betaFeedback

WorksPhysics and Astronomy

Fluorite-related iridate Pr3_3IrO7_7: Crystal growth, structure, magnetism, thermodynamic, and optical properties

Abstract

Spin-orbit coupling in heavy 5dd metal oxides, in particular, iridates have received tremendous interest in recent years due to the realization of exotic electronic and magnetic phases. Here, we report the synthesis, structural, magnetic, thermodynamic, and optical properties of the ternary iridate Pr3_3IrO7_7. Single crystals of Pr3_3IrO7_7 have been grown by the KF flux method. Structural analysis shows that Pr3_3IrO7_7 crystallizes in an orthorhombic phase with CmcmCmcm symmetry. The electron energy loss spectroscopy study indicates that Pr is in a 3+ valence state, which implies a 5+ oxidation state of Ir. Magnetization data measured at high and low magnetic fields do not exhibit any bifurcation between MZFCM_{ZFC} and MFCM_{FC}, however, a weak hump in M(T)M(T) is observed at T∗T^*∼\sim10.4~K. The specific heat data reveal two maxima at ∼\sim253 K and ∼\sim4.8 K. The optical conductivity σ1(ω)σ_1(ω) spectrum shows 24 infrared-active phonon modes and reveals an insulating behavior with an optical gap ΔOPΔ_{OP} of size ∼\sim500~meV. During cooling down, the temperature-dependent reflectivity spectrum reveals eight extra phonon modes below the structural phase transition (∼\sim 253 K). An anomaly is observed at around T∗T^* in the temperature evolution of infrared-active mode frequencies suggesting the presence of significant spin-phonon coupling in the system.

Introduction

In recent years, iridates have drawn much attention due to a variety of exotic properties arising from the presence of spin-orbit coupling (SOC), on-site Coulomb (UU), and crystal field (ΔCFE\Delta_{CFE}) interactions of comparable strength [1, 2]. As compared to the 3dd transition metal oxides, iridates exhibit a large SOC and smaller UU due to the heavy and extended nature of the 5dd orbitals, respectively. In iridates, the comparable energy strength of SOC, UU, and ΔCFE\Delta_{CFE} creates a fragile balance between interactions that are predicted to host the novel topological phases i.e., Mott insulator, Weyl semimetal and axion insulator [3, 4, 5, 6]. Experimentally and theoretically, these interactions have been extensively studied in the context of tetravalent Ir4+^{4+} (5d55d^{5}) within the single particle scenario, where the strong SOC splits the Ir t2gt_{2g} states into a completely filled Jeff=3/2J_{eff}=3/2 band and a half-filled Jeff=1/2J_{eff}=1/2 band, which lies close to the Fermi energy. This half-filled Jeff=1/2J_{eff}=1/2 band further splits into a lower (filled) and an upper (empty) Hubbard band due to the presence of small UU, thus leading to a Jeff=1/2J_{eff}=1/2 Mott state [7, 8, 9]. In contrast, the Ir5+^{5+} ions have four 5d5d electrons, the Jeff=3/2J_{eff}=3/2 band is expected to be fully filled and the Jeff=1/2J_{eff}=1/2 band to be empty, leading to a nonmagnetic Jeff=0J_{eff}=0 state in the strong SOC limit. However, recent theoretical and experimental studies have shown strong evidence against the SOC driven Jeff=0J_{eff}=0 state [10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 15]. The magnetism in the Ir5+^{5+} Jeff=0J_{eff}=0 picture under strong SOC is thus debatable.

Generally, the 5dd Ir based ternary oxide materials with chemical composition A3_3IrO7_7 (AA = rare-earth metal) belong to the family of pentavalent (Ir5+^{5+}) iridates. These materials basically belong to the class of the defect-fluorite structure with orthorhombic CmcmCmcm symmetry in which the Ir5+^{5+} ions form IrO6_6 octahedra and are arranged in one-dimensional chains along the cc axis [16, 17, 18]. Previously, the structural, magnetic and thermal properties for A3_3IrO7_7 (AA = Pr, Nd, Sm, and Eu) compounds have been studied in the polycrystalline form, in addition, a single crystal study of Pr3_3IrO7_7 is reported for the electrocatalyst properties [17, 18, 19]. The specific heat data for (Pr, Nd, Sm and Eu)3_3IrO7_7 exhibit a thermal anomaly at 261, 342, 420, 485 K, respectively, which has been later assigned to a structural phase transition [17, 18]. It was reported that among these materials only Nd3_3IrO7_7 reveals an antiferromagnetic (AFM) transition at around 2.6 K [17].

In the present work, we report the synthesis and characterization of Pr3_3IrO7_7 single crystals. Molten KF flux method has been used to grow the Pr3_3IrO7_7 single crystals, which were characterized by Laue x-ray diffraction, electron energy loss spectroscopy, magnetization, specific heat, and infrared reflectivity measurements. The obtained magnetization data show a weak hump at T∗∼T^{*}\sim10.4 K and a continuous rise below 5.6 K with lowering the temperature. The M(T)M(T) data measured at low and high fields do not exhibit any bifurcation between MZFCM_{ZFC} and MFCM_{FC} either. Our specific heat results exhibit two maxima at ∼\sim253 K and ∼\sim4.8 K. The infrared reflectivity measurements show several infrared-active phonon modes, and the low reflectivity value in the low-frequency range implies an insulating behavior for Pr3_3IrO7_7. The temperature evolution of the phonon modes clearly reveal a change across the structural phase transition and a hump around T∗T^{*}.

Experimental Details

High-quality ingredient powder materials Pr6O11\mathrm{Pr}_{6}\mathrm{O}_{11} and IrO2\mathrm{IrO}_{2} with a phase purity of more than 99.99% (M/s Sigma-Aldrich) were mixed in their stoichiometric ratios with a slight excess of IrO2\mathrm{IrO}_{2} and ground well. A pre-heat treatment was performed for the starting material Pr6O11\mathrm{Pr}_{6}\mathrm{O}_{11} at 800°C for ∼8\sim8 hours to remove any residual atmospheric moisture. The powder mixture was subsequently pelletized and sintered in air at temperatures 950 - 1130°C for several days with intermediate grindings. Single crystals of Pr3IrO7\mathrm{Pr}_{3}\mathrm{IrO}_{7} were grown by KF flux method using polycrystalline sample (slight excess of IrO2\mathrm{IrO}_{2}) and KF flux in a ratio of 1:200. For the crystal growth, the sample was heated at 1100°C for 4 hours and slowly cooled to 850°C at a rate of 2°C/hour. Many small crystals were found at the wall of the Pt-crucible [left inset of Figure 1(a)]. The crystals were removed from the residual KF by rinsing them out with water. The structure and chemical composition of Pr3IrO7\mathrm{Pr}_{3}\mathrm{IrO}_{7} samples were analysed using powder x-ray diffraction (XRD) and energy dispersive analysis of x-ray (EDX) using a ZEISS Crossbeam 550/550L scanning electron microscope with an Oxford detector. To check the purity of the crystals, powder XRD was performed on the powder of the crystals using a Rigaku diffractometer (Model: Miniflex 600) with CuKα_{\alpha} radiation in 2θ2\theta range 10° to 90° with a step of 0.02°. The XRD data were analysed by Rietveld refinement using the FULLPROF program. To further check the purity of the crystals, x-ray Laue diffraction experiments were performed, confirming the high crystallinity of the crystals.

Room-temperature XRD pattern and crystal structure of Pr3IrO7

Figure 1. (a) Room-temperature XRD pattern along with Rietveld refinement for Pr3IrO7\mathrm{Pr}_3\mathrm{IrO}_7. Right and left inset show crystal image and x-ray Laue diffraction pattern of the Pr3IrO7\mathrm{Pr}_3\mathrm{IrO}_7 single crystal, respectively. (b) Crystal structure of Pr3IrO7\mathrm{Pr}_3\mathrm{IrO}_7 with the Pr(1)O8\mathrm{Pr}(1)\mathrm{O}_8 pseudocubes (blue) and IrO6\mathrm{IrO}_6 octahedra (green).

The transmission electron microscopy including electron energy-loss spectroscopy (EELS) was carried out with a JEOL NEOARM F200 instrument, equipped with a Gatan OneView camera and a Continuum S EELS spectrometer. The EELS analysis was done at 200 keV beam energy in the DualEELSTM^{\mathrm{TM}} mode. DC magnetization data were collected from 1.8 K to 300 K using a superconducting quantum interference device (SQUID, Quantum Design) magnetometer MPMS. Specific heat data were measured in the temperature range from 1.8 K to 300 K using Quantum Design PPMS DynaCool with a heat pulse relaxation method. The temperature-dependent reflectance measurements were carried out in the temperature range 300 - 5.4 K and frequency range 126 - 20000 cm−1^{-1} using a CryoVac Konti cryostat attached to a Bruker Vertex v80 Fourier transform infrared spectrometer and an infrared microscope (Bruker Hyperion). A thin silver layer was evaporated on half of the crystal, which served as reference to obtain the absolute reflectivity. The frequency resolution was set to 2 cm−1^{-1} in the far-infrared range, while a resolution of 4 cm−1^{-1} was chosen for the higher-frequency range. For the analysis, the measured reflectivity spectrum was extrapolated in the low- and high-energy regime by Lorentz fitting and x-ray optic volumetric data, respectively [20]. Note that a power-law ω3\omega^{3} interpolation with an integer n=3n=3 was used to cover the region between measured reflectivity and calculated high-energy extrapolated data.

The so-obtained reflectivity spectrum was used to obtain the real part of the optical conductivity σ1(ω)\sigma_1(\omega) and the loss function −Im⁡(1/ϵ)-\operatorname{Im}(1/\epsilon) using the Kramers-Kronig relations and a Lorentz model was used to fit the optical spectra using the RefFIT program [21].

Results and Discussions

Structural Analysis

The room-temperature XRD pattern of Pr3IrO7\mathrm{Pr}_3\mathrm{IrO}_7 together with the Rietveld refinement is shown in Figure 1 (a). The refinement analysis confirms that Pr3IrO7\mathrm{Pr}_3\mathrm{IrO}_7 is in a single phase and crystallises in an orthorhombic phase with CmcmCmcm symmetry (space group 63). The unit cell parameters aa, bb and cc are found to be 10.9710.97 Å, 7.427.42 Å and 7.537.53 Å, resp., which match the reported values [17]. We have confirmed the crystallographic planes for Pr3IrO7\mathrm{Pr}_3\mathrm{IrO}_7 single crystal through Laue diffraction, which insures that Pr3IrO7\mathrm{Pr}_3\mathrm{IrO}_7 crystals are in a unique crystalline domain [right inset of Figure 1(a)]. Figure 1(b) shows the schematic representation of the crystal structure of Pr3IrO7\mathrm{Pr}_3\mathrm{IrO}_7, where the Ir cations are six-fold coordinated and form one-dimensional chains of the corner-sharing IrO6\mathrm{IrO}_6 octahedra along the cc axis. The Pr cations are eight-fold coordinated and form a chain of eightfold-distorted Pr(1)O8\mathrm{Pr}(1)\mathrm{O}_8 cubes, which simultaneously share the edges with the chains of IrO6\mathrm{IrO}_6 octahedra. The remaining Pr(2)\mathrm{Pr}(2) cations lie in between the Pr(1)O8\mathrm{Pr}(1)\mathrm{O}_8 pseudocubes and IrO6\mathrm{IrO}_6 octahedra [17].

Electron Energy Loss Spectroscopy

In this class of oxide materials, understanding the valence state of rare-earth/transition metals is very important, since they play an important role governing the electronic, magnetic, and optical properties. As precursors, Pr6O11\mathrm{Pr}_6\mathrm{O}_{11} and IrO2\mathrm{IrO}_2 are used for the sample preparation. In Pr6O11\mathrm{Pr}_6\mathrm{O}_{11}, Pr exists in a mixed valence state of 3+/4+, i.e., 3+ for Pr2O3\mathrm{Pr}_2\mathrm{O}_3 and 4+ PrO2\mathrm{PrO}_2 [22]. In order to understand the Pr cationic charge state in Pr3IrO7\mathrm{Pr}_3\mathrm{IrO}_7, electron energy loss spectroscopy (EELS) measurements have been performed on fine powder of Pr3IrO7\mathrm{Pr}_3\mathrm{IrO}_7 single crystals. The Pr2O3\mathrm{Pr}_2\mathrm{O}_3 material with phase purity of > 99.9% was used as reference sample for the Pr 3+ charge state. The low loss spectra of the Dual EELS have been used for precise calibration of the zero-point. To process the EELS data, a power-law background fitting has been used. Furthermore, the spectra have been recorded as line scans for five different regions of each sample and analyzed. Figure 2(a) and (b) show the Pr M4M_4 and M5M_5 edge absorption spectra for Pr2O3\mathrm{Pr}_2\mathrm{O}_3 and Pr3IrO7\mathrm{Pr}_3\mathrm{IrO}_7, respectively.

EELS spectra and relative intensity ratios for Pr₂O₃ and Pr₃IrO₇

Figure 2. (a) and (b) show the EELS spectra as a function of energy for the Pr-M4M_4 and M5M_5 edges of Pr2_2O3_3 and Pr3_3IrO7_7, respectively. (c) and (d) show the relative intensity ratios of the Pr M5M_5 and M4M_4 edges at different positions of the Pr2_2O3_3 and Pr3_3IrO7_7 samples, respectively.

The M4,5M_{4,5} white lines of Pr correspond to the electronic transitions between the initial state 3d3d and the unoccupied 4f4f orbitals. For Pr2O3\mathrm{Pr}_2\mathrm{O}_3, the M5,4M_{5,4} white lines are observed around 931.3 eV and 950.8 eV, respectively. A shoulder is present on the left side of the Pr M4M_4 edge, which is indicative for the Pr 3+ valence state [22, 23, 24, 25]. As evident in Figure 2, the line shape and peak position of the M5,4M_{5,4}-edge for Pr3IrO7\mathrm{Pr}_3\mathrm{IrO}_7 are similar to the M5,4M_{5,4}-edge spectra of Pr2O3\mathrm{Pr}_2\mathrm{O}_3. A small chemical shift in the Pr M5M_5 and M4M_4 edge is observed, which amounts to ∼\sim0.16 eV and ∼\sim0.23 eV, resp., toward the low energy side, however, the shift is small. A shoulder is also found for Pr3IrO7\mathrm{Pr}_3\mathrm{IrO}_7 on the left side of the Pr M4M_4 edge. For the Pr 4+ valence state, the two peaks have been previously reported on the right side of both Pr M5M_5 and M4M_4 edges around ∼\sim935 eV and ∼\sim955 eV. These are distinctly absent for the present Pr3IrO7\mathrm{Pr}_3\mathrm{IrO}_7 sample, which also suggests that Pr is in a 3+ valence state [23, 24]. Furthermore, we have analyzed all the other recorded regions of each sample (not shown). We have found similar types of signatures i.e., a similar amount of chemical shift in Pr M5,4M_{5,4} edges, the absence of two peaks on the right side of both Pr M5M_5 and M4M_4 edges, and the presence of a shoulder on the left side of Pr M4M_4 edge. Additionally, we have further looked at the intensity ratio IM5/IM4I_{M_5}/I_{M_4} for both Pr2O3\mathrm{Pr}_2\mathrm{O}_3 and Pr3IrO7\mathrm{Pr}_3\mathrm{IrO}_7 materials in Figure 2(c) and (d), respectively. The intensity ratio for Pr2O3\mathrm{Pr}_2\mathrm{O}_3 shows no systematic variation at different position of the sample, and the change in IM5/IM4I_{M_5}/I_{M_4} lies between 1.5 to 2 according to Figure 2(c). For Pr3_3IrO7_7, we observe a complete fluctuation in IM5/IM4I_{M_5}/I_{M_4} ratio [see Figure 2(d)], however, these fluctuations lie in the same range as for Pr2_2O3_3. Similar types of variation have been found in IM5/IM4I_{M_5}/I_{M_4} for other regions of the Pr3_3IrO7_7 sample (not shown). These results imply that Pr is in 3+ valence state, which points to a 5+ charge state of Ir.

Magnetization study

Figure 3 shows the temperature-dependent dc magnetization M(T)M(T) data for Pr3_3IrO7_7, measured for the magnetic field orientation H∥c\mathbf{H} \parallel c at 0.5, 1, 2, and 5 kOe magnetic fields by following zero field-cooled (ZFC) and field-cooled (FC) protocols. As evident in the Figure 3, the magnetic moment in the field of 0.5 kOe increases with decreasing temperature and exhibits a broad (weak) hump in the particular temperature range of ∼22\sim22 K to ∼5.6\sim5.6 K and centered around T∗∼10.4T^{*} \sim10.4 K. Upon further cooling the magnetization increases continuously from 5.6 K to the lowest measured temperature. For a spin-glass behavior, the magnetization is expected to exhibit a bifurcation between MZFCM_{ZFC} and MFCM_{FC} and an anomaly in MZFCM_{ZFC} across the glassy temperature, which shifts to lower temperature with increasing the field [11]. Our M(T)M(T) does not show any such bifurcation between MZFCM_{ZFC} and MFCM_{FC} in the whole temperature range, which rules out the possibility of a glassy phase. The left inset of Figure 3 depicts the low-temperature ZFC magnetization data for H = 0.5 kOe, which clearly shows the presence of a hump around ∼\sim10.4 K and a prominent change around ∼\sim5.6 K, as highlighted by the arrow. The M(T)M(T) data measured at higher magnetic fields (1, 2, and 5 kOe) reveal that the weak hump becomes more prominent with increasing magnetic field (Figure 3). As evident in the high field M(T)M(T) data, with increasing the field the moment below ∼\sim5.6 K increases continuously and exhibits a clear change in curvature of M(T)M(T) in that particular temperature regime.

Temperature dependence of the dc magnetization following ZFC and FC protocols

Figure 3. Temperature dependence of the dc magnetization following a ZFC and FC protocol at magnetic fields of 0.5, 1, 2 and 5 kOe for Pr3_3IrO7_7. The open symbols and line represent the ZFC and FC magnetic curves, respectively. Left inset: MZFC(T)M_{ZFC}(T) data measured at 0.5 kOe, where the red arrow marks the temperature 5.6 K. Right inset: Temperature derivative dM/dTdM/dT at a magnetic field of 0.5 kOe.

For a more detailed analysis, we have plotted the first derivative of the MZFC(T)M_{ZFC}(T) magnetization (dM/dTdM/dT) in the right inset of Figure 3 for 0.5 kOe field data. The dM/dTdM/dT data distinctly show a sharp drop below ∼\sim5.6 K, and a clear change in the curvature of M(T)M(T) at T∗T^* in the temperature range of 22 K to 5.6 K. This weak hump in M(T)M(T) could be associated with the magnetic degree of freedom, which leads to a significant deviation in magnetic susceptibility from the Curie-Weiss behavior at low temperature [see Fig. 4 (c)]. It is interesting to note that a similar type of weak hump in magnetization data has been seen for other Pr based perovskites PrBO3_3 (B = transition metals) at low temperature where the rare-earth spins order in an AFM arrangement [27, 28, 29, 30]. The continuous increase in magnetization below T∗T^* could be associated with a minor paramagnetic (PM) impurity phase consisting of non-interacting and isolated Pr or Ir moments. To obtain further insight into the low-temperature magnetic state of Pr3_3IrO7_7, we have measured M(T)M(T) at low fields 25 and 50 Oe [see Figs. 4 (a) and (b), respectively]. The M(T)M(T) data at the low field also exhibit a continuous increase in moment across the same temperature (∼5.6\sim5.6 K), as observed in high field measurements, however, the weak hump around ∼10.4\sim10.4 K is not clearly visible. The notable observations in the M(T)M(T) data occur at low field, namely, (i) no change in the temperature, where the magnetization continuously increases, (ii) increase in magnetic moment with increasing fields, and (iii) no hysteresis between MZFCM_{ZFC} and MFCM_{FC}.

Fig. 4 (c) depicts the temperature-dependent inverse magnetic susceptibility (χ−1=H/M\chi^{-1} = H/M), which is deduced from the MZFCM_{ZFC} data (Fig. 3). The χ−1(T)\chi^{-1}(T) data have been analyzed using a modified Curie–Weiss (CW) law in the temperature range 150 - 248 K [26], according to

χ(T)=χ0+C(T−θCW)(1)\chi(T) = \chi_0 + \frac{C}{(T-\theta_{CW})} \tag*{(1)}

where χ0\chi_0, CC, and θCW\theta_{CW} are the temperature-independent magnetic susceptibility, the Curie constant, and Curie-Weiss temperature, respectively. The (χ−χ0)−1(\chi-\chi_0)^{-1} vs T plot shows a linear behavior in the high temperature regime [see Figure 4 (c)]. The fitting of χ(T)\chi(T) with (1) gives χ0=9.5×10−3\chi_0 = 9.5\times10^{-3} emu/mole, C=2.36C = 2.36 emu K/mole, and θCW=−5.7\theta_{CW} = -5.7 K. The magnitude of θCW\theta_{CW} is close to T∗T^*. The negative sign of θCW\theta_{CW} and its magnitude suggest AFM type interactions in Pr3_3IrO7_7. From the obtained Curie constant CC, the effective paramagnetic moment (μeff\mu_{eff}) is calculated and found to be 4.34 μB\mu_B/f.u., and hence 2.5 μB\mu_B/Pr, which is low compared to the theoretically expected moment (μeff=gJ(J+1)\mu_{eff} = g\sqrt{J(J+1)}) value 3.58 μB\mu_B, where the Lande gg factor and the JJ value for Pr3+^{3+} (4f24f^2) electronic configuration are 4/5 and 4, respectively. The observed low moment (μeff\mu_{eff}) implies that the four dd-electrons of Ir5+^{5+} (5d45d^4 electronic state) occupy completely Jeff=3/2J_{eff} = 3/2 quartet state, which means μeff=0\mu_{eff} = 0 for the Ir5+^{5+} state. This low moment (μeff\mu_{eff}) discrepancy with expected moment has been seen in other Pr-based ternary oxide Pr3_3MO7_7 (M = Nb, Ta and Sb) materials [16].

DC magnetization and inverse susceptibility data

Figure 4. DC magnetization data as a function of temperature for Pr3_3IrO7_7 measured in low magnetic fields (a) 25 Oe and (b) 50 Oe using the ZFC and FC protocol. (c) Temperature-dependent inverse susceptibility (χ−χ0)−1(\chi-\chi_0)^{-1} deduced from the MZFCM_{ZFC} data for Pr3_3IrO7_7, where the solid red line represents a linear fitting describing a modified Curie–Weiss behavior as defined in the text.

The magnetic field-induced magnetic behavior in Pr3_3IrO7_7 below and above T∗T^* was characterized in terms of the isothermal magnetization as a function of magnetic field (HH) for H∥cH \parallel c at various temperatures in the field range of ±\pm 70 kOe, and the results are shown in Figure 5. It is evident that the M(H)M(H) data do not show any sign of saturation for all temperatures up to the maximum applied field, i.e., 70 kOe. Accordingly, the M(H)M(H) data above T∗T^* exhibit a linear behavior like PM. In contrast, the M(H)M(H) curve at 1.8 K exhibits a linear behaviour up to about ∼\sim20 kOe, and above this field the M(H)M(H) data show a slight deviation from the linearity with field. Furthermore, the absence of any hysteresis in the M(H)M(H) curve at 1.8 K suggests that the magnetic ground state is neither a ferromagnetic nor spin-glass but could be AFM type. The magnetic moment at 1.8 K and 70 kOe is found to be 0.92 μB\mu_{\mathrm{B}}/f.u.; this value is low compared to the expected moment (μH=gJμB\mu_{\mathrm{H}} = gJ\mu_{\mathrm{B}}), which is calculated as 3.2 μB\mu_{\mathrm{B}}, where gg and JJ are 4/5 and 4 for Pr3+^{3+} (4f24f^2) electronic configuration. This low values of the magnetization and the μeff\mu_{\mathrm{eff}} in Pr3_3IrO7_7 may be due to the crystal field splitting of the Pr3+^{3+} ion because of the site symmetry of Pr(1) and Pr(2) ions [16, 31], which needs to be understood through microscopic probe.

Magnetic field-dependent magnetization $M(H)$ collected at 1.8, 15, and 30 K

Figure 5. Magnetic field-dependent magnetization M(H)M(H) collected at 1.8, 15, and 30 K.

Specific heat capacity

For a better understanding of the thermodynamic behavior in the vicinity of the observed weak hump in the M(T)M(T) data, the specific heat capacity CC as a function of temperature has been measured down to 1.8 K. Figure 6 shows the obtained specific heat capacity C(T)C(T) in the form of a C/TC/T vs TT plot. The C(T)C(T) data exhibit two maxima/peaks: one in the high temperature (∼\sim 253 K) and one in the low temperature (∼\sim 4.8 K) regime. The latter could be related to the weak hump of M(T)M(T) (that manifest the maxima at ∼\sim 10.4 K), however, the small shift in temperature is not clear at the moment. A similar low-temperature change in C(T)C(T) data is also present in a previous study but it has not been discussed so far [17]. The observed high-temperature maxima around ∼253\sim253 K is close to the reported value of the Pr3IrO7\mathrm{Pr}_{3}\mathrm{Ir}\mathrm{O}_{7} polycrystalline sample, where it was related to a structural phase transition from orthorhombic to monoclinic [17, 18].

Temperature-dependent specific heat and magnetic specific heat of $\mathrm{Pr}_{3}\mathrm{Ir}\mathrm{O}_{7}$

Figure 6. (a) Temperature-dependent specific heat (C/TC/T) of Pr3IrO7\mathrm{Pr}_{3}\mathrm{Ir}\mathrm{O}_{7}. The inset shows C(T)C(T) along with the lattice contributions (solid red line) obtained from fitting with the combined Debye and Einstein model. (b) Temperature-dependent magnetic specific heat (Cm/TC_{\mathrm{m}}/T) (left panel) and the calculated magnetic entropy with temperature Sm(T)S_{\mathrm{m}}(T) (right panel).

Furthermore, the magnetic contribution (CmC_{\mathrm{m}}) to the total heat capacity is calculated by subtracting its lattice (phonon) contribution (ClC_{\mathrm{l}}) from CC. The ClC_{\mathrm{l}} is determined by fitting of the C(T)C(T) data from 30 to 150 K using a combined Debye-Einstein model (Cl=CDebye+CEinsteinC_{\mathrm{l}} = C_{\mathrm{Debye}} + C_{\mathrm{Einstein}}). The CDebyeC_{\mathrm{Debye}} and CEinsteinC_{\mathrm{Einstein}} terms are given as [32, 11]

CDebye=a1[9R(TθD)3∫0θD/Tx4ex(ex−1)2 dx](2)C_{\mathrm{Debye}} = a_{1}\left[9R\left(\frac{T}{\theta_{D}}\right)^{3}\int_{0}^{\theta_{D}/T}\frac{x^{4}e^{x}}{(e^{x}-1)^{2}}\,dx\right] \tag*{(2)}
CEinstein=3R∑i=13bi[(θEiT)2eθEi/T(eθEi/T−1)2](3)C_{\mathrm{Einstein}} = 3R\sum_{i=1}^{3}b_{i}\left[\left(\frac{\theta_{E_{i}}}{T}\right)^{2}\frac{e^{\theta_{E_{i}}/T}}{(e^{\theta_{E_{i}}/T}-1)^{2}}\right] \tag*{(3)}

where RR is the universal gas constant, and θD\theta_{D} and θE\theta_{E} are the Debye and Einstein temperature, respectively. The a1a_{1} and bib_{i} coefficients are the weighting factors corresponding to acoustic and optical phonons (Debye and Einstein coefficients), respectively. The C(T)C(T) data can be fitted well with one Debye and three Einstein (1D + 3E) terms of lattice specific heat and is represented by a solid line in the inset of Figure 6 (a). The obtained ClC_l is extrapolated down to 1.8 K for CmC_m. From the combined fitting, the Debye and Einstein temperatures θD\theta_D, θE1\theta_{E1}, θE2\theta_{E2} and θE3\theta_{E3} are found to be 94.6 K, 493.7 K, 201.6 K, and 728 K, resp., and the associated weighing factors a1a_1, b1b_1, b2b_2, and b3b_3 are fixed in the ratio of 1, 5, 3, and 2, respectively. The total sum of coefficients a1+∑bia_1 + \sum b_i matches well with the total number of atoms in the formula unit in Pr3IrO7\mathrm{Pr}_3\mathrm{IrO}_7. The obtained magnetic specific heat (CmC_m) is shown in the left panel of Figure 6 (b) in the form of a Cm/TC_m/T vs TT plot. The magnetic specific heat shows a clear broad peak around ∼\sim 4.8 K, which is close to T∗T^* where the weak magnetic hump is observed in the M(T)M(T) data.

To understand this further through the change in entropy, the magnetic entropy SmS_m is calculated by integrating Cm/TC_m/T with TT according to

Sm(T)=∫0TCm(T)TdT.(4)S_m(T) = \int_0^T \frac{C_m(T)}{T}\mathrm{d}T . \tag*{(4)}

The change in magnetic entropy with temperature Sm(T)S_m(T) is shown in the right panel of Figure 6 (b). Accordingly, SmS_m almost saturates at ∼\sim 6.9 J/mole K above ∼\sim 22.2 K, which is close to the the temperature (∼\sim 22 K) below which the magnetization shows a change in its curvature. We have calculated the expected entropy change due to the Pr3+\mathrm{Pr}^{3+} ions with J=4J = 4 and found it to be 18.2 J/(mole K) [Rln⁡(2J+1)R \ln(2J + 1)]. The obtained SmS_m is low and about 37.9% of the theoretical value. This lower value of SmS_m may be due to the higher alignment of crystal field effect levels around 22 K.

Optical Conductivity

For the characterization of the electronic and vibrational properties of Pr3IrO7\mathrm{Pr}_3\mathrm{IrO}_7, we carried out reflectivity measurements in the infrared frequency range. The temperature-dependent reflectivity spectrum over the whole measured frequency range is shown in Figure 7 (a) at various temperatures, while the corresponding optical conductivity σ1\sigma_1 is displayed in Figure 7 (b). Pr3IrO7\mathrm{Pr}_3\mathrm{IrO}_7 crystallises in an orthorhombic phase with CmcmCmcm symmetry. According to the factor group analysis for the CmcmCmcm structure symmetry, the irreducible representation of optical active phonons is given as

Reflectivity and optical conductivity of Pr3IrO7

Figure 7. (a) Reflectivity and (b) optical conductivity (σ1\sigma_1) of Pr3_3IrO7_7 at various temperatures in the whole measured frequency range. Inset in (b): Room-temperature optical conductivity σ1\sigma_1 together with the Lorentz fit and the individual Lorentz contributions.

Γoptic=[10B1u+12B2u+10B3u]IR+[8Ag+8B1g+5B2g+6B3g]R(5)\Gamma_{\mathrm{optic}} = [10B_{1u} + 12B_{2u} + 10B_{3u}]_{\mathrm{IR}} + [8A_g + 8B_{1g} + 5B_{2g} + 6B_{3g}]_{\mathrm{R}} \tag*{(5)}

where IRIR (RR) indicates the infrared-active (Raman-active) modes. Theoretically, 32 infrared-active phonons are expected for Pr3_3IrO7_7 due its CmcmCmcm structure symmetry, see Table 1. Note that all Pr, Ir and O atoms in Pr3_3IrO7_7 are involved in these lattice vibrations. From the room temperature low-energy optical conductivity spectrum σ1\sigma_1, two main observations can be made: First, the overall low value of σ1\sigma_1 in the far-IR region, which signals the insulating character of Pr3_3IrO7_7. Second, 24 IR-active transverse phonon modes can be resolved and noted in Table 2. In analogy to the related compound Gd3_3NbO7_7 [33] the modes above ∼190 cm−1\sim190\ \mathrm{cm}^{-1} can be ascribed to stretching and bending vibrations of IrO6_6 octahedra, and the modes below ∼190 cm−1\sim190\ \mathrm{cm}^{-1} can be assigned to translational modes of the Pr3+^{3+} and Ir5+^{5+} ions.

AtomsWyckoff positonΓ\Gamma representation
Pr(1)4a4a2B1u+2B2u+B3u2B_{1u} + 2B_{2u} + B_{3u}
Pr(2)8g8gB1u+2B2u+2B3uB_{1u} + 2B_{2u} + 2B_{3u}
Ir4b4b2B1u+2B2u+B3u2B_{1u} + 2B_{2u} + B_{3u}
O(1)16h16h3B1u+3B2u+3B3u3B_{1u} + 3B_{2u} + 3B_{3u}
O(2)8g8gB1u+2B2u+2B3uB_{1u} + 2B_{2u} + 2B_{3u}
O(3)4c4cB1u+B2u+B3uB_{1u} + B_{2u} + B_{3u}

Table 1. Wyckoff positions and Γ\Gamma point representations for CmcmCmcm (No. 63) space group.

Transverse phonon frequenciesLongitudinal phonon frequencies
300 K200 K5.4 K300 K200 K5.4 K
128.4128.4128.7132.8134.1134.4
133.0135.8135.3140.6140.6141.1
148.1151.6153.2151.2153.0154.2
163.6161.4161.4173.1170.2166.9
188.8167.5169.6195.8174.8175.4
193.6177.9177.2204.2178.9179.7
212.9189.9191.5215.3197.2198.5
218.6202.5201.7219.5203.4204.2
240.3213.6214.3242.9215.5216.5
265.5218.4221.4269.4221.4222.5
279.9229.8232.0291.4231.2233.3
295.5240.2243.4302.4244.3245.0
314.1263.6263.6325.1271.0270.5
362.7283.1284.8429.3293.1293.4
366.1297.2297.1451.4305.1304.6
391.5306.7311.0468.0325.6327.5
454.2323.2324.7495.5339.7340.0
478.9337.1335.6519.2391.9391.0
506.7358.4357.3541.0431.5426.0
545.0373.6373.4591.0455.8451.1
564.2394.7394.1633.0472.0477.1
579.8455.1454.1657.0495.2495.2
595.8471.1471.7670.7508.0506.9
664.6483.8485.6713.7520.7524.0
504.4504.8540.6537.2
517.3517.1557.0556.6
542.0536.6590.5593.5
569.9554.6634.4637.1
585.3586.6660.6660.3
601.2605.0675.8679.6
628.3636.2689.8696.8
664.7667.4715.9717.2

Table 2. Observed transverse and longitudinal IR phonon mode frequencies (in cm−1^{-1}) for Pr3_3IrO7_7 at 300 K, 200 K, and 5.4 K.

The onset of electronic excitations in the optical conductivity spectrum [see inset of Figure 7 (b)] is located at around 0.5 eV, which can serve as an estimate of the optical gap, ΔOP∼500\Delta_{\mathrm{OP}} \sim500 meV. The size of ΔOP\Delta_{\mathrm{OP}} is comparable to that in the honeycomb-type iridates Na2_2IrO3_3 and α\alpha-Li2_2IrO3_3 with Ir 5d55d^5 electronic configuration [34, 35]. The high-energy σ1\sigma_1 spectrum shows weak Lorentz contributions located at ∼0.56\sim0.56 eV, ∼0.83\sim0.83 eV, and ∼1.03\sim1.03 eV and a stronger contribution ∼1.43\sim1.43 eV. In analogy to other iridates [42, 43, 44, 35, 36], these excitations can be ascribed to on-site and inter-site transitions between Jeff=1/2J_{\mathrm{eff}} = 1/2 and Jeff=3/2J_{\mathrm{eff}} = 3/2 states, which could show additional splittings due to octahedral distortion. The Lorentz term at ∼2.4\sim2.4 eV can be attributed to charge-transfer excitations between the Ir 5d5d and O 2p2p orbitals.

It is furthermore intriguing to compare the high-energy σ1\sigma_1 spectrum of Pr3_3IrO7_7 with that of insulating Li2_2RuO3_3, where Ru4+^{4+} has a 4d44d^4 electron configuration similar to Ir5+^{5+} (5d45d^4), however, with a smaller SOC and higher UU-value [37]. Interestingly, for Li2_2RuO3_3 one observes a similar gap size ΔOP∼600\Delta_{\mathrm{OP}} \sim600 meV, and the excitations around ∼0.95\sim0.95 eV and ∼1.46\sim1.46 eV are slightly blueshifted in energy [37], which might be due to the different SOC strength. In addition, it has been seen in a local probe study that the Ir5+\mathrm{Ir}^{5+} systems exhibit higher angular strength of the SOC, ⟨L⋅S⟩\langle\mathbf{L}\cdot\mathbf{S} \rangle, compared to the Ir4+\mathrm{Ir}^{4+} state [38]. Therefore, in the context of SOC, more investigations employing theoretical

calculations are required to understand the electronic excitations in the strong SOC limit in Ir5+\mathrm{Ir}^{5+}-based oxides.

Furthermore, we checked the possible impact of the structural phase transition at ∼253\sim253 K and the magnetic ordering at T∗T^{*} on the vibrational and electronic excitations. The temperature-dependent reflectivity spectrum of Pr3IrO7\mathrm{Pr}_{3}\mathrm{IrO}_{7} is shown in Figure 8 (a) at various temperatures in the far-infrared range, since here the pronounced changes occur. With decreasing temperature, we observe several changes, namely the appearance of eight additional transverse IR modes at 167.5 (20.7), 177.9 (22.0), 229.8 (28.5), 306.7 (38.0), 337.1 (41.7), 471.1 (58.4), 517.3 (64.1), 628.3 (77.8) cm−1\mathrm{cm}^{-1} (meV) around 250 K in the far-infrared range (Table 2), a large change in the observed modes in the frequency range 290 - 350 cm−1\mathrm{cm}^{-1} (especially for the 314.1 cm−1\mathrm{cm}^{-1} mode), and the IR modes become sharper at low temperature. These changes are also clearly seen in temperature-dependent conductivity σ1\sigma_{1} spectrum of the far-infrared regime as shown in Figure 8 (c). The observed additional modes around 250 K are probably due to the structural phase transition which was previously reported [17, 18] and also seen in the above-described heat capacity data [see Figure 6 (a)]. Figure 8 (b) shows temperature-dependent loss function in the far-infrared range. The eigenfrequencies of the longitudinal optical phonon modes appear as maxima in the loss function [45]. We found 24 longitudinal phonon modes at room temperature and eight extra modes below the structural phase transition temperature ∼253\sim253 K, see Table 2, which further confirms the observed extra phonon modes as seen in the optical conductivity spectrum. Like the reflectivity and conductivity spectrum, the temperature-dependent loss function exhibits a large change in the longitudinal modes in the frequency range 285 - 350 cm−1\mathrm{cm}^{-1}. Moreover, an additional phonon mode around ∼371.0\sim371.0 cm−1\mathrm{cm}^{-1} is seen in the loss function spectrum compared to conductivity spectrum. The temperature-dependent σ1\sigma_{1} spectrum in the higher energy region is shown in the Figure 7 (b). Obviously, the observed Lorentz contributions (∼0.56\sim0.56 eV, ∼0.83\sim0.83 eV, ∼1.03\sim1.03 and ∼1.43\sim1.43 eV) do not show any noticeable change with lowering the temperature. Figure 8 (d) shows the frequency position of three selected phonon modes as a function of temperature. The frequency of the modes at 579.8 and 391.5 cm−1\mathrm{cm}^{-1} show an abrupt increase around 250 K, which we attribute to the structural phase transition occurring at this temperature. All three selected modes show an anomaly at around T∗T^{*}, where a weak hump is observed in the magnetization data. It is well known that the Dzyaloshinskii-Moriya interaction (DMI) mainly occurs due to the distortions of IrO6\mathrm{IrO}_{6} octahedra which are induced by the presence of strong SOC in iridates [39]. In recent studies, it has been shown that spin-phonon coupling occurs due to the bending of Ir-O-Ir bonds which is mainly mediated by the DMI [40, 41]. For Ln3IrO7\mathrm{Ln}_{3}\mathrm{IrO}_{7} (Ln = Pr, Nd, Sm and Eu), it has been reported that both tilt of the IrO6\mathrm{IrO}_{6} octahedra and distortion in the Ir-Ln-O slab increase at the low temperature [18]. Therefore, the observed an anomaly for the IR phonon modes around T∗T^{*} underlines the importance of spin-phonon coupling in Pr3IrO7\mathrm{Pr}_{3}\mathrm{IrO}_{7}.

Reflectivity, loss function, optical conductivity, and phonon mode positions at various temperatures

Figure 8. (a) Reflectivity, (b) loss function, and (c) optical conductivity σ1\sigma_1 at various temperatures in the low-energy range. (d) Temperature evolution of the frequency of three selected phonon modes. The two vertical dashed red lines in (d) mark the T∗T^* and structural phase transition temperature (∼253\sim253 K).

Conclusion

In summary, the structural, magnetic, thermodynamic, and optical properties are studied in detail for single-crystalline Pr3IrO7\mathrm{Pr}_3\mathrm{IrO}_7 ternary iridate. The structural analysis shows that Pr3IrO7\mathrm{Pr}_3\mathrm{IrO}_7 crystallizes in the orthorhombic phase with CmcmCmcm symmetry. The electron energy loss spectroscopy measurements reveal a 3+ oxidation state for Pr, hence 5+ oxidation state of Ir in Pr3IrO7\mathrm{Pr}_3\mathrm{IrO}_7. As a consequence, it represents the ideal system to study the magnetic and electronic evolution of Pr rare-earth. Our magnetic and specific heat results suggest a possible weak low-temperature AFM state for Pr3IrO7\mathrm{Pr}_3\mathrm{IrO}_7. Based on the reflectivity data analysis, we conclude an insulating electronic structure for Pr3IrO7\mathrm{Pr}_3\mathrm{IrO}_7 with an optical gap ΔOP∼500\Delta_{\mathrm{OP}}\sim500 meV. The temperature-dependent reflectivity spectrum shows eight extra phonon modes below 250 K, which can be attributed to a structural phase transition. Furthermore, several phonon modes reveal an anomaly in the temperature dependence of their frequency position at T∗∼10.4T^* \sim10.4 K, where a weak hump is observed in the magnetization data, indicative for sizeable spin-phonon coupling in the system.

Acknowledgments

H. K. acknowledges Dr. J. Ebad-Allah and Dr. S. Ghara for fruitful discussions. H. K. acknowledges funding (PDOK-95-19) from the Bavarian Science Foundation and by the Deutsche Forschungsgemeinschaft, Germany, through Grant No. KU 4080/2-1.

References

  1. [1]Witczak-Krempa W, Chen G, Kim Y B, and Balents L, 2014 Annual Rev. of Condens. Matter Physics. 5, 57
  2. [2]Rau J G, Lee E K H, and Kee H Y, 2015 Annual Rev. of Condens. Matter Physics. 7, 195
  3. [3]Pesin D, and Balents L, 2010 Nat. Phys. 6, 376.
  4. [4]Wan X, Turner A M, Vishwanath A, and Savrasov S Y, 2011 Phys. Rev. B 83, 205101.
  5. [5]Ueda K, Kaneko R, Ishizuka H, Fujioka J, Nagaosa N and Tokura Y, 2018 Nat. Comm. 9, 3032.
  6. [6]Ueda K, Fukuda H, Kaneko R, Fujioka J, and Tokura Y, 2020 Phys. Rev. B 102, 245131.
  7. [7]Kim B J, Jin H, Moon S J, Kim J Y, Park B G, Leem C S, Yu J, Noh T W, Kim C, Oh S J, Park J H, Durairaj V, Cao G, and Rotenberg E, 2008 Phys. Rev. Lett. 101, 076402
  8. [8]Kim B J, Ohsumi H, Komesu T, Sakai S, Morita T, Takagi H, and Arima T, 2009 Science 323, 1329
  9. [9]Moon S J, Jin H, Kim K W, Choi W S, Lee Y S, Yu J, Cao G, Sumi A, Funakubo H, Bernhard C, and Noh T W. 2008 Phys. Rev. Lett. 101, 226402
  10. [10]Kharkwal K C, Roy R, Kumar H, Bera A K, Yusuf S M, Shukla A K, Kumar K, Kanungo S, and Pramanik A K, 2020 Phys. Rev. B 102, 174401
  11. [11]Gondh S, Patidar M M, Kumar K, Saravanan M P, Ganesan V, and Pramanik A K, 2021 Phys. Rev. B 104, 014401
  12. [12]Garg C, Roy D, Lonsky M, Manuel P, Cervellino A, Müller J, Kabir M, and Nair S, 2021 Phys. Rev. B 103, 014437
  13. [13]Dey T, Majumder M, Orain J C, Senyshyn A, Prinz-Zwick M, Bachus S, Tokiwa Y, Bert F, Khuntia P, Büttgen N, Tsirlin A A, and Gegenwart P, 2017 Phys. Rev. B 96, 174411
  14. [14]Nag A, Middey S, Bhowal S, Panda S K, Mathieu R, Orain J C, Bert F, Mendels P, Freeman P G, Mansson M, Ronn​​ow H M, Telling M, Biswas P K, Sheptyakov D, Kaushik S D, Siruguri V, Meneghini C, Sarma D D, Dasgupta I, and Ray S, 2016 Phys. Rev. Lett. 116, 097205
  15. [15]Cao G, Qi T F, Li L, Terzic J, Yuan S J, DeLong L E, Murthy G, and Kaul R K, 2014 Phys. Rev. Lett. 112, 056402
  16. [16]Vente J F, Helmholdt R B, and Ijdo D J W, 2004 J. Solid State Chem. 108, 18
  17. [17]Nishimine H, Wakeshima M, and Hinatsu Y, 2004 J. Solid State Chem. 739, 177
  18. [18]Nishimine H, Doi Y, Hinatsu Y, and Sato M, 2007 J. Ceramic Soc. Jpn. 115, 577
  19. [19]Wang Y, Liu S, Qin Q, Liu H, Zhang L, Wei T, Li H, and Liu X, 2021 Sci. China Mater. 64, 2193
  20. [20]Tanner D B, 2015 Phys. Rev. B 91, 035123
  21. [21]Kuzmenko A B, 2005 Rev. Sci. Instruments 76, 083108
  22. [22]Kumar H, Kharkwal K C, Kumar K, Asokan K, Banerjee A, and Pramanik A K, 2020 Phys. Rev. B 101, 064405
  23. [23]Richter J, Brauna A, Harveyb A S, Holtappelsa P, Graulea T, and Gauckler L J, 2008 Physica B 403, 87
  24. [24]López-Cartes C, Bernal S, Calvino J J, Cauqui M A, Blanco G, Pérez-Omil J A, Pintado J M, Helveg S, and Hansen P L, 2003 Chem. Commun. 5, 644
  25. [25]Abel J, 2012 Corrélations compositions chimiques, structures d’oxydes mixtes (Ce/Zr) à base de Pr4+/Pr3+ et propriétés de réductibilité, Ph.D. Thesis, Institut de Chimie de la Matière Condensée de Bordeaux, FranceDOI
  26. [26]Kumar H, Dhaka R S, and Pramanik A K, 2017 Phys. Rev. B 95, 054415
  27. [27]Kumar Anil, Warshi M. Kamal, Sagdeo Archna, Krzystyniak Matthew, Rudic Svemir, Adroja D T, Silva Ivan da, and Sagdeo P R, 2021 Phys. Rev. B 104, 035101
  28. [28]Venugopal R B, Vittal P B, Narsinga R G, Chou F C, Suresh B D, 2015 Advanced Mat. Res. 1086 96
  29. [29]Mendivil, L F, Alvarado-Rivera, J, Verdín E, Díaz J A, Mata J, Conde A, and Durán A, 2020 Appl. Phys. A 126 574
  30. [30]Mendivil, L F, Alvarado-Rivera, J, Tavizon G, Verdín E, Arenas-Alatorre J, and Durán A, 2020 J Mater Sci. Mater Electron 32 24484
  31. [31]Zhou Z X, Cao G, McCall S, Crow J E, Guertin R P, Mielke C H and Rickel D G, 2002 Philosophical Magazine B 82 1401
  32. [32]Ghara S, Ter-Ognessian N V, and Sundaresan A, 2017 Phys. Rev. B 95, 094404
  33. [33]Ptak M, Pilarek B, Watras A, Godlewska P, Szczygiel I, and Hanuza J, 2019 J. Alloys and Compounds 810, 151892
  34. [34]Comin R, Levy G, Ludbrook B, Zhu Z H, Veenstra C N, Rosen J A, Singh Y, Gegenwart P, Stricker D, Hancock J N, van der Marel D, Elfimov I S, and Damascelli A, 2012 Phys. Rev. Lett. 109, 266406
  35. [35]Hermann V, Ebad-Allah J, Freund F, Pietsch I M, Jesche A, Tsirlin A A, Deisenhofer J, Hanfland M, Gegenwart P, and Kuntscher C A, 2017 Phys. Rev. B 96, 195137
  36. [36]Hermann V, Ebad-Allah J, Freund F, Jesche A, Tsirlin A A, Gegenwart P, and Kuntscher C A, 2019 Phys. Rev. B 99, 235116
  37. [37]Yun S, 2020 Studies on Transition metal dimers in Li2RuO3, Ph.D. Thesis, Seoul National University, South Korea
  38. [38]Laguna-Marco M A, Kayser P, Alonso J A, Martínez-Lope M J, Veenendaal M van, Choi Y, and Haskel D, 2015 Phys. Rev. B 91, 214433
  39. [39]Bhatti I N, Rawat R, Banerjee A, Pramanik A K, 2014 J. Phys.: Condens. Matter 27, 016005
  40. [40]Son J, Park B C, Kim C H, Cho H, Kim S Y, Sandilands L J, Sohn C, Park J G, Moon S J and Noh T W, 2019 Npj Quantum Mater. 4, 17
  41. [41]Kumar H, Sathe V G, and Pramanik A K, J. Magn. Magn. Mater 478 148 (2019)
  42. [42]Li Y, Foyevtsova K, Jesche H. O., Valenti R, 2015 Phys. Rev. B 91, 161101
  43. [43]Kim B. H., Shirakawa T, Yunoki S., 2016 Phys. Rev. Lett. 117, 187201
  44. [44]Li Y, Winter S. M., Jeschke H. O., Valenti R, 2017 Phys. Rev. B 95, 045129
  45. [45]Klingshirn C F, 2012 Semiconductor Optics, Springer Berlin, Heidelberg.

Paper details

vlnc:W_urps5qyh
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 0

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Physics and Astronomy

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents