betaFeedback

WorksPhysics and Astronomy

Comparison of observed and theoretically calculated amplitudes of Forbush effects for events associated with the arrival of a shock wave

Abstract

This paper examines the role of plasma compression regions ahead of interplanetary coronal mass ejections in the formation of Forbush effects decreases in cosmic ray intensity during the first phase. The aim of this study is to identify and quantify the relationship between the structure of the CME (specifically, the parameters of the compression region behind the shock front) and the nature of the observed Forbush effect. To this end, events with intensity decrease amplitudes greater than 5 percent were selected, and a theoretical model of cosmic ray behavior at the shock front was tested using modern analytical methods and mathematical models. Analysis of the results for two dozen events revealed satisfactory agreement between the theory and observations. The key reason for some discrepancies is the need to integrate the magnetic field over the particle gyro radius. The obtained data provide insight into the mechanisms of cosmic ray modulation in such environments.

Introduction

The ability of coronal mass ejections (CMEs) including the shock waves and compression regions that precede bodies of CMEs to dictate the behavior of cosmic rays has been repeatedly demonstrated through experimental, theoretical, and statistical research. These disturbances trigger a ”Forbush effect,” which is characterized by a multi-phase structure. The sequence of phases includes: precursors, manifesting as a pre-increase and/or pre-decrease in cosmic ray (CR) intensity ahead of the shock front; a phase of sharp intensity decline, which can sometimes be two-staged; the peak of the effect, corresponding to the minimum recorded intensity; and a recovery phase, during which CR intensity returns to background levels. A pre-increase is caused by the acceleration of particles at the front of an approaching disturbance, resulting from their reflection off the shock wave. A pre-decrease occurs when the Earth becomes magnetically connected via magnetic field lines to a region of a lower particle density; consequently, some cosmic rays from the region behind the shock front travel along these field lines and move away from the observation zone, which is observed as a pre-decrease in galactic cosmic ray (GCR) intensity prior to the main Forbush effect.

In cases where the decline profile is two-staged, the first stage corresponds to the passage of the compression region (the ”sheath”) located between the shock wave and the CME body, while the second stage corresponds to the passage of the CME body itself.

The plasma compression region (sheath) behind the shock front plays a pivotal role, as it governs the development of the Forbush effect during its initial phase. It is this region forming behind the shock front that acts as the ”trigger” for changes in the structure of the interplanetary magnetic field. This, in turn, leads to the modulation of cosmic-ray fluxes that is, to the occurrence of a Forbush effect.

The objective of this study is to identify and quantify the relationship between the structure of a solar ejection and the formation of an observed Forbush effect during its initial stage, as well as to analyze how the plasma compression parameters behind a shock front influence the nature of this effect.

Analysis, methodology and event selection

Model for intensity at the shock wave boundary.

The first phase of a Forbush decrease, associated with the arrival of an interplanetary shock wave, typically lasts only a few hours. This duration, in terms of its spatial scale, corresponds to the gyroradius of the particles. This short time interval can be explained by the reflection of particles from a region of enhanced magnetic field located behind the shock front.

The jump in the isotropic part of the cosmic-ray (CR) momentum distribution function N(p)N(p) across the shock front was calculated analytically by Webb (1983).

N1−N2=2μ031−μ02vcos⁡ψ,j=−Vshp3∂N∂p(1)N_{1} - N_{2} = \frac{2\mu_{0}^{3}}{1-\mu_{0}^{2}v\cos\psi}, \quad j = -\frac{V_{\mathrm{sh}}p}{3}\frac{\partial N}{\partial p} \tag*{(1)}

Here, VshV_{\mathrm{sh}} is the shock wave velocity, vv is the velocity of the cosmic ray (CR) particles, ψ\psi is the angle between the shock front normal and the magnetic field upstream of the front, μ0\mu_{0} is the critical value of the cosine of the pitch angle, which corresponds to magnetic reflection and is determined by the ratio of the magnetic fields downstream B2B_{2} and upstream B1B_{1} of the shock front, defined as μ02=1−B1/B2\mu_{0}^{2} = 1 - B_{1}/B_{2}. The expression (1) is valid under the condition that the projection of the cosmic ray anisotropy vector onto the shock front normal is zero. This assumption is well justified because the observed radial anisotropy of galactic cosmic rays is small. We assume that the galactic CR spectrum is a power law function on momentum N(p)=ap−(γ+2)N(p) = ap^{-(\gamma+2)}, where γ=2.5\gamma= 2.5 is the spectral index, and the amplitude aa is the only free parameter. The differential on energy cosmic ray intensity J(E)J(E) is related with the momentum distribution N(p)N(p) as J(E)=p2N(p)J(E) = p^{2}N(p).

Equation (1) demonstrates that the discontinuity in CR density at the shock front is directly proportional to the critical pitch-angle cosine μ0\mu_{0} (determined by the magnetic field ratio) and the radial flux jj (which is related to the momentum derivative of the spectrum). In physical terms, this means that particles with pitch angle cosines below the critical value μ0\mu_{0} are reflected as in the magnetic bottle downstream of the shock front and cannot penetrate further into the downstream region, whereas those with larger pitch angle cosines pass through. The difference (N1−N2)(N_{1} - N_{2}) represents a drop in CR number density immediately downstream of the shock front, which is observed as the initial phase of the Forbush decrease.

The existence of a jump in cosmic-ray (CR) number density at a shock front has been confirmed through numerical solutions of the kinetic equation that account for the particle pitch-angle scattering (Ruffolo, 1999; Kirk et al., 1989). In this study, the analytical results (Eq. (1)) are compared with observed Forbush decreases.

Sample

Groups of events were selected from the last three solar activity cycles (2000-2006, 2011-2015, and 2023-2026). A total of 20 Forbush effects were examined; the selection criteria were limited to a recorded Forbush-effect amplitude exceeding 5% and the availability of continuous data on the magnetic field and solar wind speed (from the OMNI dataset).

No selection was performed based on the magnetic field conditions downstream of the shock front, nor was there any filtering based on the angle ψ\psi between the shock-front normal and the magnetic field upstream of the front. Such events are expected to fall into the category of bad cases, as the theoretical framework employed here does not apply under those specific parameters.

Data used

The experimental basis for deriving cosmic ray (CR) intensity at an effective rigidity of Reff=10R_{\mathrm{eff}} = 10 GV outside the magnetosphere is the global network of neutron monitors, treated as a single, multidirectional detector. Data from this network were processed using the Global Spectrographic Method (GSM) (Krymsky et al. 1966; Nagashima 1971; Belov et al. 1983, 2018), which is, in essence, an advanced form of spherical analysis. The method accounts for the influence of both the atmosphere and the Earth’s magnetosphere (based on the asymptotic direction of each detector). This yields the characteristics of cosmic rays beyond the magnetosphere specifically, hourly estimates of isotropic intensity and of the CR anisotropy vector. The data are calibrated against the PAMELA proton flux measurements for 2009 (Belov et al., 2021) and are available via the (Database GSM, 2026) resource. The method ensures data homogeneity and stability, provides good statistical precision (∼0.01%\sim0.01\% per hour), and guarantees a completely continuous time series. It serves as a powerful tool for solar-terrestrial physics, enabling researchers to use ground-based data to look into regions where direct experimental observation is not possible.

The following resources concerning interplanetary parameters were utilized in this analysis: Continuous interplanetary data (magnetic field and velocity) were obtained from the OMNI database, which covers solar wind and interplanetary events. These data are accessible via the (Database NASA OMNI, 2026) portal. To minimize data gaps, a combination of OMNI records with different temporal resolutions one-minute and one-hour was used.

Shock wave velocity, the orientation of the shock surface normal, and plasma parameters were extracted from the CfA interplanetary disturbances database ((Database CfA, 2026)). Data on heliospheric shock waves and various parameters for each event were obtained from the IPShocks database ((Database IPShocks, 2026)). Forbush effects and interplanetary disturbances were sourced from the FEID database ((Database FEID, 2026)). The core concept of this catalog is to demonstrate the link between solar wind disturbances and variations of cosmic rays for each event. The database covers the period from July 1957 to December 2026 and includes over 9,400 events, encompassing 120 parameters related to cosmic rays, the interplanetary environment, and solar sources. To determine the angle between the normal to an interplanetary shock wave and the Sun-Earth line, data from spacecraft as presented in established, widely recognized catalogs were used ((Database IPShocks, 2026; Database CfA, 2026)). A description of standard magnetohydrodynamic and kinematic methods, which utilize data from multiple spacecraft to calculate the normals to interplanetary shock waves, can be found in (Shiryaev】【。 et al., 2025).

Discussion of results

This study examined 20 Forbush decreases with amplitudes exceeding 5%, occurring during the solar activity maxima of cycles 23-25. In summary, the agreement between theory and observation was found to be good in 8 cases and satisfactory in 6 cases the latter likely due to the need to integrate the magnetic field over a volume defined by the gyroradius. In the remaining cases, specific, anomalous features in cosmic-ray behavior were observed during the initial phase of the Forbush decrease. Examples of such events are presented below, along with a discussion of the potential reasons for any discrepancies.

Figure 1 illustrates the case of a strong agreement between observations and theory (the results are plotted as individual points). The duration of the plasma compression region is approximately 4 hours. This level of agreement can be attributed to several factors: a large angle between the shock front normal and the magnetic field ahead of the front, a narrow plasma compression region (lasting only a few hours), and a monotonic increase in the magnetic field during this interval.

Example of good theory-measurement agreement

Figure 1. Example of good theory-measurement agreement. CR intensity according to GSM data (left scale) and interplanetary magnetic field induction (right scale) for the Forbush effect 2005-05-16. The right scale also shows induction of zz-component of magnetic field (vertical lines) and solar wind speed (dots). The green vertical dashed lines mark the passage of a shock wave associated with an interplanetary coronal mass ejection (ICME), while the yellow and blue shaded areas correspond to the sheath and magnetic cloud (MC), respectively. The area between the two red vertical dashed lines corresponds to the ICME.

An example of satisfactory agreement is shown in Figure 2 - only the general course is consistent, but there is a large scatter in the theoretical and observed intensity values, which is apparently associated with large fluctuations and a non-monotonic course of the magnetic field. These reasons can be eliminated by integrating the magnetic field over the volume determined by the gyroradius, which requires the development of an appropriate technique.

Example of satisfactory agreement between theory and measurements for the Forbush effect on 2014-12-21

Figure 2. Example of satisfactory agreement between theory and measurements for the Forbush effect on 2014-12-21 (notation is the same as in Figure 1).

An example of poor agreement is shown in Figure 3. Such agreement should not be expected, as the angle ψ\psi that is the angle between the shock front normal and the magnetic field ahead of the front is small, the theory is not valid for events of this type. Furthermore, the event is not entirely isolated: a minor shock wave is observed within a 3-day window, and a significant decrease (likely a very large diurnal variation) occurs one day prior. Additionally, satellite data do not provide a clear determination of the angle ψ\psi or the shock velocity VshV_{\mathrm{sh}}.

Example of poor agreement between theory and measurements for the Forbush effect on March 8, 2012

Figure 3. Example of poor agreement between theory and measurements for the Forbush effect on March 8, 2012 (notation is the same as in Figure 1).

Conclusions

  1. The analysis demonstrates that the analytical expression derived by Webb (1983) for the jump of the particle number density at the shock front (Eq. (1)) provides a qualitatively accurate description of the initial phase of the Forbush effect specifically, the phase associated with the plasma sheath region preceding an interplanetary coronal mass ejection (ICME) during the first few hours of the event.

  1. Among the events examined, only one-third show good agreement between theory and measurements (ρ>0.8\rho> 0.8). A second group also comprising one-third of the events exhibits only qualitative agreement, characterized by significant scatter. In the third group, there is no agreement; this may be due to the event not being isolated, the presence of unique features in the Forbush effect, or the fact that the magnetic field lines are not tangential to the shock front meaning the angle ψ\psi (between the shock front normal and the magnetic field ahead of the front) is small.

  1. The approach proposed by Webb (1983) is applicable only during the initial period (the first few hours) of the plasma sheath region. To provide a complete description of cosmic-ray behavior throughout the entire plasma compression region, it is necessary to develop a theory applicable to this entire domain. This task is a part of our future plans.

  1. The discrepancy between theoretical and observed cosmic-ray intensity values for the second group of events could likely be resolved by integrating the magnetic field over a volume defined by the gyroradius. This, however, requires the development of an appropriate methodology.

Acknowledgments

The authors are grateful to the participants of the NMDB project (http://www.nmdb.eu) and the Russian National Ground-based Network of CR Stations (CR Network) (https://ckp-rf.ru/catalog/usu/433536) for the experimental data provided.

Funding

This work was supported by the IZMIRAN budget under project 1021025032100209-7-1-1.3.8, ”Solar activity and its manifestations in the heliosphere and near-Earth space” (FFUM-2026-0005).

Conflict of interest

The authors declare that they have no conflicts of interest with other researchers in this field.

ORCID iDs

Kobelev P.G. (https://orcid.org/0000-0002-9727-4395)

Zirakashvili V.N. (https://orcid.org/0009-0001-3524-641X)

Yanke V.G. (https://orcid.org/0000-0001-7098-9094)

References

  1. [1]Belov A.V., Dorman L.I., Yanke V.G. (1983). Proc. 18-th ICRC. 10, 144
  2. [2]Belov A.V., Eroshenko E.A., Yanke V.G. et al. (2018) Sol. Phys. 293(4), 68 https://doi.org/10.1007/s11207-018-1277-6
  3. [3]Belov A.V., Gushchina R.T., Shlyk N.S., Yanke V.G. (2021) Bull. Russ. Acad. Sci. Phys. 85, 1039 https://doi.org/10.3103/S1062873821090045
  4. [4]Catalog ICME. Catalog near-Earth Interplanetary CME Since 1996.
  5. [5]Richardson I., Cane H. URL: https://izw1.caltech.edu/ACE/ASC/DATA/level3/icmetable2.htm (accessed: 17.10.2026). http://doi.org/10.7910/DVN/C2MHTH
  6. [6]Database GSM. URL: https://disk.yandex.ru/d/mKHMM2dztqNoHw (part GSM). (accessed: 17.10.2026)
  7. [7]Database NASA OMNI. URL: https://nssdc.gsfc.nasa.gov (accessed: 17.10.2026)
  8. [8]Database of interplanetary shocks. A database of heliospheric shock waves maintained at the University of Helsinki. URL: https://ipshocks.helsinki.fi (accessed: 17.10.2026)

Paper details

vlnc:W_ue2rbeht
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 0

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Physics and Astronomy

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents