In this paper
AbstractIntroductionThe JAM model and simulations at GeVMoments, cumulants, and factorial cumulantsCentrality-Independent Genuine Cumulant Analysis Framework (CIGAR)Results and DiscussionSummaryAcknowledgementReferencesWorksPhysics and Astronomy
Proton Number Fluctuations in Au+Au and Ag+Ag Collisions at : A JAM Model Study
Abstract
Proton number fluctuations in low-energy heavy-ion collisions are sensitive to nuclear interactions, baryon-number conservation, and fluctuations of the collision volume, all of which can complicate searches for critical phenomena. We investigate proton-number cumulants and factorial cumulants up to fourth order in Au+Au and Ag+Ag collisions at using the JAM hadronic transport model in cascade and mean-field modes. We employ the Centrality-Independent Genuine Cumulant Analysis fRamework (CIGAR) to suppress the initial-volume fluctuations and compare its results with those obtained using conventional centrality-bin-width corrections. CIGAR closely reproduces the participant-number-based reference, whereas the multiplicity-based analysis exhibits substantial deviations. In both collision systems, the ratios , , and generally decrease toward more central collisions and with increasing rapidity acceptance, while the mean field modifies their magnitudes. A simplified treatment of light-nucleus formation through probabilistic proton removal shifts toward less negative values. These results establish a hadronic-transport reference without an explicit QCD critical contribution and highlight the importance of controlling centrality fluctuations, acceptance, and light-nucleus formation when interpreting experimental measurements at high baryon density.
Introduction
Mapping the phase structure of strongly interacting matter is a central objective of relativistic heavy-ion physics. The QCD phase diagram is commonly expressed in terms of temperature and baryon chemical potential, and theoretical studies suggest the possible existence of a critical point at the endpoint of a first-order phase-transition line [1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11, 12, 13]. Higher-order cumulants of conserved quantities, including net-baryon number, net-electric charge, and net-strangeness, are especially promising observables because of their sensitivity to multi-particle correlations and, near a critical point, to the correlation length [14, 15, 16, 17, 18]. Experimentally, higher-order cumulants of net-proton, net-charge, and net-kaon multiplicity distributions have been measured by the STAR Collaboration across the RHIC beam-energy scan (BES), including precision net-proton fluctuation results, providing the primary experimental motivation for systematic fluctuation studies at finite baryon chemical potential [19, 20, 21, 22, 23, 24]. Nonmonotonic collision-energy dependence has therefore been proposed as a possible signature of critical behavior [25, 26]. Establishing reliable noncritical reference calculations is essential, particularly in the high-baryon-density region reached at low collision energies.
The HADES Collaboration has measured proton-number fluctuations in Au+Au collisions at GeV, providing a valuable experimental constraint at very high baryon chemical potential [27]. At this energy, nuclear interactions and potentially the nuclear liquid-gas transition may influence fluctuation observables in addition to any effect associated with the QCD phase structure [28]. Throughout this paper, denotes the th-order ordinary proton-number cumulant and the corresponding factorial cumulant. The HADES notation differs: the quantities denoted and in Ref. [27] correspond to and , respectively, in the present work. HADES reported proton cumulants up to fourth order and observed an approximately power-law dependence of factorial cumulants on the mean proton number, , suggestive of substantial multi-proton correlations in momentum space [27].
At such low energies, however, measured proton-number fluctuations also reflect baryon stopping, resonance production and decay, hadronic rescattering, nuclear cluster formation, the conservation of baryon number, fluctuations in the collision volume, and experimental acceptance and efficiency [29]. Separating these contributions from possible critical correlations requires a microscopic description of the underlying hadronic dynamics. The JAM transport model provides such a description and has been used to investigate the influence of rescattering, decays, centrality fluctuations, and deuteron formation on proton cumulants at low collision energies [30, 31, 32, 33, 34]. These JAM-based studies are directly relevant to the cumulant and correlation-function measurements reported by STAR for net-proton, proton, and antiproton multiplicity distributions across BES energies, as well as to the cumulants and factorial cumulants measured at GeV [23, 35, 36]. Extending these calculations to GeV is particularly timely in view of the HADES results. This is further reinforced by STAR measurements of proton and net-proton cumulants down to GeV and by broader experimental reviews of fluctuation results from the RHIC BES program, which together define the experimental landscape that transport-model baselines need to address [36, 37].
A further challenge is that conventional centrality definitions become less precise as the collision energy decreases. Because charged-particle multiplicities are relatively small, residual collision-volume fluctuations can significantly bias higher-order cumulants even after applying standard centrality-bin-width corrections. We therefore analyze the JAM events using the Centrality-Independent Genuine Cumulant Analysis fRamework (CIGAR) [38]. This approach reconstructs centrality-resolved proton-number distributions from an overall multiplicity distribution using an Edgeworth-based parameterization and an optimization procedure combining differential evolution with Bayesian inference. In the present study, we examine how well this method suppresses initial-volume-fluctuation biases at GeV.
We systematically compare Au+Au and Ag+Ag collisions in cascade and mean-field modes, focusing on the centrality and rapidity-acceptance dependence of ordinary and factorial cumulants. We also estimate, using a simplified proton-removal prescription, how the depletion of free protons by light-nucleus formation may modify these observables. Section II describes the JAM simulation and kinematic acceptance; Sec. III defines the fluctuation observables; Sec. IV outlines the CIGAR analysis; Sec. V presents the results; and Sec. VI summarizes our conclusions.
The JAM model and simulations at GeV
The Jet AA Microscopic Transport Model (JAM) is a nonequilibrium hadronic transport approach applicable over a broad range of collision energies [30, 31]. It propagates hadrons and resonances through successive microscopic interactions and includes energy-dependent mechanisms for inelastic hadron-hadron collisions, such as resonance excitation at low energies and string excitation at higher energies. JAM has previously been employed to investigate proton-number fluctuations and the influence of hadronic processes on higher-order cumulants [33, 34, 39].
We simulate Au+Au () and Ag+Ag () collisions at GeV using both the cascade and mean-field versions of JAM [27]. The impact parameter is sampled over fm. In cascade mode (MeanField:mode = 0), hadrons propagate between binary scatterings and resonance decays without an explicit mean-field potential. In mean-field mode, their propagation is additionally modified by a density-dependent nuclear potential. The single-particle Hamiltonian and the corresponding equations of motion are given in Eqs. (1) and (2) of the original manuscript. The interaction potential, Eq. (3), contains isoscalar density-dependent and isovector symmetry terms.
where is the momentum, denotes the mass of stable hadrons and, for resonances, the effective mass determined by the resonance mass distribution, and is a coordinate-dependent potential.
The mean-field potential is calculated as a function of the local density,
In Eq. (3), is the local baryon density evaluated in the Eckart frame, is the corresponding isospin density, and is the saturation density. The symmetry-potential contribution has opposite signs for neutrons and protons. The potential acts on baryons; mesonic mean fields and electromagnetic Coulomb and Lorentz forces are not included in this setup. We use the soft, momentum-independent nuclear equation of state with incompressibility MeV and parameters MeV, MeV, , and MeV [32, 40]. These settings follow Ref. [41].
The HADES Collaboration has measured proton-number fluctuations in Au+Au collisions at GeV at GSI [27]. To compare our JAM calculations with these data, we adopt the same proton acceptance as in the HADES analysis. In the fixed-target laboratory frame, protons are selected with and GeV/, and the analysis of proton-number fluctuations is performed in GeV/ and , with and –. Here and in what follows, denotes the rapidity in the nucleon-nucleon center-of-mass frame, , where is the laboratory-frame rapidity and is the rapidity of the nucleon-nucleon center-of-mass frame in the laboratory; the interval therefore corresponds to . Figure 1 shows the accepted phase space in the – plane for Au+Au and Ag+Ag collisions at GeV in both cascade and mean-field modes. The red boxes indicate the largest rapidity window used in the present analysis; varying within this window allows us to study the rapidity dependence of the proton cumulants. The angular cut corresponds to . Since the HADES results and their physics implications were discussed in § 1, here we focus on the JAM implementation and the acceptance used for the comparison.
Figure 1. Proton transverse momentum versus center-of-mass rapidity in Au+Au and Ag+Ag collisions at GeV, calculated with the JAM model. The upper (lower) panels show Au+Au (Ag+Ag), and the left (right) panels show cascade (mean-field) mode. Red rectangles mark GeV/ and corresponding to .
| mode | cascade | mean-field | |
| Events(Au+Au) /million | 50 | 23 | |
| Events(Ag+Ag) / million | 36 | 23 |
Table 1. Numbers of generated JAM events (in millions) for Au+Au and Ag+Ag collisions at GeV in cascade and mean-field modes.
The event samples comprise 50 million Au+Au and 36 million Ag+Ag collisions in cascade mode, and 23 million events for each system in mean-field mode (Table I). Unless stated otherwise, the fluctuation analysis uses the acceptance GeV/ and .
Moments, cumulants, and factorial cumulants
The shape of a probability distribution can be characterized by its moments. The variance measures the width of the distribution, while the skewness and kurtosis quantify, respectively, its asymmetry and its peakedness around the mean.
For an event-by-event proton multiplicity with probability distribution , the moment-generating function is defined as
The -order moment is obtained from the Taylor expansion of around :
Introducing the deviation from the mean, , the th-order central moment is defined as
The cumulant generating function is
and the th-order cumulant is defined by the Taylor expansion
The first four cumulants are related to the central moments by
For , the cumulants can be obtained recursively:
The mean, variance, skewness, and excess kurtosis are then
The first two cumulants are the mean and variance, and . The third and fourth cumulants quantify the asymmetry and excess kurtosis of the distribution, through and in Eqs (11).
Ratios of cumulants are useful because the leading extensive contribution can cancel under suitable assumptions. The commonly studied ratios are
Here, we use in place of , which can be written as , to facilitate a common normalization by the mean proton number. We report , , and throughout.
Factorial cumulants related to by
quantify connected multiplicity correlations of a given order. For a Poisson distribution, for all . Thus, nonzero higher-order factorial cumulants provide a direct measure of deviations from an independent-emission Poisson baseline. We report the normalized quantities , , and alongside the ordinary cumulant ratios. They therefore isolate genuine -particle correlations beyond the Poisson baseline, which is particularly useful when analyzing proton-number fluctuations in heavy-ion collisions.
Centrality-Independent Genuine Cumulant Analysis Framework (CIGAR)
We employ the centrality-independent analysis framework of Ref. [38], referred to as CIGAR in the present study, to mitigate biases associated with event-by-event fluctuations of the initial collision volume. The effects of initial-volume fluctuations are more pronounced in low-energy heavy-ion collisions than at high energies. Rather than assigning each event to a centrality class using a single measured multiplicity estimator, the framework models the observed proton-number distribution as a superposition of distributions associated with narrower centrality intervals. The parameters of these component distributions are inferred from the full multiplicity distribution.
Statistically, the probability density function of a distribution can be approximated by a Gram–Charlier series expressed in terms of its cumulants. As a practical solution to the moment problem, the Edgeworth expansion approximates around a Gaussian distribution and incorporates higher-order cumulants to refine the shape of the distribution.
Let denote the standard normal density,
The Gram–Charlier series can be written as
where the coefficients are given by
The Chebyshev–Hermite polynomials are defined as
Equivalently, the Edgeworth expansion expresses directly in terms of the standardized cumulants , where is the th cumulant in the notation of this paper and is the standard deviation. Up to fourth order, the expansion reads
where is the mean, is the skewness, and is the excess kurtosis.
To reconstruct the proton-number distribution for a given centrality interval, CIGAR optimizes a set of parameters such that the sum of all sub-distributions closely matches the simulated or measured total distribution. A differential evolution algorithm is employed for the global search of the parameter space. Within this framework, the cumulants and their ratios are parameterized as functions of the centrality bin index (ordered from the most central to the most peripheral interval):
Equation (19) shows the adopted parameterization strategy, in which the cumulants are described by low-order polynomials. This approach reduces the number of free parameters, stabilizes the optimization, and preserves the physical interpretation of the extracted cumulants.
Figure 2 compares the input JAM proton-number distributions with their reconstructed counterparts for both collision systems and both JAM modes. within the acceptance GeV/ and . The black solid circles represent the proton-number distributions from the JAM model. The colored dashed lines each correspond to a fitted sub-distribution over a 2.5% centrality interval, ranging from 0–2.5% to 57.5–60%. The black solid line represents the 60%–100% peripheral events, and the red solid line is the sum of all individual contributions, i.e., the total fitted distribution. From the fitted parameters of these sub-distributions, the cumulants are extracted for each centrality interval and are presented in § 5.
Figure 2. Proton-number distributions and fit results in Au+Au and Ag+Ag collisions at GeV from the JAM model. The first and second rows correspond to Au+Au and Ag+Ag collisions, respectively, and the first and second columns correspond to cascade and mean-field modes, respectively. Black solid circles represent the proton-number distributions from JAM. Colored dashed lines show the fitted sub-distributions for consecutive 2.5% centrality bins, from 0–2.5% to 57.5–60%. The black solid line indicates the 60%–100% peripheral events, and the red solid line is the sum of all sub-distributions. The proton transverse momentum and rapidity windows are GeV/ and , respectively.
In addition to CIGAR method, we also performed calculation with the conventional method using centrality bin width correction (CBWC) [42]. The CBWC calculation are performed with both and RefMult3 which is a reference multiplicity excluding protons to avoid auto-correlation effect [42]. The -based CBWC results are used as baseline calculations without volume fluctuations.
Results and Discussion
Figure 3 compares the centrality dependence of the –, –, the ordinary cumulant ratios, and the corresponding factorial cumulant ratios for Au+Au collisions at GeV from the JAM model in cascade mode, within and GeV/. The -based CBWC results (red open squares) are used as a benchmark, since centrality bins defined by are least affected by fluctuations of the centrality estimator. The RefMult3-based CBWC results (blue solid triangles) and the CIGAR results (black solid circles) are then compared with this benchmark. In all panels and for all centrality bins, the CIGAR results closely follow the -based benchmark, including for the higher-order observables. In contrast, the RefMult3-based CBWC results systematically deviate from the benchmark. At this low collision energy, charged-pion and charged-kaon yields are relatively small, reducing the multiplicity available for centrality determination and degrading the resolution of a reference-multiplicity estimator. Residual fluctuations in the number of participants can therefore significantly affect the conventionally corrected cumulants. The agreement between CIGAR and the -based benchmark supports the use of the reconstruction method to reduce such biases arising from initial-volume fluctuations in low-energy proton-number fluctuation analyses.
Figure 3. Centrality dependence of the proton-number cumulants (, , , and ), factorial cumulants (, , , and ), cumulant ratios (, , and ), and factorial cumulant ratios (, , and ) from the JAM model in cascade mode for Au+Au collisions at GeV. Results from CIGAR (Black solid circles) are compared with CBWC using (red open squares) and RefMult3 (blue solid triangles). The acceptance is and GeV/.
This comparison provides a useful closure test within the chosen JAM sample. It provides qualitative support that the CIGAR framework remains effective in the low-energy, low-multiplicity regime at GeV, where initial-volume fluctuations are most pronounced, and indicates that the method is applicable to experimental multiplicity distributions in the energy region accessed by HADES. However, quantifying the residual systematic uncertainty of the reconstructed cumulants is beyond the scope of the present work and would additionally require tests of the Edgeworth truncation, parameterization flexibility, reconstruction stability, and possible model dependence. Such checks are particularly relevant before applying the method to experimental multiplicity distributions in future analyses.
Figure 4 shows the centrality dependence of the cumulant ratios (, , and ) and factorial cumulant ratios (, , and ) as a function of from the JAM model at GeV, within and GeV/. Black solid circles, red open boxes, blue solid triangles, and magenta open crosses correspond to Au+Au cascade, Au+Au mean-field, Ag+Ag cascade, and Ag+Ag mean-field, respectively. For a given centrality interval, the cascade-mode results extend to larger than the mean-field results, and this difference is more pronounced in Au+Au than in Ag+Ag collisions. The values in Au+Au collisions are systematically larger than those in Ag+Ag collisions, as expected from the larger mass number of Au compared with Ag. For all four simulation configurations, , , and generally decrease as the collisions become more central.
Figure 4. Proton-number cumulant ratios (, , ) and factorial cumulant ratios (, , ) from the JAM model at GeV as a function of . Symbols represent Au+Au cascade (black solid circles), Au+Au mean field (red open squares), Ag+Ag cascade (blue solid triangles), and Ag+Ag mean field (magenta open crosses). The acceptance is and GeV/.
The nuclear mean field produces observable changes in several cumulant ratios. In the 10–60% centrality region, , , , and are larger in cascade mode than in the mean-field. In the most central 0–5% events, by contrast, the mean-field values of , , and exceed the corresponding cascade values, whereas the mean-field values of and are lower. Within the statistical uncertainties, shows no robust separation between the two transport modes. Similar decreases of higher-order cumulant ratios toward central events have been observed in other hadronic-transport calculations [43, 44]. Such behavior can arise from the interplay of baryon-number conservation, the fraction of baryons contained within the measured acceptance, and the hadronic collision dynamics.
In peripheral collisions, the mean-field values of , , and are consistent with unity for both collision systems and are lower than the corresponding cascade values. The behavior of is similar to that of : its peripheral mean-field values are close to zero and lower than the cascade values. The differences between the cascade and mean-field results can be understood as follows. In cascade mode, nucleons propagate along straight-line trajectories between collisions and the nuclear mean-field potential is absent. In mean-field mode, the attractive nuclear potential and momentum-independent interactions modify the expansion dynamics, leading to a more pronounced collective flow and a different freeze-out geometry [32, 33]. A recent study has shown that at 2.4 GeV the fraction of protons preserving their initial isospin is higher in mean-field mode, whereas the fraction originating from isospin conversion is higher in cascade mode [29]. These different proton-source compositions partly account for the observed mode dependence of the cumulant ratios.
At GeV, a phenomenological freeze-out parameterization gives MeV [45], placing the system in a region where nuclear-matter correlations and possible nuclear liquid-gas transition effects may become relevant. Calculations based on other theoretical approaches have found that nucleon interactions and liquid-gas dynamics can affect higher-order baryon-number cumulants in this energy domain [28]. The present JAM results establish sensitivity to hadronic interactions but do not by themselves identify a phase transition; a dedicated comparison between transport dynamics and models with controlled phase-transition physics would be required.
Figure 5 presents the rapidity dependence of the cumulant ratios (, , and ) and factorial cumulant ratios (, , and ) from the JAM model at GeV, for GeV/ and with –0.5. Black solid circles, red open boxes, blue solid triangles, and magenta open crosses indicate Au+Au cascade, Au+Au mean-field, Ag+Ag cascade, and Ag+Ag mean-field, respectively. For , , , and , all four simulation configurations exhibit a decreasing trend with increasing . For both Au+Au and Ag+Ag collisions, these four ratios in mean-field mode are larger than the corresponding cascade-mode values, except in the range , where in cascade mode is essentially the same as that in mean-field mode. In contrast, increases with for all four simulation configurations, and its mean-field values are lower than the cascade-mode values in both collision systems. This contrasting behavior may partly reflect the different sensitivities of the two-particle and three-particle cumulants to the mean-field-driven collective expansion and to the proton-source composition, which differs between the two modes [29, 32]; a quantitative attribution, however, requires further study. For and , the Ag+Ag values are slightly lower than the Au+Au values, although the difference is small and, for the largest rapidity window, comparable to the statistical uncertainty; a weaker trend is seen for . For , no clear rapidity dependence can be established, and all values are consistent with zero within statistical uncertainties.
Figure 5. Rapidity dependence of the proton-number cumulant ratios (, , ) and factorial cumulant ratios (, , ) from the JAM model at GeV. Symbol definitions are the same as in Figure 4. The transverse-momentum range is GeV/c, and the rapidity window is with ranging from 0.1 to 0.5.
These system-dependent differences may partly arise from the smaller number of participating nucleons in Ag+Ag collisions, which can reduce the baryon-number-conservation constraint and modify the freeze-out dynamics, and may also reflect the different effective rapidity coverage of multi-particle correlations. A quantitative attribution requires further study. These differences are, however, small and not significant at the current statistical accuracy; in the largest rapidity window the two systems agree within about one standard deviation. We therefore do not assign strong significance to these differences. As the rapidity acceptance grows, a larger fraction of the baryons participates in the measured proton multiplicity, increasing sensitivity to global conservation constraints and to correlations spanning the accepted phase space [29, 43]. Changes in proton-source composition and freeze-out dynamics may further influence the observed acceptance dependence. The distinct trends of and suggest that different correlation orders respond differently to these mechanisms, but a quantitative decomposition would require additional differential studies.
Light nuclei are not produced in the present JAM simulations. Previous work has shown that the effect of light nuclei such as deuterons on proton cumulants is similar to that of an efficiency [34]. To estimate the possible depletion of measured free protons by cluster formation, we perform a simple test in which a fraction of the protons is removed event by event according to an efficiency factor. For Au+Au collisions at GeV, the yields of protons, deuterons, tritons, and other particles measured by HADES are listed in Table I of Ref. [46]. Since deuterons are the most abundant species after protons, we estimate the fraction of protons remaining as free protons after deuteron formation from the measured deuteron-to-proton ratio, , obtaining for Au+Au collisions. For Ag+Ag collisions at the same energy, we use a rough estimate of obtained from an unpublished thermal-model calculation. Because this procedure does not model correlated nucleon coalescence or event-by-event cluster production, it should be interpreted only as a qualitative sensitivity test rather than a physical correction or a quantitative prediction.
Figure 6 presents the cumulant ratios (, , and ) and factorial cumulant ratios (, , and ) obtained with CIGAR in central collisions from the JAM model at GeV, for GeV/c. The abscissa is divided into four groups: (1) , w/ D; (2) , w/o D; (3) , w/o D; and (4) , w/o D. Here “w/ D” denotes the original JAM results without light-nuclei formation, and “w/o D” denotes the results after applying the efficiency factor to mimic the removal of free protons due to light-nuclei formation. For , , , and , group (1) gives the lowest values, groups (2) and (3) are higher, and group (4) gives the highest values. Thus, both enlarging the rapidity window and not removing a fraction of the protons by forming deuterons will decrease these four ratios, qualitatively similar to the effect of reducing the rapidity window shown in Figure 5. For , the values in group (1) are about to , those in group (2) increase to about to , those in group (3) increase to about to , with the two Au+Au results becoming positive, and those in group (4) reach about to . The differences between Au+Au and Ag+Ag and between cascade and mean-field modes are smallest in group (4). For , group (1) gives the largest values. For , all results are consistent with zero within uncertainties, except for the Ag+Ag cascade result in group (3), approximately , which remains close to zero and does not imply any significant physical effect.
Figure 6. Proton-number cumulant ratios (, , and ) and factorial cumulant ratios (, , and ) in central collisions from the JAM model at GeV, for GeV/. Black solid circles, red open boxes, blue solid triangles, and magenta open crosses indicate Au+Au cascade, Au+Au mean-field, Ag+Ag cascade, and Ag+Ag mean-field, respectively. The abscissa is divided into four groups: (1) , w/ D; (2) , w/ D; (3) , w/o D; and (4) , w/o D. Here “w/ D” denotes the original JAM results without light-nuclei formation, and “w/o D” denotes the results after applying an efficiency factor to mimic the removal of free protons due to deuteron-like light-nuclei formation.
These results suggest that the negative values obtained without light-nuclei formation may partly originate from the baryon-number-conservation constraint, which is stronger for a larger acceptance and a larger number of free protons. Reducing the rapidity window or removing a fraction of the protons weakens this constraint and drives toward less negative values. In addition, in group (4), where both the acceptance and the number of free protons are smallest, the differences between Au+Au and Ag+Ag and between cascade and mean-field modes are visibly reduced. This indicates that at smaller acceptance and lower proton multiplicity, the system-size and mean-field effects are diluted and become less significant. A more realistic assessment of light-nucleus production should explicitly model deuteron and triton formation, for example through phase-space coalescence or a Wigner-function-based prescription, and propagate the associated correlations into the fluctuation observables; these improvements can be considered in future work.
Summary
We have investigated proton-number cumulants and factorial cumulants up to fourth order in Au+Au and Ag+Ag collisions at GeV with the JAM hadronic transport model, considering both cascade dynamics and a soft nuclear mean field. By employing the CIGAR framework, we have examined the effects of centrality determination and initial collision-volume fluctuations on these observables and established a simulation-based reference for studies at high baryon density.
Our analysis leads to several main findings. First, the cumulants obtained with CIGAR closely reproduce the -based CBWC benchmark, whereas RefMult3-based CBWC exhibits substantial biases at this low collision energy. Second, , , and generally decrease from peripheral to central collisions in both systems. The nuclear mean field modifies their magnitudes, with differences that depend on collision centrality and cumulant order. Third, increasing the rapidity acceptance suppresses these three ratios in the most central collisions, consistent with an enhanced sensitivity to global baryon-number conservation and other hadronic correlations. The fourth-order factorial-cumulant ratio remains consistent with zero within the present statistical precision for most of the investigated conditions.
We have also explored the possible influence of light-nucleus formation using a simplified proton-removal prescription. This test indicates that reducing the detected free-proton fraction shifts toward less negative values, similar to narrowing the rapidity window. Because the calculation does not explicitly simulate nuclear coalescence, the magnitude of this effect should not be interpreted quantitatively. Future work should incorporate realistic light-nucleus formation, assess the systematic robustness of the CIGAR reconstruction, and apply consistent analysis and acceptance procedures in direct comparisons with HADES data.
Taken together, the results provide a hadronic-transport baseline without an explicit QCD critical contribution and demonstrate that volume fluctuations, nuclear mean fields, baryon-number conservation, experimental acceptance, and free-proton depletion must be controlled when interpreting higher-order proton-number fluctuations at very low collision energies.
Acknowledgement
This work is supported in part by the National Natural Science Foundation of China under Grant No. 12525509, No. 12447102, and the National Key Research and Development Program of China under contract No. 2022YFA1604900, and the Fundamental Research Funds for the Central Universities (XJ2026000302). Yu Zhang was supported by the Guangxi Natural Science Foundation (No. 2025GXNSFBA069067).
References
References
- [1]A. Bzdak, S. Esumi, V. Koch, J. Liao, M. Stephanov, and N. Xu, Phys. Rept. 853, 1 (2020), 1906.00936.
- [2]P. Braun-Munzinger, A. Rustamov, and N. Xu, Ann. Rev. Nucl. Part. Sci. 76, 295 (2026), 2601.18666.
- [3]X. Luo, Q. Wang, N. Xu, and P. Zhuang, eds., Properties of QCD Matter at High Baryon Density (Springer, 2022), ISBN 978-981-19-4440-6, 978-981-19-4443-7, 978-981-19-4441-3.DOI
- [4]V. Koch and V. Vovchenko (2025), 2512.04288.
- [5]D. A. Clarke, P. Dimopoulos, F. Di Renzo, J. Goswami, C. Schmidt, S. Singh, and K. Zambello, Phys. Rev. D 112, L091504 (2025), 2405.10196.
- [6]M. Hippert, J. Grefa, T. A. Manning, J. Noronha, J. Noronha-Hostler, I. Portillo Vazquez, C. Ratti, R. Rougemont, and M. Trujillo, Phys. Rev. D 110, 094006 (2024), 2309.00579.
- [7]W.-j. Fu, J. M. Pawlowski, and F. Rennecke, Phys. Rev. D 101, 054032 (2020), 1909.02991.
- [8]P. J. Gunkel and C. S. Fischer, Phys. Rev. D 104, 054022 (2021), 2106.08356.
- [9]F. Gao and J. M. Pawlowski, Phys. Lett. B 820, 136584 (2021), 2010.13705.
- [10]A. Sorensen and P. Sorensen (2024), 2405.10278.
- [11]R.-G. Cai, S. He, L. Li, and H.-A. Zeng, Sci. China Phys. Mech. Astron. 69, 240414 (2026), 2406.12772.
- [12]L. Zhu, X. Chen, K. Zhou, H. Zhang, and M. Huang, Phys. Rev. D 112, 026019 (2025), 2501.17763.
- [13]Y. Lu, C. S. Fischer, F. Gao, Y.-x. Liu, and J. M. Pawlowski (2026), 2603.09336.
- [14]M. A. Stephanov, Phys. Rev. Lett. 102, 032301 (2009), 0809.3450.
- [15]M. Asakawa and M. Kitazawa, Prog. Part. Nucl. Phys. 90, 299 (2016), 1512.05038.
- [16]M. Kitazawa and X. Luo, Phys. Rev. C 96, 024910 (2017), 1704.04909.
- [17]X. Luo and N. Xu, Nucl. Sci. Tech. 28, 112 (2017), 1701.02105.
- [18]Z. Li, K. Xu, X. Wang, and M. Huang, Eur. Phys. J. C 79, 245 (2019), 1801.09215.
- [19]M. M. Abdallah et al. (STAR), Phys. Rev. Lett. 105, 022023 (2010), 1004.4959.
- [20]L. Adamczyk et al. (STAR), Phys. Rev. Lett. 112, 032302 (2014), 1309.5681.
- [21]L. Adamczyk et al. (STAR), Phys. Rev. Lett. 113, 092301 (2014), 1402.1558.
- [22]J. Adam et al. (STAR), Phys. Rev. Lett. 126, 092301 (2021), [Erratum: PhysRev.Lett. 134, 139902 (2025)], 2001.02852.
- [23]M. Abdallah et al. (STAR), Phys. Rev. C 104, 024902 (2021), [Erratum: Phys.Rev.C 111, 029902 (2025)], 2101.12413.
- [24]B. E. Aboona et al. (STAR), Phys. Rev. Lett. 135, 142301 (2025), 2504.00817.
- [25]Z. Li, Y. Chen, D. Li, and M. Huang, Chin. Phys. C 42, 013103 (2018), 1706.02238.
- [26]W.-j. Fu, X. Luo, J. M. Pawlowski, F. Rennecke, and S. Yin, Phys. Rev. D 111, L031502 (2025), 2308.15508.
- [27]J. Adamczewski-Musch et al. (HADES), Phys. Rev. C 102, 024914 (2020), 2002.08701.
- [28]M. Recchi and S. Yin (2026), 2609.17328.
- [29]S. P. Rode, Phys. Rev. C 114, 034908 (2026), 2609.06502.
- [30]Y. Nara, EPJ Web Conf. 208, 11004 (2019).
- [31]Y. Nara, N. Otuka, A. Ohnishi, K. Niita, and S. Chiba, Phys. Rev. C 61, 024901 (2000), nucl-th/9904059.
- [32]Y. Nara and A. Ohnishi, Phys. Rev. C 105, 014911 (2022), 2109.07594.
- [33]Y. Zhang, S. He, H. Liu, Z. Yang, and X. Luo, Phys. Rev. C 101, 034909 (2020), 1905.01095.
- [34]A. Chatterjee, Y. Zhang, H. Liu, R. Wang, S. He, and X. Luo, Chin. Phys. C 45, 064003 (2021), 2009.03755.
- [35]L. Adamczyk et al. (STAR), Phys. Lett. B 785, 551 (2018), 1709.00773.
- [36]M. Abdallah et al. (STAR), Phys. Rev. C 107, 024908 (2023), 2209.11940.
- [37]J. Chen et al., Nucl. Sci. Tech. 35, 214 (2024), 2407.02935.
- [38]Z. Wang and X. Luo, Phys. Lett. B 871, 139984 (2025), 2505.03666.
- [39]S. He, X. Luo, Y. Nara, S. Esumi, and N. Xu, Phys. Lett. B 762, 296 (2016), 1607.06376.
- [40]M. Isse, A. Ohnishi, N. Otuka, P. K. Sahu, and Y. Nara, Phys. Rev. C 72, 064908 (2005), nucl-th/0502058.
- [41]L.-K. Liu and S. Shi, Phys. Rev. C 112, 064912 (2025), 2508.21577.
- [42]X. Luo, J. Xu, B. Mohanty, and N. Xu, J. Phys. G 40, 105104 (2013), 1302.2332.
- [43]X. Zhang, Y. Zhang, X. Luo, and N. Xu, Chin. Phys. C 50, 011003 (2026), 2506.18832.
- [44]Y. Xu, Z. Wang, Y. Zhang, and X. Luo (2026), 2606.00786.
- [45]J. Cleymans, H. Oeschler, K. Redlich, and S. Wheaton, Phys. Rev. C 73, 034905 (2006), hep-ph/0511094.
- [46]A. Motornenko, J. Steinheimer, V. Vovchenko, R. Stock, and H. Stoecker, Phys. Lett. B 822, 136703 (2021), 2104.06036.





