betaFeedback

WorksMathematics

The recent counterexamples to the Eisenbud-Schreyer-Weyman Ulrich problem (2003) and to Hochster's small Cohen-Macaulay conjecture (1973): a survey, with a generalization to arbitrary dimension

Abstract

In September 2026 four preprints and an AI-generated manuscript moved one numerical obstruction from projective geometry to local algebra. For a smooth complex projective surface YY with an ample, globally generated divisor HH such that H2<σ(Y)H^2<σ(Y), the signature, one obtains in turn: no Ulrich bundles when HH is very ample (Anghel, arXiv:2609.02718; extended to every dimension by Lopez, arXiv:2609.06678), answering negatively the Eisenbud-Schreyer-Weyman question of 2003 for sheaves supported on the whole variety; no arithmetically Cohen-Macaulay bundles, i.e. section rings without graded maximal Cohen-Macaulay modules in characteristic zero (Anghel, arXiv:2609.15589); and complete local domains without small Cohen-Macaulay modules, counterexamples to Hochster's 1973 conjecture, if KY≡4HK_Y\equiv4H (Chen, arXiv:2609.24142, proposed) or σ>2H2σ>2H^2 (OpenAI, released 6 October). We recall the definitions and main statements, and add two things. First, through a finite projection to P2\mathbb P^2 and an identity already present in the OpenAI manuscript, the three obstructions become one variance identity; for surfaces this explains the factor 22 between the graded bound σ≤H2σ\le H^2 and the local σ≤2H2σ\le2H^2. Second, we generalize the argument of the OpenAI manuscript to every dimension m≥2m\ge2, with complete proofs: if XX is a smooth complex projective variety of dimension mm and HH an ample, globally generated divisor, a small Cohen-Macaulay module over the completed section ring of (X,H)(X,H) forces (KX2−2c2(X))⋅Hm−2≤(m+4)Hm(K_X^2-2c_2(X))\cdot H^{m-2}\le(m+4)H^m. Consequently the completed section rings of all Hesse pairs, including the ball quotient of the first preprint, have no small Cohen-Macaulay module, and products of Hesse surfaces with projective spaces give complete local domains with an isolated singularity, of every dimension ≥3\ge3, without small Cohen-Macaulay modules.

Introduction

This survey tells a short story. In three weeks of September 2026 a numerical obstruction for vector bundles on polarized surfaces was pushed, one step at a time, from projective geometry to local commutative algebra. The central steps are recorded in three preprints and an AI-generated manuscript; a further preprint, [24], is a side branch towards higher dimension:

[1] 2 September: smooth polarized surfaces with no Ulrich bundle [1];

[24] 6 September (v3: 10 September): smooth polarized varieties of every dimension ≥2\ge2 with no Ulrich bundle [24]; used in [2 §5], not in the local arguments;

[2] 14 September: no arithmetically Cohen–Macaulay (aCM) bundles, hence section rings with no graded maximal Cohen–Macaulay (MCM) module [2];

[9] 21 September: a proposed local cohomology obstruction for arbitrary modules over the completed section ring, under K≡4HK \equiv4H [9];

[26] 23 September (date of the manuscript): a complete local domain without a small Cohen–Macaulay module [26], published on 6 October in OpenAI’s catalogue of mathematical manuscripts [27].

Figure 1 places them on a timeline, and Figure 2 records the citations among them (details in § 11).

Figure 1. The five texts (September–October 2026).

Figure 2. Citations among the five texts (an arrow points from a text to one that uses or cites it). The central chain is drawn thick; [24] (dashed) is a side branch towards higher dimension. Dotted arrows lead from the texts on which § 10 builds to this paper’s higher-dimensional counterexamples to Hochster’s conjecture: the argument of [26], the examples of [1], the product construction of [2], and the higher-dimensional Ulrich inequality of [24], which § 10 recovers.

Three existence questions sit behind the story, and they form a tower (Figure 3). For a smooth projective surface YY with a polarization HH, let R=R(Y,H)=⨁t≥0H0(Y,OY(tH))R = R(Y,H) = \bigoplus_{t\geq0} H^0(Y,\mathcal{O}_Y(tH)) be the section ring and R^\widehat{R} its completion at the vertex. The three questions ask for the existence of (R1) an Ulrich bundle on (Y,H)(Y,H) — the question of Eisenbud, Schreyer and Weyman [ESW];

The tower of existence questions

Figure 3. The tower of existence questions.

(R2) an aCM bundle on (Y,H)(Y,H), equivalently a graded MCM module over RR — the question Eisenbud and Schreyer asked after [1];

(R3) a small Cohen–Macaulay module over R^\widehat{R} — Hochster’s conjecture [17, 18, 20].

Existence propagates downwards: (R1)⇒\Rightarrow(R2)⇒\Rightarrow(R3) (Lemma 2.5). Non-existence propagates upwards, so each step of the story excludes a further level ([24] extends the first level to higher dimension).

All obstructions compare the degree and the signature,

d=H2,σ=σ(Y)=KY2−8χ(OY)=13(KY2−2c2(Y)).d = H^2,\qquad\sigma= \sigma(Y) = K_Y^2 - 8\chi(\mathcal{O}_Y) = \frac{1}{3}(K_Y^2 - 2c_2(Y)).

Table 1 compares the numerical criteria, including Chen’s proposed one.

object excludednumerical criterionhypotheses on HH
[1]Ulrich bundlesH2<σH^2 < \sigmaHH very ample
[24]Ulrich bundles, dim X=mX=m(m+1)Hm<(K2−2c2)⋅Hm−2(m+1)H^m < (K^2-2c_2)\cdot H^{m-2}HH very ample
[2]aCM bundles / graded MCMH2<σH^2 < \sigmaHH ample, bpf
[9]MCM over R^\widehat{R} (proposed)H2<σH^2 < \sigmaHH ample, bpf, K≡4HK\equiv4H
[26]MCM over R^\widehat{R}2H2<σ2H^2 < \sigmaHH ample, bpf
Thm. 10.3MCM over R^\widehat{R}, dim X=mX=m(m+4)Hm<(K2−2c2)⋅Hm−2(m+4)H^m < (K^2-2c_2)\cdot H^{m-2}HH ample, bpf

Table 1. The five results, and the extension of [26] proved in Section 10 (bpf = base-point-free).

Both local arguments take their examples from the complete-quadrangle family (Yn,3An−En)(Y_n,3A_n-E_n) (§ 4): Hirzebruch’s surfaces with the polarization 3An−En3A_n-E_n of [1 §7.2], whose degree lies below the signature for n≥6n\geq6. [26] takes the construction from [1 §7.2] and uses the prime n=7n=7, and [9] takes n=6n=6 from [2 Rem. 4.2, Cor. 4.3], where its section ring is shown to be quasi-Gorenstein. For both values of nn, [2] had already shown that the section ring has no graded MCM module. The Hesse pairs, the main examples of [1], are used by neither local argument; see Corollary 9.3.

What this survey adds. Besides a unified exposition, the survey makes two observations explicit and proves one extension.

(a) Through a finite map f:Y→P2f:Y\to\mathbb{P}^2 with f∗O(1)=O(H)f^*\mathcal{O}(1)=\mathcal{O}(H), the three obstructions are one computation: a variance of the push-forward, decomposed along a filtration with semistable factors (Proposition 9.1). This identity keeps all terms in [26 (10), (11)] and contains [2 Prop. 2.6]. What changes from level to level is what we know about the push-forward: trivial, split, or the restriction to an exceptional plane of a sheaf that is trivial off it. For surfaces this explains the factor 2 between σ≤d\sigma\leq d (graded) and σ≤2d\sigma\leq2d (local, [26]); Chen’s argument fits the same computation, with a stronger lower bound for the variance (Remark 9.2).

(b) By [26 Thm. 1.2] (proved in § 10), the completed section rings of the Hesse pairs (Yn,4An−En)(Y_n,4A_n-E_n), n≥3n \ge3, of the dual Hesse pairs (Yn,6An−En)(Y_n,6A_n-E_n), n≥6n \ge6, and of the complete-quadrangle pairs (Yn,3An−En)(Y_n,3A_n-E_n), n≥7n \ge7, have no small CM module (Corollary 9.3); this includes the ball quotient Y3Y_3 of [1].

(c) We generalize the argument of [26] to every dimension m≥2m \ge2 (Theorem 10.3, with complete proof): for XX smooth projective of dimension mm and HH ample and globally generated, a small CM module over R^(X,H)\widehat{R}(X,H) forces (KX2−2c2(X))⋅Hm−2≤(m+4)Hm(K_X^2-2c_2(X))\cdot H^{m-2} \le(m+4)H^m, compared with the bound (m+1)Hm(m+1)H^m for Ulrich and aCM bundles. With X=Yn×Pm−2X=Y_n \times\mathbb{P}^{m-2}, the products used in [2 Cor. 5.3] for the graded statement, this gives complete normal local domains with an isolated singularity, of every dimension ≥3\ge3, without small CM modules (Corollaries 10.9 and 10.10). Adjoining power series variables, the local analogue of a remark in [2 §5], gives such domains with non-isolated singularities (Corollary 10.2). In characteristic pp the completed section rings of smooth varieties always have small CM modules, by Hartshorne–Hochster–Peskine–Szpiro and Shimomoto–Tavanfar, so the characteristic hypothesis in these results is essential even locally (Remark 10.11).

Organization. Sections 2–8 recall definitions and statements, with at most brief indications of proof: the three questions and the tower (§ 2), the Ulrich obstruction (§ 3), the examples (§ 4), the aCM obstruction (§ 5), the local setting (§ 6) and the two local arguments (§ 7 and § 8). Sections 9 and 10 contain the new material, with complete proofs: a single variance identity on P2\mathbb{P}^2 from which the three obstructions are read off (§ 9), and the extension of the local obstruction to every dimension (§ 10). Section 11 records provenance and status, and Section 12 open questions.

Conventions. We work over C\mathbb{C}. Surfaces are smooth, connected and projective. For a coherent sheaf F\mathcal{F} and a divisor HH, F(t)=F⊗O(tH)\mathcal{F}(t)=\mathcal{F}\otimes\mathcal{O}(tH). For a torsion-free sheaf G\mathcal{G} of rank ρ\rho on a polarized surface (Y,H)(Y,H) we use the slope μH(G)=c1(G)⋅H/ρ\mu_H(\mathcal{G})=c_1(\mathcal{G})\cdot H/\rho and the normalized slope μ(G)=μH(G)/H2\mu(\mathcal{G})=\mu_H(\mathcal{G})/H^2; the discriminant is Δ(G)=2ρc2−(ρ−1)c12\Delta(\mathcal{G})=2\rho c_2-(\rho-1)c_1^2. Bogomolov’s inequality says Δ≥0\Delta\ge0 for μH\mu_H-semistable torsion-free sheaves [16 Thm. 3.4.1].

Three existence questions

This section states the three questions Q1–Q3 behind the levels (R1)–(R3) of the tower (Figure 3) and the implications between them.

Ulrich bundles

Let X⊂PNX \subset\mathbb{P}^N be a smooth projective variety of dimension mm and H=OX(1)H=\mathcal{O}_X(1).

Definition 2.1. A vector bundle E\mathcal{E} on XX is Ulrich if Hi(X,E(−p))=0H^i(X,\mathcal{E}(-p))=0 for all ii and all 1≤p≤m1 \le p \le m.

Proposition 2.2 ([ESW, Prop. 2.1, Cor. 2.2]). For a vector bundle E\mathcal{E} on XX the following are equivalent:

(i) E\mathcal{E} is Ulrich;

(ii) for some (equivalently, every) finite linear projection π:X→Pm\pi:X \to\mathbb{P}^m, the sheaf π∗E\pi_*\mathcal{E} is trivial, π∗E≅OPm⊕deg⁡X\pi_*\mathcal{E} \cong\mathcal{O}_{\mathbb{P}^m}^{\oplus\deg X};

(iii) the module Γ∗(E)=⨁tH0(X,E(t))\Gamma_*(\mathcal{E})=\bigoplus_t H^0(X,\mathcal{E}(t)) is Cohen–Macaulay of dimension m+1m+1 and has a linear minimal free resolution over S=C[x0,…,xN]S=\mathbb{C}[x_0,\ldots,x_N], generated in degree 0.

On a surface, E\mathcal{E} is Ulrich if and only if it is aCM (Definition 2.3) and χ(E(t))=12rk⁡E⋅H2(t+1)(t+2)\chi(\mathcal{E}(t))=\frac{1}{2}\operatorname{rk}\mathcal{E}\cdot H^2(t+1)(t+2).

Question Q1 (Eisenbud–Schreyer–Weyman, 2003 [ESW, p. 543]). Does every embedded projective variety X⊂PNX \subset\mathbb{P}^N carry an Ulrich sheaf?

As in [1 §1], following the restatement of Hanselka and Kummer [15 Problem 4.3], the sheaf is required to have support XX; on smooth surfaces such sheaves are locally free [1 Lemma 9.1]. Since (X,ℓH)(X,\ell H) carries Ulrich bundles of rank two for ℓ≫0\ell\gg0, for every smooth surface XX and ample HH [CoHu, Thm. 1.2], Question Q1 concerns a fixed embedding. Following [4], uc⁡(X,H)\operatorname{uc}(X,H) denotes the smallest rank of an Ulrich bundle, and uc⁡=∞\operatorname{uc}=\infty if there is none.

aCM bundles and graded MCM modules

Let YY be a smooth surface and HH a divisor such that ∣H∣|H| is base-point-free and φH\varphi_H is finite; equivalently, HH is ample and globally generated.

Definition 2.3. A vector bundle E\mathcal{E} on YY is arithmetically Cohen–Macaulay (aCM) with respect to HH if H1(Y,E(t))=0H^1(Y,\mathcal{E}(t))=0 for every t∈Zt\in\mathbb{Z}.

Let R=R(Y,H)=⨁t≥0H0(Y,OY(tH))R=R(Y,H)=\bigoplus_{t\geq0}H^0(Y,\mathcal{O}_Y(tH)) and m=R+\mathfrak{m}=R_+. By [2 Lemma 1.2], RR is a finitely generated normal graded C\mathbb{C}-domain of dimension 3 with Proj⁡R=Y\operatorname{Proj}R=Y, and its punctured spectrum is smooth.

Lemma 2.4 ([2 Lemma 3.2]). The assignments M↦M~M\mapsto\widetilde{M} and E↦Γ∗(E)=⨁t∈ZH0(Y,E(t))\mathcal{E}\mapsto\Gamma_*(\mathcal{E})=\bigoplus_{t\in\mathbb{Z}}H^0(Y,\mathcal{E}(t)) are mutually inverse bijections between graded MCM RR-modules and aCM bundles of positive rank on (Y,H)(Y,H).

Question Q2 (Eisenbud–Schreyer, after [1]; see [2 Acknowledgements]). Do the polarized surfaces (Y,H)(Y,H) constructed in [1] carry an aCM bundle; equivalently (Lemma 2.4), do their section rings have a graded MCM module?

They also asked for the Boij–Söderberg cone of cohomology tables of aCM bundles on these surfaces. For H2<σ(Y)H^2<\sigma(Y), the cone spanned by the cohomology tables of vector bundles on (Y,H)(Y,H) meets the tables with vanishing h1h^1-row only in 0 [2 Rem. 6.2]; see item 4 of § 12.

Small Cohen–Macaulay modules

Let (R,m)(R,\mathfrak{m}) be a Noetherian local ring. A finitely generated RR-module M≠0M\ne0 with depth⁡RM=dim⁡R\operatorname{depth}_R M=\dim R is called a small (or maximal) Cohen–Macaulay module.

Question Q3 (Hochster, 1973 [17, 18]). Does every complete Noetherian local domain have a small Cohen–Macaulay module?

Hochster’s small Cohen–Macaulay conjecture predicts a positive answer. It holds in dimension ≤2\leq2. In dimension three and characteristic p>0p>0, every finitely generated N\mathbb{N}-graded domain RR with R0R_0 a perfect field has a graded MCM module (Hartshorne, Hochster, Peskine–Szpiro [19, 28]), and the conjecture is known for further classes, such as three-dimensional complete weakly FF-split rings [29]. In any characteristic there are existence criteria in terms of deficiency modules [32 Thm. 3.2], [Xie1, Xie2]. In characteristic zero the conjecture was open from dimension three on, even for localizations of affine domains at maximal ideals [6 §1.3]. The main motivation is Serre’s positivity of intersection multiplicities [18].

The tower

References

  1. [1]C. Anghel, Smooth counterexamples to the Eisenbud–Schreyer–Weyman Ulrich existence problem, arXiv:2609.02718v1 (2 September 2026).arxiv.org/abs/2609.02718
  2. [2]C. Anghel, Polarized varieties without arithmetically Cohen–Macaulay bundles and section rings without graded maximal Cohen–Macaulay modules in characteristic zero, arXiv:2609.15589v1 (14 September 2026).arxiv.org/abs/2609.15589
  3. [3]A. Beauville, Ulrich bundles: to be or not to be, lecture slides, Beijing, October 2017, https://math.univ-cotedazur.fr/u/beauvill/conf/Ulrich.pdf.
  4. [4]M. Bläser, D. Eisenbud, F.-O. Schreyer, Ulrich complexity, Differential Geom. Appl. 55 (2017), 128–145.
  5. [6]B. Bhatt, M. Hochster, L. Ma, Lim Cohen–Macaulay sequences of modules, J. Reine Angew. Math. 835 (2026), 111–169.arxiv.org/abs/2410.18372
  6. [7]W. Bruns, J. Herzog, Cohen–Macaulay rings, revised ed., Cambridge Stud. Adv. Math. 39, Cambridge Univ. Press, 1998.
  7. [8]M. Casanellas, R. Hartshorne, Stable Ulrich bundles, with an appendix by F. Geiß and F.-O. Schreyer, Internat. J. Math. 23 (2012), 1250083.
  8. [9]L. Chen, A local cohomology obstruction to small Cohen–Macaulay modules, arXiv:2609.24142v1 (21 September 2026).
  9. [11]D. Eisenbud, F.-O. Schreyer, Betti numbers of graded modules and cohomology of vector bundles, J. Amer. Math. Soc. 22 (2009), 859–888.
  10. [13]R. Hartshorne, Algebraic geometry, Grad. Texts in Math. 52, Springer, 1977.
  11. [14]F. Hirzebruch, Arrangements of lines and algebraic surfaces, in: Arithmetic and Geometry, Vol. II, Progr. Math. 36, Birkhäuser, 1983, 113–140.
  12. [15]C. Hanselka, M. Kummer, Positive Ulrich sheaves, Canad. J. Math. 76 (2024), 881–914.DOI
  13. [16]D. Huybrechts, M. Lehn, The geometry of moduli spaces of sheaves, 2nd ed., Cambridge Univ. Press, 2010.
  14. [17]M. Hochster, Cohen–Macaulay modules, in: Conference on Commutative Algebra (Lawrence, Kansas, 1972), Lecture Notes in Math. 311, Springer, 1973, 120–152.DOI
  15. [18]M. Hochster, Topics in the homological theory of modules over commutative rings, CBMS Regional Conf. Ser. Math. 24, AMS, 1975.DOI
  16. [19]M. Hochster, Current state of the homological conjectures, notes of a VIGRE minicourse, University of Utah, June 2004 (dated 28 July 2004), https://www.math.utah.edu/vigre/minicourses/algebra/hochster.pdf.
  17. [20]M. Hochster, Homological conjectures and lim Cohen–Macaulay sequences, in: Homological and Computational Methods in Commutative Algebra, Springer INdAM Ser. 20, Springer, Cham, 2017, 173–197.
  18. [21]G. Horrocks, Vector bundles on the punctured spectrum of a local ring, Proc. London Math. Soc. (3) 14 (1964), 689–713.
  19. [22]J. Karamata, Sur une inégalité relative aux fonctions convexes, Publ. Math. Univ. Belgrade 1 (1932), 145–148.
  20. [23]A. Langer, Semistable sheaves in positive characteristic, Ann. of Math. (2) 159 (2004), 251–276.DOI
  21. [24]A. F. Lopez, On the existence of smooth varieties of any dimension carrying no Ulrich bundles for some very ample line bundle, arXiv:2609.06678v3 (10 September 2026).
  22. [25]H. Matsumura, Commutative ring theory, Cambridge Stud. Adv. Math. 8, Cambridge Univ. Press, 1986.DOI
  23. [26]OpenAI, A complete local domain without a small Cohen–Macaulay module, manuscript dated 23 September 2026, family 195 of [OAI-repo], https://github.com/openai/math/blob/1581d4c/preprints/A-Complete-Local-Domain-Without-a-Small-Cohen-Macaulay-Module-September-23-2026/paper.pdf.hub.valency.io/works/W_6ntgw49r
  24. [27]OpenAI, openai/math repository, release of 6 October 2026, https://github.com/openai/math; cited at commit 1581d4c (12 October 2026).
  25. [28]C. Peskine, L. Szpiro, Dimension projective finie et cohomologie locale, Publ. Math. IHÉS 42 (1973), 47–119.DOI
  26. [29]H. Schoutens, Hochster’s small MCM conjecture for three-dimensional weakly F-split rings, Comm. Algebra 45 (2017), 262–274.arxiv.org/abs/1408.6212
  27. [30]F.-O. Schreyer, D. Eisenbud, Betti numbers of syzygies and cohomology of coherent sheaves, in: Proceedings of the International Congress of Mathematicians (Hyderabad, 2010), Vol. II, Hindustan Book Agency, New Delhi, 2011, 586–602.arxiv.org/abs/1102.3559
  28. [32]K. Shimomoto, E. Tavanfar, Remarks on the small Cohen–Macaulay conjecture and new instances of maximal Cohen–Macaulay modules, J. Algebra 634 (2023), 667–697.

Paper details

vlnc:W_v25z84qd
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 0

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Mathematics

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents