betaFeedback

WorksPhysics and Astronomy

Theoretical Developments for Jets in Heavy-Ion Collisions

Abstract

The quark-gluon plasma (QGP) is an exotic phase of matter, composed of deconfined quarks and gluons and is briefly created in heavy-ion collisions (HIC) at the LHC and at the RHIC. High-energy, self-collimated structures of final-state particles also created in HIC, called jets, probe the QGP, piercing through it on their way to the particle detector. Quantum field theory at finite temperature or thermal field theory, is then an extremely powerful tool, capable of analytically quantifying how such a high-energy object interacts with a weakly coupled thermal bath. In this thesis, we work towards the computation of corrections to two quantities, which dictate how jets are quenched by the QGP. The first being the transverse momentum broadening coefficient, which describes how the jet diffuses in transverse momentum space through its interaction with the medium. We focus on the computation of logarithmically enhanced corrections, carefully showing how the thermal scale affects the logarithmic phase space. The second is the asymptotic mass, which can be thought of as a shift in the jet dispersion relation as it undergoes forward scattering with the medium. We complete a matching calculation, which rids the mass' classical corrections of any unphysical divergences, while also beginning the completion of its full two-loop, quantum corrections.

THESE DE DOCTORAT

NANTES UNIVERSITE

ECOLE DOCTORALE N° 596

Matière, Molécules, Matériaux et Géosciences

Spécialité : Physique Théorique

Par

Eamonn WEITZ

Thèse présentée et soutenue à Nantes, le 22 Septembre 2023

Unité de recherche : SUBATECH UMR6457

Rapporteurs avant soutenance :

Cristina MANUEL — Directrice de Recherche, ICE, CSIC Barcelone

Konrad TYWONIUK — Professeur Associé, Université de Bergen

Composition du Jury :

Président : Grégory SOYEZ — Directeur de Recherche, IPhT, CEA Saclay

Examinateurs : Cristina MANUEL — Directrice de Recherche, ICE, CSIC Barcelone

Konrad TYWONIUK — Professeur Associé, Université de Bergen

Grégory SOYEZ — Directeur de Recherche, IPhT, CEA Saclay

Dir. de thèse : Thierry GOUSSET — Professeur, SUBATECH NANTES

Co-enc. de thèse : Jacopo GHIGLIERI — Chargé de Recherche, SUBATECH Nantes

To my grandparents

Acknowledgements/Reflections

Completing this PhD has been an arduous, demanding yet profoundly gratifying journey. With that being said, I found myself contemplating on numerous occasions along the way, how much more difficult it would have been, had I not been fortunate enough to be surrounded by such tremendous people.

I arrived at Subatech in September 2020 in less than ideal conditions, amid the backdrop of a global pandemic, with a very basic level of French. For those first few months, during which time I was largely confined to my room because of lockdowns, there was no shortage of colleagues who realised the vulnerability of my situation and regularly checked up on me. To this, I am eternally grateful.

To my various officemates, from the basement with Nadiya and Hanna to H221 with Grég oire, Stéphane, Nathan, Jakub, Alexandre, Jean-Baptiste, Julie, Tobie and Jakub, I will always look back fondly on our interactions, be it through stimulating discussions or unapologetic procrastination. As well as being wonderful company, I owe Johannès, Michael, Victor Lebrin, Maxime Pierre and Arthur all much thanks for your patience and willingness to help me in situations where I needed an english translator, particularly during my initial days. I extend my thanks to many other PhD’s and post-docs: Vincent, Marten, Claudia, Johan, Nicolas, Felix, Yohannes, Mahbobeh, Victor Valencia, Keerthana, Pinar, Léonard, Quentin, Kazu, Jiaxing, Jakub; it has been an absolute joy to share the lab with each of you over these past three years.

I owe many thanks to the administrative and IT staff at Subatech, for their everpresent and impressive patience. Along with Pierrick, Farah, Sophie, Tanja and Nadège, I want to give a special thanks to Véronique and Séverine from the missions department; you have never made me feel like a burden or a chore, despite my inability to understand certain aspects of the reimbursement procedures, which I must admit persist to the current day.

Jacopo, your brilliance as a scientist coupled with your unyielding patience as a teacher has made it a pleasure to work under your supervision during the past three years. Pol-Bernard and Thierry, while we did not get the opportunity to work together directly as was originally envisioned, you were reliable and helpful when I came to you for information and I will always be thankful for that. I would also like to thank Stéphane and François for organising the QCD Masterclass in 2021 and Marlene, Marcus and Maxime Guilbaud for orchestrating the heavy-ion school in 2022.

In addition to Jacopo and Thierry, I would also like to thank Grégory, Cristina and Konrad for agreeing to be on my jury. Despite the inevitable stress surrounding my defense, I nevertheless found it to be a great learning opportunity; your questions and comments allowed me to understand my own work from a slightly different angle.

Away from the lab, I have my family to thank, who have provided their unrelenting support for as long as I can remember, always trying to do whatever they can to make my life easier. From my friends in Dublin to those scattered around the globe, you have all been sorely missed over these last three years.

Last but certainly not least, I must thank my wife, Emerald. Besides being a such wonderful life companion, your constant encouragement and caring nature has allowed me to grow significantly as a person during our time together — I could not appreciate it more.

Introduction

In the early 1980s, heavy-ion collisions were proposed as a means to provide a window into the inner workings of the early universe. In particular, it was hoped that these kinds of experiments would be able to produce a deconfined state of matter with quarks and gluons as the fundamental degrees of freedom. Around that time, Bjorken posited that objects known as jets, high-energy sprays of collimated hadrons would interact with such a state of matter if it were produced in these collisions and in doing so, would become extinguished or quenched [3]. Indeed, it has been over 20 years since the phenomenon of jet quenching was first observed at RHIC, providing strong evidence that for the existence of a quark-gluon plasma (QGP) in heavy-ion collisions [4, 5].

In recent years, the arrival of more powerful experiments at the LHC and RHIC has put us in a position where we can reasonably ask sharp questions concerning the make-up and the nature of the QGP, thereby definitively moving on from solely pondering its existence. Nevertheless, it goes without saying that with such progress comes the need to improve the accuracy of our theoretical models to the stage where they can make pointed, meaningful predictions.

As an example, consider the phenomenon of transverse momentum broadening: in traversing the QGP, a jet receives kicks in transverse momentum space, giving rise to a diffusive process, characterised by the transverse momentum broadening coefficient, q^\hat{q}. It recently has been suggested that such momentum broadening effects may be imprinted on the jet acoplanarity observable [6–10]. Moreover, q^\hat{q} has an indirect but strong influence on the production of medium-induced radiation. Quantum corrections to q^\hat{q} (at O(g2)O(g^2)) have drawn a significant amount of attention over the past ten years or so since it was realised that they have the potential to be logarithmically enhanced [1, 2]. We follow this line of enquiry here, computing these logarithmic corrections using thermal field theory. In doing so, we rigorously analyse how the thermal scale affects the region of phase space from which these corrections are borne. Another important advancement in improving the quantification of jet quenching phenomena has come with the development of a resummation method, which provides a non-perturbative evaluation of the classical contributions to transverse momentum broadening [11–14].

The asymptotic mass, m∞m_\infty is a correction to a hard parton’s dispersion relation as it forward scatters with plasma constituents and is also known to control in part the mechanism of medium-induced radiation. The computation of non-perturbative corrections to m∞m_\infty is firmly underway [15, 16]. In computing quantum corrections to m∞m_\infty (also at O(g2)O(g^2)) in the thermal field theory framework, we concretely further this program. We complete a matching calculation, which eliminates unphysical infinities from the previously computed non-perturbative evaluation while also beginning the full computation of the O(g2)\mathcal{O}(g^2) corrections.

This thesis is organised in such a way to slowly but surely build up the intuition and introduce the tools that are needed to understand the reasonably technical computations of quantum corrections to the aforementioned quantities that come in the later chapters. Specifically, the thesis is laid out as follows:

  • Starting from the basics of quantum field theory, Ch. 2 is intended to convince the reader of the existence of a QGP in heavy-ion collisions through the provision of both theoretical arguments and experimental evidence. Along the way, we introduce the concept of jets and describe the different stages of a heavy-ion collision.

  • In Ch. 3, we set up the physical picture, which is helpful to keep in mind throughout the rest of the thesis. Namely, a jet, which for our purposes can be taken as a hard parton, propagates through a quark-gluon plasma, interacting with the medium constituents and in doing so, is forced to radiate. We make a point to emphasise how the triggering mechanism for this radiation is controlled by the associated formation time and we identify the conditions under which Landau-Pomeranchuk-Migdal (LPM) interference must be accounted for. We furthermore compute the radiation rate in the multiple scattering regime, where LPM resummation is necessary and in the single scattering regime, where one can instead use the opacity expansion. The chapter closes with a brief overview of the literature and a short discussion of some recent developments.

  • Ch 4 introduces some of the modern theoretical tools, which support the calculations to follow in the later chapters. In particular, we give some general ideas regarding the basics of effective field theories and thermal field theory before moving on to discuss the finite-temperature effective theories EQCD and HTL theory. In § 7.1, we examine how a seminal idea from Caron-Huot [17] can, in certain situations, provide an extremely useful connection between these two theories, which furthermore allows for the non-perturbative computation of classical corrections to the transverse momentum broadening kernel and the asymptotic mass. The chapter then continues with a demonstration of how this idea can also be utilised to efficiently extract the leading order soft contributions to the transverse momentum broadening kernel and the asymptotic mass.

  • Ch 5 is largely based on the work [18]. There, we carefully scrutinise the previous computations of double logarithmic corrections to q^\hat{q} [1, 2] before showing how the double logarithmic phase space is deformed for a computation done in the setting of a weakly coupled quark-gluon plasma. In addition, we clearly demonstrate how this region of phase space is situated with respect to the one from which the classical corrections to q^\hat{q} emerge. Most of our computation is performed in the harmonic oscillator approximation. However, a pathway, which could allow us to go beyond this approximation is also presented. Technical details are contained in App. § 13.

  • Ch 6 contains our yet to published work on the O(g2)\mathcal{O}(g^2) asymptotic mass corrections. We list all the diagrams that can contribute at this order of perturbation theory, before arguing that only one of them, what we label as diagram (c) contributes. We show how some of the IR divergences associated with this diagram cancel with corresponding UV divergences from the EQCD calculation, completed in [16]. We then proceed to a computation of the full fermionic and gluonic parts of diagram (c), which turn out to contain some unforeseen UV and collinear divergences. Technical details are contained in App. § 14.

  • A broad summary and conclusion are given in Ch. 7 in addition to discussions of how we plan to push the works contained in Chs. 5 and 6 further.

  • Our conventions are specified in App. § 11 and some details on the basics of Wilson loops are located in App. § 12.

QCD and Heavy-Ion Collisions

The Standard Model of Particle Physics is arguably one of the greatest intellectual achievements to have come out of the 20th century. While it is not expected to be the end of the story as far as elementary physics is concerned, the well-tested Standard Model provides a remarkably clean and coherent description of three out of the four fundamental forces: the electromagnetic and weak forces, which are unified into the Electroweak Theory as well as the strong force, described by Quantum Chromodynamics (QCD). This thesis is concerned with the study of the latter.

In this first chapter, we introduce QCD in Sec. 2.1 through a somewhat formal lens before discussing some of its properties. In Secs. 2.2 and 2.3 we highlight how some of these properties manifest themselves in systems with a large number of particles. Sec. 2.4 is then devoted to a discussion of heavy-ion collisions, which have proved extremely successful in aiding the experimental exploration of the QCD phase diagram. This is intended to appropriately set up and motivate what is to follow in the rest of the thesis, where we study in great detail how jets, high energy showers of radiation interact with the quark-gluon plasma.

Introduction to QCD

Locality is generally considered to be an essential feature of any (fundamental) quantum field theory (QFT). However, by insisting on a theory to be local, a certain redundancy is necessarily introduced. This redundancy manifests itself in the Lagrangian description as what is known as gauge freedom. To understand this in a more concrete way, consider what happens when we demand that a Lagrangian describing NfN_f fermionic fields, ψi(X)\psi_i(X) (i=1,2,...,Nfi = 1, 2, ..., N_f) remain invariant under the local transformation

ψi(X)→ψi′(X)=U(X)ψi(X),U=exp⁡(iξa(X)TFa),a=1,2,..,dA,(1)\psi_i(X) \to\psi_i'(X) = \mathcal{U}(X)\psi_i(X), \qquad\mathcal{U} = \exp(i\xi^a(X)T_F^a), \qquad a = 1, 2, .., d_A, \tag*{(1)}

with a sum over aa implied. The transformation, U\mathcal{U} is said to be in the fundamental representation of the Lie group SU(Nc)\mathrm{SU}(N_c), meaning in practice that U(X)\mathcal{U}(X) is an Nc×NcN_c \times N_c unitary matrix with det⁡U=1\det\mathcal{U} = 1. Since SU(Nc)\mathrm{SU}(N_c) is a topologically trivial group, the matrices U\mathcal{U} are given in terms of the so-called generators, TRaT_R^a, which are in the fundamental representation of the su(Nc)\mathfrak{su}(N_c) Lie algebra. The ξa(X)\xi_a(X) are then arbitrary functions of spacetime coordinates. The fact that the TRaT_R^a generate a Lie algebra means that they obey, for a general representation, RR

[TRa,TRb]=ifabcTRc(2)[T_R^a,T_R^b] = i f^{abc}T_R^c \tag*{(2)}
fabdfdce+fbcdfdae+fcadfdbe=0(3)f^{abd}f^{dce} + f^{bcd}f^{dae} + f^{cad}f^{dbe} = 0 \tag*{(3)}

If the structure constants fabcf^{abc} are zero, then the matrices, U(X)U(X) are in a representation of an Abelian group. Otherwise, the group is said to be non-Abelian, which is the case that we are presently interested in. Moreover, we have that

TRaTRa=CRI,Tr⁡TRaTRb=TRδab,(4)T_R^aT_R^a = C_R\mathbb{I}, \qquad\operatorname{Tr} T_R^aT_R^b = T_R\delta^{ab}, \tag*{(4)}

where CR,TRC_R,T_R are respectively the Casimir and index of the representation, RR.

At this point, it is easy to see that a mass term for the quark fields, i.e mψˉiψim\bar{\psi}_i\psi_i is invariant under the transformation Eq. (2.1). Be that as it may, because of the spacetime dependence in U(X)U(X), any term with a derivative acting on ψi\psi_i will not be so fortunate since

∂μψi(X)→[∂μψi(X)]′=U(X)∂μψi(X)+(∂μU(X))ψi(X).(5)\partial_\mu\psi_i(X) \to[\partial_\mu\psi_i(X)]' = U(X)\partial_\mu\psi_i(X) + (\partial_\mu U(X))\psi_i(X). \tag*{(5)}

To fix the kinetic term, we must define a covariant derivative operator, DμD_\mu such that

Dμψi(X)→[Dμψi(X)]′=U(X)Dμψi(X).(6)D_\mu\psi_i(X) \to[D_\mu\psi_i(X)]' = U(X)D_\mu\psi_i(X). \tag*{(6)}

It turns out that the covariant derivative should take the form

Dμ=∂μ−igAμ,(7)D_\mu= \partial_\mu- igA_\mu, \tag*{(7)}

where Aμ=AμaTRaA_\mu= A_\mu^aT_R^a is a Lie-algebra-valued gauge field and gg is the (bare) coupling constant that characterises the strength of the interaction between this field and ψ\psi. It transforms in such a way

Aμ(X)→Aμ′(X)=U(X)Aμ(X)U−1(X)−ig(∂μU(X))U−1(X)(8)A_\mu(X) \to A'_\mu(X) = U(X)A_\mu(X)U^{-1}(X) - \frac{i}{g}(\partial_\mu U(X))U^{-1}(X) \tag*{(8)}

to ensure that Eq. (2.6) holds true. The gauge field is said to transform according to the adjoint representation of SU(Nc)\mathrm{SU}(N_c), modified by an inhomogeneous term (the second term above). The adjoint representation of a group is defined such that the generators are given in terms of the structure constants themselves

(TAa)bc=−ifabc,(9)(T_A^a)^{bc} = -if^{abc}, \tag*{(9)}

where these are now dA×dAd_A \times d_A matrices.

To briefly recap, by insisting on a Lagrangian description of a field ψ\psi that is blind to local, non-Abelian phases, the Lagrangian is forced to be furthermore invariant under the transformation Eq. (2.8) – it is forced to be gauge-invariant. Under these restrictions, the resultant theory that one derives, describing the interaction between dynamical gauge and matter fields goes by the name of Yang-Mills Theory [19].

It turns out that Yang-Mills theory with Nc=3N_c = 3 colours and Nf=6N_f = 6 flavours yields a theory that describes well the strong interaction, which is responsible for the binding of nucleons inside atomic nuclei. The colours: red, green and blue are non-Abelian charges and are mediated by the gluon field, AμA_\mu. Each flavour corresponds to a different quark field: up, down, strange, charm, bottom, top, listed from least to most massive. The resultant theory is known as Quantum Chromodynamics and is given by the Lagrangian [20]1 constructed to be suitably gauge-invariant and renormalisable

QuantitySymbolValue for QCD
Number of matter fieldsNfN_f6
Number of chargesNcN_c3
Fundamental CasimirCF=Nc2−12NcC_F = \frac{N_c^2-1}{2N_c}43\frac{4}{3}
Adjoint CasimirCA=NcC_A = N_c3
Fundamental indexTF=12T_F = \frac{1}{2}12\frac{1}{2}
Adjoint indexTA=NcT_A = N_c3
Fundamental dimensiondF=Ncd_F = N_c3
Adjoint dimensiondA=Nc2−1d_A = N_c^2-18

Table 2.1. Collection of group theory factors, specific to QCD, intended to be used for future reference. Note that while 6 flavours of quarks are included in the Standard Model, oftentimes perturbative calculations are performed with Nf<6N_f < 6 if the energy scale of interest is much smaller than the heavier quarks.

LQCD=−14FμνaFμνa+ψˉi(iD̸−mi)ψi,(10)\mathcal{L}_{\mathrm{QCD}}=-\frac{1}{4}F_{\mu\nu}^{a}F^{\mu\nu a}+\bar{\psi}_{i}(i\not{D}-m_{i})\psi_{i}, \tag*{(10)}

with a sum over ii implied. The field strength tensor is

Fμνa=∂μAνa−∂νAμa+gfabcAμbAνc(11)F_{\mu\nu}^{a}=\partial_{\mu}A_{\nu}^{a}-\partial_{\nu}A_{\mu}^{a}+g f^{abc}A_{\mu}^{b}A_{\nu}^{c} \tag*{(11)}

and gg is the strong coupling constant. An immediately remarkable aspect of Eq. (10) is that of the self-interactions between gluons, a feature, which is not present in QCD’s Abelian counterpart, Quantum Electrodynamics (QED).

Eq. (10) should be considered the Lagrangian for classical QCD. The quantisation of non-Abelian gauge theories is usually done using the functional integral formalism. Along the way, one runs into the issue of gauge-fixing at the level of the path integral, which is dealt with by introducing so-called ghost fields in the Fadeev-Popov procedure. We refer the reader to any of the textbooks [21–23] for the details pertaining to the quantisation procedure.

In the form of Eq. (10), QCD does not possess any predictive power beyond tree-level – it must be renormalised. Divergences that emerge at one-loop level and beyond can be absorbed by replacing the bare coupling constants of the theory, gig_i renormalised couplings, gi(μ)g_i(\mu), which now depend on an additional scale, μ\mu. The idea is then to demand that physical observables be independent of this scale, which gives rise to a set of coupled differential equations known as renormalisation group equations (RGE). The RGE for the strong coupling reads

dg(μ)dμ=β(g(μ)),(12)\frac{d g(\mu)}{d\mu}=\beta(g(\mu)), \tag*{(12)}

where the β\beta-function, defined above, can be calculated order by order in perturbation theory. At one-loop level, one finds [24, 25]

β(g(μ))one−loop=−g3(μ)16π2β0,β0≡(113CA−43NfTF),(13)\beta(g(\mu))_{\mathrm{one-loop}}=-\frac{g^3(\mu)}{16\pi^2}\beta_0,\qquad\beta_0\equiv\left(\frac{11}{3}C_A-\frac{4}{3}N_fT_F\right), \tag*{(13)}

from which one can proceed to solve Eq. (12). The solution can be written as

References

  1. [296]C. Manuel, J. Soto and S. Stetina, On-shell effective field theory: A systematic tool to compute power corrections to the hard thermal loops, Phys. Rev. D 94 (2016) 025017 [1603.05514].DOI
  2. [297]S. Carignano, C. Manuel and J. Soto, Power corrections to the HTL effective Lagrangian of QED, Phys. Lett. B 780 (2018) 308 [1712.07949].DOI
  3. [298]P.B. Arnold, High-energy gluon bremsstrahlung in a finite medium: harmonic oscillator versus single scattering approximation, Phys. Rev. D 80 (2009) 025004 [0903.1081].DOI
  4. [299]C. Andres, F. Dominguez and M. Gonzalez Martinez, From soft to hard radiation: the role of multiple scatterings in medium-induced gluon emissions, JHEP 03 (2021) 102 [2011.06522].DOI
  5. [300]J. Ghiglieri, G.D. Moore, P. Schicho, N. Schlusser and E. Weitz, Hard parton dispersion in the quark-gluon plasma, non-perturbatively, in 11th International Conference on Hard and Electromagnetic Probes of High-Energy Nuclear Collisions: Hard Probes 2023, 7, 7 2023 [2307.09297].
  6. [301]R.M. Yazdi, S. Shi, C. Gale and S. Jeon, Leading order, next-to-leading order, and nonperturbative parton collision kernels: Effects in static and evolving media, Phys. Rev. C 106 (2022) 064902 [2206.05855].DOI
  7. [302]S. Shi, R. Modarresi Yazdi, C. Gale and S. Jeon, Comparing the martini and cujet models for jet quenching: Medium modification of jets and jet substructure, Phys. Rev. C 107 (2023) 034908 [2212.05944].DOI

Paper details

vlnc:W_uh3yxcsp
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 0

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Physics and Astronomy

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents