betaFeedback

WorksPhysics and Astronomy

Reflection positivity in Euclidean formulations of relativistic quantum mechanics of particles

Abstract

This paper discusses the general structure of reflection positive Euclidean covariant distributions that can be used to construct Euclidean representations of relativistic quantum mechanical models of systems of a finite number of degrees of freedom. Because quantum systems of a finite number of degrees of freedom are not local, reflection positivity is not as restrictive as it is in a local field theory. The motivation for the Euclidean approach is that it is straightforward to construct exactly Poincaré invariant quantum models of finite number of degrees of freedom systems that satisfy cluster properties and a spectral condition. In addition the quantum mechanical inner product can be computed without requiring an analytic continuation. Whether these distributions can be generated by a dynamical principle remains to be determined, but understanding the general structure of the Euclidean covariant distributions is an important first step.

Introduction

The purpose of this work is to explore a Euclidean formulation of relativistic quantum mechanics [1] [2],[3] [4] [5].

From a purely academic perspective this Euclidean formulation yields a Hilbert space structure with a representation of the Poincaré Lie algebra by self-adjoint operators. The Poincaré generators satisfy cluster properties and the Hamiltonian is bounded from below. These elements are sufficient to formulate any kind of quantum mechanical calculation. The interesting feature of the Euclidean representation is that it is not necessary to perform an analytic continuation to perform these calculations. The dynamical input to this representation of relativistic quantum mechanics is a collection of Euclidean covariant distributions that satisfy a reflection positivity condition. Reflection positivity is used to construct a Hilbert space representation with a non-trivial kernel. The reflection positivity requirement in the quantum mechanical case is weaker than the corresponding condition in quantum field theory. The purpose of this work is to understand the general structure of these distributions. What is still missing is a dynamical framework to generate these model distributions.

The motivation for this exploration is discussed below. Understanding the internal structure of elementary hadrons is a goal of nuclear and particle physics. Hadronic structure can be studied by scattering weak or electromagnetic probes off of strongly interacting hadronic systems. In a typical reaction the probe scatters off of an initial hadronic state and causes a transition to a final hadronic state. These reactions are complex since the target and strongly interacting reaction products are composite systems, and particle number is not generally conserved. In addition, because the probe can transfer momentum to the initial hadronic state, the final hadronic state(s) is in a moving frame relative to the initial state. Relativistic momentum transfers are needed for a resolution that is sensitive to the internal structure of hadrons. QCD is the appropriate theory to model the hadronic states. It is a challenging problem to use QCD to solve for these strongly interacting Poincaré covariant states. Most non-perturbative calculations utilize truncations, which are not mathematically controlled approximations. Lattice calculations are directly based on QCD, but they break Poincaré symmetry and the treatment of scattering problems with composite initial and final states is challenging, particularly in the Euclidean formulation.

While there are many difficulties associated with solving quantum field theories, one of them is due to the local nature of quantum field theories, which cannot be satisfied in theories of a finite number of degrees of freedom. The expectation is that for a given momentum transfer the dynamics will be approximately governed by a relativistic model of a finite number of relevant degrees of freedom, limited by the available energy and interaction volume.

Axiomatic formulations of quantum field theory [6][7] [8][9] provide a mathematical formulation of physical properties that are expected to hold in any reasonable formulation of relativistic quantum field theory. The axioms are internally consistent since they are satisfied by free field theories. The challenge is the absence of examples of non-trivial quantum theories that satisfy the axioms in 3+13+1 dimensional spacetime. The property responsible for most of the difficulties is the locality axiom. While direct tests of locality on arbitrarily small distances are not possible, consequences of locality such as the PCT theorem, crossing symmetry and the need for antiparticles make it a compelling constraint.

One approach that avoids some of these difficulties is to use relativistic quantum mechanical models of a finite number of degrees of freedom to model the initial and final hadronic states [10] [11] [12] [13] [14] [15] [16] [17] [18] [19] [20] [21] [22] [23] [24] [25] [26] [27] [28] [29] [30] [31] [32] [33] [34] [35] [36] [37] [38] [39] [40] [41] [42]. These phenomenological models can be constructed so they satisfy most of the axioms of a quantum field theory, however they are not local, since they are formulated in terms of a finite number of degrees of freedom. The advantage is that model states can be calculated using the same methods that are used in non-relativistic calculations and the relativistic invariance is exact. While relativistic models have been used successfully, their relation to QCD or a more fundamental local field theory is not direct.

While relativistic quantum models do not satisfy microscopic locality, in order to be useful they need to satisfy cluster properties (macroscopic locality). This is needed to justify tests of special relativity on isolated subsystems and more importantly to provide a connection between few and many-body systems. While macroscopic locality can be realized in relativistic models, the construction of dynamical Poincaré generators satisfying macroscopic locality is based on a recursive construction that uses chains of unitary transformations that map tensor products of subsystem unitary representations of the Poincaré group and transforms them to a form where the interactions can be added in a manner that preserves the Poincaré invariance. This is followed by another overall unitary transformation that restores cluster properties [43][13] [14][21]. This is a complicated construction that has never been used in applications. Allowing for production reactions in these models presents an additional set of problems.

While relativistic quantum models can provide a formal construction of a relativistically invariant quantum theory satisfying cluster properties and a spectral condition, it is not a practical solution for more than two or three-body systems due to the complexity and non-uniqueness of the construction. In addition there is no direct relation to an underlying local relativistic quantum field theory that can be used to systematically improve the models. The complexity of this construction, due to requiring macroscopic locality, and the absence of a direct connection to a local field theory provides motivation for exploring alternative non-local formulations of relativistic quantum mechanics where cluster properties can be established in a straightforward manner.

This work contributes to an approach based on a Euclidean formulation of Hamiltonian dynamics [1] [2],[3] [4]. In the axioms of Euclidean quantum field theory [8] [9] the locality axiom is logically independent of the other axioms. This means that it should be possible to formulate relativistic quantum mechanical models satisfying all of the other Euclidean axioms. The theory is expressed in terms of a collection of Euclidean covariant distributions that satisfy a condition called reflection positivity [8] [9][44]. The motivation for considering this approach is that cluster properties are easy to satisfy. In addition, because of the reflection positivity, physical Hilbert space inner products can be computed without analytic continuation. The consequence of not requiring locality is that there is no required relation between NN-point functions with different numbers of initial and final coordinates. This makes the positivity of the Hilbert space norm into a more manageable problem. It has the additional advantage that the NN-point distributions of a local quantum theory satisfy all of the required conditions, so there is a clear relation to the Schwinger functions of a local field theory.

While Wightman functions of a local quantum field theory [6] also have some of the same advantages, they are not as closely tied to the dynamics. Euclidean NN-point functions can be approximated in lattice calculations and they are solutions of the infinite hierarchy of Euclidean Schwinger-Dyson equations. Scattering is normally formulated in terms of time-ordered Green functions, which can be obtained from the Euclidean NN-point functions by analytic continuation [45]. The relation to time-ordered distributions focuses on the scattering matrix rather than on the Hamiltonian as a Hilbert space operator [46][47] [48][49]. An alternative analytic continuation gives the Wightman distributions, which are kernels of the physical Hilbert space inner product. When the Euclidean NN-point distributions are reflection positive, the quantum mechanical inner product on a dense set of states can be constructed from the Euclidean distributions without analytic continuation. There is a representation of the Poincaré Lie algebra with self-adjoint operators on this Hilbert space satisfying both a spectral condition and cluster properties. These conditions also hold in the non-local case. It is even possible to directly formulate time-dependent scattering calculations in this representation of the Hilbert space without analytic continuation [1] [2][3] [4].

While analytic continuation is needed to construct the Wightman distributions from the Euclidean distributions, it is not needed to formulate quantum mechanical calculations. The elements needed for a relativistic quantum mechanical model are a representation of the physical Hilbert space inner product, a self-adjoint representation of the Poincaré Lie algebra satisfying cluster properties on this space, and a Hamiltonian satisfying spectral condition. Reflection positivity allows these properties to be satisfied without explicit analytic continuation. Reflection positivity ensures both the positivity of the physical Hilbert space norm and that the spectrum of Hamiltonian is bounded from below [44]. The resulting spectral condition implies the existence of the analytic condition, however analytic continuation is not needed to calculate physical Hilbert space inner products. In the Euclidean axioms of a local field theory the NN-point Schwinger functions are completely symmetric (anti-symmetric). They serve as the kernel of a quadratic form related to the Hilbert space inner product. Because of the symmetry one NN-point distribution appears in the kernel of the Euclidean distributions with MM initial and KK final variables for any M+K=NM+K=N [8] [9] [44]. By relaxing the locality condition a single NN-point distribution can be replaced by N−1N-1 NN-point distributions with MM initial points and N−MN-M final points. Because these are no longer required to be related by locality, the reflection positivity condition is less restrictive.

Having a Hilbert space representation and a set of self-adjoint generators of the Poincaré group satisfying cluster properties on this space are all that is needed to perform calculations. Cluster properties can be used to formulate scattering asymptotic conditions [50][51] [52][4]. In the Euclidean case the dynamics is encoded in the collection of Euclidean covariant distributions which will be referred to as quasi-Schwinger functions. While some aspects of this approach have been previously discussed [1] [2][3] [4] [5], the purpose of this paper is to understand the general structure of the reflection positive M+K=NM+K=N point distributions which provide the dynamical content of this formulation of non-local relativistic quantum mechanics. This needs to be understood in order to address the problem of formulating realistic models.

While the purpose of this work is to demonstrate that it is possible to construct a large class of non-trivial examples of sets of Euclidean covariant distributions that are consistent with all of the desired properties, what is still missing is a dynamical principle that can be used to determine reflection positive quasi-Schwinger functions from some simple input. The fact that Schwinger functions can be approximated using Euclidean lattice theories or Schwinger-Dyson equations suggests that this is possible, however this is beyond the scope of this paper, and will be investigated in future work.

Notation

The following notation will be used. Euclidean four vectors are denoted with a subscript ee:

xe=(xe0,xe1,xe2,xe3).(1)x_e=(x_e^0,x_e^1,x_e^2,x_e^3). \tag*{(1)}

Minkowski 4 vectors are denoted with a subscript mm:

xm=(xm0,xm1,xm2,xm3).(2)x_m=(x_m^0,x_m^1,x_m^2,x_m^3). \tag*{(2)}

The signature of the Minkowski metric is (−+++).(-+++). The following matrices:

σmμ=((1001),(0110),(0−ii0),(100−1))(3)\sigma_{m\mu}=\left(\left(\begin{matrix}1&0\\0&1\end{matrix}\right),\left(\begin{matrix}0&1\\1&0\end{matrix}\right),\left(\begin{matrix}0&-i\\i&0\end{matrix}\right),\left(\begin{matrix}1&0\\0&-1\end{matrix}\right)\right) \tag*{(3)}
σeμ=((i00i),(0110),(0−ii0),(100−1))(4)\sigma_{e\mu}=\left(\left(\begin{matrix}i&0\\0&i\end{matrix}\right),\left(\begin{matrix}0&1\\1&0\end{matrix}\right),\left(\begin{matrix}0&-i\\i&0\end{matrix}\right),\left(\begin{matrix}1&0\\0&-1\end{matrix}\right)\right) \tag*{(4)}

are used to construct the 2×22\times2 matrix representations of Euclidean or Minkowski four vectors:

Xe=∑μ=03xeμσeμ=(ixe0+xe3xe1−ixe2xe1+ixe2ixe0−xe3)xeμ=12Tr⁡(σeμ†Xe)(5)X_e=\sum_{\mu=0}^{3}x_e^\mu\sigma_{e\mu}=\left(\begin{matrix}ix_e^0+x_e^3&x_e^1-ix_e^2\\x_e^1+ix_e^2&ix_e^0-x_e^3\end{matrix}\right)\qquad x_e^\mu=\frac{1}{2}\operatorname{Tr}(\sigma_{e\mu}^{\dagger}X_e) \tag*{(5)}
Xm=∑μ=03xmμσmμ=(xm0+xm3xm1−ixm2xm1+ixm2xm0−xm3)xmμ=12Tr⁡(σmμX).(6)X_m=\sum_{\mu=0}^{3}x_m^\mu\sigma_{m\mu}=\left(\begin{matrix}x_m^0+x_m^3&x_m^1-ix_m^2\\x_m^1+ix_m^2&x_m^0-x_m^3\end{matrix}\right)\qquad x_m^\mu=\frac{1}{2}\operatorname{Tr}(\sigma_{m\mu}X). \tag*{(6)}

The Euclidean time-reflection operator, θ\theta, which changes the sign of the Euclidean time, is defined by

θxe=(−xe0,xe1,xe2,xe3).(7)\theta x_e=(-x_e^0,x_e^1,x_e^2,x_e^3). \tag*{(7)}

The Euclidean or Minkowski parity operator Π\Pi is defined by

Πxe=(xe0,−xe1,−xe2,−xe3)Πxm=(xm0,−xm1,−xm2,−xm3).(8)\Pi x_e=(x_e^0,-x_e^1,-x_e^2,-x_e^3)\qquad\Pi x_m=(x_m^0,-x_m^1,-x_m^2,-x_m^3). \tag*{(8)}

Widder's theorem

The goal of this work is to understand the general structure of reflection positive distributions. The simplest prototype of a reflection positive kernel is a k(t)k(t) satisfying

∫0∞dt dt′f(t)k(t+t′)f(t′)≥0(9)\int_{0}^{\infty}dt\,dt' f(t)k(t+t')f(t') \geq0 \tag*{(9)}

for continuous functions f(t)f(t) with compact support on (0,∞)(0,\infty). The general form of continuous k(t)k(t) satisfying (9) is (see of [53])

k(t)=∫ρ(λ)dλe−tλ(10)k(t)=\int\rho(\lambda)d\lambda e^{-t\lambda} \tag*{(10)}

where ρ(λ)\rho(\lambda) is non-decreasing and the integral converges for 0≤t≤2T0\leq t\leq2T where support⁡(f(t))∈[0,T]\operatorname{support}(f(t))\in[0,T]. For t>0t>0 this can be written as

k(t)=∫ρ~(λ)e−itpλ2+p2dpdλ(11)k(t)=\int\widetilde{\rho}(\lambda)\frac{e^{-itp}}{\lambda^2+p^2}dpd\lambda \tag*{(11)}

where ρ~(λ)=ρ(λ)λπ\widetilde{\rho}(\lambda)=\rho(\lambda)\frac{\lambda}{\pi} and the restriction on the support of f(t)f(t) means that the pp integral can be computed using the residue theorem. The relevant observation is that (11) has a structure similar to a Lehmann representation. In what follows it is shown that all positive mass, positive energy unitary irreducible representations of the Poincaré group can be constructed using a generalization of this construction. Since any unitary representation of the Poincaré group can be decomposed into direct integrals of irreducible representations, this provides the general structure of reflection positive distributions.

Relativistic covariance: SL(2,C)SL(2,\mathbb{C}) and SU(2)×SU(2)SU(2)\times SU(2)

The relation between the Lorentz and orthogonal groups in four dimensions plays a central role in the connection between the Euclidean and Minkowski representation of relativistic quantum mechanics.

The covering groups of the complex Lorentz and the four dimensional complex orthogonal groups are isomorphic. Because of this there are formal expressions for the Poincaré generators as linear combinations of the generators of the Euclidean group. These operators satisfy the commutation relations of the Poincaré Lie algebra, but they are not self-adjoint on the Hilbert space where the Euclidean generators are self-adjoint. Reflection positivity leads to a Hilbert space inner product where the Poincaré generators constructed from the Euclidean generators are represented by self-adjoint operators.

The purpose of this section is to review the relation between the complex Lorentz and complex orthogonal groups. The starting point is to note that Euclidean and Minkowski 4-vectors can be represented by 2×22\times2 matrices. Minkowski 4-vectors xmx_m can be represented by Hermitian matrices (5) while the Euclidean 4 vectors xex_e can be represented by matrices of the form (6).

The advantage of these matrix representations is that the determinants of these matrices are related to the Minkowski and Euclidean invariant line elements respectively:

det⁡(Xm)=(xm0)2−xm⋅xmdet⁡(Xe)=−((xe0)2+xe⋅xe).(12)\det(X_m)=(x_m^0)^2-\mathbf{x}_m\cdot\mathbf{x}_m \qquad\det(X_e)=-\left((x_e^0)^2+\mathbf{x}_e\cdot\mathbf{x}_e\right). \tag*{(12)}

In both cases the determinants are preserved under linear transformations of the form

X→X′=AXBt(13)X\to X'=AXB^t \tag*{(13)}

where AA and BB are both SL(2,C)SL(2,\mathbb{C}) matrices and XX can be XmX_m or XeX_e. In both cases the relevant symmetry group is SL(2,C)×SL(2,C)SL(2,\mathbb{C})\times SL(2,\mathbb{C}). For arbitrary elements (A,B)∈SL(2,C)×SL(2,C)(A,B)\in SL(2,\mathbb{C})\times SL(2,\mathbb{C}) the transformation (13) defines a complex Lorentz or complex orthogonal transformation that preserves the real invariant line elements. The corresponding complex 4×44\times4 Lorentz and orthogonal matrices are

Λ(A,B)αβ=12Tr⁡(σαAσβBt)(14)\Lambda(A,B)^\alpha{}_\beta=\frac{1}{2}\operatorname{Tr}(\sigma_\alpha A\sigma_\beta B^t) \tag*{(14)}
O(A,B)αβ=12Tr⁡(σeα†AσeβBt).(15)O(A,B)^\alpha{}_\beta=\frac{1}{2}\operatorname{Tr}(\sigma^\dagger_{e\alpha}A\sigma_{e\beta}B^t). \tag*{(15)}

For real Lorentz transformations B=A∗B=A^* and for real orthogonal transformations AA and BB are independent SU(2)SU(2) matrices. When the left sides of (14) and (15) are real, the 4×44 \times4 transformations can also be expressed by taking complex conjugates

References

  1. [5]G. S. Samad and W. N. Polyzou, Euclidean formulation of relativistic quantum mechanics of n particles, Phys. Rev. C 103, 025203 (2021).DOI
  2. [6]R. F. Streater and A. S. Wightman, PCT, Spin and Statistics, and All That (Princeton Landmarks in Physics, 1980) pp. 168–170.
  3. [9]K. Osterwalder and R. Schrader, Axioms for Euclidean Green’s Functions II, Commun. Math. Phys. 42, 281 (1975).DOI
  4. [21]B. D. Keister and W. N. Polyzou, Relativistic Hamiltonian dynamics in nuclear and particle physics, Adv. Nucl. Phys. 20, 225 (1991).
  5. [42]A. Grassi, J. Golak, W. N. Polyzou, R. Skibiński, H. Witała, and H. Kamada, Electron and neutrino scattering off the deuteron in a relativistic framework, Phys. Rev. C 107, 024617 (2023).
  6. [44]J. Gillman and A. Jaffe, Quantum Physics - A functional Integral Point of View (Springer, 1981).
  7. [45]J. Schwinger, On Angular Momentum (Dover, NY, 2015).
  8. [46]N. N. Bogoliubov and D. V. Shirkov, Introduction to the theory of quantized fields (Wiley-Interscience, 1959) p. 150.DOI
  9. [49]G. Scharf, Quantum gauge theories: A true ghost story (Wiley, New York, USA, 2001).
  10. [53]D. V. Widder, Necessary and Sufficient conditions for the representation of a function by a doubly infinite laplace integral, Bull. Amer. Math. Soc. 40, 321 (1934).DOI
  11. [54]E. P. Wigner, On Unitary Representations of the Inhomogeneous Lorentz Group, Annals Math. 40, 149 (1939).
  12. [55]M. Reed and B. Simon, Methods of Modern mathematical Physics, Vol. III Scattering Theory (Academic Press, 1979) p. 317.
  13. [56]T. Carleman, Les fonctions quasi analytiques, Collection de Monographies sur la Théorie des Fonctions (Gauthier–Villars, Paris, 1926).DOI

Paper details

vlnc:W_uj6rygtc
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 0

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Physics and Astronomy

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents