WorksPhysics and Astronomy
Odd Capillarity
Abstract
Capillarity governs interfacial relaxation and hydrodynamic motion in binary fluids through parity-even mechanical stresses. Here, we introduce odd capillarity, a parity-breaking interfacial mechanical response, by incorporating a symmetric, nonvariational, parity-odd capillary stress into the Cahn–Hilliard–Navier–Stokes (CHNS) equations. This stress generates forces along interfaces, transverse to ordinary capillary forces, and performs mechanical work that is not balanced by changes in the composition free energy. Direct numerical simulations reveal that odd capillarity arrests domain coarsening while sustaining turbulent fluid motion without a conventional inertial energy cascade, as energy injection is predominantly balanced by viscous dissipation. In asymmetric mixtures, odd capillarity driven deformation and breakup interrupt droplet growth, producing dynamically arrested emulsions with composition hyperuniformity and suppressed large-scale vorticity fluctuations. These findings establish odd capillarity as a distinct interfacial mechanism for controlling phase separation and sustaining nonequilibrium fluid motion.
Introduction: Capillarity converts the geometry of a fluid interface into mechanical stress [1, 2]. This fundamental coupling governs a broad range of interfacial phenomena, from phase separation and wetting to droplet coalescence and breakup, and capillary waves [3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8]. By favoring the reduction of interfacial free energy, capillary forces drive interfacial relaxation and generate flows in the surrounding fluid, which in turn advect and deform the interfaces. This basic interplay is captured by the Cahn–Hilliard–Navier–Stokes (CHNS) equations, or Model H, in which the capillary stress couples composition gradients to fluid momentum [9, 10, 11, 12, 13]. Derived from the free energy, this stress preserves spatial parity symmetry.
The mechanical response of a material can change fundamentally when spatial reflection symmetry (parity) is broken. In chiral fluids, broken parity permits odd viscosity, a nondissipative transverse stress response [14, 15]. In active solids and mechanical metamaterials, non-reciprocal interactions can give rise to odd elasticity, where elastic stresses are not derivable from a scalar energy and can perform work over cyclic deformations [16, 17]. These developments [18] have primarily concerned bulk mechanical responses, whereas parity-odd capillary stresses at fluid interfaces remain comparatively unexplored. Recent theories of chiral phase separation have demonstrated persistent interfacial currents and their influence on domain morphology [19, 20, 21, 22]. These theories, however, describe dry systems, where chirality drives tangential currents of particles or composition along interfaces without momentum-conserving hydrody-
namics. This raises a fundamental question: If capillarity itself acquires a parity-odd component, how does it reshape interfacial dynamics through its coupling to fluid motion?
In this Letter, we introduce odd capillarity, a parity-breaking interfacial mechanical response, and develop a minimal hydrodynamic model incorporating a nonvariational, parity-odd capillary stress within the CHNS equations. This stress generates a force transverse to the even capillary force without introducing an intrinsic torque density. Unlike the conventional capillary coupling, the odd stress can perform mechanical work that is not balanced by changes in the binary-fluid free energy. By direct numerical simulations (DNSs) we explore the possibility of odd capillarity to arrest domain coarsening and study its impact on turbulent fluid motion. We perform a scale-by-scale kinetic-energy analysis to understand the impact of odd capillarity and analyse the vorticity field with respect to hyperuniformity. Our findings establish odd capillarity as a distinct mechanism through which fluid interfaces can organize and sustain nonequilibrium motion.
Model: We consider an incompressible binary fluid in two dimensions, described by a conserved composition field , a velocity field and a pressure field . The composition distinguishes the two coexisting phases, while its spatial gradients identify the diffuse interfaces separating them. We formulate a minimal hydrodynamic model by extending the CHNS equations [9, 10, 11, 12, 13], retaining the usual conservation laws and introducing parity breaking solely through an additional interfacial mechanical stress. The governing equations read
with . Here is the mobility, and the kinematic viscosity. We assume equal densities and viscosities in both phases, with the density set to unity. The chemical potential follows from the standard Ginzburg–Landau free energy
where is the equilibrium surface tension and sets the diffuse-interface thickness. Thus, the phase-separation thermodynamics remains unchanged and the additional nonequilibrium ingredient enters only through the stress.
In ordinary CHNS equations, the capillary force derives from the same free energy and can be expressed, up to an isotropic pressure contribution, as the divergence of the Korteweg stress,
This stress is symmetric and parity even. Its mechanical work is compensated by changes in the binary-fluid free energy, so that capillary forces redistribute energy between interfacial and hydrodynamic degrees of freedom.
To construct an odd interfacial response, we exploit the geometry intrinsic to a diffuse interface. The composition gradient defines its local normal direction, while a rotation by gives the corresponding tangent. These two directions allow an interfacial stress to distinguish longitudinal and transverse mechanical responses without introducing an independent orientational field. We therefore seek a stress that is quadratic in composition gradients, symmetric under interchange of tensor indices, and odd under spatial reflection. A minimal choice satisfying these requirements is
where is the two-dimensional Levi–Civita tensor, with . The coefficient determines the strength and handedness of odd capillarity and has the dimensions of surface tension. For , the model reduces to the classical CHNS equations.
Several distinguishing mechanical properties follow from this construction. The stress is symmetric and traceless, and therefore introduces no intrinsic antisymmetric torque density. It vanishes in homogeneous phases and is concentrated in the interfacial regions where . Most importantly, its divergence generates a force perpendicular to the passive capillary force:
where and . The dimensionless chirality parameter measures the relative strength of odd capillarity, with recovering the achiral limit and its sign determining the handedness of the transverse response. Thus, the same composition gradients that generate ordinary capillary forcing also support an independent, parity-breaking mechanical response. For a planar interface parallel to the -axis, with , the odd stress produces a tangential force density , forming a localized force-dipole layer characterized by , , where the second equality follows from the equilibrium diffuse-interface profile [see Appendix § 1 for the derivations]. The resulting force-dipole layer drives tangential shear across the interface, while the symmetry of the underlying stress ensures the absence of intrinsic torque density.
The proposed coupling is distinct from other nonequilibrium mechanical responses. In Active Model H [23], an independent active stress modifies the parity-even interfacial coupling and can oppose ordinary surface tension. Its chiral extension has been developed to describe layered chiral active matter, where it yields odd elastic responses [24]. In this Letter, we instead consider a parity-odd capillary stress acting at the interfaces of a phase-separating binary fluid. This also makes it distinct from odd viscosity, which is a parity-breaking constitutive response to velocity gradients [15].
The energetic consequences of the additional stress distinguish odd capillarity from passive interfacial relaxation. We define the mean kinetic energy , the mean free energy , and the total mean energy , where denotes a spatial average. For periodic boundary conditions, the corresponding energy balances are
where and are the powers transferred to the fluid by even and odd capillary forces, respectively. The viscous and diffusive dissipation rates are and , respectively, with [see Appendix § 2 for detailed derivations]. Unlike the passive capillary contribution, whose mechanical work is balanced by changes in the composition free energy, the odd stress produces an independent power term , which can have either sign. The model therefore permits sustained mechanical energy injection through stresses localized at fluid interfaces, even though the composition dynamics retains its conventional Cahn–Hilliard form.
Phase ordering and coarsening arrest: We first investigate how odd capillarity modifies the phase-ordering dynamics of a binary fluid. We perform DNS of Eqs. (1) and (2) using a Fourier pseudospectral method [13] in a two-dimensional periodic square of side , with collocation points [see Appendix § 4 for numerical details]. Starting from a nearly homogeneous mixture, , where is the mean composition and is a small-amplitude random perturbation, we examine the evolution of the characteristic domain size. We first consider a symmetric mixture, , and define the coarsening length scale as
where is the shell-integrated composition spectrum, with . Here, denotes the spatial Fourier coefficient of , is the wavevector, is the wavenumber defining the shell, and is its width. Figure 1(a) shows the temporal evolution of for different values of chirality parameter , while Figure 1(b)–(Figure 1e) display representative pseudocolor plots of . In the achiral limit (), the mixture undergoes spinodal decomposition, forming interconnected domains that grow through diffusive transport and hydrodynamic motion [Fig. 1(b)]. In the observed scaling regime, , consistent with the classical viscous hydrodynamic growth law of binary-fluid mixtures [3, 25]. Introducing odd capillarity significantly alters these dynamics. For and , coarsening continues but becomes progressively slower, with the growth rate decreasing as increases. The corresponding interfaces exhibit pronounced deformations and irregular domain morphologies [Fig. 1(c)]. Upon increasing to , the characteristic length ceases to grow systematically
Figure 1. Odd capillarity slows and arrests domain coarsening. (a) Evolution of the characteristic coarsening length for different chirality parameter , with . For (black solid line), the ordinary CHNS model exhibits approximately linear hydrodynamic coarsening, (black dotted line). Increasing progressively suppresses domain growth, with coarsening arrest observed for , , and . The arrested length decreases with increasing . (b)–(e) Representative pseudocolor plots of the composition field : (b) at ; (c)–(e) , , and , respectively, at , illustrating the increasingly fine domain structures.
and fluctuates around a statistically stationary value, indicating coarsening arrest. At stronger odd capillarity (), the arrested state persists with a further reduction in the characteristic domain size [Figs. 1(d) and 1(e)]. In the arrested state, the interfaces keep evolving through diffusive growth, reconnection, neck thinning, and breakup, and spiral-like structures form. The state is dynamically sustained rather than frozen. The free-energy balance [Eq. 7b] provides an energetic interpretation of this behaviour. In a non-equilibrium steady state, . Thus, on average, the flow must continuously do work against capillarity and regenerate interfacial free energy at the rate it is dissipated by diffusion. In contrast, for conventional CHNS equations in the Stokes limit, , and the free energy decreases monotonically. Odd capillarity therefore sustains a dynamically arrested state in which interfaces continually evolve despite the absence of systematic domain growth. Coarsening arrest in hydrodynamically coupled binary fluids has previously been observed under externally driven turbulent flows [26, 27, 28], through contractile interfacial stresses in Active Model H [25, 29, 30], and through bulk active flows [31, 32]. Arrested phase separation has also been reported in active-spinner fluids and non-reciprocal binary-fluid turbulence [33, 34]. The described mechanism differs from these examples as odd capillarity suppresses coarsening through self-generated tangential interfacial flows and the resulting hydrodynamic deformation of domains.
Odd-capillarity-driven turbulence: The persistent interfacial deformations and coarsening arrest raise a fundamental question about the origin of the accompanying fluid motion. Can odd capillarity itself sustain complex flows in the absence of appreciable inertia or external forcing? To address this question, we examine the kinetic-energy spectrum and the mechanisms of energy transfer across scales. The shell-integrated kinetic-energy spectrum, , satisfies the scale-by-scale energy balance [[35, 36] [37]
where , , and denote the contributions from nonlinear advection (inertia), even capillary forcing, and odd-capillary forcing, respectively, and is the viscous dissipation spectrum [see Appendix § 3 for the definitions]. Hereafter, , , and denote their statistically stationary time averages, with , even, odd. In the dynamically arrested regime, the kinetic energy fluctuates around a statistically stationary mean [Figure 2(b)], while its spectrum extends over a broad range of wavenumbers [Figure 2(c)], with for and
Figure 2. Odd-capillarity-driven turbulence. (a) Representative pseudocolor plot of the scalar vorticity field , normalized by its root-mean-square value , for at . (b) Time evolution of the spatially averaged kinetic energy for , , and . (c) Time-averaged kinetic-energy spectra , normalized by , for the same values of . The dotted and dashed lines indicate the reference scalings and , respectively. The spectra are averaged over 400 snapshots in the statistically stationary state. (d) Spectral contributions , , , and to the kinetic-energy balance [Eq. (11)] for , plotted on a logarithmic wavenumber axis. The inertial transfer is negligible, while odd-capillary energy injection is predominantly balanced by viscous dissipation; the even capillary contribution is approximately two orders of magnitude smaller. (e) Mean odd-capillary power , viscous dissipation , and even capillary power versus . The dotted line indicates the scaling . The ratio . (f) Probability density functions of the local odd-capillary power , normalized by its root-mean-square value, for , , and .
for , where is the characteristic arrested domain size. The scale-by-scale energy balance reveals that is predominantly positive, demonstrating that odd capillarity injects mechanical energy directly into the fluid across a range of scales [Figure 2(d)]. The injected energy is balanced primarily by viscous dissipation , while the nonlinear advective transfer is negligible. The even capillary contribution is comparatively weak and changes sign with wavenumber, while the nonlinear advective transfer is negligible. In the non-equilibrium stationary state, , so Eq. 9 gives . Since the even capillary contribution is comparatively small, , indicating that energy injected by odd capillarity is dissipated predominantly at the same scales by viscosity, without appreciable transfer through an inertial cascade.
Since the advective transfer only redistributes energy among scales, for incompressible periodic flow, summing Eq. 9 over all wavenumbers recovers the global kinetic-energy balance Eq. 7a, with , , , and . Figure 2(e) shows the time-averaged terms in the non-equilibrium steady state. We find and , which indicates that odd capillarity injects kinetic energy globally, while the even capillary force converts a small fraction of it into composition free energy, . This fraction balances diffusive dissipation, , as required by the free-energy balance [Eq. 7b]. The remainder is dissipated by viscosity, so that . The mean odd capillary power scales as . Although odd capillarity injects energy on average, the local power density fluctuates between positive and negative values. Its probability density exhibits tails of both signs, with a stronger positive tail [Figure 2(f)]. The distributions broaden with increasing , indicating increasingly pronounced relative fluctuations in local energy transfer. Thus, odd capillarity acts as a net energy source while locally both injecting and extracting kinetic energy. In contrast to externally sustained interface-induced turbulence in viscous binary fluids [38], the present turbulent dynamics are powered directly by parity-odd stresses at evolving fluid interfaces.
Arrested droplet growth and hyperuniformity: Having established coarsening arrest and sustained fluid motion in symmetric mixtures, we now examine phase separation in asymmetric mixtures with and . Figure 3(a) shows a representative composition field for and , revealing a dynamically evolving droplet-rich state. Unlike passive binary-fluid mixtures, where droplets grow through Ostwald ripening and coalescence, odd capillarity interrupts their continued growth. Although smaller droplets shrink and disappear while larger ones grow through Ostwald ripening, the latter undergo interfacial instabilities that lead to deformation and breakup. The associated velocity fields [Figure 3(b) and (c)] reveal strong tangential flows near the droplet interfaces, which also hinder coalescence between neighboring droplets. Thus, the competition between diffusive growth, coalescence, and odd capillarity driven breakup maintains a dynamically arrested droplet-rich state.
Figure 3. Arrested droplet growth and hyperuniformity. All results are for . (a) Representative pseudocolor plot of the composition field for at . (b) Corresponding pseudocolor plot of the velocity magnitude , overlaid with velocity vectors. (c) Magnified view of an individual droplet in (b), highlighting the interfacial flow and velocity vectors. (d) Time evolution of the spatially averaged kinetic energy for , , , , , and . (e) Time-averaged vorticity spectral density for different , showing suppressed long-wavelength fluctuations and the emergence of hyperuniformity. The reference slopes indicate the scalings , , and . (f) Time-averaged composition spectral density for the same values of . The reference slopes and illustrate the transition from nonhyperuniform to hyperuniform composition fluctuations. The color legend in (e) applies to (d)–(f).
Figure 3(d) shows that the mean kinetic energy approaches a statistically stationary state for different . Its temporal fluctuations become progressively weaker with increasing , accompanied by increasingly localized flows associated with individual droplets. To characterize the resulting large-scale vorticity fluctuations, we examine its hyperuniformity, which is characterized by anomalously suppressed large scale fluctuations [39]. We consider the time-averaged spectral density of the vorticity field, , defined as , where is the number of Fourier modes in the shell . In two dimensions, [40], which relates the vorticity spectral density to the kinetic-energy spectrum. For symmetric mixtures (), we find at small wavenumbers [Fig. 3(e)], consistent with discussed earlier [Fig. 2(c)]. With increasing , this scaling gives way to two distinct regimes, at smaller wavenumbers and at relatively higher wavenumbers. These positive exponents indicate hyperuniform vorticity fluctuations, with increasingly strong suppression at large scales.
The composition field also exhibits a marked change in its large-scale fluctuations. Figure 3(f) shows the time-averaged spectral density , defined analogously to . For symmetric mixtures, at small wavenumbers, indicating nonhyperuniform composition fluctuations. In contrast, the droplet-rich states exhibit , revealing the emergence of composition hyperuniformity. As vortical flows become increasingly localized around individual droplets, their spatial arrangement influences the large-scale distribution of vorticity, providing a physical connection between the hyperuniformity of the composition and vorticity fields. Hydrodynamically interrupted droplet growth has also been reported in Active Model H with contractile interfacial stresses [41]. However, such activity can suppress composition hyperuniformity and produce anti-hyperuniform vorticity fluctuations, [25]. In contrast, odd capillarity arrests droplet growth while promoting composition hyperuniformity and suppressing large-scale vorticity fluctuations.
Conclusions and outlook: We have shown that capillarity admits a parity-odd counterpart, odd capillarity, through which fluid interfaces generate transverse forces and sustain non-equilibrium motion. We introduced this response within the CHNS equations by supplementing the ordinary Korteweg stress with a symmetric, parity-odd capillary stress. The resulting localized force-dipole structure drives interfacial shear flows that, in turn, deform and reorganize the interfaces themselves. This feedback fundamentally changes phase separation, progressively slowing and ultimately arresting coarsening.
We have identified a sustained energy-transfer cycle underlying coarsening arrest. Odd-capillarity stresses inject kinetic energy into the fluid, most of which is dissipated by viscosity, while a smaller fraction is transferred through ordinary capillary stresses to replenish the composition free energy lost through diffusion. This energy transfer sustains interfacial rearrangements and prevents continued domain growth. We have further demonstrated that the arrested state exhibits odd-capillary-driven turbulence, characterized by persistent kinetic-energy fluctuations and broadband kinetic energy spectra.
Our scale-by-scale analysis reveals that energy injection is predominantly balanced by viscous dissipation at the same scales, with negligible inertial transfer. In asymmetric mixtures, the same interfacial feedback interrupts droplet growth: although Ostwald ripening persists, growing droplets deform and break under odd-capillarity forcing, while tangential interfacial flows hinder coalescence. The resulting dynamically arrested droplet-rich states exhibit composition hyperuniformity and strongly suppressed large-scale vorticity fluctuations.
Odd capillarity opens new possibilities for revisiting classical capillary phenomena in systems with broken parity. Unlike chiral surface waves arising from bulk odd viscosity [42] or odd slip at chiral active boundaries [43], parity breaking here enters directly through the capillary stress. A natural next step is to develop a systematic sharp-interface theory to establish the mechanisms of interfacial deformation and instability. Such a theory would provide a foundation for exploring whether odd capillarity can destabilize interfaces even in the absence of inertia, how it modifies capillary waves and Rayleigh–Plateau breakup [44], and how it interacts with external forces. In particular, the motion of rising or falling droplets under gravity presents an intriguing problem, complementing studies of deformable droplets with bulk odd viscosity [45]. Deriving odd capillarity from microscopic models of chiral active constituents remains an open challenge. Coarse-graining approaches that have yielded interfacial tension and odd surface flows [19] and odd transport coefficients [46] for chiral active particles offer natural routes. Experiments provide different routes to generating chiral flows near fluid interfaces. In a colloidal fluid driven by external torques, the particles develop persistent edge flows, while the free surface exhibits waves and instabilities [47]. Another possibility involves motile constituents interacting directly with fluid interfaces. Bacteria adsorbed at oil–water interfaces can drive droplet rotation, with angular speed decreasing with droplet size [48]. Bacteria trapped at fluid interfaces also exhibit circular swimming trajectories [49] and generate localized hydrodynamic force dipoles [50]. These observations motivate investigating whether microscopic chirality can produce the parity-odd interfacial stress proposed here, providing a possible experimental route to odd capillarity. These observations suggest possible experimental routes to odd capillarity, although whether microscopic chirality generates the proposed parity-odd interfacial stress remains to be established. Incorporating substrate friction, which is relevant to many experimental systems, would extend our model to settings with momentum loss. More broadly, from ordinary surface tension in passive fluids to negative mechanical tension in active fluids [41], capillarity has acquired new roles in interfacial dynamics. Odd capillarity introduces a distinct possibility: fluid interfaces that retain their ordinary surface tension while generating handed, tangential flows that inject mechanical energy and organize the surrounding fluid.
Acknowledgments: We acknowledges the support by the German Research Foundation (DFG) through the project “Analysing structure–property relations in equilibrium and non-equilibrium hyperuniform systems” (project number VO 899/32-1). We further acknowledge computing resources at JSC under grant ”MORPH” and at ZIH under grant ”WIR”.
Tangential force-dipole structure of odd capillarity
To characterize the interfacial forcing generated by the odd stress, consider a planar interface parallel to the -axis, with . For , the odd stress reduces to
Its divergence yields a purely tangential force density,
For the equilibrium diffuse-interface profile , this becomes
The force density is antisymmetric with respect to the interface. Its zeroth moment vanishes, whereas its first normal moment remains finite:
The latter follows by integration by parts and the identity . Thus, the odd stress produces a localized tangential force-dipole layer with zero resultant force and a nonzero first moment.
Derivation of the energy balances
We derive the kinetic-, free-, and total-energy balances [Eqs. (7)] for incompressible flow with periodic boundary conditions. The derivation also applies to boundary conditions for which the corresponding boundary terms vanish. We define the spatial average as
The mean kinetic energy, mean free energy, and total mean energy are
where the density is constant and set to . The chemical potential is defined by .
Free-energy balance. Since , the time derivative of the mean free energy is
Substituting the Cahn–Hilliard equation,
gives
where we have used incompressibility, periodicity, and integration by parts. The ordinary capillary force appearing in the Navier–Stokes equation is . Its mean mechanical power is
Equivalently, since and differ only by a gradient, whose mechanical work vanishes for incompressible periodic flow,
Defining the nonnegative diffusive dissipation rate as
we obtain
Kinetic-energy balance. Multiplying the Navier–Stokes equation [Eq. (2)] by and taking the spatial average gives
where the nonlinear advective contribution vanishes because
Likewise, the pressure term vanishes:
For constant viscosity, integration by parts gives
where . We therefore define the positive viscous dissipation rate as
The mechanical power supplied by the odd capillary force is
Collecting the contributions, the kinetic-energy balance becomes
Total-energy balance. Adding Eqs. (B9) and (B16), the ordinary capillary power cancels exactly between the kinetic- and free-energy balances. Thus,
This recovers the total-energy balance in Eq. (7c). The ordinary capillary force mediates energy exchange between the fluid motion and the composition field, whereas the odd capillary stress contributes an independent, sign-indefinite power to the total-energy budget. For , the odd power vanishes, and the total mean energy satisfies
recovering the dissipative structure of passive Cahn–Hilliard–Navier–Stokes dynamics.
Spectral kinetic-energy balance
We derive the scale-by-scale kinetic-energy balance used in the main text, following the spectral-transfer framework for Cahn–Hilliard–Navier–Stokes turbulence [30, 35, 38]. For constant density , the incompressible Navier–Stokes equation is
where and . The ordinary capillary force is equivalent to up to a gradient, which does not contribute to the kinetic-energy balance of incompressible periodic flow.
For an periodic grid, we define the normalized discrete Fourier coefficients as
The same convention applies to all other fields. Here is the physical wavevector for a square domain of side . The Fourier-transformed momentum equation can be written as
where
is the incompressible projection operator for . It removes the pressure contribution and ensures that .
The shell-integrated kinetic-energy spectrum is
where denotes a wavenumber shell of width . Multiplying Eq. (36) by , taking the real part, and summing over the shell gives
The nonlinear advective transfer is
The ordinary and odd capillary contributions are
The viscous dissipation spectrum is
Direct Numerical Simulations
We solve the coupled Cahn–Hilliard–Navier–Stokes equations using a Fourier pseudospectral method in a two-dimensional periodic square domain , following the numerical framework of Ref. [25]. To eliminate the pressure, we rewrite the incompressible momentum equation in the vorticity–streamfunction formulation,
where is the scalar vorticity. The streamfunction satisfies
which automatically enforces .
The composition, vorticity, and streamfunction fields are represented by truncated Fourier series,
where is the Fourier wavevector, and the sum extends over all resolved Fourier modes. The evolution equations in Fourier space become
where and . The chemical potential is
The velocity is reconstructed from for , with the zero mode of the streamfunction set to zero. Spatial derivatives are evaluated spectrally, while nonlinear products and capillary forcing are computed in physical space and transformed back to Fourier space. The coupled equations are advanced using the second-order exponential time-differencing Runge–Kutta method (ET-DRK2) [51], which treats the linear dissipative operators exactly and the remaining nonlinear contributions explicitly. We implement the Fourier pseudospectral solver in CUDA C, with GPU-optimized routines for the numerical operations. All simulations are performed on NVIDIA GPUs, including the H100 architecture.
Throughout our simulations, we fix the parameters , , , , and . We define the Reynolds number as , where and is the characteristic coarsening length in the statistically stationary state. For , 4, and 10, we obtain , 0.23, and 0.28, respectively, confirming that the arrested states occur at low Reynolds numbers.
References
References
- [1]P.-G. Gennes, F. Brochard-Wyart, D. Quéré, et al., Capillarity and wetting phenomena: drops, bubbles, pearls, waves (Springer, 2004).
- [2]Y. Pomeau and E. Villermaux, Physics Today 59, 39 (2006).
- [3]E. D. Siggia, Physical review A 20, 595 (1979).
- [4]A. A. Hyman, C. A. Weber, and F. Jülicher, Annual Review of Cell and Developmental Biology 30, 39 (2014).
- [5]D. Bonn, J. Eggers, J. Indekeu, J. Meunier, and E. Rolley, Reviews of modern physics 81, 739 (2009).
- [6]J. Eggers, Reviews of modern physics 69, 865 (1997).
- [7]J. Eggers, J. R. Lister, and H. A. Stone, Journal of Fluid Mechanics 401, 293 (1999).
- [8]M. J. Lighthill and J. Lighthill, Waves in fluids (Cambridge university press, 2001).
- [9]P. C. Hohenberg and B. I. Halperin, Reviews of Modern Physics 49, 435 (1977).
- [10]D. Jacqmin, Journal of computational physics 155, 96 (1999).
- [11]H. Abels, Archive for rational mechanics and analysis 194, 463 (2009).
- [12]M. E. Cates and E. Tjhung, Journal of Fluid Mechanics 836, P1 (2018).
- [13]N. B. Padhan and R. Pandit, Journal of Fluid Mechanics 1010, P1 (2025).
- [14]J. Avron, Journal of statistical physics 92, 543 (1998).
- [15]D. Banerjee, A. Souslov, A. G. Abanov, and V. Vitelli, Nature communications 8, 1573 (2017).
- [16]C. Scheibner, A. Souslov, D. Banerjee, P. Surowka, W. T. Irvine, and V. Vitelli, Nature Physics 16, 475 (2020).
- [17]L. Braverman, C. Scheibner, B. VanSaders, and V. Vitelli, Physical review letters 127, 268001 (2021).
- [18]M. Fruchart, C. Scheibner, and V. Vitelli, Annual Review of Condensed Matter Physics 14, 471 (2023).
- [19]L. Langford and A. K. Omar, Physical Review Letters 134, 068301 (2025).
- [20]S. Burekovic, S. Kole, A. Maitra, and C. Nardini, arXiv preprint arXiv:2607.12045 (2026).arxiv.org/abs/2607.12045
- [21]B. Wang, P. Pietzonka, and F. Jülicher, arXiv preprint arXiv:2603.20064 (2026).arxiv.org/abs/2603.20064
- [22]K. Blom and U. Thiele, arXiv preprint arXiv:2607.27305 (2026).arxiv.org/abs/2607.27305
- [23]A. Tiribocchi, R. Wittkowski, D. Marenduzzo, and M. E. Cates, Physical review letters 115, 188302 (2015).
- [24]S. J. Kole, G. P. Alexander, S. Ramaswamy, and A. Maitra, Phys. Rev. Lett. 126, 248001 (2021).
- [25]N. B. Padhan and A. Voigt, Journal of Physics: Condensed Matter 37, 105101 (2025).
- [26]S. Berti, G. Boffetta, M. Cencini, and A. Vulpiani, Phys. Rev. Lett. 95, 224501 (2005).
- [27]P. Perlekar, R. Benzi, H. J. H. Clercx, D. R. Nelson, and F. Toschi, Phys. Rev. Lett. 112, 014502 (2014).
- [28]P. Perlekar, N. Pal, and R. Pandit, Scientific Reports 7, 44589 (2017).
- [29]A. Tiribocchi, R. Wittkowski, D. Marenduzzo, and M. E. Cates, Phys. Rev. Lett. 115, 188302 (2015).
- [30]N. B. Padhan, K. V. Kiran, and R. Pandit, Soft Matter 20, 3620 (2024).
- [31]F. Caballero and M. C. Marchetti, Phys. Rev. Lett. 129, 268002 (2022).
- [32]R. Backofen and A. Voigt, arXiv preprint arXiv:2601.15001 (2026).arxiv.org/abs/2601.15001
- [33]B. Maji, N. B. Padhan, and R. Pandit, Communications Physics 8, 488 (2025).
- [34]B. Maji, N. B. Padhan, A. Voigt, and R. Pandit, arXiv preprint arXiv:2602.06928 (2026).arxiv.org/abs/2602.06928
- [35]P. Perlekar, Journal of Fluid Mechanics 873, 459 (2019).
- [36][36*] A. Alexakis and L. Biferale, Physics Reports 767, 1 [37] M. K. Verma, Energy transfers in fluid flows: multiscale and spectral perspectives (Cambridge University Press, 2019).
- [38]N. B. Padhan, D. Vincenzi, and R. Pandit, Phys. Rev. Fluids 9, L122401 (2024).
- [39]S. Torquato, Physics Reports 745, 1 (2018).
- [40]R. Backofen, A. Y. Altawil, M. Salvalaglio, and A. Voigt, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 121, e2320719121 (2024).
- [41]R. Singh and M. E. Cates, Phys. Rev. Lett. 123, 148005 (2019).
- [42]A. G. Abanov, T. Can, and S. Ganeshan, SciPost Phys. 010 (2018).
- [43]Y. Hosaka and A. Vilfan, arXiv preprint arXiv:2609.17005 (2026).DOI
- [44]B. Barker, J. B. Bell, and A. L. Garcia, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 120, e2306088120 (2023).
- [45]H. França and M. Jalaal, Phys. Rev. Res. 8, 033140 (2026).
- [46]R. Maire, A. Petrini, U. Marini Bettolo Marconi, and L. Caprini, The Journal of Chemical Physics 165 (2026).
- [47]V. Soni, E. S. Billigin, S. Magkiriadou, S. Saccanna, D. Bartolo, M. J. Shelley, and W. T. Irvine, Nature physics 15, 1188 (2019).
- [48]N. K. Dewangan and J. C. Conrad, Soft Matter 15, 9368 (2019).
- [49]J. Deng, M. Molaei, N. G. Chisholm, and K. J. Stebe, Langmuir 36, 6888 (2020).
- [50]J. Deng, M. Molaei, N. G. Chisholm, and K. J. Stebe, Journal of Fluid Mechanics 976, A18 (2023).
- [51]S. M. Cox and P. C. Matthews, Journal of Computational Physics 176, 430 (2002).


