betaFeedback

WorksPhysics and Astronomy

Theory of the divacancy in 4H-SiC: Impact of Jahn-Teller effect on optical properties

Abstract

Understanding the optical properties of color centers in silicon carbide is essential for their use in quantum technologies, such as single-photon emission and spin-based qubits. In this work, first-principles calculations were employed using the r2SCAN density functional to investigate the electronic and vibrational properties of neutral divacancy configurations in 4H-SiC. Our approach addresses the dynamical Jahn-Teller effect in the excited states of axial divacancies. By explicitly solving the multimode dynamical Jahn-Teller problem, we compute emission and absorption lineshapes for axial divacancy configurations, providing insights into the complex interplay between electronic and vibrational degrees of freedom. The results show strong alignment with experimental data, underscoring the predictive power of the methodologies. Our calculations predict spontaneous symmetry breaking due to the pseudo Jahn-Teller effect in the excited state of the khkh divacancy, accompanied by the lowest electron-phonon coupling among the four configurations and distinct polarizability. These unique properties facilitate its selective excitation, setting it apart from other divacancy configurations, and highlight its potential utility in quantum technology applications. These findings underscore the critical role of electron-phonon interactions and optical properties in spin defects with pronounced Jahn-Teller effects, offering valuable insights for the design and integration of quantum emitters for quantum technologies.

Introduction

Silicon carbide (SiC) is a wide band gap material with great potential for high-power and high-frequency electronic devices [1] and quantum technologies (QT). Deep-level defects in the SiC crystal structure can significantly affect carrier mobility and lifetime, negatively impacting the performance of power devices [2, 3, 4]. While not all deep-level defects are optically active, some can introduce discrete energy levels deep within the band gap that can be optically addressed. At sufficiently low densities, such color centers can serve as sources of non-classical light [5]. Furthermore, some states reveal a paramagnetic spin structure with long coherence times even at room temperature (RT), and may therefore be optically accessible for spin initialization and readout protocols [6]. These properties position solid-state color centers as promising candidates for single-photon emitters (SPEs) and spin qubits. When integrated with advanced material processing and fabrication capabilities, color centers in SiC emerge as a robust platform for future solid-state quantum technologies [7, 8].

SiC hosts a variety of defects with QT-compatible properties [9] [10, 11]. Key intrinsic defects such as the silicon vacancy (VSiV_{\mathrm{Si}}), divacancy (VSiVCV_{\mathrm{Si}}V_{\mathrm{C}}), and carbon antisite-vacancy pair (CSiVCC_{\mathrm{Si}}V_{\mathrm{C}}) are introduced by irradiation and annealing and are proven to be photostable SPEs at RT [12–14]. CSiVCC_{\mathrm{Si}}V_{\mathrm{C}} emits in the visible spectrum (640–680 nm), VSiV_{\mathrm{Si}} in the near-infrared (858–916 nm) [12, 13], whereas the divacancy exhibits zero-phonon line (ZPL) energies closer to the telecommunications band at 1040–1140 nm [14, 15]. A deterministic single-photon emission in the infrared, such as that from the divacancy, is essential for fiber optic technology, enabling low-loss, secure long-distance quantum communication and cryptography. Furthermore, the divacancy’s electron spins show outstanding longevity, with coherence times exceeding those of nitrogen-vacancy (NV) centers in diamond, with VSiVCV_{\mathrm{Si}}V_{\mathrm{C}} exhibiting T2>5T_2 > 5 s [16]. Thus, the divacancy stands out as a versatile candidate for QT applications, functioning as both an SPE and a spin qubit.

Although color centers in crystals offer numerous advantages as SPEs and qubits, including RT operation, photostability, and scalability, the solid-state matrix also presents several challenges. These include both inhomogeneous and homogeneous optical broadening effects. Inhomogeneous broadening can be mitigated by improving the material quality. However, homogeneous broadening, which results from interactions with the continuum of vibrational degrees of freedom in solids, is more challenging to control. Such electron–phonon interactions not only lead to the emergence of phonon sidebands that reduce the number of photons emitted at the ZPL but also contribute to its temperature broadening, thereby diminishing the photon indistinguishability properties of the emitter. Furthermore, spin–phonon coupling plays a crucial role in determining the coherence properties of spin systems, as well as in driving the mechanisms that lead to intersystem crossing, which are essential for spin initialization and optical-spin contrast in optically detected magnetic resonance (ODMR) experiments. The theoretical description of the vibrational structure and electron–phonon coupling mechanisms of deep-level defects poses significant challenges, as defects exhibit characteristics of both atomic and solid-state physics, necessitating advanced methodologies that extend beyond conventional ab initio calculations [17, 18].

Advancements in understanding crystal defects as potential quantum systems have stimulated a renewed focus on the Jahn–Teller (JT) effect in color centers [19–25]. This effect emerges when degenerate or near-degenerate electronic states interact with symmetry-breaking vibrational modes. This coupling intricately mixes the electronic and vibrational degrees of freedom, giving rise to complex dynamics that influence the system’s electronic and optical properties [26–28]. Specifically, the JT interaction induces unique vibronic states, distinct from their adiabatic counterparts, manifesting as characteristic features in the absorption and emission spectra. These effects underscore the pivotal role of electron–phonon coupling in shaping the optical signatures of these systems. The description of JT systems typically employs a phenomenological model, approximating the numerous JT active modes with a single effective degenerate mode [19, 20, 22, 27]. However, accurately capturing optical signatures often necessitates solving the multi-mode JT problem, as recently demonstrated in modeling optical spectra for the negatively charged nitrogen-vacancy [18] and nickel-vacancy [29] centers in diamond.

In this work, first-principles calculations were performed utilizing the recently developed r²SCAN density functional [30] to investigate the electronic and vibrational properties of the four distinct configurations of the neutral divacancy in the 4H polytype of SiC. Previous work [31] modeled emission lineshapes for three divacancy configurations but did not explicitly solve the multimode dynamic Jahn–Teller (DJT) problem present in the excited state of axial divacancies or calculate absorption lineshapes. This work addresses these gaps by providing calculated emission and absorption lineshapes for all four divacancy configurations and explicitly treating the multimode DJT problem for axial divacancies, which exhibit a pronounced DJT effect. The dynamical coupling between electronic and vibrational degrees of freedom can create distinct vibronic states, resulting in specific emission or absorption spectra features. Herein, we demonstrate that this must be considered to correctly capture the optical properties of the divacancy in 4H-SiC and discuss the implications of these findings for other systems.

Results

Electronic structure

Divacancies in the neutral charge state were studied by performing calculations within the spin-polarized density functional theory (DFT) framework and using the r2r^{2}SCAN meta-GGA functional [30]. In the 4H-SiC polytype, each atomic site can take on either a hexagonal (hh) or pseudo-cubic (kk) configuration. Thus, four distinct defect configurations must be considered for a binary complex, such as the silicon-carbon divacancy that can take on different symmetries and exhibit different electro-optical properties (see Figure 1).

Structure of neutral divacancy defects in 4H-SiC

Figure 1. Structure of neutral divacancy (VSiVC0\mathrm{V}_{\mathrm{Si}}\mathrm{V}_{\mathrm{C}}^{0} or VV0\mathrm{VV}^{0}) defects in 4H-SiC. Ball and stick representation of vacancy pairs depicted as hollow spheres. The carbon and silicon atoms are represented by brown and blue spheres, respectively. Four nonequivalent configurations (hhhh, kkkk, hkhk, khkh) of divacancy defects are shown. The planes labeled hh and kk indicate the symmetry of lattice sites.

The electronic structure of neutral divacancies in 4H-SiC can be described using three molecular orbitals derived from the carbon dangling bonds, as depicted in Figure 2c and 2d. Axial divacancies, hhhh-VV0\mathrm{VV}^{0} and kkkk-VV0\mathrm{VV}^{0}, which exhibit C3vC_{3v} point-group symmetry (see Figure 2a and 2b), consist of an orbital of the a1a_{1} irreducible representation and a doublet of orbitals with ee-symmetry (see Figure 2c). DFT calculations reveal an additional orbital doublet of ee-symmetry within the band gap close to the conduction band edge, originating from silicon dangling bonds; these orbitals, however, remain optically inactive under standard excitation conditions. The ground state is a spin-triplet with A2A_{2} orbital symmetry, designated as 3A2^{3}A_{2} for axial divacancies, and is characterized by the orbital configuration a12e2a_{1}^{2}e^{2}. This state maintains a single-determinant wave function ∣a1aˉ1exey∣\lvert a_{1}\bar{a}_{1}e_{x}e_{y}\rvert for the spin projection ms=1m_{s}=1. The transition of a spin-down electron from the a1a_{1} an ee orbital located on carbon, leads to the excited spin-triplet state 3E^{3}E which is characterized by a degenerate orbital configuration a1e3a_{1}e^{3}. For ms=1m_{s}=1, this electron configuration manifests as two single-determinant wave functions ∣a1exeyeˉy∣\lvert a_{1}e_{x}e_{y}\bar{e}_{y}\rvert and ∣a1eˉxexey∣\lvert a_{1}\bar{e}_{x}e_{x}e_{y}\rvert. The symmetry dictates that the dipole moment for the transition 3A2↔3E^{3}A_{2}\leftrightarrow{}^{3}E in 4H-SiC is polarized within the cc-plane.

Description of electronic structure of axial divacancies

Figure 2. Description of electronic structure of axial divacancies. a Ball and stick representation of the kkkk-VV0^{0} defect in 4H-SiC. b Top-down view of kkkk-VV0^{0} along the cc-axis showcasing the C3vC_{3v} symmetry of the defect. c Schematic representation of single-particle defect levels in the band gap of 4H-SiC showing the occupancy of these levels in the ground 3A2^{3}A_{2} state and excited 3E^{3}E state of kkkk-VV0^{0}. d Isosurfaces of the real part of the single-particle orbitals associated with the defect levels aˉ1\bar{a}_{1}, eˉx\bar{e}_{x} and eˉy\bar{e}_{y}. The color (blue/red) represents the sign (+/−) of the orbital.

In contrast to axial divacancies, hkhk and khkh divacancies exhibit reduced C1hC_{1h} point group symmetry in the ground state, impacting their electronic and optical properties. The hkhk divacancy displays three lowest-lying levels within the band gap, ordered from lowest to highest energy respectively as a′(1)a'(1), a′′a'', and a′(2)a'(2), where a′a' and a′′a'' denote irreducible representations of the C1hC_{1h} point group. DFT calculations predict that the ground state of khkh divacancy has orbital symmetries denoted as a′(1)a'(1), a′(2)a'(2), and a′′a'' while the excited state of this divacancy has a reduced C1C_1 symmetry with its orbitals all having aa-symmetry. Illustrations of single-particle levels for each basal configuration are provided in Supplementary Figure 1. Using group-theoretical analysis based on the C1hC_{1h} point group, different polarization of the ZPL can be expected for hkhk and khkh divacancies. In the hkhk divacancy, the optical transition occurs between the a′(1)a'(1) and a′′a'' levels, involving a change in parity from a′a' to a′′a''. Consequently, the transition dipole moment (TDM) must transform according to the a′′a'' irreducible representation. This symmetry implies that the polarization of the emitted or absorbed light will be oriented perpendicular to the mirror plane σh\sigma_h, resulting in a dipole moment polarized within the cc-plane (similar to hhhh-VV0\mathrm{VV}^{0} and kkkk-VV0\mathrm{VV}^{0}). For the khkh divacancy, however, the optical transition occurs between the a′(1)a'(1) and a′(2)a'(2) levels. Since there is no change in parity, the polarization of the emitted or absorbed light is within the symmetry reflection plane of the defect, with most of its projection perpendicular to the cc-plane (theoretical transition dipole matrix elements are provided in Supplementary Table 1). This analysis is consistent with previously reported experimental and theoretical findings [32–34].

The calculated ZPL energies and zero-field splitting (ZFS) parameters for all divacancy configurations are compared with the experimental results and presented in Table 1. The results obtained using the r2r^2SCAN functional are in excellent agreement with experimental data [35] (see Supplementary Table 2 and Supplementary Table 3 for a comparison of results obtained using the SCAN [36] functional and other theoretical works). From the mean absolute errors, SCAN and r2r^2SCAN functionals enhance the accuracy compared to other calculations and come closest to the experimental values while requiring only a fraction of the computational cost needed for hybrid functionals.

ConfigurationCalc. ZPLExp. ZPL [35]Calc. ZFSExpt. ZFS [35]
hhhh1.0791.0951.3351.336
kkkk1.0811.0961.2851.305
khkh1.0621.1191.2921.222
hkhk1.1001.1501.3281.334

Table 1. Calculated zero-phonon line (ZPL) energies (in units of eV) and zero-field splitting (ZFS) parameters (in units of GHz) compared to experimental values.

Jahn–Teller effect

The excited state 3E{}^{3}E of the axial hhhh and kkkk divacancies is a degenerate orbital doublet with orbital configurations a1ex1ey2a_{1}e_{x}^{1}e_{y}^{2} and a1ex2ey1a_{1}e_{x}^{2}e_{y}^{1}. This degeneracy results in an intricate non-adiabatic coupling between electronic EE states and ee-symmetry degenerate vibrational modes forming an E⊗(e⊕e⋯ )E \otimes(e \oplus e \cdots) JT system. Since the coupling is not too strong, it leads to a DJT effect with dynamical distortions along symmetry-breaking directions, generating a distinct array of vibronic states and giving rise to specific features within optical spectra. The electronic structure of this DJT system is analogous to that of the negatively charged NV center in diamond, where the interplay between electronic and vibrational states due to the DJT effect has been well-studied [18–20, 37].

To analyze the adiabatic potential energy surface (APES) of the excited triplet state 3E{}^{3}E, an effective single-degenerate-mode model for quadratic E⊗eE \otimes e vibronic coupling is used to measure the effective parameters describing a two-dimensional representation of a multidimensional potential energy surface [28]. The expression for the APES in the space of polar mass-weighted displacement coordinates QxQ_x and QyQ_y (where QxQ_x and QyQ_y describe a pair of effective coordinates that parametrize a collective ionic motion along the ee-symmetry direction) takes the form

ϵ(ρ,ϕ)=12κρ2±ρ[F2+G2ρ2+2FGρcos⁡(3ϕ)]1/2,(1)\epsilon(\rho,\phi) = \frac{1}{2}\kappa\rho^2 \pm\rho\left[F^2 + G^2\rho^2 + 2FG\rho\cos(3\phi)\right]^{1/2}, \tag*{(1)}

where ρ=(Qx2+Qy2)\rho= \sqrt{(Q_x^2+Q_y^2)}, ϕ=arctan⁡(Qy/Qx)\phi= \arctan(Q_y/Q_x), κ\kappa is the elastic force constant, FF is the linear vibronic constant, and GG is the quadratic vibronic constant. The values of the three vibronic constants, mass-weighted displacements, and details of first-principles calculation of the APES are provided in Supplementary Note 4. The lower branch of the 3E^3E APES takes a ”tricorn sombrero” shape with three minima and three saddle points (see Figure 3a). The three minima have a JT stabilization energy EJTE_{\mathrm{JT}} of 69 meV for hhhh-VV0^0 and 64 meV for kkkk-VV0^0. These three minima are separated by energy barriers δJT\delta_{\mathrm{JT}} of 23 meV for hhhh-VV0^0 and 19 meV for kkkk-VV0^0. These results are in good agreement with other theoretical studies, where the use of the hybrid HSE06 functional yielded JT stabilization energy and barrier values for the hhhh-VV0^0 defect of 74 meV and 18 meV, respectively [38]. Figure 3b shows the APES contour plot and the path used to calculate the potential energy curve (see Figure 3c) and parametrize the JT relaxation. For the analysis of the multi-mode vibronic states of axial divacancy, including the quadratic JT effect would significantly increase the complexity of an already intricate problem. Therefore, we use linear JT theory to analyze the impact of the JT effect on vibronic dynamics and its influence on the optical properties of axial divacancies.

Adiabatic potential energy surface of the $kk$-$VV^{0}$ excited state ${}^{3}E$

Figure 3. Adiabatic potential energy surface (APES) of the kkkk-VV0VV^{0} excited state 3E{}^{3}E. a APES of the lower branch of the 3E{}^{3}E state, which takes a ”tricorn sombrero” shape with three minima and three saddle points. QxQ_x, QyQ_y configuration coordinates represent the collective motion of effective ee-symmetry modes. EJTE_{\mathrm{JT}} is the JT stabilization energy, which is the difference in energy between the high-symmetry and distorted configurations. The three minima are separated by three barriers with the energy of δJT\delta_{\mathrm{JT}}. b Contour plot of the APES. c Computed potential energy curve along the path defined in b. The potential energy curve is fitted by Eq. (1) (see text).

For basal divacancies, the excited states exhibit non-degenerate energy levels that are closely spaced. Δ\DeltaSCF calculations indicate that in the ground-state geometry, the energy separation between these excited states is 62 meV for the hkhk divacancy and 100 meV for the khkh divacancy. This small distance suggests the potential presence of a pseudo-Jahn–Teller (PJT) effect, where symmetry-breaking vibrational modes of a′′a^{\prime\prime} symmetry couple to electronic states that are close in energy. In static adiabatic calculations, the PJT effect modifies the harmonic potential. For weak coupling, this manifests as changes in the effective frequency of PJT-active modes, while stronger coupling can lead to the appearance of double minima and symmetry breaking [28]. Our results reveal that the khkh divacancy in the excited state undergoes symmetry breaking, providing additional stabilization energy of 15 meV. In contrast, no such symmetry breaking is observed for the hkhk divacancy, indicating weaker PJT coupling. A comprehensive analysis of the PJT effect necessitates the explicit determination of electron–phonon coupling parameters (⟨ψi∣∂ψi/∂Qk⟩\langle\psi_i|\partial\psi_i/\partial Q_k\rangle) directly from the wave functions. In the case of pure degeneracy, these parameters can be inferred from the shape of the APES. However, such an analysis is beyond the scope of the present study. As a result, for the examination of the optical properties of basal divacancies, we neglect the non-adiabatic nature of the PJT effect and instead rely on the Huang–Rhys (HR) theory [39]. This approximation could be justified for the emission process [18], where the final state can be effectively treated as adiabatic. Nonetheless, a more detailed investigation is necessary to rigorously address the absorption spectra, which is left for future work.

Vibrational properties

Vibrational structures of the ground and excited states and the subsequent relaxation profiles were calculated to obtain electron–phonon coupling densities for all four divacancy configurations. The embedding methodology of Refs. [17, 18] was employed to simulate these parameters in supercells containing nearly 30 000 atomic sites, approaching the dilute limit.

The calculated spectral densities of electron–phonon coupling for the emission (3E→3A2{}^{3}E \to{}^{3}A_{2}) and absorption (3A2→3E{}^{3}A_{2} \to{}^{3}E) processes for the axial divacancies are presented in Figure 4. The coupling to JT inactive (a1a_{1}-symmetry) modes is represented by Sa1(ℏω)=∑kSkδ(ℏω−ℏωk)S_{a_{1}}(\hbar\omega) = \sum_{k} S_{k}\delta(\hbar\omega-\hbar\omega_{k}) (see Figure 4a and 4b), where SkS_{k} is the HR factor [17, 18, 39] for vibrational mode kk, quantifying the average number of a1a_{1}-symmetry phonons emitted during an optical transition. The linear JT coupling spectral density for ee-symmetry modes is given by K2(ℏω)=∑kKk2δ(ℏω−ℏωk)K^{2}(\hbar\omega) = \sum_{k} K_{k}^{2}\delta(\hbar\omega-\hbar\omega_{k}) (see Figure 4c and 4d), where KkK_{k} is the dimensionless vibronic coupling constant [18, 29, 40] quantifying the coupling between the ee-symmetry vibrational doublet kk and components of the degenerate electronic state EE. The total HR factor Stot=∑kSkS_{\mathrm{tot}} = \sum_{k} S_{k} and the total JT coupling Ktot2=∑kKk2K_{\mathrm{tot}}^{2} = \sum_{k} K_{k}^{2} are included in Figure 4.

Spectral densities of electron–phonon coupling for axial divacancies

Figure 4. Spectral densities of electron–phonon coupling for axial divacancies. a Spectral densities Sa1(ℏω)S_{a_1}(\hbar\omega) associated with a1a_1-symmetry phonons of the 3E→3A2{}^3E \to{}^3A_2 and b 3A2→3E{}^3A_2 \to{}^3E transitions. c Spectral densities of JT linear coupling K2(ℏω)K^2(\hbar\omega) associated with ee-symmetry phonons of the 3E→3A2{}^3E \to{}^3A_2 and d 3A2→3E{}^3A_2 \to{}^3E transitions. The spectral densities are for hhhh and kkkk divacancies. The total HR factor StotS_{\mathrm{tot}} and the total JT coupling Ktot2K^2_{\mathrm{tot}} are included in the panels. Results are for the (23×23×7)(23 \times23 \times7) supercell with 29 622 atomic sites.

The parameters SkS_{k} and Kk2K_{k}^{2} describe alterations in the APES and are directly related to relaxation energies. The relaxation energy along the symmetry-preserving direction following the vertical transition A→EA \to E is given by ΔEa1=∑kℏωkSk\Delta E_{a_{1}} = \sum_{k} \hbar\omega_{k}S_{k}. In contrast, the linear theory defines the JT stabilization energy as ΔEJT=∑kℏωkKk2\Delta E_{\mathrm{JT}} = \sum_{k} \hbar\omega_{k}K_{k}^{2}. Our computations yield ΔEa1=74.2\Delta E_{a_{1}} = 74.2 meV for hhhh-VV0\mathrm{VV}^{0} and 76.1 meV for kkkk-VV0\mathrm{VV}^{0}. This suggests that the contribution to the electron–phonon coupling from JT-active modes (EJT=69E_{\mathrm{JT}} = 69 meV for hhhh and 64 meV for kkkk) is comparable to that from symmetry-preserving modes.

During the 3E→3A2{}^{3}E \to{}^{3}A_{2} optical transition, the total HR factor of a1a_{1}-symmetry modes is found to be equal for hhhh and kkkk divacancies, although the hhhh divacancy has a higher total JT coupling (K2=1.36K^{2} = 1.36) than the kkkk divacancy (K2=1.16K^{2} = 1.16). The main difference in the vibrational structures between emission and absorption processes lies in the contribution from ee-symmetry phonons. The JT linear coupling K2(ℏω)K^{2}(\hbar\omega) for the absorption process is overall shifted to higher energy levels compared to the emission process, particularly for phonon energies above 100 meV. In the case of the 3A2→3E{}^{3}A_{2} \to{}^{3}E optical transition, the total calculated JT coupling of ee-symmetry phonons is 1.52 (hhhh-VV0\mathrm{VV}^{0}) and 1.30 (kkkk-VV0\mathrm{VV}^{0}), respectively, which is several times stronger than that for the NV−\mathrm{NV}^{-} center in diamond [18]. This warrants the use of multimode DJT theory to model the absorption lineshapes for the axial divacancies. During the emission process, degeneracy resides in the initial state, and therefore, HR theory can be utilized to calculate the emission lineshapes [18]. For a complete comparison, the

DJT theory was still applied to calculate the spectral densities of JT linear coupling and subsequent luminescence lineshapes for axial divacancies.

The calculated spectral densities of electron–phonon coupling for both emission and absorption processes for basal divacancies are presented in Figure 5. Each panel includes the total HR factor [39], Stot=∑kSkS_{\mathrm{tot}} = \sum_k S_k. Our findings indicate that the total electron–phonon coupling is noticeably stronger for hkhk divacancies (2.83 for emission and 3.11 for absorption) compared to khkh divacancies (2.47 and 2.83, respectively), with the main difference lying in the spectral region around 35 meV.

Spectral densities of electron–phonon coupling for basal divacancies

Figure 5. Spectral densities of electron–phonon coupling for basal divacancies. a Spectral function S(ℏω)S(\hbar\omega) of the 3A′→3A′′^{3}A^{\prime} \rightarrow{}^{3}A^{\prime\prime} and b 3A′′→3A′^{3}A^{\prime\prime} \rightarrow{}^{3}A^{\prime} optical transitions for hkhk divacancy. c Spectral function S(ℏω)S(\hbar\omega) of the 3A→3A^{3}A \rightarrow{}^{3}A and d 3A′′→3A′′^{3}A^{\prime\prime} \rightarrow{}^{3}A^{\prime\prime} optical transitions for khkh divacancy. Results are for the (23×23×7)(23 \times23 \times7) supercell with 29 622 atomic sites.

By comparing the spectral functions between the emission and absorption processes, a noticeable difference can be observed, which arises from changes in the vibrational structures of the ground and excited states. For axial divacancies, the main distinction lies in the vibrational structure of JT-active modes (see Figure 4c and Figure 4d), where a significant shift of electron–phonon coupling to higher vibrational frequencies is observed during absorption. A similar, but less pronounced, effect is observed for basal divacancies (Figure 5). The electron–phonon coupling was calculated using the equal mode approximation, which assumes identical vibrational structures in both states. Although this assumption is not entirely accurate, for low-temperature spectra, a good approximation is to use the vibrational structure of the final state in the transition [18]. However, this change in vibrational structure indicates a quadratic electron–phonon coupling on top of the DJT effect, which we do not account for in the following analysis. This could have important implications for modeling temperature effects and temperature broadening of the ZPL in future works.

Optical spectra of emission

The 3E→3A2{}^{3}E \to{}^{3}A_{2} optical transition lineshapes calculated using HR theory and multimode DJT theory (in the case of axial divacancies) are presented in Figure 6 and compared with the experimental lineshapes (in gray) [31, 41]. The emission lineshapes calculated using both theories are in very good agreement with the experiment and capture all the spectral features. The similarity of the lineshapes obtained by both theories agrees with the findings of Ref. [18], where it was shown that for an 3E→3A2{}^{3}E \to{}^{3}A_{2} optical transition and K2≈1K^{2} \approx1, the HR theory provides a quantitatively similar description to the rigorous DJT theory. The main difference between the emission lineshapes calculated using HR and DJT theories lies in the intensity redistribution. The DJT approach yields a higher ZPL intensity and, subsequently, a higher Debye–Waller factor (DWF), defined as the ratio of the ZPL to the entire lineshape (see Table 2), with a sideband that is less extended compared to that predicted by HR theory.

Optical spectra of emission for hh–VV^0, kk–VV^0, hk–VV^0, and kh–VV^0

Figure 6. Optical spectra of emission. Blue lines are luminescence lineshapes calculated using HR theory, while the orange lines are lineshapes calculated using DJT theory. The gray area represents experimental data from Ref. [31, 41]. The small peak marked with a star ”∗” in the experimental curve for hkhk–VV0VV^{0} is the ZPL of hhhh–VV0VV^{0} and should be disregarded in the comparison between theory and experiment. The intensities of the experimental lineshapes have been scaled to match the peaks of the computed lineshapes. Results reported here are computed at the r2r^{2}SCAN level of theory and extrapolated to the dilute limit, approximated by a (23×23×7)(23 \times23 \times7) supercell with 29 622 atomic sites.

ConfigurationCalc. HRCalc. DJTExpt.
hh5.607.043.69 [31]
kk6.827.036.11 [31]
hk7.84—7.54 [31]
kh11.22—13 [41]

Table 2. Computed Debye–Waller factor (DWF) (%) of emission computed using different levels of theory for the four different neutral divacancy configurations. The results are compared with experimental values.

The hh, kk, and hk divacancies exhibit similar emission lineshape profiles and DWFs. In contrast, the kh divacancy shows significantly different characteristics when compared to the other divacancies. The computed mass-weighted displacements ΔQ\Delta Q (amu0.5^{0.5} Å) between the equilibrium structures of the ground state and the excited state are as follows: 0.823 (hh), 0.802 (kk), 0.798 (hk), and 0.762 (kh). Moreover, the total electron–phonon coupling factors are 3.21 (hh), 3.01 (kk), 2.83 (hk), and 2.47 (kh). The noticeably lower mass-weighted displacement and total electron–phonon coupling for the kh divacancy lead to its more prominent DWF. These distinctions underscore the unique vibrational characteristics of the kh configuration along with different polarization properties, setting it apart from the hh, kk, and hk configurations.

Optical spectra of absorption

The absorption lineshapes for the 3A2→3E^{3}A_{2} \rightarrow{}^{3}E optical transition, calculated using both HR and multimode DJT theories for axial divacancies, are displayed in Figure 7. Additionally, the absorption lineshapes for the 3A′′→3A′^{3}A^{\prime\prime} \rightarrow{}^{3}A^{\prime} transition in the hkhk divacancy and the 3A′′→3A′′^{3}A^{\prime\prime} \rightarrow{}^{3}A^{\prime\prime} transition in the khkh divacancy, calculated with HR theory, are presented in the same figure.

Optical spectra of absorption for hh–VV$^{0}$, kk–VV$^{0}$, hk–VV$^{0}$, and kh–VV$^{0}$ divacancies

Figure 7. Optical spectra of absorption. Blue lines are absorption lineshapes calculated using HR theory, while the orange lines are absorption lineshapes calculated using DJT theory. Results reported here are computed at the r2r^{2}SCAN level of theory and extrapolated to the dilute limit, approximated by a (23×23×7)(23 \times23 \times7) supercell with 29 622 atomic sites.

Comparing the HR and DJT calculations, the DJT theory predicts a higher ZPL intensity along with more extended sidebands than HR theory, a difference that becomes particularly significant beyond 250 meV above the ZPL. Across all absorption spectra, sharp peaks near 75 meV arise from quasi-localized phonon modes. In the khkh divacancy, an additional prominent peak at 38 meV, resulting from delocalized bulk-like vibrations, exhibits a more pronounced intensity and a sideband that decays faster than in other divacancies. The total electron–phonon coupling factors are calculated to be 3.54 (hhhh), 3.37 (kkkk), 3.11 (hkhk), and 2.83 (khkh). The DWFs computed using HR theory are 2.53% (hhhh), 3.02% (kkkk), 4.02% (hkhk), and 5.39% (khkh). For the DJT model, the calculated DWFs for the hhhh and kkkk divacancies are slightly higher, at 3.42% and 3.72%, respectively.

Discussion

In summary, first-principles calculations were employed to examine the optical properties of neutral divacancies in the 4H-SiC polytype, with particular attention to the DJT effect present in the excited state of axial configurations. The approach used herein enables accurate predictions of emission and absorption spectra in the dilute limit using the force constant embedding methodology, filling gaps left by previous works that did not explicitly address the DJT effect or calculate absorption lineshapes for all configurations. Furthermore, our findings demonstrate that the r2^{2}SCAN functional provides accurate predictions of the electronic, vibrational and vibronic properties, as reflected in the strong agreement between calculated and experimental ZPL, ZFS, DWF values and lineshapes.

During the 3E→3A2{}^{3}E \to{}^{3}A_2 optical transition for axial divacancies, where degeneracy is present in the initial state, the lineshapes calculated using HR theory closely match those obtained with the more rigorous multimode DJT approach. In contrast, for the 3A2→3E{}^{3}A_2 \to{}^{3}E optical transition to the degenerate excited state, multimode DJT treatment becomes essential to accurately capture the complex optical features that are characteristic of systems with strong JT interactions, such as the emission lineshape in the negatively charged nickel-vacancy center in diamond. Furthermore, the DWFs derived from multimode DJT theory predict a higher ZPL intensity with more extended sidebands compared to HR theory, particularly beyond 250 meV above the ZPL. This difference highlights the critical role of DJT effects in accurately describing optical transitions involving degenerate states.

Interestingly, our results predict spontaneous symmetry breaking in the excited state of the khkh divacancy due to the PJT effect. Compared to the other configurations, the khkh-VV0^{0} was found to have the lowest total electron–phonon coupling, the highest DWF, and unique polarization characteristics, making it selectively excitable in applications involving an ensemble of divacancies.

The methodologies discussed herein not only advance understanding of the neutral divacancy’s optical properties in 4H-SiC, but also illustrate a broader framework for applying multimode DJT theory to other defects with strong vibronic coupling. By addressing both emission and absorption phenomena with multimode DJT theory, the present study paves the way for exploring electron–phonon interactions and optical properties in other spin defects with pronounced JT effect, informing future designs for quantum emitters, sensors and related applications in quantum technologies.

Methods

Electronic structure calculations

Calculations have been performed within the spin-polarized DFT framework. Projector-augmented wave (PAW) approach was used with a plane-wave energy cutoff of 600 eV to describe the interaction of electrons with atomic cores. All calculations were performed using the Vienna Ab initio Simulation Package (VASP) with the meta-GGA class r2SCANr^{2}\mathrm{SCAN} functional [30, 42]. This functional was chosen due to its accuracy in describing the APES for covalent materials like diamond, SiC, and Si compared to both GGA and hybrid functionals [43]. Furthermore, when calculating optical excitation energies, r2SCANr^{2}\mathrm{SCAN} yields results with accuracy that is close to the much more computationally expensive hybrid or beyond-RPA methods [29, 43–45].

Divacancy defects were modeled using the supercell approach [46]. All neutral divacancy (VSiVC0V_{\mathrm{Si}}V_{\mathrm{C}}^{0} or VV0V_{\mathrm{V}}^{0}) centers were created by removing one Si and one C atom from a (6×6×2)(6 \times6 \times2) supercell with 576 atomic sites. Brillouin zone sampling was done using a single k-point (at Γ\Gamma). The stopping criterion for the electronic self-consistent loop and ionic relaxation were set to 10−8 eV10^{-8}\,\mathrm{eV} and 10−4 eV A˚−110^{-4}\,\mathrm{eV}\,\mathring{\mathrm{A}}^{-1}, respectively.

Zero-field splitting and optical excitation energy calculations

The methodology of Ivady et al. implemented in the VASP code was used to calculate the ZFS parameters [47]. The ZPL energies were calculated utilizing the Δ\Delta-self consistent field or Δ\DeltaSCF approximation, the accuracy of which has been demonstrated in various instances when applied to defects in solids [22, 31, 48–54]. The excited states are obtained by constraining the occupancies of the Kohn–Sham single-particle levels by promoting one electron from the highest occupied level in the spin-minority channel to the next higher energy level in the same spin channel. In the case of hh and kk divacancies, the excited triplet state 3E^{3}E has an electronic configuration a1e3a_{1}e^{3} and is an E⊗(e⊕e⋯ )E \otimes(e \oplus e \cdots) JT system.

To address computational issues stemming from the JT distortion in the excited state, caused by the degeneracy between the a1ex1ey2a_{1}e_{x}^{1}e_{y}^{2} and a1ex2ey1a_{1}e_{x}^{2}e_{y}^{1} configurations, the charge density was approximated by maintaining an electronic configuration of a1ex1.5ey1.5a_{1}e_{x}^{1.5}e_{y}^{1.5}. This practical approach helps limit the excited state density to an average between the two degenerate configurations while preserving the C3vC_{3v} symmetry.

Vibronic states and Jahn–Teller Hamiltonian

In this section, we focus exclusively on the vibronic states of axial divacancies exhibiting C3vC_{3v} symmetry. For a non-degenerate electronic state, the vibronic state is expressed within the adiabatic approximation as

∣Ψkl⟩=χla1(Qa1)χke(Qe)∣A⟩(2)\lvert\Psi_{kl}\rangle= \chi_{l}^{a_{1}}(\mathbf{Q}_{a_{1}})\chi_{k}^{e}(\mathbf{Q}_{e})\lvert A\rangle \tag*{(2)}

where χla1(Qa1)\chi_{l}^{a_{1}}(\mathbf{Q}_{a_{1}}) and χke(Qe)\chi_{k}^{e}(\mathbf{Q}_{e}) represent the harmonic components of the vibrational wave function, corresponding to symmetry-preserving (a1a_{1}) and symmetry-breaking (ee) vibrational modes, respectively. These components are derived from standard adiabatic phonon analysis, where ll and kk label the respective harmonic excitations. The symmetry-adapted normal coordinates Q\mathbf{Q} collectively encapsulate the vibrational degrees of freedom. The electronic wave function, denoted by ∣A⟩\lvert A\rangle, depends solely on the electronic degrees of freedom within the static adiabatic approximation, remaining decoupled from vibrational dynamics in this formalism.

For an E⊗(e⊕e⊕⋯ )E \otimes(e \oplus e \oplus\cdots) system, the vibronic Hamiltonian describing the linear JT interaction between an orbital doublet and ee-symmetry vibrational modes can be expressed as H^=H^0+H^JT\hat{H} = \hat{H}_{0}+\hat{H}_{\mathrm{JT}}. In the basis of electronic states ∣Ex⟩\lvert E_{x}\rangle and ∣Ey⟩\lvert E_{y}\rangle, the zero-order Hamiltonian describes vibrational motion within a harmonic potential and is given by

H^0=∑k;γ∈{x,y}(−ℏ22∂2∂Qkγ2+12ωk2Qkγ2)(1001)(3)\hat{H}_{0} = \sum_{k;\gamma\in\{x,y\}} \left(-\frac{\hbar^{2}}{2}\frac{\partial^{2}}{\partial Q_{k\gamma}^{2}}+\frac{1}{2}\omega_{k}^{2}Q_{k\gamma}^{2}\right)\begin{pmatrix} 1 & 0 \\ 0 & 1 \end{pmatrix} \tag*{(3)}

The linear JT coupling term is [28, 55]

H^JT=∑k2ℏωk3Kk(Qk,yQk,xQk,x−Qk,y)(4)\hat{H}_{\mathrm{JT}} = \sum_{k}\sqrt{2\hbar\omega_{k}^{3}}K_{k}\begin{pmatrix} Q_{k,y} & Q_{k,x} \\ Q_{k,x} & -Q_{k,y} \end{pmatrix} \tag*{(4)}

where ωk\omega_{k} are the angular frequencies of vibrations, derived as eigenvalues of the zero-order Hamiltonian [Eq. (3)], and KkK_{k} are the dimensionless vibronic coupling constants [40]. The index k=1,…,Nk = 1, \ldots, N encompasses all pairs of degenerate ee-symmetry vibrations, which transform according to the Cartesian xyxy representation, analogous to the transformation properties of the electronic states. The solutions of the vibronic Hamiltonian are

∣Φm⟩=χme;x(Qe)∣Ex⟩+χme;y(Qe)∣Ey⟩,(5)|\Phi_m\rangle= \chi_m^{e;x}(\mathbf{Q}_e)|E_x\rangle+ \chi_m^{e;y}(\mathbf{Q}_e)|E_y\rangle, \tag*{(5)}

where the coefficients χme;γ(Qe)\chi_m^{e;\gamma}(\mathbf{Q}_e) are ionic prefactors determined by solving the JT problem, and the quantum number mm labels the vibronic excitations of the system.

The complete wave function, including the symmetry-preserving modes, within the degenerate electronic manifold corresponding to the JT-active state, is given as [18, 29] ∣Ψnm⟩=χna(Qa)∣Φj;m⟩|\Psi_{nm}\rangle= \chi_n^a(\mathbf{Q}_a)|\Phi_{j;m}\rangle, where nn labels the harmonic states associated with the symmetry-preserving modes.

The solution to the DJT problem involves three essential steps:

  1. Calculation of the zero-order vibrational structure. This step requires solving the zero-order Hamiltonian Eq. (3). To suppress the JT interactions, the electronic configuration a1ex1.5ey1.5a_1e_x^{1.5}e_y^{1.5} is used, following the methodology outlined in Refs. [18, 29]. This configuration effectively models an ensemble of two degenerate electronic states with equal probability, ensuring that the C3vC_{3v} symmetry is preserved. By maintaining this symmetry, the vibrational modes can be systematically classified according to the irreducible representations of the C3vC_{3v} point group.

  1. Estimation of the vibronic coupling parameters. The vibronic coupling constants, KkK_k, are extracted by analyzing the geometry change ΔQJT\Delta\mathbf{Q}_{\mathrm{JT}} associated with the transition from the high-symmetry to the low-symmetry atomic configuration, as detailed in Supplementary Note 4. These constants are calculated by projecting ΔQJT\Delta\mathbf{Q}_{\mathrm{JT}} onto a pair kk of ee-symmetry normal modes, according to the expression [18]

Kk2=ωkΔQk22ℏ,(6)K_k^2 = \frac{\omega_k \Delta Q_k^2}{2\hbar}, \tag*{(6)}

where ΔQk2=ΔQkx2+ΔQky2\Delta Q_k^2 = \Delta Q_{kx}^2 + \Delta Q_{ky}^2 represents the squared projection of the kk-doublet normal coordinates along the relaxation path ΔQJT\Delta\mathbf{Q}_{\mathrm{JT}}. For embedded supercells, recovering ΔQJT\Delta\mathbf{Q}_{\mathrm{JT}} in the dilute limit is achieved through force-based methods, as described in Refs. [18, 29].

  1. Diagonalizing the vibronic Hamiltonian. The diagonalization of the Hamiltonian H=H0+HJT\mathcal{H} = \mathcal{H}_0 + \mathcal{H}_{\mathrm{JT}}, which includes many vibrational modes, poses significant computational challenges due to the large matrix dimensions. To manage this complexity, we

adopt an approach based on a reduced set of effective modes [18, 29]. In this method, the spectral density of the JT coupling is defined as K2(ℏω)=∑kKk2δ(ℏω−ℏωk)K^{2}(\hbar\omega)=\sum_{k}K_{k}^{2}\delta(\hbar\omega-\hbar\omega_{k}). This density is then approximated by a density stemming from a smaller number of effective modes Keff2(ℏω)=∑n=1NeffK‾n2gσ(ℏω‾n−ℏω)K_{\mathrm{eff}}^{2}(\hbar\omega)=\sum_{n=1}^{N_{\mathrm{eff}}}\overline{K}_{n}^{2}g_{\sigma}(\hbar\overline{\omega}_{n}-\hbar\omega), where gσg_{\sigma} is a Gaussian function with width σ\sigma. The approximation uses NeffN_{\mathrm{eff}} effective vibrations, each characterized by a frequency ω‾n\overline{\omega}_{n} and an associated vibronic coupling strength K‾n2\overline{K}_{n}^{2}. The parameters K‾n2\overline{K}_{n}^{2}, ω‾n\overline{\omega}_{n}, and σ\sigma are optimized to ensure that Keff2(ℏω)K_{\mathrm{eff}}^{2}(\hbar\omega) accurately reproduces K2(ℏω)K^{2}(\hbar\omega). This reduction significantly lowers the computational burden, as the number of effective modes is much smaller than the total number of modes, Neff≪NN_{\mathrm{eff}}\ll N.

To validate the reliability of the spectral functions derived from this approximation, we systematically monitor their convergence with respect to the number of effective modes. Details on the convergence analysis are provided in Supplementary Note 6.

Phonon calculations

Phonon modes of divacancies were calculated using the finite displacement method with configurations generated using the PHONOPY software package [56]. Displacements of ±0.01\pm0.01 Å from equilibrium geometries were used. Extrapolation of phonon modes to the dilute limit was done with a (23×23×7)(23\times23\times7) supercell with 29 622 atomic sites using the force constant matrix embedding methodology presented in Refs. [17, 18]. To achieve a smooth representation of the electron–phonon spectral function, delta functions were approximated with Gaussian functions of variable widths (σ\sigma), decreasing linearly from 3.5 meV at zero frequency to 1.5 meV at the highest phonon energy.

Calculation of optical lineshapes

In the zero-temperature limit (T=0T=0 K) of the Franck–Condon approximation, the normalized lineshape L(ℏω)L(\hbar\omega) for absorption and luminescence is given by [18]

L(ℏω)=CωκA(ℏω),(7)L(\hbar\omega)=C\omega^{\kappa}A(\hbar\omega), \tag*{(7)}

where CC is a normalization constant, A(ℏω)A(\hbar\omega) is the spectral function describing the phonon sideband, and κ\kappa takes the value of 3 for emission and 1 for absorption. For transitions involving a single degenerate orbital doublet, the spectral function is expressed as a convolution [18]:

A(ℏω)=∫Aa1(ℏω−ℏω′)Ae(ℏω′)d(ℏω′)(8)A(\hbar\omega) = \int A_{a_1}(\hbar\omega-\hbar\omega')A_e(\hbar\omega')\mathrm{d}(\hbar\omega') \tag*{(8)}

where Aa1A_{a_1} and AeA_e are the spectral functions corresponding to symmetry-preserving (a1a_1) and symmetry-breaking (ee) vibrational modes, respectively. The a1a_1 spectral function is given by

Aa1(ℏω)=∑n∣⟨χi0a1∣χfna1⟩∣2δ(EZPL∓(εfna1−εf0a1)−ℏω)(9)A_{a_1}(\hbar\omega) = \sum_n \left|\langle\chi_{i0}^{a_1} \mid\chi_{fn}^{a_1}\rangle\right|^2 \delta\left(E_{\mathrm{ZPL}} \mp\left(\varepsilon_{fn}^{a_1}-\varepsilon_{f0}^{a_1}\right)-\hbar\omega\right) \tag*{(9)}

where the minus sign applies to emission, the plus sign to absorption, ii and ff refer to the initial and final electronic states, and εfna1\varepsilon_{fn}^{a_1} is the energy eigenvalue of the nn-th vibrational level in state ff.

The spectral function for JT active ee vibrational modes is

Ae(ℏω)=∑m[∣⟨χi0e;x∣χfme⟩∣2+∣⟨χi0e;y∣χfme⟩∣2]δ(εi0e−εime−ℏω)(10)A_e(\hbar\omega) = \sum_m \left[\left|\langle\chi_{i0}^{e;x}\mid\chi_{fm}^{e}\rangle\right|^2+\left|\langle\chi_{i0}^{e;y}\mid\chi_{fm}^{e}\rangle\right|^2\right]\delta\left(\varepsilon_{i0}^{e}-\varepsilon_{im}^{e}-\hbar\omega\right) \tag*{(10)}

for emission, whereby the initial state is degenerate, and

Ae(ℏω)=∑m[∣⟨χi0e∣χfme;x⟩∣2+∣⟨χi0e∣χfme;y⟩∣2]δ(εfme−εf0e−ℏω)(11)A_e(\hbar\omega) = \sum_m \left[\left|\langle\chi_{i0}^{e}\mid\chi_{fm}^{e;x}\rangle\right|^2+\left|\langle\chi_{i0}^{e}\mid\chi_{fm}^{e;y}\rangle\right|^2\right]\delta\left(\varepsilon_{fm}^{e}-\varepsilon_{f0}^{e}-\hbar\omega\right) \tag*{(11)}

for absorption, whereby the degeneracy is in the final state. Here, the xx and yy superscripts refer to ionic prefactors in Eq. (5), and εfme\varepsilon_{fm}^{e} represents the energy of the mm-th vibronic quantum level in the electronic state ff.

The spectral function for symmetry-preserving a1a_1 modes [Eq. (9)] was computed using the HR theory and the method of generating functions. This approach involves calculating partial HR factors SkS_k and the spectral density of electron–phonon coupling, which is defined as S(ℏω)=∑kSkδ(ℏω−ℏωk)S(\hbar\omega)=\sum_k S_k\delta(\hbar\omega-\hbar\omega_k). The spectral function Aa1A_{a_1} is then derived from this spectral density using a time-domain generating function formalism. The methodology for calculating SkS_k and Aa1A_{a_1} is well established and described in detail in Refs. [17, 18, 57].

For the degenerate ee-symmetry modes [Eqs. (10) and (11)], the spectral function was obtained by explicitly solving the vibronic problem in the form of Eq. (5) and evaluating the overlaps between the vibrational wave functions described by Eqs. (2) and (5). The delta functions in Eqs. (10) and (11) were replaced with Gaussian functions of width 3.5 meV to account for finite broadening. For benchmarking purposes, we also computed the spectral function for emission pertaining to JT active ee modes using the HR theory with Eq. (9), instead of Eq. (10). In this approach, the contribution of ee modes is approximated by treating the minimum of APES for ee degrees of freedom in the initial state as the minimum of harmonic potential. This approximation enables the estimation of HR parameters. Although this method is not rigorous, it offers a reasonable approximation within zero-temperature theory for an initial state that is JT active, provided the total vibronic coupling strength, Ktot2K_{\mathrm{tot}}^{2}, lies within the range of about 0.5–1 [18].

Acknowledgements

Financial support was kindly provided by the Research Council of Norway and the University of Oslo through the frontier research project QuTe (no. 325573, FriPro ToppForskprogram). The work of MEB was supported by an ETH Zürich Postdoctoral Fellowship. Computational resources were provided by supercomputer GALAX of the Center for Physical Sciences and Technology, Lithuania, and the High Performance Computing Center “HPC Saulėtekis” in the Faculty of Physics, Vilnius University.

Author Contributions

LR, LV, and MEB designed the research. VŽ, RS, and LR wrote the codes and performed the electron–phonon coupling calculations with supervision by MEB and LR. VŽ performed the ZPL, ZFS, APES, and DWF calculations with supervision by MEB and LR. VŽ and LR analyzed the data. VŽ, MEB, and LR wrote the manuscript with support and editing from all authors.

Competing Interests

The authors declare no competing interests.

Supplementary Information

Electronic Structure of Basal Divacancies

The electronic structure of neutral basal divacancies (hkhk-VV0\mathrm{VV}^{0} and khkh-VV0\mathrm{VV}^{0}) is presented in Supplementary Figure 1. The three lowest-lying molecular orbitals in the bandgap are derived from dangling carbon bonds. In the ground state these basal divacancies exhibit reduced C1hC_{1h} symmetry with molecular orbitals that can either have a′a^{\prime} or a′′a^{\prime\prime} irreducible representations. The hkhk divacancy displays three lower-lying levels within the band gap, ordered from lowest to highest energy as a′(1)a^{\prime}(1), a′′a^{\prime\prime}, and a′(2)a^{\prime}(2) respectively (see Supplementary Figure 1). The orbital symmetries of the ground state khkh divacancy, arranged from lowest to highest energy, are denoted as a′(1)a^{\prime}(1), a′(2)a^{\prime}(2), and a′′a^{\prime\prime} while the excited state of the khkh divacancy has C1C_{1} symmetry with aa-symmetry orbitals (see Supplementary Figure 1). For the hkhk divacancy, the ground state 3A′′^{3}A^{\prime\prime} can be described by a single-determinant wave function ∣a′(1)aˉ′(1)a′′a′(2)∣\lvert a^{\prime}(1)\bar{a}^{\prime}(1)a^{\prime\prime}a^{\prime}(2)\rvert while the excited state will be 3A′^{3}A^{\prime} with a single-determinant wave function ∣a′(1)a′′aˉ′′a′(2)∣\lvert a^{\prime}(1)a^{\prime\prime}\bar{a}^{\prime\prime}a^{\prime}(2)\rvert. For the khkh divacancy the ground state has A′′A^{\prime\prime} orbital symmetry, designated as 3A′′^{3}A^{\prime\prime}, whereas the excited triplet state with AA orbital symmetry is denoted as 3A^{3}A.

Schematic representation of single-particle defect levels in the band gap of 4H-SiC for basal divacancies

Supplementary Figure 1. Description of electronic structure of basal divacancies. a Schematic representation of single-particle defect levels in the band gap of 4H-SiC showing the occupancy of these levels in the ground 3A′′^{3}A^{\prime\prime} state and excited 3A′^{3}A^{\prime} state of hkhk-VV0\mathrm{VV}^{0}. b Schematic representation of single-particle defect levels in the band gap of 4H-SiC showing the occupancy of these levels in the ground 3A′′^{3}A^{\prime\prime} state and excited 3A^{3}A state of khkh-VV0\mathrm{VV}^{0}.

hhhhkkkkhkhkkhkh
∣μˉ⊥∣2|\bar{\mu}_{\perp}|^{2}27.1625.8133.156.32
∣μˉ∥∣2|\bar{\mu}_{\parallel}|^{2}00045.56

Supplementary Table 1. Transition dipole moments (in units of Debye2^{2}) for each divacancy configuration for absorption.

Transition Dipole Moments

Perpendicular (μ⊥\mu_{\perp}) and parallel (μ∥\mu_{\parallel}) transition dipole moments (TDM), calculated using the r2r^{2}SCAN density functional, are presented in Supplementary Table 1. The transition dipole moments are estimated using the expression for molecular orbital states as

μ=⟨ψi∣q r∣ψj⟩,(12)\mu= \langle\psi_i | q\,r | \psi_j \rangle, \tag*{(12)}

where the Slater–Condon rule enables evaluation of the transition dipole moment for Kohn–Sham single-particle states, ψi\psi_i and ψj\psi_j, rather than for many-electron states, Ψi\Psi_i and Ψj\Psi_j. Here, ψi\psi_i and ψj\psi_j are computed using single-particle Kohn–Sham orbitals obtained from the triplet electronic configuration, a standard approach in density functional theory calculations.

Zero-Phonon Line Energies and Zero-Field Splitting

Comparison of calculated and experimental zero-phonon line (ZPL) energies for four divacancy configurations are presented in Supplementary Table 2. Our ZPL values were computed using SCAN and r2r^{2}SCAN functionals. Previous theoretical ZPL energy predictions for available divacancy configurations in 4H-SiC with different density functionals are also presented in the table, along with brief computational details shown below. Similarly, Supplementary Table 3 presents the zero-field splitting (ZFS) values in the same manner. From the mean absolute errors, we can observe that SCAN and r2r^{2}SCAN functionals enhance the accuracy compared to other calculations and come closest to the experimental values while requiring only a fraction of the computational cost needed for hybrid functionals.

hhhhkkkkhkhkkhkhMAE
This workSCAN1.3361.2711.3201.2790.026
This workr2^{2}SCAN1.3351.2851.3281.2920.024
Previous theoretical workPBE1.358a^{a}1.321a^{a}1.320a^{a}1.376a^{a}0.052
Previous theoretical work1.387(1.682)b^{b}1.349(1.635)b^{b}1.306(1.580)b^{b}1.356(1.641)b^{b}0.064(0.335)
Previous theoretical workHSE1.329c^{c}1.307c^{c}1.363c^{c}1.314c^{c}0.033
Expt. [1]1.3361.3051.3341.222

Supplementary Table 3. Calculated and experimental zero-field splitting (ZFS) values (in units of GHz) computed using different levels of theory for the neutral divacancy centers in 4H-SiC. Previous theoretical predictions on ZFS values are also shown. MAE is the mean absolute error (in units of GHz).

hhhhkkkkhkhkkhkhMAE
This workSCAN1.1291.1231.1411.1030.021
This workr2r^2SCAN1.0791.0811.1001.0620.035
Previous theoretical workPBE0.92a0.92^{a}0.94a0.94^{a}0.97a0.97^{a}0.95a0.95^{a}0.170
Previous theoretical workPBE0.937b0.937^{b}0.951b0.951^{b}0.979b0.979^{b}—0.158
Previous theoretical workHSE1.056a1.056^{a}1.044a1.044^{a}1.103a1.103^{a}1.081a1.081^{a}0.044
Previous theoretical workHSE1.221b1.221^{b}1.218b1.218^{b}1.269b1.269^{b}—0.122
Previous theoretical work1.13c1.13^{c}1.14c1.14^{c}1.21c1.21^{c}1.24c1.24^{c}0.065
Previous theoretical workDDH1.196b1.196^{b}1.201b1.201^{b}1.259b1.259^{b}—0.105
Expt. [1]1.0951.0961.1501.119

Table S2. Calculated and experimental zero-phonon line (ZPL) energies (in units of eV) for spin-conserving transitions computed using different levels of theory for the neutral divacancy centers in 4H-SiC. Previous theoretical predictions on ZPL energies are also shown. MAE denotes the mean absolute error (in units of eV).

Details on Calculation of Adiabatic Potential Energy Surfaces

To obtain the adiabatic potential energy surface (APES) of the lower branch of the 3E^{3}E state, depicted in Figure 3a of the main text, we first calculated the potential energy curve (PEC) to obtain the KK (elastic force constant), FF (linear vibronic constant), and GG (quadratic vibronic constant) parameters. At first, two calculations were performed: one where the geometry was relaxed with the a1ex1.5ey1.5a_{1}e_{x}^{1.5}e_{y}^{1.5} electronic configuration, maintaining the C3vC_{3v} symmetry, and another where the geometry was relaxed with the a1ex2ey1a_{1}e_{x}^{2}e_{y}^{1} electronic configuration, allowing the symmetry to break and the system to relax to a Jahn–Teller minimum with C1hC_{1h} symmetry. We then obtained

the projected displacements along the ee-symmetry breaking direction between these two relaxed structures. We calculated the mass-weighted displacements ΔQ\Delta Q (amu0.5^{0.5}Å) between these two equilibrium geometries to be 0.519 (amu0.5^{0.5}Å) for the hhhh-VV0^{0} and 0.472 for kkkk-VV0^{0}.

We generated new geometries to probe the potential energy surface along the symmetry-breaking direction by systematically displacing the atoms along the exe_x component of the ee-symmetry-breaking mode. This was achieved by projecting the displacements onto the exe_x direction using the irreducible representation matrices of the C3vC_{3v} point group. The displacements were then scaled by a range of factors (from -1.5 to 1.5 in increments of 0.1) to create a series of geometries along the APES. The resulting structures were then used as inputs for further single-shot VASP calculations with a1ex2ey1a_1e_x^2e_y^1 electronic configuration to map out the potential energy curve. At the C3vC_{3v} geometry, the calculations did not converge due to electronic degeneracy. However, the results from other geometries were sufficient to fit the computed energy values using Equation 1 as outlined in the main text. We found the corresponding vibronic coupling constants to be K=0.641K = 0.641 eV/Å2^{2}, F=0.266F = 0.266 eV/Å, and G=0.064G = 0.064 eV/Å2^{2} for the hhhh divacancy. For the kkkk divacancy, these parameters were

K=0.701K = 0.701 eV/Å2^{2}, F=0.272F = 0.272 eV/Å, and G=0.061G = 0.061 eV/Å2^{2}.

Supplementary Note 5: Benchmarking the diagonalization of the Jahn–Teller Hamiltonian

We studied the convergence of calculated absorption lineshapes for the optical transition from 3A2^{3}A_{2} to 3E^{3}E, focusing on the parameters that define the Jahn–Teller (JT) Hamiltonian basis. In particular, we examined the convergence of absorption lineshapes for axial divacancies hhhh–VV0^{0} and kkkk–VV0^{0}, while varying the number of effective modes NeffN_{\mathrm{eff}} (see Supplementary Figure S2) and the number of excited phonons ntotn_{\mathrm{tot}} (see Supplementary Figure 3). The theoretical framework for vibronic broadening of optical lineshapes in A→EA \to E transitions and the analysis of multi-mode E⊗(e⊕e⊕⋯ )E \otimes(e \oplus e \oplus\cdots) JT systems is detailed in Ref. [7, 8]. Our results show that the absorption lineshapes for axial divacancies in 4H-SiC converge when Neff=9N_{\mathrm{eff}} = 9 and ntot=6n_{\mathrm{tot}} = 6.

Convergence of calculated absorption lineshapes for hh–VV$^{0}$ and kk–VV$^{0}$ with $N_{\mathrm{eff}}=7$, $9$, and $11$

Figure S2. Supplementary Figure 2. Convergence of calculated absorption lineshapes depending on the number of effective JT modes. Convergence of the theoretical normalized luminescence lineshapes (in arbitrary units) for axial divacancies (hhhh–VV0^{0} and kkkk–VV0^{0}) calculated using dynamical Jahn–Teller theory with respect to the number of effective modes NeffN_{\mathrm{eff}}. The total number of excited phonons used for each lineshape was ntot=6n_{\mathrm{tot}} = 6.

Convergence of calculated absorption lineshapes for axial divacancies

Supplementary Figure 3. Convergence of calculated absorption lineshapes depending on the number of excited phonons. Convergence of the theoretical normalized luminescence lineshapes (in arbitrary units) for axial divacancies (hhhh–VV0VV^{0} and kkkk–VV0VV^{0}) calculated using dynamical Jahn–Teller theory with respect to the number of excited phonons ntotn_{\mathrm{tot}}. The total number of effective modes used for each lineshape was Neff=9N_{\mathrm{eff}} = 9.

Supplementary Note 6: Details of the embedding methodology

The force constant embedding methodology outlined in Refs. [7, 9] was used to examine the vibrational properties of large supercells. This method uses the short-range interatomic interactions in semiconductors to create a Hessian matrix for supercells with thousands of atoms. When constructing the Hessian matrix elements, the following criteria are used. If pairs of atoms are within a cutoff radius rdr_{d} from any vacancy, matrix elements from the actual (6×6×2)(6 \times6 \times2) defect supercell are used. Otherwise, if two atoms are within another specified cutoff radius rbr_b, elements from the Hessian matrix of the bulk (8×8×38 \times8 \times3) supercell are used, as shown in Supplementary Figure 4. In this study, we chose rb=12.200r_b = 12.200 Å and rd=7.346r_d = 7.346 Å.

Embedding methodology for defect vibrational structure calculations

Supplementary Figure 4. Embedding methodology. Illustration of the force constant matrix embedding methodology for defect vibrational structure calculations.

References

  1. [1]Falk, A. L. et al. Polytype control of spin qubits in silicon carbide. Nature communications 4, 1819 (2013).DOI
  2. [2]Davidsson, J. et al. First principles predictions of magneto-optical data for semiconductor point defect identification: the case of divacancy defects in 4h–sic. New Journal of Physics 20, 023035 (2018).DOI
  3. [3]Jin, Y. et al. Photoluminescence spectra of point defects in semiconductors: Validation of first-principles calculations. Physical Review Materials 5, 084603 (2021).DOI
  4. [4]Gordon, L., Janotti, A. & Van de Walle, C. G. Defects as qubits in 3c− and 4h−SiC. Physical Review B 92, 045208 (2015).DOI
  5. [5]Falk, A. L. et al. Electrically and mechanically tunable electron spins in silicon carbide color centers. Physical Review Letters 112, 187601 (2014).pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/24856721
  6. [6]Seo, H., Ma, H., Govoni, M. & Galli, G. Designing defect-based qubit candidates in wide-gap binary semiconductors for solid-state quantum technologies. Physical Review Materials 1, 075002 (2017).DOI
  7. [7]Razinkovas, L., Doherty, M. W., Manson, N. B., Van de Walle, C. G. & Alkauskas, A. Vibrational and vibronic structure of isolated point defects: The nitrogen-vacancy center in diamond. Physical Review B 104, 045303 (2021).DOI
  8. [8]Razinkovas, L. Vibrational properties and photoionization of color centers in diamond: theory and ab initio calculations. Ph.D. thesis, Center for Physical Sciences and Technology (FTMC) (2021). URL https://talpykla.elaba.lt/elaba-fedora/objects/elaba:114210427/datastreams/MAIN/content.DOI
  9. [9]Alkauskas, A., Buckley, B. B., Awschalom, D. D. & Van de Walle, C. G. First-principles theory of the luminescence lineshape for the triplet transition in diamond nv centres. New Journal of Physics 16, 073026 (2014).DOI

Paper details

vlnc:W_u2cqmz2u
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 0

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Physics and Astronomy

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents