WorksPhysics and Astronomy
Transient Synchronization and Entanglement through Shared Dissipation in Circuit QED
Abstract
We propose a superconducting circuit in which two resonators couple through DC-biased SQUIDs to a common lossy auxiliary mode. Adiabatic elimination yields collective damping and correlated noise with an overlap whose magnitude is tuned by the flux biases and whose sign follows the relative sign of the couplings. The full three-mode dynamics confirm this reduced description. For detuned resonators, we derive the exceptional-point condition, above which the mean amplitudes lock to a common frequency. For resonant modes, unequal collective decay produces transient synchronization, antiphase or in phase depending on the relative sign of the couplings, with an analytical synchronization time set by the collective decay splitting and the initial mean amplitudes. For initially separable squeezed states, the same relaxation converts local squeezing into transient entanglement, quantified by logarithmic negativity. We obtain closed-form expressions for the squeezing threshold above which entanglement appears and for the time at which it disappears. Thermal noise suppresses entanglement without changing the mean-amplitude synchronization time at fixed parameters. For realistic circuit parameters, these effects occur within a few hundred nanoseconds and are accessible through output-field measurements. A single tunable shared channel thus produces an exceptional point, transient synchronization, and transient entanglement, and provides a controllable source of correlated noise for superconducting circuits.
Introduction
In 1665, Christiaan Huygens observed antiphase synchronization between two pendulum clocks coupled through a common support [1]. Modern experiments with clocks and metronomes demonstrate how the coupling structure selects synchronized motion [2, 3]. In open quantum systems, a common reservoir provides a related mechanism: unequal damping of collective modes allows a slowly decaying contribution to dominate, establishing a fixed phase relation between oscillators [4, 5].
Reservoir engineering uses dissipation for quantum-state preparation [6, 7], including entanglement stabilization in superconducting circuits [8]. Bittner and Tyagi showed that correlated dissipative environments can select long-lived phase-synchronized motion through the symmetry of the dissipator [9]. A circuit realization must connect these effective correlations to tunable parameters and establish how private losses and thermal fluctuations affect both collective motion and quantum correlations.
A strongly damped auxiliary mode provides a shared reservoir and mediates dissipative interactions [10, 11]. Such interactions connect reservoir engineering to non-Hermitian spectral physics, including level attraction and exceptional points, where eigenvalues and eigenvectors coalesce [12, 13, 14]. Exceptional points have been observed in superconducting circuits, both in tunable resonators [15] and in a dissipative qubit [16]. For balanced losses and opposite detunings, dissipative coupling realizes anti-parity–time symmetry [17]. Exceptional points and synchronization are nevertheless distinct: selection of a slowly decaying collective mode does not require spectral coalescence.
Here, we propose a superconducting circuit that supports exceptional points, transient synchronization, and transient entanglement through tunable shared dissipation. Two system resonators couple to a lossy auxiliary resonator through DC-biased SQUIDs, while independent transmission lines provide private loss channels and readout ports. The design uses flux-tunable resonator couplings [18] and established circuit-QED elements [19, 20]. All couplings are static, with no direct coherent coupling between the system resonators. Eliminating the auxiliary mode yields collective damping and correlated input noise. We relate the normalized cross-decay coefficient to the circuit couplings and decay rates: its magnitude is set by the flux biases, while its sign follows the relative sign of the two couplings and determines which collective mode is protected from the shared channel. We check the reduced description against the full three-mode dynamics throughout.
For detuned resonators, we derive the exceptional-point condition at fixed private loss. Above the exceptional point, the mean amplitudes lock to a common frequency with a fixed relative phase. Comparison with the full three-mode spectrum shows that the finite response time of the auxiliary mode shifts the exceptional point by an amount that scales as . For equal system frequencies, we obtain the time required to reach a prescribed antiphase tolerance; for couplings of opposite sign the same analysis gives in-phase alignment. This time is set by the collective decay splitting and the initial mean amplitudes, and numerical integration confirms the analytical prediction.
For initially separable squeezed states, we solve the reduced covariance dynamics and quantify entanglement using the logarithmic negativity [21, 22, 23]. Unequal collective relaxation converts local squeezing into transient intermode entanglement. We derive closed-form expressions for the squeezing threshold above which entanglement appears and for the time at which it disappears, and we examine the effects of shared coupling, thermal occupation, and the amount of initial squeezing. Entanglement and antiphase alignment can coexist, but they remain distinct: synchronization concerns decaying first moments, whereas entanglement concerns centered quantum fluctuations.
For realistic circuit parameters, these effects occur within a few hundred nanoseconds and persist at thermal occupations an order of magnitude higher than those of typical devices. We describe how the squeezed initial states can be prepared with a parametric pump, and how both the synchronization criterion and the covariance matrix are obtained from output-field quadrature measurements, including the surviving antiphase signal at the synchronization threshold. Because can be calibrated from two ring-down rates, the circuit also provides a controllable source of correlated noise for studying correlated errors in superconducting processors [24, 25].
Section II presents the circuit, the reduced dynamics, and the physical parameters. Section III discusses the exceptional-point spectrum, synchronization, and entanglement. Section IV addresses state preparation, readout, and imperfections, and Section V summarizes the findings and discusses possible applications.
Model
Circuit model
We consider two superconducting resonators, and , coupled to a common lossy auxiliary resonator , as shown in Figure 1. The system resonators are represented by the parallel LC circuits and , and the auxiliary resonator by . Each system resonator is coupled to through a DC-biased SQUID, whose flux bias sets the coupling strength [18]. There is no direct coupling between and . Each resonator is also coupled through a capacitor to an independent 50 transmission line, which produces private energy decay of the system modes and strong damping of the auxiliary mode [19, 26]. When this damping is large, acts as a common reservoir for and .

Figure 1. Circuit realizing a shared dissipation channel. The system resonators and (blue) couple to the lossy auxiliary resonator (orange) through two DC-biased SQUIDs, whose fluxes and set and . The capacitors , , and couple the modes to independent 50 lines, producing the energy-decay rates , , and . There is no direct coupling between the system resonators.
We work in the small-phase, linear regime of the SQUIDs and employ the rotating-wave approximation. Since the couplings are static, and are real. Their magnitudes are set by the flux biases, while their signs are fixed by the circuit geometry, i.e., by the polarity with which each coupler is connected to its resonator. We keep the signs general in Sec. II B, since the relative sign of and determines which collective mode is protected from the shared channel. The resonance frequencies include the local reactive shifts from the couplers and ports.
We use dimensionless units with the private energy-decay rate as the reference scale. Time is measured in units of , so that ; frequencies, coupling strengths, and decay rates are measured in units of , and energies in units of . We retain the same symbols for the scaled parameters, and an overdot denotes . Input fields are normalized with respect to , while mode operators and quadrature variances are unchanged. Physical values are given in Sec. II C.
In a frame rotating at the auxiliary frequency , the Hamiltonian is
where . The Markov quantum Langevin equations are
The inputs are independent, zero-mean thermal fields. Writing , , and , their nonvanishing second moments are
where . The occupations are taken constant over the relevant bandwidth, and all anomalous input correlations vanish.
The private lines also serve as readout ports. With the sign convention of Eqs. (2) and (3), the field leaving resonator is
Since the inputs have zero mean, , so averaged output traces give the mean amplitudes of both resonators directly. The fluctuations of carry the intracavity covariances. The quantities computed in Sec. III are therefore accessible through the private ports; the measurement is discussed in Sec. IV.
Effective dissipative coupling
We eliminate the auxiliary mode in the regime
Setting in Eq. (4) gives
Keeping the detunings in the response of replaces by . The resulting corrections, of relative order , introduce frequency shifts and a coherent exchange between and , and are neglected here. Substitution gives the reduced equations
where
and the effective noise forces are
The local rates depend only on , whereas the cross-damping and the shared part of the noise carry the relative sign of the couplings. These equations describe private damping of each mode together with a collective dissipator with jump operator . The cross-damping and the correlated fluctuations thus originate from the same channel and must be retained together.
We characterize the shared channel by
For positive private decay rates and finite couplings, : the magnitude of is set by the flux biases and its sign by the relative sign of and . The normalized effective inputs satisfy
and their cross-correlations are
The local effective occupations are
so that
Thus measures the overlap of the effective input channels. For unequal reservoir occupations, it need not equal the cross-correlation normalized by the local thermal noise powers. The circuit realizes the correlated dissipation of Ref. [9] without a direct coherent coupling between the oscillators. The auxiliary mode couples only to the bright combination , while the orthogonal combination
is decoupled from the shared channel and is damped only by the private losses. For , this dark mode is the antisymmetric combination when the couplings have equal signs (), and the symmetric combination when they have opposite signs (). Because and interact only through , the two cases are related by the local phase rotation , which reverses the sign of and of . This transformation leaves the decay rates, the eigenvalue spectrum, and the entanglement unchanged, and only shifts the relative phase of the long-lived collective motion from to .
Hereafter we consider symmetric private decay and couplings of equal sign, and , so that ; the results for follow from . Then and . At fixed private decay, the coupling sweep is parameterized by
and
In this configuration the coupling condition in Eq. (8) reads , or equivalently , so larger values of require a larger .
For , the reduced dynamics take the form
where and
The creation operators obey the complex-conjugate equations. Both the local damping and the cross-damping vary with . Reservoir occupations enter the noise correlations but not ; consequently, its eigenvalues and the mean amplitudes are independent of these occupations for fixed rates and initial first moments.
Two detuning configurations are used below. Opposite detunings, and , with , are used to investigate exceptional points. Resonant modes, , are used for synchronization and entanglement; a common detuning would only add a common rotation in the reduced model while increasing the neglected corrections. Varying at fixed detunings and private decay assumes that the frequency shifts accompanying changes of the SQUID flux biases are compensated.
Physical parameters
To connect the scaled parameters to a device, we take resonance frequencies near 5 GHz, a private decay rate MHz, and an auxiliary decay rate MHz, so that in scaled units. The time unit is then . For , Eq. (24) gives MHz and ; for , MHz and . These couplings are well within the range of flux-tunable couplers between superconducting resonators [18]. All rates remain small compared with the resonance frequencies, consistent with the rotating-wave and Markov approximations. The private decay is dominated by the engineered port loss: an internal quality factor near contributes an internal decay rate of kHz, about 1% of .
Results
Exceptional point
For opposite detunings, , the drift matrix of Eq. (26) can be written as , with the effective non-Hermitian Hamiltonian
The coupling is purely imaginary, so is anti-PT symmetric [17]. The eigenvalues of are
For , the two eigenvalues and their eigenvectors coalesce at , giving
Below this point, the modes have equal decay rates and different oscillation frequencies. Above it, their frequencies coincide in the rotating frame while their decay rates split. The transition is driven entirely by the shared dissipation; no direct coherent coupling between the system resonators is needed. For the parameters of § 2 C, a mismatch corresponds to kHz, and the exceptional point is reached at MHz.
To assess the elimination, we compare these eigenvalues with the two slow branches of the full three-mode drift matrix,
with given by Eq. (24), so that the same value of specifies corresponding full and reduced parameters. Figure 2 shows close agreement between the slow branches. The finite response time of the auxiliary mode shifts the coalescence point slightly, from to , a relative shift of 0.5%. This shift scales as ; halving to 100 doubles it. The rapidly decaying auxiliary branch is not shown.

Figure 2. Exceptional-point structure of the full and reduced models at fixed private decay. (a) Real and (b) imaginary parts of the two slow eigenvalues as functions of . (c) Eigenvalue splitting near the coalescence points. Solid orange and dashed blue curves denote the full and reduced models, respectively. The vertical orange dash-dotted and blue dotted lines mark their respective exceptional points. Parameters are and (). Eigenvalues are in units of , and is varied according to Eq. (24).
Mean-amplitude synchronization
Above the exceptional point, the mean amplitudes lock to a common frequency. The slower eigenvector, belonging to , satisfies
where . The two resonators therefore oscillate with equal amplitudes and a fixed phase difference , which approaches antiphase for and reduces to at the exceptional point. Below the exceptional point, the two eigenmodes have different frequencies and the relative phase does not settle. For identical resonators, , the locked state is exactly antiphase; we use this limit below because it admits closed-form expressions. For couplings of opposite sign, , the eigenvalues are unchanged and , so the locked state approaches in-phase motion instead.
Mean-amplitude synchronization
For resonant modes, , we introduce the collective modes . Their equations are
where and
The symmetric mode couples to the shared reservoir, whereas the shared noise and damping cancel from the antisymmetric mode. The latter is dark with respect to the shared channel but still undergoes private decay. This mechanism is the common-bath route to synchronization studied in Refs. [4, 5]; here it arises from an explicit circuit element whose strength is set by the SQUID flux bias.
Since the input fields have zero mean, the collective amplitudes obey
For and , the faster decay of the symmetric component leads to the antiphase relation . For couplings of opposite sign the roles of are exchanged, the symmetric mode is dark, and the resonators synchronize in phase; the expressions below then hold with and interchanged, so that is replaced by . We quantify the remaining symmetric component by
where . For a tolerance $0<\epsilon<1$, the synchronization time is the earliest time after which $R\le\epsilon remains satisfied. For nonzero initial symmetric and antisymmetric components,
For and ,
An initially antisymmetric mean has , while an initially symmetric mean has no antisymmetric component and never reaches the antiphase condition. If both means vanish, the criterion is undefined.
This criterion describes antiphase alignment of decaying mean amplitudes rather than sustained oscillations, and sets the allowed symmetric admixture. At fixed drift parameters and initial means, is independent of the bath occupations and of the initial squeezing.
Figure 3 illustrates the initial-phase dependence at . An initially symmetric mean remains symmetric and decays rapidly, whereas any nonzero antisymmetric component eventually dominates. Increasing the initial phase difference toward reduces the symmetric admixture and hence the synchronization time. Numerical integration agrees with Eq. (37). These trajectories are the same for coherent and displaced squeezed initial states with the same and . For and , , which corresponds to about for the parameters of § 2 C.
In the full three-mode model with , is 3–4% shorter for the initial phases shown, because the exact decay rate of the symmetric mode slightly exceeds . This difference scales as .
Gaussian dynamics and entanglement
We introduce the quadratures
with , so the vacuum variance is . For , the centered covariance matrix is
The system is initially prepared in a product of displaced squeezed states,
where and , with equal real so that both modes are squeezed along the same quadrature. The initial covariance is
which does not depend on the displacements.
The linear dynamics with thermal Gaussian inputs preserve Gaussianity [23], and the covariance evolves as
with

Figure 3. Initial-state dependence of antiphase synchronization in the reduced model. (a)–(g) Evolution of (solid orange) and (dashed blue) for and , with , , , , , , . The common reference rotation is applied for visibility only and does not affect or . Dotted vertical lines mark the analytical synchronization times; triangles mark the numerically determined threshold crossings. Shading indicates . (h) Analytical synchronization time versus the initial phase (solid curve), with numerical values (markers). Parameters are (, ), , and . The reduced model describes the device of § 2 C with ; at fixed , the curves do not depend on .
For equal input occupations , the diffusion matrix is , with . The stationary covariance is then , and
Entanglement is quantified by the logarithmic negativity [22]. Partial transposition of mode 2 reverses , with . Writing in blocks , , and , and defining , the smallest symplectic eigenvalue of is
and
For two-mode Gaussian states, is necessary and sufficient for entanglement [21].
The collective decay hierarchy that produces synchronization also converts local squeezing into intermode entanglement. To see this, we use the quadratures of the collective modes introduced in Sec. III B,
In the physical basis, each quadrature is damped at the rate and coupled to the other resonator through the cross-damping . In the collective basis, the cross-damping adds to the symmetric rate and cancels from the antisymmetric one, so becomes diagonal with entries , where are the rates of Eq. (33). For equal occupations, the collective noises are uncorrelated. Since both resonators are squeezed identically, has the same diagonal form in the collective basis. The collective covariance therefore remains diagonal, with variances
Partial transposition interchanges and , so that
Both products equal at . Entanglement develops when the anti-squeezed variance of the symmetric mode relaxes quickly while the squeezed variance of the antisymmetric mode degrades slowly, giving . Initial squeezing supplies the nonclassical resource, and the shared channel converts it into entanglement between the resonators. For couplings of opposite sign, and exchange roles and the relevant product becomes ; since the two cases are related by the local rotation , is unchanged.
The disappearance of entanglement can be estimated in closed form. For , the symmetric mode reaches quickly, and the condition becomes . This holds until
Since depends only on the antisymmetric mode, it is independent of once is large. For (), the denominator vanishes and the entanglement decays only asymptotically.
The dynamics contain neither parametric pair creation nor a squeezed reservoir. For coherent initial states (), passive linear evolution with thermal inputs keeps the Glauber function positive and cannot generate entanglement. For the entanglement is transient, since private damping drives both collective modes to the same thermal covariance. The role of squeezing is also visible in the centered anomalous correlation , with :
A nonzero is not sufficient for entanglement, because thermal fluctuations can render the state separable while remains finite.
The onset of entanglement also follows from Eq. (50). The product equals at , and it falls below immediately afterward when its initial slope is negative. With , this condition reads
The smaller root of the left-hand side gives the threshold squeezing above which entanglement appears. For , Eq. (53) gives , 1.06, and 2.13 dB for , 0.1, and 0.2, in agreement with the numerical thresholds to within 0.01 dB. The quadratic has no real roots when , that is, for . Numerically, we find no entanglement for at any squeezing up to 17 dB.
Figure 4 shows for initial squeezing of 6.5 dB () and 3 dB (). At fixed [Figure 4(a)], increasing separates the collective decay rates and enhances the peak entanglement: and 0.4 give none, gives a weak transient, and and 0.9 give pronounced peaks. The and 0.9 curves vanish at the same time, , which coincides with Eq. (51) because both and are large compared with .

Figure 4. Transient entanglement generated by collective dissipation, obtained from Eq. (42) (solid lines). (a) Dependence on at fixed , with the private decay held fixed. (b) Dependence on at fixed . (c) Same as (b) for 3 dB of initial squeezing. Panels (a) and (b) use 6.5 dB () and panel (c) 3 dB () of squeezing, with identical squeezing orientations and . Dashed black lines in (a) and (b) show the full three-mode model with . In (b), the dotted line marks for , , and , and the shaded band marks the coexistence of and for . Displacements affect the synchronization marker but not .
At fixed [Figure 4(b)], increasing raises the diffusion without changing the drift. Both the peak entanglement and its lifetime decrease, and no entanglement is obtained for . Equation (51) gives , 0.98, and 0.54 for , 0.1, and 0.2, close to the numerical values 1.52, 0.98, and 0.52. For the parameters of § 2 C, corresponds to about .
At 5 GHz, corresponds to an effective temperature of about 100 mK. Superconducting resonators in dilution refrigerators typically thermalize near 40–60 mK, where . The value is therefore conservative, and Figure 4(b) shows that the entanglement survives at occupations an order of magnitude above the expected value; Eq. (53) sets the limit at for . For , Eq. (51) gives , or about .
With 3 dB of initial squeezing [Figure 4(c)], the entanglement is weaker and shorter-lived, with a peak that vanishes at for . Since 3 dB lies above the threshold for , entanglement persists for all occupations except , although it becomes weak for .
The full three-mode covariance dynamics with , including the auxiliary mode , reproduce these results [dashed lines in Figure 4(a) and Figure 4(b)]. For and and all occupations shown, the peak differs by less than 2% and the time at which entanglement vanishes agrees to within 0.01. The only visible difference is a short initial delay, during which the auxiliary mode builds up its correlations with the system modes.
The synchronization time is unaffected by , because the first moments do not depend on the occupations. For and , , so at antiphase alignment and entanglement coexist over [shaded in Figure 4(b)]. The width of this window depends on and . The two effects share their origin in the collective decay hierarchy but are distinct: synchronization concerns the first moments, whereas concerns the centered fluctuations. Coherent initial states show the same synchronization while remaining separable.
Experimental considerations
Preparation of the squeezed initial state
The entanglement results of Sec. III C require each system resonator to be squeezed before . This can be done with a flux-pumped SQUID in each system resonator, as in flux-driven Josephson parametric amplifiers [27]. Modulating its flux at generates the squeezing Hamiltonian , and a pump pulse of duration produces in the absence of loss. The pump is switched off before . Afterward the flux through this SQUID is static, so it only renormalizes , and the dynamics remain those of the time-independent model of § 2.
In the steady state, intracavity squeezing generated by a parametric drive on a damped mode is limited to 3 dB. A short pump pulse with avoids this limit, because the private loss acts only weakly during the pulse. Intracavity squeezing beyond 3 dB has also been demonstrated by reservoir engineering [28]. For the parameters of § 2 C, a pump rate MHz reaches 6.5 dB in about 26 ns, including the private loss during the pulse. This is an order of magnitude shorter than , and the resulting state has a purity of about 0.95. A pump rate of 3 MHz requires about 45 ns.
During the preparation, the couplers should be biased at a weakly coupled point, so that the shared channel does not act on the resonators while they are being squeezed. Stepping the flux biases to the operating point then starts the dynamics at . The step switches between two static configurations, and the auxiliary mode relaxes to its thermal state within ns. This is the initial condition used in the full three-mode calculations of Sec. III.
Readout
Both quantities studied in Sec. III are obtained from the fields leaving the private ports, Eq. (7). Averaged heterodyne records give , and hence and .
For equal private decay rates, is independent of once the gain and phase of the two detection chains are calibrated against each other.
At the synchronization threshold the antiphase signal is still large. The antisymmetric amplitude has decayed only by the factor , which equals 0.66 for . The demanding part of the measurement is resolving the symmetric admixture at the level , which requires averaging over many repetitions. Since the resonators return to equilibrium within a few microseconds, repetitions take less than one second.
The covariance matrix, and hence , follows from the second moments of the amplified output records. The added noise of the amplification chain is subtracted using reference measurements with the resonators in their thermal state [29, 30]. Near-quantum-limited amplifiers [31] reduce the number of repetitions required. Reconstructing the intracavity covariance requires temporal mode matching: the output records are integrated with filter functions matched to the resonator modes, and the measured moments are related to the intracavity moments through Eq. (7) [30]. Because evolves on the timescale , the filter windows must be short compared with it, or the measured output correlations can be compared directly with the model.
The dynamics last about , and their fastest timescale is the decay of the symmetric mode, at rate MHz for . A detection bandwidth of several megahertz is therefore sufficient. This is well within the bandwidth of current readout chains, including traveling-wave parametric amplifiers [31]. The strongly damped auxiliary port does not need to be measured.
Imperfections
Coupling asymmetry. For equal private decay and , the combination remains an exact eigenmode of the reduced drift matrix, decaying at the private rate. The long-time state is then still antiphase, but with amplitude ratio . Unequal private decay rates, , mix this mode with the bright mode; the admixture is small when .
Residual detuning. A residual frequency mismatch above the exceptional point shifts the locked relative phase from to , according to Eq. (31). For () and , the shift is 0.025 rad.
Flux noise. Away from zero flux, the SQUID inductance depends on to first order, so flux noise modulates both and the resonator frequencies. Since the relevant dynamics last a few hundred nanoseconds, slow flux drift mainly produces shot-to-shot variation of and of the detunings. This variation can be reduced by operating close to zero flux, where the inductance is first-order insensitive.
Conclusion
We have proposed a superconducting circuit in which two resonators share a dissipation channel through a strongly damped auxiliary resonator, with the couplings set by static flux biases of two DC SQUIDs. Adiabatic elimination of the auxiliary mode yields cross-damping and correlated noise that originate from the same collective dissipator. The magnitude of the shared-channel parameter is tuned continuously within by the coupler biases, while its sign is fixed by the relative sign of the two couplings. The circuit thus realizes the correlated dissipation of Ref. [9] without a direct coherent coupling between the resonators.
The shared channel produces three effects. For detuned resonators, the eigenvalues coalesce at an exceptional point , above which the mean amplitudes lock to a common frequency with a fixed relative phase. For identical resonators, the collective mode that couples to the auxiliary resonator decays faster than the dark mode, which drives the mean amplitudes into antiphase alignment for couplings of equal sign and into in-phase alignment for couplings of opposite sign. The synchronization time is set by the collective decay splitting and the initial mean amplitudes. When the resonators are initially squeezed, the same decay hierarchy converts local squeezing into transient entanglement. We obtained closed-form expressions for the squeezing threshold above which entanglement appears and for the time at which it disappears. Synchronization and entanglement share this origin but remain distinct: the former concerns first moments and also occurs for coherent states, whereas the latter requires initial squeezing and is limited by thermal noise. The full three-mode dynamics confirm the reduced description to within a few percent for . For a private decay rate MHz, these effects occur within about , persist at thermal occupations an order of magnitude higher than those of typical devices, and are accessible through the output fields of the private ports. Beyond realizing the Bittner–Tyagi model, the circuit is useful in its own right because the noise correlation is set by the coupler fluxes and, for identical modes, can be calibrated from the two collective ring-down rates, . It can therefore serve as a controllable source of correlated noise, a test bed for the correlated errors that limit error correction in superconducting processors [24, 25]. The dark mode, which decays only through the private losses, is a bosonic analogue of a decoherence-free subspace [32] whose protection can be switched with the flux. Since the entanglement leaks out through the two independent lines, the device can also serve as a source of entangled microwave fields that requires no two-mode pump [33].
Data availability
The code and data that support the findings of this article will be made openly available upon publication.
Acknowledgments
This work was supported by the National Science Foundation under Grant No. CHE-2404788 and the Robert A. Welch Foundation (Grant No. E-1337).
Author contributions
Areeda Ayoub conceived the circuit-based approach to engineering thermal correlations, developed the model, performed the analytical and numerical calculations, prepared the figures, and wrote the initial manuscript. Eric Bittner provided scientific guidance, helped refine the research direction, and supervised the project. Both authors contributed to interpreting the results and reviewing and editing the manuscript.
Declaration of AI assistance
During this work, the authors used ChatGPT (OpenAI) and Claude (Anthropic) to assist with discussions of the theoretical model, checking analytical derivations, developing and reviewing numerical and plotting code, verifying references, and drafting and editing the manuscript. All AI-assisted material was critically reviewed and verified by the authors, who take full responsibility for the accuracy and integrity of the reported results and the final manuscript.
Conflicts of Interest
The authors declare no competing financial or non-financial interests.
References
- [1]M. Bennett, M. F. Schatz, H. Rockwood, and K. Wiesenfeld, Proc. R. Soc. Lond. A 458, 563 (2002).
- [2]J. Pantalone, Am. J. Phys. 70, 999 (2002).
- [3]J. Peña Ramirez, L. A. Olvera, H. Nijmeijer, and J. Alvarez, Sci. Rep. 6, 23580 (2016).
- [4]G. L. Giorgi, F. Galve, G. Manzano, P. Colet, and R. Zambrini, Phys. Rev. A 85, 052101 (2012).
- [5]G. Manzano, F. Galve, G. L. Giorgi, E. Hernández-García, and R. Zambrini, Sci. Rep. 3, 1439 (2013).
- [6]J. F. Poyatos, J. I. Cirac, and P. Zoller, Phys. Rev. Lett. 77, 4728 (1996).
- [7]F. Verstraete, M. M. Wolf, and J. I. Cirac, Nat. Phys. 5, 633 (2009).
- [8]S. Shankar, M. Hartridge, Z. Leghtas, K. M. Sliwa, A. Narla, U. Vool, S. M. Girvin, L. Frunzio, M. Mirrahimi, and M. H. Devoret, Nat. 504, 419 (2013).
- [9]E. R. Bittner and B. Tyagi, J. Chem. Phys. 162, 104116 (2025).
- [10]A. Metelmann and A. A. Clerk, Phys. Rev. X 5, 021025 (2015).
- [11]W. Yu, J. Wang, H. Y. Yuan, and J. Xiao, Phys. Rev. Lett. 123, 227201 (2019).
- [12]M. Harder, Y. Yang, B. M. Yao, C. H. Yu, J. W. Rao, Y. S. Gui, R. L. Stamps, and C.-M. Hu, Phys. Rev. Lett. 121, 137203 (2018).
- [13]M.-A. Miri and A. Alù, Sci. 363, eaar7709 (2019).
- [14]Y. Ashida, Z. Gong, and M. Ueda, Adv. Phys. 69, 249 (2020).
- [15]M. Partanen, J. Goetz, K. Y. Tan, K. Kohvakka, V. Sevriuk, R. E. Lake, R. Kokkonie mi, J. Ikonen, D. Hazra, A. Mäkinen, E. Hyyp pä, L. Grönberg, V. Vesterinen, M. Silveri, and M. Möttönen, Phys. Rev. B 100, 134505 (2019).
- [16]M. Naghi loo, M. Abbasi, Y. N. Jog le kar, and K. W. Murch, Nat. Phys. 15, 1232 (2019).
- [17]P. Peng, W. Cao, C. Shen, W. Qu, J. Wen, L. Jiang, and Y. Xiao, Nat. Phys. 12, 1139 (2016).
- [18]B. Peropadre, D. Zueco, F. Wulschner, F. Deppe, A. Marx, R. Gross, and J. J. García-Ripoll, Phys. Rev. B 87, 134504 (2013).
- [19]M. Cattaneo and G. S. Paraoanu, Adv. Quantum Technol. 4, 2100054 (2021).
- [20]A. Blais, A. L. Grimsmo, S. M. Girvin, and A. Wallraff, Rev. Mod. Phys. 93, 025005 (2021).
- [21]R. Simon, Phys. Rev. Lett. 84, 2726 (2000).
- [22]G. Vidal and R. F. Werner, Phys. Rev. A 65, 032314 (2002).
- [23]C. Weedbrook, S. Pirandola, R. García-Patrón, N. J. C. F. T. C. Ralph, J. H. Shapiro, and S. Lloyd, Rev. Mod. Phys. 84, 621 (2012).
- [24]C. D. Wilson, S. Abdullah, N. A. Kurinsky, C. Stanford, L. Cardani, G. D’Imperio, C. Tomei, L. Faoro, L. B. Ioffe, C. H. Liu, A. Ompreczak, B. G. Christensen, J. L. DuBois, and R. McDermott, Nature 594, 369 (2021).
- [25]M. McEwen, L. Faoro, K. Arya, A. Dunsworth, T. Huang, S. Kim, B. Burkett, A. Fowler, F. Arute, J. C. Bardin, A. Bengtsson, A. Bilmes, B. B. Buckley, N. Bushnell, Z. Chen, R. Collins, S. Demura, A. R. Derk, C. Erickson, M. Giustina, S. D. Harrington, S. Hong, E. Jeffrey, J. Kelly, P. V. Klimov, F. Kostr it sa, P. Laptev, A. Locharla, X. Mi, K. C. Miao, S. Montazeri, J. Mutus, O. Naaman, M. Neeley, C. Neill, A. Opre mack, C. Quintana, N. Redd, P. Roushan, D. Sank, K. J. Satzinger, V. Shvarts, T. White, Z. J. Yao, P. Yeh, J. Yoo, Y. Chen, V. Smelyansky, J. M. Martinis, H. Neven, A. Megrant, L. Ioffe, and R. Barends, Nat. Phys. 18, 107 (2022).
- [26]P. Krantz, M. Kjaergaard, F. Yan, T. P. Orlando, S. Gustavsson, and W. D. Oliver, Appl. Phys. Rev. 6, 021318 (2019).
- [27]T. Yamamoto, K. Inomata, M. Watanabe, K. Matsuba, T. Miyazaki, W. D. Oliver, Y. Nakamura, and J. S. Tsai, Appl. Phys. Lett. 93, 042510 (2008).
- [28]R. Dassonneville, R. Assouly, T. Peronnin, A. A. Clerk, A. Bienfait, and B. Huard, PRX Quantum 2, 020323 (2021).
- [29]C. Eichler, D. Bozyigit, C. Lang, M. Baur, L. Steffen, J. M. Fink, S. Filipp, and A. Wallraff, Phys. Rev. Lett. 107, 113601 (2011).
- [30]C. Eichler, D. Bozyigit, and A. Wallraff, Phys. Rev. A 86, 032106 (2012).
- [31]C. Macklin, K. O’Brien, D. Hover, M. E. Schwartz, A. Bolkhovsky, X. Zhang, W. D. Oliver, and I. Siddiqi, Sci. 350, 307 (2015).
- [32]D. A. Lidar, I. L. Chuang, and K. B. Whaley, Phys. Rev. Lett. 81, 2594 (1998).
- [33]E. Fink, F. N. Roch, F. Mallet, M. H. Devoret, and B. Huard, Phys. Rev. Lett. 109, 183901 (2012).