WorksMathematics
Local Nevanlinna embedding for Hardy space of Dirichlet series below critical exponent
Abstract
In this paper, we investigate a problem posed by Saksman and Seip [ Contemp. Math., 2016] on whether functions in the Hardy space of Dirichlet series , , are locally in the Nevanlinna class of the critical half-plane . We show that the local Nevanlinna embedding fails below critical exponent by constructing -functions whose local logarithmic mass becomes unbounded as . This also clarifies the distinction between global Jessen-type logarithmic control and local boundary Nevanlinna behavior for Dirichlet series.
Introduction
Hardy spaces of Dirichlet series form a natural meeting point of analytic function theory, harmonic analysis, and complex analysis. If is a Dirichlet series, then the Bohr’s correspondence identifies with a holomorphic function on the infinite-dimensional polydisk by writing and associating to the formal power series . For , the Hardy space is obtained as the completion of Dirichlet polynomials with respect to the norm
Equivalently, for Dirichlet polynomials this norm is represented by the global vertical mean
A basic question is to understand how this global mean norm controls the behavior of on finite portions of vertical lines. The natural boundary for this problem is the critical line . Indeed, point-evaluation functionals are bounded on throughout the half-plane , where for any , we denote
and the corresponding evaluation norm grows without bound as . Thus the line is the endpoint at which one may ask whether the global -norm gives a uniform local trace estimate. The recent formulation emphasizes that restriction to this line amounts, under the Bohr transform, to sampling an infinite-dimensional Hardy function along a single one-dimensional prime-flow orbit, whereas the -norm averages over all prime coordinates.
This leads to the local embedding problem: determine for which there exists a constant such that every Dirichlet polynomial satisfies
The essential feature of this estimate is that the constant must be independent of the number and choice of prime variables appearing in . In this sense, the local embedding problem is a genuinely dimension-free trace problem.
The local embedding problem was formulated explicitly by Hedenmalam, Lindqvist and Seip [11 Theorem 4.11] and later Saksman and Seip [16 Section 3] recorded as Problem 1.2 in their list of open problems for Dirichlet series [17 Problem 2.1]. Subsequent investigations revealed several equivalent formulations of the problem. Bayart and Brevig [2] demonstrated that the local embedding property is equivalent to both the conformally invariant half-plane embedding and the boundedness of all characteristic zero symbols in the Gordon-Hedenmalm class [9] of composition operators; notably, the boundedness of a single canonical operator suffices. Olsen and Saksman [14] identified local embedding with the reverse transfer of local Carleson measures, proving that this transfer may be tested on a distinguished family of atomic measures whose masses are proportional to their distance from the critical boundary. Furthermore, for , Saksman and Seip [16] established that the local embedding problem is equivalent to a strengthened Carleson-type ergodic identity on the critical distinguished boundary, required to hold for every starting point. Brevig, Ortega-Cerdà, and Seip [5] highlighted the local embedding problem as “perhaps the most important open problem” concerning the Hardy spaces .
Historically, the estimate was known at , where the Hilbert-space structure and orthogonality of Dirichlet monomials play a decisive role. By applying the result to integer powers, one also obtains the inequality for every even exponent . In contrast, Harper’s low-moment estimates for random multiplicative functions imply that the local embedding inequality fails for every . Thus, for a long time, the unresolved range consisted of the non-even exponents . This gap was recently closed by Chen, Fang, Guo, Hou, Shao, and Zhou [8], who proved a dimension-free local trace estimate for every . Combined with the classical case and the known failure for , their result gives the sharp classification
LEP holds if, and only if, .
Hence is the critical exponent for the local embedding problem. The significance of the local embedding problem extends well beyond the estimate itself. It is closely connected with boundary behavior of Hardy space of Dirichlet series, Carleson measure transfer, critical-line sampling, composition operators, and the geometry of the prime flow. The recent work shows that the local embedding property is equivalent, in the appropriate exponent ranges, to several classical trace and Carleson-measure formulations. At the same time, failure of the local -embedding below raises a subtler question: although may fail to admit uniform local control, can the much weaker logarithmic quantity still remain locally integrable near the critical line? This question leads naturally to the problem posed by Saksman and Seip [17] concerning local Nevanlinna behavior of -functions for . They imposed the following problem:
Problem 1.2. [17 Problem 2.4] Are elements of for locally in the Nevanlinna class?
Since, for
the local -embedding implies local logarithmic control whenever it holds. Below the critical exponent , however, the -embedding breaks down, and it becomes meaningful to ask whether the weaker Nevanlinna-type trace can nevertheless survive. Thus the local Nevanlinna problem may be viewed as a natural logarithmic counterpart of the local embedding problem and provides a finer test of boundary regularity in Hardy spaces of Dirichlet series.
Let denote the space of holomorphic functions on a domain , endowed with the topology of uniform convergence on compact subsets. A function belongs to the local Nevanlinna class, denoted as , if for every there exist and a positive harmonic function on the local rectangle
such that
Equivalently, if admits a harmonic majorant in a neighborhood, relative to , of every finite boundary segment of the line .
A useful consequence of the definition is the following logarithmic trace criterion, that if , then for every compact interval , after possibly shrinking the surrounding rectangle, there exists such that
Conversely, if the uniform estimate
holds on a slightly larger open interval , then admits a positive harmonic majorant on a smaller boundary rectangle over . Thus, up to standard enlargement or shrinking of intervals, the harmonic-majorant definition and the local logarithmic trace condition are equivalent.
Recently, Guo, Ni and Zhou [10] introduced the Nevanlinna class in the infinite many variables. It is well-known that functions of infinitely many variables and Dirichlet series are intimately linked via the Bohr correspondence. In connection with composition operators on Dirichlet series spaces, Brevig and Perfekt [6] introduced the following notion of the Nevanlinna class for a Dirichlet series .
Definition 1.1. [6] A Dirichlet series with uniform abscissa is defined in the Nevanlinna class of Dirichlet series if the following condition holds:
where .
The abscissa of uniform convergence of a Dirichlet series , denoted by , is defined by
If and , then , which follows from the elementary inequality
(valid for and ). We emphasize that the condition is essential; without it, the class can not be properly defined. For example, consider the Dirichlet series
It is easy to see that , whereas . The inequalities
along with (1.3) ensures that if, and only if,
Here, the class is an -space (see for instance [18]); that is, a topological vector space whose topology is induced by a complete, translation-invariant metric defined by
Since is a Dirichlet series with and is continuous and non-decreasing on , the composition is almost periodic (see, e.g., [3, 15]). Consequently, the limit in (1.4) exists. In contrast, Guo et al. [10] defined the Nevanlinna-Dirichlet class as the completion of under the metric given in (1.4). Under the canonical embedding of into , the topology induced on by the completion coincides with the topology induced by .
The novelty of the present work lies in identifying and resolving the gap between global Nevanlinna-type control for Dirichlet series and local boundary Nevanlinna behavior on the critical half-plane. More precisely, for , we show that membership in the Hardy space does not in general imply local Nevanlinna regularity in , thereby giving a negative answer to Saksman-Seip’s Problem 2.4. The argument exploits Harper-type low-moment estimates together with a gliding-hump construction to produce an Dirichlet series whose logarithmic mass becomes unbounded on a fixed finite interval as the line is approached. After translation, this also yields a separation between the global Nevanlinna class and local classical Nevanlinna behavior, showing that global logarithmic control need not imply local boundary control. In this way, the result identifies as a natural threshold not only for local trace estimates, but also for universal local Nevanlinna behavior of Hardy-Dirichlet series.
The paper is organized as follows. Section 2 presents our main results concerning the negative resolution to Problem 1.2, along with several key supporting lemmas largely inspired by the work of Harper [13]. Section 3 opens with the proof of Theorem 2.1, followed by a detailed investigation linking the local Nevanlinna embedding problem (LNEP) to global and local logarithmic mean control, as well as to the original problem of Saksman and Seip (Problem 1.2).
Notation. Throughout this article, denotes a positive constant which may vary from line to line. When necessary, we write that to indicate that the constant depends on a parameter . If and are two real functions defined on the same set , the notation (or ) means that there exists a constant such that (or ), for all , while (or ) signifies that there exists a constant such that (or ), for all . Also, the symbol indicates a sequence is bounded by a constant depending exclusively on the parameter ; that is, there exist and such that for all .
Main Results and Supporting Lemmas
This section starts with our primary result, which provides a negative resolution to Problem 1.2, followed by a few key supporting lemmas required for its proof.
Theorem 2.1. Let . Then there exists a Dirichlet series such that
Consequently, does not belong locally to the Nevanlinna class in the half-plane . In particular,
thereby answering Problem 2.4 of Saksman and Seip in the negative.
Remark 2.1. For every , there exists a Dirichlet series satisfying and , such that , where . More precisely,
so that . The function is obtained from in Theorem 2.1 via the translation , highlighting the sharp distinction between global Jessen-type logarithmic control and local logarithmic boundary trace control near a finite segment of the imaginary axis.
Lemma 2.1. Let . If and admits a harmonic majorant in , then for every compact sub interval and every ,
Proof. Let . The local Nevanlinna membership near a bounded interval of the critical boundary line is equivalent to the restriction property . This condition holds precisely when
for every compact subinterval and some . Using the elementary inequality for and , we observe that
Consequently, the Local Embedding Problem (LEP) directly implies the Local Nevanlinna Embedding Problem (LNEP). □
Moreover, the argument above breaks down for . Consequently, if there exists a sequence such that
then fails to belong locally to the Nevanlinna class near the boundary segment .
Lemma 2.2. Fix , and define and , so that . By Harper’s low-moment estimates, as . Setting , we have
In particular,
Proof. Let , and write with . By Harper’s moment bounds [13 Theorem 1],
where is a Steinhaus random multiplicative function defined by for all , with denoting the exact prime power dividing . Under the Bohr transform, the expectation in (5) corresponds to the -norm of . Consequently, for ,
which yields the asymptotic behavior
On the critical line , partial summation and Riemann–Stieltjes integration give
from which it follows that
By normal family estimates, replacing with where preserves the bound .
Normalizing so that , we combine (6) and (7) to obtain
Taking logarithms on both sides yields
which tends to as . This completes the proof. □
Lemma 2.3. For and , point evaluations on satisfy uniformly in . Consequently, for every ,
which controls the tail-block contributions in the gliding-hump construction along vertical lines .
The proof of Lemma 2.3 is straightforward and arises directly from the point evaluations of the function , applying the Cauchy–Schwarz inequality effectively.
Lemma 2.4. There exist a sequence with and a rapidly increasing sequence of integers such that the series
converges in . Setting , the sequences and can be chosen recursively so that
Consequently, , yielding
The technique used in Lemma 2.4 is known as gliding-hump technique. This technique converts a sequence of singular test polynomials into a single function exhibiting unbounded localized behavior along a sequence of scales. Each block is chosen to be small in the ambient norm , ensuring series convergence . Moreover, each block is exceptionally large at the newly selected -th scale, and negligible at all previously established scales . By ensuring dominates both the prior partial sum and the future tail at scale , the resulting limit displays infinitely many bad scales simultaneously, upgrading quantitative norm blowups into a qualitative counterexample.
Proof of Lemma 2.4. Assume the hypotheses of Lemma 2.2. From (2.1), the normalized Harper blocks satisfy
where . We construct a function by setting
Let . By choosing coefficients such that , the quasi-norm triangle inequality in guarantees the convergence of in , ensuring . We construct the sequences and inductively. Suppose have been chosen, and define the partial sum
Since is a Dirichlet polynomial, it is bounded on the compact rectangle ; hence,
Next, choose sufficiently small such that and
where denotes the point-evaluation bound on from Lemma 2.3. With fixed, choose so large that and the -th block dominates both and the future tail:
Now evaluate at for , and decompose into
where . By choice of , we have . By Lemma 2.3 and our bound on , the tail satisfies
Applying the reverse triangle inequality yields, for all ,
Integrating the positive part of the logarithm yields
Since as , taking the limit superior establishes
which implies . This completes the proof.
Lemma 2.5. Let , where is the Dirichlet series constructed in Lemma 2.4. Then and its uniform convergence abscissa satisfies , placing in the Nevanlinna class . Since
it follows that , establishing that .
Proof. Set , where is the Dirichlet series constructed in Lemma 2.4. Expanding as a Dirichlet series yields
where the coefficients are given by
Since , its uniform convergence abscissa satisfies . The translated function therefore satisfies , placing in the Nevanlinna class . By construction, . Applying (2.7) from Lemma 2.4, we obtain
Consequently, cannot admit a local harmonic majorant near the imaginary axis . Hence , which establishes that .
Remark 2.2. The construction in Lemma 2.5 demonstrates that the Hardy space of Dirichlet series fails to lie locally in the Nevanlinna class whenever . Combining this negative result for with the local -embedding theorem for , and applying the elementary inequality for , we establish the following sharp threshold classification for local Nevanlinna boundary behavior: Let . Then
Consequently, is the critical exponent governing local Nevanlinna boundary behavior in Hardy spaces of Dirichlet series.
Proof of Theorem 2.1 and Global Vs Local Logarithmic Mean Control
In [1], we posed the following open problem regarding quantitative logarithmic trace estimates:
Problem 3.1. [1] Does there exist a constant such that, for every with ,
We refer to condition (11) as the quantitative local Nevanlinna embedding problem (LNEP). This naturally leads to the following underlying question:
Question 3.3. Does global mean logarithmic control imply uniform local logarithmic control on short interval segments?
For , define the global logarithmic mean (Jessen-type) by
By classical results of Jessen [12], this limit exists for every , and the norm defining the metric is given by
The corresponding short-interval local mass quantity is defined as
with the uniform local norm given by . Problem 3.1 reduces to testing the implication
or, quantitatively, asking whether there exists a universal constant such that .
Control of does not automatically yield control of short-interval masses. Indeed, setting and , Fubini’s theorem gives
Thus, controls only the average over of the unit-interval masses , whereas requires peak control. For arbitrary non-negative functions, mean control implies no upper bound on the supreme local mass.
When , the function is almost periodic for each fixed , ensuring is almost periodic and thus for each fixed . The central obstruction lies in whether these bounds remain uniform as . A potential pathology arises if uniformly for small , while simultaneously along some sequence . Using the Harper block polynomials, we establish in the next section that this pathology indeed occurs, answering Question 3.3 in the negative.
Finally, we note that finiteness of requires a uniform bound across all translation intervals . By contrast, membership in requires logarithmic control only locally near each compact boundary segment. Consequently, while implies , local membership does not guarantee a uniform constant independent of .
Let and define the translation . As established, its uniform convergence abscissa satisfies , placing . If the quantitative Local Nevanlinna Embedding Problem (LNEP) held affirmatively, applying (11) to would yield
Condition (11) in Problem 3.1 is strictly stronger than the local logarithmic boundary condition required for membership in . Indeed, since any compact interval can be covered by finitely many unit intervals , (3.4) immediately implies
Consequently, an affirmative resolution to Problem 3.1 concerning LNEP would imply an affirmative solution to Saksman and Seip’s Problem 1.2. Crucially, this logical implication holds for all , not merely . The contrapositive of this reduction is particularly decisive:
Theorem 3.1. A negative resolution to Problem 1.2 implies a negative resolution to Problem 3.1 (LNEP).
Proof. Suppose () is the Dirichlet series produced by the gliding-hump construction (Lemma 2.4), associated with sequence satisfying
Define the translated function . Since , we have , which guarantees . However,
Since the interval is a subset of the unit translation interval , taking the supremum over all and yields
Consequently, no universal constant can exist satisfying inequality (11) in Problem 3.1, providing a negative answer to LNEP. □
Moreover, the following proof resolves Problem 3.1 in the negative, establishing the failure of the quantitative local Nevanlinna embedding for .
Proof of failure of Problem 3.1. Choose disjoint pairs of prime numbers satisfying recursively via Bertrand’s postulate. For each , define the Dirichlet polynomial
Since each is a Dirichlet polynomial, its uniform convergence abscissa satisfies , so .
The Bohr lift of to the compact abelian group is given by
Applying the elementary bound for , the global logarithmic norm satisfies
where we have used the standard torus integral evaluation . Because , the right-hand side of (14) satisfies as .
On the other hand, along the imaginary axis for , each factor satisfies
Since , we obtain the lower bound . Consequently, uniformly for , which implies
since . By continuity, for each we can select sufficiently small such that
for a fixed constant with . Thus, as ,
while . Therefore, there exists no universal constant such that
holds for all , answering Problem 3.1 (LNEP) in the negative. □
Remark 3.1. The underlying chain of logical implications is structured as follows:
In general, no reverse implications hold. First, the failure of quantitative LNEP guarantees a sequence satisfying
even though each individually may lie in . Second, Saksman and Seip’s question [17] is restricted to -derived Dirichlet series, whereas LNEP encompasses all of .
Proof of Theorem 2.1. The Harper polynomial estimates establish that the quantitative local embedding fails for . However, because each individual Harper polynomial is entire, it individually satisfies the local Nevanlinna embedding condition. To upgrade this quantitative blowup to a genuine qualitative counterexample in , we deploy a Baire category argument.
Fix the compact interval . For , define the subset
We first claim that each is closed in . Indeed, let be a sequence converging to in . By Lemma 2.3, point evaluations are bounded on compact subsets of the half-plane . Thus uniformly for for each fixed . By Fatou’s lemma (or uniform convergence), the functional
is continuous on . Taking the supremum over yields a lower semicontinuous functional, which guarantees that is closed.
Suppose now, for contradiction, that every lies locally in . By definition, admits a local harmonic majorant near each compact boundary segment. Thus for every , there exist integers such that . Consequently, we obtain the countable exhaustion
Since is a complete metric space (a Banach space for and a quasi-Banach F-space for ), the Baire Category Theorem asserts that at least one set must contain an open ball. That is, there exist and such that whenever . Using the elementary inequality , taking logarithms yields
Integrating over and using , we deduce that for all ,
By scaling, choose sufficiently small so that whenever . Substituting into (15) yields . Applying the identity , we obtain
Restricting (16) to the subspace of Dirichlet polynomials and taking the boundary limit , we conclude that
However, the sequence of normalized Harper polynomials satisfies while as (from (8)), directly contradicting (17).
Thus, the assumption is false. For every , there exists a function which fails to belong to , resolving Problem 1.2 in the negative.
Answer to Question 3.3. Fix . Let denote the partial sums of the Riemann zeta function, and let . Define the normalized polynomial
so that . By Harper’s low-moment estimates [13], the norm satisfies
Define the translated function . Since is a Dirichlet polynomial, its uniform convergence abscissa satisfies , placing .
We first demonstrate that the global logarithmic norm is uniformly bounded in . Since right translations are contractive on , we have
for all .
Applying the elementary inequalities for , we obtain
Taking the limit superior as yields uniformly for all . We now show that the local short-interval mass explodes as . Set . By partial summation, for we have
Since , evaluating the modulus yields the lower bound
for some constant . Integrating over the short interval gives
Thus, while . Consequently, no universal constant can exist satisfying for all , establishing the failure of global-to-local logarithmic control and resolving Question 3.3 in the negative.
Remark 3.2. The Harper block sequence provides a simpler and more transparent refutation of the quantitative embedding inequality than the full gliding-hump argument. Indeed, because
no universal constant can satisfy across . However, because each is a Dirichlet polynomial, for every individual . Consequently, the sequence alone does not establish the existence of an element for which . To obtain this stronger qualitative statement, the gliding-hump construction is indispensable. By concatenating successively larger, well-separated
Harper blocks into a single Dirichlet series , the construction yields a function satisfying , while simultaneously
along a sequence . This provides the definitive qualitative proof that global mean logarithmic control fails to imply uniform short-interval logarithmic control.
Acknowledgment: The second named author is supported by CSIR-UGC Fellowship, New Delhi, India.
Vasudevarao Allu, Department of Mathematics, School of Basic Sciences, Indian Institute of Technology Bhubaneswar, Bhubaneswar-752051, Odisha, India. Email address: [email protected]
Dipon Kumar Mondal, Department of Mathematics, School of Basic Sciences, Indian Institute of Technology Bhubaneswar, Bhubaneswar-752051, Odisha, India. Email address: [email protected]
References
- [1]V. Allu and D. K. Mondal, Composition operators and Carlson embeddings for the Nevanlinna class of Dirichlet series, https://arXiv:2609.17133v1, (2026).arxiv.org/abs/2609.17133
- [2]F. Bayart and O. F. Brevig, Composition operators and embedding theorems for some function spaces of Dirichlet series, Math. Z. 293 (2019), 989–1004.
- [3]A. S. Besicovitch, Almost periodic functions, Dover publications, Inc., New York, (1955).
- [5]O. F. Brevig, J. O. Cerdà and K. Seip, Idempotents Fourier multipliers acting contractively on Hp spaces, Geom. Funct. Anal. 31 (2021), 1377–1413.
- [6]O. F. Brevig and K. M. Perfekt, A mean counting function for Dirichlet series and compact composition operators, Adv. Math. 385 (2021), paper no. 107775, 48 pp.DOI
- [8]B. Chen, X. Fang, F. Guo, S. Hou, Y. Shao and Q. Zhou, The local embedding problem for Hardy spaces of Dirichlet series, https://arXiv:2609.11560v2, (2026).arxiv.org/abs/2609.11560
- [9]J. Gördon and H. Hedenmalm, The Composition operators on the space of Dirichlet series with square summable coefficients, Michigan. Math. J. 46(2) (1999), 313–329.DOI
- [10]K. Guo, J. Ni and Q. Zhou, Nevanlinna class, Dirichlet series and Szegő’s problem, Ann. Inst. Fourier (Grenoble) 75(4) (2025), 1603–1647.
- [11]H. Hedenmalm, P. Lindqvist and K. Seip, A Hilbert space of Dirichlet series and systems of dilated functions in L²(0,1), Duke Math. J. 86(1) (1997), 1–37.DOI
- [12]B. Jessen and H. Tornehave, Mean motions and zeroes of almost periodic functions, Acta Math. 77 (1945), 137–279.DOI
- [13]A. J. Harper, Moments of random multiplicative functions: I. Low moments, better than squareroot cancellation, and critical multiplicative chaos, Forum Math. Pi 8 (2020), e1, 95.arxiv.org/abs/1703.06654
- [14]J. F. Olsen and E. Saksman, On the boundary behaviour of the Hardy spaces of Dirichlet series and a frame bounded estimate, J. Reine Angew. Math. 663 (2012), 33–66.arxiv.org/abs/0907.2708
- [15]H. Queffélec and M. Queffélec, Diophantine approximation and Dirichlet series, Texts and Readings in Mathematics, Springer 80 (2020).
- [16]E. Saksman and K. Seip, Integral means and boundary limits of Dirichlet series, Bull. London Math. Soc. 41(3) (2009), 411–422.
- [17]E. Saksman and K. Seip, Some open questions in analysis for Dirichlet series, in Recent Progress on Operator Theory and Approximation in Spaces of Analytic Functions (C. Bénéteau, A. A. Condori, C. Liaw, W. T. Ross and A. A. Sola, eds.), Contemp. Math. 679, American Mathematical Society, Providence, RI, (2016), 179–191.arxiv.org/abs/1601.01616
- [18]J. H. Shapiro and A. L. Shields, Unusual topological properties of the Nevanlinna class, Amer. J. Math. 97(4) (1975), 915–936.DOI