betaFeedback

WorksPhysics and Astronomy

Exotic phases in finite-density Z3\mathbb{Z}_3 theories

Abstract

Lattice Z3\mathbb{Z}_3 theories with complex actions share many key features with finite-density QCD including a sign problem and CKCK symmetry. Complex Z3\mathbb{Z}_3 spin and gauge models exhibit a generalized Kramers-Wannier duality mapping them onto chiral Z3\mathbb{Z}_3 spin and gauge models, which are simulatable with standard lattice methods in large regions of parameter space. The Migdal-Kadanoff real-space renormalization group (RG) preserves this duality, and we use it to compute the approximate phase diagram of both spin and gauge Z3\mathbb{Z}_3 models in dimensions one through four. Chiral Z3\mathbb{Z}_3 spin models are known to exhibit a Devil's Flower phase structure, with inhomogeneous phases which can be thought of as Z3\mathbb{Z}_3 analogues of chiral spirals. Out of the large class of models we study, we find that only chiral spin models and their duals have a Devil's Flower structure with an infinite set of inhomogeneous phases, a result we attribute to Elitzur's theorem. We also find that different forms of the Migdal-Kadanoff RG produce different numbers of phases, a violation of the expectation for universal behavior from a real-space RG. We discuss extensions of our work to ZN\mathbb{Z}_N models, SU(NN) models and nonzero temperature.

E-mail: [email protected], [email protected]

Introduction

A central objective of nuclear physics is mapping out the phases of QCD in the baryon density-temperature (μB\mu_B-TT) plane [1, 2, 3]. Several major collider experiments are pursuing this goal, including RHIC at Brookhaven [4, 5], ALICE at CERN [6], and the planned CBM experiment at FAIR [7]. To complement this work, a simultaneous theoretical effort is targeting QCD phase structure from first principles [8]; however, at present we lack rigorous and systematically improvable methods to probe much of μB\mu_B-TT plane. On the numerical front, lattice QCD calculations at μB≳T\mu_B \gtrsim T are obstructed by a sign problem [9, 10, 11, 12]. While many approaches are under development to overcome sign problems [13, 14, 15, 16, 17, 18, 19, 20, 21, 22, 23, 24, 25, 26, 27, 28, 29, 30, 31, 32, 33, 34, 35, 36], they cannot fully handle QCD yet. On the analytic front, various effective field theories (EFTs) have been developed such as hard thermal loops [37, 38] and high density effective theory [39, 40], but these only cover limited regions of parameter space. In the near term, there exist few viable first-principles approaches to finite-density QCD, such as Taylor expansions off the TT-axis [41, 42, 43, 44] and studies at imaginary baryon chemical potential [45, 46, 47, 48, 49].

A more recently proposed approach to understanding finite-density QCD capitalizes on one of its symmetries, combined charge and complex conjugation symmetry CK\mathcal{C}\mathcal{K} [50, 51, 52]. We can see this symmetry directly from the QCD Lagrangian at finite density [52],

\mathcal{L}_{\mathrm{QCD}}^{\mathrm{Eucl}}=\bar{\psi}_{j}(i\slashed{D}-m)\psi_{j}+\frac{1}{4}G_{\mu\nu}^{A}G_{\mu\nu}^{A}+i\mu_{B}\bar{\psi}\gamma^{4}\psi \tag*{(1)}

where ψj\psi_j are fermion fields, DD is a covariant derivative, GG is the gluon field strength, μB\mu_B is the baryon chemical potential, and γi\gamma^i represents the standard Dirac matrices. It is well known that when μB=0\mu_B=0, QCD preserves charge conjugation C\mathcal{C}, parity inversion P\mathcal{P}, and time-reversal T\mathcal{T} symmetries individually and in combination. The situation changes substantially when we turn on a nonzero baryon density term μB\mu_B in eq. (1). While the fermion bilinear ψˉγ4ψ\bar{\psi}\gamma^{4}\psi remains invariant under P\mathcal{P} and T\mathcal{T}, it flips sign under C\mathcal{C}. In turn, the lattice path integral weights in eq. (1) and the fermion determinant become complex, the transfer matrix becomes non-Hermitian, and QCD develops a sign problem. Additionally, eq. (1) loses Lorentz invariance at μB≠0\mu_B\ne0, as the chemical potential picks out a preferred direction (γ4\gamma^4 rather than γμ\gamma^\mu). However, the complex conjugation operation K\mathcal{K} flips the sign of ii while leaving the constant μB\mu_B and the bilinear ψˉγ4ψ\bar{\psi}\gamma^4\psi invariant. Thus, the combined operation CK\mathcal{C}\mathcal{K} leaves the entire Lagrangian invariant.

The operation CK\mathcal{C}\mathcal{K} belongs to the class of PT\mathcal{P}\mathcal{T}-type symmetries, which are widely studied in optics and condensed matter for their unique properties and extensive experimental applications [53, 54, 55, 56, 57, 58, 59, 60, 61]. A PT\mathcal{P}\mathcal{T}-type symmetry is any symmetry combining one linear operator (e.g. P\mathcal{P} or C\mathcal{C}) and one antilinear operator (e.g. T\mathcal{T} or K\mathcal{K}). Importantly, PT\mathcal{P}\mathcal{T}-symmetric matrices may be non-Hermitian; however, every eigenvalue of a PT\mathcal{P}\mathcal{T}-symmetric system is always either real or part of a complex-conjugate pair [53, 62]. The study of quantum field theories with non-Hermitian transfer matrices and PT\mathcal{P}\mathcal{T}-type symmetries is a far younger field than PT\mathcal{P}\mathcal{T}-symmetric quantum mechanics and optics. Nonetheless, many steps have been taken towards developing a formal understanding of and techniques for these systems [63, 64, 65, 66, 67, 68, 69, 70, 71, 72, 73, 74, 75, 76, 77, 78, 79, 80]. A number of PT\mathcal{P}\mathcal{T}-QFTs have been studied within the context of Beyond the Standard Model (BSM) model building [81, 82, 83, 84, 85, 86, 87, 88, 89, 90, 91]. Within the Standard Model, several models sharing features of dense QCD have been analyzed using tools based on non-Hermiticity and CK\mathcal{C}\mathcal{K} symmetry [50, 92, 93, 94, 95, 96, 97].

Most importantly for this work, theories with non-Hermitian transfer matrices and PT\mathcal{P}\mathcal{T}-type symmetries generally support unusual phase structure not seen in conventional field theories [51, 52, 90, 96]. The appearance of complex conjugate pairs of transfer matrix eigenvalues is a hallmark of PT\mathcal{P}\mathcal{T}-type symmetries, leading to sinusoidally-modulated exponential decay in correlation functions, similar to Friedel oscillations [98, 99]. Regions of parameter space with conjugate pairs may also behave as moat regimes [100], a name that originates in the condensed matter literature [101, 102]. The boundary between a region where all eigenvalues are positive and a region with complex conjugate pairs is referred to in the statistical mechanics literature as a disorder line [103]. PT\mathcal{P}\mathcal{T}-type symmetric transfer matrices may also lead to inhomogeneous phases as a consequence of a Lifshitz instability.

We summarize the possible behaviors in Table 1. Note that an arbitrary non-Hermitian system without a PTPT-type symmetry generally has a mix of positive, negative, and complex eigenvalues and thus does not in general support the types of stable exotic phases we see in PTPT systems.

Transfer matrix eigenvaluesPhase behavior
All positiveNormal
Some complex conjugate pairsComplex (Friedel-like)
Even number of negative eigenvaluesInhomogeneous (Lifshitz instability)
Odd number of negative eigenvaluesUnstable

Table 1. Relationship between the phases in a moat regime and the spectral properties of a theory; see ref. [51]. A disorder line marks the onset of a complex phase.

The loss of Hermiticity and/or Lorentz invariance can give rise to non-positivity, moat regimes, and their associated phases. A large body of literature on inhomogeneous phases has been developed in condensed matter systems, which are naturally non-relativistic [104, 105, 106, 107, 108, 109, 110, 111, 112, 113, 114, 115, 116, 117, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 125, 126, 127, 128, 129, 130, 131, 132, 133, 134, 135, 136, 137, 138, 139, 140, 141, 142, 143, 144, 145, 146, 147, 148, 149, 150, 151, 152, 153, 154, 155, 156, 157, 158, 159, 160, 161, 162, 163, 164, 165, 166, 167, 168, 169, 170, 171, 172, 173, 174]; these phases are often associated with competing interactions [175, 176, 177, 178, 179, 180, 181]. In many models sharing features with QCD, Friedel-like phases and disorder lines have been observed, including in flux tube models [182], finite-density Potts models [183], PNJL models [92, 93], static quark models at strong coupling [94], liquid-gas models [95], mass-mixing models [51], and heavy quark models [96]. Inhomogeneous phases have also been explored in models sharing features with QCD, including O(N)O(N) models [184, 185, 186, 187, 188], scalar models [51, 189], various Gross-Neveu models [190, 191, 192, 193, 194, 195, 196, 196, 197, 197, 198, 199, 200, 201, 202], NJL models [203, 204, 205, 206, 207, 208, 209], PNJL models [210], Yukawa models [211], quark-meson models [212, 213, 214, 215], and functional renormalization group (FRG) studies of QCD [216]. Note that one well-studied class of inhomogeneous field configurations that will relate to inhomogeneous phases in this work are chiral spirals, nonlinear waves with expected values of σ\sigma and π3\pi_3 behaving as a spiral; i.e., ⟨σ+iπ3⟩∼exp⁡(ik⋅r)\langle\sigma+ i\pi_3 \rangle\sim\exp(i k \cdot r) [217, 218]. The widespread presence of exotic phases in finite-density models suggests that QCD phase structure could be more complicated than conventionally anticipated, particularly near the QCD phase transition and hypothesized critical endpoint [219]. Experimental signatures of moat regimes in heavy ion collisions have been developed, including in Hanbury-Brown-Twiss (HBT) interferometry [100, 220, 221, 222] and enhanced dilepton production [219].

In this work, we compute the phase diagram of lattice spin and gauge models with Z3\mathbb{Z}_3 symmetry (the center of the QCD gauge group SU(3)\mathrm{SU}(3)) and CK\mathcal{C}\mathcal{K}-symmetric complex couplings, which mimic a chemical potential and induce a sign problem. Due to CK\mathcal{C}\mathcal{K} symmetry, we can often construct dualities between complex Z3\mathbb{Z}_3 models and sign problem-free chiral Z3\mathbb{Z}_3 models. The duality is a complex-chiral generalization of the Kramers-Wannier duality of the Ising model. Next, we generalize the real-space renormalization group (RG) for use in systems with chemical potential, and we use it to compute the phase diagram of the complex and chiral Z3Z_3 models. One class of these models, chiral Z3Z_3 spin systems, exhibit Z3Z_3 analogues of chiral spirals: an imaginary analogue of chemical potential induces a phase in which Z3Z_3 variables exhibit sinusoidal modulation along a given direction. We predict the phase diagrams for broad classes of lattice Z3Z_3 spin and gauge models with real and imaginary chemical potentials for in three and four dimensions, determining which have Z3Z_3 spirals. We also explore the extension of our results to ZNZ_N models with N>3N > 3 and to SU(N)\mathrm{SU}(N) models with N≥3N \ge3.

The outline of this paper is as follows. In the remainder of § 1, we introduce the Z3Z_3 models that form the focus of our paper. In § 2, we introduce two key techniques used in this paper, Kramers-Wannier duality and the Migdal-Kadanoff renormalization group (RG), and discuss their extensions to complex and chiral models. In § 3, we use the Migdal-Kadanoff RG to compute the phase diagram of our models. In § 4, we discuss our results, highlighting how different RG schemes lead to qualitatively different phase diagrams in finite-density models. We also extend our results to certain SU(N)\mathrm{SU}(N) lattice models. Finally, in § 5, we offer concluding remarks and outlook.

Complex and chiral Z3Z_3 models

We define 1D complex and chiral Z3Z_3 spin models with actions

Sc[sj]=∑j=1M[J2(sjsj+1∗+sj∗sj+1)+θ3(sjsj+1∗−sj∗sj+1)]S_c[s_j] = \sum_{j=1}^{M} \left[\frac{J}{2}\left(s_j s_{j+1}^{*}+s_j^{*}s_{j+1}\right) + \frac{\theta}{\sqrt{3}}\left(s_j s_{j+1}^{*}-s_j^{*}s_{j+1}\right)\right]
Sχ[sj]=∑j=1MJ~2(eiθ~sjsj+1∗+e−iθ~sj∗sj+1),(2)S_\chi[s_j] = \sum_{j=1}^{M} \frac{\tilde{J}}{2}\left(e^{i\tilde{\theta}}s_j s_{j+1}^{*}+e^{-i\tilde{\theta}}s_j^{*}s_{j+1}\right), \tag*{(2)}

respectively. Here, sjs_j are ZNZ_N spin variables taking values exp⁡[2πn/N]\exp[2\pi n/N], the parameter jj runs over the MM lattice sites, and the parameters (J,θ)(J,\theta) and (J~,θ~)(\tilde{J},\tilde{\theta}) are real-valued. In ScS_c, the complex interaction term θ\theta induces a nonzero density. The parametrization we use for ScS_c is not the standard one, which can be obtained from SχS_\chi via the analytic continuation θ~→−iμ\tilde{\theta} \to-i\mu. It is easy to see that μ∼θ\mu\sim\theta for small μ\mu, and the general relation between parametrizations is straightforward. However, the (J,θ)(J,\theta) parametrization is more convenient for RG calculations.

To define higher-dimensional complex (chiral) spin models, we impose the interaction with θ≠0\theta\ne0 (θ~≠0\tilde{\theta} \ne0) in only a single direction, leaving the other d−1d-1 transverse directions as standard-nearest neighbor interactions with couplings JJ (J~\tilde{J}). In all dimensions, the complex spin models are a model of ZNZ_N particles in the presence of a chemical potential.

To define gauge models, we replace site-based spins with link-based gauge fields, and we replace nearest-neighbor spin interactions with Wilson plaquette interactions:

Sc[uj]=∑p[J2(up+up∗)+θ3(up−up∗)]S_c[u_j] = \sum_p \left[\frac{J}{2}\left(u_p+u_p^{*}\right) + \frac{\theta}{\sqrt{3}}\left(u_p-u_p^{*}\right)\right]
Sχ[uj]=∑pJ~2(eiθ~up+e−iθ~up∗),(3)S_\chi[u_j] = \sum_p \frac{\tilde{J}}{2}\left(e^{i\tilde{\theta}}u_p+e^{-i\tilde{\theta}}u_p^{*}\right), \tag*{(3)}

where the sum is taken over all plaquettes pp in the 2D plane, and the variables upu_p are the standard plaquette variables, i.e. the product of four Z3\mathbb{Z}_3 link variables around a plaquette.

To define higher-dimensional gauge models, we replace site-based spins with link-based gauge fields, and we replace nearest-neighbor spin interactions with Wilson plaquette interactions. Just as in the spin models, we take the complex (chiral) term θ\theta (θ~\tilde{\theta}) to be nonzero in only a single preferred plane. In the complex gauge models, the θ\theta term corresponds to a background electric field that is real in Minkowski space and imaginary in Euclidean space; this field induces a sign problem on the lattice. The θ~\tilde{\theta} interaction in the chiral gauge models gives rise to a real magnetic field in both Euclidean and Minkowski space.

Phase structure of real and chiral ZN\mathbb{Z}_N models. The phase structure of standard ZN\mathbb{Z}_N models (where θ\theta and θ~\tilde{\theta} are both zero) has been extensively investigated [223, 224, 225, 226, 227, 228]. Less is known about general chiral and complex ZN\mathbb{Z}_N models, though many studies of chiral spin models have been carried out. In three and higher dimensions, chiral Z3\mathbb{Z}_3 spin models have an infinite number of stable inhomogeneous phases that are commensurate with the underlying lattice in the low temperature (small J~\tilde{J}) region. In a given inhomogeneous phase, (d−1)(d-1)-dimensional sheets of spins, each characterized by a certain expectation value, are layered along the chiral direction [229, 230, 231, 232, 233, 234, 235, 236]. These phases are Z3\mathbb{Z}_3 analogues of chiral spirals, with each phase corresponding to a particular wave number. Similar spirals occur in ZN\mathbb{Z}_N with N≥4N \ge4. It is likely that the N→∞N \to\infty limit is smooth, although to our knowledge this has not been investigated. The phase diagrams of the chiral spin models exhibit a fractal structure called a Devil’s flower, by analogy with the well-known Devil’s staircase [237]. The behavior of Z3\mathbb{Z}_3 spin models in 2D is a special case, and is closely tied to the physics of the BKT transition [238, 239]. For example, there is a nontrivial critical point on the positive real axis associated with a second-order phase transition, whereas higher dimensions have first-order transitions. It is known that a technique called the Migdal-Kadanoff real-space RG (which we discuss below in detail) does only a fair job of capturing 2D ZN\mathbb{Z}_N critical behavior [240].

Techniques

Next, we introduce two key techniques that we will use in our analysis: Kramers-Wannier duality in § 2.1 and § 2.2, and the real-space RG in § 2.3 and § 2.4.

Kramers-Wannier duality

Kramers-Wannier duality maps the 2D Ising model onto itself, interchanging low- and high-temperature behavior [241, 242]. It is simple to establish this duality by mapping the Boltzmann weights of one model to the character expansion of the other [227].1 This is simple to see in the 2D Ising model, defined as

H=−J∑j,kσjσk,(4)\mathcal{H} = -J \sum_{j,k} \sigma_j \sigma_k, \tag*{(4)}
DimensionalityDuality of real ZN\mathbb{Z}_N models
2DSpin systems ↔\leftrightarrow Spin systems
3DSpin systems ↔\leftrightarrow Gauge theories
4DGauge theories ↔\leftrightarrow Gauge theories

Table 2. Kramers-Wannier duality for real lattice ZN\mathbb{Z}_N models.

where JJ and hh are couplings, {j,k}\{j,k\} are nearest-neighbor sites, and σi\sigma_i are Z2\mathbb{Z}_2 spin variables. Using shorthand notation to write nearest-neighbor interactions σjσk=σℓ\sigma_j\sigma_k=\sigma_\ell, we can write the character expansion of each Ising model Boltzmann weight as

w(σℓ)=eKσℓ=cosh⁡K+σℓsinh⁡K.(5)w(\sigma_\ell)=e^{K\sigma_\ell}=\cosh K+\sigma_\ell\sinh K . \tag*{(5)}

where we use the Z2\mathbb{Z}_2 group characters {1,σℓ}\{1,\sigma_\ell\} with hyperbolic functions as coefficients. The Boltzmann weights themselves are exp⁡(K~σ0)={exp⁡(K~),exp⁡(−K~)}\exp(\widetilde{K}\sigma_0)=\{\exp(\widetilde{K}),\exp(-\widetilde{K})\}. We only care about the relative weighting of the Boltzmann weights, so we can construct a duality

exp⁡(−2K~)↔tanh⁡K.(6)\exp(-2\widetilde{K})\leftrightarrow\tanh K . \tag*{(6)}

This duality maps the small-KK region of the Ising model, which is paramagnetic with zero magnetization, to the large-KK region of the Ising model, which is ferromagnetic with nonzero magnetization. The fixed point of the duality transform is the critical point of the Ising model. This duality extends to operators [243], and is the most well-known example of order-disorder duality.

This duality extends to other Z2\mathbb{Z}_2 and ZN\mathbb{Z}_N models generally. The form of the duality is dimension-dependent, as shown in Table 3. In spin systems, nearest-neighbor spins are connected by links. The Kramers-Wannier dual of a link interaction on a square lattice in two dimensions is a link on the dual lattice perpendicular to the original link. In three dimensions, the dual of a link is a plaquette in 3D, and a cube in 4D. Thus, the dual of a ZN\mathbb{Z}_N spin system is a ZN\mathbb{Z}_N spin system in two dimensions, a gauge theory in three dimensions, and a theory of fundamental plaquettes interacting around a cube in four dimensions. Similarly, the dual of a ZN\mathbb{Z}_N gauge theory is a ZN\mathbb{Z}_N spin theory in three dimensions and a ZN\mathbb{Z}_N gauge theory in four dimension. For a concise treatment of Abelian lattice duality, see e.g. [227].

Complex formDual real form
2DSpin with chemical potentialSpin with chiral interaction
3DSpin with chemical potentialGauge with background magnetic field
3DGauge with background electric fieldSpin with chiral interaction
4DGauge with background electric fieldGauge with background magnetic field

Table 3. Generalization of the Kramers-Wannier duality introduced in § 2.1 to ZN\mathbb{Z}_N models with a non-Hermitian transfer matrix.

Complex-chiral extension of Kramers-Wannier duality

Building off studies of similar PT\mathcal{PT} ZN\mathbb{Z}_N models in refs. [50, 97] and studies of duality in other PT\mathcal{PT}-symmetric lattice models [244], it is straightforward to show that complex and chiral ZN\mathbb{Z}_N models exhibit an extension of the Kramers-Wannier duality. We begin by examining the character expansion and Boltzmann weights of our chiral and complex models, which allows us to demonstrate a duality between these models. Next, we highlight the regions of parameter space in which the complex models have a sign problem-free dual form.

Character expansion of Z3\mathbb{Z}_3 links. The partition functions for the spin and gauge models are defined by sums over Z3\mathbb{Z}_3 spins and links in the usual way, as:

Zspin=∑{sj}exp⁡[∑ℓA(sℓ)],Zgauge=∑{uℓ}exp⁡[∑pA(up)].(7)Z_{\mathrm{spin}} = \sum_{\{s_j\}} \exp\left[\sum_{\ell} A(s_\ell)\right], \qquad Z_{\mathrm{gauge}} = \sum_{\{u_\ell\}} \exp\left[\sum_p A(u_p)\right]. \tag*{(7)}

where the fundamental variables in the two sums over configurations are the site variables sjs_j and link variables uℓu_\ell respectively; the total action is a sum over functions A(sℓ)A(s_\ell) of the link variables sℓs_\ell in the spin case and the plaquette variables upu_p in the gauge case. We can write these expressions as a sum over products of Boltzmann weights:

Zspin=∑{sj}∏ℓexp⁡[A(sℓ)],Zgauge=∑{uℓ}∏pexp⁡[A(up)].(8)Z_{\mathrm{spin}} = \sum_{\{s_j\}} \prod_\ell\exp[A(s_\ell)], \qquad Z_{\mathrm{gauge}} = \sum_{\{u_\ell\}} \prod_p \exp[A(u_p)]. \tag*{(8)}

The character expression for any Boltzmann weight w(sℓ)=exp⁡[A(sℓ)]w(s_\ell) = \exp[A(s_\ell)] has the form

w(sℓ)=a+bsℓ+csℓ∗,(9)w(s_\ell) = a + b s_\ell+ c s_\ell^*, \tag*{(9)}

with character coefficients a,b,c∈Ca,b,c \in\mathbb{C}. The character coefficients represent the Z3\mathbb{Z}_3 Fourier transform of the weight functions [227, 245].

Let us now examine the form of the character coefficients and Boltzmann weights for our models introduced in § 1. The symmetries of a link action A(sℓ)A(s_\ell) typically are inherited by their corresponding Boltzmann weights w(sℓ)=exp⁡A(sℓ)w(s_\ell) = \exp A(s_\ell). For a conventional ZN\mathbb{Z}_N model, the link action must be real, implying invariance under complex conjugation K\mathcal{K}. We also require invariance under charge conjugation C\mathcal{C}, which takes sℓ→sℓ∗s_\ell\to s_\ell^*. These two conditions fix eq. (9) to

wH(sℓ)=a+b(sℓ+sℓ∗),(10)w_{\mathrm{H}}(s_\ell) = a + b(s_\ell+ s_\ell^*), \tag*{(10)}

where a,b∈Ra,b \in\mathbb{R}. This Boltzmann weight is positive for b>−a/2b > -a/2.

To formulate the chiral Z3\mathbb{Z}_3 nearest-neighbor action, we remove the condition that eq. (9) is invariant under C\mathcal{C} and only require the action to be real, finding that

wχ(sℓ)=1+zsℓ+z∗sℓ∗,(11)w_\chi(s_\ell) = 1 + z s_\ell+ z^*s_\ell^*, \tag*{(11)}

where we have normalized aa to one and parametrized bb as z=x+iy∈Cz = x + iy \in\mathbb{C}.

The complex Z3\mathbb{Z}_3 action requires invariance under combined CK\mathcal{C}\mathcal{K} without imposing invariance under C\mathcal{C} or K\mathcal{K} individually. Under these conditions, eq. (9) must satisfy

wc(sℓ∗)=wc∗(sℓ),(12)w_{\mathrm{c}}(s_\ell^*) = w_{\mathrm{c}}^*(s_\ell), \tag*{(12)}

This bears close resemblance to the CK\mathcal{C}\mathcal{K} symmetry condition in quantum mechanics, V(x)=V∗(−x)V(x) = V^*(-x) [53]. Under these conditions, {a,b,c}∈R\{a,b,c\} \in\mathbb{R} in eq. (9), but wc(sℓ)w_{\mathrm{c}}(s_\ell) is complex as the Z3\mathbb{Z}_3 spin variables sℓs_\ell are complex.

Duality conditions. The character expansion of the Boltzmann weights in the complex Z3\mathbb{Z}_3 model is

wc(sℓ)=exp⁡[J2(sℓ+sℓ∗)+θ3(sℓ−sℓ∗)−J](13)w_c(s_\ell) = \exp\left[\frac{J}{2}\left(s_\ell+s_\ell^*\right)+\frac{\theta}{\sqrt{3}}\left(s_\ell-s_\ell^*\right)-J\right] \tag*{(13)}

where we have added a constant −J-J to AcA_c, which normalizes w(1)=1w(1)=1. The weights of the complex model are then

w(1)=1,w(e2πi/3)=e−J/2+iθ,w(e4πi/3)=e−J/2−iθ.(14)w(1)=1,\qquad w\left(e^{2\pi i/3}\right)=e^{-J/2+i\theta},\qquad w\left(e^{4\pi i/3}\right)=e^{-J/2-i\theta}. \tag*{(14)}

The character coefficients are

a=1+2e−3J/2cos⁡θ,b=1−2e−3J/2cos⁡(θ−2π3),c=1−2e−3J/2cos⁡(θ−4π3).(15)a=1+2e^{-3J/2}\cos\theta,\qquad b=1-2e^{-3J/2}\cos\left(\theta-\frac{2\pi}{3}\right),\qquad c=1-2e^{-3J/2}\cos\left(\theta-\frac{4\pi}{3}\right). \tag*{(15)}

We parametrized the character coefficients of the Z3\mathbb{Z}_3 chiral model in eq. (11) as

a~=1,b~=z,c~=z∗.(16)\tilde{a}=1,\qquad\tilde{b}=z,\qquad\tilde{c}=z^*. \tag*{(16)}

As in the Ising model, we want to identify the Boltzmann weights with dual representation character coefficients, implying that

z=e−J/2+iθ.(17)z=e^{-J/2+i\theta}. \tag*{(17)}

This relation is involutive because the Z3\mathbb{Z}_3 Fourier transform is involutive, and it is straightforward to check that the real character coefficients of the complex model are the weights of the chiral model. Note that the normalization condition a~=1\tilde{a}=1 for chiral models is equivalent to the normalization condition a+b+c=1a+b+c=1 for complex models.

We see that the high-temperature (small-zz) behavior of the chiral spin model is dual to the low-temperature (J≫1J\gg1) expansion of the complex spin model. Likewise, the low-TT (∣z∣→1|z|\to1) chiral behavior is dual to the high-TT (J→0J\to0) complex behavior. This invertible involution extends the duality of conventional Z3\mathbb{Z}_3 models to the complex plane. We summarize several important mappings in Table 3.

Sign problem-free region. Complex ZN\mathbb{Z}_N models always have a sign problem, but their chiral duals only have a sign problem outside the triangle defined by

1+2x>0,1−x−3y>0,1−x+3y>0.(18)1+2x>0,\qquad1-x-\sqrt{3}y>0,\qquad1-x+\sqrt{3}y>0. \tag*{(18)}

where z=x+iyz=x+iy as before. While chiral models are not typically defined outside of this triangle, due to the complex-chiral duality, we see that it is natural to consider chiral models on the full range of (x,y)(x,y) values.

Migdal-Kadanoff renormalization group

The Migdal-Kadanoff renormalization group (MKRG) yields qualitative information about the phase structure of lattice systems [246, 247, 248, 249]. Due to its simplicity and utility, this technique has been extensively studied and applied to many models [250]. Effectively, we apply a Migdal-Kadanoff RG transform RR multiple times to a system, and map out the basins of attraction of the model, which tell us the phase structure of a system. The MKRG is approximate on conventional lattices, and exact on hierarchical lattices [251]. Interestingly, MKRG schemes respect Kramers-Wannier dualities [249], and thus give us information about both a given ZN\mathbb{Z}_N model and its dual.

The MKRG is built from two primary operations: decimation (DλD_\lambda) and bond-moving (BλB_\lambda), as shown in Figure 1. A decimation transformation of a 1D spin lattice changes the lattice spacing from aa to λa\lambda a by integrating out every (λ−1)(\lambda-1) out of λ\lambda spins, leaving us with lattice points spaced by λa\lambda a from one another. In a 1D Ising model characterized by nearest-neighbor couplings JJ and spacing aa, decimation creates a new Ising model with coupling J′J' and lattice spacing λa\lambda a. In the 1D Ising model, decimation acts as tanh⁡J′=tanh⁡λ(J)\tanh J'=\tanh^\lambda(J).

Schematic representations of Migdal-Kadanoff transforms

Figure 1. Schematic representations of Migdal-Kadanoff transforms. In decimation transforms, we eliminate n2−1n^2-1 out of every n2n^2 lattice sites, as in eq. (19). In bond-moving transforms, we move the entire strength of one bond onto another, as in eq. (20).

Decimation can only be carried out analytically in 1D. Bond moving is a technique which changes local interactions in a way which allows decimation to be carried out in higher dimensions. A bond-moving transformation on a spin system moves all the bonds inside a dd-dimensional hypercube of size (λa)d(\lambda a)^d to links on the boundaries of the hypercube, changing the strength of an interaction on the boundary of the hypercube from JJ to λd−1J\lambda^{d-1}J.

Let us use lowercase bλb_\lambda and dλd_\lambda to represent MKRG operations in Z3\mathbb{Z}_3 models. Here, a decimation transform with blocking factor λ=2\lambda=2 maps weights a,b,ca,b,c as:

d2(a,b,c)=(a2,b2,c2)(19)d_2(a,b,c)=(a^2,b^2,c^2) \tag*{(19)}

and bond moving squares the Boltzmann weights, so

b2(a,b,c)=(a2+2bc,c2+2ab,b2+2ac).(20)b_2(a,b,c)=(a^2+2bc,c^2+2ab,b^2+2ac). \tag*{(20)}

Every MKRG transformation for Z3\mathbb{Z}_3 lattice models can be written as the composition of a sequence of these two operations. From these two primitive operations, we can build a large set of MKRG transformations for Z3\mathbb{Z}_3 lattice models. Note that when discussing these transforms, it is convenient to write functional composition as if it were multiplication, so d2b2(a,b,c)d_2b_2(a,b,c) represents d2(b2(a,b,c))d_2(b_2(a,b,c)).

The original Migdal form of the spin model RG has the general form DBd−1DB^{d-1} [249], i.e., bond moving for links in all d−1d-1 directions followed by decimation. This formulation leads to an RG transform

J′=Rλ(J)=Dλ(λd−1J),(21)J' = R_\lambda(J) = D_\lambda\left(\lambda^{d-1}J\right), \tag*{(21)}

Kadanoff [243] showed bond-moving can also be carried out sequentially along different lattice directions, resulting in an anisotropic system after an RG transformation, e.g.

Jk′=Rλ(J)=λd−kDλ(λk−1Jk).(22)J_k' = R_\lambda(J) = \lambda^{d-k}D_\lambda\left(\lambda^{k-1}J_k\right). \tag*{(22)}

for k=1,…,dk = 1,\ldots,d. This produces a set of MKRG transformations that can have different fixed points for couplings in different directions, but which lead to similar critical behavior for standard lattice systems. That is, Kadanoff’s extension to anisotropic RG flows posits that the RG transformations BjDBd−1−jB^jDB^{d-1-j}, with j=0…d−1j = 0\ldots d-1, all exhibit the same phase structure for a given spin system. For a gauge theory, Migdal’s original RG scheme has R=D2Bd−2R = D^2B^{d-2}, and Kadanoff’s scheme extends this to all permutations of two DD’s and d−2d-2 BB’s [249].

Migdal-Kadanoff RG transforms respect Kramer-Wannier duality [243]: decimation DλD_\lambda in a given ZN\mathbb{Z}_N model is equivalent to bond-moving B~λ\widetilde{B}_\lambda in its dual model, and likewise for BλB_\lambda and D~λ\widetilde{D}_\lambda. This relation holds because decimation is convolution of Boltzmann weights, which is multiplication of the character expansion coefficients of the weights, and bond-moving is multiplication of weights. The two operations are related by the ZN\mathbb{Z}_N Fourier transform, which transforms the parameters of one model to the parameters of its dual.

Symmetries of the real-space RG for complex and chiral models

Ref. [231] pointed out the crucial role of two symmetries in the RG analysis of chiral Z3\mathbb{Z}_3 spin systems, a PT\mathcal{P}\mathcal{T}-type symmetry and a Roberge-Weiss symmetry. These symmetries extend to all Z3\mathbb{Z}_3 chiral and lattice models. To see this, let us construct the Migdal-Kadanoff RG operations for our models, choosing a blocking factor λ=2\lambda= 2 in eqs. (19) and (20). For the chiral model with weights in eq. (11), we have bond-moving and decimation transforms

B~(z)=2z+z∗21+2zz∗,D~(z)=z2,(23)\widetilde{B}(z) = \frac{2z+z^{*2}}{1+2zz^*}, \qquad\widetilde{D}(z) = z^2, \tag*{(23)}

which impose a normalization a=1a = 1 and we recall from § 2.2 that z~=x+iy\widetilde{z} = x+iy. It is straightforward to show that the chiral transforms (D~,B~)(\widetilde{D},\widetilde{B}) are dual under a Z3\mathbb{Z}_3 Fourier transform to the corresponding complex transforms (B,D)(B,D), which we can obtain from eqs. (19) and (20). Despite their equivalence, these transforms have different algebraic forms and provide useful cross-checks on one another.

Roberge-Weiss symmetry is invariance of the partition function under z→ωzz \to\omega z, where ω∈Z3\omega\in\mathbb{Z}_3. This symmetry manifests itself directly in the RG recursion relation. From the explicit forms of (D~,B~)(\widetilde{D},\widetilde{B}) in eq. (23) we see that

B~(ωz)=ωB~(z),D~(ωz)=ω2D~(z).(24)\widetilde{B}(\omega z) = \omega\widetilde{B}(z), \qquad\widetilde{D}(\omega z) = \omega^2 \widetilde{D}(z). \tag*{(24)}

for any ω∈Z3\omega\in\mathbb{Z}_3. As a consequence, RG transforms RR built from a sequence of B~\widetilde{B}'s and D~\widetilde{D}'s obey

R(ωz)=ωpR(z),(25)R(\omega z) = \omega^p R(z), \tag*{(25)}

where p=0,1,2p = 0, 1, 2. A special case of eq. (25) was first found in ref. [231] using an argument based on space-dependent Z3\mathbb{Z}_3 transformations of the spins and the behavior of the two-point function. The RG transforms also respect CKCK symmetry:

R(z∗)=R∗(z),(26)R(z^*) = R^*(z), \tag*{(26)}

which follows from B~(z∗)=B~∗(z)\widetilde{B}(z^*) = \widetilde{B}^*(z) and D~(z∗)=D~∗(z)\widetilde{D}(z^*) = \widetilde{D}^*(z). This relation was first found in ref. [231] for chiral spin models.

Results

We now apply the Migdal-Kadanoff RG and duality to find the phase diagram of our Z3\mathbb{Z}_3 models in eq. (2). First, it is useful to examine some general features of the fixed points R(z0)=z0R(z_0) = z_0 of Z3\mathbb{Z}_3 models under RG transforms RR. In dimensions d≥2d \ge2, Z3\mathbb{Z}_3 models have a nontrivial fixed point z0=x0+iy0z_0 = x_0 + iy_0 for some x0∈[0,1]x_0 \in[0,1] and y0=0y_0 = 0. For standard Z3\mathbb{Z}_3 models, this fixed point separates a large-JJ region x<x0x < x_0 from a small-JJ region x>x0x > x_0. For chiral and complex Z3\mathbb{Z}_3 models, these phases extend into the complex plane. From eq. (25), we have that

R(ωz0)=ωpR(z0).(27)R(\omega z_0) = \omega^p R(z_0). \tag*{(27)}

In the case p=0p = 0, we see that ωz0\omega z_0 is mapped to z0z_0. For p=1p = 1, we have two additional nontrivial fixed points {ω0z0,ω02z0}\{\omega_0 z_0,\omega_0^2 z_0\}, for ω0=exp⁡(2πi/3)\omega_0 = \exp(2\pi i/3). For p=2p = 2, we have R(ω0z0)=ω02z0R(\omega_0 z_0) = \omega_0^2 z_0 and vice versa, meaning that {ω0z0,ω02z0}\{\omega_0 z_0,\omega_0^2 z_0\} form a two-cycle. These features are a natural result of CKCK and Roberge-Weiss symmetries. To summarize:

pR(z0)R(ω0z0)R(ω02z0)0z0z0z01z0ω0z0ω02z02z0ω02z0ω0z0(28)\begin{array}{c|c|c|c} p & R(z_0) & R(\omega_0 z_0) & R(\omega_0^2 z_0) \\ 0 & z_0 & z_0 & z_0 \\ 1 & z_0 & \omega_0 z_0 & \omega_0^2 z_0 \\ 2 & z_0 & \omega_0^2 z_0 & \omega_0 z_0 \tag*{(28)} \end{array}

The chiral models also have a high-TT fixed point at z=0z = 0, which is dual to a low-TT fixed point at J=∞J = \infty with arbitrary θ\theta in the corresponding complex models. In all cases, lower and upper half-planes have mirror-image phase structure due to eq. (26).

1D spin systems

We determine the phase structure of our models by iterating a given RG transform RR on each zz a number of times nn, until the value of Rn(z)R^n(z) is stable for all values of zz. Typically, we find that n=6n=6 is sufficient to give an accurate depiction of the basins of attraction of RR and the phase diagram of the model.

We can express the partition functions of 1D spin models and 2D gauge models exactly in terms of their character weights. For 1D complex Z3\mathbb{Z}_3 spin models, this is

Z=aN+bN+cN(29)Z=a^N+b^N+c^N \tag*{(29)}

where NN is the number of spins and {a,b,c}\{a,b,c\} are the coefficients of the character expansion of the Boltzmann weight given in eq. (15); they are also the eigenvalues of the transfer matrix. From the form of {a,b,c}\{a,b,c\} given in eq. (15), we see that two of the eigenvalues cross when θ={π/3,π,5π/3}\theta=\{\pi/3,\pi,5\pi/3\}, leading to first-order phase transitions at those values of θ\theta. We confirm this behavior by carrying out an RG analysis with R(z)=D(z)R(z)=D(z), as shown in the left panel of Figure 2. The points z={1,ω0,ω02}z=\{1,\omega_0,\omega_0^2\} are all stable high-temperature fixed points, and z=0z=0 is an unstable low-temperature fixed point of the complex spin model. The critical lines separating the three phases are the boundaries of the basins of attraction for the high-temperature fixed points, which emanate outward as rays from the z=0z=0 along θ={π/3,π,5π/3}\theta=\{\pi/3,\pi,5\pi/3\}.

Phase structure of 1D complex and chiral spin models

Figure 2. 1D complex and chiral spin models. (Left) 1D complex model with phase structure in the z=x+iyz=x+iy plane obtained from repeated decimation transformations D≅B~D \cong\widetilde{B}. Solid colors correspond to different phases. The light blue triangle in the center represents the region where the action is real. (right) 1D chiral spin model, obtained from repeated action of D~≅B\widetilde{D} \cong B. All points inside the unit circle eventually map to z=0z=0.

We carry out a similar analysis for the 1D chiral spin model, which has partition function

Z=a~N+b~N+c~N=1+zN+z∗N(30)Z=\widetilde{a}^N+\widetilde{b}^N+\widetilde{c}^N=1+z^N+z^{*N} \tag*{(30)}

where {a~,b~,c~}\{\widetilde{a},\widetilde{b},\widetilde{c}\} are given by eq. (16) and NN is the number of lattice sites. We display the phase structure obtained from repeated application of the RG transform R(z)=D~(z)=z2R(z)=\widetilde{D}(z)=z^2 in the right panel of Figure 2. For ∣z∣<1|z|<1, the a~=1\widetilde{a}=1 term dominates the partition function.

All values ∣z∣<1|z| < 1 are attracted to the stable fixed point at z=0z = 0, which is a high-temperature fixed point. Values of zz with ∣z∣>1|z| > 1 move off to infinity. RG flows to the origin, to infinity, or along the unit circle are chaotic maps. We can easily see this for ∣z∣=1|z| = 1, where RR effectively takes θ→2θ mod 2π\theta\to2\theta\bmod2\pi (mapping the unit circle to itself). Taking x=sin⁡2θx = \sin^2\theta, we see that this is a particular case of the logistic map x→κx(1−x)x \to\kappa x(1-x) with κ=4\kappa= 4, which is known to be chaotic.

In all figures in this section, we draw the sign problem-free region, where the character coefficients {a,b,c}\{a,b,c\} are all positive, as a light blue equilaterial triangle given by eq. (18). The vertices of the equilateral triangle are stable fixed points, but other than that, the region of positive weights does not appear to be of fundamental importance to phase structure. Indeed, even in these simple 1D models, we see that restricting the parameter zz to the region of positivity in chiral models misses significant aspects of RG flow.

2D complex gauge model

The phase diagram of the complex gauge model in 2D is similar to that of the 1D complex spin model. The RG flow is generated by R=D2=z4R = D^2 = z^4, so that R(ωz)=ωB~2(z)R(\omega z) = \omega\widetilde{B}^2(z). Thus we again have three stable fixed points z={1,ω,ω2}z = \{1,\omega,\omega^2\}, where ω=exp⁡(2πi/3)\omega= \exp(2\pi i/3), as in the 1D complex spin model. The phase diagram of the 2D chiral gauge model is effectively the same as that of the 1D chiral spin model: R={z2,z4}R = \{z^2,z^4\} have similar properties, including the chaotic map on the unit circle; the small change in exponent does not affect RG flow significantly.

2D spin systems

2D chiral and complex spin systems are dual to one another. In Migdal’s original formulation of the real-space RG, the natural 2D spin RG transforms are R=DBR = DB for the complex model and R=D~B~=BDR = \widetilde{D}\widetilde{B} = BD for the chiral model. Both DBDB and BDBD occur naturally in Kadanoff’s anisotropic reformulation. In a standard Z3\mathbb{Z}_3 spin model where zz is restricted to a real number xx, these two transformations have a similar phase structure, with some changes in the location of the nontrivial fixed point.

However, in the chiral and complex models, it is clear from Figure 3 that the phase diagrams generated by BDBD and DBDB differ significantly, producing four and seven phases, respectively. Neither phase diagram shows a Devil’s flower, consistent with the results in [231]. The fixed points are nonuniversal; there is a nontrivial fixed point z0z_0 along the positive xx axis between zero and one at the tip of the orange region, whose value is different for the BDBD and DBDB. The points (ωz0,ω2z0)(\omega z_0,\omega^2 z_0) form a two-cycle in both cases.

2D complex spin model phase diagrams for transforms $BD$ and $DB$

Figure 3. 2D complex spin model, analyzed using transforms BDBD (left) and DBDB (right).

3D spin and gauge systems

In Figure 4, we plot the phase diagrams of the 3D complex spin model, which is dual to the 3D chiral gauge model. As expected, the location of the nontrivial fixed point on the positive real axis is not universal. As in the 2D complex spin model, the number of phases that appear depends on the order of the basic RG operations, with BDBBDB producing the smallest number of phases (4), and DBBDBB producing the largest number of phases (13).

3D complex spin model phase diagrams for transforms $BBD$, $BDB$, and $DBB$

Figure 4. 3D complex spin models, analyzed using the transforms (left to right): BBDBBD, BDBBDB, DBBDBB. The phase diagrams are identical to those for 3D gauge models using D~D~B~\widetilde{D}\widetilde{D}\widetilde{B}, D~B~D~\widetilde{D}\widetilde{B}\widetilde{D} and B~D~D~\widetilde{B}\widetilde{D}\widetilde{D}, respectively.

In Figure 5, we plot the 3D complex gauge model, which is dual to the 3D chiral spin model. These models exhibit a Devil’s flower for each of the transformations BDDBDD, DBDDBD, and DDBDDB. Intriguingly, BDDBDD and DBDDBD have a three-fold symmetry, while DDBDDB has a six-fold symmetry. From the point of view of the chiral spin model, there are an infinite number of commensurate inhomogeneous phases in the low-temperature region, which corresponds to the strong coupling region near J=0J = 0 for complex models.

3D complex gauge model phase diagrams for transforms $BDD$, $DBD$, and $DDB$

Figure 5. 3D complex gauge models, analyzed using the transforms (left to right): BDDBDD, DBDDBD, DDBDDB. The presence of the Devil’s flower phase structure is clear in all three cases. These are identical to the phase diagrams for the 3D chiral spin model.

4D spin and gauge systems

In Figure 6, we see that just as in the 3D models, the order of bond-moving and decimation transforms produces different results for 4D complex spin systems. The RG transform DB3DB^{3} generates only four regions (one homogeneous and three inhomogeneous). As more BB operators are placed to the right of DD, more phases of smaller sizes appear, with DBBBDBBB having 25 different phases, 21 of which lie outside of the triangle of positive weights.

4D complex spin models

Figure 6. 4D complex spin models, analyzed using the transforms (left to right): BBBDBBBD, BBDBBBDB (top row); and BDBBBDBB, DBBBDBBB (bottom row). In the dual chiral model, the fundamental variables are plaquettes interacting around cubes.

Figure 7 shows the behavior of the 4D chiral spin model. The RG transformation BD3BD^{3} (equivalent to D~B~3\widetilde{D}\widetilde{B}^{3}) is the original Migdal transformation for this model. The phase diagram takes the form of a Devil’s flower, with the critical point on the positive real axis close to the origin. Other permutations of BD3BD^{3} show similar behavior, albeit with critical points further from the origin. Note that the phase diagram of the transform D3BD^{3}B has a six-fold symmetry, while the other transforms have a three-fold symmetry.

4D chiral spin models

Figure 7. 4D chiral spin models, analyzed using the transforms BDDDBDDD, DBDDDBDD (top); and DDBDDDBD, DDDBDDDB (bottom). In the dual complex model, the fundamental variables are plaquettes interacting around cubes.

In Figure 8, we plot the phase diagram of the 4D Z3\mathbb{Z}_{3} gauge theory. Using the original Migdal transformation D~2B~2\widetilde{D}^{2}\widetilde{B}^{2}, we see four phases. On the other hand, the transformation B~2D~2\widetilde{B}^{2}\widetilde{D}^{2} generates many more phases.

Six phase diagrams for 4D gauge models

Figure 8. 4D gauge models, using the transforms: BBDD, BDBD, and DBBD (1st row); and BDDB, DBDB and DDBB (2nd row).

Discussion

Many features of the phase diagrams in § 3 are consistent with our intuition from real-space RG analyses of conventional models. All of the spin models have at least four phases for d≥2d \ge2, and all of the gauge models have at least four phases for d≥3d \ge3, which is the minimum number of phases consistent with three nontrivial fixed points. The location of these nontrivial fixed points is dependent on the form of the RG transforms (i.e. the order of bond-moving and decimation operations), consistent with Kadanoff’s interpretation of the real-space RG. However, the phase structures predicted by different RG transforms are far from identical. Here, we discuss a number of their important features.

Failure of universality and black spurious symmetries

The symmetry of phase diagrams often change from threefold, to sixfold, to even higher-fold as we change the order of bond-moving and decimation operations; see e.g. Figure 3 and Figure 4. This behavior, to our knowledge, has not been observed in conventional lattice models. Critical behavior usually depends on the symmetries and dimensionality of a system, and our results are at odds with Kadanoff’s interpretation of different orderings as belonging to the same universality class [249]. Although all Migdal-Kadanoff RG schemes give exact results for appropriate hierarchical models [251], the phase diagram’s symmetry on a normal cubic lattice cannot depend on the precise scheme used: there is a single correct answer.

This difference in symmetry represents a failure of the predictive power of the MKRG to respect the universality within a given model in non-Hermitian systems.

The number of phases appears to be tied to the number of D≡B~D \equiv\widetilde{B} operators appearing to the right of the rightmost B≡D~B \equiv\widetilde{D} in a given Z3\mathbb{Z}_3 renormalization transformation RR. To understand this behavior, let us compare the RG transforms BDBD and DBDB acting on a 2D complex spin model. Writing zz in polar form as reiθr e^{i\theta}, we find explicitly that

BD(eiθr)=2r2ei2θ+r4e−4iθ1+2r4.(31)BD(e^{i\theta}r)=\frac{2r^2e^{i2\theta}+r^4e^{-4i\theta}}{1+2r^4}. \tag*{(31)}

Eq. (31) only contains a single overall phase factor if θ=πn/3\theta=\pi n/3: along these constant-θ\theta lines, ∣z∣\lvert z\rvert evolves just as it would along the positive real axis. Off these lines, however, the phase can evolve, thus explaining the six-fold symmetry of the BDBD phase diagram. On the other hand,

DB(eiθr)=(2reiθ+e−2iθr21+2r2)2.(32)DB(e^{i\theta}r)=\left(\frac{2re^{i\theta}+e^{-2i\theta}r^2}{1+2r^2}\right)^2. \tag*{(32)}

Eq. (32) has an overall phase if θ=2πn/3\theta=2\pi n/3, giving the phase diagram threefold symmetry.

If we now consider the general Migdal-Kadanoff transform for a complex Z3\mathbb{Z}_3 spin model

R(z)=Dd−1−jBDj(z),(33)R(z)=D^{d-1-j}BD^j(z), \tag*{(33)}

we see that

Dj(eiθr)=e2jiθDj(r)(34)D^j(e^{i\theta}r)=e^{2ji\theta}D^j(r) \tag*{(34)}

suggesting a proliferation of copies of the positive real axis with increasing jj. However, B(eiθr)B(e^{i\theta}r) produces copies of the positive real axis only for θ=2πn/3\theta= 2\pi n/3. Subsequent application of DD does not produce further copies of the positive real axis, so the phase diagram has a 3×2j3 \times2^j-fold symmetry, in agreement with the observed behavior. The analysis of other cases follows from similar reasoning.

We see that the real-space RG cannot answer which symmetry is correct on a standard cubic lattice for complex and chiral models. All of the models have a Z3\mathbb{Z}_3-symmetric action, with no indication that a larger-symmetry group is somehow hidden in the action. This logic favors the RG scheme that produces a three-fold symmetric phase diagram as the correct one. Another argument in favor of the three-fold symmetric phase diagram, which relies on properties of chiral model low-temperature expansions, is given in Appendix § 7.

Presence and absence of Devil’s flowers

In d≥3d \ge3, only chiral spin models and their complex duals have a Devil’s flower phase structure. The Devil’s flower appears for all possible RG scheme choices RR in these models, though the size of each phase and the symmetries differ based on the scheme.

One might wonder whether the Devil’s flower stems from Roberge-Weiss symmetry, as the chiral spin models and their duals are unique among our models in having p=2p = 2. As noted in [231], for a blocking factor λ=2\lambda= 2, we have one fixed point z=1z = 1 and a two-cycle z={Ω,Ω2}z = \{\Omega,\Omega^2\}; thus, it makes sense that adjacent phases of the Devil’s flower map after many iterations to different points in {1,Ω,Ω2}\{1,\Omega,\Omega^2\}. However, for λ=3\lambda= 3 we have B~3(ωz)=ωB~3(z)\widetilde{B}_3(\omega z) = \omega\widetilde{B}_3(z) and D~3(ωz)=D~(z)\widetilde{D}_3(\omega z) = \widetilde{D}(z). For a chiral spin model, R3(z)R_3(z) contains only one D~3\widetilde{D}_3, implying that p=0p = 0. However, the lines separating the different regions still map into all three elements of {1,Ω,Ω2}\{1,\Omega,\Omega^2\}. In other words, the phase structure is not gone for λ=3\lambda= 3, but is just harder to discern. That is, p=2p = 2 is not required for a Devil’s flower.

Instead, let us write the coarse-grained order parameter for chiral spin models as M(x)=ρ(x)exp⁡[iϕ(x)]M(x) = \rho(x)\exp[i\phi(x)]. Symmetry arguments suggest the Landau free energy density takes the form

f=12(∇+iA)M∗⋅(∇−iA)M+BM∗M+C(M3+M∗3)+O(M4)(35)f = \frac{1}{2}(\nabla+ iA)M^* \cdot(\nabla- iA)M + BM^*M + C(M^3 + M^{*3}) + O(M^4) \tag*{(35)}

where AA is a constant vector field in the chiral direction, and {B,C}\{B,C\} are scalar parameters. In the low-temperature limit, we can take the magnitude of MM and ρ0\rho_0 to be fixed and reduce the Landau free energy density to

f=12ρ02(∇ϕ−A)2−2Cρ03cos⁡(3ϕ).(36)f = \frac{1}{2}\rho_0^2(\nabla\phi- A)^2 - 2C\rho_0^3\cos(3\phi). \tag*{(36)}

Minimization of eq. (36) leads to the fundamental equation of the Frenkel-Kontorova model [164], a well-known system with Devil’s staircase behavior. (The explicit form of the parameters in the model can be easily obtained using, for example, mean field theory [252].) The potential term favors a constant value of ϕ=2πn/3\phi= 2\pi n/3, while the kinetic term is minimized if ϕ\phi changes at a constant rate along chiral direction. In the Frenkel-Kontorova model, the interplay between these two terms leads to a Devil’s staircase for ϕ\phi along the direction of A. For general ZN\mathbb{Z}_N models, eq. (36) generalizes to

f=12ρ02(∇ϕ−A)2−2Cρ0Ncos⁡(Nϕ).(37)f = \frac{1}{2}\rho_0^2(\nabla\phi-A)^2-2C\rho_0^N\cos(N\phi). \tag*{(37)}

The key feature of this connection is the presence of a local order parameter MM in the chiral spin models and their duals. However, for the other cases, the fundamental field of the chiral model is not an order parameter due to Elitzur’s theorem [253], which prohibits the spontaneous breaking of local gauge symmetry in gauge theories without gauge fixing. Generally, unless an Abelian lattice model or its chiral dual has a local order parameter, it cannot support a Devil’s flower.

Extension to finite temperature

So far we have only included the effects of a nonzero chemical potential in an infinite Euclidean spacetime. To build models with a closer relationship to QCD at nonzero density and temperature, we must also consider the effects of nonzero temperature, obtained by giving the lattice a toroidal topology, R3⊗T1\mathbb{R}^3 \otimes\mathbb{T}^1, where the circumference of T1\mathbb{T}^1 is β=1/T\beta=1/T, the inverse temperature. Note that the temperature introduced here is completely distinct from our previous use of low- and high-temperature to encapsulate our intuition about phases for J≫1J\gg1 and J≪1J\ll1. Here, we take the direction associated with temperature to be that of θ\theta (chemical potential); we refer to this as the Euclidean time direction.

In general, when β\beta is much larger than any correlation length in a system, the system’s behavior resembles that of β=∞\beta=\infty. When we decrease β\beta to become commensurate with one of the correlation lengths, finite temperature effects become non-negligible. From an RG perspective, the RG flow near a dd-dimensional fixed point typically crosses over to behavior associated with a (d−1)(d-1)-dimensional fixed point. This is closely associated with dimensional reduction, the description of a dd-dimensional field theory at high temperature by an effective (d−1)(d-1)-dimensional theory. This behavior occurs naturally in the Migdal-Kadanoff RG. For a complex spin model in dd dimensions, the RG transformation is

Rd(z)=DBd−1(z)(38)R_d(z)=DB^{d-1}(z) \tag*{(38)}

for all directions. When β=2\beta=2 in lattice units, periodic boundary conditions in time imply that there is no spin-spin interaction in that direction anymore; it has been integrated out. This leads to a dimensionally-reduced spin model in (d−1)(d-1) dimensions with no chemical potential. The RG flow for this reduced model evolves as

Rd−1(z)=DBd−2(z).(39)R_{d-1}(z)=DB^{d-2}(z). \tag*{(39)}

A more interesting behavior occurs for gauge theories. The Polyakov loop PP, a closed thermal Wilson line, is the product of the link variables U(x⃗,t)U(\vec{x},t) winding around the lattice in the time direction:

P(x⃗,t)=U(x⃗,t)U(x⃗,t+1)…U(x⃗,t−1)(40)P(\vec{x},t)=U(\vec{x},t)U(\vec{x},t+1)\ldots U(\vec{x},t-1) \tag*{(40)}

where periodic boundary conditions close the loop. Note that Tr⁡P(x⃗,t)\operatorname{Tr}P(\vec{x},t) is gauge-invariant and independent of the choice of tt, and it functions like a scalar from a (d−1)(d-1)-dimensional perspective. This is the order parameter for the deconfinement phase transition in a pure gauge theory at nonzero temperature. Using, for example, the original form of the Migdal-Kadanoff RG, the complex Z3\mathbb{Z}_3 gauge theory has the RG transformation

Rd(z)=D2Bd−2(z).(41)R_d(z) = D^2B^{d-2}(z). \tag*{(41)}

When we repeatedly act with RR on timelike plaquettes, we eventually reach a point where the system is effectively (d−1)(d-1)-dimensional, like before. However, the timelike gauge interactions remain between neighboring Polyakov loops P(x⃗,0)P(\vec{x},0), effectively generating a spin-spin interaction between them.2 In the Migdal-Kadanoff framework, once we reach the limiting case of a (d−1)(d-1)-dimensional spin system, the timelike couplings evolve as

Rd−1(z)=DBd−2(z)(42)R_{d-1}(z) = DB^{d-2}(z) \tag*{(42)}

which is precisely the evolution of a (d−1)(d-1)-dimensional spin system. At this point, a dd-dimensional Z3\mathbb{Z}_3 gauge theory evolves as two separate systems: a (d−1)(d-1)-dimensional Z3\mathbb{Z}_3 spin system with Polyakov loops playing the roles of spins and a (d−1)(d-1)-dimensional Z3\mathbb{Z}_3 gauge theory. This decoupling is unique to Abelian gauge theories; for non-Abelian gauge theories, the Polyakov loops act as adjoint scalars in (d−1)(d-1) dimensions and remain coupled to the gauge field. In the case of chiral Z3\mathbb{Z}_3 gauge theory, the dimensionally-reduced Z3\mathbb{Z}_3 spin system is chiral, and the gauge theory is Hermitian. For a complex Z3\mathbb{Z}_3 gauge theory, the dimensionally-reduced Z3\mathbb{Z}_3 spin system is complex. In four dimensions, a chiral Z3\mathbb{Z}_3 gauge theory at nonzero temperature has a Devil’s flower phase structure associated with Polyakov loops, but the corresponding complex Z3\mathbb{Z}_3 gauge theory does not.

Extension to ZN\mathbb{Z}_N

Carrying out real-space RG analyses of ZN\mathbb{Z}_N models becomes increasingly more complicated for increasing NN. To parametrize nearest-neighbor Z3\mathbb{Z}_3 models, we only need one parameter in the Hermitian case and two parameters in the chiral and complex cases. As we increase NN, the number of required parameters increases according to the number of nontrivial simple representations of the group. For example, Z4\mathbb{Z}_4 has 4 irreps, associated with the mapping s→{1,s,s2,s3}s \to\{1,s,s^2,s^3\}, two of which are complex and conjugate (s3=s∗s^3=s^*) and one of which is real (s2s^2); thus, it requires one complex and one real parameter.

While we do not work out the behavior of ZN\mathbb{Z}_N models explicitly, it seems likely that phase diagram characteristics of Z3\mathbb{Z}_3 models will persist for all NN. For example, chiral Z4\mathbb{Z}_4 spin models are known to exhibit Devil’s flowers for d≥3d \ge3 [233]; we expect chiral spin models and their duals to exhibit this structure for all NN in d≥3d \ge3. Likewise, we expect that ZN\mathbb{Z}_N complex spin models have similar phase diagrams as the Z3\mathbb{Z}_3 case, with a disordered phase and at least NN ordered phases; however, as discussed above, we expect that the correct ZN\mathbb{Z}_N result for cubic lattices is a disordered phase and exactly NN ordered phases.

Extension to SU(3)

While neither Z2\mathbb{Z}_2 nor SU(2)\mathrm{SU}(2) models have complex irreducible representations (irreps), extending our ZN\mathbb{Z}_N results to complex and chiral SU(N)\mathrm{SU}(N) models for N≥3N \ge3 is more complex because SU(N)\mathrm{SU}(N) has an infinite number of irreps. Nonetheless, Migdal-Kadanoff methods have been applied to Hermitian SU(N)\mathrm{SU}(N) gauge theories in 4D and d=4−ϵd = 4-\epsilon [255, 256], which provides us a starting point.

As with ZN\mathbb{Z}_N gauge theories, 2D gauge models are exactly solvable. The Migdal-Kadanoff RG consists only of decimations, which map a class of SU(N)\mathrm{SU}(N) heat kernel actions, parametrized by a single real parameter β\beta, into itself. These actions give results essentially identical to those of continuum 2D SU(N)\mathrm{SU}(N) pure gauge theories. There are two fixed points: an unstable high-temperature fixed point at β=∞\beta= \infty and a stable low-temperature fixed point at β=0\beta= 0, similar to the behavior of a standard 1D Z3\mathbb{Z}_3 spin model. In 4D, a perturbative analysis around β=∞\beta= \infty shows that this is a good approximation to the standard UV fixed point at g2=0g^2 = 0. In d=4+ϵd = 4 + \epsilon, that fixed point becomes an IR fixed point, and a new UV fixed point at g2=O(ϵ)g^2 = O(\epsilon) emerges. This is consistent with the continuum behavior of such theories; parallel results hold for SU(N)\mathrm{SU}(N) spin models in d=2+ϵd = 2 + \epsilon [257, 258].

Lattice SU(N)\mathrm{SU}(N) models display additional structure when we extend the usual Wilson lattice action to include a term in the adjoint representation. For example, for a gauge theory the extended action is [259, 260]

S[Up]=∑p[βF2N(χF(Up)+χF(Up)∗)+βAN2−1χA(Up)].(43)S[U_p] = \sum_p \left[\frac{\beta_F}{2N}\left(\chi_F(U_p) + \chi_F(U_p)^*\right) + \frac{\beta_A}{N^2 - 1}\chi_A(U_p)\right]. \tag*{(43)}

Here χR\chi_R is the group character for the irrep RR: χF(Up)\chi_F(U_p) is the trace of the plaquette variable UpU_p in the fundamental representation, and χA(Up)=∣χF(Up)∣2−1\chi_A(U_p) = \lvert\chi_F(U_p)\rvert^2 - 1. In the limit βA→∞\beta_A \to\infty, the plaquette variables take on values in ZN\mathbb{Z}_N. Thus in this limit, an SU(N)\mathrm{SU}(N) gauge theory reduces to a ZN\mathbb{Z}_N gauge theory, and similarly for SU(N)\mathrm{SU}(N) spin systems.

We can also define chiral and complex SU(N)\mathrm{SU}(N) lattice models; for spin models, we have

Sc[Ux]=∑x,r[βF2N(χF(Ux+r^+Ux)+χF(Ux−r^Ux+))+θrN3(χF(Ux+r^+Ux)−χF(Ux−r^Ux+))+βAN2−1χA(Ux+r^+Ux)],Sχ[Ux]=∑x,r[βF2N(eiθ~rχF(Ux+r^+Ux)+e−iθ~rχF(Ux−r^Ux+))+βAN2−1χA(Ux+r^+Ux)].(44)\begin{aligned} S_c[U_x] &= \sum_{x,r}\left[\frac{\beta_F}{2N}\left(\chi_F(U_{x+\hat{r}}^+U_x) + \chi_F(U_{x-\hat{r}}U_x^+)\right) + \frac{\theta_r}{N\sqrt{3}}\left(\chi_F(U_{x+\hat{r}}^+U_x) - \chi_F(U_{x-\hat{r}}U_x^+)\right) \right.\\ &\qquad\left. + \frac{\beta_A}{N^2 - 1}\chi_A(U_{x+\hat{r}}^+U_x)\right],\\ S_\chi[U_x] &= \sum_{x,r}\left[\frac{\beta_F}{2N}\left(e^{i\widetilde{\theta}_r}\chi_F(U_{x+\hat{r}}^+U_x) + e^{-i\widetilde{\theta}_r}\chi_F(U_{x-\hat{r}}U_x^+)\right) + \frac{\beta_A}{N^2 - 1}\chi_A(U_{x+\hat{r}}^+U_x)\right]. \tag*{(44)} \end{aligned}

where {x,r}\{x,r\} index lattice sites and directions, and {θr,θ~r}\{\theta_r,\widetilde{\theta}_r\} are nonzero only along the complex or chiral direction, respectively. The normalizations of the parameters agree with the Z3\mathbb{Z}_3 models in the limit βA→∞\beta_A \to\infty.

There is no known general connection between the two models in eq. (44) except in the ZN\mathbb{Z}_N limit. However, the first-order transitions we have found for Z3\mathbb{Z}_3 models should extend to large but finite values of βF\beta_F, which allows us to make predictions for T=0T = 0 behavior. We expect that chiral SU(N)\mathrm{SU}(N) spin models in d≥3d \ge3 exhibit a Devil’s flower phase structure as θ~\widetilde{\theta} is varied for at sufficiently large βF\beta_F and βA\beta_A. We also expect that chiral SU(N)\mathrm{SU}(N) gauge models for d≥3d \ge3 exhibit a four-phase structure as we vary θ~\tilde{\theta} at sufficiently large βF\beta_F and βA\beta_A. Similarly, we expect that complex spin and gauge models in d≥3d \ge3 exhibit a four-phase structure as we vary θ\theta for small βF\beta_F and large βA\beta_A.

Outlook

In this work, we studied lattice Z3\mathbb{Z}_3 spin and gauge theories with complex and chiral interactions. We demonstrated an extension of Kramers-Wannier duality that maps complex and chiral models onto one another. We analyzed the phase structure of these models with real-space RG methods, and showed how Z3\mathbb{Z}_3 and CKCK symmetries impact the RG flow and phase structure. In particular, we showed that spatially-modulated phases appear in both chiral and complex models, and that these phases manifest in a Devil’s flower structure in the specific case of chiral spin models and their duals.

We have shown that the phase structure of Z3\mathbb{Z}_3 non-Hermitian models obtained from Migdal-Kadanoff RG calculations depends strongly on the order of bond moving and decimation, a violation of expectations of universality. This finding underscores the need to explore whether other real-space RG formulations, and other theoretical tools like mean field theory exhibit similar issues when applied to non-Hermitian and finite-density models. In cases where a real dual form is available, standard lattice methods can in principle determine the correct phase structure. In practice, it may be necessary to consider both order and disorder variables for a complete understanding.

We have also found that the Devil’s flower phase structure only occurs in a given model if there is a gauge-invariant order parameter available in the model or its dual, a behavior we trace to Elitzur’s theorem. This has profound implications for the appearance of inhomogeneous phases in lattice field theories in general.

We have partially extended our results on Z3\mathbb{Z}_3 to ZN\mathbb{Z}_N and SU(N)\mathrm{SU}(N) lattice models. The ZN\mathbb{Z}_N chiral spin models with N≥3N \ge3 are all expected to have ZN\mathbb{Z}_N spirals. As in the Z3\mathbb{Z}_3 case, we predict that chiral SU(N)\mathrm{SU}(N) spin models exhibit a Devil’s flower phase structure for d≥3d \ge3, but that chiral gauge theories do not, due to Elitzur’s theorem. Unfortunately, the lack of a simple duality for non-Abelian lattice models prevents us from making corresponding statements about complex SU(N)\mathrm{SU}(N) lattice models, which are more directly related to finite-density QCD. It is possible that chiral spirals and ZN\mathbb{Z}_N spirals may have a synergistic effect for models in which Polyakov loops and fermion bilinear order parameters are coupled, such as PNJL models.

Acknowledgments

We thank Zohar Nussinov and Jesse Thaler for helpful discussions. S.T.S. was supported by the U.S. Department of Energy, Office of Science, Office of Nuclear Physics from DE-SC0011090; the U.S. National Science Foundation through a Graduate Research Fellowship under Grant No. 1745302; fellowships from the MIT Physics Department and School of Science; and the Hoffman Distinguished Postdoctoral Fellowship through the LDRD Program of Los Alamos National Laboratory under Project 20240786PRD1. Los Alamos National

Laboratory is operated by Triad National Security, LLC, for the National Nuclear Security Administration of the U.S. Department of Energy (Contract Nr. 892332188CNA000001).

Configuration-worldline duality

Chiral Z3\mathbb{Z}_3 spin models have an unusual low-temperature (small J~\tilde{J}) phase structure for d≥3d \ge3, with an infinite number of periodic inhomogeneous phases commensurate with the underlying lattice. Evidence for this behavior was first obtained via low-temperature (TT) expansions [230], and has also been indicated by other approaches [229, 231, 232, 235]. In a given inhomogeneous phase, (d−1)(d-1)-dimensional sheets of spins, each characterized by a certain expectation value, are layered along the chiral direction, forming a Z3\mathbb{Z}_3 spiral along the chiral direction.

A low-TT expansion of a spin system typically entails expanding about the lowest-energy configuration(s); in our sign convention, these configurations have the largest lattice action. In our Z3\mathbb{Z}_3 chiral spin models at θ~=0\tilde{\theta}=0, the ground state configurations have all their spins aligned, leading to three possibilities for the starting point for our expansion (one for each possible spin). Higher-order terms in the expansion reflect contributions to the partition function from configurations formed by flipping one or more spins in the original configuration.

As we vary θ~\tilde{\theta}, configurations become inhomogeneous in the chiral direction θ~\tilde{\theta} but remain homogeneous in the directions transverse to θ~\tilde{\theta}; this behavior is called a chiral spiral. We describe these configurations by the element of Z3\mathbb{Z}_3 associated with each transverse slice of the lattice configuration, using n=0,1,2n=0,1,2 as a shorthand to denote the three Z3\mathbb{Z}_3 spins exp⁡(2πn/3)\exp(2\pi n/3). For example, we can write the three homogeneous ground states at θ~=0\tilde{\theta}=0 as a sequence of period one: (000…)(000\ldots), (111…)(111\ldots), and (222…)(222\ldots). These configurations are all equivalent up to a global Z3\mathbb{Z}_3 rotation. Likewise, at the special values θ~=2π/3,4π/3\tilde{\theta}=2\pi/3,4\pi/3, the ground state configurations have period three; specifically, repeated sequences of (012)(012) and (021)(021), up to a global rotation. Every value of θ~\tilde{\theta} is associated with a sequence of spins, each associated with a phase. A first-order transition occurs when the free energies of two stable phases are degenerate in parameter space.

An alternative notation for describing field configurations tells us how many times a spin value repeats before changing. For example, in the configuration (012)(012), the spin value repeats once before changing, which we can write as

(012012…)=⟨1⟩.(45)(012012\ldots)=\langle1\rangle. \tag*{(45)}

We can generalize this notation to more complicated patterns ⟨k1 k2…kn⟩\langle k_1\, k_2\ldots k_n\rangle. For example, we could have a spin configuration that looks like

{01122 0001 2200111 2…}=⟨1223⟩.(46)\{01122\,0001\,2200111\,2\ldots\}=\langle1^2 2^3\rangle. \tag*{(46)}

The righthand side indicates that there is a layer consisting of one spin, followed by a layer of two spins, followed by another layer of two spins, followed by a layer of three spins, before the pattern repeats. The notation

{000…}={111…}={222…}=⟨∞⟩(47)\{000\ldots\}=\{111\ldots\}=\{222\ldots\}=\langle\infty\rangle \tag*{(47)}

indicates a homogeneous phase.

Due to the duality between the low-TT expansion of a chiral model and the high-TT expansion of its corresponding complex model, we can associate configurations of chiral models with contributions to the high-TT expansion of complex models. For example, in d=2d=2 spin systems, duality relates each spin configuration of the chiral model to a set of closed paths in a worldline expansion of the corresponding complex model, and vice versa. In d=3d=3, spin configurations of the chiral spin model are dual to terms in a worldsheet expansion of the dual complex gauge theory. We refer to this relationship as spin configuration-worldline duality.

In d=2d=2, configurations of the chiral spin model are mapped by duality into straight worldlines in the direction transverse to the chiral direction. In between each two adjacent slices of the (012) configuration, there is a worldline carrying Z3\mathbb{Z}_{3} triality 1. Similarly, in between each two adjacent slices of the (021) configuration, there is a worldline carrying Z3\mathbb{Z}_{3} triality 2≡−12 \equiv-1. We can associate the spin configurations described above with their corresponding worldlines as follows:

(000)↔[000](012)↔[111](021)↔[222]\begin{aligned} (000) &\leftrightarrow[000] \\ (012) &\leftrightarrow[111] \\ (021) &\leftrightarrow[222] \end{aligned}

The worldline value on the right is the difference of the successive spins on the left. We can think of [111, 222] in d=2d=2 as representing constant currents in the Euclidean timelike direction, arising from a nonzero chemical potential. We give further examples of this configuration-worldline duality in Table 4.

Brief notationSpin configurationWorldlines
⟨∞⟩\langle\infty\rangle(000000)[000000]
⟨3⟩\langle3 \rangle(000111222)[001001001]
⟨32⟩\langle32 \rangle(000112220011122)[001010010100101]
⟨322⟩\langle32^{2} \rangle(0001122)[0010101]
⟨2⟩\langle2 \rangle(001122)[010101]
⟨1⟩\langle1 \rangle(012012)[111111]

Table 4. Examples of spin configuration-worldline duality.

The spin configurations (012) and (021) are atypical in the chiral models: they are inhomogeneous, but their worldline duals [111] and [222] are homogeneous. From this analysis, we see that it is natural that a Z3\mathbb{Z}_{3} model without a Devil’s flower has only four phases, with a three-fold symmetric phase diagram: Each of the three ordered phases of a chiral model is obtained in the complex form of the model from a starting point of constant density.

References

  1. [1]The Frontiers of Nuclear Science, A Long Range Plan, 0809.3137.
  2. [2]Y. Akiba et al., The Hot QCD White Paper: Exploring the Phases of QCD at RHIC and the LHC, 1502.02730.arxiv.org/abs/1502.02730
  3. [3]P. Achenbach et al., The Present and Future of QCD, 2303.02579.
  4. [4]STAR collaboration, K. H. Ackermann et al., STAR detector overview, Nucl. Instrum. Meth. A 499 (2003) 624.
  5. [5]PHENIX collaboration, A. Adare et al., An Upgrade Proposal from the PHENIX Collaboration, 1501.06197.
  6. [6]ALICE collaboration, K. Aamodt et al., The ALICE experiment at the CERN LHC, JINST 3 (2008) S08002.
  7. [7]CBM collaboration, T. Ablyazimov et al., Challenges in QCD matter physics –The scientific programme of the Compressed Baryonic Matter experiment at FAIR, Eur. Phys. J. A 53 (2017) 60 [1607.01487].DOI
  8. [8]W. Busza, K. Rajagopal and W. van der Schee, Heavy Ion Collisions: The Big Picture, and the Big Questions, Ann. Rev. Nucl. Part. Sci. 68 (2018) 339 [1802.04801].DOI
  9. [9]G. Aarts, Introductory lectures on lattice QCD at nonzero baryon number, J. Phys. Conf. Ser. 706 (2016) 022004 [1512.05145].DOI
  10. [10]K. Nagata, Finite-density lattice QCD and sign problem: Current status and open problems, Prog. Part. Nucl. Phys. 127 (2022) 103991 [2108.12423].DOI
  11. [11]C. Ratti, Lattice QCD and heavy ion collisions: a review of recent progress, Rept. Prog. Phys. 81 (2018) 084301 [1804.07810].DOI
  12. [12]C. Ratti and R. Bellwied, The Deconfinement Transition of QCD: Theory Meets Experiment, vol. 981 of Lecture Notes in Physics, 6, 2021, 10.1007/978-3-030-67235-5.
  13. [13]I. M. Barbour, S. E. Morrison, E. G. Klepfish, J. B. Kogut and M.-P. Lombardo, Results on finite density QCD, Nucl. Phys. B Proc. Suppl. 60 (1998) 220 [hep-lat/9705042].
  14. [14]Z. Fodor and S. D. Katz, A New method to study lattice QCD at finite temperature and chemical potential, Phys. Lett. B 534 (2002) 87 [hep-lat/0104001].DOI
  15. [15]Z. Fodor and S. D. Katz, Lattice determination of the critical point of QCD at finite T and μ, JHEP 03 (2002) 014 [hep-lat/0166002].DOI
  16. [16]Z. Fodor, S. D. Katz and C. Schmidt, The Density of states method at non-zero chemical potential, JHEP 03 (2007) 121 [hep-lat/0701022].
  17. [17]A. Alexandru, C. Gattringer, H. P. Schadler, K. Splittorff and J. J. M. Verbaarschot, Distribution of Canonical Determinants in QCD, Phys. Rev. D 91 (2015) 074501 [1411.4143].
  18. [18]A. Alexandru, M. Faber, I. Horvath and K.-F. Liu, Lattice QCD at finite density via a new canonical approach, Phys. Rev. D 72 (2005) 114513 [hep-lat/0507020].
  19. [19]S. Kratochvila and P. de Forcrand, The Canonical approach to finite density QCD, PoS LAT2005 (2006) 167 [hep-lat/0509143].
  20. [20]S. Ejiri, Canonical partition function and finite density phase transition in lattice QCD, Phys. Rev. D 78 (2008) 074507 [0804.3227].DOI
  21. [21]C. Gattringer, New developments for dual methods in lattice field theory at non-zero density, PoS LATTICE2013 (2014) 002 [1401.7788].arxiv.org/abs/1401.7788
  22. [22]AURORASCIENCE collaboration, M. Cristoforetti, F. Di Renzo and L. Scorzato, New approach to the sign problem in quantum field theories: High density QCD on a Lefschetz thimble, Phys. Rev. D 86 (2012) 074506 [1205.3996].DOI
  23. [23]A. Alexandru, G. Basar and P. F. Bedaque, Monte Carlo algorithm for simulating fermions on Lefschetz thimbles, Phys. Rev. D 93 (2016) 014504 [1510.03258].DOI
  24. [24]A. Alexandru, G. Basar, P. F. Bedaque, G. W. Ridgway and N. C. Warrington, Sign problem and Monte Carlo calculations beyond Lefschetz thimbles, JHEP 05 (2016) 053 [1512.08764].
  25. [25]G. Parisi, ON COMPLEX PROBABILITIES, Phys. Lett. B 131 (1983) 393.
  26. [26]F. Attanasio, B. Jäger and F. P. G. Ziegler, Complex Langevin simulations and the QCD phase diagram: Recent developments, Eur. Phys. J. A 56 (2020) 251 [2006.00476].
  27. [27]M. S. Albergo, G. Kanwar and P. E. Shanahan, Flow-based generative models for Markov chain Monte Carlo in lattice field theory, Phys. Rev. D 100 (2019) 034515 [1904.12072].DOI
  28. [28]S. Lawrence and Y. Yamauchi, Normalizing Flows and the Real-Time Sign Problem, Phys. Rev. D 103 (2021) 114509 [2101.05755].DOI
  29. [29]E. Rico, T. Pichler, M. Dalmonte, P. Zoller and S. Montangero, Tensor networks for Lattice Gauge Theories and Atomic Quantum Simulation, Phys. Rev. Lett. 112 (2014) 201601 [1312.3127].
  30. [30]T. Pichler, M. Dalmonte, E. Rico, P. Zoller and S. Montangero, Real-time Dynamics in U(1) Lattice Gauge Theories with Tensor Networks, Phys. Rev. X 6 (2016) 011023 [1505.04440].DOI
  31. [31]D. Kadoh, Y. Kuramashi, Y. Nakamura, R. Sakai, S. Takeda and Y. Yoshimura, Tensor network formulation for two-dimensional lattice N = 1 Wess-Zumino model, JHEP 03 (2018) 141 [1801.04183].
  32. [32]D. Kadoh, Y. Kuramashi, Y. Nakamura, R. Sakai, S. Takeda and Y. Yoshimura, Tensor network analysis of critical coupling in two dimensional ϕ4 theory, JHEP 05 (2019) 184 [1811.12376].DOI
  33. [33]Y. Kuramashi and Y. Yoshimura, Three-dimensional finite temperature Z2 gauge theory with tensor network scheme, JHEP 08 (2019) 023 [1808.08025].DOI
  34. [34]G. Magnifico, T. Felser, P. Silvi and S. Montangero, Lattice quantum electrodynamics in (3+1)-dimensions at finite density with tensor networks, Nature Commun. 12 (2021) 3600 [2011.10658].DOI
  35. [35]X. Yuan, J. Sun, J. Liu, Q. Zhao and Y. Zhou, Quantum Simulation with Hybrid Tensor Networks, Phys. Rev. Lett. 127 (2021) 040501 [2007.00958].
  36. [36]Y. Meurice, J. C. Osborn, R. Sakai, J. Unmuth-Yockey, S. Catterall and R. D. Somma, Tensor networks for High Energy Physics: contribution to Snowmass 2021, in 2022 Snowmass Summer Study, 3, 2022, 2203.04902.arxiv.org/abs/2203.04902
  37. [37]E. Braaten and R. D. Pisarski, Soft Amplitudes in Hot Gauge Theories: A General Analysis, Nucl. Phys. B 337 (1990) 569.DOI
  38. [38]J. O. Andersen and M. Strickland, Resummation in hot field theories, Annals Phys. 317 (2005) 281 [hep-ph/0404164].
  39. [39]D. K. Hong, Aspects of high density effective theory in QCD, Nucl. Phys. B 582 (2000) 451 [hep-ph/9905523].
  40. [40]T. Schäfer, Hard loops, soft loops, and high density effective field theory, Nucl. Phys. A 728 (2003) 251 [hep-ph/0307074].DOI
  41. [41]C. R. Allton, S. Ejiri, S. J. Hands, O. Kaczmarek, F. Karsch, E. Laermann et al., The QCD thermal phase transition in the presence of a small chemical potential, Phys. Rev. D 66 (2002) 074507 [hep-lat/0204010].
  42. [42]C. R. Allton, M. Doring, S. Ejiri, S. J. Hands, O. Kaczmarek, F. Karsch et al., Thermodynamics of two flavor QCD to sixth order in quark chemical potential, Phys. Rev. D 71 (2005) 054508 [hep-lat/0501030].DOI
  43. [43]R. V. Gavai and S. Gupta, QCD at finite chemical potential with six time slices, Phys. Rev. D 78 (2008) 114503 [0806.2233].DOI
  44. [44]O. Kaczmarek, F. Karsch, E. Laermann, C. Miao, S. Mukherjee, P. Petreczky et al., Phase boundary for the chiral transition in (2+1) -flavor QCD at small values of the chemical potential, Phys. Rev. D 83 (2011) 014504 [1011.3130].DOI
  45. [45]E. Dagotto, A. Moreo, R. L. Sugar and D. Toussaint, Binding of Holes in the Hubbard Model, Phys. Rev. B 41 (1990) 811.
  46. [46]A. Hasenfratz and D. Toussaint, Canonical ensembles and nonzero density quantum chromodynamics, Nucl. Phys. B 371 (1992) 539.DOI
  47. [47]M. G. Alford, A. Kapustin and F. Wilczek, Imaginary chemical potential and finite fermion density on the lattice, Phys. Rev. D 59 (1999) 054502 [hep-lat/9807039].
  48. [48]P. de Forcrand and O. Philipsen, The QCD phase diagram for small densities from imaginary chemical potential, Nucl. Phys. B 642 (2002) 290 [hep-lat/0205016].
  49. [49]M. D’Elia and M.-P. Lombardo, Finite density QCD via imaginary chemical potential, Phys. Rev. D 67 (2003) 014505 [hep-lat/0209146].
  50. [50]P. N. Meisinger and M. C. Ogilvie, PT Symmetry in Classical and Quantum Statistical Mechanics, Phil. Trans. Roy. Soc. Lond. A 371 (2013) 20120058 [1208.5077].DOI
  51. [51]M. A. Schindler, S. T. Schindler, L. Medina and M. C. Ogilvie, Universality of Pattern Formation, Phys. Rev. D 102 (2020) 114510 [1906.07288].
  52. [52]M. A. Schindler, S. T. Schindler and M. C. Ogilvie, PT symmetry, pattern formation, and finite-density QCD, J. Phys.: Conf. Ser. 2038 (2021) [2106.07092].DOI
  53. [53]C. M. Bender and S. Boettcher, Real spectra in nonHermitian Hamiltonians having PT symmetry, Phys. Rev. Lett. 80 (1998) 5243 [physics/9712001].
  54. [54]C. M. Bender, P. E. Dorey, C. Dunning, A. Fring, D. W. Hook, H. F. Jones et al., PT Symmetry: in Quantum and Classical Physics. WORLD SCIENTIFIC (EUROPE), 2019, 10.1142/Q0178, [https://www.worldscientific.com/doi/pdf/10.1142/q0178].
  55. [55]C. M. Bender and D. W. Hook, PT-symmetric quantum mechanics, Rev. Mod. Phys. 96 (2023) 045002 [2312.17386].
  56. [56]V. V. Konotop, J. Yang and D. A. Zezyulin, Nonlinear waves in PT-symmetric systems, Rev. Mod. Phys. 88 (2016) 035002.
  57. [57]L. Feng, R. El-Ganainy and L. Ge, Non-hermitian photonics based on parity–time symmetry, Nature Photonics 11 (2017) 752.
  58. [58]S. K. Ozdemir, S. Rotter, F. Nori and L. Yang, Parity-time symmetry and exceptional points in photonics, Nature Materials 18 (2019) 783.DOI
  59. [59]M.-A. Miri and A. Alù, Exceptional points in optics and photonics, Science 363 (2019) .
  60. [60]Y. Ashida, Z. Gong and M. Ueda, Non-Hermitian physics, Adv. Phys. 69 (2021) 249 [2006.01837].
  61. [61]K. Ding, C. Fang and G. Ma, Non-Hermitian topology and exceptional-point geometries, Nature Rev. Phys. 4 (2022) 745 [2204.11601].
  62. [62]C. M. Bender, Making sense of non-Hermitian Hamiltonians, Rept. Prog. Phys. 70 (2007) 947 [hep-th/0703096].DOI
  63. [63]C. M. Bender, D. C. Brody and H. F. Jones, Must a Hamiltonian be Hermitian?, Am. J. Phys. 71 (2003) 1095 [hep-th/0303005].DOI
  64. [64]C. M. Bender, S. F. Brandt, J.-H. Chen and Q.-h. Wang, Ghost busting: PT-symmetric interpretation of the Lee model, Phys. Rev. D 71 (2005) 025014 [hep-th/0411064].DOI
  65. [65]C. M. Bender and P. D. Mannheim, No-ghost theorem for the fourth-order derivative Pais-Uhlenbeck oscillator model, Phys. Rev. Lett. 100 (2008) 110402 [0706.0207].
  66. [66]E. A. Ivanov and A. V. Smilga, Cryptoreality of nonanticommutative Hamiltonians, JHEP 07 (2007) 036 [hep-th/0703038].DOI
  67. [67]T. Curtright, E. Ivanov, L. Mezincescu and P. K. Townsend, Planar super-Landau models revisited, JHEP 04 (2007) 020 [hep-th/0612300].
  68. [68]T. Curtright and A. Veitia, Quasi-hermitian quantum mechanics in phase space, J. Math. Phys. 48 (2007) 102112 [quant-ph/0701006].DOI
  69. [69]W.-Y. Ai, C. M. Bender and S. Sarkar, PT-symmetric -φ4 theory, Phys. Rev. D 106 (2022) 125016 [2209.07897].
  70. [70]S. Lawrence, R. Weller, C. Peterson and P. Romatschke, Instantons, analytic continuation, and PT-symmetric field theory, Phys. Rev. D 108 (2023) 085013 [2303.01470].arxiv.org/abs/2303.01470
  71. [71]P. Romatschke, Life at the Landau pole, AppliedMath 4 (2024) 55 [2212.03254].DOI
  72. [72]C. M. Bender, N. Hassanpour, S. P. Klevansky and S. Sarkar, PT-symmetric quantum field theory in D dimensions, Phys. Rev. D 98 (2018) 125003 [1810.12479].
  73. [73]C. M. Bender, C. K. Raoulopitidis and S. P. Klevansky, Underdetermined Dyson-Schwinger Equations, Phys. Rev. Lett. 130 (2023) 101602 [2211.13026].DOI
  74. [74]J. Alexandre, P. Millington and D. Seynaeve, Symmetries and conservation laws in non-Hermitian field theories, Phys. Rev. D 96 (2017) 065027 [1707.01057].
  75. [75]A. Felski, C. M. Bender, S. P. Klevansky and S. Sarkar, Towards perturbative renormalization of φ2(iφ)ϵ quantum field theory, Phys. Rev. D 104 (2021) 085011 [2103.07577].
  76. [76]C. M. Bender, A. Felski, S. P. Klevansky and S. Sarkar, PT Symmetry and Renormalisation in Quantum Field Theory, J. Phys. Conf. Ser. 2038 (2021) 012004 [2103.14864].
  77. [77]A. Fring and T. Taira, Complex BPS solitons with real energies from duality, J. Phys. A 53 (2020) 455701 [2007.15425].DOI
  78. [78]A. Fring and T. Taira, Non-Hermitian gauge field theories and BPS limits, J. Phys. Conf. Ser. 2038 (2021) 012010 [2103.13519].
  79. [79]F. Correa, A. Fring and T. Taira, Complex BPS Skyrmions with real energy, Nucl. Phys. B 971 (2021) 115516 [2102.05781].
  80. [80]M. N. Chernodub, The Nielsen-Ninomiya theorem, PT-invariant non-Hermiticity and single 8-shaped Dirac cone, J. Phys. A 50 (2017) 385001 [1701.07426].DOI
  81. [81]K. Jones-Smith and H. Mathur, Relativistic Non-Hermitian Quantum Mechanics, Phys. Rev. D 89 (2014) 125014 [0908.4257].
  82. [82]T. Ohlsson, Non-Hermitian neutrino oscillations in matter with PT symmetric Hamiltonians, EPL 113 (2016) 61001 [1509.06452].DOI
  83. [83]L. Chen and S. Sarkar, PT symmetric fermionic particle oscillations in even dimensional representations, 2407.02036.arxiv.org/abs/2407.02036
  84. [84]J. Alexandre, C. M. Bender and P. Millington, Non-Hermitian extension of gauge theories and implications for neutrino physics, JHEP 11 (2015) 111 [1509.01203].DOI
  85. [85]J. Alexandre, N. E. Mavromatos and A. Soto, Dynamical Majorana neutrino masses and axions I, Nucl. Phys. B 961 (2020) 115212 [2004.04611].
  86. [86]N. E. Mavromatos and A. Soto, Dynamical Majorana neutrino masses and axions II: Inclusion of anomaly terms and axial background, Nucl. Phys. B 962 (2021) 115275 [2006.13616].DOI
  87. [87]J. Alexandre and N. E. Mavromatos, On the consistency of a non-Hermitian Yukawa interaction, Phys. Lett. B 807 (2020) 135562 [2004.03699].DOI
  88. [88]N. E. Mavromatos, S. Sarkar and A. Soto, PT symmetric fermionic field theories with axions: Renormalization and dynamical mass generation, Phys. Rev. D 106 (2022) 015009 [2111.05131].DOI
  89. [89]N. E. Mavromatos, S. Sarkar and A. Soto, Schwinger-Dyson equations and mass generation for an axion theory with a PT symmetric Yukawa fermion interaction, Nucl. Phys. B 986 (2023) 116048 [2208.12436].DOI
  90. [90]M. C. Ogilvie, M. A. Schindler and S. T. Schindler, Finite-density QCD, PT symmetry, and dual algorithms, PoS LATTICE2021 (2022) 117 [2110.14009].
  91. [91]P. D. Mannheim, Making the Case for Conformal Gravity, Found. Phys. 42 (2012) 388 [1101.2186].
  92. [92]H. Nishimura, M. C. Ogilvie and K. Pangeni, Complex saddle points in QCD at finite temperature and density, Phys. Rev. D 90 (2014) 045039 [1401.7982].DOI
  93. [93]H. Nishimura, M. C. Ogilvie and K. Pangeni, Complex Saddle Points and Disorder Lines in QCD at finite temperature and density, Phys. Rev. D 91 (2015) 054004 [1411.4959].
  94. [94]H. Nishimura, M. C. Ogilvie and K. Pangeni, Complex spectrum of finite-density lattice QCD with static quarks at strong coupling, Phys. Rev. D 93 (2016) 094501 [1512.09131].DOI
  95. [95]H. Nishimura, M. C. Ogilvie and K. Pangeni, Liquid-Gas Phase Transitions and CK Symmetry in Quantum Field Theories, Phys. Rev. D 95 (2017) 076003 [1612.09575].DOI
  96. [96]M. A. Schindler, S. T. Schindler and M. C. Ogilvie, Finite-density QCD, PT symmetry, and exotic phases, PoS LATTICE2021 (2022) 555 [2110.07761].
  97. [97]P. N. Meisinger and M. C. Ogilvie, The sign problem and Abelian lattice duality, PoS LATTICE2013 (2014) 205 [1311.5515].
  98. [98]A. L. Fetter and J. D. Walecka, Quantum theory of many-particle systems. Courier Corporation, 2012.
  99. [99]J. I. Kapusta and T. Toimela, Friedel Oscillations in Relativistic QED and QCD, Phys. Rev. D 37 (1988) 3731.
  100. [100]R. D. Pisarski and F. Rennecke, Signatures of Moat Regimes in Heavy-Ion Collisions, Phys. Rev. Lett. 127 (2021) 152302 [2103.06890].DOI
  101. [101]S. Pu, A. C. Balrma, J. Taylor, E. Fradkin and Z. Papic, Microscopic model for fractional quantum Hall nematics, Phys. Rev. Lett. 132 (2024) 236503.
  102. [102]T. A. Sedrакyan, L. I. Glazman and A. Kamenev, Absence of bose condensation on lattices with moat bands, Phys. Rev. B 89 (2014) 201112(R).DOI
  103. [103]J. Stephenson, Ising Model with Antiferromagnetic Next-Nearest-Neighbor Coupling: Spin Correlations and Disorder Points, Physical Review B 1 (1970) 4405.DOI
  104. [104]S. W. Hui and N. B. He, Molecular organization in cholesterol-lecithin bilayers by x-ray and electron diffraction measurements, Biochemistry 22 (1983) 1159.
  105. [105]F. C. Frank and J. S. Kasper, Complex alloy structures regarded as sphere packings. i. definitions and basic principles, Acta Cryst. 11 (1958) .DOI
  106. [106]D. R. Nelson, Order, frustration, and defects in liquids and glasses, Phys. Rev. B 28 (1983) 5515.
  107. [107]R. Mosseri and J. F. Sadoc, Hierarchical structure of defects in non-crystalline sphere packings, J. Phys. (Paris) Lett. 45 (1984) L827.DOI
  108. [108]J. P. Sethna, Frustration, curvature, and defect lines in metallic glasses and the cholesteric blue phase, Phys. Rev. B 31 (1985) 6278.
  109. [109]Z. Nussinov, Avoided phase transitions and glassy dynamics in geometrically frustrated systems and non-abelian theories, Phys. Rev. B 69 (2004) 014208.DOI
  110. [110]G. Tarjus, S. A. Kivelson, Z. Nussinov and P. Viot, The frustration-based approach of supercooled liquids and the glass transition: a review and critical assessment, Journal of Physics: Condensed Matter 17 (2005) R1143.DOI
  111. [111]J. Schmalian and P. G. Wolynes, Stripe glasses: Self-generated randomness in a uniformly frustrated system, Phys. Rev. Lett. 85 (2000) 836.
  112. [112]S. A. Brazovskii and S. G. Dmitriev, Phase transitions in cholesteric liquid crystals, Zh. Eksp. Teor. Fiz. 69 (1975) 979.
  113. [113]B. Ma, B. Yao, T. Ye and M. Lei, Prediction of optical modulation properties of twisted-nematic liquid-crystal display by improved measurement of Jones matrix, Journal of Applied Physics 107 (2010) 073107.DOI
  114. [114]J. V. Selinger, Director deformations, geometric frustration, and modulated phases in liquid crystals, Annual Review of Condensed Matter Physics 13 (2022) 49.
  115. [115]A. Mesaros, K. Fujita, H. Eisaki, S. Uchida, J. C. Davis, S. Sachdev et al., Topological defects coupling smectic modulations to intra�#x2013;unit-cell nematicity in cuprates, Science 333 (2011) 426.
  116. [116]R. E. PeierlsHelv. Phys. Acta Suppl. 7 (1934) 81.
  117. [117]L. D. Landau and E. M. Lifshitz, Statistical Physics, Course of Theoretical Physics (volume 5) second edition. Addison-Wesley, 1969.
  118. [118]P. G. de Gennes, The Physics of Liquid Crystals. Clarendon, Oxford, 1974.
  119. [119]J. Als-Nielsen, J. D. J. D. Litster, R. J. Birgeneau, M. Kaplan, C. R. Safinya, A. Lindegaard-Andersen et al., Observation of algebraic decay of positional order in a smectic liquid crystal, Phys. Rev. B 22 (1980) 312.DOI
  120. [120]S. A. Kivelson, E. Fradkin and V. J. Emery, Electronic liquid-crystal phases of a doped mott insulator, Nature 393 (1998) 550.
  121. [121]J. M. Tranquada, B. J. Sternlieb, J. D. Axe, Y. Nakamura and S. Uchida, Evidence for stripe correlations of spins and holes in copper oxide superconductors, Nature 375 (1995) 561.
  122. [122]V. Emery and S. Kivelson, Frustrated electronic phase separation and high-temperature superconductors, Physica C: Superconductivity 209 (1993) 597.
  123. [123]U. Löw, V. J. Emery, K. Fabricius and S. A. Kivelson, Study of an ising model with competing long- and short-range interactions, Phys. Rev. Lett. 72 (1994) 1918.
  124. [124]J. C. Phillips, A. Saxena and A. R. Bishop, Pseudogaps, dopants, and strong disorder in cuprate high-temperature superconductors, Reports on Progress in Physics 66 (2003) 2111.
  125. [125]D. Valdez-Balderas and D. Stroud, Superconductivity versus phase separation, stripes, and checkerboard ordering: A two-dimensional monte carlo study, Phys. Rev. B 72 (2005) 214501.DOI
  126. [126]T. Mertelj, V. V. Kabanov and D. Mihailovic, Charged particles on a two-dimensional lattice subject to an anisotropic jahn-teller interactions, Phys. Rev. Lett. 94 (2005) 147003.
  127. [127]K. Yamada, C. H. Lee, K. Kurahashi, J. Wada, S. Wakimoto, S. Ueki et al., Doping dependence of the spatially modulated dynamical spin correlations and the superconducting-transition temperature in la₂₋ₓsrₓcuo₄, Phys. Rev. B 57 (1998) 6165.DOI
  128. [128]S. R. White and D. J. Scalapino, Density matrix renormalization group study of the striped phase in the 2d t − J model, Phys. Rev. Lett. 80 (1998) 1272.
  129. [129]J. Zaanen and O. Gunnarsson, Charged magnetic domain lines and the magnetism of high-Tc oxides, Phys. Rev. B 40 (1989) 7391.
  130. [130]K. Machida, Magnetism in la2cuo4 based compounds, Physica C: Superconductivity 158 (1989) 192.
  131. [131]M. P. Lilly, K. B. Cooper, J. P. Eisenstein, L. N. Pfeiffer and K. W. West, Evidence for an anisotropic state of two-dimensional electrons in high landau levels, Phys. Rev. Lett. 82 (1999) 394.
  132. [132]E. Fradkin and S. A. Kivelson, Liquid-crystal phases of quantum hall systems, Phys. Rev. B 59 (1999) 8065.DOI
  133. [133]M. M. Fogler, A. A. Koulakov and B. I. Shklovskii, Ground state of a two-dimensional electron liquid in a weak magnetic field, Phys. Rev. B 54 (1996) 1853.
  134. [134]R. Moessner and J. T. Chalker, Exact results for interacting electrons in high landau levels, Phys. Rev. B 54 (1996) 5006.
  135. [135]A. A. Koulakov, M. M. Fogler and B. I. Shklovskii, Charge density wave in two-dimensional electron liquid in weak magnetic field, Phys. Rev. Lett. 76 (1996) 499.
  136. [136]R. Du, D. Tsui, H. Stormer, L. Pfeiffer, K. Baldwin and K. West, Strongly anisotropic transport in higher two-dimensional landau levels, Solid State Communications 109 (1999) 389.
  137. [137]M. Seul and R. Wolfe, Evolution of disorder in magnetic stripe domains. i: transverse instabilities and disclination unbinding in lamellar patterns, Phys. Rev. A 46 (1992) 7519.
  138. [138]A. D. Stoycheva and S. J. Singer, Computer simulations of a two-dimensional system with competing interactions, Phys. Rev. E 65 (2002) 036706.
  139. [139]G. Lawes, M. Kenzelmann, N. Rogado, K. H. Kim, G. A. Jorge, R. J. Cava et al., Competing magnetic phases on a kagomé staircase, Phys. Rev. Lett. 93 (2004) 247201.
  140. [140]G. Malescio and G. Pellicane, Stripe phases from isotropic repulsive interactions, Nature Materials 2 (2003) 97.
  141. [141]G. Malescio and G. Pellicane, Stripe patterns in two-dimensional systems with core-corona molecular architecture, Phys. Rev. E 70 (2004) 021202.
  142. [142]M. A. Glaser, G. M. Grason, R. D. Kamien, A. Kösmrlj, C. D. Santangelo and P. Ziherl, Soft spheres make more mesophases, Europhysics Letters 78 (2007) 46004.
  143. [143]C. J. Olson Reichhardt, C. Reichhardt and A. R. Bishop, Fibrillar templates and soft phases in systems with short-range dipolar and long-range interactions, Phys. Rev. Lett. 92 (2004) 016801.
  144. [144]K. L. Babcock and R. M. Westervelt, Elements of cellular domain patterns in magnetic garnet films, Phys. Rev. A 40 (1989) 2022.
  145. [145]S. Chakrabarty and Z. Nussinov, High temperature correlation functions: universality, extraction of exchange interactions, divergent correlation lengths and generalized debye length scales, Physical Review B 84 (2011) 064124.DOI
  146. [146]B. Różycki, T. R. Weikl and R. Lipowsky, Stable patterns of membrane domains at corrugated substrates, Phys. Rev. Lett. 100 (2008) 098103.
  147. [147]A. Giuliani, J. L. Lebowitz and E. H. Lieb, Striped phases in two-dimensional dipole systems, Phys. Rev. B 76 (2007) 184426.
  148. [148]A. Vindigni, N. Saratz, O. Portmann, D. Pescia and P. Politi, Stripe width and nonlocal domain walls in the two-dimensional dipolar frustrated Ising ferromagnet, Phys. Rev. B 77 (2008) 092414.DOI
  149. [149]F. S. Bates and G. H. Fredrickson, Block Copolymers—Designer Soft Materials, Physics Today 52 (1999) 32.
  150. [150]L. Leibler, Theory of microphase separation in block copolymers, Macromolecules 13 (1980) 1602.
  151. [151]F. S. Bates, J. H. Rosedale and G. H. Fredrickson, Fluctuation effects in a symmetric diblock copolymer near the order–disorder transition, The Journal of Chemical Physics 92 (1990) 6255.
  152. [152]A. Ciach, J. Pękalski and W. T. Góźdź, Origin of similarity of phase diagrams in amphiphilic and colloidal systems with competing interactions, Soft Matter 9 (2013) 6301.DOI
  153. [153]P. N. Timonin and G. Y. Chitov, Disorder lines, modulation, and partition function zeros in free fermion models, Phys. Rev. B 104 (2021) 045106.DOI
  154. [154]B. Kalisky, J. R. Kirtley, J. G. Analytis, J.-H. Chu, A. Vailionis, I. R. Fisher et al., Stripes of increased diamagnetic susceptibility in underdoped superconducting Ba(Fe₁−ₓCoₓ)₂As₂ single crystals: Evidence for an enhanced superfluid density at twin boundaries, Phys. Rev. B 81 (2010) 184513.DOI
  155. [155]J. R. Kirtley, B. Kalisky, L. Luan and K. A. Moler, Meissner response of a bulk superconductor with an embedded sheet of reduced penetration depth, Phys. Rev. B 81 (2010) 184514.DOI
  156. [156]S.-W. Cheong, G. Aeppli, T. E. Mason, H. Mook, S. M. Hayden, P. C. Canfield et al., Incommensurate magnetic fluctuations in La₂−ₓSrₓCuO₄, Phys. Rev. Lett. 67 (1991) 1791.
  157. [157]D. I. Golosov, Magnetic domain walls in single-phase and phase-separated double-exchange systems, Phys. Rev. B 67 (2003) 064404.DOI
  158. [158]M. B. Salamon and M. Jaime, The physics of manganites: Structure and transport, Rev. Mod. Phys. 73 (2001) 583.
  159. [159]J. Zaanen, Stripes defeat the fermi liquid, Nature 404 (2000) 714.
  160. [160]S. A. Kivelson, I. P. Bindloss, E. Fradkin, V. Oganesyan, J. M. Tranquada, A. Kapitulnik et al., How to detect fluctuating stripes in the high-temperature superconductors, Rev. Mod. Phys. 75 (2003) 1201.
  161. [161]R. J. Elliott, Phenomenological discussion of magnetic ordering in the heavy rare-earth metals, Phys. Rev. 124 (1961) 346.DOI
  162. [162]M. E. Fisher and W. Selke, Infinitely many commensurate phases in a simple ising model, Phys. Rev. Lett. 44 (1980) 1502.
  163. [163]W. Selke, The annni model- theoretical analysis and experimental application, Physics Reports 170 (1988) 213.
  164. [164]Y. Frenkel and T. Kontorova, The model of dislocation in solid body, Phys. Z. Sowietunion 13 (1938) 1.
  165. [165]P. Bak, Commensurate phases, incommensurate phases and the devil's staircase, Reports on Progress in Physics 45 (1982) 587.
  166. [166]A. Giuliani, J. L. Lebowitz and E. H. Lieb, Ising models with long-range antiferromagnetic and short-range ferromagnetic interactions, Phys. Rev. B 74 (2006) 064420.
  167. [167]C. Ortix, J. Lorenzana and C. Di Castro, Frustrated phase separation in two-dimensional charged systems, Phys. Rev. B 73 (2006) 245117.
  168. [168]I. Daruka and Z. Gulácsi, Correlation transitions in the ising chain with competing short-range and long-range mirror interactions, Phys. Rev. E 58 (1998) 5403.DOI
  169. [169]D. G. Barci and D. A. Stariolo, Orientational order in two dimensions from competing interactions at different scales, Phys. Rev. B 79 (2009) 075437.DOI
  170. [170]V. L. Pokrovsky and A. L. Talapov, Ground state, spectrum, and phase diagram of two-dimensional incommensurate crystals, Phys. Rev. Lett. 42 (1979) 65.
  171. [171]S. A. Brazovskii, Phase transition of an isotropic system to a nonuniform state, Zh. Eksp. Teor. Fiz. 68 (1975) 175.
  172. [172]S. Chakrabarty, V. Dobrosavljevic, A. Seidel and Z. Nussinov, Universality of modulation length (and time) exponents, Physical Review E 86 (2012) 041132.
  173. [173]S. Chakrabarty and Z. Nussinov, Modulation and correlations lengths in systems with competing interactions: new exponents and other universal features, Physical Review B 84 (2011) 144402.
  174. [174]D. Mukamel, Critical behaviour associated with helical order near a lifshitz point, Journal of Physics A: Mathematical and General 10 (1977) L249.DOI
  175. [175]M. Seul and D. Andelman, Domain shapes and patterns: The phenomenology of modulated phases, Science 267 (1995) 476.
  176. [176]C. Reichhardt, C. J. Olson, I. Martin and A. R. Bishop, Depinning and dynamics of systems with competing interactions in quenched disorder, Europhysics Letters 61 (2003) 221.DOI
  177. [177]C. Reichhardt, C. J. O. Reichhardt, I. Martin and A. R. Bishop, Dynamical ordering of driven stripe phases in quenched disorder, Phys. Rev. Lett. 90 (2003) 026401.
  178. [178]C. J. Olson Reichhardt, C. Reichhardt and A. R. Bishop, Structural transitions, melting, and intermediate phases for stripe- and clump-forming systems, Phys. Rev. E 82 (2010) 041502.
  179. [179]G. H. Derrick, Comments on nonlinear wave equations as models for elementary particles, J. Math. Phys. 5 (1964) 1252.DOI
  180. [180]L. P. Pryadko, S. A. Kivelson, V. J. Emery, Y. B. Bazaliy and E. A. Demler, Topological doping and the stability of stripe phases, Phys. Rev. B 60 (1999) 7541.DOI
  181. [181]Z. Nussinov, I. Vekther and A. V. Balatsky, Nonuniform glassy electronic phases from competing local orders, Phys. Rev. B 79 (2009) 165122.
  182. [182]A. Patel, Flux Tube Model Signals for Baryon Correlations in Heavy Ion Collisions, Phys. Rev. D 85 (2012) 114019 [1111.0177].DOI
  183. [183]O. Akerlund, P. de Forcrand and T. Rindlisbacher, Oscillating propagators in heavy-dense QCD, JHEP 10 (2016) 055 [1602.02925].DOI
  184. [184]Z. Nussinov, O(n) spin systems, some general properties: A Generalized Mermin-Wagner-Coleman theorem, ground states, Peierls bounds, and dynamics, hep-ph/0105143.
  185. [185]Z. Nussinov, Commensurate and incommensurate o(n) spin systems: Novel even-odd effects, a generalized mermin-wagner-coleman theorem, and ground states, 2004.DOI
  186. [186]S. Chakrabarty, V. Dobrosavljevic, A. Seidel and Z. Nussinov, Universality of modulation length and time exponents, Phys. Rev. E 86 (2012) 041132.
  187. [187]R. D. Pisarski, A. M. Tsvelik and S. Valgushev, How transverse thermal fluctuations disorder a condensate of chiral spirals into a quantum spin liquid, Phys. Rev. D 102 (2020) 016015 [2005.10259].DOI
  188. [188]M. Winstel and S. Valgushev, Lattice study of disordering of inhomogeneous condensates and the Quantum Pion Liquid in effective O(N) model, in Excited QCD 2024 Workshop, 3, 2024, 2403.18640.
  189. [189]R. D. Pisarski, V. V. Skokov and A. M. Tsvelik, A Pedagogical Introduction to the Lifshitz Regime, Universe 5 (2019) 48 [2202.01036].
  190. [190]M. Thies and K. Urlichs, Revised phase diagram of the Gross-Neveu model, Phys. Rev. D 67 (2003) 125015 [hep-th/0302092].
  191. [191]G. Basar and G. V. Dunne, Self-consistent crystalline condensate in chiral Gross-Neveu and Bogoliubov-de Gennes systems, Phys. Rev. Lett. 100 (2008) 200404 [0803.1501].
  192. [192]G. Basar and G. V. Dunne, A Twisted Kink Crystal in the Chiral Gross-Neveu model, 0806.2659.
  193. [193]J. Lenz, L. Pannullo, M. Wagner, B. Wellegehausen and A. Wipf, Inhomogeneous phases in the Gross-Neveu model in 1+1 dimensions at finite number of flavours, Phys. Rev. D 101 (2020) 094512 [2004.00295].
  194. [194]M. Buballa, L. Kurth, M. Wagner and M. Winstel, Regulator dependence of inhomogeneous phases in the 2+1-dimensional Gross-Neveu model, Physical Review D 103 (2021) 2012.09588.
  195. [195]A. Koenigstein, L. Pannullo, S. Rechenberger, M. J. Steil and M. Winstel, Detecting inhomogeneous chiral condensation from the bosonic two-point function in the (1 + 1)-dimensional Gross–Neveu model in the mean-field approximation*, J. Phys. A 55 (2022) 375402 [2112.07024].DOI
  196. [196]L. Pannullo, M. Wagner and M. Winstel, Inhomogeneous Phases in the Chirally Imbalanced 2 + 1-Dimensional Gross-Neveu Model and Their Absence in the Continuum Limit, Symmetry 14 (2022) 265 [2112.11183].DOI
  197. [197]J. J. Lenz, M. Mandl and A. Wipf, Inhomogeneities in the two-flavor chiral Gross-Neveu model, Phys. Rev. D 105 (2022) 034512 [2109.05525].DOI
  198. [198]J. J. Lenz and M. Mandl, Remnants of large-Nf inhomogeneities in the 2-flavor chiral Gross-Neveu model, PoS LATTICE2021 (2022) 415 [2110.12757].
  199. [199]C. Nonaka and K. Horie, Inhomogeneous phases in the chiral Gross-Neveu model on the lattice, PoS LATTICE2021 (2022) 150 [2112.02261].
  200. [200]M. Winstel, L. Pannullo and M. Wagner, Phase diagram of the 2+1-dimensional Gross-Neveu model with chiral imbalance, PoS LATTICE2021 (2022) 381 [2109.04277].
  201. [201]M. Winstel, Spatially oscillating correlation functions in (2+1)-dimensional four-fermion models: The mixing of scalar and vector modes at finite density, Phys. Rev. D 110 (2024) 034008 [2403.07430].DOI
  202. [202]A. Koenigstein and M. Winstel, Revisiting the spatially inhomogeneous condensates in the (1 + 1)-dimensional chiral Gross-Neveu model via the bosonic two-point function in the infinite-N limit, J. Phys. A 57 (2024) 335401 [2405.03459].DOI
  203. [203]G. Basar, G. V. Dunne and M. Thies, Inhomogeneous Condensates in the Thermodynamics of the Chiral NJL(2) model, Phys. Rev. D 79 (2009) 105012 [0903.1868].
  204. [204]S. Carignano and M. Buballa, Inhomogeneous chiral condensates in three-flavor quark matter, Phys. Rev. D 101 (2020) 014026 [1910.03604].
  205. [205]L. Pannullo, M. Wagner and M. Winstel, Inhomogeneous phases in the 3+1-dimensional Nambu-Jona-Lasinio model and their dependence on the regularization scheme, PoS LATTICE2022 (2023) 156 [2212.05783].arxiv.org/abs/2212.05783
  206. [206]L. Pannullo, Inhomogeneous condensation in the Gross-Neveu model in noninteger spatial dimensions 1≤d<3, Phys. Rev. D 108 (2023) 036022 [2306.16290].
  207. [207]A. Koenigstein and L. Pannullo, Inhomogeneous condensation in the Gross-Neveu model in noninteger spatial dimensions 1 ≤ d < 3. II. Nonzero temperature and chemical potential, 2312. 04904.
  208. [208]T. F. Motta, J. Bernhardt, M. Buballa and C. S. Fischer, Toward a stability analysis of inhomogeneous phases in QCD, Phys. Rev. D 108 (2023) 114019 [2306.09749].arxiv.org/abs/2306.09749
  209. [209]L. Pannullo, M. Wagner and M. Winstel, Regularization effects in the Nambu–Jona-Lasinio model: Strong scheme dependence of inhomogeneous phases and persistence of the moat regime, Phys. Rev. D 110 (2024) 076006 [2406.11312].
  210. [210]S. Carignano, D. Nickel and M. Buballa, Influence of vector interaction and Polyakov loop dynamics on inhomogeneous chiral symmetry breaking phases, Phys. Rev. D 82 (2010) 054009 [1007.1397].
  211. [211]L. Pannullo and M. Winstel, Absence of inhomogeneous chiral phases in 2+1-dimensional four-fermion and Yukawa models, 2305.09444.
  212. [212]S. Carignano, M. Buballa and B.-J. Schaefer, Inhomogeneous phases in the quark-meson model with vacuum fluctuations, Phys. Rev. D 90 (2014) 014033 [1404.0057].
  213. [213]M. Buballa and S. Carignano, Inhomogeneous chiral phases away from the chiral limit, Phys. Lett. B 791 (2019) 361 [1809.10066].
  214. [214]M. Buballa, S. Carignano and L. Kurth, Inhomogeneous phases in the quark-meson model with explicit chiral-symmetry breaking, Eur. Phys. J. ST 229 (2020) 3371 [2006.02133].
  215. [215]M. Haensch, F. Rennecke and L. von Smekal, Medium Induced Mixing and Critical Modes in QCD, 2308.16244.
  216. [216]W.-j. Fu, J. M. Pawlowski and F. Rennecke, QCD phase structure at finite temperature and density, Phys. Rev. D 101 (2020) 054032 [1909.02991].
  217. [217]V. Schon and M. Thies, Emergence of Skyrme crystal in Gross-Neveu and ’t Hooft models at finite density, Phys. Rev. D 62 (2000) 096002 [hep-th/0003195].
  218. [218]T. Kojo, Y. Hidaka, L. McLerran and R. D. Pisarski, Quarkyonic Chiral Spirals, Nucl. Phys. A 843 (2010) 37 [0912.3800].
  219. [219]Z. Nussinov, M. C. Ogilvie, L. Pannullo, R. D. Pisarski, F. Rennecke, S. T. Schindler et al., Dilepton production from moaton quasiparticles, 2410.22418.
  220. [220]R. D. Pisarski, F. Rennecke, A. Tsvelik and S. Valgushev, The Lifshitz Regime and its Experimental Signals, Nucl. Phys. A 1005 (2021) 121910 [2005.00045].
  221. [221]F. Rennecke, R. D. Pisarski and D. H. Rischke, Particle interferometry in a moat regime, Phys. Rev. D 107 (2023) 116011 [2301.11484].
  222. [222]K. Fukushima, Y. Hidaka, K. Inoue, K. Shigaki and Y. Yamaguchi, Hanbury–Brown–Twiss signature for clustered substructures probing primordial inhomogeneity in hot and dense QCD matter, Phys. Rev. C 109 (2024) L051903 [2306.17619].
  223. [223]T. Banks, R. Myerson and J. B. Kogut, Phase Transitions in Abelian Lattice Gauge Theories, Nucl. Phys. B 129 (1977) 493.
  224. [224]S. Elitzur, R. B. Pearson and J. Shigemitsu, Phase structure of discrete abelian spin and gauge systems, Phys. Rev. D 19 (1979) 3698.
  225. [225]D. Horn, M. Weinstein and S. Yankielowicz, Hamiltonian approach to z(n) lattice gauge theories, Phys. Rev. D 19 (1979) 3715.
  226. [226]J. V. José, L. P. Kadanoff, S. Kirkpatrick and D. R. Nelson, Renormalization, vortices, and symmetry-breaking perturbations in the two-dimensional planar model, Phys. Rev. B 16 (1977) 1217.
  227. [227]A. Ukawa, P. Windey and A. H. Guth, Dual Variables for Lattice Gauge Theories and the Phase Structure of Z(N) Systems, Phys. Rev. D 21 (1980) 1013.
  228. [228]J. L. Cardy, Duality and the Theta Parameter in Abelian Lattice Models, Nucl. Phys. B 205 (1982) 17.
  229. [229]S. Ostlund, Incommensurate and commensurate phases in asymmetric clock models, Phys. Rev. B 24 (1981) 398.
  230. [230]J. M. Yeomans and M. E. Fisher, Many commensurate phases in the chiral potts or asymmetric clock models, Journal of Physics C: Solid State Physics 14 (1981) L835.
  231. [231]D. A. Huse, Simple three-state model with infinitely many phases, Phys. Rev. B 24 (1981) 5180.
  232. [232]W. Selke and J. M. Yeomans, A Monte Carlo study of the asymmetric clock or chiral Potts model in two dimensions, Zeitschrift für Physik B Condensed Matter 46 (1982) 311.
  233. [233]J. Yeomans, Low-temperature analysis of the p-state asymmetric clock model for general p, Journal of Physics C: Solid State Physics 15 (1982) 7305.
  234. [234]P. Bak, Commensurate phases, incommensurate phases and the devil’s staircase, Reports on Progress in Physics 45 (1982) 587.
  235. [235]W. S. McCullough, Mean-field transfer-matrix analysis of the p-state chiral clock model, Physical Review B 46 (1992) 5084.
  236. [236]M. Asorey, J. G. Esteve and J. Salas, Exact renormalization group analysis of first order phase transitions in clock models, Phys. Rev. B 48 (1993) 3626 [hep-lat/9305021].
  237. [237]G. Cantor, De la puissance des ensembles parfaits de points: Extrait d’une lettre adressée à l’éditeur, Acta Mathematica 4 (1900) 381.
  238. [238]V. L. Berezinsky, Destruction of long range order in one-dimensional and two-dimensional systems having a continuous symmetry group. I. Classical systems, Sov. Phys. JETP 32 (1971) 493.
  239. [239]J. M. Kosterlitz and D. J. Thouless, Ordering, metastability and phase transitions in two-dimensional systems, J. Phys. C 6 (1973) 1181.
  240. [240]J. V. Jose, L. P. Kadanoff, S. Kirkpatrick and D. R. Nelson, Renormalization, vortices, and symmetry breaking perturbations on the two-dimensional planar model, Phys. Rev. B 16 (1977) 1217.
  241. [241]H. A. Kramers and G. H. Wannier, Statistics of the two-dimensional ferromagnet. Part 1., Phys. Rev. 60 (1941) 252.
  242. [242]R. Savit, Duality in Field Theory and Statistical Systems, Rev. Mod. Phys. 52 (1980) 453.
  243. [243]L. P. Kadanoff and H. Ceva, Determination of an operator algebra for the two-dimensional Ising model, Phys. Rev. B 3 (1971) 3918.
  244. [244]M. C. Ogilvie and L. Medina, Simulation of Scalar Field Theories with Complex Actions, PoS LATTICE2018 (2018) 157 [1811.11112].
  245. [245]A. Kapustin and N. Seiberg, Coupling a QFT to a TQFT and Duality, JHEP 04 (2014) 001 [1401.0740].
  246. [246]A. A. Migdal, Gauge Transitions in Gauge and Spin Lattice Systems, Sov. Phys. JETP 42 (1975) 743.
  247. [247]A. A. Migdal, Recursion Equations in Gauge Theories, Sov. Phys. JETP 42 (1975) 413.
  248. [248]L. P. Kadanoff, Variational principles and approximate renormalization group calculations, Phys. Rev. Lett. 34 (1975) 1005.
  249. [249]L. P. Kadanoff, Notes on migdal’s recursion formulas, Annals of Physics 100 (1976) 359.
  250. [250]L. P. Kadanoff, The application of renormalization group techniques to quarks and strings, Rev. Mod. Phys. 49 (1977) 267.
  251. [251]B. Derrida, L. De Seze and C. Itzykson, Fractal structure of zeros in hierarchical models, Journal of Statistical Physics 33 (1983) 559.
  252. [252]H. C. Ottinger, Two-dimensional iterated mapping for the mean-field theory of the chiral Potts model, Journal of Physics C: Solid State Physics 16 (1983) L257.
  253. [253]S. Elitzur, Impossibility of Spontaneously Breaking Local Symmetries, Phys. Rev. D 12 (1975) 3978.
  254. [254]B. Svetitsky and L. G. Yaffe, Critical Behavior at Finite Temperature Confinement Transitions, Nucl. Phys. B 210 (1982) 423.
  255. [255]S. Caracciolo and P. Menotti, Phases of Renormalized Lattice Gauge Theories With Fermions, Annals Phys. 122 (1979) 74.
  256. [256]P. Menotti and E. Onofri, The Action of SU(N) Lattice Gauge Theory in Terms of the Heat Kernel on the Group Manifold, Nucl. Phys. B 190 (1981) 288.
  257. [257]E. Brezin and J. Zinn-Justin, Renormalization of the nonlinear sigma model in 2 + epsilon dimensions. Application to the Heisenberg ferromagnets, Phys. Rev. Lett. 36 (1976) 691.
  258. [258]D. Friedan, Nonlinear Models in Two Epsilon Dimensions, Phys. Rev. Lett. 45 (1980) 1057.
  259. [259]G. Bhanot and M. Creutz, Variant Actions and Phase Structure in Lattice Gauge Theory, Phys. Rev. D 24 (1981) 3212.
  260. [260]K. M. Bitar, S. A. Gottlieb and C. K. Zachos, Phase Structure and Renormalization Trajectories of Lattice SU(2) Gauge Theory, Phys. Rev. D 26 (1982) 2853.

Paper details

vlnc:W_ugnu39tf
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 1

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Physics and Astronomy

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents