betaFeedback

WorksPhysics and Astronomy

Analytic and Numerical Investigation of a Proposed Non-linear Extension of Quantum Mechanics

Abstract

In this paper, additional properties of a previously introduced non-linear extension of quantum mechanics are investigated. Analytically, we uncover a limit in which the model reduces to ordinary linear quantum mechanics. We also perform a perturbation analysis about an exact solution studied in earlier work. The equations represent a system that is subject to a periodic driver, and we use Floquet theory to help determine its properties. Numerically, we compare the exact solution to the analytic approximation, and we exhibit several examples of how the non-linear effects influence particle trajectories, with particular emphasis on trajectories near the linear limit.

Introduction

The Schrödinger equation of ordinary quantum mechanics is linear in the state vector, a property that gives rise to the superposition principle. From time to time, attempts have been made to construct non-linear generalizations, going back at least to Kibble in the 1970s [1, 2]. Kibble’s idea was to replace certain coupling constants in field theory with expectation values of operators, thereby introducing state-dependence into the Lagrangian. A renaissance of this approach has emerged recently in the work of Kaplan and Rajendran [3, 4].

A well-known non-linear generalization was that of Weinberg [5], whose motivation was to test quantum mechanics by deriving predictions from his model that could be probed experimentally. However, as pointed out by Gisin [6] and Polchinski [7], Weinberg’s model allowed superluminal communication, and as Polchinski also noticed, in the context of the many-worlds interpretation, it allowed communication between different branches of the wave function. As a result, Weinberg’s model languished, and, as far as we are aware, the experimental tests he proposed were never done [8]. We remark, however, that despite widespread theoretical prejudice, superluminal communication, like anything else, needs to be tested experimentally. A model should not be ruled out a priori unless its predictions contradict already established experimental bounds.

One motivation for making quantum mechanics non-linear is the possible relevance of such an extension to the relationship between quantum mechanics and gravity, a famously difficult problem that has not yet attained a generally accepted resolution. Although most attempts, such as string theory and loop quantum gravity, have sought to incorporate general relativity within the confines of ordinary quantum mechanics, others [9, 10] have argued that a successful marriage might require a modification of the rules of quantum mechanics as well. Here we begin to investigate the possibility that some, or possibly all, the properties of gravity can emerge from a suitably chosen quantum mechanical extension, without the manifest use of the machinery of general relativity. Our strategy is to study how the non-linear dynamics influences particle trajectories, expressed as the expectation values of position operators, and see whether there is any resemblance to the motion of a particle in a gravitational field.

The non-linear extension of quantum mechanics we shall use has been introduced in previous work [11, 12, 13]. The scheme departs fundamentally from ordinary quantum mechanics by employing a pair of state vectors to describe a given system, rather than the single state vector conventionally used for a pure state. Thus, the system inherently involves a mixture of two states. However, the components do not evolve independently under the action of some Hamiltonian. Rather, the equations of motion couple the two states ∣ψ1⟩|\psi_1\rangle and ∣ψ2⟩|\psi_2\rangle together via the inner products ⟨ψi∣ψj⟩\langle\psi_i|\psi_j\rangle, i,j=1,2i,j=1,2, thereby giving rise to the non-linearity.

In this work we present new analytical and numerical results. On the analytic side, we derive the limit in which our system reduces to ordinary quantum mechanics. We also find the solution in a special case that was left untreated in previous work. And we derive a perturbation expansion about an exact solution studied in reference [13]. We also use the periodicity built into the equations to perform a Floquet analysis of the solutions. Numerically, we give representative solutions for the wave functions and derive therefrom samples of the trajectories alluded to above. We also compare the analytical approximations to the numerical integration of the exact equations.

In section II we review the essence of our model. In section III, we discuss the linear limit, solve the exceptional case, and derive the perturbation expansion. In section IV we use Floquet theory to analyze our equations. In section V we present and discuss our numerical results. Section VI is devoted to some conclusions.

Review of The Model

We begin with a concise review of the non-linear extension of quantum mechanics that was studied in reference [13]. We consider a Hilbert space on which is defined a Hamiltonian operator HH. We can accommodate any system of interest, from a single particle to a relativistic quantum field theory, to something else, provided it has a Hamiltonian description. But instead of introducing a single state vector that satisfies the usual Schrödinger equation, we introduce a pair of state vectors, ∣ψi⟩|\psi_i\rangle, i=1,2i=1,2, and postulate the following equations of motion:

id∣ψ1⟩dt=[H+iμ⟨ψ2∣ψ2⟩]∣ψ1⟩+(g+λ)⟨ψ2∣ψ1⟩∣ψ2⟩id∣ψ2⟩dt=[H−iμ⟨ψ1∣ψ1⟩]∣ψ2⟩+(g∗−λ)⟨ψ1∣ψ2⟩∣ψ1⟩(1)\begin{aligned} i\frac{d|\psi_1\rangle}{dt} &= [H+i\mu\langle\psi_2|\psi_2\rangle]|\psi_1\rangle+(g+\lambda)\langle\psi_2|\psi_1\rangle|\psi_2\rangle\\ i\frac{d|\psi_2\rangle}{dt} &= [H-i\mu\langle\psi_1|\psi_1\rangle]|\psi_2\rangle+(g^*-\lambda)\langle\psi_1|\psi_2\rangle|\psi_1\rangle \tag*{(1)} \end{aligned}

Here μ\mu and λ\lambda are real parameters, and g=a+ibg=a+ib is complex. These equations are consistent with the following 3 principles:

  1. ddt[⟨ψ1∣ψ1⟩+⟨ψ2∣ψ2⟩]=0\frac{d}{dt}[\langle\psi_1|\psi_1\rangle+\langle\psi_2|\psi_2\rangle]=0.

  1. The extra terms should be linear in the inner products ⟨ψi∣ψj⟩\langle\psi_i|\psi_j\rangle, i,j=1,2i,j=1,2, and depend on time only through them.

  1. The system should possess the symmetries ∣ψj⟩→eiθj∣ψj⟩|\psi_j\rangle\rightarrow e^{i\theta_j}|\psi_j\rangle, j=1,2j=1,2 for constant θj\theta_j.

Principle 1. is the generalization to our system of the requirement that the norm of the state vector is conserved. It is important in guaranteeing that the solutions to the equations of motion remain bounded. Principle 2. distinguishes our strategy from other possible ways of rendering quantum mechanics non-linear. Principle 3. restricts the number of terms that can appear in the equations of motion. Even so, our equations are not quite the most general. As described in reference [13], there are 4 additional terms that could have been included, but these seem to have little influence over the dynamics, and in this work for simplicity we set them to zero.

Setting ⟨ψ1∣ψ1⟩+⟨ψ2∣ψ2⟩=N\langle\psi_1|\psi_1\rangle+\langle\psi_2|\psi_2\rangle=N, we define the density matrix

ρ^(t)=1N[∣ψ1(t)⟩⟨ψ1(t)∣+∣ψ2(t)⟩⟨ψ2(t)∣](2)\hat{\rho}(t)=\frac{1}{N}\left[|\psi_1(t)\rangle\langle\psi_1(t)|+|\psi_2(t)\rangle\langle\psi_2(t)|\right] \tag*{(2)}

and we postulate that the expectation value of any operator XX is given by

⟨X⟩(t)=Tr⁡ρ^(t)X.(3)\langle X\rangle(t)=\operatorname{Tr}\hat{\rho}(t)X. \tag*{(3)}

Together, the equations of motion and the formula for the expectation value of an operator define the model. Everything that follows is a consequence of these postulates.2

In this paper, we shall calculate ⟨X⟩(t)\langle X\rangle(t) for some simple instructive examples. To focus on the effects of the non-linearity, we consider the case where the underlying system is very simple, a single free particle, and where XkX_k is the position operator for that particle.

We shall find below that for appropriate choices of the input parameters, ⟨Xk⟩(t)\langle X_k\rangle(t) describes bounded, quasi-periodic orbits, whose properties we examine.

The route from the equations of motion to ⟨Xk⟩(t)\langle X_k\rangle(t) involves a series of 3 steps. As in previous work, we define

τ=⟨ψ1∣ψ1⟩−⟨ψ2∣ψ2⟩,γ=⟨ψ2∣ψ1⟩(4)\tau=\langle\psi_1|\psi_1\rangle-\langle\psi_2|\psi_2\rangle,\qquad\gamma=\langle\psi_2|\psi_1\rangle \tag*{(4)}

and

δ=∣γ∣2.(5)\delta=|\gamma|^2. \tag*{(5)}

In step 1, from the equations of motion we deduce a pair of first-order non-linear equations for the τ−δ\tau-\delta system, independent of the dynamics of the underlying system. We show that the τ−δ\tau-\delta equations can be cast in Hamiltonian form, with κ=ln⁡δ\kappa=\ln\delta the coordinate and τ\tau the momentum, and a conserved energy given by N2N^2. This is an independent subsystem, acting like an internal driver that dictates the behavior of the full system of equations. The τ−δ\tau-\delta equations also allow us to solve for γ\gamma. For our choice of parameters, the driver is a periodic system.

In step 2, we insert the information from the τ−δ\tau-\delta driver into the full equations of motion. These now take the form of a pair of linear coupled first-order equations for the ∣ψi(t)⟩|\psi_i(t)\rangle, which will have 2 linearly independent solutions. To accommodate them, we introduce two vectors ∣Ai(t)⟩|A_i(t)\rangle that evolve according to the underlying Hamiltonian (in this case just a free particle), normalized as ⟨Ai∣Aj⟩=δij\langle A_i|A_j\rangle=\delta_{ij}, and express the solutions for the ∣ψi(t)⟩|\psi_i(t)\rangle as linear combinations of the ∣Aj(t)⟩|A_j(t)\rangle with time-dependent coefficients that are determined by the equations of motion. It is these coefficients that will be crucial in evaluating ⟨Xi⟩(t)\langle X_i\rangle(t). The coefficients depend on overall constants of integration, which we fix by imposing the normalization conditions

⟨ψ1∣ψ1⟩+⟨ψ2∣ψ2⟩=N,⟨ψ1∣ψ1⟩−⟨ψ2∣ψ2⟩=τ,and⟨ψ2∣ψ1⟩=γ.(6)\langle\psi_1|\psi_1\rangle+\langle\psi_2|\psi_2\rangle=N,\qquad\langle\psi_1|\psi_1\rangle-\langle\psi_2|\psi_2\rangle=\tau,\qquad\text{and}\qquad\langle\psi_2|\psi_1\rangle=\gamma. \tag*{(6)}

Step 3 is the evaluation of ⟨Xk⟩(t)\langle X_k\rangle(t), using the information obtained in step 2. ⟨Xk⟩(t)\langle X_k\rangle(t) will depend on the matrix elements ⟨Ai∣Xk∣Aj⟩\langle A_i|X_k|A_j\rangle, which, in the case of a free particle, will be at most linear functions of time. For the purposes of this investigation, we specialize to the case in which the ⟨Ai∣Xk∣Aj⟩\langle A_i|X_k|A_j\rangle are simply constants, because we are interested in the motion induced by the non-linearity, and not the linear motion of the system as a whole.

In ref. [13] we carried out this sequence of steps analytically for a very simple case, in which κ\kappa is a constant and τ=0\tau= 0. The result was an elliptic (or possibly circular) trajectory in which the particle moves harmonically about the center. A full analytic treatment of other cases has so far not proved possible. In this paper we perturb about the simple solution and also perform a numerical investigation of the properties of more general trajectories.

The τ−δ\tau-\delta equations follow directly from the equations of motion. They are

dκdt=−2(b+μ)τ(7)\frac{d\kappa}{dt}=-2(b+\mu)\tau \tag*{(7)}

and

dτdt=μ(N2−τ2)+4beκ(8)\frac{d\tau}{dt}=\mu(N^2-\tau^2)+4be^\kappa \tag*{(8)}

where δ=eκ\delta=e^\kappa. These equations admit a first integral:

N2=τ2+4eκ+cepκ,(9)N^2=\tau^2+4e^\kappa+ce^{p\kappa}, \tag*{(9)}

where p=μb+μp=\frac{\mu}{b+\mu} and cc is a constant of integration. As shown in [13], the Schwarz inequality requires cc to be non-negative. κ\kappa satisfies the equation of motion of a classical particle in one dimension, with momentum τ\tau, moving in the potential V(κ)=4eκ+cepκV(\kappa)=4e^\kappa+ce^{p\kappa}. As in previous work, we choose p<0p<0, so that the motion of κ\kappa is bounded and periodic.

It is convenient to write our equations in 2×22\times2 matrix form. We define time-dependent functions χi(t)\chi_i(t) and ξi(t)\xi_i(t), i=1,2i=1,2, via

∣ψ1⟩=epκ/4e−12Nλt[χ1∣A1⟩+χ2∣A2⟩](10)|\psi_1\rangle=e^{p\kappa/4}e^{-\frac{1}{2}N\lambda t}\left[\chi_1|A_1\rangle+\chi_2|A_2\rangle\right] \tag*{(10)}

and

∣ψ2⟩=epκ/4e12Nλt[ξ1∣A1⟩+ξ2∣A2⟩](11)|\psi_2\rangle=e^{p\kappa/4}e^{\frac{1}{2}N\lambda t}\left[\xi_1|A_1\rangle+\xi_2|A_2\rangle\right] \tag*{(11)}

As noted above, the ∣Ai⟩|A_i\rangle are 2 linearly independent vectors that evolve according to the underlying Hamiltonian HH, and are normalized as ⟨Ai∣Aj⟩=δij\langle A_i|A_j\rangle=\delta_{ij}.

From the equations of motion, the matrix

Z=(χ1χ2ξ1ξ2)(12)Z=\begin{pmatrix}\chi_1&\chi_2\\ \xi_1&\xi_2\end{pmatrix} \tag*{(12)}

then satisfies

Z˙=MZ(13)\dot{Z}=MZ \tag*{(13)}

with

M=(N2(μ+iλ)−i(g+λ)γ′−i(g∗−λ)γ′∗−N2(μ+iλ)).(14)M=\begin{pmatrix} \frac{N}{2}(\mu+i\lambda)&-i(g+\lambda)\gamma'\\ -i(g^*-\lambda)\gamma'^*&-\frac{N}{2}(\mu+i\lambda) \end{pmatrix}. \tag*{(14)}

Here γ=⟨ψ2∣ψ1⟩=γ′e−iNλt\gamma=\langle\psi_2|\psi_1\rangle=\gamma'e^{-iN\lambda t}, and

References

  1. [1]T. W. B. Kibble, Relativistic models of nonlinear quantum mechanics, Communications in Mathematical Physics 64, 73 (1978).DOI
  2. [2]T. W. B. Kibble, Geometrization of quantum mechanics, Communications in Mathematical Physics 65, 189 (1979).DOI
  3. [3]D. E. Kaplan and S. Rajendran, Causal framework for nonlinear quantum mechanics, Physical Review D 105, 055002 (2022).DOI
  4. [4]D. E. Kaplan and S. Rajendran, A solution to the hierarchy problem with non-linear quantum mechanics (2025), arXiv:2510.12030, arXiv:2510.12030.arxiv.org/abs/2510.12030
  5. [5]S. Weinberg, Testing quantum mechanics, Annals of Physics 194, 336 (1989).DOI
  6. [6]N. Gisin, Weinberg’s non-linear quantum mechanics and supraluminal communications, Physics Letters A 143, 1 (1990).DOI
  7. [7]J. Polchinski, Weinberg’s nonlinear quantum mechanics and the Einstein–Podolsky–Rosen paradox, Physical Review Letters 66, 397 (1991).pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/10043797
  8. [8]S. D. H. Hsu, Relativistic covariance and nonlinear quantum mechanics: Tomonaga–Schwinger analysis, Physics Letters B 872, 140053 (2026).arxiv.org/abs/2511.15935
  9. [9]R. Penrose, On the gravitation of quantum mechanics 1: Quantum state reduction, Foundations of Physics 44, 557 (2014).DOI
  10. [10]S. Carlip, Is quantum gravity necessary?, Classical and Quantum Gravity 25, 154010 (2008).DOI
  11. [11]A. Chodos and F. Cooper, A solvable model of a nonlinear extension of quantum mechanics, Physica Scripta 98, 045227 (2023).DOI
  12. [12]A. Chodos and F. Cooper, Geometric interpretation of a non-linear extension of quantum mechanics, Symmetry 16, 887 (2024).DOI
  13. [13]A. Chodos and F. Cooper, A generalized nonlinear extension of quantum mechanics, Symmetry 17, 1850 (2025).
  14. [14]G. Floquet, Sur les équations différentielles linéaires à coefficients périodiques, Annales scientifiques de l’École Normale Supérieure 2, 12, 47 (1883).DOI
  15. [15]C. Chicone, Ordinary Differential Equations with Applications, 3rd ed., Texts in Applied Mathematics, Vol. 34 (Springer, Cham, 2024).
  16. [16]A. Mostafazadeh, Pseudo-unitary operators and pseudo-unitary quantum dynamics, Journal of Mathematical Physics 45, 932 (2004), arXiv:math-ph/0302050.DOI
  17. [17]I. Bengtsson and K. Życzkowski, Geometry of Quantum States: An Introduction to Quantum Entanglement, 2nd ed. (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, 2017).
  18. [18]J. H. Shirley, Solution of the Schrödinger equation with a hamiltonian periodic in time, Physical Review 138, B979 (1965).DOI
  19. [19]H. Sambe, Steady states and quasienergies of a quantum-mechanical system in an oscillating field, Physical Review A 7, 2203 (1973).DOI
  20. [20]B. Helou and Y. Chen, Extensions of Born’s rule to non-linear quantum mechanics, some of which do not imply superluminal communication, Journal of Physics: Conference Series 880, 012021 (2017).DOI
  21. [21]A. Bassi and K. Hejazi, No-faster-than-light-signaling implies linear evolution: A re-derivation, European Journal of Physics 36, 055027 (2015), arXiv:1411.1768 [quant-ph].DOI

Paper details

vlnc:W_ukm8uv9x
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 11

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Physics and Astronomy

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents