WorksMathematics
On complemented skew braces
Abstract
We investigate complemented skew left braces, that is, skew braces in which every skew subbrace admits a complement. We establish that if every minimal subbrace of a finite skew brace is complemented, then the brace is supersoluble and all its skew subbraces of prime power order are elementary abelian. We also show that the converse does not hold in general, providing a finite counterexample. Furthermore, we prove that every subbrace of a finite direct product of square-free skew braces is complemented. Finally, we extend our investigation to the infinite setting, proving that every multipermutational complemented skew brace is hypercyclic and that all its skew subbraces whose additive groups are -groups are elementary abelian.
Introduction
The study of complemented subgroups plays an important role in the structural theory of finite groups. Recall that a subgroup of a group is said to be complemented in if there exists a subgroup of such that and . Groups in which every subgroup is complemented are called complemented groups and form a particularly interesting class, since the existence of complements imposes strong restrictions on the subgroup structure. and provides a natural framework for understanding group decompositions and factorisations.
One of the classical results in this direction is due to Hall [8] and the fourth author and Guo [3], establishing the following characterisation of finite complemented groups.
Theorem 1.1. Let be a finite group. Then the following statements are equivalent:
is complemented.
Every subgroup of prime order of is complemented in .
is supersoluble and its Sylow subgroups are elementary abelian.
is isomorphic to a subgroup of a direct product of square-free finite groups.
The aim of this paper is to investigate the extent to which this characterisation can be generalised to the setting of skew left braces.
A skew (left) brace is a set endowed with two group operations , the additive group, and , the multiplicative group, that satisfy the following distributivity-like property:
Skew braces have become an important algebraic tool in the study of set-theoretic solutions of the Yang–Baxter equation. The algebraic structure of a skew brace determines a solution, while properties such as ideals, skew subbraces, quotients and decompositions play an important role in understanding the associated solutions. Consequently, identifying classes of skew braces with particularly strong decomposition properties may provide new approaches to constructing and studying solutions of the Yang–Baxter equation.
One of the key facts about skew braces is that the multiplicative group acts via automorphisms on the additive group by means of the lambda map
In case this action is trivial, we say that is a trivial skew brace. In this case for all . Furthermore, if is trivial and is abelian (respectively elementary abelian) we say that is abelian (respectively elementary abelian).
A subset of is a skew subbrace of if is subgroup of and simultaneously. A skew subbrace of a brace is called simply subbrace throughout.
This leads us to consider skew braces in which every subbrace admits a complement that is itself a subbrace. According to [2 Definition 8], a subbrace of is complemented in if there exists a subbrace such that
In this case, is called a complement of in .
We shall refer to skew braces where every subbrace is complemented as complemented skew braces.
Recall that a minimal subbrace of a brace is a subbrace of prime order.
Our first main result establishes a structural consequence of the complementability of minimal subbraces.
Theorem A. Let be a finite skew brace in which every minimal subbrace is complemented in . Then is supersoluble and every subbrace of prime power order is elementary abelian.
In particular, this result provides an analogue of the implication from condition 2 to condition 3 in the classical characterisation of complemented groups. Moreover, the complementability of a finite skew brace imposes strong restrictions on both of its underlying group structures.
Corollary 1.2. Let be a finite complemented skew brace. Then and are complemented groups.
However, the converse of Theorem A does not hold in general. More precisely, we show that the conditions of supersolubility and having elementary abelian -subbraces are not sufficient to guarantee that every minimal subbrace of a finite skew brace is complemented.
Theorem B. There exists a finite supersoluble skew brace in which every -subbrace is elementary abelian, but has minimal subbraces that are not complemented.
Thus, unlike the group case, the structural conditions appearing in the classical characterisation do not provide a complete characterisation of complemented skew braces. This illustrates the additional difficulties arising from the compatibility between the additive and multiplicative operations.
We also investigate the role of square-free skew braces, which provide a natural analogue of the groups appearing in condition 4 of the classical result.
Theorem C. Every subbrace of a finite direct product of square-free skew braces is complemented.
Finally, we consider infinite complemented braces. Although the finite characterisation of complemented groups relies on finiteness in an essential way, an infinite analogous structural result can be obtained for multipermutational skew braces.
Theorem D. Let be a multipermutational complemented skew brace. Then is hypercyclic and every subbrace whose additive group is a -group is elementary abelian.
Preliminaries
Let be skew brace. If is a subset of we denote by (respectively and ) the smallest subbrace (additive subgroup and multiplicative subgroup respectively) of that contains .
The star product of two elements of is defined by
for all .
The star product of two subsets is defined by
A subbrace of is a left ideal of if it is -invariant, or equivalently, . If is also normal in the additive and multiplicative group we say that is an ideal of . The relevance of ideals lies in the fact that we can make quotients with them. Two important subbraces of that play a key role here are the kernel of lambda and the fixed points set.
The former is a subbrace while the latter is a left ideal of . An important ideal of is the socle of
We can construct a socle series as follows
We will say that is multipermutational if there exists such that . Moreover, the smallest for which this happens is called the multipermutational level of .
According to [2 Definition 18], a skew brace is said to be soluble if there exists an ideal series
of such that is abelian.
We will say that an ideal of a skew brace is -hypercyclic if there exists an ascending series of ideals of
(here and are ordinal numbers) such that has prime order. If the series is finite, we will say that is -supersoluble (see [1 Definition 3.1]). If , we will simply say that is hypercyclic.
Let be a prime. A -subbrace of is a subbrace of such that and are -groups, that is, groups in which every element has order a power of . In the finite case that means that is a power of .
If is a finite skew brace and , where a prime and , has subbraces of order (see [5]). Such -subbraces are called Sylow -subbraces.
Proof of Theorem A
The following result is elementary, therefore, we omit its proof.
Proposition 3.1. Let be a complemented skew brace, a subbrace of and an ideal of . Then and are complemented skew braces.
Proposition 3.2. Let be a finite -skew brace. If every minimal subbrace of is complemented in , then is elementary abelian.
Proof. Suppose that the result is false, and let be a minimal counterexample. By Proposition 3.1 and the minimality of , all subbraces are elementary abelian. We can also suppose that is a non-trivial brace, because in other case, the result is true by Theorem 1.1.
By [7 Theorem 4.8 and Corollary 2.27], . Since is a trivial brace, every subgroup of is a subbrace of . Hence, we can consider a subbrace of of order contained in . Then there exists a proper subbrace of such that and . Let and . Then there exists and such that . Since and is elementary abelian, we have that
Hence, , and . Therefore . Since is not trivial, we have that and . Furthermore, this forces , because otherwise we could suppose that which is a contradiction. Therefore, is a complement of in and .
On the other hand, , since in other case, and would be trivial. Since is a trivial brace, contains a subbrace of order . Let be a complement of in . Let and . Then there exists and such that . Since and is elementary abelian, we have that
Therefore, and so . Analogously to the previous case, is complemented by in . Hence and .
Finally, . In this case and are abelian groups, therefore, , a contradiction. □
Proposition 3.3. Let be a finite skew brace with every minimal subbrace complemented in , and let be the largest prime dividing . Then has a Sylow -subbrace that is an ideal of .
Proof. We argue by induction on . If is a -skew brace, then is its Sylow -subbrace and the result holds. Suppose that is divisible by at least two primes. By Cauchy’s Theorem for braces (see [5]), has a subbrace of order , where is the smallest prime dividing . Let be a complement of in .
By induction, has a Sylow -subbrace that is an ideal of . In particular, and are characteristic in and respectively. Since and is the smallest prime dividing , we have that and are normal in and respectively. Hence, and are normal in and respectively. Since , we have that is a Sylow subbrace of . Since is characteristic in and normal in , it follows that is an ideal of . □
Proof of Theorem A. We argue by induction on . Let be the largest prime dividing , by Proposition 3.3, has a Sylow -subbrace that is an ideal of . By Proposition 3.2, is elementary abelian as is a complemented skew brace by Proposition 3.1. Let be a minimal subbrace of . Then for some . By the Schur-Zassenhaus theorem for skew braces (see [4]), has a minimal subbrace such that and . Let be a complement of in . Then and (note that is contained in ). Therefore, every minimal subbrace of is complemented in . By induction is supersoluble, and is elementary abelian. Therefore, is soluble.
Let be a minimal ideal of . By [2], is abelian. Consider a subbrace of of order , and let be a complement of in . Since is an ideal of , is an ideal of . Moreover, is abelian; therefore, normalises additively and multiplicatively. Hence, is normal in additively and multiplicatively. Let and . Then there exists and such that . Since is abelian,
Therefore, is an ideal of . The minimality of yields . It follows that . Hence, is of order . By induction, is supersoluble, and so is supersoluble.
Let be a prime. By Proposition 3.1, every minimal subbrace of a -subbrace of is complemented. Thus, by Proposition 3.2, is elementary abelian.
Proof of Corollary 1.2. By Theorem A, is supersoluble and every subbrace of prime power order is elementary abelian. In particular, the Sylow subbraces of are elementary abelian. By [1 Lemma 3.5], and are supersoluble. Consequently, both and are supersoluble groups with elementary abelian Sylow subgroups. By Theorem 1.1, and are complemented groups.
The example of Theorem B
According to [2], a subbrace of a skew brace is called a maximal subbrace of if is the only proper subbrace of containing . The Frattini subbrace of is defined as the intersection of all maximal subbraces of , if such exist, and otherwise ([2 Definition 24]). If is finite, every proper subbrace of is contained in a maximal subbrace of and so is a proper subbrace of .
Lemma 4.1. Let be a finite skew brace with every minimal subbrace complemented in . Then .
Proof. Assume that , and let be a prime dividing . Then, by Cauchy’s theorem for skew braces (see [5]), has a subbrace of order . Let be a complement of in . Then . Since is a proper subbrace of , there exists a maximal subbrace of such that . Since , it follows that , a contradiction. Hence . □
Example 4.2. Let be the skew brace defined in [6 Example 3.2]. This skew brace corresponds to S(18, 14) of the YangBaxter library [10] of GAP [9].
Notice that and .
is normal in and and lambda invariant. Therefore, it is a cyclic ideal. Moreover, is abelian; thus, is supersoluble.
Every 2-subbrace has order 2, so it is elementary abelian. Also, every 3-subbrace is elementary abelian since they are contained in , which it is the only Sylow 3-subgroup of .
Furthermore, and are maximal subbraces since their indices is prime. They also contain every 2-subgroup and 3-subgroup of respectively. We show that is the only subbrace of order 6. The subgroups of with order 6 are
Since
the first three subgroups are not closed under the product, hence, is the only subbrace of with order 6.
In conclusion, and are the only maximal subbraces. Therefore, . By Lemma 4.1, is not complemented.
Proof of Theorem C
Proof of Theorem C. As in the case of groups, the finite direct product of complemented skew braces is complemented (see [8]). By Proposition 3.1, subbraces of complemented skew braces are complemented. Hence, we only need to show that a square-free skew brace is complemented. Suppose that is a square-free skew brace. By [1 Corollary 3.9], is supersoluble, in particular it is soluble. Hence, by Hall’s theorem for soluble braces (see [5]), has a subbrace for every integer dividing and, therefore, every subbrace has a complement in . □
Proof of Theorem D
Lemma 6.1. Let be a prime and let be a skew brace such that is -elementary abelian. Let and . Then is finite.
Proof. Let and write . Consider
Obviously, is a subgroup of . Let us see that is a subbrace. First, notice that if , hence, for all . Moreover, for all . Consider . Then
for some . Then
Notice that
Hence, . Moreover,
Since and have additive orders either or , we have that and are in . Since the product of any two elements of belongs to , it follows that . Hence is a finite subbrace of containing .
Proposition 6.2. Let be a multipermutational complemented skew brace such that is a -group for a prime . Then is elementary abelian. Proof. First, let us prove that is elementary abelian. By [7 Theorem 2.20], is nilpotent. We argue by induction on the nilpotency class of .
Suppose that is abelian, and consider . Suppose that . Since is abelian, is a characteristic subgroup of ; therefore, is a subbrace of . Let be a subbrace of such that and . If , then has an element of order by Cauchy’s theorem, a contradiction. Hence , and is elementary abelian.
Now suppose that the nilpotency class of is and that the result is true for multipermutational complemented skew braces whose additive group has nilpotency class . Since is a characteristic subgroup of , it is a subbrace of , so that there exists a subbrace complementing in . We have that . By [7 Lemma 2.6 and Theorem 2.20] and Proposition 3.1, is a multipermutational complemented skew brace and the nilpotency class of is less than . By induction, is elementary abelian. Since is an abelian subbrace of , we have that is elementary abelian. Finally, , so that is elementary abelian.
Next, we show that is a trivial brace by induction on the multipermutational level of . It is clear that we may assume and that the result is true for multipermutational complemented skew braces of multipermutational level . Let be a complement of in . Then . By [7 Lemma 2.6 and Theorem 2.20] and Proposition 3.1, is a multipermutational complemented skew brace with multipermutational level . By induction, is a trivial brace. Let and . Then there exists and such that . Since and is trivial, we have that
Hence, , and .
Consider and . By Lemma 6.1, is finite. Therefore, is a finite complemented -skew brace. Thus, by Theorem A, is trivial, in particular, .
Let . Since , there exists and such that and . Therefore,
Consequently, is a trivial brace.
Recall that if is a periodic abelian group and is a prime, then for some is the unique Sylow -subgroup of . If is a skew brace, then is the Sylow -subbrace of .
Lemma 6.3. Let be a skew brace and let be an ideal of contained in . If is periodic, then the Sylow subgroups of are ideals of .
Proof. Let be a Sylow -subbrace of for some prime . Since is a trivial brace, is a subbrace of . Moreover, and are characteristic in and , respectively. Since and are normal in and , respectively, it follows that and are characteristic in and respectively. Finally, since is -invariant and is characteristic in , we have that is -invariant. Therefore, is an ideal of .
Lemma 6.4. If is a complemented skew brace, then is periodic.
Proof. Assume that has an element of infinite additive order. Since is an abelian subbrace, the additive infinite cyclic group and its subgroup are subbraces of . By Proposition 3.1, has a complement in , a contradiction. Hence, is periodic.
Proposition 6.5. Let be a complemented skew brace and let be a non-zero ideal of contained in . Then there exists an ideal of of prime order contained in .
Proof. By Lemma 6.4, is a periodic abelian skew brace. Let be a non-zero Sylow subgroup of . By Lemma 6.3, is an ideal of . By Proposition 3.1, is complemented. Since is a trivial brace, we can consider a subbrace of of order , and then take a complement in . Then is a subbrace of such that .
Consider a complement of in , and let . Then , and
Hence, . By Proposition 3.1, is complemented. Let be a complement of in . Since is an ideal of , we have that is an ideal of ; in particular, is lambda invariant by the elements of . Moreover, since , we have that is lambda invariant by the elements of . Thus, is lambda invariant by the elements of . Consequently, is a left ideal of . Finally, note that every left ideal of contained in is an ideal.
Lemma 6.6. Let be a skew brace and let be ideals of such that is -hypercyclic. Then is -hypercyclic.
Proof. Let
be an ascending series of ideals of such that has prime order. Denote . Then
is an ascending series of ideals of . Moreover,
Since has prime order, either has prime order or . Therefore, if we remove the repeated terms from the chain we have an ascending chain of ideals of whose successive quotients have prime order. Thus, is -hypercyclic. □
Proposition 6.7. Let be a complemented skew brace. Then is -hypercyclic.
Proof. Let be the set of all -hypercyclic ideals of contained in . Obviously , so it is not an empty set. Let
be an ascending chain of elements of . Consider . Clearly, is an ideal of contained in . Moreover, by Lemma 6.6, we can find an ascending series of ideals of from to such that the quotients have prime order. Therefore, we can construct an ascending series of ideals of from to such that the quotients have prime order. Therefore, .
By Zorn’s lemma, there exists , a maximal element of . If , then is a non-zero ideal of contained in . By Proposition 3.1, is a complemented skew brace. Then, by Proposition 6.5, there exists an ideal of of prime order contained in . Since is -hypercyclic and has prime order, is -hypercyclic. This contradicts the maximality of . Thus, is -hypercyclic. □
Proof of Theorem D. We show that is hypercyclic by induction on the multipermutational level of . By Proposition 6.7, is -hypercyclic and, by Proposition 3.1, is a multipermutational complemented skew brace of smaller multipermutational level. By induction, is hypercyclic, and hence is hypercyclic.
By [7 Lemma 2.6 and Theorem 2.20] and Proposition 3.1, every subbrace of is a complemented multipermutational skew brace. Hence, by Proposition 6.2, every subbrace whose additive group is a -group is elementary abelian for every prime .
Acknowledgements
The first author was supported by Guangdong Basic and Applied Research Foundation (2025A1515012072). The second and fourth authors are supported by the grant PID2024-159495NB-I00, funded byMI-CIU/AEI/10.13039/501100011033 and by ERDF/EU, and by the grant CI-AICO/2023/007 from the Conselleria d’Educació, Cultura, Universitats i Ocupació of the Generalitat Valenciana. The second author is funded by the Spanish Ministry of Science, Innovation and Universities through an FPU predoctoral grant FPU24/01319. The third author is grateful to the Universitat de València for their support to host researchers affected by the war in Ukraine.
References
- [1]A. Ballester-Bolinches, R. Esteban-Romero, M. Ferrara, V. Pérez-Calabuig, and M. Trombetti. Finite skew braces of square-free order and supersolubility. Forum Math. Sigma, 12:e39, 2024.
- [2]A. Ballester-Bolinches, R. Esteban-Romero, P. Jiménez-Seral, and V. Pérez-Calabuig. Soluble skew left braces and soluble solutions of the Yang–Baxter equation. Adv. Math., 455:109880, 2024.
- [3]A. Ballester-Bolinches and X. Guo. On complemented subgroups of finite groups. Arch. Math. (Basel), 72(3):161–166, 1999.
- [4]A. Ballester-Bolinches, P. Pérez-Altarriba, and V. Pérez-Calabuig. On finite trifactorised groups and dominance Sylow and Hall theorems for finite skew braces, 2026. Preprint.
- [5]A. Ballester-Bolinches, P. Pérez-Altarriba, and V. Pérez-Calabuig. On finite trifactorised groups and Sylow and Hall theorems for skew braces. Ricerche Mat., 2026.
- [6]Sergio Camp-Mora and P. Pérez-Altarriba. Carter-like theorems for skew braces, 2026. preprint.
- [7]F. Cedó, A. Smoktunowicz, and L. Vendramin. Skew left braces of nilpotent type. Proc. London Math. Soc., 118(6):1367–1392, 2019.DOI
- [8]P. Hall. Complemented Groups. J. London Math. Soc., s1-12(3):201–204, 1937.DOI
- [9]The GAP Group. GAP – Groups, Algorithms, and Programming, Version 4.15.1. The GAP Group, 2025. http://www.gap-system.org.
- [10]L. Vendramin and O. Konovalov. YangBaxter: combinatorial solutions for the Yang–Baxter equation, 2025. version 0.10.7, https://gap-packages.github.io/YangBaxter/.