betaFeedback

WorksPhysics and Astronomy

Nonlinear bubble behaviours of compressible Rayleigh-Taylor instability with isothermal stratification in cylindrical geometry

Abstract

Nonlinear evolutions of two-dimensional single-mode compressible Rayleigh–Taylor instability (RTI) with isothermal stratification are investigated in cylindrical geometry via direct numerical simulation for different Atwood numbers (AT=0.1−0.9A_T=0.1-0.9) and Mach numbers (Ma=0.1−0.9Ma=0.1-0.9). It is found that the nonlinear bubble growth involves the effects of density stratification, vorticity accumulation and flow compressibility and shows considerable differences between convergent (acceleration acting radially inward) and divergent (acceleration acting radially outward) cases. Specifically, the density stratification leads to non-acceleration at low ATA_T and high MaMa. The accelerations in convergent cases are dominated by vorticity accumulation at low ATA_T and low MaMa and by flow compressibility at high ATA_T and high MaMa whereas the accelerations in divergent cases are purely induced by flow compressibility at high ATA_T and high MaMa. Based on the nonlinear theory of incompressible cylindrical RTI with uniform-density background~(Zhao et al., J. Fluid Mech., vol. 900, 2020, A24), an improved model is proposed by taking the density variation, vorticity accumulation and flow compressibility into consideration. This model is verified by numerical results and well reproduces the bubble evolution for different ATA_T and MaMa from linear to highly nonlinear regimes.

Introduction

Rayleigh–Taylor (RT) instability arises at a perturbed interface between two fluids with different densities when the heavy fluid is accelerated by the light fluid in the presence of an external acceleration [25, 29]. With the development of RT instability (RTI), the light fluid rising into the heavy one and the heavy fluid sinking into the light one result in the formation of bubble-like and spike-like finger structures [39 b], respectively. These structures are of both fundamental interest and practical importance in many phenomena and applications, including geological flows [15], oceanic flows [21], astrophysical flows [3, 16], premixed combustion [7, 14, 28], nuclear fusion [19] and explosive detonation [1]. Many of these systems often intimately involve background stratification due to the presence of an acceleration field [21], which results in particularly significant flow compressibility induced by the variation of the fluid density. Thus, stratified compressible RTI development has attracted widespread attention through theoretical and numerical studies over the past decades.

Great advancement has emerged on the stratified RTI development in planar geometry from linear to nonlinear saturation and highly nonlinear regimes. Specifically, Livescu [20] performed a linear stability analysis of compressible RTI in the linear regime and concluded that the density stratification has a stabilizing effect on early instability growth by reducing the average local Atwood number (ATA_T), a parameter characterising the density ratio. In the nonlinear saturation regime [26, 24] (Fu et al. 2022), density stratification at small (large) ATA_T makes bubble velocity lower (higher) than the saturation value obtained from the corresponding incompressible uniform-density counterpart [18, 12]. This is attributed to the fact that the effect of density stratification plays a dominantly stabilizing role at small ATA_T while flow compressibility becomes dominating and acts as a destabilizing role at high ATA_T due to the compression of heavy fluid exerted by the rising bubble [24] (Fu et al. 2022). As for the highly nonlinear bubble behaviours after nonlinear saturation regime, the bubble is re-accelerated to a velocity well above the saturation value due to vorticity accumulation inside the bubble in incompressible and weakly compressible RTI with sufficiently high Reynolds numbers [5, 6]. And the Betti–Sanz model [5] by introducing a vorticity term to the saturation velocity model can successfully describe the bubble re-acceleration (RA) behaviours. Recently, Fu et al. (2023) examined the bubble RA behaviours of stratified RTI with various ATA_T and Mach numbers (MaMa), a parameter characterising the stratification strength, and found that flow compressibility would dominate the bubble RA behaviours at high ATA_T and high MaMa. An improved model was proposed by introducing an additional term characterising the flow compressibility to the Betti–Sanz model [5] and well captured the bubble RA dynamics of stratified RTI. Furthermore, the density stratification weakens the conversion from potential energy to kinetic energy while flow compressibility is critical to convert the internal energy into the kinetic energy in compressible RT turbulence [36, 22, 23] (Zhao et al. 2022).

Compared with planar RTI, the RTI in a convergent geometry is of more particular relevance to supernova explosions [13] and inertial confinement fusion (ICF) [17, 4], and thus is of more practical interest. Cylindrical geometry which involves principal effects of convergent geometries has been widely used as a natural choice to study the convergent effects on hydrodynamic instability evolution [2, 27, 31, 30, 37, 38, 34] (Wu et al. 2021; Ge et al. 2022). In the incompressible limit, cylindrical RTI increases exponentially with a growth rate Γ=AT∣g∣n/r0\Gamma= \sqrt{A_T |g| n/r_0} for both convergent (acceleration acting radially inward g<0g < 0) and divergent (acceleration acting radially outward g>0g > 0) cases in the linear regime (Wang et al. 2013), where nn is the number of cosinoidal perturbation waves and r0r_0 is the radius of the unperturbed interface. To further elucidate the bubble evolution of convergent and divergent cases, Zhao et al. [37] employed a nonlinear theory based on potential flow assumption and presented an analytical model covering bubble evolution at arbitrary ATA_T from linear to nonlinear regimes. It is revealed from this nonlinear theory that the bubble velocity in a convergent (divergent) case undergoes a uniform acceleration (deceleration) in the nonlinear regime instead of keeping an asymptotic value like planar cases. In such instances, both theoretical analysis and simulation [30, 37] have been considered near the incompressible limit with negligible background stratification while stratified RTI has received much less attention in cylindrical geometry. It is found from the work of Yu & Livescu (2008) that density stratification also plays a stabilizing role in cylindrical RTI growth in the linear regime, similar to the results of planar cases [20]. However, nonlinear and highly nonlinear bubble behaviors of stratified cylindrical RTI have not been systematically investigated yet.

Motivated by the aforementioned findings, nonlinear and highly nonlinear evolutions of stratified compressible RTI in cylindrical geometry are worthy of further investigation. This paper focuses on the cylindrical RTI growth characteristics of convergent and divergent cases, with special interest directed to answer the following questions. What will the bubble dynamics of compressible cylindrical RTI like and how will flow compressibility and vorticity accumulation set in the highly nonlinear regime? Towards this goal, direct numerical simulation (DNS) of two-dimensional single-mode stratified compressible RTI is performed in cylindrical geometry over a range of ATA_T and MaMa. The remainder of this paper is organized as follows. The numerical strategy used to simulate the instability evolution is briefly described in § 2. The general features of bubble behaviors are discussed and an improved model is proposed to characterise the bubble growth in § 3. Finally, conclusions and recommendations for future work are addressed in § 4.

Numerical simulations

Governing equations

Direct numerical simulation has been performed on stratified compressible RTI in cylindrical geometry to study the bubble behaviours. According to previous studies [37, 38], the radius of the unperturbed interface r0∗r_0^*, the pressure pI∗p_I^* and density ρI∗\rho_I^* at the initial interface are chosen as the characteristic scales. Here, the characteristic velocity and temperature are described, respectively, as uI∗=pI∗/ρI∗u_I^*=\sqrt{p_I^*/\rho_I^*} and TI∗=pI∗MI∗/(R∗ρI∗)T_I^*=p_I^*M_I^*/(R^*\rho_I^*), where R∗R^* is the universal gas constant and the molar mass is MI∗=(Mh∗+Ml∗)/2M_I^*=(M_h^*+M_l^*)/2 with Mh∗M_h^* and Ml∗M_l^* representing the molar masses of heavy and light fluids, respectively. Hereafter, the superscript ‘∗*’ denotes dimensional physical quantities and the subscript ‘II’ corresponds to the quantities at the initial interface. Thus, the non-dimensionalized governing equations in cylindrical coordinates (r,ϕ)(r,\phi) are

∂ρ∂t+∇⋅(ρu)=0,(1)\frac{\partial\rho}{\partial t}+\nabla\cdot(\rho\boldsymbol{u})=0, \tag*{(1)}
∂(ρu)∂t+∇⋅(ρuu)=−∇p+1Re∇⋅τ+ρFrer,(2)\frac{\partial(\rho\boldsymbol{u})}{\partial t}+\nabla\cdot(\rho\boldsymbol{u}\boldsymbol{u})=-\nabla p+\frac{1}{Re}\nabla\cdot\boldsymbol{\tau}+\frac{\rho}{Fr}\boldsymbol{e}_r, \tag*{(2)}
∂(ρE)∂t+∇⋅[(ρE+p)u]=1Re∇⋅(τ⋅u)−1RePr∇⋅qc−1ReSc∇⋅qd+ρFru⋅er.(3)\frac{\partial(\rho E)}{\partial t}+\nabla\cdot[(\rho E+p)\boldsymbol{u}]=\frac{1}{Re}\nabla\cdot(\boldsymbol{\tau}\cdot\boldsymbol{u})-\frac{1}{RePr}\nabla\cdot\boldsymbol{q}_c-\frac{1}{ReSc}\nabla\cdot\boldsymbol{q}_d+\frac{\rho}{Fr}\boldsymbol{u}\cdot\boldsymbol{e}_r. \tag*{(3)}
∂(ρYh)∂t+∇⋅(ρYhu)=−1ReSc∇⋅Jh(4)\frac{\partial(\rho Y_h)}{\partial t}+\nabla\cdot(\rho Y_h\boldsymbol{u})=-\frac{1}{ReSc}\nabla\cdot\boldsymbol{J}_h \tag*{(4)}

where ρ\rho is the fluid density; u=(ur,uϕ)\boldsymbol{u}=(u_r,u_\phi) denotes the velocity vector; pp is the pressure; er\boldsymbol{e}_r is the unit vector in the radial direction; E=CvT+u⋅u/2E=C_vT+\boldsymbol{u}\cdot\boldsymbol{u}/2 denotes the specific total energy with CvC_v being the specific heat at constant volume and TT the temperature; Yh=ρh/ρY_h=\rho_h/\rho is the species mass fraction of heavy fluid and Yl=1−YhY_l=1-Y_h is the species mass fraction of light fluid; and the symbol ∇\nabla denotes the vector-differentiation operator. The stress tensor is obtained as τ=2μS−2μ/3(∇⋅u)δ\boldsymbol{\tau}=2\mu\boldsymbol{S}-2\mu/3(\nabla\cdot\boldsymbol{u})\boldsymbol{\delta}, where the dynamic viscosity μ=T3/2(1+c)/(T+c)\mu=T^{3/2}(1+c)/(T+c) is computed by the Sutherland law with c=Ts∗/Tr∗c=T_s^*/T_r^* where the constant temperature Ts∗=124T_s^*=124 K and the reference temperature Tr∗=273.15T_r^*=273.15 K, S=(∇u+(∇u)T)/2\boldsymbol{S}=(\nabla\boldsymbol{u}+(\nabla\boldsymbol{u})^{T})/2 is the strain-rate tensor and δ\boldsymbol{\delta} represents the unit tensor. The heat fluxes due to heat conduction (qc\boldsymbol{q}_c) and interspecies enthalpy diffusion (qd\boldsymbol{q}_d) are given by qc=−γ/[MI(γ−1)]κ∇T\boldsymbol{q}_c=-\gamma/[M_I(\gamma-1)]\kappa\nabla T and qd=∑hiJi\boldsymbol{q}_d=\sum h_i\boldsymbol{J}_i (i=h,li=h,l), respectively, where γ\gamma is the ratio of specific heats, MIM_I is the molar mass at the initial interface, κ\kappa is the heat conduction coefficient, hih_i is the enthalpy, Ji=−ρD∇Yi\boldsymbol{J}_i=-\rho D\nabla Y_i is the diffusive mass flux obtained by the Fick law and DD is the diffusion coefficient. The above governing equations are closed with the non-dimensionalized ideal gas equation of state, i.e. p=ρT/Mp=\rho T/M, where MM is the molar mass.

Following recent work Ge et al. (2022), the density and pressure of the mixture are obtained by the summation of each species, while the temperature is equal for each species of the mixture. Therefore, the molecular mass of the mixture is given by M=(∑Yi/Mi)−1M=(\sum Y_i/M_i)^{-1}, where MiM_i is the molecular mass of the iith species. The quantities describing the physical properties of the mixture, such as the dynamic viscosity μ\mu, the diffusion coefficient DD, the heat conduction coefficient κ\kappa, the specific heat at constant pressure CpC_p and the specific heat at constant volume CvC_v, are calculated by the linear combinations of each species weighted with their mass fractions Reckinger et al. [26].

The non-dimensional parameters in (1)–(4) are the Reynolds, Prandtl, Schmidt and Froude numbers defined, respectively, as

Re=ρI∗uI∗r0∗μI∗,Pr=Cp,I∗μI∗κI∗,Sc=μI∗ρI∗DI∗,Fr=pI∗/ρI∗r0∗g∗(5)Re=\frac{\rho_I^*u_I^*r_0^*}{\mu_I^*},\qquad Pr=\frac{C_{p,I}^*\mu_I^*}{\kappa_I^*},\qquad Sc=\frac{\mu_I^*}{\rho_I^*D_I^*},\qquad Fr=\frac{p_I^*/\rho_I^*}{r_0^*g^*} \tag*{(5)}

where g∗g^* is the radially external acceleration with g∗<0g^*<0 for convergent cases and g∗>0g^*>0 for divergent cases.

Problem set-up and numerical method

In the present study, the shape function of a cosinoidally perturbed interface takes form as ζ(ϕ)=r0+η0cos⁡(nϕ)\zeta(\phi)=r_0+\eta_0\cos(n\phi). Here, η0\eta_0 represents the initial amplitude and nn denotes the number of perturbation waves. Then, the Mach number based on the initial perturbation wavelength λ0∗=2πr0∗/n\lambda_0^*=2\pi r_0^*/n is defined as Ma=∣g∗∣λ0∗/(pI∗/ρI∗)Ma=\sqrt{|g^*|\lambda_0^*/(p_I^*/\rho_I^*)} to illustrate the strength of background stratification, following previous studies Reckinger et al. [26]; Fu et al. (2023). Initially, this compressible RT system keeps hydrostatic equilibrium (u=0\boldsymbol{u}=0). By integrating the momentum equation (2) with ideal gas equation of state and isothermal assumption (T=1T=1) Livescu [20]; Reckinger et al. [26]; Fu et al. (2023), the initial density and pressure fields are yielded as

ρh,l=(1±AT)exp⁡[sgn⁡(g∗)Ma2(1±AT)r−ζ(ϕ)2π/n](6)\rho_{h,l}=(1\pm A_T)\exp\left[\operatorname{sgn}(g^*)Ma^2(1\pm A_T)\frac{r-\zeta(\phi)}{2\pi/n}\right] \tag*{(6)}
ph,l=exp⁡[sgn⁡(g∗)Ma2(1±AT)r−ζ(ϕ)2π/n](7)p_{h,l}=\exp\left[\operatorname{sgn}(g^*)Ma^2(1\pm A_T)\frac{r-\zeta(\phi)}{2\pi/n}\right] \tag*{(7)}

where AT=(Mh∗−Ml∗)/(Mh∗+Ml∗)A_T = (M_h^* - M_l^*)/(M_h^* + M_l^*) is the Atwood number and sgn⁡(g∗)\operatorname{sgn}(g^*) is the sign function, namely if g∗>0g^* > 0, sgn⁡(g∗)=1\operatorname{sgn}(g^*) = 1, and if g∗<0g^* < 0, sgn⁡(g∗)=−1\operatorname{sgn}(g^*) = -1. To smooth the interface density jump, the error function is introduced [26, 6] (Fu et al. 2023).

A wide range of Mach numbers (Ma=0.1−0.9Ma = 0.1 - 0.9) and Atwood numbers (AT=0.1−0.9A_T = 0.1 - 0.9) is considered to examine the RTI development with various stratification strengths and density ratios. The number of perturbation waves is chosen as n=8n = 8 according to Zhao et al. [37] and the initial amplitude is set as η0=0.02λ0\eta_0 = 0.02\lambda_0 to satisfy the small-perturbation assumption (Fu et al. 2023). To make the bubble acceleration behavior in highly nonlinear regime clearly evident as pointed by Bian et al. [6], a sufficiently high perturbation Reynolds number (Rep=ρ0∗λ0∗AT/(1+AT)∣g∗∣λ0∗/μ0∗Re_p = \rho_0^*\lambda_0^* \sqrt{A_T/(1 + A_T)|g^*|\lambda_0^*}/\mu_0^*) is chosen as 10000. Notably, this Reynolds number is defined by the initial perturbation wavelength λ0∗\lambda_0^* and a characteristic velocity Vt=AT/(1+AT)∣g∗∣λ0∗V_t = \sqrt{A_T/(1 + A_T)|g^*|\lambda_0^*} proportional to the saturation velocity obtained from potential flow theory Goncharov [12]. Other parameters in governing equations (2.1)–(2.4) are fixed as Pr=0.72Pr = 0.72, Sc=1Sc = 1 and γ=1.4\gamma= 1.4. The bubble position and velocity are determined as the point of the bubble tip with the mole fraction of heavy fluid Xh=[(1−AT)Yh]/(1+AT−2ATYh)=0.5X_h = [(1 - A_T)Y_h]/(1 + A_T - 2A_TY_h) = 0.5 [22]. To compare nonlinear bubble evolution under different parameters, the bubble velocity and time in the following discussion are rescaled to ensure that the bubbles have the same scaled velocity when entering the nonlinear regime at the same scaled time [6] (Fu et al. 2023). The exponential growth rate of cylindrical RTI Γ=AT∣g∗∣n/r0∗\Gamma= \sqrt{A_T|g^*|n/r_0^*} is chosen to characterise the time following recent work Zhao et al. [37] and the characteristic velocity VtV_t in the definition of RepRe_p is used neutrally to rescale the bubble velocity, referring to the work of Bian et al. [6] and Fu et al. (2023).

In addition, all simulations are performed within a two-dimensional circular domain D={(r,ϕ)∣0.05≤r≤2.5,0≤ϕ<2π}D = \{(r,\phi)|0.05 \le r \le2.5, 0 \le\phi< 2\pi\}. The computational domain has been verified to have a negligible effect on cylindrical RTI evolution in previous simulations [37, 38]. It is noted that a micro-hole with a radius of 0.05 is dug out to avoid a pole singularity at the centre of cylindrical coordinates, following previous treatments [37, 34] (Wu et al. 2021). The free-slip (stress-free) conditions for velocities, a zero heat flux condition for temperature and a zero mass flux condition for mass fraction are applied to the interior and exterior boundaries [10, 6].

A numerical algorithm of high-order finite difference schemes is used to solve the governing equations (2.1)–(2.4) in cylindrical coordinates [37, 38, 34]. Specifically, the fifth-order weighted essentially non-oscillatory scheme is implemented to discretize the convective terms. The sixth-order central difference scheme is performed to discretize the viscous terms. The time derivative is approximated by the classical third-order Runge–Kutta method. At a sufficiently weak stratification strength (Ma=0.1Ma = 0.1), the flow can be considered to be nearly the incompressible limit [22] and the corresponding bubble growth consequently satisfies the nonlinear theory [37]. As shown in Figure 1(a), the time-varying positions of bubble tips of the simulation data at AT=0.9A_T = 0.9 and Ma=0.1Ma = 0.1 show good consistency with the nonlinear theory [37] from linear to nonlinear regimes, indicating the reliability of the present numerical settings. Furthermore, grid convergence should be examined in order to accurately capture the bubble growth. Since the flow compressibility are the strongest at AT=0.9A_T = 0.9 and Ma=0.9Ma = 0.9, we here show the numerical results with different grid resolutions at AT=0.9A_T = 0.9 and Ma=0.9Ma = 0.9, the most demanding in grid resolution. Figure 1(b) shows that the data at three grid resolutions almost collapse together and thus the present simulations are reliable for capturing the essential flow dynamics in cylindrical RTI evolution. To obtain fine flow field characteristics, the following discussion and analysis are obtained on the finest grid (102421024^2).

Figure 1. Time-varying positions of bubble tips rbr_b for convergent (rb>1r_b > 1) and divergent (rb<1r_b < 1) cases at (a) AT=0.9A_T = 0.9 and Ma=0.1Ma = 0.1 with symbols representing the simulation data and at (b) AT=0.9A_T = 0.9 and Ma=0.9Ma = 0.9 with three grid resolutions: 2562256^2 (dashed lines), 5122512^2 (dot-dashed lines) and 102421024^2 (long-dashed lines). The solid lines denote the nonlinear theory (Zhao et al. [37]).

Results and discussions

Bubble nonlinear behaviors

To investigate the influence of MaMa and ATA_T, the time-varying bubble velocity VbV_b at different ATA_T for weak (Ma=0.1Ma = 0.1) and strong (Ma=0.9Ma = 0.9) stratification strengths is shown in Figure 2. Similar to the results of recent works (Bian et al. [6]; Fu et al. 2023), the simulations with a higher Atwood number (e.g. AT=0.9A_T = 0.9) end sooner due to the spike approaching the interior (g∗<0g^* < 0) or exterior (g∗>0g^* > 0) wall in less time. Bubble velocity VbV_b increases exponentially for all cases during the linear stage about Γt<2\Gamma t < 2 and then shows distinct growth trends for different parameters settings when evolving into the nonlinear regimes. More details and explanations will be given in the following.

Figure 2. Temporal bubble velocity VbV_b at different ATA_T of (a) Ma=0.1Ma=0.1 and of (b) Ma=0.9Ma=0.9. The solid and long-dashed lines in each panel represent the bubble velocities of convergent and divergent cases for n=8n=8, respectively. The horizontal black dot-dashed lines in each panel denote the saturation velocity obtained from potential flow theory Goncharov [12].

At Ma=0.1Ma = 0.1, VbV_b for different ATA_T reaches the saturation value obtained from potential flow theory (Goncharov [12]) at Γt≈4\Gamma t \approx4. After that, the bubble behaviors of convergent cases differ significantly from those of corresponding divergent cases. As for convergent cases, VbV_b first experiences a slightly uniform acceleration about Γt<6\Gamma t < 6 and then undergoes an obvious acceleration where VbV_b increases rapidly. Previous nonlinear theory (Zhao et al. [37]) correctly predicts the bubble behavior in the early nonlinear stage (Γt<6\Gamma t < 6) but fails in this highly nonlinear phase. Figure 3 illustrates vorticity contours (ω=∇×u\boldsymbol{\omega} = \nabla\times\mathbf{u}) for various cases into highly nonlinear stage and it can be clearly seen from Figure 3(a,Figure 3b) that the vorticity dominates the flow field inside the bubbles for convergent cases at Ma=0.1Ma = 0.1. At this point, both density stratification and flow compressibility are negligibly weak and thus vorticity accumulation inside the bubble is responsible for this acceleration behavior. The main destabilizing mechanism induced by vorticity accumulation inside the bubble is that the vortex pairs inside the bubble approach towards bubble tip, inducing an equivalently centrifugal force to aid bubble growth (Betti & Sanz [5]). Furthermore, increasing ATA_T from 0.1 to 0.9 reduces the maximum value of VbV_b, which is consistent with the results of planar RTI (Bian et al. [6]; Luo & Wang [22]; Fu et al. 2023). Increasing ATA_T makes sites of vortex generation around the sinking spike drift further away from the bubble tip, so that vortices at higher ATA_T travel for a longer distance and obtain an attenuated dissipation before entering the bubble tip region for a fixed RepRe_p [6]. Differently, VbV_b for divergent cases undergoes a long-time uniform deceleration after reaching the saturation value, as predicted by the nonlinear theory [37]. Figure 3(c, Figure 3d) shows that the vortex pairs generated from outward spikes are highly far away from inward bubble tips and thus cannot make bubble accelerate. Therefore, the acceleration induced by vorticity accumulation cannot be observed for divergent cases. These results indicate that the acceleration mechanism of vorticity accumulation is fundamentally different in convergent and divergent cases.

Vorticity contours for cases into highly nonlinear stage

Figure 3. Vorticity contours for the cases into highly nonlinear stage (Γt=6.5\Gamma t = 6.5) at different ATA_T with n=8n = 8 for (a−d)(a-d) Ma=0.1Ma = 0.1 and for (e−h)(e-h) Ma=0.9Ma = 0.9. The left column (a,c,e,g)(a, c, e, g) and right column (b,d,f,h)(b, d, f, h) denote convergent and divergent cases, respectively. The first and third rows (a,b,e,f)(a, b, e, f) represent cases at AT=0.1A_T = 0.1 and the second and last rows (c,d,g,h)(c, d, g, h) denote cases at AT=0.9A_T = 0.9. The black solid lines denote the interfaces at Xh=0.5X_h = 0.5. The colored dashed circular lines represent radial positions of bubble tips.

At Ma=0.9Ma=0.9, the bubble accelerates more obviously at higher ATA_T in highly nonlinear stage and varying ATA_T leads to different bubble development trends compared with those at Ma=0.1Ma=0.1. Specifically, decreasing ATA_T from 0.9 to 0.1 suppresses the bubble evolution and this interesting phenomenon also appears in planar stratified RTI [24] (Fu et al. 2022; Fu et al. 2023). There are two mechanisms of the stabilizing effect of density stratification and the destabilizing effect of flow compressibility. They compete with each other, giving rise to different manifestations at different ATA_T. Figure 4 shows density profiles along the radial lines across bubble tips for different parameters settings. At AT=0.1A_T=0.1, the density difference at the bubble tip suffers a decrease versus time for both convergent and divergent cases as shown in Figure 4(e, Figure 4f). As a result, the stabilizing effect of density stratification becomes dominant at low ATA_T, leading to that VbV_b starts to decay before reaching the saturated value. However, the density difference at the bubble tip reduces more slowly with the development of RTI at higher ATA_T. On the one hand, the initial density difference between two sides of the interface increases with the increase of ATA_T, thus weakening the initial density stratification. On the other hand, it is found from Figure 4(g, Figure 4h) that the decreasing trend of density difference is greatly suppressed since the density before the bubble front has a significant increase compared to its initial state under the compression of heavy fluid exerted by the rising bubble [24] (Fu et al. 2022). Consequently, the stabilizing effect of density stratification gradually weakens while the destabilizing effect of flow compressibility strengthens with the increasing ATA_T, resulting in that the effect of ATA_T on bubble behaviors at Ma=0.9Ma=0.9 is quite different from those at Ma=0.1Ma=0.1. Moreover, it is observed that there are profound differences between

Figure 4. Density profiles along the radial lines across bubble tips at different ATA_T with n=8n = 8 for (a−d)(a-d) Ma=0.1Ma = 0.1 and for (e−h)(e-h) Ma=0.9Ma = 0.9. The left column (a,c,e,g)(a,c,e,g) and right column (b,d,f,h)(b,d,f,h) denote convergent and divergent cases, respectively. The first and third rows (a,b,e,f)(a,b,e,f) represent cases at AT=0.1A_T = 0.1 and the second and last rows (c,d,g,h)(c,d,g,h) denote cases at AT=0.9A_T = 0.9. The circle/square marked on the density profile represents radial position of the bubble/spike tip at each moment (Γt=0,3,6.5\Gamma t = 0, 3, 6.5).

convergent and divergent cases for the bubble acceleration behaviors at Ma=0.9Ma = 0.9 where flow compressibility dominates the bubble acceleration behaviors. Specifically, VbV_b for convergent cases increases robustly while keeps the fluctuation growth for divergent cases, indicating that the acceleration mechanism of flow compressibility is also fundamentally different in convergent and divergent cases.

Analogous to previous studies [6] (Fu et al. 2023), the highly nonlinear bubble behaviors are divided into three phases in Figure 5: robust acceleration, transient acceleration and non-acceleration. In a robust acceleration phase, a bubble accelerates robustly at late time (e.g. convergent case with AT=0.1A_T = 0.1 and Ma=0.1Ma = 0.1). In a transient acceleration phase, a bubble accelerates transiently but then decelerates (e.g. divergent case with AT=0.9A_T = 0.9 and Ma=0.9Ma = 0.9). A non-acceleration phase denotes that bubble velocity starts to decay after reaching the asymptotic value [12] (e.g. divergent cases with Ma=0.1Ma = 0.1). Summarized in Figure 5, a robust acceleration occurs in most AT−MaA_T-Ma space in convergent cases except for a non-acceleration of low ATA_T and high MaMa cases, and a transient acceleration of high ATA_T and low MaMa cases. Differently, a non-acceleration occurs for low ATA_T or low MaMa and a transient acceleration appears at high ATA_T and high MaMa without any robust acceleration phase in divergent cases. These results also vary considerably from the highly nonlinear bubble behaviors of planar stratified RTI ((Fu et al. 2023)), which indicates that the traditional studies of late-time RTI performed in planar geometry cannot be robustly applied to the cylindrical or spherical counterparts.

Bubble acceleration phase diagram

Figure 5. Bubble acceleration phase diagram of AT−MaA_T-Ma of (a) convergent and of (b) divergent cases for n=8n=8 in highly nonlinear stage. Triangle, circle and square represent the phases of non-acceleration, transient acceleration and robust acceleration, respectively. Red and blue symbols indicate that the bubble acceleration mechanism is dominated by vorticity accumulation and flow compressibility, respectively.

Bubble growth model

Based on potential flow assumption, Zhao et al. [37] derived a nonlinear ordinary differential equation (ODE) covering bubble evolution of incompressible cylindrical RTI with uniform-density background at arbitrary ATA_T from linear to nonlinear regimes. The bubble amplitude η(t)=rb−r0\eta(t)=r_b-r_0 in convergent case satisfies the following evolution equation

−n2−4ATHn−12ATH22(6H−n)(r0+η)d[(r0+η)η˙]dt−ATHη˙2r0+η+(4AT−3)n2+6(3AT−5)Hn+36ATH2+12(AT−1)H2(6H−n)2(r0+η)n2η˙2=ATgH.(8)-\frac{n^2-4A_T Hn-12A_T H^2}{2(6H-n)(r_0+\eta)}\frac{\mathrm{d}[(r_0+\eta)\dot{\eta}]}{\mathrm{d}t}-\frac{A_T H\dot{\eta}^2}{r_0+\eta}+\frac{(4A_T-3)n^2+6(3A_T-5)Hn+36A_T H^2+12(A_T-1)H}{2(6H-n)^2(r_0+\eta)}n^2\dot{\eta}^2=A_T gH. \tag*{(8)}

Here, the parameter HH takes form as

H=[n26n+4−n2η02(r0+η0)](r0+η0r0+η)3n+2−n26n+4.(9)H=\left[\frac{n^2}{6n+4}-\frac{n^2\eta_0}{2(r_0+\eta_0)}\right]\left(\frac{r_0+\eta_0}{r_0+\eta}\right)^{3n+2}-\frac{n^2}{6n+4}. \tag*{(9)}

Similarly, the evolution equation for the bubble amplitude η(t)\eta(t) in divergent case is

−n2+4ATHn−12ATH22(6H+n)(r0+η)d[(r0+η)η˙]dt−ATHη˙2r0+η+(4AT−3)n2−6(3AT−5)Hn+36ATH2+12(AT−1)H2(6H+n)2(r0+η)n2η˙2=ATgH.(10)-\frac{n^2+4A_T Hn-12A_T H^2}{2(6H+n)(r_0+\eta)}\frac{\mathrm{d}[(r_0+\eta)\dot{\eta}]}{\mathrm{d}t}-\frac{A_T H\dot{\eta}^2}{r_0+\eta}+\frac{(4A_T-3)n^2-6(3A_T-5)Hn+36A_T H^2+12(A_T-1)H}{2(6H+n)^2(r_0+\eta)}n^2\dot{\eta}^2=A_T gH. \tag*{(10)}

Here, the parameter HH is expressed as

H=[−n26n−4−n2η02(r0+η0)](r0+ηr0+η0)3n−2+n26n−4.(11)H=\left[-\frac{n^2}{6n-4}-\frac{n^2\eta_0}{2(r_0+\eta_0)}\right]\left(\frac{r_0+\eta}{r_0+\eta_0}\right)^{3n-2}+\frac{n^2}{6n-4}. \tag*{(11)}

However, the effects of density variation, vorticity accumulation and flow compressibility are not taken into consideration and thus this nonlinear theory (8)–(11) cannot reasonably capture the nonlinear bubble behaviors of compressible cylindrical RTI. For example, this nonlinear theory (8)–(11) correctly predicts the bubble behavior in the early nonlinear stage but fails in highly nonlinear phase when the flow compressibility dominates the flow field near the bubble at AT=0.9AT = 0.9 and Ma=0.9Ma = 0.9 as shown in Figure 1(b). Here, we attempt to improve this nonlinear theory Zhao et al. [37] to quantitatively characterise the bubble growths of cylindrical RTI with isothermal stratification by considering effects of density variation, vorticity accumulation and flow compressibility.

In groundbreaking work, Betti & Sanz [5] took the effects of vorticity into account in planar ablative RTI and creatively modified the saturated velocity model Goncharov [12] by introducing a vorticity term. Bian et al. [6] further improved the highly nonlinear bubble growth model Betti & Sanz [5] by adding an efficiency factor η=0.45\eta= 0.45 to the vorticity term to account for the attenuation of vortices as they travel through the bubble tip region. The accumulated vorticity inside the bubble can additionally induce an equivalent bubble velocity of ηdrωˉ/(2k)\eta d_r\bar{\omega}/(2k) in the opposite direction of the external acceleration (gg), where ωˉ=∫Vρ∣ω∣ dV/∫Vρ dV\bar{\omega} = \int_V \rho|\omega|\,\mathrm{d}V/\int_V \rho\,\mathrm{d}V is the average vorticity in the volume (VV) inside the bubble between the bubble vertex and the distance 1/k1/k from the vertex into the bubble, and dr=ρl′/ρh′d_r = \rho'_l/\rho'_h is the density ratio at bubble tip with ρh′\rho'_h being the maximum density at the bubble vertex and ρl′\rho'_l being the average density in the volume (VV). Substituting temporally varied wavelength k=2π/λ=n/rbk = 2\pi/\lambda= n/r_b into ηdrωˉ/(2k)\eta d_r\bar{\omega}/(2k) can yield the equivalent velocity VvV_v induced by the vorticity accumulation in cylindrical RTI as

Vv=ηdrωˉ2n/rb.(12)V_v = \eta d_r\frac{\bar{\omega}}{2n/r_b}. \tag*{(12)}

The efficiency factor η=0.4\eta= 0.4 is used here to account for the attenuation of vortices in cylindrical geometry. Notably, drd_r can illustrate the density variation at bubble tip and thus a local Atwood number AT=(1−dr)/(1+dr)A_T = (1-d_r)/(1+d_r) is introduced to the nonlinear ODE (8)–(11). To this end, the equivalent velocity VpV_p caused by the potential flow can be determined by means of a numerical solution of the nonlinear ODE (8)–(11), i.e. Vp=η˙(t)V_p = \dot{\eta}(t).

By employing Green’s formula, Fu et al. (2023) recently established a relation between dilatation (θ=∇⋅u\theta= \nabla\cdot\boldsymbol{u}) and the velocity VcV_c contributed by flow compressibility in planar compressible RTI. The similar strategy is employed here and integrating θ\theta yields

∬Sθ dS=∮∂Suϕd dr−urdr dϕ.(13)\iint_S \theta\,\mathrm{d}S = \oint_{\partial S} u_\phi^d\,\mathrm{d}r - u_r^d r\,\mathrm{d}\phi. \tag*{(13)}

Here, (uϕd,urd)(u_\phi^d,u_r^d) is the dilatational (irrotational) component of fluid velocity and SS is the annulus region where the heavy fluid is compressed by the bubble, from the bubble tip rbr_b to its front position r∞r_\infty where the fluid keeps the hydrostatic equilibrium with the fluid velocity being zero. Naturally, interior or exterior boundary of computational domain with the fluid velocity being almost zero is used as r∞r_\infty for divergent or convergent cases, respectively. The left-hand side of (13) can be expressed by the spatial average dilatation θˉ\bar{\theta} in the region SS, i.e. π(r∞2−rb2)θˉ\pi(r_\infty^2-r_b^2)\bar{\theta}. Given that a rising bubble of light fluid acts like a piston uniformly compressing its front heavy fluid [24] (Fu et al. 2022; Fu et al. 2023), the compressing velocity urdu_r^d at the radial position rbr_b is almost uniform along the periodic ϕ\phi-direction and can be approximated as VcV_c (Fu et al. (2023)). Thus, the right-hand side of (13) can be approximately calculated as −2πrbVc-2\pi r_bV_c. Therefore, the equivalent velocity VcV_c contributed by flow compressibility is modelled as

Vc=−θˉ(r∞−rb)1+r∞/rb2.(14)V_c = -\bar{\theta}(r_\infty-r_b)\frac{1+r_\infty/r_b}{2}. \tag*{(14)}

Particularly, the factor (1+r∞/rb)/2(1+r_\infty/r_b)/2 in (14) characterises the effect of interfacial curvature on flow compressibility. When the interfacial curvature doesn’t matter, i.e. rb→r∞r_b \to r_\infty, the factor (1+r∞/rb)/2→1(1+r_\infty/r_b)/2 \to1 makes (14) recover the velocity contributed by flow compressibility in planar compressible RTI (Fu et al. (2023)).

The VpV_p based on the potential flow assumption and density variation at bubble tip excludes the effects of vorticity accumulation and flow compressibility. By adding (12) and (14) to VpV_p, the bubble velocity can be completed as the following model:

Vb=Vp+Vv+Vc.(15)V_b = V_p + V_v + V_c. \tag*{(15)}

To verify the above improved model, we employ DNS on compressible cylindrical RTI over a wide range of Atwood numbers (AT=0.1−0.9A_T=0.1-0.9) and Mach numbers (Ma=0.1−0.9Ma=0.1-0.9), especially in the nonlinear and highly nonlinear regimes. Figure 6 shows bubble velocities obtained from DNS results (symbols) and calculated by this improved model (lines) for convergent (top row) and divergent (bottom row) cases. It is identified that this improved model (15) well reproduces the bubble velocity development from linear to highly nonlinear regimes.

Bubble velocities for different Atwood and Mach numbers

Figure 6. Bubble velocities obtained from DNS results (symbols) and calculated by the present model (lines) for different ATA_T at (a,d)(a,d) Ma=0.1Ma=0.1, (b,e)(b,e) Ma=0.5Ma=0.5 and (c,f)(c,f) Ma=0.9Ma=0.9. The top row (a−c)(a-c) and bottom row (d−f)(d-f) denote convergent and divergent cases for n=8n=8, respectively. The horizontal black dot-dashed lines in each panel denote the saturation velocity obtained from potential flow theory (Goncharov [12]).

To further elucidate the acceleration mechanism in the highly nonlinear regime, the values of ⟨Vv−Vv∣ts⟩\langle V_v-V_v|_{t_s}\rangle and ⟨Vc−Vc∣ts⟩\langle V_c-V_c|_{t_s}\rangle roughly correspond to the contributions of vorticity accumulation and flow compressibility, respectively, following closely previous work (Fu et al. (2023)). Here, ⟨⋅⟩\langle\cdot\rangle denotes the time average from the moment tst_s when the bubble velocity reaches the value predicted by Goncharov [12] to the end of simulation. Vv∣tsV_v|_{t_s} and Vc∣tsV_c|_{t_s} denote the values of VvV_v and VcV_c at time tst_s, respectively. It is clearly seen in Figure 5 that the acceleration in convergent cases is dominated by vorticity accumulation at low ATA_T and low MaMa and by flow compressibility at high ATA_T and high MaMa whereas the acceleration in divergent cases is purely induced by flow compressibility. Besides, the AT−MaA_T-Ma space of acceleration dominated by vorticity accumulation becomes greatly broader in convergent cases than that in corresponding planar counterparts with the same RepRe_p (Fu et al. (2023)) and does not appear in divergent cases, and the AT−MaA_T-Ma space of acceleration induced by flow compressibility is much narrower in convergent cases than that in divergent cases.

To further validate the present improved model (15), both convergent and divergent cases for n=16n = 16 are simulated. Other parameters have kept the same as those of corresponding cases for n=8n = 8. It is clearly shown in Figure 7 that the present model can also well describe the compressible cylindrical RTI evolution of the cases for n=16n = 16, indicating the reliability of the present characterision of bubble evolution for single-mode cylindrical RTI with isothermal stratification.

Bubble velocities for different $A_T$ and $Ma$ in convergent and divergent cases

Figure 7. Bubble velocities obtained from DNS results (symbols) and calculated by the present model (lines) for different ATA_T at (a,d)(a,d) Ma=0.1Ma = 0.1, (b,e)(b,e) Ma=0.5Ma = 0.5 and (c,f)(c,f) Ma=0.9Ma = 0.9. The top row (a−c)(a-c) and bottom row (d−f)(d-f) denote convergent and divergent cases for n=16n = 16, respectively. The horizontal black dot-dashed lines in each panel denote the saturation velocity obtained from potential flow theory (Goncharov [12]).

Concluding remarks

In this paper, nonlinear and highly nonlinear bubble evolutions of two-dimensional single-mode RTI with isothermal stratification are investigated in cylindrical geometry via DNS for different Atwood numbers (AT=0.1−0.9A_T = 0.1 - 0.9) and Mach numbers (Ma=0.1−0.9Ma = 0.1 - 0.9). It is found that the nonlinear bubble growth involves the effects of density stratification, vorticity accumulation and flow compressibility and shows considerable differences between convergent and divergent cases. Specifically, strong stabilizing effect of density stratification leads to non-acceleration at low ATA_T and high MaMa. The accelerations in convergent cases are dominated by vorticity accumulation at low ATA_T and low MaMa and by flow compressibility at high ATA_T and high MaMa whereas the accelerations in divergent cases are purely induced by flow compressibility at high ATA_T and high MaMa. Moreover, the AT−MaA_T-Ma space of acceleration dominated by vorticity accumulation becomes broader in convergent cases than that in corresponding planar counterparts (Fu et al. 2023) and does not appear in divergent cases. And the acceleration dominated by flow compressibility is always robust in convergent cases while transient in divergent cases.

Based on the nonlinear theory (Zhao et al. [37]) of incompressible cylindrical RTI with uniform-density background, an improved model has been proposed to describe the bubble velocity development by taking density variation, vorticity accumulation and flow compressibility into consideration. This model well reproduces the bubble velocity development from linear to highly nonlinear regimes. It is noted that current model inheriting the illuminating idea of the Betti-Sanz model [5] requires the simulation and thus is not predictive. Nevertheless, it will be helpful to understand the physical mechanisms of compressible RTI in cylindrical geometry. The present work sheds light on the mechanisms of two-dimensional single-mode RTI. If insight is further taken into the behaviour of compressible multi-mode cylindrical RTI, it is possible to better understand the evolution of the resultant turbulent mixing.

Acknowledgements. The authors are very grateful to Dr. Y.-S. Zhang at the Institute of Applied Physics and Computational Mathematics for useful discussions on the algorithm and code.

Funding. This work was supported by the National Natural Science Foundation of China (Nos. 12202436, 12388101, 12293000 and 12293002), by Science Challenge Project, by LCP Fund for Young Scholar (No. 6142A05QN22002) and by the Strategic Priority Research Program of the Chinese Academy of Sciences (No. XDB0500301)

Declaration of interests. The authors report no conflict of interest.

Author ORCIDs.

Ming Yuan, https://orcid.org/0000-0002-2602-9990;

Zhiye Zhao, https://orcid.org/0000-0003-1509-5084;

Luoqin Liu, https://orcid.org/0000-0002-6020-3702;

Nan-Sheng Liu, https://orcid.org/0000-0001-9128-1933;

Xi-Yun Lu, https://orcid.org/0000-0002-0737-6460.

References

  1. [1]Balakrishnan, K. & Menon, S. 2010 On turbulent chemical explosions into dilute aluminum particle clouds. Combust. Theory Model. 14 (4), 583–617.DOI
  2. [2]Bell, G. I. 1951 Taylor instability on cylinders and spheres in the small amplitude approximation. Report No. LA-1321, LANL.
  3. [3]Bell, J. B., Day, M. S., Rendleman, C. A., Woosley, S. E. & Zingale, M. 2004 Direct numerical simulations of type Ia supernovae flames. II. The Rayleigh–Taylor instability. Astrophys. J. 608 (2), 883.
  4. [4]Betti, R. & Hurricane, O. A. 2016 Inertial-confinement fusion with lasers. Nat. Phys. 12 (5), 435–448.DOI
  5. [5]Betti, R. & Sanz, J. 2006 Bubble acceleration in the ablative Rayleigh–Taylor instability. Phys. Rev. Lett. 97 (20), 205002.
  6. [6]Bian, X., Aluie, H., Zhao, D., Zhang, H. & Livescu, D. 2020 Revisiting the late-time growth of single-mode Rayleigh–Taylor instability and the role of vorticity. Physica D 403, 132250.DOI
  7. [7]Chertkov, M., Lebedev, V. & Vladimirova, N. 2009 Reactive Rayleigh–Taylor turbulence. J. Fluid Mech. 633, 1–16.DOI
  8. [10]Gauthier, S. 2017 Compressible Rayleigh–Taylor turbulent mixing layer between Newtonian miscible fluids. J. Fluid Mech. 830, 211–256.DOI
  9. [12]Goncharov, V. N. 2002 Analytical model of nonlinear, single-mode, classical Rayleigh–Taylor instability at arbitrary Atwood numbers. Phys. Rev. Lett. 88 (13), 134502.pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/11955101
  10. [13]Hester, J. J. 2008 The Crab Nebula: an astrophysical chimera. Annu. Rev. Astron. Astrophys. 46 (1), 127–155.DOI
  11. [14]Hicks, E. P. 2014 A shear instability mechanism for the pulsations of Rayleigh–Taylor unstable model flames. J. Fluid Mech. 748, 618–640.
  12. [15]Houseman, G. A. & Molnar, P. 1997 Gravitational (Rayleigh–Taylor) instability of a layer with non-linear viscosity and convective thinning of continental lithosphere. Geophys. J. Int. 128 (1), 125–150.
  13. [16]Isobe, H., Miyagoshi, T., Shibata, K. & Yokoyama, T. 2005 Filamentary structure on the Sun from the magnetic Rayleigh–Taylor instability. Nature 434 (7032), 478–481.
  14. [17]Kishony, R. & Shvarts, D. 2001 Ignition condition and gain prediction for perturbed inertial confinement fusion targets. Phys. Plasmas 8 (11), 4925–4936.
  15. [18]Layzer, D. 1955 On the instability of superposed fluids in a gravitational field. Astrophys. J. 122, 1.
  16. [19]Lindl, J., Landen, O., Edwards, J., Moses, E. & team, N.I.C. 2014 Review of the national ignition campaign 2009-2012. Phys. Plasmas 21 (2), 020501.
  17. [20]Livescu, D. 2004 Compressibility effects on the Rayleigh–Taylor instability growth between immiscible fluids. Phys. Fluids 16 (1), 118–127.
  18. [21]Livescu, D. 2013 Numerical simulations of two-fluid turbulent mixing at large density ratios and applications to the Rayleigh–Taylor instability. Philos. Trans. R. Soc. A 371 (2003), 20120185.
  19. [22]Luo, T. & Wang, J. 2021 Effects of Atwood number and stratification parameter on compressible multi-mode Rayleigh–Taylor instability. Phys. Fluids 33 (11), 115111.
  20. [23]Luo, T. & Wang, J. 2022 Mixing and energy transfer in compressible Rayleigh–Taylor turbulence for initial isothermal stratification. Phys. Rev. Fluid 7 (10), 104608.
  21. [24]Luo, T., Wang, J., Xie, C., Wan, M. & Chen, S. 2020 Effects of compressibility and Atwood number on the single-mode Rayleigh–Taylor instability. Phys. Fluids 32 (1), 012110.
  22. [25]Rayleigh, L. 1883 Investigation of the character of the equilibrium of an incompressible heavy fluid of variable density. Proc. Lond. Math. Soc. s1–14 (1), 170–177.
  23. [26]Reckinger, S. J., Livescu, D. & Vasilyev, O. V. 2016 Comprehensive numerical methodology for direct numerical simulations of compressible Rayleigh–Taylor instability. J. Comput. Phys. 313, 181–208.
  24. [27]Sakagami, H. & Nishihara, K. 1990 Rayleigh–Taylor instability on the pusher–fuel contact surface of stagnating targets. Phys. Fluids B 2 (11), 2715–2730.
  25. [28]Sykes, J. P., Gallagher, T. P. & Rankin, B. A. 2021 Effects of Rayleigh–Taylor instabilities on turbulent premixed flames in a curved rectangular duct. Proc. Combust. Inst. 38 (4), 6059–6066.
  26. [29]Taylor, G. I. 1950 The instability of liquid surfaces when accelerated in a direction perpendicular to their planes. I. Proc. R. Soc. Lond. A 201 (1065), 192–196.
  27. [30]Wang, L.-F., Wu, J.-F., Ye, W.-H., Zhang, W.-Y. & He, X.-T. 2013 Weakly nonlinear incompressible Rayleigh–Taylor instability growth at cylindrically convergent interfaces. Phys. Plasmas 20 (4), 042708.
  28. [31]Weir, S. T., Chandler, E. A. & Goodwin, B. T. 1998 Rayleigh–Taylor instability experiments examining feedthrough growth in an incompressible, convergent geometry. Phys. Rev. Lett. 80 (17), 3763.
  29. [34]Yuan, M., Zhao, Z., Liu, L., Wang, P., Liu, N.-S. & Lu, X.-Y. 2023 Instability evolution of a shock-accelerated thin heavy fluid layer in cylindrical geometry. J. Fluid Mech. 969, A6.
  30. [36]Zhao, Z., Liu, N.-S. & Lu, X.-Y. 2020a Kinetic energy and enstrophy transfer in compressible Rayleigh–Taylor turbulence. J. Fluid Mech. 904, A37.
  31. [37]Zhao, Z., Wang, P., Liu, N.-S. & Lu, X.-Y. 2020b Analytical model of nonlinear evolution of single-mode Rayleigh–Taylor instability in cylindrical geometry. J. Fluid Mech. 900, A24.
  32. [38]Zhao, Z., Wang, P., Liu, N.-S. & Lu, X.-Y. 2021 Scaling law of mixing layer in cylindrical Rayleigh–Taylor turbulence. Phys. Rev. E 104 (5), 055104.
  33. [39]Zhou, Y. 2017a Rayleigh–Taylor and Richtmyer–Meshkov instability induced flow, turbulence, and mixing. I. Phys. Rep. 720–722, 1–136.

Paper details

vlnc:W_v4bt2kjz
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 0

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Physics and Astronomy

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents