betaFeedback

WorksPhysics and Astronomy

Reconsidering the nonlinear emergent inductance: time-varying Joule heating and its impact on the AC electrical response

Abstract

A nonlinearly enhanced electrical reactance, ℑZ\Im Z, under a large AC current has been measured to explore emergent inductors, which constitute a new class of inductors based on the spin-transfer torque effect. A nonlinear ℑZ\Im Z has been observed in conducting magnets that contain noncollinear spin textures and interpreted as the realization of an inductance due to current-induced spin dynamics. However, curious behavior has concomitantly been observed. For instance, the nonlinear ℑZ\Im Z always has a cutoff frequency of 10010^0–10410^4 Hz, which is much lower than the resonance frequency of a ferromagnetic domain wall, ∼\sim107^7 Hz; furthermore, the temperature and magnetic field variations in ℑZ\Im Z appear to be considerably correlated with those in the temperature derivative of resistance. This behavior appears to be difficult to understand in terms of the current-induced spin dynamics, and therefore, the earlier interpretation of the nonlinear ℑZ\Im Z should be further verified. Here, we theoretically and experimentally show that time-varying Joule heating and its impact on the AC electrical response can naturally explain these observations. In the experimental approach, we study the nonlinear AC electrical response of two conducting materials that exhibit no magnetic order, CuIr2_2S4_4 and 1TT'-MoTe2_2. Under time-varying Joule heating, a nonlinearly enhanced ℑZ\Im Z with the curious behavior mentioned above is observed in both systems. Our study implies that the nonlinear ℑZ\Im Z previously observed in noncollinear magnets includes a considerable contribution of the Joule-heating-induced apparent AC impedance.

INTRODUCTION

The exchange of spin angular momentum between flowing conduction electrons and an underlying magnetic texture leads to the spin-transfer-torque (STT) effect on the magnetic texture [1, 2]. Nagaosa theoretically proposed a new class of inductors arising from the STT-induced elastic deformation of noncollinear magnetic textures [3], and these inductors are now referred to as emergent inductors. The time evolution of a magnetic texture creates an emergent electric field (EEF) [4, 5]. Under an AC electric current below the threshold value, the magnetic texture remains in the pinned regime [6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14] and is periodically deformed, creating a time-varying effective U(1) gauge field and thus an oscillating EEF. From an energetic perspective, an emergent inductor stores energy in a magnetic texture under a current [15, 16], in contrast to classical inductors, which store energy as the magnetic field under a current [17].

Soon after the theoretical proposal of emergent inductors [3], experimental studies were launched. The AC impedance Z(ω)Z(\omega), also termed complex resistivity ρ(ω)\rho(\omega) (normalized with the sample dimensions), where ω\omega represents the angular frequency, was extensively investigated for materials that contain a noncollinear magnetic texture [18, 19, 20, 21]. Thus far, the imaginary part of the complex resistivity of such magnetic materials divided by ω\omega, i.e., Im⁡ρ1ω(ω,j0)/ω\operatorname{Im}\rho^{1\omega}(\omega,j_0)/\omega, has been commonly found to be negligibly small for a weak AC current density, j0eiωtj_0 e^{i\omega t}, whereas it is significantly enhanced and becomes detectable for a relatively large AC current density, j0∼108 A m−2j_0 \sim10^{8}\ \mathrm{A\,m^{-2}}. Here, the complex ρ1ω(ω,j0)\rho^{1\omega}(\omega,j_0) is not differential resistivity but defined by the 1ω1\omega Fourier component of the time-varying electric field under j0eiωtj_0 e^{i\omega t} divided by j0j_0. The nonlinearly enhanced Im⁡ρ1ω(ω,j0)/ω\operatorname{Im}\rho^{1\omega}(\omega,j_0)/\omega has been interpreted as emergent inductance. The present authors believe, however, that this interpretation needs to be reconsidered; in particular, several observations seem to be not well explained within the EEF-based inductance scenario. Here, we raise fundamental questions associated with the interpretation.

Question I. The values of Im⁡ρ1ω(j0,ω)/ω\operatorname{Im}\rho^{1\omega}(j_0,\omega)/\omega reported in experiments [18, 19, 20, 21] appear too large to be ascribed to the EEF origin. Linear-response EEF theory includes ℏ\hbar and predicts only a small value of Im⁡ρ1ω(ω)/ω\operatorname{Im}\rho^{1\omega}(\omega)/\omega, on the order of 10−1110^{-11}–10−13 μΩ cm s10^{-13}\ \mu\Omega\,\mathrm{cm\,s} [3, 15]. In contrast, for j0∼108 A m−2j_0 \sim10^{8}\ \mathrm{A\,m^{-2}}, the magnitudes of experimentally observed Im⁡ρ1ω(ω,j0)/ω\operatorname{Im}\rho^{1\omega}(\omega,j_0)/\omega at low ω\omega are ≈−9×10−7 μΩ cm s\approx-9 \times10^{-7}\ \mu\Omega\,\mathrm{cm\,s} for Gd3_3Ru4_4Al12_{12} [18], ≈−4×10−4 μΩ cm s\approx-4 \times10^{-4}\ \mu\Omega\,\mathrm{cm\,s} for YMn6_6Sn6_6 [19], and

≈−3×10−3 μΩ cm s\approx-3 \times10^{-3}\ \mu\Omega\ \mathrm{cm\ s} for FeSn2\mathrm{FeSn}_{2} [20]. Although the experimental reports emphasize that these values are observed in the nonlinear regime, understanding such gigantic responses within the EEF framework is nontrivial even if the EEF beyond the linear-response regime is considered. Furthermore, the sign of the reported Im⁡ρ1ω(ω,j0)\operatorname{Im}\rho^{1\omega}(\omega,j_{0}) is negative in most cases. The negative Im⁡ρ1ω(ω,j0)/ω\operatorname{Im}\rho^{1\omega}(\omega,j_{0})/\omega was interpreted as the inductance being negative, but the theory of dynamical systems concludes that unstable behavior occurs when the coefficient of the time derivative of the electric current, dI/dt\mathrm{d}I/\mathrm{d}t, is negative, contradicting the experimental observations [22] (for details, see Supplemental Materials [23]).

Question II. The ω\omega dependence of the nonlinear Im⁡ρ1ω(ω,j0)/ω\operatorname{Im}\rho^{1\omega}(\omega,j_{0})/\omega reported thus far exhibits a cutoff frequency as low as ∼1\sim1–10 kHz10\ \mathrm{kHz} for micrometer-sized fabricated Gd3Ru4Al12\mathrm{Gd}_{3}\mathrm{Ru}_{4}\mathrm{Al}_{12} and YMn6Sn6\mathrm{YMn}_{6}\mathrm{Sn}_{6} [18, 19] and ∼0.1 kHz\sim0.1\ \mathrm{kHz} for needle-like bulk FeSn2\mathrm{FeSn}_{2} [20]. These results were interpreted as indicating that the magnetic texture under consideration has slow dynamics, but the experimentally obtained resonance frequency of a ferromagnetic domain wall of ∼107 Hz\sim10^{7}\ \mathrm{Hz} should be noted [24]. Currently, there is no understanding of why such extremely slow dynamics are ubiquitously observed in the study of nonlinear emergent inductance.

Question III. In Gd3Ru4Al12\mathrm{Gd}_{3}\mathrm{Ru}_{4}\mathrm{Al}_{12} [18] and YMn6Sn6\mathrm{YMn}_{6}\mathrm{Sn}_{6} [19], Im⁡ρ1ω(ω,j0)/ω\operatorname{Im}\rho^{1\omega}(\omega,j_{0})/\omega exhibits complicated magnetic-field dependence in response to the successive magnetic phase transitions. Although these observations reveal a considerable correlation between Im⁡ρ1ω(ω,j0)/ω\operatorname{Im}\rho^{1\omega}(\omega,j_{0})/\omega and the magnetic phases, the complicated behavior has not yet been well substantiated in terms of EEF.

In exploring clues to answer questions I–III, we realize that the magnitude of the nonlinear enhancement of Re⁡ρ1ω(ω,j0)\operatorname{Re}\rho^{1\omega}(\omega,j_{0}) is larger than that of Im⁡ρ1ω(ω,j0)\operatorname{Im}\rho^{1\omega}(\omega,j_{0}); i.e., regarding the nonlinear part, Re⁡Δρ1ω>Im⁡Δρ1ω\operatorname{Re}\Delta\rho^{1\omega} > \operatorname{Im}\Delta\rho^{1\omega} holds, where Δρ1ω(ω,j0)≡ρ1ω(ω,j0)−ρ0(ω)\Delta\rho^{1\omega}(\omega,j_{0}) \equiv\rho^{1\omega}(\omega,j_{0})-\rho_{0}(\omega), with ρ0(ω)\rho_{0}(\omega) representing a linear-response complex value. For Gd3Ru4Al12\mathrm{Gd}_{3}\mathrm{Ru}_{4}\mathrm{Al}_{12}, for instance, the j0j_{0}-dependent Re⁡ρ1ω(j0)\operatorname{Re}\rho^{1\omega}(j_{0})–TT and Im⁡ρ1ω(j0)\operatorname{Im}\rho^{1\omega}(j_{0})–TT profiles in Figure 1(a) and (Figure 1b), respectively, were reported [18]. A static temperature increase cannot explain the pronounced variations in Im⁡ρ1ω(j0)\operatorname{Im}\rho^{1\omega}(j_{0}) at 10 kHz10\ \mathrm{kHz}, and on this basis, the nonlinear Im⁡ρ1ω(j0)\operatorname{Im}\rho^{1\omega}(j_{0}) was interpreted as originating from the current-induced EEF. However, the nonlinear part, which is here defined as Δρ1ω(j0)≡ρ1ω(j0)−ρ1ω(0.7×108 A m−2)\Delta\rho^{1\omega}(j_{0}) \equiv\rho^{1\omega}(j_{0})-\rho^{1\omega}(0.7 \times10^{8}\ \mathrm{A\ m}^{-2}), exhibits a Re⁡Δρ1ω\operatorname{Re}\Delta\rho^{1\omega} that is approximately 10 times larger than Im⁡Δρ1ω\operatorname{Im}\Delta\rho^{1\omega} for all j0j_{0} values [Fig. 1(c)]. Re⁡ρ≫Im⁡ρ\operatorname{Re}\rho\gg\operatorname{Im}\rho at low ω\omega is a characteristic of dissipative responses of a resistor, and therefore, the nonlinear impedance Δρ1ω(j0)\Delta\rho^{1\omega}(j_{0}) is resistor-like. This perspective is in contrast to the nonlinear inductance mechanism, which assumes nondissipative characteristics, i.e., Im Δρ1ω≫\Delta\rho^{1\omega} \gg Re Δρ1ω\Delta\rho^{1\omega} at low ω\omega. The observation of Re ρ≫\rho\gg Im ρ\rho at low ω\omega implies that the nonlinear impedance observed in Gd3_3Ru4_4Al12_{12} represent not a manifestation of an nonlinear emergent inductor but a manifestation of a nonlinear resistor. Thus, it appears more reasonable to regard the Im Δρ1ω(j0)\Delta\rho^{1\omega}(j_0) under an AC current as a delayed response of the much larger Re Δρ1ω(j0)\Delta\rho^{1\omega}(j_0), rather than the emergent inductance.

Nonlinear resistivity in Gd3Ru4Al12

Figure 1. Nonlinear ρ1ω\rho^{1\omega} in Gd3_3Ru4_4Al12_{12}. (a, b) Re ρ1ω\rho^{1\omega}–TT (a) and Im ρ1ω\rho^{1\omega}–TT (b) profiles under various AC current densities, j0eiωtj_0 e^{i\omega t}, at ω/(2π)=10\omega/(2\pi) = 10 kHz. (c) Current-density dependence of complex Δρ1ω(j0)=ρ1ω(j0)−ρ1ω(0.7×108\Delta\rho^{1\omega}(j_0) = \rho^{1\omega}(j_0) - \rho^{1\omega}(0.7 \times10^8 A m−2)^{-2}) at 15 K. The panels are constructed from the raw data published in the literature [18].

This notice led us to reconsider the unresolved issues regarding nonlinear Im Δρ1ω\Delta\rho^{1\omega} from a perspective of a dissipative mechanism. In general, when nonlinear electrical responses under a large current are examined, the impact of Joule heating must be considered. In AC impedance measurements, the sample temperature is time-varying with a 2ω2\omega modulation as a result of the time-varying current. Thus, the situation is more complicated than DC measurements, in which Joule heating only results in a static temperature increase. Such time-varying heating may cause a nonlinear Im Δρ1ω\Delta\rho^{1\omega}. While its impact has been discussed in the context of detecting a superconducting transition [25], to the best of the authors’ knowledge, the impact of time-varying Joule heating on the nonlinearly enhanced Im ρ1ω\rho^{1\omega} has not been discussed in the experimental studies on emergent inductance. This finding motivated us to scrutinize whether the nonlinear Im ρ1ω\rho^{1\omega} caused by AC Joule heating is truly negligible in the reported results [18, 19, 20].

The paper is organized as follows: In Sec. II, we construct a Joule-heating model up to the power-linear order and derive the expressions of the Joule-heating-induced AC electrical response. In Sec. III, we show the experimental observations of the Joule-heating-induced AC electrical response in CuIr2S4\mathrm{CuIr_2S_4}, which contains no magnetic order, and verify our Joule-heating model. Section IV is devoted to reconsidering the nonlinear emergent inductance previously reported and showing that the Joule-heating-induced AC electrical response approximately reproduces the temperature and magnetic field dependences, cutoff frequency, and magnitude of the Im⁡ρ/ω\operatorname{Im}\rho/\omega. In Sec. V, we consider the coexistence of dissipative and nondissipative mechanisms in impedance and argue that a nonlinear low-frequency regime should be avoided when exploring nondissipative signals in conducting materials. Section VI summarizes and concludes the paper.

Joule heating model for the nonlinear AC electrical response

Model construction

Below, we clarify ρ(ω,j0)\rho(\omega,j_0) characteristics when a large AC current is applied to the sample such that the effect of time-varying Joule heating is not negligible; that is, we consider a sample in contact with a heat bath of temperature T0T_0 and derive the voltage responses under the time-varying sample temperature, T(t)T(t), due to Joule heating. For simplicity, we disregard the temperature gradient within the sample. To analytically solve this problem, we make the following assumptions that appear to be physically reasonable.

Assumption #1. The instantaneous voltage drop in the time-varying self-heated sample is given by:

V(t)=R0(T(t))I(t),(1)V(t)=R_0(T(t))I(t), \tag*{(1)}

where R0(T)R_0(T) denotes the linear-response resistance at TT. In this model, only this resistive mechanism is considered for the relationship between the voltage and current. In other words, neither inductive nor capacitive mechanisms are considered.

Assumption #2. We treat the temperature increase of the sample, ΔT(t)=T(t)−T0\Delta T(t)=T(t)-T_0, with respect to the AC power input with angular frequency Ω\Omega, P(t)=Re⁡(P0eiΩt)P(t)=\operatorname{Re}(P_0e^{\mathrm{i}\Omega t}), as being within the power-in-linear-response regime. Thus, we consider the lowest-order nonlinear response to the AC current input. By introducing a complex response function, χ∗(Ω,T0)=\chi^*(\Omega,T_0)= χ′(Ω,T0)−iχ′′(Ω,T0)\chi'(\Omega,T_0)-i\chi''(\Omega,T_0), ΔT(t)\Delta T(t) is given by:

ΔT(t)=Re⁡[χ∗(Ω,T0)P0eiΩt]=  P0[χ′(Ω,T0)cos⁡Ωt+χ′′(Ω,T0)sin⁡Ωt],(2)\Delta T(t)=\operatorname{Re}\left[\chi^*(\Omega,T_0)P_0e^{i\Omega t}\right] =\;P_0\left[\chi'(\Omega,T_0)\cos\Omega t+\chi''(\Omega,T_0)\sin\Omega t\right], \tag*{(2)}

which is the expression for a cosine-wave power input, P(t)=P0cos⁡ΩtP(t)=P_0\cos\Omega t. By definition, in the DC limit, χ′(Ω,T0)\chi'(\Omega,T_0) approaches a finite value, χ0(T0)\chi_0(T_0), and χ′′(Ω,T0)\chi''(\Omega,T_0) approaches zero; i.e., we impose lim⁡Ω→0χ′(Ω,T0)=χ0(T0)\lim_{\Omega\to0}\chi'(\Omega,T_0)=\chi_0(T_0) and lim⁡Ω→0χ′′(Ω,T0)=0\lim_{\Omega\to0}\chi''(\Omega,T_0)=0. Note that χ∗\chi^* is determined by the heat capacitance of the system and the heat conduction to the heat bath; thus, χ∗\chi^* depends on the volume and geometry of the sample, the details of the thermal contacts, etc.

Assumption #3. A system has a nonzero thermal-response time, τtherm(>0)\tau_{\mathrm{therm}} (>0), which is a phenomenon known as thermal relaxation. Thus, under an AC power input, the thermal response of the sample is more or less delayed (i.e., χ′′>0\chi''>0), and correspondingly, χ∗(Ω,T0)\chi^*(\Omega,T_0) has a Ω\Omega dependence with a cutoff frequency of ≈1/(2πτtherm)\approx1/(2\pi\tau_{\mathrm{therm}}). The form of χ∗(Ω,T0)\chi^*(\Omega,T_0) can be approximately captured by a polydispersive Cole-Cole-type response:

χ∗(Ω,T0)=χ0(T0)1+(iΩτtherm(T0))1−α,(3)\chi^*(\Omega,T_0)=\frac{\chi_0(T_0)}{1+(i\Omega\tau_{\mathrm{therm}}(T_0))^{1-\alpha}}, \tag*{(3)}

where α\alpha represents the polydispersivity. For the readers’ reference, we display the functional form of (3) for the case of a monodispersive relaxation, α=0\alpha=0, in Figure 2. The details of χ∗\chi^* depend on the system, as mentioned above. Nevertheless, the only important feature in the following discussion is that χ∗(Ω,T0)\chi^*(\Omega,T_0) has a cutoff frequency determined by the thermal-response dynamics and satisfies lim⁡Ω→0χ′(Ω,T0)=χ0(T0)\lim_{\Omega\to0}\chi'(\Omega,T_0)=\chi_0(T_0) and lim⁡Ω→0χ′′(Ω,T0)=0\lim_{\Omega\to0}\chi''(\Omega,T_0)=0. (3) is an example of a function that satisfies these characteristics.

Example of the response function

Figure 2. Example of the response function, χ∗(Ω)=χ′−iχ′′\chi^{*}(\Omega)=\chi^{\prime}-i\chi^{\prime\prime}, which describes the temperature change in response to the power input. The functional form of Eq. (3) with α=0\alpha=0 is displayed on a double logarithmic scale.

Assumption #4. ΔT(t)\Delta T(t) is so small that the time-dependent resistance, R(T(t))R(T(t)), is well approximated by:

R(T(t))=R0(T0)+ΔR0(ΔT(t))≈R0(T0)+dR0(T0)dTΔT(t),(4)R(T(t))=R_0(T_0)+\Delta R_0(\Delta T(t)) \approx R_0(T_0)+\frac{\mathrm{d}R_0(T_0)}{\mathrm{d}T}\Delta T(t), \tag*{(4)}

where dR0(T0)/dT≡dR0/dT∣T=T0\mathrm{d}R_0(T_0)/\mathrm{d}T\equiv\left.\mathrm{d}R_0/\mathrm{d}T\right|_{T=T_0}.

Derivation of the nonlinear AC electrical response

With the above assumptions, one can analytically derive P(t)P(t), ΔT(t)\Delta T(t), R(t)R(t), and V(t)V(t) in sequence. We consider the situation in which a sine-wave AC current with angular frequency ω\omega, I(t)=I0sin⁡ωtI(t)=I_{0}\sin\omega t, is applied to the sample. Hence, the time-varying power input, P(t)P(t), is given by:

P(t)≈R2probe(T0)(I0sin⁡ωt)2=P01−cos⁡2ωt2=P02−P02Re⁡(ei2ωt),(5)\begin{aligned} P(t) &\approx R_{2\mathrm{probe}}(T_{0})(I_{0}\sin\omega t)^{2}\\ &=P_{0}\frac{1-\cos2\omega t}{2}\\ &=\frac{P_{0}}{2}-\frac{P_{0}}{2}\operatorname{Re}(e^{i2\omega t}), \tag*{(5)} \end{aligned}

where R2probeR_{2\mathrm{probe}} denotes the two-probe resistance including the contact resistance RcontactR_{\mathrm{contact}} and P0(I0,T0)≡R2probe(T0)I02=(R0(T0)+Rcontact(T0))I02P_{0}(I_{0},T_{0})\equiv R_{2\mathrm{probe}}(T_{0})I_{0}^{2}=(R_{0}(T_{0})+R_{\mathrm{contact}}(T_{0}))I_{0}^{2}. Here, we disregard the deviation from Eq. (5) due to the time-varying, two-probe resistance. By combining this result with Eq. (2) and further considering Eqs. (4) and (1) in sequence, one obtains:

ΔT(t)≈χ0(T0)P02−P02Re⁡[χ∗(2ω,T0)ei2ωt]=χ0(T0)P02−P02[χ′(2ω,T0)cos⁡2ωt+χ′′(2ω,T0)sin⁡2ωt].∴R(t)≈R0(T0)+dR0(T0)dT{χ0(T0)P02−P02[χ′(2ω,T0)cos⁡2ωt+χ′′(2ω,T0)sin⁡2ωt]}.∴V(t)≈R0(T0)I0sin⁡ωt+dR0(T0)dT{χ0(T0)P02−P02[χ′(2ω,T0)cos⁡2ωt+χ′′(2ω,T0)sin⁡2ωt]}I0sin⁡ωt.∴V(t)I0≈R0(T0)sin⁡ωt+dR0(T0)dTχ0(T0)P02sin⁡ωt+dR0(T0)dTP04[χ′(2ω,T0)sin⁡ωt−χ′′(2ω,T0)cos⁡ωt−χ′(2ω,T0)sin⁡3ωt+χ′′(2ω,T0)cos⁡3ωt].(6)\begin{aligned} \Delta T(t) &\approx\frac{\chi_0(T_0)P_0}{2}-\frac{P_0}{2}\operatorname{Re}\left[\chi^*(2\omega,T_0)e^{i2\omega t}\right]\\ &=\frac{\chi_0(T_0)P_0}{2}-\frac{P_0}{2}\left[\chi'(2\omega,T_0)\cos2\omega t+\chi''(2\omega,T_0)\sin2\omega t\right].\\ \therefore R(t)&\approx R_0(T_0)+\frac{\mathrm{d}R_0(T_0)}{\mathrm{d}T}\left\{\frac{\chi_0(T_0)P_0}{2}-\frac{P_0}{2}\left[\chi'(2\omega,T_0)\cos2\omega t+\chi''(2\omega,T_0)\sin2\omega t\right]\right\}.\\ \therefore V(t)&\approx R_0(T_0)I_0\sin\omega t\\ &\quad+\frac{\mathrm{d}R_0(T_0)}{\mathrm{d}T}\left\{\frac{\chi_0(T_0)P_0}{2}-\frac{P_0}{2}\left[\chi'(2\omega,T_0)\cos2\omega t+\chi''(2\omega,T_0)\sin2\omega t\right]\right\}I_0\sin\omega t.\\ \therefore\frac{V(t)}{I_0}&\approx R_0(T_0)\sin\omega t+\frac{\mathrm{d}R_0(T_0)}{\mathrm{d}T}\frac{\chi_0(T_0)P_0}{2}\sin\omega t\\ &\quad+\frac{\mathrm{d}R_0(T_0)}{\mathrm{d}T}\frac{P_0}{4}\left[\chi'(2\omega,T_0)\sin\omega t-\chi''(2\omega,T_0)\cos\omega t-\chi'(2\omega,T_0)\sin3\omega t+\chi''(2\omega,T_0)\cos3\omega t\right]. \tag*{(6)} \end{aligned}

Thus, for an input of I(t)=I0sin⁡ωtI(t)=I_0\sin\omega t, the Fourier series of V(t)/I0V(t)/I_0 has been analytically derived up to the 3ω3\omega components. Following previous studies [18, 19, 20], we introduce ZnωZ^{n\omega} to describe the resulting in-phase and out-of-phase electrical responses of the nωn\omega components (n=1,3n=1,3); i.e., Re⁡Znω≡Re⁡Vnω(ω,I0)/I0\operatorname{Re}Z^{n\omega}\equiv\operatorname{Re}V^{n\omega}(\omega,I_0)/I_0 and Im⁡Znω≡Im⁡Vnω(ω,I0)/I0\operatorname{Im}Z^{n\omega}\equiv\operatorname{Im}V^{n\omega}(\omega,I_0)/I_0, where Vnω(ω,I0)V^{n\omega}(\omega,I_0) is the nωn\omega Fourier component of V(t)V(t) under an AC current with ω\omega. The real and imaginary parts of ZnωZ^{n\omega} are given by:

Re⁡Z1ω(ω,I0,T0)−R0(T0)=dR0(T0)dTP0(I0,T0)4[2χ0(T0)+χ′(2ω,T0)],(7)\operatorname{Re}Z^{1\omega}(\omega,I_0,T_0)-R_0(T_0)=\frac{\mathrm{d}R_0(T_0)}{\mathrm{d}T}\frac{P_0(I_0,T_0)}{4}\left[2\chi_0(T_0)+\chi'(2\omega,T_0)\right], \tag*{(7)}
Im⁡Z1ω(ω,I0,T0)=−dR0(T0)dTP0(I0,T0)4χ′′(2ω,T0),(8)\operatorname{Im}Z^{1\omega}(\omega,I_0,T_0)=-\frac{\mathrm{d}R_0(T_0)}{\mathrm{d}T}\frac{P_0(I_0,T_0)}{4}\chi''(2\omega,T_0), \tag*{(8)}
Re⁡Z3ω(ω,I0,T0)=−dR0(T0)dTP0(I0,T0)4χ′(2ω,T0),(9)\operatorname{Re}Z^{3\omega}(\omega,I_0,T_0)=-\frac{\mathrm{d}R_0(T_0)}{\mathrm{d}T}\frac{P_0(I_0,T_0)}{4}\chi'(2\omega,T_0), \tag*{(9)}
Im⁡Z3ω(ω,I0,T0)=dR0(T0)dTP0(I0,T0)4χ′′(2ω,T0).(10)\operatorname{Im}Z^{3\omega}(\omega,I_0,T_0)=\frac{\mathrm{d}R_0(T_0)}{\mathrm{d}T}\frac{P_0(I_0,T_0)}{4}\chi''(2\omega,T_0). \tag*{(10)}

Note that the right-hand sides of Eqs. (7)–(10) are I0I_0 dependent via P0(I0,T0)=R2probe(T0)I02P_0(I_0,T_0)=R_{\mathrm{2probe}}(T_0)I_0^2, and thus, they represent nonlinear responses. The emergence of these nonlinear terms can be qualitatively understood as follows: Under an AC current with angular frequency ω\omega, the sample temperature and resistance are time-varying, with a 2ω2\omega modulation; the 2ω2\omega resistance modulation couples with the AC current with ω\omega, generating additional output voltage modulations of both ω\omega and 3ω3\omega. Thus, Im⁡Z1ω\operatorname{Im}Z^{1\omega} and Im⁡Z3ω\operatorname{Im}Z^{3\omega} appear due to a delay of the thermal response (i.e., χ′′\chi''). Note again that Eqs. (7)–(10) are valid only when variations of dR0/dTdR_0/dT and χ∗\chi^{*} under a Joule-heating-induced temperature oscillation are negligible. This condition becomes less likely to be satisfied at and near a phase transition: in such a critical region, dR0/dTdR_0/dT and χ∗\chi^{*} may pronouncedly change as a function of temperature.

Characteristics of the Joule-heating-induced AC electrical response

Having derived the expressions of the Joule-heating-induced AC electrical response up to the power-linear order, Eqs. (7)–(10), we now discuss their characteristics. Below we use TT to denote the sample-holder temperature, which corresponds to T0T_0 of the previous sections. Because the physical quantities also depend on the magnetic field, HH, the function arguments shall include HH in addition to TT. In that case, dR0/dTdR_0/dT should be read as ∂R0/∂T\partial R_0/\partial T.

First, Im⁡Z1ω=−Im⁡Z3ω\operatorname{Im} Z^{1\omega}=-\operatorname{Im} Z^{3\omega} holds.

Second, the expressions of Im⁡Z1ω\operatorname{Im} Z^{1\omega} (=−Im⁡Z3ω=-\operatorname{Im} Z^{3\omega}) and Re⁡Z3ω\operatorname{Re} Z^{3\omega} involve P0×dR0/dTP_0\times dR_0/dT [Eqs. (8)–(10)]. Thus, the variations in Im⁡Z1ω/3ω\operatorname{Im} Z^{1\omega/3\omega} when changing temperature or magnetic field are correlated with those in dR0/dTdR_0/dT. Since P0=(R0(T)+Rcontact(T))I02P_0=(R_0(T)+R_{\mathrm{contact}}(T))I_0^2, whether dR0/dTdR_0/dT or R0×dR0/dTR_0\times dR_0/dT better describes the Im⁡Z1ω/3ω\operatorname{Im} Z^{1\omega/3\omega} variations depends on whether the Joule heating is dominant in the bulk or at the contacts of the current electrodes. If the Joule heat is produced exclusively in the bulk [i.e., P0≈R0(T)I02P_0\approx R_0(T)I_0^2], then Im⁡Z1ω/3ω\operatorname{Im} Z^{1\omega/3\omega} variations would scale with R0×dR0/dTR_0\times dR_0/dT. If the Joule heat is generated mainly at the contacts of the current electrodes [i.e., P0≈Rcontact(T)I02P_0\approx R_{\mathrm{contact}}(T)I_0^2] and if Rcontact(T)R_{\mathrm{contact}}(T) only weakly depends on TT, then Im⁡Z1ω/3ω\operatorname{Im} Z^{1\omega/3\omega} variations would scale with dR0/dTdR_0/dT. However, the scaling should only be qualitative because the χ∗(ω,T)\chi^{*}(\omega,T), which scales with the heat conductance and inversely scales with the heat capacitance, is also temperature and magnetic field dependent.

Third, the Joule-heating-induced AC electrical response has a cutoff frequency ωc\omega_c that is determined by the thermal relaxation time of the sample: ωc≈1/(2τtherm)\omega_c\approx1/(2\tau_{\mathrm{therm}}). The thermal relaxation time depends on the system details, such as the sample dimensions and thermal contacts. For a millimeter-sized bulk sample, the typical value of τtherm\tau_{\mathrm{therm}} can be as long as ∼10−1\sim10^{-1}–10−2 s10^{-2}\,\mathrm{s} [26], which leads to ∼100\sim10^{0}–101 Hz10^{1}\,\mathrm{Hz} for the cutoff frequency of χ∗(ω)\chi^{*}(\omega). For an exfoliated thin plate with a submicrometer thickness, the typical thermal relaxation time is ∼10−6\sim10^{-6}–10−3 s10^{-3}\,\mathrm{s} (depending on the thermal conductivity of the substrate) [27], which leads to ∼102\sim10^{2}–105 Hz10^{5}\,\mathrm{Hz} for the cutoff frequency. As shown in Sec. III, our microfabricated CuIr2_2S4_4 and bulk MoTe2_2 exhibit cutoff frequencies of 20 kHz and 1 Hz, respectively. Thus, in general, the cutoff frequency of the Joule-heating-induced AC electrical response can be much lower than the resonance frequency of the magnetic texture under consideration.

Fourth, the following relations hold at low frequencies, ω≪ωc=1/(2τtherm)\omega\ll\omega_c = 1/(2\tau_{\mathrm{therm}}):

∣Im⁡Z1ωRe⁡Z1ω−R0∣=χ′′(2ω,T0)2χ0(T0)+χ′(2ω,T0)≪1for ω≪ωc.(11)\left|\frac{\operatorname{Im} Z^{1\omega}}{\operatorname{Re} Z^{1\omega} - R_0}\right| = \frac{\chi^{\prime\prime}(2\omega,T_0)}{2\chi_0(T_0) + \chi^\prime(2\omega,T_0)} \ll1 \quad\text{for } \omega\ll\omega_c. \tag*{(11)}
∣Im⁡Z3ωRe⁡Z3ω∣=χ′′(2ω,T0)χ′(2ω,T0)≪1for ω≪ωc.(12)\left|\frac{\operatorname{Im} Z^{3\omega}}{\operatorname{Re} Z^{3\omega}}\right| = \frac{\chi^{\prime\prime}(2\omega,T_0)}{\chi^\prime(2\omega,T_0)} \ll1 \quad\text{for } \omega\ll\omega_c. \tag*{(12)}

These equations indicate that at low ω\omega, the nonlinearly induced change from the linear-response impedance occurs mainly in the real part, rather than in the imaginary part. These characteristics are also evident in the Cole-Cole representation Figure 3(a) and (Figure 3b), in which Re⁡Z1ω−R0\operatorname{Re} Z^{1\omega} - R_0 is adopted for the real axis for clarity. In the Cole-Cole representation of Z3ωZ^{3\omega}, the ω\omega-evolving trajectory starts somewhere on the real axis at DC and converges to the origin at high ω\omega [Fig. 3(b)]. The behavior shown in Figure 3(a) and (Figure 3b) indicates that the Joule-heating-induced AC electrical response has dissipative characteristics. In contrast, when nonlinear Z1ωZ^{1\omega} and Z3ωZ^{3\omega} are caused by the nonlinear inductance, the nonlinear change should exclusively appear in the imaginary part; that is, at low ω\omega, ∣Im⁡Z1ω∣≫∣Re⁡Z1ω−R0∣\lvert\operatorname{Im} Z^{1\omega}\rvert\gg\lvert\operatorname{Re} Z^{1\omega} - R_0\rvert and ∣Im⁡Z3ω∣≫∣Re⁡Z3ω∣\lvert\operatorname{Im} Z^{3\omega}\rvert\gg\lvert\operatorname{Re} Z^{3\omega}\rvert should hold. In the Cole-Cole representation, these nondissipative characteristics are observed as shown in Figure 3(c) and (Figure 3d). In particular, the ω\omega-evolving trajectory of Z3ωZ^{3\omega} should start from the origin at DC [Figure 3(d)], which is distinctly different from the Z3ωZ^{3\omega} caused by Joule heating [Figure 3(b)]. Thus, the Cole-Cole representation provides key insight into whether the observed nonlinear AC electrical response has dissipative or nondissipative characteristics.

Schematic Cole-Cole representation of the AC electrical response

Figure 3. Schematic Cole-Cole representation of the AC electrical response. (a, b) Cole-Cole representations of Z1ωZ^{1\omega} (a) and Z3ωZ^{3\omega} (b) under Joule heating. R0R_0 represents the DC linear-response impedance. Schematics are drawn for both cases of dR0/dT>0\mathrm{d}R_0/\mathrm{d}T > 0 and dR0/dT<0\mathrm{d}R_0/\mathrm{d}T < 0. (c, d) Cole-Cole representations of Z1ωZ^{1\omega} (c) and Z3ωZ^{3\omega} (d) of a nonlinear inductor element.

Experiments

To experimentally test the Joule heating model, we measured the nonlinear AC electrical response for two conducting systems: a microfabricated CuIr2S4\mathrm{CuIr_2S_4} crystal (sample dimensions of 20×4×1 μm320\times4\times1\ \mu\mathrm{m^3}) and a bulk 1T′1T^\prime-MoTe2\mathrm{MoTe_2} crystal (approximately, 1.3×0.7×0.14 mm31.3\times0.7\times0.14\ \mathrm{mm^3}); images of the two samples are shown in the APPENDIX [Figure 9(a) and (Figure 9b)]. These materials exhibit no magnetic order, and a current-induced spin dynamics contribution to the AC electrical response can therefore be ruled out. In both materials, we find a good agreement between the experimental results and expected results for the Joule-heating-induced AC electrical response. For readability, only results for the microfabricated CuIr2S4\mathrm{CuIr}_{2}\mathrm{S}_{4} are shown in the main text. The results for the bulk MoTe2\mathrm{MoTe}_{2} are shown in the APPENDIX (Figure 10 and Figure 11).

Raw data and microscopy images for CuIr₂S₄ and MoTe₂

Figure 9. (a) Scanning electron microscopy image of the microfabricated CuIr2_2S4_4 device used in this study. (b) Photograph of the bulk MoTe2_2 used in this study. (c) Raw data of the Im ρ1ω\rho^{1\omega}–TT profile of the microfabricated CuIr2_2S4_4. (d) Raw data of the Im Z1ωZ^{1\omega}–TT profile of the microfabricated MoTe2_2. (e) R2R^2 vs Im Z1ωZ^{1\omega} plot for the microfabricated CuIr2_2S4_4 under a low AC current density of 5.0×1075.0 \times10^7 A m−2^{-2}.

Temperature dependence of AC electrical response of MoTe2 measured at various current amplitudes

Figure 10. Temperature dependence of AC electrical response of MoTe2_2 measured at various current amplitudes. (a) Re⁡Z1ω\operatorname{Re} Z^{1\omega}, (b) Im⁡Z1ω\operatorname{Im} Z^{1\omega}, (c) Re⁡Z3ω\operatorname{Re} Z^{3\omega}, and (d) Im⁡Z3ω\operatorname{Im} Z^{3\omega}. The data were recorded in the heating process. (e) Comparison between Im⁡ΔZ1ω\operatorname{Im}\Delta Z^{1\omega} and −dR0/dT-\mathrm{d}R_0/\mathrm{d}T. (f) Comparison between Im⁡ΔZ1ω\operatorname{Im}\Delta Z^{1\omega} and −Im⁡Z3ω-\operatorname{Im} Z^{3\omega}.

Frequency dependence of the nonlinear AC electrical response of MoTe₂ at 181 K

Figure 11. Frequency dependence of the nonlinear AC electrical response of MoTe2_2 at 181 K. (a) Re ΔZ1ω\Delta Z^{1\omega}, (b) Im ΔZ1ω\Delta Z^{1\omega}, and (c) Cole-Cole representation of ΔZ1ω\Delta Z^{1\omega}. (d) Re Z3ωZ^{3\omega}, (e) Im Z3ωZ^{3\omega}, and (f) Cole-Cole representation of Z3ωZ^{3\omega}. The data were recorded using an AC current of j0=179j_0 = 179 mA. As the experiments progressed, the contact resistance changed from the state shown in Figure 10, and the sample is therefore labelled Sample A’ instead of A. The geometries of Sample A and Sample A’ are exactly the same.

CuIr2S4\mathrm{CuIr}_{2}\mathrm{S}_{4} shows a first-order metal-insulator transition at Tc≈230 KT_{\mathrm{c}} \approx230\ \mathrm{K} [28, 29]. This material is paramagnetic and metallic (i.e., dρ0/dT>0\mathrm{d}\rho_{0}/\mathrm{d}T > 0 with ρ0\rho_{0} representing a linear-response DC value) above TcT_{\mathrm{c}}, whereas it is nonmagnetic and semiconducting (i.e., dρ0/dT<0\mathrm{d}\rho_{0}/\mathrm{d}T < 0) below TcT_{\mathrm{c}}. Figure 4(a), (Figure 4b), (Figure 4c), and (Figure 4d) display the temperature dependences of Re⁡ρ1ω\operatorname{Re}\rho^{1\omega}, Im⁡Δρ1ω\operatorname{Im}\Delta\rho^{1\omega}, Re⁡ρ3ω\operatorname{Re}\rho^{3\omega}, and Im⁡ρ3ω\operatorname{Im}\rho^{3\omega} at ω/2π=6 kHz\omega/2\pi= 6\ \mathrm{kHz}, respectively, measured at various AC current densities. Here, we display Im⁡Δρ1ω≡Im⁡ρ1ω(j0)−Im⁡ρ1ω(5.0×107 A m−2)\operatorname{Im}\Delta\rho^{1\omega} \equiv\operatorname{Im}\rho^{1\omega}(j_{0}) - \operatorname{Im}\rho^{1\omega}(5.0 \times10^{7}\ \mathrm{A}\ \mathrm{m}^{-2}) only for Im⁡ρ1ω\operatorname{Im}\rho^{1\omega} to subtract the contribution of the nonnegligible linear-response background; for the raw data of Im⁡ρ1ω\operatorname{Im}\rho^{1\omega}, see the APPENDIX [Figure 9(c)]. In contrast, for ρ3ω\rho^{3\omega}, we discover that the background signal is not significant, so we display the raw data.

Temperature dependence of the AC electrical response of CuIr2S4 measured at various AC current densities

Figure 4. Temperature dependence of the AC electrical response of CuIr2S4\mathrm{CuIr_2S_4} measured at various AC current densities. (a) Re⁡ρ1ω\operatorname{Re}\rho^{1\omega}, (b) Im⁡Δρ1ω\operatorname{Im}\Delta\rho^{1\omega}, (c) Re⁡ρ3ω\operatorname{Re}\rho^{3\omega}, and (d) Im⁡ρ3ω\operatorname{Im}\rho^{3\omega}. The Im⁡Δρ1ω\operatorname{Im}\Delta\rho^{1\omega} shown in (b) is defined as Im⁡Δρ1ω≡Im⁡ρ1ω(j0)−Im⁡ρ1ω(5.0×107 A m−2)\operatorname{Im}\Delta\rho^{1\omega}\equiv\operatorname{Im}\rho^{1\omega}(j_0)-\operatorname{Im}\rho^{1\omega}(5.0\times10^{7}\ \mathrm{A\,m^{-2}}). (e) Comparison between Im⁡Δρ1ω\operatorname{Im}\Delta\rho^{1\omega} and −ρ0×dρ0/dT-\rho_0\times d\rho_0/dT. The data were recorded in the heating process. (f) Comparison between Im⁡Δρ1ω\operatorname{Im}\Delta\rho^{1\omega} and −Im⁡ρ3ω-\operatorname{Im}\rho^{3\omega}.

In the Re⁡ρ1ω\operatorname{Re}\rho^{1\omega}–TT profile [Figure 4(a)], the apparent transition temperature clearly decreases with increasing current, indicating that the sample temperature is elevated from the sample-holder temperature, TholderT_{\mathrm{holder}}, by Joule heating. In the insulating phase, the four-probe resistance is 30–80 Ω\Omega within 225–160 K, whereas the contact resistance is ≈20 Ω\approx20\ \Omega. Thus, the Joule heat is assumed to be generated mainly in the bulk, rather than at the contacts of the current electrodes.

Figure 4(b)–(Figure 4f) show characteristic features consistent with the Joule heating model. First, in the insulating phase, Im⁡Δρ1ω\operatorname{Im}\Delta\rho^{1\omega}, Re⁡ρ3ω\operatorname{Re}\rho^{3\omega} and Im⁡ρ3ω\operatorname{Im}\rho^{3\omega} nonlinearly emerge as the AC current density increases [Figure 4(b)–(Figure 4d)]. The signs of these quantities are consistent with Eqs. (8)–(10) for the case of dρ0/dT<0\mathrm{d}\rho_{0}/\mathrm{d}T < 0. Second, the Im⁡Δρ1ω\operatorname{Im}\Delta\rho^{1\omega}–TT profile agrees well with the (−ρ0×dρ0/dT)(-\rho_{0} \times\mathrm{d}\rho_{0}/\mathrm{d}T)–TT profile [Figure 4(e)], which is consistent with the results expected when Joule heating occurs mainly in the bulk. Third, Im⁡Δρ1ω=−Im⁡ρ3ω\operatorname{Im}\Delta\rho^{1\omega} = -\operatorname{Im}\rho^{3\omega} is well satisfied [Figure 4(f)].

The frequency dependences and Cole-Cole representations of Δρ1ω\Delta\rho^{1\omega} and ρ3ω\rho^{3\omega} at 210 K are shown in Figure 5(a)–(Figure 5f). The Cole-Cole representations [Figure 5(c) and (Figure 5f)] are consistent with the predictions of the Joule heating model for the case of dρ0/dT<0\mathrm{d}\rho_{0}/\mathrm{d}T < 0 [Figure 3(a) and (Figure 3c)]. The lengths of the arc strings are approximately the same for both cases (200 μΩ\mu\Omega cm). These observations confirm that the observed Δρ1ω\Delta\rho^{1\omega} and ρ3ω\rho^{3\omega} have dissipative characteristics and that the origin of their imaginary parts lies in the delay of the nonlinear real parts.

Frequency dependence of the nonlinear AC electrical response of CuIr₂S₄ at 210 K

Figure 5. Frequency dependence of the nonlinear AC electrical response of CuIr2S4\mathrm{CuIr}_{2}\mathrm{S}_{4} at 210 K. (a) Re Δρ1ω\Delta\rho^{1\omega}, (b) Im Δρ1ω\Delta\rho^{1\omega}, and (c) Cole-Cole representation of Δρ1ω\Delta\rho^{1\omega}. Δρ1ω\Delta\rho^{1\omega} is defined as Δρ1ω≡ρ1ω(j0)−ρ1ω(5.0×107 A m−2)\Delta\rho^{1\omega} \equiv\rho^{1\omega}(j_{0})-\rho^{1\omega}(5.0 \times10^{7}\ \mathrm{A}\ \mathrm{m}^{-2}). (d) Re ρ3ω\rho^{3\omega}, (e) Im ρ3ω\rho^{3\omega}, and (f) Cole-Cole representation of ρ3ω\rho^{3\omega}. The data were recorded at j0=3.5×108 A m−2j_{0}=3.5 \times10^{8}\ \mathrm{A}\ \mathrm{m}^{-2}.

From the frequency dependence, the cutoff frequency in the present device is found to be ≈20\approx20 kHz. Note that this value is not an intrinsic quantity of the material but should depend on the sample volume, details of the thermal contacts, etc. In the bulk MoTe2\mathrm{MoTe}_{2}, for instance, the cutoff frequency is as low as 1 Hz (see the APPENDIX, Figure 11), indicating that the sample dimensions are a crucial factor determining the cutoff frequency of the Joule-heating-induced AC electrical response. The cutoff frequency in the microfabricated CuIr2S4\mathrm{CuIr}_{2}\mathrm{S}_{4} depends on temperature only weakly, except for at the transition point, at which it decreases to 7 kHz. This decrease in the cutoff frequency is ascribed to an apparent increase in the heat capacity at a first-order phase transition.

For an applied current density below 5×108 A m−25 \times10^{8}\ \mathrm{A}\ \mathrm{m}^{-2}, the nonlinear AC electrical response is difficult to detect in the metallic phase above 230 K. To observe the sign of the nonlinear behavior in the metallic phase, we measured the Im Δρ1ω\Delta\rho^{1\omega}–j0j_{0} profile up to a higher current density, and the results are shown in Figure 6. The finite nonlinear Im Δρ1ω\Delta\rho^{1\omega} exhibits a detectable magnitude in the metallic phase when j0j_{0} exceeds 7×108 A m−27 \times10^{8}\ \mathrm{A}\ \mathrm{m}^{-2}, and its sign is negative. Thus, we confirm that the sign of the nonlinear Im⁡Δρ1ω\operatorname{Im}\Delta\rho^{1\omega} is negative in the metallic phase (dρ0/dT>0d\rho_0/dT>0), whereas it is positive in the insulating phase (dρ0/dT<0d\rho_0/dT<0). The relationship between the signs of Im⁡Δρ1ω\operatorname{Im}\Delta\rho^{1\omega} and dρ0/dTd\rho_0/dT is consistent with the Joule heating model.

Current-density dependence of $\operatorname{Im}\Delta\rho^{1\omega}$ in the insulating and metallic phases

Figure 6. Current-density dependence of Im⁡Δρ1ω\operatorname{Im}\Delta\rho^{1\omega} in the insulating and metallic phases. Δρ1ω\Delta\rho^{1\omega} is defined as Δρ1ω≡Im⁡ρ1ω(j0)−ρ1ω(5.0×107 A m−2)\Delta\rho^{1\omega}\equiv\operatorname{Im}\rho^{1\omega}(j_0)-\rho^{1\omega}(5.0\times10^{7}\ \mathrm{A\,m}^{-2}).

Reconsidering the nonlinear emergent inductance: answers to questions I–III

Having experimentally verified the Joule-heating-induced AC electrical response, we examine whether the nonlinear Im⁡ρ1ω(ω,j0)\operatorname{Im}\rho^{1\omega}(\omega,j_0) previously reported [18, 19, 20] has the characteristics of the Joule-heating-induced AC electrical response. In particular, we discuss the temperature and magnetic field dependences, cutoff frequency, and magnitude of Im⁡ρ1ω\operatorname{Im}\rho^{1\omega}, and show that the Joule-heating-induced AC electrical response gives answers to questions I–III. We begin by discussing the temperature and magnetic field dependences and answering question III.

Temperature and magnetic field dependences: answer to question III

As discussed in Sec. II C, a main characteristic of the Joule-heating-induced AC electrical response is a correlation between the nonlinearly enhanced Im⁡ρ1ω(ω,j0)\operatorname{Im}\rho^{1\omega}(\omega,j_0) and −dρ0/dT-d\rho_0/dT. Thus, it is of interest whether the temperature and magnetic field dependences of Im⁡ρ1ω(ω,j0)\operatorname{Im}\rho^{1\omega}(\omega,j_0) are similar to those of −dρ0/dT-d\rho_0/dT (or −ρ0×dρ0/dT-\rho_0\times d\rho_0/dT).

The comparative results regarding the temperature dependence for Gd3_3Ru4_4Al12_{12}, YMn6_6Sn6_6, and FeSn2_2 are summarized in Figure 7. We determine that the Im⁡Δρ1ω(ω,j0)\operatorname{Im}\Delta\rho^{1\omega}(\omega,j_0)–TT profile is similar to the (−dρ0/dT)(-\mathrm{d}\rho_0/\mathrm{d}T)–TT profile for Gd3_3Ru4_4Al12_{12} [Figs. 7(a) and (b)] [18] and YMn6_6Sn6_6 [Figs. 7(c) and (d)] [19] or to the (−ρ0×dρ0/dT)(-\rho_0\times\mathrm{d}\rho_0/\mathrm{d}T)–TT profile for FeSn2_2 [Figs. 7(e) and (f)] [20]. In YMn6_6Sn6_6, notably, the Im⁡Δρ1ω(ω,j0)\operatorname{Im}\Delta\rho^{1\omega}(\omega,j_0)–TT and (−dρ0/dT)(-\mathrm{d}\rho_0/\mathrm{d}T)–TT profiles commonly exhibit a sign change.

Correlation between nonlinear imaginary resistivity and temperature derivative of resistivity

Figure 7. Correlation between nonlinear Im⁡ρ(j0)\operatorname{Im}\rho(j_0) and −dρ0/dT-\mathrm{d}\rho_0/\mathrm{d}T in the reported data. (a, b) ρ0\rho_0–TT profile (a) and Im⁡Δρ1ω(j0)\operatorname{Im}\Delta\rho^{1\omega}(j_0)–TT and (−dρ0/dT)(-\mathrm{d}\rho_0/\mathrm{d}T)–TT profiles (b) of Gd3_3Ru4_4Al12_{12}. (c, d) ρ0\rho_0–TT profile (c) and Im⁡ρ1ω(j0)\operatorname{Im}\rho^{1\omega}(j_0)–TT and (−dρ0/dT)(-\mathrm{d}\rho_0/\mathrm{d}T)–TT profiles (d) of YMn6_6Sn6_6. (e, f) ρ0\rho_0–TT profile (e) and Im⁡ρ1ω(j0)\operatorname{Im}\rho^{1\omega}(j_0)–TT and (−ρ0×dρ0/dT)(-\rho_0\times\mathrm{d}\rho_0/\mathrm{d}T)–TT profiles (f) of FeSn2_2. The ρ0\rho_0–TT and Im⁡ρ1ω(j0)\operatorname{Im}\rho^{1\omega}(j_0)–TT profiles were obtained from the literature [18, 19, 20], and we constructed the (−dρ0/dT)(-\mathrm{d}\rho_0/\mathrm{d}T)–TT profiles from the reported data. Note that for YMn6_6Sn6_6, the Im⁡ρ1ω(j0)\operatorname{Im}\rho^{1\omega}(j_0)–TT and (−dρ0/dT)(-\mathrm{d}\rho_0/\mathrm{d}T)–TT profiles were collected from different devices.

Figure 8 shows the comparative results regarding the magnetic field dependence for Gd3_3Ru4_4Al12_{12}. The Re⁡ρ1ω(j0)\operatorname{Re}\rho^{1\omega}(j_0)–HH profiles at Tholder=5.1T_{\mathrm{holder}} = 5.1 and 5.35.3 K were measured at a current density of j0=3.3×108j_0 = 3.3\times10^8 A m−2^{-2} [Fig. 8(a)]. We estimate the ∂ρ(j0)/∂T\partial\rho(j_0)/\partial T–HH profile at this current density by simply taking the difference between the two sets of data divided by the small TT increment, 0.2 K, as shown in Figure 8(b). The Im⁡ρ1ω(j0)−H\operatorname{Im}\rho^{1\omega}(j_0)-H profile at Tholder=5.1T_{\mathrm{holder}}=5.1 K measured at the same current density is shown in Figure 8(c). We determine that the magnetic field dependences shown in Figure 8(b) and (c) are similar. Thus, we conclude that the complicated behavior of Im⁡ρ1ω(j0)−H\operatorname{Im}\rho^{1\omega}(j_0)-H profile originates from that of the (−∂ρ(j0)/∂T)−H(-\partial\rho(j_0)/\partial T)-H profile [31]. This is the answer to question III.

Magnetic-field dependence of Re $\rho^{1\omega}(j_0)$, estimated $-\partial\rho(j_0)/\partial T-H$ profile, and $\operatorname{Im}\rho^{1\omega}(j_0)-H$ profile

Figure 8. (a) Magnetic-field dependence of Re⁡ρ1ω(j0)\operatorname{Re}\rho^{1\omega}(j_0) in Gd3_3Ru4_4Al12_{12} at Tholder=5.1T_{\mathrm{holder}}=5.1 and 5.35.3 K, measured at a relatively high current density, j0=3.3×108j_0=3.3\times10^8 A m−2^{-2}. (b) Estimated (−∂ρ(j0)/∂T)−H(-\partial\rho(j_0)/\partial T)-H profile at j0=3.3×108j_0=3.3\times10^8 A m−2^{-2}. (c) Im⁡ρ1ω(j0)−H\operatorname{Im}\rho^{1\omega}(j_0)-H profile at j0=3.3×108j_0=3.3\times10^8 A m−2^{-2}. The data were collected from the raw data published in the literature [18].

Because Im⁡ρ1ω(j0)\operatorname{Im}\rho^{1\omega}(j_0) and −∂ρ0/∂T-\partial\rho_0/\partial T (or −∂ρ(j0)/∂T-\partial\rho(j_0)/\partial T) show similar temperature and magnetic field dependences, there is a considerable correlation between the two quantities. This correlation appears difficult to understand in terms of the EEF, which is determined by the spin dynamics and does not involve the TT derivative of the scattering rate of the charge carrier.

Cutoff frequency: answer to question II

As mentioned in Sec. I, the cutoff frequency of the nonlinear Im⁡ρ1ω\operatorname{Im}\rho^{1\omega} is ≈20\approx20 kHz for the microfabricated Gd3_3Ru4_4Al12_{12} [18], ≈1\approx1 kHz for the microfabricated YMn6_6Sn6_6 [19], and ≈0.1\approx0.1 kHz for the needle-like bulk FeSn2_2 [20]. These values and the corresponding sample volumes are shown in Table I, and they are within the range of those observed for the present microfabricated CuIr2_2S4_4 device (the cutoff frequency is ≈20\approx20 kHz and the sample volume is ≈80\approx80 μ\mum3^3) and the bulk MoTe2_2 crystal (the cutoff frequency is ≈1\approx1 Hz and the sample volume is ≈0.13\approx0.13 mm3^3). Given that thermal-response dynamics are also affected by details of the thermal contact, the low cutoff frequencies reported previously [18, 19, 20] thus appear to be reasonably explained by the time scale of the thermal response. This is the answer to question II.

MaterialGd3_3Ru4_4Al12_{12}YMn6_6Sn6_6FeSn2_2
SpecimenMicrofabricatedMicrofabricatedBulk
Sample-holder temperature, T0T_0 [K]15270350
Applied current density, j0j_0 [10810^8 A m−2^{-2}]4.02.50.8
Sample volume [μ\mum3^3]132908.9×1048.9 \times10^4
Observed cutoff frequency, ωc/2π\omega_c/2\pi [kHz]2010.1
Re Δρ1ω(j0,T)\Delta\rho^{1\omega}(j_0,T) at low ω\omega (<ωc<\omega_c) [μΩ\mu\Omega cm]0.71.52.9
Im Δρ1ω(ω,j0,T)/ω\Delta\rho^{1\omega}(\omega,j_0,T)/\omega at low ω\omega (<ωc<\omega_c) [μΩ\mu\Omega cm s] (Cal.)−2×10−6-2 \times10^{-6}−0.8×10−4-0.8 \times10^{-4}−1×10−3-1 \times10^{-3}
Im Δρ1ω(ω,j0,T)/ω\Delta\rho^{1\omega}(\omega,j_0,T)/\omega at low ω\omega (<ωc<\omega_c) [μΩ\mu\Omega cm s] (Exp.)−1.1×10−6-1.1 \times10^{-6}−2.6×10−4-2.6 \times10^{-4}−1.4×10−3-1.4 \times10^{-3}

Table I. Order of magnitude estimate of Im Δρ1ω(ω,j0,T)/ω\Delta\rho^{1\omega}(\omega,j_0,T)/\omega for Gd3_3Ru4_4Al12_{12} [18], YMn6_6Sn6_6 [19], and FeSn2_2 [20]. The parameters used for the calculations are obtained from the literature [18, 19, 20] or Figure 1.

Order of magnitude estimate: answer to question I

For the Joule-heating-induced AC electrical response, an order of magnitude estimate of Im Δρ1ω(j0)\Delta\rho^{1\omega}(j_0) can be obtained by referring to Re Δρ1ω(j0)\Delta\rho^{1\omega}(j_0) and ωc\omega_c as follows:

Im⁡Δρ1ω(ω,j0,T)Re⁡Δρ1ω(ω,j0,T)=−χ′′(2ω,T)2χ0(T)+χ′(2ω,T).(13)\frac{\operatorname{Im}\Delta\rho^{1\omega}(\omega,j_0,T)}{\operatorname{Re}\Delta\rho^{1\omega}(\omega,j_0,T)} = -\frac{\chi^{\prime\prime}(2\omega,T)}{2\chi_0(T)+\chi^\prime(2\omega,T)}. \tag*{(13)}

Note that within the present model, which considers the power-linear term and disregards higher-order terms, the ratio of Im Δρ1ω(ω,j0,T)\Delta\rho^{1\omega}(\omega,j_0,T) to Re Δρ1ω(ω,j0,T)\Delta\rho^{1\omega}(\omega,j_0,T) does not depend on j0j_0. Using Eq. (3) with α=0\alpha=0 for simplicity, we obtain:

Im⁡Δρ1ω(ω,j0,T)ω≈−13Re⁡Δρ1ω(j0,T)ωcfor ω<ωc,(14)\frac{\operatorname{Im}\Delta\rho^{1\omega}(\omega,j_0,T)}{\omega} \approx-\frac{1}{3}\frac{\operatorname{Re}\Delta\rho^{1\omega}(j_0,T)}{\omega_c} \qquad\text{for }\omega<\omega_c, \tag*{(14)}

where Re Δρ1ω(j0,T)\Delta\rho^{1\omega}(j_0,T) represents the low-frequency limit value. By referring to the Re Δρ1ω(j0,T)\Delta\rho^{1\omega}(j_0,T) and ωc\omega_c reported for Gd3_3Ru4_4Al12_{12} [18], YMn6_6Sn6_6 [19], and FeSn2_2 [20], we calculate the Im⁡Δρ1ω(ω,j0,T)/ω\operatorname{Im}\Delta\rho^{1\omega}(\omega,j_0,T)/\omega at low ω\omega (<ωc<\omega_c) for each system. The results are summarized in Table I. The calculated values are in agreement with the reported data for all three systems. This correspondence on the order of magnitude indicates that the origin of the nonlinear Im⁡Δρ1ω(j0)\operatorname{Im}\Delta\rho^{1\omega}(j_0) observed in the experiments [18, 19, 20] lies in the delay of the nonlinear Re⁡Δρ1ω(j0)\operatorname{Re}\Delta\rho^{1\omega}(j_0) with a cutoff frequency ωc\omega_c. In other words, the above analysis suggests that the reported Im⁡Δρ1ω(j0)\operatorname{Im}\Delta\rho^{1\omega}(j_0) does not represent the EEF-derived emergent inductance, and therefore, the Im⁡Δρ1ω(j0)\operatorname{Im}\Delta\rho^{1\omega}(j_0) reported previously can be markedly larger than that expected based on the EEF mechanism. This is the answer to question I. Incidentally, Figure 1, Figure 7 and Figure 8 indicate Re⁡Δρ1ω(j0)∝Im⁡Δρ1ω(j0)∝−dρ0/dT\operatorname{Re}\Delta\rho^{1\omega}(j_0) \propto\operatorname{Im}\Delta\rho^{1\omega}(j_0) \propto-\mathrm{d}\rho_0/\mathrm{d}T, and thus, the Re⁡Δρ1ω(j0)\operatorname{Re}\Delta\rho^{1\omega}(j_0) is also naturally explained by considering Joule heating [Eq. (7)].

Discussion

In general, dissipative and nondissipative mechanisms can coexist in impedance. Phenomenologically, the nonlinear Δρ(j0)\Delta\rho(j_0) is thus likely described by the sum of the two mechanisms: Δρ(j0)=Δρdiss(j0)+Δρnondiss(j0)\Delta\rho(j_0)=\Delta\rho_{\mathrm{diss}}(j_0)+\Delta\rho_{\mathrm{nondiss}}(j_0), where Δρdiss\Delta\rho_{\mathrm{diss}} and Δρnondiss\Delta\rho_{\mathrm{nondiss}} represent the nonlinear impedances due to dissipative mechanisms and nondissipative mechanisms, respectively. Note that by definition, at low ω\omega close to DC, Re⁡Δρdiss≫Im⁡Δρdiss\operatorname{Re}\Delta\rho_{\mathrm{diss}}\gg\operatorname{Im}\Delta\rho_{\mathrm{diss}}, and Im⁡Δρnondiss≫Re⁡Δρnondiss\operatorname{Im}\Delta\rho_{\mathrm{nondiss}}\gg\operatorname{Re}\Delta\rho_{\mathrm{nondiss}}. As mentioned in Sec. II C, the inductor mechanism due to the EEF caused by a pinned magnetic texture assumes Im⁡Δρ1ω≫Re⁡Δρ1ω\operatorname{Im}\Delta\rho^{1\omega}\gg\operatorname{Re}\Delta\rho^{1\omega} at low ω\omega and therefore belongs to Δρnondiss\Delta\rho_{\mathrm{nondiss}}, whereas the Joule-heating-induced AC electrical response satisfies Re⁡Δρ1ω≫Im⁡Δρ1ω\operatorname{Re}\Delta\rho^{1\omega}\gg\operatorname{Im}\Delta\rho^{1\omega} at low ω\omega and therefore belongs to Δρdiss\Delta\rho_{\mathrm{diss}}. As shown in § 0.4, we have discovered that regardless of whether the material under consideration exhibits a magnetic order (as in [18, 19, 20]) or not (as in this study), the observed nonlinear Δρ(j0)\Delta\rho(j_0) is categorized into Δρdiss\Delta\rho_{\mathrm{diss}} and has the characteristics of the Joule-heating-induced AC electrical response [Eqs. (7)–(10)]. This finding implies that unless the time-varying Joule heating is negligibly small, any nondissipative signals that may coexist are easily masked by the Joule-heating-induced AC electrical response. Note that the nonlinear Im⁡Δρ1ω/ω\operatorname{Im}\Delta\rho^{1\omega}/\omega becomes pronounced when large AC currents are used at low frequencies for impedance measurements, as indicated by Eq. (8). Therefore, when exploring nondissipative signals in conducting materials, it is important to avoid a nonlinear low-frequency regime and to suppress the time-varying Joule heating as much as possible. Since an order of magnitude estimate of the Joule-heating-induced Im⁡Δρ1ω(j0)\operatorname{Im}\Delta\rho^{1\omega}(j_0) can be obtained if the amount of the temperature increase due to the Joule heating and the thermal-response time are determined from experimental results, it would also be important to double-check that the nondissipative signals thus obtained are greater than this estimated value.

Conclusion

To clarify fundamental questions that have remained unanswered in the previous experiments on emergent inductors, we have considered the impact of time-varying Joule heating on the AC electrical responses. From a theoretical point of view, several key characteristics of the Joule-heating-induced AC electrical response within a power-linear regime have been clarified. To further examine the Joule-heating-induced AC electrical response, we have performed experiments on two materials that exhibit no magnetic order, CuIr2S4\mathrm{CuIr_2S_4} and 1T′-MoTe21T^{\prime}\text{-}\mathrm{MoTe_2}, and verified the characteristics of the Joule heating model. We have reconsidered the nonlinear emergent inductance previously reported and determined that the temperature and magnetic field dependences, cutoff frequency, and magnitude of Im⁡ρ1ω/ω\operatorname{Im}\rho^{1\omega}/\omega can be naturally explained in terms of the Joule-heating-induced AC electrical response.

The Joule-heating-induced AC electrical response inevitably yields finite Im⁡ρ1ω/ω\operatorname{Im}\rho^{1\omega}/\omega and Im⁡ρ3ω/ω\operatorname{Im}\rho^{3\omega}/\omega, unless the Joule heating is negligible and the measurement frequency is far greater than the inverse of the thermal response time. Even temperature oscillations as small as 0.1 K may cause a Im⁡Δρ1ω/ω\operatorname{Im}\Delta\rho^{1\omega}/\omega of considerable magnitude, which is much larger than that expected from the linear-response EEF. In previous experiments on emergent inductors, the nonlinear Im⁡ρ1ω/ω\operatorname{Im}\rho^{1\omega}/\omega below the cutoff frequency was discussed, and the nonlinearity more pronouncedly occurred in real impedance than in imaginary impedance. Our results thus suggest that the reported data regarding emergent inductors need to be reconsidered by taking into account the impact of the Joule-heating-induced AC electrical response.

Note added in proof. During the review process, our manuscript was commented by Yokouchi et al. [32] from Tokura group [32]. After careful consideration of their comment and new data, we found no need to change our conclusion. Our response to the comment is provided in Ref. [33].

ACKNOWLEDGMENTS

F.K., S.F. and W.K. thank T. Yokouchi and A. Kitaori for providing us with the raw data from the literature [18, 19]. F.K., S.F. and W.K. thank T. Yokouchi and S. Maekawa for fruitful discussions. We thank Y. Tokumura for the synthesis of CuIr2_2S4_4. This work was partially supported by JSPS KAKENHI (Grants No. 21H04442 and No. 23K03291), JST CREST (Grants No. JPMJCR1874 and No. JPMJCR20T1).

APPENDIX

Methods

The images of the microfabricated CuIr2_2S4_4 device and the bulk MoTe2_2 are shown in Figure 9(a) and (Figure 9b), respectively. In the experiments on MoTe2_2, we used carbon paste for the current electrodes to facilitate the Joule heating; the resistivity of MoTe2_2 is too low to achieve a Joule heating in bulk with use of ∼100\sim100 mA for the case of bulk crystal.

Figure 9(c) and (Figure 9d) show the raw data of the Im ρ1ω\rho^{1\omega}–TT profile of the microfabricated CuIr2_2S4_4 device and the Im Z1ωZ^{1\omega}–TT profile of the bulk MoTe2_2 crystal, respectively. The linear-response background signal is nonmonotonically TT dependent in the microfabricated CuIr2_2S4_4 device, whereas it is relatively small and weakly TT dependent in the bulk MoTe2_2 crystal. The linear-response background in the CuIr2_2S4_4 device is likely due to the impact of the stray capacitance CC, which generates a linear-response background of −iωR02C-i\omega R_0^2C [15], where R0R_0 is the linear-response DC resistance. The Im Z1ωZ^{1\omega} is proportional to R02R_0^2 in the present temperature range [Figure 9(e)], indicating that the (−R02C)(-R_0^2C)-type background dominates the imaginary part of the linear-response signal in the microfabricated sample. Since the nonlinearly enhanced electrical response is the main focus of this study, we present Im ΔZ1ω\Delta Z^{1\omega}, which represents a nonlinear change from the linear-response value.

Nonlinear AC electrical response of MoTe2_2 bulk crystal

MoTe2_2 shows a distinct change in dR0/dTdR_0/dT through a first-order structural phase transition at Tc≈250T_{\mathrm{c}} \approx250 K [30], and thus, this feature is helpful to study the correlation between Im Z1ωZ^{1\omega} and −dR0/dT-dR_0/dT.

Figure 10(a), (Figure 10b), (Figure 10c), and (Figure 10d) display the temperature dependences of Re Z1ωZ^{1\omega}, Im ΔZ1ω\Delta Z^{1\omega}, Re Z3ωZ^{3\omega}, and Im Z3ωZ^{3\omega} at ω/2π=1\omega/2\pi= 1 Hz, respectively, measured using various AC current amplitudes. In the Re Z1ωZ^{1\omega}–TT profile [Figure 10(a)], the apparent transition temperature clearly decreases as the current increases, indicating that the sample temperature increases from the sample-holder temperature, TholderT_{\mathrm{holder}}, by Joule heating. Figure 10(b)–(Figure 10f) show characteristic features consistent with the Joule heating model. First, Im ΔZ1ω\Delta Z^{1\omega}, Re Z3ωZ^{3\omega} and Im Z3ωZ^{3\omega} nonlinearly emerge as the AC current increases [Figure 10(b)–(Figure 10d)]. Second, the Im ΔZ1ω\Delta Z^{1\omega}–TT profile qualitatively agrees with the (−dR0/dT)(-dR_0/dT)–TT profile [Figure 10(e)], which is consistent with the Joule heating model. with the results expected when Joule heating occurs mainly at the contacts. Third, the relation of Im⁡ΔZ1ω=−Im⁡Z3ω\operatorname{Im}\Delta Z^{1\omega}=-\operatorname{Im}Z^{3\omega} is well satisfied, with the exception of the transition region at 245 K [Fig. 10(f)]. The breakdown of Im⁡ΔZ1ω=−Im⁡Z3ω\operatorname{Im}\Delta Z^{1\omega}=-\operatorname{Im}Z^{3\omega} at 245 K appears reasonable considering that Eqs. (7)–(10) do not generally describe the data at and near a phase transition well.

The frequency dependences and Cole-Cole representations of ΔZ1ω\Delta Z^{1\omega} and Z3ωZ^{3\omega} at 180 K are shown in Figure 11(a)–(Figure 11f). They are also consistent with the predictions of the Joule heating model for the case of dR0/dT>0\mathrm{d}R_0/\mathrm{d}T>0, although ΔZ1ω\Delta Z^{1\omega} appears to be more susceptible to the linear-response background than Z3ωZ^{3\omega} is. In the Cole-Cole representations of ΔZ1ω\Delta Z^{1\omega} and Z3ωZ^{3\omega}, the lengths of the arc strings are approximately the same (0.5 mΩ\Omega). The cutoff frequency of the nonlinear AC electrical response is estimated as ≈1\approx1 Hz. This frequency is typical for the thermal response in a bulk crystal, as often reported in AC-temperature calorimetry experiments [34].

Supplemental Material

In Supplemental Material, we show that the negative nonlinear reactance reported in previous experimental studies [18, 19, 20] is not a manifestation of negative nonlinear inductance. In previous experimental reports, the impedance at the fundamental and higher harmonic frequencies was measured for the input frequency ω/(2π)\omega/(2\pi) using the lock-in technique. The typical experimental setup is displayed in Figure S1: a magnetic material, a load resistor with resistance, RLR_{\mathrm{L}}, and an AC voltage output of the lock-in amplifier, V0sin⁡ωtV_{0}\sin\omega t, are connected in series. For simplicity, we consider a sample with a two-probe configuration and do not explicitly consider the contact resistance. The current flowing through the circuit, I1ω(ω)\mathcal{I}^{1\omega}(\omega) [the 1ω1\omega Fourier component of I(t)I(t)], was determined from the voltage drop at the load resistor, and the voltage drop at the sample, Vs1ω(ω)\mathcal{V}_{\mathrm{s}}^{1\omega}(\omega) [the 1ω1\omega Fourier component of Vs(t)V_{\mathrm{s}}(t)], was measured. Then, they defined the complex impedance Z1ω(ω,I)Z^{1\omega}(\omega,\mathcal{I}) at I1ω(ω)\mathcal{I}^{1\omega}(\omega) by Vs1ω(ω)/I1ω(ω)\mathcal{V}_{\mathrm{s}}^{1\omega}(\omega)/\mathcal{I}^{1\omega}(\omega). Note that this definition was also used for a large I1ω(ω)\mathcal{I}^{1\omega}(\omega) such that the proportionality between Vs1ω(ω)\mathcal{V}_{\mathrm{s}}^{1\omega}(\omega) and I1ω(ω)\mathcal{I}^{1\omega}(\omega) is no longer valid. From a theoretical perspective, they defined an emergent inductor as an element showing the following voltage drop:

Typical experimental circuit used for measurement of the complex impedance

Figure S1. Typical experimental circuit used for measurement of the complex impedance.

Vs(t)=RsI(t)+L0(1+AI(t)2+BI(t)4+⋯ )dIdt,(15)V_{\mathrm{s}}(t)=R_{\mathrm{s}}I(t)+L_{0}\left(1+AI(t)^{2}+BI(t)^{4}+\cdots\right)\frac{\mathrm{d}I}{\mathrm{d}t}, \tag*{(15)}

where RsR_{\mathrm{s}} is the resistance of the sample, L0L_{0} denotes the inductance in the linear response, and A and B are coefficients representing the nonlinearity related to the inductive response. From an energetic perspective, Eq. (15) corresponds to the fact that under current II, the inductive element with a finite resistance can store the following energy:

EL(I(t))=L0(12I(t)2+14AI(t)4+16BI(t)6+⋯ ).(16)E_{\mathrm{L}}(I(t))=L_{0}\left(\frac{1}{2}I(t)^{2}+\frac{1}{4}AI(t)^{4}+\frac{1}{6}BI(t)^{6}+\cdots\right). \tag*{(16)}

Note that the inductive term in Eq. (15), multiplied by II, is equal to dEL/dt\mathrm{d}E_{\mathrm{L}}/\mathrm{d}t, indicating the relationship between the inductive electric response and the energy stored in the inductor. Given Eq. (15), the circuit equation of the measurement system is given as:

V0sin⁡ωt=(RL+Rs)I(t)+L0(1+AI(t)2+BI(t)4+⋯ )dIdt=RI(t)+L0(1+AI(t)2+BI(t)4+⋯ )dIdt,(17)V_{0}\sin\omega t=(R_{\mathrm{L}}+R_{\mathrm{s}})I(t)+L_{0}\left(1+AI(t)^{2}+BI(t)^{4}+\cdots\right)\frac{\mathrm{d}I}{\mathrm{d}t} =RI(t)+L_{0}\left(1+AI(t)^{2}+BI(t)^{4}+\cdots\right)\frac{\mathrm{d}I}{\mathrm{d}t}, \tag*{(17)}

where V0V_{0} is the output voltage amplitude of the lock-in amplifier and RR is the sum of the sample and load resistances. Experimentally, they observed Im⁡[Vs1ω(ω)/I1ω(ω)]≈−∣η∣ω\operatorname{Im}[V_{\mathrm{s}}^{1\omega}(\omega)/I^{1\omega}(\omega)]\approx-|\eta|\omega at low frequencies, especially when the flowing current is large under a large V0V_{0}. This observation was interpreted as indicating that the coefficient of dI/dt\mathrm{d}I/\mathrm{d}t in Eq. (17) became negative under large currents. However, it has not been discussed whether Eq. (17) truly shows Im⁡[Vs1ω(ω)/I1ω(ω)]≈−∣η∣ω\operatorname{Im}[V_{\mathrm{s}}^{1\omega}(\omega)/I^{1\omega}(\omega)]\approx-|\eta|\omega when the coefficient of dI/dt\mathrm{d}I/\mathrm{d}t is negative at a large II. Therefore, the correspondence between the experimental observations and Eqs. (15)–(17) remains unclear. In fact, as shown below, the solution of Eq. (17) has instability towards self-sustained oscillations when the coefficient of dI/dt\mathrm{d}I/\mathrm{d}t becomes negative at a large II, and it does not show an electric response such that Im⁡[Vs1ω(ω)/I1ω(ω)]≈−∣η∣ω\operatorname{Im}[V_{\mathrm{s}}^{1\omega}(\omega)/I^{1\omega}(\omega)]\approx-|\eta|\omega; i.e., the experimental observations are not described by Eqs. (15)–(17). In the following, we numerically examine the nature of the nonlinear negative inductance represented by Eqs. (15)–(17).

Equation (S3) is complicated because the coefficient of dI/dt\mathrm{d}I/\mathrm{d}t is time dependent and may change the sign during the time evolution. To gain insights into Eq. (17), it would be instructive to begin with a simpler case. We consider a different form of circuit equation, which is nonlinear with respect to the input voltage amplitude, V0V_{0}, instead of the current:

V0sin⁡ωt=RI(t)+L0(1+AVV02+BVV04+⋯ )dIdt=RI(t)+LV(V0)dIdt.(18)V_{0}\sin\omega t=RI(t)+L_{0}\left(1+A_{\mathrm{V}}V_{0}^{2}+B_{\mathrm{V}}V_{0}^{4}+\cdots\right)\frac{\mathrm{d}I}{\mathrm{d}t} =RI(t)+L_{\mathrm{V}}(V_{0})\frac{\mathrm{d}I}{\mathrm{d}t}. \tag*{(18)}

Note that in Eq. (18), the coefficient of dI/dt\mathrm{d}I/\mathrm{d}t, LV(V0)L_{\mathrm{V}}(V_{0}), is constant during the time evolution of the system, and thus, the profile of I(t)I(t) can be easily deduced from the knowledge of dynamic systems [22]. The numerical results are displayed in Figure S2 and (Figure S2). For clarity, here, we chose a simplified parameter set: V0=1V_{0}=1, ω=1\omega=1, R=10R=10, I(0)=0I(0)=0, and LV(V0)=+5L_{\mathrm{V}}(V_{0})=+5 [Figure S2] or −5-5 [Figure S2]. Note that the qualitative behavior of the solution depends only on whether the coefficient of dI/dt\mathrm{d}I/\mathrm{d}t is positive or negative, and we chose parameters such that the characteristics of I(t)I(t) can be clearly observed. Figure S2 shows the result for the case of LV(V0)=+5L_{\mathrm{V}}(V_0)=+5. When the coefficient of dI/dt\mathrm{d}I/\mathrm{d}t is positive, the focus, I0(t)=(V0sin⁡ωt)/RI_0(t)=(V_0\sin\omega t)/R (denoted by the dotted line), is a stable focus (but time dependent due to the AC driving force, V0sin⁡ωtV_0\sin\omega t); thus, I(t)I(t) tracks the time-varying focus, with a finite delay. Figure S2 shows the case of LV(V0)=−5L_{\mathrm{V}}(V_0)=-5. When the coefficient is negative, the focus is unstable, and thus, I(t)I(t) tends to separate from it over time. As a result, once I(t)I(t) deviates from the focus by an infinitesimal amount, the deviation is unlimitedly amplified and diverges. Thus, a constant negative inductance makes the system unstable. This divergence instability is a natural consequence of the fact that the energy of the inductor, 12LV(V0)I2\frac{1}{2}L_{\mathrm{V}}(V_0)I^2, diverges to negative infinity by increasing ∣I∣\lvert I\rvert under constant negative inductance LV(V0)L_{\mathrm{V}}(V_0).

Time evolution of the current for positive and negative inductance

Figure S2. Time evolution of the current in the differential equation, Eq. (18), for the case of positive inductance, LV(V0)=+5L_{\mathrm{V}}(V_0)=+5 (a) and negative inductance, LV(V0)=−5L_{\mathrm{V}}(V_0)=-5 (b).

We next consider the main issue, Eq. (17), which is a more nontrivial circuit equation in the sense that the coefficient of dI/dt\mathrm{d}I/\mathrm{d}t varies during the time evolution. We set positive L0L_0 (= 0.3) so that the system is stable in the linear response. By choosing appropriate AA and BB, Eq. (17) represents a nontrivial situation such that the coefficient of dI/dt\mathrm{d}I/\mathrm{d}t changes its sign from positive to negative when the current becomes sufficiently large. Note that Eq. (17) can be rewritten as dI/dt=(V0sin⁡ωt−RI)/[L0(1+AI2+BI4)]\mathrm{d}I/\mathrm{d}t=(V_0\sin\omega t-RI)/[L_0(1+AI^2+BI^4)], and thus, it shows singularity the moment L0(1+AI2+BI4)L_0(1+AI^2+BI^4) reaches zero. To numerically solve Eq. (17), we therefore introduce d2I/dt2\mathrm{d}^2I/\mathrm{d}t^2 with an infinitesimally small positive coefficient, Γ\Gamma (= 10−810^{-8} in the present numerical calculation), which is just for the sake of the stability of the numerical tracking of the solution and is not important in the following discussion. Namely, the differential equation actually computed in this Supplemental Material is:

V0sin⁡ωt=RI(t)+L0(1+AI(t)2+BI(t)4)dIdt+Γd2Idt2.(19)V_0 \sin\omega t = R I(t) + L_0 \left(1 + A I(t)^2 + B I(t)^4\right) \frac{dI}{dt} + \Gamma\frac{d^2 I}{dt^2}. \tag*{(19)}

When considering real systems, it is also natural to assume that I(t)I(t) is always first-order differentiable (i.e., dI/dtdI/dt is always finite), and it therefore makes sense to consider such a second-order derivative term to ensure first-order differentiability.

First, we consider the case in which A=−1.25A = -1.25 and B=0B = 0; thus, the coefficient of dI/dtdI/dt and ELE_L depend on ∣I∣\lvert I\rvert, as shown in Figure S3 and (Figure S3), respectively. The coefficient of dI/dtdI/dt and dEL/dIdE_L/dI reach zero at I≈±0.9I \approx\pm0.9. Figure S3 and (Figure S3) show the numerical results in the nonlinear regime such that the coefficient of dI/dtdI/dt reaches zero: the parameter set used is: V0=2.25V_0 = 2.25, ω=1\omega= 1, R=2R = 2, L0=0.3L_0 = 0.3, Γ=1×10−8\Gamma= 1 \times10^{-8}, I(0)=0I(0) = 0, and I′(0)=0I'(0) = 0. As the current increases with time, the coefficient of dI/dtdI/dt decreases and eventually reaches zero at t≈0.92t \approx0.92 [Fig. S3(c)]. Concomitantly, dI/dt≈(V0sin⁡ωt−RI)/[L0(1+AI2+BI4)]\mathrm{d}I/\mathrm{d}t \approx(V_0\sin\omega t - RI)/[L_0(1 + AI^2 + BI^4)] diverges approximately positively so that the current catches up with the time-varying focus, I0(t)=(V0sin⁡ωt)/RI_0(t) = (V_0\sin\omega t)/R, from below and overshoots it [Fig. S3(d)]. This upwards overshoot causes the coefficient of dI/dt\mathrm{d}I/\mathrm{d}t to become negative [Fig. S3(c)], which never reverts to a positive value. Thus, the time-varying focus is unstable for t>0.92t > 0.92, and accordingly, the current continues to separate from it and eventually diverges, similar to the case of Figure S2. Thus, the system is unstable for a large V0V_0. This behavior reflects the fact that in the absence of the I4I^4 term in Eq. (19), the inductor energy can be unlimitedly decreased by increasing ∣I∣|I| when the current exceeds the threshold value, ∣I∣≈0.9|I| \approx0.9 [Fig. S3(b)].

Four-panel plots showing the coefficient of $dI/dt$, stored energy, and time evolutions of the coefficient and current

Figure S3. Time evolution of the current in the differential equation, Eq. (19) with B=0B = 0. (a, b) The coefficient of dI/dtdI/dt (divided by L0L_0) (a) and the energy stored in the inductor (b) as a function of current. (c, d) Time evolutions of the coefficient of dI/dtdI/dt (c) and current (d).

Next, we consider the case in which A =−1.25= -1.25 and B =0.3= 0.3; i.e., the I4I^4 term with a positive coefficient is present in Eq. (19). Thus, as ∣I∣|I| increases, the coefficient of dI/dt\mathrm{d}I/\mathrm{d}t first changes from positive to negative and then back to positive again [Fig. S4(a)]; furthermore,

for this parameter choice, the inductor energy is always positive for arbitrarily chosen II [Fig. S4(b)]. These features imply that the simultaneous divergence of II and the coefficient of dI/dt\mathrm{d}I/\mathrm{d}t, as observed in Figure S3 and (Figure S3), does not occur. Figure S4 and (Figure S4) show the numerical results in the nonlinear regime such that the coefficient of dI/dt\mathrm{d}I/\mathrm{d}t reaches zero: the parameter set used is: V0=2.25V_0 = 2.25, ω=1\omega= 1, R=2R = 2, L0=0.3L_0 = 0.3, Γ=1×10−8\Gamma= 1 \times10^{-8}, I(0)=0I(0) = 0, and I′(0)=0I'(0) = 0. When the coefficient of dI/dt\mathrm{d}I/\mathrm{d}t decreases from positive to zero, the system starts to oscillate [see also Figure S4 and (Figure S4), which are magnified views of Figure S4 and (Figure S4) during oscillation, respectively]. This oscillating behavior can be understood by considering the time evolution of Eq. (19) in steps as follows. Whenever the coefficient of dI/dt\mathrm{d}I/\mathrm{d}t reaches zero, the current tends to quickly catch up with the focus, I0(t)=(V0sin⁡ωt)/RI_0(t) = (V_0 \sin\omega t)/R, overshoot it upwards from below (or downwards from above), and diverge while 1+AI2+BI4<01 + AI^2 + BI^4 < 0 (i.e., 1<∣I∣<1.751 < |I| < 1.75); however, when the current falls outside this range, the coefficient of dI/dt\mathrm{d}I/\mathrm{d}t becomes positive again [Figure S4]; thus, unlike in the case of B=0B = 0 [Figure S3 and (Figure S3)], the divergence of the current is halted, and the tracking towards the focus from above (or from below) restarts, resulting in decreasing (or increasing) current; during this tracking, the coefficient of dI/dt\mathrm{d}I/\mathrm{d}t decreases and reaches zero again. In this way, a jerky oscillation of the current is achieved around the time-varying focus [Figure S4 and (Figure S4)] when the current value results in a negative coefficient of dI/dt\mathrm{d}I/\mathrm{d}t, exemplifying the unstable nature inherent to a negative coefficient of dI/dt\mathrm{d}I/\mathrm{d}t.

Time evolution of the current in the differential equation

Figure S4. Time evolution of the current in the differential equation, Eq. (19) with positive B. (a, b) The coefficient of dI/dt\mathrm{d}I/\mathrm{d}t (divided by L0L_0) (a) and the energy stored in the inductor (b) as a function of current. (c, d) Time evolutions of the coefficient of dI/dt\mathrm{d}I/\mathrm{d}t (c) and current (d). (e, f) Enlarged view of the squared area in panel (c) and (d), respectively.

In summary, numerical examinations have demonstrated that the hallmark of a negative coefficient of dI/dt\mathrm{d}I/\mathrm{d}t is instability, such as divergence or spontaneous oscillation, and this phenomenon is never observed as an impedance with negative reactance. As would be best demonstrated by connecting a DC-voltage source of appropriate magnitude, an element that has a negative coefficient of dI/dt\mathrm{d}I/\mathrm{d}t in a certain current range will operate as an oscillator [Figure S5–(Figure S5)]. Therefore, the experimental observation, Im⁡[Vsω(ω)/Iω(ω)]≈−∣η∣ω\operatorname{Im}[V_s^{\omega}(\omega)/I^{\omega}(\omega)] \approx-|\eta|\omega, in the nonlinear regime should be considered beyond the framework of Eqs. (15)–(17). As discussed in the main text, we consider this issue in terms of time-varying Joule heating and its impact on the AC electrical response.

Oscillator function of an element: experimental circuit, coefficient of $\mathrm{d}I/\mathrm{d}t$ as a function of current, and self-sustained current oscillation

Figure S5. Oscillator function of an element that shows a negative coefficient of dI/dt\mathrm{d}I/\mathrm{d}t under the application of a DC-voltage of appropriate magnitude. (a) Experimental circuit for the demonstration of the oscillator function. (b) The coefficient of dI/dt\mathrm{d}I/\mathrm{d}t (divided by L0L_0) as a function of current. The broken line indicates a condition of V0V_0 and RR that show the oscillator function. (c) Time evolution of the self-sustained current oscillation in the differential equation, Eq. (19) with positive BB.

References

  1. [1]J. C. Slonczewski, Current-driven excitation of magnetic multilayer, J. Magn. Magn. Mater. 159, L1 (1996).DOI
  2. [2]L. Berger, Emission of spin waves by a magnetic multilayer traversed by a current, Phys. Rev. B 54, 9353 (1996).pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/9984672
  3. [3]N. Nagaosa, Emergent inductor by spiral magnets, Jpn. J. Appl. Phys. 58, 120909 (2019).DOI
  4. [4]G. E. Volovik, Linear momentum in ferromagnets, J. Phys. C 20, L83 (1987).DOI
  5. [5]S. E. Barnes and S. Maekawa, Generalization of Faraday’s Law to Include Nonconservative Spin Forces, Phys. Rev. Lett. 98, 246601 (2007).pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/17677979
  6. [6]T. Nattermann, Y. Shapir, and I. Wilfan, Interface pinning and dynamics in random systems, Phys. Rev. B 42, 8577 (1990).pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/9995034
  7. [7]P. Chauve, T. Giamarchi, and P. LeDoussal, Creep and depinning in disordered media, Phys. Rev. B 62, 6241 (2000).DOI
  8. [8]W. Kleemann, Universal domain wall dynamics in disordered ferroic materials, Annu. Rev. Mater. Res. 37, 415 (2007).DOI
  9. [9]G. Tatara and H. Kohno, Theory of Current-Driven Domain Wall Motion: Spin Transfer versus Momentum Transfer, Phys. Rev. Lett. 92, 086601 (2004).pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/14995801
  10. [10]A. Thiaville, Y. Nakatani, J. Miltat, and Y. Suzuki, Micromagnetic understanding of current-driven domain wall motion in patterned nanowires, Europhys. Lett. 69, 990 (2005).
  11. [11]G. Tatara, T. Takayama, H. Kohno, J. Shibata, Y. Nakatani, and H. Fukuyama, Threshold current of domain wall motion under extrinsic pinning, β-term and non-adiabaticity, J. Phys. Soc. Jpn. 75, 064708 (2006).
  12. [12]T. Koyama, D. Chiba, K. Ueda, K. Kondou, H. Tanigawa, S. Fukami, T. Suzuki, N. Ohshima, N. Ishiwata, Y. Nakatani, K. Kobayashi, and T. Ono, Observation of the intrinsic pinning of a magnetic domain wall in a ferromagnetic nanowire, Nat. Mat. 10, 194 (2011).DOI
  13. [13]G. Tatara, H. Kohno, and J. Shibata, Microscopic approach to current-driven domain wall dynamics. Phys. Rep. 468, 213 (2008).DOI
  14. [14]C. Burrowes, A. P. Mihai, D. Ravelosona, J.-V. Kim, C. Chappert, L. Vila, A. Marty, Y. Samson, F. Garcia-Sanchez, L. D. Buda-Prejbeanu, I. Tudosa, E. E. Fullerton, and J.-P. Attané, Non-adiabatic spin-torques in narrow magnetic domain walls, Nat. Phys. 6, 17 (2010).DOI
  15. [15]S. Furuta, S. H. Moody, K. Kado, W. Koshibae, and F. Kagawa, Energetic perspective on emergent inductance exhibited by magnetic textures in the pinned regime, npj Spintronics 1, 1 (2023).DOI
  16. [16]S. Furuta, W. Koshibae, and F. Kagawa, Symmetry of the emergent inductance tensor exhibited by magnetic textures, npj Spintronics 1, 3 (2023).
  17. [17]J. D. Jackson, Classical Electrodynamics, 3rd Edition. (Wiley, 1998).
  18. [18]T. Yokouchi, F. Kagawa, M. Hirschberger, Y. Otani, N. Nagaosa, and Y. Tokura, Emergent electromagnetic induction in a helical-spin magnet, Nature 586, 232 (2020).DOI
  19. [19]A. Kitaori, N. Kanazawa, T. Yokouchi, F. Kagawa, N. Nagaosa, and Y. Tokura, Emergent electromagnetic induction beyond room temperature, Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U.S.A. 118, e2105422118 (2021).DOI
  20. [20]T. Yokouchi, Y. Yamane, Y. Araki, J. Ieda, and Y. Shiomi, Emergent electric field induced by current-driven domain wall motion in a room-temperature antiferromagnet FeSn₂, arXiv:2312.01553.
  21. [21]A. Kitaori, J. S. White, N. Kanazawa, V. Ukleev, D. Singh, Y. Furukawa, T. Arima, N. Nagaosa, and Y. Tokura, Doping control of magnetism and emergent electromagnetic induction in high-temperature helimagnets, Phys. Rev. B 107, 024406 (2023).DOI
  22. [22]M. P. Shaw, V. V. Mitin, E. Schöll, and H. L. Grubin, The Physics of Instabilities in Solid State Electron Devices. Plenum Press (New York), 1992.DOI
  23. [23]See Supplemental Material at http://XXXXXX for the supplemental note for a hypothetical negative coefficient of dI/dt.
  24. [24]E. Saitoh, H. Miyajima, T. Yamaoka, and G. Tatara, Current-induced resonance and mass determination of a single magnetic domain wall, Nature 432, 203 (2004).pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/15538364
  25. [25]D. Perconte, S. Mañas-Valero, E. Coronado, I. Guillamón, and H. Suderow, Low-Frequency Imaginary Impedance at the Superconducting Transition of 2H-NbSe₂, Phys. Rev. Appl. 13, 054040 (2020).DOI
  26. [26]H. Oike, A. Kikkawa, N. Kanazawa, Y. Taguchi, M. Kawasaki, Y. Tokura, and F. Kagawa, Interplay between topological and thermodynamic stability in a metastable magnetic skyrmion lattice, Nat. Phys. 12, 62 (2016).DOI
  27. [27]H. Oike, M. Kamitani, Y. Tokura, and F. Kagawa, Kinetic approach to superconductivity hidden behind a competing order, Sci. Adv. 4, eaau3489 (2018).DOI
  28. [28]T. Furubayashi, T. Matsumoto, T. Hagino, and S. Nagata, Structural and Magnetic Studies of Metal-Insulator Transition in Thiospinel CuIr₂S₄, J. Phys. Soc. Jpn. 63, 3333 (1994).DOI
  29. [29]P. G. Radaelli, Y. Horibe, M. J. Gutmann, H. Ishibashi, C. H. Chen, R. M. Ibberson, Y. Koyama, Y.-S. Hor, V. Kiryukhin, and S.-W. Cheong, Formation of isomorphic Ir³⁺ and Ir⁴⁺ octamers and spin dimerization in the spinel CuIr₂S₄, Nature 416, 155 (2002).pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/11894088
  30. [30]K. Zhang, C. Bao, Q. Gu, X. Ren, H. Zhang, K. Deng, Y. Wu, Y. Li, J. Feng, and S. Zhou, Raman signatures of inversion symmetry breaking and structural phase transition in type-II Weyl semimetal MoTe₂, Nat. Commun. 7, 13552 (2016).DOI
  31. [31]Note that this comparison is not necessarily an ideal verification of the Joule-heating model up to the power-linear order [Eq. (8)] because Fig. 1(a) indicates that ∂ρ(j₀)/∂T at 5 K pronouncedly depends on j₀, which is beyond the scope of assumption #4 of the model.
  32. [32]T. Yokouchi, A. Kitaori, D. Yamaguchi, N. Kanazawa, M. Hirschberger, N. Nagaosa, and Y. Tokura, Comment on “Reconsidering the nonlinear emergent inductance: time-varying Joule heating and its impact on the AC electrical response”, arXiv:2407.15682.arxiv.org/abs/2407.15682
  33. [33]S. Furuta, W. Koshibae, T. Arima, and F. Kagawa, Reply to “Comment on “Reconsidering the nonlinear emergent inductance: time-varying Joule heating and its impact on the AC electrical response””, arXiv:2410.04325.arxiv.org/abs/2410.04325
  34. [34]P. F. Sullivan and G. Seidel, Steady-State, ac-Temperature Calorimetry, Phys. Rev. 173, 679 (1968).DOI

Paper details

vlnc:W_ukdtaw6n
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 0

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Physics and Astronomy

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents