betaFeedback

WorksPhysics and Astronomy

Nonlinear Hall Effects induced by Berry Curvature Dipole in CuPb9_9(PO4_4)6_6O

Abstract

The nonlinear Hall effect (NLHE), an emergent response in systems with broken inversion symmetry, provides a powerful tool for probing topological transport properties. In this context, we investigate copper-substituted lead apatite (LK-99), a material that initially garnered attention for its controversial claim of room-temperature superconductivity. Despite the unresolved nature of its superconducting properties, LK-99's unique electronic structure characterized by flat bands near the Fermi level and broken inversion symmetry makes it a promising candidate for exploring Berry curvature-driven phenomena, such as the NLHE. Using first-principles density functional theory and an augmented tight-binding Hamiltonian model, we investigate LK-99's band topology and transport properties. Our calculations indicate that spin-orbit coupling in LK-99 generates multiple Weyl points near the Fermi level, thereby enhancing the Berry curvature distribution by further splitting the bands. Crucially, the absence of inversion symmetry in LK-99 leads to a net Berry curvature dipole, producing a nonlinear Hall current that scales quadratically with the applied electric field. The nonlinear Hall effect is solely due to the BCD, as the contributions from the Drude weight and quantum metric are zero due to time reversal symmetry. Moreover, we demonstrate that the NLHE in LK-99 can be tuned by varying the direction of the applied electric field, underscoring its potential as a versatile platform for exploring topological transport phenomena and designing next-generation nonlinear electronic devices.

Introduction

The nonlinear Hall effect (NLHE) is a second-order response in time-reversal-invariant systems, where a transverse voltage is generated in response to the square of an applied electric field [1, 2]. Unlike the conventional Hall effect, which relies on an external magnetic field, the NLHE arises intrinsically from the Berry curvature dipole (BCD) a dipolar distribution of Berry curvature in momentum space [3]. This phenomenon is of great interest due to its potential applications in next-generation electronic devices, such as rectifiers and energy harvesters, as well as its ability to probe the topological properties of materials. NLHE offers a powerful probe of inversion symmetry breaking and topological transport, linking electronic structure to Berry curvature. Notably, it enables a transverse voltage without the need for an external magnetic field, in both metals and insulators. This intrinsic, symmetry-driven response holds promise for applications in modulators, photodetectors, and light-emitting diodes, as well as high-sensitivity strain sensors and wireless radio frequency rectifiers [4, 5]. Due to its sensitivity to crystal geometry, the NLHE also provides insight into topological phase transitions and quantum geometric properties, with emerging relevance in energy harvesting and current rectification technologies [3, 6, 7, 8]. Recent studies have identified materials with low crystal symmetry, such as transition metal dichalcogenides [9, 10, 11, 12], Weyl semimetals [13], and topological insulators [14], as promising candidates for exhibiting prominent nonlinear Hall responses.

Among these, Weyl semimetals have emerged as particularly fascinating systems for investigating the nonlinear Hall effect. As topological materials with broken inversion or time-reversal symmetry, Weyl semimetals feature Berry curvature concentrated around Weyl nodes—band-touching points in momentum space [15]. The unique electronic structure of Weyl semimetals, combined with their low crystal symmetries, makes them ideal platforms for realizing a substantial BCD [8, 16, 17, 18, 19]. Furthermore, the tunability of Weyl semimetals via external perturbations, such as strain, electric fields, or chemical doping, provides a versatile route to engineer and optimize their nonlinear Hall response [20, 21]. These properties not only deepen our understanding of topological transport phenomena but also position Weyl semimetals as candidates for next-generation electronic and optoelectronic devices.

In this context, LK-99, a copper-substituted lead apatite (CuPb9(PO4)6O\mathrm{CuPb}_{9}(\mathrm{PO}_{4})_{6}\mathrm{O}), presents a compelling case. Initially proposed as a room-temperature ambient-pressure superconductor, LK-99 generated significant excitement in the scientific community [22, 23]. The claim was supported by experimental evidence, including zero resistivity, the critical temperature, and the Meissner effect. However, repeated attempts to reproduce these results were unsuccessful, raising doubts about the superconductivity claim [24, 25, 26, 27, 28, 29, 30, 31, 32, 33]. Despite this setback, LK-99 remains a material of interest due to its unique electronic structure, particularly the presence of flat bands near the Fermi level with multiple degeneracies as reported by the various first-principles based calculations [34, 35, 36, 37, 38, 39, 40, 41, 42, 43, 44].

These flat bands, combined with inversion symmetry breaking and spin-orbit coupling (SOC) effects due to the heavy Pb atoms, suggest that LK-99 may exhibit topological features akin to those observed in Weyl semimetals. Firstprinciple calculations indicate that SOC can split the flat bands, leading to Weyl-like crossings near the Fermi level. This electronic structure creates conditions for an unequal distribution of Berry curvature, making LK-99 a promising candidate for studying nonlinear Hall effects. The ability to manipulate these features through strain, chemical doping, or electric fields further enhances its potential for exploring topological transport phenomena and designing nonlinear electronic devices. Recent advancements in Weyl physics and correlated metallic states further emphasize the relevance of studying the unique electronic structure of LK-99 within this framework [45, 46, 47, 48]. Additionally, the successful experimental synthesis and confirmation of dynamic stability through phonon band calculations reinforce the importance of investigating these properties in greater detail [42, 49].

In this study, we investigate the nonlinear Hall effects in LK-99 using first-principle calculations, focusing on the role of inversion symmetry breaking and Berry curvature distribution. The lack of inversion symmetry leads to an asymmetric distribution of Berry curvature, resulting in a nonzero Berry curvature dipole (BCD). Notably, the BCD exhibits peaks at the locations of Weyl points, which play a crucial role in generating the nonlinear Hall current. For the confirmation of the origin of the non linear Hall current we also calculated the contribution from the quantum metric (QM) dipole, as the contribution from quantum metric is prominent in the systems that breaks both the time reversal and inversion symmetry like CuMnAs [50], MnBi2_2Te4_4 [51, 52] and some altermagnets [53]. Furthermore, the nonlinear Hall current can be tuned by altering the direction of the applied electric field, offering a means to control topological transport behavior. By drawing parallels with Weyl semimetals, we aim to provide deeper insight into LK-99’s topological and transport properties.

The structure of this paper is organized as follows. Section II provides an overview of the crystal structure and the methodologies utilized in this study. Section III details the results and conclusions, focusing on the electronic and topological properties examined through density functional theory (DFT) and an enhanced tight-binding model, along with an analysis of nonlinear Hall effects.

Crystal structure and Methods

The original crystal structure of lead hydroxyapatite Pb10_{10}(PO4_4)6_6(OH)2_2 was initially determined through powder X-ray diffraction by Bruckner et al. in 1995 [54]. This crystal is categorized under space group 176 (P63_3/m), which features an inversion center. There are two sites (Pb(I) and Pb(II)) for the Pb atom, which forms a hexagonal crystal sublattice. As one of the Pb(I) sites is replaced by Cu, the substituted Cu is not mapped to itself under inversion. Moreover, in the model we are using, the fractional site occupancy is removed for the Oxygen and hydroxide groups, lowering the symmetry to 143. Thus the structure is non-centrosymmetric and based on a trigonal Bravais lattice. The structure forms a complex network with central atoms Cu, P, and Pb forming polyhedra with O as shown in Figure 1. The selected lattice parameters are as follows: a = b = 9.80 Å, c = 7.34 Å, and α = β = 90°, while γ = 120°. We employed the full potential local orbital (FPLO) code version 22.00, as outlined in the work by Koeppernik and Eschrig in 1999 [55], to carry out calculations using density functional theory (DFT). The Perdew, Burke, and Ernzerhof (PBE-96) parametrization of the generalized gradient approximation (GGA) was utilized to compute the exchange and correlation energy [56]. Our approach involved self-consistent calculations conducted in the four-component fully relativistic mode of FPLO. The basis sets encompassed valence states for Cu [3s, 3p, 4s, 5s, 3d, 4d, 5d], Pb [5s, 5p, 5d, 6s, 6p, 6d, 6p, 7p], P [2s, 2p, 3s, 4s, 3p, 4p, 3d] and O [1s, 2s, 3s,2p, 3p, 3d]. For Brillouin zone sampling, we employed a k-mesh subdivision of 8 × 8 × 10. The energy convergence criteria is set to be 10−5^{-5} Ha and the charge density convergence criteria is 10−4^{-4} e/(Bohr radii)3^3. Maximally localized Wannier functions were generated from self-consistent, fully relativistic DFT band structures using the PYFPLO module of the FPLO code. The localized Wannier basis consists of Cu [3d3z2_{3z^2}, 3dxz_{xz}] orbitals. The Wannier model was constructed using the same k-mesh as in the self-consistent calculations. The resulting Wannier Hamiltonians were employed to interpolate the band structure on a 200 × 200 × 200 k-point grid and to identify Weyl points, utilizing the PYFPLO module for this purpose. To compute BCD wannierberri package has been utilized [57].

Crystal structure of LK-99 and Brillouin zone

Figure 1. (a) Crystal Structure of LK-99 consisting of oxygen (red), lead (yellow), phosphorus (black) and copper (blue) atoms. (b) Structure seen in a-b plane with Cu forming polyhedra with O. (c) Structure seen in a-b plane with Pb forming polyhedra with O. (d) Brilloun zone (BZ) with high symmmetry points. The chosen points are Γ(0,0,0)\Gamma(0,0,0), M(0.577,0,0)(0.577,0,0), K(0.577,1/3,0)(0.577,1/3,0), A(0,0,0.688)(0,0,0.688), L(0.577,0,0.668)(0.577,0,0.668) and H(0,0,0.688)(0,0,0.688) in the units of (2π/a,2π/b,2π/c)(2\pi/a, 2\pi/b, 2\pi/c). (e) Structure seen in a-b plane with P forming tetrahedra with O.

RESULTS AND DISCUSSION

Electronic Features

We begin by investigating the electronic structure of LK-99 through an analysis of the density of states and band features. Figure 2(a) depicts the total density of states, indicating that the system is metallic due to a prominent peak at the Fermi level. This peak resembles a Van Hove singularity (VHS) and is followed by a relative scarcity of states in the positive energy range up to 3.1 eV. In contrast, the density of states is notably richer below the Fermi level.

Electronic structure of LK-99

Figure 2. Electronic structure of LK-99. The Fermi level is set to zero energy. (a) Total density of states and partial density of states of Cu-3d in the units of per eV per unit cell. (b) Fat band analysis that includes the contribution from the Cu-3dyz3d_{yz} and Cu-3dxz3d_{xz} orbitals. The numbering is in the order of the band energy at each k-point. (c) Density of states of the individual atoms of the system. (d) Fermi surface of the four bands that contribute to the Fermi level. The color bar shows the band velocity.

The presence of the VHS is linked to the existence of flat bands near the Fermi level, primarily contributed by Cu orbitals.

Among the five d orbitals, the most significant contribution to this density is by Cu-3dyz3d_{yz} and Cu-3dxz3d_{xz}, as indicated by the thickness of the lines in Figure 2(b). Here, the thickness of the lines represents the sum of the squares of coefficients associated with the basis states used in the expansion of the Kohn-Sham wavefunction into localized orbitals. We see isolated flat bands near the Fermi level, which are the result of the VHS peak in the density of states in Figure 2(b). These flat characteristics of the band have been shown from the minimal model as in Ref [37]. This flatness of the bands is more prominent when the Hubbard U potential is taken into account, as done in the Ref [38]. Below these bands, the O-2p2p orbitals seem to dominate over the Cu-3d3d orbitals. Most of the transport phenomena of the system are governed by these two bands due to their low energy states; therefore, the rest of our discussion focuses on the features of these bands.

The Fermi surfaces (FSs) plot, which includes the effects of spin-orbit coupling (SOC), is shown in Figure 2(d). Four bands contribute to the FS: bands 1, 2, and 3 create flat, electron pocket-like FSs, while the fourth band generates an open FS that spans the entire Brillouin zone (BZ). Incorporating the effects of SOC yields significant changes in the band structure, as demonstrated in Figure 3(b) and (d). In the absence of SOC, two isolated bands are initially positioned near the Fermi level. There are two degenerate points present at the high symmetry points Γ\Gamma and A, as indicated by the arrows in Figure 3(a). These points were proposed based on symmetry arguments in tight-binding models [46, 47] and were shown to carry Weyl charge ±2\pm2. Upon activation of spin-orbit coupling, these two bands split into four distinct bands. Notably, the introduction of SOC leads to the creation of multiple doubly degenerate points. At the Γ\Gamma point, we see two doubly degenerate points with a small gap in between them. The degeneracies at Γ\Gamma point is between the Kramer's pair {∣+↑⟩\{|+ \uparrow\rangle and ∣+↓⟩}|+ \downarrow\rangle\}, {∣−↑⟩\{|- \uparrow\rangle and ∣−↓⟩}|- \downarrow\rangle\}. Other symmetry-protected double degeneracies are also observed at the high symmetry points M, A, and L.

Comparison of electronic band structure with and without SOC

Figure 3. Comparison of electronic band structure with and without SOC. a) Isolated bands near the Fermi level without considering SOC. Arrows highlight double degeneracies at Γ\Gamma and AA protected by C3zC_{3z} and spinless time-reversal symmetry. b) Splitting of the bands after consideration of the case of spin orbit coupling. The arrows in the band indicate the doubly degenerate points at the high symmetry points. c) Zoomed-in view of the region Γ\Gamma-AA without SOC d) Zoomed-in view of the region Γ\Gamma-AA with SOC.

Intriguingly, the high symmetry line Γ\Gamma-A experiences distinctive behavior. Four doubly degenerate points (labeled as w1, w2, s1, and s2) emerge when SOC is considered, as depicted in Figure 3(d). Among these points, w1 is the mixing between the states {∣+↓⟩\{|+ \downarrow\rangle, ∣−↑⟩}|- \uparrow\rangle\} and w2 as a crossing point between {∣+↑⟩\{|+ \uparrow\rangle, ∣−↓⟩}|- \downarrow\rangle\}. Point s1 signifies the mixing between {∣+↑⟩\{|+ \uparrow\rangle, ∣−↑⟩}|- \uparrow\rangle\}, while point s2 represents the crossing between {∣+↓⟩\{|+ \downarrow\rangle, ∣−↓⟩}|- \downarrow\rangle\}. Here, we see that w1 and w2 are the result of mixing between different orbitals and different spins, while s1 and s2 are the result of mixing between different orbitals with the same spin states. The nomenclature is based on an analysis of the tight-binding model, which shows that w1 and w2 are Weyl points while s1 and s2 are points on nodal surfaces. To verify them and study their topological invariants, we modified the Hamiltonian by Zhou and Franz [47].

Comparison with other first-principles computations

Within the framework of GGA+SOC in a non-magnetic state, our investigation examines the material system’s band structure, revealing distinct topological Weyl features. Simultaneously, an alternative study utilizing DFT and a minimal model Hamiltonian without SOC suggests the presence of double Weyl nodes at high symmetry points Γ\Gamma and Z [46]. It is noteworthy that our study specifically excludes the incorporation of the Hubbard-U potential. Despite this omission, the semiconductor characteristics of the system are highlighted [34]. Additionally, first-principle calculations still indicate a ferromagnetic behavior within the system, with a magnetic moment of 1μB1\mu_B per unit cell [58]. Also, there is a claim that the system shows Mott-insulating-like features from dynamic mean field calculations [59].

Augmented tight-binding model

Initially, without considering SOC, our DFT band matches the band from theoretical calculations. But, after consideration of SOC, we see the differences in the band structure. Our results show four doubly degenerate points between Γ\Gamma-ZZ, while their results show only two. The model Hamiltonian with spin-orbit coupling, which they have adapted for band structure:

H=H0+HSOC(1)H = H_0 + H_{\mathrm{SOC}} \tag*{(1)}

Here, H0H_0 is the symmetry based realistic two-band tight binding model and HSOCH_{\mathrm{SOC}} is the spin orbit coupling term, which has the form,

HSOC=λ2τz⊗σz(2)H_{\mathrm{SOC}} = \frac{\lambda}{2}\tau_z \otimes\sigma_z \tag*{(2)}

λ\lambda being the strength of spin orbit coupling term and τz\tau_z as orbital degrees of freedom and σz\sigma_z as spin degrees of freedom. The chosen basis sets are:

{∣+,↑⟩,∣+,↓⟩,∣−,↑⟩,∣−,↓⟩}\{|+,\uparrow\rangle, |+,\downarrow\rangle, |-,\uparrow\rangle, |-,\downarrow\rangle\}.

Using this Hamiltonian, we observe only two points of intersection when moving along the Γ\Gamma-Z direction, which disagrees with our DFT results, where we see four crossings. To address this discrepancy, we have introduced an additional term in HSOCH_{\mathrm{SOC}}, λ′cos⁡(kzc)\lambda'\cos(k_zc), which preserves all the symmetries of the original model, cc being the lattice constant in the zz direction. Physically, it accounts for the nearest neighbor hopping in the zz-direction between the Cu-dd orbitals. Thus, HSOCH_{\mathrm{SOC}} now takes the form,

HSOC=(λ2+λ′cos⁡(kzc))τz⊗σz(3)H_{\mathrm{SOC}}=\left(\frac{\lambda}{2}+\lambda'\cos(k_zc)\right)\tau_z\otimes\sigma_z \tag*{(3)}

The additional term in the Hamiltonian switches the eigenstates {∣+,↑⟩,∣+,↓⟩}\{|+,\uparrow\rangle,|+,\downarrow\rangle\} and {∣−,↓⟩,∣−,↑⟩}\{|-,\downarrow\rangle,|-,\uparrow\rangle\} while evolving along kzk_z. This generates four doubly degenerated crossings in the band structure. This is presented in Figure 4(c).

Band structures and vector diagram

Figure 4. a) Band structure from the modified model Hamiltonian without inclusion of SOC (λ=λ′=0\lambda=\lambda'=0) along Γ\Gamma-Z. b) Band structure from the modified model Hamiltonian with inclusion of SOC (λ≠0\lambda\ne0, λ′=0\lambda'=0) along Γ\Gamma-Z. c) Band structure from the modified model Hamiltonian with inclusion of SOC (λ≠0\lambda\ne0, λ′≠0\lambda'\ne0) along Γ\Gamma-Z. d) Vector diagram for V=(fx,fy)\mathbf{V}=(f_x,f_y) around kxk_x and kyk_y.

The low energy Hamiltonian around the points w1w_1 and w2w_2 are described by the following Hamiltonian:

Hw1,w2=a(kx2−ky2)τx+2akxkyτy+bkzτz+ckz2τz(4)H_{w_1,w_2}=a(k_x^2-k_y^2)\tau_x+2ak_xk_y\tau_y+bk_z\tau_z+ck_z^2\tau_z \tag*{(4)}

The Hamiltonian takes the form,

Hw1,w2=fxτx+fyτy+fzτz(5)H_{w_1,w_2}=f_x\tau_x+f_y\tau_y+f_z\tau_z \tag*{(5)}

We define the winding vector V=(fx,fy)\mathbf{V}=(f_x,f_y) which is linear in third direction so choosing the dispersion in kx−kyk_x-k_y plane is sufficient to define the Chern number for the above Hamiltonian (See Appendix § 4.1). The vector V=(fx,fy)\mathbf{V}=(f_x,f_y) simply makes ±4π\pm4\pi rotation while coming back to original position in kx−kyk_x-k_y plane along a loop shown in Figure 4(d), thus the topological invariant Chern number of the node is given by,

Cw1,w2=2sgn⁡(a)sgn⁡(b)(6)C_{w_1,w_2}=2\operatorname{sgn}(a)\operatorname{sgn}(b) \tag*{(6)}

Hence, Cw1=2C_{w_1}=2 and Cw2=−2C_{w_2}=-2 verifies the points w1 and w2 to be double Weyl points. The details of the numerical parameters of aa, bb, cc are presented in supplementary Table I.

WPabcChern(C)
w1-0.0065-0.044-0.0152
w2-0.0250.2560.0045-2

Table I. Numerical parameters for the low energy Hamiltonian at different Weyl crossing points

Similarly, the low energy Hamiltonian at the points s2 and s3 are given by,

Hs1,s2=bkzτz+ckz2τz(7)H_{s_1,s_2}=bk_z\tau_z+ck_z^2\tau_z \tag*{(7)}

The Chern number is not defined for this Hamiltonian, and the degeneracies are just the accidental nodes. These nodes are only protected by τz\tau_z conservation, and will generically split into Weyl nodes once terms proportional to τx\tau_x and τy\tau_y are added. Thus, from this model, we can say that only w1 and w2 are the real Weyl nodes, while s1 and s2 are accidental crossings.

Non Linear Hall Effects

To further explore the topological characteristics and transport behavior, we constructed a Wannier Hamiltonian based on the Cu-3dyz3d_{yz} and Cu-3dzx3d_{zx} orbitals. The resulting Wannier functions are well localized, and the computed band structure aligns closely with the DFT band structure (see Appendix, Fig. 9). Since the augmented model Hamiltonian is confined to the Γ\Gamma-ZZ region, it effectively captures the features of the entire Brillouin zone (BZ). Without including SOC, the model reveals the presence of two Weyl points at the high-symmetry points Γ\Gamma and ZZ. However, incorporating SOC induces band splitting, significantly increasing the total number of Weyl points across the BZ to 60. Detailed information on the Weyl points and their locations can be found in Appendix F. The Weyl points in this system emerge due to the breaking of inversion symmetry. This symmetry breaking leads to an asymmetric distribution of Berry curvature around the Weyl points, resulting in a non-zero Berry BCD, which is the first moment of the Berry curvature. The BCD plays a central role in driving the nonlinear Hall effect under an applied external electric field. The nonlinear Hall current is expressed as:

Ja2ω=χabcEbEc(8)J_{a}^{2\omega} = \chi_{abc} E_b E_c \tag*{(8)}

Here, JJ is the transverse current that is related to the applied electric field by the tensor χ\chi. This tensor quantity can be related to the BCD by the following relations[60],

χabc=−ϵadce3τ2ℏ2(1+iωτ)Dbd(9)\chi_{abc} = -\frac{\epsilon_{adc} e^{3}\tau}{2\hbar^{2}(1+i\omega\tau)}D_{bd} \tag*{(9)}

where,

Dbd(μ,T)=∫[dk]∑n∂En∂kbΩn,d(−∂f(T,μ,E)∂E)E=En(10)D_{bd}(\mu,T)=\int[dk]\sum_n \frac{\partial E_n}{\partial k_b}\Omega_{n,d}\left(-\frac{\partial f(T,\mu,E)}{\partial E}\right)_{E=E_n} \tag*{(10)}

is the BCD, Ω\Omega is the Berry curvature, μ\mu is the chemical potential, τ\tau is the relaxation time, ϵ\epsilon is the Levi-Civita symbol, ff is the Fermi Dirac distribution given by, f(T,μ,E)=1exp⁡((E−μ)/kT)+1f(T,\mu,E)=\frac{1}{\exp((E-\mu)/kT)+1}, Integration [dk]=d3k2π3[dk]=\frac{d^3k}{2\pi^3}, The indices a,b,ca,b,c are the crystal direction and nn is the band index. We computed the BCD for both the case of SOC and without SOC which are presented in Figure 5. The various components of the BCD exhibit sharp peaks at the locations of the Weyl points. The first row in Figure 5 highlights peaks at -0.052 eV and 0.0054 eV. In the absence of spin-orbit coupling (SOC), only the diagonal components are non-zero. However, when SOC is activated, we observe the emergence of several sharp peaks, primarily due to the appearance of new Weyl points influenced by SOC effects. Additionally, the band structure exhibits tilts near the nodal points, resulting in asymmetric electronic features. This band tilting is a significant factor contributing to the non-zero BCD [63, 64, 65]. The lack of mirror symmetry leads to most of the components being non-zero, adhering to the relation Dij−DjiD_{ij}-D_{ji}. Using this calculated BCD, we estimated the nonlinear Hall current of the system. When an electric field of unit magnitude is applied in the xyxy, yzyz, and zxzx planes, the resulting transverse currents take the following forms:

Various components of the Berry curvature dipole plotted against chemical potential

Figure 5. Various components of the Berry curvature dipole plotted against chemical potential. The individual row consists of 3 figures where row1 (R1) case of without SOC row2 (R2) case of SOC.

Jz=Dxy+12(Dyy−Dxx)sin⁡2θ(11)J_z=D_{xy}+\frac{1}{2}(D_{yy}-D_{xx})\sin2\theta \tag*{(11)}
Jx=Dyz+12(Dzz−Dyy)sin⁡2θ(12)J_x=D_{yz}+\frac{1}{2}(D_{zz}-D_{yy})\sin2\theta \tag*{(12)}
Jy=Dxz+12(Dxx−Dzz)sin⁡2θ(13)J_y=D_{xz}+\frac{1}{2}(D_{xx}-D_{zz})\sin2\theta \tag*{(13)}

From the BCD values of DyyD_{yy} DxxD_{xx}, first term in the eqn (11) dominates making the current unaffected by the angle whereas the second term dominates for JxJ_x and JyJ_y making the current to be sinusoidal as illustrated in Figure 6. The highly intense region of the current corresponds to the location of Weyl points. As from the results we can say that the current can be controlled through chemical doping and changing the direction of applied electric field. Along with BCD contribution to JJ come from the QM and Drude weight also. The contribution due to the QM and Drude weight is given by [50, 52],

Schematic diagram and nonlinear Hall current plots

Figure 6. (a) Schematic diagram of non linear Hall effect. Horizontal red arrow is the direction of applied electric field. The vertical red arrow indicates the direction of non linear Hall current (JNLHJ_{NLH}). (b),(c) Non linear Hall current with respect to the chemical potential and the direction of applied electric field without and with spin orbit coupling respectively. Axis shows the plane of applied electric field and θ\theta is the direction of applied electric field. Here, considering the static limit ω→0\omega\to0, τ\tau is 1 ps choosen from the expermental Refs. [61, 62] and the physically applicable laboratory electric field strength 1 V/cm is considered for the numerical estimation of current.

χQMαβγ=2e3∑n,mϵn≠ϵmRe⁡∫d3k(2π)3∂f(ϵn)∂ϵn1ϵn−ϵm(vncgnab−vnagncb)(14)\chi_{\mathrm{QM}}^{\alpha\beta\gamma}=2e^3\sum_{\substack{n,m\\ \epsilon_n\ne\epsilon_m}}\operatorname{Re}\int\frac{d^3k}{(2\pi)^3}\frac{\partial f(\epsilon_n)}{\partial\epsilon_n}\frac{1}{\epsilon_n-\epsilon_m}\left(v_n^c g_n^{ab}-v_n^a g_n^{cb}\right) \tag*{(14)}

The quantity gnabg_n^{ab} measures the distance between neighboring Bloch states and can be expressed as gnab=∑ijRe⁡[AnimjaAmj,nib]g_n^{ab}=\sum_{ij}\operatorname{Re}[A_{nimj}^a A_{mj,ni}^b] for n≠mn\ne m. The term vncgnabv_n^c g_n^{ab} is known as the quantum metric dipole, where Anm=⟨un∣i∇kum⟩A_{nm}=\langle u_n|i\nabla_k u_m\rangle represents the Berry connection. In this context, χ\chi is antisymmetric with respect to its first two indices. Due to the time-reversal symmetry of the system, the contribution from the QM is zero because χQM\chi_{\mathrm{QM}} is odd under time reversal. The contribution due to drude weight is given by,

χDrudeabc=−e3τ2ℏ3∑n∫d3k(2π)3(∂ka∂kb∂kcϵn)f(ϵn)(15)\chi_{\mathrm{Drude}}^{abc}=-\frac{e^3\tau^2}{\hbar^3}\sum_n\int\frac{d^3k}{(2\pi)^3}(\partial_{k_a}\partial_{k_b}\partial_{k_c}\epsilon_n)f(\epsilon_n) \tag*{(15)}

In our system, which exhibits time reversal symmetry, the integral becomes an odd function of kk, resulting in a total Drude contribution of zero. Therefore, we conclude that the non-linear Hall conductivity arises solely from the BCD.

CONCLUSION

The initial excitement surrounding room-temperature ambient-pressure superconductivity in LK-99 has redirected scientific interest toward its unique electronic and topological properties after the inability to reproduce the claimed superconductivity. In this work, we used first-principles density functional theory and developed a refined tight-binding Hamiltonian to investigate the material’s band topology and transport characteristics, with a particular focus on on its nonlinear Hall response. Our analysis revealed that, without spin-orbit coupling, two distinct flat bands exist near the Fermi level. The inclusion of spin-orbit coupling leads to the splitting of these bands into four, resulting in multiple Weyl points that act as sources and sinks of Berry curvature. This feature, confirmed by both the augmented and Wannier based Hamiltonians, highlights the topological richness of LK-99. Moreover, the breaking of inversion symmetry in the material gives rise to a non-zero Berry curvature dipole, driving a nonlinear Hall current as a second-order response to the applied electric field. This nonlinear Hall effect, characterized by its quadratic dependence on the electric field and tunability with the field direction, underscores LK-99’s potential as a platform for exploring Berry curvature driven transport phenomena. The origin of the nonlinear Hall conductivity is solely from the BCD, as the contributions from the QM and the Drude weight are zero due to time reversal symmetry. By uncovering these features, our study positions LK-99 as a promising material for advancing the understanding of topological transport and nonlinear electronic devices, independent of its initially proposed superconducting properties.

Acknowledgments

This work was supported by National Science Foundation grant no. DMR 2047193.

Parameters

The values of different parameters from the Hamiltonian around the Weyl points are listed in Table I.

λ=0.0020\lambda=0.0020, λ′=0.0065\lambda'=0.0065

Modified tight binding Hamiltonian

The parameters here are based on the model by Zhou and Franz [47],

H=H0+λ2τz⊗σz+λ′cos⁡(kzc)τz⊗σz(16)H=H_0+\frac{\lambda}{2}\tau_z\otimes\sigma_z+\lambda'\cos(k_zc)\tau_z\otimes\sigma_z \tag*{(16)}
H0=[h+h+−h−+h−](17)H_0=\begin{bmatrix} h_+ & h_{+-} \\ h_{-+} & h_- \end{bmatrix} \tag*{(17)}
H=[h++λ+λ′cos⁡(kzc)h+−00h−+h−−λ−λ′cos⁡(kzc)0000h+−λ−λ′cos⁡(kzc)h+−00h−+h−+λ+λ′cos⁡(kzc)](18)H=\begin{bmatrix} h_++\lambda+\lambda'\cos(k_zc) & h_{+-} & 0 & 0 \\ h_{-+} & h_--\lambda-\lambda'\cos(k_zc) & 0 & 0 \\ 0 & 0 & h_+-\lambda-\lambda'\cos(k_zc) & h_{+-} \\ 0 & 0 & h_{-+} & h_-+\lambda+\lambda'\cos(k_zc) \end{bmatrix} \tag*{(18)}
h±=E0+2t0C(k∥)±2u0S(k∥)+2g0Cz(kz)±2u1S(k∥)Cz(kz)±2g0zSz(kz),h+−=2t1C−(k∥)+2g1C−(k∥)Cz(kz),h−+=2t1C+(k∥)+2g1C+(k∥)Cz(kz)(19)\begin{aligned} h_\pm&= E_0+2t_0C(k_\parallel)\pm2u_0S(k_\parallel)+2g_0C_z(k_z)\pm2u_1S(k_\parallel)C_z(k_z)\pm2g_{0z}S_z(k_z),\\ h_{+-} &= 2t_1C_-(k_\parallel)+2g_1C_-(k_\parallel)C_z(k_z),\\ h_{-+} &= 2t_1C_+(k_\parallel)+2g_1C_+(k_\parallel)C_z(k_z) \tag*{(19)} \end{aligned}

The basis functions of S3 are,

C(k∥)=∑j=1,2,3cos⁡(k∥⋅R2j−1),S(k∥)=∑j=1,2,3sin⁡(k∥⋅R2j−1),C±(k∥)=∑j=1,2,3ω±j−1cos⁡(k∥⋅R2j−1),Cz(kz)=cos⁡(kzc),Sz(kz)=sin⁡(kzc)(20)\begin{aligned} C(k_\parallel)&=\sum_{j=1,2,3}\cos(k_\parallel\cdot R_{2j-1}),\\ S(k_\parallel)&=\sum_{j=1,2,3}\sin(k_\parallel\cdot R_{2j-1}),\\ C_\pm(k_\parallel)&=\sum_{j=1,2,3}\omega_\pm^{j-1}\cos(k_\parallel\cdot R_{2j-1}),\\ C_z(k_z)&=\cos(k_zc),\quad S_z(k_z)=\sin(k_zc) \tag*{(20)} \end{aligned}

The values of numerical parameters,

E0=0.01E_0=0.01 ; t0=−0.006t_0=-0.006; t1=−0.002t_1=-0.002 ; u0=−0.012u_0=-0.012; g0=−0.0125g_0=-0.0125; u1=0.001u_1=0.001 ; g1=0.01g_1=0.01; g0z=0.004g_{0z}=0.004

Effective 2 × 2 Hamiltonian around different degenerate points

Around w1:

Hw1=[h+−λ−λ′cos⁡(kzc)h+−h−+h−+λ+λ′cos⁡(kzc)](21)H_{w1}=\begin{bmatrix} h_+-\lambda-\lambda'\cos(k_zc) & h_{+-}\\ h_{-+} & h_-+\lambda+\lambda'\cos(k_zc) \end{bmatrix} \tag*{(21)}

Around w2:

Hw2=[h++λ+λ′cos⁡(kzc)h+−h−+h−−λ−λ′cos⁡(kzc)](22)H_{w2}=\begin{bmatrix} h_{+}+\lambda+\lambda'\cos(k_zc) & h_{+-} \\ h_{-+} & h_{-}-\lambda-\lambda'\cos(k_zc) \end{bmatrix} \tag*{(22)}

Around s1:

Hs1=[h−−λ−λ′cos⁡(kzc)00h++λ+λ′cos⁡(kzc)](23)H_{s1}=\begin{bmatrix} h_{-}-\lambda-\lambda'\cos(k_zc) & 0 \\ 0 & h_{+}+\lambda+\lambda'\cos(k_zc) \end{bmatrix} \tag*{(23)}

Around s2:

Hs2=[h++λ+λ′cos⁡(kzc)00h+−λ−λ′cos⁡(kzc)](24)H_{s2}=\begin{bmatrix} h_{+}+\lambda+\lambda'\cos(k_zc) & 0 \\ 0 & h_{+}-\lambda-\lambda'\cos(k_zc) \end{bmatrix} \tag*{(24)}

Dispersion of winding vector around Weyl points

Visualization of the winding textures of the vector field $\mathbf{f}(\mathbf{k})$ in momentum space

Figure 7. Visualization of the winding textures of the vector field f(k)\mathbf{f}(\mathbf{k}) in momentum space. (a) Winding texture in the kxk_x–kyk_y plane at fixed kz=0k_z = 0. (b) Texture in the kyk_y–kzk_z plane at fixed kx=0k_x = 0. (c) Texture in the kxk_x–kzk_z plane at fixed ky=0k_y = 0. (d) Texture on the unit sphere, illustrating the full 3D structure of f(k)\mathbf{f}(\mathbf{k}). The arrows show the direction of f^(k)\hat{\mathbf{f}}(\mathbf{k}). The winding structure reveals the topological nature of the Hamiltonian.

Berry Curvature

The Hamiltonian at the Weyl points (w1 and w2) is given by the equation,

H=a(kx2−ky2)τx+2akxkyτy+(bkz+ckz2)τz(25)H = a(k_x^2-k_y^2)\tau_x + 2ak_xk_y\tau_y + (bk_z+ck_z^2)\tau_z \tag*{(25)}

The eigen values obtained analytically,

λ=±a2(kx2−ky2)2+(2akxky)2+(bkz+ckz2)2(26)\lambda= \pm\sqrt{a^2(k_x^2-k_y^2)^2+(2ak_xk_y)^2+(bk_z+ck_z^2)^2} \tag*{(26)}

The band velocities can be simply obtained by ;

vi=∂λ∂ki(27)v_i = \frac{\partial\lambda}{\partial k_i} \tag*{(27)}

The different components of Berry curvature can be obtained by simply using the formula:

Ω=12f⃗∣f⃗∣3⋅(∂f⃗∂kj×∂f⃗∂kk)ϵ^i(28)\Omega= \frac{1}{2}\frac{\vec{f}}{|\vec{f}|^3}\cdot\left(\frac{\partial\vec{f}}{\partial k_j}\times\frac{\partial\vec{f}}{\partial k_k}\right)\hat{\epsilon}_i \tag*{(28)}

Different components of f⃗\vec{f} are; fx=a(kx2−ky2)f_x=a(k_x^2-k_y^2); fy=2akxkyf_y=2ak_xk_y; fz=bkz+ckz2f_z=bk_z+ck_z^2

Using eqn (4), the different components of Berry curvature are:

Ωz=4a2(bkz+ckz2)(kx2+ky2)[a2(kx2+ky2)2+(bkz+ckz2)2]3/2\Omega_z = \frac{4a^2(bk_z+ck_z^2)(k_x^2+k_y^2)}{\left[a^2(k_x^2+k_y^2)^2+(bk_z+ck_z^2)^2\right]^{3/2}}
Ωx=4a2(bkz+ckz2)(ky2−kx2)[a2(ky2+kx2)2+(bkz+ckz2)2]3/2\Omega_x = \frac{4a^2(bk_z+ck_z^2)(k_y^2-k_x^2)}{\left[a^2(k_y^2+k_x^2)^2+(bk_z+ck_z^2)^2\right]^{3/2}}
Ωy=8a2(bkz+ckz2)(kxky)[a2(kx2+ky2)2+(bkz+ckz2)2]3/2\Omega_y = \frac{8a^2(bk_z+ck_z^2)(k_xk_y)}{\left[a^2(k_x^2+k_y^2)^2+(bk_z+ck_z^2)^2\right]^{3/2}}

With simply using Berry curvature and band velocity one can calculate the Berry curvature dipole Dij∝∑nvinΩjnD_{ij}\propto\sum_n v_i^n\Omega_j^n

Temperature Dependence of BCD

Temperature dependence of one component of the Berry Curvature Dipole

Figure 8. Temperature dependence on one of the component(DzzD_{zz}) of Berry Curvature Dipole

Wannier Function Model Bandstructure

Comparison of band structures from DFT calculations and Wannier function model

Figure 9. Comparision of band structures from DFT calculations(black) and Wannier function model (green) .

Distribution of Berry Curvature

Projection of the components of Berry curvature on the individual bands

Figure 10. Projection of the components of Berry curvature on the individual bands. The first three are (a) Ωx\Omega_x (b) Ωy\Omega_y and (c) Ωz\Omega_z without SOC. The next three are the case with SOC (d) Ωx\Omega_x (e) Ωy\Omega_y and (f) Ωz\Omega_z. Red and blue colors represent the positive and negative values of the Berry curvature. The thickness indicates the magnitude of Berry curvature.

Weyl Points

Absence of SOC

WPkx[2π/a]k_x[2\pi/a]ky[2π/b]k_y[2\pi/b]kz[2π/c]k_z[2\pi/c]E(eV)E(eV)χ\chiM
W+W_+0.0000.0000.000-0.052+11
W−W_-0.0000.000-0.6880.005-11

Table II. Properties of low-energy Weyl points for two bands without SOC. "WPs" represents the set of Weyl points, EE indicates their energy relative to the Fermi level, kik_i (i=x,y,zi=x,y,z) are their coordinates, "M" denotes the symmetry-determined multiplicity of the Weyl points, and χ\chi refers to their associated chirality.

Two Weyl points distributed in the 3D Brillouin zone

Figure 11. Two Weyl points distributed in the 3D Brillouin zone for the case of absence of SOC. The red and blue colors indicate the positive and negative chirality respectively.

Inclusion of SOC

WPkx[2π/a]k_x[2\pi/a]ky[2π/b]k_y[2\pi/b]kz[2π/c]k_z[2\pi/c]E(eV)E(eV)χ\chiM
W1W_1-0.867-0.5000.000-0.069-13
W2W_2-0.506-0.012-0.097-0.065+16
W3W_3-0.866-0.500-0.668-0.029-13
W4W_4-0.163-0.0030.668-0.003+16
W5W_5-0.1200.062-0.173-0.049-16
W6W_60.0000.000-0.6680.004-11
W7W_70.0000.0000.000-0.059+11
W8W_80.0000.0000.411-0.004+12

Table III. Properties of low-energy Weyl points in LK-99, considering the bands n=1n=1 and n+1=2n+1=2. "WPs" represents the set of Weyl points, EE denotes their energy relative to the Fermi level, kik_i (i=x,y,zi=x,y,z) are their coordinates, "M" refers to the symmetry-determined multiplicity of these Weyl points, and χ\chi indicates their associated chirality.

Eight sets of Weyl points distribution in the 3D Brillouin zone

Figure 12. Eight sets of Weyl points distribution in the 3D Brillouin zone. The red and blue colors indicate the opposite Chern number containing Weyl points.

WPkx[2π/a]k_x[2\pi/a]ky[2π/b]k_y[2\pi/b]kz[2π/c]k_z[2\pi/c]E(eV)E(eV)χ\chiM
W9W_9-0.210-0.097-0.285-0.021+16
W10W_{10}-0.1850.088-0.4610.003-16
W11W_{11}-0.0000.0000.301-0.019+12
W12W_{12}0.000-0.0000.4590.004-12

Table IV. Properties of low-energy Weyl points in LK-99, considering the bands n=2n = 2 and n+1=3n + 1 = 3. "WPs" represents the set of Weyl points, EE denotes their energy relative to the Fermi level, kik_i (i=x,y,zi = x,y,z) are their coordinates, "M" refers to the symmetry-determined multiplicity of these Weyl points, and χ\chi indicates their associated chirality.

Eight sets of Weyl points distribution in the 3D Brillouin zone

Figure 13. Eight sets of Weyl points distribution in the 3D Brillouin zone. The red and blue colors indicate the opposite Chern number containing Weyl points.

WPkx[2π/a]k_x[2\pi/a]ky[2π/b]k_y[2\pi/b]kz[2π/c]k_z[2\pi/c]E(eV)E(\mathrm{eV})χ\chiM
W13W_{13}-0.5770.000-0.6880.030-13
W14W_{14}-0.866-0.5000.000-0.013+13
W15W_{15}-0.1580.01520.354-0.000+16
W16W_{16}-0.000-0.0000.000-0.041-11
W17W_{17}-0.0000.0000.392-0.000-12
W18W_{18}0.0000.000-0.6880.008-11

Table V. Properties of low-energy Weyl points in LK-99, considering the bands n=3n = 3 and n+1=4n + 1 = 4. "WPs" represents the set of Weyl points, EE denotes their energy relative to the Fermi level, kik_i (i=x,y,zi = x, y, z) are their coordinates, "M" refers to the symmetry-determined multiplicity of these Weyl points, and χ\chi indicates their associated chirality.

Eight sets of Weyl points distribution in the 3D Brillouin zone

Figure 14. Eight sets of Weyl points distribution in the 3D Brillouin zone. The red and blue colors indicate the opposite Chern number containing Weyl points.

References

References

  1. [1]Z. Du, H.-Z. Lu, and X. Xie, Nat. Rev. Phys. 3, 744 (2021).
  2. [2]Q. Ma, S.-Y. Xu, H. Shen, D. MacNeill, V. Fatemi, T.-R. Chang, A. M. Mier Valdivia, S. Wu, Z. Du, C.-H. Hsu, et al., Nature 565, 337 (2019).
  3. [3]C. Ortix, Adv. Quantum Technol. 4, 2100056 (2021).
  4. [4]D. Kumar, C.-H. Hsu, R. Sharma, T.-R. Chang, P. Yu, J. Wang, G. Eda, G. Liang, and H. Yang, Nat. Nanotechnol. 16, 421 (2021).
  5. [5]H. Isobe, S.-Y. Xu, and L. Fu, Sci. Adv. 6, eaay2497 (2020).
  6. [6]Y. Zhang and L. Fu, Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. 118, e2100736118 (2021).
  7. [7]S. Wang, W. Niu, and Y.-W. Fang, Microstructures 5, 2025060 (2025).
  8. [8]A. Bandyopadhyay, N. B. Joseph, and A. Narayan, Mater. Today Electronics 8, 100101 (2024).
  9. [9]P. T. Zhou, C.-P. Zhang, and K. Law, Phys. Rev. Appl. 13, 024053 (2020).
  10. [10]A. Taghizadeh and T. G. Pedersen, 2D Mater. 7, 015003 (2019).
  11. [11]X.-G. Ye, H. Liu, P.-F. Zhu, W.-Z. Xu, S. A. Yang, N. Shang, K. Liu, and Z.-M. Liao, Phys. Rev. Lett. 130, 016301 (2023).
  12. [12]Y. Zhao, J. Cao, Z. Zhang, S. Li, Y. Li, F. Ma, and S. A. Yang, Phys. Rev. B 107, 205124 (2023).
  13. [13]Y. Gao, F. Zhang, and W. Zhang, Phys. Rev. B 102, 245116 (2020).
  14. [14]W. Rao, Y.-L. Zhou, Y.-j. Wu, H.-J. Duan, M.-X. Deng, and R.-Q. Wang, Phys. Rev. B 103, 155415 (2021).
  15. [15]P. Hosur and X. Qi, Comptes Rendus Physique 14, 857 (2013).
  16. [16]S. Roy and A. Narayan, Journal of Physics: Condensed Matter 34, 385301 (2022).
  17. [17]S. Singh, J. Kim, K. M. Rabe, and D. Vanderbilt, Phys. Rev. Lett. 125, 046402 (2020).
  18. [18]J.-S. You, S. Fang, S.-Y. Xu, E. Kaxiras, and T. Low, Phys. Rev. B 98, 121109 (2018).
  19. [19]Y. Zhang, Y. Sun, and B. Yan, Phys. Rev. B 97, 041101 (2018).
  20. [20]S. Singh, J. Kim, K. M. Rabe, and D. Vanderbilt, Phys. Rev. Lett. 125, 046402 (2020).
  21. [21]B. Karki, B. P. Belbase, G. B. Acharya, S. Singh, and M. P. Ghimire, Phys. Rev. B 105, 125138 (2022).
  22. [22]S. Lee, J.-H. Kim, and Y.-W. Kwon, arXiv preprint arXiv:2307.12008 (2023).
  23. [23]S. Lee, J. Kim, S. Im, S. An, and K. H. Auh, arXiv preprint arXiv:2307.12037 (2023), 10.48550/arXiv.2307.12037.
  24. [24]D. Kumar, N. K. Karn, and V. P. S. Awana, Supercond. Sci. Technol. 36, 10LT02 (2023).
  25. [25]L. Liu, Z. Meng, X. Wang, H. Chen, Z. Duan, X. Zhou, H. Yan, P. Qin, and Z. Liu, Advanced Functional Materials 33, 2308938 (2023).
  26. [26]I. Timokhin, C. Chen, Q. Yang, and A. Mishchenko, arXiv preprint arXiv:2308.03823 (2023).
  27. [27]G. S. Thakur, M. Schulze, and M. Ruck, Supercond. Sci. Technol. 37, 015013 (2023).
  28. [28]H. Singh, A. Gautam, M. Singh, P. Saha, P. Kumar, P. Das, M. Lamba, K. Yadav, P. Mishra, S. Patnaik, and A. Ganguli, arXiv preprint arXiv:2308.06589 (2023).
  29. [29]K. Guo, Y. Li, and S. Jia, Sci. China: Phys. Mech. Astron. 66, 107411 (2023).
  30. [30]H. Wu, L. Yang, B. Xiao, and H. Chang, arXiv preprint arXiv:2308.01516 (2023).
  31. [31]P. K. Jain, J. Phys. Chem. C 127, 18253 (2023).
  32. [32]S. Zhu, W. Wu, Z. Li, and J. Luo, Matter 6, 4401 (2023).
  33. [33]T. Habamahoro, T. Bontke, M. Chirom, Z. Wu, J. M. Bao, L. Z. Deng, and C. W. Chu, Supercond. Sci. Tech. 37, 045004 (2024).
  34. [34]H. Bai, J. Ye, L. Gao, C. Zeng, and W. Liu, Sci. Rep. 13, 21085 (2023).
  35. [35]J. Cabezas-Escares, N. F. Barrera, R. H. Lavroff, A. N. Alexandrova, C. Cardenas, and F. Munoz, Phys. Rev. B 109, 144515 (2024).
  36. [36]H. Oh and Y.-H. Zhang, arXiv preprint arXiv:2308.02469 (2023).
  37. [37]O. Tavakol and T. Scaffidi, Phys. Rev. B 109, L100504 (2024).
  38. [38]S. M. Griffin, arXiv preprint arXiv:2307.16892 (2023).
  39. [39]R. Kurlerto, S. Lany, D. Pashov, S. Acharya, M. van Schilfgaarde, and D. S. Dessau, arXiv preprint arXiv:2308.00698 (2023).
  40. [40]N. Mao, N. Peschcherenko, and Y. Zhang, arXiv preprint arXiv:2308.05528 (2023).
  41. [41]J. Shen, D. I. Gaines, S. Shahabfar, Z. Li, D. Kang, S. Griesemer, A. Salgado-Casanova, T.-c. Liu, C.-T. Chou, Y. Xia, and C. Wolverton, Chem. Mater. 36, 275 (2024).
  42. [42]H. Paudyal, M. E. Flatté, and D. Paudyal, Phys. Rev. Mater. 8, L011801 (2024).
  43. [43]R. Liu, T. Guo, J. Lu, J. Ren, and T. Ma, Int. J. Mod. Phys. C 0, 2450259 (2024).
  44. [44]W. Chen, J. Phys.: Condens. Matter 36, 235601 (2024).
  45. [45]M. Braß, L. Si, and K. Held, Phys. Rev. B 109, 085103 (2024).
  46. [46]M. M. Hirschmann and J. Mitscherling, Phys. Rev. Mater. 8, 014201 (2024).
  47. [47]B. T. Zhou and M. Franz, arXiv preprint arXiv:2308.07408 (2023).
  48. [48]S.-W. Kim, K. Haule, G. L. Pascut, and B. Monserrat, Mater. Horiz. 11, 5622 (2024).
  49. [49]S.-W. Kim, K. Wang, S. Chen, L. J. Conway, G. L. Pascut, I. Errea, C. J. Pickard, and B. Monserrat, npj Comput. Mater. 10, 16 (2024).
  50. [50]C. Wang, Y. Gao, and D. Xiao, Phys. Rev. Lett. 127, 277201 (2021).
  51. [51]N. Wang, D. Kaplan, Z. Zhang, T. Holder, N. Cao, A. Wang, X. Zhou, F. Zhou, Z. Jiang, C. Zhang, et al., Nature 621, 487 (2023).
  52. [52]A. Gao, Y.-F. Liu, J.-X. Qiu, B. Ghosh, T. V. Trevisan, Y. Onishi, C. Hu, T. Qian, H.-J. Tien, S.-W. Chen, et al., Sci. 381, 181 (2023).
  53. [53]Y. Fang, J. Cano, and S. A. A. Ghorashi, Phys. Rev. Lett. 133, 106701 (2024).
  54. [54]S. Brückner, G. Lusvardi, L. Menabue, and M. Saladini, Inorganica Chim. Acta 236, 209 (1995).
  55. [55]K. Koepernik and H. Eschrig, Phys. Rev. B 59, 1743 (1999).
  56. [56]J. P. Perdew, K. Burke, and M. Ernzerhof, Phys. Rev. Lett. 77, 3865 (1996).
  57. [57]S. S. Tsirkin, npj Comput. Mater. 7, 33 (2021).
  58. [58]H. Bai, L. Gao, and C. Zeng, arXiv preprint arXiv:2308.05134 (2023).arxiv.org/abs/2308.05134
  59. [59]L. Si, M. Wallerberger, A. Smolyanyuk, S. di Cataldo, J. M. Tomczak, and K. Held, J. Phys.: Condens. Matter 36, 065601 (2023).
  60. [60]I. Sodemann and L. Fu, Phys. Rev. Lett. 115, 216806 (2015).
  61. [61]C. Shekhar, A. K. Nayak, Y. Sun, M. Schmidt, M. Nicklas, I. Leeramakers, U. Zeitler, Y. Skourski, J. Wosnitza, Z. Liu, et al., Nat. Phys. 11, 645 (2015).
  62. [62]F. Arnold, C. Shekhar, S.-C. Wu, Y. Sun, R. D. Dos Reis, N. Kumar, M. Naumann, M. O. Ajeesh, M. Schmidt, A. G. Grushin, et al., Nat. Commun. 7, 11615 (2016).
  63. [63]A. Yar, J. Jäsra, and K. Saebeeh, J. Appl. Phys. 131 (2022).
  64. [64]R.-H. Li, O. G. Heinenen, A. A. Burkov, and S. S.-L. Zhang, Phys. Rev. B 103, 045105 (2021).
  65. [65]Y. Gao, F. Zhang, and W. Zhang, Phys. Rev. B 102, 245116 (2020).

Paper details

vlnc:W_v8t9sbdt
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 0

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Physics and Astronomy

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents