WorksPhysics and Astronomy
Measurement of the angle between jet axes in PbPb collisions at TeV
Abstract
This paper presents the first measurement of the angle between different jet axes (denoted as ) in PbPb collisions. The measurement is carried out in the 010% most-central events at TeV. Jets are assembled by clustering charged particles at midrapidity using the anti-algorithm with resolution parameters and and transverse momenta in the intervals GeV/ and GeV/, respectively. Measurements at these low transverse momenta enhance the sensitivity to quarkgluon plasma (QGP) effects. A comparison to models implementing various mechanisms of jet energy loss in the QGP suggests that the observed narrowing of the PbPb distribution relative to pp can be explained if quark-initiated jets are more likely to emerge from the medium than gluon-initiated jets. These new measurements disfavor intra-jet broadening as implemented in a simple model calculation with the BDMPS formalism for energy loss in the QGP. The comparison of PbPb and pp collisions shows sensitivity to the angular scale at which the QGP can resolve two independent splittings, favoring mechanisms that incorporate incoherent energy loss.
The strongly interacting, deconfined state of matter of our universe a few microseconds after the Big Bang can be recreated in ultrarelativistic heavy-ion collisions at the Large Hadron Collider (LHC) [1, 2]. Studying the microscopic structure of this quark–gluon plasma (QGP) can elucidate the physics of many-body strongly coupled systems [3]. Because droplets of QGP created at colliders are small and short-lived, studying interactions within those droplets requires auto-generated probes. In this study, jets of energetic hadrons, which arise from high-momentum-transfer (hard) collisions between quarks and gluons (partons) in the incoming nuclei, are used. These hard-scattered particles produce showers of secondary partons, which give rise to jets of multiple correlated hadrons (see Figure 1, left).
Figure 1. Left: schematic of how energetic partons split or fragment into lower-energy prongs or branches of partons down to a scale in which hadrons emerge. An algorithm can then be run over final-state hadrons to cluster them into jets. An inverse declustering algorithm can be used to recursively explore the jet substructure. Right: schematic showing that different jet axes (solid arrows) can be selected from a jet to construct the observable. The Standard axis (represented by a black arrow) is constrained by all the jet constituents (represented by dashed arrows). The SD axis (represented by a dark blue arrow) is determined by the particles left in the jet after grooming (blue and dark red arrows). Finally, the WTA axis (represented by a pink arrow) tends to be aligned with the most energetic constituent.
When traversing the QGP, jets interact with the medium, lose energy, and are modified relative to their structure in elementary (e.g., ee or pp) collisions [4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 15, 16, 17, 18]. Thus, measuring the substructure of jets can provide sensitivity to different scales within the jet modification process. The direction of a jet in rapidity () and azimuth (), referred to as the jet axis, is affected by transverse modification of the partonic shower, with varying sensitivity to soft radiation, depending on how the axis is defined [19].
This paper presents the first measurement in heavy-ion collisions of the angle between pairs of jet axes, (see Figure 1, right). This observable shows how well the QGP resolves the angular structure of the parton shower [19] and is defined as
where and are the rapidity and azimuthal coordinates of the axes, respectively. The axes considered in this analysis are:
“Standard”: coordinates in – of the 4-vector resulting from clustering jets with the anti- algorithm [20] using the recombination scheme (two branches combined into one by adding their 4-momenta). In this case, all jet constituents including soft (low-transverse-momentum) and hard radiation contribute to the axis.
“Soft Drop” (SD): coordinates in – of jet after soft wide-angle radiation is removed using the Soft Drop grooming procedure [21] with the Cambridge–Aachen (C/A) reclustering algorithm [22,
23]. The procedure stops when a splitting is found that satisfies the condition
where are the transverse momenta of each of the two branches in the splitting, is the distance between them in the – plane, is the jet resolution parameter, and and are user-set parameters.
– “Winner-Takes-All” (WTA): coordinates in – of the jet after reclustering its constituents using the C/A algorithm and the WTA recombination scheme [24], which combines two jet branches into one by giving the merged branch the total of the two sub-branches and the direction of the hardest sub-branch. The WTA axis is often consistent with the direction of the hardest constituent of the jet and is insensitive to soft radiation at the leading power of the observable [19].
Measurements of are perturbatively calculable, but also sensitive to medium-induced effects; we examine sensitivity to such effects by studying jets of different and radius parameter, . An increase in the relative fraction of quark- vs. gluon-initiated jets due to medium-induced radiative energy loss can narrow the angular distribution, while multiple scattering of the hard-scattered parton off medium partons can broaden it [25]. Reference 8 reported a net narrowing of the distribution in Pb–Pb collisions, quantitatively consistent with the former. This can be expected if the broadening was primarily in the wide-angle radiation that grooming removes from the jet. This is tested by looking for broadening effects in an ungroomed angular observable, such as the angle between the Standard and WTA axes. Increasing the grooming intensity and simultaneously varying the jet resolution parameter can uncover medium-induced effects. Comparing experimental results with multiple models can help disentangle medium response and medium-induced large-angle radiation.
The medium resolution length, , is a property of the QGP proportional to the inverse of its local temperature [26]. It characterizes the minimum separation distance at which two color charges within the same jet interact independently with the QGP. Certain jet substructure observables are sensitive to this scale [27]. In this analysis, the sensitivity of to is investigated.
The measured distributions in pp collisions at TeV reported in Ref. 28 are used as the reference for QGP-induced effects reported here. Perturbative QCD calculations [19] were found to agree with the measurements in pp collisions within the experimental uncertainties, demonstrating good theoretical control of the observables.
Data were collected in 2018 from Pb–Pb collisions at a center-of-mass energy per nucleon–nucleon pair of TeV with the ALICE detector [2]. A detailed description of the detector and its performance can be found in Refs. 29 and 30. A trigger based on the charged-particle multiplicity in the forward region [31] was used to select events in the 0–10% centrality class [32, 33]. The events were required to have a reconstructed primary vertex within cm of the nominal interaction point in the longitudinal direction. Beam-induced background events were removed using two Zero Degree Calorimeters and pileup effects were removed by discarding events that contained multiple reconstructed vertices [4]. These selection criteria yield a data sample with 92 million events, corresponding to an integrated luminosity of nb.
Charged-particle tracks reconstructed in the Inner Tracking System (ITS) [34] and Time Projection Chamber (TPC) [35] used in the analysis were required to have a transverse momentum GeV/ and a pseudorapidity . For details, see the supplemental materials [36], including references [2, 5] therein. The detector performance was estimated by propagating simulated events through a GEANT 3 [37] model of the ALICE detector. The transverse-momentum resolution increases linearly from at GeV/ to at GeV/ [30]. The tracking efficiency rapidly increases from at GeV/ to at GeV/, and remains above at higher . The large uncorrelated background from the underlying event (UE) [38] in high-multiplicity heavy-ion collisions is subtracted before jet finding using the event-wide constituent subtraction procedure from Refs. 39 and 40. The parameters used are , , and (0.25) when the track sample is used to cluster jets of (0.4).
Tracks included in jet clustering are assigned the charged-pion mass. Charged-particle jets are clustered with the anti- algorithm, the recombination scheme, and resolution parameters and 0.4, using FastJet [41]. Jets containing a track with GeV/ and jets with their Standard axis not pointing inside the fiducial volume of the TPC () are discarded to minimize contamination by fake or partially reconstructed jets
The measured distributions are unfolded to correct for detector effects as well as residual UE fluctuations using an iterative Bayesian procedure [42, 43]. The procedure uses a 4D response matrix (RM) that captures the correspondence between and jet transverse momentum () at the generator and detector levels. The generator-level component of the RM is modeled using generated PYTHIA 8 [44] Monash 2013 [45] events. The detector-level component of the RM is modeled by propagating those events through a GEANT 3 [37] model of the ALICE detector and embedding the smeared events into measured Pb–Pb events.
Systematic uncertainties arise from the tracking inefficiency, unfolding procedure, unfolding model dependence, UE subtraction procedure, and residual effects from combinatorial jets. The tracking-inefficiency uncertainty is determined by repeating the analysis with an RM based on a track sample with 4% of all tracks randomly rejected. This number corresponds to the uncertainty in the tracking efficiency, determined by varying the track selection parameters and ITS–TPC matching criteria.
The unfolding-procedure uncertainty is determined by extending the lower and upper bounds of the spectrum by 5 GeV/, changing the detector-level binning, changing the number of unfolding iterations, and scaling the prior distribution. The four categories of variations are carried out individually and combined into an unfolding uncertainty using their standard deviation. The uncertainty from the model dependence in the unfolding is determined by repeating the analysis with response matrices based on different event generators including Herwig 7 [46] and JEWEL [47] with and without the inclusion of medium partons recoiling after interactions with the jet.
Potential bias introduced by the event-wide UE subtraction [39, 40] is quantified as the maximum difference between the nominal result and the results obtained by repeating the procedure with parameters (0.1), which lead to an under-subtraction, and (0.7), which lead to an over-subtraction of the background, for jets of (0.4). Deviations between the generator-level and unfolded distributions due to residual combinatorial jets are determined with a closure test. PYTHIA 8 events are embedded into background events with no jets and analyzed identically to the measured data. Deviations between the unfolded and PYTHIA 8 generator-level spectra are assigned as the uncertainty.
The systematic uncertainties are added in quadrature. The total systematic uncertainty is in the range of 2–61% depending on and . The large variation comes primarily from the background subtraction procedure at low (where background effects are largest). It is small at low values of , and smoothly grows in the tails of the distributions. The supplemental materials [36] provide details.
The measured distributions are normalized to the total number of jets in a given interval, , which is equivalent to reporting the self-normalized cross section:
This normalization choice causes the Pb–Pb/pp ratios to go above unity at low . In an absolute cross section measurement, the ratio would be below unity as a result of jet suppression in heavy-ion collisions. The suppression factor was measured in Ref. 48. Thus, only the shape and not the absolute scale of the spectra is reported.
The measured WTA–Standard distributions are shown in Figure 2 for jets in the ranges [40, 60] and [60,80] GeV/. The top panels show spectra from Pb–Pb and pp collisions. The vertical error bars represent the statistical uncertainties and the rectangles represent the total systematic uncertainties. The central and bottom panels show the Pb–Pb/pp ratio, with all uncertainties assumed uncorrelated and added in quadrature when calculating the ratio. The equivalent results for other ranges, jet resolution parameters, and grooming settings are included in the supplemental materials [36].
Figure 2. Top panels: fully corrected Pb–Pb and pp distributions in the intervals [40, 60] (left), and [60,80] (right) GeV/ for jets of . The pp baseline is taken from Ref. 28. Central and bottom panels: measured Pb–Pb/pp ratio in black, as well as predictions from a selection of jet quenching models.
The data are compared with several jet quenching models. These models have different implementations of the microscopic properties of the medium, its evolution, and the jet–medium interaction. The JEWEL event generator [47] models the medium with a boost-invariant longitudinally expanding ideal quark–gluon gas [49]. Parameters from Ref. 50, which are adequate for the kinematics of this measurement, are used. The medium partons recoiling after interacting with jet constituents can be discarded from the event (recoils off) or allowed to hadronize together with the jet (recoils on). “MATTER+LBT” is from the JETSCAPE event generator [51, 52], implementing an in-medium parton shower with interactions of high- (low-) virtuality partons with the medium described by the MATTER [53] (Linear Boltzmann Transport [54]) model. The curve labeled “medium q/g” corresponds to a phenomenological model in which the only difference between the Pb–Pb and pp results comes from a modification of the fraction of quarks and gluons that initiate the jets [55, 56], highlighting that these two jet populations lose energy differently in the medium. The “ broadening” calculation adds to the previous model a broadening caused by incoherent multiple scatterings with the medium partons [25] following the Baier-Dokshitzer-Mueller-Peigne-Schiff (BDMPS) approach [57, 58, 59]. This calculation uses a mean square momentum transfer coefficient between the jet and medium constituents GeV. “Hybrid” is from the hybrid model [60], which describes the weakly coupled jet showering process using the Dokshitzer-Gribov-Lipatov-Altarelli-Parisi (DGLAP) formalism and the strongly coupled interaction between the jet constituents and medium partons via holographic calculations of energy loss based on
AdS/CFT. The case corresponds to fully incoherent energy loss, where the medium is able to resolve the splitting immediately after the parton fragments, resulting in higher energy loss [26]. The case corresponds to fully coherent energy loss, where the medium is not able to resolve splittings, and the energy loss is lower. The intermediate case , where is the medium local temperature, is also included. All “Hybrid” curves include medium-response effects from Ref. 61.
Figure 2 shows that the distributions in Pb–Pb are narrower than those measured in pp collisions, as was also observed in Ref. [8]. The narrowing may be due to a selection bias, as jets selected using (rather than the initial momentum before the jet-medium interactions, which is not accessible experimentally) tend to come from the surface and lose little energy in the QGP [62]. The data are also consistent with a quark-enhanced mixture of jets surviving the interaction with the medium relative to the vacuum case. This is expected since gluon-initiated jets couple more strongly to partons of the QGP and thus lose more energy [8, 55, 63]. The MATTER+LBT model generally describes the data for all considered kinematical regions.
Figure 3 compares jet axis difference distributions for 100-140 GeV/ jets with and . We note that jets have significantly larger systematic uncertainty due to larger background corrections; the systematics partially cancel in the ratio for and . Consequently, model predictions are compared to this ratio. In contrast with , for larger there are significant differences in JEWEL predictions with and without recoils for jets. This is expected, as the medium response populates larger angles away from the Standard jet axis. The Hybrid model does not predict a significant effect on the jet axis from the medium response; see Ref. [36] for details. Comparison to other models in which the medium response can be turned on and off (e.g. the jet wake in Co-LBT [64, 65]) could help clarify the sensitivity of to the properties and magnitude of this effect. Narrowing of the distributions relative to those measured in pp collisions for jets of is qualitatively predicted by all models except for “ broadening”, which is calculated in a relatively simple formulation with a single value of . This tends to disagree with the hypothesis that intra-jet broadening manifests in the groomed radiation in previous measurements [8].
Figure 3. Top panels: fully corrected Pb–Pb (left), and with () (right) distributions in the interval GeV/. Central and bottom panels: measured Pb–Pb()/Pb–Pb() ratio in black, as well as predictions from a selection of jet quenching models.
The data are closest to incoherent energy loss of jets in the Hybrid model (); the fully coherent case () predicts significantly less narrowing. Incoherent energy loss better reproduces the data than the intermediate case of even though holographic calculations of the Debye screening length indicate that the intermediate case is closer to the true medium resolution scale [26].
The precision of the data at higher is limited by the integrated luminosity of the pp dataset, which only allows for an extraction of the Pb–Pb/pp results up to 100 GeV/. However, in heavy-ion collisions, larger can be studied through the ratio of ()/() spectra, where the systematic uncertainties partially cancel. This kinematic range is also important for future comparisons with results from other experiments. The ratio is reported as a function of the jet angular scale that, by construction, is independent of [19]. Figure 3 shows the ratio for GeV/ in ungroomed and groomed jets, together with theoretical predictions. The left side shows that the Standard-WTA jet axis difference is narrower (closer to zero) for than jets. This implies, perhaps surprisingly, that jets including more wide angle radiation have their standard jet axis closer to the WTA. In groomed jets, the jet axis is even more aligned with the WTA. It should be noted, however, that the grooming here uses , which means that there is no angular weight and any soft branch can be groomed away.
The ungroomed WTA–Standard result is challenging to models, as can be seen in Figure 3 (left). Grooming improves the agreement between the models and the data (see Figure 3 (right)), suggesting that the ungroomed result captures significantly more of the non-perturbative aspects of jet quenching. The ()/() ratio of WTA–Standard jet axis is not very sensitive to either with or without grooming. We have run PYTHIA8 MC to compare the ratios =0.2/=0.4 and we find that the WTA–Standard difference distribution does not change with the jet resolution parameter. In this, PYTHIA agrees with the measurement in PbPb.
Figure 4 shows an intermediate grooming setting for 100–140 GeV/ jets. One can see by comparing to with different grooming settings (Figure 4 vs. Figure 3 right) that once the softest branches are removed, further grooming does not substantially impact the jet axis. This was also seen in pp collisions, and shows that the Standard and SD axes are more aligned with each other than either of them is with the WTA axis. While the Standard axis is influenced by the soft wide-angle radiation present in R=0.4 jets, grooming away more of the soft radiation does not further change the SD axis. This shows that once the softest particles are groomed away, the jet axis is dominated by the hard radiation. The models generally reproduce the intermediate grooming result, with the exception of JEWEL with recoils off. Stronger grooming improves the agreement, though some tension with the data remains. This reflects the importance of including medium response when calculating jet substructure in Pb–Pb collisions. PYTHIA studies agree with the general trend, but do not quantitatively reproduce the ratios. Given the medium effects, this is not surprising.
Figure 4. Fully corrected WTA–SD () distributions in the GeV/ interval.
In summary, the first measurement of the angle between the WTA and Standard or Soft Drop groomed charged-particle jet axes in Pb–Pb collisions is reported. The measurement was carried out using the 0–10% most-central collisions at TeV with the ALICE detector and for ([80,140]) GeV/ for jets of (0.4).
Narrowing of the distribution relative to the vacuum case is found. The narrowing may be explained if the Pb–Pb distribution is dominated by quark-initiated jets, since gluon-initiated jets are expected to interact more with the medium. This is consistent with the prediction from the “medium q/g” model. A selection bias causing apparent narrowing of the jet core should be reflected in all of the models which include energy loss. However, the distributions for ungroomed jets are not equally well described by the models, suggesting that the fate of large angle prongs in the medium is important. The measurement disfavors intra-jet broadening, as implemented in Ref. 25 utilizing a single value of . The observable is sensitive to the medium resolution length, favoring incoherent energy loss of jets, where the medium resolves a splitting immediately after it happens, regardless of the angular separation between the prongs.
For jets of 100-140 GeV , R=0.4 jet axes are more aligned with the WTA axis than those with R=0.2. Grooming with enhances this alignment. While grooming decreases the effects of medium response, fully reproducing both groomed and ungroomed jet axis differences requires including medium response in the models. Future measurements of in photon- or Z-boson-tagged jets could provide a way to experimentally vary the fraction of quark- vs. gluon-initiated jets and explore the relationship of the WTA axis to the initial parton direction.
Acknowledgements
We gratefully acknowledge Felix Ringer, Daniel Pablos, and the JETSCAPE collaboration for providing theoretical predictions. We also acknowledge Xin-Nian Wang and Feng Yuan for fruitful discussions.
The ALICE Collaboration would like to thank all its engineers and technicians for their invaluable contributions to the construction of the experiment and the CERN accelerator teams for the outstanding performance of the LHC complex. The ALICE Collaboration gratefully acknowledges the resources and support provided by all Grid centres and the Worldwide LHC Computing Grid (WLCG) collaboration. The ALICE Collaboration acknowledges the following funding agencies for their support in building and running the ALICE detector: A. I. Alikhanyan National Science Laboratory (Yerevan Physics Institute) Foundation (ANSL), State Committee of Science and World Federation of Scientists (WFS), Armenia; Austrian Academy of Sciences, Austrian Science Fund (FWF): [M 2467-N36] and Nationalstiftung für Forschung, Technologie und Entwicklung, Austria; Ministry of Communications and High Technologies, National Nuclear Research Center, Azerbaijan; Rede Nacional de Física de Altas Energias (Renafae), Financiadora de Estudos e Projetos (Finep), Fundação de Amparo à Pesquisa do Estado de São Paulo (FAPESP) and Universidade Federal do Rio Grande do Sul (UFRGS), Brazil; Bulgarian Ministry of Education and Science, within the National Roadmap for Research Infrastructures 2020–2027 (object CERN), Bulgaria; Ministry of Education of China (MOEC) , Ministry of Science & Technology of China (MSTC) and National Natural Science Foundation of China (NSFC), China; Ministry of Science and Education and Croatian Science Foundation, Croatia; Centro de Aplicaciones Tecnológicas y Desarrollo Nuclear (CEADEN), Cubaenergía, Cuba; Ministry of Education, Youth and Sports of the Czech Republic, Czech Republic; The Danish Council for Independent Research | Natural Sciences, the VILLUM FONDEN and Danish National Research Foundation (DNRF), Denmark; Helsinki Institute of Physics (HIP), Finland; Commissariat à l’Energie Atomique (CEA) and Institut National de Physique Nucléaire et de Physique des Particules (IN2P3) and Centre National de la Recherche Scientifique (CNRS), France; Bundesministerium für Forschung, Technologie und Raumfahrt (BMFTR) and GSI Helmholtzzentrum für Schwerionenforschung GmbH, Germany; General Secretariat for Research and Technology, Ministry of Education, Research and Religions, Greece; National Research, Development and Innovation Office, Hungary; Department of Atomic Energy Government of India (DAE), Department of Science and Technology, Government of India (DST), University Grants Commission, Government of India (UGC) and Council of Scientific and Industrial Research (CSIR), India; National Research and Innovation Agency - BRIN, Indonesia; Istituto Nazionale di Fisica Nucleare (INFN), Italy; Japanese Ministry of Education, Culture, Sports, Science and Technology (MEXT) and Japan Society for the Promotion of Science (JSPS) KAKENHI, Japan; Consejo Nacional de Ciencia (CONACYT) y Tecnología, through Fondo de Cooperación Internacional en Ciencia y Tecnología (FONCICYT) and Dirección General de Asuntos del Personal Academico (DGAPA), Mexico; Nederlandse Organisatie voor Wetenschappelijk Onderzoek (NWO), Netherlands; The Research Council of Norway, Norway; Commission on Science and Technology for Sustainable Development in the South (COMSATS), Pakistan; Pontificia Universidad Católica del Perú, Peru; Ministry of Science and Higher Education, National Science Centre and WUT ID-UB, Poland; Korea Institute of Science and Technology Information and National Research Foundation of Korea (NRF), Republic of Korea; Ministry of Education and Scientific Research, Institute of Atomic Physics, Ministry of Research and Innovation and Institute of Atomic Physics and Universitatea Nationala de Stiinta si Tehnologie Politehnica Bucuresti, Romania; Ministerstvo skolstva, vyskumu, vyvoja a mladeze SR, Slovakia; National Research Foundation of South Africa, South Africa; Swedish Research Council (VR) and Knut & Alice Wallenberg Foundation (KAW), Sweden; European Organization for Nuclear Research, Switzerland; Suranaree University of Technology (SUT), National Science and Technology Development Agency (NSTDA) and National Science, Research and Innovation Fund (NSRF via PMU-B B05F650021), Thailand; Turkish Energy, Nuclear and Mineral Research Agency (TENMAK), Turkey; National Academy of Sciences of Ukraine, Ukraine; Science and Technology Facilities Council (STFC), United Kingdom; National Science Foundation of the United States of America (NSF) and United States Department of Energy, Office of Nuclear Physics (DOE NP), United States of America. In addition, individual groups or members have received support from: Czech Science Foundation (grant no. 23-07499S), Czech Republic; European Research Council (grant nos. 950692), European Union; Strong 2020 - Horizon 2020 (grant nos. 824093), European Union; ICSC - Centro Nazionale di Ricerca in High Performance Computing, Big Data and Quantum Computing, European Union - NextGenerationEU; Academy of Finland (Center of Excellence in Quark Matter) (grant nos. 346327, 346328), Finland; Deutsche Forschungsgemeinschaft (DFG, German Research Foundation) “Neutrinos and Dark Matter in Astro- and Particle Physics” (grant no. SFB 1258), Germany; Programa de Apoyos para la Superación del Personal Académico, UNAM, Mexico.
Data availability statement
This manuscript has associated data in the HEPData repository [66].
The ALICE Collaboration
S. Acharya , D. Adamová , A. Adler, G. Aglieri Rinella , M. Agnello , N. Agrawal , Z. Ahammed , S. Ahmad , S.U. Ahn , I. Ahuja , A. Akindinov , M. Al-Turany , D. Aleksandrov , S. Alessandro , H.M. Alfanda , R. Alfaro Molina , B. Ali , A. Alici , N. Alizadehvandchali , A. Alkin , J. Alme , G. Alocco , T. Alt , I. Altsybeev , J.R. Alvarado , M.N. Anaam , C. Andrei , A. Andronic , V. Anguelov , F. Antinori , P. Antonioli , N. Apadula , L. Aphecetche , H. Appelshäuser , C. Arata , S. Arcelli , M. Aresti , R. Arnaldi , J.G.M.C.A. Arneiro , I.C. Arsene , M. Arslandok , A. Augustinus , R. Averbeck , M.D. Azmi , A. Badalà , J. Bae , Y.W. Baek , X. Bai , R. Bailhache , Y. Bailung , A. Balbino , A. Baldisseri , B. Balis , D. Banerjee , Z. Banoo , R. Barbera , F. Barile , L. Barioglio , M. Barlou , G.G. Barnaföldi , L.S. Barnby , V. Barret , L. Barreto , C. Bartels , K. Barth , E. Bartsch , N. Bastid , S. Basu , G. Batigne , D. Battistini , B. Batyunya , D. Bauri , J.L. Bazo Alba , I.G. Bearden , C. Beattie , P. Becht , D. Behera , I. Belikov , A.D.C. Bell Hechavarria , F. Bellini , R. Bellwied , S. Belokurova , G. Bencedi , S. Beole , Y. Berdnikov , A. Berdnikova , L. Bergmann , M.G. Besoiu , L. Betev , P.P. Bhaduri , A. Bhasin , M.A. Bhat , B. Bhattacharjee , L. Bianchi , N. Bianchi , J. Bielčík , J. Bielčíková , J. Biernat , A.P. Bigot , A. Bilandzic , G. Biro , S. Biswas , N. Bize , J.T. Blair , D. Blau , M.B. Blidaru , N. Bluhme , C. Blume , G. Boca , F. Bock , T. Bodova , A. Bogdanov , S. Boi , J. Bok , L. Boldizsár , M. Bombara , P.M. Bond , G. Bonomi , H. Borel , A. Borissov , A.G. Borquez Carcamo , H. Bossi , E. Botta , Y.E.M. Bouziani , L. Bratrud , P. Braun-Munzinger , M. Bregant , M. Broz , G.E. Bruno , M.D. Buckland , D. Budnikov , H. Buesching , S. Bufalino , P. Buhler , Z. Buthelezi , A. Bylinkin , S.A. Bysiak , M. Cai , H. Caines , A. Caliva , E. Calvo Villar , J.M.M. Camacho , P. Camerini , F.D.M. Canedo , S.L. Cantway , M. Carabas , A.A. Carballo , F. Carnesecchi , R. Caron , L.A.D. Carvalho , J. Castillo Castellanos , F. Catalano , C. Ceballos Sanchez , I. Chakaberia , P. Chakraborty , S. Chandra , S. Chapeland , M. Chartier , S. Chattopadhyay , S. Chattopadhyay , T. Cheng , C. Cheshkov , B. Cheynis , V. Chibante Barroso , D.D. Chinellato , E.S. Chizzali , J. Cho , S. Cho , P. Chochula , S. Choudhury , P. Christakoglou , C.H. Christensen , P. Christiansen , T. Chujo , C. Ciaccio , C. Cicalo , F. Cindolo , M.R. Ciupek , G. Clai, F. Colamaria , J.S. Colburn , D. Colella , M. Colocci , M. Concas , G. Conesa Balbastre , Z. Conesa del Valle , G. Contin , J.G. Contreras , M.L. Coquet , T.M. Cormier , P. Cortese , M.R. Cosentino , F. Costa , S. Costanza , C. Cot , J. Crkovská , P. Crochet , R. Cruz-Torres , P. Cui , A. Dainese , M.C. Danisch , A. Danu , P. Das , P. Das , S. Das , A.R. Dash , S. Dash , A. De Caro , G. De Cataldo , J. De Cuveland , A. De Falco , D. De Gruttola , N. De Marco , C. De Martin , S. De Pasquale , R. Deb , S. Deb , K.R. Deja , R. Del Grande , L. Dello Stritto , W. Deng , P. Dhankher , D. Di Bari , A. Di Mauro , B. Diab , R.A. Diaz , T. Dietel , Y. Ding , R. Divia , D.U. Dixit , Ø. Djuvsland , U. Dmitrieva , A. Dobrin , B. Donigus , J.M. Dubinski , A. Dubla , S. Dudi , P. Dupieux , M. Durack , N. Dzalalova , T.M. Eder , R.J. Ehlers , F. Eisenhut , D. Elia , B. Erazmus , F. Ercolessi , F. Erhardt , M.R. Ersdal , B. Espagnon , G. Eulisse , D. Evans , S. Evdokimov , L. Fabbietti , M. Faggins , J. Faivre , F. Fan , W. Fan , T. Fang , A. Fantoni , M. Fasel , P. Fecchio , A. Feliciello , G. Feofilov , A. Fernández Téllez , L. Ferrandi , M.B. Ferrer , A. Ferrero , C. Ferrero , A. Ferretti , V.J.G. Feuillard , D. Finogeev , F.M. Fionda , F. Flor , A.N. Flores , S. Foertsch , I. Fokin , S. Fokin , E. Fragiacomo , E. Frajna , U. Fuchs , N. Funicello , C. Furget , A. Furs , T. Fusayasu , J.J. Gaardhøje , M. Gagliardi , A.M. Gago , C.D. Galvan , D.R. Gandhaian , P. Ganoti , C. Garabatos , T. García Chávez , E. Garcia-Solis , C. Gargiulo , K. Garner , P. Gasik , A. Gautam , M.B. Gay Ducat , M. Germain , A. Ghimouz , C. Ghosh , M. Giacalone , P. Giubellino , P. Giubilato , A.M.C. Glaenzer , P. Glässel , E. Glimos , D.J.Q. Goh , V. Gonzalez , M. Gordon , K. Goswami , S. Gotovac , V. Grabsky , L.K. Graczykowski , E. Grecka , A. Grelli , C. Grigoros , V. Grigoriev , S. Grigoriyan , F. Grosа , J.F. Grosse-Oetringhaus , R. Grosso , D. Grund , G.G. Guardiano , R. Guernane , M. Guilbaud , K. Gulbrandsen , T. Gündem , T. Gunji , W. Guo , A. Gupta , R. Gupta R. Gupta 48, K. Gwizdziel 135, L. Gyulai 46, M.K. Habib98, C. Hadjidakis 130, F.U. Haider92, H. Hamagaki 77, A. Hamdi 74, M. Hamid6, Y. Han 138, B.G. Hanley 136, R. Hannigan 108, J. Hansen 75, M.R. Haque 135, J.W. Harris 137, A. Harton 9, H. Hassan 88, D. Hatzifotiadou 51, P. Hauer 42, L.B. Havener 137, S.T. Heckel 96, E. Hellbär 98, H. Helstrup 37, M. Hemmer 64, T. Herman 34, G. Herrera Corral 8, F. Herrmann125, S. Herrmann 127, K.F. Hetland 37, B. Heybeck 64, H. Hillemanns 32, B. Hippolyte 128, F.W. Hoffmann 70, B. Hofman 59, B. Hohlweger 85, G.H. Hong 138, A. Horzyk 2 Y. Hou 6, P. Hristov 32, C. Hughes 121, P. Huhn64, L.M. Huhta 116, T.J. Humanic 89, V. Humlova 34, A. Hutson 115, D. Hutter 38, R. Ilkaev140, H. Ilyas 13, M. Inaba 124, G.M. Innocenti 32, M. Ippolitov 140, A. Isakov 87, T. Isidori 117, M.S. Islam 100, M. Ivanov12, M. Ivanov 98, V. Ivanov 140, K.E. Iversen 75, M. Jablonski 2, B. Jacak 74, N. Jacazio 25, P.M. Jacobs 74, S. Jadlovska106, J. Jadlovsky106, S. Jaelani 83, C. Jahnke 111, M.J. Jakubowska 135, D.M. Janik 34, M.A. Janik 135, T. Janson70, M. Jercic90, S. Ji 16 S. Jia 10, A.A.P. Jimenez 65, F. Jonas 88,125, J.M. Jowett 32,98, J. Jung 64, M. Jung 64, A. Junique 32, A. Jusko 101, J. Kaewjai105, P. Kalinak 60, A.S. Kalteyer 98, A. Kalweit 32, V. Kaplin 140, A. Karasu Uysal 72, D. Karatovic 90, O. Karavichev 140, T. Karavicheva 140, P. Karczmarczyk 135, E. Karpechev 140, M. Karwowska 32,135, U. Kebschull 70, R. Keidel 139, D.L.D. Keijdener59, M. Keil 32, B. Ketzer 42, S.S. Khade 48, A.M. Khan 119,6, S. Khan 15, A. Khanzadeev 140, Y. Kharlov 140, A. Khatun 117, A. Khuntia 107, M.B. Kidson114, B. Kileng 37, B. Kim 104, C. Kim 16, D.J. Kim 116, E.J. Kim 69, J. Kim 138, J.S. Kim 40, J. Kim 58, J. Kim 69, M. Kim 18, S. Kim 17 T. Kim 138, K. Kimura 93, O.A.M. Kirjamäki 43, S. Kirsch 64, I. Kisel 38, S. Kiselev 140, A. Kisiel 135, J.P. Kitowski 2, J.L. Klay 5, J. Klein 32, S. Klein 74, C. Klein-Bösing 125, M. Kleiner 64, T. Klemenz 96, A. Kluge 32, A.G. KnospeV,115, C. Kobdaj 105, T. Kollegger98, A. Kondratyev 141, N. Kondratyeva 140, E. Kondratyuk 140, J. Konig 64, S.A. Konigstorfer 96, P.J. Konopka 32, G. Kornakov 135, M. Korwieser 96, S.D. Koryciak 2, A. Kotliarov 87, V. Kovalenko 140, M. Kowalski 107, V. Kozhuharov 35, I. Králik 60, A. Kravčáková36, L. Krcal 32,38, M. Krivda 101,60, F. Krizek 87, K. Krizkova Gajdosova 32, M. Kroesen 95, M. Krüger 64, E. Kryshen 140, V. Kucera58, C. Kuhn 128, P.G. Kuijer 1,85, T. Kumaoka124, D. Kumar 134, L. Kumar 91, N. Kumar 91, S. Kumar 31, S. Kundu 32, P. Kurashvili 80, A. Kurepin 140, A.B. Kurepin 140, A. Kuryakin 140, S. Kushpil 87, J. Kvapil 101, M.J. Kweon 8, Y. Kwon 8, S.L. La Pointe 1, P. La Rocca 26, A. Lakrathok 80, M. Lamanna 32, A.R. Lando 73, R. Langoy 120, P. Larionov 132, E. Laudi 32, L. Lautner 32,96, R. Lavicka 76, R. Lea 133,55, H. Lee 104, I. Legrand 45, G. Legras 125, J. Lehrbach 38, T.M. Lelek 2, R.C. Lemmon 1,86, I. León Monzón 109, M.M. Lesch 96, E.D. Lesser 18, P. Lévai 46, X. Li10, X.L. Li6, J. Lien 120, R. Lietava 101, I. Likmeta 115, B. Lim 24, S.H. Lim 16, V. Lindenstruth 38, A. Lindner45, C. Lippmann 98, A. Liu 18, D.H. Liu 6, J. Liu 118, G.S.S. Liveraro 61, I.M. Lofnes 20, C. Loizides 88, S. Lokos 107, J. Łomkor 59, P. Loncar 33, J.A. Lopez 95, X. Lopez 126, E. López Torres 7, P. Lopez 98,119, J.R. Luhder 125, M. Lunardon 27, G. Luparello 57, Y.G. Ma 39, M. Mager 32, M. Mahlein 96, A. Maire 128, M.V. Makariev 35, M. Malaev 140, G. Malfattore 25, N.M. Malik 92, Q.W. Malik19, S.K. Malik 92, L. Malinina 6,81, D. Mallick 81, N. Mallick 48, G. Mandaglio 50,53, S.K. Mandal 1, V. Manko 140, F. Manso 126, V. Manzari 50, Y. Mao 6, R.W. Marcian 2, G.V. Margagliotti 23, A. Margotti 51, A. Marín 98, C. Markert 108, P. Martinengo 32, M.I. Martínez 44, G. Martínez García 103, M.P.P. Martins 110, S. Masciocchi 98, M. Masera 24, A. Masoni 52, L. Massacrier 130, A. Mastroserio 131,50, O. Matonoha 75, S. Mattiazzo 27, P.F.T. Matuoka110, A. Matyja 107, C. Mayer 107, A.L. Mazuecos 32, F. Mazzaschi 24, M. Mazzilli 32, J.E. Mdhuli 122, A.F. Mechler 43,140, Y. Melikyan 67, A. Menchaca-Rocha 67, E. Meninno 76, A.S. Menon 115, M. Meres 12, S. Mhlanga 114,68, Y. Miake 124, L. Micheletti 32, L.C. Migliorin 127, D.L. Mihaylov 96, K. Mikhaylov 141,140, A.N. Mishra 46, D. Miśkowiec 98, A. Modak 4, A.P. Mohanty 59, B. Mohanty 81, M. Mohisin Khan VI,15, M.A. Molander 43, Z. Moravcova 84, C. Mordasini 96, D.A. Moreira De Godoy 125, I. Morozov 140, A. Morsch 32, M. Mrnjavac 32, V. Muccifora 49, S. Muhuri 6, J.D. Mulligan 74, A. Mulliri 22, M.G. Munhoz 110, R.H. Munzer 64, H. Murakami 123, S. Murray 114, L. Musa 32, J. Musinsky 60, J.W. Myrcha 135, B. Naik 122, A.I. Nambrath 18, B.K. Nandi 47, R. Nania 51, E. Nappi 50, A.F. Nassirpour 17,75, A. Nath 95, C. Nattrass 121, M.N. Naydenov 35, A. Neagu19, A. Negru113, L. Nellen 65, G. Neskovic 8, N. Nicassio 31, B.S. Nielsen 84, E.G. Nielsen 60, S. Nikolaev 140, S. Nikulin 140, V. Nikulin 140, F. Noferini 51, S. Noh 11, P. Nomokonov 141, J. Norman 118, N. Novitzky 124, P. Nowakowski 135, A. Nyanin 140, J. Nystrand 20, M. Ogino 77, A. Ohlson 75, V.A. Okorokov 140, J. Oleniacz 135, A.C. Oliveira Da Silva 121, M.H. Oliver 137, A. Onnerstad 116, C. Oppedisano 56, A. Ortiz Velasquez 65, J. Otwinowski 107, M. Oya3, K. Oyama 77, Y. Pachmayer 95, S. Padhan 47, D. Pagano 133,55, G. Paić 65, S. Paisano-Guzmán 44, A. Palasciano 50, S. Panebianco 129 H. Park124, H. Park104, J. Park58, J.E. Parkkila32, R.N. Patra92, B. Paul22, H. Pei6, T. Peitzmann59, X. Peng6, M. Pennisi24, D. Peresunko140, G.M. Perez7, S. Perrin129, Y. Pestov140, V. Petrov140, M. Petrovici45, R.P. Pezzi103,66, S. Piano57, M. Pikna12, P. Pillot103, O. Pinazza51,32, L. Pinsky115, C. Pinto96, S. Pisano49, M. Płoskoń74, M. Planinic90, F. Pliquett64, M.G. Poghosyan88, B. Polichtchouk140, S. Politano29, N. Poljak90, A. Pop45, S. Porteboeuf-Houssais126, V. PozdniakovI,141, I.Y. Pozos44, K.K. Pradhan48, S.K. Prasad4, S. Prasad48, R. Preghenella51, F. Prino56, C.A. Pruneau136, I. Pshenichnov140, M. Puccio32, S. Pucillo24, Z. Pugelova106, S. Qiu85, L. Quaglia24, R.E. Quishpe115, S. Ragoni14, A. Rakotozafindrabe129, L. Ramello132,56, F. Rami128, T.A. Rancien73, M. Rasa26, S.S. Räsänen43, R. Rath51, M.P. Rauch20, I. Ravasenga85, K.F. Read88,121, C. Reckziegel112, A.R. Redelbach38, K. RedlichVII,80, C.A. Reetz98, H.D. Regules-Medel44, A. Rehman20, F. Reidt32, H.A. Reme-Ness37, Z. Rescakova36, K. Reygers95, A. Riabov140, V. Riabov140, R. Ricci28, M. Richter19, A.A. Riedel96, W. Riegler32, C. Ristea63, M.V. Rodriguez32, M. Rodríguez Cahuantzi44, S.A. Rodríguez Ramírez44, K. Røed19, R. Rogalev140, E. Rogochaya141, T.S. Rogoschinski64, D. Rohr32, D. Röhrich20, P.F. Rojas44, S. Rojas Torres34, P.S. Rokita135, G. Romanenko141, F. Ronchetti49, A. Rosano30,53, E.D. Rosas65, K. Roslon135, A. Rossi54, A. Roy48, S. Roy47, N. Rubini25, D. Ruggiano135, R. Rui23, P.G. Russek2, R. Russo85, A. Rustamov82, E. Ryabinkin140, Y. Ryabov140, A. Rybicki107, H. Rytkonen116, J. Ryu16, W. Rzesa135, R. Sadek103, S. Sadhu31, S. Sadovsky140, J. Saetre20, K. ŠafaříkI,34, P. Saha41, S.K. Saha4, S. Saha81, B. Sahoo47, B. Sahoo48, R. Sahoo48, S. Sahoo61, D. Sahu48, P.K. Sahu61, J. Saini134, K. Sajdakova36, S. Sakai124, M.P. Salvan98, S. Sambyal92, I. Sanna32,96, T.B. Saramela110, D. Sarkar136, N. Sarkar134, P. Sarma41, V. Sarritzu22, V.M. Sarti96, M.H.P. Sas137, J. Schambach88, H.S. Scheid64, C. Schiaua45, R. Schicker95, A. Schmah95, C. Schmidt98, H.R. Schmidt94, M.O. Schmidt32, M. Schmidt94, N.V. Schmidt88, A.R. Schmier121, R. Schotter128, A. Schröter38, J. Schukraft32, K. Schwarz98, K. Schweda98, G. Scioli25, E. Scomparin56, J.E. Seger14, Y. Sekiguchi123, D. Sekihata123, I. Selyuzhenkov98, S. Senyukov128, J.J. Seo58, D. Serebryakov140, L. Šerkšnytė96, A. Sevcenko63, T.J. Shaba68, A. Shabetai103, R. Shahoyan32, A. Shangaraev140, A. Sharma91, B. Sharma92, D. Sharma91, H. Sharma5, M. Sharma92, S. Sharma77, S. Sharma92, U. Sharma92, A. Shatat130, O. Shebani115, K. Shigaki93, M. Shimomura78, J. Shin11, S. Shirinkin140, Q. Shou39, Y. Sibiriak140, S. Siddhanta52, T. Siemiarczuk80, T.F. Silva110, D. Silvermyr75, T. Simantathammakul105, R. Simeonov35, B. Singh92, B. Singh96, K. Singh48, R. Singh81, R. Singh92, R. Singh48, S. Singh15, V.K. Singh134, V. Singhal134, T. Sinha100, B. Sitar12, M. Sitta132,56, T.B. Skaali19, G. Skorodumovs95, M. Slupecki43, N. Smirnov137, R.J.M. Snellings59, E.H. Solheim19, J. Song115,16, A. Somnackoolnak105, C. Sonnabend32,98, F. Soramel27, A.B. Soto-Hernandez89, R. Spijkers85, I. Sputowska107, J. Staa75, J. Stachel95, I. Stan63, P.J. Steffanic121, S.F. Stiefelmaier95, D. Stocco103, I. Storehaug19, P. Stratmann125, S. Strazzi25, C.P. Stylianidis85, A.A.P. Suaide10, C. Suire130, M. Sukhanov140, M. Suljic32, R. Sultanov140, V. Sumbera92, S. Sumowidagdo83, S. Surian61, I. Szarka12, M. Szymkowski135, S.F. Taghavi96, G. Taillipied98, J. Takahashi111, G.J. Tambave81, S. Tang6, Z. Tang119, J.D. Tapia Takaki117, N. Tapus113, L.A. Tarasovicova125, M.G. Tarzila45, G.F. Tassielli31, A. Tauro32, G. Tejeda Muñoz44, A. Telesca32, L. Terlizzi24, C. Terrevoli115, S. Thakur4, D. Thomas108, A. Tikhonov140, A.R. Timmins115, M. TkacikT, T. TkacikC, A. Toia64, R. Tokumoto9, N. Topilskaya140, M. Toppi49, T. Tork130, A.G. Torres Ramos31, A.S. Triolo30,53, S. Tripathy51, T. Tripathy47, S. Trogolo32, V. Trubnikov3, W.H. Trzaska116, T.P. Trzcinski135, A. Tumkin140, R. Turrisi54, T.S. Tveter19, K. Ullaland20, B. Ulukutlu96, A. Uras127, M. Urioni55,133, G.L. Usai22, M. Vala36, N. Valle52, L.V.R. van Doremalen59, M. van Leeuwen85, C.A. van Velden95, R.J.G. van Weelden85, P. Vande Vyvre115, D. Varga46, Z. Varga46, M. Vasilaeou79, A. VasileiouI,140, O. Vázquez Doce49, O. Vazquez Rueda115, V. Vechernin140, E. Vercelelin24, S. Vergara Limón44, L. Vermunt98, R. Vértési46, M. Verweij59, L. Vickovic33, Z. Vilakazi122, O. Villalobos Baillie101, A. Villani23, G. Vino50, A. Vinogradov140, T. Virgili28, M.M.O. Virta116, V. Vislavičius75, A. Vodopyanov9, B. Völker3, M.A. Völkl140, K. Voloshin45, S.A. Voloshin90, G. Volpe31, B. von Haller32, I. Vorobyev96, N. Vozniuk140, J. Vláčková36, J. Wan39, C. Wang39, D. Wang39, Y. Wang39, A. Wegrzynek32, F. Weighofer38, S.C. Wenzel32, J.P. Wessels125, J. Wiechula64, J. Wikne19, G. Wilk80, J. Wilkinson98, G.A. Willems125, B. Windelband95, M. Winn129, J.R. Wright108, W. Wu39, Y. Wu119, L. Xu6, R. Xu6, A. Yadav2, A.K. Yadav134, S. Yalcin72, Y. Yamaguchi93, S. Yang20, S. Yano9, Z. Yin6, I.-K. Yoo16, J.H. Yoon58, H. Yu11, S. Yuan20, A. Yuncu95, V. Zaccolo23, C. Zampolli32, F. Zanone95, N. Zardoshti32, A. Zarochentsev140, P. Závada62, N. Zaviyalov140, M. Zhalov140, B. Zhang6, L. Zhang39, M. Zhang6, S. Zhang39, X. Zhang6, Y. Zhang119, Z. Zhang6, M. Zhao10, V. Zherebchevskii140, Y. Zhi10, D. Zhou6, Y. Zhou84, J. Zhu98,6, Y. Zhu6, S.C. Zugravel56, N. Zurlo133,55
Affiliation Notes
I Deceased
II Also at: Max-Planck-Institut fur Physik, Munich, Germany
III Also at: Italian National Agency for New Technologies, Energy and Sustainable Economic Development (ENEA), Bologna, Italy
IV Also at: Dipartimento DET del Politecnico di Torino, Turin, Italy
V Also at: Lehigh University, United States
VI Also at: Department of Applied Physics, Aligarh Muslim University, Aligarh, India
VII Also at: Institute of Theoretical Physics, University of Wroclaw, Poland
Collaboration Institutes
1 A.I. Alikhanyan National Science Laboratory (Yerevan Physics Institute) Foundation, Yerevan, Armenia
2 AGH University of Krakow, Cracow, Poland
3 Bogolyubov Institute for Theoretical Physics, National Academy of Sciences of Ukraine, Kyiv, Ukraine
4 Bose Institute, Department of Physics and Centre for Astroparticle Physics and Space Science (CAPSS), Kolkata, India
5 California Polytechnic State University, San Luis Obispo, California, United States
6 Central China Normal University, Wuhan, China
7 Centro de Aplicaciones Tecnológicas y Desarrollo Nuclear (CEADEN), Havana, Cuba
8 Centro de Investigación y de Estudios Avanzados (CINVESTAV), Mexico City and Mérida, Mexico
9 Chicago State University, Chicago, Illinois, United States
10 China Nuclear Data Center, China Institute of Atomic Energy, Beijing, China
11 Chungbuk National University, Cheongju, Republic of Korea
12 Comenius University Bratislava, Faculty of Mathematics, Physics and Informatics, Bratislava, Slovak Republic
13 COMSATS University Islamabad, Islamabad, Pakistan
14 Creighton University, Omaha, Nebraska, United States
15 Department of Physics, Aligarh Muslim University, Aligarh, India
16 Department of Physics, Pusan National University, Pusan, Republic of Korea
17 Department of Physics, Sejong University, Seoul, Republic of Korea
18 Department of Physics, University of California, Berkeley, California, United States
19 Department of Physics, University of Oslo, Oslo, Norway
20 Department of Physics and Technology, University of Bergen, Bergen, Norway
21 Dipartimento di Fisica, Università di Pavia, Pavia, Italy
22 Dipartimento di Fisica dell’Università and Sezione INFN, Cagliari, Italy
23 Dipartimento di Fisica dell’Università and Sezione INFN, Trieste, Italy
24 Dipartimento di Fisica dell’Università and Sezione INFN, Turin, Italy
25 Dipartimento di Fisica e Astronomia dell’Università and Sezione INFN, Bologna, Italy
26 Dipartimento di Fisica e Astronomia dell’Università and Sezione INFN, Catania, Italy
27 Dipartimento di Fisica e Astronomia dell’Università and Sezione INFN, Padova, Italy
28 Dipartimento di Fisica ‘E.R. Caianiello’ dell’Università and Gruppo Collegato INFN, Salerno, Italy
29 Dipartimento DISAT del Politecnico and Sezione INFN, Turin, Italy
30 Dipartimento di Scienze MIFT, Università di Messina, Messina, Italy
31 Dipartimento Interateneo di Fisica ‘M. Merlin’ and Sezione INFN, Bari, Italy
32 European Organization for Nuclear Research (CERN), Geneva, Switzerland
33 Faculty of Electrical Engineering, Mechanical Engineering and Naval Architecture, University of Split, Split, Croatia
34 Faculty of Nuclear Sciences and Physical Engineering, Czech Technical University in Prague, Prague, Czech Republic
35 Faculty of Physics, Sofia University, Sofia, Bulgaria 36 Faculty of Science, P.J. Šafárik University, Košice, Slovak Republic
37 Faculty of Technology, Environmental and Social Sciences, Bergen, Norway
38 Frankfurt Institute for Advanced Studies, Johann Wolfgang Goethe-Universität Frankfurt, Frankfurt, Germany
39 Fudan University, Shanghai, China
40 Gangneung-Wonju National University, Gangneung, Republic of Korea
41 Gauhati University, Department of Physics, Guwahati, India
42 Helmholtz-Institut für Strahlen- und Kernphysik, Rheinische Friedrich-Wilhelms-Universität Bonn, Bonn, Germany
43 Helsinki Institute of Physics (HIP), Helsinki, Finland
44 High Energy Physics Group, Universidad Autónoma de Puebla, Puebla, Mexico
45 Horia Hulubei National Institute of Physics and Nuclear Engineering, Bucharest, Romania
46 HUN-REN Wigner Research Centre for Physics, Budapest, Hungary
47 Indian Institute of Technology Bombay (IIT), Mumbai, India
48 Indian Institute of Technology Indore, Indore, India
49 INFN, Laboratori Nazionali di Frascati, Frascati, Italy
50 INFN, Sezione di Bari, Bari, Italy
51 INFN, Sezione di Bologna, Bologna, Italy
52 INFN, Sezione di Cagliari, Cagliari, Italy
53 INFN, Sezione di Catania, Catania, Italy
54 INFN, Sezione di Padova, Padova, Italy
55 INFN, Sezione di Pavia, Pavia, Italy
56 INFN, Sezione di Torino, Turin, Italy
57 INFN, Sezione di Trieste, Trieste, Italy
58 Inha University, Incheon, Republic of Korea
59 Institute for Gravitational and Subatomic Physics (GRASP), Utrecht University/Nikhef, Utrecht, Netherlands
60 Institute of Experimental Physics, Slovak Academy of Sciences, Košice, Slovak Republic
61 Institute of Physics, Homi Bhabha National Institute, Bhubaneswar, India
62 Institute of Physics of the Czech Academy of Sciences, Prague, Czech Republic
63 Institute of Space Science (ISS), Bucharest, Romania
64 Institut für Kernphysik, Johann Wolfgang Goethe-Universität Frankfurt, Frankfurt, Germany
65 Instituto de Ciencias Nucleares, Universidad Nacional Autónoma de México, Mexico City, Mexico
66 Instituto de Física, Universidade Federal do Rio Grande do Sul (UFRGS), Porto Alegre, Brazil
67 Instituto de Física, Universidad Nacional Autónoma de México, Mexico City, Mexico
68 iThemba LABS, National Research Foundation, Somerset West, South Africa
69 Jeonbuk National University, Jeonju, Republic of Korea
70 Johann-Wolfgang-Goethe Universität Frankfurt Institut für Informatik, Fachbereich Informatik und Mathematik, Frankfurt, Germany
71 Korea Institute of Science and Technology Information, Daejeon, Republic of Korea
72 KTO Karatay University, Konya, Turkey
73 Laboratoire de Physique Subatomique et de Cosmologie, Université Grenoble-Alpes, CNRS-IN2P3, Grenoble, France
74 Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory, Berkeley, California, United States
75 Lund University Department of Physics, Division of Particle Physics, Lund, Sweden
76 Marietta Blau Institute, Vienna, Austria
77 Nagasaki Institute of Applied Science, Nagasaki, Japan
78 Nara Women’s University (NWU), Nara, Japan
79 National and Kapodistrian University of Athens, School of Science, Department of Physics , Athens, Greece
80 National Centre for Nuclear Research, Warsaw, Poland
81 National Institute of Science Education and Research, Homi Bhabha National Institute, Jatni, India
82 National Nuclear Research Center, Baku, Azerbaijan
83 National Research and Innovation Agency - BRIN, Jakarta, Indonesia
84 Niels Bohr Institute, University of Copenhagen, Copenhagen, Denmark
85 Nikhef, National institute for subatomic physics, Amsterdam, Netherlands
86 Nuclear Physics Group, STFC Daresbury Laboratory, Daresbury, United Kingdom
87 Nuclear Physics Institute of the Czech Academy of Sciences, Husinec-Řež, Czech Republic
88 Oak Ridge National Laboratory, Oak Ridge, Tennessee, United States 89 Ohio State University, Columbus, Ohio, United States
90 Physics department, Faculty of science, University of Zagreb, Zagreb, Croatia
91 Physics Department, Panjab University, Chandigarh, India
92 Physics Department, University of Jammu, Jammu, India
93 Physics Program and International Institute for Sustainability with Knotted Chiral Meta Matter (WPI-SKCM²), Hiroshima University, Hiroshima, Japan
94 Physikalisches Institut, Eberhard-Karls-Universität Tübingen, Tübingen, Germany
95 Physikalisches Institut, Ruprecht-Karls-Universität Heidelberg, Heidelberg, Germany
96 Physik Department, Technische Universität München, Munich, Germany
97 Politecnico di Bari and Sezione INFN, Bari, Italy
98 Research Division and ExtreMe Matter Institute EMMI, GSI Helmholtzzentrum für Schwerionenforschung GmbH, Darmstadt, Germany
99 Saga University, Saga, Japan
100 Saha Institute of Nuclear Physics, Homi Bhabha National Institute, Kolkata, India
101 School of Physics and Astronomy, University of Birmingham, Birmingham, United Kingdom
102 Sección Física, Departamento de Ciencias, Pontificia Universidad Católica del Perú, Lima, Peru
103 SUBATECH, IMT Atlantique, Nantes Université, CNRS-IN2P3, Nantes, France
104 Sungkyunkwan University, Suwon City, Republic of Korea
105 Suranaree University of Technology, Nakhon Ratchasima, Thailand
106 Technical University of Košice, Košice, Slovak Republic
107 The Henryk Niewodniczanski Institute of Nuclear Physics, Polish Academy of Sciences, Cracow, Poland
108 The University of Texas at Austin, Austin, Texas, United States
109 Universidad Autónoma de Sinaloa, Culiacán, Mexico
110 Universidade de São Paulo (USP), São Paulo, Brazil
111 Universidade Estadual de Campinas (UNICAMP), Campinas, Brazil
112 Universidade Federal do ABC, Santo Andre, Brazil
113 Universitatea Nationala de Stiinta si Tehnologie Politehnica Bucuresti, Bucharest, Romania
114 University of Cape Town, Cape Town, South Africa
115 University of Houston, Houston, Texas, United States
116 University of Jyväskylä, Jyväskylä, Finland
117 University of Kansas, Lawrence, Kansas, United States
118 University of Liverpool, Liverpool, United Kingdom
119 University of Science and Technology of China, Hefei, China
120 University of South-Eastern Norway, Kongsberg, Norway
121 University of Tennessee, Knoxville, Tennessee, United States
122 University of the Witwatersrand, Johannesburg, South Africa
123 University of Tokyo, Tokyo, Japan
124 University of Tsukuba, Tsukuba, Japan
125 Universität Münster, Institut für Kernphysik, Münster, Germany
126 Université Clermont Auvergne, CNRS/IN2P3, LPC, Clermont-Ferrand, France
127 Université de Lyon, CNRS/IN2P3, Institut de Physique des 2 Infinis de Lyon, Lyon, France
128 Université de Strasbourg, CNRS, IPHC UMR 7178, F-67000 Strasbourg, France, Strasbourg, France
129 Université Paris-Saclay, Centre d’Etudes de Saclay (CEA), IRFU, Département de Physique Nucléaire (DPhN), Saclay, France
130 Université Paris-Saclay, CNRS/IN2P3, IJCLab, Orsay, France
131 Università degli Studi di Foggia, Foggia, Italy
132 Università del Piemonte Orientale, Vercelli, Italy
133 Università di Brescia, Brescia, Italy
134 Variable Energy Cyclotron Centre, Homi Bhabha National Institute, Kolkata, India
135 Warsaw University of Technology, Warsaw, Poland
136 Wayne State University, Detroit, Michigan, United States
137 Yale University, New Haven, Connecticut, United States
138 Yonsei University, Seoul, Republic of Korea
139 Zentrum für Technologie und Transfer (ZTT), Worms, Germany
140 Affiliated with an institute formerly covered by a cooperation agreement with CERN
141 Affiliated with an international laboratory covered by a cooperation agreement with CERN.
References
- [1]W. Busza, K. Rajagopal, and W. van der Schee, “Heavy Ion Collisions: The Big Picture, and the Big Questions”, Ann. Rev. Nucl. Part. Sci. 68 (2018) 339–376, arXiv:1802.04801 [hep-ph].DOI
- [2]ALICE Collaboration, S. Acharya et al., “The ALICE experiment – A journey through QCD”, arXiv:2211.04384 [nucl-ex].DOI
- [3]B. V. Jacak and B. Müller, “The exploration of hot nuclear matter”, Science 337 (Jul, 2012) 310–314.DOI
- [4]ALICE Collaboration, S. Acharya et al., “Measurements of inclusive jet spectra in pp and central Pb–Pb collisions at √sNN = 5.02 TeV”, Phys. Rev. C 101 (Mar, 2020) 034911, arXiv:1909.09718 [nucl-ex].DOI
- [5]ATLAS Collaboration, M. Aaboud et al., “Measurement of the nuclear modification factor for inclusive jets in Pb+Pb collisions at √sNN = 5.02 TeV with the ATLAS detector”, Phys. Lett. B 790 (2019) 108–128, arXiv:1805.05635 [nucl-ex].DOI
- [6]CMS Collaboration, A. M. Sirunyan et al., “First measurement of large area jet transverse momentum spectra in heavy-ion collisions”, JHEP 05 (2021) 284, arXiv:2102.13080 [hep-ex].DOI
- [7]STAR Collaboration, J. Adam et al., “Measurement of inclusive charged-particle jet production in Au + Au collisions at √sNN = 200 GeV”, Phys. Rev. C 102 (2020) 054913, arXiv:2006.00582 [nucl-ex].
- [8]ALICE Collaboration, S. Acharya et al., “Measurement of the groomed jet radius and momentum splitting fraction in pp and Pb–Pb collisions at √sNN = 5.02 TeV”, Phys. Rev. Lett. 128 (2022) 102001, arXiv:2107.12984 [nucl-ex].DOI
- [9]ALICE Collaboration, S. Acharya et al., “Medium modification of the shape of small-radius jets in central Pb-Pb collisions at √sNN = 2.76 TeV”, JHEP 10 (2018) 139, arXiv:1807.06854 [nucl-ex].DOI
- [10]ATLAS Collaboration, M. Aaboud et al., “Measurement of jet fragmentation in Pb+Pb and pp collisions at √sNN = 5.02 TeV with the ATLAS detector”, Phys. Rev. C 98 (2018) 024908, arXiv:1805.05424 [nucl-ex].DOI
- [11]ATLAS Collaboration, M. Aaboud et al., “Comparison of Fragmentation Functions for Jets Dominated by Light Quarks and Gluons from pp and Pb+Pb Collisions in ATLAS”, Phys. Rev. Lett. 123 (2019) 042001, arXiv:1902.10007 [nucl-ex].DOI
- [12]ATLAS Collaboration, G. Aad et al., “Measurement of suppression of large-radius jets and its dependence on substructure in Pb+Pb collisions at √sNN = 5.02 TeV with the ATLAS detector”, arXiv:2301.05606 [nucl-ex].DOI
- [13]CMS Collaboration, S. Chatrchyan et al., “Measurement of Jet Fragmentation in PbPb and pp Collisions at √sNN = 2.76 TeV”, Phys. Rev. C 90 (2014) 024908, arXiv:1406.0932 [nucl-ex].DOI
- [14]CMS Collaboration, A. M. Sirunyan et al., “Observation of Medium-Induced Modifications of Jet Fragmentation in Pb-Pb Collisions at √sNN = 5.02 TeV Using Isolated Photon-Tagged Jets”, Phys. Rev. Lett. 121 (2018) 242301, arXiv:1801.04895 [hep-ex].DOI
- [15]CMS Collaboration, A. M. Sirunyan et al., “Measurement of the Splitting Function in pp and Pb-Pb Collisions at √sNN = 5.02 TeV”, Phys. Rev. Lett. 120 (2018) 142302, arXiv:1708.09429 [nucl-ex].DOI
- [16]CMS Collaboration, A. M. Sirunyan et al., “Measurement of the groomed jet mass in PbPb and pp collisions at √sNN = 5.02 TeV”, JHEP 10 (2018) 161, arXiv:1805.05145 [hep-ex].DOI
- [17]ALICE Collaboration, J. Adam et al., “Measurement of jet quenching with semi-inclusive hadron-jet distributions in central Pb-Pb collisions at √sNN = 2.76 TeV”, JHEP 09 (2015) 170, arXiv:1506.03984 [nucl-ex].DOI
- [18]STAR Collaboration, L. Adamczyk et al., “Measurements of jet quenching with semi-inclusive hadron+jet distributions in Au+Au collisions at √s_NN = 200 GeV”, Phys. Rev. C 96 (2017) 024905, arXiv:1702.01108 [nucl-ex].
- [19]P. Cal, D. Neill, F. Ringer, and W. J. Waalewijn, “Calculating the angle between jet axes”, JHEP 04 (2020) 211, arXiv:1911.06840 [hep-ph].DOI
- [20]M. Cacciari, G. P. Salam, and G. Soyez, “The anti-k_t jet clustering algorithm”, JHEP 04 (2008) 063, arXiv:0802.1189 [hep-ph].DOI
- [21]A. J. Larkoski, S. Marzani, G. Soyez, and J. Thaler, “Soft Drop”, JHEP 05 (2014) 146, arXiv:1402.2657 [hep-ph].DOI
- [24]D. Bertolini, T. Chan, and J. Thaler, “Jet Observables Without Jet Algorithms”, JHEP 04 (2014) 013, arXiv:1310.7584 [hep-ph].DOI
- [25]F. Ringer, B.-W. Xiao, and F. Yuan, “Can we observe jet p_T-broadening in heavy-ion collisions at the LHC?”, Phys. Lett. B 808 (2020) 135634, arXiv:1907.12541 [hep-ph].DOI
- [26]Z. Hulcher, D. Pablos, and K. Rajagopal, “Resolution Effects in the Hybrid Strong/Weak Coupling Model”, JHEP 03 (2018) 010, arXiv:1707.05245 [hep-ph].DOI
- [27]J. Casalderrey-Solana, J. G. Milhano, D. Pablos, and K. Rajagopal, “Modification of Jet Substructure in Heavy Ion Collisions as a Probe of the Resolution Length of Quark-Gluon Plasma”, JHEP 2020 (Jan, 2020) 044, arXiv:1907.11248 [hep-ph].
- [30]ALICE Collaboration, B. Abelev et al., “Performance of the ALICE Experiment at the CERN LHC”, Int. J. Mod. Phys. A 29 (2014) 1430044, arXiv:1402.4476 [nucl-ex].DOI
- [31]ALICE Collaboration, E. Abbas et al., “Performance of the ALICE VZERO system”, JINST 8 (2013) P10016, arXiv:1306.3130 [nucl-ex].DOI
- [32]ALICE Collaboration, B. Abelev et al., “Centrality determination of Pb–Pb collisions at √s_NN = 2.76 TeV with ALICE”, Phys. Rev. C 88 (2013) 044909, arXiv:1301.4361 [nucl-ex].DOI
- [33]ALICE Collaboration, “Centrality determination in heavy ion collisions”, ALICE-PUBLIC-2018-011 (8, 2018). https://cds.cern.ch/record/2636623.
- [34]ALICE Collaboration, K. Aamodt et al., “Alignment of the ALICE Inner Tracking System with cosmic-ray tracks”, JINST 5 (2010) P03003, arXiv:1001.0502 [physics.ins-det].DOI
- [35]J. Alme et al., “The ALICE TPC, a large 3-dimensional tracking device with fast readout for ultra-high multiplicity events”, Nucl. Instrum. Meth. A 622 (2010) 316–367, arXiv:1001.1950 [physics.ins-det].DOI
- [36]ALICE Collaboration, S. Acharya et al., “Supplemental materials: Measurement of the angle between jet axes in Pb–Pb collisions at √sNN = 5.02 TeV”, CERN-EP-2023-046.
- [37]R. Brun, F. Bruyant, M. Maire, A. C. McPherson, and P. Zanarini, “GEANT 3: user’s guide Geant 3.10, Geant 3.11; rev. version”, CERN-DD-EE-84-01.
- [38]ALICE Collaboration, B. Abelev et al., “Measurement of Event Background Fluctuations for Charged Particle Jet Reconstruction in Pb–Pb collisions at √sNN = 2.76 TeV”, JHEP 03 (2012) 053, arXiv:1201.2423 [hep-ex].DOI
- [39]P. Berta, M. Spousta, D. W. Miller, and R. Leitner, “Particle-level pileup subtraction for jets and jet shapes”, JHEP 06 (2014) 092, arXiv:1403.3108 [hep-ex].DOI
- [40]P. Berta, L. Masetti, D. W. Miller, and M. Spousta, “Pileup and Underlying Event Mitigation with Iterative Constituent Subtraction”, JHEP 08 (2019) 175, arXiv:1905.03470 [hep-ph].DOI
- [41]M. Cacciari, G. P. Salam, and G. Soyez, “FastJet User Manual”, Eur. Phys. J. C 72 (2012) 1896, arXiv:1111.6097 [hep-ph].DOI
- [42]G. D’Agostini, “A multidimensional unfolding method based on Bayes’ theorem”, Nucl. Instrum. Meth. A 362 (1994) 487 – 498.
- [43]G. D’Agostini, “Improved iterative Bayesian unfolding”, in Alliance Workshop on Unfolding and Data Correction. 10, 2010. arXiv:1010.0632 [physics.data-an].arxiv.org/abs/1010.0632
- [44]T. Sjöstrand, S. Ask, J. R. Christiansen, R. Corke, N. Desai, P. Ilten, S. Mrenna, S. Prestel, C. O. Rasmussen, and P. Z. Skands, “An introduction to PYTHIA 8.2”, Comput. Phys. Commun. 191 (2015) 159–177, arXiv:1410.3012 [hep-ph].DOI
- [45]P. Skands, S. Carrazza, and J. Rojo, “Tuning PYTHIA 8.1: the Monash 2013 Tune”, Eur. Phys. J. C 74 (2014) 3024, arXiv:1404.5630 [hep-ph].DOI
- [46]S. Gieseke, C. Rohr, and A. Siodmok, “Colour reconnections in Herwig++”, Eur. Phys. J. C 72 (Nov, 2012) 2225, arXiv:1206.0041 [hep-ph].DOI
- [47]K. C. Zapp, “JEWEL 2.0.0: directions for use”, Eur. Phys. J. C 74 (2014) 2762, arXiv:1311.0048 [hep-ph].DOI
- [49]K. C. Zapp, F. Krauss, and U. A. Wiedemann, “A perturbative framework for jet quenching”, JHEP 03 (2013) 080, arXiv:1212.1599 [hep-ph].DOI
- [51]J. H. Putschke et al., “The JETSCAPE framework”, arXiv:1903.07706 [nucl-th].arxiv.org/abs/1903.07706
- [52]JETSCAPE Collaboration, A. Kumar et al., “Inclusive Jet and Hadron Suppression in a Multi-Stage Approach”, arXiv:2204.01163 [hep-ph].
- [53]A. Majumder, “Incorporating Space-Time Within Medium-Modified Jet Event Generators”, Phys. Rev. C 88 (2013) 014909, arXiv:1301.5323 [nucl-th].DOI
- [54]Y. He, T. Luo, X.-N. Wang, and Y. Zhu, “Linear Boltzmann Transport for Jet Propagation in the Quark-Gluon Plasma: Elastic Processes and Medium Recoil”, Phys. Rev. C 91 (2015) 054908, arXiv:1503.03313 [nucl-th]. [Erratum: Phys. Rev. C 97 (2018), 019902].DOI
- [55]J.-W. Qiu, F. Ringer, N. Sato, and P. Zurita, “Factorization of jet cross sections in heavy-ion collisions”, Phys. Rev. Lett. 122 (2019) 252301, arXiv:1903.01993 [hep-ph].DOI
- [56]J.-W. Qiu, F. Ringer, N. Sato, and P. Zurita, “QCD factorization and universality of jet cross sections in heavy-ion collisions”, Nucl. Phys. A 1005 (2021) 121853, arXiv:2002.01652 [hep-ph].DOI
- [57]R. Baier, Y. L. Dokshitzer, A. H. Mueller, S. Peigne, and D. Schiff, “Radiative energy loss of high-energy quarks and gluons in a finite volume quark-gluon plasma”, Nucl. Phys. B 483 (1997) 291–320, arXiv:hep-ph/9607355.DOI
- [58]R. Baier, Y. L. Dokshitzer, A. H. Mueller, S. Peigne, and D. Schiff, “Radiative energy loss and p(T) broadening of high-energy partons in nuclei”, Nucl. Phys. B 484 (1997) 265–282, arXiv:hep-ph/9608322.DOI
- [59]R. Baier, Y. L. Dokshitzer, A. H. Mueller, and D. Schiff, “Medium induced radiative energy loss: Equivalence between the BDMPS and Zakharov formalisms”, Nucl. Phys. B 531 (1998) 403–425, arXiv:hep-ph/9804212.DOI
- [60]J. Casalderrey-Solana, D. C. Gulhan, J. G. Milhano, D. Pablos, and K. Rajagopal, “A Hybrid Strong/Weak Coupling Approach to Jet Quenching”, JHEP 10 (2014) 019, arXiv:1405.3864 [hep-ph]. [Erratum: JHEP 09, 175 (2015)].
- [62]J. Brewer, Q. Brodsky, and K. Rajagopal, “Disentangling jet modification in jet simulations and in Z+jet data”, JHEP 02 (2022) 175, arXiv:2110.13159 [hep-ph].DOI
- [63]M. Spousta and B. Cole, “Interpreting single jet measurements in Pb + Pb collisions at the LHC”, Eur. Phys. J. C 76 (2016) 50, arXiv:1504.05169 [hep-ph].DOI
- [64]W. Chen, S. Cao, T. Luo, L.-G. Pang, and X.-N. Wang, “Effects of jet-induced medium excitation in γ-hadron correlation in A+A collisions”, Phys. Lett. B 777 (2018) 86–90, arXiv:1704.03648 [nucl-th].DOI
- [65]W. Zhao, W. Ke, W. Chen, T. Luo, and X.-N. Wang, “From Hydrodynamics to Jet Quenching, Coalescence, and Hadron Cascade: A Coupled Approach to Solving the RAA⊗v2 Puzzle”, Phys. Rev. Lett. 128 (2022) 022302, arXiv:2103.14657 [hep-ph].DOI
- [66]ALICE Collaboration, “This paper HEPData (collection).” 2026.



