WorksAgricultural and Biological Sciences
Diversification under Global Competition: A Cutoff-Induced Localization Mechanism
Abstract
Niche differentiation promotes biological diversity but does not necessarily eliminate competition for shared limiting resources. What determines the extent of diversity when evolutionary diversification takes place under such constraints? We investigate this question using a simple, analytically tractable model combining mutations in continuous trait space, local competition, and global competition for shared resources. We show that, without an establishment threshold, the population spreads indefinitely in trait space even as its total abundance approaches a finite limit. In contrast, an arbitrarily small establishment threshold allows a stable localized distribution. Together with mortality induced by global competition, the threshold creates bistability, and global feedback drives the system exponentially close to the Maxwell point, where an isolated invasion front is stationary. The resulting soliton has height and width . Simulations with discrete individuals reveal an archipelago of fluctuating clusters whose spatial extent eventually reaches statistical saturation, unlike the continuous deterministic soliton. Nevertheless, an effective cutoff reproduces the observed scaling of the population mass deficit. Remarkably, both occupied trait-site richness and effective species richness exhibit approximately the same scaling as the deterministic soliton width. Thus, deterministic cutoff theory captures global diversity scaling despite failing to reproduce the community's spatial organization.
Introduction
The coexistence of what Darwin called “endless forms most beautiful and most wonderful” is a source of wonder, but also poses a scientific puzzle: how can such an extraordinary diversity be sustained in a world of limited resources? One of the central answers offered by evolutionary ecology is niche differentiation: species with different traits may specialize in exploiting different resources, thereby reducing competition among themselves [1, 2]. Yet in many ecological systems, niche differentiation does not eliminate competition for shared resources. Two tree species specializing in different nutrients still compete for water, sunlight, and space; in general, species occupying distinct niches may remain dependent on common limiting resources. What, then, determines the species richness that can be sustained under such conditions? Under what circumstances can evolutionary diversification continue despite competition for shared resources?
Ecological limits to diversification need not arise from a shortage of available niches. Storch and Okie argued that, although the addition of species may increase total community abundance by allowing more complete utilization of resources, this increase is ultimately constrained by finite resource and energy availability. Consequently, as species richness grows, individual populations tend to become smaller and more vulnerable to extinction, potentially limiting diversity even when niche space remains unsaturated [3]. A complementary perspective was provided by Tilman, who showed that the establishment of new species depends on the resources left available by resident species within a habitat, as well as on the stochastic survival of initially rare colonists [4].
Theoretical studies have also shown how trait-dependent competition can lead to differentiation and clustering in niche space [2, 5]. Yet the emergence of distinct niches does not, by itself, determine how far diversification can proceed when populations occupying different niches remain constrained by shared resources. This raises a more specific question: how do global competition for shared resources and the ability of initially small populations to establish themselves in previously unoccupied niches jointly determine the extent of diversification in trait space?
Here we introduce a simple, analytically tractable model of evolutionary diversification. Mutations allow a population to spread along a continuous axis of ecological traits; local competition limits the density of individuals with similar traits, while global competition for shared resources constrains the total population size. We examine how these ingredients determine the extent of ecological diversity, represented in the model by the width of the trait distribution. In the simplest version of the dynamics, the population continues to spread indefinitely in trait space even though its total mass approaches a finite limit. Consequently, an ever wider range of niches is occupied at progressively lower average density.
The unbounded spreading predicted by the deterministic continuum model relies on the assumption that reproduction remains possible at arbitrarily low local densities. In real populations, reproduction at low densities may be suppressed by an ecological Allee effect [6]; moreover, even in the absence of such an effect, demographic discreteness limits the validity of the continuum description and generates an effective cutoff [7, 8]. We therefore begin by examining the deterministic consequences of a sharp establishment threshold, below which reproduction is suppressed, and subsequently investigate what changes when demographic fluctuations are treated explicitly. We show that even an arbitrarily small threshold qualitatively changes the dynamics, allowing a stable localized trait distribution. The analytical tractability of the model enables us to construct the family of stationary localized solutions, determine their conditions of existence, and examine which branch is dynamically selected.
Physically, the establishment cutoff, together with the mortality imposed by global competition, creates bistability between empty and populated states. Global competition then provides feedback that nearly balances the invasion of empty niches against the retreat of populated ones, driving the system exceptionally close to the Maxwell point at which an isolated front is stationary. We show that the distance from this point is exponentially small in the inverse global competition strength (with a cutoff-dependent scale), whereas the width of the localized profile diverges logarithmically as the Maxwell point is approached. These results lead to nontrivial scaling laws: as the threshold tends to zero, the profile height scales as , while its width scales as .
Finally, we return to the demographic interpretation of the establishment threshold and ask how faithfully a deterministic cutoff can describe a population composed of discrete individuals. Previous studies have shown that demographic fluctuations can generate clusters in trait space even when the corresponding deterministic dynamics does not predict amplitude oscillations [9, 10]. We make a quantitative comparison between the individual-based model and the deterministic soliton, whose properties have been characterized analytically. We find that whereas the deterministic cutoff produces a continuous, localized profile, the stochastic dynamics generates an ever-changing archipelago of separated clusters whose spatial extent eventually reaches statistical saturation. Despite this fundamental difference in spatial organization, the analytical soliton prediction, with the cutoff identified as an effective discreteness scale, approximately captures the scaling of the population mass deficit in the individual-based model. This deficit, , measures the fractional shortfall of the mean total population mass from its limiting value in the absence of a cutoff. Moreover, the number of occupied trait niches and the effective species richness exhibit approximately the same scaling as the deterministic soliton width, although the spatial extent of the stochastic population is substantially larger. These results demonstrate that a simple deterministic description can capture the scaling laws of global ecological properties even when it fails to reproduce the spatial organization of the community.
A SOLVABLE ONE-DIMENSIONAL CONTINUUM MODEL OF LINEAGE LOCALIZATION
In this section, we introduce a minimal continuum model of evolution in trait space. We assume that represents a phenotypic trait and that denotes the population density along this trait axis at time . During reproduction, offspring inherit their parents’ traits with small random modifications, so that, in the continuum limit, mutations are represented by diffusion in trait space with diffusion coefficient . We assume that competition has two components: local competition between individuals with similar traits, represented by a quadratic density-dependent term, and global competition for a shared limiting resource, which persists even as organisms diversify into distinct ecological niches. The strength of global competition is proportional to the total population, . Finally, we introduce a local establishment threshold , below which reproduction is suppressed while competition-induced mortality remains operative. This threshold admits two distinct interpretations. It may represent a genuine ecological constraint, such as an idealized Allee effect, in which small local populations cannot reproduce effectively. Alternatively, it may serve as a deterministic approximation to demographic discreteness, following the cutoff approach of Brunet and Derrida [7]. These ingredients lead to a nonlinear reaction–diffusion equation, a nonlocal form of the cut-off Fisher-KPP equation [11] which we use to investigate how establishment thresholds and global competition for shared resources jointly regulate the spread of an evolving population in trait space.
Under these assumptions, the dynamics of the population density in trait space is governed by
where
Here, is the Heaviside step function, and controls the strength of global competition. We have chosen units in which both the reproduction rate and the coefficient of local competition are unity. Reproduction therefore occurs only where the population density exceeds the threshold , whereas mortality due to local and global competition operates at all densities. Crucially, the global competition term depends on the integral over the entire trait space, so that populations occupying widely separated regions of this space continue to compete for the same shared resource.
We wish to determine whether the dynamics can support a stationary state in which the population remains localized within an effectively bounded region of trait space, despite the continuous spreading induced by mutations. Such a state does not imply that reproduction and mutation have ceased, but rather that a dynamical balance has been established in which the trait distribution remains constant in time. We therefore seek a stationary profile with finite total mass, satisfying and as . Since the model is translationally invariant, we may center the profile at and seek a symmetric solution. Importantly, the strength of global competition is determined by the total population in addition to . Defining , we first seek localized stationary solutions for a given , and then impose the self-consistency condition
where denotes the stationary profile obtained for that value of .
In the stationary state, the equation of motion then becomes
To find localized solutions, we employ the standard technique of a mechanical analogy in which the trait coordinate plays the role of time, while represents the position of a particle moving, with no friction, in an effective potential . The stationary equation can then be written as
The effective potential is obtained by integrating Eq. (5). The integration constants are fixed by choosing and requiring the potential to be continuous at , where the reproduction term switches on. This gives
The mechanical analogy provides a simple way to identify localized stationary solutions. Since we seek a profile for which both and its derivative vanish as , and since , conservation of mechanical energy requires
A localized solution corresponds to a homoclinic orbit: the particle starts at as , moves towards positive values of , reaches a turning point , and returns to as . Choosing the turning point at , the corresponding population profile satisfies
The turning point, at which the kinetic energy vanishes, thus satisfies
Eq. (7) implies
Thus, a localized solution requires the potential to be negative between the origin and the turning point,
As increases from 0, the potential initially decreases till , then starts rising and eventually reaches a maximum beyond which it decreases (Figure 1). Thus the maximum value of has to be positive for there to be a turning point . The local maximum of the potential occurs at , where

Figure 1. Mechanical potential of the one-dimensional continuum model. A representative example for . For (solid), the zero-energy orbit leaves , reaches the first positive zero of , and returns, giving a localized stationary pulse. At (dashed), the right-hand maximum touches at ; the turning point becomes marginal and the pulse width diverges. For , the maximum lies below zero and no zero-energy localized pulse exists.
Requiring yields
provided the cutoff is sufficiently small, , so that .
For every , we have, therefore, a localized stationary solution . However, in the original model, is not an independent parameter but must satisfy the self-consistency condition (Eq. (3)) . Thus, each soliton in this family can be associated with a global competition strength for which it is a stationary solution:
Figure 2 shows for and . The function is nonmonotonic and exhibits a maximum. Consequently, a given global competition strength may admit either zero or two distinct stationary solutions. For example, the horizontal line corresponding to intersects the curve at two points, and , representing solitons with different heights and widths, as illustrated by the profiles shown in the insets. The existence of these stationary solutions does not, by itself, establish their dynamical stability.

Figure 2. Self-consistency along the family of localized stationary solutions. For and , each admits a localized solution with total mass . The solid curve shows the corresponding global competition strength, . For the chosen value (horizontal dashed line), two intersections are obtained, at and , representing two distinct stationary solutions of the same model. The maximum and the critical value are indicated by dotted lines. The insets show the corresponding density profiles, with dotted horizontal lines marking the reproduction cutoff . As , the mass diverges logarithmically and approaches zero; this limiting behavior occurs on a scale too narrow to be resolved in the main plot.
To understand the behavior of the localized solutions, we first consider the limit in which the reproduction cutoff approaches zero. In the absence of this cutoff, our model reduces to a Fisher-type reaction–diffusion equation with global competition between individuals, regardless of their separation in trait space. While global competition limits the total population, it cannot prevent its spreading in trait space. In particular, as we demonstrate in Appendix § 6, even in the presence of infinite-range interactions, the population distribution continues to spread indefinitely when . Since the total population remains bounded, this spreading is accompanied by a progressive decrease in population density. Thus, the reproduction cutoff provides the mechanism that allows a localized stationary profile to exist, and we expect its width to diverge as . We therefore focus on the broad branch of stationary solutions, which turns out to be dynamically stable, whereas the narrow branch is unstable, as discussed in Appendix § 7.
From the mechanical analogy, we know that this divergence occurs as approaches its critical value from below. In this limit, the particle spends an increasingly long time near the maximum of the effective potential, producing a broad, nearly flat population profile whose height approaches the position of that maximum.
Using the critical value obtained in Eq. (13), the soliton height satisfies
On the other hand, the self-consistency condition requires
Thus, although the soliton height vanishes, its total mass remains finite. Defining the effective soliton width as the ratio of its total mass to its height, we obtain
We therefore arrive at the scaling laws
Interestingly, the diffusion coefficient does not appear in the leading-order expressions for the soliton height and width. In this limit, the height is determined by the reproduction cutoff, the total mass by global competition, and the width follows from their ratio. These scaling laws are confirmed numerically in Figure 3(B)–(D).

Figure 3. Numerical verification of soliton scaling laws. Results for fixed global competition strength and diffusion coefficient . (A) Stationary density profiles on the broad soliton branch for decreasing values of the reproduction cutoff . As the cutoff decreases, the soliton becomes broader and lower, developing a nearly flat plateau. The horizontal dotted lines indicate the corresponding cutoff values. (B) Peak height as a function of . The dashed line shows the asymptotic prediction . (C) Effective width and full width at half maximum (FWHM). Both approach the parameter-free asymptotic prediction (dashed line). (D) Total mass as a function of . The dashed horizontal line marks the limiting value , while the dotted curve shows the approximation , where . (E) Exponential approach to criticality. Writing and , we plot against . The dashed line has the theoretically predicted slope , with a fitted additive constant. Blue circles represent self-consistent stationary solutions calculated from the full mechanical energy integral. Red squares show the long-time states obtained by direct numerical integration of the time-dependent equation, confirming convergence to the broad stationary branch. The results in panel (E) were obtained independently of the asymptotic approximation, by solving the full self-consistency condition using arbitrary-precision arithmetic with as the numerical parameter.
We can further characterize how the broad soliton approaches the critical point. Let us define
As , the local maximum of the effective potential approaches zero energy. In the mechanical analogy, the particle spends an increasingly long time near a quadratic maximum, causing the soliton width to diverge logarithmically:
Since the profile becomes broad and nearly flat, with a height approaching , its total mass also diverges logarithmically:
However, the self-consistency condition requires
Consequently,
Substituting this result into Eq. (20) gives , in agreement with Eq. (18). This result fixes the leading exponential dependence of on ,
Thus, self-consistency drives the stable soliton exponentially close to the critical point as , as confirmed numerically in Figure 3(E). This proximity allows the soliton to become extremely broad even as its height vanishes.
For completeness, we briefly examine the asymptotic decay of the soliton tails. In the region where , reproduction is suppressed, and at sufficiently low densities the stationary equation reduces to
For , the tails therefore decay exponentially,
with a characteristic decay length
Formally, when , the local competition term must be retained, yielding an algebraic decay,
However, this limit is not relevant to the broad self-consistent soliton considered here. As at fixed , we have , so that remains finite. The divergence of the soliton width, , therefore originates from the expansion of its nearly flat, populated interior rather than from the dilute tails.
Demographic discreteness and deterministic establishment thresholds
We have so far represented the failure of small populations to establish themselves by a deterministic reproductive cutoff. This approximation has a natural demographic interpretation, but it is not equivalent to an explicit population of discrete individuals. A single individual arriving in an unoccupied niche can reproduce, although its descendants may subsequently become extinct through demographic fluctuations. In contrast, the deterministic cutoff suppresses reproduction altogether below a prescribed density. The question is therefore which predictions of the localized state survive when the cutoff is replaced by stochastic birth, death, and mutation. Previous work has shown that deterministic cutoffs can capture aspects of front propagation while missing spreading driven by stochastic cluster formation [10]. Our analytically characterized localized solution provides an opportunity to test this correspondence quantitatively.
We perform this comparison on a one-dimensional lattice of trait values, keeping the mutation and competition rules fixed while changing the description of the population. In the individual-based model, site contains an integer number of individuals, with density and total rescaled population . Each individual reproduces at rate one, hops to either neighboring site at rate per direction, and dies at a rate
The first term represents competition with other individuals at the same site, and the second represents competition for shared global resources. There is no reproductive cutoff or Allee effect in this stochastic model: the per-capita reproduction rate is independent of local density. As a complementary approximation, we simulate demographic noise in a continuous-density lattice model using the scheme developed by [12], which builds on the split-step algorithm introduced by [13], with a leading-order noise variance of per unit time. Finally, we evolve the deterministic lattice equation with a reproductive cutoff,
The use of the same trait lattice separates the effects of discreteness in trait space from those of demographic fluctuations.
Demographic fluctuations are known to generate spontaneous spatial clustering even in the absence of attractive interactions between individuals [14, 15, 16]. More directly relevant to evolutionary diversification, Rogers, McKane, and Rossberg demonstrated that demographic noise can produce clusters in trait space even when the corresponding deterministic dynamics does not predict pattern formation [9]. Figure 4(A) illustrates this effect in our model: the continuous deterministic soliton is replaced by an archipelago of spatially separated population clusters, each comprising individuals with similar traits. In an evolutionary interpretation, these clusters may be viewed as groups of closely related species, analogous to genera separated in trait space. Following an initial period of expansion, the stochastic population reaches a statistically stationary spatial extent, as shown in the inset, although its saturated width is substantially larger than that of the deterministic soliton. Individual clusters continue to fluctuate, migrate, appear, and disappear, so that the stochastic state is not a stationary density profile but a dynamically maintained, fragmented population. This pronounced difference in spatial organization raises a natural question: to what extent do the analytical predictions obtained for the deterministic soliton remain applicable to the stochastic population?

Figure 4. Comparison between the deterministic soliton and the discrete-individual population. (A) Population density in trait space for , , and . The dark-blue curve shows the deterministic soliton with ; the red profile is a Gillespie realization at . The dotted line marks the single-individual density . The inset shows the evolution of for three realizations (thin lines), their eight-realization mean (thick line), and the deterministic soliton width. (B) Stationary mass deficit versus . Orange and blue triangles show Gillespie results for and , respectively; teal-filled and open grey symbols show split-step and discrete-time simulations. Marker orientation distinguishes mutation rates. For , averages are taken over the stationary regime of 8 realizations (16 at ). The solid line is the analytical prediction with ; the dashed line uses , with a single fitted coefficient. (C) Spatial extent (triangles), occupied trait sites (circles), and effective species richness (squares), for . Filled and open symbols correspond to and , respectively. Solid and dashed lines show the corresponding deterministic soliton widths with . The inset shows the ratios to . The indicated exponents are power-law fits over the investigated range.
We begin with the total population mass. To compare the analytical prediction for the deterministic soliton with the individual-based model, we must identify the reproductive cutoff with an appropriate discreteness scale in the stochastic system. Since a single individual at a lattice site corresponds to a density , this would appear to be the natural scale. However, diffusion reduces local demographic fluctuations by mixing individuals between neighboring sites. When distances are measured in units of the diffusive length scale , the demographic noise strength is controlled by the combination rather than by alone. This suggests an effective cutoff of the form , where the numerical prefactor is not determined by this scaling argument. For the deterministic soliton, we found that the mass deficit obeys . Figure 4(B) shows that the mean mass deficit in the stochastic model is well described by the same expression, with . This agreement holds across different values of the population-size parameter , the mutation rate , and the global competition strength .
Next we examine whether a similar correspondence holds for the extent and diversity of the stochastic population in trait space. Figure 4(C) compares the width of the deterministic soliton with three measures of the stochastic population: the spatial extent containing 95% of all individuals, the number of occupied trait sites , which may be interpreted as species richness, and the effective species richness , which accounts for differences in abundance among species. Despite the fragmented structure of the stochastic population, both measures of richness exhibit approximately the same scaling as the deterministic soliton width. In particular, the ratio of occupied sites to soliton width approaches a value of approximately 1.6, while the ratio remains nearly constant. The spatial extent also increases with , but is substantially larger and grows somewhat faster over the investigated range, reflecting the empty gaps separating the clusters. Thus, although the deterministic theory does not reproduce the spatial organization of the stochastic population, it approximately captures the scaling of the number of occupied trait niches.
In summary, the comparison between the deterministic and individual-based models shows that an effective reproductive cutoff can approximately reproduce the scaling laws of total population mass and species richness, even though it fails to capture the spatial organization of the population. Whereas the deterministic cutoff produces a continuous, localized soliton, demographic fluctuations generate a dynamic archipelago of separated clusters spanning a substantially broader range of trait space. This distinction highlights two different interpretations of the reproductive cutoff. A genuine ecological establishment threshold, such as an Allee effect, may arrest diversification through the front-pinning mechanism analyzed here. Demographic discreteness, in contrast, does not completely prevent small populations from establishing, but instead gives rise to stochastic dynamics in which clusters continually emerge and disappear. Despite these differences, our results suggest that a simple deterministic description can correctly predict the scaling of global ecological properties even when it fails to reproduce the spatial organization of the community.
Discussion
A central question in evolutionary ecology is what determines the extent of biological diversity when differentiation into new niches reduces competition among species but does not eliminate competition for shared resources. Our results suggest that resource limitation, even when it regulates the total population size, is not sufficient by itself to constrain the spread of a population in trait space: without an establishment threshold, the population occupies an ever-widening range of traits at ever lower density, whereas an arbitrarily small threshold allows a stable localized distribution. Thus, the extent of diversity depends not only on the availability of potential niches or the total amount of resources, but also on the ability of initially small populations to establish themselves in new niches. The analytical tractability of the model makes this dependence quantitative, . Although the width of a trait distribution is not equivalent to species richness, it provides a quantitative measure of the extent of ecological differentiation and of the constraints acting upon it.
The localization mechanism identified here differs from the pattern-forming instabilities found in models with nonlocal competition, where trait-dependent interactions can destabilize homogeneous states and generate spatial patterns [5, 17, 18]. Our model has no such finite-wavelength instability. Instead, the establishment threshold, together with mortality imposed by global competition, creates bistability between empty and populated states, allowing localization through the arrest of invasion fronts. As the population expands, global competition increases and suppresses further invasion of unoccupied niches; as it contracts, competition weakens. In the small-cutoff regime, this feedback drives the system exponentially close to the Maxwell point, where invasion and retreat of an isolated front are balanced. The logarithmic divergence of the profile width near this point, combined with the global self-consistency condition, explains how a finite extent is selected without an externally imposed niche-scale length. Front arrest and localized colonies have previously been studied in systems with Allee effects and nonlocal interactions [6, 19, 20, 21]. The distinctive contribution of the present model is an analytically tractable description of how a local establishment threshold and global resource competition jointly select the extent of evolutionary diversification.
The establishment threshold admits two biological interpretations, and distinguishing between them is essential. When it represents an Allee effect, it describes a genuine ecological limitation on the ability of small populations to establish themselves, and the front-arrest mechanism analyzed here provides a possible explanation for the limitation of diversification into new niches. When the cutoff serves instead as a deterministic proxy for demographic discreteness, a more complex picture emerges. As established in previous studies, demographic fluctuations can generate separated clusters in trait space even when the corresponding deterministic dynamics does not predict such patterns [9, 15, 16]. Nevertheless, our quantitative comparison shows that, despite this fundamental difference in spatial organization, the deterministic cutoff approximately reproduces the scaling of the population mass deficit. when identified with an effective discreteness scale, . Moreover, both the number of occupied trait niches and the effective species richness exhibit approximately the same scaling as the deterministic soliton width. Thus, the deterministic theory captures the scaling of global community properties even though it fails to describe the spatial organization of the population.
The difference between the two descriptions is particularly evident in the role of rare events at the edges of the population. In the deterministic cutoff model, reproduction is completely suppressed below the threshold, preventing invasion fronts from advancing beyond the populated region. In the stochastic model, however, even a single individual arriving in an unoccupied niche may reproduce and establish a new population. Such events, together with local extinctions, generate a dynamic archipelago of clusters that appear, disappear, and migrate through trait space. Our simulations show that, following an initial period of expansion, the spatial extent of this archipelago also reaches statistical saturation, although its saturated width is substantially larger than that of the deterministic soliton. Furthermore, whereas the number of occupied trait niches approximately follows the soliton scaling law, the spatial extent grows somewhat faster over the investigated parameter range, reflecting the empty gaps between clusters. Thus, the mechanism determining the scale of ecological diversity does not necessarily determine its spatial extent. Deriving the observed scaling laws directly from the microscopic stochastic dynamics, and understanding the factors controlling the separation between clusters, remain open theoretical questions.
Our results also have implications for eco-evolutionary models based on generalized Lotka–Volterra dynamics, in which new species inherit interaction coefficients similar to those of their ancestors [22, 23, 24]. In such models, evolutionary differentiation may progressively weaken competition between species, potentially driving the community toward nearly noninteracting populations. Similarly, models with finite-range competition in niche space explicitly allow sufficiently dissimilar species to avoid competition altogether [25]. When such models are intended to describe communities constrained by shared limiting resources, this complete decoupling should be prevented. One simple implementation is to retain a positive baseline of competition, irrespective of the evolutionary distance between species. Our analysis shows, however, that this global competitive constraint limits total population size without necessarily limiting the extent of diversification in trait space. A mechanism suppressing the establishment of sufficiently small populations is also needed to obtain localization.
Finally, our model describes an idealized ecological system: a one-dimensional trait space, local competition between individuals with identical traits, and uniform global competition for shared resources. In natural communities, competition typically extends over a finite range of trait differences, while shared resources may themselves be heterogeneous or fluctuate in time. An important question is therefore how robust the front-arrest mechanism and the resulting scaling laws are to relaxing these assumptions. In particular, it would be interesting to consider smooth establishment thresholds and finite-range competition kernels, and to investigate under what conditions the clusters emerging from stochastic dynamics may develop into distinct evolutionary lineages.
The role of the dimensionality of trait space is particularly interesting. In one dimension a mutant almost always lands in a niche that is already occupied, so that mutation acts as diffusion and neighboring populations continually rescue one another. In the opposite limit of a high-dimensional trait space a mutant never lands in an occupied niche; every mutation founds a new type, and the individual-based model of § 3 reduces to an infinite-allele community in which each type is limited by its own density while all types share a common competitive load. This is the niche-stabilized neutral model solved by Pigolotti and Cencini [26], with their stabilization parameter corresponding to . In that limit there are no fronts and no soliton: each type fluctuates around its own carrying capacity until it is lost, and the mass deficit is set by the balance between origination and extinction of types. The scaling laws found here need not survive in that limit.
More broadly, our results emphasize that the emergence of new ecological opportunities does not guarantee that they will be occupied. The fate of initially rare populations attempting to establish themselves in new niches may play a decisive role in determining the extent of biological diversity.
Appendices
Absence of localization without a cutoff
Here we show that, in the absence of a reproduction cutoff, global competition can limit the total population but cannot prevent its spreading in trait space. In particular, any initially localized population must broaden indefinitely.
Setting , the evolution equation becomes
We consider nonnegative, nonzero initial conditions with finite total mass and sufficient regularity and decay for the following integrations to be valid.
To separate the total population from its spatial distribution, we introduce the normalized density
Integrating Eq. (30) over space gives
Substituting into Eq. (30), and using Eq. (32), we obtain
Notice that the global competition term has disappeared explicitly from the equation for the normalized distribution. Global competition regulates the total population, but does not directly favor one position in trait space over another.
The quantity provides a convenient measure of localization. For a distribution that is approximately uniform over a region of width , normalization gives , and hence . We may therefore define an effective width
To establish unlimited spreading, it is sufficient to show that tends to zero.
Differentiating and using Eq. (33), we find
where we have integrated the diffusion term by parts. By the Cauchy–Schwarz inequality,
Consequently, both terms on the right-hand side of Eq. (35) are nonpositive, and
Thus diffusion and local competition both act to reduce localization.
To show that the spreading continues indefinitely, rather than approaching a finite width, we use the one-dimensional Nash inequality [27]. For a normalized nonnegative density , it states that
where is a universal constant. Combining Eqs. (37) and (38) gives
Integrating this differential inequality yields
It follows that
Therefore, the effective width grows without bound, at least as fast as at long times. In particular, no nonzero localized stationary solution can exist when .
Finally, we show that this unlimited spreading is compatible with a finite total population. Introducing , Eq. (32) becomes
Since Eq. (40) establishes , the solution of this linear equation satisfies . Hence
Thus, without a cutoff, global competition determines the asymptotic population mass but does not confine its distribution in trait space. The population becomes increasingly dilute as it spreads over an ever-growing range of traits. A reproduction cutoff is therefore essential for the localized stationary solutions studied in the main text.
Stability of the localized solutions
We analyze the stability of localized stationary solutions of the full nonlocal evolution equation introduced in the main text, which we reproduce here for completeness:
As explained in the main text, stationary localized profiles can be constructed by temporarily treating as an independent parameter and solving
for . The corresponding global competition strength is then fixed by the self-consistency condition
As shown in Figure 2 of the main text, has a maximum . For any fixed , the condition admits two stationary localized solutions, a narrow pulse and a broad pulse. We now examine their dynamical stability.
For either stationary solution, let , where is a small perturbation and is held fixed. Linearizing the full evolution equation gives
where
For the sharp cutoff, is understood in the distributional sense (or as the limit of a smooth cutoff).
To identify the zero mode associated with the fold, we differentiate the stationary profile equation (B2) with respect to the parameter , obtaining
Applying the full linearized operator and using Eq. (49), we obtain
Here we used and , the latter following directly from . At the maximum of the self-consistency curve, , and hence
Thus the fold is accompanied by a neutral mode corresponding to a change in the stationary pulse profile. This mode is distinct from the neutral translation mode, which exists for every .
To examine which side of the fold is stable, we choose a fixed just below . As illustrated in Figure 5, the line intersects the self-consistency curve at (the narrow pulse) and (the broad pulse). To test the stability of each stationary solution , with , at fixed , we replace it by the nearby stationary profile , where . This new profile corresponds to . We then use it as the initial condition for the dynamics at the original competition strength . On the rising branch , whereas on the falling branch .

Figure 5. Schematic enlargement of the fold in Figure 2 of the main text. At , the two filled points denote the narrow and broad stationary pulses. Rightward shifts lead to nearby auxiliary stationary profiles (open points), requiring , with and . In the argument, is very close to ; their separation and the shifts are exaggerated for visibility.
Write and . The shifted profile is stationary at , and therefore satisfies
The evolution of the same profile at the original competition strength instead obeys, at ,
Subtracting the stationary equation cancels the diffusion and local growth terms, leaving
Integrating over space, we obtain the exact initial mass response:
To interpret the sign of this response, note that implies at the fold. Thus the positive shift increases the initial mass on both branches. For the narrow pulse, , so the mass initially grows still further; for the broad pulse, , so it initially decreases. Thus the initial mass response reinforces the perturbation for the narrow pulse and opposes it for the broad pulse. Although this is not a complete stability analysis, it provides a plausible physical explanation for the instability of the narrow pulse and the stability of the broad one, consistent with the numerical time evolution. This picture is also supported by Appendix § 6, which shows that without a reproduction cutoff () a localized population spreads indefinitely. The resulting expectation that the stable localized solution becomes arbitrarily broad as is consistent with the behavior of the broad branch established in the main text.
References
- [1]U. Dieckmann and M. Doebeli, On the origin of species by sympatric speciation, Nature 400, 354 (1999).
- [2]M. Scheffer and E. H. van Nes, Self-organized similarity, the evolutionary emergence of groups of similar species, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 103, 6230 (2006).pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/16585519
- [3]D. Storch and J. G. Okie, The carrying capacity for species richness, Global Ecology and Biogeography 28, 1519 (2019).DOI
- [4]D. Tilman, Niche tradeoffs, neutrality, and community structure: A stochastic theory of resource competition, invasion, and community assembly, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 101, 10854 (2004).pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/15243158
- [5]S. Pigolotti, C. López, and E. Hernández-García, Species clustering in competitive Lotka–Volterra models, Physical Review Letters 98, 258101 (2007).DOI
- [6]T. H. Keitt, M. A. Lewis, and R. D. Holt, Allee effects, invasion pinning, and species’ borders, The American Naturalist 157, 203 (2001).DOI
- [7]E. Brunet and B. Derrida, Shift in the velocity of a front due to a cutoff, Physical Review E 56, 2597 (1997).DOI
- [8]B. Perthame and M. Gauduchon, Survival thresholds and mortality rates in adaptive dynamics: Conciliating deterministic and stochastic simulations, Mathematical Medicine and Biology 27, 195 (2010).DOI
- [9]T. Rogers, A. J. McKane, and A. G. Rossberg, Demographic noise can lead to the spontaneous formation of species, EPL (Europhysics Letters) 97, 40008 (2012).DOI
- [10]Y. A. Ganan and D. A. Kessler, Front propagation and clustering in the stochastic nonlocal Fisher equation, Physical Review E 97, 042213 (2018).DOI
- [11]H. Berestycki, G. Nadin, B. Perthame, and L. Ryzhik, The non-local Fisher–KPP equation: travelling waves and steady states, Nonlinearity 22, 2813 (2009).DOI
- [12]H. Weissmann, N. M. Shnerb, and D. A. Kessler, Simulation of spatial systems with demographic noise, Physical Review E 98, 022131 (2018).DOI
- [13]I. Dornic, H. Chaté, and M. A. Munoz, Integration of Langevin equations with multiplicative noise and the viability of field theories for absorbing phase transitions, Physical Review Letters 94, 100601 (2005).pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/15783467
- [14]M. Meyer, S. Havlin, and A. Bunde, Clustering of independently diffusing individuals by birth and death processes, Physical Review E 54, 5567 (1996).pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/9965742
- [15]W. R. Young, A. J. Roberts, and G. Stuhne, Reproductive pair correlations and the clustering of organisms, Nature 412, 328 (2001).pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/11460162
- [16]B. Houchmandzadeh, Clustering of diffusing organisms, Physical Review E 66, 052902 (2002).pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/12513541
- [17]Y. E. Maruvka and N. M. Shnerb, Nonlocal competition and logistic growth: patterns, defects, and fronts, Physical Review E 73, 011903 (2006).pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/16486181
- [18]M. Fuentes, M. Kuperman, and V. Kenkre, Nonlocal interaction effects on pattern formation in population dynamics, Physical Review Letters 91, 158104 (2003).pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/14611503
- [19]M. G. Clerc, D. Escaff, and V. M. Kenkre, Analytical studies of fronts, colonies, and patterns: Combination of the Allee effect and nonlocal competition interactions, Physical Review E 82, 036210 (2010).pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/21230164
- [20]Y. E. Maruvka and N. M. Shnerb, Nonlocal competition and front propagation in branching-coalescence systems, Physical Review E—Statistical, Nonlinear, and Soft Matter Physics 75, 042901 (2007).pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/17500943
- [21]D. A. Kessler and H. Levine, Pulse instabilities can shape virus-immune coevolution, Physical Review Research 6, 033300 (2024).DOI
- [22]L. R. Ginzburg, H. R. Akçakaya, and J. Kim, Evolution of community structure: Competition, Journal of Theoretical Biology 133, 513 (1988).DOI
- [23]E. Shtilerman, D. A. Kessler, and N. M. Shnerb, Emergence of structured communities through evolutionary dynamics, Journal of Theoretical Biology 383, 138 (2015).DOI
- [24]F. Farahpour, M. Saeedghalati, V. S. Brauer, and D. Hoffmann, Trade-off shapes diversity in eco-evolutionary dynamics, eLife 7, e36273 (2018).DOI
- [25]S. Y. Li, M. Kardar, Z. Feng, and W. Taylor, Minimal model of self-organized clusters with phase transitions in ecological communities, Physical Review E 113, 044306 (2026).DOI
- [26]S. Pigolotti and M. Cencini, Species abundances and lifetimes: From neutral to niche-stabilized communities, Journal of Theoretical Biology 338, 1 (2013).DOI
- [27]J. Nash, Continuity of solutions of parabolic and elliptic equations, American Journal of Mathematics 80, 931 (1958).DOI