betaFeedback

WorksPhysics and Astronomy

Laminar post-stall wakes of tapered swept wings

Abstract

While tapered swept wings are widely used, the influence of taper on their post-stall wake characteristics remains largely unexplored. To address this issue, we conduct an extensive study using direct numerical simulations to characterize the wing taper and sweep effects on laminar separated wakes. We analyze flows behind NACA 0015 cross-sectional profile wings at post-stall angles of attack α=14∘α=14^\circ–22∘22^\circ with taper ratios λ=0.27λ=0.27–11, leading edge sweep angles 0∘0^\circ–50∘50^\circ, and semi aspect ratios sAR=1sAR =1 and 22 at a mean-chord-based Reynolds number of 600600. Tapered wings have smaller tip chord length, which generates a weaker tip vortex, and attenuates inboard downwash. This results in the development of unsteadiness over a large portion of the wingspan at high angles of attack. For tapered wings with backward-swept leading edges unsteadiness emerges near the wing tip. On the other hand, wings with forward-swept trailing edges are shown to concentrate wake shedding structures near the wing root. For highly swept untapered wings, the wake is steady, while unsteady shedding vortices appear near the tip for tapered wings with high leading edge sweep angles. For such wings, larger wake oscillations emerge near the root as the taper ratio decreases. While the combination of taper and sweep increases flow unsteadiness, we find that tapered swept wings have more enhanced aerodynamic performance than untapered and unswept wings, exhibiting higher time-averaged lift and lift-to-drag ratio. The current findings shed light on the fundamental aspects of flow separation over tapered wings in the absence of turbulent flow effects.

Introduction

Flow separation over aerodynamic lifting bodies has been a subject of research interest for decades, especially for small-scale air vehicles [51, 4]. To further understand the post-stall wake dynamics, it is important to analyze the influence of wing planform geometry. This characterization is challenging for high-Reynolds-number flows, due to the multiscale nature of the wakes. Nevertheless, for massively separated flows, the large vortex structures observed in high-Reynolds-number flows are topologically analogous to the core structures in low-Reynolds-number flows [40, 16, 17]. To examine the fundamental aspects of unsteady 3-D flow separation, we study post-stall flows in the absence of turbulence [72, 90 b]. This characterization has been largely unexplored for low-Reynolds-number flows over tapered wings.

In aircraft design, tapered wings are used to approximate the elliptic aerodynamic loading over the wingspan. Tapered wings are more feasible to manufacture due to their less complex geometry compared to elliptic wings [63, 48]. The usage of tapered wings in aeronautics led to initial studies that explored the wing taper effect, especially for high-Reynolds-number flows [50, 5, 42, 71, 24]. For the laminar flow regime, the effect of wing taper on the wake dynamics is critical as the local Reynolds number is drastically reduced near the tip. For flows over wings at a chord-based Reynolds number Rec=O(104)Re_c = O(10^4), taper affects the aerodynamic loading with an increase in the pressure drag [79, 80]. For Rec=O(103)Re_c = O(10^3), the aerodynamic characteristics are affected significantly by the viscous effects and the influence of wing taper on the wakes remains elusive, especially for massively separated flows.

Post-stall wake dynamics has attracted attention of aeronautical researchers for many decades. The early efforts to understand post-stall flows over wings were performed over two-dimensional (2-D) spanwise homogeneous wings [1, 28, 75]. Valuable insights were obtained from 2-D analysis characterizing the behavior of the separated laminar boundary layer [37] and describing the relation between vortex shedding structures, adverse pressure gradient, and shear layer characteristics [59]. Moreover, the emergence of wake patterns associated with 3-D separation bubbles, as predicted in topological studies [36, 61], was shown by global linear stability analysis to arise from self-excitation of the laminar separation bubble [74].

The analysis of 2-D flows around canonical wings continues providing fundamental insights on the effect of angle of attack and Reynolds number on the wake shedding structures [47, 38, 86, 69, 21]. For separated flows, the increase in Reynolds number and the angle of attack yields a 3-D flow field even around infinite and spanwise homogeneous wings [6, 85, 70, 9, 35, 57]. In such cases, spanwise fluctuations emerge, producing 3-D vortices in the wake, as a result of the growth of 3-D structures associated with secondary linear instability (He *et al.* 2017a).

For finite wings, 3-D wakes result from tip effects, as a strong streamwise vortex is formed rolling up around the wing tip. [85, 27, 77]. While turbulence has an important influence on the 3-D wake [57], some of the core global flow structures remain coherent over a broad range of Reynolds numbers, including the quasi-spanwise midspan shedding and the tip vortex [55, 58]. Tip vortices induce downwash inboard over the wing, which reduces the effective angle of attack near the tip, even suppressing stall formation [20, 76] and the wake shedding for low-aspect-ratio wings [72, 91]. The tip vortex has been extensively studied to reveal its influence on the wake dynamics, aerodynamic forces, and pitch moments [25, 29, 18, 60, 7, 78, 12, 89, 2] (He *et al.* 2017b). Beyond understanding the tip vortex formation and evolution, a characterization of its instabilities has enabled the development of control techniques that improve the aerodynamic performance around finite wings [31, 22, 53].

Wing sweep also has a strong influence on post-stall wake dynamics. For laminar flow regimes, a number of experimental and numerical efforts were carried out to examine the effects of backward and forward wing sweep [87, 88, 90] and identify global modes [13, 66] that give rise to fundamental global coherent structures of flow separation around swept wings. It is noteworthy that some of the wing sweep effects on laminar post-stall flows are topologically analogous over a wide range of Reynolds numbers. For instance, for low-Reynolds-number flows over swept wings, some of the core coherent structures emerging in the near-wake, such as the “ram’s horn” vortex and the canard leading-edge vortices, were also identified in experiments performed at higher Reynolds numbers [8, 10, 54]. Moreover, the stabilizing effect of the sweep-induced spanwise flow on the wake structures, which significantly impacts stall characteristics, as observed at low-Reynolds-number flows [90, 67, 66], is further noticed in both experiments and high-fidelity large-eddy simulations performed at a higher Reynolds number regime [32, 83].

The aforementioned studies highlight the importance of the low-Reynolds-number post-stall wake characterization to reveal fundamental aspects of the unsteady 3-D flow separation physics. In fact, the insights obtained from studies of post-stall laminar flows have been important to expand our knowledge of the stalled flow physics over a wide range of Reynolds numbers. Thus far, however, most studies have not considered wing taper effects on low-Reynolds number flows at high angles of attack. Only recently, a combined experimental, numerical, and theoretical effort has been initiated towards the understanding of the laminar flow over tapered wings in post-stall flow conditions [65, 56, 14]. Effects of taper have been analyzed for planforms with tubercles to analyze swimming of whales [84], for flows over tapered cylinders [62, 73, 81], and for separated wakes over tapered plates [52]. For wing planforms with continuously variable chord-length over the wingspan, the delta wings have also received substantial attention [68, 30, 72]. For laminar post-stall flows, wing taper was studied using trapezoidal plates [39]. Nonetheless, there still is a lack of fundamental studies to understand the role of taper ratio, and how it interplays with leading edge (LE) and trailing edge (TE) sweep angle effects for massively separated laminar flows.

For laminar separated flows, the combined effect of wing taper and sweep remains elusive. In the present work, we aim to reveal the effects of taper in the laminar wake dynamics and the influence of LE and TE sweep angles on the vortical interactions through a comprehensive campaign of direct numerical simulations of 3-D flows over finite NACA 0015 wings. We characterize the stalled wakes of wings with backward-swept LE and forward-swept TE, identifying the combined effects of taper and sweep on the post-stall wake dynamics. Our work is organized as follows. In § 2, we present our wing planform geometry definitions and the setup for direct numerical simulations. In § 3, we offer a detailed analysis and classification of the wake structures, highlighting the effects of taper and sweep on the wakes and aerodynamic forces. Finally, we conclude our study by summarizing our findings in § 4.

Problem setup

We consider laminar flows over tapered wings with a NACA 0015 cross-sectional profile. The spatial coordinates of streamwise, transverse, and spanwise directions are denoted by (x,y,z)(x,y,z), respectively. The origin is placed at the LE of the wing root, as shown in Figure 1. The NACA 0015 profile is defined on the (x,y)(x,y) plane, which is extruded from the wing root in the spanwise direction to form the 3-D wing. Wing taper is defined by the taper ratio λ=ctip/croot\lambda= c_{\mathrm{tip}}/c_{\mathrm{root}}, where ctipc_{\mathrm{tip}} and crootc_{\mathrm{root}} are tip and root chord-lengths, respectively, as shown in Figure 1(a). For all wings considered herein, the chord length decreases linearly from root to tip. The non-dimensional mean chord length cc at the spanwise location of z=b/2z=b/2 is taken to be the characteristic length used to non-dimensionalize all spatial variables. The mean chord cc is fixed and independent of λ\lambda for all wing planforms studied herein.

Problem setup for tapered wings

Figure 1. Problem setup for tapered wings. (a) Geometrical parameters shown in a wing planform with sAR=b/c=2sAR=b/c=2, α=18∘\alpha=18^\circ, λ=0.27\lambda=0.27, and ΛLE=18.4∘\Lambda_{\mathrm{LE}}=18.4^\circ. (b) For a (λ,ΛLE)=(0.5,0∘)(\lambda,\Lambda_{\mathrm{LE}})=(0.5,0^\circ) wing, we show the computational domain and (c, d) grids with 2-D planes at z/c=1z/c=1 and y/c=−0.5y/c=-0.5, respectively.

The semi aspect ratio of the wings is set as sAR=b/c=1sAR = b/c = 1 and 22, where bb is the half-span length, as shown in Figure 1(d). We consider half-span wing models with symmetry imposed at the root. The angles of attack, α=14∘\alpha= 14^\circ, 18∘18^\circ, and 22∘22^\circ, are defined between the airfoil chord line and the streamwise direction. The present wing geometries have sharp trailing edge and straight-cut wing tip. The mean-chord-based Reynolds number is set to Rec=600Re_c=600 and the freestream Mach number is set to M∞=0.1M_\infty=0.1. Taper changes the local Reynolds number ReLcRe_{L_c}, defined as a function of the spanwise location [80]. For the present study, the difference between ctipc_{\mathrm{tip}} and crootc_{\mathrm{root}} accounts for a maximum variation of 60% on ReLcRe_{L_c} along the span, from min⁡(ReLc)=250\min(Re_{L_c})=250 to max⁡(ReLc)=950\max(Re_{L_c})=950 at the lowest taper ratio.

For tapered swept wings, the 3-D computational setup is sheared in the chordwise direction and the LE sweep angle is defined between the zz-direction and the LE. Tapered wings have different LE and TE sweep angles (ΛLE\Lambda_{\mathrm{LE}} and ΛTE\Lambda_{\mathrm{TE}}, respectively), as shown in Figure 1(a). Note that the wing planform can be specified with two parameters out of the three parameters of taper ratio (λ\lambda), LE, and TE sweep. Given that (ctip+croot)/2=c(c_{\mathrm{tip}}+c_{\mathrm{root}})/2=c, for a chosen λ\lambda, ΛLE\Lambda_{\mathrm{LE}}, and sARsAR we have

λ=ctipcroot,croot=21+λ,andΛTE=arctan⁡[−2sAR(1−λ1+λ)+tan⁡(ΛLE)].(1)\lambda=\frac{c_{\mathrm{tip}}}{c_{\mathrm{root}}},\qquad c_{\mathrm{root}}=\frac{2}{1+\lambda},\qquad\text{and}\qquad\Lambda_{\mathrm{TE}}=\arctan\left[-\frac{2}{sAR}\left(\frac{1-\lambda}{1+\lambda}\right)+\tan\left(\Lambda_{\mathrm{LE}}\right)\right]. \tag*{(1)}

In this work, we explore the combined effects of the LE and TE sweep angles on the wake dynamics for LE sweep angles 0≤ΛLE≤50∘0 \leq\Lambda_{\mathrm{LE}} \leq50^\circ and taper ratios 0.27≤λ≤10.27 \leq\lambda\leq1. The corresponding TE sweep angles take −30∘≤ΛTE≤50∘-30^\circ\leq\Lambda_{\mathrm{TE}} \leq50^\circ. Herein, negative sweep angles indicate a forward sweep, as shown in Figure 1(a), while a positive sweep angle represents a backward sweep.

Traditionally in aeronautics, tapered swept wings have wing sweep angles observed with respect to the quarter-chord line [4, 5, 24] denoted by Λc/4\Lambda_{c/4}, as shown in Figure 1(a). Anderson [3] considered the half-chord sweep angle Λc/2\Lambda_{c/2}, such that aerodynamic load distribution becomes independent of the taper ratio. Straight tapered wings with Λc/4=0∘\Lambda_{c/4}=0^\circ were studied by Traub et al. [80]. On the other hand, Irving [42] considered the effect of the LE and TE sweep angles. For the present laminar post-stall wakes, due to the crucial role played by the LE vortex in defining the wake characteristics [82, 23], we focus on the distinct effects of ΛLE\Lambda_{\mathrm{LE}} and ΛTE\Lambda_{\mathrm{TE}} in our analysis and describe their influence on the wake dynamics. We note, however, that it is also possible to translate the findings reported herein with respect to the traditional quarter-chord and half-chord sweep angles, Λc/4\Lambda_{c/4} and Λc/2\Lambda_{c/2}, respectively.

Direct numerical simulations

We conduct direct numerical simulations with a compressible flow solver CharLES [44] (Brès et al. 2017), which uses a second-order accurate finite-volume method in space with a third-order accurate total-variation diminishing Runge–Kutta scheme for time integration. The computational domain is discretized with a C-type grid with mesh refinement near the wing and in the wake. With the origin at the airfoil LE on the symmetry plane (x/c,y/c,z/c)=(0,0,0)(x/c,y/c,z/c)=(0,0,0), the computational domain extends over (x/c,y/c,z/c)∈[−20,25]×[−20,20]×[0,20](x/c,y/c,z/c)\in[-20,25]\times[-20,20]\times[0,20], which yields a maximum blockage ratio of 0.8% for the wing with λ=0.27\lambda=0.27, sAR=2sAR=2, and α=22∘\alpha=22^\circ. The computational setup is shown in Figure 1(b-Figure 1d).

We have prescribed a Dirichlet boundary condition of (ρ,ux,uy,uz,p)=(ρ∞,U∞,0,0,p∞)(\rho,u_x,u_y,u_z,p)=(\rho_\infty,U_\infty,0,0,p_\infty) at the inlet and farfield boundaries, where ρ\rho is density, pp is pressure, uxu_x, uyu_y, and uzu_z are velocity components in xx, yy, and zz directions respectively. The subscript ∞\infty denotes the freestream values. A symmetry boundary condition is prescribed along the root plane, z/c=0z/c=0. We have evaluated the applicability of the root-symmetry boundary condition by conducting DNS of flows over full wing configurations, without root-symmetry, for wings at α=22∘\alpha=22^\circ and λ=0.27\lambda=0.27 and 1. For both wings, we note that the wake exhibits root-concentrated vortex shedding and remains symmetric with respect to the wing root over large computational times.

A no-slip adiabatic boundary condition is set on the airfoil surface. For vortical structures to convect out of the domain, a sponge layer is applied over x/Lc∈[15,25]x/L_c\in[15,25] with the target state being the running time-averaged state over 5 convective time units [26]. Simulations start from uniform flow and are performed with a constant acoustic Courant–Friedrichs–Lewy (CFL) number of 1 until transients are washed out of the computational domain. The time to flush out the transients varies depending on the wing planform and angle of attack, generally ranging from 50 to 300 convective time units. After the transients are washed out the domain, flows are simulated with a constant time step defined such that CFL is smaller than one. Flow statistics are collected for 100 to 300 convective time units, depending on the flow field characteristics and spectral content to ensure convergence. A detailed discussion on verification is provided in appendix § 5.

Results

Overview of tapered wing wakes

Overview of tapered wing wakes

In Figure 2, we present instantaneous post-stall flows over tapered wings, which exhibit a rich diversity of wake structures through the combined effects of LE and TE sweep. Taper effects on laminar separated flows are entwined with the effects of LE and TE sweep. However, by studying straight tapered wings, that is, wings with Λc/2\Lambda_{c/2} and Λc/4\Lambda_{c/4} approximately zero, we can distinguish the effects of taper from other geometrical parameters.

Instantaneous flows around tapered wings for varying taper ratio and leading-edge sweep

Figure 2. Instantaneous flows around tapered wings with sAR=2s_{AR}=2, 0.27≤λ≤10.27 \le\lambda\le1, and 0∘≤ΛLE≤30∘0^\circ\le\Lambda_{\mathrm{LE}} \le30^\circ, at α=18∘\alpha=18^\circ visualized using gray-colored isosurfaces of Q=1Q=1.

For instance, let us explore the flows over wings with (λ,ΛLE)=(1,0∘)(\lambda,\Lambda_{\mathrm{LE}})=(1,0^\circ) and compare them to the wake structures around (λ,ΛLE)=(0.27,10∘)(\lambda,\Lambda_{\mathrm{LE}})=(0.27,10^\circ) wings; these flows have Λc/4=0∘\Lambda_{c/4}=0^\circ and 1.8∘1.8^\circ, respectively. For the tapered wing, we note a significant reduction of the tip vortex length caused by the smaller ctipc_{\mathrm{tip}}. The downstream root shedding, however, exhibits similar hairpin-like structures for both wings. In the near-wake region, for the tapered wing, the spatial spanwise flow fluctuations emerge near the root, over the spanwise vortex on the suction side. Such wake oscillations are absent in the vortical structure that forms over the untapered wing.

We can further explore the distinct taper effects on the wake dynamics by considering wings with Λc/2≈0∘\Lambda_{c/2} \approx0^{\circ}, as shown for the similar flow patterns that develop at the root region for (λ,ΛLE)=(1,0∘)(\lambda, \Lambda_{\mathrm{LE}}) = (1, 0^{\circ}) and (0.27,18.4∘)(0.27, 18.4^{\circ}) wings. Here, with a lower taper ratio, tip vortices are considerably weakened when compared to the structures near the free end of the untapered wing. The vortical roll structures emerging over the tapered wing appear slanted and aligned with ΛLE\Lambda_{\mathrm{LE}}, suggesting that the LE sweep angle plays an important role to define the behavior of the near-wake shedding structures.

For tapered wings, the backward-swept LE effect can be observed by fixing the ΛTE=0∘\Lambda_{\mathrm{TE}} = 0^{\circ} while the LE is swept backwards with ΛLE=18.4∘\Lambda_{\mathrm{LE}} = 18.4^{\circ} and 30∘30^{\circ} for λ=0.5\lambda= 0.5 and 0.270.27, respectively. For such wings, taper shifts the wake shedding structures closer to the wing tip. An opposite effect is shown in the top row of Figure 2, for flows over forward-swept TE wings. These planforms have fixed ΛLE=0∘\Lambda_{\mathrm{LE}} = 0^{\circ}, while ΛTE=−18.4∘\Lambda_{\mathrm{TE}} = -18.4^{\circ} and −30∘-30^{\circ} for λ=0.5\lambda= 0.5 and 0.270.27, respectively. For these cases, we observe that taper reduces the tip vortex length and changes the topology of the root shedding structures. Let us further study the taper effect for highly swept wings, shown at the bottom row of Figure 2, with a fixed ΛLE=30∘\Lambda_{\mathrm{LE}} = 30^{\circ}, while ΛTE=13.7∘\Lambda_{\mathrm{TE}} = 13.7^{\circ} and 0∘0^{\circ} for λ=0.5\lambda= 0.5 and 0.270.27, respectively. Here, taper increases the amplitude of wake oscillations. We further detail the discussions on the effects of taper, LE, and TE sweep in section 3.3.

The variety of wake structures that appear around tapered wings, as seen in Figure 2, calls for a proper characterization of the wake dynamics that associates its behavior with the wing planform geometry. The above discussions suggest that taper affects the location where unsteadiness emerges and the characteristics of the vortical structures. In the following section, we provide a map that characterized the wakes of tapered wings.

Wake classification and aerodynamic forces

We now classify the flow patterns with respect to the wing geometry. Our criterion is based on the examination of the flow characteristics downstream of the airfoil on a 2-D plane at x/c=4x/c = 4, where we identify the spatial location of maximum time-averaged Q‾\overline{Q} and the maximum fluctuating component of Q′=Q−Q‾Q^{\prime} = Q - \overline{Q}, where QQ is the second invariant of the velocity gradient tensor used to identify the vortical structures ([41, 43]). Maximum Q‾\overline{Q} and Q′Q^{\prime} located between 0≤z/(c sAR)<0.50 \leq z/(c\,sAR) < 0.5 are labeled root dominant, while points with maximum Q‾\overline{Q} or Q′Q^{\prime} between 0.5≤z/(c sAR)≤10.5 \leq z/(c\,sAR) \leq1 are named tip-dominant. We consider the flow as steady when the maximum fluctuating value of Q′Q^{\prime} is smaller than 0.1 at x/c=4x/c = 4. Using the root and tip locations of Q‾\overline{Q} and Q′Q^{\prime}, we classify their wakes into 3 unsteady and 2 steady regimes, as shown in Figure 3, where the steady-unsteady threshold (black dotted line) is computed via biharmonic spline interpolation. We further verify our classification criterion by carefully inspecting the flow fields. Instantaneous flow fields for all tapered wings shown in Figure 3 are provided in the appendix B using isosurfaces of Q=1Q = 1 colored by streamwise velocity uxu_x.

Classification of laminar flows over tapered wings into five distinct wake patterns and classification maps

Figure 3. Classification of laminar flows over tapered wings into five distinct wake patterns (aa-ee) shown for sAR=2sAR = 2 wings visualized with time-averaged Q‾=1\overline{Q} = 1 in gray and instantaneous Q′=0.2Q' = 0.2 colored by ux′u'_x. Classification map for (ff-hh) sAR=1sAR = 1 and (ii-kk) sAR=2sAR = 2 colored by CL/CD‾\overline{C_L/C_D}. Black dashed lines mark transition from steady to unsteady flows.

The first flow regime (△\triangle) is composed of tapered wings wakes that have both maximum Q‾\overline{Q} and Q′Q^{\prime} found near the root region. Such wakes appear for tapered wings with low LE sweep angles. For such wings, the tip vortex tends to be short in length and the taper and forward-swept TE effects concentrate shedding at the wing root, as shown in Figure 3(a) for (λ,ΛLE)=(0.27,20∘)(\lambda, \Lambda_{\mathrm{LE}}) = (0.27, 20^{\circ}) at α=22∘\alpha= 22^{\circ}. The second flow regime of unsteady wakes (⋄\diamond) occurs when both maximum Q‾\overline{Q} and Q′Q^{\prime} are found over the tip region. Such wakes are observed around tapered wings over a broad range of λ\lambda values, being present for wings with high LE sweep angles. The flow over such wings often exhibits hairpin-like vortices downstream in the wake aligned with the wing tip, as shown in Figure 3(b) for (λ,ΛLE)=(0.27,50∘)(\lambda, \Lambda_{\mathrm{LE}}) = (0.27, 50^{\circ}) at α=22∘\alpha= 22^{\circ}.

The third flow regime of unsteady wakes (◃\triangleleft) around tapered wings presents maximum Q‾\overline{Q} at the wing tip with maximum Q′Q^{\prime} at the root. This wake characteristic is often present for slightly tapered and swept wings, that is, wings with high λ\lambda and low LE sweep angles. Such wings exhibit a distinct tip vortex formation, at the location of the maximum Q‾\overline{Q}, and wake shedding near the root. On some occasions, the tip vortex exhibits weak unsteady flow oscillations, as shown in Figure 3(c) for (λ,ΛLE)=(1,10∘)(\lambda, \Lambda_{\mathrm{LE}}) = (1, 10^\circ) at α=22∘\alpha= 22^\circ, while the most energetic vortices are generally observed over the root region.

There are two distinct flow regimes of steady wakes shown herein, as seen in Figure 3(d,Figure 3e). The first one (▽\triangledown) is comprised of wakes with a steady streamwise vortex that develops into the wake. Such flows are mainly exhibited around highly swept sAR=2sAR = 2 wings with high and moderate taper ratios, λ≥0.5\lambda\ge0.5, as shown in Figure 3(d) for (λ,ΛLE)=(0.5,50∘)(\lambda, \Lambda_{\mathrm{LE}}) = (0.5, 50^\circ) at α=22∘\alpha= 22^\circ. The second steady wakes regime (□\square) is comprised of flows with no significant wake structures, with maximum Q‾≤0.1\overline{Q} \le0.1 in the wake and are commonly observed for sAR=1sAR = 1 wings, as shown in Figure 3(e) for a (λ,ΛLE)=(1,30∘)(\lambda, \Lambda_{\mathrm{LE}}) = (1, 30^\circ) wing at α=14∘\alpha= 14^\circ, and for sAR=2sAR = 2 wings at lower angles of attack, low taper ratios, and high LE sweep angles.

In Figure 3(f-Figure 3k), we present the classification for all wings studied herein. For sAR=1sAR = 1 wings, whose classification is shown in Figure 3(f-Figure 3h), there are fewer changes in wake class, when compared to sAR=2sAR = 2 wings. For the higher aspect ratio wings, with a fixed ΛLE\Lambda_{LE}, we often notice 2 or 3 distinct classes of wake behavior as λ\lambda changes. On the other hand, for sAR=1sAR = 1 wings, the same class for all λ\lambda is observed regularly. Taper effects become increasingly important for sAR=2sAR = 2 wings to alter their wake characteristics, as shown in Figure 3(i-Figure 3k), not only affecting the steady-unsteady wake behavior, but also producing distinct wakes as a function of λ\lambda. For sAR=2sAR = 2 wings with high LE sweep angles, the transition from steady to unsteady wakes is dependent on λ\lambda. Generally, untapered wings with high LE sweep angle wakes remain steady, while unsteady flow structures emerge in the wakes of tapered swept wings.

The combination LE sweep angle increase and taper ratio decrease is shown to promote wake unsteadiness. In addition, tapered wings with high LE sweep angles exhibit enhanced aerodynamic performance when compared to untapered and unswept wings, as shown in Figure 3(f-Figure 3k). To visualize this trend, each symbol associated with a wake class is colored by the time-averaged lift-to-drag ratio, CL‾/CD‾\overline{C_L}/\overline{C_D}, showing that the higher lift-to-drag ratio coefficients, for all sARsAR and α\alpha combination, appear for the wings with lower λ\lambda and higher backward-swept LE. Here, the aerodynamic forces are reported with lift and drag coefficients defined as

CL=Fy12ρU∞2bcandCD=Fx12ρU∞2bc,(2)C_L = \frac{F_y}{\frac{1}{2}\rho U_{\infty}^{2}bc} \qquad\text{and}\qquad C_D = \frac{F_x}{\frac{1}{2}\rho U_{\infty}^{2}bc}, \tag*{(2)}

where FxF_x and FyF_y are the xx and yy components of the force on the wing, respectively. Furthermore, we study the aerodynamic loads through the time-averaged CL‾\overline{C_L}, CD‾\overline{C_D}, and CL‾/CD‾\overline{C_L}/\overline{C_D} for selected sAR=2sAR=2 wings, as shown in Figure 4, to reveal the influence of taper and sweep on the aerodynamic forces. The blue symbols present the aerodynamic loads for tapered wings with unswept LE and forward-swept TE. The red symbols show the results for tapered wings with backward-swept LE and unswept TE, while the yellow symbols represent tapered wings with ΛLE=40∘\Lambda_{\mathrm{LE}}=40^\circ.

Time-averaged lift, drag, and lift-to-drag coefficients for tapered swept wings

Figure 4. Time-averaged lift, drag, and lift-to-drag coefficients, CL‾\overline{C_L}, CD‾\overline{C_D}, and CL‾/CD‾\overline{C_L}/\overline{C_D}, respectively, for sAR=2sAR = 2 tapered wings with 0.27≤λ≤10.27 \le\lambda\le1 at 14∘≤α≤22∘14^\circ\le\alpha\le22^\circ. Blue downward-pointing triangles, wings with unswept LE and forward-swept TE; red upward-pointing triangles, wings with backward-swept LE and unswept TE; yellow diamonds, wings with ΛLE=40∘\Lambda_{LE} = 40^\circ.

The effects of wing taper on the wakes and aerodynamic forces are strongly dependent on the combination of taper and sweep angle. Let us start from the untapered and unswept wings, marked by blue downward-pointing triangles at λ=1\lambda=1. The flow fields around these wings are characterized by root shedding and a strong tip vortex, as seen in Figure 2. While keeping the LE unswept, the TE is forward-swept for low λ\lambda. In the wake, such taper produces a concentration of both steady and fluctuating wake structures near the root, as shown in Figure 3(i-Figure 3k). A root-concentrated wake with a small tip vortex substantially decreases CLC_L, CDC_D, and CL/CDC_L/C_D with λ\lambda. It is noteworthy that at the same λ\lambda, tapered wings have backward-swept LE and unswept TE exhibit a higher CLC_L and CL/CDC_L/C_D, as shown in Figure 4. For such wings, we recall that taper shifts wake structures toward the tip region, as shown in Figure 2.

Backward-swept LE enhances the aerodynamic efficiency of tapered wings in post-stall laminar flow conditions. This LE-sweep-induced improvement in aerodynamic loads also occurs for tapered wings with high LE sweep angles. For instance, untapered swept wings present lower values of CL‾\overline{C_L} for all angles of attack, as shown by the diamond-shaped yellow symbols for λ=1\lambda=1 in Figure 4, while significantly reducing wake oscillations, as shown in Figure 2 and Figure 3(d-Figure 3f).

For sAR=2sAR=2 wings with high LE sweep at high incidence α≥18∘\alpha\geq18^\circ, taper causes a change in the wake regime, as shown in Figure 3(i-Figure 3k). For such wings, wake shedding emerges near the wing tip. The change in wake flow regime for tapered wings at high incidence causes an increase in CL/CDC_L/C_D. At lower incidence, α=14∘\alpha=14^\circ, the wake regime remains steady without noticeable vortices for tapered wings and the aerodynamic forces remain fairly constant for all λ\lambda, as shown in Figure 4(a). Let us now describe in detail the taper effects on the wake characteristics in the following section and relate the wakes to the lift distribution over the wing.

Wake characteristics

Tapered wings with unswept LE and forward-swept TE

Let us take a closer look at the effect of wing taper for unswept LE wings with forward-swept TE, as it allows us to isolate the ΛTE\Lambda_{\mathrm{TE}} effect on the wake dynamics. For tapered wings with λ=0.27\lambda=0.27, 0.50.5, 0.70.7, and 11, the planforms we study in this section have ΛTE=−30∘\Lambda_{\mathrm{TE}=-30^\circ}, −18.4∘-18.4^\circ, −10∘-10^\circ, and 0∘0^\circ, respectively. The negative ΛTE\Lambda_{\mathrm{TE}} indicates forward sweep. The LE is fixed with ΛLE=0∘\Lambda_{\mathrm{LE}}=0^\circ. For such wings, taper has a negative impact on the aerodynamic performance, while concentrating the unsteady shedding to a narrow region near the root, and significantly reducing the tip vortex strength, as shown in Figure 5(a).

Isosurfaces of flow fields around tapered wings and spanwise distributions

Figure 5. (a) Isosurfaces of flow fields around tapered wings with sAR=2sAR = 2, ΛLE=0∘\Lambda_{\mathrm{LE}} = 0^\circ, λ=0.27\lambda= 0.27 and 11, α=14∘\alpha= 14^\circ and 22∘22^\circ. Time-averaged Q‾=1\overline{Q} = 1 isosurface is shown in gray. Instantaneous Q′=0.2Q' = 0.2 isosurface is shown colored by ux′u'_x. (b) Spanwise distribution of ∥u∥2\lVert\mathbf{u} \rVert_2 for different λ\lambda for ΛLE=0∘\Lambda_{\mathrm{LE}} = 0^\circ wings. (c) Spatial-temporal (top) and PSD (bottom) of uyu_y distribution over the spanwise direction from probes located at (x,y)/c=(3,−0.5)(x,y)/c = (3,-0.5) for the λ=0.27\lambda= 0.27 and 11 tapered wings at α=22∘\alpha= 22^\circ shown above. (d) Sectional lift distribution over wingspan for tapered wings at α=22∘\alpha= 22^\circ.

Tapered wings have a smaller ctipc_{\mathrm{tip}}, which weakens the tip vortices and decreases its length, alleviating the inboard downwash over the wing. Such tip vortex attenuation and the aforementioned concentration of shedding over the root region occur for all angles of attack shown herein. The influence of the incidence angle appears on the formation of secondary vortices near the wing tip. For wings at high incidence angle, a secondary tip vortex is known to emerge from the LE, as shown in Figure 6 [19, 91]. For the tapered wings with forward-swept TE at α=22∘\alpha=22^\circ, there is also another core vortex that emerges near the wing tip from the TE. This structure is seen over the vortex sheet rolling up the TE as a slanted vortex pointing toward the root for the lower taper ratio, as visualized in Figure 6.

Vortical structures emerging near the wing tip around tapered wings

Figure 6. Vortical structures emerging near the wing tip around tapered wings with unswept LE and forward-swept TE. Top view of time-averaged flow fields around sAR=2sAR = 2 tapered wings at α=14∘\alpha= 14^\circ and 22∘22^\circ, with ΛLE=0∘\Lambda_{\mathrm{LE}} = 0^\circ, visualized using gray-colored time-averaged isosurfaces of Q‾=2\overline{Q} = 2.

To gain further insights on the characteristics of wake vortices, we study the unsteady flow behavior over the wingspan using probe measurements of velocity fluctuations over x/c∈[3,4]x/c\in[3,4], y/c∈[−1.5,0.5]y/c\in[-1.5,0.5]. The x/cx/c location is arbitrary and does not affect significantly the results. The y/cy/c range encompasses the region where vortical structures appear. Over this region, we probe

the norm of the root-mean-square (RMS) of the velocity, ∥u′′∥2\lVert\mathbf{u}''\rVert_2. This measurement represents the spanwise distribution of flow unsteadiness, as shown in Figure 5(b).

By examining at the spanwise ∥u′′∥2\lVert\mathbf{u}''\rVert_2 distribution in Figure 5(b) for untapered wings (blue), we notice that the flow unsteadiness peaks at z/c≈0.5z/c \approx0.5 and decays towards the wing tip for both angles of attack. For tapered wings, the spanwise ∥u′′∥2\lVert\mathbf{u}''\rVert_2 curves are independent of the taper ratio for λ≤0.7\lambda\le0.7. For such wings, taper yields an attenuation of the ∥u′′∥2\lVert\mathbf{u}''\rVert_2 peak. The peak of ∥u′′∥2\lVert\mathbf{u}''\rVert_2 also moves towards z/c≈0z/c \approx0, showing a concentration of unsteadiness towards the wing root for tapered wings.

Next, we analyze the spatial-temporal distribution of uyu_y from probes located at (x,y)/c=(3,−0.5)(x,y)/c = (3,-0.5) over the spanwise direction, to investigate how wing taper affects the shedding behavior. Herein, temporal frequency is characterized through the Strouhal number defined as St=f(csin⁡α/U∞)St = f(c \sin\alpha/U_\infty), where ff is the frequency. For comparison, the wake spectra for the flow over an untapered wing is shown on the left of Figure 5(c). For this wing, there is a narrow peak of oscillations at St≈0.14St \approx0.14. The wake spectra is clean with a vortex shedding pattern comprised of spanwise-dominated vorticity near the root, forming hairpin vortices and a steady streamwise vortex at the wing tip. For the tapered wing, the spectra is broadband as a result of the mixing of streamwise and spanwise vortices near the wing root. Even though the wake exhibits more mixing, the spanwise structures remain dominant, being related to the PSD peak at St≈0.13St \approx0.13. We note that the PSD peak occurs at a lower StSt than the one observed for the untapered wing, as the core unsteady structures that populate the downstream wake arise from the root region of the wing, where the chord-length is large.

As the post-stall wakes around tapered wings with forward-swept TE concentrate shedding near the root, they also alter the sectional load distribution as the near-wake vortices play an important role in generating lift and drag over the wing. While untapered wings exhibit a peak in sectional lift near the tip region, we note that the root contribution to lift is higher for tapered wings, as shown in Figure 5(d). Such load distribution is generally positive for flight stability [4]. For laminar post-stall flows over wings, the emergence of near-wake vortices closer to the wing surface can provide added lift [45, 93]. As shown in Figure 5(a), there are fewer large near-wake structures over the wing for the lower λ\lambda. This is a possible reason of the decrease in ClC_l over the entire wingspan experienced by the λ=0.27\lambda= 0.27 wing.

Tapered wings with backward-swept LE and unswept TE

Next, let us analyze the taper effects of wings with backward-swept LE and fixed unswept TE, to understand and separate the effects of the ΛLE\Lambda_{\mathrm{LE}} on the global wake. For such wings with λ=0.27,0.5,0.7,\lambda= 0.27, 0.5, 0.7, and 11, the planforms have ΛLE=30∘,18.4∘,10∘,\Lambda_{\mathrm{LE}} = 30^\circ, 18.4^\circ, 10^\circ, and 0∘0^\circ, respectively. The positive ΛLE\Lambda_{\mathrm{LE}} indicates backward sweep. The TE is fixed with ΛTE=0∘\Lambda_{\mathrm{TE}} = 0^\circ. For such wings, taper yields an opposite effect on the wake characteristics, when compared to those discussed in § 3.4.1. As shown in Figure 4, such wake pattern results in a better aerodynamic performance for wings with the same λ\lambda but distinct LE and TE sweep angles. Herein, taper shifts the unsteadiness region toward the wing tip, as shown in Figure 7(a).

Isosurfaces of flow fields around tapered wings and related wake distributions

Figure 7. Isosurfaces of flow fields around tapered wings with sAR=2sAR = 2, ΛTE=0∘\Lambda_{\mathrm{TE}} = 0^\circ, λ=0.27\lambda= 0.27 and 0.70.7, α=14∘\alpha= 14^\circ and 22∘22^\circ. Time-averaged Q‾=1\overline{Q} = 1 isosurface is shown in gray. Instantaneous Q′=0.2Q' = 0.2 isosurface is shown colored by ux′u'_x. (b) Spanwise distribution of ∥u′∥2\lVert\boldsymbol{u}' \rVert_2 for different λ\lambda for ΛLE=0∘\Lambda_{\mathrm{LE}} = 0^\circ wings. (c) Spatial-temporal (top) and PSD (bottom) of uyu_y distribution over the spanwise direction from probes located at (x,y)/c=(3,−0.5)(x,y)/c = (3,-0.5) for the λ=0.27\lambda= 0.27 and 0.70.7 tapered wings at α=22∘\alpha= 22^\circ shown above. (d) Sectional lift distribution over wingspan for tapered wings at α=22∘\alpha= 22^\circ.

Concurrently, the tip vortex weakens for tapered wings with the shortened ctipc_{\mathrm{tip}}, which alleviates of the inboard downwash near the tip, similar to what was observed for the wings in § 3.4.1. This increases the effective angle of attack near the tip and allows for the flow to detach from the wing surface and form wake shedding structures near z/c≈1z/c \approx1, as shown in Figure 7(a). We quantify the effect of wing taper on flow unsteadiness through the wingspan distribution of ∥u′′∥2\lVert\mathbf{u}''\rVert_2, as shown in Figure 7(b). For both angles of attack, taper affects the wake shedding distribution over the wingspan. For λ=0.27\lambda= 0.27 (purple), at α=22∘\alpha= 22^\circ, the peak of ∥u′′∥2\lVert\mathbf{u}''\rVert_2 appears near the quarter-span at z/c≈1.25z/c \approx1.25, with a gradual transition towards z/c≈0.5z/c \approx0.5 from λ=0.27\lambda= 0.27 to 11.

As seen in Figure 7(b), tapered wings with backward-swept LE and unswept TE exhibit unsteadiness over a larger spanwise length than untapered wings. For instance, let us observe the spanwise ∥u′∥2\lVert\boldsymbol{u}' \rVert_2 distribution for wings at α=22∘\alpha= 22^\circ. For the untapered wing (blue), u′≥0.02\boldsymbol{u}' \ge0.02 over 0≤z/c≤10 \le z/c \le1, which is the region where significant unsteady wake structures appear. Now, for the tapered wing with λ=0.27\lambda= 0.27, u′≥0.02\boldsymbol{u}' \ge0.02 over 0≤z/c≤1.60 \le z/c \le1.6, hence large unsteady structures can be observed over a larger spanwise portion of the wake.

The spatial-temporal distribution of the transverse velocity uyu_y over the spanwise direction also shows that the wake of backward-swept LE and unswept TE tapered wings exhibits 3-D vortical structures that result in a broadband wake spectrum, as shown in Figure 7(c). The wake, however, is mainly dominated by large quasi-2-D spanwise aligned vortex rolls observed for all taper ratios. For λ=0.27\lambda= 0.27, as unsteadiness appears over a larger portion of the wingspan, the stronger shedding structures are hairpin-like vortices that appear between 0.5≤z/c≤1.50.5 \le z/c \le1.5, as shown on the right of Figure 7(c).

The sectional lift distribution, shown in Figure 7(d), reveal that tapered wings with backward-swept LE and unswept TE significantly increase the root contribution and reduce the influence of the near tip region on the overall lift. The increase in root contribution to lift results from the shifting of the separation bubble toward the tip. This shifting causes a pair of near-wake vortices to emerge over the wing surface at the root region, as shown in Figure 7(a). Using force element analysis (Chang [15]), we reveal the near-wake structures that contribute to lift. In this approach, the volume force elements are identified by the dot product of the Lamb vector u×ω\mathbf{u} \times\boldsymbol{\omega} and an auxiliary potential ∇ϕi\nabla\phi_i (details in appendix § 7). Force element analysis shows a vortex pair emerging near the root, which increases the local contribution to the total lift over the wing.

In Figure 8, force elements further show that vortical structures with major contribution to lift appear over the separation bubble. Here, this region is illustrated by a black solid line contour at u‾x=0\overline{u}_x = 0 on the 2-D slices at z/c=0.1z/c = 0.1 and 0.30.3. In particular, the emergence of the near-root vortex pair is persistent for wings with backward-swept LE as similar structures have been identified for backward-swept untapered wings by Zhang & Taira [93]. These structures are absent for unswept LE wings both tapered and untapered, as shown in Figure 8(b). In fact, force elements over tapered unswept LE wings show that the lift elements emerging over the wing are much smaller than the ones over tapered wings with backward-swept LE. As the separation bubble near the root becomes larger over tapered wings with unswept LE, the wake structures are shifted far from the wing, reducing their contribution to the total lift.

Lift elements around tapered wings

Figure 8. Lift elements around λ=0.27\lambda= 0.27 tapered wings at α=22∘\alpha= 22^\circ at the time of maximum lift. (a) backward-swept LE with unswept TE and (b) Unswept LE with forward-swept TE. Perspective view shown with isosurfaces of Q=1Q = 1 colored by (u×ω)⋅∇ϕy(\mathbf{u} \times\boldsymbol{\omega}) \cdot\nabla\phi_y. Slices at selected z/cz/c locations with isocontours of lift elements and a black solid line over u‾x=0\overline{u}_x = 0.

The tip vortex is also substantially affected by wing taper, becoming smaller than the tip vortex around untapered wings, as shown in Figure 9(a). Tip vortices have high importance in terms of the aerodynamic characteristics of the wing ([25, 29, 18, 7, 72, 91, 20, 76, 77]) and, in the case of tapered wings, due to the small ctipc_{\mathrm{tip}}, tip vortices are attenuated, as a result of the reduced pressure differences between upper and lower side of the wing near the tip. Beyond that, even for wings with the same λ\lambda, the tip vortex behavior can be shifted in xx-direction depending on how the wing is tapered, whether it has a backward-swept LE or a forward-swept TE, as shown in Figure 9(b,Figure 9c). For this reason, we must also analyze the tip vortex at a distance x/cx/c from the LE at the wing tip, which is identified herein as xtip,LEx_{\mathrm{tip,LE}}.

Streamwise circulation profiles and flow fields around tapered swept wings

Figure 9. Streamwise circulation ∣Γx∣|\Gamma_x| of tip vortex around (a) an untapered wing and tapered wings with λ=0.5\lambda= 0.5 with (b) unswept LE and forward-swept TE and (c) backward-swept LE and unswept LE at α=22∘\alpha= 22^\circ. Flow field visualized with grey-colored isosurfaces of ωx=−2\omega_x = -2 and 2-D slices with isolines of ωx\omega_x at specific (x−xtip,LE)/c(x - x_{\mathrm{tip,LE}})/c locations. The magnitude of ∣Γx∣|\Gamma_x| computed for the isocontour of (d) ωx=−2\omega_x = -2 for tapered swept wings with different planform configurations.

We can observe how wing taper affects the strength of the tip vortex by analyzing the ω‾x\overline{\omega}_x near the tip, as shown in Figure 9(a-Figure 9c). The isosurfaces of ω‾x\overline{\omega}_x and the contour lines at representative (x−xtip,LE)/c(x-x_{\mathrm{tip,LE}})/c locations show the decay of vorticity magnitude for tapered wings with λ=0.5\lambda= 0.5. However, the effect of taper is not the same for both wings, even though they share the same taper ratio. This difference can be quantified as we compute the streamwise circulation Γ=∮Cu⋅dl\Gamma= \oint_C \mathbf{u} \cdot\mathrm{d}\mathbf{l}. Here, CC is the isocontour of ωx=−2\omega_x = -2, as shown in Figure 9(d). The choice of ωx\omega_x level is carefully chosen to isolate the tip vortex.

The tip vortex diffuses downstream of the wing, which makes the ∣Γx∣|\Gamma_x| profiles decay slowly ([22, 91]). In general, for tapered wings the reduction in ctipc_{\mathrm{tip}} is the main cause of the tip vortex weakening, thus the ∣Γx∣|\Gamma_x| circulation decays with λ\lambda at any distance from the wing tip. The circulation ∣Γx∣|\Gamma_x| further reveals how different types of wing taper can affect the strength of the tip vortex, as shown in Figure 9(d). At any given streamwise distance from the wing tip at the LE, (x−xtip,LE)/c(x - x_{\mathrm{tip,LE}})/c, for λ=0.5\lambda= 0.5, the streamwise circulation decay is similar for both tapered wings. For λ=0.27\lambda= 0.27, the tip vortex strength decays considerably depending on the LE and TE sweep angles. For tapered wings with backward-swept LE and unswept TE, the root shedding is shifted toward the tip region and reduces the tip vortex strength at any distance from the TE, when compared to the wing with same λ\lambda and forward-swept TE. For forward-swept TE wings, as vortex shedding is concentrated near the wing root, it has a minor influence on the tip vortex.

Tapered wings with high LE sweep angles

The final class of tapered wing shapes we consider are those with high LE sweep. For the swept wings discussed herein, with ΛLE>30∘\Lambda_{\mathrm{LE}} > 30^\circ, wake oscillations are strongly attenuated. For laminar flows over untapered wings with high sweep angles at moderate angles of attack, the wake becomes steady, while at high angles of attack, unsteadiness may develop in the wing tip region ([90, 66]). For highly swept and tapered wings, the flow exhibits wake shedding for small λ\lambda, as shown in Figure 10(a).

Isosurfaces of flow fields around tapered swept wings and distributions of flow quantities

Figure 10. Isosurfaces of flow fields around tapered swept wings with sAR=2sAR = 2, ΛLE=40∘\Lambda_{\mathrm{LE}} = 40^\circ, λ=0.27\lambda= 0.27 and 0.70.7, α=18∘\alpha= 18^\circ and 22∘22^\circ. Time-averaged Q‾=1\overline{Q} = 1 isosurface is shown in gray. Instantaneous Q′=0.2Q' = 0.2 isosurface is shown colored by ux′u'_x. (b) Spanwise distribution of ∥u′∥2\lVert\mathbf{u}' \rVert_2 for different λ\lambda for ΛLE=0∘\Lambda_{\mathrm{LE}} = 0^\circ wings. (c) Spatial-temporal (top) and PSD (bottom) of uy′u_y' distribution over the spanwise direction from probes located at (x,y)/c=(3,−0.5)(x,y)/c = (3,-0.5) for the λ=0.27\lambda= 0.27 and 0.70.7 tapered wings at α=22∘\alpha= 22^\circ shown above. (d) Sectional lift distribution over wingspan for tapered wings at α=22∘\alpha= 22^\circ.

Here, we analyze wings with a fixed ΛLE=40∘\Lambda_{\mathrm{LE}} = 40^\circ, while the TE is swept with ΛTE=10∘\Lambda_{\mathrm{TE}} = 10^\circ, 21.6∘21.6^\circ, 30∘30^\circ, and 40∘40^\circ for λ=0.27\lambda= 0.27, 0.50.5, 0.70.7, and 11, respectively. The onset of shedding for highly swept and tapered wings results from the distinct effects of ΛLE\Lambda_{\mathrm{LE}} and ΛTE\Lambda_{\mathrm{TE}}. For the present tapered swept wings, the vortical structures emerging from the TE promote unsteadiness in the wake near the wing tip. For lower taper ratios, wings have a low ΛTE\Lambda_{\mathrm{TE}}, which causes wake oscillation to appear and become large towards the root. Such effects show that while the high ΛLE\Lambda_{\mathrm{LE}} has the effect of stabilizing wake oscillations for untapered wings, the combination of wing taper and sweep can promote wake unsteadiness.

For instance, at α=18∘\alpha= 18^\circ the wake is steady for λ=0.7\lambda= 0.7 with long steady streamwise vortices developing from both LE and TE. At λ=0.5\lambda= 0.5, unsteadiness appears with vortex rolls at the wing tip, with wake shedding appearing for λ=0.27\lambda= 0.27. We quantify the wing taper effect in Figure 10(b). For instance, for the wings with λ≥0.7\lambda\ge0.7 at α=18∘\alpha= 18^\circ, the flow is steady and ∥u′∥2\lVert\mathbf{u}' \rVert_2 is negligible in the wake. At α=22∘\alpha= 22^\circ, ∥u′∥2\lVert\mathbf{u}' \rVert_2 is small for untapered wings, increasing considerably in magnitude and spanwise length as the taper ratio decreases. For highly swept tapered wings, the flow fluctuations are exhibited at the tip, further appearing over the midspan for the lower taper ratios.

The unsteady vortices exhibited in the wakes of tapered wings with high LE sweep angles behave as vortex shedding structures, as shown by the probed uyu_y in the wake in Figure 10(c).

For λ=0.7\lambda= 0.7, the vortices appear as a consistent flow oscillation departing from the wing tip. For λ=0.27\lambda= 0.27, the wake is dominated by spanwise-aligned roll structures that occupy a large portion of the wingspan. As these structures develop from the wingspan region near the wing tip, that has a reduced chord length, their frequency St≈0.15St \approx0.15 is slightly higher than the shedding frequency of untapered wings.

The sectional lift distributions around tapered wings with high LE sweep, seen in Figure 7(d), show how wing taper substantially increases the root contribution to the overall lift. Backward swept wings have a higher contribution of lift from the root region due to the pair of vortical structures near the midspan that attach closer to the wing surface [93] similar to the structures shown in Figure 8(a). For tapered wings, the combined effect of the midspan vortex pair and the development of shedding structures near the wing results in a considerable increase of the overall lift over the entire wingspan for the λ=0.27\lambda= 0.27 wing.

Conclusions

We have examined the influence of taper and sweep on the dynamics of wake structures for finite NACA 0015 wings with straight-cut tip at a Reynolds number of 600 and a Mach number 0.1. For this study, we performed an extensive campaign of direct numerical simulations of flows over half-span wings with symmetry boundary condition imposed at the wing root. The present numerical study spans over a wide parameter space with angles of attack between 14∘≤α≤22∘14^\circ\leq\alpha\leq22^\circ, aspect ratios sAR=1sAR = 1 and 2, leading edge sweep angles 0∘≤ΛLE≤50∘0^\circ\leq\Lambda_{\mathrm{LE}} \leq50^\circ, and taper ratios between 0.27≤λ≤10.27 \leq\lambda\leq1. This parameter space was chosen to characterize the effects of wing taper as well as the LE and TE sweep angles on the wake dynamics.

Through direct numerical simulations, we observe that the flow over unswept and untapered wings forms a strong tip vortex, which interacts with the spanwise vortex detaching from the wing surface at the root region. This flow yields a three-dimensional and unsteady wake for all angles of attack considered herein. Untapered and swept wings are observed to advect the shedding region towards the wing tip for lower angles of sweep. At higher sweep angles, the wake oscillations are attenuated, yielding a steady wake around wings at lower angles of attack.

Wing taper has a strong influence on the wake dynamics. For tapered wings, the LE and TE are not parallel and have a distinct influence on the flow structures within the stalled flow region. For tapered wings with unswept LE and forward-swept TE, taper concentrates shedding structures towards the wing root and yields a broadband spectral content downstream in the wake as a result of increased mixing in that region. Beyond the unsteady wake shedding, the tip vortex is heavily affected by wing taper, reducing its length considerably for tapered wings, as the chord-length decreases towards the tip.

For tapered wings with backward-swept LE and unswept TE, the spanwise length where wake unsteadiness is observed increases as shedding is promoted over a larger portion of the wingspan. For this type of tapered wing planform, in contrast to the forward-swept wing effect, the peak of wake unsteadiness moves towards the wing tip region for lower taper ratios. Moreover, for wings with high LE sweep, although the flow is steady for λ=1\lambda= 1, taper causes wake unsteadiness to appear. The wake oscillations develop near the wing tip for moderate taper ratios. For low λ\lambda, wings with high LE sweep angles exhibit strong wake shedding structures occupying a large portion of the wingspan.

Through the detailed analysis of the wake structures, we also provide a map that classifies the wake behavior of tapered wings associating its behavior with the wing planform geometry and its angle of attack. The map provides an unique description of the overall flow physics of the wakes around tapered wings and reveals, for each semi aspect ratio and angle of attack, how the steady-unsteady flow behavior is related to the wing taper and LE sweep angle. The present study shows the effect of taper, as well as the effects of LE and TE sweep and evaluates its impact on the formation of the wake structures.

Lastly, we show how the wing taper affects the aerodynamic forces over the wing. We show that wings with the same taper ratio may present distinct overall lift and aerodynamic performance, as these characteristics are also influenced by the LE sweep of the wing. Our findings show that the combination of wing taper and high LE sweep can considerably improve lift and the aerodynamic performance of the wing in laminar post-stall flows conditions. The present insights gained on the effect of wing taper in the absence of turbulence serve as a stepping stone for future efforts that aim to study, interpret and control higher Reynolds number post-stall flows over tapered wings.

Grid verification

We verify the convergence of grid resolution for the numerical results using a wing with (sAR,α,ΛLE,λ)=(2,22∘,40∘,0.27)(sAR, \alpha, \Lambda_{\mathrm{LE}}, \lambda) = (2, 22^\circ, 40^\circ, 0.27). This planform combines a high leading-edge sweep angle and the lowest taper ratio considered in the present study. Herein, we report the aerodynamic forces through their lift coefficients CLC_L. Two meshes are used for verification: a medium and a refined mesh. The medium mesh refinement is the one used throughout the present work. This mesh has 80 grid points on both pressure and suction sides of the wing and 48 grid points along the wingspan, with a total of approximately 3.1×1063.1 \times10^6 control volumes. The refined mesh has 120 grid points on pressure and suction sides, with 64 grid points along the wingspan, resulting in approximately 4.3×1064.3 \times10^6 control volumes in total. For the refined mesh we have increased the temporal resolution by setting the CFL to 0.5. The quality of our medium mesh is assessed through the forces exerted over the wing and the instantaneous vortical elements as shown in Figure 11.

Lift coefficient over time and instantaneous flow field structures

Figure 11. Lift coefficient over time and instantaneous flow field structures visualized using Q=1Q = 1 colored by instantaneous velocity component uxu_x at the lift peak for the two sets of meshes used for grid verification for the wing with (sAR,α,ΛLE,λ)=(2,22∘,40∘,0.27)(sAR, \alpha, \Lambda_{\mathrm{LE}}, \lambda) = (2, 22^\circ, 40^\circ, 0.27).

A portfolio of flow fields around tapered wings

In this appendix, we provide flow field visualizations of the wake structures around all tapered wings considered in the present study. Flows around sAR=1sAR = 1 wings at α=14∘\alpha= 14^\circ, 18∘18^\circ, and 22∘22^\circ are shown in figures 12, 13, and 14, respectively. Similarly, flows around sAR=2sAR = 2 wings α=14∘\alpha= 14^\circ, 18∘18^\circ, and 22∘22^\circ are shown in figures 15, 16, and 17, respectively. All flows are visualized using isosurfaces of Q=1Q = 1, colored by the streamwise velocity uxu_x.

Force element analysis

Force element analysis [15] is a method used to identify vortical structures emerging near the wake that play a significant role in exerting aerodynamic loads over the wing. We note

Instantaneous flow fields around wings of $sAR = 1$ at $\alpha = 14^\circ$

Figure 12. Instantaneous flow fields around wings of sAR=1sAR = 1 at α=14∘\alpha= 14^\circ visualized using isosurfaces of Q=1Q = 1 colored by streamwise velocity uxu_x.

Instantaneous flow fields around wings of $sAR = 1$ at $\alpha = 18^\circ$

Figure 13. Instantaneous flow fields around wings of sAR=1sAR = 1 at α=18∘\alpha= 18^\circ visualized using isosurfaces of Q=1Q = 1 colored by streamwise velocity uxu_x.

Instantaneous flow fields around wings of $sAR = 1$ at $\alpha = 22^\circ$

Figure 14. Instantaneous flow fields around wings of sAR=1sAR = 1 at α=22∘\alpha= 22^\circ visualized using isosurfaces of Q=1Q = 1 colored by streamwise velocity uxu_x.

Instantaneous flow fields around wings of $sAR = 2$ at $\alpha = 14^\circ$

Figure 15. Instantaneous flow fields around wings of sAR=2sAR = 2 at α=14∘\alpha= 14^\circ visualized using isosurfaces of Q=1Q = 1 colored by streamwise velocity uxu_x.

Instantaneous flow fields around wings of $sAR = 2$ at $\alpha = 18^\circ$

Figure 16. Instantaneous flow fields around wings of sAR=2sAR = 2 at α=18∘\alpha= 18^\circ visualized using isosurfaces of Q=1Q = 1 colored by streamwise velocity uxu_x.

Instantaneous flow fields around wings of $sAR = 2$ at $\alpha = 22^\circ$

Figure 17. Instantaneous flow fields around wings of sAR=2sAR = 2 at α=22∘\alpha= 22^\circ visualized using isosurfaces of Q=1Q = 1 colored by streamwise velocity uxu_x.

that force element theory is similar in spirit to other force element methods derived through a variational approach [64], as well as to vortex force maps (Li et al. 2020), and force partition approaches [49]. The present force element analysis was previously employed to analyze incompressible flows over wings in multiple configurations [45, 91, 92, 93].

Initially, we define an auxiliary potential with a specific boundary condition of −n⋅∇ϕi=n⋅ei-\boldsymbol{n} \cdot\nabla\phi_i = \boldsymbol{n} \cdot\boldsymbol{e}_i set on the wing surface, where ϕ\phi is the auxiliary potential, n\boldsymbol{n} is the unit wall normal vector, and ei\boldsymbol{e}_i is the unit vector in the iith direction. The inner product of the Navier–Stokes equations with ∇ϕ\nabla\phi and performing an integral over the fluid domain, the forces exerted in the ii-th direction may be expressed as

Fi=∫Vω×u⋅∇ϕi dV+1Re∫Sω×n⋅(∇ϕi+ei) dS,(3)F_i = \int_V \boldsymbol{\omega} \times\boldsymbol{u} \cdot\nabla\phi_i \,\mathrm{d}V + \frac{1}{Re} \int_S \boldsymbol{\omega} \times\boldsymbol{n} \cdot(\nabla\phi_i + \boldsymbol{e}_i) \,\mathrm{d}S, \tag*{(3)}

where the first integral represents the volume force elements and the second integral term is comprised of the surface force elements. For Rec=600Re_c = 600 flows, the volume elements are responsible for the major contribution to the total force over the wing. We note that the auxiliary potential velocity field ϕi\phi_i decays rapidly far from the surface. For this reason, the structures that have a higher contribution to lift are the ones that emerge near the surface.

To visualize the vortical structures associated with lift generation, one can take the Hadamard product of the ∇ϕi\nabla\phi_i and the Lamb vector (ω×u)(\boldsymbol{\omega} \times\boldsymbol{u}), as shown in Figure 8. The resulting (u×ω)⋅∇ϕy(\boldsymbol{u} \times\boldsymbol{\omega}) \cdot\nabla\phi_y variable is often called as lift element. Lastly, we recall that the force element theory used herein considers incompressible Navier–Stokes equations. Nevertheless, important insights on the flow structures may still be obtained for weakly compressible flows, such as the ones considered herein and in previous studies as well [67].

Acknowledgments

We acknowledge the support from the US Air Force Office of Scientific Research (program manager: Dr. G. Abate, grant: FA9550-21-1-0174). The first author thanks T. R. Ricciardi and K. Zhang for the enlightening discussions. Computational resources were provided by the High Performance Computing Modernization Program at the US Department of Defense and the Texas Advanced Computing Center.

Declaration of interest

The authors report no conflict of interest.

References

  1. [1]ABBOTT, I. H. & VON DOENHOFF, A. E. 1959 Theory of wing sections: including a summary of airfoil data. Dover.
  2. [2]ANANDA, G. K., SUKUMAR, P. P. & SELIG, M. S. 2015 Measured aerodynamic characteristics of wings at low reynolds numbers. Aerosp. Sci. Technol. 42, 392–406.
  3. [3]ANDERSON, J. D. 1999 Aircraft performance and design. WCB/McGraw-Hill Boston.
  4. [4]ANDERSON, J. D. 2010 Fundamentals of aerodynamics. McGraw-Hill.
  5. [5]ANDERSON, R. F. 1936 Determination of the characteristics of tapered wings. Tech. Rep. NACA-TR-572. NASA Langley.
  6. [6]BIPPES, H. & TURK, M. 1980 Windkanalmessungen in einem Rechteckflügel bei anliegender und abgelöster Strömung. Tech. Rep. 251-80 A 18. DFVLR Forschungsbericht IB.
  7. [7]BIRCH, D., LEE, T., MOKHTARIAN, F. & KAFYEKE, F. 2004 Structure and induced drag of a tip vortex. J. Aircraft 41 (5), 1138–1145.DOI
  8. [8]Black, J. 1956 Flow studies of the leading edge stall on a swept-back wing at high incidence. Aeronaut. J. 60 (541), 51–60.DOI
  9. [9]Braza, M., Faghani, D. & Persillon, H. 2001 Successive stages and the role of natural vortex dislocations in three-dimensional wake transition. J. Fluid Mech. 439, 1–41.DOI
  10. [10]Breitsamter, C. & Laschka, B. 2001 Vertical flowfield structure at forward swept-wing configurations. J. Aircraft 38 (2), 193–207.
  11. [12]Buchholz, J. H. J. & Smits, A. J. 2006 On the evolution of the wake structure produced by a low-aspect-ratio pitching panel. J. Fluid Mech. 546, 433–443.pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/19746198
  12. [13]Burtsev, A., He, W., Hayostek, S., Zhang, K., TheofilIs, V., Taira, K. & Amitay, M. 2022 Linear modal instabilities around post-stall swept finite wings at low Reynolds numbers. J. Fluid Mech. 944, A6.DOI
  13. [14]Burtsev, A., TheofilIs, V., Ribeiro, J. H. M., Taira, K., Neal, J. M. & Amitay, M. 2023 Wake dynamics of tapered wings. Part III: triglobal linear stability analysis. In AIAA Paper 2023-2299.DOI
  14. [15]Chang, C.-C. 1992 Potential flow and forces for incompressible viscous flow. Proc. R. Soc. Lond. A 437 (1901), 517–525.DOI
  15. [16]Dallmann, U. C. 1988 Three-dimensional vortex structures and vorticity topology. Fluid Dyn. Res. 3 (1-4), 183–189.DOI
  16. [17]Délery, J. M. 2001 Robert Legendre and Henri Werlé: toward the elucidation of three-dimensional separation. Annu. Rev. Fluid Mech. 33, 128.DOI
  17. [18]Devenport, W. J., Rife, M. C., Liapis, S. I. & Follin, G. J. 1996 The structure and development of a wing-tip vortex. J. Fluid Mech. 312, 67–106.DOI
  18. [19]DeVoria, A. C. & Mohseni, K. 2017 On the mechanism of high-incidence lift generation for steadily translating low-aspect-ratio wings. J. Fluid Mech. 813, 110–126.DOI
  19. [20]Dong, L., Choi, K.-S. & Mao, X. 2020 Interplay of the leading-edge vortex and the tip vortex of a low-aspect-ratio thin wing. Exp. Fluids 61 (9), 1–15.DOI
  20. [21]Durante, D., Rossi, E. & A. Colagrossi, Andrea 2020 Bifurcations and chaos transition of the flow over an airfoil at low Reynolds number varying the angle of attack. Commun. Nonlinear Sci. Numer. Simul. 89, 105285.DOI
  21. [22]Edstrand, A. M., Sun, Y., Schmid, P. J., Taira, K. & Cattafesta, L. N. 2018 Active attenuation of a trailing vortex inspired by a parabolized stability analysis. J. Fluid Mech. 855, R2.
  22. [23]Eldredge, J. D. & Jones, A. R. 2019 Leading-edge vortices: mechanics and modeling. Annu. Rev. Fluid Mech. 51, 75–104.DOI
  23. [24]Falkner, V. M. 1950 Sweepback and wing taper: The effect of sweepback on the lift, drag, and aerodynamic centre of a tapered wing. Aircraft Eng. Aero. Tech. 22 (10), 296–300.DOI
  24. [25]Francis, M. S. & Kennedy, D. A. 1979 Formation of a trailing vortex. J. Aircraft 16 (3), 148–154.DOI
  25. [26]Freund, J. B. 1997 Proposed inflow/outflow boundary condition for direct computation of aerodynamic sound. AIAA J. 35 (4), 740–742.DOI
  26. [27]Freymuth, P., Finaish, F. & Bank, W. 1987 Further visualization of combined wing tip and starting vortex systems. AIAA J. 25 (9), 1153–1159.DOI
  27. [28]Gaster, M. 1967 The structure and behaviour of laminar separation bubbles pp. 813–854.
  28. [29]Green, S. I. & Acosta, A. J. 1991 Unsteady flow in trailing vortices. J. Fluid Mech. 227, 107–134.DOI
  29. [30]Gursul, I., Gordnier, R. & Visbal, M. 2005 Unsteady aerodynamics of nonslender delta wings. Prog. Aero. Sci. 41 (7), 515–557.DOI
  30. [31]Gursul, I. & Wang, Z. 2018 Flow control of tip/edge vortices. AIAA J. 56 (5), 1731–1749.DOI
  31. [32]Harper, C. W. & Maki, R. L. 1964 A review of the stall characteristics of swept wings. Tech. Rep. NASA/TN D-2373. NASA, Washington, DC.
  32. [35]Hoarau, Y., Braza, M., Ventikos, Y., Faghani, D. & Tzabiras, G. 2003 Organized modes and the three-dimensional transition to turbulence in the incompressible flow around a NACA 0012 wing. J. Fluid Mech. 496, 63–72.DOI
  33. [36]Hornung, H. G. & Perry, A. E. 1984 Some aspects of three-dimensional separation. Part I. Streamsurface bifurcations. Z. Flugwiss. Weltraumforsch 8, 77–87.
  34. [37]Horton, H. P. 1968 Laminar separation bubbles in two and three dimensional incompressible flow. PhD thesis, Queen Mary University of London.
  35. [38]Huang, R. F., Wu, J. Y., Jeng, J. H. & Chen, R. C. 2001 Surface flow and vortex shedding of an impulsively started wing. J. Fluid Mech. 441, 265–292.DOI
  36. [39]Huang, Y., Venning, J., Thompson, M. C. & Sheridan, J. 2015 Vortex separation and interaction in the wake of inclined trapezoidal plates. J. Fluid Mech. 771, 341–369.
  37. [40]Hunt, J. C. R., Abel, C. J., Peterka, J. A. & Woo, H. 1978 Kinematic studies of the flows around free or surface-mounted obstacles; applying topology to flow visualization. J. Fluid Mech. 86 (1), 179–200.
  38. [41]Hunt, J. C. R., Wray, A. A. & Moin, P. 1988 Eddies, streams, and convergence zones in turbulent flows. pp. 193–208. Proc. Summ. Prog., Center for Turbulence Research, Stanford, CA.
  39. [42]Irving, H. B. 1937 Some notes on tapered wings: The effects of brake flaps, taper and “sweep” on stalling. Aircraft Eng. Aero. Tech. 9 (2), 31–36.DOI
  40. [43]Jeong, J. & Hussain, F. 1995 On the identification of a vortex. J. Fluid Mech. 285, 69–94.
  41. [44]Khalighi, Y., Ham, F., Nichols, J., Lele, S. K. & Moin, P. 2011 Unstructured large eddy simulation for prediction of noise issued from turbulent jets in various configurations. In AIAA Paper 2011–2886.
  42. [45]Lee, J.-J., Hsieh, C.-T., Chang, C.-C. & Chu, C.-C. 2012 Vorticity forces on an impulsively started finite plate. J. Fluid Mech. 694, 464–492.
  43. [47]Lin, J. C. M. & Pauley, L. L. 1996 Low-Reynolds-number separation on an airfoil. AIAA J. 34 (8), 1570–1577.
  44. [48]McCormick, B. W. 1995 Aerodynamics, aeronautics, and flight mechanics. John Wiley & Sons.
  45. [49]Menon, K. & Mittal, R. 2021 Quantitative analysis of the kinematics and induced aerodynamic loading of individual vortices in vortex-dominated flows: a computation and data-driven approach. J. Comput. Phys. 443, 110515.
  46. [50]Millikan, C. B. 1936 On the stalling of highly tapered wings. J. Aero. Sci. 3 (5), 145–150.DOI
  47. [51]Mueller, T. J. 2001 Fixed and flapping wing aerodynamics for micro air vehicle applications. American Institute of Aeronautics and Astronautics, Inc. Reston, VA.
  48. [52]Narasimhamurthy, V. D., Andersson, H. I. & Pettersen, B. 2008 Cellular vortex shedding in the wake of a tapered plate. J. Fluid Mech. 617, 355–379.
  49. [53]Navrose, Brion, V. & Jacquin, L. 2019 Transient growth in the near wake region of the flow past a finite span wing. J. Fluid Mech. 866, 399–430.
  50. [54]Neal, J., Burtsev, A., Ribeiro, J. H. M., Taira, K., Theofilis, V. & Amitay, M. 2023a Similarities in massive separation across Reynolds numbers for swept and tapered finite span wings. arXiv preprint arXiv:2308.12442.
  51. [55]Neal, J. M. & Amitay, M. 2023 Three-dimensional separation over unswept cantilevered wings at a moderate Reynolds number. Phys. Rev. Fluids 8, 014703.
  52. [56]Neal, J. M., Gares, B., Amitay, M., Burtsev, A., Theofilis, V., Ribeiro, J. H. M. & Taira, K. 2023b Wake dynamics of tapered wings. Part II: an experimental study. In AIAA Paper 2023-2298.
  53. [57]Pandi, J. S. S. & Mittal, S. 2019 Wake transitions and laminar separation bubble in the flow past an Eppler 61 airfoil. Phys. Fluids 31 (11), 114102.
  54. [58]Pandi, J. S. S. & Mittal, S. 2023 Streamwise vortices, cellular shedding and force coefficients on finite wing at low Reynolds number. J. Fluid Mech. 958, A10.
  55. [59]Pauley, L. L., Moin, P. & Reynolds, W. C. 1990 The structure of two-dimensional separation. J. Fluid Mech. 220, 397–411.
  56. [60]Pelletier, A. & Mueller, T. J. 2000 Low Reynolds number aerodynamics of low-aspect-ratio, thin/flat/cambered-plate wings. J. Aircraft 37 (5), 825–832.
  57. [61]Perry, A. E. & Hornung, H. G. 1984 Some aspects of three-dimensional separation. Part II. Vortex skeletons. Z. Flugwiss Weltraumforsch 8, 155–160.
  58. [62]Piccirillo, P. S. & Van Atta, C. W. 1993 An experimental study of vortex shedding behind linearly tapered cylinders at low Reynolds number. J. Fluid Mech. 246, 163–195.
  59. [63]Prandtl, L. 1920 Theory of lifting surfaces. Tech. Rep. NACA/TN-9. NASA, Washington, DC.
  60. [64]Quartapelle, L. & Napolitano, M. 1983 Force and moment in incompressible flows. AIAA J. 21 (6), 911–913.
  61. [65]Ribeiro, J. H. M., Taira, K., Neal, J. M., Amitay, M., Burtsev, A. & Theofilis, V. 2023a Wake dynamics of tapered wings. Part I: a computational study. In AIAA Paper 2023-2297.
  62. [66]Ribeiro, J. H. M., Yeh, C.-A. & Taira, K. 2023b Triglobal resolvent analysis of swept-wing wakes. J. Fluid Mech. 954, A42.
  63. [67]Ribeiro, J. H. M., Yeh, C.-A., Zhang, K. & Taira, K. 2022 Wing sweep effects on laminar separated flows. J. Fluid Mech. 950, A23.
  64. [68]Rockwell, D. 1993 Three-dimensional flow structure on delta wings at high angle-of-attack-experimental concepts and issues. In AIAA Paper 1993-0550.DOI
  65. [69]Rossi, E., Colagrossi, A., Oger, G. & Le Touzé, D. 2018 Multiple bifurcations of the flow over stalled airfoils when changing the Reynolds number. J. Fluid Mech. 846, 356–391.DOI
  66. [70]Schewe, G. 2001 Reynolds-number effects in flow around more-or-less bluff bodies. J. Wind Eng. Ind. Aerodyn. 8, 1267–1289.DOI
  67. [71]Soule, H. A. & Anderson, R. F. 1940 Design charts relating to the stalling of tapered wings. Tech. Rep. NACA-TR-703. NASA.
  68. [72]Taira, K. & Colonius, T. 2009 Three-dimensional flows around low-aspect-ratio flat-plate wings at low Reynolds numbers. J. Fluid Mech. 623, 187–207.DOI
  69. [73]Techet, A. H., Hover, F. S. & Triantafyllou, M. S. 1998 Vertical patterns behind a tapered cylinder oscillating transversely to a uniform flow. J. Fluid Mech. 363, 79–96.DOI
  70. [74]Theofilis, V., Hein, S. & Dallmann, U.Ch. 2000 On the origins of unsteadiness and three-dimensionality in a laminar separation bubble. Phil. Trans. Roy. Soc. London (A) 358, 3229–3244.
  71. [75]Tobak, M. & Peake, D. J. 1982 Topology of three-dimensional separated flows. Annu. Rev. Fluid Mech. 14 (1), 61–85.DOI
  72. [76]Toppings, C. E. & Yarusevych, S. 2021 Structure and dynamics of a laminar separation bubble near a wingtip. J. Fluid Mech. 929, A39.DOI
  73. [77]Toppings, C. E. & Yarusevych, S. 2022 Structure and dynamics of a laminar separation bubble near a wing root: towards reconstructing the complete lsb topology on a finite wing. J. Fluid Mech. 944, A14.DOI
  74. [78]Torres, G. E. & Mueller, T. J. 2004 Low-aspect-ratio aerodynamics at low Reynolds numbers. AIAA J. 42 (5), 865–873.DOI
  75. [79]Traub, L. W. 2013 Aerodynamic impact of aspect ratio at low Reynolds number. J. Aircraft 50 (2), 626–634.DOI
  76. [80]Traub, L. W., Botero, E., Waghela, R., Callahan, R. & Watson, A. 2015 Effect of taper ratio at low Reynolds number. J. Aircraft 52 (3), 734–747.DOI
  77. [81]Valles, B., Andersson, H. I. & Jenssen, C. B. 2002 Oblique vortex shedding behind tapered cylinders. J. Fluids Struct. 16 (4), 453–463.DOI
  78. [82]Videler, J. J., Stamhuis, E. J. & Povel, G. D. E. 2004 Leading-edge vortex lifts swifts. Science 306 (5703), 1960–1962.pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/15591209
  79. [83]Visbal, M. R. & Garmann, D. J. 2019 Effect of sweep on dynamic stall of a pitching finite-aspect-ratio wing. AIAA J. 57 (8), 3274–3289.DOI
  80. [84]Wei, Z., New, T. H. & Cui, Y. D. 2018 Aerodynamic performance and surface flow structures of leading-edge tubercled tapered swept-back wings. AIAA J. 56 (1), 423–431.DOI
  81. [85]Winkelman, A. E. & Barlow, J. B. 1980 Flowfield model for a rectangular planform wing beyond stall. AIAA J. 18 (8), 1006–1008.DOI
  82. [86]Yarusevych, S., Sullivan, P. E. & Kawall, J. G. 2009 On vortex shedding from an airfoil in low-Reynolds-number flows. J. Fluid Mech. 632, 245–271.DOI
  83. [87]Yen, S.-C. & Hsu, C. M. 2007 Flow patterns and wake structure of a swept-back wing. AIAA J. 45 (1), 228–236.
  84. [88]Yen, S.-C. & Huang, L.-C. 2009 Flow patterns and aerodynamic performance of unswept and swept-back wings. J. Fluids Eng. 131 (11).DOI
  85. [89]Yilmaz, T. O. & Rockwell, D. 2012 Flow structure on finite-span wings due to pitch-up motion. J. Fluid Mech. 691, 518–545.DOI
  86. [90]Zhang, K., Hayostek, S., Amitay, M., Burstev, A., Theofilis, V. & Taira, K. 2020a Laminar separated flows over finite-aspect-ratio swept wings. J. Fluid Mech. 905, R1.DOI
  87. [91]Zhang, K., Hayostek, S., Amitay, M., He, W., Theofilis, V. & Taira, K. 2020b On the formation of three-dimensional separated flows over wings under tip effects. J. Fluid Mech. 895, A9.DOI
  88. [92]Zhang, K., Shah, B. & Bilgen, O. 2022 Low-reynolds-number aerodynamic characteristics of airfoils with piezocomposite trailing surfaces. AIAA J. 60 (4), 2701–2706.
  89. [93]Zhang, K. & Taira, K. 2022 Laminar vortex dynamics around forward-swept wings. Phys. Rev. Fluids 7 (2), 024704.arxiv.org/abs/2109.09027

Paper details

vlnc:W_uzrw2mn5
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 0

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Physics and Astronomy

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents