WorksMathematics
Lehto-type growth conditions and a Picard theorem for the gradient of entire solutions to the Euler – Lagrange equations of variational integrals with linear growth in the plane including a small extension of Moser's Bernstein result
Abstract
We mainly consider entire solutions of the Euler – Lagrange equation for a variational integral with density of linear growth. Assuming a Lehto-type condition at infinity, we show that either is a constant vector or the image of is the whole plane with the possible exception of at most one point. This result is extended to certain energy densities of nearly linear growth. Moreover, we slightly generalize the Bernstein result of Moser.
Introduction
In our note we first discuss entire solutions of the equation
arising as the Euler equation of the variational integral , where is a domain in . Concerning the function we suppose that is of class satisfying
for all with numbers . We further assume ( denoting a positive constant)
and finally add the technical condition
Evidently the second part of (1.2) is just a consequence of inequality (1.4), and (1.5) will follow, if for instance we require
For the choice we have the nonparametric minimal surface case for which (4) holds with , and as it was shown by Bernstein in his famous papers [1], [2], the only entire solutions are the affine functions . This Bernstein property of equation (1) under the assumptions (2), (3) combined with the reverse inequality in (4) was extended independently by Mikljukov [3] and by Farina, Sciunzi and Valdinoci [4]: in [3] the author considers the case actually working with the weaker condition
replacing the opposite inequality in (4), whereas in [4] the authors can cover the case of exponents . The reader being in addition interested in the history of Bernstein’s problem is also referred to the papers [3], [4], and in our note [5] we summarized both approaches in the setting of equation (1), but – as we emphasize again – with (4) being replaced by the opposite inequality.
To our knowledge the validity of Bernstein’s theorem in the presence of condition (4) is an unsolved problem to which we can not present any substantial contribution. Quite the contrary, we start with the discussion of a rather strange behaviour of entire solutions , whose gradients do not grow too fast at infinity: in this case either is an affine function or the image of is the whole plane with at most one exceptional point. More precisely, it holds
Theorem 1.1. Let the conditions (2) – (5) hold for the function , where in (4) we recall that . Assume that is an entire solution of (1) such that
with some constant . Then we have
or: for a point .
Remark 1.2. In the second case of Theorem 1.1 the situation is comparable to the so-called little Picard theorem from complex analysis (see, e.g. [6], Theorem 16.22, p. 357).
Remark 1.3. We have no idea, if the “or” case in Theorem 1.1 actually occurs. However, under rather strong assumptions, it can be excluded, we refer to Theorem 1.8 and Theorem 1.10 below.
Remark 1.4. As we will discuss later, condition (6) can be replaced by the weaker requirement
where . The divergence of the integral guarantees the validity of the famous Lehto-condition for quasiconformal mappings (see, e.g., [7] or [8]) being of crucial importance for the proof of Theorem 1.1.
Remark 1.5. We note that in the situation of (6) the solution can not grow much faster than an affine function.
Let us now briefly look at a more general setting: instead of using the radial Euler–Lagrange equation (1), we consider the more general divergence equation
with and an integrand , . For some and with constants , let the following ellipticity condition hold:
for all . Inequality (1.9) is just the condition of -ellipticity introduced in the paper [9]. We have in extension of Theorem 1.1
Theorem 1.6. Let denote an entire solution of equation (8) with satisfying (1.9). If in addition we have inequality (1.6), then the conclusions of Theorem 1.1 hold.
Remark 1.7. Clearly the conditions (1.2), (1.3), (1.4) and (1.5) imposed on the function yield inequality (1.9) for the density , where is the norm of . We note that (1.9) inherits more flexibility, for instance, not necessarily is of linear growth, however, the case of integrands with radial structure seems to be of more geometric interest.
Coming back to Bernstein’s problem, we recall the famous result of Moser [10] stating that if in Theorem 1.1 and Theorem 1.6 condition (1.6) is replaced by the global boundedness of the gradient of the solution , then is an affine function. We have the following minor extension of Moser’s theorem:
Theorem 1.8. Let denote an entire solution of equation (8) with satisfying (1.9). If inequality (1.6) is replaced by the condition
with some constant and for all points such that is sufficiently large, then is an affine function.
Remark 1.9. Condition (1.10) is much more restrictive than the upper bound from (1.6), however, from the proof of Theorem 1.8 we get
Theorem 1.10. Let the Landau -condition for the gradient at infinity hold, i.e.
where denotes an entire solution of equation (8) with satisfying (1.9). Then must be affine.
Our paper is organized as follows: in Section 2 we transform (1.1) into a generalized Beltrami equation and collect some technical tools. The proof of Theorem 1.1 is outlined in Section 3 making essential use of results due to Lehto and Virtanen presented in the monograph [7], and our line of arguments will mainly follow ideas taken from the work [8] of Astala, Iwaniec and Martin. In Section 4 we will add some short comments concerning the modifications necessary for the proof of Theorem 1.6, and Section 5 contains the proof of Theorem 1.8, the proof of Theorem 1.10 being presented in Section 6.
Transformation of equation (1.1) into a generalized Beltrami equation
Consider satisfying (1.1) and let the function just denote an element of satisfying the condition (1.2). We define the quantities
where , . Clearly we have the identity
and (1.1) turns into
From (2.1), (2.2) we infer
with coefficients defined through the formulas
Quoting (1.2) it follows from (2.4) that
holds, where in case the quantity is just .
Let us consider the function
and introduce the Wirtinger derivatives
Then we have
Lemma 2.1. The function from (2.6) is a solution of the generalized Beltrami equation
with coefficients (recall (2.5))
Proof of Lemma 2.1. We express the quantities , , in terms of , , and return to (2.3) with the result
After collecting terms this immediately yields equation (2.7) with and according to (2.8).
For preparing the next auxiliary result we remark that the eigenvalues of the symmetric matrix are given by
being strictly positive on account of (1.2), hence the matrix of the coefficients is positive definite.
Lemma 2.2. The determinant of the Jacobian matrix of from (17) is nonnegative, i.e.
Proof of Lemma 2.2. It holds on account of (12)
Recalling (15) we have
and (14) implies
hence
which proves our claim.
We finish this section by adding a few technical comments: returning to the defining equations (19) it is immediate that , moreover, we have the identity
hence
on account of (20), and we find
Proof of Theorem 1.1
Let the conditions (2)–(5) hold for the function and consider an entire solution of equation (1) for which we have (6). We consider two cases:
Case 1: is a constant function.
Then our claim is a direct consequence of equation (17).
Case 2: is not constant.
In order to prove the Picard-property of the gradient mapping, we will apply techniques outlined in [8], Chapter 20.9, demonstrating the strength of the Lehto-condition . According to Lemma 2.1, the complex gradient mapping is of class and satisfies the generalized Beltrami-type system (recall (18))
Due to (21) we have the global uniform bound everywhere. By combining this with the nonnegativity of the Jacobian determinant, (Lemma 2.2), we obtain the distortion inequality for the Wirtinger derivatives:
We define the local maximal dilatation quotient . In view of condition (1.5), it satisfies everywhere the upper bound:
Since is a strictly convex function of linear growth and , the maximal dilatation is locally bounded. Consequently, is a classical mapping of bounded distortion. By Reshetnyak’s regularity theorem, any non-constant solution of the elliptic system inherits the qualitative topological properties of holomorphic functions. Namely, the gradient mapping is both open and discrete.
In order to show in more detail that the gradient mapping is both open and discrete, we can refer to Theorem 1.1 from the work [11] of Manfredi and Villamor or to the paper of Iwaniec and Sverak [12]. For quoting the second reference we just note that a mapping being locally open and discrete clearly inherits these properties globally.
Since is discrete and open, we can apply the generalized topological factorization theorem of Stoilow as for instance it is stated on p. 305 in the work of Luisto and Pankka [13]: there exists a decomposition of the form
where:
is a global quasiconformal homeomorphism satisfying the Beltrami equation everywhere, with the complex dilatation defined by on the set where .
is a holomorphic function defined on the image domain .
In addition we refer to the analytic version of the factorization theorem presented in [8], which keeps the degree of regularity.
The maximal dilatation of the global homeomorphism is pointwise bounded by the dilatation of the gradient, i.e., . For later purposes we recall the Lehto-type asymptotic growth condition: our assumption (1.6) implies the divergence of the integrated dilatation over concentric circles, more precisely we have
In order to continue we need to know that the image domain of the quasiconformal homeomorphism is the complex plane:
However, we can not immediately guarantee that (23) holds. We proceed by contradiction: assume that the image domain is not the entire complex plane, i.e., . Since is a global homeomorphism, is a proper, simply connected domain in . By the Riemann mapping theorem (see [6], Theorem 14.8, p. 302) there exists a biholomorphic (conformal) mapping onto the open unit disk .
Let us define the composite mapping as . By construction, is a homeomorphism from onto , meaning . Since is conformal, the complex dilatation is preserved, and the maximal dilatation satisfies pointwise. Thus, satisfies the Lehto growth condition (22) on .
For any radius , consider the annulus . Its image under is a topological ring domain . The complement of in the entire complex plane, , consists of exactly two disjoint connected components:
, which is the image of the closed unit disk. Since is compact and is continuous, is a compact, bounded set in . Evidently, is independent of . Since is a homeomorphism, is a fixed positive constant.
. This component is closed and unbounded because it contains the entire exterior of the unit disk, .
The geometric assumptions of Theorem 20.9.3 are satisfied for the ring domain . Therefore, there exists an increasing homeomorphism , independent of the continua, such that
Since and , the Euclidean distance between and cannot exceed the distance from to the boundary . The unit disk has diameter , hence we have . By the monotonicity of , we obtain a uniform upper bound independent of :
On the other hand, the modulus estimate from below for mappings with integrable dilatation (compare [8], Corollary 20.9.2) provides the following lower bound for the conformal modulus of
where the integrated maximal dilatation is defined as
By the Lehto condition (22), the integral on the right-hand side of (25) diverges to infinity as . Thus, by taking the limit, we obtain
The divergence stated in (26) contradicts the uniform upper bound established in (24), which requires to hold globally for all .
Consequently, the initial assumption was false, which completes the proof of
Now, on account of (23), is defined for any complex number and thereby a classical entire holomorphic function. In consequence, Picard’s little theorem applies to and we arrive at the ”or” case from Theorem 1.1.
Remarks concerning Theorem 1.6
The coefficient matrix in this new setting is just the Hessian matrix of : we define
Inequality (16) requires the strict positivity of the trace of the coefficient matrix, i.e., . Since represents the components of the Hessian matrix , the sum corresponds exactly to . From condition (1.9), it follows for the eigenvalues of that:
Since , this sum is strictly positive everywhere. Consequently, (16) holds in the new setting.
The transformation of the Euler–Lagrange equation (1.8) into the generalized Beltrami equation
is of purely algebraic nature: expanding equation (1.8) via the chain rule yields, due to the symmetry of the mixed derivatives ():
This matches equation (14) exactly. The proof of Lemma 2.1 thus remains valid without modification, and the coefficients possess the identical structure as in (2.8). We check the validity of Lemma 2.2 and inequality (2.10):
Lemma 2.2 (): The proof just uses relation (2.3) and the positive definiteness of the coefficient matrix. Since condition (1.9) guarantees the positive definiteness of , the Jacobian determinant remains non-negative.
Equation (2.10) (): Due to the real-valuedness of , the coefficients are real, which implies . For the absolute value, it holds that:
By the strict ellipticity, the eigenvalues satisfy , and consequently . Thus, a strictly positive value is subtracted from , ensuring that is always satisfied.
Since and , is a mapping of bounded distortion, and as before it can be factored as with a quasiconformal homeomorphism and a holomorphic function .
The maximal dilatation satisfies:
This corresponds precisely to the asymptotic growth behavior found in the radial case. Under the assumption of the growth condition (1.6) for the gradient, the integrated dilatation grows logarithmically, whereby the Lehto condition is satisfied and follows, provided we assume that is not constant. Thus, the arguments in Section 3 carry over completely.
Proof of Theorem 1.8
As in § 3 we argue by contradiction assuming that the complex gradient mapping is not constant. With the help of (1.10) we will derive a precise asymptotic lower bound for the global quasiconformal homeomorphism for large values of leading to the desired contradiction.
From the former growth condition (1.6) for the gradient,
combined with the previous dilatation estimate, we deduce that the maximal dilatation quotient satisfies an asymptotic upper bound of the form for sufficiently large . Consequently, the integrated maximal dilatation defined in (3.1) grows at most logarithmically, more precisely it holds,
where is a positive constant depending only on the data.
Using the distortion property under the global quasiconformal mapping , the conformal modulus of the image of the annulus satisfies the lower Lehto estimate (compare again [8], Corollary 20.9.2)
Substituting the logarithmic upper bound for into (27) yields a double-logarithmic lower estimate for the modulus of the form
On the other hand, we can normalize and choose a radius such that . We further abbreviate . The Grötzsch ring estimate, applied after inversion, gives
For details the reader is referred to the monograph [14] of Gehring, Martin and Palka.
Combining the lower bound (28) with the upper bound (29) leads to
where for notational simplicity we have just assumed that . Applying the exponential function to both sides, the following lower bound for sufficiently large is established:
where and are positive constants.
Inequality (30) immediately translates into an upper bound for the inverse mapping , more precisely, it holds
Recalling the Stoilow factorization , the entire holomorphic function is given by . Combining the gradient growth condition (10) with the upper bound (31), we obtain an estimate for the modulus of :
being valid for sufficiently large values of . By a variant of Liouville’s theorem we deduce from (32) the constancy of and thereby of , leading to the desired contradiction, which completes the proof of Theorem 1.8.
Proof of Theorem 1.10
Assuming that the conditions (2)–(5) hold for the energy density with a fixed exponent , we consider an entire solution to the Euler–Lagrange equation (1) or its more general variant (8) under the -ellipticity condition (9).
Instead of the Lehto growth condition (6) or the double-logarithmic bound (10) required in Theorem 1.8, we now impose the Landau -condition (11) for the gradient at infinity, i.e., we require
and claim that must be an affine function.
By contradiction, suppose that the complex gradient mapping is non-constant. As outlined in § 3 and 5 is an open and discrete mapping, and using Stoilow’s factorization theorem, decomposes into , where is a global quasiconformal homeomorphism and is an entire holomorphic function. We now repeat the calculations from § 5 having a more careful look at the constants:
Under the -condition (33), the local maximal dilatation satisfies for any choice of and sufficiently large . Consequently, the integrated dilatation over concentric circles satisfies the asymptotic upper bound:
Inserting estimate (34) into the lower Lehto distortion inequality for the conformal modulus of the ring domain yields:
Combining (35) with the upper bound derived from the Grötzsch ring estimate (compare (29) and again choose ), we apply the exponential function to both sides. This implies a controlled asymptotic lower bound for the global homeomorphism for :
Inequality (36) yields a sub-exponential growth rate for the inverse mapping for , more precisely, it holds
We now estimate the modulus of the entire holomorphic function by inserting the growth bound (37) into inequality (6):
The resulting growth exponent is defined as . Since can be chosen arbitrarily small from the very beginning, the requirement for a strictly sub-polynomial growth rate
can evidently be fulfilled. By the extended variant of Liouville’s theorem for entire functions, the sub-polynomial growth stated in (38) shows that , and thereby , is a constant vector. This provides the desired contradiction to our initial assumption, completing the proof that must be an affine function. □
Remark 6.1. We think that the proof of Theorem 1.10 can be adjusted to the case of densities satisfying an anisotropic -ellipticity condition with exponents in place of (9). If , we then have to replace (11) by the condition
implying that is an affine function, whereas in the isotropic setting this follows from the requirement with the sharp bound for the exponent
Acknowledgements
The author is very grateful to Kari Astala and Gaven Martin for their helpful comments.
Funding. Open Access funding enabled and organized by Projekt DEAL.
Data availability. No additional data are involved.
Declarations
Conflict of interest. There is no conflict of interest to be declared.
Martin Fuchs Saarland University Department of Mathematics P.O. Box 15 11 50 66041 Saarbrücken, Germany [email protected]
References
- [1]S. Bernstein, Sur un theoreme de geometrie et ses applications aux equations aux derivees partielles du type elliptique. Comm. de la Soc. Mat. de Kharkov (2eme ser. 15), 38–45 (1915–1917).
- [2]S. Bernstein, Über ein geometrisches Theorem und seine Anwendungen auf die partiellen Differentialgleichungen vom elliptischen Typus. Math. Z. 26, 551–558 (1927).DOI
- [3]V.M.Mikljukov, A new approach to the Bernstein theorem and to related questions of equations of minimal surface type. Mat. Sb. (N.S.) 108(150), no. 2, 268–289, 304 (1979).DOI
- [4]A.Farina, B.Sciunzi, E.Valdinoci, Bernstein and De Giorgi type problems: new results via a geometric approach. Ann. Sc. Norm. Super. Pisa Cl. Sci. (5) 7, no.4, 741–791 (2008).
- [5]M.Bildhauer, M.Fuchs, Bernstein’s theorem for variational integrals of linear growth and radial structure.(to appear)
- [6]W.Rudin, Real and complex analysis. McGraw-Hill (1970).
- [7]O.Lehto, K.I.Virtanen, Quasiconformal Mappings in the Plane. Grundlehren der mathematischen Wissenschaften, Band 126, Springer Verlag (1973).DOI
- [8]K.Astala, T.Iwaniec, G.Martin, Elliptic partial differential equations and quasiconformal mappings in the plane. Princeton Mathematical Series, 48. Princeton University Press, Princeton, NJ (2009).
- [9]M.Bildhauer, M.Fuchs, On a class of variational integrals with linear growth satisfying the condition of μ—ellipticity. Rendiconti di Matematica e delle sue applicazioni 22, 249-274 (2002).
- [10]J.Moser, On Harnack’s theorem for elliptic differential equations. Comm. Pure Appl. Math. 14, 577-591 (1961).DOI
- [11]J.Manfredi, E.Villamor, Mappings with integrable dilation in higher dimensions. Bulletin (New Series) of the American Mathematical Society Volume 32, Number 2 (1995).arxiv.org/abs/math/9504225
- [12]T.Iwaniec, V.Sverak, On mappings with integrable dilation. Proceedings of the American Mathematical Society , May, 1993, Vol. 118, No. 1(May, 1993), pp. 181-188.DOI
- [13]R.Luisto, P.Pankka, Stoilow’s theorem revisited. Expo.Math.38, 303-318(2020).DOI
- [14]F.Gehring, G.Martin, B.Palka, An introduction to the theory of higher-dimensional quasiconformal mappings. AMS Mathematical Surveys and Monographs Volume 216 (2017).DOI