WorksMathematics
Rigidity and classification of complete translating solitons and self-expanders with constant curvature in
Abstract
For complete immersed surfaces in Euclidean four-space whose mean curvature vector has constant length, translators are affine planes parallel to their fixed nonzero velocity, and self-expanders are planes through their centre. This rigidity requires no Lagrangian assumption, properness, volume growth control, or bound on the second fundamental form. Complete Lagrangian translators and self-expanders in with constant Gaussian curvature are flat and, up to unitary equivalence, are properly embedded products of two complete planar curves. Translating factors are lines or grim reapers. Expanding factors are lines through the origin or nonstraight self-expanders. The proofs use moving frames, a transnormal function, a cubic tensor identity, and analytic continuation.
Introduction
Mean curvature flow evolves a family of immersed submanifolds by
where is the mean curvature vector of at . Its self-similar solutions play a central role both in the local analysis of singularities and in the long-time behaviour of the flow. Two basic examples are translating solitons (or, simply, translators), characterised by
and self-expanders, satisfying
Under our convention , equation (1.1) generates translation by , while (1.2) generates the homothetic flow for , up to tangential reparametrisation. The normalisation in (1.2) is essential for the numerical coefficients below. Basic examples and the theory of translators and expanders may be found in [1, 2, 9, 10, 12, 13, 25].
The interaction between intrinsic and extrinsic geometry becomes particularly interesting for Lagrangian mean curvature flow in . The Lagrangian condition is preserved along smooth mean curvature flow, and the parallel complex structure identifies the tangent and normal bundles. This produces additional symmetry in the second fundamental form, a feature absent for general submanifolds. Foundational constructions and rigidity results include [3, 4, 6, 8, 14, 15, 24].
From view points of submanifolds theory, it is very natural to study rigidity and classification theorems for the Lagrangian self-shrinkers, the Lagrangian translators and the Lagrangian self-expanders. Two curvature assumptions that often arise in classification problems must be distinguished. The extrinsic condition constant fixes the mean curvature length. The intrinsic condition constant fixes the Gaussian curvature. For an immersed surface in , the Gauss equation gives . Thus neither of these two constancy assumptions implies the other without further information. Recent results on Lagrangian translators and Lagrangian self-expanders under hypotheses involving or appear in [16, 19, 20]; complete Lagrangian self-shrinkers are investigated in [8, 18, 21]. In contrast, our second classification problem below concerns constant Gaussian curvature.
We first address the mean curvature length problem without imposing the Lagrangian condition.
Theorem 1.1. Let be a smooth, complete, connected translator without boundary. If is constant, then and . Consequently, is a global isometry onto an affine two-plane with .
Theorem 1.2. Let be a smooth, complete, connected self-expander without boundary. If is constant, then , and is a global isometry onto a linear two-plane through the origin.
Remark 1.1. The above conclusion, without conditions the squared norm of the second fundamental form being bounded from above and Lagrangian condition, proves that the conclusion of [20] still holds true. The same transnormal function occurs for self-shrinkers, with a different Laplacian, in the preprint of Li, Wei and Xing [21].
Remark 1.2. The mechanisms are different. For translators, the nonzero mean curvature case is ruled out locally using a moving frame, the Gauss equation, and Codazzi compatibility. For expanders, completeness and a transnormal identity force the constant mean curvature to vanish. In particular, the translator’s vanishing conclusion does not itself require completeness; completeness is used only to identify the entire plane.
Our second condition prescribes the intrinsic Gaussian curvature . In particular, constant fixes the difference of two extrinsic curvature functions. The constant problem for complete Lagrangian surfaces was treated by Li, Liu and Qiao for translators [16] and by Li and Wei for expanders [19]. Chen [7] classified general constant-curvature Lagrangian surfaces in locally on an open dense set. For the intrinsic problem, let be the standard complex structure on . An immersion is Lagrangian when . The stronger cubic-tensor symmetry leads to global classifications.
Theorem 1.3. Let be a smooth, complete, connected Lagrangian translator without boundary. If the Gaussian curvature is constant, then the surface is flat and isometric to , and there exist a unitary transformation and complete unit-speed plane curves such that
Here denotes projection onto the normal line of the curve. Each factor is a straight line or a grim reaper curve; the product is a proper embedding. Conversely, every such product is a complete flat Lagrangian translator, provided the factor equations hold for the prescribed .
Theorem 1.4. Let be a smooth, complete, connected Lagrangian self-expander without boundary. If its gaussian curvature is constant, then , and is isometric to , and
for a unitary transformation and complete unit speed planar self-expanders . Each factor is a line through the origin or a nonstraight complete expanding curve. The product is properly embedded. Conversely, each such product is a complete flat Lagrangian self-expander.
Remark 1.3. In fact, the authors of the present paper [22] proved that the conclusion remains valid for self-shrinkers under the same hypotheses as those in Theorems 1.3 and 1.4.
Joyce, Lee and Tsui [14] constructed families of Lagrangian translators and self-expanders. The translating products of a line and a grim reaper, or of two grim reapers, already appear in Castro and Lerma [5]. For self-shrinkers, Li and Wang [17] obtained a product decomposition for complete flat Lagrangian surfaces. Here the exclusion of negative constant uses an identity for the covariant derivative of the Lagrangian cubic tensor. After proving flatness, we extend the local product decomposition to the universal cover. The known classification of planar soliton curves [12] then gives injectivity and properness on the original surface.
The exclusion of negative constant Gaussian curvature rests on an explicit identity for the covariant derivative of the Lagrangian cubic tensor, combined with an approximate extremal sequence. Flatness is then promoted to a global Cartesian splitting by commutation of shape operators and real-analytic elliptic regularity. Finally, planar curve classification gives embeddedness and eliminates nontrivial deck transformations. We include the calculations and the completeness arguments to make precise where each hypothesis enters.
The paper is organised as follows. § 2 fixes conventions and gives auxiliary lemmas. § 3-§ 4 prove the general-surface rigidity statements. § 5-§ 7 establish the curvature identities and exclude nonzero constant . § 8-§ 9 prove the global product classification.
Preliminaries
Let be a smooth immersion. Throughout, is connected and without boundary, and completeness refers to the induced metric. For an orthonormal tangent frame , write . Thus
where is the second fundamental form. Denote by , and the Euclidean, Levi-Civita, and normal connections, respectively. For tangent vector fields and a normal field , the Gauss and Weingarten formulas are
where . Our curvature convention is
With , the Gauss equation gives
The covariant derivative of is
and the Euclidean Codazzi equation is
Lemma 2.1. ([21]) Let be a nonempty complete Riemannian manifold. If is smooth and nonnegative and satisfies . Then vanishes somewhere.
Proof. If , the conclusion is immediate. On define , then . Fix and take the maximal integral curve of with . Its speed equals one and
so . The curve is Cauchy as because . Completeness supplies . If , then and the smooth vector field extends the integral curve, contradicting maximality. Hence and . □
Lemma 2.2. Under the hypotheses of Lemma 2.1, if , the self-adjoint Hessian endomorphism defined by satisfies . Consequently, its eigenvalues lie in and .
Proof. At a zero of the nonnegative smooth function , . Twice differentiating in normal coordinates gives
At the second term vanishes, so , and the eigenvalue equation proves the assertion. □
Lemma 2.3. Every complete connected totally geodesic isometric immersion is a global isometry onto an affine -plane.
Proof. Fix and put . For any , completeness makes the geodesic available for all . Since ,
and hence
By Hopf-Rinow, is surjective. Therefore the image is precisely . If , choose with ; the displayed equation implies , so and . The bijective local isometry is a global isometry. □
Lemma 2.4. If is complete and is bounded below, there are such that
For a function bounded above, the analogous statement holds at the supremum.
Proof. Choose and with . Ekeland’s variational principle [11] on the complete metric space gives satisfying and
Apply this to for unit , first with and then with , to find . Taking the supremum over gives the required gradient estimate. Replace by for a maximum sequence. □
Rigidity of translators with constant
Proposition 3.1. Let be a connected translator with nonzero fixed velocity . If is constant, then , even without completeness.
Proof. Set , and . Because is a fixed ambient vector, (4) yields, for all tangent ,
Taking the gradient and Laplacian of gives
where . We will prove by contradiction that . Assume . If , then is constant, contrary to . Thus . The constant length of implies
so . On a local oriented chart let and choose perpendicular to it. Since , we obtain
Put . The first identity of (7) and metric compatibility give
Since is constant, these connection coefficients give
The negative value is not yet a contradiction; we must impose the normal Codazzi equations.
Let and choose a local orthonormal normal frame . Equation (9) yields and . Since , for smooth functions we have
The Gauss equation gives
Together with (11), this gives the fixed radius relation
Define normal connection functions by and . The second identity of (7) with and (12) yield
Step 3. Use (10) to expand the first Codazzi equation
The component of the left-hand side is . The right-hand side has component : indeed,
Thus
Similarly, the component of gives
Substituting (14) gives the closed system
Since , equation (13) allows a smooth local angle with , . Substituting into (17) and inverting the rotation matrix gives
From (3.5), . Differentiating (3.12) gives
The commutator equality therefore reduces, after collecting terms, to
All coefficients are positive constants, so must be constant. Locally, smoothness then forces to be constant, because each level set of consists of isolated points. But (3.12) gives . This is a contradiction. Hence is impossible.
Now and , so is a nowhere-zero tangent vector, and (3.1) gives for every . Choosing yields . Since , we also have . Thus . □
Proof of Theorem 1.1. Proposition 3.1 gives , and Lemma 2.3 identifies the complete immersion with an entire affine plane . Since is tangent to the plane at every point, it lies in . □
Rigidity of self-expanders with constant
Proof of Theorem 1.2. Write and . For the constant , the self-expander equation gives
Directly from (2.1),
Lemma 2.1 gives with . By Lemma 2.2, . Equation (4.2) therefore forces and . Then equation (1.2) gives , i.e. is tangent everywhere. Taking normal parts of yields
At any point where , choose . Equation (4.3) shows , and gives . By (4.2), , so cannot vanish on an open set and the set is dense. Continuity gives globally. By Lemma 2.3, parametrizes an entire affine plane. Finally and imply , so the plane passes through the origin. □
Lagrangian structure and drift identities
For the remainder of the paper assume that is Lagrangian. Set
Because is parallel and , the cubic tensor is totally symmetric. The covariant derivative is totally symmetric in its four arguments by the Codazzi equation. The normal curvature is identified with the tangent curvature through . That is, . Then implies flat normal connection.
The equations (1) and (2) can be written as
Define
Thus for translators and for self-expanders. Direct differentiation of (24) gives
The final formula follows from
With the conventions in (24)–(25), we obtain the following drift identities.
Lemma 5.1. For a Lagrangian surface satisfying (5.2), we have
and
Consequently, as ,
Proof. Tracing the derivative of the first identity in (26) and using Codazzi gives
Taking its inner product with and using yields (27). For clarity, here is the algebraic part of the Simons formula used in (28). With respect to a tangent orthonormal frame write
Then
A direct expansion of these two symmetric matrices verifies
The standard Euclidean Simons identity for the second fundamental form, combined with (5.4), is
Substituting (5.9) into the Simons identity gives (5.6). Finally, and subtraction of the first two equations give (5.7). □
The cubic-tensor identity at negative constant curvature
The next calculation is the key point in excluding . It is important that a frame identity valid only at one point is not differentiated as though it held on a neighbourhood.
Lemma 6.1. Suppose is constant and (5.2) holds. At any point where , choose an orthonormal tangent frame with and write . Then
Proof. The cubic tensor and its covariant derivative are totally symmetric. At the point in question write
The last component is because the component of is zero at this point. Directly from the Gauss equation,
For clarity, the three normal-valued coefficients are
At the point, denote the independent components of the symmetric four-tensor by
Because by (5.4), we have
Define
The multiplicities of symmetric entries yield
Using , , ,
where .
One must use the differentiated full cubic invariant, rather than differentiating on a neighborhood. In an arbitrary frame, the intrinsic Gauss expression is
Differentiate this invariant formula first, and only then evaluate in the adapted frame where . Total symmetry of gives
Inserting (6.4) and (6.5) simplifies these to
Let
From and (6.3),
so . Since is constant and , equations (6.9)-(6.10) imply
Taking norms and using yields
Combining (6.6) and (6.11), and simplifying the coefficient of , gives the full identity
Indeed,
Finally, since , inserting (6.12) into (5.7), setting , and multiplying by gives
which is (32). □
Exclusion of nonzero constant Gaussian curvature
Proposition 7.1. No complete immersed translator or self-expander in has positive constant Gaussian curvature.
Proof. For a surface, . A positive constant makes compact by the Bonnet-Myers theorem. For a translator, satisfies . Integration gives , then , contradicting compactness. For a self-expander,
which is also impossible on a compact manifold. □
Proposition 7.2. A complete Lagrangian self-expander in cannot have negative constant Gaussian curvature.
Proof. Suppose . Let . For self-expanders, and . On , Lemma 6.1 implies
We show that is dense. If on a nonempty open set, the self-expander equation gives there. For tangent vectors , the second equation of (5.4) yields
Thus there. Commuting these derivatives yields . For a 2-dimensional Riemannian manifold, its curvature tensor is completely determined by the Gaussian curvature:
where the corresponding curvature sign convention is adopted. Choose a local orthonormal frame , and write . It follows from and that . Then on a surface of nonzero Gaussian curvature this implies , contrary to . Consequently the continuous estimate (7.1) holds on all of . Since is bounded below, Lemma 2.4 supplies points with . Inequality (7.1) gives instead , a contradiction. □
Proposition 7.3. A complete Lagrangian translator in cannot have negative constant Gaussian curvature.
Proof. Suppose . The translator equation and Gauss identity yield
If identically, then is tangent, and from , it is a nonzero parallel tangent field which forces , contrary to hypothesis. Therefore . Apply Lemma 2.4 to . We find with
For large , use the mean curvature frame of Lemma 6.1, so that . By (7.2), the coefficients of (6.2) and of are uniformly bounded. After taking a subsequence, these five real numbers converge to , with . Let
At the points , the gradient identity in (5.4) is . In the chosen frame . Passing to the limit in (7.3) gives
Similarly, Lemma 6.1 with passes to the limit as
The right-hand side is positive, so . Equation (47) therefore implies that . Combining this with the Gauss relation (6.3) gives
The eigenvalues of the symmetric matrix are and . Hence is one-dimensional. Direct calculation yields for . Then . Since and , there necessarily exists a non-zero real number such that . Thus,
from (7.6). Therefore, inserting and yields
Substitution of (7.7) into (7.5) forces , the desired contradiction. □
From the above analysis, the following result can be derived.
Corollary 7.1. Every complete connected Lagrangian translator or self-expander in with constant Gaussian curvature is flat.
Global splitting in the flat case
Proposition 8.1. Let be a complete, connected, flat Lagrangian immersion satisfying (5.2). Up to a unitary transformation, its lift to the universal cover is a Cartesian product of two complete, unit-speed planar soliton curves in orthogonal complex lines.
Proof. As identifies the tangent and normal connections, implies the normal curvature vanishes. By the Ricci equation all shape operators commute. At a point with , at least one shape operator is nonscalar: otherwise Lagrangian symmetry would force . A nonscalar self-adjoint operator in dimension two has distinct eigenvalues, hence determines a smooth local orthonormal eigenframe ; commutation diagonalizes the remaining shape operators simultaneously. In this common principal frame, for any normal vector , we have . That is, . Total symmetry of then yields
Write , . In the diagonal frame, total symmetry of gives
For completeness, these are obtained by equating with , with , and with , respectively. Moreover, the component of equals zero. Since , this component is . Together with (52),
The determinant is at every point of this neighbourhood. Thus
on this nonflat neighbourhood. In particular, the local diagonalising frame is parallel.
The universal Riemannian cover is complete, simply connected, and flat; hence it is globally isometric to the Euclidean plane with coordinates . Extend the local parallel eigenframe uniquely to global parallel fields on the cover. As and on the initial neighbourhood,
To propagate this identity, use the soliton equation in the global Euclidean coordinates:
Here and . Equation (55) is a semilinear elliptic system with analytic nonlinearities; standard analytic elliptic regularity [23] implies that is real analytic. Therefore the analytic tensor , which vanishes on the open set in (54), vanishes throughout . If instead, the same conclusion follows immediately. Thus
Integrating gives , with . The orthogonality of and the Lagrangian condition yield
By (51) on the initial neighbourhood and analyticity,
Therefore the real two-planes and are each independent of their parameters. Equation (57) gives . They are fixed orthogonal complex lines in . Choosing a unitary that sends the coordinate lines to and absorbing the constant components of into the factors, we obtain
The normal projection in (24) splits over these complex lines, giving
where and denotes the projection onto the normal direction of the corresponding plane curve. Both parameters traverse all of , so the curve factors are complete. □
Planar curve factors and proofs of classification
Translating plane curves
Let be complete and unit speed with for fixed . If , the curve is a line. For , rotate the plane so that with . Write and . The curvature equation is
An equilibrium solution is a straight line parallel to . Every nonequilibrium solution has of a fixed sign; reversing orientation allows . On that branch the curve is a graph , and (58) becomes
Integrating twice yields, after translations,
The arclength form diverges at both endpoints, so the maximal arclength parametrisation has domain . It is injective because the horizontal coordinate is strictly monotone, and proper because its height diverges at both ends. Uniqueness of the curve ODE shows that a complete curve must be one of these maximal solutions. For a prescribed velocity , each factor velocity is fixed: a line must be parallel to when , and a grim reaper has speed parameter .
Expanding plane curves
Let be a unit-speed solution of . Put
Since and , differentiating gives
As , a solution defined for all has as and as , so it has a unique zero. Translate the arc-length parameter to make this zero occur at , reverse orientation if necessary, and rotate the ambient plane so that
If , uniqueness gives , and the line through the origin. Suppose . By uniqueness remains positive, and on ,
The analogous backward bounds hold for . Therefore the solution of (9.4) exists for all . Conversely, solving (9.4) and then putting gives
so the reconstructed curve satisfies the desired expander equation.
To prove embeddedness, write with ; thus . For set . Direct differentiation yields
Here , hence on . The symmetry of the initial-value system implies and are odd and is even. Therefore for all . It follows that , proving injectivity.
Also for and for ; since
the curve is proper. Denote the normalized curve by , with . Every complete planar expanding curve has this form up to rotation and reparametrization. The planar classification was established in [12].
Descent to the surface and proof of the main theorems
Proofs of Theorems 1.3 and 1.4. Corollary 7.1 gives . By Proposition 8.1, the universal cover has lifted immersion . The preceding subsections show that each complete factor is injective and proper, so the Cartesian product is injective and proper. If is a deck transformation, then . Injectivity forces to be the identity. Hence the deck group is trivial and itself is isometric to . The original immersion is the proper embedded product stated in the theorems.
Conversely, for complete unit-speed curves in orthogonal complex lines, the product has metric and is flat and complete. Its tangent planes are Lagrangian, and both its mean curvature vector and the normal projection of or split into the respective planar components. The factor curve equations imply the corresponding surface soliton equation. □
Acknowledgements
The first author was partially supported by NSFC grant No.12401060, Natural Science Foundation of Henan Province grant No.262300421232. The second author was partially supported by NSFC grant No. 12501063, Postdoctoral Fellowship Program of CPSF grant No. GZC20252036.
Declarations
Conflict of interest There are no conflicts of interest with third parties.
Data availability No datasets were generated or analysed in this study.
Zhi Li,
School of Mathematics and Statistics, Henan Normal University, 453007, Xinxiang, Henan, China.
Email address: [email protected]
Cheng Xing,
School of Mathematics and Statistics, Henan Normal University, 453007, Xinxiang, Henan, China.
Email address: [email protected]
References
- [1]S. J. Altschuler and L. F. Wu, Translating surfaces of the non-parametric mean curvature flow with prescribed contact angle, Calc. Var. Partial Differential Equations, 2 (1994), no. 1, 101-111.DOI
- [2]S. Ancari and X. Cheng, Volume properties and rigidity on self-expanders of mean curvature flow, Geom. Dedicata, 216 (2022), no. 2, Paper No. 24, 25 pp.arxiv.org/abs/2012.03364
- [3]H. Anciaux, Construction of Lagrangian self-similar solutions to the mean curvature flow in C^n, Geom. Dedicata, 120 (2006), 37-48.DOI
- [4]I. Castro and A. M. Lerma, Hamiltonian stationary self-similar solutions for Lagrangian mean curvature flow in the complex Euclidean plane, Proc. Amer. Math. Soc., 138 (2010), no. 5, 1821-1832.
- [5]I. Castro and A. M. Lerma, Translating solitons for Lagrangian mean curvature flow in complex Euclidean plane, Internat. J. Math., 23 (2012), no. 10, 1250101.arxiv.org/abs/1007.1886
- [6]I. Castro, A. M. Lerma, The Clifford torus as a self-shrinker for the Lagrangian mean curvature flow, Int. Math. Res. Not., 6 (2014), 1515-1527.
- [7]B.-Y. Chen, Classification of Lagrangian surfaces of constant curvature in the complex Euclidean plane, Proc. Edinb. Math. Soc., 48 (2005), no. 2, 337-364.DOI
- [8]Q. -M. Cheng, H. Hori and G. Wei, Complete Lagrangian self-shrinkers in ℝ⁴, Math. Z., 301 (2022), no. 4, 3417-3468.
- [9]X. Cheng and D. Zhou, Spectral properties and rigidity for self-expanding solutions of the mean curvature flows, Math. Ann., 371 (2018), no. 1-2, 371-389.arxiv.org/abs/1709.04086
- [10]J. Clutterbuck, O. Schnürer and F. Schulze, Stability of translating solutions to mean curvature flow, Calc. Var. Partial Differential Equations, 29 (2007), no. 3, 281-293.DOI
- [11]I. Ekeland, On the variational principle, J. Math. Anal. Appl., 47 (1974), no.2, 324-353.DOI
- [12]P. H. Halldorsson, Self-similar solutions to the curve shortening flow, Trans. Amer. Math. Soc., 364 (2012), no.10, 5285-5309.
- [13]H. P. Halldorsson, Helicoidal surfaces rotating/translating under the mean curvature flow, Geom. Dedicata, 162 (2013), 45-65.
- [14]D. Joyce, Y. -I. Lee and M. -T. Tsui, Self-similar solutions and translating solitons for Lagrangian mean curvature flow, J. Differential Geom., 84 (2010), 127-161.arxiv.org/abs/0801.3721
- [15]Y. -I. Lee and M. -T. Wang, Hamiltonian stationary shrinkers and expanders for Lagrangian mean curvature flows, J. Differential Geom., 83 (2009), 27-42.arxiv.org/abs/0707.0239
- [16]X. X. Li, Y. Y. Lu and R. N. Qiao, A uniqueness theorem of complete Lagrangian translator in C², Manuscripta Math., 164 (2021), no. 1-2, 251-265.DOI
- [17]H. Li and X. Wang, New characterizations of the Clifford torus as a Lagrangian self-shrinker, J. Geom. Anal., 27 (2017), no. 2, 1393-1412.arxiv.org/abs/1505.05593
- [18]Z. Li, R. X. Wang and G. Wei, The rigidity theorem for complete Lagrangian self-shrinkers, J. Geom. Anal., 35 (2025), no. 2, Paper No. 69, 17 pp.arxiv.org/abs/2412.01162
- [19]Z. Li and G. Wei, Complete Lagrangian self-expanders in C², J. Geom. Phys., 198 (2024), Paper No. 105107, 10 pp.DOI
- [20]Z. Li and G. Wei, Classification of Lagrangian translators and Lagrangian self-expanders in ℂ², Manuscripta Math., 176 (2025), no. 3, Paper No. 30, 17 pp.arxiv.org/abs/2405.14086
- [21]Z. Li, G. Wei and C. Xing, Rigidity theorems of complete self-shrinkers in the Euclidean space, 2026, arXiv:2610.29842v1.arxiv.org/abs/2610.29842
- [22]Z. Li, G. Wei and C. Xing, Complete lagrangian self-shrinkers with constant gaussian curvature, 2026, preprint.
- [23]C. B. Morrey, Jr., Multiple Integrals in the Calculus of Variations. Classics in Math., Springer-Verlag, Berlin, 2008; reprint of the 1966 edition.
- [24]A. Neves and G. Tian, Translating solutions to Lagrangian mean curvature flow, Trans. Amer. Math. Soc., 365 (2013), no. 11, 5655-5680.arxiv.org/abs/0711.4341
- [25]K. Smoczyk, Self-expanders of the mean curvature flow, Vietnam J. Math., 49 (2021), no. 2, 433-445.arxiv.org/abs/2005.05803