betaFeedback

WorksPhysics and Astronomy

Beyond the Standard Model EFT: Stress Testing the Electroweak Phase Transition in the Real Singlet Model

Abstract

The real singlet scalar extension of the Standard Model is a much studied benchmark model for a strong first order electroweak phase transition (EWPT) and its role in electroweak baryogenesis. However, this model is not sufficient to generate the baryon asymmetry of the Universe, since it does not introduce any additional sources of CP violation. That is, additional new physics is still expected in the TeV range. In this paper we use effective field theory (EFT) methods to study the effects of new physics on the EWPT in the real singlet model with no Z2Z_2. Effective operators up to dimension six with a cutoff scale of Λ=1Λ=1 TeV are included in the scalar potential. We study the correlations between a strong first order EWPT, the Higgs trilinear coupling, resonant di-Higgs production, and gravitational wave signals in the EFT. We find that in the real singlet model with a strong first order EWPT the allowed region of the Higgs trilinear coupling is sensitive to TeV scale new physics, while the predictions of the gravitational wave signal and maximum resonant di-Higgs rate (with no additional production mechanisms) are robust against additional weakly coupled physics at or above the TeV scale.

Introduction

Extended scalar sectors are well-motivated extensions of the Standard Model of Particle Physics (SM) [1, 2] that can help solve many of the puzzles of particle physics. A particularly interesting problem they can help solve is the baryon asymmetry of the Universe (BAU). The introduction of new scalars can alter the scalar potential away from the SM predictions, potentially leading to a strong first order electroweak phase transition (EWPT), which is a necessary ingredient for electroweak baryogenesis (EWBG). This EWBG scenario is interesting from the collider physics perspective in that these new scalars must couple to the Higgs and have masses in the TeV range [3, 4]. Indeed, measuring the properties of the scalar potential is one of the long term goals of the LHC [5, 6] and future collider program [7, 8, 9, 10, 11, 12]. Additionally, there are many searches for new scalars see App. A.

Even the simplest extension of the SM, a real scalar singlet, can provide a strong first order EWPT (SFOEWPT). This is a much studied scenario, see [7, 8, 9, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 15, 16, 17, 18, 19, 20, 21, 22, 23, 24, 25, 26, 27, 28, 29, 30, 31, 32, 33] and references therein. However, such a real scalar singlet is expected to be only one particle in a larger sector. Indeed, while the real singlet scalar can provide a SFOEWPT, at the renormalizable level it does not introduce any additional CP violation that is necessary for EWBG to satisfy the Sakharov conditions [34]. Hence, even within the context of generating the BAU, it is expected that there would be additional new physics beyond the real singlet scalar [32, 33, 35, 36, 37, 38, 39, 40, 41, 42]. Assuming the scalar singlet is the lowest lying state and the only state accessible at the LHC, effective field theory (EFT) methods can be used to study the stability of the predictions of the simplified model against the addition of heavy new physics. Often beyond the Standard Model (BSM) EFTs can introduce new search channels or change the interpretation of LHC measurements and searches within a simplified model [43, 44, 45, 46, 47, 48, 49, 50, 51, 52, 53, 54, 55, 56, 57, 58, 59, 60, 61, 62]. For example, in the real singlet model, it has been shown that effective operators can significantly change the interpretation of LHC Higgs measurements and scalar searches [60, 61, 62].

In this paper we will study the EWPT in the real scalar singlet model with the scalar potential extended up to dimension-6 operators1. We will consider the real singlet model with no additional symmetries2. The goal is to determine if the parameter space that can produce a strong first order EWPT is expanded when the higher dimensional operators are considered. Once the allowed parameter space is determined, we will study the phenomenology of this model. The singlet model will alter the Higgs trilinear coupling and, if kinematically allowed, can give rise to resonant di-Higgs signals at the LHC, see Refs. [65, 66, 67, 68, 69, 70, 71, 72] and references therein. Additionally, strong first order phase transitions in the early Universe will produce gravitational waves (GWs). We will study how large the resonant di-Higgs rates and variations in the trilinear couplings can be in the parameter space that successfully produces a SFOEWPT. We will also study the effects of including these operators and the prospects for detection at future GW detectors. As stated previously, these signals have been studied extensively in the renormalizable model [65]. Our study extends this previous work to determine the impact of effective operators on these signals in the context of a SFOEWPT. This study will help determine if the conclusions based on the renormalizable model are stable against heavy new physics, and if the signals can be enhanced when heavy off-shell new physics is included.

In § 2 we give an overview of the model, including the constraints on the zero temperature tree level and one-loop potential. The EWPT is studied in § 3. In § 4 we study the collider and GW phenomenology. We conclude in § 5. In App. § 7 we list the Higgs measurements and scalar resonant searches used to find current bounds on the model. The trilinear and quartic couplings in the EFT at tree level are provided in App. § 8, and the one loop trilinears are in App. § 9. The thermal masses used for the phase transition are discussed in App. § 10. In App. § 11 we give the details of the GW calculation. Supplementary results studying collider observables at tree level while requiring a SFOEWPT as well as in the strongly interacting EFT are given in App. § 12.

Model

We consider the SM extended by a real gauge singlet scalar. At the renormalizable level, the singlet scalar can only couple to the SM through the scalar potential [13, 71]:

Vren(Φ,S)=−μ2∣Φ∣2+λ∣Φ∣4+a12S∣Φ∣2+a22S2∣Φ∣2+b1S+b22S2+b33S3+b44S4(1)V_{\mathrm{ren}}(\Phi,S)=-\mu^2|\Phi|^2+\lambda|\Phi|^4+\frac{a_1}{2}S|\Phi|^2+\frac{a_2}{2}S^2|\Phi|^2+b_1S+\frac{b_2}{2}S^2+\frac{b_3}{3}S^3+\frac{b_4}{4}S^4 \tag*{(1)}

where Φ\Phi is the SM Higgs doublet and SS is the gauge singlet scalar. The renormalizable potential will be extended to include up to dimension-6 operators consisting of the Higgs doublet and scalar singlet [61, 63]:

Vnon−ren(Φ,S)=a32ΛS3∣Φ∣2+a42Λ∣Φ∣4S+b55ΛS5+a52Λ2S4∣Φ∣2+a62Λ2S2∣Φ∣4+cHΛ2∣Φ∣6+b66Λ2S6+O(Λ−3),(2)\begin{aligned} V_{\mathrm{non-ren}}(\Phi,S)={}&\frac{a_3}{2\Lambda}S^3|\Phi|^2+\frac{a_4}{2\Lambda}|\Phi|^4S+\frac{b_5}{5\Lambda}S^5+\frac{a_5}{2\Lambda^2}S^4|\Phi|^2+\frac{a_6}{2\Lambda^2}S^2|\Phi|^4\\ &+\frac{c_H}{\Lambda^2}|\Phi|^6+\frac{b_6}{6\Lambda^2}S^6+O(\Lambda^{-3}), \tag*{(2)} \end{aligned}

where Λ\Lambda is the scale of new physics. The full tree level potential is then

Vtree(Φ,S)=Vren(Φ,S)+Vnon−ren(Φ,S).(3)V_{\mathrm{tree}}(\Phi,S)=V_{\mathrm{ren}}(\Phi,S)+V_{\mathrm{non-ren}}(\Phi,S). \tag*{(3)}

As with the renormalizable model [71], since SS is a true singlet, the theory is invariant under a shift S→vs+SS\to v_s+S. Hence, there is freedom to set a parameter to zero. For simplicity we choose to set the vacuum expectation value of SS to zero3: ⟨S⟩=0\langle S\rangle=0.

To ensure that the SM mass spectrum can be reproduced, there must be a minimum at

⟨Φ†Φ⟩=vEW22,⟨S⟩=0,(4)\langle\Phi^\dagger\Phi\rangle=\frac{v_{\mathrm{EW}}^2}{2},\qquad\langle S\rangle=0, \tag*{(4)}

where vEW=246 GeVv_{\mathrm{EW}} = 246\ \mathrm{GeV}. This requirement leads to the relationships

μ2=vEW2λ+34vEW4Λ2CH+O(Λ−3)(5)\mu^2 = v_{\mathrm{EW}}^2 \lambda+ \frac{3}{4}\frac{v_{\mathrm{EW}}^4}{\Lambda^2}C_H + O(\Lambda^{-3}) \tag*{(5)}
b1=−14vEW2a1−18vEW4Λa4+O(Λ−3).b_1 = -\frac{1}{4}v_{\mathrm{EW}}^2 a_1 - \frac{1}{8}\frac{v_{\mathrm{EW}}^4}{\Lambda}a_4 + O(\Lambda^{-3}).

After EWSB, there are two scalar mass eigenstates h1h_1 and h2h_2. These are admixtures of the SM Higgs boson hh and scalar singlet SS:

\begin{pmatrix} h_1 \\ h_2 \end{pmatrix} = \begin{pmatrix} \cos\theta& \sin\theta\\ -\sin\theta& \cos\theta\end{pmatrix} \begin{pmatrix} h \\ S \end{pmatrix}, \tag*{(6)}\end{pmatrix}

where in the unitary gauge Φ=(0,ϕ0)T/2\Phi= (0,\phi_0)^{\mathsf{T}}/\sqrt{2}, ϕ0=vEW+h\phi_0 = v_{\mathrm{EW}}+h, and h1h_1, h2h_2 have masses m1m_1, m2m_2, respectively. The mass matrix can then be used to solve for the relationships

a1=m12−m22vEWsin⁡2θ−vEW2Λa4+O(Λ−3)(7)a_1 = \frac{m_1^2-m_2^2}{v_{\mathrm{EW}}}\sin2\theta-\frac{v_{\mathrm{EW}}^2}{\Lambda}a_4+O(\Lambda^{-3}) \tag*{(7)}
b2+a22vEW2=m12sin⁡2θ+m22cos⁡2θ−14vEW4Λ2a6+O(Λ−3)b_2+\frac{a_2}{2}v_{\mathrm{EW}}^2 = m_1^2\sin^2\theta+m_2^2\cos^2\theta-\frac{1}{4}\frac{v_{\mathrm{EW}}^4}{\Lambda^2}a_6+O(\Lambda^{-3})
λ=m12cos⁡2θ+m22sin⁡2θ2vEW2−32vEW2Λ2CH+O(Λ−3).\lambda= \frac{m_1^2\cos^2\theta+m_2^2\sin^2\theta}{2v_{\mathrm{EW}}^2}-\frac{3}{2}\frac{v_{\mathrm{EW}}^2}{\Lambda^2}C_H+O(\Lambda^{-3}).

Equations (2.5, 2.7) reproduce the results of [71] with corrections from the EFT. We will identify h1h_1 as the discovered SM-like Higgs boson with mass m1=125 GeVm_1 = 125\ \mathrm{GeV} [73, 74, 75] and assume m2>m1m_2 > m_1. The free parameters are then

m1=125 GeV, m2, vEW=246 GeV, ⟨S⟩=0, θ, a2, b3, b4, a3, a4, a5, a6, b5, b6, CH(8)m_1 = 125\ \mathrm{GeV},\ m_2,\ v_{\mathrm{EW}} = 246\ \mathrm{GeV},\ \langle S\rangle= 0,\ \theta,\ a_2,\ b_3,\ b_4,\ a_3,\ a_4,\ a_5,\ a_6,\ b_5,\ b_6,\ C_H \tag*{(8)}

For di-Higgs phenomenology, the most important trilinear couplings are h1−h1−h1h_1-h_1-h_1 and h1−h1−h2h_1-h_1-h_2:

V(Φ,S)⊃13!λ111h13+12λ112h12h2(9)V(\Phi,S) \supset\frac{1}{3!}\lambda_{111}h_1^3+\frac{1}{2}\lambda_{112}h_1^2h_2 \tag*{(9)}

At tree level, the trilinear couplings are

λ111=3m12vEWcos⁡3θ+(3a2vEWcos⁡θ+2b3sin⁡θ)sin⁡2θ+3vEW2Λsin⁡θ(12a3sin⁡2θ+a4cos⁡2θ)+6vEW3Λ2cos⁡θ(CHcos⁡2θ+12a6sin⁡2θ)+O(Λ−3)(10)\lambda_{111} = 3\frac{m_1^2}{v_{\mathrm{EW}}}\cos^3\theta+ (3a_2v_{\mathrm{EW}}\cos\theta+2b_3\sin\theta)\sin^2\theta+ 3\frac{v_{\mathrm{EW}}^2}{\Lambda}\sin\theta\left(\frac{1}{2}a_3\sin^2\theta+a_4\cos^2\theta\right) +6\frac{v_{\mathrm{EW}}^3}{\Lambda^2}\cos\theta\left(C_H\cos^2\theta+\frac{1}{2}a_6\sin^2\theta\right)+O(\Lambda^{-3}) \tag*{(10)}
λ112=−2m12+m22vEWcos⁡2θsin⁡θ+2(a2vEW(1−32sin⁡2θ)+b3cos⁡θsin⁡θ)sin⁡θ+vEW2Λcos⁡θ(32a3sin⁡2θ+a4(1−3sin⁡2θ))−6vEW3Λ2sin⁡θ(CHcos⁡2θ−13a6(1−32sin⁡2θ))+O(Λ−3)(11)\lambda_{112} = -\frac{2m_1^2+m_2^2}{v_{\mathrm{EW}}}\cos^2\theta\sin\theta+ 2\left(a_2v_{\mathrm{EW}}\left(1-\frac{3}{2}\sin^2\theta\right)+b_3\cos\theta\sin\theta\right)\sin\theta +\frac{v_{\mathrm{EW}}^2}{\Lambda}\cos\theta\left(\frac{3}{2}a_3\sin^2\theta+a_4(1-3\sin^2\theta)\right) -6\frac{v_{\mathrm{EW}}^3}{\Lambda^2}\sin\theta\left(C_H\cos^2\theta-\frac{1}{3}a_6\left(1-\frac{3}{2}\sin^2\theta\right)\right)+O(\Lambda^{-3}) \tag*{(11)}

For completeness, other trilinear and quartic couplings are given at tree level in App. § 8. The partial width for h2→h1h1h_2 \to h_1h_1 is

Γ(h2→h1h1)=λ112232πm21−4m12m22.(12)\Gamma(h_2 \to h_1h_1) = \frac{\lambda_{112}^2}{32\pi m_2}\sqrt{1-4\frac{m_1^2}{m_2^2}}. \tag*{(12)}

If the trilinear coupling λ112\lambda_{112} in Eq. (11) is used in Γ(h2→h1h1)\Gamma(h_2 \to h_1h_1) this would introduce Λ−3\Lambda^{-3} and Λ−4\Lambda^{-4} in the partial width. To be consistent with the EFT, we would then need to add dimension-7 and dimension-8 terms in the scalar potential. For consistent EFT counting, we introduce

(λ112eff)2≡(λ112(0)+1Λλ112(1))2+2Λ2λ112(2)λ112(0),(13)\left(\lambda_{112}^{\mathrm{eff}}\right)^2 \equiv\left(\lambda_{112}^{(0)}+\frac{1}{\Lambda}\lambda_{112}^{(1)}\right)^2+\frac{2}{\Lambda^2}\lambda_{112}^{(2)}\lambda_{112}^{(0)}, \tag*{(13)}

where λ112(n)\lambda_{112}^{(n)} are the coefficients of the Λ−n\Lambda^{-n} terms in Eq. (11):

λ112=λ112(0)+1Λλ112(1)+1Λ2λ112(2)+O(Λ−3).(14)\lambda_{112}=\lambda_{112}^{(0)}+\frac{1}{\Lambda}\lambda_{112}^{(1)}+\frac{1}{\Lambda^2}\lambda_{112}^{(2)}+\mathcal{O}(\Lambda^{-3}). \tag*{(14)}

With this definition, we have

(λ112)2=(λ112eff)2+O(Λ−3)(15)(\lambda_{112})^2=(\lambda_{112}^{\mathrm{eff}})^2+\mathcal{O}(\Lambda^{-3}) \tag*{(15)}

and the calculation of the total width using λ112eff\lambda_{112}^{\mathrm{eff}} is self-consistently truncated at dimension-6:

Γeff(h2→h1h1)=(λ112eff)232πm21−4m12m22.(16)\Gamma^{\mathrm{eff}}(h_2 \to h_1h_1)=\frac{(\lambda_{112}^{\mathrm{eff}})^2}{32\pi m_2}\sqrt{1-4\frac{m_1^2}{m_2^2}}. \tag*{(16)}

Zero Temperature One-Loop Potential

In the on-shell renormalization scheme and Landau gauge, the one-loop effective potential, i.e., Coleman-Weinberg potential [76], is [77, 78]

ΔVT=0(1)(ϕ0,S)=∑i=W,Z,t,ϕ0,Sni64π2mi4(ϕ0,S)[log⁡mi2(ϕ0,S)mi2(vEW,0)−32]+nχ64π2mχ4(ϕ0,S)[log⁡mχ2(ϕ0,S)mh2(vEW,0)−32]+2mi2(ϕ0,S)mi2(vEW,0).(17)\begin{aligned} \Delta V_{T=0}^{(1)}(\phi_0,S)={}&\sum_{i=W,Z,t,\phi_0,S}\frac{n_i}{64\pi^2}m_i^4(\phi_0,S)\left[\log\frac{m_i^2(\phi_0,S)}{m_i^2(v_{\mathrm{EW}},0)}-\frac{3}{2}\right]\\ &+\frac{n_\chi}{64\pi^2}m_\chi^4(\phi_0,S)\left[\log\frac{m_\chi^2(\phi_0,S)}{m_h^2(v_{\mathrm{EW}},0)}-\frac{3}{2}\right]\\ &+2m_i^2(\phi_0,S)m_i^2(v_{\mathrm{EW}},0). \tag*{(17)} \end{aligned}

where ϕ0\phi_0 is the neutral scalar component of the SM Higgs doublet; the sum is over WW, ZZ, top, ϕ0\phi_0, and SS; χ\chi are the Goldstone bosons; nin_i is the number of degrees of freedom for each particle; and mi(ϕ0,S)m_i(\phi_0,S) are scalar field-dependent masses. The degrees of freedom are nW=6n_W=6 for Ws, nZ=3n_Z=3 for Zs, ni=1n_i=1 for the Higgs boson and scalar SS, nχ=3n_\chi=3 for the Goldstone bosons, and nt=−12n_t=-12 for top quarks. This form of the effective potential ensures that the one-loop corrections do not shift the tree level mass and vev relations from Eqs. (5),(7) at the EW minimum:

0=∂ΔVT=0(1)∂ϕ0∣ϕ0=vEW,S=0=∂ΔVT=0(1)∂S∣ϕ0=vEW,S=0.(18)0=\left.\frac{\partial\Delta V_{T=0}^{(1)}}{\partial\phi_0}\right|_{\phi_0=v_{\mathrm{EW}},S=0}=\left.\frac{\partial\Delta V_{T=0}^{(1)}}{\partial S}\right|_{\phi_0=v_{\mathrm{EW}},S=0}. \tag*{(18)}
0=∂2ΔVT=0(1)∂ϕ02∣ϕ0=vEW,S=0=∂2ΔVT=0(1)∂S2∣ϕ0=vEW,S=0=∂2ΔVT=0(1)∂ϕ0∂S∣ϕ0=vEW,S=0.(19)0=\left.\frac{\partial^2\Delta V_{T=0}^{(1)}}{\partial\phi_0^2}\right|_{\phi_0=v_{\mathrm{EW}},S=0}=\left.\frac{\partial^2\Delta V_{T=0}^{(1)}}{\partial S^2}\right|_{\phi_0=v_{\mathrm{EW}},S=0}=\left.\frac{\partial^2\Delta V_{T=0}^{(1)}}{\partial\phi_0\partial S}\right|_{\phi_0=v_{\mathrm{EW}},S=0}. \tag*{(19)}

However, the trilinears in Eqs. (10), (11) will have loop corrections. The full zero temperature potential is then

VT=0(1)(ϕ0,S)=Vtree((0,ϕ0/2)T,S)+ΔVT=0(1)(ϕ0,S).(20)V_{T=0}^{(1)}(\phi_0,S)=V_{\mathrm{tree}}((0,\phi_0/\sqrt{2})^{\mathrm{T}},S)+\Delta V_{T=0}^{(1)}(\phi_0,S). \tag*{(20)}

In principle, the on-shell renormalization conditions of Eq. (19) introduce infrared (IR) divergences for massless particles (such as Goldstone bosons) included in the sum over particles in the effective potential. These IR divergences can be traced to the fact that the effective potential is evaluated with zero external momentum. The IR divergences can be tamed by properly shifting the mass renormalization conditions to the Higgs pole mass, see Refs. [78, 79]. While the Goldstones do introduce IR divergences in the renormalization of the scalar mass, their effects after shifting the renormalization conditions are small. Hence, we use the form of the on-shell effective potential in Eq. (17) and neglect the Goldstone bosons when calculating the one-loop scalar trilinear couplings.

Theory Constraints

There are many theory constraints on the parameters of this model. For example, parameters should be perturbative, the scalar potential should be bounded from below, and the global minimum of the scalar potential should be (⟨Φ†Φ⟩,S)=(vEW2/2,0)(\langle\Phi^\dagger\Phi\rangle,S)=(v_{\mathrm{EW}}^2/2,0). In this section we give an overview of these constraints.

Perturbativity

Perturbative unitarity applied to two-to-two scattering essentially places perturbative bounds on the quartics. The matrix element for two-to-two scattering has the partial wave decomposition:

M=16π∑k(2k+1)akPk(cos⁡θ).(21)\mathcal{M}=16\pi\sum_k(2k+1)a_kP_k(\cos\theta). \tag*{(21)}

The unitarity upper bound on matrix elements implies that in the complex plane the coefficients aka_k must lie within a circle centered at ak=i/2a_k=i/2 with a radius of 1/21/2. Projecting this onto the real axis results in the perturbative unitarity upper limit

∣Re⁡(ak)∣≤12.(22)\left|\operatorname{Re}(a_k)\right|\leq\frac{1}{2}. \tag*{(22)}

This bound is applied order-by-order in perturbation theory. When it is saturated, there is a minimum of a 41% higher order correction to return aka_k back into the unitarity circle [80]. Using Eq. (22) on the scattering processes hh→hhhh\to hh, SS→SSSS\to SS, and Sh→ShSh\to Sh, we find the upper limits on the quartic couplings

∣λ∣≤4π3,∣b4∣≤4π3,and∣a2∣≤8π,(23)|\lambda|\leq\frac{4\pi}{3},\qquad|b_4|\leq\frac{4\pi}{3},\qquad\text{and}\qquad|a_2|\leq8\pi, \tag*{(23)}

respectively. To ensure perturbativity, we further constrain a2a_2:

∣a2∣≤4π.(24)|a_2|\leq4\pi. \tag*{(24)}

The trilinear terms in the scalar potential in Eq. (1) also have perturbative upper limits. Roughly, a triangle loop correction to a trilinear would scale as ∼κ3/(16π2mi2)\sim\kappa^3/(16\pi^2 m_i^2) where κ\kappa is a trilinear coupling entering the loop and mim_i is the relevant mass scale. Since loops correcting a1a_1 or b3b_3 involve the scalar SS, we choose m2m_2 as the relevant mass scale. Requiring that the loop corrections be smaller than the tree-level contributions leads to the rough upper bounds of

∣a1∣≲4πm2,∣b3∣≲4πm2.(25)\lvert a_1\rvert\lesssim4\pi m_2,\qquad\lvert b_3\rvert\lesssim4\pi m_2. \tag*{(25)}

Finally, we place perturbative upper bounds on the Wilson coefficients in Eq. (2). Throughout the paper, we will consider two cases of upper bounds:

Weakly coupled:∣a3,4,5,6∣, ∣b5,6∣, ∣CH∣≤1Strongly coupled:∣a3,4,5,6∣, ∣b5,6∣, ∣CH∣≤4π.(26)\begin{aligned} \text{Weakly coupled}:&\quad\lvert a_{3,4,5,6}\rvert,\ \lvert b_{5,6}\rvert,\ \lvert C_H\rvert\le1 \\ \text{Strongly coupled}:&\quad\lvert a_{3,4,5,6}\rvert,\ \lvert b_{5,6}\rvert,\ \lvert C_H\rvert\le4\pi. \tag*{(26)} \end{aligned}

The strongly coupled theory is at the limit of a perturbative theory, but we use it as a benchmark to determine if a strongly coupled theory is necessary to have large phenomenological effects.

Bounded From Below/Global Minimum Constraints

To prevent runaway directions in field space, the potential must be bounded from below. At the renormalizable level, this requirement is typically enforced for arbitrarily large field values. In that case, the dominant contributions to the renormalizable scalar potential are the quartics. The bounded from below condition on Eq. (1) is then:

0≤λ4ϕ04+a24S2ϕ02+b44S4=14(λ−a224b4)ϕ04+b44(S2+12a2b4ϕ02)2.(27)0 \le\frac{\lambda}{4}\phi_0^4+\frac{a_2}{4}S^2\phi_0^2+\frac{b_4}{4}S^4=\frac{1}{4}\left(\lambda-\frac{a_2^2}{4b_4}\right)\phi_0^4+\frac{b_4}{4}\left(S^2+\frac{1}{2}\frac{a_2}{b_4}\phi_0^2\right)^2. \tag*{(27)}

Hence, we have the global minimum constraints:

0≤λ,0≤b4,and−2λb4≤a2.(28)0\le\lambda,\quad0\le b_4,\quad\text{and}\quad-2\sqrt{\lambda b_4}\le a_2. \tag*{(28)}

Including the non-renormalizable interactions in Eq. (2) relaxes these constraints. Since this is an EFT, we only require that the theory be defined up to the cutoff scale: ∣ϕ0∣,∣S∣≤Λ\lvert\phi_0\rvert,\lvert S\rvert\le\Lambda. Hence, we enforce a boundedness condition at the boundaries of the allowed field space:

V(ϕ0=±Λ,S=±Λ)−V(0,0)≥0.(29)V(\phi_0=\pm\Lambda,S=\pm\Lambda)-V(0,0)\ge0. \tag*{(29)}

It is assumed that whatever new physics exists above the cutoff scale will stabilize the potential to arbitrarily large field values.

Since the new scalar SS is a gauge singlet, it does not contribute to the gauge boson or fermion masses at the renormalizable level. Hence, (⟨Φ†Φ⟩,S)=(vEW2/2,0)(\langle\Phi^\dagger\Phi\rangle,S)=(v_{\mathrm{EW}}^2/2,0) must be a global minimum. In the renormalizable theory, this must be true for all field values:

Vren((0,ϕ0/2)T,S)≥Vren((0,vEW/2)T,0),for∣ϕ0∣,∣S∣<∞.(30)V_{\mathrm{ren}}\left((0,\phi_0/\sqrt{2})^{\mathrm{T}},S\right)\ge V_{\mathrm{ren}}\left((0,v_{\mathrm{EW}}/\sqrt{2})^{\mathrm{T}},0\right),\quad\text{for}\quad\lvert\phi_0\rvert,\lvert S\rvert<\infty. \tag*{(30)}

The renormalizable potential VrenV_{\mathrm{ren}} has six extrema, whose analytical formulae can be found in Refs. [71, 72]. Hence, this condition can be checked explicitly.

Once the effective operators are considered, the global minimum constraint only needs to be valid to field values at the cutoff scale. The global minimum constraint is then

V(ϕ0,S)≥V(ϕ0=vEW,S=0),for∣ϕ0∣,∣S∣≤Λ.(31)V(\phi_0,S) \ge V(\phi_0=v_{\mathrm{EW}},S=0), \qquad\text{for}\quad|\phi_0|,|S| \le\Lambda. \tag*{(31)}

Numerical Results

We now explore the parameter space allowed by the various theoretical limits. We will explore three cases:

\begin{aligned} \text{renormalizable}: \qquad&V(\phi_0,S)=V_{\mathrm{ren}}\left(\left(0,\frac{\phi_0}{\sqrt{2}}\right)^{\mathrm{T}},S\right) && \text{[Eq. }\text{\xref}`(2.1)`\text{]} \\ \text{tree level}: \qquad&V(\phi_0,S)=V_{\mathrm{tree}}\left(\left(0,\frac{\phi_0}{\sqrt{2}}\right)^{\mathrm{T}},S\right) && \text{[Eq. }\text{\xref}`(2.3)`\text{]} \\ \text{one-loop}: \qquad&V(\phi_0,S)=V^{T=0}_{\mathrm{1-loop}}(\phi_0,S) && \text{[Eq. }\text{\xref}`(2.20)`\text{]}. \tag*{(32)} \end{aligned}

In all cases, the perturbative bounds on the quartics and trilinears in Eqs. (2.23,2.24) and (25), respectively, are applied.

Figure 1(a) shows the theoretically allowed parameter space considering (cyan) the boundedness and global minimum constraints on the tree level renormalizable theory in Eqs. (2.29,2.31) and (blue) those bounds only applied up to field values of 1 TeV in Eqs. (2.30,2.32). As can be seen, there is no appreciable difference in allowed parameter spaces whether the constraints are applied to arbitrarily high field values or for field values up to the cutoff: ∣ϕ0∣,∣S∣<Λ|\phi_0|,|S| < \Lambda.

In Fig. 1(b) we show the allowed parameter space considering boundedness and global minimum constraints up to field values of 1 TeV [Eqs. (2.30,2.32)] for tree level (blue) the renormalizable model, (pink) EFT with weakly coupled Wilson coefficients in Eq. (26), and (orange) the EFT with strongly coupled Wilson coefficients in Eq. (2.27). When the EFT operators are added, the allowed parameter space is increased compared to the renormalizable model. Unsurprisingly, when the Wilson coefficients are allowed to be as large as 4π4\pi the allowed parameter space greatly expands.

Figure 1(c) is the same as Fig. 1(b), but with the one-loop, zero temperature effective potential as described in Eq. (20). As can be seen, similarly to the tree level results, adding the weakly coupled EFT slightly expands the allowed region. However, the strongly coupled EFT greatly expands the allowed parameter space at one loop. Indeed, in the strongly coupled case, the allowed parameter space often saturates the perturbative bounds on a2a_2 and b3b_3 except in the region ∣b3∣≲10vEW|b_3| \lesssim10v_{\mathrm{EW}} and 0≲a2≲50 \lesssim a_2 \lesssim5. Comparing the bounds in the tree level and one-loop strongly interacting EFT indicates that the strongly interacting EFT is non-perturbative. We will neglect the strongly interacting theory until we discuss the GW signal, where we will show that the EFT will need to be strongly interacting to effect the GW phenomenology.

Experimental Constraints

In the real singlet model, after rotating to the mass basis, the couplings of the scalar h1h_1 are suppressed by cos⁡θ\cos\theta relative to the SM Higgs boson. Hence, all h1h_1 rates are suppressed

Figure 1. In (a) we show the allowed parameter region for the tree level renormalizable potential VrenV_{\mathrm{ren}} in Eq. (1) with global minimum and boundedness constraints applied (cyan) to all field values [Eqs. (2.29,2.31)] and (blue) up to field values of 1 TeV [Eqs. (2.30,2.32)]. In (b) we show the allowed parameter space with global minimum and boundedness constraints applied to tree level potential out to field values of 1 TeV for (blue) VrenV_{\mathrm{ren}}, (pink) the non-renormalizable potential VtreeV_{\mathrm{tree}} in Eq. (3) with Wilson coefficients in the weakly coupled limit [Eq. (2.26)], and (orange) VtreeV_{\mathrm{tree}} with Wilson coefficients in the strongly coupled limit [Eq. (2.27)]. (c) is the same as (b), using the one-loop potential. In all plots, m2=370m_2 = 370 GeV, b4=1b_4 = 1 and sin⁡θ=0.1\sin\theta= 0.1. For the EFT we set Λ=1\Lambda= 1 TeV.

by cos⁡2θ\cos^2 \theta relative to the SM predictions:

σi(pp→h1)=cos⁡2θ σi,SM(pp→h1),Γ(h1→fSM)=cos⁡2θ ΓSM(h1→fSM),(33)\sigma_i(pp \to h_1) = \cos^2 \theta\, \sigma_{i,\mathrm{SM}}(pp \to h_1), \qquad\Gamma(h_1 \to f_{\mathrm{SM}}) = \cos^2 \theta\, \Gamma_{\mathrm{SM}}(h_1 \to f_{\mathrm{SM}}), \tag*{(33)}

where the subscript SM on rates indicates the predictions of a SM Higgs at m1=125m_1 = 125 GeV and fSMf_{\mathrm{SM}} indicates SM gauge boson and fermion final states. Hence, assuming h2h_2 is massive enough to forbid h1→h2h2h_1 \to h_2h_2, there is a universal signal strength for h1h_1:

μif=σi(pp→h1)BR(h1→fSM)σi,SM(pp→h1)BRSM(h1→fSM)=cos⁡2θ.(34)\mu_i^f = \frac{\sigma_i(pp \to h_1)\mathrm{BR}(h_1 \to f_{\mathrm{SM}})}{\sigma_{i,\mathrm{SM}}(pp \to h_1)\mathrm{BR}_{\mathrm{SM}}(h_1 \to f_{\mathrm{SM}})} = \cos^2 \theta. \tag*{(34)}

Bounds from Higgs precision data then put a bound on the scalar mixing angle. The bounds are found via a χ2\chi^2 fit:

χh12=∑i,f(μif−μ^if)2(δif)2,(35)\chi_{h_1}^2 = \sum_{i,f} \frac{(\mu_i^f - \hat{\mu}_i^f)^2}{(\delta_i^f)^2}, \tag*{(35)}

where μ^if\hat{\mu}_i^f is the measured signal strength and δif\delta_i^f are the 1σ1\sigma uncertainties on μ^if\hat{\mu}_i^f. A list of signal strengths included in the fit is given in App. § 7.§ 1. We find the following 95% CL upper limits from Higgs precision measurements:

∣sin⁡θ∣<0.25.(36)\lvert\sin\theta\rvert< 0.25. \tag*{(36)}

There are many searches at the LHC for scalar resonances. The coupling of h2h_2 to SM fermions and gauge bosons is suppressed by sin⁡θ\sin\theta relative to the SM Higgs couplings. Hence, the production rate at the LHC and decay rates into SM fermions and gauge bosons are

σi(pp→h2)=sin⁡2θ σi,SM(pp→h2),Γ(h2→fSM)=sin⁡2θ ΓSM(h2→fSM),(37)\sigma_i(pp \to h_2) = \sin^2 \theta\, \sigma_{i,\mathrm{SM}}(pp \to h_2), \qquad\Gamma(h_2 \to f_{\mathrm{SM}}) = \sin^2 \theta\, \Gamma_{\mathrm{SM}}(h_2 \to f_{\mathrm{SM}}), \tag*{(37)}

where the subscript SM indicates a rate calculated for a SM Higgs boson at a mass of m2m_2. For the SM-rates we use the results from the LHC Higgs Cross Section Working Group [81]. We will keep sin⁡θ\sin\theta, m2m_2, and BR(h2→h1h1)\mathrm{BR}(h_2 \to h_1h_1) as free parameters. With this choice, the branching ratio of h2h_2 into SM fermions and gauge bosons can be expressed as

BR(h2→fSM)=BRSM(h2→fSM)[1−BR(h2→h1h1)].(38)\mathrm{BR}(h_2 \to f_{\mathrm{SM}}) = \mathrm{BR}_{\mathrm{SM}}(h_2 \to f_{\mathrm{SM}}) \left[1 - \mathrm{BR}(h_2 \to h_1h_1)\right]. \tag*{(38)}

The experimental constraints are then applied using the narrow width approximation

σi(pp→h2→f)≈σi(pp→h2)BR(h2→f),(39)\sigma_i(pp \to h_2 \to f) \approx\sigma_i(pp \to h_2)\mathrm{BR}(h_2 \to f), \tag*{(39)}

where ff can be any kinematically allowed decay product. A list of experimental results included in the fits is given in App. § 7.§ 2.

Bounds from scalar searches are implemented in two ways: a hard cut or a Δχ2\Delta\chi^2 method. The hard cut method accepts a parameter point only if all predicted production rates are below the observed limits:

σi(pp→h2→f)<σ^i,Obsf,(40)\sigma_i(pp \to h_2 \to f) < \hat{\sigma}_{i,\mathrm{Obs}}^f, \tag*{(40)}

where σ^i,Obsf\hat{\sigma}^{f}_{i,\mathrm{Obs}} is the 95% CL observed upper limit on the cross section for initial state ii and final state ff. This is the traditional method used in tools such as HiggsTools [82]. The Δχ2\Delta\chi^2 method was developed in Ref. [62]:

χh22=∑i,f(χi,h2f)2(41)\chi^2_{h_2} = \sum_{i,f} \left(\chi^f_{i,h_2}\right)^2 \tag*{(41)}
(χi,h2f)2={(σi(pp→h2→f)+σ^i,Expf−σ^i,Obsfσ^i,Expf/1.96)2if σ^i,Obsf≥σ^i,Expf,(σi(pp→h2→f)σ^i,Obsf/1.96)2if σ^i,Obsf<σ^i,Expf.\left(\chi^f_{i,h_2}\right)^2 = \begin{cases} \left(\dfrac{\sigma_i(pp \to h_2 \to f) + \hat{\sigma}^{f}_{i,\mathrm{Exp}} - \hat{\sigma}^{f}_{i,\mathrm{Obs}}}{\hat{\sigma}^{f}_{i,\mathrm{Exp}}/1.96}\right)^2 & \text{if } \hat{\sigma}^{f}_{i,\mathrm{Obs}} \ge\hat{\sigma}^{f}_{i,\mathrm{Exp}}, \\ \left(\dfrac{\sigma_i(pp \to h_2 \to f)}{\hat{\sigma}^{f}_{i,\mathrm{Obs}}/1.96}\right)^2 & \text{if } \hat{\sigma}^{f}_{i,\mathrm{Obs}} < \hat{\sigma}^{f}_{i,\mathrm{Exp}}. \end{cases}

For a single measurement, applying a Δχh22\Delta\chi^2_{h_2} fit will reproduce the hard cut upper bound in Eq. (40). The Δχh22\Delta\chi^2_{h_2} allows for a consistent combination of all searches together with Higgs precision measurements.

Figure 2 shows the bounds on the scalar mixing angle ∣sin⁡θ∣|\sin\theta| as a function of h2h_2 mass for (a) BR⁡(h2→h1h1)=0\operatorname{BR}(h_2 \to h_1h_1) = 0, (b) BR⁡(h2→h1h1)=1\operatorname{BR}(h_2 \to h_1h_1) = 1, and (c) most stringent for all BR⁡(h2→h1h1)\operatorname{BR}(h_2 \to h_1h_1). As can be seen in all the plots, the hard cut and Δχ2\Delta\chi^2 methods for employing scalar searches give similar results while the Δχ2\Delta\chi^2 combination of scalar searches and Higgs data is slightly stronger. When kinematically allowed, the bounds assuming BR⁡(h2→h1h1)=1\operatorname{BR}(h_2 \to h_1h_1) = 1 are stronger than those assuming BR⁡(h2→h1h1)=0\operatorname{BR}(h_2 \to h_1h_1) = 0 for all m2m_2 masses except 320 GeV≲m2≲355−365 GeV320\ \mathrm{GeV} \lesssim m_2 \lesssim355 - 365\ \mathrm{GeV}. For all masses, the bounds from scalar searches with BR⁡(h2→h1h1)=1\operatorname{BR}(h_2 \to h_1h_1) = 1 are stronger than Higgs precision measurements.

Figure 2. Bounds on ∣sin⁡θ∣|\sin\theta| for (a) BR⁡(h2→h1h1)=0\operatorname{BR}(h_2 \to h_1h_1) = 0, (b) BR⁡(h2→h1h1)=1\operatorname{BR}(h_2 \to h_1h_1) = 1, and (c) minimized over BR⁡(h2→h1h1)\operatorname{BR}(h_2 \to h_1h_1). All plots show constraints from (orange solid) the hard cut method for scalar searches, (magenta solid) the Δχ2\Delta\chi^2 method for scalar searches, (blue solid) the combination of Δχ2\Delta\chi^2 method for scalar searches and Higgs precision, and (black dashed) Δχh12\Delta\chi^2_{h_1} fits from Eq. (35).

Electroweak Phase Transition

The main results of this paper will be how the dimension-5 and 6 non-renormalizable operators in the scalar potential [Eq. (2.2)] affect the parameter space that accommodates a SFOEWPT in the real scalar singlet model, as well as the signatures of the model. Here we give an overview of the finite temperature calculation we use and report on the parameter space that allows for a SFOEWPT.

At finite temperatures, the effective scalar potential has additional contributions at one loop.4

Veff(ϕ0,S,T)=VT=0(1)(ϕ0,S)+VT(ϕ0,S,T)(42)V_{\mathrm{eff}}(\phi_0,S,T) = V_{T=0}^{(1)}(\phi_0,S) + V_T(\phi_0,S,T) \tag*{(42)}

where VT=0(1)(ϕ0,S)V_{T=0}^{(1)}(\phi_0,S) is the zero temperature one-loop effective potential in Eq. (2.20) and the finite temperature contributions, VTV_T, are given as

VT(ϕ0,S,T)=∑iniT42π2∫0∞dy y2log⁡(1±e−y2+mi2(ϕ0,S)/T2)(43)V_T(\phi_0,S,T) = \sum_i \frac{n_i T^4}{2\pi^2} \int_0^\infty dy\,y^2 \log\left(1 \pm e^{-\sqrt{y^2 + m_i^2(\phi_0,S)/T^2}}\right) \tag*{(43)}

where the sum is over all fields, ++ is for fermions, and −- is for bosons.

When calculating the temperature dependent effective potential, there are well-known infrared divergences in the form of “daisy” diagrams [83, 85, 86, 87, 88, 89, 90, 91, 92, 93, 94] where perturbation theory begins to fail when m≪Tm \ll T, where mm is a typical mass scale. For more accurate and stable predictions, these contributions need to be resummed. We will use the Parwani scheme [85].5 In this scheme, all the boson masses are replaced by their high temperature thermally corrected masses in both the zero temperature Coleman-Weinberg potential ΔVT=0(1)\Delta V_{T=0}^{(1)} and the finite temperature contributions VTV_T:

mi2(ϕ0,S)⟶Mi2(ϕ0,S,T)=mi2(ϕ0,S)+Πi(T)(44)m_i^2(\phi_0,S) \longrightarrow M_i^2(\phi_0,S,T) = m_i^2(\phi_0,S) + \Pi_i(T) \tag*{(44)}

where Πi(T)\Pi_i(T) are the high temperature one-particle irreducible self-energies. The Πi(T)\Pi_i(T) that we use are given in App. § 10.

For sphalerons to turn off sufficiently fast to freeze in the baryon asymmetry, the phase transition must be strong and first order. The first order phase transition occurs when a barrier forms between two degenerate minima of the effective potential at a critical temperature TcT_c. Bubbles will nucleate when the vacuum decay rate matches the Hubble rate at the nucleation temperature TnT_n. For temperatures around the EW scale, nucleation occurs when S3/Tn≈140S_3/T_n \approx140, where S3S_3 is the 3D Euclidean action. We use CosmoTransitions [95] to solve the bounce equations and determine the nucleation temperature.

The first order phase transition is said to be strong where ϕn/Tn≳1\phi_n/T_n \gtrsim1 [96, 97, 98, 99] such that the sphalerons fall out of equilibrium sufficiently quickly, where ϕn\phi_n is the location of the EW symmetry breaking minimum at the nucleation temperature. There are uncertainties in this relation due to the gauge dependence of the finite temperature effective potential [100, 101, 102, 103, 104, 105, 106] which introduces gauge dependence in both ϕn\phi_n and TnT_n. This can be traced to the Nielsen identities [107, 108] not being implemented order-by-order in the ℏ\hbar expansion. While there are proposals for gauge invariant criteria for a SFOEWPT [104, 105, 106], for our purposes, we will use the naïve estimation of ϕn/Tn≳1\phi_n/T_n \gtrsim1 to compare the predictions of the renormalizable and non-renormalizable theories.

In Figure 3 we show the allowed parameter space for a SFOEWPT in the (a) renormalizable model and (b) the weakly coupled non-renormalizable model defined in Eq. (26). We use a cutoff of Λ=1\Lambda= 1 TeV and apply the boundedness and global minimum criteria of Eqs. (29),(31) up to the cutoff. In the renormalizable model, we find that only a relatively small band of allowed parameter space allows for a SFOEWPT. This is similar to results for the Z2Z_2 symmetric singlet model [18]. We do note that the allowed parameter space consistent with a SFOEWPT is smaller than in Ref. [11]. This is due to Ref. [11] using the condition ϕc/Tc≳1\phi_c/T_c \gtrsim1 as the SFOEWPT condition, where ϕc\phi_c is the location of the second minimum at the critical temperature. The condition ϕc/Tc≳1\phi_c/T_c \gtrsim1 is weaker than ϕn/Tn≳1\phi_n/T_n \gtrsim1. Even if ϕc/Tc≳1\phi_c/T_c \gtrsim1, it is possible for the field to be stuck in the electroweak symmetric vacuum and fail to nucleate. As shown in Figure 3(b), the weakly coupled EFT expands the region that nucleates while still requiring a2≳1.5a_2 \gtrsim1.5.

Comparison of the parameter space for a SFOEWPT

Figure 3. Comparison of the parameter space with a SFOEWPT for (a) the renormalizable model and (b) the weakly coupled non-renormalizable model. Grey regions show the allowed parameter space at zero temperature while the colored heat map shows the strength of the phase transition. We fix sin⁡θ=0.1\sin\theta= 0.1, m2=370m_2 = 370 GeV, b4=1b_4 = 1, and Λ=1\Lambda= 1 TeV.

Phenomenology

We now discuss the phenomenology of the SFOEWPT in the singlet extended model with non-renormalizable operators in the potential. All constraints discussed in § 2.2 and § 2.3 are applied for ∣ϕ0∣,∣S∣<Λ|\phi_0|, |S| < \Lambda using the one-loop effective potential, as well as requiring (λ112eff)2>0(\lambda_{112}^{\mathrm{eff}})^2 > 0. Throughout this section we use Λ=1\Lambda= 1 TeV, as in the previous sections.

Collider Phenomenology

Since we focused on the effective operators in the scalar potential, the main effects of the EFT at a collider are to change the maximal pp→h2→h1h1pp \to h_2 \to h_1h_1 rate and the variation of the Higgs trilinear coupling

κ111=λ111λ111,SM,(45)\kappa_{111} = \frac{\lambda_{111}}{\lambda_{111,\mathrm{SM}}}, \tag*{(45)}

where the subscript SM indicates the prediction within the Standard Model. In Figure 4, Figure 5, and Figure 7, we compare the maximal BR⁡(h2→h1h1)\operatorname{BR}(h_2 \to h_1h_1) in the (left) sin⁡θ−m2\sin\theta- m_2 plane and (right) κ111−m2\kappa_{111} - m_2 plane in the (top two) renormalizable model and (bottom two) weakly coupled EFT. All free parameters are scanned over. On the left the plots are paired such that when BR⁡(h2→h1h1)\operatorname{BR}(h_2 \to h_1h_1) is maximized the corresponding λ111\lambda_{111} variation is shown directly below. Similarly, on the right, we pair the maximal BR⁡(h2→h1h1)\operatorname{BR}(h_2 \to h_1h_1) with the corresponding production rate σggF(pp→h2→h1h1)\sigma_{ggF}(pp \to h_2 \to h_1h_1) in the gluon fusion channel in the narrow width approximation directly below. The branching ratio of h2→h1h1h_2 \to h_1h_1 is calculated consistently using λ112eff\lambda_{112}^{\mathrm{eff}} defined in Eq. (13).

Plots of branching ratios, trilinear couplings, and resonant cross sections for the renormalizable model and weakly coupled EFT

Figure 4. Plots are paired vertically to show (left) the maximum BR⁡(h2→h1h1)\operatorname{BR}(h_2 \to h_1h_1) in the sin⁡θ−m2\sin\theta-m_2 plane and directly below the corresponding variation in κ111\kappa_{111}, and (right) the maximum BR⁡(h2→h1h1)\operatorname{BR}(h_2 \to h_1h_1) in the κ111−m2\kappa_{111}-m_2 plane and directly below the corresponding resonant cross section σ(pp→h2→h1h1)\sigma(pp \to h_2 \to h_1h_1). The top two plots show the renormalizable model and the bottom two show the weakly coupled EFT. All parameters are scanned over. All trilinear couplings are evaluated at tree level and we use λ112eff\lambda_{112}^{\mathrm{eff}}. Dashed lines on the right correspond to projected HL-LHC bounds 0.74≤κ111≤1.290.74 \le\kappa_{111} \le1.29 [6].

Plots of mixing angle, trilinear coupling, branching ratio, and partial width for the renormalizable model and weakly coupled EFT

Figure 5. Same as Figure 4 with Coleman Weinberg definition of trilinears. Solid black lines on the right correspond to current LHC bounds −0.71≤κ111≤6.1-0.71 \le\kappa_{111} \le6.1 [5].

Same as Fig. 5 but now requiring a strong first order EWPT

Figure 7. Same as Figure 5 but now requiring a strong first order EWPT.

Figure 4 shows these results when the trilinears are evaluated at tree level, while Figure 5 is the same but with the trilinear couplings evaluated at the one-loop level calculated with the zero temperature effective potential. In the renormalizable model, at tree level the maximal BR⁡(h2→h1h1)\operatorname{BR}(h_2 \to h_1h_1) can reach as high as ∼70%\sim70\% over the entire mass range. However, for m2≳750m_2 \gtrsim750 GeV the largest branching ratios occur for ∣sin⁡θ∣≲0.1|\sin\theta| \lesssim0.1. This can be understood numerically from Figure 6(a), which shows the corresponding values of a2a_2. For m2≲750m_2 \lesssim750 GeV, the h2→h1h1h_2 \to h_1h_1 branching ratio can be enhanced by large positive a2a_2, as seen in Ref. [67]. For m2≳750m_2 \gtrsim750 GeV, the large branching ratios occur for a2a_2 that are large and negative. When boundedness is applied to all field values, as in Eq. (28), a2a_2 cannot be as large and negative as when the boundedness condition is applied only to field values out to Λ=1\Lambda= 1 TeV. Those large and negative a2a_2 only occur for ∣sin⁡θ∣≲0.1|\sin\theta| \lesssim0.1.

Figure 6. (a) Heat map of a2a_2 that maximizes BR⁡(h2→h1h1)\operatorname{BR}(h_2 \to h_1h_1) at tree level in the renormalizable model Figure 4 in the sin⁡θ−m2\sin\theta-m_2 plane. (b,c) Heat map of sin⁡θ\sin\theta that maximizes BR⁡(h2→h1h1)\operatorname{BR}(h_2 \to h_1h_1) for the weakly coupled EFT in (b) Figure 4 and (c) Figure 5.

Comparing Figure 4 and Figure 5 the importance of loop level corrections is apparent. With the loop corrections, the BR⁡(h2→h1h1)\operatorname{BR}(h_2 \to h_1h_1) can be ∼100%\sim100\% across the entire m2m_2 range in the renormalizable model. In particular, as shown in App. § 9, 1-loop corrections to the h1−h1−h2h_1-h_1-h_2 coupling in the renormalizable model persist as ∣sin⁡θ∣→0\lvert\sin\theta\rvert\to0:

λ112=a22b3vEW216π2m22+O(sin⁡θ,Λ−1).(46)\lambda_{112} = \frac{a_2^2 b_3 v_{\mathrm{EW}}^2}{16\pi^2 m_2^2} + \mathcal{O}\left(\sin\theta,\Lambda^{-1}\right). \tag*{(46)}

Hence, in the small mixing angle limit the h2→h1h1h_2 \to h_1h_1 partial width can be enhanced over the h2→WW,ZZ,tth_2 \to WW, ZZ, tt partial widths. This also explains why the resonant di-Higgs rate is smaller at larger BR⁡(h2→h1h1)\operatorname{BR}(h_2 \to h_1h_1) at the one-loop trilinear level, since the h2h_2 production rate is suppressed by sin⁡2θ\sin^2\theta.

Loop corrections are similarly important for κ111\kappa_{111}. At tree level in the renormalizable model, the value of κ111\kappa_{111} can be as large as 2 or as small as zero for m2≳800 GeVm_2 \gtrsim800\,\mathrm{GeV}6. With the loop corrections, κ111\kappa_{111} can be larger than 2 for m2≳550 GeVm_2 \gtrsim550\,\mathrm{GeV}. Additionally, the loop corrections open up a region of parameter space where κ111\kappa_{111} can be substantially lower than 1, even negative. That is, in the renormalizable model loop corrections show that there is a substantially larger region of parameter space with larger κ111\kappa_{111} variations than indicated by a tree level analysis. These results are similar to those found in Refs. [109, 110, 111, 112, 113].

When the non-renormalizable operators are turned on, these results change considerably. In the weakly coupled EFT, the tree and one-loop level h2→h1h1h_2 \to h_1h_1 branching ratio can reach as high as ∼100%\sim100\% across the entire mass range. In the small mixing angle limit, the partial widths h2→WW,ZZ,tth_2 \to WW, ZZ, tt are suppressed, while the Wilson coefficient a4a_4 can enhance the partial width of h2→h1h1h_2 \to h_1h_1 at tree level. This can be seen clearly via the h1−h1−h2h_1-h_1-h_2 coupling in Eq. (11). The role of effective operators in enhancing

BR⁡(h2→h1h1)\operatorname{BR}(h_2 \to h_1h_1) and other multi-Higgs resonant channels has recently gained attention in the literature [46, 47], and we show the importance of these effective operators at one loop as well.

In the weakly coupled EFT, κ111\kappa_{111} can generically be further from the SM predictions for both the tree and loop level, with larger variations at loop level. Unlike the renormalizable model, the tree level κ111\kappa_{111} can be as large as 1.5 – 1.6 across the entire mass range, and can be lower than 0.5 for m2≳400m_2 \gtrsim400 GeV. A striking feature of the weakly coupled EFT at tree level is that for κ111≲1.5\kappa_{111} \lesssim1.5 the branching ratio of h2→h1h1h_2 \to h_1h_1 is ∼100%\sim100\% across the entire parameter space, while for κ111≳1.5\kappa_{111} \gtrsim1.5 the h2→h1h1h_2 \to h_1h_1 branching ratio is smaller. This can be understood from Figure 6(b). For 0.5≲κ111≲1.50.5 \lesssim\kappa_{111} \lesssim1.5, the sin⁡θ\sin\theta that maximizes BR⁡(h2→h1h1)\operatorname{BR}(h_2 \to h_1h_1) is very small. In this limit, the ratio of the Higgs trilinear at tree level is

κ111=1+2CHvEW4Λ2m12+O(sin⁡θ,Λ−3).(47)\kappa_{111} = 1 + 2\frac{C_H v_{\mathrm{EW}}^4}{\Lambda^2m_1^2} + O(\sin\theta,\Lambda^{-3}). \tag*{(47)}

Hence, 0.5≲κ111≲1.50.5 \lesssim\kappa_{111} \lesssim1.5 for −1<CH<1-1 < C_H < 1, small sin⁡θ\sin\theta, and Λ=1\Lambda= 1 TeV. For κ111\kappa_{111} to be outside of that range, a larger ∣sin⁡θ∣|\sin\theta| is needed, resulting in a smaller h2→h1h1h_2 \to h_1h_1 branching ratio. However, the cross sections at maximum branching ratio are enhanced for κ111≳1.5\kappa_{111} \gtrsim1.5 due to a larger mixing angle. As shown in Figure 6(c), at one loop κ111\kappa_{111} can be larger with smaller ∣sin⁡θ∣|\sin\theta|. Hence, the range of κ111\kappa_{111} with larger h2→h1h1h_2 \to h_1h_1 is increased. However, again, there is an anti-correlation between maximum branching ratios and corresponding rates due to large branching ratios occurring mostly at small mixing angle.

The HL-LHC is expected to measure the Higgs trilinear coupling to within −26%-26\% and +29%+29\% of the SM expectations [6]. Currently, the LHC places a bound of −0.71≤κ111≤6.1-0.71 \le\kappa_{111} \le6.1 [5]. In Figure 4 and Figure 5, HL-LHC projected limits are shown as dashed black lines and current LHC sensitivities as solid black lines. As is clear, loop corrections to the Higgs trilinear are necessary to fully determine the reach of the LHC. Current LHC limits on κ111\kappa_{111} already rule out some of the weakly coupled EFT space. The HL-LHC will be sensitive to the renormalizable model and weakly coupled EFT.

Figure 7 is the same as Figure 5 but now requiring a strong first order EW phase transition. For all models, there are fewer points that have the branching ratio of h2→h1h1h_2 \to h_1h_1 above 90%, and the variation of κ111\kappa_{111} is smaller. At the renormalizable level, requiring that there be a SFOEWPT forces the Higgs trilinear to be larger than the SM prediction for m2≳400m_2 \gtrsim400 GeV. From Figure 3(a), a SFOEWPT is driven by an a2a_2 that is greater than zero. As shown in App. § 9, in the small sin⁡θ\sin\theta limit, the loop corrected Higgs trilinear in the renormalizable model is [9]:

κ111=1+a2332π2vEW3λ111,SMm22+O(sin⁡θ,Λ−1),(48)\kappa_{111} = 1 + \frac{a_2^3}{32\pi^2}\frac{v_{\mathrm{EW}}^3}{\lambda_{111,\mathrm{SM}}m_2^2} + \mathcal{O}\left(\sin\theta,\Lambda^{-1}\right), \tag*{(48)}

where λ111,SM=0.71 vEW\lambda_{111,\mathrm{SM}} = 0.71\,v_{\mathrm{EW}} at one loop. Hence, positive a2a_2 raises κ111\kappa_{111} above one. As the mass m2m_2 increases, the lower bound on a2a_2 also increases, which in turn increases the one-loop correction to λ111\lambda_{111}. Indeed, we find that the HL-LHC measurements of the Higgs trilinear will be sensitive to the majority of parameter space of the renormalizable model consistent with a SFOEWPT for m2≳450m_2 \gtrsim450 GeV. Similar results show that a SFOEWPT requires a non-SM Higgs trilinear [4, 9, 114, 115, 116, 117, 118, 119, 120] for heavier scalars ≳400−500\gtrsim400 - 500 GeV.

The situation in the EFTs is different. In the weakly coupled EFT, after requiring a SFOEWPT, the current LHC bounds on κ111\kappa_{111} no longer rule out any parameter points. While the HL-LHC is sensitive to a large portion of the parameter space in the weakly coupled EFT, there are points consistent with a strong first order EWPT that will survive across the entire h2h_2 mass range, in contrast to the renormalizable model. It should be noted that as m2m_2 approaches 1 TeV, it is approaching the cutoff and the validity comes into question. However, even for m2m_2 far below the cutoff scale, the weakly coupled EFT still has many more points that would evade HL-LHC Higgs trilinear measurements than would survive in the renormalizable model.

Finally, in Figure 8 we show the maximum allowed di-Higgs rate for (a) trilinears evaluated at tree level, (b) trilinears evaluated via the one-loop Coleman-Weinberg potential, and (c) requiring a strong first order EWPT. We only show points that pass current LHC bounds on the Higgs trilinear coupling. In all three cases (a,b,c), the maximum resonant di-Higgs cross section is similar in the renormalizable and weakly coupled EFT. This is true when effective operators are added only to the potential and the largest BR(h2→h1h1)\mathrm{BR}(h_2 \to h_1h_1) occur for small sin⁡θ\sin\theta. However, if new physics or effective operators alter the h2h_2 production mechanism, the resonant di-Higgs rate can be enhanced [47]. Additionally, the maximum rates for the trilinear evaluated at tree or one loop level are similar. Once a SFOEWPT is required, the maximum rate for the renormalizable and weakly coupled EFT is decreased. Even though the di-Higgs rate is decreased, as we showed earlier, measurements of the Higgs trilinear are still promising at large masses.

Figure 8. Maximum allowed rate σ(pp→h2→h1h1)\sigma(pp \to h_2 \to h_1h_1) vs. m2m_2 for (a) trilinears evaluated at tree level, (b) trilinears defined with Coleman-Weinberg potential, and (c) after applying EWPT constraints for (magenta) renormalizable and (navy) weakly coupled EFT. All constraints, including current bounds on the Higgs trilinear, are applied.

Gravitational Waves

A SFOEWPT offers a direct cosmological probe of physics beyond the SM through the production of a stochastic GW background. The transition proceeds by the nucleation of bubbles of the EW symmetry breaking phase, followed by their expansion in the primordial plasma. The released vacuum energy is converted into collective plasma motion, including sound waves and turbulence, as well as bubble wall collisions, which act as sources of gravitational radiation. For transitions occurring near the EW scale, the peak frequency of the resulting spectrum typically lies in the millihertz band, allowing space based interferometers to probe this scenario. In this work, we compute the GW signal associated with the SFOEWPT in the singlet-extended SM with higher-dimensional effective operators. In addition to the theoretical and experimental constraints discussed previously, in this section we also apply the current LHC bounds on the Higgs trilinear.

The GW spectrum is primarily characterized by four macroscopic parameters: the transition strength α\alpha, the inverse duration of the phase transition normalized by the Hubble rate, β/H\beta/H, the bubble wall velocity vwv_w, and the characteristic transition temperature T∗T_*, which we set to the nucleation temperature TnT_n. The parameter α\alpha characterizes the amount of energy released during the transition relative to the radiation energy density.

α=Δ(−Veff+Tn4dVeffdT)ρr(49)\alpha= \frac{\Delta\left(-V_{\mathrm{eff}}+\frac{T_n}{4}\frac{dV_{\mathrm{eff}}}{dT}\right)}{\rho_r} \tag*{(49)}

where

ρr=π230g∗Tn4(50)\rho_r = \frac{\pi^2}{30}g_*T_n^4 \tag*{(50)}

is the radiation energy density and Δ\Delta denotes taking the difference between the true and false vacuum. Our scans result in α≲10−1\alpha\lesssim10^{-1} for the renormalizable model and weakly coupled EFT, while for the strongly coupled EFT we find α≲3×10−1\alpha\lesssim3 \times10^{-1}. We calculate the inverse duration of the phase transition as

βH=TnddT(S3T)∣T=Tn(51)\frac{\beta}{H} = T_n \frac{d}{dT}\left(\frac{S_3}{T}\right)\bigg|_{T=T_n} \tag*{(51)}

and find 102≲β/H≲6×10410^2 \lesssim\beta/H \lesssim6 \times10^4. Determining the wall velocity is an involved calculation that requires solving the coupled scalar field equations of motion and fluid equations for the plasma including the effects of hydrodynamic backreaction and, in general, deviations from local thermal equilibrium [125, 126, 127]. A full calculation is beyond the scope of the present analysis. We instead adopt the simple analytic approximation proposed in Ref. [128]

vw={ΔVeffαρrfor ΔVeffαρr<vJ1for ΔVeffαρr≥vJ(52)v_w = \begin{cases} \sqrt{\frac{\Delta V_{\mathrm{eff}}}{\alpha\rho_r}} & \text{for } \sqrt{\frac{\Delta V_{\mathrm{eff}}}{\alpha\rho_r}} < v_J \\ 1 & \text{for } \sqrt{\frac{\Delta V_{\mathrm{eff}}}{\alpha\rho_r}} \ge v_J \end{cases} \tag*{(52)}

where ΔV≡Vfalse−Vtrue\Delta V \equiv V_{\mathrm{false}} - V_{\mathrm{true}} denotes the free energy difference between the false and true vacua. The Jouguet velocity is given by

vJ=131+3α2+2α1+α.(53)v_J = \frac{1}{\sqrt{3}}\frac{1+\sqrt{3\alpha^2+2\alpha}}{1+\alpha}. \tag*{(53)}

For the sub-Jouguet branch, the expression of vwv_w follows from the steady state momentum flux matching condition in the local thermodynamic equilibrium approximation. It provides a useful estimate of the wall velocity when deviations from thermal equilibrium are small. For transitions sufficiently strong that this estimate exceeds vJv_J, we follow Ref. [128] and take the wall to be highly relativistic, setting vw=1v_w = 1.

For parameter points with ΔVeffαρr>vJ\sqrt{\frac{\Delta V_{\mathrm{eff}}}{\alpha\rho_r}} > v_J we calculate the contributions to the GW spectrum from sound waves and bubble collisions. We use PTPlot [129, 130] to calculate the contributions from sound waves to the GW spectrum. App. § 11 contains the details of the GW calculations for both sound waves and bubble collisions. We show the spectrum in Figure 9 for a subset of 100 randomly selected points. The peak is set by sound waves and lies at f∼10−3f \sim10^{-3}–10−210^{-2} Hz. In the renormalizable model and the weakly coupled EFT the peak amplitudes are h2ΩGW≲10−13h^2\Omega_{\mathrm{GW}} \lesssim10^{-13}, at or below the LISA sensitivity, with a handful of points within reach of DECIGO and BBO. In the strongly coupled EFT, where α\alpha reaches 0.3, the amplitudes are larger and a few points exceed the LISA sensitivity. The peak of the spectrum is dominated by the sound waves, while the change in the power spectrum at higher frequencies is due to the dominance of bubble wall collisions at those frequencies.

GW spectra sourced by bubble collisions and sound waves for the renormalizable modelGW spectra sourced by bubble collisions and sound waves for the weakly coupled EFTGW spectra sourced by bubble collisions and sound waves for the strongly coupled EFT

Figure 9. GW spectrum sourced by bubble collisions and sound waves for 100 randomly selected points with ΔVeff/αρr>vJ\sqrt{\Delta V_{\mathrm{eff}}/\alpha\rho_r} > v_J for (a) the renormalizable model, (b) weakly coupled EFT, and (c) the strongly coupled EFT. The sensitivity curves are taken from [121] for BBO [122], DECIGO [123], and LISA [124].

In Figure 10 and Figure 11 we show the peak frequency of the GW spectrum as a heat map in the resonant di-Higgs cross section and κ111\kappa_{111}, respectively. This is shown for the (a) renormalizable model, (b) weakly interacting EFT, and (c) strongly interacting EFT. The prospects for GW observation are similar in the renormalizable and weakly coupled EFT, while many more points in the strongly coupled EFT have detection prospects at GW detectors. This shows that to have a significant change in GW prospects away from that in the renormalizable model, either there should be a strongly interacting theory at a TeV or new physics below a TeV beyond that in the real scalar singlet model.

Figure 10. Peak amplitudes versus frequency for GW sourced by sound waves for (a) the renormalizable model (b) weakly coupled EFT, and (c) strongly coupled EFT. The color of each point shows the corresponding σ(pp→h2→h1h1)\sigma(pp \to h_2 \to h_1h_1).

Peak amplitudes versus frequency for GW sourced by sound waves for the renormalizable model

(a)

Peak amplitudes versus frequency for GW sourced by sound waves for the weakly coupled EFT

(b)

Peak amplitudes versus frequency for GW sourced by sound waves for the strongly coupled EFT

(c)

Figure 11. Peak amplitudes versus frequency for GW sourced by sound waves for (a) the renormalizable model (b) weakly coupled EFT, and (c) strongly coupled EFT. The color of each point shows the corresponding value of κ111\kappa_{111}.

As can be seen in Figure 10, there is little to no correlation between the GW signal and resonant di-Higgs production, indicating a complementarity between the two signals. In contrast, in Figure 12 we show the peak frequency of the GW spectrum while applying HL-LHC projected bounds 0.74≲κ111≲1.290.74 \lesssim\kappa_{111} \lesssim1.29. We show this for (a,b) the renormalizable model, (c,d) the weakly coupled EFT, and (e,f) the strongly coupled EFT. For completeness, we show the results when the trilinear is evaluated at (a,c,e) tree level and (b,d,f) loop level. As can be seen at loop level, applying the bounds on κ111\kappa_{111} at one loop level eliminates most of the parameter space with a detectable GW spectrum. This is not the case when the trilinears are evaluated at tree level. As discussed above, loop corrections raise the value of κ111\kappa_{111} at high h2h_2 masses. In Ref. [29] it was found that in the low mass region there exist points with a GW signature and almost no signature at the LHC in the di-Higgs final state. Our bounds on sin⁡θ\sin\theta in Figure 2(c) are in conflict with most of that parameter space. Hence, we find only a few points that pass future Higgs trilinear bounds that still have a potential GW signature in the renormalizable or weakly coupled EFT.

Peak amplitudes versus frequency for gravitational waves sourced by sound waves

Figure 12. Peak amplitudes versus frequency for GW sourced by sound waves for (a,b) the renormalizable model (c,d) weakly coupled EFT, and (e,f) strongly coupled EFT. The color of each point shows the corresponding value of κ111\kappa_{111} after imposing 0.74≲κ111≲1.290.74 \lesssim\kappa_{111} \lesssim1.29. The trilinear scalar couplings are evaluated at (a,c,e) tree and (b,d,f) loop level.

While more points pass in the strongly interacting EFT, this theory is non-perturbative and its predictions are unreliable, as mentioned previously.

Conclusions

While the real singlet model is a much studied benchmark model for a strong first order EWPT necessary for EWBG, it is not sufficient to generate the matter-antimatter asymmetry. That is, there is expected to be additional new physics at the TeV scale. In this paper we studied the potential effects of this new physics on the EWPT using EFT methods and extending the scalar potential to include effective operators up to dimension six. Both a weakly coupled EFT, with Wilson coefficients bounded by ∣Ci∣≤1|C_i| \le1, and a strongly coupled theory ∣Ci∣≤4π|C_i| \le4\pi were studied. We found that requiring global minimum and bounded from below constraints on the scalar potential for field values up to 1 TeV increased the allowed parameter space of the renormalizable model. Unsurprisingly, the allowed parameter space was increased further in the EFTs, even after the requirement of a strong first order electroweak phase transition.

Similar to previous literature, we found the one loop corrections to scalar trilinear couplings effected the phenomenology of these models considerably. At the renormalizable level, one loop corrections to the Higgs trilinear significantly increased the deviations away from SM predictions. Once a strong first order EWPT was required, the HL-LHC measurement of the Higgs trilinear would be sensitive to the majority of the parameter space for heavy scalar masses above ∼450\sim450 GeV. For the LHC phenomenology, we presented results for the weakly coupled EFT only, since the one-loop effective potential with the strongly coupled EFT indicated it was non-perturbative or nearly non-perturbative. The weakly coupled EFT increases the allowed ranges of the Higgs trilinear significantly. There were parameter points for all scalar masses that could evade HL-LHC Higgs trilinear measurements, in contrast to the renormalizable case where the HL-LHC would be sensitive to the large majority of parameter points at high scalar masses. We also found that in the renormalizable and weakly coupled EFT requiring a SFOEWPT suppressed the maximum resonant di-Higgs rate relative to when the SFOEWPT was not required. The maximum resonant di-Higgs rates were similar in the renormalizable and weakly coupled EFT. This is true when effective operators are added only to the potential and the largest BR⁡(h2→h1h1)\operatorname{BR}(h_2 \to h_1h_1) occur for small sin⁡θ\sin\theta. However, if new physics or effective operators alter the h2h_2 production mechanism, the resonant di-Higgs rate can be enhanced [47].

For the gravitational wave signals, the results in both the renormalizable model and weakly coupled theory were similar. Only a few points had peak frequencies that would be observable at future gravitational wave detectors. That is, the predictions of the GW signal in the real singlet model are robust against additional weakly coupled physics at the TeV scale. The strongly coupled EFT had many more points that are potentially observable. This indicates that to enhance the GW signature in the real singlet model, either there should be a strongly interacting theory in the TeV range or the theory needs additional contributions to the phase transition below a TeV. Additionally, there is a correlation between the one-loop Higgs trilinear and gravitational wave signals. When HL-LHC constraints were applied, most of the points in the renormalizable model and weakly coupled EFT with stronger gravitational wave signals are eliminated. This is not the case when the trilinear coupling is evaluated at tree level. In the strongly coupled EFT, there were still many points with an observable GW signal even after the HL-LHC constraints.

Finally, our analysis of the one-loop trilinear scalar couplings used the zero temperature effective potential. However, the effective potential is evaluated when the external momenta are zero, which is not the case in measurements of the Higgs trilinear coupling and the decay h2→h1h1h_2 \to h_1 h_1. Indeed, there are loops that can contribute when the external momenta are non-zero which do not contribute when the external momenta are zero. Our work shows the importance of these loop corrections at the renormalizable and EFT level, as has been found in other studies on the renormalizable level [4, 9, 114, 115, 116, 117, 118, 119]. We leave a more careful calculation of the one-loop corrections to trilinear scalar couplings [110, 131, 132, 133] to future work.

Acknowledgements

MC is supported by the National Science Foundation Graduate Research Fellowship Program. PH is supported by the National Science Foundation under grant number PHY-2412875. IML is supported in part by the United States Department of Energy grant number DE-SC0024673. Data to reproduce the figures are available upon request.

Experimental Searches

In this appendix are detailed the Higgs signal strengths [App. A.1] and scalar searches [App. A.2] included in the sin⁡θ\sin\theta bounds as presented in § 2.3.

Higgs Precision Measurements

Both ATLAS [134] and CMS [75] have released combinations of Higgs signal strengths measured during Run 2 at 13 TeV. Since the renormalizable singlet model has a universal Higgs signal strength we use the combined global signal strengths:

μ^ATLAS=0.990−0.051+0.053ATLAS Combination\hat{\mu}_{\mathrm{ATLAS}} = 0.990^{+0.053}_{-0.051}\quad\text{ATLAS Combination}
μ^CMS=1.014−0.053+0.055CMS Combination.(54)\hat{\mu}_{\mathrm{CMS}} = 1.014^{+0.055}_{-0.053}\quad\text{CMS Combination.} \tag*{(54)}

Not included in the CMS combination are Run 2 searches for a boosted Higgs decaying to hadronic or semi-hadronic WW∗WW^{*} [135] or boosted VhVh production with hadronic VV and h→bbˉh \to b\bar{b} [136]. Hence, we also include those signal strengths in our fit:

μ^CMSWW=−0.19−0.46+0.48\hat{\mu}_{\mathrm{CMS}}^{WW} = -0.19^{+0.48}_{-0.46}
μ^Vh,CMSbb=0.72−0.71+0.75.(55)\hat{\mu}_{Vh,\mathrm{CMS}}^{bb} = 0.72^{+0.75}_{-0.71}. \tag*{(55)}

Both ATLAS and CMS have released several Run 3 measurements at 13.6 TeV. ATLAS has released Run 3 measurements of h→Zγh \to Z\gamma with 165 fb−1^{-1} of data [137], h→ZZh \to ZZ with 164 fb−1^{-1} [138], h→μμh \to\mu\mu with 165 fb−1^{-1} [139], and h→γγh \to\gamma\gamma with 31.4 fb−1^{-1} [140]:

μ^ATLASZγ=0.9−0.6+0.7μ^ATLASZZ=0.99±0.13μ^ATLASμμ=1.4±0.4μ^ATLASγγ=1.12±0.21.(56)\begin{aligned} \hat{\mu}_{\mathrm{ATLAS}}^{Z\gamma} &= 0.9^{+0.7}_{-0.6} \\ \hat{\mu}_{\mathrm{ATLAS}}^{ZZ} &= 0.99 \pm0.13 \\ \hat{\mu}_{\mathrm{ATLAS}}^{\mu\mu} &= 1.4 \pm0.4 \\ \hat{\mu}_{\mathrm{ATLAS}}^{\gamma\gamma} &= 1.12 \pm0.21. \tag*{(56)} \end{aligned}

CMS has released Run 3 measurements of h→γγh \to\gamma\gamma with 34.7 fb−1^{-1} [141] and h→ZZh \to ZZ with 171 fb−1^{-1} [142]:

μ^CMSγγ=1.09±0.19μ^CMSZZ=1.02±0.11.(57)\begin{aligned} \hat{\mu}_{\mathrm{CMS}}^{\gamma\gamma} &= 1.09 \pm0.19 \\ \hat{\mu}_{\mathrm{CMS}}^{ZZ} &= 1.02 \pm0.11. \tag*{(57)} \end{aligned}

All the signal strengths in Eqs. (A.1-A.4) are included in the χ2\chi^2 fit for h1h_1 in Eq. (35).

Scalar Searches

Table 1 lists all the scalar searches included in the sin⁡θ\sin\theta bounds that are presented in § 2.3. Since the couplings of h2h_2 to SM fermions and gauge bosons are the same as a SM Higgs at the same mass, h2h_2 is expected to decay like a SM Higgs at mass m2m_2 with the additional decay channel of h2→h1h1h_2 \to h_1h_1. That is, when kinematically allowed, h2h_2 predominantly decays into WWWW, ZZZZ, and h1h1h_1h_1. Hence, those are the searches included in our fits. If two searches from a collaboration have overlapping data sets, the most constraining of the two searches was used.

ExperimentSearch ChannelLuminosityh2h_2 Mass RangeRef.
ATLASh2→WW→eνμνh_2 \to WW \to e\nu\mu\nu in ggF and VBF139 fb−1^{-1}200-3800 GeV in ggF 200-4000 GeV in VBF[143]
ATLASh2→ZZ→4ℓ/2ℓ2νh_2 \to ZZ \to4\ell/2\ell2\nu in ggF and VBF139 fb−1^{-1}210-2000 GeV[144]
ATLASh2→WW+ZZ→2ℓ2q/ℓν2qh_2 \to WW + ZZ \to2\ell2q/\ell\nu2q in ggF and VBF139 fb−1^{-1}300-5000 GeV[145]
ATLASh2→h1h1→4b/2b2γ/2b2τh_2 \to h_1h_1 \to4b/2b2\gamma/2b2\tau in ggF126-136 fb−1^{-1}250-5000 GeV[146]
ATLASh2→(h1→2b)(S→2γ)h_2 \to(h_1 \to2b)(S \to2\gamma) in ggF140 fb−1^{-1} at 13 TeV +59 fb−1^{-1} at 13.6 TeV275-1000 GeV[147]
ATLASh2→h1h1→4Wh_2 \to h_1h_1 \to4W in ggF36.1 fb−1^{-1}250-500 GeV[148]
ATLASh2→h1h1→2b2Wh_2 \to h_1h_1 \to2b2W in ggF36.1 fb−1^{-1}500-3000 GeV[149]
ATLASh2→h1h1→2γ2Wh_2 \to h_1h_1 \to2\gamma2W in ggF36.1 fb−1^{-1}250-500 GeV[150]
ATLASh2→h1h1→4bh_2 \to h_1h_1 \to4b in VBF126 fb−1^{-1}260-1000 GeV[151]
CMSh2→ZZ→4ℓh_2 \to ZZ \to4\ell in ggF and VBF138 fb−1^{-1}130-3000 GeV[152]
CMSh2→ZZ→2ℓ2qh_2 \to ZZ \to2\ell2q in ggF138 fb−1^{-1}450-1800 GeV[153]
CMSh2→WW→2ℓ2νh_2 \to WW \to2\ell2\nu in ggF and VBF combined138 fb−1^{-1}180-5000 GeV[154]
CMSh2→WW→2ℓ2ν/ℓν2qh_2 \to WW \to2\ell2\nu/\ell\nu2q in ggF and VBF combined35.9 fb−1^{-1}200-3000 GeV[155]
CMSh2→h1h1→4W/4τ/2W2τ/2b2W/2b2τ/2b2γ/4bh_2 \to h_1h_1 \to4W/4\tau/2W2\tau/2b2W/2b2\tau/2b2\gamma/4b in ggF138 fb−1^{-1}250-4000 GeV[156]
CMSh2→h1h1→4bh_2 \to h_1h_1 \to4b in ggF138 fb−1^{-1}400-1400 GeV[157]
CMSh2→(h1→2b)(S→2γ)h_2 \to(h_1 \to2b)(S \to2\gamma) in ggF132 fb−1^{-1}280-1000 GeV[158]
CMSh2→(h1→2γ)(S→2b)h_2 \to(h_1 \to2\gamma)(S \to2b) in ggF138 fb−1^{-1}260-1000 GeV[159]
CMSh2→h1h1→2τ2γh_2 \to h_1h_1 \to2\tau2\gamma138 fb−1^{-1}300-1000 GeV[160]
CMSh2→h1h1→2b2Zh_2 \to h_1h_1 \to2b2Z in ggF138 fb−1^{-1}260-4000 GeV[161]
CMSh2→h1h1→2b2τh_2 \to h_1h_1 \to2b2\tau in ggF138 fb−1^{-1}250-3000 GeV[162]

Table 1. The scalar searches included in the bounds on sin⁡θ\sin\theta. All searches at 13 TeV unless otherwise noted.

Trilinear and Quartic Scalar Couplings

The trilinear and quartic scalar couplings are defined as

V(Φ,S)⊃13!λ111h13+12λ112h12h2+12λ122h1h22+13!λ222h23+14!λ1111h14+13!λ1112h13h2+14λ1122h12h22+13!λ1222h1h23+14!λ2222h24(58)\begin{aligned} V(\Phi,S) \supset{}& \frac{1}{3!}\lambda_{111}h_1^3 + \frac{1}{2}\lambda_{112}h_1^2h_2 + \frac{1}{2}\lambda_{122}h_1h_2^2 + \frac{1}{3!}\lambda_{222}h_2^3 + \frac{1}{4!}\lambda_{1111}h_1^4 \\ &+ \frac{1}{3!}\lambda_{1112}h_1^3h_2 + \frac{1}{4}\lambda_{1122}h_1^2h_2^2 + \frac{1}{3!}\lambda_{1222}h_1h_2^3 + \frac{1}{4!}\lambda_{2222}h_2^4 \tag*{(58)} \end{aligned}

The trilinear couplings λ111\lambda_{111} and λ112\lambda_{112} are already reported in Eqs. (10),(11), respectively. The remaining trilinear and quartic couplings are:

λ122=2m22+m12vEWcos⁡θsin⁡2θ−2(a2vEW(1−32cos⁡2θ)−b3sin⁡θcos⁡θ)cos⁡θ+vEW2Λsin⁡θ(32a3cos⁡2θ+a4(1−3cos⁡2θ))+6vEW3Λ2cos⁡θ(CHsin⁡2θ−13a6(1−32cos⁡2θ))+O(Λ−3)(59)\begin{aligned} \lambda_{122} ={}& \frac{2m_2^2+m_1^2}{v_{\mathrm{EW}}}\cos\theta\sin^2\theta- 2\left(a_2v_{\mathrm{EW}}\left(1-\frac{3}{2}\cos^2\theta\right)-b_3\sin\theta\cos\theta\right)\cos\theta\\ &+\frac{v_{\mathrm{EW}}^2}{\Lambda}\sin\theta\left(\frac{3}{2}a_3\cos^2\theta+a_4\left(1-3\cos^2\theta\right)\right) \\ &+\frac{6v_{\mathrm{EW}}^3}{\Lambda^2}\cos\theta\left(C_H\sin^2\theta-\frac{1}{3}a_6\left(1-\frac{3}{2}\cos^2\theta\right)\right)+O(\Lambda^{-3}) \tag*{(59)} \end{aligned}
λ222=−3m22vEWsin⁡3θ+(−3a2vEWsin⁡θ+2b3cos⁡θ)cos⁡2θ+3vEW2Λcos⁡θ(12a3cos⁡2θ+a4sin⁡2θ\lambda_{222}=-3\frac{m_2^2}{v_{\mathrm{EW}}}\sin^3\theta+(-3a_2v_{\mathrm{EW}}\sin\theta+2b_3\cos\theta)\cos^2\theta+3\frac{v_{\mathrm{EW}}^2}{\Lambda}\cos\theta(\frac{1}{2}a_3\cos^2\theta+a_4\sin^2\theta
−6vEW3Λ2sin⁡θ(CHsin⁡2θ+12a6cos⁡2θ)+O(Λ−3)(60)-6\frac{v_{\mathrm{EW}}^3}{\Lambda^2}\sin\theta\left(C_H\sin^2\theta+\frac{1}{2}a_6\cos^2\theta\right)+O(\Lambda^{-3}) \tag*{(60)}
λ1111=3m12cos⁡2θ+m22sin⁡2θvEW2cos⁡4θ+6(a2cos⁡2θ+b4sin⁡2θ)sin⁡2θ+12vEWΛcos⁡θsin⁡θ(a3sin⁡2θ+a4cos⁡2θ)+36vEW2Λ2(CHcos⁡4θ+16a5sin⁡4θ+12a6cos⁡2θsin⁡2θ)+O(Λ−3)(61)\lambda_{1111}=3\frac{m_1^2\cos^2\theta+m_2^2\sin^2\theta}{v_{\mathrm{EW}}^2}\cos^4\theta+6\left(a_2\cos^2\theta+b_4\sin^2\theta\right)\sin^2\theta +12\frac{v_{\mathrm{EW}}}{\Lambda}\cos\theta\sin\theta\left(a_3\sin^2\theta+a_4\cos^2\theta\right) +36\frac{v_{\mathrm{EW}}^2}{\Lambda^2}\left(C_H\cos^4\theta+\frac{1}{6}a_5\sin^4\theta+\frac{1}{2}a_6\cos^2\theta\sin^2\theta\right)+O(\Lambda^{-3}) \tag*{(61)}
λ1112=−3m12cos⁡2θ+m22sin⁡2θvEW2cos⁡3θsin⁡θ+3(a2(cos⁡2θ−sin⁡2θ)+2b4sin⁡2θ)cos⁡θsin⁡θ+3vEWΛ(3a3(1−43sin⁡2θ)sin⁡2θ+a4(1−4sin⁡2θ)cos⁡2θ)−36vEW2Λ2cos⁡θsin⁡θ(CHcos⁡2θ−16a5sin⁡2θ−14a6(cos⁡2θ−sin⁡2θ))+O(Λ−3)(62)\lambda_{1112}=-3\frac{m_1^2\cos^2\theta+m_2^2\sin^2\theta}{v_{\mathrm{EW}}^2}\cos^3\theta\sin\theta+3\left(a_2\left(\cos^2\theta-\sin^2\theta\right)+2b_4\sin^2\theta\right)\cos\theta\sin\theta +3\frac{v_{\mathrm{EW}}}{\Lambda}\left(3a_3\left(1-\frac{4}{3}\sin^2\theta\right)\sin^2\theta+a_4\left(1-4\sin^2\theta\right)\cos^2\theta\right) -36\frac{v_{\mathrm{EW}}^2}{\Lambda^2}\cos\theta\sin\theta\left(C_H\cos^2\theta-\frac{1}{6}a_5\sin^2\theta-\frac{1}{4}a_6\left(\cos^2\theta-\sin^2\theta\right)\right)+O(\Lambda^{-3}) \tag*{(62)}
λ1122=3m12cos⁡2θ+m22sin⁡2θvEW2cos⁡2θsin⁡2θ+a2(1−6cos⁡2θsin⁡2θ)+6b4cos⁡2θsin⁡2θ+6vEWΛ(cos⁡2θ−sin⁡2θ)cos⁡θsin⁡θ(a3−a4)+36vEW2Λ2(CHcos⁡2θsin⁡2θ+16a5cos⁡2θsin⁡2θ+112a6(1−6cos⁡2θsin⁡2θ))+O(Λ−3)(63)\lambda_{1122}=3\frac{m_1^2\cos^2\theta+m_2^2\sin^2\theta}{v_{\mathrm{EW}}^2}\cos^2\theta\sin^2\theta+a_2\left(1-6\cos^2\theta\sin^2\theta\right)+6b_4\cos^2\theta\sin^2\theta +6\frac{v_{\mathrm{EW}}}{\Lambda}\left(\cos^2\theta-\sin^2\theta\right)\cos\theta\sin\theta\left(a_3-a_4\right) +36\frac{v_{\mathrm{EW}}^2}{\Lambda^2}\left(C_H\cos^2\theta\sin^2\theta+\frac{1}{6}a_5\cos^2\theta\sin^2\theta+\frac{1}{12}a_6\left(1-6\cos^2\theta\sin^2\theta\right)\right)+O(\Lambda^{-3}) \tag*{(63)}
λ1222=−3m12cos⁡2θ+m22sin⁡2θvEW2cos⁡θsin⁡3θ+3(a2(sin⁡2θ−cos⁡2θ)+2b4cos⁡2θ)sin⁡θcos⁡θ\lambda_{1222}=-3\frac{m_1^2\cos^2\theta+m_2^2\sin^2\theta}{v_{\mathrm{EW}}^2}\cos\theta\sin^3\theta+3\left(a_2\left(\sin^2\theta-\cos^2\theta\right)+2b_4\cos^2\theta\right)\sin\theta\cos\theta
−3vEWΛ(3a3(1−43cos⁡2θ)cos⁡2θ+a4(1−4cos⁡2θ)sin⁡2θ)−36vEW2Λ2sin⁡θcos⁡θ(CHsin⁡2θ−16a5cos⁡2θ−14a6(sin⁡2θ−cos⁡2θ))+O(Λ−3)(64)-3\frac{v_{\mathrm{EW}}}{\Lambda}\left(3a_3\left(1-\frac{4}{3}\cos^2\theta\right)\cos^2\theta+a_4\left(1-4\cos^2\theta\right)\sin^2\theta\right) -36\frac{v_{\mathrm{EW}}^2}{\Lambda^2}\sin\theta\cos\theta\left(C_H\sin^2\theta-\frac{1}{6}a_5\cos^2\theta-\frac{1}{4}a_6\left(\sin^2\theta-\cos^2\theta\right)\right)+\mathcal{O}(\Lambda^{-3}) \tag*{(64)}
λ2222=3m12cos⁡2θ+m22sin⁡2θvEW2sin⁡4θ+6(a2sin⁡2θ+b4cos⁡2θ)cos⁡2θ−12vEWΛcos⁡θsin⁡θ(a3cos⁡2θ+a4sin⁡2θ)+36vEW2Λ2(CHsin⁡4θ+16a5cos⁡4θ+12a6cos⁡2θsin⁡2θ)+O(Λ−3)(65)\lambda_{2222}=3\frac{m_1^2\cos^2\theta+m_2^2\sin^2\theta}{v_{\mathrm{EW}}^2}\sin^4\theta+6\left(a_2\sin^2\theta+b_4\cos^2\theta\right)\cos^2\theta -12\frac{v_{\mathrm{EW}}}{\Lambda}\cos\theta\sin\theta\left(a_3\cos^2\theta+a_4\sin^2\theta\right) +36\frac{v_{\mathrm{EW}}^2}{\Lambda^2}\left(C_H\sin^4\theta+\frac{1}{6}a_5\cos^4\theta+\frac{1}{2}a_6\cos^2\theta\sin^2\theta\right)+\mathcal{O}(\Lambda^{-3}) \tag*{(65)}

Truncating V(1)V^{(1)} for 1 loop trilinears

In this appendix we discuss the expansion of the scalar mass matrix in inverse powers of the new physics scale and the calculation of the scalar contributions to the trilinears λ111\lambda_{111} and λ112\lambda_{112}.

The two-by-two scalar mass matrix is organized as

M=M0+1ΛM1+1Λ2M2,(66)\mathcal{M}=\mathcal{M}_0+\frac{1}{\Lambda}\mathcal{M}_1+\frac{1}{\Lambda^2}\mathcal{M}_2, \tag*{(66)}

where the subscript indicates the order of Λ−n\Lambda^{-n}. The eigenvalues are then:

m±2=12(Tr⁡M±(Tr⁡M)2−4det⁡M)(67)m_\pm^2=\frac{1}{2}\left(\operatorname{Tr}\mathcal{M}\pm\sqrt{(\operatorname{Tr}\mathcal{M})^2-4\det\mathcal{M}}\right) \tag*{(67)}

To order Λ−2\Lambda^{-2}, the determinant is:

det⁡M=A0+1ΛA1+1Λ2A2(68)\det\mathcal{M}=A_0+\frac{1}{\Lambda}A_1+\frac{1}{\Lambda^2}A_2 \tag*{(68)}

where

A0=(M0)11(M0)22−[(M0)12]2(69)A_0=(\mathcal{M}_0)_{11}(\mathcal{M}_0)_{22}-[(\mathcal{M}_0)_{12}]^2 \tag*{(69)}
A1=(M0)11(M1)22+(M0)22(M1)11−2(M0)12(M1)12A2=(M2)11(M0)22+(M2)22(M0)11+(M1)11(M1)22−2(M2)12(M0)12−[(M1)12]2\begin{aligned} A_1&=(\mathcal{M}_0)_{11}(\mathcal{M}_1)_{22}+(\mathcal{M}_0)_{22}(\mathcal{M}_1)_{11}-2(\mathcal{M}_0)_{12}(\mathcal{M}_1)_{12}\\ A_2&=(\mathcal{M}_2)_{11}(\mathcal{M}_0)_{22}+(\mathcal{M}_2)_{22}(\mathcal{M}_0)_{11}+(\mathcal{M}_1)_{11}(\mathcal{M}_1)_{22}-2(\mathcal{M}_2)_{12}(\mathcal{M}_0)_{12}-[(\mathcal{M}_1)_{12}]^2 \end{aligned}

The eigenvalues to order Λ−2\Lambda^{-2} are

m±2(ϕ0,S)=m±,02+1Λm±,12+1Λ2m±,22(70)m_\pm^2(\phi_0,S)=m_{\pm,0}^2+\frac{1}{\Lambda}m_{\pm,1}^2+\frac{1}{\Lambda^2}m_{\pm,2}^2 \tag*{(70)}

where

m±,02=12(Tr⁡(M0)±Tr⁡(M0)2−4A0)(71)m_{\pm,0}^2=\frac{1}{2}\left(\operatorname{Tr}(\mathcal{M}_0)\pm\sqrt{\operatorname{Tr}(\mathcal{M}_0)^2-4A_0}\right) \tag*{(71)}
m±,12=12(Tr⁡(M1)±Tr⁡(M0)Tr⁡(M1)−2A1Tr⁡(M0)2−4A0)m_{\pm,1}^2=\frac{1}{2}\left(\operatorname{Tr}(\mathcal{M}_1)\pm\frac{\operatorname{Tr}(\mathcal{M}_0)\operatorname{Tr}(\mathcal{M}_1)-2A_1}{\sqrt{\operatorname{Tr}(\mathcal{M}_0)^2-4A_0}}\right)
m±,22=12(Tr⁡(M2)±(2Tr⁡(M0)Tr⁡(M2)+Tr⁡(M1)2−4A22Tr⁡(M0)2−4A0−(Tr⁡(M0)Tr⁡(M1)−2A1)22(Tr⁡(M0)2−4A0)3/2))m_{\pm,2}^2=\frac{1}{2}\left(\operatorname{Tr}(\mathcal{M}_2)\pm\left(\frac{2\operatorname{Tr}(\mathcal{M}_0)\operatorname{Tr}(\mathcal{M}_2)+\operatorname{Tr}(\mathcal{M}_1)^2-4A_2}{2\sqrt{\operatorname{Tr}(\mathcal{M}_0)^2-4A_0}}-\frac{(\operatorname{Tr}(\mathcal{M}_0)\operatorname{Tr}(\mathcal{M}_1)-2A_1)^2}{2(\operatorname{Tr}(\mathcal{M}_0)^2-4A_0)^{3/2}}\right)\right)

Then for a term in the 1 loop potential,

ΔVT=0,i(1)=ni64π2[mi4(ϕ0,S)(log⁡mi2(ϕ0,S)mi2(vEW,0)−32)+2mi2(ϕ0,S)mi2(vEW,0)](72)\Delta V^{(1)}_{T=0,i}=\frac{n_i}{64\pi^2}\left[m_i^4(\phi_0,S)\left(\log\frac{m_i^2(\phi_0,S)}{m_i^2(v_{\rm EW},0)}-\frac{3}{2}\right)+2m_i^2(\phi_0,S)m_i^2(v_{\rm EW},0)\right] \tag*{(72)}

with a mass that depends on Λ\Lambda, the truncated potential is

ΔVT=0(1)=ΔV0,(T=0)(1)+1ΛΔV1,(T=0)(1)+1Λ2ΔV2,(T=0)(1)(73)\Delta V^{(1)}_{T=0}=\Delta V^{(1)}_{0,(T=0)}+\frac{1}{\Lambda}\Delta V^{(1)}_{1,(T=0)}+\frac{1}{\Lambda^2}\Delta V^{(1)}_{2,(T=0)} \tag*{(73)}

where

ΔV0,(T=0)(1)=ni64π2[(m±,02(ϕ0,S))2(log⁡m±,02(ϕ0,S)m±2(vEW,0)−32)+2m±,02(ϕ0,S)m±2(vEW,0)]\Delta V^{(1)}_{0,(T=0)}=\frac{n_i}{64\pi^2}\left[(m^2_{\pm,0}(\phi_0,S))^2\left(\log\frac{m^2_{\pm,0}(\phi_0,S)}{m^2_{\pm}(v_{\rm EW},0)}-\frac{3}{2}\right)+2m^2_{\pm,0}(\phi_0,S)m^2_{\pm}(v_{\rm EW},0)\right]
ΔV1,(T=0)(1)=ni64π2[2m±,02(ϕ0,S)m±,12(ϕ0,S)(log⁡m±,02(ϕ0,S)m±2(vEW,0)−1)+2m±,12(ϕ0,S)m±2(vEW,0)]\Delta V^{(1)}_{1,(T=0)}=\frac{n_i}{64\pi^2}\left[2m^2_{\pm,0}(\phi_0,S)m^2_{\pm,1}(\phi_0,S)\left(\log\frac{m^2_{\pm,0}(\phi_0,S)}{m^2_{\pm}(v_{\rm EW},0)}-1\right)+2m^2_{\pm,1}(\phi_0,S)m^2_{\pm}(v_{\rm EW},0)\right]
ΔV2,(T=0)(1)=ni64π2[2m±,02(ϕ0,S)m±,22(ϕ0,S)(log⁡m±,02(ϕ0,S)m±2(vEW,0)−1)(74)\Delta V^{(1)}_{2,(T=0)}=\frac{n_i}{64\pi^2}[2m^2_{\pm,0}(\phi_0,S)m^2_{\pm,2}(\phi_0,S)(\log\frac{m^2_{\pm,0}(\phi_0,S)}{m^2_{\pm}(v_{\rm EW},0)}-1) \tag*{(74)}
+(m±,12(ϕ0,S))2(log⁡m±,02(ϕ0,S)m±2(vEW,0))+2m±,22(ϕ0,S)m±2(vEW,0)](75)+(m^2_{\pm,1}(\phi_0,S))^2(\log\frac{m^2_{\pm,0}(\phi_0,S)}{m^2_{\pm}(v_{\rm EW},0)})+2m^2_{\pm,2}(\phi_0,S)m^2_{\pm}(v_{\rm EW},0)] \tag*{(75)}

In the sin⁡θ→0\sin\theta\to0 limit, we find the one-loop correction to the Higgs trilinear including the top, WW, and ZZ:

λ111(1)=vEW4π2[3vEW4(−4mt4+2MW4+MZ4+98m14)+814CHm12Λ2+18vEW2m22a22(a2+3a6vEW2Λ2)]+O(sin⁡θ,Λ−3)(76)\lambda^{(1)}_{111}=\frac{v_{\rm EW}}{4\pi^2}\left[\frac{3}{v_{\rm EW}^4}\left(-4m_t^4+2M_W^4+M_Z^4+\frac{9}{8}m_1^4\right)+\frac{81}{4}C_H\frac{m_1^2}{\Lambda^2} +\frac{1}{8}\frac{v_{\rm EW}^2}{m_2^2}a_2^2\left(a_2+3a_6\frac{v_{\rm EW}^2}{\Lambda^2}\right)\right]+\mathcal{O}\left(\sin\theta,\Lambda^{-3}\right) \tag*{(76)}
λ112(1)=116π2[vEW2m22a2(a2b3+34a2a3vEW2Λ+2a6b3vEW2Λ2)+92a4m12Λ]+O(sin⁡θ,Λ−3).(77)\lambda^{(1)}_{112}=\frac{1}{16\pi^2}\left[\frac{v_{\rm EW}^2}{m_2^2}a_2\left(a_2b_3+\frac{3}{4}a_2a_3\frac{v_{\rm EW}^2}{\Lambda}+2a_6b_3\frac{v_{\rm EW}^2}{\Lambda^2}\right) +\frac{9}{2}a_4\frac{m_1^2}{\Lambda}\right]+\mathcal{O}\left(\sin\theta,\Lambda^{-3}\right). \tag*{(77)}

Temperature Corrected Masses

The temperature corrections to the Goldstone boson masses are

ΠG(T)=(316g2+116g′2+14yt2+12λ+124a2)T2.(78)\Pi_G(T)=\left(\frac{3}{16}g^2+\frac{1}{16}g'^2+\frac{1}{4}y_t^2+\frac{1}{2}\lambda+\frac{1}{24}a_2\right)T^2. \tag*{(78)}

For the scalars, the temperature dependent mass corrections are

ΔMT2=(316g2+116g′2+14yt2+12λ+124a20016a2+14b4)T2.(79)\Delta\mathcal{M}_T^2= \begin{pmatrix} \frac{3}{16}g^2+\frac{1}{16}g'^2+\frac{1}{4}y_t^2+\frac{1}{2}\lambda+\frac{1}{24}a_2 & 0\\ 0 & \frac{1}{6}a_2+\frac{1}{4}b_4 \end{pmatrix}T^2. \tag*{(79)}

The thermally corrected masses are then the eigenvalues of M+ΔMT2\mathcal{M}+\Delta\mathcal{M}_T^2, where M\mathcal{M} is the zero temperature tree level mass matrix defined in Eq. (C.1).

For the longitudinal modes of the gauge bosons, the temperature corrections to the masses are

ΠWL(T)=116g2T2(80)\Pi_{W_L}(T) = \frac{11}{6}g^2T^2 \tag*{(80)}
MZL2(ϕ0,S,T)=12[mz2(ϕ0,S)+116g2cos⁡2θWT2+Δ(ϕ0,S,T)](81)\mathcal{M}^2_{Z_L}(\phi_0,S,T) = \frac{1}{2}\left[m_z^2(\phi_0,S) + \frac{11}{6}\frac{g^2}{\cos^2\theta_W}T^2 + \Delta(\phi_0,S,T)\right] \tag*{(81)}
MγL2(ϕ0,S,T)=12[mz2(ϕ0,S)+116g2cos⁡2θWT2−Δ(ϕ0,S,T)](82)\mathcal{M}^2_{\gamma_L}(\phi_0,S,T) = \frac{1}{2}\left[m_z^2(\phi_0,S) + \frac{11}{6}\frac{g^2}{\cos^2\theta_W}T^2 - \Delta(\phi_0,S,T)\right] \tag*{(82)}
Δ(ϕ0,S,T)=mz4(ϕ0,S)+113g2cos⁡22θWcos⁡2θW(mz2(ϕ0,S)+1112g2cos⁡2θWT2)(83)\Delta(\phi_0,S,T) = \sqrt{m_z^4(\phi_0,S) + \frac{11}{3}\frac{g^2\cos^2 2\theta_W}{\cos^2\theta_W}\left(m_z^2(\phi_0,S) + \frac{11}{12}\frac{g^2}{\cos^2\theta_W}T^2\right)} \tag*{(83)}

and transverse components

ΠWT=ΠZT=ΠγT=0.(84)\Pi_{W_T} = \Pi_{Z_T} = \Pi_{\gamma_T} = 0. \tag*{(84)}

Using the Parwani scheme, the photon is now introduced into the CW potential via the finite temperature mass. This term has a similar IR divergence as the Goldstone bosons, which we regulate in the same way.

Gravitational Wave Signal

A first order EWPT can produce detectable GWs sourced by bubble wall collisions, pressure waves in the plasma, and turbulence. We consider contributions from bubble wall collisions and sound waves. In the following, it is understood that ΩGW=dΩGW/dln⁡(f)\Omega_{GW} = d\Omega_{GW}/d\ln(f).

Bubble Collisions: Following [163], the GW power spectrum from bubble collisions is determined through

ΩGWenvh2=Ω~GWenvh2(a+b)f~bfaf~(a+b)+af(a+b)(85)\Omega_{GW}^{env}h^2 = \widetilde{\Omega}_{GW}^{env}h^2\frac{(a+b)\widetilde{f}^{b}f^{a}}{\widetilde{f}^{(a+b)}+af^{(a+b)}} \tag*{(85)}

where

f~=2.62×10−61.961−0.051vw+0.88vw2(βH∗)(T∗100 GeV)(g∗100)1/6Hz(86)\widetilde{f} = 2.62 \times10^{-6}\frac{1.96}{1-0.051v_w+0.88v_w^2}\left(\frac{\beta}{H_*}\right)\left(\frac{T_*}{100\ \mathrm{GeV}}\right)\left(\frac{g_*}{100}\right)^{1/6}\mathrm{Hz} \tag*{(86)}

and

Ω~GWenv=1.67×10−50.44vw31+8.28vw3(H∗β)2(κcαα+1)2(100g∗)1/3(87)\widetilde{\Omega}_{GW}^{env} = 1.67 \times10^{-5}\frac{0.44v_w^3}{1+8.28v_w^3}\left(\frac{H_*}{\beta}\right)^2\left(\frac{\kappa_c\alpha}{\alpha+1}\right)^2\left(\frac{100}{g_*}\right)^{1/3} \tag*{(87)}

with {a,b}={2.9,0.9}\{a,b\} = \{2.9,0.9\} and κc\kappa_c corresponds to the efficiency factor with numerical fits given in [164]. Because we only calculate GW sourced by bubble collisions for points with vw=1v_w = 1, we use

κc=α0.73+0.083α+α.(88)\kappa_c = \frac{\alpha}{0.73+0.083\sqrt{\alpha}+\alpha}. \tag*{(88)}

Soundwaves: As described in [130, 165] the gravitational wave power spectrum from sound waves is calculated as

ΩGWswh2=Ω~GWswh2 7.35×10−5(100g∗)1/3(κswαα+1)2(H∗R∗)(ffp,0)3(74+3(f/fp,0)2)7/2(89)\Omega_{GW}^{sw} h^2 = \widetilde{\Omega}_{GW}^{sw} h^2 \, 7.35 \times10^{-5} \left(\frac{100}{g_*}\right)^{1/3} \left(\frac{\kappa_{sw}\alpha}{\alpha+1}\right)^2 (H_*R_*) \left(\frac{f}{f_{p,0}}\right)^3 \left(\frac{7}{4+3(f/f_{p,0})^2}\right)^{7/2} \tag*{(89)}

where Ω~GWsw=0.012\widetilde{\Omega}_{GW}^{sw}=0.012, and fp,0f_{p,0} is the peak frequency today, given by

fp,0=26×10−6(1H∗R∗)(zp10)(T∗102 GeV)(g∗100)1/6 Hz(90)f_{p,0} = 26 \times10^{-6} \left(\frac{1}{H_*R_*}\right) \left(\frac{z_p}{10}\right) \left(\frac{T_*}{10^2\ \mathrm{GeV}}\right) \left(\frac{g_*}{100}\right)^{1/6}\ \mathrm{Hz} \tag*{(90)}

with zp≃10z_p \simeq10 and the mean bubble separation, R∗=(8π)1/3vw/βR_*=(8\pi)^{1/3}v_w/\beta. Additionally, Eq. (E.5) assumes the source lasts near a Hubble time. For GW sourced by sound waves, the efficiency factors are taken from the fits in Appendix A of [164]. To be conservative, we reduce the total GW power by a factor of

H∗R∗κα1+α(91)\frac{H_*R_*}{\sqrt{\frac{\kappa\alpha}{1+\alpha}}} \tag*{(91)}

which is the statement that the shock front formation timescale is shorter than a Hubble time.

Supplementary Numerical Results

In this appendix we provide supplemental numerical results for the collider phenomenology. Figure 13 is the same as Figure 4 but with the scalar trilinears evaluated at loop level. In Figure 14 we show results for the collider phenomenology in the strongly coupled EFT with ∣Ci∣≤4π|C_i| \le4\pi. The top is the same as Figure 4, the middle is the same as Figure 5, and the bottom is the same as Figure 7.

Renormalizable and Weakly Coupled EFT plots

Figure 13. Same as Figure 4 but now requiring a strong first order EWPT.

Results for the strongly coupled EFT with $|C_i| \le 4\pi$

Figure 14. Results for the strongly coupled EFT with ∣Ci∣≤4π|C_i| \le4\pi: (top) is the same as Figure 4, (middle) is the same as Figure 5, (bottom) is the same as Figure 7.

References

  1. [1]I.P. Ivanov, Building and testing models with extended Higgs sectors, Prog. Part. Nucl. Phys. 95 (2017) 160 [1702.03776].DOI
  2. [2]T. Robens and R. Santos, Bsm: Extended scalar sectors, 7, 2025 [2507.21910].
  3. [3]M.J. Ramsey-Musolf, The electroweak phase transition: a collider target, JHEP 09 (2020) 179 [1912.07189].
  4. [4]D. Goncalves, A. Kaladharan and Y. Wu, Electroweak phase transition in the 2HDM: Collider and gravitational wave complementarity, Phys. Rev. D 105 (2022) 095041 [2108.05356].
  5. [5]CMS, ATLAS collaboration, Combination of ATLAS and CMS searches for Higgs boson pair production at √s = 13 TeV, 2602.23991.
  6. [6]ATLAS, CMS collaboration, Highlights of the HL-LHC physics projections by ATLAS and CMS, 2504.00672.
  7. [7]S. Profumo, M.J. Ramsey-Musolf, C.L. Wainwright and P. Winslow, Singlet-catalyzed electroweak phase transitions and precision Higgs boson studies, Phys. Rev. D 91 (2015) 035018 [1407.5342].DOI
  8. [8]P. Huang, A.J. Long and L.-T. Wang, Probing the Electroweak Phase Transition with Higgs Factories and Gravitational Waves, Phys. Rev. D 94 (2016) 075008 [1608.06619].
  9. [9]D. Curtin, P. Meade and C.-T. Yu, Testing Electroweak Baryogenesis with Future Colliders, JHEP 11 (2014) 127 [1409.0005].
  10. [10]A.V. Kotwal, M.J. Ramsey-Musolf, J.M. No and P. Winslow, Singlet-catalyzed electroweak phase transitions in the 100 TeV frontier, Phys. Rev. D 94 (2016) 035022 [1605.06123].DOI
  11. [11]C.-Y. Chen, I. Kozaczuk and I.M. Lewis, Non-resonant Collider Signatures of a Singlet-Driven Electroweak Phase Transition, JHEP 08 (2017) 096 [1704.05844].DOI
  12. [12]A. Papaefstathiou and G. White, The Electro-Weak Phase Transition at Colliders: Discovery Post-Mortem, JHEP 02 (2022) 185 [2108.11394].DOI
  13. [13]S. Profumo, M.J. Ramsey-Musolf and G. Shaughnessy, Singlet Higgs phenomenology and the electroweak phase transition, JHEP 08 (2007) 010 [0705.2425].DOI
  14. [14]V. Barger, P. Langacker, M. McCaskey, M.J. Ramsey-Musolf and G. Shaughnessy, LHC Phenomenology of an Extended Standard Model with a Real Scalar Singlet, Phys. Rev. D 77 (2008) 035005 [0706.4311].DOI
  15. [15]J.R. Espinosa, T. Konstandin and F. Riva, Strong Electroweak Phase Transitions in the Standard Model with a Singlet, Nucl. Phys. B 854 (2012) 592 [1107.5441].DOI
  16. [16]A. Noble and M. Perelstein, Higgs self-coupling as a probe of electroweak phase transition, Phys. Rev. D 78 (2008) 065318 [0711.3018].DOI
  17. [17]P. Huang, A. Joglekar, B. Li and C.E.M. Wagner, Probing the Electroweak Phase Transition at the LHC, Phys. Rev. D 93 (2016) 055049 [1512.00068].
  18. [18]G. Kurup and M. Perelstein, Dynamics of Electroweak Phase Transition In Singlet-Scalar Extension of the Standard Model, Phys. Rev. D 96 (2017) 015036 [1704.03381].DOI
  19. [19]A. Beniwal, M. Lewicki, J.D. Wells, M. White and A.G. Williams, Gravitational wave, collider and dark matter signals from a scalar singlet electroweak baryogenesis, JHEP 08 (2017) 108 [1702.08624].DOI
  20. [20]M. Carena, Z. Liu and M. Riembau, Probing the electroweak phase transition via enhanced di-Higgs boson production, Phys. Rev. D 97 (2018) 095032 [1801.00794].DOI
  21. [21]M. Carena, Z. Liu and Y. Wang, Electroweak phase transition with spontaneous Z₂-breaking, JHEP 08 (2020) 107 [1911.10206].DOI
  22. [22]L. Niemi, P. Schicho and T.V.I. Tenkanen, Singlet-assisted electroweak phase transition at two loops, Phys. Rev. D 103 (2021) 115035 [2103.07467].
  23. [23]J. Ellis, M. Lewicki, M. Merchand, J.M. No and M. Zych, The scalar singlet extension of the Standard Model: gravitational waves versus baryogenesis, JHEP 01 (2023) 093 [2210.16305].
  24. [24]P. Huang and K.-P. Xie, Primordial black holes from an electroweak phase transition, Phys. Rev. D 105 (2022) 115033 [2201.07243].
  25. [25]M. Aboudonia, C. Balazs, A. Papaefstathiou and G. White, Investigating the electroweak phase transition with a real scalar singlet at a muon collider, JHEP 04 (2025) 093 [2410.22700].DOI
  26. [26]L. Niemi, M.J. Ramsey-Musolf and G. Xia, Nonperturbative study of the electroweak phase transition in the real scalar singlet extended standard model, Phys. Rev. D 110 (2024) 115016 [2405.01191].arxiv.org/abs/2405.01191
  27. [27]M.J. Ramsey-Musolf, T.V.I. Tenkanen and V.Q. Tran, Refining gravitational wave and collider physics dialogue via singlet scalar extension, JHEP 09 (2026) 260 [2409.17554].
  28. [28]V.K. Oikonomou and A. Gioanvakis, Electroweak phase transition in singlet extensions of the standard model with dimension-six operators, Phys. Rev. D 109 (2024) 055044 [2403.01591].arxiv.org/abs/2403.01591
  29. [29]J. Braathen, S. Heinemeyer, C.P. Boatella and A. Verduras Schaeidt, Complementarity of gravitational wave analyses and di-Higgs production in the exploration of the electroweak phase transition dynamics in the RxSM, JHEP 06 (2026) 035 [2510.12569].DOI
  30. [30]M. Bosse, G. Hiller, D. Litim, F. Maltoni, M.J. Ramsey-Musolf, S. Tentori et al., Constraining the real scalar singlet extension of the SM, 2606.12533.
  31. [31]P.H. Damgaard, A. Haarr, D. O’Connell and A. Tranberg, Effective Field Theory and Electroweak Baryogenesis in the Singlet-Extended Standard Model, JHEP 02 (2016) 107 [1512.01963].DOI
  32. [32]V. Vaskonen, Electroweak baryogenesis and gravitational waves from a real scalar singlet, Phys. Rev. D 95 (2017) 123515 [1611.02073].DOI
  33. [33]J.M. Cline, A. Friedlander, D.-M. He, K. Kainulainen, B. Laurent and D. Tucker-Smith, Baryogenesis and gravity waves from a UV-completed electroweak phase transition, Phys. Rev. D 103 (2021) 123529 [2102.12490].DOI
  34. [34]A.D. Sakharov, Violation of CP Invariance, C asymmetry, and baryon asymmetry of the universe, Pisma Zh. Eksp. Teor. Fiz. 5 (1967) 32.
  35. [35]M.-L. Xiao and J.-H. Yu, Electroweak baryogenesis in a scalar-assisted vectorlike fermion model, Phys. Rev. D 94 (2016) 015011 [1509.02931].DOI
  36. [36]J.M. Cline, Is electroweak baryogenesis dead?, 1704.08911.DOI
  37. [37]W. Chao, CP Violation at the Finite Temperature, Phys. Lett. B 796 (2019) 102 [1706.01041].
  38. [38]N.F. Bell, M.J. Dolan, L.S. Friedrich, M.J. Ramsey-Musolf and R.R. Volkas, Electroweak Baryogenesis with Vector-like Leptons and Scalar Singlets, JHEP 09 (2019) 012 [1903.11255].DOI
  39. [39]J.R. Espinosa, B. Gripaios, T. Konstantin and F. Riva, Electroweak Baryogenesis in Non-minimal Composite Higgs Models, JCAP 01 (2012) 012 [1110.2876].DOI
  40. [40]J.M. Cline and K. Kainulainen, Electroweak baryogenesis and dark matter from a singlet Higgs, JCAP 01 (2013) 012 [1210.4196].
  41. [41]F.P. Huang, Z. Qian and M. Zhang, Exploring dynamical CP violation induced baryogenesis by gravitational waves and colliders, Phys. Rev. D 98 (2018) 015014 [1804.06813].DOI
  42. [42]M. Carena, Y.-Y. Li, T. Ou and Y. Wang, Anatomy of the electroweak phase transition for dark sector induced baryogenesis, JHEP 02 (2023) 139 [2210.14352].DOI
  43. [43]J.H. Kim and I.M. Lewis, Loop induced single top partner production and decay at the lhc, JHEP 05 (2018) 095 [1803.06351].DOI
  44. [44]H. Alhazmi, J.H. Kim, K. Kong and I.M. Lewis, Shedding light on top partner at the lhc, JHEP 01 (2019) 139 [1808.03649].DOI
  45. [45]J.C. Criado and M. Perez-Victoria, Vector-like quarks with non-renormalizable interactions, JHEP 01 (2020) 057 [1908.08964].DOI
  46. [46]P. Li, Z. Liu and L.-T. Wang, A Busy Higgs Signal, 2604.14284.arxiv.org/abs/2604.14284
  47. [47]S. Roy and C.E.M. Wagner, Alignment and Enhanced Multi-Higgs Production, 2605.29345.arxiv.org/abs/2605.29345
  48. [48]A. Crivellin, M. Ghezzi and M. Proсura, Effective Field Theory with Two Higgs Doublets, JHEP 09 (2016) 160 [1608.00975].
  49. [49]A. Carmona, F. Goertz and A. Papaefstathiou, Uncovering the relation of a scalar resonance to the Higgs boson, Phys. Rev. D 95 (2017) 095022 [1606.02716].DOI
  50. [50]Anisha, S. Das Bakshi, J. Chakrabortty and S. Prakash, Hilbert Series and Plethystics: Paving the path towards 2HDM- and MLRS-MEFT, JHEP 09 (2019) 035 [1905.11047].DOI
  51. [51]S. Karmakar and S. Rakshit, Relaxed constraints on the heavy scalar masses in 2HDM, Phys. Rev. D 100 (2019) 055016 [1901.11361].DOI
  52. [52]J.L. Diaz-Cruz, J. Hernandez-Sanchez and J.J. Toscano, An Effective Lagrangian description of charged Higgs decays H+ → W+γ, W+Z and W+ h0, Phys. Lett. B 512 (2001) 339 [hep-ph/0106001].DOI
  53. [53]S. Bar-Shalom, J. Cohen, A. Soni and J. Wudka, Phenomenology of TeV-scale scalar Leptoquarks in the EFT, Phys. Rev. D 100 (2019) 055020 [1812.03178].DOI
  54. [54]M. Chala, G. Durieux, C. Grojean, D. de Lima and O. Matsedonskyi, Minimally extended SILH, JHEP 06 (2017) 088 [1703.10624].DOI
  55. [55]J.F. Kamenik, B.R. Safdi, Y. Soreq and J. Zupan, Comments on the diphoton excess: critical reappraisal of effective field theory interpretations, JHEP 07 (2016) 042 [1603.06566].DOI
  56. [56]U. Banerjee, J. Chakrabortty, S. Prakash, S.U. Rahaman and M. Spannowsky, Effective Operator Bases for Beyond Standard Model Scenarios: An EFT compendium for discoveries, JHEP 01 (2021) 028 [2008.11512].DOI
  57. [57]Anisha, U. Banerjee, J. Chakrabortty, C. Englert, M. Spannowsky and P. Stylianou, Effective connections of μ, Higgs physics, and the collider frontier, Phys. Rev. D 105 (2022) 016019 [2108.07683].
  58. [58]M. Mitra, S. Mandal, R. Padhan, A. Sarkar and M. Spannowsky, Reexamining right-handed neutrino EFTs up to dimension six, Phys. Rev. D 106 (2022) 113008 [2210.12404].DOI
  59. [59]M. Mitra, S.U. Rahaman, S. Saha and M. Spannowsky, Differentiating Dimension-6 and Dimension-8 Effects in νSMEFT at the HL-LHC, 2602.02720.
  60. [60]S. Dawson and I.M. Lewis, Singlet model interference effects with high scale uv physics, Phys. Rev. D 95 (2017) 015004 [1605.04944].DOI
  61. [61]M. Bauer, A. Butter, J. Gonzalez-Fraile, T. Plehn and M. Rauch, Learning from a higgs-like scalar resonance, Phys. Rev. D 95 (2017) 055011 [1607.04562].DOI
  62. [62]S. Adhikari, I.M. Lewis and M. Sullivan, Beyond the standard model effective field theory: The singlet extended standard model, Phys. Rev. D 103 (2021) 075027 [2003.10449].
  63. [63]B. Gripaios and D. Sutherland, An operator basis for the standard model with an added scalar singlet, JHEP 08 (2016) 103 [1604.07365].DOI
  64. [64]A. Bhattacharyya, S. Biswas and S. Niyogi, Electroweak phase transitions in a U(1)D extension of the standard model with dimension-six operators: Gravitational waves and LHC signatures, Phys. Rev. D 114 (2026) 035014 [2603.18583].arxiv.org/abs/2603.18583
  65. [65]J. Alison et al., Higgs boson potential at colliders: Status and perspectives, Rev. Phys. 5 (2020) 100045 [1910.00012].DOI
  66. [66]S. Dawson and I.M. Lewis, NLO corrections to double Higgs boson production in the Higgs singlet model, Phys. Rev. D 92 (2015) 094023 [1508.05397].DOI
  67. [67]I.M. Lewis, J.L. Scott, M.A.S. Alcaraz and M. Sullivan, Real singlet scalar benchmarks in the multi-TeV resonance regime, Phys. Rev. D 112 (2025) 095024 [2410.08275].DOI
  68. [68]S.D. Lane, I.M. Lewis and M. Sullivan, Resonant multiscalar production in the generic complex singlet model in the multi-TeV region, Phys. Rev. D 110 (2024) 055017 [2403.18003].DOI
  69. [69]T. Robens and T. Stefaniak, Status of the Higgs Singlet Extension of the Standard Model after LHC Run 1, Eur. Phys. J. C 75 (2015) 104 [1501.02234].DOI
  70. [70]T. Robens and T. Stefaniak, LHC Benchmark Scenarios for the Real Higgs Singlet Extension of the Standard Model, Eur. Phys. J. C 76 (2016) 268 [1601.07880].DOI
  71. [71]C.-Y. Chen, S. Dawson and I.M. Lewis, Exploring resonant di-higgs boson production in the higgs singlet model, Phys. Rev. D 91 (2015) 035015 [1410.5488].DOI
  72. [72]I.M. Lewis and M. Sullivan, Benchmarks for double higgs production in the singlet extended standard model at the lhc, Phys. Rev. D 96 (2017) 035037 [1701.08774].DOI
  73. [73]Particle Data Group collaboration, Review of Particle Physics, Int. J. Mod. Phys. A 41 (2026) 2630011.
  74. [74]ATLAS collaboration, Combined Measurement of the Higgs Boson Mass from the H→γγ and H→ZZ*→4ℓ Decay Channels with the ATLAS Detector Using √s=7, 8, and 13 TeV pp Collision Data, Phys. Rev. Lett. 131 (2023) 251802 [2308.04775].DOI
  75. [75]CMS collaboration, Combined measurements and interpretations of Higgs boson production and decay in proton-proton collisions at √s = 13 TeV, 2602.18611.
  76. [76]S.R. Coleman and E.J. Weinberg, Radiative corrections as the origin of spontaneous symmetry breaking, Phys. Rev. D 7 (1973) 1888.
  77. [77]G.W. Anderson and L.J. Hall, The Electroweak phase transition and baryogenesis, Phys. Rev. D 45 (1992) 2685.
  78. [78]C. Delaunay, C. Grojean and J.D. Wells, Dynamics of non-renormalizable electroweak symmetry breaking, JHEP 04 (2008) 029 [0711.2511].DOI
  79. [79]J.A. Casas, J.R. Espinosa, M. Quiros and A. Riotto, The Lightest Higgs boson mass in the minimal supersymmetric standard model, Nucl. Phys. B 436 (1995) 3 [hep-ph/9407389].
  80. [80]A. Schuessler and D. Zeppenfeld, Unitarity constraints on mssm trilinear couplings, in 15th International Conference on Supersymmetry and the Unification of Fundamental Interactions (SUSY07), pp. 236–239, 10, 2007 [0710.5175].arxiv.org/abs/0710.5175
  81. [81]LHC Higgs Cross Section Working Group collaboration, Handbook of LHC Higgs Cross Sections: 4. Deciphering the Nature of the Higgs Sector, CERN Yellow Rep. Monogr. 2 (2017) 1 [1610.07922].
  82. [82]H. Bahl, T. Biekötter, S. Heinemeyer, C. Li, S. Paasch, G. Weiglein et al., HiggsTools: BSM scalar phenomenology with new versions of HiggsBounds and HiggsSignals, Comput. Phys. Commun. 291 (2023) 108803 [2210.09332].DOI
  83. [83]H. Bahl, M. Carena, A. Ireland and C.E.M. Wagner, Improved thermal resummation for multi-field potentials, JHEP 09 (2024) 153 [2404.12439].arxiv.org/abs/2404.12439
  84. [84]A. Ekstedt, O. Gould and J. Löfgren, Radiative first-order phase transitions to next-to-next-to-leading order, Phys. Rev. D 106 (2022) 036012 [2205.07241].DOI
  85. [85]R.R. Parwani, Resummation in a hot scalar field theory, Phys. Rev. D 45 (1992) 4695 [hep-ph/9204216].
  86. [86]P.B. Arnold and O. Espinosa, The Effective potential and first order phase transitions: Beyond leading-order, Phys. Rev. D 47 (1993) 3546 [hep-ph/9212235].
  87. [87]A. Pilaftsis and D. Teresi, Symmetry Improved CJT Effective Action, Nucl. Phys. B 874 (2013) 594 [1305.3221].DOI
  88. [88]A. Pilaftsis and D. Teresi, Symmetry Improved 2PI Effective Action and the Infrared Divergences of the Standard Model, J. Phys. Conf. Ser. 631 (2015) 012008 [1502.07986].DOI
  89. [89]K. Funakubo and E. Senaha, Renormalization group improvement for thermally resummed effective potential, Phys. Rev. D 109 (2024) L071901 [2307.02153].
  90. [90]K. Funakubo and E. Senaha, Refined renormalization group improvement for thermally resummed effective potential, Phys. Rev. D 109 (2024) 056023 [2308.15876].
  91. [91]C.G. Boyd, D.E. Brahm and S.D.H. Hsu, Resummation methods at finite temperature: The Tadpole way, Phys. Rev. D 48 (1993) 4963 [hep-ph/9304254].
  92. [92]D. Curtin, P. Meade and H. Ramani, Thermal Resummation and Phase Transitions, Eur. Phys. J. C 78 (2018) 787 [1612.00466].
  93. [93]D. Curtin, J. Roy and G. White, Gravitational waves and tadpole resummation: Efficient and easy convergence of finite temperature QFT, Phys. Rev. D 109 (2024) 116001 [2211.08218].DOI
  94. [94]P. Bittar, S. Roy and C.E.M. Wagner, Self consistent thermal resummation: a case study of the phase transition in 2HDM, JHEP 12 (2025) 021 [2504.02024].DOI
  95. [95]C.L. Wainwright, CosmoTransitions: Computing Cosmological Phase Transition Temperatures and Bubble Profiles with Multiple Fields, Comput. Phys. Commun. 183 (2012) 2006 [1109.4189].DOI
  96. [96]V.A. Kuzmin, V.A. Rubakov and M.E. Shaposhnikov, On the Anomalous Electroweak Baryon Number Nonconservation in the Early Universe, Phys. Lett. B 155 (1985) 36.
  97. [97]P.B. Arnold and L.D. McLerran, Sphalerons, Small Fluctuations and Baryon Number Violation in Electroweak Theory, Phys. Rev. D 36 (1987) 581.
  98. [98]M.E. Shaposhnikov, Baryon Asymmetry of the Universe in Standard Electroweak Theory, Nucl. Phys. B 287 (1987) 757.DOI
  99. [99]A.G. Cohen, D.B. Kaplan and A.E. Nelson, Progress in electroweak baryogenesis, Ann. Rev. Nucl. Part. Sci. 43 (1993) 27 [hep-ph/9302210].DOI
  100. [100]L. Dolan and R. Jackiw, Symmetry Behavior at Finite Temperature, Phys. Rev. D 9 (1974) 3320.
  101. [101]L. Dolan and R. Jackiw, Gauge Invariant Signal for Gauge Symmetry Breaking, Phys. Rev. D 9 (1974) 2904.
  102. [102]D.E. Morrissey and M.J. Ramsey-Musolf, Electroweak baryogenesis, New J. Phys. 14 (2012) 125003 [1206.2942].
  103. [103]M. Garny and T. Konstandin, On the gauge dependence of vacuum transitions at finite temperature, JHEP 07 (2012) 189 [1205.3392].DOI
  104. [104]H.H. Patel and M.J. Ramsey-Musolf, Baryon Washout, Electroweak Phase Transition, and Perturbation Theory, JHEP 07 (2011) 029 [1101.4665].DOI
  105. [105]S. Arunasalam and M.J. Ramsey-Musolf, Tunneling potentials for the tunneling action: gauge invariance, JHEP 08 (2022) 138 [2105.07588].DOI
  106. [106]J. Löfgren, M.J. Ramsey-Musolf, P. Schicho and T.V.I. Tenkanen, Nucleation at Finite Temperature. A Gauge-Invariant Perturbative Framework, Phys. Rev. Lett. 130 (2023) 251801 [2112.05472].DOI
  107. [107]N.K. Nielsen, On the Gauge Dependence of Spontaneous Symmetry Breaking in Gauge Theories, Nucl. Phys. B 101 (1975) 173.
  108. [108]R. Fukuda and T. Kugo, Gauge Invariance in the Effective Action and Potential, Phys. Rev. D 13 (1976) 3469.
  109. [109]S. Kanemura, S. Kiyoura, Y. Okada, E. Senaha and C.P. Yuan, New physics effect on the Higgs selfcoupling, Phys. Lett. B 558 (2003) 157 [hep-ph/0211308].
  110. [110]H. Bahl, J. Braathen, M. Gabelmann and G. Weiglein, anyH3: precise predictions for the trilinear Higgs coupling in the Standard Model and beyond, Eur. Phys. J. C 83 (2023) 1156 [2305.03015].arxiv.org/abs/2305.03015
  111. [111]F. Arco, S. Heinemeier and M. Mühlleitner, Large one-loop effect of BSM triple Higgs couplings on double Higgs production at e+e− colliders, JHEP 01 (2026) 160 [2505.02947].
  112. [112]J. Braathen, W. Naskar and G. Weiglein, Impact of model-independent higher-order contributions to the Higgs-boson self-couplings, 2608.25705.
  113. [113]S. Kanemura, M. Kikuchi and K. Yagyu, One-loop corrections to the Higgs self-couplings in the singlet extension, Nucl. Phys. B 917 (2017) 154 [1608.01582].DOI
  114. [114]J. Braathen, S. Heinemeyer, C. Pulido Boetella and A. Verduras Schaeidt, Investigating a strong first-order electroweak phase transition in the RxSM at future linear e+e− colliders and LISA, Eur. Phys. J. Plus 141 (2026) 764 [2603.18799].DOI
  115. [115]S. Kanemura, Y. Okada and E. Senaha, Electroweak baryogenesis and quantum corrections to the triple Higgs boson coupling, Phys. Lett. B 606 (2005) 361 [hep-ph/0411354].
  116. [116]M. Reichert, A. Eichhorn, H. Gies, J.M. Pawlowski, T. Plehn and M.M. Scherer, Probing baryogenesis through the Higgs boson self-coupling, Phys. Rev. D 97 (2018) 075008 [1711.00019].DOI
  117. [117]G.C. Dorsch, S.J. Huber, K. Mimasu and J.M. No, The Higgs Vacuum Uplifted: Revisiting the Electroweak Phase Transition with a Second Higgs Doublet, JHEP 12 (2017) 086 [1705.09186].DOI
  118. [118]P. Basler, M. Mühlleitner and J. Wittbrodt, The CP-Violating 2HDM in Light of a Strong First Order Electroweak Phase Transition and Implications for Higgs Pair Production, JHEP 03 (2018) 061 [1711.04097].DOI
  119. [119]T. Biekötter, S. Heinemeyer, J.M. No, M.O. Olea-Romacho and G. Weiglein, The trap in the early Universe: impact on the interplay between gravitational waves and LHC physics in the 2HDM, JCAP 03 (2023) 031 [2208.14466].DOI
  120. [120]J. Braathen, S. Heinemeyer, A.P. Arnay and A. Verduras Schaeidt, Impact of one-loop corrections to trilinear scalar couplings on di-Higgs production in the RxSM, Eur. Phys. J. C 85 (2025) 1153 [2507.02569].DOI
  121. [121]K. Schmitz, New Sensitivity Curves for Gravitational-Wave Signals from Cosmological Phase Transitions, JHEP 01 (2021) 097 [2002.04615].DOI
  122. [122]C. Cutler and J. Harms, BBO and the neutron-star-binary subtraction problem, Phys. Rev. D 73 (2006) 042001 [gr-qc/0511092].DOI
  123. [123]S. Kawamura et al., Current status of space gravitational wave antenna DECIGO and B-DECIGO, PTEP 2021 (2021) 05A105 [2006.13545].
  124. [124]LISA collaboration, LISA Definition Study Report, 2402.07571.
  125. [125]M. Carena, A. Ireland, T. Ou and I.R. Wang, The discriminant power of bubble wall velocities: gravitational waves and electroweak baryogenesis, JHEP 09 (2025) 175 [2504.17841].arxiv.org/abs/2504.17841
  126. [126]J. van de Vis, P. Schicho, L. Niemi, B. Laurent, J. Hirvonen and O. Gould, WallGo investigates: Theoretical uncertainties in the bubble wall velocity, JHEP 04 (2026) 041 [2510.27691].
  127. [127]A. Ekstedt, O. Gould, J. Hirvonen, B. Laurent, L. Niemi, P. Schicho et al., How fast does the WallGo? A package for computing wall velocities in first-order phase transitions, JHEP 04 (2025) 101 [2411.04970].
  128. [128]M. Lewicki, M. Merchand and M. Zych, Electroweak bubble wall expansion: gravitational waves and baryogenesis in Standard Model-like thermal plasma, JHEP 02 (2022) 017 [2111.02393].
  129. [129]C. Caprini et al., Science with the space-based interferometer eLISA. II: Gravitational waves from cosmological phase transitions, JCAP 04 (2016) 001 [1512.06239].DOI
  130. [130]C. Caprini et al., Detecting gravitational waves from cosmological phase transitions with LISA: an update, JCAP 03 (2020) 024 [1910.13125].DOI
  131. [131]S. Kanemura, M. Kikuchi, K. Sakurai and K. Yagyu, H-COUP: a program for one-loop corrected Higgs boson couplings in non-minimal Higgs sectors, Comput. Phys. Commun. 233 (2018) 134 [1710.04603].DOI
  132. [132]M. Aiko, S. Kanemura, M. Kikuchi, K. Sakurai and K. Yagyu, H-COUP Version 3: A program for one-loop corrected decays of any Higgs bosons in non-minimal Higgs models, Comput. Phys. Commun. 301 (2024) 109231 [2311.15892].
  133. [133]S. Kanemura, M. Kikuchi, K. Mawatari, K. Sakurai and K. Yagyu, H-COUP Version 2: a program for one-loop corrected Higgs boson decay in non-minimal Higgs sectors, Comput. Phys. Commun. 257 (2020) 107512 [1910.12769].DOI
  134. [134]ATLAS collaboration, Combination of Higgs boson measurements at √s = 13 TeV and their interpretations by the ATLAS experiment, 2608.07332.
  135. [135]CMS collaboration, Search for Higgs boson production at high transverse momentum in the WW decay channel in proton-proton collisions at √s = 13 TeV, 2603.22233.
  136. [136]CMS collaboration, Search for a boosted higgs boson decaying to bottom quark pairs in association with a W or Z boson in proton-proton collisions at √s = 13 tev, 2601.05362.
  137. [137]ATLAS collaboration, Search for the Higgs boson decay to a Z boson and a photon in pp collisions at √s = 13 TeV and 13.6 TeV with the ATLAS detector, Phys. Lett. B 876 (2026) 140313 [2507.12598].
  138. [138]ATLAS collaboration, Measurements of the Higgs boson production, fiducial and differential cross-sections in the four lepton decay channel using 164 fb−1 of data collected at √s = 13.6 TeV with the ATLAS detector, 2605.19016.
  139. [139]ATLAS collaboration, Evidence for the dimuon decay of the higgs boson in pp collisions with the atlas detector, Phys. Rev. Lett. 135 (2025) 231802 [2507.03595].
  140. [140]ATLAS collaboration, Measurement of the h → γγ and h → zz* → 4ℓ cross-sections in pp collisions at √s = 13.6 tev with the atlas detector, Eur. Phys. J. C 84 (2024) 78 [2306.11379].
  141. [141]CMS collaboration, Measurements of inclusive and differential higgs boson production cross sections at √s = 13.6 tev in the h → γγ decay channel, JHEP 09 (2025) 070 [2504.17755].
  142. [142]CMS collaboration, Measurements of inclusive and differential cross sections for higgs boson production with decay to four leptons in proton-proton collisions at 13.6 tev, Tech. Rep. CMS-PAS-HIG-25-015, CERN, Geneva (2026).
  143. [143]ATLAS collaboration, Search for heavy resonances in the decay channel w+w− → eνμν in p p collisions at √s = 13 tev using 139 fb−1 of data with the atlas detector, Tech. Rep. ATLAS-CONF-2022-066, CERN, Geneva (2022).
  144. [144]ATLAS collaboration, Search for heavy resonances decaying into a pair of z bosons in the ℓ+ℓ−ℓ′+ℓ′− and ℓ+ℓ−νν̄ final states using 139 fb−1 of proton–proton collisions at √s = 13 tev with the atlas detector, Eur. Phys. J. C 81 (2021) 332 [2009.14791].
  145. [145]ATLAS collaboration, Search for heavy diboson resonances in semileptonic final states in pp collisions at √s = 13 tev with the atlas detector, Eur. Phys. J. C 80 (2020) 1165 [2004.14636].
  146. [146]ATLAS collaboration, Combination of searches for resonant higgs boson pair production using pp collisions at s=13 tev with the atlas detector, Phys. Rev. Lett. 132 (2024) 231801 [2311.15956].
  147. [147]ATLAS collaboration, Search for a resonance decaying into a scalar particle and a Higgs boson in the final state with two bottom quarks and two photons with 199 fb−1 of data collected at √s=13 and 13.6 TeV with the ATLAS detector, Phys. Lett. B 877 (2026) 140425 [2510.02857].
  148. [148]ATLAS collaboration, Search for higgs boson pair production in the ww(*)ww(*) decay channel using atlas data recorded at √s = 13 tev, JHEP 05 (2019) 124 [1811.11028].
  149. [149]ATLAS collaboration, Search for higgs boson pair production in the bb̄ww* decay mode at √s = 13 tev with the atlas detector, JHEP 04 (2019) 092 [1811.04671].
  150. [150]ATLAS collaboration, Search for higgs boson pair production in the γγww* channel using pp collision data recorded at √s = 13 tev with the atlas detector, Eur. Phys. J. C 78 (2018) 1007 [1807.08567].
  151. [151]ATLAS collaboration, Search for the hh → b̄b̄b̄b̄ process via vector-boson fusion production using proton-proton collisions at √s = 13 tev with the atlas detector, JHEP 07 (2020) 108 [2001.05178].DOI
  152. [152]CMS collaboration, Search for a new heavy scalar resonance decaying to a pair of Z bosons in the four-lepton final state in proton-proton collisions at √s = 13 TeV, 2605.26462.
  153. [153]CMS collaboration, Search for heavy resonances decaying to zz or zw and axion-like particles mediating nonresonant zz or zh production at √s = 13 tev, JHEP 04 (2022) 087 [2111.13669].
  154. [154]CMS collaboration, Search for high mass resonances decaying into W+W− in the dileptonic final state with 138 fb−1 of proton-proton collisions at √s = 13 TeV, Tech. Rep. CMS-PAS-HIG-20-016, CERN, Geneva (2022).
  155. [155]CMS collaboration, Search for a heavy higgs boson decaying to a pair of w bosons in proton-proton collisions at √s = 13 tev, JHEP 03 (2020) 034 [1912.01594].
  156. [156]CMS collaboration, Searches for higgs boson production through decays of heavy resonances, Phys. Rept. 1115 (2025) 368 [2403.16926].
  157. [157]CMS collaboration, Search for a new heavy scalar resonance decaying into the Higgs boson and a new scalar particle in the b̄bb̄ final state using proton-proton collisions at √s = 13 TeV, 2605.02848.
  158. [158]CMS collaboration, Search for a new scalar resonance decaying to a Higgs boson and another new scalar particle in the final state with two bottom quarks and two photons in proton-proton collisions at √s = 13 TeV, JHEP 12 (2025) 178 [2508.11494].
  159. [159]CMS collaboration, Search for a new resonance decaying into two spin-0 bosons in a final state with two photons and two bottom quarks in proton-proton collisions at √s = 13 TeV, JHEP 05 (2024) 316 [2310.01643].
  160. [160]CMS collaboration, Search for the nonresonant and resonant production of a Higgs boson in association with an additional scalar boson in the γγτ final state in proton-proton collisions at √s = 13 TeV, JHEP 05 (2026) 186 [2506.23012].
  161. [161]CMS collaboration, Search for a new resonance decaying to a Higgs boson and a scalar boson in events with two b jets and two Z bosons in proton-proton collisions at √s = 13.6 TeV, 2602.18223.
  162. [162]CMS collaboration, Search for new resonances decaying into a pair of Higgs bosons in the bb̄ττ final state in proton-proton collisions at √s = 13 TeV, Tech. Rep. CMS-PAS-B2G-24-011, CERN, Geneva (2026).
  163. [163]T. Konstandin, Gravitational radiation from a bulk flow model, Journal of Cosmology and Astroparticle Physics 2018 (2018) 047–047.
  164. [164]J.R. Espinosa, T. Konstandin, J.M. No and G. Servant, Energy budget of cosmological first-order phase transitions, Journal of Cosmology and Astroparticle Physics 2010 (2010) 028–028.
  165. [165]M. Hindmarsh, S.J. Huber, K. Rummukainen and D.J. Weir, Shape of the acoustic gravitational wave power spectrum from a first order phase transition, Phys. Rev. D 96 (2017) 103520 [1704.05871].

Paper details

vlnc:W_umwckek5
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 1

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Physics and Astronomy

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents