WorksMathematics
Plane Algebraic Curve Families from Normalized Zeta Series: Prime-Base Extensions and Composite Breakdown
Abstract
In a companion study of Euler's alternating series , distributing the prefactor across individual summands exposed two distinct families of plane curves along vertical lines in the critical strip. On the critical line , the pure powers trace an infinite hierarchy of closed, irreducible plane algebraic curves of degree in whose enclosed signed areas sum to zero, whereas weighting non-power terms by yields concentric circles centered at uniquely at and open, precessing rosettes for . This sequel investigates whether the emergence of these curve families is specific to base or extends to general integer normalizations for . We show that every prime base generates an analogous two-family structure: the pure-power terms form irreducible degree- algebraic curves over governed by a two-step polynomial recurrence, a Blaschke-involution elliptic perimeter integral, and a zero-sum signed-area law; their seed quartics evolve geometrically from figure-eights () to teardrops and asymptotically circular ovals () while retaining degree- integer structure; their rational equations in uniquely single out among rational abscissas ; and all paired non-power curves () transition from concentric circles of radius on to two-dimensional rosettes off it. When is composite, however, this classification fractures. Proper prime powers () produce rational algebraic curves on vertical lines and create a hybrid third family of resonant sub-powers () that remain closed algebraic loops off , while multi-prime composites fail to gather their prime divisors into algebraic towers and break the multiplicative structure of Euler's product.
Introduction
For , the Riemann zeta function is defined both additively and multiplicatively by
To continue into the critical strip , Euler introduced the alternating Dirichlet series , canceling the simple pole at so that the series converges conditionally throughout [3, 7].
In our companion paper [4], absorbing directly into each summand gave the termwise representation with . Tracking the trajectories along vertical lines separated the positive integers into two contrasting curve families:
Pure-power algebraic curves (): Sharing the single frequency in numerator and denominator, closes into an irreducible degree-$2k$ curve in with complete elliptic perimeter and signed areas summing to zero across $k\ge 1.
Paired circles and rosettes (): Pairing odd-index neighbors and multiples-of-4 differences via yields origin-centered circles of constant radius on and two-dimensional rosettes for .
Because Euler’s alternating signs rely on even and odd parity, a natural question is whether generating integer algebraic curves from requires base 2, extends to every prime , or works equally well for any integer . Here we show that the two-family curve classification extends intact to every prime base , examine how the non-circular seed quartics evolve geometrically across increasing primes, and determine how composite bases fracture both the rational vertical-line pin and the circle-versus-rosette split.
Base- Normalizations and the Prime Circle–Rosette Split
For any integer base , subtracting from on cancels the pole at by assigning weight to integers indivisible by and weight to multiples of [1, 5].
Definition 2.1 (Base- Series and Normalized Curve Terms). Fix an integer and define the -periodic weight
Set , and away from the prefactor poles on , define the normalized curve terms
Because every block of consecutive weights sums to , Dirichlet’s test guarantees conditional convergence across the right half-plane.
Proposition 2.1 (Termwise Continuation Across ). For every integer , converges conditionally on to , giving whenever and .
To compare non-power terms across vertical lines, introduce the base- pairing factor , which converts into the Möbius ratio [6]
At , and unify the companion paper’s odd-index sums ( odd, radius ) and multiples-of-4 differences [4]. On , summing across also matches the index-sieved Dirichlet series by canceling multiples of .
Proposition 2.2 (Critical-Line Circle Criterion for ). For any integer and any vertical line (, ), traces an exact Euclidean circle of period with real center and radius
This circle is centered at if and only if , where is constant.
When is prime, irrationality of for every produces a clean dichotomy across all non-power indices [8].
Theorem 2.3 (Circle-Versus-Rosette Family for Prime Bases). Let be a prime and let satisfy for all (including when is odd).
Concentric Critical-Line Circles: At , every curve traces a circle centered at of constant radius .
Off-Line Precessing Rosettes: For every , the curve unravels into an open, non-periodic rosette densely filling the annulus with inner and outer radii and .
Pure-Power Algebraic Curve Towers for Prime Bases
Unlike the non-power terms, the unpaired pure powers () oscillate exclusively at integer harmonics of , so closes into a periodic curve of period on every vertical line . Defining the epicyclic step circles (recovering at [4]), each curve in the tower is generated from its predecessor by phase-locked circle addition.
Proposition 3.1 (Epicyclic Construction of the Pure-Power Family). For every prime and every with , the pure-power terms satisfy
Along , is a circle of radius centered at , and each step attaches an origin-centered circle of radius rotating clockwise at frequency .
On the critical line , setting writes . Despite the appearance of in this parameterization, eliminating clears every radical simultaneously. Scaling out the integer factor via with coordinates —related to by , so directly at —places all prime bases under a single recurrence.
Theorem 3.2 (Integer Polynomial Hierarchy on ). Let be a prime, let , and write . Putting , the locus of traces an irreducible plane algebraic curve of degree in defined by
where is determined by the initial polynomials
and the two-step recurrence
Every has degree , leading coefficient , and constant term ; substituting and clearing gives the irreducible degree- equation of in (matching at [4]).
Across every prime tower, the positively oriented base circle and negatively oriented higher-order loops () satisfy an exact signed-area conservation law, while the unit-circle Blaschke involution reduces every perimeter to a complete elliptic integral [2]. Notably, just as base 2 produces the isometric arc-length twin pair [4], base 3 yields a second and final prime isometric twin pair before third-kind II terms persist across all higher primes .
Theorem 3.3 (Signed-Area Conservation and Elliptic Perimeter Across Prime Towers). Let be a prime and orient by increasing ().
Zero-Sum Signed-Area Law: The enclosed signed area of is
vanishing for an individual curve if and only if (occurring uniquely for the Bernoulli lemniscate at , [4]).
Blaschke-Involution Elliptic Perimeter: Setting , the fundamental-period arc length of is given by
Geometric Evolution of Seed Quartics Across Prime Bases
In base , the companion study [4] centered on the term , which serves as the first non-circular curve in the dyadic tower after the shifted circle and anchors all higher inner-loop curves () under circle addition. For a general prime , the quadratic seed occupies this exact structural position: it is the first folded degree-4 algebraic curve generated by and the second initial seed required to launch the two-step recurrence for .
Plotting the curve () across increasing primes shows how the denominator governs the curve’s silhouette. Rationalizing the denominator shows that vanishes away from the apsides if and only if , while expanding in powers of gives the convergent Fourier representation
As illustrated across the first nine primes ( through ) in Figure 1, this produces a smooth three-stage geometric progression:

Figure 1. Geometric evolution of the degree-4 seed quartics across the first nine primes (), with the origin marked in black and real-axis double points marked for . Although each panel is scaled to display its silhouette, the curves contract in true diameter as and oscillate at -linearly independent frequencies .
Self-intersecting figure-eights (): Only and satisfy , creating a real-axis double point at . At , forms the symmetric Bernoulli lemniscate crossing at with ; at , crosses at with a smaller right-hand lobe and net signed area .
Unfolded teardrops and ovals (): Once , admits no real angle , erasing the self-intersection node so that unfolds into a simple pointed teardrop that rounds progressively into a smooth convex oval across and .
Asymptotic circularity (): As increases, the leading Fourier mode dominates, rounding each seed curve toward a clockwise circle of radius shifted right by with real-axis apsides at and .
Figure 1 also clarifies why primality is an arithmetic and whole-series property rather than a silhouette property: even as becomes visually indistinguishable from a circle at larger primes, each curve remains an irreducible degree-4 locus in built from cancelling the quadratic radical on its own independent clock , from which higher powers fold nested loops around the origin.
Field-Theoretic Characterization of the Critical Line
When moves off inside , the pure-power curves remain closed real algebraic curves in , but their defining coefficients leave at every other rational abscissa.
Theorem 5.1 (Q-Rationality and Dual Integrality of Prime Curve Towers). Let be a prime, let , and fix . Define the base parameter and write for .
1. Off-Line Cartesian Equations: Along , the curve satisfies the
degree- equation
generated from and by the recurrence
matching of [4] identically at and reducing to at .
2. Uniqueness Among Rational Vertical Lines: For , the curve is defined over if and only if . For any (), forces coefficients in the radical extension .
3. Dual Integrality Under : Across all real , is the unique abscissa at which both functional-equation partner parameters and belong to (both equaling ).
How the Curve Families Break Down for Composite Bases
Formally, the circle and polynomial sequence remain well-defined for any composite integer . However, the clean two-family architecture—one tower of rational algebraic curves pinned to , plus a complementary family of non-power curves that unravel into rosettes off while preserving Euler’s prime product—breaks down in two distinct ways depending on the prime factorization of .
Proper Prime Powers (, )
When is a higher power of a single prime (such as ), fractional powers of exist as integers () and alter both curve families simultaneously.
Theorem 6.1 (Extra Rational Lines and Leaked Algebraic Curves for ). Let for a prime and an integer .
Proliferation of Rational and Integer Curve Lines: Because , the pure-power curves belong to (with integer parameter ) on all rational vertical lines
Moreover, whenever is even, off-critical partner pairs and () satisfy simultaneously (for instance, and at ).
Emergence of a Third Hybrid Family Off : Every sub-power with (such as when ) satisfies and therefore belongs to the paired non-power family . Because , fails to unravel into an area-filling rosette for , tracing instead a closed, periodic one-dimensional algebraic curve on every vertical line .
Multi-Prime Composites (q = 6, 10, 12, ...)
When has at least two distinct prime factors (such as ), and is not itself a perfect power, once again holds uniquely at for rational , and no rational frequency ratios leak into . Instead, the curve decomposition loses alignment with the prime factorization of the integers.
For a prime base , every prime power belongs to the closed algebraic curve family , while the index-sieved series (Re) is supported on integers indivisible by —a set closed under multiplication by Euclid’s lemma [5]. Multi-prime bases forfeit both properties.
Theorem 6.2 (Prime-Tower Stranding and Multiplicative Breakdown for Multi-Prime ). Suppose is divisible by at least two distinct primes ().
Stranded Prime-Power Rosettes: Only joint powers enter the closed algebraic curve tower . For every constituent prime and every , the pure prime power has irrational frequency ratio and unravels into an open two-dimensional rosette even on the critical line .
Loss of Multiplicative Closure and Euler Factorization: Writing with and , the indicator satisfies but . Consequently, the paired series lacks multiplicative coefficients and does not factor as a sub-product of Euler’s prime product.
Classification of Curve Families Across Integer Bases
Table Table 1 summarizes how the algebraic and geometric curve families generated by depend on the arithmetic type of .
| Base Type | Lines | () | Powers () | Set |
| Prime | Unique | All 2D rosettes | In tower | Completely mult. |
| Prime power | lines | Rosettes + 1D loops | Split across families | Coprime mult. only |
| Multi-prime | (if non-power) | All 2D rosettes | Stranded 2D rosettes | Non-multiplicative |
Table 1. Classification of algebraic and geometric curve families across integer bases .
In Table 1, “ Lines” lists rational abscissas on which satisfies a rational polynomial equation, “ ()” classifies the paired curves off the critical line, “Powers ()” tracks the fate of individual prime-factor powers , and “Set ” records the multiplicativity of .
This trichotomy clarifies what is special about prime normalizations of : primes are the unique integer bases for which simultaneously gathers all powers of ’s prime divisors into an irreducible algebraic curve tower on , confines rational curve equations exclusively to , forces every remaining paired term off to unravel into a two-dimensional rosette, and preserves multiplicative closure across the surviving integers.
References
- [1]T. M. Apostol, Introduction to Analytic Number Theory, Undergraduate Texts in Mathematics, Springer-Verlag, New York, 1976.
- [2]P. F. Byrd and M. D. Friedman, Handbook of Elliptic Integrals for Engineers and Scientists, 2nd ed., Grundlehren der mathematischen Wissenschaften, vol. 67, Springer-Verlag, Berlin, 1971.
- [3]L. Euler, “Remarques sur un beau rapport entre les séries des puissances tant directes que réciproques,” Mémoires de l’Académie des Sciences et Belles-Lettres de Berlin 17 (1768), 83–106 (read 1749).
- [4]R. Hackbarth, “Characterizing the Critical Line via Normalized Dirichlet Eta Terms: Concentric Circles, a Bernoulli Lemniscate, and Integer Algebraic Curves,” preprint, 2026, https://zenodo.org/records/24325291.
- [5]G. H. Hardy and E. M. Wright, An Introduction to the Theory of Numbers, 6th ed., Oxford University Press, Oxford, 2008.
- [6]T. Needham, Visual Complex Analysis, Clarendon Press, Oxford University Press, Oxford, 1997.
- [7]E. C. Titchmarsh, The Theory of the Riemann Zeta-Function, 2nd ed., Clarendon Press, Oxford, 1986.
- [8]H. Weyl, “Über die gleichverteilung von Zahlen mod. Eins,” Mathematische Annalen 77 (1916), 313–352.