betaFeedback

WorksPhysics and Astronomy

Frustrated Interlayer Coupling Creates a Higher-Order Helical Superstructure in a Twist-Bend Smectic Phase

Abstract

Bent liquid-crystalline dimers provide a model system for studying the spontaneous emergence of chirality from achiral molecules. Depending on terminal-chain length, these materials exhibit a competition between heliconical, synclinic, and anticlinic packing tendencies in tilted smectic phases. In short homologues, the tendency to form twist-bend phases dominates, leading to two distinct helical phases: the SmCTB-SH phase, with a helical periodicity of four molecular lengths, and at lower temperatures, a double helical structure - the SmCTB-DH phase, with progressive rotation of the four-layer unit. With increasing terminal chain length, this twist-bend tendency is gradually suppressed, favoring phases with simple synclinic and anticlinic tilt arrangement in successive layers. Remarkably, in the regime where these tendencies become comparable, a new modulated smectic phase, SmCTB-mod develops; a double helical structure in which the internal four-layer unit undergoes a periodic modulation. This additional level of structural organization provides a means of accommodating competing heliconical and synclinic/anticlinic tendencies and produces a characteristic splitting of the resonant x-ray diffraction peaks into four signals symmetrically located around a signal of four-layer periodicity. These results reveal how bent dimers resolve local-packing-mode frustration through complex spontaneous hierarchical structural organization.

Hierarchical self-organization, whereby molecular building blocks assemble into increasingly complex structures across multiple length scales, is a pervasive principle underlying both natural and synthetic materials [1]. In biological systems, hierarchical organization is essential for functionality, enabling the emergence of sophisticated mechanical, optical, and transport properties from comparatively simple molecular constituents. Inspired by such examples, the design and control of such architectures have become central goals in materials science, because organization at multiple levels often gives rise to emergent phenomena that cannot be inferred from the properties of individual molecules alone. Hierarchical structures are therefore of fundamental interest for understanding self-assembly and symmetry breaking, while also offering opportunities for applications in photonics, sensing, energy conversion, information storage, and responsive materials.

Soft matter systems provide an especially rich platform for investigating hierarchical self-organization due to the delicate balance between the energy of intermolecular interactions and that of thermal fluctuations. Among them, liquid crystals are unique as they combine fluidity with long-range orientational and, in some cases, limited positional order [2]. The structures of liquid crystal mesophases are extremely sensitive to molecular architecture, making them the ideal model system for exploring how nanoscale molecular design translates into mesoscale and macroscopic organization. One of the most effective approaches for establishing structure-property relationships in liquid crystals is the study of homologous series, in which a single feature of molecular structure is systematically varied. In particular, the length of terminal alkyl chains strongly influences molecular packing through the competition between chain microsegregation, steric constraints, and orientational order. As a result, seemingly subtle molecular modifications can generate profound changes in self-assembled structures and lead to the emergence of new levels of hierarchical organization [3].

A typical phase behavior of rod-like liquid-crystalline molecules as a function of terminal alkyl-chain length is well established [4]: short-chain homologues generally exhibit only a nematic phase, whereas elongation of the terminal chains promotes the appearance of smectic phases. The formation of layers, characteristic of smectic ordering, is driven by microsegregation between chemically-incompatible flexible alkyl chains and rigid aromatic mesogenic cores. The phase behavior of liquid-crystalline dimers is considerably more complex because it is strongly influenced by the length and parity of flexible spacer linking two rigid mesogenic units [5,6]. Dimers might form smectic phases with layer spacing equal to the molecular length, half of the molecular length or, in the case of asymmetric dimers, also double the molecular length [7]. Moreover, dimers containing odd-membered spacers often exhibit modulated structures as a consequence of their on-average bent shape. The orientation of such dimers is therefore described not only by a molecular long axis connecting the molecular termini, but also by a secondary axis associated with the bend direction. Thus, orientational ordering may involve both alignment of the molecular long axes and correlation of molecular bend orientation, making their packing substantially more complex than that of conventional calamitic liquid crystals [8].

The bent molecular geometry of odd-membered dimers also promotes spontaneous elastic deformation of the director field [9], giving rise to the twist-bend nematic, NTBN_{\mathrm{TB}} [10,11] and smectic phases [12]. These phases exhibit increasingly complex hierarchical organization, including structures characterized by short-pitch, few-molecular-length periodicity (NTBN_{\mathrm{TB}}, SmCTB−SH\mathrm{SmC}_{\mathrm{TB-SH}}) and the recently discovered SmCTB−DH\mathrm{SmC}_{\mathrm{TB-DH}} phase, in which a long-wavelength helical modulation is superimposed on the primary four-layer helix to generate a double-helical architecture [13,14]. These phases represent striking examples of multilevel self-organization, where chirality spontaneously emerges sequentially on distinct length scales in systems made of achiral molecules.

Here, we investigate four homologous series of asymmetric liquid-crystalline dimers containing odd-membered spacers and substantially extended terminal alkyl chains, reaching up to eighteen carbon atoms (Figure 1). The selected compounds span a broad family of closely related dimeric mesogens that differ in their terminal-chain length and mesogenic core architecture, while preserving the key structural features responsible for twist-bend-type molecular arrangement: namely, an odd-membered spacer endowing an overall bent molecular shape. However, the influence of this geometry on the resulting phase behaviour is expected to be screened by elongated terminal chains. Indeed, across all series, a remarkably consistent phase behavior emerges, revealing distinct regions of the phase diagram governed by different intermolecular interactions and thus packing mechanisms. As the terminal-chain length increases, the balance between molecular bend and alkyl-chain microsegregation evolves systematically, producing a rich sequence of hierarchical structures. The resulting phase diagrams, summarized in Figure 1, provide a unified framework for understanding this structural evolution and reveal the emergence of a previously unrecognized modulated twist-bend smectic phase, SmCTB−mod\mathrm{SmC}_{\mathrm{TB-mod}}. In this phase, the established four-layer heliconical organization develops an additional long-period modulation, giving rise to a higher-order helical superstructure. Resonant soft X-ray scattering and theoretical analysis show that this hierarchy emerges from frustration between competing interlayer packing tendencies, providing a new example of how complex multilevel organizations can spontaneously arise in soft-matter systems.

Phase diagrams and molecular structures for four homologous series

Figure 1. Phase behavior of the four studied homologous series. Phase diagrams plotted as a function of the number of carbon atoms in the molecular terminal chain, mm, for dimeric molecules of (a) CT4O2Me.mm, (b) CT6O2Me.mm, (c) CT6O2F.mm and (d) CT6O2,6dF.mm homologue series. Molecular structures are given above each panel. The SmCTB_{\mathrm{TB}}-type phases exhibit helical structures, the SmCS_{\mathrm{S}} phase is synclinic, whereas the SmC4_4 phase is characterized by alternating synclinic and anticlinic interlayer arrangements. Phase transition temperatures were determined from DSC and optical birefringence measurements, however, for some of the longest homologues the precise temperature ranges and structural characteristics of the phases formed could not always be determined unambiguously, due to their short temperature ranges.

Results

Liquid crystalline phases formed by the studied mesogens were identified by a combination of experimental techniques including polarized-light optical microscopy and x-ray diffraction, both conventional and resonant. The resonant soft x-ray scattering (RSoXS), with beam energy tuned to the carbon absorption edge, is uniquely sensitive to orientational modulations of molecular ordering and therefore particularly suited for studies of heliconical and other complex liquid-crystalline structures [15-18]. By probing variations in molecular orientation, rather than electron density alone, RSoXS provides direct access to the periodicity of the structures defined solely by orientation of molecules.

All four of the studied homologous series exhibit the same fundamental trends; therefore we will focus on the CT4O2Me.mm series as a representative model system, which captures the essential features observed throughout the entire family, while the remaining series are discussed in terms of their similarities and deviations from this general behavior. On cooling, the shortest homologues in the CT4O2Me.mm series exhibit the phase sequence N→NTB→SmCTB−CN \to N_{\mathrm{TB}} \to\mathrm{SmC}_{\mathrm{TB-C}}, where the SmCTB−C\mathrm{SmC}_{\mathrm{TB-C}} phase is a tilted intercalated smectic with layer spacing equal half the molecular length (Fig. S1), each sublayer made of mesogenic cores is separated by alkyl sublayer made of terminal and spacer chains. The thermal stability of this intercalated smectic phase reaches a maximum for the homologue with m=4m = 4. This can be attributed to the close correspondence between the lengths of the terminal alkyl chains and the flexible spacer, which optimizes molecular packing within the intercalated arrangement [19]. A locally intercalated structure is observed also for the nematic and twist-bend nematic phases of short homologues (Fig. S1). The helical pitch in the NTBN_{\mathrm{TB}} phase determined by RSoXS has a typical temperature dependence, the pitch is close to 4 molecular lengths at low temperatures but critically unwinds on approaching the NTB−NN_{\mathrm{TB-N}} phase transition (Figure 2a,Figure 2d) [20,21].

RSoXS data showing temperature evolution of resonant x-ray diffraction patterns and scattering-vector positions

Figure 2. RSoXS data. Temperature evolution of the resonant x-ray diffraction patterns for (a) CT4O2Me.4 in the NTB_{\mathrm{TB}} phase and (b) CT4O2Me.10 across the SmA-SmCTB−SH_{\mathrm{TB-SH}} and SmCTB−DH_{\mathrm{TB-DH}} phase sequence. The signal observed at diffraction angle of approximately 38 deg. (nearly insensitive to the temperature) is non-resonant and corresponds to the electron density modulation associated with the bilayer periodicity of the smectic phases and (c) CT4O2Me.14 showing a SmA - SmCTB−DH_{\mathrm{TB-DH}} phase sequence. Panels (d)-(e) show the positions of the diffraction signals recalculated to the scattering vector magnitude qq, and the corresponding real-space periodicity, dd. The q4q_4 reflection corresponds to a four-layer periodicity; the increase in the splitting of the resonant signals q4+qmq_4+q_m and q4−qmq_4-q_m in the SmCTB−DH_{\mathrm{TB-DH}} phase indicates a decreasing pitch of the secondary helix.

A distinct change in phase behavior, from an intercalated packing regime to a bilayer regime, occurs for homologues with terminal chains m=6−14m = 6 - 14. Within this regime, the nematic phase is gradually replaced by the smectic A phase and the twist-bend nematic phase is replaced by a sequence of heliconical smectic phases, yielding the typical phase sequence SmA →\rightarrow SmCTB−SH_{\mathrm{TB-SH}} →\rightarrow SmCTB−DH_{\mathrm{TB-DH}}. Smectic phases, studied by conventional x-ray diffraction, show electron density modulation with periodicity close to twice the molecular length, indicative of antiparallel pairing of neighboring dimers in successive molecular layers; the repeating unit is composed of two molecular layers (Fig. S2). In RSoXS experiments the SmCTB−SH_{\mathrm{TB-SH}} phase exhibits a characteristic resonant x-ray reflection corresponding to a four-molecular-layer periodicity, at q4=2π/(4d0)q_4 = 2\pi/(4d_0), where d0d_0 is the molecular layer thickness (Figure 2). Throughout this work, resonant reflections are labeled according to their positions in reciprocal space; we therefore refer to this signal as the q4 reflection [13]. The observation of the q4 reflection, together with its biaxial optical character – evidenced by a schlieren texture observed when light propagates along the layer normal – and a decrease of optical birefringence compared to the preceding SmA phase when the light propagates perpendicular to layer normal (Fig. S3), demonstrates that the four-layer heliconical unit in SmCTB−SH_{\mathrm{TB-SH}} phase is distorted from an ideal clock-structure. In the SmCTB−DH_{\mathrm{TB-DH}} phase, the q4q_4 reflection splits symmetrically into two reflections located at q4+qmq_4+q_m and q4−qmq_4-q_m (Figure 2b,Figure 2e), revealing the emergence of an additional long-wavelength rotation of the four-layer structural unit [13] - the phase is thus an analogue of chiral SmCFI2 phase [22], but we must emphasize that our present system is built from achiral molecules. Upon cooling, the separation between the two resonant peaks increases, indicating a progressive shortening of the pitch (p=2πqmp = \frac{2\pi}{q_m}) associated with this secondary modulation. The SmCTB−DH_{\mathrm{TB-DH}} phase is optically uniaxial because the superimposed helix produces an azimuthal rotation of the molecular tilt direction, averaging the in-plane optical anisotropy. As the terminal alkyl chain becomes longer, the temperature range of the SmCTB−SH_{\mathrm{TB-SH}} phase gradually narrows. Consequently, for the CT4O2Me.mm homologues with m=12m = 12 and 14, this phase disappears and a direct SmA →\rightarrow SmCTB−DH_{\mathrm{TB-DH}} transition takes place (Figure 2c,Figure 2f).

The longest homologues (m=16m = 16 and 18) define the third region in the phase diagram, in which alkyl chain segregation becomes the dominant factor governing self-assembly. X-ray diffraction measurements indicate a bilayer organization throughout all smectic phases in this regime (Fig. S4). Detailed RSoXS studies, performed for the homologue with m=18m = 18, identified a sequence of 5 tilted smectic phases below the SmA phase (Figure 3a,Figure 3b), with the lowest temperature phase being the SmCTB−DH_{\mathrm{TB-DH}} phase, as in the shorter homologues.

Phase sequence for CT4O2Me.18

Figure 3. Phase sequence for CT4O2Me.18. Temperature evolution of (a) the RSoXS pattern and (b) corresponding diffraction peak positions. In the SmC4_4 phase, the resonant diffraction signal corresponds to a four-layer periodicity. Upon transition to the SmCTB−DH_{\mathrm{TB-DH}} phase, the resonant signal splits into two reflections q4_4+qm_m and q4_4-qm_m. The resonant signals disappear in the SmCS_S phase. In the SmCTB−mod_{\mathrm{TB-mod}} phase, four resonant peaks emerge, positioned symmetrically around the q4_4+qm_m and q4_4-qm_m reflections. Upon entering the lowest temperature SmCTB−DH_{\mathrm{TB-DH}} phase, the signals q4_4+qm_m and q4_4-qm_m reappear. (c) Optical textures observed for selected smectic phases. The temperature range over which the resonant signal disappears completely corresponds to the optical texture in which tilt domains can be clearly distinguished, the SmC4_4 and SmCTB−DH_{\mathrm{TB-DH}} phases are optically uniaxial with optical axis oriented along layer normal.

In the phase formed directly below the SmA phase, resonant scattering measurements revealed the signal related to a four-layer periodicity. However, the onset temperature of this phase, which we have termed here SmC4_4, is substantially higher than that of the SmCTB−SH_{\mathrm{TB-SH}} phase found in shorter homologues (Figure 1), indicating that the underlying mechanisms responsible for four-layer periodicity in the SmC4_4 and SmCTB−SH_{\mathrm{TB-SH}} phases are distinct. While the SmCTB−SH_{\mathrm{TB-SH}} phase can transform continuously into the double-helical SmCTB−DH_{\mathrm{TB-DH}} phase [23], as observed for the shorter homologues, the evolution from the SmC4_4 phase to the stable SmCTB−DH_{\mathrm{TB-DH}} phase in homologue m=18m = 18 proceeds through several intermediate states. Although immediately below the SmC4_4 phase the resonant peak associated with the four-layer periodicity splits into a pair of satellites, signaling the narrow temperature range (∼1\sim1 K) of SmCTB−DH_{\mathrm{TB-DH}}, upon further cooling the resonant scattering signals disappear. In this temperature range, optical texture with tilt domains is formed in planar cells, characteristic for synclinic SmCS_S phase (Figure 3c). At further cooling, in the phase named SmCTB−mod_{\mathrm{TB-mod}}, resonant x-ray diffraction signals reappear, but with a fundamentally different pattern. Two pairs of reflections are observed, one located around q4+qm\mathbf{q}_{4}+\mathbf{q}_{m} and the other around q4−qm\mathbf{q}_{4}-\mathbf{q}_{m}, producing a total of four resonant peaks symmetrically distributed around the original q4\mathbf{q}_{4} peak of the SmC4\mathrm{SmC}_{4} phase. The outer satellites exhibit substantially larger intensity than the inner ones. Finally, this complex diffraction pattern disappears, and the characteristic scattering signature of the SmCTB−DH\mathrm{SmC}_{\mathrm{TB-DH}} phase is recovered, changing only weakly on further cooling. The unusual resonant diffraction pattern with four peaks observed in the intermediate SmCTB−mod\mathrm{SmC}_{\mathrm{TB-mod}} phase cannot be explained within the framework of the previously established double-helical structure.13 The diffraction pattern therefore reveals a new level of hierarchical organization superimposed on the already existing double-helical structure. The SmCTB−mod\mathrm{SmC}_{\mathrm{TB-mod}} phase has been also observed in homologue m=16m=16, however in this homologue the SmC4\mathrm{SmC}_{4} phase is missing, the observed sequence is SmA\mathrm{SmA}-SmCS\mathrm{SmC}_{\mathrm{S}}-SmCTB−mod\mathrm{SmC}_{\mathrm{TB-mod}}-SmCTB−DH\mathrm{SmC}_{\mathrm{TB-DH}} (Fig. S5).

A similar overall evolution of phase behavior with increasing mm has been observed for several related homologous series of bent liquid-crystalline dimers (Figure 1), suggesting that the sequence of structural transformations reflects a general consequence of extending terminal chain length. In all of these systems, the phase diagrams can be divided into three regions characterized by different balance between interlayer coupling, molecular tilt organization, and nanosegregation. A notable difference, however, is that whereas in the CT4O2Me.m\mathrm{CT}_{4}\mathrm{O}_{2}\mathrm{Me}.m series the SmC4\mathrm{SmC}_{4} phase emerges directly from the orthogonal SmA\mathrm{SmA} phase, in materials of other studied homologue series it is preceded by a synclinic SmCS\mathrm{SmC}_{\mathrm{S}} phase, characterized by well-developed tilt domains in optical textures observed in planar-aligned cells (Figure 4a).

Optical textures and physical properties of tilted phases

Figure 4. Phase sequence and physical properties of tilted phases. (a) Optical textures observed between crossed polarizers for a sequence of smectic phases: SmA, SmCS_{\mathrm{S}}, SmC4_4, reentrant SmCS_{\mathrm{S}} and SmCTB−DH_{\mathrm{TB-DH}} for the CT6O2Me.S17 homologue. In the SmCS_{\mathrm{S}} phases the sample was rotated to obtain light extinction in one of the tilted domains, whereas in the SmC4_4 and SmCTB−DH_{\mathrm{TB-DH}} phases extinction occurs when the rubbing direction (layer normal) is aligned with the polarizer axis. Temperature dependence of (b) birefringence, (c) tilt, and (d) layer spacing for the CT6O2Me.S17 (blue) and CT6O2,6dF.16 (black) compounds.

In all studied series the lowest temperature smectic phase formed by long homologues is SmCTB−DH_{\mathrm{TB-DH}}, and the evolution from the SmC4_4 phase again involves several intermediate structures, however it was not possible to unambiguously determine whether the exact path is the same as observed for CT4O2Me.mm series. Nevertheless, it should be noted that the tilt angle magnitude, as well as smectic layer thickness evolves smoothly upon cooling through the sequence of phases (Figure 4c,Figure 4d), from SmA to SmCTB−DH_{\mathrm{TB-DH}}, suggesting that all the phase transitions are driven by re-arrangement of the azimuthal tilt directions in consecutive molecular layers. Additional structural information about intermediate phases can be revealed from optical studies. SmCTB−DH_{\mathrm{TB-DH}} and SmCTB−mod_{\mathrm{TB-mod}} are optically uniaxial and thus give homeotropic textures under the polarized optical microscope, while in the SmCTB−SH_{\mathrm{TB-SH}}, SmCS_{\mathrm{S}} and SmC4_4 phases, schlieren textures evidence optical biaxiality. In wedge cells with homeotropic anchoring condition, the SmCS_{\mathrm{S}} phase forms a regular array of stripes originating from the discrete variation in the number of smectic layers across the continuously varying cell thickness (Figure 5a).

References

  1. [1][S1] M. Salamończyk, N. Vaupotič, D. Pociecha, R. Walker, J. M. D. Storey, C. T. Imrie, C. Wang, C. Zhu, E. Górecka, Multi-level chirality in liquid crystals formed by achiral molecules, Nat. Commun. 10, 1922 (2019). DOI: 10.1038/s41467-019-09862-y
  2. [2][S2] A. Pearson, A. Alshammari, G. J. Strachan, M. Majewska, D. Pociecha, J. M. D. Storey, C.T. Imrie, N. Vaupotič, R. Walker, E. Gorecka, Diverse helical structures made of achiral mesogenic dimers, Nat. Commun. 17, 6090 (2026). DOI:10.1038/s41467-026-72565-8DOI
  3. [3][S3] V. E. Dmitrienko, Forbidden reflections due to anisotropic X-ray susceptibility of crystals, Acta Crystallogr. Sect. A 39, 29-35 (1983).DOI

Paper details

vlnc:W_u9yfk4dt
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 0

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Physics and Astronomy

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents