrounds that are well described by power-laws. In this paper we construct likelihoods using the standard power-spectrum template based foreground model, as described in previous Planck papers, and we also construct high frequency ‘cleaned’ likelihoods using a much simpler foreground model. Comparison of these likelihoods gives an indication of residual uncertainties in the cosmological results associated with temperature foreground modelling. We present, for the first time, a detailed analysis to demonstrate that high frequency cleaning can be used to extend the sky coverage at 143 and 217 GHz reliably to 80% of the sky. Extragalactic foregrounds in polarization are well below the sensitivity level of Planck. All of our likelihoods use 353 GHz maps to subtract polarized dust emission, as discussed in Sect. 8. Instrumental nuisance parameters and the extragalactic foreground templates are discussed in Sect. 9, together with the priors adopted in the likelihood analysis. We have made minor changes to the foreground/nuisance model used in PCP18. Here we fix the relative calibrations of the cross-spectra, rather than carrying them as nuisance parameters, since they can be determined to high accuracy as described in Sect. 9.1.1; we also allow the amplitude of the Cosmic Infrared Background (CIB) contribution to the 143 × 217 spectrum to vary independently of the amplitude in the 217 × 217 spectrum. These changes have relatively little impact on cosmological parameters.

[3] Sections 10 - 12: Likelihoods and inter-frequency comparisons of power spectra.

Comparison of temperature power spectra at different frequencies requires a likelihood analysis to determine the foreground parameters. In this part of the paper, we adopt the six parameter base ΛCDM model. § 11 compares the consistency of the temperature spectra in the half mission, cleaned and full mission likelihoods and analyses spectrum residuals as a function of sky coverage. § 12 presents a similar analysis for the TE and EE spectra cleaned with 353 GHz. We also compare our spectra with the spectra used to form the low multipole (ℓ<30\ell< 30) temperature and polarization likelihoods.

[4] Sections 13 - 14: Science results.

§ 13 discusses cosmological parameters for the base ΛCDM model, demonstrating the consistency of the cosmological parameters determined from various sky areas, temperature and polarization combinations, and different methods of temperature foreground cleaning. As highlighted in Figure 1.1, by extending the sky coverage in temperature and polarization we have created more powerful likelihoods than those discussed in the 2018 Planck legacy papers. This allows more sensitive tests of consistency with, and deviations from, the base ΛCDM cosmology. We therefore revisit the consistency of cosmological parameters determined from different multipole ranges, the significance of oscillatory features in the temperature power spectra, and possible tensions of the base ΛCDM model with other astrophysical data. One-parameter extensions to the base ΛCDM model are discussed in Sect. 14. Since, for the most part, our results are consistent with those given in PCP18, we do not present a comprehensive analysis of extended models, but instead focus mainly on the parameters ALA_L and ΩK\Omega_K for which there were hints of anomalies in PCP15 and PCP18 and for which the Planck papers reported differences between the CamSpec and Plik likelihoods. A comparison of our best fit Λ\LambdaCDM cosmology with the power spectra measured from ground based polarization experiments [15, 16, 17, 18, 19] is presented in Appendix § 18.

To further guide the reader we note the main differences between the CamSpec analyses presented in PCP18 and in this paper:

  • PCP18 presented two TT likelihoods using approximately 60%, 70% and 80% of sky at 217, 143 and 100 GHz respectively (mask60, mask70, mask80, see Figure 3.1 and Table 1). The default TT likelihood used the standard multi-parametric foreground model described in PCP18 and earlier Planck papers (see also Sect. 9). However, we also produced a 545 GHz ‘cleaned’ TT likelihood which allowed the use of a much simpler heuristic model for the TT foreground contributions to the 143×143, 143×217 and 217×217 spectra. In PCP18 we showed that the spectra and cosmological parameters from the default and cleaned CamSpec likelihoods were in very good agreement. In this paper, we increase the sky coverage in temperature to 80% of the sky at 143 and 217 GHz. This can only be done reliably by constructing ‘cleaned’ likelihoods (to eliminate noise arising from CMB-foreground cross correlations). Thus a large part of this paper is devoted to demonstrating that the residual cleaned foreground contributions to the TT power spectra at 143 and 217 GHz are statistically isotropic on the sky and therefore of extragalactic origin as sky coverage is increased (see e.g. Figure 11.5).

Temperature Maskfskyf_{\rm sky} (%)fskyWf_{\rm sky}^{W} (%)Polarization Maskfskyf_{\rm sky} (%)fskyWf_{\rm sky}^{W} (%)
mask2524.6818.55–––
mask5049.2741.07maskpol5050.2638.94
mask6059.1050.01maskpol6059.5748.81
mask7069.4060.19–––
mask8079.1370.15–––

Table 1. Sky fractions retained by the diffuse temperature and polarization masks

Sequence of apodised diffuse foreground temperature masks and point source, CO, and extended object masks for the 217, 143, and 100 GHz maps

Figure 3.1. Figures to the left show the sequence of apodised diffuse foreground temperature masks (from top to bottom) applied to the 217, 143 and 100 GHz maps used to form our 12.1HM likelihood. Figures to the right show the point source+CO+extended object masks that we apply to the 217, 143 and 100 GHz maps.

Figure 11.5. As Figure 11.2, but for spectra cleaned with 545 GHz as used in the 12.1HMcl likelihood. The residuals here are computed with respect to the best fit base Λ\LambdaCDM cosmology + foreground model derived from the 12.1HMcl TT likelihood. The black line shows the residuals of the maximum likelihood frequency coadded spectrum smoothed with a Gaussian of width σℓ=40\sigma_\ell= 40. The dashed line shows the difference between the best-fit ALA_L model (with AL=1.14A_L = 1.14) and the fiducial model smoothed with a Gaussian of width σℓ=40\sigma_\ell= 40.

  • We demonstrate that over 80% of the sky, 143 GHz maps dust-cleaned with 545 GHz are ‘cleaner’ than 100 GHz maps cleaned with 545 GHz. This is because at large angular scales 100 GHz maps contain low levels of synchrotron and CO emission (even though we apply a CO mask at 100 GHz see Figure 9.1). At small angular scales, the 100 GHz maps are noisy and are contaminated by extragalactic radio sources and thermal Sunyaev-Zeldovich fluctuations. In this paper we discard the 100 × 100 spectra from the cleaned TT likelihood, significantly reducing the number of parameters required to model TT foregrounds at negligible loss to the science of interest.

Figure 9.1. Differences between recalibrated 545 GHz cleaned half mission temperature cross spectra and the 143×143 545 GHz cleaned spectrum. The relative calibration coefficients are given in Eqs. 9.2a–9.2c.

  • In PCP18 we allowed relative effective calibrations of the TT spectra with (over-)generous priors to vary along with the foreground parameters. We show in this paper that using 545 GHz cleaning, the relative calibrations of the TT spectra can be determined to such high accuracy that they do not need to be carried as nuisance parameters (see Sect. 9).

  • The polarization analysis in PCP18 used approximately 60% of sky at all frequencies with a specially constructed polarization mask (maskpol60, see Figure 3.2). In this paper, we construct likelihoods using up to 80% of sky in polarization at all frequencies.

Polarization masks constructed from a degraded resolution full mission 353 GHz map

Figure 3.2. Polarization masks constructed from a degraded resolution full mission 353 GHz P=(Q2+U2)1/2P=(Q^2+U^2)^{1/2} map.

It is also worth summarizing the main differences between Plik, used as the baseline likelihood in PCP18, and the CamSpec likelihoods discussed in this paper:

  • The ‘uncleaned’ CamSpec and Plik TT likelihoods are essentially identical and give almost identical cosmological parameters as discussed in PCP18. In this paper, we use 545 GHz cleaning to extend the sky coverage in temperature.

  • In CamSpec we remove polarized Galactic dust emission at low multipoles (ℓ<150\ell< 150) by subtracting 353 GHz polarization maps. At higher multipoles (where polarized foregrounds are sub-dominant to the primordial fluctuations) we remove the contribution at Galactic dust emission at the power spectrum level by subtracting power-law dust models fitted to low multipoles. Since there are no other detectable foreground contributions in polarization, we compress the dust corrected polarization spectra to form frequency averaged TE and EE spectra. The combined TTTEEE CamSpec likelihoods are compact and there is therefore computational requirement to band average the spectra. Since dust emission has already been removed from the TE and EE spectra to high accuracy, there is no need to carry nuisance parameters in the likelihood associated with polarized dust emission. In contrast, the Plik likelihood retains all distinct spectral combinations in the TE and EE blocks (note that in Plik the TE and ET spectra are averaged). Twelve additional nuisance parameters are then required to characterise Galactic dust emission in TE and EE. In addition, to make the Plik TTTEEE likelihood compact, the default Plik likelihood is band averaged as described in Sect. 3.2.5 of PPL15.

  • In CamSpec we calibrate each individual TE and EE spectrum assuming a fiducial cosmological model to determine effective (‘spectrum-based’) polarization efficiencies. The Plik team chose to use ‘map-based’ effective polarization efficiencies computed from the EE spectra to correct the EE and TE spectra. This procedure results in poor χ2\chi^2 values for the Plik TE spectra (cf tbl:20 for PPL18).

The differences between CamSpec and Plik are therefore mainly in the TE and EE blocks of the likelihoods. Nevertheless, for almost all cosmological models, the two likelihoods give closely similar results. As shown in PCP18, the main science conclusions of that paper would have been unaltered had CamSpec been used as the baseline in place of Plik. For some extended models, particularly ALA_L and Ωk\Omega_k, the CamSpec TTTEEE likelihoods used in PCP18 (and in this paper) give results that are more consistent with the base Λ\LambdaCDM model than those from Plik. These differences come almost entirely from the TE blocks of the likelihood, since for Planck EE is so noisy that the EE block contributes little statistical weight to the TTTEEE likelihood. The main differences between the CamSpec and Plik TTTEEE likelihoods can be traced to the polarization efficiency corrections; Plik TTTEEE using spectrum-based polarization efficiencies comes into closer agreement with CamSpec (see Sect. 2.2.1 of PCP18). In our view, the CamSpec TE efficiencies are internally self-consistent, since they lead to acceptable χ2\chi^2 values for Λ\LambdaCDM-like models for the statistically dominant TT and TE blocks of the TTTEEE likelihood. Readers who are unpersuaded by this argument should at the very least treat the differences between CamSpec and Plik TTTEEE as indicative of errors arising from inaccuracies in the calibrations of polarization efficiencies and angles of the Planck HFI detectors.

Since most of this paper is technical in nature, readers interested only in the final cosmological results can skip to Sect. 13, though the earlier sections are essential reading if one wants to acquire an appreciation of the fidelity of the results. Our conclusions are summarized in Sect. 15. Throughout this paper, we use the same notation and definitions of cosmological parameters as in PCP18.

Spectra and covariance matrices

This section presents a summary of the mathematical framework developed for the CamSpec pipeline. Analytic expressions for the covariance matrices have been presented in [20, 21, 22, 23] and are summarized in Appendix § 17.§ 2. These are based on a number of idealised assumptions which do not apply exactly to the real Planck data. We discuss the mismatch between the theoretical framework and the real data in this section.

Pseudo-cross spectra

The CamSpec likelihood uses pseudo-cross spectra computed on masked skies. Since the masks are apodised (see Sect. 3), they are described by weight functions wpTw_{p}^{T} for temperature and wpPw_{p}^{P} for QQ and UU polarization maps at each map pixel pp. Note that we always apply identical weight functions to QQ and UU maps.8

For a particular weighting scheme we compute the following pseudo-spectra from maps ii and jj expressed as a vector:

C‾ℓij=(C‾ℓTiTj, C‾ℓTiEj, C‾ℓEiTj, C‾ℓEiEj, C‾ℓBiBj, C‾ℓEiBj, C‾ℓBiEj, C‾ℓTiBj, C‾ℓBiTj)T.(1)\overline{\mathbf{C}}_{\ell}^{ij} = \left(\overline{C}_{\ell}^{T_iT_j},\ \overline{C}_{\ell}^{T_iE_j},\ \overline{C}_{\ell}^{E_iT_j},\ \overline{C}_{\ell}^{E_iE_j},\ \overline{C}_{\ell}^{B_iB_j},\ \overline{C}_{\ell}^{E_iB_j},\ \overline{C}_{\ell}^{B_iE_j},\ \overline{C}_{\ell}^{T_iB_j},\ \overline{C}_{\ell}^{B_iT_j}\right)^{T}. \tag*{(1)}

The pseudo-spectra of equation (1) are constructed from the following transforms:

a‾ℓmTi=∑p(Ti)pwpTiΩpYℓm∗(θp),(2)\overline{a}_{\ell m}^{T_i} = \sum_{p} (T_i)_p w_{p}^{T_i} \Omega_p Y_{\ell m}^{*}(\theta_p), \tag*{(2)}
a‾ℓmEi=−12∑p[(Qi+iUi)pwpPiΩp 2Yℓm∗(θp)+(Qi−iUi)pwpPiΩp −2Yℓm∗(θp)],(3)\overline{a}_{\ell m}^{E_i} = -\frac{1}{2}\sum_{p}\left[(Q_i+iU_i)_p w_{p}^{P_i}\Omega_p\,{}_{2}Y_{\ell m}^{*}(\theta_p) + (Q_i-iU_i)_p w_{p}^{P_i}\Omega_p\,{}_{-2}Y_{\ell m}^{*}(\theta_p)\right], \tag*{(3)}
a‾ℓmBi=−12∑p[(Ui−iQi)pwpPiΩp 2Yℓm∗(θp)+(Ui+iQi)pwpPiΩp −2Yℓm∗(θp)],(4)\overline{a}_{\ell m}^{B_i} = -\frac{1}{2}\sum_{p}\left[(U_i-iQ_i)_p w_{p}^{P_i}\Omega_p\,{}_{2}Y_{\ell m}^{*}(\theta_p) + (U_i+iQ_i)_p w_{p}^{P_i}\Omega_p\,{}_{-2}Y_{\ell m}^{*}(\theta_p)\right], \tag*{(4)}

where the sums extend over the number of map pixels each of solid angle Ωp\Omega_p. The pseudo-power spectra are then computed in the usual way, for example,

C‾ℓTiTj=12ℓ+1∑ma‾ℓmTia‾ℓm∗Tj.(5)\overline{C}_{\ell}^{T_iT_j} = \frac{1}{2\ell+1}\sum_{m}\overline{a}_{\ell m}^{T_i}\overline{a}_{\ell m}^{*T_j}. \tag*{(5)}

For the majority of this paper, we use the Planck 2018 HFI half-mission frequency maps in Healpix format [24] at a resolution NSIDE=2048 available from the Planck Legacy Archive9 (hereafter PLA). The only preprocessing applied to these maps before applying the transforms 2.2a–2.2c is to remove the means within the unmasked area of sky. For example, for map TiT_i we subtract the mean

(Ti)mean=∑pwpTi(Ti)p∑pwpTi,(6)(T_i)_{\mathrm{mean}} = \frac{\sum_{p} w_{p}^{T_i}(T_i)_p}{\sum_{p} w_{p}^{T_i}}, \tag*{(6)}

(and similarly for the QiQ_i and UiU_i maps) to eliminate Galactic emission at low latitudes leaking to higher multipoles. We make no other corrections to the maps prior to transformation.

The expectation values of the pseudo-spectral estimates are related to the beam convolved theoretical spectra C‾ℓij\overline{C}_{\ell}^{ij} via a coupling matrix KijK^{ij} [25, 26]. The components of the coupling matrix are given in Sect. A.1. At this stage, for clarity we recap on the notation used for various power spectra:

  • C‾ℓ\overline{C}_{\ell} is the beam convolved spectrum computed on the incomplete sky.

  • C~ℓ\widetilde{C}_{\ell} is a beam corrected spectrum computed on incomplete sky.

  • C^ℓ\widehat{C}_{\ell} is a beam corrected spectrum deconvolved for the sky mask.

  • C‾ℓ\overline{C}_{\ell} is a beam convolved theoretical spectrum.

  • C~ℓ\widetilde{C}_{\ell} is the theoretical spectrum.

The power spectrum estimates need to be deconvolved for the effects of the sky mask (described by the coupling matrix KijK^{ij}), the Planck instrumental beams and the effects of the finite size of the sky pixels, which we assume are described by functions that depend only on multipole ℓ\ell. To simplify the discussion, we will discuss estimates of the temperature power spectrum. The power spectra measured on the incomplete sky are related to the theoretical power spectrum as

References

  1. [1]Planck Collaboration et al., A&A 641, A6 (2020), astro-ph/1807.06209.
  2. [2]A. A. Penzias and R. W. Wilson, ApJ 142, 419 (1965).
  3. [3]Planck Collaboration et al., A&A 571, A1 (2014), astro-ph/1303.5062.
  4. [4]Planck Collaboration et al., A&A 594, A1 (2016), astro-ph/1502.01582.
  5. [5]G. F. Smoot et al., ApJ 396, L1 (1992).
  6. [6]C. L. Bennett et al., ApJS 148, 1 (2003), astro-ph/0302207.
  7. [7]C. L. Bennett et al., ApJS 208, 20 (2013), astro-ph/1212.5225.
  8. [8]Planck Collaboration et al., A&A 571, A16 (2014), astro-ph/1303.5076.
  9. [9]Planck Collaboration et al., A&A 594, A13 (2016), astro-ph/1502.01589.
  10. [10]Planck Collaboration et al., A&A 571, A15 (2014), astro-ph/1303.5075.
  11. [11]Planck Collaboration et al., A&A 594, A11 (2016), astro-ph/1507.02704.
  12. [12]Planck Collaboration et al., A&A 641, A5 (2020), astro-ph/1907.12875.
  13. [13]M. Lueker et al., ApJ 719, 1045 (2010), astro-ph/0912.4317.
  14. [14]D. N. Spencer, R. Flauger, and R. Hložek, Phys. Rev. D 91, 023518 (2015), astro-ph/1312.3313.
  15. [15]T. Louis et al., J. Cosmology Astropart. Phys. 6, 031 (2017), astro-ph/1610.02360.
  16. [16]J. W. Henning et al., ApJ 852, 97 (2018), astro-ph/1707.09353.
  17. [17]S. K. Choi et al., J. Cosmology Astropart. Phys. 2020, 045 (2020), astro-ph/2007.07289.
  18. [18]S. Aiola et al., J. Cosmology Astropart. Phys. 2020, 047 (2020), astro-ph/2007.07288.
  19. [19]D. Dutcher et al., Phys. Rev. D 104, 022003 (2021), astro-ph/2101.01684.
  20. [20]G. Efstathiou, MNRAS 348, 885 (2004), astro-ph/0310207.
  21. [21]A. Challinor and G. Chon, MNRAS 360, 509 (2005), astro-ph/0410097.
  22. [22]G. Efstathiou, MNRAS 370, 343 (2006), astro-ph/0601107.
  23. [23]S. Hamimeche and A. Lewis, Phys. Rev. D 77, 103013 (2008), astro-ph/0801.0554.
  24. [24]K. M. Górski et al., ApJ 622, 759 (2005), astro-ph/0409513.
  25. [25]E. Hivon et al., ApJ 567, 2 (2002), astro-ph/0105302.
  26. [26]A. Kogut et al., ApJS 148, 161 (2003), astro-ph/0302213.
  27. [27]D. S. Y. Mak, A. Challinor, G. Efstathiou, and G. Lagache, MNRAS 466, 286 (2017), astro-ph/1609.08942.
  28. [28]Planck Collaboration et al., A&A 641, A3 (2020), astro-ph/1807.06207.
  29. [29]R. Flauger, L. McAllister, E. Silverstein, and A. Westphal, J. Cosmology Astropart. Phys. 2017, 055 (2017), hep-th/1412.1814.
  30. [30]Planck Collaboration et al., A&A 571, A13 (2014), astro-ph/1303.5073.
  31. [31]P. Lemos, PhD Thesis, University of Cambridge (2018).
  32. [32]R. de Belsunce, S. Gratton, W. Coulton, and G. Efstathiou, arXiv e-prints (2021), astro-ph/2103.14378.
  33. [33]C. Rosset et al., A&A 520, A13 (2010), astro-ph/1004.2595.
  34. [34]Planck Collaboration et al., A&A 596, A110 (2016), astro-ph/1605.08633.
  35. [35]Planck Collaboration et al., A&A 596, A107 (2016), astro-ph/1605.02985.
  36. [36]Planck Collaboration et al., A&A 571, A7 (2014), astro-ph/1303.5068.
  37. [37]S. Mitra et al., ApJS 193, 5 (2011), astro-ph/1005.1929.
  38. [38]E. Hivon, S. Mottet, and N. Ponthieu, A&A 598, A25 (2017), astro-ph/1608.08833.
  39. [39]E. Hivon, A. Ducout, S. Mottet, and G. Roudier, Planck Internal Communication (2015).
  40. [40]Planck Collaboration et al., A&A 571, A12 (2014), astro-ph/1303.5072.
  41. [41]Planck Collaboration et al., A&A 594, A9 (2016), astro-ph/1502.05956.
  42. [42]Planck Collaboration et al., A&A 641, A4 (2020), astro-ph/1807.06208.
  43. [43]H. K. Eriksen et al., ApJ 641, 665 (2006), astro-ph/0508268.
  44. [44]H. K. Eriksen et al., ApJ 676, 10 (2008), astro-ph/0709.1058.
  45. [45]J.-F. Cardoso, M. Martin, J. Delabrouille, M. Betoule, and G. Patanchon, arXiv e-prints (2008), astro-ph/0803.1814.
  46. [46]J. Delabrouille et al., A&A 493, 835 (2009), astro-ph/0807.0773.
  47. [47]S. M. Leach et al., A&A 491, 597 (2008), astro-ph/0805.0269.
  48. [48]R. Fernández-Cobos, P. Vielva, R. B. Barreiro, and E. Martínez-González, MNRAS 420, 2162 (2012), astro-ph/1106.2016.
  49. [49]Planck Collaboration et al., A&A 571, A30 (2014), astro-ph/1309.0382.
  50. [50]Planck Collaboration et al., A&A 571, A11 (2014), astro-ph/1312.1300.
  51. [51]P. Larsen, A. Challinor, B. D. Sherwin, and D. Mak, Physical Review Letters 117, 151102 (2016), astro-ph/1607.05733.
  52. [52]Planck Collaboration et al., A&A 571, A9 (2014), astro-ph/1303.5070.
  53. [53]Planck Collaboration et al., A&A 594, A8 (2016), astro-ph/1502.01587.
  54. [54]D. P. Finkbeiner, M. Davis, and D. J. Schlegel, ApJ 524, 867 (1999), astro-ph/9905128.
  55. [55]A. M. Meisner and D. P. Finkbeiner, ApJ 798, 88 (2015), astro-ph/1411.7523.
  56. [56]Planck Collaboration et al., A&A 576, A107 (2015), astro-ph/1405.0874.
  57. [57]Planck Collaboration et al., A&A 586, A133 (2016), astro-ph/1409.5738.
  58. [58]T. Ghosh et al., A&A 601, A71 (2017), astro-ph/1611.02418.
  59. [59]Planck Collaboration et al., A&A 641, A11 (2020), astro-ph/1801.04945.
  60. [60]A. Lewis and S. Bridle, Phys. Rev. D 66, 103511 (2002), astro-ph/0205436.
  61. [62]C. L. Reichardt et al., ApJ 755, 70 (2012), astro-ph/1111.0932.
  62. [63]J. M. Delouis, L. Pagano, S. Mottet, J. L. Puget, and L. Vibert, A&A 629, A38 (2019), astro-ph/1901.11386.
  63. [64]M. P. Viero et al., ApJ 772, 77 (2013), astro-ph/1208.5049.
  64. [65]G. Efstathiou and M. Migliaccio, MNRAS 423, 2492 (2012), astro-ph/1106.3208.
  65. [66]N. Battaglia, J. R. Bond, C. Pfrommer, J. L. Sievers, and D. Sijacki, ApJ 725, 91 (2010), astro-ph/1003.4256.
  66. [67]I. G. McCarthy, A. M. C. Le Brun, J. S. Schaye, and G. P. Holder, MNRAS 440, 3645 (2014), astro-ph/1312.5341.
  67. [68]H. Trac, P. Bode, and J. P. Ostriker, ApJ 727, 94 (2011), astro-ph/1006.2828.
  68. [69]G. E. Addison, J. Dunkley, and D. N. Spergel, MNRAS 427, 1741 (2012), astro-ph/1204.5927.
  69. [70]E. M. George et al., ApJ 799, 177 (2015), astro-ph/1408.3161.
  70. [71]X. Chen and M. H. Namjoo, Physics Letters B 739, 285 (2014), astro-ph/1404.1536.
  71. [72]Planck Collaboration et al., A&A 607, A95 (2017), astro-ph/1608.02487.
  72. [73]G. Efstathiou and S. Gratton, Planck Internal Communication (2014).
  73. [74]Planck Collaboration et al., A&A 641, A8 (2020), astro-ph/1807.06210.
  74. [75]S. Alam et al., MNRAS 470, 2617 (2017), astro-ph/1607.03155.
  75. [76]F. Beutler et al., MNRAS 416, 3017 (2011), astro-ph/1106.3366.
  76. [77]A. J. Ross et al., MNRAS449, 835 (2015), astro-ph/1409.3242.
  77. [78]W. J. Percival et al., MNRAS 337, 1068 (2002), astro-ph/0206256.
  78. [79]Planck Collaboration et al., A&A 571, A31 (2014), astro-ph/1508.03375.
  79. [80]Y. Huang, G. E. Addison, J. L. Weiland, and C. L. Bennett, ApJ 869, 38 (2018), astro-ph/1804.05428.
  80. [81]G. E. Addison et al., ApJ 818, 132 (2016), astro-ph/1511.00055.
  81. [82]A. G. Riess et al., ApJ 730, 119 (2011), astro-ph/1103.2976.
  82. [83]A. G. Riess et al., ApJ 826, 56 (2016), astro-ph/1604.01424.
  83. [84]A. G. Riess et al., ApJ 861, 126 (2018), astro-ph/1804.10655.
  84. [85]A. G. Riess, S. Casertano, W. Yuan, L. M. Macri, and D. Scolnic, ApJ 876, 85 (2019), astro-ph/1903.07603.
  85. [86]S. Birrer et al., MNRAS 484, 4726 (2019), astro-ph/1809.01274.
  86. [87]É. Aubourg et al., Phys. Rev. D 92, 123516 (2015), astro-ph/1411.1074.
  87. [88]A. J. Cuésta, L. Verde, A. Riess, and R. Jimenez, MNRAS 448, 3463 (2015), astro-ph/1411.1094.
  88. [89]J. L. Bernal, L. Verde, and A. G. Riess, J. Cosmology Astropart. Phys. 10, 019 (2016), astro-ph/1607.05617.
  89. [90]P. Lemos, E. Lee, G. Efstathiou, and S. Gratton, MNRAS (2018), astro-ph/1806.06781.
  90. [91]E. Macaulay et al., MNRAS 486, 2184 (2019), astro-ph/1811.02376.
  91. [92]G. Efstathiou, MNRAS 505, 3866 (2021), astro-ph/2103.08723.
  92. [93]L. Knox and M. Millea, Phys. Rev. D 101, 043533 (2020), astro-ph/1908.03663.
  93. [94]E. Di Valentino et al., Classical and Quantum Gravity 38, 153001 (2021), astro-ph/2103.01183.
  94. [95]N. Schönberger et al., arXiv e-prints (2021), astro-ph/2107.10291.
  95. [96]C. Hikage et al., PASJ 71, 43 (2019), astro-ph/1809.09148.
  96. [97]C. Heymans et al., A&A 646, A140 (2021), astro-ph/2007.15632.
  97. [98]H. Hildebrandt et al., A&A 633, A69 (2020), astro-ph/1812.06076.
  98. [99]DES Collaboration et al., arXiv e-prints (2021), astro-ph/2105.13549.
  99. [100]T. M. C. Abbott et al., Phys. Rev. D 98, 043526 (2018), astro-ph/1708.01530.
  100. [101]S. Joudaki et al., A&A 638, L1 (2020), astro-ph/1906.09262.
  101. [102]M. Asgari et al., A&A 634, A127 (2020), astro-ph/1910.05336.
  102. [103]C. García-García et al., arXiv e-prints (2021), astro-ph/2105.12108.
  103. [104]C. Park and B. Ratra, ApJ 882, 158 (2019), astro-ph/1801.00213.
  104. [105]E. Di Valentino, A. Melchiorri, and J. Silk, Nature Astronomy 4, 484 (2019), astro-ph/1911.02087.
  105. [106]E. Di Valentino, A. Melchiorri, and J. Silk, ApJ 908, L9 (2021), astro-ph/2003.04935.
  106. [107]W. Handley, arXiv e-prints (2019), astro-ph/1908.09139.
  107. [108]J. R. Bond, G. Efstathiou, and M. Tegmark, MNRAS 291, L33 (1997), astro-ph/9702100.
  108. [109]R. Stompor and G. Efstathiou, MNRAS 302, 735 (1999), astro-ph/9805294.
  109. [110]G. Efstathiou and S. Gratton, MNRAS 496, L91 (2020), astri-ph/2002.06892.
  110. [111]I. G. McCarthy et al., MNRAS 476, 2999 (2018), astro-ph/1712.02411.
  111. [112]BICEP2 Collaboration et al., Physical Review Letters 121, 221301 (2018), astro-ph/1810.05216.
  112. [113]Planck Collaboration et al., A&A 571, A24 (2014), astro-ph/1303.5084.
  113. [114]Planck Collaboration et al., A&A 594, A17 (2016), astro-ph/1502.01592.
  114. [115]Planck Collaboration et al., A&A 571, A22 (2014), astro-ph/1303.5082.
  115. [116]Planck Collaboration et al., A&A 594, A20 (2016), astro-ph/1502.02114.
  116. [117]Planck Collaboration et al., A&A 641, A10 (2020), astro-ph/1807.06211.
  117. [118]A. A. Starobinskij, Pisma v Zhurnal Eksperimentalnoi i Teoreticheskoi Fisiki 30, 719 (1979).
  118. [119]L. Knox and M. S. Turner, Physical Review Letters 73, 3347 (1994), astro-ph/9407037.
  119. [120]M. Kamionkowski, A. Kosowsky, and A. Stebbins, Phys. Rev. D 55, 7368 (1997), astro-ph/9611125.
  120. [121]U. Seljak and M. Zaldarriaga, Physical Review Letters 78, 2054 (1997), astro-ph/9609169.
  121. [122]BICEP2/Keck Collaboration et al., Physical Review Letters 114, 101301 (2015), astro-ph/1502.00612.
  122. [123]BICEP2 Collaboration et al., Physical Review Letters 116, 031302 (2016), astro-ph/1510.09217.
  123. [124]BICEP2 Collaboration et al., Physical Review Letters 112, 241101 (2014), astro-ph/1403.3985.
  124. [125]M. Tristram et al., A&A 647, A128 (2021), astro-ph/2010.01139.
  125. [126]R. Kallosh, A. Linde, D. Roest, A. Westphal, and Y. Yamada, Journal of High Energy Physics 2, 117 (2018), hep-th/1707.05830.
  126. [127]A. Achúcarro, R. Kallosh, A. Linde, D.-G. Wang, and Y. Welling, J. Cosmology Astropart. Phys. 4, 028 (2018), hep-th/1711.09478.
  127. [128]Y. Akrami, R. Kallosh, A. Linde, and V. Vardanyan, J. Cosmology Astropart. Phys. 6, 041 (2018), hep-th/1712.09693.
  128. [129]C. D. Kreisch, F.-Y. Cyr-Racine, and O. Doré, Phys. Rev. D 101, 123505 (2020), astro-ph/1902.00534.
  129. [130]P. Ade et al., J. Cosmology Astropart. Phys. 2, 056 (2019), astro-ph/1808.07445.
  130. [131]Y. Sekimoto et al., Concept design of the LiteBIRD satellite for CMB B-mode polarization, in Space Telescopes and Instrumentation 2018: Optical, Infrared, and Millimeter Wave, Society of Photo-Optical Instrumentation Engineers (SPIE) Conference Series Vol. 10698, p. 106981Y, 2018.
  131. [132]L. Lancaster, F.-Y. Cyr-Racine, L. Knox, and Z. Pan, J. Cosmology Astropart. Phys. 7, 033 (2017), astro-ph/1704.06657.
  132. [133]M. Park, C. D. Kreisch, J. Dunkley, B. Hadzhyiska, and F.-Y. Cyr-Racine, Phys. Rev. D 100, 063524 (2019), astro-ph/1904.02625.
  133. [134]A. T. Crites et al., ApJ 805, 36 (2015), astro-ph/1411.1042.
  134. [135]R. Keisler et al., ApJ 807, 151 (2015), astro-ph/1503.02315.

Paper details

vlnc:W_tyvpjzxd
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 0

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Physics and Astronomy

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents